2018 Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan Table of Contents Acknowledgements i Glossary ii Executive Summary ES1 Introduction and Strategy 1 Current Status 4 Goals and Objectives 10 Detection Projects 14 Seasonal Intensive Monitoring in the CAWS 15 Strategy for eDNA Sampling in the CAWS 23 Larval Fish Monitoring in the Illinois Waterway 26 Distribution and Movement of Small Asian Carp in the Illinois Waterway 30 Distribution and Movement of Small Asian Carp in the Illinois Waterway Using Telemetry 33 Fixed Site Monitoring Downstream of the Dispersal Barrier 37 Telemetry Monitoring Plan 44 Monitoring Fish Abundance, Behavior, and Species Composition Near the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal Electric Dispersal Barrier 54 Alternative Pathway Surveillance - Urban Pond Monitoring 58 Young-of-year and Juvenile Asian Carp Monitoring 62 Des Plaines River and Overflow Monitoring 65 USGS Support for Implementation of MRP 69 Manage and Control Projects 74 Barrier Maintenance Fish Suppression 75 Barrier Defense Asian Carp Removal 87 Barrier Defense Using Novel Gear 90 Optimization of Mass Removal Techniques 92 Using Long-term Asian Carp Abundance and Movement Data to Reduce Uncertainty of Management Decisions 96 Evaluation of Gear Efficiency and Asian Carp Detectability 101 Unconventional Gear Development 104 Barge Entrainment and Asian Carp Interaction Study and Monitoring Barge Entrainment Dynamics and Assessment of Mitigation Protocols 108 Asian Carp Population Modeling to Support an Adaptive Management Framework 111 Telemetry Support for the Spatially Explicit Asian Carp Population Model (SEACarP) 120 Asian Carp Demographics 123 Asian Carp Enhanced Contract Removal Program 128 Alternative Pathway Surveillance in Illinois - Law Enforcement 131 Response Projects 135 Upper Illinois Waterway Contingency Response Plan 136 Appendices A1 Appendix A: Integration of New Science and Technology A2 Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan Table of Contents Appendix B: MRWG Participants B1 Appendix C: Best Management Practices to Prevent the Spread of Aquatic Nuisance Species during Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Field Activities C1 Appendix D: Detailed Maps of Fixed and Random Site Sampling Locations D1 Appendix E: Handling Captured Asian Carp and Maintaining Chain-of-Custody Records E1 Appendix F: Shipping, Handling, and Data Protocols for Wild Captured Black Carp and Grass Carp F1 Appendix G: Fish Species Computer Codes G1 Appendix H: Sample Data Sheets H1 Appendix I: Understanding Surrogate Fish Movement with Barriers Floy Tagging Data Sheet I1 Appendix J: Analysis of Bighead and Silver Carp Spawn Patches J1 Appendix K: Black and Grass Carp Identification K1 Appendix L: Hydroacoustic Surveys Paper L1 Appendix M: Using zooplankton to measure ecosystem responses to Asian carp barrier defense and removal in the Illinois River M1 Appendix N: Detection Using Novel Gear N1 Appendix O: Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Equipment O1 Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan was created by a team of biologists, scientists, managers, and administrators from state and federal agencies and includes technical input from government, university, and the private sector specialists. The original plan released in May 2010 was developed by S. Finney, R. Simmonds, S. Pescitelli, S. Shults, J. Mick, G. Sass, and R. Maher. This and earlier versions of the plan have benefitted from reviews by participants of the Monitoring and Response Work Group, Great Lakes state’s natural resource agencies, nongovernmental organizations, and staff from the Illinois Department of Natural Resources Division of Fisheries, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. K. Irons, J. Dettmers, K. Baerwaldt, J. Davis, M. Shanks, N. Barkowski, E. Monroe, J. Merry, R. Simmonds, S. Finney, J. Stewart, N. Bloomfield, A. Coulter, D. Coulter, E. Pherigo, R. Neeley, R. Anderson, J. Kallis, M. O’Hara, T. Widloe, B. Caputo, B. Bushman, J. Widloe, L. Nelson, N. Bloomfield, B. Fehrenbacher, S. Morrison, B. Knights, J. R. Haun, R. Young, M. Brey, S. Butler, M. Diana, S. Collins, and D. Wahl contributed project write-ups for the plan. USFWS, IDNR, and INHS provided pictures for the cover. i GLOSSARY TERM DEFINITION °C Degrees centigrade °F Degrees Fahrenheit µS/cm microSiemen per centimeter A Amps ACRCC Asian Carp Regional Coordinating Committee ANCOVA Analysis of covariance ANOVA Analysis of variance ANS Aquatic Nuisance Species CAWS Chicago Area Waterway System CERL Construction Engineering and Research Laboratory cm Centimeter cm2 Square centimeters CPO Conservation Police Officers CPUE Catch per unit effort CSSC Chicago Sanitary and Shipping Canal dB Decibels DC Direct