Viewed Faculty Dia Manager Under the Leadership of Former from Whom I Had the Pleasure of Learning Love
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HE OMMENTATOR T The Independent C Student Newspaper of Yeshiva University VOL. LXXXVI WEDNESDAY, MAY 5, 2021 ISSUE NO. 12 The YU Pride Alliance, three YU alumni and a student are suing YU for LGBTQ discrimination. Full story on page 6. THE YU PRIDE ALLIANCE YU Plans In-Person Return April 2021 News Briefs: Bagpipes, for Fall 2021 Elevator Malfunctions, Gottesman in university housing. The university will Pool and More By JARED SCHARF institute “appropriate health and safety modifications.” Details regarding safety returned to the Wilf Campus on Tuesday, measures were not specified in the email, This article was originally published online By SRULI FRUCHTER April 27. including whether masks will be mandated on April 28. AND YOSEF LEMEL The last time Dixon was seen on campus indoors. was in February 2020, prior to the closure According to the 2021-22 academic Full in-person instruction and op- YU Alum Recuses Himself From of the Wilf and Beren campuses due to the calendar, there will be remote instruction eration will return to Yeshiva University LGBTQ Discrimination Lawsuit COVID-19 pandemic. “I was very busy,” he for Fall 2021, announced President Ari for certain sets of days in both the fall and explained. Dixon told The Commentator spring semester, such as the five school Berman in an email to students on Apr. 28. Hon. Shlomo Hagler, a 1988 graduate of that during the pandemic he was perform- days between Rosh Hashanah and Simchat Additionally, the university will require all Yeshiva University, recused himself from ing in locations such as Crown Heights and Torah. returning students in graduate and under- presiding over the LGBTQ discrimination Flatbush. Before they return to campus, students graduate school to be fully vaccinated by lawsuit against the university on April The day before Dixon’s return, Baruch will require full COVID-19 vaccination. the opening of the fall semester. 29 to “avoid the appearance of impropri- Lerman (YC ‘23), the Yeshiva Student Berman stated that “medical and religious ety.” Hon. Lynn Kotler will serve as his Union vice-president elect of clubs, re- exceptions will be considered” for vaccina- replacement. posted a 2017 Commentator article on Before they return to campus, tions, but the email did not explain what A 1991 graduate of the City University Facebook about Jerry with a caption say- constitutes a medical or religious exemp- students will require full of New York’s School of Law, Hagler was ing “Come back Jerry!!! - We miss you!!” tion. The university will aid in the vaccina- elected to the Supreme Court Bench in 2013 After seeing Lerman’s Facebook post, Akiva COVID-19 vaccination. tion efforts of international students who and has served on the New York County Lipschitz (YC ‘22) reached out to Dixon and cannot be adequately vaccinated in their Supreme Court since then. He is also a asked him to return to campus, which he home countries. The email stated that the planned shift member of the Association of the Bar of did the next day. Many students, including On April 22, NYC officials announced to in-person instruction is due to the in- New York and the Jewish Lawyers Guild. Lerman, were able to listen to Jerry’s tunes creased efforts regarding the distribution that all NYC operating vaccination sites from around 12:00 p.m. to 2:00 p.m. on will begin offering walk-in appointments of the COVID-19 vaccine on a regional The Return of ‘Bagpipe Guy’ April 27. Dixon returned on the following and national level. In addition to classes, for all New Yorkers, including those who day, April 28, to continue performing for work or study there, ages 16 and older. the university plans to offer “more on- After a long hiatus, Jerry Dixon, com- onlookers. campus activities” and offer more space Continued on Page 6 monly known by students as “Bagpipe Guy,” Continued on Page 7 NEWS | 7 FEATURES | 13 OPINIONS | 21 BUSINESS | 27 SCW Jewish Studies Adjuncts Rehired The Twenty-Somethings Minyan Demystifying Academic Talmud Trendy Trading 2 From the Editors' Desk Wednesday , May 5, 2021 THE COMMENTATOR FROM THE EDITORS' DESK 2020-2021 In Retrospect: Institutional Memories Editor-in-Chief YOSEF LEMEL exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandem- would open up near campus and the By YOSEF LEMEL ic. First-year students never received disappointment we felt when Subaba a true COVID-free Yeshiva experience closed. Sometimes, I played football in Managing Editor and second-year students only received Tenzer Garden, an area that currently A KBY bochur upset a five-year streak ELISHEVA KOHN of “Commie” editors-in-chief from Gush a half-year’s worth. Of current students, cannot legitimately be termed a “garden.” — my greatest claim to fame. Other it is only the graduating class — my year In