Lok Sabha Debates 2085 2086
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Fourth Series1R.18 Thursday, March 7, 1968 Phalguna 17, 1889 (Saka) /2.6$%+$ '(%$7(6 Fourth Session Fourth/RN6DEKD /2.6$%+$6(&5(7$5,$7 New Delhi Rs:1.00 CONTENTS COLUMNS No. 18-Thursday, March 7, 1968/Phalguna 17, 1889 (Saka) Oral Answers to Questions- ·Starred Questions Nos. 479 to 482 2085-2114 Written Answers to Questions- Starred QUestions Nos. 483 to 508 . 2114-30 Unstarred Questions Nos. 3107 to 3131,3133 to 3176, 3178 to 3230 and 3230-A 2131-2215 Short Notice Questions-4 2215 Calling Attention to Matter of Urgent Public Importance- Reported kidnapping of Police constable by Chinese Embassy Red Guards 2215-17, 2341-55 Papers Laid on the Table . 2217·18 Estimates Commiltec- Twentieth, Twenty-first, Twenty-second and Thirty-fifth Reports 2218 Business Advisory Committee- Fifteenth Report 2218-20 Motion Re. Reports on Industrial Planning and Licensing Policy 2220-2341 Shri Yogendra Sharma 2220-25 Shri Shantilal Shah 2226-30 Shri J. B. Kripalani 2230-33 Shri Thirumala Rao . 2233-39 Shri Chintamani Panigrahi 2240-45 Shri Sheo Narain 2245-49 Shri Umatiath . 2249-56 Shrimati Sucheta Kripalani 2263-72 Shri Bal Raj Madhok 2272-80 Shri Randhir Singh 2280-86 Shri Amrit Nahata 2288-96 Shri P. Viswambharan . 2296-2302 Shrimati Tarkeshwari Sinha 2302-08 Shri Humayun Kabir 2308-15 Dr. Melkote . 2315-18 Shri Ram Avtar Sharma 2318-23 Shri Himatsingka 2323-24 Shri Prakash Vir Shastri 2324-30 Shri F. A. Ahmed 2330-40 Statement reo Landslide and obstruction in the river Buri Gan- dak in Nepal 2355-56 Dr. K. L. Rao 2355-56 Discussion reo Reported Atrocities on Harijans in Bilaspur district of Madhya Pradesh 2357-82 Shri Madhu Limaye . 2358-68 Shrimati Minimata Agam Dass Guru 2369-76 Shri Jagannath Rao Joshi 2376-79 Shri R. D. Bhandare 2379-82 *Thc ~ign + marked above the name of a Member indicates that the question was actually asked on the floor of the House by that Member. MllLSS{68-1 LOK SABHA DEBATES 2085 2086 LOK SABHA although it was branded by the Govern- ment as a limb of the Planning Commis- Thursday, March 7, 1968/ sion. Phalgl4na 17, 1889 (Saka) The Central Government alone paid over ~ 230 lakhs wi thout any supervision The Lok SaMa met at and examination of accounts. They clenrly Eleven of rile Clock violated the provisions of the GFR, rule 149(3). The Information and Broadcasting [MR. SPEAlUR ill the Chair] Ministry gave ~ 28,701 but what was publiCised did not serve the Government purpOse as stipulated; it served the pUrpo,e 'ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS of Bharat Sewak Samaj. In West Bengal, where Shri Asoke Sen was the chief of the 'GRANTS TO BHARAT SEWAK SAMAJ ~ Sewak Samaj. he fully utilised the funds of Bharat Sewak Samaj to meet his ·479. SHRI JYOTIRMOY BASU: Will the Minister of FOOD AND AGRICUL- eleCtion exPenses. TURE be pleased to state: (a) the total amount given to the Bharat MR. SPEAKER You arc giving Sewak Samaj sinc<: its incePtion; and information to the Minister. You are giving the whole history of Dharat Sewak (b) the value of Government land and Samaj but are not asking the