DOCSLIB.ORG

An Analysis of Nietzsche's Conception Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
An Analysis of Nietzsche's Conception Of Open Research Online The Open University’s repository of research publications and other research outputs An Analysis of Nietzsche’s Conception of Decadence Thesis How to cite: Hurrell, David (2019). An Analysis of Nietzsche’s Conception of Decadence. PhD thesis The Open University. For guidance on citations see FAQs. c 2019 The Author https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Version: Version of Record Link(s) to article on publisher’s website: http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21954/ou.ro.00010463 Copyright and Moral Rights for the articles on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. For more information on Open Research Online’s data policy on reuse of materials please consult the policies page. oro.open.ac.uk AN ANALYSIS OF NIETZSCHE’S CONCEPTION OF DECADENCE David Hurrell AN ANALYSIS OF NIETZSCHE’S CONCEPTION OF DECADENCE A thesis submitted for the qualification of PhD in Philosophy, April 2019, The Open University. David Hurrell Abstract Nietzsche’s readership often assumes that what is meant by the term ‘decadence’ is simply a condition of moral and cultural decline. This study argues that Nietzsche’s conception amounts to a more complex hypothesis. While Nietzsche gives no formal analysis of decadence, Chapter 1 provides an initial discussion of the ‘formulae’ and ‘recipes’ for decadence that Nietzsche mentions. It emerges that decadence denotes a disunity within a self and a culture, and the dynamic relationship between the two. Moreover, Nietzsche describes decadence as a physiological condition with psychological consequences that inclines those who suffer from it to be against life. An investigation of the method Nietzsche uses to unmask decadence’s workings in Chapter 2 reveals that he arrives at his ‘decadence hypothesis’ by reasoning backwards from the assumption that cultural values stem from individuals’ physiological and psychological weaknesses. Central to his hypothesis is that adoption and proliferation of decadent values inhibit and further weaken decadent lives. An initial critical assessment shows that Nietzsche’s hypothesis is possibly self- referential, incomplete, and cannot be seen as established as the best explanation. Chapter 3 elucidates in more detail the underlying causes of decadence as a process of physiological corruption of humanity by the forces of civilization that suppress an individual’s powers. Decadence emerges as possibly self-reinforcing, self-replicating, and self-propagating. Since Nietzsche and commentators frequently use the term ‘decadence’ to describe also the subsequent psychological expressions of decadence, Chapter 4 presents an analysis of the effects, and then discusses a number of exemplar decadents (Chapters 5-8) to demonstrate a discernible set of common attributes: psychological, epistemological, and metaphysical expressions of weakness underpin decadence’s most important attribute, i.e., restricted agency and failure to realize an authentic self. Chapters 9 and 10 offer further support for a physiological reading of decadence and provide a summary of my findings. Acknowledgements I should like to thank most warmly my primary supervisor, Dr Manuel Dries, for his incisive, challenging feedback and generous, encouraging support. This research was supported by a full Studentship awarded by the Consortium for the Humanities and the Arts South-East England (CHASE), and funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council (AHRC). Table of Contents Abbreviations ix Introduction 1 PART I: UNRAVELLING DECADENCE 7 Chapter 1: An Outline of Decadence 8 1.1 Introduction 8 1.2 Disunity as the Hallmark of Decadence 8 1.3 Decadence and the Individual: Nietzsche’s Three Formulae, Two Recipes and One Analogy for Decadence 12 1.3.1 The First Formula: Anti-Instincts 14 1.3.2 The Second Formula: Harmful Instincts 17 1.3.3 The Third Formula: Anti-Reality 19 1.3.4 The First Recipe: The Christian 23 1.3.5 The Second Recipe: The Kantian 24 1.3.6 An Analogy for Decadence: Christianity and Alcohol 25 1.4 Decadence and Culture and Their Relationship to the Individual 28 1.4.1 The Individual-Cultural Dynamic: The Example of Socrates 31 1.4.2 The Individual-Cultural Dynamic: Examples from the Secondary Literature 34 1.5 Conclusion 37 Chapter 2: Nietzsche’s Modus Operandi in His Exposition of the Nature of Decadence 38 2.1 Introduction 38 2.2 