APPENDIX G Regulatory Database Search Results for Hazardous Materials, October 2003

LIMITED WARRANTY AND DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY

Who is Covered This limited warranty is extended by Toxics Targeting, Inc. only to the original purchaser of the accompanying Computerized Environmental Report ("Report"). It may not be assigned to any other person.

What is Warranted Toxics Targeting, Inc. warrants that it uses reasonable care to accurately transcribe the information contained in this Report from the sources from which it is obtained. This limited warranty is in lieu of all other express warranties which might otherwise arise with respect to the Report. No one is authorized to change or add to this limited warranty.

What We Will Do If during the warranty period there is shown to be a material error in the transcription of the information contained in this Report from the sources from which it was obtained, Toxics Targeting, Inc. shall refund to the original purchaser the full purchase price paid for the Report. The remedy stated above is the exclusive remedy extended to the Purchaser by Toxics Targeting, Inc. for any failure of the Report to conform with this Warranty, or otherwise for breach of this Warranty or any other warranty, whether expressed or implied.

What We Won't Cover Toxics Targeting, Inc. has not and can not verify the accuracy, correctness or completion of the information contained in this Report. Information is obtained from government agencies, site owners, and other sources, and errors are common in such information. Because Toxics Targeting, Inc. can not control the accuracy of the information contained in this Report, or the uses which may be made of the information, TOXICS TARGETING, INC. DISCLAIMS LIABILITY TO ANYONE FOR ANY EVENTS ARISING OUT OF THE USE OF THE INFORMATION. TOXICS TARGETING, INC. SHALL NOT BE LIABLE FOR ANY DAMAGE CAUSED BY THIS REPORT, WHETHER DIRECT OR INDIRECT, AND WHETHER OR NOT TOXICS TARGETING, INC. HAS BEEN ADVISED OF OR HAS KNOWLEDGE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. TOXICS TARGETING, INC. EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS ANY AND ALL IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR USE. Some jurisdictions do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages, so the above exclusion or limitation may not apply to you.

Period of Warranty The period of warranty coverage is ninety days from the date of purchase of this Report. There shall be no warranty after the period of coverage. ANY AND ALL IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR PARTICULAR USE SHALL HAVE NO GREATER DURATION THAN THE PERIOD OF WARRANTY STATED HERE, AND SHALL TERMINATE AUTOMATICALLY UPON THE EXPIRATION OF SUCH PERIOD. Some jurisdictions do not allow limitations on how long an implied warranty lasts, so the above exclusion or limitation may not apply to you.

PLEASE REFER TO PAGES ONE AND FOUR FOR A DESCRIPTION OF SOME OF THE LIMITATIONS OF THIS COMPUTERIZED ENVIRONMENTAL REPORT.

Table of Contents

Introduction...... ……………………………………...... …………………. 1

• The Three Sections of Your Report

• How to Use Your Report

• Toxic Site Databases Analyzed In Your Report

• Limitations Of the Information In Your Report

Section One: Your Report Summary...... ………………………..…....…………………. 5

• Table One: Number of Identified Toxic Sites By Distance Interval

• Table Two: Identified Toxic Sites By Direction

• Table Three: Identified Toxic Sites Ranked by Proximity

• Table Four: Identified Toxic Sites By Category

• Map One: One-Mile Radius Map

• Map Two: Half-Mile Radius Map

• Map Three: Eighth-Mile Radius Map

• Map Four: Eighth-Mile Radius Close-up Map

Section Two: Toxic Site Profiles

Section Three: Appendices

• USEPA ERNS Check

• Unmappable Sites

• Hazardous Waste Codes

• How Toxic Sites Are Mapped

• Information Source Guide

© Toxics Targeting, Inc. 2003 Introduction Toxics Targeting has combined environmental database searches, extensive regulatory analysis and sophisticated mapping techniques to produce your Computerized Environmental Report. It checks for the presence of 17 categories of government-reported toxic sites and provides detailed, up-to-date information on each identified site. The findings of your report are presented in an easy-to-understand format that:

1. Maps the approximate locations of selected government-reported toxic sites identified on or near a specified target address.

2. Estimates the distance and direction between the target address and each identified toxic site.

3. Reports air and water permit non-compliance and other regulatory violations.

4. Profiles some aspects of the usage, manufacture, storage, handling, transport or disposal of toxic chemicals at individual sites.

5. Summarizes some potential health effect information and drinking water standards for selected chemicals reported at individual sites.

The Three Sections Of Your Report

The first section highlights your report's findings by summarizing identified sites according to: a) distance intervals, b) direction, c) proximity to the target address and d) individual site categories. In addition, the locations of all identified toxic sites are illustrated on individual maps for each radius search distance used in your report. Finally, a close-up map illustrates the locations of all identified toxic sites, at the shortest radius search distance used in your report.

The second section of your report contains Toxic Site Profiles that provide detailed information on each identified toxic site. The information in each Toxic Site Profile varies according to its source. Some toxic site categories have extensive information, some have limited information. All the information is updated on a regular basis.

The third section of the report contains appendices that identify: 1) on-site spills reported to the national Emergency Response Notification System (ERNS), 2) various toxic sites that cannot be mapped due to incomplete or erroneous addresses or other mapping problems, 3) codes that characterize hazardous wastes reported at various facilities, 4) methods used to map toxic sites identified in your report and 5) information sources used in your report.

How to Use Your Report

• Check Table One to see the number of identified sites by distance intervals.

• Check Table Two to see identified sites sorted by direction.

• Check Table Three to see identified sites ranked by proximity to the target address.

• Check Table Four to see identified sites sorted by site categories.

• Refer to the various maps to see the locations of identified toxic sites. Refer to the Toxic Site Profile and Appendix sections for additional information.

1

Toxic Site Databases Analyzed In Your Report

Search Radius

One-Mile 1) New York Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Site Registry: a state listing of sites that can pose environmental or public health hazards requiring investigation or clean up.

One-Mile 2) CERCLIS (Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Information System): a federal listing of sites that can pose environmental or public health hazards requiring investigation or clean up.

One-Mile 3) National Priority List for Federal Superfund Cleanup: a listing of sites known to pose environmental or health hazards that are being investigated or cleaned up under the Federal Superfund program.

One-Mile 4) New York Hazardous Substance Disposal Site Draft Study: a state listing of sites contaminated with toxic substances that can pose environmental or public health hazards. These sites are not eligible for state clean up funding programs.

One-Mile 5) New York Solid Waste Facilities Registry, including 1934 Sites: active and inactive landfills, incinerators, transfer stations or other solid waste management facilities.

One-Mile 6) New York State Major Oil Storage Facilities: sites with more than a 400,000 gallon capacity for storing petroleum products.

One-Mile 7) New York and Federal Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage or Disposal Facilities: sites reported by the NYS manifest system and the USEPA's Resource Conservation and Recovery Act Information System (RCRIS). Also includes the following databases:

• RCRA violations: waste facilities with violations reported by the USEPA pursuant to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act. • RCRIS corrective action activity (CORRACTS): waste facilities with RCRIS corrective action activity reported by the USEPA.

Half-Mile 8a) Toxic Spills: active stationary source spills reported to state environmental authorities, including unremediated leaking underground storage tanks.

Half-Mile 8b) Toxic Spills: inactive stationary and non-stationary source spills reported to state environmental authorities, including remediated leaking underground storage tanks.

Eighth-Mile 9) New York and Local Petroleum Bulk Storage Facilities: sites with more than an 1,100 gallon capacity for storing petroleum products.

2 Eighth-Mile 10) New York and Federal Hazardous Waste Generators and Transporters: sites reported by the NYS manifest system and the USEPA's Resource Conservation and Recovery Act Information System (RCRA). Also includes the following databases:

• RCRA violations: waste facilities with violations reported by the USEPA pursuant to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act . • RCRIS corrective action activity (CORRACTS): waste facilities with RCRIS corrective action activity reported by the USEPA.

Eighth-Mile 11) New York Chemical Bulk Storage Facilities: Sites storing hazardous substances listed in 6 NYCRR Part 597 in aboveground tanks with capacities of 185 gallons or more and/or underground tanks of any size

Eighth-Mile 12) New York Toxic Release Inventory Facilities: discharges of selected toxic chemicals to air, land, water or treatment facilities.

Eighth-Mile 13) Historic New York City Utility Sites (1890's to 1940's): power generating stations, manufactured gas plants, gas storage facilities, maintenance yards and other gas and electric utility sites.

Eighth-Mile 14) Air Discharges: Air pollution point sources monitored by U.S. EPA and/or state and local air regulatory agencies.

Eighth-Mile 15) Federal Permit Compliance System Toxic Wastewater Discharges: permitted toxic wastewater discharges.

Eighth-Mile 16) Federal Civil Enforcement Docket: civil judiciary cases filed on behalf of the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency by the Department of Justice.

Property only 17) ERNS: Federal Emergency Response Notification System Spills: a listing of federally reported spills.

3 Limitations Of The Information In Your Report

The information presented in your Computerized Environmental Report has been obtained from various local, state and federal government agencies. Please be aware that: 1) additional information on individual sites may be available, 2) newly discovered sites are continually reported and 3) all map locations are approximate. As a result, this report is intended to be the FIRST STEP in the process of identifying and evaluating possible environmental threats to specific properties and can only serve as a guide for conducting on-site visits or additional, more detailed toxic hazard research.

Toxics Targeting tries to ensure that the information in your report is presented accurately and with minimal alteration. The only systematic changes that are made correct obvious address errors in order to allow sites to be mapped. Any address changes that are made are noted in the map information section at the top of each corresponding Toxic Site Profile. Since the information presented in your report is not edited, please be aware that it can contain reporting errors or typographical mistakes made by the site owners/operators or government agencies that produced the information. Please be aware of some other limitations of the information in your report:

• The computerized map used by Toxics Targeting is the same one used by the U. S. Census. While the map is generally accurate, no map is perfect. In addition, Toxics Targeting's mapping methods estimate where toxic site addresses are located if the address is not specifically designated on the Census map. FOR THESE REASONS, ALL MAP LOCATIONS OF ADDRESSES AND REPORTED TOXIC SITES SHOULD BE CONSIDERED APPROXIMATE AND SHOULD BE VERIFIED BY ON-SITE VISITS;

• UNDISCOVERED, UNREPORTED OR UNMAPPABLE TOXIC SITES MIGHT NOT BE IDENTIFIED BY THIS REPORT'S CHECK OF 17 TOXIC SITE CATEGORIES. TOXIC SITES REPORTED IN OTHER GOVERNMENT DATABASES MIGHT ALSO EXIST. FOR THESE REASONS, YOUR REPORT MIGHT NOT IDENTIFY ALL THE TOXIC SITES THAT EXIST IN THE AREA IT SEARCHES;

• The appendix of your report contains a listing of sites that could not be mapped due to incomplete or erroneous address information or other mapping problems. This listing includes unmappable toxic sites in zip code areas within one mile of the target address as well as toxic sites without zip codes reported in the same county. IF YOU WOULD LIKE INFORMATION ON ANY OF THE LISTED SITES, PLEASE CONTACT TOXICS TARGETING AND REFER TO THE SITE ID NUMBER.

• Some toxic sites identified in your report may be classified as known hazards. Most of the toxic sites identified in your report involve potential hazards related to the on-site use, manufacture, handling, storage, transport or disposal of toxic chemicals. Some of the toxic sites identified in your report may be the addresses of parties responsible for toxic sites located elsewhere. YOU SHOULD ONLY CONCLUDE THAT TOXIC HAZARDS ACTUALLY EXIST AT A SPECIFIC SITE WHEN GOVERNMENT AUTHORITIES MAKE THAT DETERMINATION OR WHEN THAT CONCLUSION IS FULLY DOCUMENTED BY THE FINDINGS OF AN APPROPRIATE SITE INVESTIGATION UNDERTAKEN BY LICENSED PROFESSIONALS;

• Compass directions and distances are approximate. Compass directions are calculated from the subject property address to the mapped location of each identified toxic site. The compass direction does not necessarily refer to the closest property boundary of an identified toxic site. The compass direction also can vary substantially for toxic sites that are located very close to the subject property address.

• The information presented in your report is a summary of the information that Toxics Targeting obtains from government agencies on reported toxic sites. YOU MAY BE ABLE TO OBTAIN ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ABOUT REPORTED SITES WITH THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST FORM LETTERS THAT ARE PROVIDED ON THE INSIDE OF THE BACK COVER.

4

Section One:

Report Summary

• Table One: Number of Identified Toxic Sites By Distance Interval

• Table Two: Identified Toxic Sites By Direction

• Table Three: Identified Toxic Sites Ranked By Proximity

• Table Four: Identified Toxic Sites By Category

• Map One: One-Mile Radius Map

• Map Two: Half-Mile Radius Map

• Map Three: Eighth-Mile Radius Map

• Map Four: Eighth-Mile Radius Close up Map

5 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. 44- 50 E October 14, 2003

NUMBER OF IDENTIFIED SITES BY DISTANCE INTERVAL

Site(s) Category Database Searched 0 - 100 ft 100 ft - 1/8 mi 1/8 mi - 1/4 mi 1/4 mi - 1/2 mi 1/2 mi - 1 mi Totals ------NYS Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Sites * 0 0 0 0 0 0

CERCLIS Sites * 0 0 1 0 1 2

National Priority List Sites * 0 0 0 0 0 0

Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Sites * 0 0 1 0 1 2

NYS Solid Waste Facilities * 0 0 0 0 0 0

NYS Major Oil Storage Facilities * 0 0 0 0 1 1

RCRA Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage, Disposal Sites * 0 0 0 0 1 1

NYS Toxic Spills (incl. Leaking Undrgrnd Storage Tanks) ** 0 13 33(37) 193(158) Not searched 239(195)

Local & State Petroleum Bulk Storage Sites *** 0 6 Not searched Not searched Not searched 6

RCRA Hazardous Waste Generators & Transporters *** 0 30 Not searched Not searched Not searched 30

NYS Chemical Bulk Storage Sites *** 0 0 Not searched Not searched Not searched 0

Toxic Release Inventory Sites (TRI) *** 0 0 Not searched Not searched Not searched 0

Historic Utility Facilities *** 0 0 Not searched Not searched Not searched 0

Permit Compliance System Toxic Wastewater Discharges *** 0 0 Not searched Not searched Not searched 0

NYS Air Discharges *** 0 2 Not searched Not searched Not searched 2

Civil Enforcement Docket Facilities *** 0 0 Not searched Not searched Not searched 0

ERNS (Onsite) ***** 0 Not searched Not searched Not searched Not searched 0

NYC Fire Marshall Tank Sites (Onsite) ***** 0 Not searched Not searched Not searched Not searched 0

------Distance Interval Totals 0 51 35(37) 193(158) 4 283(195)

Search Radius: * 1 Mile Search Radius ** 1/2 Mile Search Radius *** 1/8 Mile Search Radius **** 1/8 Mile Search Radius ***** on-site only

Numbers in ( ) indicate spills not mapped and profiled, and are found in the tables at the end of the active and closed spills sections. See these tables for a description of the parameters involved with identifying these spills.

Identified Toxic Sites by Direction

44- 50 E 50th Street New York, NY 10022

* Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Sites less than 100 feet from subject property sorted by distance ------No sites found less than 100 feet from subject property ------

Sites between 100 ft and 400 ft from the subject property sorted by direction and distance

Approximate Map Distance & Direction Toxic Site Id# Site Name Site Street From Property Category ------261 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V1362-49 E 51ST ST 322 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter

246 MUTUAL OF AMERICA BUILDING 320 246 feet to the E Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 253 MUTUAL OF AMERICA BLDG THE 320 PARK AVE 246 feet to the E Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter

128 VAULT 1371 100 EAST 50TH ST 278 feet to the ESE Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause)

24 304 PARK AVE 304 PARK AVE 208 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

231 300 PARK AVE 300 PARK AVE 239 feet to the SSE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 232 300 PARK AVE. 300 PARK AVE. 239 feet to the SSE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 252 COLGATE PALMOLIVE COMPANY 300 PARK AVE 245 feet to the SSE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 248 299 PARK AVENUE 330 feet to the SSE Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 262 WALDORF ASTORIA 301 PARK AVE 331 feet to the SSE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 263 CON EDISON @ WALDORF ASTORIA HILTON 301 PARK AVE 331 feet to the SSE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter

259 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V3054-F/O 48 E 49TH ST 300 feet to the WSW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter

147 BOISE CASCADE CO/MANH 437 MASISON AVENUE 280 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 256 437 FEE ASSOCIATES 437 MADISON AVENUE 286 feet to the W Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 257 HITACHI 437 MADISON AVE 32ND FL 286 feet to the W Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 258 KISS PHOTO INC 437 MADISON AVE 286 feet to the W Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 148 NE CORNER OF E 49TH ST & MADISON AV 362 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause)

260 NEWSWEEK INC 444 MADISON AVE 312 feet to the WNW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter

247 THE NEW YORK PALACE 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 254 AMERICAN EAGLE FDR CORPORATION 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 255 HELMSLEY PALACE 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 145 CORNER OF 50TH ST AND MADISON AV 278 feet to the NW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 146 MADISON AV E 50TH ST 278 feet to the NW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) ------

Sites equal to or greater than 400 ft from subject property sorted by direction and distance

Approximate Map Distance & Direction Toxic Site Id# Site Name Site Street From Property Category ------249 NEW DAWN DAVIDSON L.P. 477 MADISON AVENUE 425 feet to the N Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 150 488 MADISON AVE 488 MADISON AVE 543 feet to the N Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 251 40 EAST COMPANY 40 EAST 558 feet to the N Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 269 40 EASTCO 40 E 52ND ST 558 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 270 CON ED V1307-28 E 52ND ST 575 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 271 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V3838-28 E 52ND ST 587 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 276 HANCO JEWELRY INC 501 MADISON AVE 612 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 277 CONSOLIDATED EDISON 8170975-24 E 52ND ST 614 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 27 MANHOLE #DMA5N-39 53RD ST & MADISON AVE 838 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 28 520 MADISON AV 965 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 153 MANHOLE #50134 520 MADISON AVE 965 feet to the N Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 39 VAULT #V185 685 5TH AVE 1300 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 42 MH 59238 WEST 54TH ST/5TH AVE 1346 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 48 VOLT #04784 700 5TH AV 1491 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 186 MANHOLE 10878 IFO 25-27 W56TH ST 1934 feet to the N Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 62 25 WEST 56TH ST 25 WEST 56TH ST 1956 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 63 VAULT #2588 25-27 W 56TH ST 1961 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 73 MANHOLE 33909 57TH ST AND 5TH AVE 2041 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 141 743 743 FIFTH AVENUE 2092 feet to the N Closed Status Tank Test Failure 91 VAULT 2975 2 WEST 58TH ST 2338 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 220 MANHOLE #V167 IFO 1 W 58TH ST 2376 feet to the N Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 113 IFO 21 WEST 58 ST 2500 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 118 MH #58552 EAST 59TH ST & 5TH AVE 2547 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 132 W. 59TH ST/5TH AVE W. 59TH ST/5TH AVE 2547 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 123 ROADWAY 2 SO/5TH AVE 2607 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

272 55 E 52ND STREET 592 feet to the NNE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 273 INGES BEARING 55 E 52ND ST 12 FLOOR 592 feet to the NNE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 163 VAULT 443 71 E 55ST 1372 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 171 MANHOLE 50332 MADISON AVE/E 56TH ST 1641 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 58 MANHOLE 59454 MADISON AVENUE / EAST 57T 1895 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 185 MANHOLE #59454 MADISON AV & E 57TH ST 1895 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 59 FOUR SEASONS HOTEL 57 TH EST 1908 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 193 601 MADISON AVE/ 601 MADISON AVENUE 1983 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 204 MANHOLE 11300 EAST 58TH STREET/MADISON 2139 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 205 45 EAST 58TH STREET 45 EAST 58TH STREET 2167 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 97 IN FRONT OF 62 EAST 59TH ST 2401 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 102 S E CORNER AT MADISON AVENUE 2453 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 105 59 EAST 59TH ST 2460 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 106 MANHOLE 59453 MADISON AVENUE AT E 59 ST 2461 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 107 MANHOLE E 59TH ST & MADISON AV 2461 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 108 MANHOLE #58552 59TH ST & MADISON AV 2461 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 112 MANHOLE 58552 5TH AVE AND MADISON 2496 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

237 E 55 ST @ PARK AV E 55 ST @ PARK AV 1353 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 49 SERVICE BOX 10745 127 E55TH ST 1505 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 166 SERVICE BOX 17045 129 EAST 1519 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause)

238 VAULT 2831 101 E.56TH ST 1649 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 173 130 E 56TH ST 130 E 56TH ST 1715 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 174 440 PARK AVENUE 440 PARK AVENUE 1722 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 239 THE DRAKE HOTEL 440 PARK AVE 1722 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 177 MANHOLE 38745 56TH ST/LEXINGTON ST 1780 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 178 BET 140-150 EAST 56TH ST. BET 140-150 EAST 56TH ST 1783 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 20 686 LEXINGTON AVE 686 LEXINGTON AVE 1856 feet to the NE Active Tank Test Failure 241 CORNER OF LEXINGTON & 57 124 E 57TH ST 1931 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 64 COMMERCIAL BUILDING 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 130 AT A BUSINESS 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 189 130 EAST 57TH ST 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 68 136 57TH STREET 136 E 57TH STREET 1976 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 194 136 E. 57TH STREET 136 E. 57TH STREET 1994 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 195 MANHOLE #59825 LEXICTION AV & E 57TH ST 2003 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 9 142-148 EAST 57TH ST 142-148 EAST 57TH ST 2069 feet to the NE Active Tank Failure 79 470 PARK AVE 2145 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 81 MANHOLE 11322 E58TH ST/LEX & PARK 2191 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 210 MANHOLE 58TH ST/LEXINGTON AVE 2227 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 89 VAULT`S #0988-5687 & 5769 137 E 58TH ST/LEXINGTON 2268 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 109 VAULT 3165 107 EAST 59TH ST 2469 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

282 SUMITOMO CORP(DUPL SEE 015-NO1O6 INSTEAD 593 feet to the ENE Air Discharge Site 283 BRISTOL MYERS 345 PARK AVE 593 feet to the ENE Air Discharge Site 274 345 PARK CO 345 PARK AVE 596 feet to the ENE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 275 BRISTOL MYERS 345 PARK AVE 596 feet to the ENE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 32 EAST 53RD ST & LEXINGTON AVE 1111 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 159 135 EAST 135 EAST 54 ST. 1288 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 18 APARTMENT BLDG 135 E. 54TH ST 1292 feet to the ENE Active Tank Test Failure 38 VAULT 9376 130 EAST 54TH ST 1297 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 182 MANHOLE 45012 EAST 55TH ST / 3RD AVE 1836 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 60 EAST 56TH ST 201FT WEST OF 3RD AVE 1913 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 72 EAST 56TH ST/3RD AVE EAST 56TH ST/3RD AVE 2033 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 90 MANHOLE 45032 EAST 57TH ST/ 3RD AV 2269 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 214 MANHOLE 59816 E57TH ST/3RD AVE 2269 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 224 MANHOLE 11346 208 E 58TH ST 2503 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 119 VAULT 5611 E58TH ST / 201-13 E58TH S 2549 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 122 VIVILO RESTRUANT 228 E. 58TH STREET 2580 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 245 219 E 58TH ST/MANH/CON ED 219 EAST 58TH STREET 2590 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 6 CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK 321 EAST 63RD STREET 4136 feet to the ENE Hazardous Waste Treat, Storage, Disposal

155 MANHOLE 6262 163-65 EAST 52ND ST 1099 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 160 MANHOLE #59064 IFO 845 3RD AV 1310 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 40 3RD AVE BETWEEN EAST 51 & 52 ST 1321 feet to the E Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 162 MANHOLE #43976 EAST 52ND ST & 3RD AVE 1361 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 172 ABBANGTON HOLDING 237 EAST 1708 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 19 246 E 53RD ST 246 E 53RD ST 1741 feet to the E Active Tank Test Failure 242 992 2ND AVE 992 2ND AVE 2072 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 86 EAST 54TH ST & 2ND AV 2244 feet to the E Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 87 MANHOLE 54449 E 54TH ST & 2ND AV 2244 feet to the E Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 213 MANHOLE 55146 E54TH ST/2ND AV 2244 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 226 MANHOLE #24 E 56TH ST & 2ND AV 2536 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 17 333 EAST 55TH ST 333 EAST 55TH ST 2589 feet to the E Active Tank Failure 229 340 EAST 55TH STREET 340 EAST 55TH STREET 2614 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause)

230 315 E. 56TH ST 315 E. 56TH ST 2639 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 5 GOLDWATER MEMORIAL HOSPITAL ONE MAIN STREET 5190 feet to the E Major Oil Storage Facility

167 242 E. 50TH STREET 242 E. 50TH STREET 1544 feet to the ESE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 21 941 2ND AVE 1919 feet to the ESE Active Tank Test Failure 61 50TH ST/2ND AV 1949 feet to the ESE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 188 BUILDING AT EAST 50TH JUST W OF 2ND 1949 feet to the ESE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 192 J & M LEASING MNGMT 304 E 50TH STREET 1980 feet to the ESE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 71 309 EAST 49TH ST 309 EAST 49TH ST 2029 feet to the ESE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 197 311A EAST 51ST ST/MANH 311A EAST 2041 feet to the ESE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 12 337 EAST 50TH STREET 337 EAST 50TH STREET 2228 feet to the ESE Active Tank Failure 94 LANDRESS RESIDENCE 352 EAST 51ST ST 2364 feet to the ESE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

7 MARRIOT EAST HOTEL 525 LEXINGTON AVE 831 feet to the SE Active Tank Failure 41 VAULT 5813 201 EAST 48TH ST 1338 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 169 245 E 49TH ST/U N MISSION 245 E 49TH ST 1565 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 67 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH/2ND AVE 1972 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 190 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH/2ND AV 1972 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 191 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH ST/2ND AVE 1972 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 22 SOL GOLDMAN ESTATES 300 EAST 49TH ST 2003 feet to the SE Active Tank Test Failure 69 MANHOLE 5047 300 E 49TH ST 2003 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 70 MANHOLE 54384 2ND AV / E 48TH ST 2021 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 10 310 E 48TH ST/HERTZ 310 E 48TH ST 2101 feet to the SE Active Tank Failure 138 3 DAG PLAZA 305 EAST 47TH ST 2131 feet to the SE Closed Status Tank Failure 203 305 EAST / NE 305 E 47 ST 2131 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 111 VAULT #V1815 345 EAST 46TH ST 2482 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 223 V1815 339-353 E 46TH ST 2485 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause)

135 127 EAST 47TH ST 127 EAST 47TH ST 1072 feet to the SSE Closed Status Tank Failure 136 127 E. 47TH ST 127 E. 47TH ST 1072 feet to the SSE Closed Status Tank Failure 175 MANHOLE 43909 E 45TH ST & 3RD AV 1752 feet to the SSE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 55 NEW CONSTRUCTION SITE 205-209 EAST 45TH STREET 1758 feet to the SSE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 137 216 EAST 45TH ST/MANH 216 EAST 45TH STREET 1859 feet to the SSE Closed Status Tank Failure 57 VAULT #4018 703-719 3RD AV 1872 feet to the SSE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 184 227 E. 45TH STREET 227 EAST 45TH ST 1877 feet to the SSE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 78 MANHOLE IFO 230 E44TH ST 230 EAST 44TH STREET 2141 feet to the SSE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 11 APARTMENT BUILDING 245 EAST 44TH STREET 2174 feet to the SSE Active Tank Failure 95 CON EDISON - VAULT #5241 304 EAST 45TH ST 2374 feet to the SSE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

250 RICH D`ANGELO 280 PARK AVENUE 513 feet to the S Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 266 BANKERS TRUST SECURITIES 280 PARK AVENUE 513 feet to the S Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 233 METRO NORTH RAILROAD/MANH 48TH ST/GRAND CENTRAL STA 522 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 278 CITOH & CO INC 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 279 WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC CORP 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 280 CHASE MANHATTEN BANK 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 45 45 ST & LEXINGTON AVE 45TH ST / LEXINGTON AVE 1470 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 165 45TH ST & LEXINTON AVE MANHOLE AT 45TH ST & 1470 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 56 44TH STREET BETWEEN 3RD AND LEXINGTON 1841 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 65 MANHOLE #57881 3RD AVE/E 44 ST 1970 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 66 MANHOLE 57881 THIRD AVE/E 44 ST 1970 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 196 VAULT 3486 144 EAST 43 STREET 2027 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 199 EAST 43RD ST BET LEXINGTON AND 3RD AVE 2052 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 200 43RD BETWEEN 3RD & LEXING 2054 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause)

80 MANHOLE COVER 43RD ST /3 RD AVE 2171 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 82 E 42ND ST & LEXINGTON AV 2191 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 83 EAST 42ND ST&LEXINGTON AV E 42ND ST / LEXINGTON AVE 2191 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 207 SUBWAY,LEX&42ND-AVIS RENT LEXINGTON AVE / 42ND ST 2191 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 208 MANHOLE 56570 EAST 42ND ST/LEXINGTON AV 2191 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 13 225 EAST 43RD ST 225 EAST 43RD ST 2259 feet to the S Active Tank Failure 14 BUDGET RENT-A- CAR 225 EAST 43RD STREET 2259 feet to the S Active Tank Failure 215 MANHOLE #8242 150 E 42ND ST 2274 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 98 VAULT #5673 201 EAST 42ND ST 2401 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 104 MANHOLE #38626 E 41ST ST & LEXINGTON AV 2459 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

151 EAST 47TH ST AND PARK AVE 758 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 179 GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16& 3 GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16&3 1808 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 180 GRAND CENTRAL STATION TRACK #1 1808 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 74 47-65 EAST 2070 feet to the SSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 217 MH 4308 107 EAST 41ST ST 2341 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 93 MANHOLE #56305 EAST 41ST ST AND PARK AV 2357 feet to the SSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 218 MANHOLE 2394 E 41ST ST / PARK AV 2357 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 221 VAULT 3841 117 E. 41ST STREET 2378 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 103 VAULT 3108 120 E41ST STREET 2454 feet to the SSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

235 MANHATTAN PACIFIC 400 MADISON AVE 724 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 154 46TH ST/MADISON AV 1050 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 33 VAULT V4639 18 EAST 46TH STREET 1145 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 36 ROOSEVELT HOTEL 45 E 45TH ST 1257 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 50 MANHOLE #8595 IFO 22 E 44TH ST 1610 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 51 VAULT #`S 4593 & 3686 IFO 22 E 44TH ST 1610 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 53 VAULT 3686 16 EAST 44TH ST 1670 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 54 V#4567/3473/3686/4593 16 EAST 44TH ST 1670 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 176 MANHOLE 33819 44TH ST / 5TH AV 1752 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 187 43RD ST & 5TH AVE 43RD ST & 5TH AVE 1945 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 76 MANHOLE 50224 E42ND ST/MADISON AV 2112 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 84 MANHOLE 56635 W 42ND STREET & 5TH AVE 2235 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 85 VAULT 2691 WEST 42ND STREET AT 5TH A 2235 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 212 VAULT # 2520,2445,4719 9 W 42ND ST 2237 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 88 VAULT 4437 11 WEST 42ND ST 2246 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 244 501 501 5TH AVENUE 2253 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 216 VAULT #3525 301 MADISON AVE 2320 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 15 BETWEEN 40TH ST & 42 ND ST/MADISON AV 2355 feet to the SW Active Tank Failure 92 MANHOLE #50214 E 41S ST & MADISON AV 2355 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 99 UNK 485 5TH AVE 2406 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 222 MANHOLE MH50208 293 MADISON AV 2410 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 110 EAST 41ST ST & 5TH AV 2481 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 116 MANHOLE 50208 285 MADISON AV 2525 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 117 285 MADISON AVENUE 2525 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 120 VAULT 5891 471 5TH AV 2557 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 133 VAULT 4090 279-293 MADISON AV 2598 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause)

264 415 MADISON INC 415 MADISON AVE 476 feet to the WSW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 265 RUTH L WEINTRAUB INC 420 MADISON AVENUE 483 feet to the WSW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 149 GASOLINE ODOR, 13TH FLOOR 420 MADISON AVE,13TH FL. 487 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 25 MANHOLE 50263 E 48TH ST/MADISON AVE 539 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 234 MADISON AVE & 48TH STREET MADISON AVE & 48TH STREET 539 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause)

268 CON ED V3980-28 E 48TH ST 549 feet to the WSW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 31 ''' VS 4673''' 5TH AVE / EAST 47TH ST 1083 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 8 WEST 46TH ST & 5TH AVE WEST 46TH ST / 5TH AVE 1285 feet to the WSW Active Tank Failure 37 MANHOLE 8962 5 WEST 46TH ST 1287 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 161 VAULT #2074 2 EAST 46TH ST 1319 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 43 MANHOLE 56454 IFO 16-18 W46TH ST 1388 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 46 MANHOLE 120087 IFO 31-33 W46TH ST 1480 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 202 67 W 44TH ST 67 W 44TH ST 2113 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 206 / MAN 47 WEST 43 ST 2173 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 209 PIER 81 81 WEST 44 ST. 2213 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 219 MAN HOLE # 46678 WEST 44TH ST / 6TH AVE 2367 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 100 47 W 42ND ST 47 W 42ND ST 2417 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 101 47 WEST 42ND ST 47 WEST 42ND ST 2417 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

267 SWISS BANK TOWER 17 EAST 49TH ST 523 feet to the W Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 34 38 WEST 48TH ST 38 WEST 48TH ST 1189 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 1 ANCHOR CASTING CO INC. 38 W 48TH ST 1193 feet to the W CERCLIS Site 3 ANCHOR CASTING CO. 38 W. 48TH ST. 1204 feet to the W Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Site 35 MANHOLE 21 WEST 47TH ST 1224 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 157 42 WEST 48TH ST 42 WEST 48TH ST 1236 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 236 MH 09335 WEST 48TH ST/ROCKERFELL P 1252 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 164 DIAMOND EXCHNGE OF AMER 36 W 47 ST 1384 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 168 J & J GOLD 64 W 48 TH ST 1558 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 170 62 WEST 47TH STREET 62 WEST 47TH STREET 1620 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 52 46 WEST 46TH ST 1622 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 129 VAULT #6388 FRONT OF 61-77 W 46TH ST 1784 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 198 WEST 46TH ST & 6TH AVE WEST 46TH ST & 6TH AV E 2048 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 243 1177 AVE OF AMERICAS 1177 AVE OF AMERICAS 2088 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 211 MANHOLE 9124 132-134 W 47TH ST 2232 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 16 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY 150 W 47TH ST 2385 feet to the W Active Tank Failure 131 PENN ZONE MGT CO 155 WEST 46TH ST 2476 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 4 NEW YORK TIMES CO. 229 W 431ST STREET 3523 feet to the W Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Site 2 NEW YORK TIMES CO 229 W 43 ST 3530 feet to the W CERCLIS Site

281 SWISS BANK TOWER 10 E 50TH ST SUBCELLAR 646 feet to the WNW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 156 NBC STUDIOS 1A 32 1192 feet to the WNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 181 VAULT 8609 & 6705 WEST 49TH ST/6TH AVE 1820 feet to the WNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 183 MANHOLE 9322 W 48TH ST/6TH AVE 1857 feet to the WNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 77 MANHOLE #TM4654 137 WEST 49TH ST 2138 feet to the WNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 139 148 W 48TH ST/MANH/KINNEY 148 WEST 48TH ST 2281 feet to the WNW Closed Status Tank Failure 140 157 W 47TH ST/QUALITY INN 157 W 47TH ST 2420 feet to the WNW Closed Status Tank Failure

240 TIME & LIFE BLDG ROCK. CT 1271 AVE OF THE AMERICAS 1858 feet to the NW Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 142 53RD STREET POWER BLDG 126 W 53RD ST 2180 feet to the NW Closed Status Tank Test Failure 96 KINNEY GARAGE 149 W 53RD ST 2393 feet to the NW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 114 AVIS RENT A CAR 151 W 54TH ST 2507 feet to the NW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 115 AVIS CAR RENTAL 151 WEST 54TH ST 2507 feet to the NW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 23 AVIS RENT A CAR 153 WEST 54TH 2524 feet to the NW Active Tank Test Failure 143 AVIS RENT-A-CAR 153-155 W. 54TH ST 2524 feet to the NW Closed Status Tank Test Failure 144 153 W 54TH STREET 153 W 54TH STREET 2524 feet to the NW Closed Status Tank Test Failure 225 AVIS RENT-A-CAR 153 WEST 54TH STREET 2524 feet to the NW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause)

134 14 EAST 52ND STREET 14 EAST 52ND STREET 758 feet to the NNW Closed Status Tank Failure

26 OMNI HOTEL 21 E 52ND ST 778 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 152 OMNI BERKSHIRE PLACE HOTE 21 EAST 52ND STREET 778 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 29 MANHOLE 33871 E 52ND ST/5TH AVE 990 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 30 5 TH AV & E 52ND ST 990 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 158 MANHOLE 33885 680 FIFTH AV 1251 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 44 RESIDENCE 39 WEST 53RD ST 1459 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 47 43 WEST 53RD ST 1491 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 201 APT GAS LEAK 54 W.56TH ST APT 3B 2081 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 75 TRANSFORMER VAULT #VS3986 W 54TH ST - 1723 6TH AVE 2093 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 121 SERVICE BOX 10860 IFO 123 WEST 56TH ST 2564 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 227 SERVICE BOX 10860 123-125 W 56TH ST 2590 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 228 SB #10860 125 WEST 56TH ST 2599 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 124 100WEST 57TH ST/MANH 100 W. 57TH STREET 2617 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 125 MANHOLE #58457 W. 57TH ST & 6TH AVE 2623 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 126 MANHOLE #58470 6TH AVE & WEST 57TH ST 2623 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 127 MANHOLE 10858 131 WEST 56TH ST 2639 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

Identified Toxic Sites by Proximity

44- 50 E 50th Street, New York, NY 10022

* Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Approximate Map Distance & Direction Toxic Site Id# Site Name Site Street From Property Category ------24 304 PARK AVE 304 PARK AVE 208 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 231 300 PARK AVE 300 PARK AVE 239 feet to the SSE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 232 300 PARK AVE. 300 PARK AVE. 239 feet to the SSE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 252 COLGATE PALMOLIVE COMPANY 300 PARK AVE 245 feet to the SSE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 246 MUTUAL OF AMERICA BUILDING 320 PARK AVENUE 246 feet to the E Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 253 MUTUAL OF AMERICA BLDG THE 320 PARK AVE 246 feet to the E Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 247 THE NEW YORK PALACE 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 254 AMERICAN EAGLE FDR CORPORATION 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 255 HELMSLEY PALACE 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 128 VAULT 1371 100 EAST 50TH ST 278 feet to the ESE Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 145 CORNER OF 50TH ST AND MADISON AV 278 feet to the NW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 146 MADISON AV E 50TH ST 278 feet to the NW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 147 BOISE CASCADE CO/MANH 437 MASISON AVENUE 280 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 256 437 MADISON AVENUE FEE ASSOCIATES 437 MADISON AVENUE 286 feet to the W Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 257 HITACHI 437 MADISON AVE 32ND FL 286 feet to the W Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 258 KISS PHOTO INC 437 MADISON AVE 286 feet to the W Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 259 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V3054-F/O 48 E 49TH ST 300 feet to the WSW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 260 NEWSWEEK INC 444 MADISON AVE 312 feet to the WNW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 261 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V1362-49 E 51ST ST 322 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 248 299 PARK AVENUE 299 PARK AVENUE 330 feet to the SSE Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 262 WALDORF ASTORIA 301 PARK AVE 331 feet to the SSE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 263 CON EDISON @ WALDORF ASTORIA HILTON 301 PARK AVE 331 feet to the SSE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 148 NE CORNER OF E 49TH ST & MADISON AV 362 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 249 NEW DAWN DAVIDSON L.P. 477 MADISON AVENUE 425 feet to the N Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 264 415 MADISON INC 415 MADISON AVE 476 feet to the WSW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 265 RUTH L WEINTRAUB INC 420 MADISON AVENUE 483 feet to the WSW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 149 GASOLINE ODOR, 13TH FLOOR 420 MADISON AVE,13TH FL. 487 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 250 RICH D`ANGELO 280 PARK AVENUE 513 feet to the S Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 266 BANKERS TRUST SECURITIES 280 PARK AVENUE 513 feet to the S Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 233 METRO NORTH RAILROAD/MANH 48TH ST/GRAND CENTRAL STA 522 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 267 SWISS BANK TOWER 17 EAST 49TH ST 523 feet to the W Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 25 MANHOLE 50263 E 48TH ST/MADISON AVE 539 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 234 MADISON AVE & 48TH STREET MADISON AVE & 48TH STREET 539 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 150 488 MADISON AVE 488 MADISON AVE 543 feet to the N Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 268 CON ED V3980-28 E 48TH ST 549 feet to the WSW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 251 40 EAST COMPANY 40 EAST 52ND STREET 558 feet to the N Petroleum Bulk Storage Site 269 40 EASTCO 40 E 52ND ST 558 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 270 CON ED V1307-28 E 52ND ST 575 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 271 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V3838-28 E 52ND ST 587 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 272 PARK AVENUE PLAZA 55 E 52ND STREET 592 feet to the NNE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 273 INGES BEARING 55 E 52ND ST 12 FLOOR 592 feet to the NNE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 282 SUMITOMO CORP(DUPL SEE 015-NO1O6 INSTEAD 345 PARK AVENUE 593 feet to the ENE Air Discharge Site 283 BRISTOL MYERS 345 PARK AVE 593 feet to the ENE Air Discharge Site 274 345 PARK CO 345 PARK AVE 596 feet to the ENE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 275 BRISTOL MYERS 345 PARK AVE 596 feet to the ENE Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter

