Billy Bishop City Airport Monthly Noise Comments NOTE: The Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (BBTCA) authorities do not have control of airborne aircraft in the BBTCA Control Zone or on maneuvering surfaces of BBTCA proper. Control of aircraft in the air is a Transport jurisdiction and is managed by the NAV CANADA Air Traffic Control Unit at BBTCA and Lester B. Pearson International Airport.

SUMMARY: Total Noise Related Comments 37 Number of Individuals 16

Noise Related 21 Presence Related 11 Noise and Presence Related 5 Non-Noise/presence Related 0

Armed Forces 1 Police Helicopters 0 General Aviation 9 Helicopters 0 Medevac Fixed Wing 6 Medevac Helicopters 2 Non-Aircraft Related 1 Non-Specific Event 5 Scheduled Air Service 6 Unidentified * 7

Algonquin Island 6 Bathurst/Queen’s Quay 19 Eastern Beaches 0 Harbour Square Area 1 Area 3 Other Areas of City 4 Wards Island 4

Total Aircraft Movements for the Month 10,240

* “Unidentified” represents aircraft which were not identified by the complainant or could not be established from the Aircraft Flight Tracking and Noise System (AFTNS).

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 1 of 22 2010-03-05 23:25:00 R-06 Harbour Square Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence airplane landing at TCCA from east, in front of Harbour Square Aircraft Category Medevac Helicopter S76 Sikorsky Helicopter MOH Response: AFTNS tracked Medevac Helicopter arrive on runway 26 at time noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-08 10:53:00 H-02 Algonquin Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence You d be lying if you said that the plane that just took off is within the allowable limits set out by the Tripartite Agreement. When is this airport going to abide by the rules that were put in place to protect Toronto s community and waterfront? Aircraft Category Medevac Fixed Wing FA10 Response: AFTNS tracked FA10 medevac aircraft depart on runway 26 at time noted. Permitted operation.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 2 of 22 2010-03-08 13:35:00 U-05 Other Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence The anti-airport "activists" are driving me nuts. They have a link stating "Click Here to Make a Noise Complaint"... I think it s about time to shut these idiots up. (I hope you see the humour in this message) Aircraft Category Non - Specific Response: Comment noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-08 23:07:00 W-06 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence A small jet plane took off after 11pm when I was watching CTV news. What is this? emergency? It is not the medevac helicopter. Aircraft Category Medevac Fixed Wing PC12 Pilatus Response: AFTNS tracked a Medevac Fixed Wing aircraft depart on runway 26 at time noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 3 of 22 2010-03-09 11:31:00 L-01 Ward's Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence At 11:31 this morning a Beechcraft SuperKing Air200 ; SPR810 flew very low over the houses on Ward s Island. It was at or below 500 feet. How can you get pilots to abide by the NSAs - one way to do this is to FINE offenders. After a few large fines the word would get out among the pilot community and they would stop flying over the community. Aircraft Category General Aviation BE10 Response: AFTNS tracked a BE10 aircraft, but unable to track flight path.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-10 16:10:00 E-04 Algonquin Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence small white craft, stubby body, twin engine, low wing, flying from west to east over the house Aircraft Category Unidentified Unidentified Response: AFTNS was unable to track aircraft at time noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 4 of 22 2010-03-11 04:54:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence loud engine noise befor 5am Aircraft Category Medevac Fixed Wing PC12 Pilatus Response: AFTNS tracked a Medevac Fixed Wing aircraft arrive on runway 08 at time noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-12 06:42:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence loud engine noise prior to 645am, loud sustained noise straddling 7:18am and 8:34am Aircraft Category Unidentified Unidentified Response: Airport Security was unable to identify any unusal noises at times noted in comment.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 5 of 22 2010-03-12 08:23:00 L-01 Ward's Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence A twin engined float plane taking off from the Island Airport flew very low (500 feet) directly over the houses on Ward s Island. Visibility was 10 kms in light rain at the time. Aircraft Category Unidentified Unidentified Response: AFTNS was unable to track aircraft at time noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-14 23:50:00 T-01 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence excessive airplane engine noise. Aircraft Category Medevac Fixed Wing PC12 Pilatus Response: AFTNS tracked a Medevac Fixed Wing aircraft depart on runway 08 at 23:38 hours.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 6 of 22 2010-03-15 18:19:00 E-04 Algonquin Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence reporting noise and presence of a small white craft, high-wing, single engine, flying over my area from north-west to east, no registration visible. not the first time this craft has been seen and heard over this area. Aircraft Category General Aviation C172 Cessna Single Piston Response: AFTNS tracked a Cessna C172 aircraft depart on runway 08, unable to track flight path.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-15 20:00:00 H-13 Algonquin Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Incident Time: 20 - 21 Noisy airplanes constantly circling over our house Aircraft Category General Aviation C172 Cessna Single Piston Response: AFTNS tracked a Cessna C172 aircraft conducting circuit training during time noted. No flight over noise sensitive area.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 7 of 22 2010-03-16 14:34:00 L-01 Ward's Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence A Dassault Falcon 10 twin JET took off from the Island Airport. Why was this jet allowed to land and take off from the Island Airport contrary to the Tripartite Agreement Aircraft Category Medevac Fixed Wing FA10 Response: AFTNS tracked FA10 medevac aircraft depart on runway 26 at time noted. Permitted operation.