Nietzsche’s Conception of Physiology 41 2.3 Nietzsche’s Conception of Causality 46 2.4 Nietzsche’s Negative Portrayal of Abductive Reasoning 51 2.4.1 The Role of Causality and Physiology 51 2.4.2 Metonymy as Mistaken Explanation 53 2.4.3 The Correlation between Metonymy, Physiology and Decadence 59 2.5 Nietzsche’s Positive Portrayal of Abductive Reasoning 64 2.5.1 A Backward Inference as a Method of Explanation 64 2.5.2 Genealogy as Explanation 68 2.5.3 Symptomatology as Explanation 70 v 2.6 Conclusion: A Critical Appraisal of Nietzsche’s Method 76 PART II: CAUSES AND EFFECTS 83 Chapter 3: The Causes of Decadence 84 3.1 Introduction 84 3.2 The Immediate Cause of Decadence: A Physiological Disorder of the Self Due to a Lack of Will to Power 85 3.2.1 Will To Power as Demarcation 87 3.2.2 Will To Power as Explanation 93 3.2.3 Weakness of the Will and Exhaustion 96 3.3 The Underlying and Intermediate Causes of Decadence: Civilization and Bad Conscience 98 3.3.1 The Role of Civilization 99 3.3.2 The Inception of a Bad Conscience 103 3.3.3 The Correlations between Bad Conscience and Decadence 108 3.4 Conclusion 117 Chapter 4: The Effects of Decadence 120 4.1 Introduction 120 4.2 The Psychological: Weakness and Suffering 123 4.2.1 Decadence in the Pejorative Sense 123 4.2.2 The Psychology of Sickliness and Morbidity 124 4.2.3 The Psychology of Error and Ressentiment 128 4.3 The Epistemological: Weakness and Scepticism 132 4.3.1 Scepticism as an Effect of Decadence 132 4.3.2 The Moral Origins of Scepticism and the Association with Nihilism 133 4.3.3 ‘Weak’ versus ‘Strong’ Scepticism 135 4.3.4 A ‘Weak’ Scepticism Based on Doubt and Passivity 137 4.3.5 A ‘Weak’ Scepticism Based on Fear and Illusory Hope 139 4.4 The Metaphysical: Weakness and Idealism 143 4.4.1 Decadence and Humanity’s ‘Metaphysical Need’ 143 4.4.2 The Rejection of Reality and the Embracing of Ideals 147 4.5 Restricted Agency: Weakness Not Freedom 150 4.5.1 Freedom as Autonomous Agency 150 4.5.2 Willing and Freedom 152 4.5.3 Unfree Due to ‘Not Willing’: Merely Reactive Behaviour 153 vi 4.5.4 Unfree Due to an ‘Imposed Willing’: The Morality of Selflessness 155 4.5.5 The Advantages and Disadvantages of ‘Imposed Willing’ Over ‘Not Willing’ 159 4.6 Conclusion 162 PART III: EXEMPLARS OF DECADENCE 166 Chapter 5: Exemplar Decadents – An Overview 167 5.1 Introduction 167 5.2 Wagner – The Archetypal Decadent 170 5.3 Goethe – The Archetypal Non-Decadent 174 Chapter 6: Pascal – The Decadent Christian 178 6.1 Introduction 178 6.2 The Psychological: A Weakness Inspired by Christianity 180 6.3 The Epistemological: Pascal’s ‘Weak’ Scepticism 183 6.4 The Metaphysical: Pascal’s Rejection of Reality and Embracing of Idealism 185 6.5 A Restricted Agency: Pascal’s Extreme Asceticism 187 6.6 Conclusion 189 Chapter 7: Pyrrho and Epicurus – The Decadent Philosophers 192 7.1 Introduction 192 7.2 Pyrrho – Sceptic and Buddhist 193 7.2.1 The Psychological: Pyrrho’s Sagacious Weariness 194 7.2.2 The Epistemological: Pyrrho’s ‘Weak’ and ‘Moralistic’ Scepticism 195 7.2.3 The Metaphysical: Pyrrho’s Rejection of Reality and Embracing of Idealism 198 7.2.4 A Restricted Agency: Pyrrho’s Fanaticism 199 7.2.5 A Brief Evaluation of Nietzsche’s Portrayal of Pyrrho 202 7.3 Epicurus – Ethical Hedonist and Proto-Christian 205 7.3.1 A Brief Evaluation of Nietzsche’s Portrayal of Epicurus 211 7.4 Conclusion 213 Chapter 8: Spencer – The Decadent Scientist 215 8.1 Introduction 215 8.2 The Psychological: Spencer’s Need of Moral Certitude 216 8.3 The Epistemological: Spencer’s Claims of Objectivity 219 8.4 The Metaphysical: Spencer’s Rejection of Reality and the Embracing of Ideals 221 8.4.1 The Decadent Ideals of Morality and Altruism 223 8.4.2 The Decadent Ideals of Society 231 vii 8.5 A Restricted Agency: The ‘Imposed Will’ of Spencer’s Science 236 8.6 Conclusion 238 PART IV: A PHYSIOLOGICAL CONCEPTION OF DECADENCE 240 Chapter 9: The Functioning of Decadence and its Potential Remedies 241 9.1 Introduction 241 9.2 Decadence as an Expansive Physiological Process 241 9.3 Combatting and Remedying Decadence 245 Chapter 10: Conclusion 252 Bibliography 258 viii Abbreviations The following abbreviations are used for citations of Nietzsche's writings, and are then associated with an applicable translated edition, or in the case of KGB and KSA, with the original German edition, as cited in the Bibliography at the end of this work. These abbreviations generally conform to the de facto standard used by The Journal of Nietzsche Studies, but with a few required additions. A: The Anti-Christ, Nietzsche (2005). AOM: Assorted Opinions and Maxims, Nietzsche (1996a). BGE: Beyond Good and Evil, Nietzsche (2002). BT: The Birth of Tragedy, Nietzsche (1999a). CW: The Case of Wagner, Nietzsche (2005). D: Daybreak, Nietzsche (1997b). DS: David Strauss, the Confessor and the Writer, Nietzsche (1997a). EH: Ecce Homo (sections abbreviated: ‘Wise’, ‘Clever’, ‘Books’, ‘Destiny’; abbreviations for titles discussed in ‘Books’ are indicated instead of ‘Books’ where relevant), Nietzsche (2005). GM: On the Genealogy of Morality, Nietzsche (2007).