question. property Biven to the Samaj in Delhi; and ,other places ~ SHRI JYOTIRMOY BASU: Under the THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE circumstances may I ask the Minister whether MINISTRY OF FOOD, AGRICULTURE, any tax exemption was allowed to Bharat COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND Sewak Samaj; if so, under what rules, what COOPERATION (SHRI M. S. GURUPA- is the amount and arc Ihere aay arrears? DASWAMy) : (a) and (b). A statement is laid on the Table of the House. [Placed in SHRI M. S. GURUPADASWAMY: Library. See No. LT-374/68). Comprehensive consolidated accouats arc not available Yet; so. I am not in a position SHRJ JYOTIRMOY DASU This to say whal concessions have been allowed Bharat Sewak Samaj, or you miabt call it 10 Dharat Sewak Samuj. Bharat Experiment Samaj. is an adventure of Shri Nanda, whose conscience may SHRI JYOTIRMOY BASU: But you rest in peace. who wanted a powerful have received the PAC Report. Do nol organisation of his own to be parallel 10 pretend that you do not know about it. the ~ng SHRI M. S. GURUPADASWAMY: I SHRI S. KANDAPPAN: Parallel to do aot pretend at all. I am aware of the the Planning Commi"ion. PAC Report. I only say lhis much that comprehcasivc information is not avail- SHRI JYOTIRMOY BASU: In theory able yet. they said that it was a concern for the uplift of the PeOple but in practice the aim was to SHRI JYOTIRMOY BASU: My second have an industrial empire for furthering question is whether afterthe PublieACcounts political causes. It was repstered under Committee luggcstcd a ban, further grants ~ So<:ieties Registration Act of 1860 have been giveD in viOlation of the ban by 2087 Oral n~ MARCH 7, 1968 Oral Answers 2088 the Ministries and the Plannin8 Ccmmis- '3if if; ~ ~ ~ ~ fit; sion; if so, the details thereer and the reason t, t for doing the same. ~~~~~~~~ ~~~in~~ SHRI M. S. GURUPADASWAMY: After the Public Accounts Commitee made ~ ~ ~~ R<iT t ~ ~ ~ its recommendation the Government of ~~~~~~~ India stopped all grants and loans to the Bharat Sewak Samaj. Regarding the other (f) ~ lti't ~ it ~ ;r R<iT UlTfI; I aspect of the question whether the minis- ~ if; ;nG 3)1q' ~ 1ft ~ lti't l!fo'IT 'IT am: tries have violated it, I think we have stopped ~ ~ 'IT ~ ~~ ~ all payments to Bharat Sewak Samaj. am: i\1: Even the Planning Commission has stopPed ~i ~ t' ~ it 3{lq' ~ 30 fuw.R that. ~~ ~~ ~ <m: SHRI S. KANDAPPAN: The st3te- 1ft ~ if; '¥ if; ;ift am<m!'f ~ am: ment contradicts what the Minister says. ~ ~ ifilftt '1>1 ;;IT ~ SHRI RANGA: I am rising only on a ~ii~~~ i~~~ point of procedure. The other day you were ~ ~ ~ ~ f'l> 'tIfT m<Ii1'<1' ~ good enough to insist that they should be U prepared with in(ormation. Shri Hanu· ~~~~~~~ manthaiya also had some interesting remarks i~ ~~~~~ to make. Even today they ceme forward and say that have not collected the infor· ~~ ~ if "'W ~ 3f1<: ~ if; mifmr mation. TheY do not have the audited ~ lI'\ft 3fT<: arflVrnT ~ '3"if if; fumq; accounts, although they have studied I he ;;rt;;r 3l'T1iFT 'f.T1P1 ~ ~ ffi;r m report of the PAC. Is that corre,t'? 