276 HANCO JEWELRY INC 501 MADISON AVE 612 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 277 CONSOLIDATED EDISON 8170975-24 E 52ND ST 614 feet to the N Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 278 CITOH & CO INC 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 279 WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC CORP 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 280 CHASE MANHATTEN BANK 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 281 SWISS BANK TOWER 10 E 50TH ST SUBCELLAR 646 feet to the WNW Hazardous Waste Generator/Transporter 235 MANHATTAN PACIFIC 400 MADISON AVE 724 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 134 14 EAST 52ND STREET 14 EAST 52ND STREET 758 feet to the NNW Closed Status Tank Failure 151 EAST 47TH ST AND PARK AVE 758 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 26 OMNI HOTEL 21 E 52ND ST 778 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 152 OMNI BERKSHIRE PLACE HOTE 21 EAST 52ND STREET 778 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 7 MARRIOT EAST HOTEL 525 LEXINGTON AVE 831 feet to the SE Active Tank Failure 27 MANHOLE #DMA5N-39 53RD ST & MADISON AVE 838 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 28 520 MADISON AV 965 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 153 MANHOLE #50134 520 MADISON AVE 965 feet to the N Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 29 MANHOLE 33871 E 52ND ST/5TH AVE 990 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 30 5 TH AV & E 52ND ST 990 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 154 46TH ST/MADISON AV 1050 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 135 127 EAST 47TH ST 127 EAST 47TH ST 1072 feet to the SSE Closed Status Tank Failure 136 127 E. 47TH ST 127 E. 47TH ST 1072 feet to the SSE Closed Status Tank Failure 31 ''' VS 4673''' 5TH AVE / EAST 47TH ST 1083 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 155 MANHOLE 6262 163-65 EAST 52ND ST 1099 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 32 EAST 53RD ST & LEXINGTON AVE 1111 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 33 VAULT V4639 18 EAST 46TH STREET 1145 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 34 38 WEST 48TH ST 38 WEST 48TH ST 1189 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 156 NBC STUDIOS 1A 32 ROCKEFELLER CENTER 1192 feet to the WNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 1 ANCHOR CASTING CO INC. 38 W 48TH ST 1193 feet to the W CERCLIS Site 3 ANCHOR CASTING CO. 38 W. 48TH ST. 1204 feet to the W Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Site 35 MANHOLE 21 WEST 47TH ST 1224 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 157 42 WEST 48TH ST 42 WEST 48TH ST 1236 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 158 MANHOLE 33885 680 FIFTH AV 1251 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 236 MH 09335 WEST 48TH ST/ROCKERFELL P 1252 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 36 ROOSEVELT HOTEL 45 E 45TH ST 1257 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 8 WEST 46TH ST & 5TH AVE WEST 46TH ST / 5TH AVE 1285 feet to the WSW Active Tank Failure 37 MANHOLE 8962 5 WEST 46TH ST 1287 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 159 135 EAST 54TH STREET 135 EAST 54 ST. 1288 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 18 APARTMENT BLDG 135 E. 54TH ST 1292 feet to the ENE Active Tank Test Failure 38 VAULT 9376 130 EAST 54TH ST 1297 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 39 VAULT #V185 685 5TH AVE 1300 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 160 MANHOLE #59064 IFO 845 3RD AV 1310 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 161 VAULT #2074 2 EAST 46TH ST 1319 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 40 3RD AVE BETWEEN EAST 51 & 52 ST 1321 feet to the E Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 41 VAULT 5813 201 EAST 48TH ST 1338 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 42 MH 59238 WEST 54TH ST/5TH AVE 1346 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 237 E 55 ST @ PARK AV E 55 ST @ PARK AV 1353 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 162 MANHOLE #43976 EAST 52ND ST & 3RD AVE 1361 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 163 VAULT 443 71 E 55ST 1372 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 164 DIAMOND EXCHNGE OF AMER 36 W 47 ST 1384 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 43 MANHOLE 56454 IFO 16-18 W46TH ST 1388 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 44 RESIDENCE 39 WEST 53RD ST 1459 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 45 45 ST & LEXINGTON AVE 45TH ST / LEXINGTON AVE 1470 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 165 45TH ST & LEXINTON AVE MANHOLE AT 45TH ST & 1470 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 46 MANHOLE 120087 IFO 31-33 W46TH ST 1480 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

47 43 WEST 53RD ST 1491 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 48 VOLT #04784 700 5TH AV 1491 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 49 SERVICE BOX 10745 127 E55TH ST 1505 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 166 SERVICE BOX 17045 129 EAST 55TH STREET 1519 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 167 242 E. 50TH STREET 242 E. 50TH STREET 1544 feet to the ESE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 168 J & J GOLD 64 W 48 TH ST 1558 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 169 245 E 49TH ST/U N MISSION 245 E 49TH ST 1565 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 50 MANHOLE #8595 IFO 22 E 44TH ST 1610 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 51 VAULT #`S 4593 & 3686 IFO 22 E 44TH ST 1610 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 170 62 WEST 47TH STREET 62 WEST 47TH STREET 1620 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 52 46 WEST 46TH ST 1622 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 171 MANHOLE 50332 MADISON AVE/E 56TH ST 1641 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 238 VAULT 2831 101 E.56TH ST 1649 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 53 VAULT 3686 16 EAST 44TH ST 1670 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 54 V#4567/3473/3686/4593 16 EAST 44TH ST 1670 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 172 ABBANGTON HOLDING 237 EAST 53RD STREET 1708 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 173 130 E 56TH ST 130 E 56TH ST 1715 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 174 440 PARK AVENUE 440 PARK AVENUE 1722 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 239 THE DRAKE HOTEL 440 PARK AVE 1722 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 19 246 E 53RD ST 246 E 53RD ST 1741 feet to the E Active Tank Test Failure 175 MANHOLE 43909 E 45TH ST & 3RD AV 1752 feet to the SSE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 176 MANHOLE 33819 44TH ST / 5TH AV 1752 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 55 NEW CONSTRUCTION SITE 205-209 EAST 45TH STREET 1758 feet to the SSE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 177 MANHOLE 38745 56TH ST/LEXINGTON ST 1780 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 178 BET 140-150 EAST 56TH ST. BET 140-150 EAST 56TH ST 1783 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 129 VAULT #6388 FRONT OF 61-77 W 46TH ST 1784 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 179 GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16& 3 GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16&3 1808 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 180 GRAND CENTRAL STATION TRACK #1 1808 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 181 VAULT 8609 & 6705 WEST 49TH ST/6TH AVE 1820 feet to the WNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 182 MANHOLE 45012 EAST 55TH ST / 3RD AVE 1836 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 56 44TH STREET BETWEEN 3RD AND LEXINGTON 1841 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 20 686 LEXINGTON AVE 686 LEXINGTON AVE 1856 feet to the NE Active Tank Test Failure 183 MANHOLE 9322 W 48TH ST/6TH AVE 1857 feet to the WNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 240 TIME & LIFE BLDG ROCK. CT 1271 AVE OF THE AMERICAS 1858 feet to the NW Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 137 216 EAST 45TH ST/MANH 216 EAST 45TH STREET 1859 feet to the SSE Closed Status Tank Failure 57 VAULT #4018 703-719 3RD AV 1872 feet to the SSE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 184 227 E. 45TH STREET 227 EAST 45TH ST 1877 feet to the SSE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 58 MANHOLE 59454 MADISON AVENUE / EAST 57T 1895 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 185 MANHOLE #59454 MADISON AV & E 57TH ST 1895 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 59 FOUR SEASONS HOTEL 57 TH EST 57TH STREET 1908 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 60 EAST 56TH ST 201FT WEST OF 3RD AVE 1913 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 21 941 2ND AVE 1919 feet to the ESE Active Tank Test Failure 241 CORNER OF LEXINGTON & 57 124 E 57TH ST 1931 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 186 MANHOLE 10878 IFO 25-27 W56TH ST 1934 feet to the N Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 187 43RD ST & 5TH AVE 43RD ST & 5TH AVE 1945 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 61 50TH ST/2ND AV 1949 feet to the ESE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 188 BUILDING AT EAST 50TH JUST W OF 2ND 1949 feet to the ESE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 62 25 WEST 56TH ST 25 WEST 56TH ST 1956 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 63 VAULT #2588 25-27 W 56TH ST 1961 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 64 COMMERCIAL BUILDING 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 130 AT A BUSINESS 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 189 130 EAST 57TH ST 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 65 MANHOLE #57881 3RD AVE/E 44 ST 1970 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause)

66 MANHOLE 57881 THIRD AVE/E 44 ST 1970 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 67 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH/2ND AVE 1972 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 190 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH/2ND AV 1972 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 191 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH ST/2ND AVE 1972 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 68 136 57TH STREET 136 E 57TH STREET 1976 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 192 J & M LEASING MNGMT 304 E 50TH STREET 1980 feet to the ESE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 193 601 MADISON AVE/MANHATTAN 601 MADISON AVENUE 1983 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 194 136 E. 57TH STREET 136 E. 57TH STREET 1994 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 22 SOL GOLDMAN ESTATES 300 EAST 49TH ST 2003 feet to the SE Active Tank Test Failure 69 MANHOLE 5047 300 E 49TH ST 2003 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 195 MANHOLE #59825 LEXICTION AV & E 57TH ST 2003 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 70 MANHOLE 54384 2ND AV / E 48TH ST 2021 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 196 VAULT 3486 144 EAST 43 STREET 2027 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 71 309 EAST 49TH ST 309 EAST 49TH ST 2029 feet to the ESE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 72 EAST 56TH ST/3RD AVE EAST 56TH ST/3RD AVE 2033 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 73 MANHOLE 33909 57TH ST AND 5TH AVE 2041 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 197 311A EAST 51ST ST/MANH 311A EAST 51ST STREET 2041 feet to the ESE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 198 WEST 46TH ST & 6TH AVE WEST 46TH ST & 6TH AV E 2048 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 199 EAST 43RD ST BET LEXINGTON AND 3RD AVE 2052 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 200 CHRYSLER BUILDING 43RD BETWEEN 3RD & LEXING 2054 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 9 142-148 EAST 57TH ST 142-148 EAST 57TH ST 2069 feet to the NE Active Tank Failure 74 47-65 EAST 42ND STREET 2070 feet to the SSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 242 992 2ND AVE 992 2ND AVE 2072 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 201 APT GAS LEAK 54 W.56TH ST APT 3B 2081 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 243 1177 AVE OF AMERICAS 1177 AVE OF AMERICAS 2088 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 141 743 FIFTH AVENUE 743 FIFTH AVENUE 2092 feet to the N Closed Status Tank Test Failure 75 TRANSFORMER VAULT #VS3986 W 54TH ST - 1723 6TH AVE 2093 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 10 310 E 48TH ST/HERTZ 310 E 48TH ST 2101 feet to the SE Active Tank Failure 76 MANHOLE 50224 E42ND ST/MADISON AV 2112 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 202 67 W 44TH ST 67 W 44TH ST 2113 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 138 3 DAG PLAZA 305 EAST 47TH ST 2131 feet to the SE Closed Status Tank Failure 203 305 EAST 47TH STREET / NE 305 E 47 ST 2131 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 77 MANHOLE #TM4654 137 WEST 49TH ST 2138 feet to the WNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 204 MANHOLE 11300 EAST 58TH STREET/MADISON 2139 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 78 MANHOLE IFO 230 E44TH ST 230 EAST 44TH STREET 2141 feet to the SSE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 79 470 PARK AVE 2145 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 205 45 EAST 58TH STREET 45 EAST 58TH STREET 2167 feet to the NNE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 80 MANHOLE COVER 43RD ST /3 RD AVE 2171 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 206 ROYALTON HOTEL / MAN 47 WEST 43 ST 2173 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 11 APARTMENT BUILDING 245 EAST 44TH STREET 2174 feet to the SSE Active Tank Failure 142 53RD STREET POWER BLDG 126 W 53RD ST 2180 feet to the NW Closed Status Tank Test Failure 81 MANHOLE 11322 E58TH ST/LEX & PARK 2191 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 82 E 42ND ST & LEXINGTON AV 2191 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 83 EAST 42ND ST&LEXINGTON AV E 42ND ST / LEXINGTON AVE 2191 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 207 SUBWAY,LEX&42ND-AVIS RENT LEXINGTON AVE / 42ND ST 2191 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 208 MANHOLE 56570 EAST 42ND ST/LEXINGTON AV 2191 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 209 PIER 81 81 WEST 44 ST. 2213 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 210 MANHOLE 58TH ST/LEXINGTON AVE 2227 feet to the NE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 12 337 EAST 50TH STREET 337 EAST 50TH STREET 2228 feet to the ESE Active Tank Failure 211 MANHOLE 9124 132-134 W 47TH ST 2232 feet to the W Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 84 MANHOLE 56635 W 42ND STREET & 5TH AVE 2235 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 85 VAULT 2691 WEST 42ND STREET AT 5TH A 2235 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 212 VAULT # 2520,2445,4719 9 W 42ND ST 2237 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause)

86 EAST 54TH ST & 2ND AV 2244 feet to the E Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 87 MANHOLE 54449 E 54TH ST & 2ND AV 2244 feet to the E Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 213 MANHOLE 55146 E54TH ST/2ND AV 2244 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 88 VAULT 4437 11 WEST 42ND ST 2246 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 244 501 501 5TH AVENUE 2253 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 13 225 EAST 43RD ST 225 EAST 43RD ST 2259 feet to the S Active Tank Failure 14 BUDGET RENT-A- CAR 225 EAST 43RD STREET 2259 feet to the S Active Tank Failure 89 VAULT`S #0988-5687 & 5769 137 E 58TH ST/LEXINGTON 2268 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 90 MANHOLE 45032 EAST 57TH ST/ 3RD AV 2269 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 214 MANHOLE 59816 E57TH ST/3RD AVE 2269 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 215 MANHOLE #8242 150 E 42ND ST 2274 feet to the S Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 139 148 W 48TH ST/MANH/KINNEY 148 WEST 48TH ST 2281 feet to the WNW Closed Status Tank Failure 216 VAULT #3525 301 MADISON AVE 2320 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 91 VAULT 2975 2 WEST 58TH ST 2338 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 217 MH 4308 107 EAST 41ST ST 2341 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 15 BETWEEN 40TH ST & 42 ND ST/MADISON AV 2355 feet to the SW Active Tank Failure 92 MANHOLE #50214 E 41S ST & MADISON AV 2355 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 93 MANHOLE #56305 EAST 41ST ST AND PARK AV 2357 feet to the SSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 218 MANHOLE 2394 E 41ST ST / PARK AV 2357 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 94 LANDRESS RESIDENCE 352 EAST 51ST ST 2364 feet to the ESE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 219 MAN HOLE # 46678 WEST 44TH ST / 6TH AVE 2367 feet to the WSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 95 CON EDISON - VAULT #5241 304 EAST 45TH ST 2374 feet to the SSE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 220 MANHOLE #V167 IFO 1 W 58TH ST 2376 feet to the N Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 221 VAULT 3841 117 E. 41ST STREET 2378 feet to the SSW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 16 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY 150 W 47TH ST 2385 feet to the W Active Tank Failure 96 KINNEY GARAGE 149 W 53RD ST 2393 feet to the NW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 97 IN FRONT OF 62 EAST 59TH ST 2401 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 98 VAULT #5673 201 EAST 42ND ST 2401 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 99 UNK 485 5TH AVE 2406 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 222 MANHOLE MH50208 293 MADISON AV 2410 feet to the SW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 100 47 W 42ND ST 47 W 42ND ST 2417 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 101 47 WEST 42ND ST 47 WEST 42ND ST 2417 feet to the WSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 140 157 W 47TH ST/QUALITY INN 157 W 47TH ST 2420 feet to the WNW Closed Status Tank Failure 102 S E CORNER 59TH STREET AT MADISON AVENUE 2453 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 103 VAULT 3108 120 E41ST STREET 2454 feet to the SSW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 104 MANHOLE #38626 E 41ST ST & LEXINGTON AV 2459 feet to the S Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 105 59 EAST 59TH ST 2460 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 106 MANHOLE 59453 MADISON AVENUE AT E 59 ST 2461 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 107 MANHOLE E 59TH ST & MADISON AV 2461 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 108 MANHOLE #58552 59TH ST & MADISON AV 2461 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 109 VAULT 3165 107 EAST 59TH ST 2469 feet to the NE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 131 PENN ZONE MGT CO 155 WEST 46TH ST 2476 feet to the W Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 110 EAST 41ST ST & 5TH AV 2481 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 111 VAULT #V1815 345 EAST 46TH ST 2482 feet to the SE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 223 V1815 339-353 E 46TH ST 2485 feet to the SE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 112 MANHOLE 58552 5TH AVE AND MADISON 2496 feet to the NNE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 113 IFO 21 WEST 58 ST 2500 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 224 MANHOLE 11346 208 E 58TH ST 2503 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 114 AVIS RENT A CAR 151 W 54TH ST 2507 feet to the NW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 115 AVIS CAR RENTAL 151 WEST 54TH ST 2507 feet to the NW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 23 AVIS RENT A CAR 153 WEST 54TH 2524 feet to the NW Active Tank Test Failure 143 AVIS RENT-A-CAR 153-155 W. 54TH ST 2524 feet to the NW Closed Status Tank Test Failure 144 153 W 54TH STREET 153 W 54TH STREET 2524 feet to the NW Closed Status Tank Test Failure

225 AVIS RENT-A-CAR 153 WEST 54TH STREET 2524 feet to the NW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 116 MANHOLE 50208 285 MADISON AV 2525 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 117 285 MADISON AVENUE 2525 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 226 MANHOLE #24 E 56TH ST & 2ND AV 2536 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 118 MH #58552 EAST 59TH ST & 5TH AVE 2547 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 132 W. 59TH ST/5TH AVE W. 59TH ST/5TH AVE 2547 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 119 VAULT 5611 E58TH ST / 201-13 E58TH S 2549 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 120 VAULT 5891 471 5TH AV 2557 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 121 SERVICE BOX 10860 IFO 123 WEST 56TH ST 2564 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 122 VIVILO RESTRUANT 228 E. 58TH STREET 2580 feet to the ENE Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 17 333 EAST 55TH ST 333 EAST 55TH ST 2589 feet to the E Active Tank Failure 227 SERVICE BOX 10860 123-125 W 56TH ST 2590 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 245 219 E 58TH ST/MANH/CON ED 219 EAST 58TH STREET 2590 feet to the ENE Closed Status Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 133 VAULT 4090 279-293 MADISON AV 2598 feet to the SW Active Haz Spill (Misc. Spill Cause) 228 SB #10860 125 WEST 56TH ST 2599 feet to the NNW Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 123 ROADWAY 2 CENTRAL PARK SO/5TH AVE 2607 feet to the N Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 229 340 EAST 55TH STREET 340 EAST 55TH STREET 2614 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 124 100WEST 57TH ST/MANH 100 W. 57TH STREET 2617 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 125 MANHOLE #58457 W. 57TH ST & 6TH AVE 2623 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 126 MANHOLE #58470 6TH AVE & WEST 57TH ST 2623 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 127 MANHOLE 10858 131 WEST 56TH ST 2639 feet to the NNW Active Haz Spill (Unknown/Other Cause) 230 315 E. 56TH ST 315 E. 56TH ST 2639 feet to the E Closed Status Spill (Unk/Other Cause) 4 NEW YORK TIMES CO. 229 W 431ST STREET 3523 feet to the W Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Site 2 NEW YORK TIMES CO 229 W 43 ST 3530 feet to the W CERCLIS Site 6 CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK 321 EAST 63RD STREET 4136 feet to the ENE Hazardous Waste Treat, Storage, Disposal 5 GOLDWATER MEMORIAL HOSPITAL ONE MAIN STREET 5190 feet to the E Major Oil Storage Facility

Identified Toxic Sites by Category

44- 50 E 50th Street New York, NY 10022

* Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

CERCLIS Sites MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 1 NYD001617059 ANCHOR CASTING CO INC. 38 W 48TH ST 1193 feet to the W 2 NYD001315613 NEW YORK TIMES CO 229 W 43 ST 3530 feet to the W

Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Sites MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 3 ANCHOR CASTING CO. 38 W. 48TH ST. 1204 feet to the W 4 NEW YORK TIMES CO. 229 W 431ST STREET 3523 feet to the W

Major Oil Storage Facilities MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 5 2-2640 GOLDWATER MEMORIAL HOSPITAL ONE MAIN STREET 5190 feet to the E

Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage, Disposal Facilities MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 6 NYD982270043 CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK 321 EAST 63RD STREET 4136 feet to the ENE

Active Tank Failures MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 7 0109979 MARRIOT EAST HOTEL 525 LEXINGTON AVE 831 feet to the SE 8 9415266 WEST 46TH ST & 5TH AVE WEST 46TH ST / 5TH AVE 1285 feet to the WSW 9 9705231 142-148 EAST 57TH ST 142-148 EAST 57TH ST 2069 feet to the NE 10 9201045 310 E 48TH ST/HERTZ 310 E 48TH ST 2101 feet to the SE 11 0012794 APARTMENT BUILDING 245 EAST 44TH STREET 2174 feet to the SSE 12 0202387 337 EAST 50TH STREET 337 EAST 50TH STREET 2228 feet to the ESE 13 9408906 225 EAST 43RD ST 225 EAST 43RD ST 2259 feet to the S 14 9403751 BUDGET RENT-A- CAR 225 EAST 43RD STREET 2259 feet to the S 15 0205816 BETWEEN 40TH ST & 42 ND ST/MADISON AV 2355 feet to the SW 16 0007888 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY 150 W 47TH ST 2385 feet to the W 17 9712107 333 EAST 55TH ST 333 EAST 55TH ST 2589 feet to the E

Active Tank Test Failures MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 18 9800437 APARTMENT BLDG 135 E. 54TH ST 1292 feet to the ENE 19 9800497 246 E 53RD ST 246 E 53RD ST 1741 feet to the E 20 9508097 686 LEXINGTON AVE 686 LEXINGTON AVE 1856 feet to the NE 21 0212048 941 2ND AVE 1919 feet to the ESE 22 9612022 SOL GOLDMAN ESTATES 300 EAST 49TH ST 2003 feet to the SE 23 0110774 AVIS RENT A CAR 153 WEST 54TH 2524 feet to the NW

Active Haz Spills (Unknown Causes & Other Causes) MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 24 9814533 304 PARK AVE 304 PARK AVE 208 feet to the SE 25 0205867 MANHOLE 50263 E 48TH ST/MADISON AVE 539 feet to the WSW 26 0211613 OMNI HOTEL 21 E 52ND ST 778 feet to the NNW 27 9909928 MANHOLE #DMA5N-39 53RD ST & MADISON AVE 838 feet to the N 28 0009194 520 MADISON AV 965 feet to the N

29 9808714 MANHOLE 33871 E 52ND ST/5TH AVE 990 feet to the NNW 30 0204373 5 TH AV & E 52ND ST 990 feet to the NNW 31 0211713 ''' VS 4673''' 5TH AVE / EAST 47TH ST 1083 feet to the WSW 32 0201567 EAST 53RD ST & LEXINGTON AVE 1111 feet to the ENE 33 0001456 VAULT V4639 18 EAST 46TH STREET 1145 feet to the SW 34 9415241 38 WEST 48TH ST 38 WEST 48TH ST 1189 feet to the W 35 0001541 MANHOLE 21 WEST 47TH ST 1224 feet to the W 36 9912831 ROOSEVELT HOTEL 45 E 45TH ST 1257 feet to the SW 37 9809369 MANHOLE 8962 5 WEST 46TH ST 1287 feet to the WSW 38 0108646 VAULT 9376 130 EAST 54TH ST 1297 feet to the ENE 39 0000146 VAULT #V185 685 5TH AVE 1300 feet to the N 40 9713229 3RD AVE BETWEEN EAST 51 & 52 ST 1321 feet to the E 41 0001394 VAULT 5813 201 EAST 48TH ST 1338 feet to the SE 42 0001685 MH 59238 WEST 54TH ST/5TH AVE 1346 feet to the N 43 9807861 MANHOLE 56454 IFO 16-18 W46TH ST 1388 feet to the WSW 44 9803776 RESIDENCE 39 WEST 53RD ST 1459 feet to the NNW 45 9402500 45 ST & LEXINGTON AVE 45TH ST / LEXINGTON AVE 1470 feet to the S 46 9807871 MANHOLE 120087 IFO 31-33 W46TH ST 1480 feet to the WSW 47 0105782 43 WEST 53RD ST 1491 feet to the NNW 48 0300255 VOLT #04784 700 5TH AV 1491 feet to the N 49 9807873 SERVICE BOX 10745 127 E55TH ST 1505 feet to the NE 50 9906387 MANHOLE #8595 IFO 22 E 44TH ST 1610 feet to the SW 51 9906386 VAULT #`S 4593 & 3686 IFO 22 E 44TH ST 1610 feet to the SW 52 9909408 46 WEST 46TH ST 1622 feet to the W 53 9901455 VAULT 3686 16 EAST 44TH ST 1670 feet to the SW 54 9814094 V#4567/3473/3686/4593 16 EAST 44TH ST 1670 feet to the SW 55 0110276 NEW CONSTRUCTION SITE 205-209 EAST 45TH STREET 1758 feet to the SSE 56 0012892 44TH STREET BETWEEN 3RD AND LEXINGTON 1841 feet to the S 57 9808688 VAULT #4018 703-719 3RD AV 1872 feet to the SSE 58 9813265 MANHOLE 59454 MADISON AVENUE / EAST 57T 1895 feet to the NNE 59 9800666 FOUR SEASONS HOTEL 57 TH EST 57TH STREET 1908 feet to the NNE 60 9807357 EAST 56TH ST 201FT WEST OF 3RD AVE 1913 feet to the ENE 61 0203871 50TH ST/2ND AV 1949 feet to the ESE 62 9704066 25 WEST 56TH ST 25 WEST 56TH ST 1956 feet to the N 63 0100269 VAULT #2588 25-27 W 56TH ST 1961 feet to the N 64 9605869 COMMERCIAL BUILDING 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE 65 9810038 MANHOLE #57881 3RD AVE/E 44 ST 1970 feet to the S 66 9808720 MANHOLE 57881 THIRD AVE/E 44 ST 1970 feet to the S 67 0011448 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH/2ND AVE 1972 feet to the SE 68 9404041 136 57TH STREET 136 E 57TH STREET 1976 feet to the NE 69 0006000 MANHOLE 5047 300 E 49TH ST 2003 feet to the SE 70 0013307 MANHOLE 54384 2ND AV / E 48TH ST 2021 feet to the SE 71 9713117 309 EAST 49TH ST 309 EAST 49TH ST 2029 feet to the ESE 72 9513776 EAST 56TH ST/3RD AVE EAST 56TH ST/3RD AVE 2033 feet to the ENE 73 9516135 MANHOLE 33909 57TH ST AND 5TH AVE 2041 feet to the N 74 9812883 47-65 EAST 42ND STREET 2070 feet to the SSW 75 0202676 TRANSFORMER VAULT #VS3986 W 54TH ST - 1723 6TH AVE 2093 feet to the NNW 76 0107696 MANHOLE 50224 E42ND ST/MADISON AV 2112 feet to the SW 77 0107611 MANHOLE #TM4654 137 WEST 49TH ST 2138 feet to the WNW 78 9509012 MANHOLE IFO 230 E44TH ST 230 EAST 44TH STREET 2141 feet to the SSE 79 0111965 470 PARK AVE 2145 feet to the NE 80 9613010 MANHOLE COVER 43RD ST /3 RD AVE 2171 feet to the S 81 0101292 MANHOLE 11322 E58TH ST/LEX & PARK 2191 feet to the NE

82 9908420 E 42ND ST & LEXINGTON AV 2191 feet to the S 83 8807301 EAST 42ND ST&LEXINGTON AV E 42ND ST / LEXINGTON AVE 2191 feet to the S 84 9908081 MANHOLE 56635 W 42ND STREET & 5TH AVE 2235 feet to the SW 85 0107855 VAULT 2691 WEST 42ND STREET AT 5TH A 2235 feet to the SW 86 0003665 EAST 54TH ST & 2ND AV 2244 feet to the E 87 0003627 MANHOLE 54449 E 54TH ST & 2ND AV 2244 feet to the E 88 0001537 VAULT 4437 11 WEST 42ND ST 2246 feet to the SW 89 0206866 VAULT`S #0988-5687 & 5769 137 E 58TH ST/LEXINGTON 2268 feet to the NE 90 9808781 MANHOLE 45032 EAST 57TH ST/ 3RD AV 2269 feet to the ENE 91 0211679 VAULT 2975 2 WEST 58TH ST 2338 feet to the N 92 9808363 MANHOLE #50214 E 41S ST & MADISON AV 2355 feet to the SW 93 9812822 MANHOLE #56305 EAST 41ST ST AND PARK AV 2357 feet to the SSW 94 9811966 LANDRESS RESIDENCE 352 EAST 51ST ST 2364 feet to the ESE 95 9503056 CON EDISON - VAULT #5241 304 EAST 45TH ST 2374 feet to the SSE 96 0000584 KINNEY GARAGE 149 W 53RD ST 2393 feet to the NW 97 9703310 IN FRONT OF 62 EAST 59TH ST 2401 feet to the NNE 98 0205533 VAULT #5673 201 EAST 42ND ST 2401 feet to the S 99 0111384 UNK 485 5TH AVE 2406 feet to the SW 100 9608924 47 W 42ND ST 47 W 42ND ST 2417 feet to the WSW 101 9608915 47 WEST 42ND ST 47 WEST 42ND ST 2417 feet to the WSW 102 9808174 S E CORNER 59TH STREET AT MADISON AVENUE 2453 feet to the NNE 103 0008959 VAULT 3108 120 E41ST STREET 2454 feet to the SSW 104 0102080 MANHOLE #38626 E 41ST ST & LEXINGTON AV 2459 feet to the S 105 0104580 59 EAST 59TH ST 2460 feet to the NNE 106 9811112 MANHOLE 59453 MADISON AVENUE AT E 59 ST 2461 feet to the NNE 107 9808245 MANHOLE E 59TH ST & MADISON AV 2461 feet to the NNE 108 0006356 MANHOLE #58552 59TH ST & MADISON AV 2461 feet to the NNE 109 9911617 VAULT 3165 107 EAST 59TH ST 2469 feet to the NE 110 0005663 EAST 41ST ST & 5TH AV 2481 feet to the SW 111 0301704 VAULT #V1815 345 EAST 46TH ST 2482 feet to the SE 112 0105780 MANHOLE 58552 5TH AVE AND MADISON 2496 feet to the NNE 113 9808191 IFO 21 WEST 58 ST 2500 feet to the N 114 0105770 AVIS RENT A CAR 151 W 54TH ST 2507 feet to the NW 115 0105202 AVIS CAR RENTAL 151 WEST 54TH ST 2507 feet to the NW 116 9808292 MANHOLE 50208 285 MADISON AV 2525 feet to the SW 117 9807983 285 MADISON AVENUE 2525 feet to the SW 118 0002859 MH #58552 EAST 59TH ST & 5TH AVE 2547 feet to the N 119 0106197 VAULT 5611 E58TH ST / 201-13 E58TH S 2549 feet to the ENE 120 0300002 VAULT 5891 471 5TH AV 2557 feet to the SW 121 0105812 SERVICE BOX 10860 IFO 123 WEST 56TH ST 2564 feet to the NNW 122 0010767 VIVILO RESTRUANT 228 E. 58TH STREET 2580 feet to the ENE 123 0105958 ROADWAY 2 CENTRAL PARK SO/5TH AVE 2607 feet to the N 124 9007702 100WEST 57TH ST/MANH 100 W. 57TH STREET 2617 feet to the NNW 125 9811172 MANHOLE #58457 W. 57TH ST & 6TH AVE 2623 feet to the NNW 126 0204650 MANHOLE #58470 6TH AVE & WEST 57TH ST 2623 feet to the NNW 127 0005658 MANHOLE 10858 131 WEST 56TH ST 2639 feet to the NNW

Active Haz Spills (Miscellaneous Spill Causes) MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 128 0206550 VAULT 1371 100 EAST 50TH ST 278 feet to the ESE 129 0102605 VAULT #6388 FRONT OF 61-77 W 46TH ST 1784 feet to the W 130 9605914 AT A BUSINESS 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE 131 9510173 PENN ZONE MGT CO 155 WEST 46TH ST 2476 feet to the W

132 8303210 W. 59TH ST/5TH AVE W. 59TH ST/5TH AVE 2547 feet to the N 133 9906368 VAULT 4090 279-293 MADISON AV 2598 feet to the SW

Closed Status Tank Failures MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 134 9500659 14 EAST 52ND STREET 14 EAST 52ND STREET 758 feet to the NNW 135 9510310 127 EAST 47TH ST 127 EAST 47TH ST 1072 feet to the SSE 136 9411387 127 E. 47TH ST 127 E. 47TH ST 1072 feet to the SSE 137 9006446 216 EAST 45TH ST/MANH 216 EAST 45TH STREET 1859 feet to the SSE 138 0106894 3 DAG PLAZA 305 EAST 47TH ST 2131 feet to the SE 139 8707661 148 W 48TH ST/MANH/KINNEY 148 WEST 48TH ST 2281 feet to the WNW 140 9105450 157 W 47TH ST/QUALITY INN 157 W 47TH ST 2420 feet to the WNW

Closed Status Tank Test Failures MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 141 8908142 743 FIFTH AVENUE 743 FIFTH AVENUE 2092 feet to the N 142 9106500 53RD STREET POWER BLDG 126 W 53RD ST 2180 feet to the NW 143 9408988 AVIS RENT-A-CAR 153-155 W. 54TH ST 2524 feet to the NW 144 9200119 153 W 54TH STREET 153 W 54TH STREET 2524 feet to the NW

Closed Status Spills (Unknown Causes & Other Causes) MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 145 9701627 CORNER OF 50TH ST AND MADISON AV 278 feet to the NW 146 0202945 MADISON AV E 50TH ST 278 feet to the NW 147 8905629 BOISE CASCADE CO/MANH 437 MASISON AVENUE 280 feet to the W 148 0008260 NE CORNER OF E 49TH ST & MADISON AV 362 feet to the W 149 8605007 GASOLINE ODOR, 13TH FLOOR 420 MADISON AVE,13TH FL. 487 feet to the WSW 150 9609220 488 MADISON AVE 488 MADISON AVE 543 feet to the N 151 9801898 EAST 47TH ST AND PARK AVE 758 feet to the SSW 152 9811051 OMNI BERKSHIRE PLACE HOTE 21 EAST 52ND STREET 778 feet to the NNW 153 9815387 MANHOLE #50134 520 MADISON AVE 965 feet to the N 154 0001502 46TH ST/MADISON AV 1050 feet to the SW 155 0006897 MANHOLE 6262 163-65 EAST 52ND ST 1099 feet to the E 156 0103973 NBC STUDIOS 1A 32 ROCKEFELLER CENTER 1192 feet to the WNW 157 9600843 42 WEST 48TH ST 42 WEST 48TH ST 1236 feet to the W 158 0012137 MANHOLE 33885 680 FIFTH AV 1251 feet to the NNW 159 9314880 135 EAST 54TH STREET 135 EAST 54 ST. 1288 feet to the ENE 160 0012410 MANHOLE #59064 IFO 845 3RD AV 1310 feet to the E 161 9912761 VAULT #2074 2 EAST 46TH ST 1319 feet to the WSW 162 0011596 MANHOLE #43976 EAST 52ND ST & 3RD AVE 1361 feet to the E 163 9911299 VAULT 443 71 E 55ST 1372 feet to the NNE 164 8803206 DIAMOND EXCHNGE OF AMER 36 W 47 ST 1384 feet to the W 165 9402544 45TH ST & LEXINTON AVE MANHOLE AT 45TH ST & 1470 feet to the S 166 9815399 SERVICE BOX 17045 129 EAST 55TH STREET 1519 feet to the NE 167 9406395 242 E. 50TH STREET 242 E. 50TH STREET 1544 feet to the ESE 168 9510519 J & J GOLD 64 W 48 TH ST 1558 feet to the W 169 9205055 245 E 49TH ST/U N MISSION 245 E 49TH ST 1565 feet to the SE 170 9507123 62 WEST 47TH STREET 62 WEST 47TH STREET 1620 feet to the W 171 0011620 MANHOLE 50332 MADISON AVE/E 56TH ST 1641 feet to the NNE 172 9414433 ABBANGTON HOLDING 237 EAST 53RD STREET 1708 feet to the E 173 9512831 130 E 56TH ST 130 E 56TH ST 1715 feet to the NE 174 9313137 440 PARK AVENUE 440 PARK AVENUE 1722 feet to the NE 175 9900485 MANHOLE 43909 E 45TH ST & 3RD AV 1752 feet to the SSE

176 0006696 MANHOLE 33819 44TH ST / 5TH AV 1752 feet to the SW 177 0004168 MANHOLE 38745 56TH ST/LEXINGTON ST 1780 feet to the NE 178 9314441 BET 140-150 EAST 56TH ST. BET 140-150 EAST 56TH ST 1783 feet to the NE 179 9212241 GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16& 3 GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16&3 1808 feet to the SSW 180 0108498 GRAND CENTRAL STATION TRACK #1 1808 feet to the SSW 181 0004214 VAULT 8609 & 6705 WEST 49TH ST/6TH AVE 1820 feet to the WNW 182 9909287 MANHOLE 45012 EAST 55TH ST / 3RD AVE 1836 feet to the ENE 183 0008319 MANHOLE 9322 W 48TH ST/6TH AVE 1857 feet to the WNW 184 9502002 227 E. 45TH STREET 227 EAST 45TH ST 1877 feet to the SSE 185 9910067 MANHOLE #59454 MADISON AV & E 57TH ST 1895 feet to the NNE 186 0100278 MANHOLE 10878 IFO 25-27 W56TH ST 1934 feet to the N 187 9609015 43RD ST & 5TH AVE 43RD ST & 5TH AVE 1945 feet to the SW 188 9608495 BUILDING AT EAST 50TH JUST W OF 2ND 1949 feet to the ESE 189 9605857 130 EAST 57TH ST 130 EAST 57TH ST 1961 feet to the NE 190 0011785 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH/2ND AV 1972 feet to the SE 191 0010752 MANHOLE 54394 EAST 49TH ST/2ND AVE 1972 feet to the SE 192 8911382 J & M LEASING MNGMT 304 E 50TH STREET 1980 feet to the ESE 193 8903090 601 MADISON AVE/MANHATTAN 601 MADISON AVENUE 1983 feet to the NNE 194 9309337 136 E. 57TH STREET 136 E. 57TH STREET 1994 feet to the NE 195 0202413 MANHOLE #59825 LEXICTION AV & E 57TH ST 2003 feet to the NE 196 9808734 VAULT 3486 144 EAST 43 STREET 2027 feet to the S 197 9005948 311A EAST 51ST ST/MANH 311A EAST 51ST STREET 2041 feet to the ESE 198 9415274 WEST 46TH ST & 6TH AVE WEST 46TH ST & 6TH AV E 2048 feet to the W 199 9709888 EAST 43RD ST BET LEXINGTON AND 3RD AVE 2052 feet to the S 200 9813493 CHRYSLER BUILDING 43RD BETWEEN 3RD & LEXING 2054 feet to the S 201 0130037 APT GAS LEAK 54 W.56TH ST APT 3B 2081 feet to the NNW 202 9714466 67 W 44TH ST 67 W 44TH ST 2113 feet to the WSW 203 8701653 305 EAST 47TH STREET / NE 305 E 47 ST 2131 feet to the SE 204 9902179 MANHOLE 11300 EAST 58TH STREET/MADISON 2139 feet to the NNE 205 9609211 45 EAST 58TH STREET 45 EAST 58TH STREET 2167 feet to the NNE 206 8909227 ROYALTON HOTEL / MAN 47 WEST 43 ST 2173 feet to the WSW 207 7900470 SUBWAY,LEX&42ND-AVIS RENT LEXINGTON AVE / 42ND ST 2191 feet to the S 208 0101798 MANHOLE 56570 EAST 42ND ST/LEXINGTON AV 2191 feet to the S 209 0330008 PIER 81 81 WEST 44 ST. 2213 feet to the WSW 210 0207213 MANHOLE 58TH ST/LEXINGTON AVE 2227 feet to the NE 211 9902961 MANHOLE 9124 132-134 W 47TH ST 2232 feet to the W 212 0203415 VAULT # 2520,2445,4719 9 W 42ND ST 2237 feet to the SW 213 0012018 MANHOLE 55146 E54TH ST/2ND AV 2244 feet to the E 214 0100929 MANHOLE 59816 E57TH ST/3RD AVE 2269 feet to the ENE 215 0100197 MANHOLE #8242 150 E 42ND ST 2274 feet to the S 216 0009256 VAULT #3525 301 MADISON AVE 2320 feet to the SW 217 0008035 MH 4308 107 EAST 41ST ST 2341 feet to the SSW 218 0012974 MANHOLE 2394 E 41ST ST / PARK AV 2357 feet to the SSW 219 9901355 MAN HOLE # 46678 WEST 44TH ST / 6TH AVE 2367 feet to the WSW 220 0012138 MANHOLE #V167 IFO 1 W 58TH ST 2376 feet to the N 221 9815344 VAULT 3841 117 E. 41ST STREET 2378 feet to the SSW 222 9906379 MANHOLE MH50208 293 MADISON AV 2410 feet to the SW 223 0001391 V1815 339-353 E 46TH ST 2485 feet to the SE 224 0104765 MANHOLE 11346 208 E 58TH ST 2503 feet to the ENE 225 9604355 AVIS RENT-A-CAR 153 WEST 54TH STREET 2524 feet to the NW 226 0009105 MANHOLE #24 E 56TH ST & 2ND AV 2536 feet to the E 227 0005391 SERVICE BOX 10860 123-125 W 56TH ST 2590 feet to the NNW 228 0006100 SB #10860 125 WEST 56TH ST 2599 feet to the NNW

229 9711625 340 EAST 55TH STREET 340 EAST 55TH STREET 2614 feet to the E 230 9408873 315 E. 56TH ST 315 E. 56TH ST 2639 feet to the E