current DIDSON Dual Frequency Identification Sonar Fish with the natural number of reproductive chromosomes; are capable of Diploid reproducing ECALS eDNA Calibration Study eDNA Environmental DNA FWCO Fish and Wildlife Conservation Office g Grams GLFC Great Lakes Fisheries Commission GLMRIS Great Lakes Mississippi River Interbasin Study GPS Global Positioning System GSI Gonadosomatic index HACCP Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points IDNR Illinois Department of Natural Resources INHS Illinois Natural History Survey IPC Internal positive control ISU Invasive Species Unit IWW Illinois Waterway kg Kilogram kHz Kilohertz km Kilometer km/hr Kilometers per hour LOQ Limit of quantification LTRMP Long-Term Resource Monitoring Protocols m Meter m2 Square meters ii GLOSSARY TERM DEFINITION m3 Cubic meters ml Milliliter mm Millimeter MRP Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan MRWG Monitoring and Response Work Group MVN Multivariate Normal Distribution MWRD Chicago Metropolitan Water Reclamation District Ploidy Measurement of number of chromosomes, triploid fish are sterile QAPP Quality Assurance Project Plan RM River Mile SD Standard deviation SIM Seasonal Intensive Monitoring SIUC Southern Illinois University Carbondale TL Total length Fish that have been genetically modified to have an extra reproductive Triploid chromosome, rendering them sterile -TS Target Strength UMESC USGS Upper Midwest Environmental Sciences Center USACE U.S. Army Corps of Engineers USCG U.S. Coast Guard USEPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency USFWS U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service USGS U.S. Geological Survey V Volts v/cm Volts per centimeter V/in Volts per inch VHS Viral Hemorrhagic Septicemia W Watts WGL Whitney Genetics Laboratory yd Yard YOY Young of year iii Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan (MRP) was prepared by the Monitoring and Response Workgroup (MRWG), and released by the Asian Carp Regional Coordinating Committee (ACRCC). It is intended to act as an update to previous MRPs, and present up-to- date information and plans for a host of projects dedicated to preventing Asian carp from establishing populations in the Chicago Area Waterway System (CAWS) and Lake Michigan. Specifically, this document is a compilation of 26 individual project plans, each of which plays an important role in preventing the expansion of the range of Asian carp, and in furthering the understanding of Asian carp location, population dynamics, behavior, and the efficacy of control and capture methods. Each individual plan outlines anticipated actions that will take place in 2018, including project objectives, methodology, and highlights of previous work. The projects undertaken by the MRWG are designed to address three primary objectives for preventing the spread of Asian carp to Lake Michigan. These objectives are: 1) Detection: Determine the distribution and abundance of Asian carp to guide response and control actions. 2) Manage and Control: Prevent upstream passage of Asian carp towards Lake Michigan via use of barriers, mass removal, and understanding best methods for preventing passage. 3) Response: Establish comprehensive procedures for responding to changes in Asian carp population status, test these procedures through exercises, and implement if necessary. The plans included in this 2018 MRP build upon considerable work completed since 2010. Selected highlights of past efforts are presented below, grouped by primary objective. For a more detailed accounting of the results and findings of previously completed work, please refer to the 2017 Asian Carp Interim Summary Report, presented as a companion document to the 2018 MRP. HIGHLIGHTS OF PAST EFFORTS Detection Projects ▪ A total of 374,288 fish representing 73 species and six hybrid groups were sampled above the Electric Dispersal Barrier, including 2,020 Banded Killifish (state threatened species) from 2010-2017. From 2011 – 2016 no Bighead or Silver Carp were captured or observed. ▪ One Silver Carp was captured above the Electric Dispersal Barrier in the Little Calumet River in 2017. ▪ No small (< 6 inches) Asian carp were captured upstream of Peoria Pool in 2017. Three small Asian carp were caught in Peoria Pool. ▪ Observations of eggs, larvae, and juveniles in the upper Illinois River during 2015 - 2017 indicate that some reproduction occurs above Starved Rock Lock and Dam in some years, ES-1 Asian Carp Monitoring and Response Plan but the contribution of these fish to the population and the frequency of such occurrences remain uncertain. ▪ Fixed and random sampling below the Electric Dispersal Barrier has resulted in the collection of over 291,000 fish to date. No Asian carp have been captured in Brandon Road