COUNCILLOR DEIRDRE ALDEN Chairman Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee Birmingham City Council The Council House Victoria Square Birmingham B1 1BB Tel: 0121 464 7457 Fax: 0121 303 4555 E-mail:
[email protected] Our Ref: NS/PCTs (Please quote in your reply) 20th March, 2006 David Nicholson CBE Commissioning a Patient-Led NHS West Midlands Consultation Office PO Box 2675 Stafford ST16 9BW Dear Mr Nicholson Birmingham City Council’s response to “Ensuring a Patient-led NHS” - Consultation on new Primary Care Trusts arrangements in Birmingham and the Black Country I am pleased to submit the enclosed report from the Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee, in response to the above consultation. The response is supported by and incorporates the views of the Council’s Executive. A summary of our conclusions is as follows: Overall, selecting between the two options for PCTs proved to be a very close call. Objective analysis was undertaken by the Health O&S Committee based on key criteria that was important for the Council and its performance. This showed that there are equally strong arguments for 3 PCTs and for having a single PCT in the City. From a Council and City wide perspective, a single PCT is desirable as it offers the ability to strategically plan, commission and deliver services, especially for vulnerable groups and those with complex needs. Greater efforts can be made on securing equity and equality of provision and more effective use of resources across the City. 1 From an NHS/ local perspective, 3 PCTs are desirable as they enable progress to be maintained around partnership working.