place of the artificial grass that was than that, perhaps I may be remem- — that has an inkling of what Yeshiva there in 2018, there is only concrete and bered as the editor who presided over was. Only we have a small sense of insti- pipes. Large scaffolding now encircles The Commentator during such “unprec- tutional memory that is lacking among Zysman Hall, the building which houses News edented times.” Or, more likely, I will not the underclassmen, much more so than MTA. This campus and university have Senior Editor Junior Editors be remembered at all. the average year — and I don’t mean to changed in many ways, both physically SRULI FRUCHTER SHLOMIT EBBIN Yeshiva University is a school plagued be overly pompous. and institutionally, for better and worse, JARED SCHARF by an extremely short sense of institu- since I first stepped through those gold- tional memory. If asked, the standard Yeshiva University is plated doors of that then-scaffold-free Features student probably knows little about the building in 2013. Senior Editor Junior Editors Klein@9 controversy, the Rabbi Klapper a school plagued by an Importantly, I constantly reminisce ELAZAR ABRAHAMS DANIEL MELOOL controversy, the Rabbi Shulman contro- on the Torah values that were imparted NETANI SHIELDS versy and any sort of contentious situ- extremely short sense of to me from my high school and college ation that predates the last two years. rebbeim, notably through the shiurim of Opinions Generally, students are only at Yeshiva institutional memory. Rabbi Jeremy Wieder for the past two- and-a-half years and the almost-daily Senior Editor Junior Editors for three undergraduate years — not four, AHARON NISSEL ARIEL KAHAN as is the usual case in academia — which lunch-table conversations I had with NAFTALI SHAVELSON has undoubtedly contributed to this lack I had the privilege of attending MTA, Rabbi Shalom Carmy last year. I can dwell of institutional memory (tangentially, I Yeshiva’s high school, and being on the for hours on positive memories from my would encourage all students to check Wilf Campus for seven years. I remem- time at Yeshiva, from the after-minyan ber when the 185th plaza was a normal hock at the Kehillas Shulchan Baruch to out The Commentator archives, uploaded Business online this year, to expand their sense of street with cars driving on it. I recall the expanding my base of knowledge and excitement in my 10th-grade chemistry Senior Editor Junior Editors institutional memory). Continued on Page 3 YAAKOV METZ MAX ASH This phenomenon has obviously been class when we heard a Dunkin’ Donuts ALIZA LEICHTER A Conclusion Senior Layout Editor the historical record of The Commentator leaders, Commentator team members MICAH PAVA By ELISHEVA KOHN and made sure that our articles, especially and so many others — who respectfully news reports, were thoroughly written so and consistently pressed the university Social Media Manager As we approach the conclusion of a future students and editors would be able to reverse their original decision regard- SHIRA LEVITT peculiar academic year, and by exten- to use our coverage as a primary source to ing graduation. When I first discovered sion, an unusual yet successful year at examine how the coronavirus pandemic that commencement would be held in- Website Manager shaped YU — for better or worse. person, I was ecstatic; not only because The Commentator, I find myself in awe RAPHAEL ALCABES of just how anticlimactic it all seems. it meant that I would be able to celebrate Covering the happenings at YU, graduat- When I first arrived in the the conclusion of the most wonderful and ing university and transitioning to real complex years of my life with my loved Business Manager adulting despite marking more than a United States to pursue ones, but also because it marked an un- MEIR LIGHTMAN year since the outbreak of the coronavirus paralleled success story for the collective pandemic — life has been full of drama my degree at YU in August student voice. I urge my successors, as this past year, and it appears that there is well as any reader involved on campus, to Layout Staff none left to celebrate this particular oc- 2018, the thought that I let their voices be heard. Ultimately, I do DEBORAH COOPERSMITH, casion: the end of Vol. 86. If I may, these would one day publish very much believe that the university has SHIRA LEVITT are my concluding thoughts. our best interests at heart, and it is our From the start, our team was acutely my final editorial in The duty (as well as theirs) to make sure that Staff Writers we are included in every major decision. aware that this year would be different, DEBORAH COOPERSMITH, Commentator would not This past year, our editors reported on and that the student body, as well as fac- ZAHAVA FERTIG, ZACHARY GREENBERG, ulty members and staff, relied on us to myriad events: some internal and some RIKKI KOLODONY, keep the YU community informed.