Closed Status Spills (Miscellaneous Spill Causes) MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 231 9706311 300 PARK AVE 300 PARK AVE 239 feet to the SSE 232 8911006 300 PARK AVE. 300 PARK AVE. 239 feet to the SSE 233 8807268 METRO NORTH RAILROAD/MANH 48TH ST/GRAND CENTRAL STA 522 feet to the S 234 9313681 MADISON AVE & 48TH STREET MADISON AVE & 48TH STREET 539 feet to the WSW 235 9908889 MANHATTAN PACIFIC 400 MADISON AVE 724 feet to the SW 236 0205654 MH 09335 WEST 48TH ST/ROCKERFELL P 1252 feet to the W 237 8901969 E 55 ST @ PARK AV E 55 ST @ PARK AV 1353 feet to the NE 238 9905873 VAULT 2831 101 E.56TH ST 1649 feet to the NE 239 9510006 THE DRAKE HOTEL 440 PARK AVE 1722 feet to the NE 240 9408212 TIME & LIFE BLDG ROCK. CT 1271 AVE OF THE AMERICAS 1858 feet to the NW 241 9709581 CORNER OF LEXINGTON & 57 124 E 57TH ST 1931 feet to the NE 242 9110361 992 2ND AVE 992 2ND AVE 2072 feet to the E 243 9302881 1177 AVE OF AMERICAS 1177 AVE OF AMERICAS 2088 feet to the W 244 9414690 501 501 5TH AVENUE 2253 feet to the SW 245 9011516 219 E 58TH ST/MANH/CON ED 219 EAST 58TH STREET 2590 feet to the ENE

Petroleum Bulk Storage Sites MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 246 2-602867 MUTUAL OF AMERICA BUILDING 320 PARK AVENUE 246 feet to the E 247 2-476579 THE NEW YORK PALACE 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW 248 2-601820 299 PARK AVENUE 299 PARK AVENUE 330 feet to the SSE 249 2-364223 NEW DAWN DAVIDSON L.P. 477 MADISON AVENUE 425 feet to the N 250 2-603213 RICH D`ANGELO 280 PARK AVENUE 513 feet to the S 251 2-361879 40 EAST COMPANY 40 EAST 52ND STREET 558 feet to the N

Hazardous Waste Generators, Transporters MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 252 NYD001344381 COLGATE PALMOLIVE COMPANY 300 PARK AVE 245 feet to the SSE 253 NYD987036449 MUTUAL OF AMERICA BLDG THE 320 PARK AVE 246 feet to the E 254 NYD981131097 AMERICAN EAGLE FDR CORPORATION 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW 255 NYD166077602 HELMSLEY PALACE 455 MADISON AVENUE 277 feet to the NW 256 NYD986913945 437 MADISON AVENUE FEE ASSOCIATES 437 MADISON AVENUE 286 feet to the W 257 NY0000940759 HITACHI 437 MADISON AVE 32ND FL 286 feet to the W 258 NYD103233920 KISS PHOTO INC 437 MADISON AVE 286 feet to the W 259 NYP004050803 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V3054-F/O 48 E 49TH ST 300 feet to the WSW 260 NYD986977130 NEWSWEEK INC 444 MADISON AVE 312 feet to the WNW 261 NYP004041836 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V1362-49 E 51ST ST 322 feet to the N 262 NYP000892174 WALDORF ASTORIA 301 PARK AVE 331 feet to the SSE 263 NYR000089755 CON EDISON @ WALDORF ASTORIA HILTON 301 PARK AVE 331 feet to the SSE 264 NYD987038866 415 MADISON INC 415 MADISON AVE 476 feet to the WSW 265 NYD057325730 RUTH L WEINTRAUB INC 420 MADISON AVENUE 483 feet to the WSW 266 NYD986975738 BANKERS TRUST SECURITIES 280 PARK AVENUE 513 feet to the S 267 NYR000035907 SWISS BANK TOWER 17 EAST 49TH ST 523 feet to the W 268 NYP004033403 CON ED V3980-28 E 48TH ST 549 feet to the WSW 269 NYD987038320 40 EASTCO 40 E 52ND ST 558 feet to the N 270 NYP004033395 CON ED V1307-28 E 52ND ST 575 feet to the N 271 NYP004052395 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V3838-28 E 52ND ST 587 feet to the N 272 NYD987017357 PARK AVENUE PLAZA 55 E 52ND STREET 592 feet to the NNE

273 NYR000079384 INGES BEARING 55 E 52ND ST 12 FLOOR 592 feet to the NNE 274 NYD987038841 345 PARK CO 345 PARK AVE 596 feet to the ENE 275 NYD001288497 BRISTOL MYERS 345 PARK AVE 596 feet to the ENE 276 NYD071003370 HANCO JEWELRY INC 501 MADISON AVE 612 feet to the N 277 NYP004027546 CONSOLIDATED EDISON 8170975-24 E 52ND ST 614 feet to the N 278 NYD006985956 CITOH & CO INC 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S 279 NYD986896843 WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC CORP 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S 280 NYD001289008 CHASE MANHATTEN BANK 270 PARK AVE 615 feet to the S 281 NYR000055715 SWISS BANK TOWER 10 E 50TH ST SUBCELLAR 646 feet to the WNW

Air Discharge Sites MAP ID FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY STREET DISTANCE & DIRECTION 282 3606100421 SUMITOMO CORP(DUPL SEE 015-NO1O6 INSTEAD 345 PARK AVENUE 593 feet to the ENE 283 3606103014 BRISTOL MYERS 345 PARK AVE 593 feet to the ENE Toxics Targeting E 76th St E 74th St W 58th St W 59th St E 75th St 1 Mile Radius Map W 60th St 65 th 44- 50 E 50th Street S tr ee t T ra 5th Ave New York, NY 10022 ns ve rs e Ro ad E 72nd St E 66th St E 67th St

W 56th St W 57th St Central Park S E 63rd St W 54th St E 68th St E 62nd St W 50th St E 65th St

W 51st St W 55th St

W 53rd St E 64th St W 48th St W 49th St E 60th St 6

W 52nd St E 56th St Park Ave W 47th St

E 61st St W 46th St New York County W 44th St 8th Ave E 55th St E 58th St First Ave E 59th St NPL, CERCLIS, NYSDEC Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Registry or Registry Qualifying Site E 57th St Hazardous Waste Treater, 3 E 54th St Storer, Disposer 4 44- 50 E 50th Street W 45th St 1 Hazardous Substance Solid Waste 2 Waste Disposal Site Facility W 41st St E 53rd St W 42nd St Major Oil E 51st St E 52nd St Storage Facility West Road5 E 49th St W 37th St East Road E 48th St W 40th St

ve A W 39th St n E 47th St o W 38th St is W 34th St E 46th St ad E 45th St W 35th St M

3rd Ave E 43rd St E 40th St E 42nd St E 44th St W 36th St E 41st St

ve W 31st St A n to g in x Site e W 33rd St E 35th St Second Ave L E 39th St Location Waterbody W 28th St W 29th St E 36th St Minor W 27th St E 37th St Roads 5th St E 34th St Major County as c W 26th St ri Roads Border e m A E 33rd St Expressways Railroad e E 31st St E 32nd St th f 49th Ave Tracks o e u W 23rd St n 1 Mile 1/2 Mile e E 30th St 50th Ave v W 24th St A Radius Radius

5th Ave First Ave 1/4 Mile 1/8 Mile E 29th St Radius Radius

1 0 1/8 1/4 1/2 1 Distance in Miles Toxics Targeting 125 123 1/2 Mile Radius Map 126 113 127 124 220 132 112 44- 50 E 50th Street 228 118 227 102 143 121 91 106 New York, NY 10022 225 108 105 144 114 107 23 115 141 97 201 204 109 W 53rd St 63 73 205 W 55th St Park Ave 186 62 58 193 75 E 56th St 185 79 96 59 142 81 171 210 48 89 174 130 239 64 47 42 238 241 189 195 119 245 194 44 158 163 224 Ave W 52nd St 39 20 68 214 173 9 90 122 240 237 177 Seventh 153 E 57th St 29 28 60 30 49 178 77 152 27 72 26 166 159 181 as 134 ic 18 139 r New York County e 182 m 156 150 140 A 226 e 230 h 38 183 t 16 f o 32 e u n 168 211 e 145 v A 146 17 131 236 213 MTBE Gasoline 155 86 E 55th St 157 147 172 Additive Spill 243 198 170 34 44- 50 E 50th Street 87 229 148 162 Hazardous 129 164 35 24 128 19 149 40 Material Spill 5th Ave 52 231 46 232 160 242 31 234 W 45th St 235 25 37 E 53rd St 219 43 209 8 E 46th St 233 161 7 W 44th St 33 197 202 151 167 E 45th St 154 E 51st St 21 188 94 169 61 206 176 135 41 136 191 36 67 192 12 54 50 100 53 e 190 51 Av 71 101 187 t il E 43rd St b r 69 e 212 d 70 22 n 84 a 165 88 V 85 45 244 138 10 E 48th St Site W 40th St 180 203 Location Waterbody 110 99 179 W 39th St 76 175 55 E 47th St Depew Pl 74 57 Minor 56 184 120 15 66 137 223 Roads 92 W 38th St 216 207 65 111 116 83 Lexington Ave Major 78 County 117 222 93 82 196 11 95 Roads Border 218 208 199 80 14 E 45th St 200 13 W 37th St 133 E 43rd St Expressways Railroad 217 221 215 lz Tracks 103 98 E 44th St P s n E 42nd St o E 41st St i 1 Mile 1/2 Mile 104 t a N Radius Radius Park Ave d e it E 40th St n 1/4 Mile 1/8 Mile U F.D. Roosevelt Dr Radius Radius Second Ave

1/2 0 1/16 1/8 1/4 1/2 Distance in Miles Toxics Targeting 1/8 Mile Radius Map 277 44- 50 E 50th Street 276 271 New York, NY 10022 270 272 251 273 E 51st St 269

Park Ave

Madison Ave

249

E 50th St 281 261

254 255 247 274 275 282 New York County 283

260 267 256 257 253 258 246 Chemical Storage Hazardous Waste E 49th St 44- 50 E 50th Street Facility Generator, Transp. Toxic Air Release Release Wastewater Historic 259 Discharge Utility Site

265 Civil Enforcement Petroleum Bulk Docket Facility Storage Facility 252 264

268 262 263 248 E 48th St Site Location Waterbody

Madison Ave Minor Roads Major County 250 Roads Border 266 Expressways Railroad Tracks

278 1 Mile 1/2 Mile 279 Radius Radius 280 1/4 Mile 1/8 Mile Radius Radius

1/8 0 1/16 1/8 Distance in Miles 134 Toxics Targeting 1/8 Mile Closeup Map 277 44- 50 E 50th Street 276 271 270 New York, NY 10022 150 272 269 273 E 51st St 251

Park Ave

Madison Ave 249

E 50th St 281 261

254 145 255 275 146 247 274 283 New York County 282

260 NPL, CERCLIS, NYSDEC Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Registry or Registry Qualifying Site * 267 Hazardous Waste Treater, MTBE Gasoline 258 246 Storer, Disposer * Additive Spill 257 253 256 Hazardous Substance Solid Waste 147 44- 50 E 50th Street 148 Waste Disposal Site * Facility * E 49th St Major Oil Hazardous Storage Facility * Material Spill **

24 128 Chemical Storage Hazardous Waste 259 Facility *** Generator, Transp. *** 149 265 231 Toxic Air 232 Release *** Release *** 252 234 264 Wastewater Historic 25 Discharge *** Utility Site *** Civil Enforcement Petroleum Bulk 268 262 Docket Facility *** Storage Facility *** 263 248 E 48th St Site Location Waterbody 235 Madison Ave Minor Roads Major County 250 233 Roads Border 266 Expressways Railroad Tracks 280 7 279 1 Mile 1/2 Mile 278 Radius Radius 1/4 Mile 1/8 Mile Radius Radius

* 1 Mile Search Radius ** 1/2 Mile Search Radius 1/8 0 1/16 1/8 Distance in Miles *** 1/8 Mile Search Radius Section Two: Toxic Site Profiles

The heading of each Toxic Site Profile refers to the site's map location and details:

• The facility name, address, city, state, and zip code (This information does not appear in the headings for Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Sites). • Any changes that were made to a site's address in order to map its location. • The site mapping method that was used (see How Sites are Located, at the end of this section for more information).

Toxic Site Profiles summarize information provided by site owners or operators and government agencies regarding various toxic chemical activities reported at each site, such as:

• Whether chemicals were stored, produced, transported, discharged or disposed of. • The name of chemicals and their Chemical Abstract Series (CAS) numbers; • The amount of chemicals and the units (gallons/pounds) the chemical was measured in. • Whether the site or storage tanks at the site are currently active or inactive. • Special codes used by government agencies to regulate hazardous waste activities at some sites (A complete description of the codes follows the profiles section).

For selected individual chemicals reported at various toxic sites, some potential health effect summary information appears below the site profile. Each potential health effect summary identifies chemicals by name and by Chemical Abstract Series (CAS) Number. An "x" under each potential health effect heading indicates positive toxicity testing results reported by the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health's Registry of Toxic Effects of Chemical Substances (RTECS). Some chemicals (mostly appearing in profiles of Hazardous Waste facilities), are reported as mixtures, and RTECS health effect information is only available for individual chemicals. In addition, RTECS only provides information on approximately 100,000 common chemicals. Consequently, the absence of potential health effect summary information for a particular chemical identified in a Toxic Site Profile does not necessarily mean that the chemical does not pose potential health effects.

The Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) in drinking water allowed for selected chemicals is also noted. In most cases, the only applicable MCL has been set by the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH). Where NYSDOH has not set an MCL, the federal standard, if one exists, is listed and is marked by an asterisk.

Presented below are column headings that describe the health effect definitions used in RTECS and applicable New York State and federal drinking water standards. Reference sources for information presented in this section are also provided.

ACUTE TOX: Acute Toxicity: Short-term exposure to this chemical can cause lethal and non-lethal toxicity effects not included in the following four categories.

TUMOR TOX: Tumorigenic Toxicity: The chemical can cause an increase in the incidence of tumors.

MUTAG TOX: Mutagenic Toxicity: The chemical can cause genetic alterations that are passed from one generation to the next. REPRO TOX: Reproductive toxicity: May signify one of the following effects: maternal effects, paternal effects, effects on fertility, effects on the embryo or fetus, specific developmental abnormalities, tumorigenic effects, or effects on the newborn (only positive reproductive effects data for mammalian species are referenced)

IRRIT TOX: Primary Irritant: The chemical can cause eye or skin irritation

MCL: Drinking Water Standard - Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) listed under Drinking Water Supplies, 10 NYCRR Part 5, Subparts 1.51(f),(g), and (h) for NYDOH MCL's and under the Safe Drinking Water Act, 40 CFR 141, Subparts B and G, (* indicates value for total trihalomethanes) for federal MCL's.

Reference Source for Toxicity Information: Registry of Toxic Effects of Chemical Substances (RTECS), NIOSH (on-line database); For further information, contact: NIOSH, 4676 Columbia Parkway, Cincinnati, OH, 45226, 800/35-NIOSH.

Reference Source for Drinking Water Standards: New York State Department of Health, Bureau of Toxic Substances Assessment, 2 University Place, Room 240, Albany, NY 12203, 518/458-6373.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Drinking Water, 401 M St SW, Mailstop WH-556, Washington, DC, 20460, 202/260-5700.

Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Site Classifications: 1 -- Causing or presenting an imminent danger of causing irreversible or irreparable damage to the public health or the environment -- immediate action required;

2 -- Significant threat to the public health or environment -- action required;

3 -- Does not Present a significant threat to the environment or public health -- action may be deferred;

4 -- Site properly closed --requires continued management;

5 -- Site properly closed, no evidence of present or potential adverse impact -- no further action required;

2a -- This temporary classification has been assigned to sites where there is inadequate data to assign them to the five classifications specified by law.

D1, 2, 3 -- Delisted Site (1: hazardous waste not found; 2: remediated; 3: consolidated site or site incorrectly listed)

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 1

------* NPL/CERCLIS/INACTIVE HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SITES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------PLEASE NOTE: * Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Map Identification Number 1 ANCHOR CASTING CO INC. EPA Facility Id: NYD001617059 38 W 48TH ST NEW YORK, NY 10036

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1193 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

SITE DESIGNATION: NPL - CERCLIS - X NYSDEC REGISTRY -

***************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************

USEPA COMPREHENSIVE ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSE COMPENSATION AND LIABILITY INFORMATION SYSTEM (CERCLIS)

SITE INFORMATION

EPA-ID: NYD001617059 Site-ID: 0203340 Site Name: ANCHOR CASTING CO INC. Site Street: 38 W 48TH ST Site City/State/Zip: NEW YORK, NY 10036

NFRAP (No Further Remedial Activity Planned) Indicator: NO FURTHER REMEDIAL ACTION PLANNED

Owner Indicator: Private NPL Status Indicator: Not on the NPL Incident Type: USGS Hydrological Unit: 02030101 Incident Category: RCRA Flag: ENVIRON PRIORITY INITIATIVE Non-NPL Status: NFRAP Federal Facility Flag: Not a Federal Facility

SITE ALIAS INFORMATION

Alias Name: ANCHOR CASTING CO INC. Alias ID: 101 Alias Street: NY Alias City/State/Zip: NY

OPERABLE UNIT INFORMATION

Operable Unit ID: 00 Operable Unit Name: SITEWIDE

ACTION INFORMATION

Name: DISCOVERY Current Plan Start Date: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 2

Lead: EPA Fund-Financed Current Plan Completion Date: Qualifier: Actual Start Date: Category: Actual Completion Date: 19900824 Planning Status: Operable Unit ID: 00 Anomaly Indicator: Financial Budget Source: IFMS Entry: No Entry into IFMS

Name: PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT Current Plan Start Date: Lead: EPA Fund-Financed Current Plan Completion Date: Qualifier: NFRAP (No Futher Remedial Action Planned) Actual Start Date: 19910401 Category: Actual Completion Date: 19910627 Planning Status: Operable Unit ID: 00 Anomaly Indicator: Financial Budget Source: Remedial IFMS Entry: Both Intramural and Extramural Entry into IFMS

Name: ARCHIVE SITE Current Plan Start Date: Lead: EPA In-House Current Plan Completion Date: Qualifier: Actual Start Date: Category: Actual Completion Date: 19910627 Planning Status: Operable Unit ID: 00 Anomaly Indicator: Financial Budget Source: IFMS Entry: No Entry into IFMS

FINANCIAL INFORMATION

No financial information was provided

Map Identification Number 2 NEW YORK TIMES CO EPA Facility Id: NYD001315613 229 W 43 ST NEW YORK, NY 10036

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: 229 W 43RD ST Approximate distance from property: 3530 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

SITE DESIGNATION: NPL - CERCLIS - X NYSDEC REGISTRY -

***************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************

USEPA COMPREHENSIVE ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSE COMPENSATION AND LIABILITY INFORMATION SYSTEM (CERCLIS)

SITE INFORMATION

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 3

EPA-ID: NYD001315613 Site-ID: 0203350 Site Name: NEW YORK TIMES CO Site Street: 229 W 43 ST Site City/State/Zip: NEW YORK, NY 10036

NFRAP (No Further Remedial Activity Planned) Indicator: NO FURTHER REMEDIAL ACTION PLANNED

Owner Indicator: Private NPL Status Indicator: Not on the NPL Incident Type: USGS Hydrological Unit: 02030101 Incident Category: RCRA Flag: ENVIRON PRIORITY INITIATIVE Non-NPL Status: NFRAP Federal Facility Flag: Not a Federal Facility

SITE ALIAS INFORMATION

Alias Name: NEW YORK TIMES CO Alias ID: 101 Alias Street: Alias City/State/Zip: NY

OPERABLE UNIT INFORMATION

Operable Unit ID: 00 Operable Unit Name: SITEWIDE

ACTION INFORMATION

Name: DISCOVERY Current Plan Start Date: Lead: EPA Fund-Financed Current Plan Completion Date: Qualifier: Actual Start Date: Category: Actual Completion Date: 19900824 Planning Status: Operable Unit ID: 00 Anomaly Indicator: Financial Budget Source: IFMS Entry: No Entry into IFMS

Name: PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT Current Plan Start Date: Lead: EPA Fund-Financed Current Plan Completion Date: Qualifier: NFRAP (No Futher Remedial Action Planned) Actual Start Date: 19910401 Category: Actual Completion Date: 19910627 Planning Status: Operable Unit ID: 00 Anomaly Indicator: Financial Budget Source: Remedial IFMS Entry: Both Intramural and Extramural Entry into IFMS

Name: ARCHIVE SITE Current Plan Start Date: Lead: EPA In-House Current Plan Completion Date: Qualifier: Actual Start Date: Category: Actual Completion Date: 19910627 Planning Status: Operable Unit ID: 00 Anomaly Indicator: Financial Budget Source: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 4

IFMS Entry: No Entry into IFMS

FINANCIAL INFORMATION

No financial information was provided

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 5

------* HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCE WASTE DISPOSAL SITES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------PLEASE NOTE: * Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Map Identification Number 3 ANCHOR CASTING CO. Site Number Id: Registry ID N 38 W. 48TH ST. EDISON, NY 08837

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 38 W 48TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1204 feet to the W Revised zip code: 10036

*************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************** NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION Division of Hazardous Waste Remediation Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Site Study

Inventory Status: Removed from the Hazardous Substance Inventory Reason site did not qualify for the Inventory: No evidence of disposal

SITE INFORMATION

Site Name: ANCHOR CASTING CO. Site Number: Site Street: 38 W. 48TH ST. Registry: No Site City: EDISON Registry Site ID: None Site Zip: 08837 RCRA: Unknown Region: 2 EPA ID: NYD001617059

US EPA No Further Remedial Action Planned? Unknown

Site Code: 1 Description: INDUSTRIAL SITE

Acres: 0.00 Quadrangle: Unknown Completed Investigation? PA HRS Score: Unknown Is Site Active: No HRS Date: Unknown Years of Operation: Unknown to 1982

Site Description: Small jewelry manufacturer (pickling).

Owner: Private Operator: Private Owner Name: ANCHOR CASTING CO. INC. Operator Name: LEVITAN OSCAR, PRES. Owner Street: 38 WEST 48TH ST. Operator Street: SAME Owner City/ZIP/State: NYC, NY 10036 Operator City/ZIP/State: Owner Telephone: Unknown Operator Telephone: (212)757-2209

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 6

SITE IMPACT DATA

Affected Media: Hazardous Substance Exposed? Unknown Contamination of... Controlled Site Access? Unknown ...Surface Water? Unknown Ambient Air Contamination? Unknown ...Groundwater? Unknown Threat of Direct Contact? Unknown ...Drinking Water? Unknown Documented Fish or Wildlife Mortality? Unknown Surface Water Class: Unknown Impact on Special Status Fish or Wildlife Resource? Unknown Groundwater Class: Unknown Active Drinking Water Supply? Unknown

Descriptions:

Surface Water: None provided Groundwater: None provided Drinking Water: None provided Fish or Wildlife Mortality: None provided Special Status Fish or Wildlife Resource: None provided Building: None provided

THREAT TO THE ENVIRONMENT OR PUBLIC HEALTH

Threat to the Environment or the Public Health: None

Threat Posed by Disposed Hazardous Substance: No history of violations or uncontrolled releases of hazardous substances. No evidence of any RCRA activity since 1989.

HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES DISPOSED:

VOCs: No Semi-VOCs: No PCBs: No Pesticides: No Metals: No Asbestos: No

Hazardous Substances Disposed: spent sulfuric, hydrochloric, and nitric acids, detergent solutions

SELECTED ANALYTICAL INFORMATION:

Samples Collected: None

Air: None provided Surface Water: None provided Surface Soil: None provided Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 7

Waste: None provided EPToxicity: None provided Groundwater: None provided Sediment: None provided Subsurface Soil: None provided Leachate: None provided TCLP: None provided

AGENCY INFORMATION:

Regulatory Agencies Involved: NYSDEC USEPA

Preparer: Julie Welch NYSDEC, Intern, RPI Env.Eng.Tech. 1 February 15, 1994

Map Identification Number 4 NEW YORK TIMES CO. Site Number Id: Registry ID N 229 W 431ST STREET NEW YORK, NY 10036

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: 229 W 43RD STREET Approximate distance from property: 3523 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

*************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************** NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION Division of Hazardous Waste Remediation Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Site Study

Inventory Status: Removed from the Hazardous Substance Inventory Reason site did not qualify for the Inventory: No evidence of disposal

SITE INFORMATION

Site Name: NEW YORK TIMES CO. Site Number: Site Street: 229 W 431ST STREET Registry: No Site City: NEW YORK Registry Site ID: None Site Zip: 10036 RCRA: Unknown Region: 2 EPA ID: NYD001315613

US EPA No Further Remedial Action Planned? Unknown

Site Code: 1 Description: INDUSTRIAL SITE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 8

Acres: 0.00 Quadrangle: Unknown Completed Investigation? PA HRS Score: Unknown Is Site Active: Unknown HRS Date: Unknown Years of Operation: Unknown to Unknown

Site Description: Printers. One of the three largest newspapers in NYC. They generate approximately 25-30 drums of waste ink which is removed weekly.

Owner: Private Operator: Private Owner Name: NEW YORK TIMES CO. Operator Name: FRIED GEORGE, NEWSPRINT MGR. Owner Street: 229 WEST 431ST ST. Operator Street: SAME Owner City/ZIP/State: NYC, NY 10036 Operator City/ZIP/State: Owner Telephone: (212)556-1103 Operator Telephone: Unknown

SITE IMPACT DATA

Affected Media: Hazardous Substance Exposed? Unknown Contamination of... Controlled Site Access? Unknown ...Surface Water? Unknown Ambient Air Contamination? Unknown ...Groundwater? Unknown Threat of Direct Contact? Unknown ...Drinking Water? Unknown Documented Fish or Wildlife Mortality? Unknown Surface Water Class: Unknown Impact on Special Status Fish or Wildlife Resource? Unknown Groundwater Class: Unknown Active Drinking Water Supply? Unknown

Descriptions:

Surface Water: None provided Groundwater: None provided Drinking Water: None provided Fish or Wildlife Mortality: None provided Special Status Fish or Wildlife Resource: None provided Building: None provided

THREAT TO THE ENVIRONMENT OR PUBLIC HEALTH

Threat to the Environment or the Public Health: Public Health

Threat Posed by Disposed Hazardous Substance: Excessive inhalation may cause local irritation or drowsiness. Prolonged exposure could cause skin irritation.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 9

HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES DISPOSED:

VOCs: No Semi-VOCs: No PCBs: No Pesticides: No Metals: Yes Asbestos: No

Hazardous Substances Disposed: Barium, Cadmium, Lead

SELECTED ANALYTICAL INFORMATION:

Samples Collected: Waste, EPTox

Air: None provided Surface Water: None provided Surface Soil: None provided

Waste: See EPToxicity results.

EPToxicity: None provided Groundwater: None provided Sediment: None provided Subsurface Soil: None provided Leachate: None provided TCLP: None provided

AGENCY INFORMATION:

Regulatory Agencies Involved: USEPA NYSDEC

Preparer: Julie Welch NYSDEC, Intern, RPI Env. Eng. Tech 1 February 15, 1994

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 10

------* NO SOLID WASTE FACILITIES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 11

------* OIL STORAGE FACILITIES LARGER THAN 400,000 GALLONS IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------PLEASE NOTE: * Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Map Identification Number 5 GOLDWATER MEMORIAL HOSPITAL Facility Id 2-2640 ONE MAIN STREET NEW YORK CITY, NY 10044

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: F.D. ROOSEVELT ISLAND Approximate distance from property: 5190 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

TANK TANK PETROLEUM CAPACITY TANK INSTALL NUMBER STATUS PRODUCT GALLONS LOCATION DATE

1 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 50000 UNDERGROUND 01/50 2 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 50000 UNDERGROUND 01/50 3 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 50000 UNDERGROUND 01/50 4 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 50000 UNDERGROUND 01/50 5 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 50000 UNDERGROUND 01/50 6 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 50000 UNDERGROUND 01/50 7 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 25000 UNDERGROUND 00/00 8 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 25000 UNDERGROUND 00/00 9 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 25000 UNDERGROUND 00/00 10 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 25000 UNDERGROUND 00/00 11 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 25000 UNDERGROUND 00/00 12 IN SERVICE #5 OR 6 FUEL OIL 50000 UNDERGROUND 01/50 15 IN SERVICE OTHER 50 ABOVEGROUND ON CRIB RACK ETC 00/00 1D IN SERVICE DIESEL 2500 UNDERGROUND 10/67 1L IN SERVICE OTHER 200 ABOVEGROUND ON CRIB RACK ETC 00/00 2D IN SERVICE DIESEL 5000 UNDERGROUND 10/67 3D IN SERVICE DIESEL 500 ABOVEGROUND ON CRIB RACK ETC 10/67 4D IN SERVICE DIESEL 275 ABOVEGROUND ON CRIB RACK ETC 02/91

Toxicity Information Summary

------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------DIESEL 68334305 X X X DIESEL 68334305 X X X ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 12

------* HAZARDOUS WASTE TREATMENT/STORAGE/DISPOSERS IDENTIFIED WITHIN THE 1 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------PLEASE NOTE: * Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Map Identification Number 6 CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK Facility Id: NYD982270043 321 EAST 63RD STREET NEW YORK, NY 10003 EPA (RCRA) Name: ENSR OPERATIONS PCBX DIV EPA (RCRA) Address: MOBILE UNIT ALL NY CANTON OHIO, NY 99999

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 4136 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: 10021

US EPA RCRA Type: GENERATOR TYPE NOT GIVEN Notification date: 06/29/1987 Part A notification date: 06/29/1987 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------US EPA RCRA Violations: Violation Area: TSD-FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY REQUIREMENTS Responsible Agency: STATE Violation Number: 0001 Location: NY Violation Determination Date: 03/09/1988 Regulation: Violation Return to Compliance: 09/13/1988 ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent reported data. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

NONE No hazardous waste activity reported to NYS up to 2/12/2003.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 13

------HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INTRODUCTION ------

The Hazardous Material Spills in this section are divided into eight spill cause groupings. These include:

Active Spills Section: Spills with incomplete paperwork that may or may not be cleaned up (See Date Cleanup Ceased) 1) Tank Failures 2) Tank Test Failures 3) Unknown Spill Cause or Other Spill Cause Hazardous Spills 4) Miscellanous Spill Causes: Equipment Failure, Human Error, Tank Overfill, Deliberate Spill, Traffic Accidents, Housekeeping, Abandoned Drum, and Vandalism.

Closed Status Spills Section: Spills with completed paperwork that may or may not be cleaned up (See Date Cleanup Ceased) 5) Tank Failures 6) Tank Test Failures 7) Unknown Spill Cause or Other Spill Cause Hazardous Spills 8) Miscellanous Spill Causes: Equipment Failure, Human Error, Tank Overfill, Deliberate Spill, Traffic Accidents, Housekeeping, Abandoned Drum, and Vandalism.

All spills within each spill cause category are presented in order of proximity to the subject site address.

Please note that spills reported within 0.25 mile (or one-eighth mile in Manhattan) are mapped and profiled.

Between 0.25 mile (or one-eighth mile in Manhattan) and 0.5 mile, only the following spills are mapped and profiled:

* Tank Failures;

* Tank Test Failures;

* Unknown Spill Cause or Other Spill Cause;

* Spills greater than 100 units of quantity; and

* Spills reported in the NYSDEC Fall 1998 MTBE Survey.

A table at the end of each section presents a listing of reported Miscellanous Spills with less than 100 units located between 0.25 mile (or one-eighth mile in Manhattan) and 0.5 mile. These spills are neither mapped nor profiled. Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 14

------ACTIVE TANK FAILURES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/2 MILE SEARCH RADIUS ------* - Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address. ------**Site profiles in this report section contain up to 36 data fields of information obtained from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Since 1/1/02, the DEC has only released information for 12 of those data fields: spill name, address components, spill date, close date, material spilled, quantity spilled, units, cause of spill and resource affected. The date after "Information updated through:" indicates when these 12 data fields were last updated. The other 24 data fields are only updated through 1/1/02. ------

Map Identification Number 7 MARRIOT EAST HOTEL Spill Number: 0109979 Close Date: 525 LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/26/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 831 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

01/16/2002 #2 FUEL OIL 2.00 GALLONS NO TANK FAILURE ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 8 WEST 46TH ST & 5TH AVE Spill Number: 9415266 Close Date: WEST 46TH ST / 5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/21/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1285 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: DEPT OF SANITATION Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MORSTATT SS Caller Agency: NYCFD Caller Phone: (212) 570-4300 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARD T Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/21/1995 TANK FAILURE IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIESEL UNKNOWN 40.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 15

------Caller Remarks: DIKED AREA - NOTHING IN SEWER YET ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 9 142-148 EAST 57TH ST Spill Number: 9705231 Close Date: 142-148 EAST 57TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 144 E 57TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2069 feet to the NE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: ANNONYMOUS CALLER Notifier Phone: Caller Name: STEVEN SCHMALER Caller Agency: NYCDEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-3658 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: R.C. DOLNER Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/31/1997 TANK FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIESEL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CALLER IS EMPLOYEE WORKING AT A SITE - STATES THEY JUST HIT A 1000 GAL TANK WITH CONTAMINATED SOIL & FUMES ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 10 310 E 48TH ST/HERTZ Spill Number: 9201045 Close Date: 310 E 48TH ST NEW YORK NY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/22/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2101 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 16

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: SULLIVAN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES A FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill PBS # Involved Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/01/1987 TANK FAILURE 2-453293 ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE UNKNOWN -1.00 POUNDS NO 0.00 POUNDS NO ------Caller Remarks: NO REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 11 APARTMENT BUILDING Spill Number: 0012794 Close Date: 245 EAST 44TH STREET NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/31/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2174 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: PAN AM EQUITIES Spiller Phone: (212) 818-0687 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: DEAN DINOVIC Contact Person Phone: (212) 972-3223

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/27/2001 TANK FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 17

------Caller Remarks: they cleaned a 15,000 gallon tank for the above company.the leak was inside the building.the cleaned the tank . ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 12 337 EAST 50TH STREET Spill Number: 0202387 Close Date: 337 EAST 50TH STREET MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/13/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2228 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

05/31/2002 #2 FUEL OIL 100.00 GALLONS NO TANK FAILURE ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 13 225 EAST 43RD ST Spill Number: 9408906 Close Date: 225 EAST 43RD ST NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/21/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2259 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: BUDGET RENT-A CAR Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: HOWARD KALMAN Caller Agency: KALCO PUMP/TANK Caller Phone: (718) 626-8083 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill PBS # Involved Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/04/1994 TANK FAILURE 2-601235 ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 18

------Caller Remarks: WILL SEAL W/ FOAM. MARK TIBBEY TALKED TO HIM-THERES MONITORING WELLS. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 14 BUDGET RENT-A- CAR Spill Number: 9403751 Close Date: 225 EAST 43RD STREET NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/21/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2259 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: BUDGET RENT-A -CAR Spiller Phone: (718) 639-6494 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: HOWARD GREENBERG Caller Agency: ALVIN PETROLEUM Caller Phone: (718) 461-5400 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: LOU PETRONI Contact Person Phone: (212) 661-0260

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill PBS # Involved Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/16/1994 TANK FAILURE 2-601235 ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 12` WATER IN TANK. CALLER SUSPECTS CUSTOMER MAY HAVE ABANDONED TANK ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

04/25/95: CALLED HOWARD GREENBERG ON 04/25/95 TO FIND OUT IF ANY ACTION HAS BEEN TAKEN. HE WAS NOT AVAILABLE WILL CALL BACK.

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: TANK TAKING ON WATER.

ON JULY 8, 1996, Spoke to Carl Westerman, Properties & Facilities - Budget Rent-A -Car (708)955-7203

There are two 4,000 gallon UST gasoline in service at the facility. Tanks were steel installed in 1985. Tanks were laid into a bedrock foundation and had apoured concrete incasement. The problem involved one of the tanks. One tank began taking on water (12") over a rainy envent. Upon cleaning and inspecting the tank they found a hole in the bottom of the tank the size of a quarter. The tank was repaired with a steel plate and was fiberglass coated. The piping systems were repalced with fiberglass due to potential corrosion problems. The tanks were then cathodically protected by upgrading, and a leak detection system was added. According to Mr. Westerman, there was no loss of product from the system, and the only source of problems was water Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 19

entering the tank. There have apparenetly been no other indications of further leakage, or seepage into adjoining buildings. Mr. Westerman has photographs of the tank installation and documentaion on the cleanup which indicated that no product migrated back into the tank when it was emptied.