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Prospero's Monsters: Authenticity, Identity, and Hybridity in the Post-Colonial Age
    Bowling Green State University ScholarWorks@BGSU 18th Annual Africana Studies Student Research Africana Studies Student Research Conference Conference and Luncheon Feb 12th, 10:30 AM - 11:50 AM Prospero's Monsters: Authenticity, Identity, and Hybridity in the Post-Colonial Age Dominique Pen Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/africana_studies_conf Part of the African Languages and Societies Commons Pen, Dominique, "Prospero's Monsters: Authenticity, Identity, and Hybridity in the Post-Colonial Age" (2016). Africana Studies Student Research Conference. 3. https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/africana_studies_conf/2016/002/3 This Event is brought to you for free and open access by the Conferences and Events at ScholarWorks@BGSU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Africana Studies Student Research Conference by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@BGSU. Pen1 Prospero’s Monsters: Authenticity, Identity, and Hybridity in the Post-Colonial Age Dominique Pen M.A. Candidate, Art History, School of Art 18th Annual Africana Studies Student Research Conference Pen2 In 2005, Yinka Shonibare was offered the prestigious distinction of becoming recognized as a Member of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire (MBE). As an artist whose work is characterized by his direct engagement with and critiques of power, the establishment, colonialism and imperialism, in many cases specifically relating to Britain’s past and present, some questioned whether he was going to refuse the honor. This inquiry was perhaps encouraged
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Introduction the Empire at the End of Decadence the Social, Scientific
    1 Introduction The Empire at the End of Decadence The social, scientific and industrial revolutions of the later nineteenth century brought with them a ferment of new artistic visions. An emphasis on scientific determinism and the depiction of reality led to the aesthetic movement known as Naturalism, which allowed the human condition to be presented in detached, objective terms, often with a minimum of moral judgment. This in turn was counterbalanced by more metaphorical modes of expression such as Symbolism, Decadence, and Aestheticism, which flourished in both literature and the visual arts, and tended to exalt subjective individual experience at the expense of straightforward depictions of nature and reality. Dismay at the fast pace of social and technological innovation led many adherents of these less realistic movements to reject faith in the new beginnings proclaimed by the voices of progress, and instead focus in an almost perverse way on the imagery of degeneration, artificiality, and ruin. By the 1890s, the provocative, anti-traditionalist attitudes of those writers and artists who had come to be called Decadents, combined with their often bizarre personal habits, had inspired the name for an age that was fascinated by the contemplation of both sumptuousness and demise: the fin de siècle. These artistic and social visions of degeneration and death derived from a variety of inspirations. The pessimistic philosophy of Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860), who had envisioned human existence as a miserable round of unsatisfied needs and desires that might only be alleviated by the contemplation of works of art or the annihilation of the self, contributed much to fin-de-siècle consciousness.1 Another significant influence may be found in the numerous writers and artists whose works served to link the themes and imagery of Romanticism 2 with those of Symbolism and the fin-de-siècle evocations of Decadence, such as William Blake, Edgar Allen Poe, Eugène Delacroix, the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, Charles Baudelaire, and Gustave Flaubert.