'foT;;rcnif an;ry ~ I MR. SPEAKER: I myself felt it. It is unfortunate. Last time the Ministcr Ig'Rr "fl:fT ~ ~ (",) ~~ of Social Welfare was answering the quc,- lion and Isaid thatlhey might kindly collect WI'): ~ f'l> 31''Ifi ~ ~ the information. ~i~~~~~ ~~~ ........ "" "" ~ : ~ ~~ m ~ ~ ~ emf tH ~~ ~ am: .q 3{lq' If,T ",i 1ff! ~ : '!>if U ? 'l>A' m~ l1l1T-m ~ ~ f'l> ~ ~ jf? <t>iItt ttt 3 ~ ~ ~ m if; ~ ~ If,T il;<m;f ~iii ~ ~ ~ ",1 ~ WI' : aTfu:I ~ ~ if; ~ ~ ~ itiflT'f i~ ~ <T"dT m I ~ 'f>'l: <RIT ~ 1tt ~ t, ~ ~ ~ ~ ffi;r ~ If,T o,ft 'I'f! ~ : 30 ~ 1966;9- i~ t',;;IT '!(i4C;"ql+i'l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~i I .q ~ 3Al'<;1: ~ 'f>W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ fit; ~ if; "fiI;;r "" ~ WI' : ~ ~ ~ 'f>'l: if; SfSOR ~ ~ ~ ~ ;;IT 3fI!1I' t. ;;IT '3if <rnT ~ I 4<: ~ ~ iii<: ~ 'SIToIllfoT ;;rcnif ~i~~~~ ~~ o,ft i~ <mT ~ ~ 66-67 ~ ~ ~ ~ fit; 'tIfT ;;r;ro;r ~ ~ R<iT ~ ~ I ~~ ~ 149 (3) ~ aiR: ~ t f;m it, ~ ~ t fit; ~ ~ mtaTT n~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ if; =ro m: ;;niffl fit; ~ ~ ~ IR f.!;m' '11fT ~ ~ 2089 Oml Answers PHALGUNA 17, 1889 (SAKA) Oral Answers 2090 ~ ~ I ~~ IItf n~ '(\'If : "4'it III ~ fit; ~ ...... .. ~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ MR. SPEAKER: Can you lell the year, f.t;lrr if not Ihe date? if; "4' arnr {iTT I \R i ~ tRmrR!' ~ Ifilrr lJlIT ~ I ~ ~ fW ~ I IItf ~ '1lf : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3fm ~ ~ ~ ij«,,,,,,,.,lf; m'T ~ ~ ;i't 8f1ft lIN ~ ~ ~ am \fi \R i Ifilrr lJlIT ~~ ...... ~~~~~ ....... ""' ~ ~ : 3fiI' ~ W if; furl: ~ "Iltr am ~ ? mTR Wt at t .,. 3{1'1 ii~ ~ I MR. SPEAKER: Please answer the que,· tion; do nOI answer the interruptions. 'lfr ~ Ull' ~ ~ ~ ~~ IItt ~ Ull' : at ~ ~ i~ ~ f<r. ~ cm;-".ft ii~ ~ it Rl'R IItf ~ ~ : ~ <tt !:I1f3 ~ fiI;In ~~ ~ 1jt ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ \R 'liT anms ~ 3lT'1T ~ 'IT am ~ m iii ~ ~ ~ IItf ~~ ~ "4' ~ w ~ I f<m ;;n;rr • ~ ~ '1'(T. prr ~ I ~ <tt ~ 'f@ ~ I 3{1'1 '1>1 1iI1mf.t ~~~~~i i~~ 3fT1T am orR ~ ~ ~ I ~~ ~~~ <r.f ~ ~ ~ ~i '1ft vfi arcnro ~ I ~ 'f@ ~ I ~ <tt ~~ 3{1'1 ~ ~~ ~ # ~ i: I \R ~~~ ~~~ ~~~ ;r?t ~ ~ fiIi 3fT1T am ~ aom IItf ~ Ull' : ;;iT ~ I ~ w ~ if; m'4 ~ .mr w ~ I "4'it ~ If.l!T f<r. 0(1l1 artN ~ ~ ~ ~ mr IItf lfq frn : ~ ~ tit ~ ~ ~ ~ lJlIT wtt 'f@ I 'r'9T ~ ~ 'liT ft't ~ fW., If.'{ if; ~ If;) ~ ~ ...... ~ ~i~i ~~ IItf ~~ ~ ~ : ~ ifi'iI' i, ~ arm ~ tR, 1tiTf ~ ~~~ m ~~ ~ 'f@ I ~i ~ 'r'9T lIfT fit; ~ ~ ....... ~ II>1ftT ~ ~ ~ mr-ft # ro "I"rof i'l'fi ~ ~ ~ MR. SPEAKER: Order, order. You <'111m ~i cannot get up like that. You must sit ?:1f"T am ;;it arro'fft arm- down. You must at least give one minute <rnl" om: Wt ~ 'R ~ flIm'q; ~ to answer the question. After that, you ~~i ~ can ask a supplementary. You cannot interruPt like that. ;;m;r ~~ I ~~ ~~ SHRI M. S. GURUPADASWAMY; ~~~ ~ There was a question already in the Lok Sabha on the 29th and there. we have replied ~~i that we arc coasidcring the qestion oiaetliDg 2091 Oral Allswers MARCH 7, 1968 Oral Answers 2092 up an inquiry to look into all the affairs of eastisatinll.tbe Bharat Sewak Samaj, to the the Bharat Sewak Samaj. It is there. We Third Lot Sabha .....• are considering it.