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-18 06:45:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence really loud engine noise at 645am. Again loud at 21 13 and 21 25 Aircraft Category General Aviation Several Aircraft Types Response: AFTNS tracked a Q400 aircraft depart on runway 26 at 0645 hours; Cessna C152 aircraft conducting circuit training at 2113 hours; and a Q400 aircraft depart on runway 26 at 2123 hours. Normal operations.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 8 of 22 2010-03-18 21:55:00 A-04 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Excessive airplane noise. I can t put my child to sleep with that kind of noise! Aircraft Category Unidentified Unidentified Response: AFTNS or security were unable to identify the cause of the noise noted in commented.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-19 14:36:00 E-04 Algonquin Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence noise and presence of a small greyish white craft, twin engine, low wing, flying low over the house from the east, approaching the airport for landing. Aircraft Category Unidentified Unidentified Response: AFTNS was unable to track aircraft at time noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 9 of 22 2010-03-19 16:50:00 S-02 Algonquin Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Piper Aztec? overflow Algonquin Island on approach. Can I hope for a polite notification to the pilot, in the hopes he will be more observant of the noise sensitive zone next visit? There have been the same number of itinerant overflights over the island as normal, but it is a pain to record them and wait to send them in. looking forward to your reply Aircraft Category General Aviation PA27 Response: AFTNS tracked a Piper PA27 aircraft fly close to the noise sensitive area but did not fly over.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 10 of 22 2010-03-21 07:00:00 H-15 Other Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence The amount of air traffic noise from Porter flights directly over my South neighborhood at certain times of the day (between 6:30-7:30am, 5pm - 6:30 and around 10pm) is relentless and unbearable. The increase in air traffic noise and presence seems to correspond to the early March island airport expansion. Some of the planes fly so low it feels like I could throw a rock and hit the plane as it roars over my house. It is unacceptable to have so much air traffic noise and low flying presence particularly in a neighborhood that is nowhere near an airport. I want to know why Porter is not flying over the lake water on their eastern destinations versus flying over north , which is a heavily populated residential area. I will be submitting complaints through my MP as will others in my neighborhood. Aircraft Category Non - Specific Response: AFTNS tracked no aircraft activity from BBTCA in Leaside neighbourhood. Aircraft activity detected are from other airports, and aircraft well above 6000 ft AGL.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 11 of 22 2010-03-21 12:00:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence This is to include a concern raised in an article in March 2010 The Bulletin newsletter on Page 4 by a gentleman living at the end of Runway 15 (which I believe is oriented N-S). The letter questioned why people complain about airport noise; yet, he noted that his conversations get drowned out for 3 seconds, and that this occurs for him several times per hour. He was being generous with respect to impacts at my location as the duration here often exceeds 10 seconds. Aircraft Category Non - Specific Response: Comment noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-21 23:55:00 Q-01 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Sunday night I was startled to hear the noise of a plane taking off at 5 minutes to midnight. I looked out my window and sure enough a plane was taxiing down the runway... curfew is 11:00 not 12:00. Why does this continue to happen? Why does the control tower give permission to take off and land in hours that are clearly beyond curfew? Aircraft Category Medevac Fixed Wing PC12 Pilatus Response: AFTNS tracked a Medevac Fixed Wing aircraft depart on runway 26 at time noted. Medevac aircraft are permitted to use the BBTCA facilities after hours in accordance with the Tripartite Agreement.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 12 of 22 2010-03-21 23:57:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence loud engine noise Aircraft Category Medevac Fixed Wing PC12 Pilatus Response: AFTNS tracked Air Ambulance PC12 depart on runway 26 at time noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-22 03:45:00 L-16 Other Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Awakened at 3:45 am by aircraft noises NOT helicopter aircraft. Clearly a fixed wing flying low over the city. I hear jets flying overhead constantly around midnight, endless helicopters sitting on hospital roofs, the circling sounds of flight school planes and i try not to complain but i am going to start now. This was a fixed wing aircraft at 3:45 am, louder than any helicopter i have heard. Aircraft Category Medevac Helicopter S76 Sikorsky Helicopter MOH Response: AFTNS tracked a Medevac Helicopter arrive on runway 08. No Medevac Fixed Wing aircraft at time noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 13 of 22 2010-03-22 18:38:00 H-12 Mimico Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Once again a Porter aircraft flying at less than 800 feet over the our home at Lakeshore and Royal York Rd. scared the heck out of our family this evening. More than 6 kilometers from the island airport, far too low with no excuse but ignorance on the part of the pilot. Someone must take these guys to task, they have the whole of the lake to make their approaches and landings to the island airport, yet they choose to overfly residences previously protected from this outrageous noise. Aircraft Category Scheduled Air Service DH8D de Havilland Q400 Response: AFTNS tracked a Q400 aircraft arrive on runway 08, fly over residential area at 1600 ft AGL.