    [Show full text]
  • De Sade's Theatrical Passions
    06.puchner 4/19/05 2:28 PM Page 111 Martin Puchner Sade’s Theatrical Passions The Theater of the Revolution The Marquis de Sade entered theater history in 1964 when the Royal Shakespeare Company, under the direction of Peter Brook, presented a play by the unknown author Peter Weiss entitled, The Persecution and Assassination of Jean-Paul Marat as Performed by the Inmates of the Asylum of Charenton Under the Direction of the Marquis de Sade.1 Marat/Sade, as the play is usually called, became an extraordinary success story.2 By com- bining narrators with techniques developed in a multi-year workshop entitled “Theater of Cruelty,” Marat/Sade managed to link the two modernist visionaries of the theater whom everybody had considered to be irreconcilable opposites: Bertolt Brecht and Antonin Artaud. Marat/Sade not only fabricated a new revolutionary theater from the vestiges of modernism, it also coincided with a philosophical and cul- tural revision of the French revolution that had begun with Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer’s The Dialectics of Enlightenment (1944/69) and found a preliminary culmination in Michel Foucault’s History of Madness (1972). At the same time, the revival of Sade was fu- eled by the first complete publication of his work in French (1967) and by Roland Barthes’ landmark study, Sade Fourier Loyola (1971).3 Marat/Sade had thus hit a theatrical and intellectual nerve. Sade, however, belongs to theater history as more than just a char- acter in a play.Little is known about the historical Sade’s life-long pas- sion for the theater, about his work as a theater builder and manager, an actor and director.
    [Show full text]
  • Utopian Aspirations in Fascist Ideology: English and French Literary Perspectives 1914-1945
    Utopian Aspirations in Fascist Ideology: English and French Literary Perspectives 1914-1945 Ashley James Thomas Discipline of History School of History & Politics University of Adelaide Thesis presented as the requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences University of Adelaide March 2010 CONTENTS Abstract iii Declaration iv Acknowledgments v Chapter One: Introduction 1 Chapter Two: Interpreting Fascism: An Evolving 26 Historiography Chapter Three: The Fascist Critique of the Modern 86 World Chapter Four: Race, Reds and Revolution: Specific 156 Issues in the Fascist Utopia Chapter Five: Conclusion 202 Bibliography 207 ABSTRACT This thesis argues that utopian aspirations are a fruitful way to understand fascism and examines the utopian ideals held by a number of fascist writers. The intention of this thesis is not to define fascism. Rather, it is to suggest that looking at fascism’s goals and aspirations might reveal under-examined elements of fascism. This thesis shows that a useful way to analyse the ideology of fascism is through an examination of its ideals and goals, and by considering the nature of a hypothetical fascist utopia. The most common ways of examining fascism and attempting to isolate its core ideological features have been by considering it culturally, looking at the metaphysical and philosophical claims fascists made about themselves, or by studying fascist regimes, looking at the external features of fascist movements, parties and governments. In existing studies there is an unspoken middle ground, where fascism could be examined by considering practical issues in the abstract and by postulating what a fascist utopia would be like.