See also Spill #9408906.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 15 BETWEEN 40TH ST & Spill Number: 0205816 Close Date: 42 ND ST/MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/08/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: MADISON AVE Approximate distance from property: 2355 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

09/05/2002 DIESEL 30.00 GALLONS NO TANK FAILURE ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 16 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY Spill Number: 0007888 Close Date: 150 W 47TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2385 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: COMMERCIAL PROPERTY Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: SANGESLAND Contact for more spill info: ANR KALIMIN REALTY Contact Person Phone: (212) 751-8050

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/27/2000 TANK FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#4 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 20

------Caller Remarks: THEY REMOVED A TANK BACK IN JULY & DISCOVERED IT HAD BEEN LEAKING - CLEAN UP HAS BEEN IN PROGRESS ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 17 333 EAST 55TH ST Spill Number: 9712107 Close Date: 333 EAST 55TH ST NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2589 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: LEON WAGNER Spiller Phone: (212) 752-6033 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: LEON WAGNER Notifier Phone: (212) 752-6033 Caller Name: FRAN ARCHEY Caller Agency: A L EASTMOND Caller Phone: (718) 378-3000 DEC Investigator: MULQUEEN Contact for more spill info: LEON WAGNER Contact Person Phone: (212) 752-6033

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/29/1998 TANK FAILURE GROUNDWATER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 200.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CORROSION TO TANK CAUSED SPILL ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

#6 FUEL OIL TANK LET GO THAT WAS LOCATED UNDER RAMP TO PARKING GARAGE UNDER BUILDING. OIL SEEPED THRU CONCRETE RETAINING WALL AND ALSO SEEPED INTO GROUNDWATER SUMP IN THE BLDG BOILER ROOM. TANK WAS EMPTIED AND SEEPAGE STOPPED. OIL/WATER SEPARTOR INSTALLED ON SUMP TO MANAGE SITUATION. 8/27/98mmm: LAN DIN FROM ATC DOING PHASE I ON PROPERTY. CALLED ABOUT SPILL CLEANUP.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 21

------ACTIVE TANK TEST FAILURES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/2 MILE SEARCH RADIUS ------* - Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address. ------**Site profiles in this report section contain up to 36 data fields of information obtained from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Since 1/1/02, the DEC has only released information for 12 of those data fields: spill name, address components, spill date, close date, material spilled, quantity spilled, units, cause of spill and resource affected. The date after "Information updated through:" indicates when these 12 data fields were last updated. The other 24 data fields are only updated through 1/1/02. ------

Map Identification Number 18 APARTMENT BLDG Spill Number: 9800437 Close Date: 135 E. 54TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1292 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

This site was dropped from the NYDEC spills database, the last information given is listed here

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: APARTMENT BLDG Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MIKE GIUSTINIANI Notifier Phone: (718) 265-3355 Caller Name: GENE TOLVE Caller Agency: STATE ENVIRONMENTAL SVC Caller Phone: (718) 265-3355 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: RAPHAEL Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/10/1998 TANK TEST FAILURE NONE GIVEN NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 0 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------TANK TEST INFORMATION

Tank Number Tank Size Tank Test Method Leak Rate Gross Leak or Failure

1 10000 HORNER EZ CHECK 0.00 UNKNOWN ------Caller Remarks: TANK TEST FAILURE - WILL RETEST LATER DATE AFTER INSPECTING TANK ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 22

Map Identification Number 19 246 E 53RD ST Spill Number: 9800497 Close Date: 246 E 53RD ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/06/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1741 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: (718) 384-9151 Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: ALBERTO LOPEZ Notifier Phone: ( ) - Caller Name: JOHN LEDDY Caller Agency: PROTEST ENTERPRISES Caller Phone: (516) 321-4670 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: USA TANK Contact Person Phone: (718) 384-9151

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/10/1998 TANK TEST FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------TANK TEST INFORMATION

Tank Number Tank Size Tank Test Method Leak Rate Gross Leak or Failure

1 1500 HORNER EZ CHECK 0.00 UNKNOWN ------Caller Remarks: FAILURE OF TANK TEST ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 20 686 LEXINGTON AVE Spill Number: 9508097 Close Date: 686 LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/06/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1856 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 23

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: BOB KLESHELSKY Caller Agency: DRY AS A BONE INC Caller Phone: (516) 678-5115 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: GERRY CURTIN Contact Person Phone: (516) 678-5115

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/02/1995 TANK TEST FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------TANK TEST INFORMATION

Tank Number Tank Size Tank Test Method Leak Rate Gross Leak or Failure

001 1000 HORNER EZ CHECK 0.00 UNKNOWN ------Caller Remarks: NO REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 21 Spill Number: 0212048 Close Date: 941 2ND AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 04/30/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1919 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL ------

NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 24

Map Identification Number 22 SOL GOLDMAN ESTATES Spill Number: 9612022 Close Date: 300 EAST 49TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/06/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2003 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: SOL GOLDMAN ESTATES Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: BOB KOESHEFSKY Notifier Phone: (516) 678-5115 Caller Name: BOB KOESHEFSKY Caller Agency: DRY AS A BONE, INC. Caller Phone: (516) 678-5115 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: SAM Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/06/1997 TANK TEST FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL TANK TEST INFORMATION

Tank Number Tank Size Tank Test Method Leak Rate Gross Leak or Failure

001 2000 HORNER EZ CHECK 0.00 UNKNOWN ------Caller Remarks: TANK IN BASEMENT ENCASED IN CONCRETE HAD A GROSS FAILURE DURING TEST ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 23 AVIS RENT A CAR Spill Number: 0110774 Close Date: 153 WEST 54TH MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 02/10/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 153 W 54TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2524 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

02/11/2002 GASOLINE 0.00 GALLONS YES TANK TEST FAILURE ON LAND ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 25

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 26

------ACTIVE UNKNOWN CAUSE SPILLS AND OTHER CAUSE SPILLS IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/2 MILE SEARCH RADIUS ------* - Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address. ------**Site profiles in this report section contain up to 36 data fields of information obtained from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Since 1/1/02, the DEC has only released information for 12 of those data fields: spill name, address components, spill date, close date, material spilled, quantity spilled, units, cause of spill and resource affected. The date after "Information updated through:" indicates when these 12 data fields were last updated. The other 24 data fields are only updated through 1/1/02. ------

Map Identification Number 24 304 PARK AVE Spill Number: 9814533 Close Date: 304 PARK AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 208 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR CROWE Notifier Phone: ( ) - Caller Name: STEVE ROMERO Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/05/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 3.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CALLER DOING SITE WORK FOUND CONTAMINATED SOIL. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 27

Map Identification Number 25 MANHOLE 50263 Spill Number: 0205867 Close Date: E 48TH ST/MADISON AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/08/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 539 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

09/06/2002 UNKNOWN MATERIAL 1.00 POUNDS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 26 OMNI HOTEL Spill Number: 0211613 Close Date: 21 E 52ND ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 03/01/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 778 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

02/23/2003 GASOLINE 0.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 27 MANHOLE #DMA5N-39 Spill Number: 9909928 Close Date: 53RD ST & MADISON AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/19/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 53RD ST / MADISON AVE Approximate distance from property: 838 feet to the N Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK SOURCE Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MATT ALBANESE Notifier Phone: (718) 243-4144 Caller Name: PASHKO CAMAJ Caller Agency: NYC TRANSIT -ASSISTED SAF Caller Phone: (718) 243-4581 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 28

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/16/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 200.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES 200 GAL OF OIL IN MANHOLE - THEY KNOW IT IS NOT COMING FROM TRANSIT FACILITIES - UNK SOURCE ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 28 Spill Number: 0009194 Close Date: 520 MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 965 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: FEDERAL EXPRESS Spiller Phone: (901) 434-8468 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: DEMEO Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/09/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE UNKNOWN 10.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: TRUCK LEAKED IFO THE ADDRESS -REST OF ADDRESS: BUILDING B 2ND FLOOR - CLEANED UP ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 29

Map Identification Number 29 MANHOLE 33871 Spill Number: 9808714 Close Date: E 52ND ST/5TH AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 990 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR BYLACK Notifier Phone: Caller Name: FRANK MASSERIA Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: ABOVE CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/13/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: unknown liquid mixed with 100 gallons of water in manhole - cleanup pending results - con ed#120497 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 30 Spill Number: 0204373 Close Date: 5 TH AV & E 52ND ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/09/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 5TH AVE / E 52ND ST Approximate distance from property: 990 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

02/02/2001 UNKNOWN MATERIAL 5.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 30

Map Identification Number 31 ' VS 4673' Spill Number: 0211713 Close Date: 5TH AVE / EAST 47TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 03/01/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1083 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

02/26/2003 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 3.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 32 EAST 53RD ST & Spill Number: 0201567 Close Date: LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/15/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: EAST 53RD ST / LEXINGTON AVE Approximate distance from property: 1111 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

05/11/2001 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 33 VAULT V4639 Spill Number: 0001456 Close Date: 18 EAST 46TH STREET MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1145 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: BILL MURPHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 31

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/05/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 50.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: SAMPLES TAKEN - CON ED NUMBER 131222 - PCB VALUE 50 PPM - MATERIAL DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE OIL -POSSIBLE THIRD PARTY SPILL ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 34 38 WEST 48TH ST Spill Number: 9415241 Close Date: 38 WEST 48TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/21/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1189 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: SAME Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JOE OSTTROWSKI Caller Agency: AL EASTMOND & CO Caller Phone: (718) 378-3000 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/21/1995 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 40.00 POUNDS NO 0.00 POUNDS NO ------Caller Remarks: SUPER OF BUILDING FOUND LEAK UNKNOWN AT THIS TIME IF TANK OR LINE LEAKED- OIL COMPANY CLEANE DUP AND IMPUT TANK. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 32

Map Identification Number 35 MANHOLE Spill Number: 0001541 Close Date: 21 WEST 47TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1224 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: BRIAN JOYCE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/07/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

MOTOR OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: SAMPLE TO BE TAKEN-CLEANUP PENDING RESULTS-OIL SPILL WAS 3RD PARTY NO WATERWAYS OR SEWERS AFFECTED. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 36 ROOSEVELT HOTEL Spill Number: 9912831 Close Date: 45 E 45TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/18/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1257 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: ROOSEVELT HOTEL Spiller Phone: (212) 885-6115 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: ALBA Contact Person Phone: (212) 885-6115

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 33

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/10/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#4 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 200.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: a couple of hundred gallons were spilled into the tank room - at this time they are trying to clean up & make a determination as to the cause ------DEC Investigator R. LEUNG (DEC) SPOKE TO CALLER AT 15:25 HRS. SPILL CONTAINED IN TANK AND BEING CLEANED UP. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 37 MANHOLE 8962 Spill Number: 9809369 Close Date: 5 WEST 46TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1287 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MARCY Notifier Phone: Caller Name: TONY CONSTATINE Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/27/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 25.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: TREATED AS OVER 500PPM OF PCB - CASE #120839 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 34

Map Identification Number 38 VAULT 9376 Spill Number: 0108646 Close Date: 130 EAST 54TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 11/30/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1297 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: SEAN MCKEEVER Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/28/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 2 gals unk oil on 5gals water confined to vault - sample taken clean up pending results - con ed 140414 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 39 VAULT #V185 Spill Number: 0000146 Close Date: 685 5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1300 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: MIKE CESARE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 35

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/04/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 2 QUARTS UNK PETROLEUM ON 50 GALLONS OF WATER IN A VAULT. SAMPLE TAKEN-CLEANUP PENDING RESULTS- CON ED #130742. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 40 3RD AVE Spill Number: 9713229 Close Date: BETWEEN EAST 51 & 52 ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/11/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: E 51ST ST / THIRD AVE / E 52ND ST Approximate distance from property: 1321 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: JOSEPH GREEN Notifier Phone: (718) 595-6777 Caller Name: JOSEPH GREEN Caller Agency: NYC DEPT OF ENVIR PROT Caller Phone: (718) 595-6777 DEC Investigator: HALE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;UNKNOWN RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/26/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: UNK MATERIAL IS RUNNING AN EXCAVATION BEING DONE BY CALLER`S WATER SUPPLY CREW REQ CALL BACK AND RESPONCE ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 36

Map Identification Number 41 VAULT 5813 Spill Number: 0001394 Close Date: 201 EAST 48TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1338 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: MARK SCHLEGEL Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/04/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: ON 2 GALLONS OF WATER - SAMPLE TAKEN - TREATING IT AS 50 TO 499 CLEAN UP IN PROGRESS - CON ED #131197 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 42 MH 59238 Spill Number: 0001685 Close Date: WEST 54TH ST/5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1346 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: JIMMY FOX Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 37

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/09/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIELECTRIC FLUID UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1 gal of di elec. fluid found in manhole. sample taken clean up pending test results. ref #131329. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 43 MANHOLE 56454 Spill Number: 9807861 Close Date: IFO 16-18 W46TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1388 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: JOHN HEFFERNAN Notifier Phone: Caller Name: WILLIAM MURPHY Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: WILLIAM MURPHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/28/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: FOUND OIL IN A MANHOLE.UNKNOWN ORIGIN. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 38

Map Identification Number 44 RESIDENCE Spill Number: 9803776 Close Date: 39 WEST 53RD ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/10/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1459 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: RESIDENCE Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: EUGENIA BERNARD Notifier Phone: (718) 595-6700 Caller Name: EUGENIA BERNARD Caller Agency: DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6700 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: PAUL BENNETT DEP EMP Contact Person Phone: (917) 769-1282 ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/24/1998 OTHER IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: water main break caused water to flow into oil storage tank causing overflow of material into the sewer monitoring occurring at the sewer pumping station for contamination ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 45 45 ST & LEXINGTON AVE Spill Number: 9402500 Close Date: 45TH ST / LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/21/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 45TH ST / LEXINGTON AVE Approximate distance from property: 1470 feet to the S Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: SUSMITA BISWAS Caller Agency: NYNEX Caller Phone: (212) 338-7126 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/20/1994 OTHER ON LAND NO NO ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 39

Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN -1.00 POUNDS NO 0.00 POUNDS NO ------Caller Remarks: CLEAN UP BY CLEAN HARBORS (908)248-1997 POSSIBLY TODAY. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 46 MANHOLE 120087 Spill Number: 9807871 Close Date: IFO 31-33 W46TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: 31 - 33 W 46TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1480 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR MEHIAS Notifier Phone: Caller Name: BILL MURPHY Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: BILL MURPHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/28/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: OIL FOUND IN MANHOLE. UNKNOWN WHERE IT CAME FROM. INVESTIGATING. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 40

Map Identification Number 47 Spill Number: 0105782 Close Date: 43 WEST 53RD ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/03/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1491 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: (646) 557-0230 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TIPPLE Contact for more spill info: CAROL BAKER Contact Person Phone: (646) 557-0230

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/29/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: contaminate soil found while digging foundation for new building ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 48 VOLT #04784 Spill Number: 0300255 Close Date: 700 5TH AV MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 04/20/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1491 feet to the N Revised zip code: UNKNOWN

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

04/07/2003 #2 FUEL OIL 2.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 41

Map Identification Number 49 SERVICE BOX 10745 Spill Number: 9807873 Close Date: 127 E55TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 127 E 55TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1505 feet to the NE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MR HEFFERNAN Notifier Phone: (212) 338-4026 Caller Name: LISA PRIMEGGIA Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: LISA PRIMEGGIA Contact Person Phone: (211) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/28/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: SPILL IS IN SERVICE BOX. UNKNOWN WHERE IT CAME FROM. CLEAN-UP IS IN PROGRESS. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 50 MANHOLE #8595 Spill Number: 9906387 Close Date: IFO 22 E 44TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1610 feet to the SW Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: STEPHEN ROMERO Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: STEPHEN ROMERO Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: STEPHEN ROMERO Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 42

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/29/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 5 GALS OF UNK OIL - POSS COOKING OIL - ON 200 GALS OF WATER SAMPLE TAKEN CLEAN UP PENDING LAB RESULTS CON ED # 127474 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 51 VAULT #`S 4593 & 3686 Spill Number: 9906386 Close Date: IFO 22 E 44TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1610 feet to the SW Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: STEPHEN ROMERO Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: STEPHEN ROMERO Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: STEPHEN ROMERO Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/29/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 10.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: THERE IS 5 GALS OF THE MATERIAL ON 200 GALS OF WATER - POSS COOKING OIL - IN EACH VAULT SAMPLE HAS BEEN TAKEN - CLEAN UP PENDING LAB RESULTS CON ED # 127473 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 43

Map Identification Number 52 Spill Number: 9909408 Close Date: 46 WEST 46TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/19/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1622 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: NYC FD Notifier Phone: (212) 570-4261 Caller Name: ZOLA BAILEY Caller Agency: NYC DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6700 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/02/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

NITRIC ACID UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: no info provided by caller on spill ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 53 VAULT 3686 Spill Number: 9901455 Close Date: 16 EAST 44TH ST MANHATTED, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1670 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: STEVEN CRIBBIN Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: STEVEN CRIBBIN Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 44

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/07/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: unk materal found inside vault when they were doing other work - materal contained - 2 gal on 60 gal of water -- con ed spill 124715 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

CON ED E2MIS NOTES

Approx. 2 gals. of unknown fluid on approx. 60 gals. of water. Fluid is contained to the vault did not enter any sewers or waterways. Structure has a sump pump and sewer connection, on arrival found pump disconnected. There are no cracks in structure. Two samples taken and sign #25438 hung.

5-11-99 Final cleanup on 5-10-99 @18:00hrs. Used Astoria <50ppm tanker to remove liquid from vault. Used Flush truck to flush vault after Astoria tanker complete.

In accordiane with I&A OS P. Renzulli, this job was completed using a hard copy dated in Feburary from E2MIS incident #123221. The hard copy showed the pill was <49ppm. However, final sample result were not yet received from this job at time of final cleanup. The I&A discovered this at 5-11-99.

5-11-99 09:15 While I & A planner A. Johnson #81226 was updaing spill that occured in V3686, it was discovered that PCB sample results were not yet recieved. This was verified with the I&A OS involved in the job. The identification sample results posted stated that there was not enough of a sample to identify.

5-11-99 Chem Lab stated that the lab sequence number for the PCB analysis would be 99-04779, the results wer not yet posted and within a half an hour the Chem Lab could tell us when the sample would be posted.

5-11-99 09:30 Astoria Transp., tanker might be on way to Bklyn, hw willtry to catch it before it gets there and put the tanker on hold.

5-11-99 09:35 Flush advised us that the truck that flushed the spill location was #60533. The truck dumped it's load from last night this morning at approx. 08:30 in the W 28 St. WOL PCB pit. They will contact driver of the truck an put the truck on hold in W. 28th St. yard.

5-11-99 09:40 Pump and waste treatment facility at W 28th St. WOL shut down.

5-11-99 09:45 Called Chem Lab for status on ext.4123- was told that the chain of custody requests only a 4 day turn around, not an emergency turn-around. I&A Planner explained circumstances and requested an excalation to immediate results.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 45

5-11-99 09:50 Chem Lab supervisor, Lima Jones contacted and agreed to escalate sample results.

09: 55 Astoria tanker is on hold in Astoria until sample results received.

10:05 No further notification required at this time. We need to page him back as soon as sample results are recieved. He verified the waste treatment facility was shut down as soon as the lack of a official hard copy was discovered.

14:00 Chem Lab results recieved.Lab Seq#99-04779 Aroclor, none PCB <1ppm

5-11-99 14:10 All involved departments and managers listed inthis note were not advised of sample results. Hold was taken off flush pit, waste treatment plant, flush truck, and Astoria tanker.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 54 V#4567/3473/3686/4593 Spill Number: 9814094 Close Date: 16 EAST 44TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1670 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MR ROMANO Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: TONY CONSTANTINE Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/22/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTING THAT 4 VAULTS THAT ARE INTERCONNECTED HAVE APPROX 4 QTS OF AN UNKNOWN OIL. THIS IS MIXED WITH 500 GALS OF WATER. SAMPLES TAKEN, WATER TO BE PUMPED OUT. CON ED #123221. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 46

Map Identification Number 55 NEW CONSTRUCTION SITE Spill Number: 0110276 Close Date: 205-209 EAST 45TH STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/26/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1758 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

01/18/2002 OTHER PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS YES OTHER ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 56 44TH STREET BETWEEN 3RD Spill Number: 0012892 Close Date: AND LEXINGTON MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/31/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 44TH STREET Approximate distance from property: 1841 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: SUNRISE TRANSPORTATION Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: CITIZEN Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: DEMEO Contact for more spill info: N/A Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/07/2001 OTHER ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CITIZEN SAW A BUS DRIPPING WHAT LOOKED LIKE A BRIGHT GREEN SUBSTANCE ONTO THE GROUND.THE BUS HAS SUNRISE TRANSPORTATION. CELL-914-953-8588 FOR OUR COMPLAINT ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 47

Map Identification Number 57 VAULT #4018 Spill Number: 9808688 Close Date: 703-719 3RD AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1872 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: MR LEE Notifier Phone: Caller Name: BILL MURPHY Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: BILL MURPHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/13/1998 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 10.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: NOTIFIER FOUND OIL ON WATER IN TRANSFORMER VAULT - CON ED #120490 - SAMPLE TAKEN & CLEAN UP WILL BE ACCORDING TO RESULTS ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 58 MANHOLE 59454 Spill Number: 9813265 Close Date: MADISON AVENUE / EAST 57T MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: MADISON AV / E 57TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1895 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR TIMMONS Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: RICHARD ROACH Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: RICHARD ROACH Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 48

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/29/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: contained in a manhole they did take a sample con edison case is 122740 nothing furthur at this time ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 59 FOUR SEASONS HOTEL Spill Number: 9800666 Close Date: 57 TH EST 57TH STREET NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/11/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 57 E 57TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1908 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: FOUR SEASONS HOTEL Spiller Phone: (212) 758-5700 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: SAME Notifier Phone: Caller Name: CITIZEN Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: SACCACIO Contact for more spill info: HERBERT PLIESSNIG Contact Person Phone: (212) 758-5700

Spill Class: POSSIBLE RELEASE WITH MIN POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD (OR KNOWN REL W/ NO DAMAGE);NO DEC RESP;NO CORR ACTION REQUIRED ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/15/1998 OTHER ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN HAZARDOUS MATERIAL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: peck is being spilled on to the floor and causing a health problem. that is in the valet area. subject stated that people were getting dizzy and having chest pain.he was advised to call the local ems ------DEC Investigator FAX TO DEP HAZMAT. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 49

Map Identification Number 60 EAST 56TH ST Spill Number: 9807357 Close Date: 201FT WEST OF 3RD AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/10/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: E 56TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1913 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR RUSSO Notifier Phone: (212) 338-3352 Caller Name: BILL MURPHY Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: BILL MURPHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/16/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: sending a crew to see if tranformer is missing any oil - but as of this time not sure were product is coming from or what product is ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 61 Spill Number: 0203871 Close Date: 50TH ST/2ND AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/11/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 50TH ST / SECOND AVE Approximate distance from property: 1949 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

07/12/2002 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS YES UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 50

Map Identification Number 62 25 WEST 56TH ST Spill Number: 9704066 Close Date: 25 WEST 56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1956 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: (917) 880-7201 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MIKE CESARE Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: MIKE CESARE Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: MOSTEYN Contact Person Phone: (917) 880-7201

Spill Class: NO SPILL OCCURRED;NO DEC RESPONSE;NO CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/04/1997 OTHER ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

ASBESTOS UNKNOWN 2.00 POUNDS NO 0.00 POUNDS NO ------Caller Remarks: DUST COATING ON GROUND AND STREET DEC SAMPLING CAME BACK NEGATIVE NON ASBESTOS ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 63 VAULT #2588 Spill Number: 0100269 Close Date: 25-27 W 56TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/10/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1961 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: CHARLIE MCCARTHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6765

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 51

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/09/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN NON-PETRO/NON-HAZ MATERIAL UNKNOWN 70.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: WORKERS FOUND 70 GALLONS OF AN UNKNOWN PRODUCT IN THE ABPVE VAULT, THE MATERIAL IS BEING TESTED NOW - CON ED SPILL #136347 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 64 COMMERCIAL BUILDING Spill Number: 9605869 Close Date: 130 EAST 57TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1961 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

This site was dropped from the NYDEC spills database, the last information given is listed here

Source of Spill: NONE GIVEN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: NONE GIVEN Notifier Name: JOHN LAROCCHIA Notifier Phone: (718) 476-6288 Caller Name: JOHN LAROCCHIA Caller Agency: NYC FIRE DEPARTMENT Caller Phone: (718) 476-6288 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: GARY GREEN Contact Person Phone: (212) 753-8841

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/06/1996 NONE GIVEN NONE GIVEN NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#4 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 250.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: NO REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 52

Map Identification Number 65 MANHOLE #57881 Spill Number: 9810038 Close Date: 3RD AVE/E 44 ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 3RD AVE / E 44TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1970 feet to the S Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: STEVE ROMERO Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: STEVE ROMERO Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: ABOVE CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/09/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 3.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 3 gals unk oil on 580 gallons water - cleanup pending test results - con ed #121157 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 66 MANHOLE 57881 Spill Number: 9808720 Close Date: THIRD AVE/E 44 ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 3RD AV / E 44TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1970 feet to the S Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR MCHUE Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: JOE DEVOTI Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: JOE DEVOTI Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 53

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/14/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 25.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: spill contained to manhole ref # 120501 cleanup pending lab results ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 67 MANHOLE 54394 Spill Number: 0011448 Close Date: EAST 49TH/2ND AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: EAST 49TH ST / SECOND AV Approximate distance from property: 1972 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/23/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: discovered sheen in a manhole . clean up pending test results con ed#135185 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 54

Map Identification Number 68 136 57TH STREET Spill Number: 9404041 Close Date: 136 E 57TH STREET NEW YORK, NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/21/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1976 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: MYSTIC OIL Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: STEVE MINNINGER Caller Agency: CLEAN HARBOR Caller Phone: (908) 248-1997 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/27/1994 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN -1.00 POUNDS NO 0.00 POUNDS NO ------Caller Remarks: WILL VACCUM OUT MANHOLE. AT MANHOLE THERE WAS A TANK NEARBY (MAJESTIC OIL`S) ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: OIL INTO MANHOLE.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 69 MANHOLE 5047 Spill Number: 0006000 Close Date: 300 E 49TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2003 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 55

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/19/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 2 gal unk oil in manhole. cleanup pending lab results ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 70 MANHOLE 54384 Spill Number: 0013307 Close Date: 2ND AV / E 48TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/31/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: SECOND AVE / E 48TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2021 feet to the SE Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/21/2001 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 2qts unk oil in manhole - entered sewer - sample taken - tanker on way for clean up - case #136023 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 56

Map Identification Number 71 309 EAST 49TH ST Spill Number: 9713117 Close Date: 309 EAST 49TH ST NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/11/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2029 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: 309 EAST 49TH ST Spiller Phone: (212) 753-3210 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MIKE CAMBASCO Notifier Phone: (212) 753-3210 Caller Name: CATHERINE ESPOSITO Caller Agency: CAPITAL ENVIRO. SERVICES Caller Phone: (732) 747-0432 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: (212) 753-3210

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/24/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 10,000 gallon u/g tank leaking. caller is response company. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 72 EAST 56TH ST/3RD AVE Spill Number: 9513776 Close Date: EAST 56TH ST/3RD AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/16/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2033 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: BATTALION 8 Notifier Phone: Caller Name: DISP 313 Caller Agency: FDNY - MANHATTEN Caller Phone: (212) 570-4300 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 57

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/30/1996 UNKNOWN AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

ASBESTOS UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: BROKEN STEAM PIPE UNDER STREET - CON-ED HAZ MAZ AND DECON THERE FDNY HAZ-MAT ON WAY ------DEC Investigator see also spill #9513822. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 73 MANHOLE 33909 Spill Number: 9516135 Close Date: 57TH ST AND 5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/14/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: W 57TH ST / 5TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 2041 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR PINTO Notifier Phone: (212) 338-3352 Caller Name: LISA PRIMEGGIA Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: LISA PRIMEGGIA Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/15/1996 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: while pumping water from the manhole they noticed that as the water hit the street it turned the street yellow unknown why samples are being taken at the time ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 58

Map Identification Number 74 Spill Number: 9812883 Close Date: 47-65 EAST 42ND STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/06/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 47 EAST 42ND STREET Approximate distance from property: 2070 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MIKE CROWE Notifier Phone: ( ) - Caller Name: BILL MURPHY Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/20/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 4.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: VAULT #3232. FOUR GALLONS OF UNKNOWN OIL ON 50 GALLONS OF WATER. CONTAINED WITHIN MANHOLE. SAMPLES TAKEN. TO BE CLEANED UP AS IS 50-499 PPM OF PBC`S. CON EDISON REFERENCE NUMBER 122540. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 75 TRANSFORMER VAULT #VS3986 Spill Number: 0202676 Close Date: W 54TH ST - 1723 6TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/13/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: W 54TH ST / 6TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 2093 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: 10019

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

06/12/2002 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 150.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 59

Map Identification Number 76 MANHOLE 50224 Spill Number: 0107696 Close Date: E42ND ST/MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 42ND ST / MADISON AV Approximate distance from property: 2112 feet to the SW Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: RODRIGUEZ Contact for more spill info: PETE MCGUIRE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/26/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: under a transformer.con ed #139983 ***lab results back 131 ppm. pcb ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

E2MIS notes:

On 10/26 J. Thelian that he discovered 1 gallon of unknown substance and there was no water in the manhole. The spill was on the concrete floor of the manhole. The cause of the spill is unknown. There is no sewer connection. Two samples for PCB and ID were taken.

10/27/2001 9:35 hours

There was a partial cleanup at this location. There was approximately 450 gallons of fluid removed from the unit and the cleanup will continue at a later time.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 60

Map Identification Number 77 MANHOLE #TM4654 Spill Number: 0107611 Close Date: 137 WEST 49TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2138 feet to the WNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: BILL MURPHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/25/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 8.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: on 12 gals of water - cleanup follow 50-400ppm ref #139942 manhole contains a transformer - dyelectric filled equipment ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con Ed e2mis Notes:

10/25/01 8gal oil on 12gal water in transformer manhole. There is dielectric equipment in structure. Source and cause cannot be determined at this time. Conduit plate shows that there is a sewer connection. Samples were taken from the source for PCB and ID. Initial action taken--put absorbant pads down.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 78 MANHOLE IFO 230 E44TH ST Spill Number: 9509012 Close Date: 230 EAST 44TH STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/16/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2141 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 61

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: JOHN WEISE Notifier Phone: (212) 374-6029 Caller Name: MOIRA SMITH Caller Agency: DEP Caller Phone: (718) 596-6777 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: NOTIFIER Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/21/1995 OTHER IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

PCB OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CON ED TRANSFORMER ON FIRE IN A MANHOLE - NO CONFIRMATION THAT THERE HAS BEEN ANY SPILL - CHEMIST ON SCENE REQUESTED DEC NUMBER DUE TO PCBS IN TRANSFORMER ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/21/95 (Mulqueen notes): Dan Weisse, NYCDEP - there was explosion, everything under control. Transformer was on fire. According to Con Ed (Hanson 212-338-4014, Gas General Foreman 338-3352) was small explosion - nothing released to atmosphere or street. Does not know PCB count. Jim Slattery, Con Ed - transformer failure network. No release to outside, oil released inside vault. Smoke, no fire - not sure if water in vault. 34 ppm PCB. 10/21/95, 11:30 - call back from Tony Zic, COn Ed - Vault is dry. No water, no oil in or near sump. Easy clean up and will be done by 7:00 AM. Secret service putting pressure to end contruction ASAP. 10/23/95 (Engelhardt notes): Joe Devenny, Con Ed CIG - spots of oil on vault wall - 34 pppm PCB as per records. Enzo Catanzaro, NYCDEP - was a spill - sprayed onto wall of vault inside vault so DEP did not sample.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 79 Spill Number: 0111965 Close Date: 470 PARK AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/21/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2145 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: TANK TRUCK ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

03/20/2002 #6 FUEL OIL 4.00 GALLONS NO OTHER ON LAND ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 62

Map Identification Number 80 MANHOLE COVER Spill Number: 9613010 Close Date: 43RD ST /3 RD AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 43RD ST / THIRD AVE Approximate distance from property: 2171 feet to the S Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: NYNEX Spiller Phone: (212) 629-0968 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: NYNEX Notifier Phone: (212) 629-0968 Caller Name: CLARINDA WEST Caller Agency: MILRO ASSOC Caller Phone: (516) 379-1570 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: CLARINDA WEST Contact Person Phone: (516) 379-1570

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/03/1997 OTHER IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: WHILE CLEANING OUT THE MANHOLE AT THE ABOVE LOCATION THEY FOUND 3 TO 4 FEET OF OIL AND WATER MIXED IN THE MANHOLE SPILL WILL BE CLEANED UP TOMORROW ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 81 MANHOLE 11322 Spill Number: 0101292 Close Date: E58TH ST/LEX & PARK MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E58TH ST/LEX / PARK Approximate distance from property: 2191 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: BILL MURPHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 63

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/02/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CLEAN UP PENDING. NO SEWER/WATER. SPILL WAS INITIALLY CALSSIFIED AS A 24HR DIMINIMIS SPILL. DURING CLEAN UP OIL WAS DISCOVERED SEEPING THROUGH FLOOR OF MANHOLE. SITUATION TO BE INVESTIGATED, CLEAN UP WILL NOT BE COMPLETED WITH IN 24 HOURS. CON ED# 136792. SAMPLE FOR PCB AND ID. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 82 Spill Number: 9908420 Close Date: E 42ND ST & LEXINGTON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/19/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 42ND ST / LEXINGTON AV Approximate distance from property: 2191 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR. BOZE Notifier Phone: Caller Name: FRANK MASSERIA Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/12/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: MANHOLE 38633. ONE GALLON UNKNOWN OIL AND THREE GALLONS OF WATER. CONTAINED WITHIN MANHOLE. SAMPLES TAKEN. CLEAN UP PENDING TEST RESULTS. CON EDISON REFERENCE NUMBER 128367. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 64

Con ed e2mis notes:

FDR-602, unknown oil approx 1 gal mixed with 3 gals water in MH-38633, source of spill unknown, "PCB" sample taken by Mcmanus, no other oil filled equipment in structure.

AROCLOR #1254 PCB count<1.00ppm, clean up complete in MH-38633, removed 100 gals oil/Water to <50 tanker, generated 1 drum PPE, used flush truck to clean and rinse structure.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 83 EAST 42ND ST&LEXINGTON AV Spill Number: 8807301 Close Date: E 42ND ST / LEXINGTON AVE NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/24/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2191 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: CAPTAIN GORMAN Caller Agency: NYCFD Caller Phone: (718) 403-1278 DEC Investigator: ROMMEL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;UNKNOWN RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/02/1988 UNKNOWN GROUNDWATER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 2000 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: SEEPAGE NOTICED IN ELECTRICAL PIT, PRODUCT PUMPED INTO 55 GALLON DRUMS& SENT TO BE ANALYZED. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 65

Map Identification Number 84 MANHOLE 56635 Spill Number: 9908081 Close Date: W 42ND STREET & 5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/19/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: W 42ND STREET / 5TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 2235 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR ROMANO Notifier Phone: ( ) - Caller Name: MR SCHLAGEL Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: COMENALE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/04/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIELECTRIC FLUID UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: faulty cable leaked 1 gal of dielectric fluid onto ground clean up pending crew treated as 50-499 coned#128214 no callback necessary ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 85 VAULT 2691 Spill Number: 0107855 Close Date: WEST 42ND STREET AT 5TH A MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: WEST 42ND STREET / 5TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 2235 feet to the SW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: PETE MCGUIRE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 66

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/01/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIELECTRIC FLUID UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: POSSIBLE EQUIPMENT FAILURE CON ED NUMBER 140068 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con Ed e2mis #140068:

11/01/01 5gal oily dirt on concrete floor of vault 2691. Sump pump was disabled. Leak looked like it was coming out of the bottom of the transformer and not out of feeder 5M86. No water in vault. Two samples were taken for PCB and ID. Capacity is 215gal.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 86 Spill Number: 0003665 Close Date: EAST 54TH ST & 2ND AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: EAST 54TH ST / SECOND AV Approximate distance from property: 2244 feet to the E Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/26/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 67

------Caller Remarks: MANHOLE 55146. ONE GALLON UNKNOWN OIL ON 100 GALLONS OF WATER. CONTAINED WITHIN MANHOLE. SAMPLES TAKEN. CLEAN UP PENDING TEST RESULTS. CON EDISON REFERENCE NUMBER 132008. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 87 MANHOLE 54449 Spill Number: 0003627 Close Date: E 54TH ST & 2ND AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 54TH ST / SECOND AV Approximate distance from property: 2244 feet to the E Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/23/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: UNK SOLID FOUND IN MANHOLE - CLEAN UP PENDING LAB RESULTS - REF 131999 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 88 VAULT 4437 Spill Number: 0001537 Close Date: 11 WEST 42ND ST MANAHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2246 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 68

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: BRIAN JOYCE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/07/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 3.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 2 gals on floor of vault and 1 gal near sump pit. clean up pending. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 89 VAULT`S #0988-5687 & 5769 Spill Number: 0206866 Close Date: 137 E 58TH ST/LEXINGTON MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/28/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 137 E 58TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2268 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

10/02/2002 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS YES UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 90 MANHOLE 45032 Spill Number: 9808781 Close Date: EAST 57TH ST/ 3RD AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2269 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: 10022 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 69

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MCHUGH Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JOE DEVOTI Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/15/1998 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: POSS SEWER LEAK - SPILL IN MANHOLE - NYC DEP ALSO NOTIFIED - CASE #120523 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 91 VAULT 2975 Spill Number: 0211679 Close Date: 2 WEST 58TH ST MAHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 03/01/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2338 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

02/25/2003 TRANSFORMER OIL 1.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 92 MANHOLE #50214 Spill Number: 9808363 Close Date: E 41S ST & MADISON AV MAHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 41ST ST / MADISON AV Approximate distance from property: 2355 feet to the SW Revised zip code: 10017 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 70

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR BOSZE Notifier Phone: Caller Name: BILL MURPHY Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: BILL MURPHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/06/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: unknown oil in the manhole - 16 ounces - con ed ref #120362 - pcb samples taking ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

The following information was obtained from the ConEd E2MIS report. 16 ounces of unknown oil found along the south wall of the manhole.

General Info:

How spill was discovered: Found spill while rodding duct.

Containment: No sewers or waterways affected.

Oil containing equipment in manhole: Information was unavailable at the time.

Cleanup Plan: Sample taking, pads and socks placed in manhole and cleanup is pending results. -sps

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 93 MANHOLE #56305 Spill Number: 9812822 Close Date: EAST 41ST ST AND PARK AV MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/06/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: EAST 41ST ST / PARK AV Approximate distance from property: 2357 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 71

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MR CROWE Notifier Phone: ( ) - Caller Name: JOE DEVOTI Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/19/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 200.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN NON-PETRO/NON-HAZ MATERIAL UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1 GAL IS UNK OIL/OTHER IS UNK WHITE SUBSTANCE/SAMPLES OF BOTH HAVE BEEN TAKEN/CLEANUP WILL TAKE PLACE AFTER LAB RESULTS HAVE BEEN MADE CON ED REF # 122504 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 94 LANDRESS RESIDENCE Spill Number: 9811966 Close Date: 352 EAST 51ST ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/06/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2364 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: LANDRESS RESIDENCE Spiller Phone: (212) 371-5822 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: AMY LANDRESS Notifier Phone: (212) 371-5822 Caller Name: AMY LANDRESS Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (212) 371-5822 DEC Investigator: O`DOWD Contact for more spill info: AMY LANDRESS Contact Person Phone: (212) 371-5822

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/01/1997 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 72

------Caller Remarks: HOUSE HAD SOME FLOODING LAST YEAR AND WHILE DIGGING THEY FOUND A FUEL OIL SPILL AND IT STILL SMELLS OF FUEL OIL CALLER DOESN`T THINK THIS HAS BEEN REPORTS AND THERE IS STILL A ODER IN APT - SHE WOULD LIKE A CALL REGARDING THE HEALTH PROBLEMS ASAP - PAGER ##917-317-9133 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 95 CON EDISON - VAULT #5241 Spill Number: 9503056 Close Date: 304 EAST 45TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/16/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2374 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MR. MENDELSOHN Caller Agency: EPA Caller Phone: (908) 548-8730 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/12/1995 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 15.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CLEAN UP IN PROGRESS - ABSORBENTS BEING USED - 10 GALLON LAND 5 GAL INTO SEWER - 130 PARTS PER MILLION (PCB LEVEL) ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 73

Map Identification Number 96 KINNEY GARAGE Spill Number: 0000584 Close Date: 149 W 53RD ST NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2393 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: GASOLINE STATION Spiller: KINNEY GARAGE Spiller Phone: (631) 864-4200 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: ERIK ZALEWSKI Contact Person Phone: (631) 864-4200

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/14/2000 OTHER GROUNDWATER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1 4,000 GALLON TANK WAS ABANDONDED AT SITE-DUE TO CLOSURE ASSESSMENT CONTAMINATION WAS DISCOVED VIA LAB DATA. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 97 IN FRONT OF Spill Number: 9703310 Close Date: 62 EAST 59TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2401 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR BOSSE Notifier Phone: Caller Name: FRANK MASSERIA Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 74

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/17/1997 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

TRANSFORMER OIL UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 10ppm for pcb - estimate 2 gal in the vault ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 98 VAULT #5673 Spill Number: 0205533 Close Date: 201 EAST 42ND ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/08/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2401 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

08/27/2002 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 99 UNK Spill Number: 0111384 Close Date: 485 5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/25/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2406 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

03/02/2002 UNKNOWN MATERIAL 0.00 GALLONS YES UNKNOWN AIR ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 75

Map Identification Number 100 47 W 42ND ST Spill Number: 9608924 Close Date: 47 W 42ND ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/13/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2417 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6764 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: NRC Notifier Phone: Caller Name: TONY SELLERS Caller Agency: COAST GUARD Caller Phone: (212) 668-7920 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: PATRICK MCHUGH Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/17/1996 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

TRANSFORMER OIL UNKNOWN 100.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 17 ppm pcb in oil - oil contained in vault - unk at this time what caused spill - oil being cleaned up ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 101 47 WEST 42ND ST Spill Number: 9608915 Close Date: 47 WEST 42ND ST NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/13/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2417 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6764 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR CROWE Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: PATRICK MCHUGH Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: PATRICK MCHUGH Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 76

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/17/1996 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

TRANSFORMER OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CREW ON SCENE AT THIS TIME. POSSIBLE 100 GAL SPILL HAS OCCURED. SOME OF THE PRODUCT HAS GONE INTO THE SEWER SYSTEM. SUMP PUMP FOR THAT AREA WAS FOUND DISCONNECTED. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 102 S E CORNER 59TH STREET Spill Number: 9808174 Close Date: AT MADISON AVENUE NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: S/E/C 59TH ST / MADISON AV Approximate distance from property: 2453 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: CROWE Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: TONY CONSTANTINE Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: TONY CONSTANTINE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/03/1998 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 10.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: unknown posible oil in the manhole unknown how it got there or where it came from spill is contained and will be recoved ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Called ConEd CIG they didn't have much info and eventually they gave me the Manhattan Ops # 212-338-3352. Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 77

General Info: 50 Gals. of water; manhole# 50361

How spill was discovered: service connection needed repair.

Containment: In manhole and no sewer connection

Oil containing equipment in manhole: None

Cleanup Plan: Sample already taken and cleanup expected 10/3/98 12:00pm -sps

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 103 VAULT 3108 Spill Number: 0008959 Close Date: 120 E41ST STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 120 E 41ST STREET Approximate distance from property: 2454 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/02/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: caller reporting a spill of material from an unk spill coned#134220 samples taken for pcb and id clean up pending test results ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 78

Map Identification Number 104 MANHOLE #38626 Spill Number: 0102080 Close Date: E 41ST ST & LEXINGTON AV NEW YORK NY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/30/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 41ST ST / LEXINGTON AV Approximate distance from property: 2459 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: ANTHONY NATALE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/23/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

OTHER PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1 gal on 75 gals of water ref #137243 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 105 Spill Number: 0104580 Close Date: 59 EAST 59TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/03/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2460 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: DELMONICO HOTEL Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: ROMMEL Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 79

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/30/2001 OTHER AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

CLEANING CHEMICALS/PRODUCTS UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: caller can smell chemicals in his business. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 106 MANHOLE 59453 Spill Number: 9811112 Close Date: MADISON AVENUE AT E 59 ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/06/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: MADISON AVENUE / E 59TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2461 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: MT CROWE Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: LISA PRIMEGGIA Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: LISA PRIMEGGIA Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/04/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CON ED NUMBER 121698 SAMPLE TAKEN CLEAN UP PENDING RESULTS ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 80

Map Identification Number 107 MANHOLE Spill Number: 9808245 Close Date: E 59TH ST & MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 59TH ST / MADISON AV Approximate distance from property: 2461 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR COOK Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: FRANK MASSERIA Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: FRANK MASSERIA Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/05/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIELECTRIC FLUID UNKNOWN 30.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO WATER RUNOFF UNKNOWN 1000 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 30 GALLONS OF DIELECTRIC FLUID ON TOP OF 1000 GALLONS OF WATER IN THE MANHOLE - CON ED REF #120307 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 108 MANHOLE #58552 Spill Number: 0006356 Close Date: 59TH ST & MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 59TH ST / MADISON AV Approximate distance from property: 2461 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: STEVEN ROMERO Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 81

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/29/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 5 gals on 2800 gals of water - clean up pending lab results - they have been taken con ed #133091 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 109 VAULT 3165 Spill Number: 9911617 Close Date: 107 EAST 59TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/18/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2469 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: COMENALE Contact for more spill info: BRIAN JOYCE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/06/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: UNDERGROUND VAULT HALF A GALLON WILL BE TESTED CLEAN UP PENDING RESULTS OF TESTING ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 82

Map Identification Number 110 Spill Number: 0005663 Close Date: EAST 41ST ST & 5TH AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: EAST 41ST ST / 5TH AV Approximate distance from property: 2481 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/10/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: MANHOLE 33800. 1/2 GALLON UNKNOWN OIL ON 80 GALLONS OF WATER. CONTAINED WITHIN MANHOLE. SAMPLES TAKEN. CLEAN UP PENDING TEST RESULTS. CON EDISON REFERENCE NUMBER NOT AVAILABLE AT THIS TIME. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 111 VAULT #V1815 Spill Number: 0301704 Close Date: 345 EAST 46TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 05/23/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2482 feet to the SE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

05/16/2003 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 83

Map Identification Number 112 MANHOLE 58552 Spill Number: 0105780 Close Date: 5TH AVE AND MADISON MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/03/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: 5TH AVE / MADISON Approximate distance from property: 2496 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: JIMMY FOX Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/29/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 60.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: cleanup pending crews con ed 139197 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 113 Spill Number: 9808191 Close Date: IFO 21 WEST 58 ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2500 feet to the N Revised zip code: 10019

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: CALLAHAN Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MIKE CESARE Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: MIKE CESARE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 84

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/03/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

ASBESTOS UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: WHILE EXCAVATING APRROX 2 OZ`S OF PRODUCT WAS DISCOVERED - UNK SOURCE - AREA HAS BEEN TAPED OFF AND COVERED WITH PLASTIC ------DEC Investigator DEP was notified Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 114 AVIS RENT A CAR Spill Number: 0105770 Close Date: 151 W 54TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/03/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2507 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: AVIS RENT A CAR Spiller Phone: (917) 769-0483 Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TIPPLE Contact for more spill info: FF JOHN GIORDANO Contact Person Phone: (917) 769-0483

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/29/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE UNKNOWN 10.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: problem with dispenser caused spill - product did enter floor drain fire dept on scene - mostly cleaned up ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 85

Map Identification Number 115 AVIS CAR RENTAL Spill Number: 0105202 Close Date: 151 WEST 54TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/03/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2507 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: AVIS CAR RENTAL Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: DEMEO Contact for more spill info: NYC FIRE Contact Person Phone: (212) 570-4300

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/13/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: ABOVE MATERIAL SPILLED AT ABOVE LOCATION. FIRE DEPT ON THE SCENE AND HAZMAT UNIT RESPONDING FOR CLEANUP. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 116 MANHOLE 50208 Spill Number: 9808292 Close Date: 285 MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2525 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR LEE Notifier Phone: Caller Name: STEVEN ROMERO Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: STEVEN ROMERO Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 86

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/06/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: petroleum on top of water in manhole - clean up pending lab results con ed ref # 120332 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Called ConEd ERT and ConEd CIG and there was no answer. Subsequent info received by ConEd E2MIS report.