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-23 20:55:00 T-01 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence excessive airplane engine noise Aircraft Category Unidentified Unidentified Response: AFTNS or security were unable to identify the noise noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 14 of 22 2010-03-24 07:00:00 T-01 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence excessive airplane engine noise Aircraft Category Scheduled Air Service DH8D de Havilland Q400 Response: AFTNS tracked a Q400 aircraft depart on runway 26 at 0707 hours.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-24 17:00:00 H-15 Other Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Tremendous amount of increasing air traffic noise from low flying Porter aircraft over northeast Toronto neighborhoods! Why is Porter not flying planes over the water rather than coming northeast and roaring over our houses?!? There is loud air traffic noise pretty much less than every minute on certain hours. It is maddening to not live anywhere near this airport and to have to suffer through this relentless noise! It s also very nice to know that your complaint phone line voicemail is full and people are told to hang up. Aircraft Category Non - Specific Response: AFTNS tracked flights over residential area but were not using the BBTCA facilities. Comment noted and advised to contact NAV Canada.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 15 of 22 2010-03-25 06:42:00 A-04 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence definately airplane engine noise at an unacceptable hour. Aircraft Category Scheduled Air Service DH8D de Havilland Q400 Response: AFTNS tracked a Q400 aircraft depart on runway 26 at 0645 hours.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-25 08:00:00 T-01 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Continuous excessively loud engine noise, primarily of airplanes idling, also taxing, take off and landings for over half an hour... Aircraft Category General Aviation Several Aircraft Types Response: Although there were several landings and take-offs, there were no unusual airport activity note during time noted in comment.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 16 of 22 2010-03-26 06:10:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Once again this morning as on several occasions in the past I was awoken between 5Am to 6:15AM by the sound ot reverse backup beeper on a large vehicle or emergency vehicle at the Bathurst ferry terminal. Please review this immediately as this is completely unnecessary and lasts for several minutes. My windows are less than 100m from your ferry. Aircraft Category Non - Aircraft Related Response: Comment noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 17 of 22 2010-03-26 12:07:00 H-12 Mimico Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence I want to report another overflight of a porter aircraft more than 10 kilometers from the island airport on this brilliant clear day. The plane came from the east and then at Browns Line made a sharp, low 180 degree turn back toward the island airport where at Lakeshore Blvd. W. and Royal York Rd. it was just at 800 feet from the ground. These Porter pilots are needlessly desturbing our lives and destroying the property values here in South . When they have the whole of the lake to make their approaches to the Island Airport, who at Nav Canada is going to show these people the approach and departure procedure for this airport. Aircraft Category General Aviation DH8D de Havilland Q400 Response: AFTNS tracked a Q400 aircraft fly over the residential area at 1800 ft AGL (above ground level) approach runway 26 several times on designated flight path.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 18 of 22 2010-03-27 20:30:00 W-06 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence It was the Earth Hour at the Island Airport. There were limited lights and no airplanes during this hour. It was peaceful. If the lights could be turnt off during this hour, why does the lights at the Airport have to be on all night long every single night while the Airport is not in use?. If you want to conserve the energy, please consider turn them off at night. Thank you! Aircraft Category Non - Specific Response: Comment noted.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-28 10:31:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Loud sustained engine noise spanning 10 minutes around 10:31am on a Sunday morning. Is this necessary? Aircraft Category General Aviation Several Aircraft Types Response: AFTNS tracked two Cessna aircraft conducting circuit training at time noted. No engine run up recorded.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 19 of 22 2010-03-28 21:42:00 L-14 Mimico Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Please stop flying noisy Porter planes over our homes while we are trying to sleep. You are most inconsiderate. 9:42 pm, 9:46 pm, 10:22 pm Aircraft Category Scheduled Air Service DH8D de Havilland Q400 Response: AFTNS tracked three Q400 aircraft fly over residential area at 1800 ft AGL (above ground level) arrive on runway 08, at times notes.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-29 12:14:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Loud engine noise at 1214am after midnight and again at 641am. This noise generation is outside operating hours and is eating into my sleep on both ends! Aircraft Category Unidentified Unidentified Response: AFTNS or security were unable to track/identify the noise commented on.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 20 of 22 2010-03-30 10:38:00 L-01 Ward's Island Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Why did a military transport fly over the Ward s community at less than 1000 feet. I thought that there was an agreement about 2500 feet and that there wouldn t be any military aircraft accept in emergencies. Aircraft Category Armed Forces CC-130 Hercules Response: AFTNS tracked a Canadian Armed Forces aricraft depart on runway 08 at time noted. The flight path of the aircraft did not indicate a flight over Ward's Island.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