    [Show full text]
  • THE FRENCH PHILOSOPHES and THEIR ENLIGHTENING MEDIEVAL PAST by John Frederick Logan
    THE FRENCH PHILOSOPHES AND THEIR ENLIGHTENING MEDIEVAL PAST by John Frederick Logan The Enlightenment's scorn for the Middle Ages is well known. "Centuries of ignorance," "barbarous times," "miserable age"-such descriptions of medie- val life and culture seem to justify the assumption that a contempt for the Middle Ages was a uniform and central characteristic of the French Enlight- enment. B. A. Brou, for example, sees the medieval period as an epitome of everything despised by the philosophes: the men of the Enlightenment, he asserted, "rejected authority, tradition, and the past. Thus there was disdain for the Middle Ages."' Summarizing the philosophes' view of the medieval period, the French critic Edmond EstBve similarly declared that Bayle . .scarcely knew the M~ddleAges and did not like them. HISdisciples and successors knew this period no better and detested ~t even more. The historians spoke of it because, nonetheless, one could not cross out five or six centuries of our past-whatever distaste one might have. But they affected reluctance in all sorts of ways before approaching the subjecL2 Such interpretations of the attitude towards medieval history prevalent among the philosophes are quite understandable: the colorful, often-quot- ed comments of Voltaire on the decadence and ignorance of the past come immediately to mind. Furthermore, the task of the modern interpreter of Enlightenment historiography becomes much lighter if he can neatly and quickly dispense with the philosophes' view of the Middle Ages; a uniformly negative attitude toward the medieval period provides a most useful contrast to the sympathetic approach of many nineteenth century historians.
    [Show full text]
  • Download File
    A Monster for Our Times: Reading Sade across the Centuries Matthew Bridge Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY 2011 © 2011 Matthew Bridge All Rights Reserved ABSTRACT A Monster for Our Times: Reading Sade across the Centuries Matthew Bridge This doctoral dissertation looks at several readings and interpretations of the works of the Marquis de Sade, from the eighteenth century to the present. Ever since he was imprisoned under the Old Regime following highly publicized instances of physical and sexual abuse, Sade has remained a controversial figure who has been both condemned as a dangerous criminal and celebrated as an icon for artistic freedom. The most enduring aspect of his legacy has been a vast collection of obscene publications, characterized by detailed descriptions of sexual torture and murder, along with philosophical diatribes that offer theoretical justifications for the atrocities. Not surprisingly, Sade’s works have been subject to censorship almost from the beginning, leading to the author’s imprisonment under Napoleon and to the eventual trials of his mid-twentieth-century publishers in France and Japan. The following pages examine the reception of Sade’s works in relation to the legal concept of obscenity, which provides a consistent framework for textual interpretation from the 1790s to the present. I begin with a prelude discussing the 1956 trial of Jean-Jacques Pauvert, in order to situate the remainder of the dissertation within the context of how readers approached a body of work as quintessentially obscene as that of Sade.
    [Show full text]
  • “The Queen of Decadence”: Rachilde and Sado
    ‘“The Queen of Decadence”: Rachilde and Sado-Masochistic Feminism’ Author[s]: Rebekkah Dilts Source: Moveable Type, Vol.11, ‘Decadence’ (2019) DOI: 10.14324/111.1755-4527.095 Moveable Type is a Graduate, Peer-Reviewed Journal based in the Department of English at UCL. © 2019 Rebekkah Dilts. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC-BY) 4.0https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. 10 Moveable Type 11 (2019) In 1884, the novel Monsieur Vénus took the French literary world by storm, and inaugurated its controversial female author, Rachilde, the ‘queen of decadence.’ Many critics did not believe that a young, aristocratic woman could possibly have devised such a salacious story. A literary press which specialized in erotica first published the book, but it was banned regardless, and Rachilde was even condemned to prison for pornographic writing. Subsequent editions therefore required fake male co-authors and introductions by famous male writers that consigned the novel not literature at all, but the case study of a hysterical woman. Rachilde also publicly denounced the feminism of her moment, a proclamation that affected the twentieth- century reception of her writing. Yet, following new French and English editions published in 2004, Monsieur Vénus has been hailed a queer forerunner in contemporary academic circles, even while questions about Rachilde’s feminist affiliations persist. This paper goes beyond the biographical details that have dominated conversation about Rachilde’s writing to closely interrogate the use of sexual violence in Monsieur Vénus, and in her much lesser-known novel, La Marquise de Sade (1887).