General Info: 200 gallons of water, Feeder 26M48

How spill was discovered: Found in manhole when scheduled work was to be done on the feeder.

Containment: Yes - did not enter the sewer.

Oil containing equipment in manhole: Information was unavailable at the time.

Cleanup Plan: Sample taken, cleanup is pending sample results. If cleaned prior to sample results, material will be handled as 50 to 499 ppm pcb. -sps

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 117 Spill Number: 9807983 Close Date: 285 MADISON AVENUE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2525 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MR MARCY Notifier Phone: (212) 338-3352 Caller Name: LISA PRIMEGGIA Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 87

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/30/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: MANOLE 50208. UNKNOWN PETROLEUM FOUND IN MANHOLE. SAMPLES TAKEN. TO BE CLEANED UP PENDING TEST RESULTS. PROBLEM WITH COMPUTER REPORTING DATABASE AT CON EDISON DELAYED REPORTING TO DEC. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 118 MH #58552 Spill Number: 0002859 Close Date: EAST 59TH ST & 5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: EAST 59TH ST / 5TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 2547 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/07/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 20.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: Caller reporting that spill of an unknown oil was found in manhole on 1000 gals of water. Crew enroute to take samples and clean up pending those results. Con Ed #131736. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 88

Map Identification Number 119 VAULT 5611 Spill Number: 0106197 Close Date: E58TH ST / 201-13 E58TH S MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/02/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 201-213 E 58TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2549 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/11/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 4.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: caller reporting a spill called in late do to phone lines down cond#139411 samples celan up pending 90 gals of water ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 120 VAULT 5891 Spill Number: 0300002 Close Date: 471 5TH AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 04/29/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2557 feet to the SW Revised zip code: UNKNOWN

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

04/01/2003 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 4.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 89

Map Identification Number 121 SERVICE BOX 10860 Spill Number: 0105812 Close Date: IFO 123 WEST 56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/03/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2564 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: RODRIGUEZ Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/30/2001 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 15.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: redish color substance. con ed # 139212. samples taken. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 122 VIVILO RESTRUANT Spill Number: 0010767 Close Date: 228 E. 58TH STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2580 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: MIKE SELCA Contact Person Phone: (212) 421-1465

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 90

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/28/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: caller reporting a spill of material from an unk source caller states she owns the condiminium complex there and they run off steam not oil. caller unsure where it is coming from. req a callback for further info. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

DEC Sigona performed a site investigation and determined that the material impacting the restaurant was generally water, possibly from a broken water main. The probelm was referred to DEP communications for investigation. DEC Sigona spoke to AquaTerra who tested the material and thought material may also contain fuel oil. Further investigation may be appropriate after the water main is repaired. No immediate impact. No indication of petroleum vapors or oil stains visible.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 123 ROADWAY Spill Number: 0105958 Close Date: 2 CENTRAL PARK SO/5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/03/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 2 CENTRAL PARK S Approximate distance from property: 2607 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: FTA BUS Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: DEMEO Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/04/2001 OTHER ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIESEL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 91

------Caller Remarks: caller reporting a spill from a blown manhole which hit a bus fuel line causing a rupture. fire dept on scene and containing the spill no callback req. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 124 100WEST 57TH ST/MANH Spill Number: 9007702 Close Date: 100 W. 57TH STREET NEW YORK NY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/24/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: 100 WEST 57TH STREET Approximate distance from property: 2617 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: TIMOTHY GERLAND Caller Agency: USCG Caller Phone: (212) 668-7920 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;HIGHLY IMPROBABLE ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/04/1990 UNKNOWN GROUNDWATER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN -1.00 POUNDS NO 0.00 POUNDS NO ------Caller Remarks: INTO SECOND FLOOR UNDERGROUND GARAGE, NOTIFIED BY NYCDEP, USCG ENROUTE ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 125 MANHOLE #58457 Spill Number: 9811172 Close Date: W. 57TH ST & 6TH AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/06/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: W 57TH ST / AVENUE OF THE AMERICASE Approximate distance from property: 2623 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: 10019 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 92

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MR CROWE Notifier Phone: (212) 338-3352 Caller Name: MIKE CESARE Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: MIKE CESARE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763 ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/05/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: about 2 gals in a manhole waiting for test results - con ed #121740 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 126 MANHOLE #58470 Spill Number: 0204650 Close Date: 6TH AVE & WEST 57TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/09/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS / WEST 57TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2623 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

08/01/2002 UNKNOWN MATERIAL 1.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 127 MANHOLE 10858 Spill Number: 0005658 Close Date: 131 WEST 56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2639 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 93

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/10/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: discovered 1 qt of unk oil in a manhole clean up is pending ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 94

------ACTIVE HAZARDOUS SPILLS - MISC. SPILL CAUSES - EQUIPMENT FAILURE, HUMAN ERROR, TANK OVERFILL, DELIBERATE SPILL, TRAFFIC ACCIDENT, HOUSEKEEPING, ABANDONED DRUM, AND VANDALISM - IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/2 MILE SEARCH RADIUS. All spills mapped and profiled within 1/8 Mile. Between 1/8 Mile and 1/2 Mile, spills reported to be greater than 100 units and spills reported in the NYSDEC Fall 1998 MTBE Survey are mapped and profiled. Spills reported to be less than 100 units are listed in a table at the end of this section. ------* - Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address. ------**Site profiles in this report section contain up to 36 data fields of information obtained from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Since 1/1/02, the DEC has only released information for 12 of those data fields: spill name, address components, spill date, close date, material spilled, quantity spilled, units, cause of spill and resource affected. The date after "Information updated through:" indicates when these 12 data fields were last updated. The other 24 data fields are only updated through 1/1/02. ------

Map Identification Number 128 VAULT 1371 Spill Number: 0206550 Close Date: 100 EAST 50TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/06/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 278 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

09/24/2002 UNKNOWN MATERIAL 0.00 GALLONS NO EQUIPMENT FAILURE IN SEWER ------

Map Identification Number 129 VAULT #6388 Spill Number: 0102605 Close Date: FRONT OF 61-77 W 46TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/06/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1784 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: MARK SCHLAGEL Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 95

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/07/2001 EQUIPMENT FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIELECTRIC FLUID UNKNOWN 250.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: TRANSFORMER FLUID WITH NO WATER INVOLVED - CLEAN UP PENDING TEST RESULTS - HISTORICAL DATA OF 10 PPM OF PCB FROM 1994 - NO SEWERS OR WATERWAYS AFFECTED ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 130 AT A BUSINESS Spill Number: 9605914 Close Date: 130 EAST 57TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/14/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1961 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: AT A BUSINESS Spiller Phone: (212) 753-8841 Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: RICHARD SMITH Notifier Phone: (718) 476-6288 Caller Name: RICHARD SMITH Caller Agency: NYC FD - HAZMAT Caller Phone: (718) 476-6288 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: GARRY GREEN Contact Person Phone: (212) 753-8841

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/06/1996 TANK OVERFILL ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#4 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 250.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: ROTTED VENT PIPE ON TANK - WATER ENTERED THE TANK AND DISPLACED THE OIL - SPILLED INTO BASEMENT AND SEWER - BASEMENT CONCRETE FLOOR - CALL CLEAN UP COMPANY PHOENIX ENVIORMENTAL (516) 864-4200 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

TANK WAS NOT BEING USED - TANK LEAKED TO FLOOR, ALSO LEAKED INTO SUMP - CLEANED UP BY FIRE DEPT - PHOENIX WILL PUMP OUT TANK Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 96

TOMORROW. DEC (Sigona) spoke to Jed Meyers of Pheonix Environmental on July 8, 1997, to follow-up with spill report. Meyers said that the spill was cleaned up, and there was no follow-up required. The spill occurred because of heavy rains poured onto the roof of the building where the oil tank vent line was located. The roof drain was not functioning. Also, the vent pipe top was was roted nad allowed the water to enter the tank. The tank overflowed with water allowing the oil to overflow into the basement and into the sump. Phoenix cleaned up the oil. No oil entered the soil or ground. The tank was repaired and tested. Jed Meyers will send results to the DEC. DEC (Sigona) performed a follow-up inspection of the basement on 7/8/97. Found a large oil stain from #4 fuel oil and free product and water mixture (15 feet x 5 feet) along front of mounded fuel oil tank. It appears that the oil is weeping out of tank, and is residue from spill last year. I requested that the owner cleanup the spill and investigate source of contamination. Also, called Jed Meyers Pheonix Envioronmental and they will speak with owner as well. Spoke to Michael Costinos (212) 753-8841 Superintendent who will speak to manager about the cleanup. FAX TO ECS.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 131 PENN ZONE MGT CO Spill Number: 9510173 Close Date: 155 WEST 46TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/16/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2476 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CASTLE OIL Spiller Phone: (718) 579-3413 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: J C Notifier Phone: (212) 944-1685 Caller Name: JANET MATOS Caller Agency: CASTLE OIL Caller Phone: (718) 579-3413 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: JC Contact Person Phone: (212) 944-1685

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/14/1995 EQUIPMENT FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 100.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: BROKEN FUEL LINE ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 97

Map Identification Number 132 W. 59TH ST/5TH AVE Spill Number: 8303210 Close Date: W. 59TH ST/5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/30/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: W 59TH ST / 5TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 2547 feet to the N Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/26/1984 EQUIPMENT FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIELECTRIC FLUID UNKNOWN 3500 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: Reported by Con Ed as required under Consent Order. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 133 VAULT 4090 Spill Number: 9906368 Close Date: 279-293 MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2598 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: POSS AREA RESTAURANT Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MR BOSE Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: BILL MURPHY Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 98

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/28/1999 DELIBERATE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

COOKING OIL UNKNOWN 350.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: cooking oil mixed w/ 400 gallons of water contained in the manhole - believed a restaurant may have been dumping their cooking oil in the manhole - they will clean up assuming 50-499 ppm pcb as soon as they get a tank to pick it up - samples for id & pcb`s ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

THE FOLLOWING ACTIVE SPILLS FOR THIS CATEGORY WERE REPORTED BETWEEN 1/8 MILE AND 1/2 MILE FROM THE SUBJECT ADDRESS. THESE SPILLS WERE REPORTED TO BE LESS THAN 100 UNITS IN QUANTITY AND CAUSED BY: EQUIPMENT FAILURE, HUMAN ERROR, TANK OVERFILL, DELIBERATE SPILL, TRAFFIC ACCIDENT, HOUSEKEEPING, ABANDONED DRUM, OR VANDALISM. THESE SPILLS ARE NEITHER MAPPED NOR PROFILED IN THIS REPORT.

FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY 0203360 VAULT 1307 28-36 E 53RD STE MANHATTAN 9904003 5TH AND WEST 50 ST MANHATTAN 0004769 MANHOLE #50309 E53RD ST & MADISON AV MANHATTEN 9512068 PERMENANT MISSION 15 EAST 47TH ST MANHATTAN 0003626 E 48TH ST & 5TH AV MANHATTAN 9311888 NYFD ENG.8/NYPD 17TH PCT. 161 EAST 51TH STREET MANHATTAN 0108893 VAULT #0565 130 E 47TH ST MANHATTAN 0300860 BETWEEN 30 & 40 WEST 51ST ST MANHATTEN 9913942 FM RING ASSOCIATES 20 W. 47TH ST MANHATTAN 9606840 VAULT 8290 817 3RD AVE & 50 STREET MANHATTAN 0100949 VAULT 1183 40 WEST 51ST ST MANHATTAN 0109937 MH 38725 EAST 54TH AND LEXINGTON MANHATTAN 9606896 689 5TH AVE 689 5TH AVE MANHATTAN 9514567 419 PARK AVE 419 PARK AVE MANHATTAN 0011729 MANHOLE 43976 3RD AV / E 52ND ST MANHATTAN 9910024 APARTMENT BLDG 211 EST 51TH ST MANHATTAN 0211441 146 EAST 46TH ST MANHATTEN 0005082 RESIDENCE 146 E. 46TH ST MANHATTAN 0006911 MH 43998 878 3RD AVE MANHATTAN 9612567 201 EAST 47TH ST 201 EAST 47TH ST NYC 9507992 STREET / GUTTER 52 WEST 47TH ST MANHATTEN 9905621 MANHOLE #33898 E 55TH ST & 5TH AV NEW YORK CITY 0211670 MH 860 157 EAST 45TH ST MANHATTAN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 99

9611337 246 246 EAST 51 ST STREET MANHATTEN 9602848 5457 VAULT 54-66 WEST 53RD ST NEW YORK CITY 9501735 44 WEST 54TH STREET 44 WEST 54TH STREET MANHATTAN 0207373 49 WEST 45TH ST MANHATTAN 9806644 WARWICK HOTEL 65 WEST 54TH ST MANHATTAN 9901497 VAULT #2931 57 W 45TH ST MANHATTEN 9809837 200 EAST 55TH STREET 200 EAST 55TH STREET MANHATTAN 9909023 VAULT #2249 IFO 200 E 55TH ST MANHATTAN 9515338 VAULT 8352 FEDER 2M08 209 E 55TH ST MANHATTAN 0008992 W 47TH ST & 6TH AV MANHATTAN 0208223 VAULT #4160 51ST ST & 2ND AV MANHATTEN 9904730 MANHOLE 59809 E57TH ST,W OF LEXINGTON MANHATTAN 0004119 MANHOLE 38756 57TH ST/LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTAN 9905620 MANHOLE #59809 E 57TH ST & LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTAN 9911600 VAULT 7019 125-137 E 57TH ST MANHATTAN 9908908 MANHOLE 56948 138 EAST 43RD STREET MANHATTAN 9415593 108 W. 53RD STREET 108 W. 53RD STREET MANHATTAN 0007207 VAULT #3517 144 EAST 43RD ST MANHATTEN 9312855 309 EAST 49TH ST. 309 EAST 49TH ST. NYC 9512033 992 2ND AVE 992 2ND AVE MANHATTAN 0102650 54TH ST/6TH AV MANHATTAN 9611752 METRO NORTH RAILROAD 416 LEXINGTON AVE NYC 9909592 BETWEEN LEXINGTON & PARK E 42ND ST MANHATTAN 0111138 224 EAST 44TH STREET 224 EAST 44TH STREET MANHATTEN 9905222 1166 6TH AVE MANHATTAN 9414722 APP. COMPLEX 321 EAST 52ND STREET NEW YORK 0206576 42ND ST LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTEN 0004839 MH 38638 EAST 42ND ST/LEXINGTON AV MANHATTAN 0009258 SCHUBERT COURT THEATER 138 WEST 48TH ST NEW YORK 0013630 VAULT 1346 40 WEST 57TH ST MANHATTAN 0108785 VAULT 179 VAULT 789 1010-20 SECOND AVE MANHATTAN 9904714 MANHOLE 59814 EAST 57TH/WEST OF 3RD AVE NEW YORK 0107541 E 54TH ST & SECOND AVE MANHATTAN 9415136 501 5TH AVENUE 501 5TH AVENUE MANHATTAN 9914694 225 EAST 43RD STREET 225 EAST 43RD ST NEW YORK 0004980 150 WEST 51 ST 150 WEST 51 ST NEW YORK 0007672 RESIDENCE 328 EAST 53RD ST NEW YORK 0002924 VAULT #6104 IFO 21 W42ND ST MANHATTAN 9600821 1 E.58TH ST 1 E.58TH ST / MADISON AVE MANHATTAN 0007136 VAULT 4271 107 EAST 41ST STREET MANHATTAN 0004865 VAULT 2771 166 WEST 49TH STREET MANHATTEN 0204117 MANHOLE 43875 3RD AV / E 42ND ST MANHATTAN 0109223 MANHOLE #38626 E41ST ST & LEXINGTON AV MANHATTAN 0200818 VAULT # V6183 E. 41ST ST / 5TH AVE MANHATTEN 9802265 347 E 54TH ST MANHATTAN 9307409 310 EAST 44 STREET 310 EAST 44TH STREET MANHATTAN 0105414 VAULT 710 MADISON AVE+EAST 40TH STR MANHATTAN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 100

0211539 MAN HOLE 1679 157 EAST 59TH ST MANHATTAN 0208711 MANHOLE 46806 W. 57TH & 6TH AVE MANHATTEN 0101641 VAULT 2109 205 EAST 41ST STREET MANHATTAN 9812617 MANHOLE #43859 EAST 41ST 3RD AVE MANHATTAN 9914295 VALUT #7108 IFO 201-07 41ST ST MANHATTAN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 101

------CLOSED STATUS TANK FAILURES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/2 MILE SEARCH RADIUS ------* - Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address. ------**Site profiles in this report section contain up to 36 data fields of information obtained from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Since 1/1/02, the DEC has only released information for 12 of those data fields: spill name, address components, spill date, close date, material spilled, quantity spilled, units, cause of spill and resource affected. The date after "Information updated through:" indicates when these 12 data fields were last updated. The other 24 data fields are only updated through 1/1/02. ------

Map Identification Number 134 14 EAST 52ND STREET Spill Number: 9500659 Close Date: 04/17/1995 14 EAST 52ND STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 758 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: MR HILL Spiller Phone: (212) 535-3322 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: KIMBERLEY ABRAMS Caller Agency: PETRO ASTORIA Caller Phone: (718) 545-3662 DEC Investigator: MARTINKAT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/17/1995 04/17/1995 TANK FAILURE ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 1.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: TANK BOTTOM POURUS - TANK FAILURE. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 102

Map Identification Number 135 127 EAST 47TH ST Spill Number: 9510310 Close Date: 11/16/1995 127 EAST 47TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1072 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: 127 ENTERPRISES Spiller Phone: (212) 688-7832 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: 127 ENTERPRIZES Notifier Phone: (212) 688-7832 Caller Name: FRANK SACINO Caller Agency: PETRO ASTORIA Caller Phone: (718) 545-4500 DEC Investigator: TANG Contact for more spill info: TOM Contact Person Phone: (212) 688-7832

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/16/1995 TANK FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 2.00 GALLONS NO 2.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: TANK LEAKED ONTO CONCRETE FLOOR ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

CALLED TOM AT TTHE SPILL LOCATION, JUST A SLIGHT LEAK FROM A 275 GALLON TANK. UNDER CONTROL . NO DEC ACTION REQUIRED

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 136 127 E. 47TH ST Spill Number: 9411387 Close Date: 11/30/1994 127 E. 47TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1072 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: 127TH E. 47TH ENTERPRISES Spiller Phone: (212) 688-7832 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MIKE MATANKY Caller Agency: PETRO ASTORIA Caller Phone: (718) 545-4500 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 103

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/26/1994 11/30/1994 TANK FAILURE ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: PINHOLE LEAK IN TANK-STAIN ON FLOOR-PETRO ASTORIA CLEANED & REMOVED NEW TANK TO OWNER. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 137 216 EAST 45TH ST/MANH Spill Number: 9006446 Close Date: 09/20/1990 216 EAST 45TH STREET NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1859 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: VAL MACARI Caller Agency: PETRO TANK CLEANERS Caller Phone: (718) 624-4842 DEC Investigator: TANG Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/12/1990 09/20/1990 TANK FAILURE ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 400.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: TANK FAILURE, CONTAINED IN TANK ROOM, WILL USE VAC TRUCK (PETRO TANK CLEANERS), OIL HAS BEEN CLEANED UP. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 104

Map Identification Number 138 3 DAG PLAZA Spill Number: 0106894 Close Date: 01/21/2002 305 EAST 47TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/02/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2131 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: 3 DAG PLAZA Spiller Phone: (212) 355-1852 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: GOERTZ/TIPPLE Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/01/2001 TANK FAILURE ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL UNKNOWN 1000 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: caller notified of spill in basment from leak in tank. caller is supervising cleanup. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/3/01: On this date, K.Goertz inspected the site. Goertz met with the super; Dave Pilchuk, who described what had happenned, what was done, and what was going to be done. The oil which leaked from the tank, spilled onto the concrete floow, but this floor contained several drains which led to a sump pit which discharges to the sewer. Fortunately, there has been no precipitation over the last few days, so the sump pump did not discharge any oil to the sewer. The sump pump has been deactivated until the cleanup has reched its conclusion. Emteque was hired to supervise the cleanup. John Raguso (212-631-9000) arrived on site immediately after Goertz's inspection. They will continue to vacuum up remaining oil in the sump, and steam clean impacted areas. Mr.Raguso will take pictures at various staged of the cleanup and will forward a report to M. Tipple at the conclusion of the remediation. As of today, there does not seem to be any environmental impact as a result of this spill. (KG)

10/5/01: K.Goertz phoned John Reguso. He said cleanup is complete, and the basement looks better than it did before the spill occurred. He has taken several photos and will be sending a report to Michelle Tibble next week. (KG)

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 105

Map Identification Number 139 148 W 48TH ST/MANH/KINNEY Spill Number: 8707661 Close Date: 11/03/1993 148 WEST 48TH ST NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2281 feet to the WNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: KINNEY PARKING GARAGE Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: SULLIVAN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES A FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/07/1987 11/03/1993 TANK FAILURE AIR UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: FUMES IN BLDG AT 151 & 155 W 48TH ST, BLDGS BEING EVACUATED BY FIRE DEPT, DEC RESPONDING. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 140 157 W 47TH ST/QUALITY INN Spill Number: 9105450 Close Date: 02/26/1992 157 W 47TH ST NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2420 feet to the WNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: KEN RONK Caller Agency: WCC TANK TECH Caller Phone: (914) 564-9555 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/20/1991 02/26/1992 TANK FAILURE ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 106

Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM -1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 3K IN VAULT. TEST ABORTED. LEAKING MANWAY ON TANK ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 107

------CLOSED STATUS TANK TEST FAILURES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/2 MILE SEARCH RADIUS ------* - Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address. ------**Site profiles in this report section contain up to 36 data fields of information obtained from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Since 1/1/02, the DEC has only released information for 12 of those data fields: spill name, address components, spill date, close date, material spilled, quantity spilled, units, cause of spill and resource affected. The date after "Information updated through:" indicates when these 12 data fields were last updated. The other 24 data fields are only updated through 1/1/02. ------

Map Identification Number 141 743 FIFTH AVENUE Spill Number: 8908142 Close Date: 09/30/1992 743 FIFTH AVENUE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 743 5TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 2092 feet to the N Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: HYGENETICS CO Spiller Phone: (212) 893-8516 Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: NAT MOSER Caller Agency: GND Caller Phone: (516) 933-1085 DEC Investigator: BATTISTA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill PBS # Involved Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/15/1989 09/30/1992 TANK TEST FAILURE 2-311154 ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------TANK TEST INFORMATION

Tank Number Tank Size Tank Test Method Leak Rate Gross Leak or Failure

0 TANK TESTING METHOD NOT GIVEN IN DATA 0.00 UNKNOWN ------Caller Remarks: 1.5K TK FAILS PETRO - L R =-0.187GPH - E,I & R ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 108

Map Identification Number 142 53RD STREET POWER BLDG Spill Number: 9106500 Close Date: 05/02/2000 126 W 53RD ST NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2180 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: NYCTA Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: STEVEN MCGUIRE Caller Agency: TANK TECH CORP Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill PBS # Involved Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/04/1991 TANK TEST FAILURE 2-190144 ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM -1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------TANK TEST INFORMATION

Tank Number Tank Size Tank Test Method Leak Rate Gross Leak or Failure

0 TANK TESTING METHOD NOT GIVEN IN DATA 0.00 UNKNOWN ------Caller Remarks: 4K PETROTITE, GROSS LEAK. ------DEC Investigator TRANSFERED FROM ZHITOMIRSKY TO HALE. TRANSFERED FROM HALE TO TIBBE. SEE FILE. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 143 AVIS RENT-A-CAR Spill Number: 9408988 Close Date: 12/18/2000 153-155 W. 54TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2524 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 109

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: AVIS RENT-A-CAR Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: TONY RIZZO Caller Agency: ALVIN PETRO Caller Phone: (718) 461-5400 DEC Investigator: MILLER Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/05/1994 TANK TEST FAILURE IN SEWER YES NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE PETROLEUM -1.00 POUNDS NO 0.00 POUNDS YES ------TANK TEST INFORMATION

Tank Number Tank Size Tank Test Method Leak Rate Gross Leak or Failure

0 TANK TESTING METHOD NOT GIVEN IN DATA 0.00 UNKNOWN ------Caller Remarks: PRESSURE NOT HOLDING FOR TEST- TO ISOLATE & RETEST TOMORROW ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

12/18/2000 S. MILLER CORRECTED ADDRESS AND CLOSED SPILL REPORT. CROSS REFERENCE MADE TO SPILL REPORT NUMBERS 9200119 AND 9604355. ACCORDING TO FILE AND 11/14/2000 LETTER FROM AVIS: ON 10/7/94, A RETEST FOLLOWING TIGHTENING OF A TESTING PLUG TESTED TIGHT; CONTAMINATED SUMP WATER WAS PUMPED OUT AND REMOVED - LIKELY DUE TO CONDENSATION OR RAINFALL AND SURFACE SPILLAGE.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 144 153 W 54TH STREET Spill Number: 9200119 Close Date: 12/18/2000 153 W 54TH STREET MAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2524 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNK. Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: GREGORY CHARMONT Caller Agency: PETROLEUM CONSTRUCTION Caller Phone: (718) 385-8800 DEC Investigator: SULLIVAN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 110

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES A FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/03/1992 TANK TEST FAILURE GROUNDWATER YES NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE PETROLEUM 0 POUNDS NO 0 POUNDS NO ------TANK TEST INFORMATION

Tank Number Tank Size Tank Test Method Leak Rate Gross Leak or Failure

0 TANK TESTING METHOD NOT GIVEN IN DATA 0.00 UNKNOWN ------Caller Remarks: WILL E.I.R. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

12/18/2000 S. MILLER CORRECTED ADDRESS AND CLOSED SPILL REPORT. CROSS REFERENCE MADE TO SPILL REPORT NUMBERS 9408988 AND 9604355. ACCORDING TO FILE AND 11/14/2000 LETTER FROM AVIS: CRACKED BUSHINGS ON TOP OF TWO OF THE THREE 4,000 GALLONS DOUBLE-WALLED STEEL USTs IN A VAULT WERE REPAIRED AND RETESTED TIGHT ON 4/17/92. THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE OF A GASOLINE RELEASE.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 111

------CLOSED STATUS UNKNOWN CAUSE SPILLS AND OTHER CAUSE SPILLS IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/2 MILE SEARCH RADIUS ------* - Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address. ------**Site profiles in this report section contain up to 36 data fields of information obtained from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Since 1/1/02, the DEC has only released information for 12 of those data fields: spill name, address components, spill date, close date, material spilled, quantity spilled, units, cause of spill and resource affected. The date after "Information updated through:" indicates when these 12 data fields were last updated. The other 24 data fields are only updated through 1/1/02. ------

Map Identification Number 145 CORNER OF 50TH ST Spill Number: 9701627 Close Date: 05/07/1997 AND MADISON AV MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 50TH ST / MADISON AVE Approximate distance from property: 278 feet to the NW Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: CITIZEN Notifier Name: REFUSED Notifier Phone: Caller Name: REFUSED Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: MARTINKAT Contact for more spill info: UNKNOWN Contact Person Phone: (000) 000-0000

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/07/1997 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAYS EVERTIME IT RAINS HE SEES OIL ON THE CORNER AND IT LOOKS LIKE IT IS COMING UP FROM THE GROUND ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 112

Map Identification Number 146 MADISON AV Spill Number: 0202945 Close Date: 06/20/2002 E 50TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/13/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: MADISON AV / E 50TH ST Approximate distance from property: 278 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

06/20/2002 ASBESTOS 0.00 GALLONS YES OTHER ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 147 BOISE CASCADE CO/MANH Spill Number: 8905629 Close Date: 09/08/1989 437 MASISON AVENUE NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: 437 MADISON AV Approximate distance from property: 280 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: BOISE CASCADE CO Spiller Phone: (212) 595-8112 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: WOODY DOUGLAS Caller Agency: USEPA Caller Phone: (201) 321-4349 DEC Investigator: FINGER Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/06/1989 09/08/1989 OTHER AIR UNKNOWN NO ------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL Caller Remarks: TELEPHONE INSTALLER SAW FLAKES COMING OFF CEILING, DEC NOTIFIED THE NYCDEP (MS. MCCLOUD) ABOUST SITUATION, NYCDEP ASBESTOS RESPONSE TO SEND INSPECTOR TO INVESTIGATE. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: POSSIBLE ASBESTOS.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 113

Map Identification Number 148 NE CORNER OF Spill Number: 0008260 Close Date: 12/17/2001 E 49TH ST & MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 49TH ST / MADISON AV Approximate distance from property: 362 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/14/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 2 PINT OF UNK OIL - CLEAN UP PENDING LAB RESULTS - REF #133928 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con Ed e2mis #133928 Notes:

10-14-00 2 pints unknown oil in manhole 50283. Spill appears to be dielectric oil on top of debris, mud and scrap cable. Scrap cable possible source of oil. Sample results returned 100ppm PCBs. Oil ID no possible due to degraded quality of material recovered. Structure was double washed with slix. Liquids removed by over 50 tanker, solids were drummed.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 149 GASOLINE ODOR, 13TH FLOOR Spill Number: 8605007 Close Date: 11/06/1986 420 MADISON AVE,13TH FL. NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 420 MADISON AVE Approximate distance from property: 487 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 114

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/06/1986 11/06/1986 UNKNOWN AIR UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: ODOR IN BLDG. SINCE 9/86 - CON ED TOOK METER READINGS ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: GASOLINE ODOR.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 150 488 MADISON AVE Spill Number: 9609220 Close Date: 10/23/1996 488 MADISON AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 543 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: FIRE HAZMAT MANHATTAN Notifier Phone: (917) 769-0403 Caller Name: JANET MORALES Caller Agency: DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6777 DEC Investigator: O`DOWD Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: (718) 595-6777

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/23/1996 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

HYDROCHLORIC ACID HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 115

SULFURIC ACID HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 3.00 GALLONS NO 3.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: unknown cause - 1-20 people got sick over the incident ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 151 EAST 47TH ST Spill Number: 9801898 Close Date: 05/13/1998 AND PARK AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: EAST 47TH ST / PARK AVE Approximate distance from property: 758 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: METRO NORTH Notifier Phone: (212) 340-3196 Caller Name: SABINE Caller Agency: DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6700 DEC Investigator: TANG Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/13/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: green material running onto the tracks ------DEC Investigator SPOKE TO STAN SEIDINGBERG.,HE SAID IT WAS JUST SOAP SOLUTION. NO ACTION BY DEC. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 152 OMNI BERKSHIRE PLACE HOTE Spill Number: 9811051 Close Date: 02/09/1999 21 EAST 52ND STREET MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 778 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 116

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: OMNI BERKSHIRE PLACE HOTE Spiller Phone: (212) 754-5071 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: DANIEL MELENDEZ Notifier Phone: (212) 754-5071 Caller Name: DANIEL MELENDEZ Caller Agency: OMNI BERKSHIRE HOTELS Caller Phone: (212) 754-5071 DEC Investigator: SANGESLAND Contact for more spill info: DANIEL MELENDEZ Contact Person Phone: (212) 754-5071

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/02/1998 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

HYDRAULIC OIL PETROLEUM 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: POSSIBLY CONSTRUCTION WORKERS IN AREA PUT MATERIAL IN DUMPSTER ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 153 MANHOLE #50134 Spill Number: 9815387 Close Date: 03/31/1999 520 MADISON AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 965 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: MIKE CESARE Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: MIKE CESARE Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: ABOVE CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/27/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 4.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 117

------Caller Remarks: unk petroleum found in manhale spill contained - cleanup pending test results con ed#123900 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

CON ED E2MIS NOTES

Approx. 4 gals. of an unknown oil mixed with approx. 60 gals. of water in MH 50134. The spill is contained and did not enter any sewers or waterways. Unable to verify if there is a sump or sewere connection at this time. There is a PILC equipment in this structure. Sample taken, cleanup pending test results.

Lab Seq# 99-03151 6:06pm 1260 Aroclor <1.00ppm

3-29-99 Cleanup completed

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 154 Spill Number: 0001502 Close Date: 05/08/2000 46TH ST/MADISON AV NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 46TH ST / MADISON AVE Approximate distance from property: 1050 feet to the SW Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: FRANK GREMAROSOA Spiller Phone: (212) 599-2211 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: KRIMGOLD Contact for more spill info: FRANK GREMAROSOA Contact Person Phone: (212) 599-2211

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/05/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 3.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: ABOVE MATERIAL DISCOVERED AT ABOVE LOCATION. NO MATERIAL ABLE TO BE RECOVERED. NO FURTHER INFO. CR #00-01501 - RECEIVED 2 CALLS AT THE SAME TIME IN REFERENCE TO INCIDENT. ------DEC Investigator SAME SPILL AS ON 0001501. Remarks: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 118

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 155 MANHOLE 6262 Spill Number: 0006897 Close Date: 11/27/2001 163-65 EAST 52ND ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1099 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/11/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: discovered 5 gallons on top of 20 gallons of water. clean up is pending test results. con ed #133327 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Telephone update from ERT: oil ID'd as transformer oil. Re-inspection of vault found approximately 20 gallons of oil.

Con Ed e2mis #133327 Notes:

9-11-00 5gal unknown oil on 20gal water in vault 6262. Looks like cooking oil. PCB and ID taken and returned as transformer oil, 24ppm PCB.

9-13-00 Spill was caused by an internal fault in transformer. There was a bulge in the side of the unit.

9-15-00 Inspected sump and drain pipe in vault and found no residual oil in trap and pipe, indicating no release to sewer or waterway. The capacity of the unit is 800gal. The amount removed by the tanker was reported as 300gal.

9-18-00 I&A Manager reported that Transportation reported that 400gal of oil/water were removed from the vault floor and 300gal from the transformer.

9-30-00 Removed 2 drums of solid waste from vault and transported to W 28th St. Washed floor and walls of vault with slix and Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 119

an oil free degreaser, removed same with flush truck.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 156 NBC STUDIOS 1A Spill Number: 0103973 Close Date: 07/16/2001 32 ROCKEFELLER CENTER NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/21/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 32 ROCKEFELLER PLZ Approximate distance from property: 1192 feet to the WNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: KRIMGOLD Contact for more spill info: JEFFERY SKEETE Contact Person Phone: (212) 664-2231

Spill Class: NO SPILL OCCURRED;NO DEC RESPONSE;NO CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/13/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

NITROGEN UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: LIQUID NITRO SPILL. FIRE DEPT ON SCENE AND CLEANED UP. NO CALL BACK REQUESTED. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 157 42 WEST 48TH ST Spill Number: 9600843 Close Date: 04/18/1996 42 WEST 48TH ST MMANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1236 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: INC COMMANDER Notifier Phone: (212) 530-4300 Caller Name: DISPATCHER 394 Caller Agency: NYC FD Caller Phone: (212) 530-4300 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: CAR 10 DAVID Contact Person Phone: (212) 530-4300 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 120

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/17/1996 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN HAZARDOUS MATERIAL HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: accidental spill of acid in building accidental spill of acid in building fd and haz mat on scene ------DEC Investigator HANDLED BY DEP AND FD HAZ MAT HANDLED BY DEP. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 158 MANHOLE 33885 Spill Number: 0012137 Close Date: 07/11/2001 680 FIFTH AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 680 5TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 1251 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: 10019

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: JIMMY FOX Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/12/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: One gallon unknown oil on 150 gallons of water. Clean up pending results of sample. Con Ed spill number 135476.000 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 121

DEC INSPECTOR'S NOTES

CON ED E2MIS REPORT 2-12-01 1gal. of unknown oil mixed with 150gals, of water foun din MH 33885. No smoke or fire, no visual movement. No evidence of entry into the sewer or watrways. Conduit plate records indicate sewer connections. Took sample for PCB and oil ID. Hung sign, cleanup pending test results. No private property affected.

LabSeq#01-01454 Aroclor 1254; PCB 3.00ppm

Used Flush truck with a high pressure hose to double wash the floor and walls with Bio-gen, also used tanker from Astoria to take water and oil.

Spill source; cable ends. (3c cable) used shrink caps to seal open cable ends.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 159 135 EAST 54TH STREET Spill Number: 9314880 Close Date: 03/20/1994 135 EAST 54 ST. NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 135 E 54TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1288 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FEDERAL GOVERNMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MARGARET CHONG Caller Agency: EPA Caller Phone: (908) 548-8730 DEC Investigator: O`DOWD Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/19/1994 03/20/1994 UNKNOWN AIR UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 122

Caller Remarks: COMPLAINING OF FOUL ODOR - REQUEST INVESTIGATION & CALL BACK - 3/20/94 ~105/ CALLED EPA & LM W/ SERVICE FOR CALLER TO CALL ME @ 625-9385 3/20/94 ~1:15/PM CALLED & SPOKE TO MRS. LAISEN & REFERRED HER T ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: FOUL ODOR.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 160 MANHOLE #59064 Spill Number: 0012410 Close Date: 07/13/2001 IFO 845 3RD AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1310 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: PETE MCGUIRE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/20/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 5 GALS UNK GREEN LIQUID NOT ON ANY WATER CON ED #135601 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

E2MIS Notes 2/20/01: Harbeck report that while workijg for construction telecomm found 5 gallons of unknown green fluid in manhole. No fire or smoke . No sewer or waterways affeceted.No sewer connection. No visual movement. MO. 2/20/01.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 123

Map Identification Number 161 VAULT #2074 Spill Number: 9912761 Close Date: 02/26/2002 2 EAST 46TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/18/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1319 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: COMENALE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/09/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTING THAT AN UNKNOWN OIL FOUND ON 30 GALS OF WATER. SAMPLES TAKEN AND CLEAN UP PENDING RESULTS. CON ED #129913. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 162 MANHOLE #43976 Spill Number: 0011596 Close Date: 06/05/2001 EAST 52ND ST & 3RD AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: EAST 52ND ST / 3RD AVE Approximate distance from property: 1361 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: MANHOLE #43976 Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: ANTHONY NATALE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 124

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/26/2001 OTHER ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

CABLE OIL UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CAP ON CABLE WAS LOOSE CAUSING A SMALL AMOUNT OF CABLE OIL TO LEAK INTO SOIL IN BOTTOM OF MANHOLE. CONED #135228-UPDATE 16:50 BY MR NATALE TO STATE SPILL HAS BEEN TOTALLY CLEANED UP. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

E2MIS Notes1/26/01: Ten teaspoon of oil from a loose cable end in manhole. Cable end has been sealed and capped as a permanent repair.No private property was affected. No standing water or sewer connection in structure. No substantial crack. Clean up has been completed.

After reviewing this incident the Env. Desk notified CIG Anthony Natale at 12:44hrs. that this incident is not a deminimus spill and should not have been reported a such. Ed requested CIG to verify or confirm if the NYSDEC was notified of this spill, since the handwritten document of this incident indicated that CIG J. Fox. was notified of this spill at 04:37hrs.

Update NYSDEC was not notified of this incident since it was called in as deminimus spill. The CIG will make the necessary notifications. Primary cable is considered or assumed to be >50ppm PCb and should be treated accordingly. The cleanup of the spill was completed at 03:35hrs. as per discussion with the F.O.D. Supervisor.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 163 VAULT 443 Spill Number: 9911299 Close Date: 03/28/2002 71 E 55ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/18/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 71 E 55TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1372 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: STEVE ROMERO Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: COMENALE Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 125

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/27/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: caller reports 1 pint unknown on 30 gallons water. con ed #129401. sample taken cleanup pending test results. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 164 DIAMOND EXCHNGE OF AMER Spill Number: 8803206 Close Date: 07/14/1988 36 W 47 ST NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 36 W 47TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1384 feet to the W Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: SAME Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MR MIRANDA Caller Agency: SCOMSET Caller Phone: (212) 764-5216 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/14/1988 07/14/1988 OTHER AIR UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

ASBESTOS HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0 UNKNOWN NO 0 UNKNOWN NO UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: DOING CONSTRUCTION AT SITE, BELEIVES ASBESTOS IS BEING RELRASED. CON-CERNED FOR SAFETY OF PEOPLE IN BLDG. REFERRING TO NYCDEP ASBESTOS UN-IT. 2/14/88 1055AM: MIKE DAVIS(DRCTR) TOOK NOTE OF IT. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 126

Map Identification Number 165 45TH ST & LEXINTON AVE Spill Number: 9402544 Close Date: 05/20/1994 MANHOLE AT 45TH ST & LEXONGTON AVE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 45TH ST/LEXINGTON AV Approximate distance from property: 1470 feet to the S Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ALLAN MORA Caller Agency: NY TELEPHONE CO Caller Phone: (212) 338-6732 DEC Investigator: O`DOWD Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/20/1994 05/20/1994 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: NY TELEPHONE DOING WORK IN MANHOLE, DISCOVERED OIL. NOTIFIED EPA & DEP CLEANUP CREW ON SCENE. 05/20/94 AT 6:45 P.M. SPOKE TO AL MORA OF NY TEL.- NY TEL. HIRED CLEAN HARBORS TO CK. IT OUT -ALL CLEANED ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 166 SERVICE BOX 17045 Spill Number: 9815399 Close Date: 03/31/1999 129 EAST 55TH STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1519 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: SAME Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MIKE CESARE Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ' O`CONNELL' Contact for more spill info: MIKE CESARE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/27/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 127

Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: there is a unknown type oil spill in thier service box clean up pend sample result con ed 123905 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

CON ED E2MIS NOTES

Approx. 1 gal of oil and fluid found on approx. 2 gals,of water. Oil is contained to the structure. No sewers or waterways affected. tag #17802 hung. Structure has no large cracks, sump or sewer connection. 2 Samples to be taken.