2010-03-31 06:41:00 B-05 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Loud sustained plane engine noise from 641am leading to takeoff at 645am - why? I would think this is a straight forward problem that the TPA should be able to manage. We should only be hearing birds chirping (as they had for 15 years+) to at the very earliest 645am sharp, when the first plane engine is supposed to be switched on for warm up. Note that the community was never consulted regarding the TPAs imposed 6:45 AM communal wake up time. Aircraft Category Scheduled Air Service DH8D de Havilland Q400 Response: AFTNS tracked a Q400 aircraft depart on runway 26 at 0645 hours.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 21 of 22 2010-03-31 20:30:00 T-01 Bathurst/Queen's Quay Area Type of Comment: Noise Presence Noise + Presence Excessive noise for a ten minute period resulting from taxiing, 2 take-offs, one landing. The noise was beyond loud, closer to deafening. Aircraft Category Scheduled Air Service DH8D de Havilland Q400 Response: AFTNS tracked a Q400 aircraft depart on runway 08 at 20:20 hours; a Q400 aircraft arrive on runway 08 at 20:34; and a Q400 aircarft depart on runway 08 at 20:36.

Action: Pilot Contacted Airline Contacted

Flight School Contacted Control Tower Contacted

March 2010 BBTCA Monthly Noise Comments Page 22 of 22