    [Show full text]
  • The Sodomitic Reputation of Weimar Berlin Gregory Woods
    9 The Sodomitic Reputation of Weimar Berlin Gregory Woods Resumo A Berlim da Republica de Weimar tornou-se a cidade europeia, por exceli!ncia, dos sonhos eroticos e dos pesadelos morais. Berlim tornou­ Sf 0 simbolo tanto das coisas maravilhosas que poderiam ser alcanr;adas se se lutasse por eias, quanta das coisas terriveis que poderiam aeonteeer se nao se lutasse contra elas. A proliferar;ao e a visibilidade da vida homossexual berlinense era tanto uma promessa quanto uma amear;a. 0 legado de Weimar nao foi tanto 0 moralismo vingativo do Nazismo, quanto 0 fervor eficaz com 0 qual a BerUm queer conseguiu se reestabelecer e prosperar depois da guerra, apesar de estar no iwsW epicentro da Guerra Fria. Palavras-chave: Berlim. Homossexualismo. Nazismo. Gragoata Niter6i, n. 14, p. 9- 27,1. sem. 2003 10 Visiting Berlin in 1919 in the aftermath of Germany's defeat in the Great War, Kurt von Stutterheim fOlmd that "all kinds of dubious resorts had sprung up like mushrooms". Censorship had been relaxed, with the result that "Notorious magazines, which no chief of police of former times would have permitted, were sold openly on the Potzdamer Platz". Having already deplored the open display of these lmnamed publications on the streets, Shltterheim could not resist going into the "dubious resorts" to see if they were any less shocking: "An acquaintance took me into a dance-hall where painted men were dancing dressed in women's clothes. I was refused admission to another resort because it was only open to women, half of whom were dressed as men" (STUTIERHEIM, 1939, p.
    [Show full text]
  • The Age of Decadence - the New York Times
    17/8/2020 Opinion | The Age of Decadence - The New York Times https://nyti.ms/2UDjIWu Opinion The Age of Decadence Cut the drama. The real story of the West in the 21st century is one of stalemate and stagnation. By Ross Douthat An Opinion columnist and the author of the forthcoming book “The Decadent Society,” from which this essay is adapted. Feb. 7, 2020 Everyone knows that we live in a time of constant acceleration, of vertiginous change, of transformation or looming disaster everywhere you look. Partisans are girding for civil war, robots are coming for our jobs, and the news feels like a multicar pileup every time you fire up Twitter. Our pessimists see crises everywhere; our optimists insist that we’re just anxious because the world is changing faster than our primitive ape-brains can process. But what if the feeling of acceleration is an illusion, conjured by our expectations of perpetual progress and exaggerated by the distorting filter of the internet? What if we — or at least we in the developed world, in America and Europe and the Pacific Rim — really inhabit an era in which repetition is more the norm than invention; in which stalemate rather than revolution stamps our politics; in which sclerosis afflicts public institutions and private life alike; in which new developments in science, new exploratory projects, consistently underdeliver? What if the meltdown at the Iowa caucuses, an antique system undone by pseudo-innovation and incompetence, was much more emblematic of our age than any great catastrophe or breakthrough? The truth of the first decades of the 21st century, a truth that helped give us the Trump presidency but will still be an important truth when he is gone, is that we probably aren’t entering a 1930-style crisis for Western liberalism or hurtling forward toward transhumanism or extinction.
    [Show full text]
  • Sociology and Psychology of Communism
    , I Sociology and Psychology of Communism J ULES MONNEROT TRANSLATED BY JANE DEGRAS AND R ICHARD REES / BOSTON: THE BEACON PRESS Contents PART ONE THE TWENTIETH-CENTURY ' ISLAM' 1. The Twentieth-century 'Islam' 9 2. Failing Oligarchy and Impotent Plebs 24 3. A Technological Messianism 39 4. Structure of the Army 46 5. Growth of Absolutism and Concentration of Power 60 6. Bolshevisation 85 7. The Third Army 100 8. The 'Men of the Threshold' 112 PART TWO SECULAR RELIGIONS AND THE IMPERIUM MUNDI 9. The Prestige of Totality 123 10. The Psychology of Secular Religions 133 11 . The Political Phenomenon of Tyranny 164 12. Twentieth-century Absolutism 182 13. The Totalitarian Dynamic 237 14. Projections of the Sacred 264 15. What is a Revolution? 293 Postscript to Chapter 15 334 INDEX 337 THE TWENTIETH-CENTURY 'ISLAM' 13 society and shaped by a different history. And this Campaign is an answer to the particular problems posed by that history. A new type of social differentiation has appeared, whose hierarchical aspect bas become clearly recognisable in the course of thirty years to the lay (I mean the non-communist) observer, and with it has appeared a new type of regime, harsh towards the 'free' proletariat and inhuman towards its slave labour.1 The proletariat can only be called free by comparison with the labour force of the concentration camps. The revival of slavery is one of the characteristic features of 20th-century totalitarianism: the defeated in political and factional warfare, side by side wlth delinquents of every kind, many of whom would not in countries farther west be liable to any penalty at all, are all alike re­ duced to slavery, and not by a foreign power but by their own State.