3-23-99 01:30hrs. Lab Seq#99-03158 Aroclor none, PCB <1.0ppm

3-30-99 Cleanup complete <1ppm PCB removed 75 gals. oil and water to <50 tanker Used flush truck to clean and rinse structure. generated 1 bag PPE Tag removed.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 167 242 E. 50TH STREET Spill Number: 9406395 Close Date: 08/11/1994 242 E. 50TH STREET MAHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1544 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: LLORINA TOREZ Caller Agency: RESIDENT Caller Phone: (212) 750-7562 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/10/1994 08/11/1994 UNKNOWN AIR UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN YES Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 128

------Caller Remarks: STRONG ODOR IN ELAVATOR SHAFT.EYES ARE WATERING, POSSIBLE SEWAGE SMELL.REFERRED TO DEP. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: ODOR.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 168 J & J GOLD Spill Number: 9510519 Close Date: 11/21/1995 64 W 48 TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 64 W 48TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1558 feet to the W Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: J & J GOLD Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: MR BUILDER Notifier Phone: (212) 382-0840 Caller Name: SHANTEL VINSON Caller Agency: DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6777 DEC Investigator: TANG Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: POSSIBLE REL WITH MIN POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD (OR KNOWN REL W/ NO DAMAGE);NO DEC RESP;WILLING RP;CORR ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/21/1995 OTHER AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

CYANIDES(SOLUBLE CYANIDE SALTS) HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: CALLER RECEIVED CALL FROM TENANT IN BUILDING STATING THAT JEWELRY STORE USES CYANIDE ACID IN MANUFACTURING PROCESS AND FUMES GET INTO VENTILLATION SYSTEM - STORE IS ON 9TH FLOOR ROOM 906 AND AFFECTED PEOPLE ARE ON 8TH FLOOR ------DEC Investigator CALLED DEP, NO SPILL, FALSE REPORT - SPOKE TO KEN FREEKIN Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 129

Map Identification Number 169 245 E 49TH ST/U N MISSION Spill Number: 9205055 Close Date: 08/03/1992 245 E 49TH ST NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1565 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: CITIZEN Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MRS LANNI Caller Agency: Caller Phone: (212) 758-5029 DEC Investigator: MILLER Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/02/1992 08/03/1992 UNKNOWN AIR UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: NYCDEP & FD NOTIFIED. CON ED INVESTIGATED - FOUND NO GAS. REFERRED CALLER TO DEP ODOR COMPLAINT DIVISION. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: ODOR, GAS.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 170 62 WEST 47TH STREET Spill Number: 9507123 Close Date: 09/20/1995 62 WEST 47TH STREET NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1620 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: SAME Notifier Phone: Caller Name: SUSAN KINZIE Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (212) 819-3180 DEC Investigator: MULQUEEN Contact for more spill info: FRONT DESK OF BLDG Contact Person Phone: (212) 719-4384

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 130

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/11/1995 OTHER AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL PETROLEUM 0 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: JEWELRY BEING MEADE IN OFF HOURS BE 830PM-400 AM, NOXIOUS FUMES GOING INTO COMP.S VENTS USUALLY SUNDAY-THURSDAY IT HAPPENS. PROCESS CALLED CASTING THAT JEWELRY MAKERS DO, NO SATISFACTION FROM CALLS TO THE DEP. HEADACHE/EYE IRRATION COMPLAINTS... ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Odor of parafin wax detected at night, maybe casting or smolting operations. Referred problem to DEP air quality unit & DEC Reg. 2 Air Unit

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 171 MANHOLE 50332 Spill Number: 0011620 Close Date: 06/05/2001 MADISON AVE/E 56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1641 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/28/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 131

Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTING A SPILL OF MATERIAL FROM AN UNK SOURCE SAMPLES TAKEN CONED#135266 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

E2MIS Notes 1/28/01: 2 gallons of unknown oil mixed with 100 gallons of water.No smoke or fire and no sewer conditions.

Cleanup type <50 PCB <1.00ppm Liquid Amount: 70 gals. >50 tanker used Floor, sump and cable was cleaned with slix. Concrete sump.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 172 ABBANGTON HOLDING Spill Number: 9414433 Close Date: 02/06/1995 237 EAST 53RD STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1708 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: MYSTIC TRANSPORTATION Spiller Phone: (718) 982-9075 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MRS. DAY Caller Agency: NYCDEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6777 DEC Investigator: MULQUEEN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/01/1995 02/06/1995 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 35.00 GALLONS NO 35.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: HESS OIL WAS MAKING DELIVERY ON OIL WAS SPILLED IN THE BACK LOT. @1334 -SPILL CALLED TO REPORT THIS SPILL -STATED GAUGE WAS DEFECTIVE, CAUSING TANK OVERFILL. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 132

Map Identification Number 173 130 E 56TH ST Spill Number: 9512831 Close Date: 11/22/1996 130 E 56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1715 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: MR ROACH Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6764 Caller Name: RICKY WATT Caller Agency: DEPT ENV PROTECTION Caller Phone: (718) 595-6700 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: RICKY WATT Contact Person Phone: (718) 575-6700

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/15/1996 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE PETROLEUM 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: gasoline found in manhole at location - industrial waste notified and hazmat waste notified ------DEC Investigator HANDLED BY DEP. CLEANED BY CON ED. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 174 440 PARK AVENUE Spill Number: 9313137 Close Date: 02/06/1994 440 PARK AVENUE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1722 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: PHILIP DATIN Caller Agency: NYC DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6700 DEC Investigator: HEALY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 133

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/06/1994 02/06/1994 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: OIL COMING UP ONT OF SIDEWALK. AWAITING ARRIVAL OF DEP CHEMIST - NYC FD ON SCENE. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 175 MANHOLE 43909 Spill Number: 9900485 Close Date: 04/26/1999 E 45TH ST & 3RD AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 45TH ST / 3RD AV Approximate distance from property: 1752 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: DENNIS ROMANO Notifier Phone: ( ) - Caller Name: RICHARD ROACHE Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6766 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/14/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 4.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 4 gallons unk material on 100 gallons fo water - clean up pending lab results - con ed ref #124227 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con ed e2mis notes:

Approx 4 gals of unknown fluid on approx 100 gals of water. Fluid is contained to the manhole didn't enter any waterways or Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 134

sewer systems. Unable to determine if a sump exists. Sample Type: Water AROCLOR 1254, <1.00 ppm

<1.00 ppm pcb Removed 485 gals oil/water to <50 tanker. Generated 1 drum PPE. Used flush truck to clean & rinse structure. Removed Spill tag. s

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 176 MANHOLE 33819 Spill Number: 0006696 Close Date: 11/26/2001 44TH ST / 5TH AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: W 44TH ST / 5TH AV Approximate distance from property: 1752 feet to the SW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/06/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: 1QT ON 500GAL OF WATER - CASE #133230 - CONTAINED ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con Ed e2mis #133230 Notes:

9-6-00 1qt unknown oil on 500gal water in manhole. Oil filled equipment in manhole cannot be verified. No evidence of release to sewer. Samples taken for PCB and ID. Tried to diaper the oil but was unsuccessful. PCB sample returned <1ppm. Double washed manhole with slix. Found open cable ends which were sealed.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 135

Map Identification Number 177 MANHOLE 38745 Spill Number: 0004168 Close Date: 10/17/2001 56TH ST/LEXINGTON ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 56TH ST/LEXINGTON AVE Approximate distance from property: 1780 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: TED ROBICHAUD Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/07/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIELECTRIC FLUID PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CLEAN UP PENDING RESULTS. CON ED 132230. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con Ed e2mis Notes:

7/7/00 2.5 pints cable oil leaked from primary ends in manhole 38745. Sample returned 33ppm PCB. 4lbs solid waste double bagged and brought to 16st Yard. Removed soil from floor and double washed with slix and diapers. Oil was from feeder cable ends. Sealed open ends.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 178 BET 140-150 EAST 56TH ST. Spill Number: 9314441 Close Date: 03/10/1994 BET 140-150 EAST 56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 146 EAST 56TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1783 feet to the NE Revised zip code: 10022 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 136

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FEDERAL GOVERNMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MRS. TURNER Caller Agency: DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6777 DEC Investigator: MARTINKAT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/10/1994 03/10/1994 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -15.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: EMERG. TANK SPILLED THIS GOING INTO SEWER - HAZMAT WILL GO THERE - HEATING OIL FROM OVER FLOW RESERVOIR SPILLED OVER TEMPORARY TANK DUE TO RAIN WASHIRY IT OUT OIL IS COLLECTRY THE GUTTER, REFER TO NYC ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 179 GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16& 3 Spill Number: 9212241 Close Date: 01/28/1993 GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16&3 MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: GRAND CENTRAL/TRK 16/3 Approximate distance from property: 1808 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: RAILROAD CAR Spiller: METRO NORTH CONNUTER R.R. Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JOSEPH STREAMY Caller Agency: METRO NORTH COMM R.R. Caller Phone: (212) 340-2096 DEC Investigator: CAMMISA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/26/1993 01/28/1993 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

PCB OIL PETROLEUM 90.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 137

------Caller Remarks: 40 GALS WAS RECOVERED IN PASSENGER CAR 8430 AT NEW HAVEN REPAIR FACILITY KNOWN AREAS OF SPILL WILL BE CLEANED UP TRANSFORMER WAS FOUND PUNCTURED ON UNDER SIDE OF PASSENGER CAR ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 180 GRAND CENTRAL STATION Spill Number: 0108498 Close Date: 07/30/2002 TRACK #1 MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 11/30/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1808 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: NYC TRANSIT Spiller Phone: (718) 243-4581 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: BOBBY ISAAC Contact Person Phone: (718) 243-4891

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/21/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1 pt unk oil on the ground ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 181 VAULT 8609 & 6705 Spill Number: 0004214 Close Date: 10/17/2001 WEST 49TH ST/6TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: WEST 49TH ST / AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS Approximate distance from property: 1820 feet to the WNW Revised zip code: 10020 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 138

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: TONY LOPEZ Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/07/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 2.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 2 gal. unk oil on 50 gal of water in vault 6705. vaults are connected. approx 1 gal of oil in each vault. ref#132252. clean up pending test results. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con Ed e2mis Notes:

7/7/00 1gal oil mixed with dirt in vault 8609. 1gal oil and 50gal water in adjacent vault 6705. No visible leak from either transformer. Oil from vault 8609 migrated to vault 6705 via weepholes. No other equipment in vaults besides transformers.

Vault 8609 (feeder 19M31): No water in vault. No sump pit and no sump pump running. No sewer connection. Oil was mixed with 30lbs of dirt. Three samples will be taken. Previous PCB history is 47ppm.

Vault 6705 (feeder 19M32): 50gal water in vault. There is a sump pit but found pump disconnected. Previous PCB history is 9ppm.

Checked drain trap in vault 6705 and there is no evidence of oil in drain.

Sample returned 78ppm PCB.

7/9/00 Lab results for vault 8609 returned as transformer oil and 85ppm Aroclor 1242.

Transformer in vault 8609 was drained and disconnected on 7/8/00. All residual oil was removed from vaults, pads and oil absorb placed in vaults. Over 50ppm cleanup performed by double washing vault walls and floor with bio-gen 760. Spill source was bottom leaking transformer which was removed.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 139

Map Identification Number 182 MANHOLE 45012 Spill Number: 9909287 Close Date: 12/02/1999 EAST 55TH ST / 3RD AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1836 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR RUSSO Notifier Phone: (212) 338-3352 Caller Name: FRANK MASSERIA Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: FRANK MASSERIA Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/30/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 3 qts unk oil found in manhole - sample taken - cleanup pending lab results ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con ed e2mis notes:

Approx. 3 qts of an unknown oil on the floor in MH-45012. While there to cut a defective secondary section of cable. There is a sump with a sewer connection and found it filled with dirt and clogged and the oil did not reach the sump. Installed pigs around the sump to contain the spill. A.P.C.B. sample was taken.

Lab Seq#128770, AROCLOR# None PCB count<1.00PPM.

Clean up complete in MH-45012.

No liquid found in structure. Generated 1 drum PPE. Used flush truck to clean 7 rinse structure. Removed spill tag#22486 upon completion.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 140

Map Identification Number 183 MANHOLE 9322 Spill Number: 0008319 Close Date: 04/05/2002 W 48TH ST/6TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: W 48TH ST / AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS Approximate distance from property: 1857 feet to the WNW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/16/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPOTING A SPILL OF UNK MATEIAL SAMPLES TAKEN CLEAN UPPENDING LAB RESULTS CONED#133954 NO CALLBAK NCESARY ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 184 227 E. 45TH STREET Spill Number: 9502002 Close Date: 06/30/1995 227 EAST 45TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1877 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: BOB DECK Caller Agency: PETRO TANK CLEANERS Caller Phone: (718) 624-4842 DEC Investigator: O`DOWD Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 141

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/17/1995 06/30/1995 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 40.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: OIL FOUND IN BASEMENT - UNKNOWN SOURCE ------DEC Investigator 06/30/95: DRISOL APPLIED AND PICKED UP MADE REPAIRS TO TANK, IT WAS REPAIRABLE. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 185 MANHOLE #59454 Spill Number: 9910067 Close Date: 03/29/2002 MADISON AV & E 57TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/19/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: MADISON AV / E 57TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1895 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: STEPHEN ROMERO Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: STEPHEN ROMERO Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: STEPHEN ROMERO Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: POSSIBLE REL WITH MIN POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD (OR KNOWN REL W/ NO DAMAGE);NO DEC RESP;WILLING RP;CORR ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/19/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1 gal unk oil on 1 gal water - sample taken - clean up pending results con ed # 129041 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 142

Map Identification Number 186 MANHOLE 10878 Spill Number: 0100278 Close Date: 05/17/2001 IFO 25-27 W56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/10/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: IFO 25-27 W 56TH ST Approximate distance from property: 1934 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: JIMMY FOX Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/09/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 8.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 8 GALLONS ON 100 GALLONS OF WATER. CLEAN UP PENDING. NO SEWER/WATER/FIRE/SMOKE. CON ED# 136354. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 187 43RD ST & 5TH AVE Spill Number: 9609015 Close Date: 05/29/1998 43RD ST & 5TH AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: W 43RD ST/5TH AVE Approximate distance from property: 1945 feet to the SW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6764 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR YAKO Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6755 Caller Name: LISA PRIMEGGIA Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: LISA PRIMEGGIA Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: POSSIBLE REL WITH MIN POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD (OR KNOWN REL W/ NO DAMAGE);NO DEC RESP;WILLING RP;CORR ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 143

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/20/1996 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

ASBESTOS HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: EXCESSIVE STEAM EMINATING FROM EXCAVATION THROUGH STEEL PLATEING - IT IS UNKNOWN IF THERE IS A STEAM LEAK AT THIS TIME, WORKERS DID FIND MUD ON TOP OF EXCAVATION *** UPDATE - AT 12:45 ALL SMAPLES RETURNED NON-ASBESTOS ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 188 BUILDING AT Spill Number: 9608495 Close Date: 10/08/1996 EAST 50TH JUST W OF 2ND MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 50TH ST/SECOND AVE Approximate distance from property: 1949 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: BUILDING AT Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: CITIZEN Notifier Name: REFUSED Notifier Phone: Caller Name: REFUSED Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: MULQUEEN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/08/1996 UNKNOWN AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: small apartment complex - has an odor of petrolium coming from these building- it only occurs when there is smoke coming out from their chimneys ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 144

Map Identification Number 189 130 EAST 57TH ST Spill Number: 9605857 Close Date: 07/16/1997 130 EAST 57TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1961 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: FDNY Notifier Phone: (212) 570-4300 Caller Name: NANCY HUGHES Caller Agency: DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6777 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/06/1996 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: fdny on way - limited info at this time - spill poss in the basement ------DEC Investigator REFER TO 96-05914. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 190 MANHOLE 54394 Spill Number: 0011785 Close Date: 07/10/2001 EAST 49TH/2ND AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: EAST 49TH ST / SECOND AV Approximate distance from property: 1972 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: PETE MAGUIRE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6765

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 145

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/01/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL Caller Remarks: sewer connection in manhole - appears to be confined - spill on 100 gals water - con ed 135330 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

E2MIS Notes 2/1/01: 1 gallon of unknown oil on top of 100 gallons of water in MH. There is a sewer connection. No smoke or fire. No visible movement on water.

LSN 01-01061-0011 - Analysis indicates the sample is similar to lubricating fluid.

3-20-01 Cleanup completed on 3-02-01 07:00hrs. Structure double washed with slix. Spill source; unsealed cable ends Equip. Involved; Primary cable Abatement; none.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 191 MANHOLE 54394 Spill Number: 0010752 Close Date: 04/06/2001 EAST 49TH ST/2ND AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: EAST 49TH ST/SECOND AVE Approximate distance from property: 1972 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/28/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 146

------Caller Remarks: discovered 1/2 gallon of unk oil on top of 300 gallons of water con ed#134906 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

E2mis Notes:

Unknown oil spill in manhole 54394. Discovered during routine inspections for upcoming telecommunications work. 1/2 gallon on 300 gallons water. Analysis indicates substance similar to lubricating oil. PCB results returned 0ppm.

Cleanup completed 1/22/01 at 0500hrs. Oil and water mixture removed via tanker under 50ppm. Flush truck used high pressure hose to double wash and scrub walls and floor with slix. Two 55-gal drums were generated of non-hazardous waste. Tanker accumulated 1,103 gal oil and water mix. KMF 4/6/01.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 192 J & M LEASING MNGMT Spill Number: 8911382 Close Date: 03/05/1990 304 E 50TH STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1980 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: BILL VALLEY Caller Agency: PETRO HEAT & POWER Caller Phone: (718) 545-4500 DEC Investigator: WILSON Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/01/1990 03/05/1990 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: FUEL BACKED OUT OF FILL PIPE DRIVER AND SPILL TEAM APPLIED SORBENT PADS AND SPEEDY DRY PICKED UP AND DISPOSED. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 147

Map Identification Number 193 601 MADISON AVE/MANHATTAN Spill Number: 8903090 Close Date: 06/24/1989 601 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1983 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: TANK TESTER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MR. CODTER Caller Agency: FIRE DEPT HAZ MAT Caller Phone: (212) 847-0588 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/24/1989 06/24/1989 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

MEDICAL WASTE NON-PETROLEUM/NON-HAZARDOUS -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: NYCPD & NYCFD ON SCENE, FIRE DEPT DISCOVERED 2 BAGS OF MEDICAL WASTE & A DRUM OF 15 GALLONS OF MEDICAL WASTE. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 194 136 E. 57TH STREET Spill Number: 9309337 Close Date: 11/02/1993 136 E. 57TH STREET , NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1994 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: MYSTIC TRANSPORTATION Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: GARRY FLYNN Caller Agency: MYSTIC TRANSP Caller Phone: (800) 635-3835 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/02/1993 11/02/1993 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 148

Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM -100.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: BACK PRESSURE FROM TANK CAUSED SPILL FROM FILL PIPE VENT TO STREET UNABLE TO STOP IT WILL NOTIFY FIRE DEPT & PD WANT CALL BACK. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 195 MANHOLE #59825 Spill Number: 0202413 Close Date: 08/23/2002 LEXICTION AV & E 57TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/13/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: LEXINGTON AVE / E 57TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2003 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

06/06/2002 UNKNOWN PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 196 VAULT 3486 Spill Number: 9808734 Close Date: 10/25/2002 144 EAST 43 STREET MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/08/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 144 EAST 43RD STREET Approximate distance from property: 2027 feet to the S Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: VAULT 3486 Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6764 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR MARCY Notifier Phone: (212) 338-3352 Caller Name: RICHARD ROACH Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6764 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: RICHARD ROACH Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6764

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/14/1998 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 149

Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: UNKNOWN WHY SPILL OCCURRED ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 197 311A EAST 51ST ST/MANH Spill Number: 9005948 Close Date: 12/10/1990 311A EAST 51ST STREET NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2041 feet to the ESE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: SHERI BERNER Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (212) 223-3289 DEC Investigator: SULLIVAN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/29/1990 12/10/1990 UNKNOWN GROUNDWATER UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: OIL CAME OUT OF DIRT FLOOR IN CELLAR AT 311A EAST 51ST STREET. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

12/10/90: DEC INVESTIGATED, FUMES IN BASEMENT, RECOMMENDED TO VENT OUT BASEMENT & HAVE A PLUMBER CHECK SITUATION.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 150

Map Identification Number 198 WEST 46TH ST & 6TH AVE Spill Number: 9415274 Close Date: 02/22/1995 WEST 46TH ST & 6TH AV E MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: W 46TH ST / AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS Approximate distance from property: 2048 feet to the W Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: GWEN HAWKINS Caller Agency: NYC DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6700 DEC Investigator: MATINKAT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/22/1995 02/22/1995 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: OIL SPILLED ON STREET - REFER TO DEP ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 199 EAST 43RD ST BET Spill Number: 9709888 Close Date: 01/02/1998 LEXINGTON AND 3RD AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (4) Revised street: 3RD AV / E 43RD ST Approximate distance from property: 2052 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6764 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR MOSTUIN Notifier Phone: Caller Name: WILLIAM MURPHY Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: MR MOSTYN Contact Person Phone: (917) 880-7201

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 151

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/25/1997 UNKNOWN AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

ASBESTOS HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: steam leak on land air-suspected asbestos-nyc dep on scene ------DEC Investigator Con Ed reported that material tested negative for asbestos. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 200 CHRYSLER BUILDING Spill Number: 9813493 Close Date: 02/10/1999 43RD BETWEEN 3RD & LEXING NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 43RD ST Approximate distance from property: 2054 feet to the S Revised zip code: 10017

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FEDERAL GOVERNMENT Notifier Name: NATIONAL RESPONSE CENTER Notifier Phone: (800) 424-8802 Caller Name: LT FINNEY Caller Agency: US COAST GUARD Caller Phone: (718) 354-4088 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: LT FINNEY Contact Person Phone: (718) 354-4088

Spill Class: POSSIBLE REL WITH MIN POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD (OR KNOWN REL W/ NO DAMAGE);NO DEC RESP;WILLING RP;CORR ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/03/1999 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

NITROGEN NON-PETROLEUM/NON-HAZARDOUS 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: UNKNOWN SUBJECT DUMPING MATERIAL INTO STORM SEWER FROM A CONTAINER MARKED "NITROGEN". POSSIBLY LIQUID NITROGEN. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 152

Map Identification Number 201 APT GAS LEAK Spill Number: 0130037 Close Date: 12/06/2001 54 W.56TH ST APT 3B ' NEW YORK NY', NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 11/29/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 54 W 56TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2081 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: 10019

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: KRIMGOLD Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/03/2001 UNKNOWN AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

NATURAL GAS UNKNOWN 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: DUE TO AN UNKNOWN CAUSE THE RELEASE OF NATURAL GAS FROM A STOVE IN AN APT CAUSED A FLASH FIRE WITHIN THE APT. APARTMENT DWELLER REC`D BURNS FROM RIGHT HAND TO ELBOW,FACE,NECK, AND CHEST. FIRE WAS EXTINGUSHED AND STOVE SECURED. CALLER WILL NOTIFY DEP. NAT`L RESPONSE INCIDENT #587656. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 202 67 W 44TH ST Spill Number: 9714466 Close Date: 04/07/1998 67 W 44TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2113 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR BARRY Notifier Phone: Caller Name: FRANK MASSERIA Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: FRANK MASSERIA Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: NO SPILL OCCURRED;NO DEC RESPONSE;NO CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 153

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/29/1998 OTHER AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

ASBESTOS HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES CREW IS EXCAVATING TO WORK ON STEAM PIPE AND FOUND WHITE POWDERY SUBSTANCE BELIEVED TO BE ASBESTOS. CREW IS TAKING SAMPLES TO CONFIRM SUSPICION ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 203 305 EAST 47TH STREET / NE Spill Number: 8701653 Close Date: 01/01/1992 305 E 47 ST NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: 305 E 47TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2131 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: "SEE REMARKS" Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/27/1987 UNKNOWN GROUNDWATER UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE PETROLEUM -1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: HERTZ ON EAST 48TH STREET SEEMS TO BE THE SPILLER. THEIR TANKS WERE RELINED A MONTH PRIOR TO THIS INCIDENT. PREV. ASSIGNED TO SULLIVAN & BATTISTA ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

/ / : HERTZ WAS ASKED TO REMOVE THE PRODUCT FROM THEIR TANKS AND HAVE THEM TESTED. Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 154

FILE NOTE HERTZ HAS AN OPEN SPILL NUMBER 9201045. CLOSE THIS SPILL AS A DUPLICATE. L

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 204 MANHOLE 11300 Spill Number: 9902179 Close Date: 10/18/1999 EAST 58TH STREET/MADISON NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: EAST 58TH STREET / MADISON AV Approximate distance from property: 2139 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: MR HEFFERNAN Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: RICHARD ROACH Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: RICHARD ROACH Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6764

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/26/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: ONE HALF QUART ON 250 GALLON OF WATER ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con ed e2mis notes:

Approx 1/2 quart of unknown oil mixed with approx 250 gals of water was found.

A sample was taken.

Cleanup completed: on 6-11-99 at 0600 hours 50 gallons oily water removed via tanker. MH flushed. 2 - plastic bags non - hazardous waste generated. PCB <1ppm

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 155

Map Identification Number 205 45 EAST 58TH STREET Spill Number: 9609211 Close Date: 10/23/1996 45 EAST 58TH STREET MAHNATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2167 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: MR MUSSORFITI Notifier Phone: ( ) - Caller Name: ROBERT KEPICH Caller Agency: NYC DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6777 DEC Investigator: MARTINKAT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: POSSIBLE REL WITH MIN POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD (OR KNOWN REL W/ NO DAMAGE);NO DEC RESP;WILLING RP;CORR ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/23/1996 UNKNOWN IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

AUTO WASH DETERGENT NON-PETROLEUM/NON-HAZARDOUS 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: SOME TYPE OF SPILL FROM UNKNOWN VEHICLE. ONTO STREET AND INTO SEWERS. NYC FIRE DEPARTMENT HAZ-MAT ON SCENE. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 206 ROYALTON HOTEL / MAN Spill Number: 8909227 Close Date: 11/06/2001 47 WEST 43 ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 47 WEST 43RD ST Approximate distance from property: 2173 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: SAME Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: VAL MACARI Caller Agency: PETRO TANK CLNNG Caller Phone: (718) 624-4842 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 156

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/20/1989 11/06/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND YES NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM -1.00 POUNDS NO 0.00 POUNDS NO ------Caller Remarks: CONTAINED IN BASEMENT TANK RM - VAL PETRO HIRED TO CLEAN. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

11/06/01: MF-R9 NO OTHER INFO ON THIDS SPILL. SPILL 12 YEARS OLD, DEAD ISSUE. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE****COMPUTER FILE******

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 207 SUBWAY,LEX&42ND-AVIS RENT Spill Number: 7900470 Close Date: 02/22/1982 LEXINGTON AVE / 42ND ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: LEXINGTON AVE/E 42ND ST Approximate distance from property: 2191 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/03/1979 02/22/1982 UNKNOWN ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 0 POUNDS NO 0 POUNDS NO ------Caller Remarks: NO REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 157

Map Identification Number 208 MANHOLE 56570 Spill Number: 0101798 Close Date: 06/19/2001 EAST 42ND ST/LEXINGTON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/21/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2191 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: SEAN MCKEEVER Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/16/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1000 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1000 gals oil found in manhole. con ed states they have no oil based machinery in manhole. con ed 137-120. clean up crews enroute upon availability ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

DEC INSPECTOR'S NOTES Arrived on site @2:30pm location is in center lane of 42nd. St. approx. 25' west of Lexington Ave. Oil is contained to this structure- oil level is below conduits, and adjacent structures are clean. Oil visibly appears to be dielectric cable oil. However there is no transformer feeder or transformer in structure, only distribution cables. Due to location on busy street in front of Grand Central Station, cleanup will begin on midnight shift. Samples were taken for PCB & Oil ID. Once structure has been cleaned the will be able to investigate the source.

5-10-01 0445hrs. Copy of notes to ECO Duty Officer.

5-17-01 Voice mail update from Lou First. Oil/water pumped out, total water 200gals. total oil 25-50gals. Found blown joint andcut cables in MH PCB count 28ppm. Measurement origanny made in sump- actual thickness was less than 1" of oil.

CON ED E2MIS REPORT 5-16-01 1,000gals. of unknown oil found at the C/O E. 42St. 30'W/O Lexington Ave. in MH 56570. No water in the structure, all oil. No sewer connection as per conduit plate 26-j-2. Took 2 samples 1 for oil ID and 1 for PCB. Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 158

Aroclor 1254 ; <27.8ppm Analysis indictes a substance similar to dielectric fluid.

3:00am Tanker has removed approx. 250gals.of fluids, 220water & 25-30gals. of oil. The problem with the original estimate was that when the oil probe was put into the manhole it went into the sump that is directly below the opening. This gave the appearance that there was a considerably larger amount of oil. In reality there was only about two inches of fluid in the hole. They found a joint that had been cut out on the floor and the six cable ends uncapped. They were capping these ends, removing the old joint and cleaning the hole.

0900hrs. Approx. 40gals.of oil and approx. 250gals. of water ws pumped out of the MH. Underground crews are presently cleaning the manhole. They expect to be completed during the day shift.

1030hrs. As of 10:15am cleanup is complete. Manhole was washed twice with slix cleaning agent, 3 cable joints washed and removed to 28th St. yard.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 209 PIER 81 Spill Number: 0330008 Close Date: 05/08/2003 81 WEST 44 ST. NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 05/14/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 81 W 44TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2213 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: UNKNOWN

Source of Spill: VESSEL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

05/07/2003 DIESEL 25.00 GALLONS NO OTHER SURFACE WATER ------

Map Identification Number 210 MANHOLE Spill Number: 0207213 Close Date: 10/15/2002 58TH ST/LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/27/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 58TH ST / LEXINGTON AVE Approximate distance from property: 2227 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 159

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

10/11/2002 UNKNOWN MATERIAL 0.00 GALLONS YES OTHER ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 211 MANHOLE 9124 Spill Number: 9902961 Close Date: 05/18/2000 132-134 W 47TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 132 W 47TH ST Approximate distance from property: 2232 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: CROWE Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: STEVE ROMERO Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: COMENALE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/15/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 12 OUNCES OF UNK OIL ON 100GAL OF WATER - CONTAINED - CASE #125563 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con ed e2mis notes:

12 oz of unknown oil type mixed with 100 gallons of water. No agency on site, pcb sample taken by J.Braisted. PLIC in structure.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 160

Map Identification Number 212 VAULT # 2520,2445,4719 Spill Number: 0203415 Close Date: 10/02/2002 9 W 42ND ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/11/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2237 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

07/01/2002 DIELECTRIC FLUID 5.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN ON LAND ------

Map Identification Number 213 MANHOLE 55146 Spill Number: 0012018 Close Date: 07/11/2001 E54TH ST/2ND AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 54TH ST/2ND AV Approximate distance from property: 2244 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: ANTHONY NATALE Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/08/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 15 OUNCES ON 25 GALLONS OF WATER. CLEAN UP PENDING CON ED#135426 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

DEC INSPECTOR'S NOTES

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 161

CON ED E2MIS REPORT 2-08-01 15ozs. of unknown oil on top of approx. 25gals. in M55146. Unknown oil created a sheen on the top of the water in the structure. Traffic Dept. closed the work location and told Channer we would have to follow up after traffic subsided. As per conduit plate 30-k-l we show sewer connection. Condition of the sump at this time is unknown and unable to determine if the sewer has been impacted. Private property not affected. Two samples taken

21:16 LSN 01-01383-001 Oil ID of this sample is not possible due to the insufficient amount of material recovered. Aroclor -1254 PCb <1.00ppm

3-21-01 Cleanup completed on 3-20-01 by 7:00hrs by double washing floors and walls with slix. The spill source was unsealed primary cable ends. Involved equipment; Primary Cable; abatement- seal all cable ends.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 214 MANHOLE 59816 Spill Number: 0100929 Close Date: 04/26/2001 E57TH ST/3RD AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/10/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 57TH ST/3RD AVE Approximate distance from property: 2269 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: 10022

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: MARK SCHLAGEL Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/23/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1 qt unk oil - samples taken - cleanup pending results con ed 136630 - on 100 gals water ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 162

DEC INSPECTOR'S NOTES E2MIS says "no oil filled equipment' then says "dielectric filled cable in structure" called Ed Radtke 4-25-01 @4:30pm. He will gte clarification and update the report.

CON ED E2MIS REPORT 4-24-01 Unknown substance in MH59816, there is approx. 2pts. of an unknown oil on top of 100gals. of water in the structure. No oil filled equipment in structure. There is a dielectric- filled feeder in structure. 2 samples were taken on efor ID adn on for PCB. Env. tag hung.

The incident is being declassified a sa 24hr. clenaup since the cleanup cannot be completed within 24hrs. due to traffic conditions.

0704hrs 4-25-01 Clenaup completed @04:30hrs. Crew pumped out 315gals from MH, filled 2 barrels of solid and PPE waste, removed sludge and double washed MH with slix.

4-25-01 Clarfication. The initial data entry indictes that there is "no oil filled equipment in the structure" and then it states that "there is a dielectric-filled feeder in the structure'. The logger was referring to a transformer(equipmetn) when he stated that there was no oil filled equipment in structure. According to the handwrittem e2mis incident log, the splicer entered the structure to work on the open end primary cable. This is what the logger was referring to when he stated that "there is dielectric-filled feeder in the structure". The logger will be instructed regarding the definition of "oil filled equipmetn in structure".

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 215 MANHOLE #8242 Spill Number: 0100197 Close Date: 05/17/2001 150 E 42ND ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/10/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2274 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: CHARLIE MCCARTHY Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6765

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

04/06/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 163

------Caller Remarks: 1 gallon on 100 gallons of water - clean up pending test results Con Ed #136310 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 216 VAULT #3525 Spill Number: 0009256 Close Date: 04/09/2002 301 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2320 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: STEVE ROMERO Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/10/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: SAMPLE TAKEN-CLEAN UP PENDING RESULTS- CON ED #134334 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: e2mis Notes:

Found aprox 5gal unknown oil in V-3525 on feeder 4m67. Found approx 2gal unknown oil and 2gal water in V-2379. Found approx 1gal unknown oil and 3gal water in V-3323. All vaults are connected by weep holes. Total volume of oil is approx 8 gal. PCB count in V3525 is 6ppm. PCBs <1ppm in V2379 and V3323. Ed Higgins reported that vault V3525 was flush cleaned with no debris. Cleanup completed by midnight 12/6/00.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 164

Map Identification Number 217 MH 4308 Spill Number: 0008035 Close Date: 04/05/2002 107 EAST 41ST ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/03/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2341 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: OKWUOHA Contact for more spill info: BIRAN JOYCE Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/09/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 1/2 gal on 20 gal of water...poss cooking grease...samples tanke and clean up pending test results. ref #133844. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 218 MANHOLE 2394 Spill Number: 0012974 Close Date: 08/24/2001 E 41ST ST / PARK AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2357 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 165

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/10/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 5.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: on 150gal of water in the box - sample taken - contained - case 135866 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 219 MAN HOLE # 46678 Spill Number: 9901355 Close Date: 05/18/1999 WEST 44TH ST / 6TH AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: WEST 44TH ST / AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS Approximate distance from property: 2367 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: FRANK MASSERIA Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: FRANK MASSERIA Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/04/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

WASTEWATER NON-PETROLEUM/NON-HAZARDOUS 50.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: con ed # 124655 material found on the surface of water in the above manhole sample taken clean up pending lab results ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Con ed e2mis notes: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 166

1 gallon of unknown oil with 50 gallons of water spill in man hole. Contanied did not enter sewer or waterways. PLIC in structure. Aroclor 1242 pcb 3 ppm, cleanup complete in mh on 5/5/99 @ 21:00 hrs. 3ppm pcb. Removed 150 gals oil/water. Generated 2 55 gal drums solid waste (Large Debris) - Taken to chem waste via corporate Transportation. Double washed and rinsed sturcture.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 220 MANHOLE #V167 Spill Number: 0012138 Close Date: 07/11/2001 IFO 1 W 58TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 02/12/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2376 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: JIMMIE FOX Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/12/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 10.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 10 gals unk oil - on 100 gals of water - sample taken clean up pending lab results - no smoke or fire - no private property con ed #135477 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

DEC INSPECTOR'S NOTES

CON ED E2MIS REPORT 2-12-01 Unknown oil found in V-167,10gals. of unknownoil on 100gals. of water. No entry into sewers or waterways. Sample taken for PCBanalysis.Cleanup pending results.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 167

Lab Seq# 01-01466 Aroclor 1260;PCB 23ppm

Analysis for the sample from V-167 indicates the presence of an oil similar to dielectric fluid.

19:30hrs. Removed 385gals. of oily water from vault and 320gals. of oil from the tansformer for a total of 705gals. of liquid removed by Astoria Tanker Truck. Drain clogged, blocked same with pigs andoil pads. Double washed floor and walls in front of transformer.

Final cleanup of vault was performed on 3-02-01. New transformer was installed. vault inspected and found to be clean. Cleanup complete.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 221 VAULT 3841 Spill Number: 9815344 Close Date: 05/04/1999 117 E. 41ST STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2378 feet to the SSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNK SOURCE Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MR HEFFERNAN Notifier Phone: (212) 580-6763 Caller Name: STEVEN CRIBBIN Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: ENGELHARDT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

03/26/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 2 OZ OF UNK OIL MIXED WITH 2 GAL OF WATER IN VAULT - SAMPLES WERE TAKEN AND CLEAN UP PENDING RESULTS - SUMP PUMP IN VAULT IS DISCONNECTED AND TRANSFORMER IN VAULT IS NOT LEAKING ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

CON ED E2MIS NOTES

Approx. 2 oz. of unknown oil mixed with approx. 2gals.of water found in V3841. Spill contained to Vault, no sewers or waterways affected. No foundational cracks although a sewer connection exists. The sump was not running, transformer was not leaking. 2 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 168

samples were takne and tag#01427 placed. Oil filled equipment in this structure is transformer#3841 Cleanup procedure 50-499 being used.

3-26-99 Transformer associated with V3841 was found with vacuum. Pressure tested-held pressure.4 transformers in nearby vaults dry and pressure tested ok, no sign of oil in other 4 vaults.

Lab Results Seq# 99-03121 Aroclor 1260 PCB <1.00ppm

4-10-99 @1500 hrs. Cleanup completed

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 222 MANHOLE MH50208 Spill Number: 9906379 Close Date: 02/20/2002 293 MADISON AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/02/2003 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2410 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: MARCY Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MIKE CESARE Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/28/1999 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 10.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: SITTING ON 200 GALLONS OF WATER - ORDERING A TANKER & CLEAN IT AS 50-499 PPM PCB`S - REF #127466 ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 169

Map Identification Number 223 V1815 Spill Number: 0001391 Close Date: 05/30/2001 339-353 E 46TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2485 feet to the SE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/04/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 4.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: ON 50GAL OF WATER - CASE #131196 ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

DEC INSPECTOR'S NOTES

CON ED E2MIS REPORT 5-04-00 An oil spill of approximately 4gals. sitting atop 50 gals. of water was found on the ground on feeder 29m64 in vault 1815. A PCB sample was taken and sign #18307 hung.

Lab Seq# 00-04408 PCB <1.00ppm Cleanup scheduled for 2-15-01

3-15-01 12:15 Cleanup completed with vactor truck. Structure de-greased with Bio Gen cleaner, tag removed. This was a third party dumping spill. Lab result indicated PCb <1 no aroclor.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 170

Map Identification Number 224 MANHOLE 11346 Spill Number: 0104765 Close Date: 08/07/2001 208 E 58TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 12/03/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2503 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: (000) 000-0000 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: RODRIGUEZ Contact for more spill info: CALLER Contact Person Phone: ( ) -

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/02/2001 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 8.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: caller reporting a spill unk petro unk source unk cause coned#138663 samples taken pending lab results no callback ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

CON ED E2MIS REPORT 8-02-01

Approx. 8gals.of unknown oil mixed with 200gals, of water in MH-11346. There was no fire involved, no sewer/water affected. No sewer connection or sump. No dielectric filled feeder in the structure. The source of the spill is unknown. Over 50 tanker, Flush and Underground requested.

8-04-01 5:15hrs. Cleanup was completed. 250gals. of oil and water mixture was removed and one barrel of solid waste and PPE's. Structure was double washed with slix and tag removed.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 171

Map Identification Number 225 AVIS RENT-A-CAR Spill Number: 9604355 Close Date: 12/18/2000 153 WEST 54TH STREET MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2524 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: AVIS RENT-A-CAR Spiller Phone: (212) 593-8471 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: TONY RIZZO Notifier Phone: (718) 461-5400 Caller Name: TONY RIZZO Caller Agency: ALVIN PETROLEUM Caller Phone: (718) 461-5400 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: JACK O`BRIEN Contact Person Phone: (212) 593-8471

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

07/01/1996 UNKNOWN ON LAND YES NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

GASOLINE PETROLEUM 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: SPILLER NOTICED GASOLINE IN A PIT ADJACENT TO TANKS. SUSPECTED A DISCHARGE LINE LEAK, BUT LINE TESTED OKAY. FURTHER TANK TESTING AND INVESTIGATION TO FOLLOW. VISIBLE PRODUCT BEING CLEANED UP AT THIS TIME. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

12/18/2000 S. MILLER CORRECTED ADDRESS AND CLOSED SPILL REPORT. CROSS REFERENCE MADE TO SPILL REPORT NUMBERS 9200119 AND 9408988. ACCORDING TO FILE AND 11/14/2000 LETTER FROM AVIS: ON 7/11/96, A RETEST OF ALL THREE 4,000 GALLON DOUBLE-WALLED USTS IN VAULT TESTED TIGHT;

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 226 MANHOLE #24 Spill Number: 0009105 Close Date: 04/11/2001 E 56TH ST & 2ND AV MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: E 56TH ST / SECOND AV Approximate distance from property: 2536 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FOLEY Contact for more spill info: MARK SCHLAGEL Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 172

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/07/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CONED SPILL #134268 / CLEANUP PENDING RESULTS OF SAMPLE TESTING ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

DEC INSPECTOR'S NOTES

CON ED E2MIS REPORT 11-07-00 1pt.of unknown oil in MH#24, The spill was on concrete floor, no sump or sump pump. No cracks, took 2 samples. Teh cleanup will be pending lab results.

Lab Seq#00-10648 Aroclor 1254 15ppm Analysis indicates the presence a substance similar to a degraded heavy fuel oil.

Cleanup completed at 11-10-00 Used oil absorbent, absorbernt pads and Bio Gen solution, flush truck from environment operations used a high pressure hose to double wash the floor and wall with Bio gen solution. MH was then rinsed by environment operation. Generated five plastic bags of non-haz. waste. Transported to East 110St. Yard.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 227 SERVICE BOX 10860 Spill Number: 0005391 Close Date: 11/08/2001 123-125 W 56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2590 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 173

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: TED ROBICHAUD Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/05/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 3.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 3 gal spilled on 7 gal of water. samples taken clean up pending test results. ref # 132709. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 228 SB #10860 Spill Number: 0006100 Close Date: 12/14/2001 125 WEST 56TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2599 feet to the NNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: MARK SCHLAGEL Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/22/2000 UNKNOWN ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN MATERIAL UNKNOWN 1.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 174

------Caller Remarks: ABOVE MATERIAL DISCOVERED AT ABOVE LOCATION. AMOUNT REPORTED AS 2 OUNCES. SAMPLE TAKEN AND CLEANUP PENDING LAB RESULTS. CON ED # 132993. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: e2mis notes:

Aug. 22 2000: 18:10 hrs. Approx. 2 oz of an unknown oil green liquid mixed with 2 gallons of water. PCB and ID sampes were taken.

8/23/2000 22:00

Analysis of the sample from structure indicates the presence of an oil similar to dielectric fluid.

8/23/2000 11:25 hrs. PCB count less than 1 ppm. Similar to dielectric fluid.

10/10/2000 3:30 am

Final cleanup

Cleanup info: Double cleaned s/b with slix. very little liquid at location removed by flush truck.

Spill source. unknown. not Con Ed equipment. Sump type: none

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 229 340 EAST 55TH STREET Spill Number: 9711625 Close Date: 01/16/1998 340 EAST 55TH STREET NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2614 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: ANNOYAMOUS Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ANNOYMOUS Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: ( ) - DEC Investigator: MARTINKAT Contact for more spill info: UNKNOWN Contact Person Phone: (000) 000-0000

Spill Class: NO SPILL OCCURRED;NO DEC RESPONSE;NO CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 175

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/16/1998 OTHER ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

ASBESTOS HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES BUILDING BEING DEMOLISHED AT ABOVE LOCATION - ASBESTOS IN GARBAGE CANS - REQUEST CHECK ------DEC Investigator FAXED TO DEP HAZMAT Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 230 315 E. 56TH ST Spill Number: 9408873 Close Date: 08/07/1995 315 E. 56TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2639 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: APT BLDG Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FEDERAL GOVERNMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: P.O. PICKERING Caller Agency: U.S.C.G. Caller Phone: (212) 668-7920 DEC Investigator: MARTINKAT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;NO DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/04/1994 08/07/1995 OTHER AIR UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN YES ------Caller Remarks: ALSO CALL DEP-NO ONE IS GOING OUT YET ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: SMOKE.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 176

------CLOSED STATUS HAZARDOUS SPILLS - MISC. SPILL CAUSES - EQUIPMENT FAILURE, HUMAN ERROR, TANK OVERFILL, DELIBERATE SPILL, TRAFFIC ACCIDENT, HOUSEKEEPING, ABANDONED DRUM, AND VANDALISM - IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/2 MILE SEARCH RADIUS. All spills mapped and profiled within 1/8 Mile. Between 1/8 Mile and 1/2 Mile, spills reported to be greater than 100 units and spills reported in the NYSDEC Fall 1998 MTBE Survey are mapped and profiled. Spills reported to be less than 100 units are listed in a table at the end of this section. ------* - Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address. ------**Site profiles in this report section contain up to 36 data fields of information obtained from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation. Since 1/1/02, the DEC has only released information for 12 of those data fields: spill name, address components, spill date, close date, material spilled, quantity spilled, units, cause of spill and resource affected. The date after "Information updated through:" indicates when these 12 data fields were last updated. The other 24 data fields are only updated through 1/1/02. ------

Map Identification Number 231 300 PARK AVE Spill Number: 9706311 Close Date: 08/25/1997 300 PARK AVE MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 239 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FEDERAL GOVERNMENT Notifier Name: ANONYMOUS Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JOHN MENDELSOHN Caller Agency: US EPA Caller Phone: (908) 548-8730 DEC Investigator: MARTINKAT Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: POSSIBLE REL WITH MIN POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD (OR KNOWN REL W/ NO DAMAGE);NO DEC RESP;WILLING RP;CORR ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/24/1997 DELIBERATE AIR NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

FREON NON-PETROLEUM/NON-HAZARDOUS 0 GALLONS YES 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: CONTRACTOR CUT THE REFRIGERATION LINES TO PURGE THE SYSTEM ------DEC Investigator REFERRED TO AIR - DEP Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 177

Map Identification Number 232 300 PARK AVE. Spill Number: 8911006 Close Date: 12/08/1992 300 PARK AVE. MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 239 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: AMERADA HESS Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: NICK MATEE Caller Agency: AMERADA HESS Caller Phone: (201) 437-1017 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/19/1990 12/08/1992 TANK OVERFILL ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: TANK OVERFILL (12K TANK) ------DEC Investigator 02/19/90: HESS SENT OUT CLEAN UP TEAM. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 233 METRO NORTH RAILROAD/MANH Spill Number: 8807268 Close Date: 12/02/1988 48TH ST/GRAND CENTRAL STA NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 48TH ST/PARK AVE Approximate distance from property: 522 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: METRO NORTH RAILROAD Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JOSEPH STREANY Caller Agency: METRO NORTH RAILROAD Caller Phone: (212) 340-2096 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

12/02/1988 12/02/1988 HUMAN ERROR GROUNDWATER UNKNOWN NO ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 178

Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 2000 GALLONS NO 0 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: UNDERGROUND TEAM DIGGING INTO A WALL GOT INTO CABLE VAULT, OIL WAS IN VAULT & RUSHED OUT. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

12/02/88: DEC (TOMASELLO) RESPONDED, MR. MUSTAFA OF THE METRO NORTH RAILROAD WILL DISCUSS PROBLEM WITH DEC.

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: LUBRICATE OIL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 234 MADISON AVE & 48TH STREET Spill Number: 9313681 Close Date: 02/21/1994 MADISON AVE & 48TH STREET NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: MADISON AVE / E 48TH STREET Approximate distance from property: 539 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: AMY RICHARDSON Caller Agency: NYC DEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6777 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES A FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;UNABLE/UNWILLING RESPONSIBLE PARTY;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/21/1994 02/21/1994 EQUIPMENT FAILURE AIR UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM -1.00 UNKNOWN NO 0.00 UNKNOWN NO ------Caller Remarks: TRANSFORMER VALVE CAUGHT ON FIRE - NOTIFIED HAZMAT - NO CALL BACK NECESSARY. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: TRANSFORMER FIRE.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 179

Map Identification Number 235 MANHATTAN PACIFIC Spill Number: 9908889 Close Date: 11/14/2001 400 MADISON AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 724 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: MANHATTAN PACIFIC Spiller Phone: (212) 755-3123 Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: FREDDY BIANCKHI Notifier Phone: (212) 755-3123 Caller Name: STEVEN SILVER Caller Agency: AMERICAN PIPE AND TANK Caller Phone: (212) 736-6618 DEC Investigator: TOMASELLO Contact for more spill info: FREDDY Contact Person Phone: (212) 755-3123

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

10/19/1999 HUMAN ERROR ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#4 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS NO 200.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: exact cause is unknown may have been caused by someone opening a valve spill has been cleaned by callers company tank is in a concrete enclosure chris tomasello from dec did talk to caller about this spill ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

11/14/2001: SPILL# Being closed per fol. documentation: a) letter signed by S. Silver of the "American Pipe & Tank Lining Co. of 538 W.35th St NY NY dtd Nov 2, 1999....On Oct. 19, 1999, we responded to an emergency call regarding an oil spill in the boiler rm and adjacent storage rm...clean up of this oil was performed on Oct. 19 & 20, 1999. On Oct 25, 1999 the waste hauler delivered the drums which were filled and then picked up for disposal on Oct. 26 1999. b) an itemized invoice from the above company dtd 10/31/99, invoice#7912 totalling $10,635.56 c) waste certificate manifest from "Republic Environmental Systems (Cleveland) dtd 11/02/99 and signed by Bruce Williams.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 180

Map Identification Number 236 MH 09335 Spill Number: 0205654 Close Date: 10/29/2002 WEST 48TH ST/ROCKERFELL P L MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED Information updated through: 11/08/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: W 48TH ST / ROCKEFELLER PLZ Approximate distance from property: 1252 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: UNKNOWN ------Spill Material Quantity Unk Quantity Cause of Resource Date Spilled Spilled Units Spilled ? Spill Affected

NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL ------

NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL

Map Identification Number 237 E 55 ST @ PARK AV Spill Number: 8901969 Close Date: 05/26/1989 E 55 ST @ PARK AV MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: E 55TH ST / PARK AV Approximate distance from property: 1353 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER NON COMM/INSTITUTIONAL Spiller: UNK Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: F O SCHRAMM Caller Agency: NYFD HAZMAT Caller Phone: (212) 847-0588 DEC Investigator: TAYLOR Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

05/26/1989 05/26/1989 TRAFFIC ACCIDENT IN SEWER UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: TRUCK ACCIDENT - PERSONS INVOLVED WASHED SPILL INTO SEWER BEFORE NYFD COULD RESPOND. REPEATED CALLS TO F O SCHRAMM WERE UNSUCCESSFUL. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 181

Map Identification Number 238 VAULT 2831 Spill Number: 9905873 Close Date: 11/08/1999 101 E.56TH ST MANHATTEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1649 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON ED Spiller Phone: ( ) - Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: MR RUSSO Notifier Phone: (212) 338-3352 Caller Name: JOE DEVOTI Caller Agency: CON EDISON Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: O`CONNELL Contact for more spill info: JOE DEVOTI Contact Person Phone: (212) 580-6763

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

08/17/1999 EQUIPMENT FAILURE IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

TRANSMISSION FLUID PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: about 100 gals still in vault with some getting into the sewer system - cleanup crew is on the way ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

DEC Inspector notes:

Mike Kessler, ERT-- 285 gallon capacity transformer. Historical data of 10 ppm. Sample taken to Astoria for confirmation. Transformer has been de-energized. Drain leads to sump in adjacent manhole. Will pull other manhole to check-- will check sewer trap for product. Crew was on site last week. Transformer read above min. Apparently released over weekend. Relayed info to Enzo Catanzaro, NYCDEP he has someone en-route.

8/17/99, Spill #, 101 East East 56th St. 265 gallon capacity transformer in vault released contents. Possible connection to sewer or to adjacent bldg. house trap. On scene: Nancy Barsoum, DEP Mike Kessler, Con ed entered bldg. to check house trap with in tenance personnel. DEP IWCS called to check sewers. Confusion arose regarding <50 vs. >50 tankers. Con ed had under 50 tanker on site to vac out vault. DEP said until confirmatory samples read, must use over 50 tanker. My understanding is that part 364 <50 tankers are not permitted to take >50 ppm. Kessler checked with Con ed permitting group. was told all tankers (>50, <50) are 364 part permitted to take all waste. They are identified <50 and >50 for con ed's purposes of waste stream mgmt. 1 told Kessler to use over 50 tanker today and 1 would confirm permitting issue with Albany and also let Enzo C.(DEP) know.

Con ed e2mis notes:

Found approx 100 gallons of transformer oil on the floor in vault, the vault has a drain with sewer connection. There is no visable movement of the oil at this time. There is no water, no visable cracks, no smoke or fire. No sump pump, a sample was taken. Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 182

Installed spill tag, have a tanker enroute. Nany Badsoum on location 1005 hrs. Requested the under 50 tanker be replaced with over 50 tanker. 49 gallons of oil and water removed from floor. The capacity of transformer is 286 gallons. Floor was cleaned and debris removed using 1 solid wasted drum (55 gallon). Jane O'Connell from the DEC on location at 1330 hours, questioning if the oil entered the water way. She was told due to the clogged drain we do not suspect any oil release into the sewer.

Lab Analysis #99-08590, pcb 9ppm, AROCLOR 1260, drained 273 gallons of dielectric fluid from transformer in vault 2831 into corporate transportation tanker and sent to Astoria yard. Partial clean up is completed. Pending replacement of transformer. Final cleanup completed using <50ppm vactor truck. Generated and removed one 55 gallon <50ppm solid waste drum. Waste was transported to 700 E. 16 St. Cleanup was started on 9-4-99 at 10:30 hrs and completed on 9-4-99 at 13:50 hrs. I&A cleanup crew was R.Bracco, G. Johnson, F. Castor, and T.Conway.

Requested from Lou First to clarify suspected release into water way. Jane O'Connell from the DEC, inspected Customers traps from the basement of 101 E 56th st. and found no oil in traps. Drain from vault enters Customers sewer line. It was contained in vault and did not enter water way, as per Robert Biliski Operating Supervisor.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 239 THE DRAKE HOTEL Spill Number: 9510006 Close Date: 11/22/1996 440 PARK AVE MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1722 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: HESS AMARETTA Spiller Phone: (800) 437-7872 Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: JOHN PIERE MONJOIRE Notifier Phone: (212) 421-0900 Caller Name: TIM SASMAN Caller Agency: DRAKE HOTEL Caller Phone: (212) 421-0900 DEC Investigator: TIBBE Contact for more spill info: TIM SASMAN Contact Person Phone: (212) 421-0900

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/11/1995 TANK OVERFILL ON LAND NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#6 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS YES ------Caller Remarks: TANK WAS OVERFILLED - SOME OIL WENT INTO SUMP PUMPPIT AND IN ELEVATOR SHAFT - CLEAN UP IN PROGRESS ------DEC Investigator CLEANED BY RP. Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 183

Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 240 TIME & LIFE BLDG ROCK. CT Spill Number: 9408212 Close Date: 09/21/1994 1271 AVE OF THE AMERICAS MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 1271 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS Approximate distance from property: 1858 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: TIME, INC Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FIRE DEPARTMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: CAROL SCHWAMM Caller Agency: NYC HAZMAT Caller Phone: (917) 882-5464 DEC Investigator: SIGONA Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE THAT CREATES POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;UNABLE/UNWILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

09/21/1994 09/21/1994 TANK OVERFILL ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

#2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 300.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: 4,000 GALS #2 FO TANK OVERFILLED BY BACK PRESSURE FROM 275 GAL STORAGE TANKS ON UPPER FLOOR OF BLDG. OIL WENT OUT VENT INTO W. 51ST ST AND CATCH BASIN. OIL ALSO OVERFLOWED. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 241 CORNER OF LEXINGTON & 57 Spill Number: 9709581 Close Date: 04/08/1998 124 E 57TH ST MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 1931 feet to the NE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 184

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: COWEN BROTHERS - OWNERS Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: AFFECTED PERSONS Notifier Name: ANONYMOUS Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ANONYMOUS Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: O`DOWD Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: KNOWN RELEASE WITH MINIMAL POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD;DEC RESPONSE;WILLING RP;CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

11/01/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE IN SEWER NO NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

HYDRAULIC OIL PETROLEUM 400.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: IN THE VERY BOTTOM OF DAFFYS STORE (BOTTOM FLOOR OF BLDG - BLASEMENT) IN THE ELEVATOR PIT BROKEN PIPE ON ELEVATOR - RESPONSIBLE PARTY IS PUMPING IT INTO SEWER SYSTEM, MAKING NO EFFORT TO REPAIR OR CLEAN UP ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

11/20/97 10:20 AM ARRIVED AT SITE, DAFFY'S 123 E. 57 ST. MET WITH LINDA/MGR. OF DAFFY'S AND SHE DIRECTED ME TO THE BLDYS DEPT. AT 135 E. 57 ST. MET WITH EDDIE SZAREK/BLDG MGR. SAW ELEVATOR. FILL/RETURN LINE BROKE, STAINING ON CONCRETE WALL AND FLOOR. WILL HAVE FUJI TECH OPEN FLOOR, MAKE REPAIRS, REMOVE CONTAMINATION AND PUMP OIL. 11/24/97 10:15AM SPOKE TO EDDIE SZAREK. HE SAID THE PIPING WAS EXPOSED, DONE LAST WEEKEND. THERE WAS A PINHOLE LEAK IN THE LINE. LINE IS ENCASED IN CONCRETE. REMOVED MARBLE SLABS. HE ASID THERE WAS NO GROSS EVIDENCE OF A LEAK. HE SAID HOLE WAS AT THE TOP OF THE PIPE AND THE SIDES OF PIPE (CONCRETE) WEREN'T STAINED. VERY SMALL, MINIMAL LEAK. OIL STAINED IN SHAFT. I RECOMMENDED POSSIBLY STEAMING AND EPOXING. HE WILL GIVE RECOMMENDATIONS TO ELEVATOR PEOPLE. TOLD HIM TO CLOSE UP HOLE.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 242 992 2ND AVE Spill Number: 9110361 Close Date: 01/06/1992 992 2ND AVE NYC, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 992 SECOND AVE Approximate distance from property: 2072 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: NYC SANITATION Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: FEDERAL GOVERNMENT Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: B ROSEN Caller Agency: USEPA Caller Phone: (908) 906-6193 DEC Investigator: O`DOWD Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 185

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

01/03/1992 01/06/1992 EQUIPMENT FAILURE IN SEWER UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

HYDRAULIC OIL PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: STREET SWEEPER OIL LINE BROKE. CITY SPILL HOTLINE & SANITATION NOTIFIED. ------DEC Investigator / / : REFERRED TO NYCDEP & DOS. Remarks:

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 243 1177 AVE OF AMERICAS Spill Number: 9302881 Close Date: 06/03/1993 1177 AVE OF AMERICAS MANHATTAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 1177 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS Approximate distance from property: 2088 feet to the W Revised zip code: 10036

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: OTHER Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JULIE FERRARA Caller Agency: MILRO SUCS Caller Phone: (516) 486-5155 DEC Investigator: TIBBE. Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Spill Class: POSSIBLE REL WITH MIN POTENTIAL FOR FIRE OR HAZARD (OR KNOWN REL W/ NO DAMAGE);NO DEC RESP;WILLING RP;CORR ACTION TAKEN ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

06/03/1993 06/03/1993 TANK OVERFILL ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

DIESEL PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: PREPARING FOR TANK TEST AND TANK WAS OVERFILLED ??? ON CONCR. FLOOR - WILL P/U SPEEDI -DRI AND WASH - DEP NOTIFIED. ------DEC Investigator Remarks: NO DEC INVESTIGATOR REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 186

Map Identification Number 244 501 Spill Number: 9414690 Close Date: 05/18/1995 501 5TH AVENUE NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2253 feet to the SW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: LOCAL AGENCY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MS. NEAL Caller Agency: NYCDEP Caller Phone: (718) 595-6700 DEC Investigator: O`DOWD Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: ------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/07/1995 05/18/1995 EQUIPMENT FAILURE ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------Material Material Quantity Unk Quantity Quantity Unk Quantity Spilled Class Spilled Units Spilled ? Recovered Units Recovered ?

UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 150.00 GALLONS NO 0.00 GALLONS NO ------Caller Remarks: MR. PHILLIPS WORKS AT 501 5TH AVENUE IN THE BASEMENT, HE SAYS THAT THE FUEL TANK HAS A HOLE IN IT AND THERE IS 150 GAL. ON THE FLOOR, GOING PROBLEM , DUE FOR A DELIVERY TO NIGHT. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

05/18/95: FIXED FILL AND CLEANED UP OIL.

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: FUEL OIL.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

Map Identification Number 245 219 E 58TH ST/MANH/CON ED Spill Number: 9011516 Close Date: 02/01/1991 219 EAST 58TH STREET NEW YORK CITY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED **Information updated through: 01/01/2002 MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 2590 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Source of Spill: OTHER COMM/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CON EDISON Spiller Phone: (212) 580-6763 Notifier Type: RESPONSIBLE PARTY Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ERNIE ROWLAND Caller Agency: CON ED Caller Phone: (212) 580-6763 DEC Investigator: JAMES Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 187

------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Resource Affected Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended

02/01/1991 02/01/1991 EQUIPMENT FAILURE ON LAND UNKNOWN NO ------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL Caller Remarks: STEAM SERVICE LINE RUPTURED,SERVICE SHUTOFF AT 08:55,AREA ROPED OFF, DEBRIS ON SIDEWALK, CONTRACTOR EN ROUT TO SCENE TO CONDUCT CLEAN UP, DEC,DEP NOTIFIED,NRC #57563. ------DEC Investigator Remarks:

02/01/91: DEPT OF LABOR & BUREAU OF FIRE PREVENTION NOTIFIED.

10/10/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: >5% ASBESTOS.

** See beginning of spills section for more details.

THE FOLLOWING CLOSED SPILLS FOR THIS CATEGORY WERE REPORTED BETWEEN 1/8 MILE AND 1/2 MILE FROM THE SUBJECT ADDRESS. THESE SPILLS WERE REPORTED TO BE LESS THAN 100 UNITS IN QUANTITY AND CAUSED BY: EQUIPMENT FAILURE, HUMAN ERROR, TANK OVERFILL, DELIBERATE SPILL, TRAFFIC ACCIDENT, HOUSEKEEPING, ABANDONED DRUM, OR VANDALISM. THESE SPILLS ARE NEITHER MAPPED NOR PROFILED IN THIS REPORT.

FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY 9515375 ON THE STREET 5TH AV, NO OF 49TH ST MANHATTAN 0203197 53RD ST AT MADISON AVE MANHATTEN 9500422 53 EAST 82ND STREET 53 EAST 53RD STREET MANHATTAN 9712825 GANT USA 645 5TH AVENUE MANHATTAN 9311259 14 EAST 53RD STREET 14 EAST 53RD STREET MANHATTAN 8910968 CON EDISON TRANSFORMER 245 PARK AVE NEW YORK 9601209 155 EAST 50TH STREET 155 EAST 50TH STREET NEW YORK 9512487 AMERICAN BLUEPRINT 7 EAST 47TH ST MANHATTHAN 0000763 6 W 48TH ST MANHATTAN 0212247 52ND ST & 5TH AV MANHATTAN 0107450 5TH AVE/52ND ST MANHATTAN 0001501 ON SIDEWALK 46TH BET MADISON & VANDER NEW YORK 9307330 5TH AVE & EAST 47TH ST. 5TH AVE & EAST 47TH ST. MANHATTAN 8911033 5TH AVE & 47TH ST/MANH 5TH AVE & 47TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9911474 580 5TH AV MANHATTAN 9009378 7 EAST 53RD ST/MANH 7 EAST 53RD STREET NEW YORK CITY 0109740 2 WEST 47TH ST MANHATTAN 9603042 10 W 47TH ST BET 5&6TH 10 W. 47TH ST BET 5&6TH MANHATTEN 9603043 10 WEST 47TH STREET AT 5TH STREET MANHATTAN 9002949 15 WEST 47TH ST/MANH 15 WEST 47TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9610228 42 WEST 48TH ST 42 WEST 48TH ST MANHATTAN 9311792 25 WEST 47TH STREET 25 WEST 47TH STREET MANHATTAN 0101333 SCOTT`S FOOD MARKET 829 3RD AVE MANHATTAN 9811827 31 WEST 47TH ST 31 WEST 47TH ST MANHATTEN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 188

9412525 APARTMENT BLDG. 31 WEST 47TH STREET NEW YORK 9510506 417 PARK AVE 417 PARK AVE NYC 0006666 MANHOLE #50248 MADISON AV & E 45TH ST MANHATTAN 0200475 W 54TH ST / 5TH AVE MANHATTAN 9906996 VAULT 3491 W 54TH ST & 5TH AV MAHATTAN 9802028 SEWER VAULT I/F 2 WEST 54TH ST MANHATTAN 9305368 211 E 51TH STREET 211 E 51TH STREET MANHATTAN 9602620 57 E 55TH ST 57 E 55TH ST MANHATTAN 9606265 E 55TH ST & MADISON AVE E 55TH ST & MADISON AVE MANHATTAN 9711501 866 3RD AVE 866 3RD AVE MANHATTEN 9211396 5 WEST 54TH ST 5 WEST 54TH ST NEW YORK 9413006 209 EAST 48TH STREET 209 EAST 48TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9803037 REFINED METALS LTD 21 WEST 46TH ST NEW YORK 9010806 220 EAST 48TH ST/MANH 220 EAST 48TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9107505 220 E 48TH ST 220 E 48TH ST NYC 9214329 220 E. 48TH ST. 220 E. 48TH ST. MANHATTAN 9314090 220 & 224 EAST 52ND ST. 220 & 224 EAST 52ND ST. MANHATTAN 0211914 880 3RD AVENUE 880 3RD AVENUE MANHATTEN 9609816 2 WEST 45TH STREET 2 WEST 45TH STREET MANHATTAN 9602622 55TH ST/LEXINGTON AVE 55TH ST/LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTAN 9602688 EAST 55TH STREET LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTAN 9203241 25 W 54TH ST/REGENT HOUSE 25 W 54TH ST NYC 9112083 234 E 52ND ST 234 E 52ND ST NYC 9310683 44 WEST 54TH STREET 44 WEST 54TH STREET MANHATTAN 9311154 44 WEST 54TH STREET 44 WEST 54TH STREET MANHATTAN 9500210 44 WEST 54TH ST 44 WEST 54TH ST MANHATTAN 9515066 ESTATE OF I KATZ 44 WEST 54TH ST MANHATTEN 9600007 ESTATE OF KATZ 44 WEST 54TH ST MANHATTAN 9600534 ESTATE I.KATZ ETAL 44 WEST 54TH ST MANHATTAN 9513604 CIKA REALITY/GOERGE BOWMA N 44 WEST 54TH ST MANHATTAN 9412481 SOLO MANAGEMENT CORP 255 E. 50TH STREET MANHATTAN 9808258 DRAKE SWISS HOTEL 440 PARK AVE NEW YORK 9703994 SWISSOTEL NEW YORK 440 PARK AVENUE MANHATTAN 9911869 EAST 45TH STREET & 3RD AV EAST 45TH ST / 3RD AVE NEW YORK 9515585 38-40 W 55TH ST 38-40 W 55TH ST MANHATTAN 9511006 49 WEST 45TH ST 49 WEST 45TH ST MANHATTAN 9513410 49 WEST 45TH ST 49 WEST 45TH ST MANHATTAN 0108447 PAM PAM BOUTIQUE 680 LEXINGTON AVE NEW YORK 8710325 GRAND CENTRAL TERM/MANHAT NEW YORK CITY 8710309 VANDERBILT AV&43RD ST/MAN VANDERBILT AVE&43RD ST NEW YORK CITY 9909957 39 W 55TH ST NEW YORK 8805991 65 WEST 54TH ST/MANHATTAN 65 WEST 54TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 8806203 WARWICK HOTEL/HESS 65 W 54 ST NYC 9807056 29TH FLOOR 1290 AVE OF AMERICAS MANHATTEN 9309240 42 EAST 57TH STREET 42 EAST 57TH STREET MANHATTAN 9312444 38 EAST 57TH STREET 38 EAST 57TH STREET MANATTAN 9710917 6TH AVE & 48TH STREET 6TH AVE & 48TH STREET MANHATTAN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 189

9312787 BET 2ND & 3RD - 46 ST. BET 2ND & 3RD - 46ST. BRONX 9404678 43RD ST BET MADISON & 5TH 43RD ST BET MADISON & 5TH MANHATTAN 9905165 VAULT 1083 227 E 45TH ST MANHATTAN 8806107 57 ST @ MADISON AV 57 ST @ MADISON AV NYC 9012178 304 EAST 50TH ST/MANH 304 EAST 50TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9308386 136 EAST 57TH STREET 136 EAST 57TH STREET NYC 9700164 300 E 52ND ST 300 E 52ND ST MANHATTAN 9701110 300 EAST 52ND ST 300 EAST 52ND ST MANHATTAN 0006607 MANHOLE 5047 300 EAST 49TH ST MANHATTAN 9308376 57TH ST / LEXINGTON AVE. 57TH ST / LEXINGTON AVE. NYC 9312635 309 E. 49TH ST. 309 E. 49TH ST. MANHATTAN 9312786 43 EAST 42TH ST. 43 EAST 42TH ST. BRONX 8911300 311-317 EAST 50TH ST 311-317 EAST 50TH ST MANHATTAN 9002859 327 EAST 51 STREET 327 EAST 51 STREET MANHATTAN 9603417 153 E 57TH ST 153 E 57TH ST MANHATTAN 0106592 FRIED PHILL REALITY CORP 34 WEST 57TH ST MANHATTEN 8600434 NON PCB X-FORMER 126 W. 53RD ST. NEW YORK CITY 9611764 ALLEYWAY AT GRAND CENTRAL 42ND AND LEXINGTON AVE MANHATTAN 9802532 STONE CREST MANAGEMENT 500 5TH AVE MANHATTEN 9906075 VAULT 2445 1 WEST 42ND ST MANHATTAN 8904163 300 EAST 46TH ST/MANH 300 EAST 46TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9202524 300 E 46TH ST 300 E 46TH ST NYC 8709243 11 WEST 42ND ST/MANHATTAN 11 WEST 42ND ST NEW YORK CITY 9200325 11 W 42ND ST 11 W 42ND ST NYC 9511912 RESTAURANT CORP 845 2ND AVE MANHATTAN 9010922 328 EAST 53RD ST/MANH 328 EAST 53RD STREET NEW YORK CITY 9711767 45-47 WEST 57TH ST 45-47 WEST 57TH ST MANHATTAN 9606889 954 3RD AVE/57TH ST 954 3RD AVE/57TH ST MANHATTAN 9313656 58TH ST & 5TH AVENUE 58TH ST & 5TH AVENUE NEW YORK CITY 9002392 105 WEST 55TH ST/MANH 105 WEST 55TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9711507 VAULT #4212 311 E 54TH ST MANHATTAN 9610091 333 EAST 53RD ST 333 EAST 53RD ST MANHATTEN 8809268 352 E 50TH ST/MANHATTAN 352 EAST 50TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9506908 279 E. 44TH STREET 279 E, 44TH STRRET MANHATTAN 9003435 274 EAST 44TH ST/MANH 274 EAST 44TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9900567 321 EAST 54TH STREET 321 EAST 54TH ST NEW YORK 9803841 352 E 52ND ST 352 E 52ND ST MANHATTAN 0009500 MANHOLE 60842 6TH AV/W56TH ST MANHATTAN 9012392 126 W 55TH ST/MANH/HERTZ 126 WEST 55TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9213654 316 EAST 55TH ST. 316 EAST 55TH ST. MANHATTAN 9602046 976 THIRD AVE/58TH ST 976 THIRD AVE/58TH ST NEW YORK 9405243 136 WEST 55TH STREET 136 WEST 55TH STREET MANHATTAN 9514806 345 E 54TH ST 345 E 54TH ST MANHATTAN 0010906 MACKLOWE MANAGEMENT 369 LEXINGTON AV MANHATTAN 9001231 304 EAST 44TH ST/MANH 304 EAST 44TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 9011540 219 EAST 58TH ST/MANH 219 EAST 58TH STREET NEW YORK CITY 8906224 40TH ST BET.MADISON/PARK 40TH ST / MADISON AVE NEW YORK CITY Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 190

0011854 OIL COMPANY 310 E 44TH ST MANHATTAN 0011780 MANHOLE 43859 EAST 41ST MANHAATAN

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 191

------* PETROLEUM BULK STORAGE FACILITIES LESS THAN 400,000 GALLONS IDENTIFIED WITHIN THE 1/8 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------PLEASE NOTE: * Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Map Identification Number 246 MUTUAL OF AMERICA BUILDING Facility Id 2-602867 Source: NYS DEC 320 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 246 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Expiration Date of the facility's registration certificate: 12/17/2001 Facility Phone Number: (212) 308-0320

TANK TANK TANK CAPACITY TANK INSTALL TEST CLOSE NUMBER STATUS CONTENT GALLONS LOCATION DATE DATE DATE

T-375 IN SERVICE DIESEL 375 ABOVEGROUND ON LEGS RACKS ETC 06/01/1995 T-10,000 IN SERVICE DIESEL 10000 ABOVEGROUND ON LEGS RACKS ETC 06/01/1995

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------DIESEL 68334305 X X X ------

Map Identification Number 247 THE NEW YORK PALACE Facility Id 2-476579 Source: NYS DEC 455 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 277 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Expiration Date of the facility's registration certificate: 06/22/2004 Facility Phone Number: (212) 888-7000

TANK TANK TANK CAPACITY TANK INSTALL TEST CLOSE NUMBER STATUS CONTENT GALLONS LOCATION DATE DATE DATE

001 IN SERVICE DIESEL 2000 UNDERGROUND 01/01/1980 08/01/1998 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 192

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------DIESEL 68334305 X X X ------

Map Identification Number 248 299 PARK AVENUE Facility Id 2-601820 Source: NYS DEC 299 PARK AVENUE MANHATTAN, NY 10171

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 330 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: 10017

Expiration Date of the facility's registration certificate: 04/21/2004 Facility Phone Number: (212) 753-6234

TANK TANK TANK CAPACITY TANK INSTALL TEST CLOSE NUMBER STATUS CONTENT GALLONS LOCATION DATE DATE DATE

001 IN SERVICE DIESEL 6500 ABOVEGROUND ON LEGS RACKS ETC 04/01/1994 002 IN SERVICE DIESEL 275 ABOVEGROUND ON LEGS RACKS ETC 04/01/1994

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------DIESEL 68334305 X X X ------

Map Identification Number 249 NEW DAWN DAVIDSON L.P. Facility Id 2-364223 Source: NYS DEC 477 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 425 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Expiration Date of the facility's registration certificate: 12/14/1992 Facility Phone Number: (212) 758-5800

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 193

TANK TANK TANK CAPACITY TANK INSTALL TEST CLOSE NUMBER STATUS CONTENT GALLONS LOCATION DATE DATE DATE

001 IN SERVICE #1 2 OR 4 FUEL OIL 1450 UNDERGROUND VAULTED W/ ACCESS

Map Identification Number 250 RICH D`ANGELO Facility Id 2-603213 Source: NYS DEC 280 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10017

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 513 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Expiration Date of the facility's registration certificate: 11/18/2002 Facility Phone Number: (212) 682-7565

TANK TANK TANK CAPACITY TANK INSTALL TEST CLOSE NUMBER STATUS CONTENT GALLONS LOCATION DATE DATE DATE

001 IN SERVICE DIESEL 1500 ABOVEGROUND ON LEGS RACKS ETC

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------DIESEL 68334305 X X X ------

Map Identification Number 251 40 EAST COMPANY Facility Id 2-361879 Source: NYS DEC 40 EAST 52ND STREET NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 558 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Expiration Date of the facility's registration certificate: 10/23/2002 Facility Phone Number: (212) 319-3341

TANK TANK TANK CAPACITY TANK INSTALL TEST CLOSE NUMBER STATUS CONTENT GALLONS LOCATION DATE DATE DATE

001 IN SERVICE #1 2 OR 4 FUEL OIL 1500 ABOVEGROUND ON LEGS RACKS ETC 04/01/1986

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 194

------* HAZARDOUS WASTE GENERATORS/TRANSPORTERS IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/8 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------PLEASE NOTE: * Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Map Identification Number 252 COLGATE PALMOLIVE COMPANY Facility Id: NYD001344381 300 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE CO EPA (RCRA) Address: 300 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 100227499

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 245 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: LARGE QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 03/05/1985 Part A notification date: 03/05/1985 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 23 POUNDS GENERATED 1985 D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 200 POUNDS GENERATED 1985

Map Identification Number 253 MUTUAL OF AMERICA BLDG THE Facility Id: NYD987036449 320 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: MUTUAL OF AMERICA BLDG THE EPA (RCRA) Address: 320 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022 OFFICE OF THE BUILDING

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 246 feet to the E Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: LARGE QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 12/16/1994 Part A notification date: 12/16/1994 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 195

WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

NONE Site reported by US EPA. No hazardous waste activity reported to NYS.

Map Identification Number 254 AMERICAN EAGLE FDR CORPORATION Facility Id: NYD981131097 455 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: JUNG SUN EPA (RCRA) Address: 455 MADISON AVE 6TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 277 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 05/12/1997 Part A notification date: 05/12/1997 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: Historically listed as the following USEPA RCRA Generator Size(s) as well: LARGE QUANTITY GENERATOR ------US EPA RCRA Violations: Violation Area: GENRATOR-SQG REQUIREMENTS Responsible Agency: EPA Violation Number: 0001 Location: NY Violation Determination Date: 04/10/1998 Regulation: 6nycrr 372.2; 373-3.3; 376.1 Violation Return to Compliance: 10/02/1998 ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

F002 Spent halogenated solvents 195 POUNDS GENERATED 2000

Map Identification Number 255 HELMSLEY PALACE Facility Id: NYD166077602 455 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: HELMSLEY PALACE HOTEL EPA (RCRA) Address: 455 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 277 feet to the NW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 196

US EPA RCRA Type: GENERATOR TYPE NOT GIVEN Notification date: 02/17/1989 Part A notification date: 02/17/1989 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------US EPA RCRA Violations: Violation Area: GENRATOR-SQG REQUIREMENTS Responsible Agency: EPA Violation Number: 0001 Location: NY Violation Determination Date: 04/10/1998 Regulation: 6nycrr 372.2; 373.-3.3; 376.1 Violation Return to Compliance: 10/02/1998

Violation Area: GENRATOR-SQG REQUIREMENTS Responsible Agency: EPA Violation Number: 0002 Location: NY Violation Determination Date: 08/26/1998 Regulation: 262.110 Violation Return to Compliance: 09/02/1998

Violation Area: GENRATOR-SQG REQUIREMENTS Responsible Agency: EPA Violation Number: 0003 Location: NY Violation Determination Date: 04/22/1999 Regulation: 371.1(f)(7)iii Violation Return to Compliance: 06/29/1999 ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

NONE No hazardous waste activity reported to NYS up to 2/12/2003.

Map Identification Number 256 437 MADISON AVENUE FEE ASSOCIATES Facility Id: NYD986913945 437 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: 437 MADISON AVE FEE ASSOC EPA (RCRA) Address: 437 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 286 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: GENERATOR TYPE NOT GIVEN Notification date: 09/25/1990 Part A notification date: 09/25/1990 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 310 GALLONS GENERATED 1992 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 197

D007 Chromium 60 GALLONS GENERATED 1990 F002 Spent halogenated solvents 480 GALLONS GENERATED 1990 F005 Spent non-halogenated solvents 30 GALLONS GENERATED 1990 U077 Ethane, 1,2-dichloro- 55 GALLONS GENERATED 1990

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Chromium 7440473 X X 50ug/L* Ethane, 1,2-dichloro- 107062 X X X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 257 HITACHI Facility Id: NY0000940759 437 MADISON AVE 32ND FL NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED EPA (RCRA) Name: HITACHI FIE MANHATTAN EPA (RCRA) Address: 437 MADISON AVE - 32ND FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 100227001

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: 437 MADISON AVE Approximate distance from property: 286 feet to the W Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 11/17/1994 Part A notification date: 11/17/1994 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 7 POUNDS GENERATED 1994 F002 Spent halogenated solvents 180 POUNDS GENERATED 1994 U057 Cyclohexanone (I) 20 POUNDS GENERATED 1994

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Cyclohexanone (I) 108941 X X X X X 50 ug/L ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 198

Map Identification Number 258 KISS PHOTO INC Facility Id: NYD103233920 437 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: KIS COLOR SYSTEMS INC EPA (RCRA) Address: 437 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10016

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: 437 MADISON AVENUE Approximate distance from property: 286 feet to the W Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 03/27/1986 Part A notification date: 03/27/1986 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 165 GALLONS GENERATED 1986 D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 285 GALLONS GENERATED 1986 D003 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of reactivity 285 GALLONS GENERATED 1986 D011 Silver 120 GALLONS GENERATED 1986

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Silver 7440224 X 0.05mg/L* ------

Map Identification Number 259 CONSOLIDATED EDISON Facility Id: NYP004050803 V3054-F/O 48 E 49TH ST NEW YORK, NY 10003

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 48 E 49TH ST Approximate distance from property: 300 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: 10017

US EPA RCRA (Resource Conservation and Recovery Act) information not reported; Site information reported by NYS DEC. ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 199

WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

B002 Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 ppm 1986 KILOGRAMS GENERATED 2000

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 260 NEWSWEEK INC Facility Id: NYD986977130 444 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: NEWSWEEK INC - 444 MADISON AVE EPA (RCRA) Address: 444 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 312 feet to the WNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 04/03/1996 Part A notification date: 04/03/1996 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 3000 POUNDS GENERATED 1996

Map Identification Number 261 CONSOLIDATED EDISON Facility Id: NYP004041836 V1362-49 E 51ST ST MANHATTAN, NY 10027

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 49 E 51ST ST Approximate distance from property: 322 feet to the N Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA (Resource Conservation and Recovery Act) information not reported; Site information reported by NYS DEC. Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 200

------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

B002 Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 ppm 1892 KILOGRAMS GENERATED 1999

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 262 WALDORF ASTORIA Facility Id: NYP000892174 301 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 331 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA (Resource Conservation and Recovery Act) information not reported; Site information reported by NYS DEC. ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

B001 PCB Oil (concentrated) from transformers, capacitors, etc. 347 GALLONS GENERATED 1989 B006 PCB Transformers. 11650 POUNDS GENERATED 1989

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------PCB Oil (concentrated) from transformers, capacitors, etc. 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 201

Map Identification Number 263 CON EDISON @ WALDORF ASTORIA HILTON Facility Id: NYR000089755 301 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: CON EDISON @ WALDORF ASTORIA HILTON EPA (RCRA) Address: 301 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 331 feet to the SSE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 09/15/2000 Part A notification date: 09/15/2000 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D009 Mercury 10 GALLONS GENERATED 2000 D009 Mercury 335 POUNDS GENERATED 2000

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Mercury 7439976 X X X X .002mg/L* ------

Map Identification Number 264 415 MADISON INC Facility Id: NYD987038866 415 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10017 EPA (RCRA) Name: 415 MADISON INC EPA (RCRA) Address: 415 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10017 MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT ROOM

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 476 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 07/28/1993 Part A notification date: 07/28/1993 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 202

------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

NONE Site reported by US EPA. No hazardous waste activity reported to NYS.