    [Show full text]
  • The 'Regime-Model' of Fascism: a Typology
    02_Articles 30/1 19/11/99 11:10 am Page 77 Aristotle A. Kallis The ‘Regime-Model’ of Fascism: A Typology Introduction In recent years there has been a revival of interest in the nature of generic fascism. This renewed search for a paradigmatic model of fascism originated as a reaction to the trend of overstating specificity, of studying fascist phenomena in the longue durée and of using their individual differences to underscore the futility of grand theories of fascism. A large part of the blame for the dis- crediting of comparative approaches is borne by the erratic and often mystifying sample of the studies themselves. Lack of clarity about the nature and content of fascism resulted in a number of comparative studies, whose insufficiently justified sample of case studies left the concept of ‘fascism’ in disarray. The ‘totalitarian’ approach focused on the political features of fascism as regime (i.e. Italy and Germany), but then subjected it to a broader definition which dovetailed with aspects of such a disparate socio-political phenomenon as communism.1 Nolte’s Three Faces of Fascism provided an insightful account of the ideological similarities between the Italian and German regimes, only to obfuscate his paradigm by including Action Française in his analysis.2 The ideological affinities notwithstanding, the weak- nesses of his generic definition are obvious. If ‘fascism’ is a broad ideological phenomenon, then why are other case-studies ex- cluded (Austria, Britain, etc.)? If, on the other hand, ‘fascism’ is both ideology and action, movement and regime, then why is Action Française comparable to the Italian and German regimes? Even the recent account by Roger Eatwell has focused on a curious combination of two major interwar regimes (Italy, Germany) and a plethora of disparate movements (most of which achieved limited, short-lived appeal and none of which ever European History Quarterly Copyright © 2000 SAGE Publications, London, Thousand Oaks, CA and New Delhi, Vol.
    [Show full text]
  • On Fascist Ideology
    On Fascist Ideology Federico Finchelstein Comprendere e saper valutare con esattezza il nemico, significa possedere gia` una con- dizione necessaria per la vittoria. Antonio Gramsci1 Fascism is a political ideology that encompassed totalitarianism, state terrorism, imperialism, racism and, in the German case, the most radical genocide of the last century: the Holocaust. Fascism, in its many forms did not hesitate to kill its own citizens as well as its colonial subjects in its search for ideological and political closure. Millions of civilians perished on a global scale during the apogee of fascist ideologies in Europe and beyond. In historical terms, fascism can be defined as a movement and a regime. Emilio Gentile – who, with Zeev Sternhell and George Mosse,2 is the most insightful historian of fascism – presents fascism as a modern revolutionary phenomenon that was nationalist and revolution- ary, anti-liberal and anti-Marxist. Gentile also presents fascism as being typically organized in a militaristic party that had a totalitarian conception of state politics, an activist and anti- theoretical ideology as well as a focus on virility and anti-hedonistic mythical foundations. For Gentile a defining feature of fascism was its character as a secular religion which affirms the primacy of the nation understood as an organic and ethnically homogenous community. Moreover, this nation was to be hierarchically organized in a corporativist state endowed with a war-mongering vocation that searches for a politics of national expansion, potency and conquest. Fascism, in short, was not a mere reactionary ideology. Rather, fascism aimed at creating a new order and a new civilization.3 The word fascism derives from the Italian word fascio and refers to a political group (such as the political group lead by Giuseppe Garibaldi during the time of Italian unification.) Fascism also refers visually and historically to a Roman imperial symbol of authority.
    [Show full text]