Map Identification Number 265 RUTH L WEINTRAUB INC Facility Id: NYD057325730 420 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10017 EPA (RCRA) Name: RUTH L WEINTRAUB CO INC EPA (RCRA) Address: 420 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10017

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 483 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: LARGE QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 08/01/1989 Part A notification date: 08/01/1989 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

F001 Spent halogenated solvents used in degreasing 1 GALLONS GENERATED 1997

Map Identification Number 266 BANKERS TRUST SECURITIES Facility Id: NYD986975738 280 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10017 EPA (RCRA) Name: BANKERS TRUST CO EPA (RCRA) Address: 280 PARK AVE W NEW YORK, NY 100171270

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 513 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 10/30/1991 Part A notification date: 10/30/1991 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 203

------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D011 Silver 90 GALLONS GENERATED 1994 D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 1200 GALLONS GENERATED 1992 D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 1200 POUNDS GENERATED 1992 D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 90 GALLONS GENERATED 1992 D007 Chromium 1600 POUNDS GENERATED 1992

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Silver 7440224 X 0.05mg/L* Chromium 7440473 X X 50ug/L* ------

Map Identification Number 267 SWISS BANK TOWER Facility Id: NYR000035907 17 EAST 49TH ST NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: SWISS BANK CORP EPA (RCRA) Address: 17 E 49TH ST 10TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 17 E 49TH ST Approximate distance from property: 523 feet to the W Revised zip code: 10017

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 02/21/1997 Part A notification date: 02/21/1997 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 1814 POUNDS GENERATED 1997 D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 120 GALLONS GENERATED 1997 X910 Unknown waste type. 50 POUNDS GENERATED 1997

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 204

Map Identification Number 268 CON ED Facility Id: NYP004033403 V3980-28 E 48TH ST N/S, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 28 E 48TH ST Approximate distance from property: 549 feet to the WSW Revised zip code: 10017

US EPA RCRA (Resource Conservation and Recovery Act) information not reported; Site information reported by NYS DEC. ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

B002 Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 ppm 700 KILOGRAMS GENERATED 1999

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 269 40 EASTCO Facility Id: NYD987038320 40 E 52ND ST NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: 40 EASTCO EPA (RCRA) Address: 40 E 52ND ST NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 558 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 07/28/1993 Part A notification date: 07/28/1993 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

NONE Site reported by US EPA. No hazardous waste activity reported to NYS.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 205

Map Identification Number 270 CON ED Facility Id: NYP004033395 V1307-28 E 52ND ST N/S, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: 28 E 52ND ST Approximate distance from property: 575 feet to the N Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA (Resource Conservation and Recovery Act) information not reported; Site information reported by NYS DEC. ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

B002 Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 ppm 945 KILOGRAMS GENERATED 1999

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 271 CONSOLIDATED EDISON Facility Id: NYP004052395 V3838-28 E 52ND ST NEW YORK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 28 E 52ND ST Approximate distance from property: 587 feet to the N Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA (Resource Conservation and Recovery Act) information not reported; Site information reported by NYS DEC. ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

B002 Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 ppm 1334 KILOGRAMS GENERATED 2000

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 206

Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 272 PARK AVENUE PLAZA Facility Id: NYD987017357 55 E 52ND STREET MANHATTAN, NY 10055 EPA (RCRA) Name: PARK AVENUE PLAZA EPA (RCRA) Address: 55 E 52ND ST NEW YORK, NY 10055

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 592 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA Type: CONDITIONALLY EXEMPT SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 10/06/1992 Part A notification date: 10/06/1992 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

F003 Spent non-halogenated solvents 40 GALLONS GENERATED 1993

Map Identification Number 273 INGES BEARING Facility Id: NYR000079384 55 E 52ND ST 12 FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10020 EPA (RCRA) Name: INGES BEARING EPA (RCRA) Address: 55 E 52ND ST 12 FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10020

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 55 E 52ND ST Approximate distance from property: 592 feet to the NNE Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA Type: LARGE QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 12/14/1999 Part A notification date: 12/14/1999 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

NONE Site reported by US EPA. No hazardous waste activity reported to NYS.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 207

Map Identification Number 274 345 PARK CO Facility Id: NYD987038841 345 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10154 EPA (RCRA) Name: 345 PARK CO EPA (RCRA) Address: 345 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 101540101 MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT ROOM

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 596 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 07/28/1993 Part A notification date: 07/28/1993 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 80 POUNDS GENERATED 1998

Map Identification Number 275 BRISTOL MYERS Facility Id: NYD001288497 345 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10154 EPA (RCRA) Name: BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB EPA (RCRA) Address: 345 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10154

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: 345 PARK AVENUE Approximate distance from property: 596 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA Type: GENERATOR TYPE NOT GIVEN Notification date: 01/31/1986 Part A notification date: 01/31/1986 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 8 POUNDS GENERATED 1999 D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 125 POUNDS GENERATED 1997 D009 Mercury 75 POUNDS GENERATED 1996 B001 PCB Oil (concentrated) from transformers, capacitors, etc. 300 POUNDS GENERATED 1986 Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 208

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Mercury 7439976 X X X X .002mg/L* PCB Oil (concentrated) from transformers, capacitors, etc. 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 276 HANCO JEWELRY INC Facility Id: NYD071003370 501 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: HANCO JEWELRY INC EPA (RCRA) Address: 501 MADISON AVE NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (3) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 612 feet to the N Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: GENERATOR TYPE NOT GIVEN Notification date: 0 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

NONE Site reported by US EPA. No hazardous waste activity reported to NYS.

Map Identification Number 277 CONSOLIDATED EDISON Facility Id: NYP004027546 8170975-24 E 52ND ST MANHATTAN, NY 10027

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 24 E 52ND ST Approximate distance from property: 614 feet to the N Revised zip code: 10022

US EPA RCRA (Resource Conservation and Recovery Act) information not reported; Site information reported by NYS DEC. ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 209

WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

B002 Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 ppm 2132 KILOGRAMS GENERATED 1998

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 278 CITOH & CO INC Facility Id: NYD006985956 270 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10017 EPA (RCRA) Name: C ITOH & CO INC EPA (RCRA) Address: 270 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10017

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 615 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: LARGE QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 02/20/1985 Part A notification date: 02/20/1985 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 210 POUNDS GENERATED 1985 D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 200 POUNDS GENERATED 1985 U133 Hydrazine (R,T) 11 POUNDS GENERATED 1985

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Hydrazine (R,T) 302012 X X X X 50 ug/L ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 210

Map Identification Number 279 WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC CORP Facility Id: NYD986896843 270 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10017 EPA (RCRA) Name: WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC CORP EPA (RCRA) Address: 270 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10010

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 615 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: GENERATOR TYPE NOT GIVEN Notification date: 04/02/1990 Part A notification date: 04/02/1990 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: ------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

B002 Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 ppm 1898 KILOGRAMS GENERATED 1991 B007 Other PCB Wastes including contaminated soil, solids, sludges, clothing, etc. 61 KILOGRAMS GENERATED 1991

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm < PCBs < 500 1336363 X X X 5 ug/L ------

Map Identification Number 280 CHASE MANHATTEN BANK Facility Id: NYD001289008 270 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10017 EPA (RCRA) Name: J P MORGAN CHASE EPA (RCRA) Address: 270 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10017

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 615 feet to the S Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 01/05/2001 Part A notification date: 01/05/2001 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: No current info -- Previously reported Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 211

------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 40 GALLONS GENERATED 2001 D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 85 GALLONS GENERATED 2001 F002 Spent halogenated solvents 345 GALLONS GENERATED 2001 D008 Lead 280 POUNDS GENERATED 2000 F006 Wastewater treatment sludges from electroplating operations 3300 POUNDS TRANSPORTED 1984 D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability 1650 POUNDS TRANSPORTED 1983 F008 Plating bath residues from the bottom of plating baths 7700 POUNDS TRANSPORTED 1983 B009 Unknown waste type. 1596 POUNDS TRANSPORTED 1982 F001 Spent halogenated solvents used in degreasing 24738 POUNDS TRANSPORTED 1982 F006 Wastewater treatment sludges from electroplating operations 4345 GALLONS TRANSPORTED 1982 N003 Unknown waste type. 4840 GALLONS TRANSPORTED 1982 D000 Unknown waste type. 55 GALLONS GENERATED 1981 D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity 110 CUBIC YDS GENERATED 1981

Toxicity Information Summary ------CHEMICAL NAME CAS-NO ACUTE TUMOR MUTAG REPRO IRRIT MCL TOX TOX TOX TOX TOX ------Lead 7439921 X X X X 0.05mg/L* ------

Map Identification Number 281 SWISS BANK TOWER Facility Id: NYR000055715 10 E 50TH ST SUBCELLAR NEW YORK, NY 10022 EPA (RCRA) Name: SWISS BANK TOWER EPA (RCRA) Address: 10 E 50TH ST SUBCELLAR NEW YORK, NY 10022

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: ADDRESS MATCHING Revised street: 10 E 50TH ST Approximate distance from property: 646 feet to the WNW Revised zip code: NO CHANGE

US EPA RCRA Type: SMALL QUANTITY GENERATOR Notification date: 06/05/1998 Part A notification date: 06/05/1998 Land Disposal: Receives offsite waste: Incinerator: Storer: Treatment facility: Transporter: Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 212

------NYS DEC Manifested Waste Summary: Waste Codes, Waste Units, and Transaction Types are only shown for the most recent year reported. ------WASTE WASTE WASTE WASTE TRANSACTION CODE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT UNITS TYPE YEAR

NONE Site reported by US EPA. No hazardous waste activity reported to NYS.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 213

------* NO CHEMICAL STORAGE FACILITIES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/8 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 214

------* NO TOXIC AIR, LAND AND WATER RELEASES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/8 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 215

------* NO HISTORIC UTILITY SITES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/8 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 216

------* NO WASTEWATER DISCHARGES IDENTIFIED WITHIN 1/8 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 217

------* AIR DISCHARGE FACILITIES IDENTIFIED WITHIN THE 1/8 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------PLEASE NOTE: * Compass directions can vary substantially for sites located very close to the subject property address.

Map Identification Number 282 SUMITOMO CORP(DUPL SEE 015-NO1O6 INSTEAD Facility Id: 3606100421 State-county CDS Id: 3606100421 345 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 101540000 State-county NED id: EPA (FINDS) Name: SUMITOMO CORPORATION OF AMERICA EPA (FINDS) Address: 345 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK 101540000

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 593 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: 10022

CDS-ID: 00421 NED-ID: None Given EPA-ID: NY0001401744 FINDS-ID: NY0001401744 Plant Phone #1: (212)207-0700 Plant Phone #2: None Given Operating Status: PERMANENTLY CLOSED EPA Classification: State Classification: POTENTIAL UNCONTROLLED EMISSIONS < 100 TONS/YEAR EPA Plant Compliance Status: State Plant Compliance Status: UNKNOWN COMPLIANCE STATUS

AIR PROGRAM INFORMATION Regulatory Air Program: SIP SOURCE Program Status: PERMANENTLY CLOSED Regulatory Air Program: CFC TRACKING Program Status: PERMANENTLY CLOSED

POLLUTANT INFORMATION Pollutant: CHLOROFLUOROCARBONS State Pollutant Compliance for this pollutant: UNKNOWN COMPLIANCE STATUS Pollutant: VOLATILE ORGANIC COMPOUNDS State Pollutant Compliance for this pollutant: IN COMPLIANCE - INSPECTION

Map Identification Number 283 BRISTOL MYERS FINDS Id: NYD001288497 345 PARK AVE NEW YORK, NY 10154

MAP LOCATION INFORMATION ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Site location mapped by: MANUAL MAPPING (2) Revised street: NO CHANGE Approximate distance from property: 593 feet to the ENE Revised zip code: 10022

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 218

This site was identified in the EPA FINDS database. No air pollutant information given here.

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 44- 50 E 50th Street Page 219

------* NO CIVIL ENFORCEMENT DOCKET FACILITIES IDENTIFIED WITHIN THE 1/8 MILE SEARCH RADIUS * ------

U.S. EPA EMERGENCY RESPONSE NOTIFICATION SYSTEM (ERNS) AT THE LOCATION OR POTENTIALLY AT THE LOCATION OF 44− 50 E 50th Street New York, NY 10022

* Any ERNS Spills listed below are NOT mapped in this report *

ONSITE ERNS (A count of these spills can be found in the distance interval table): THIS SITE IS NOT FOUND IN THE ERNS DATABASE

POTENTIALLY ONSITE ERNS: THIS SITE IS NOT FOUND IN THE ERNS DATABASE

NEW YORK CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT TANK SEARCH AT THE LOCATION OF 44− 50 E 50th Street New York, NY 10022

None Identified. Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. October 14, 2003 ’44 − 50 E 50th Street’

Unmappable facilities for ’New York’ County

NPL/CERCLIS/NYSDEC Inactive Hazardous Waste Facilities FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP NYD980531578 LEROY SHOT & LEAD WORKS UNKNOWN NEW YORK UNKNOWN

Hazardous Substance Waste Sites FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP NY0081 ROUTE 9A − MANHATTAN WEST SIDE HIGHWAY NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN

Solid Waste Facilities FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP 31D01 CENTRAL PARK DEMO UNKNOWN 31D02 PENN CENTRAL DEMO UNKNOWN

Hazardous Spills − UNKNOWN CAUSE OR OTHER CAUSES − Active FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP 9514638 FEEDER M52 49TH ST TO SPAINBROOK S/S BRONX + WESTCHESTER UNKNOWN 9912263 UNKNOWN LOCATION ON AN UNDERGROUND FEEDER M51 49TH ST SUB UNKNOWN 9703206 607 FEET OFF WASHINGTON AVE MAHATTEN UNKNOWN 9909792 MANHOLE 621845 WEST 49TH ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9901524 FEEDER M52 WEST 49TH ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9705558 FEEDER #69M73 UNKNOWN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9503001 57TH ST & 72ND ST 57TH ST & 72ND ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8503107 MANHATTAN MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0300384 MANHOLE 56671 WEST 45TH ST MANHATTAN 10036 0206281 PARKING LOT BULKHEAD/57TH ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0105475 MANHOLE #7675 W 40TH ST & 80TH AV MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0104890 MANHOLE # 56738 EAST 41ST ST MANHATTAN 10017 0101161 SERVICE BOX #10817 WEST 56TH ST #419 MANHATTAN 10019 0010574 RR TRACK #7 LINE TRACK C2 COLUMN 57 GRAND CENTRAL MANHATTAN 10017 0009680 EMPIRE LINE BETWEEN 42ND/72ND ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9814861 SPRAINBROOK SUB STATION TO WEST 49TH ST STATION MANHATTEN UNKNOWN 9811263 MANHOLE 39273 LEXINGTON AVENUE MANHATTEN UNKNOWN 9905530 VARIOUS LOCAIONS CITY AND WESTCHESTER NEW YORK UNKNOWN 9611244 BTWN EAST 13TH TO 637 WEST 49TH ST NEW YORK UNKNOWN 9404424 WEST 65 & WEST 49TH ST WEST 65TH / 49TH ST NEW YORK UNKNOWN 0110864 ON MARIA KNUTSEN VESSEL KINDER MORGAN DOCK 4 NEW YORK UNKNOWN 0010293 W 49TH ST SUBST.−TUCKOHOE RD SUBSTATION NEW YORK UNKNOWN 9101794 LEXINGTON AVE/MANH LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN 9815046 BTWN W.49TH ST STATION SPRAINBRROK SUB STATION NEW YORK CITY AREA UNKNOWN 9810397 UNK LOCATION UNK LOCATION UNKNOWN UNKNOWN 9912656 FEEDER M52 SPRAINBROOK TO W.49TH SS YONKERS UNKNOWN

Hazardous Spills − MISC. SPILL CAUSES − Active FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP 9912351 CON ED FEEDER FROM MANH FEEDER FROM MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9907952 VAULT #6061 WEST SIDE OF 8TH AVE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9812964 CON ED M52 FEEDER LINE SPRAINBROOK TO WEST 49TH MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9811161 MANHOLE #09766 SOUTH OF W 51ST ST MANHATTAN 10019 9606335 SUBSTATION−WEST 56TH ST WEST 56TH STREET MANHATTAN 10019 9308954 BET.VERNON & WATERSIDE BET. VERNON & WATERSIDE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9013328 W49TH ST TO W65TH ST S/S W49TH ST TO W65TH ST S/S MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0110412 CON ED 1641 WEST 45TH ST MANHATTAN 10036 0013621 PIER 45 NORTH RIVER MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0012470 CHURCH ST/WEST 43RD ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0010963 FEEDER 52 SPRAINBROOK TO WEST 49TH MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9902333 FEEDER CABLE M52 W 49TH ST TO SPRAINBROOK MANHATTAN/YONKERS UNKNOWN 0202655 VAULT #4294 W 54TH ST & 60 W 6TH AVE MANHATTEN UNKNOWN 9930008 VARIOUS LOCATIONS DRUMS NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN 9606764 FEEDER #71 DUNWOODIE TO RAINEY NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN

Hazardous Spills − TANK TEST FAILURES − Closed FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP 8802622 85−09 1ST AVENUE 85−09 1ST AVENUE NYC UNKNOWN

Hazardous Spills − UNKNOWN CAUSE OR OTHER CAUSES − Closed FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP 9113202 77 ST. TO 53 ST. IN MAN. 77 ST. TO 53 ST. IN MAN. MAN. UNKNOWN 9903608 MANHOLE 107 55TH STREET MANAHTTEN UNKNOWN 9907053 IN FRONT OF WATERSIDE GENERATING STATION MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9900673 HUDSON RIVER WEST 42ND ST MANHATTAN 10036 9811460 6TH AVE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9504860 SO. QUEENSBORO BRIDGE SO. QUEENSBORO BRIDGE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9314207 N.E. CORN OF 45TH STREET N.E. CORN OF 45TH STREET MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9214390 RT 495 RT 495 MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9210087 PERSHING CIRCLE PERSHING CIRCLE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8504758 MANHATTAN MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8503796 MANHATTAN MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8503779 MANHATTAN MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8503506 MANHATTAN MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8503421 MANHATTAN MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8503366 MANHATTAN, NYC MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8503301 MANHATTAN MANHATTAN MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0201019 MANHOLE 33793 WEST 40 5TH AVE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0109755 FEEDER 38 M72 W 49TH ST & E 65TH SUBSTA MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0007797 MANHOLE 38334 WEST SIDE MADISON AVE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0004099 HUDSON RIVER BY 48TH STREET MANHATTAN 10036 9006769 RESTAURANT/UNK ADDRESS UNKNOWN MANHATTEN UNKNOWN 9400226 UNK UNK NEW YORK UNKNOWN 8604519 NEW YORK NEW YORK NEW YORK UNKNOWN 8907255 HERTZ RENT A CAR/MANH NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN 8606984 UNKNOWN ADDRESS ! UNKNOWN NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN 8605776 1 AVE BETWEEN 58&62 ST.MA 1 AVE. BTWN 58&62 STREETS NEW YORK CITY unknown 8603399 20ST−50ST 20ST−50ST NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN 9106419 E RIVER BET 14TH ST & UN E RIVER BET 14TH ST & UN NYC UNKNOWN 8605782 1 AVE 53ST.−57ST. NYC/ G 1 AVE. FROM 53 TO 57 ST. NYC 10022 8607173 UNK UNK UNK UNKNOWN

Hazardous Spills − MISC. SPILL CAUSES − Closed FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP 0004983 RT 495 BETWEEN EXIT 39 AN D 40 LONG ISLAND UNKNOWN 0010334 MANHOLE 32381 SE CORNER WEST 44TH ST MANHAATAN 10036 9907607 CANAL SANITATION MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9906600 FEEDER BTWN ASTORIA SUB S TA AND EAS13TH SUB STA MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9903692 APARTMENT HOUSE 1 COLUMBUS PLACE MANHATTAN 10019 9512157 801 60TH ST 801 60TH ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9402295 LOWER LEVEL EB #12 LOWER LEVER EB #12 MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9400476 773−787 55TH STREET 773−787 55TH STREET MANHATTAN 10019 9314991 59TH STREET 59TH STREET MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9308561 48TH STREET 48TH STREET MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 8909472 LEXINGTON & THIRD AVS 3 AV − LEXINGTON MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0203027 220 CENTRAL PARK AVE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0109602 WESTSIDE PLAZA NO ADDRESS(WESTSIDE PLAZA MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0106786 IN ROADT 5TH ST & 7TH AV MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0103252 ON STREET 59TH ST/CENTRAL PARK SOUT MANHATTAN 10019 0100974 FEEDER M51 WEST 49TH ST−SPRAINBROOK MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0012765 BETWEEN W49TH SUBSTATION & SPRAINBROOK SUBSTATION MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0008112 SUBSTATION W 56TH ST MANHATTAN 10019 0004534 FEEDER M52 WEST 49TH & SPRINGBROOK MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 0004011 FEEDER TUB FROM YONKERS TO 49TH ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN 9713418 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN MANHATTEN UNKNOWN 0105962 ROADWAY 59TH ST & CENTRAL PARK SO NEW YORK UNKNOWN 8803764 EAST 42ND STREET/BYPASS EAST 42ND STREET NEW YORK CITY 10017 8802750 44TH STREET/MANHATTAN 44TH STREET NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN 8603644 LEXINGTON & 3 LEXINGTON & 3 NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN 9501840 UNKNOWN LOCATION UNKNOWN LOCATION WESTCHESTER UNKNOWN

Petroleum Bulk Storage Facilities FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP 2−606868 5 EAST STREET 5 E STREET NEW YORK UNKNOWN 2−157856 MOBIL S/S 1 JBWBT ARDOR GARAGE MOBIL S/S 1 (JBWBT ARDOR GARAGE) NY UNKNOWN

Hazardous Waste Generation or Transport Facilities FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP NY0000010363 NEW YORK CITY DEPT OF TRANSPORTATION UNKNOWN NYN20002A347 UNKNOWN NYP000007732 NEW YORK CITY TRANSIT AUTHORITY UNKNOWN NYP000918558 NEW YORK CITY TRANSIT AUTHORITY UNKNOWN NYP004005146 CONSOLIDATED EDISON CO EAST 48TH STREET V5813 UNKNOWN NYP004005153 CONSOLIDATED EDISON CO EAST 50TH STREET V5961 10022 NYP004005187 CON ED V 1314 − E 49ST UNKNOWN NYP004005195 CON ED V 2949 − E 49ST UNKNOWN NYP004007159 CON ED MH 8979 − MADISON AVE UNKNOWN NYP004008462 CON ED MH 38679 − 48 ST UNKNOWN NYP004009544 CON ED MH 70942 − 52 ST UNKNOWN NYP004010854 CON ED MH 60652 − EAST SIDE UNKNOWN NYP004018016 CONSOLIDATED EDISON CO 393 MADISON AVE UNKNOWN NYP004024113 CONSOLIDATED EDISON CO 11 5TH AVE 47 ST UNKNOWN NYP004010674 CONSOLIDATED EDISON E/S FDR DR MANHATTAN UNKNOWN NYP004031035 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V4706−100 51ST ST MANHATTAN UNKNOWN NYP004032991 CONSOLIDATED EDISON MH60653−N/S MANHATTAN UNKNOWN NYP004034997 CONSOLIDATED EDISON HOLBAN S/S−178−16 SAYERS AVE MANHATTAN UNKNOWN NYP004035788 CONSOLIDATED EDISON FDR5Q39−LAURELTON S/S MANHATTAN UNKNOWN NYP004035796 CONSOLIDATED EDISON 7Q86−CHISHOLM S/S 15TH & 116TH MANHATTAN UNKNOWN NYP004042131 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V4090−4107−2917−2852−DRAINED MANHATTAN UNKNOWN NYP004056701 CONSOLIDATED EDISON N/S MANHATTAN UNKNOWN NYP004059077 CONSOLIDATED EDISON VS2771−195 W 49TH ST MANHATTEN 10017 NYP000929539 CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK N/S N/S UNKNOWN NYP004020566 CON ED V5715−READERS DIGEST N/S UNKNOWN NYP004028551 CON ED MAINBODY−ALLEY PD PK UNIT SS N/S UNKNOWN NYP004029039 CON ED MH2073−? N/S UNKNOWN NYP004030086 CON ED 7363 MADISON AVE N/S UNKNOWN NYP004033411 CON ED V0155 N/S UNKNOWN NYP004034377 CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK SQ50−FARMERS S/S N/S UNKNOWN NYP004039633 CON ED VS0618−N/S N/S UNKNOWN NYP004046280 CON ED V3994−E 49TH AVE N/S 10017 NYP004046512 CON ED 318 − BY SCIENCA HIGH SCHOOL N/S UNKNOWN NYP004048708 CON ED 614145 M E N/S UNKNOWN NY0005000575 JOHN DOE DELETE NEW YORK UNKNOWN NYD000146548 NEW YORK CITY DEPT OF GENERAL SERVICES 51ST STREET NEW YORK UNKNOWN NYD987026465 NYCDOT CONTRACT BRC253BD BLOCK 332 LOT 12 BETWEEN N & S NEW YORK UNKNOWN NYP000918482 NYNEX BENNETT/HUBERTON NEW YORK UNKNOWN NYP004055414 CONSOLIDATED EDISON V6835−MADISON AVE NEW YORK 10001 NYP010000628 NEW YORK CITY DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECT POLICE RANGE NEW YORK UNKNOWN NYP000931113 CONSOLIDATED EDISON CO V8190−EAST 49TH ST QUEENS UNKNOWN NYP004004594 CON ED MH 4468 VANDERBILT UNKNOWN

Air Releases FACILITY ID FACILITY NAME STREET CITY ZIP 3606100080 NYCHA−FOSTER HOUSING NO STREET ADDRESS NEW YORK UNKNOWN 3606100129 NAVY DIST COMMANDER NO STREET ADDRESS NEW YORK UNKNOWN 3606100495 FEILER BROS CORP ROOM 1700 NEW YORK UNKNOWN 3606100552 ACADEMY CONSTRUCTION NO STREET ADDRESS NEW YORK UNKNOWN 3606180051 FEILER BROS CORP ROOM 1700 NEW YORK UNKNOWN 3606100558 SOS INTERNATIONAL BOX 2976 CHURCH STAT NEW YORK CITY UNKNOWN NY061X0NP MIDTOWN HOLDING CO NEW YORK NO STREET ADDRESS NO CITY NAME UNKNOWN NY061X2DR UNIHAB CO NEW YORK NO STREET ADDRESS NO CITY NAME UNKNOWN NY061X351 ESTATE OF ADOLPH TAUSIK NEW YORK NO STREET ADDRESS NO CITY NAME UNKNOWN NY061X5WJ 101 COOPER ST CO NEW YORK NO STREET ADDRESS NO CITY NAME UNKNOWN Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. 44- 50 E 50th Street October 14, 2003

Hazardous waste codes presented in individual Toxic Information Profiles are defined below.

B001 PCB Oil (concentrated) from transformers, capacitors, etc.

B002 Petroleum oil or other liquid containing 50 ppm or greater of PCBs but less than 500 ppm PCBs. This includes oil from electrical equipment whose PCB concentration is unknown, except for circuit breakers, reclosers and cable.

B006 PCB Transformers. "PCB Transformers" means any transformer that contains 500 ppm PCB or greater.

B007 Other PCB Wastes including contaminated soil, solids, sludges, clothing, rags, and dredge material.

B009

D000

D001 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of ignitability, but is not listed under any other hazardous waste code.

D002 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of corrosivity, but is not listed under any other hazardous waste code.

D003 Solid waste that exhibits the characteristic of reactivity, but is not listed under any other hazardous waste code.

D007 Chromium

D008 Lead

D009 Mercury

D011 Silver

F001 The following spent halogenated solvents used in degreasing: Tetrachloroethylene, trichloroethylene, methylene chloride, 1,1,1-trichloroethane, carbon tetrachloride, and chlorinated fluorocarbons; all spent solvent mixtures/blends used in degreasing containing, before use, a total of ten percent or more (by volume) of one or more of the above halogenated solvents or those solvents listed in F002, F004, and F005; and still bottoms from the recovery of these spent solvents and spent solvent mixtures. (T)

F002 The following spent halogenated solvents: Tetrachloroethylene, methylene chloride, trichloroethylene, 1,1,1-trichloroethane, chlorobenzene, 1,1,2-trichloro-1,2,2-trifluoroethane, ortho-dichlorobenzene, trichlorofluoromethane, and 1,1,2-trichloroethane; all spent solvent mixtures/blends containing, before use, a total of ten percent or more (by volume) of one or more of the above halogenated solvents or those listed in F001, F004, or F005; and still bottoms from the recovery of these spent solvents and spent solvent mixtures. (T)

F003 The following spent non-halogenated solvents: Xylene, acetone, ethyl acetate, ethyl benzene, ethyl ether, methyl isobutyl ketone, n-butyl alcohol, cyclohexanone, and methanol; all spent solvent mixtures/blends containing, before use, only the above spent non-halogenated solvents; and all spent solvent mixtures/blends containing, before use, one or more of the above non-halogenated solvents, and, a total of ten percent or more (by volume) of one or more of those solvents listed in F001, F002, F004, and F005; and still bottoms from the recovery of these spent solvents and spent solvent mixtures. (I)*

Copyright 2003 Toxics Targeting, Inc. 44- 50 E 50th Street October 14, 2003

F005 The following spent non-halogenated solvents: Toluene, methyl ethyl ketone, carbon disulfide, isobutanol, pyridine, benzene, 2-ethoxyethanol, and 2-nitropropane; all spent solvent mixtures/blends containing, before use, a total of ten percent or more (by volume) of one or more of the above non-halogenated solvents or those solvents listed in F001, F002, or F004; and still bottoms from the recovery of these spent solvents and spent solvent mixtures. (I,T)

F006 Wastewater treatment sludges from electroplating operations except from the following processes: (1) Sulfuric acid anodizing of aluminum; (2) tin plating on carbon steel; (3) zinc plating (segregated basis) on carbon steel; (4) aluminum or zinc- aluminum plating on carbon steel; (5) cleaning/stripping associated with tin, zinc and aluminum plating on carbon steel; and (6) chemical etching and milling of aluminum. (T)

F008 Plating bath residues from the bottom of plating baths from electroplating operations where cyanides are used in the process. (R, T)

N003

U057 Cyclohexanone (I)

U077 Ethane, 1,2-dichloro-

U133 Hydrazine (R,T)

X910

Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency ation Site addresses are 4) sometimes corrected to eliminate obvious errors that prevent sites from being mapped. All address corrections are noted here. NO CHANGE NO CHANGE along with a description of the mapping ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised Street: Revised zip code:

Toxic Site Profile, . Incomplete addresses or map coordinates require some site locations to be 3) determined by commercial street maps (manual mapping), site visits, map coordinates from other databases and address location services. Application of any of these methods is identified accordingly. Some toxic sites are located using map coordinates provided by site 2) owners/operators or governnent agencies. These site locations are identified "map coordinate." Map coordinates for Toxics Wastewater Discharges, Toxic Release Inventory sites and Major Oil Storage Facilities should be considered suspect Most toxic sites are mapped by 1) matching addresses provided by site owners/operators or government agencies with locations on a computerized version of the U. S. Census map. These site locations are identified "address-matched." How Toxic Site Locations Are Mapped Site Address: 55 Main Street Anytown, NY 11797 maps toxic site locations on a computerized version of the U. S. Census map using addresses and coordinates

a map Address Matching or Manual Mapping or Site Visit or Map Coordinate technique used and any address corrections that were made in order to locate toxic sites with incomplete or inadequate site loc provided by site owners/operators or government agencies. In order to allow locations be verified independently, the information used to map each site is presented in the first section of Toxics Targeting information. The mapping process is explained below. Note: Some sites have an address match location and coordinate location. Both locations are mapped because they can be equally correct. Site location mapped by: Map Identification Number: 12 Site Name: Acme World Manufacturing, Inc. MAP LOCATION INFORMATION Information Source Guide

Toxics Targeting's Computerized Environmental Reports contain government and other information compiled on 18 categories of reported known or potential toxic sites. Each toxic site database is described below with information detailing a) the source of the information, b) the date when each database is covered to and c) when Toxics Targeting obtained the information..

1) Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Site Registry: New York State database that maintains information and aids decision making regarding the investigation and cleanup of toxic sites. The Registry's data includes two-page profiles noting site name, ID number, description, classification, cleanup status, types of cleanup, owner information, types and quantities of contaminants, and assessment of health and environmental problems. ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.2 Profile data updated through: 5/24/2000. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 10/5/2000. New Facilities updated to: 6/30/2001. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 9/17/2001.

2) CERCLIS: Toxic sites listed in the Federal Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Information System. NPL sites are also included in CERCLIS. ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency.1 Profile data updated through: 04/10/2003. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 05/16/2003. New Facilities updated through: 04/10/2003. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 05/16/2003.

3) National Priority List for Federal Superfund Cleanup: Toxic sites nominated for cleanup under the Federal Superfund program. Annual compilation of special two-page detailed profiles of NPL sites. ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency.1 Profile data updated from: 05/01/2002. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 09/25/2002. New Facilities updated through: 09/16/2002. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 09/26/2002.

4) Hazardous Substance Waste Disposal Site Study: NYS database of waste disposal sites that may pose threats to public health or the environment, but cannot be remediated using monies from the Hazardous Waste Remedial Fund. Source: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.2 Data updated to: 5/16/2000. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 5/16/2000.

5) Solid Waste Facilities: NYS database of solid waste facilities, including, but not limited to, landfills, incinerators, transfer stations, recycling centers. ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.2 Data updated to: 1/01/1998. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 6/30/1998.

Also includes a listing of solid waste disposal sites operated by New York City municipal authorities circa 1934. Source: City of New York Department of Sanitation (1984). Waste Disposal Problem in New York City: A Proposal For Action.

6) Major Oil Storage Facilities: NYS database of facilities licensed pursuant The to Article 12 of the Navigation Law, 6NYCRR Parts 610 and 17NYCRR Part 30, such as onshore facilities or vessels, with petroleum storage capacities equal to or greater than four hundred thousand gallons. Data withheld by the NYSDEC as of 4/1/2002. Fannie Mae required.** Source: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.2 Data update schedule: rolling basis. New facilities updated through: 1/1/2002. New facilities data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 1/11/2002. Tank data updated through: 1/1/2002. Tank data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 1/11/2002.

7) RCRA Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage or Disposal Facility Databases: (a) Manifest Information: New York State database of hazardous waste facilities and shipments regulated by the DEC's Bureau of Hazardous Waste Facility Compliance pursuant to New York State Law and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.2 New facilities updated through: 9/28/2000. New facilities obtained by Toxics Targeting: 10/5/2000. Manifest transactions data updated to: 2/12/2003. Manifest transactions data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 2/18/2003.

(b) RCRA Notifier, Violations, and Corrective Action Activity (CORRACTS) Information: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency database of hazardous facilities regulated pursuant to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency1 New facilities updated through: 2/20/2001 (3/11/2002 for CORRACTS). Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 2/20/2001. Data attributes updated through: 5/9/2003. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 6/10/2003.

8) Spills Information Database: Spills reported to the DEC as required by one or more of the following: Article 12 of the Navigation Law, 6 NYCRR Section 613.8 (from Petroleum Bulk Storage Regulations) or 6 NYCRR Section 595.2 (from Chemical Bulk Storage Regulations). The database includes active and closed spills reported before 05/30/2003. Data updated on a rolling basis. ASTM required.* Fannie Mae.** Source: NYS Department of Environmental Conservation.2

New spills through: 05/29/2003. Most spill attribute data updated through 01/01/2002. Limited spill attribute data updated to between 01/01/2002 and 05/29/2003. (See individual spill profiles.)

Active spills: paperwork not completed. Closed spills: paperwork completed. Both active and closed spills may or may not have been cleaned up (see Date Cleanup Ceased in spill profiles).

9) Petroleum Bulk Storage Facilities: Local and State databases of aboveground and underground petroleum storage facilities with a combined storage capacity over 1,100 gallons. ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.**

All New York Counties except Cortland, Nassau, Rockland, and Suffolk: Source: NYS Department of Environmental Conservation.2 Update schedule: rolling basis; Data has been withheld by the NYSDEC since 4/1/2002. Facility data updated through: 1/1/2002 (10/1/98 for Westchester Co.). Facility data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 1/11/2002. Tank data updated through: 1/1/2002 (10/1/98 for Westchester Co.). Tank data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 1/11/2002.

Nassau County: Heat producing products and other products with less than 1,000 gallons storage capacity: Source: Nassau County Department of Health.3 Data update schedule: rolling basis Data updated through: 10/4/2000. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 11/5/2000.

Generally non-heat producing products with more than 1,000 gallons storage capacity: Source: Nassau County Fire Marshall. 4 Data update schedule: rolling basis with annual update Data updated through: 9/27/1996 for mapped sites; 03/21/2000 for on-site checks.

Rockland County: Source: Rockland County Department of Health. 5 Data updated through: 8/11/1998. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 8/17/1998.

Suffolk County: Source: Suffolk County Department of Health Services. 6 Data updated through: 1/12/1999. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 2/26/1999.

10. RCRA Hazardous Waste Generators and/or Transporters Databases: (a) Manifest Information: New York State database of hazardous waste facilities and shipments regulated by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation's Bureau of Hazardous Waste Facility Compliance pursuant to New York State Law. ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.2 New facilities updated through: 9/28/2000. New facilities obtained by Toxics Targeting: 10/5/2000. Manifest transactions data updated to: 2/12/2003. Manifest transactions data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 2/18/2003.

(b) RCRA Notifier, Violations, and Corrective Action Activity (CORRACTS) Information: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency database of hazardous facilities regulated pursuant to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency1 New facilities updated through: 2/20/2001 (3/11/2002 for CORRACTS). Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 2/20/2001. Data attributes updated through: 5/9/2003. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 6/10/2003.

11) Chemical Bulk Storage Facilities: New York State database of facilities compiled pursuant to 6NYCRR Part 596 that store regulated substances listed in 6NYCRR Part 597 in aboveground tanks with capacities greater than 185 gallons and /or in underground tanks of any size. Data withheld by NYSDEC as of 4/1/2002. ASTM required.* Fannie Mae required.** Source: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.2 Data updated through: 1/1/2002. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 1/11/2002.

12) Toxic Release Inventory: New York State and Federal database of manufacturing facilities required under Section 313 of the Federal Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act to report releases to the air, water and land of any specifically listed toxic chemical. See Fannie Mae requirement** below. Source: NYS Department of Environmental Conservation2/U. S. Environmental Protection Agency.1 Data update schedule: rolling basis, with annual information summary for previous year's activities available from NYSDEC each July 1, with corrections and additional information available approximately mid-August. Data updated through: 5/9/1996. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 5/14/1996

13) Historic New York City Utility Facilities (1898 to 1950): An inventory of selected power generating stations, manufactured gas plants, gas storage facilities, maintenance yards and other gas and electric utility sites identified in various historic documents, maps and annual reports of New York utility companies, including: Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps of NYC (1898-1950); Consolidated Edison Co. Annual Reports (1922-1939); Consolidated Edison Co. Map: "Boroughs of Manhattan and the Bronx Showing Distribution Mains of the New York Edison Co.," (1922); and Consolidated Edison document: "Generating and Annex Stations," (1911).

14) Air Discharge Facilities: EPA AIRS database containing address information on each air emission facility and the type of air pollutant emission it is. Compliance information is also provided on each pollutant as well as the facility itself. See Fannie Mae requirement** below. Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency1 Data updated through: 11/24/1999. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 1/06/2000

15) Toxic Wastewater Discharges (Permit Compliance System): Federal database of discharges of wastewater to surface waters and groundwaters. See Fannie Mae requirement** below. Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency.1 Data updated through: 9/23/1996. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 9/30/1996

16) U. S. Environmental Protection Agency Civil Enforcement Docket: This database is the U. S. EPA's system for tracking civil judiciary cases filed on behalf of the agency by the Department of Justice. Fannie Mae required.** Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency.1 Date updated through: 4/1996. Date information obtained by Toxics Targeting: 8/1996

17) New York City Fire Department Tank Data: On-Site searches only. Source: New York City Fire Department. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 2/13/1997

18) Emergency Response Notification System (ERNS): Federal database of spills compiled by the Emergency Response Notification System. On-site searches only. ASTM required.* See Fannie Mae requirement** below. Source: U. S. Environmental Protection Agency.1 Data updated through: 1/31/2000. Data obtained by Toxics Targeting: 2/15/2000

*American Society of Testing Materials Standards on Environmental Site Assessments for Commercial Real Estate (E 1527-93, E 1528-93). ** Fannie Mae's Part X Environmental Hazards Management Procedures specify 1.0 mile searches for "any state or Federal list of hazardous waste sites (e.g. CERCLIS, HWDMS etc.)." Searches for the property and adjacent properties are specified for "chemical manufacturing plants," "obvious high risk neighbors engaging in storing or transporting hazardous waste, chemicals or substances" and "...any documented or visible evidence of dangerous waste handling... (e.g. stressed vegetation, stained soil, open or leaking containers, foul fumes or smells, oily ponds, etc." Searches for property and adjacent properties can include sites up to a quarter mile away (W. Hayward, Director, Multi-Family Business Planning and Control, Fannie Mae, personal communication, 5/94). 1U. S. Environmental Protection Agency, 290 Broadway, NY, NY 10007-1866. 2NYS Department of Environmental Conservation, 50 Wolf Road, Albany, NY 12233. 3Nassau County Department of Health, Bureau of Land Resources Management, 240 Old Country Road, Mineola, NY 11501. 4Nassau County Fire Commission, Office of the Fire Marshall, 899 Jerusalem Avenue, P. O. Box 128, Uniondale, NY 11553. 5Rockland County Department of Health, The Dr. Robert Yeager Health Center, Building D, Sanitorium Road, Pomona, NY 10970. 6Suffolk County Department of Health Services, Hazardous Materials Management, 15 Horseblock Place, Farmingville, NY 11738-1220.