<<

How to choose the right vaginal moisturizer or lubricant for your patient

About 20% of women report having used a vaginal lubrication product in the past 30 days. Knowing what is in these widely used products can help your patients select from the litany of options.

Jon F. Pennycuff, MD, MSPH, and Cheryl Iglesia, MD

aginal dryness, encompassed in the between vaginal moisturizers and lubricants modern term genitourinary syn- and how to best choose a product. V drome of (GSM) affects up to 40% of menopausal women and up to 60% of postmenopausal survi- Vaginal moisturizers vors.1,2 Premenopausal women also can have Vaginal moisturizers are designed to rehy- vulvovaginal dryness while drate the vaginal epithelium. Much like (lactational ) and while taking or skin moisturizers, they are intended to be 3 low-dose contraceptives. Vaginal moisturiz- applied regularly, every 2 to 3 days, but may be IN THIS ers and lubricants are the first-line treatment applied more often depending on the severity ARTICLE options for vaginal dryness, , and of symptoms. Vaginal moisturizers work by GSM.4,5 In fact, approximately two-thirds of increasing the fluid content of the vaginal tis- The effects of women have reported using a vaginal lubri- sue and by lowering the vaginal pH to mimic additives cant in their lifetime.6 Despite such ubiq- that of natural vaginal secretions. Vaginal page 46 uitous use, many health care providers and moisturizers are typically water based and use patients have questions about the difference polymers to hydrate tissues.7 They change cell morphology but do not change vaginal matu- Available ration, indicating that they bring water to the nonhormonal tissue but do not shift the balance between moisturizers Dr. Pennycuff is Fellow, Female Pelvic superficial and basal cells and do not increase page 47 Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, vaginal epithelial thickness as seen with vagi- MedStar Health, Washington DC. nal .8 Vaginal moisturizers also have Common patient been found to be a safe alternative to vaginal concerns estrogen therapy and may improve markers page 49 of vaginal health, including vaginal moisture, Dr. Iglesia is Section Director, Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive vaginal fluid volume, vaginal elasticity, and Surgery, MedStar Washington premenopausal pH.9 Commercially available Hospital Center; Associate Professor, vaginal moisturizers have been shown to be Obstetrics, Gynecology and , Georgetown University; and Assistant as effective as vaginal in reducing Professor, Department of Obstetrics vaginal symptoms such as itching, irritation, and Gynecology, Uniformed Services University of the Health and Sciences, Bethesda, MD. and dyspareunia, but some caution should be taken when interpreting these results as nei-

The authors report no financial relationships relevant to this ther vaginal moisturizer nor vaginal estrogen article. tablet were more effective than placebo in a 10,11 doi: 10.12788/obgm.0104 recent randomized controlled trial. Small

mdedge.com/obgyn Vol. 33 No. 6 | June 2021 | OBG Management 45 Choosing the right vaginal lubricant or moisturizer for your patient

studies on hyaluronic acid have shown effi- vaginal moisturizers and lubricants. Under- cacy for the treatment of vaginal dryness.12,13 standing the compositions of these products Hyaluronic acid is commercially available as and their scientific evidence is useful when a vaginal suppository ovule and as a liquid. helping patients make informed decisions It may also be obtained from a reliable com- regarding their pelvic health. Most commer- pounding pharmacy. Vaginal suppository cially available lubricants are either water- ovules may be a preferable formulation for or silicone- based. In one study comparing women who find the liquids messy or cum- these two types of lubricants, water-based bersome to apply. lubricants were associated with fewer geni- tal symptoms than silicone-based products.14 Women may want to use a natural or organic Lubricants product and may prefer plant-based oils such Lubricants differ from vaginal moisturizers as coconut oil or olive oil. Patients should be because they are specifically designed to be counseled that latex are not com- used during intercourse to provide short- patible with petroleum-, mineral oil- or plant term relief from vaginal dryness. They may oil-based lubricants. be water-, silicone-, mineral oil-, or plant oil- In our practice, we generally recommend based. The use of water- and silicone-based silicone-based lubricants, as they are readily lubricants is associated with high satisfac- available and compatible with latex condoms tion for intercourse as well as .14 and generally require a smaller amount than These products may be particularly beneficial water-based lubricants. They tend to be more to women whose chief complaint is dyspareu- expensive than water-based lubricants. For nia. In fact, women with dyspareunia report vaginal moisturizers, we often recommend FAST more lubricant use than women without commercially available formulations that can TRACK dyspareunia, and the most common reason be purchased at local pharmacies or drug for lubricant use among these women was stores. However, a patient may need to try dif- Silicone-based to reduce or alleviate pain.15 Overall, women ferent lubricants and moisturizers in order to lubricants are both with and without dyspareunia have a find a preferred product. We have included readily positive perception regarding lubricant use in TABLES 1 AND 27,17,18 a list of commercially available and and prefer that feels more available vaginal moisturizers and lubricants compatible with “wet,” and women in their forties have the with ingredient list, pH, osmolality, common latex condoms most positive perception about lubricant formulation, and cost when available, which and generally use at the time of intercourse compared with has been compiled from WHO and published require a smaller other age groups.16 Furthermore, the World research data to help guide patient counsel- amount than Health Organization (WHO) recommends ing. (Table 2 is available in the online version that -compatible lubricants be used water-based of this article at mdedge.com/obgyn.) with condoms for menopausal and post- lubricants menopausal women.17 Both water-based and silicone-based lubricants may be used with The effects of additives latex condoms, while oil-based lubricants Water-based moisturizers and lubricants should be avoided as they can degrade the may contain many ingredients, such as glyc- latex condom. While vaginal moisturizers erols, fragrance, flavors, sweeteners, warming and lubricants technically differ based on or cooling agents, buffering solutions, para- use, patients may use one product for both bens and other preservatives, and numb- purposes, and some products are marketed ing agents. These substances are added to as both a moisturizer and lubricant. water-based products to prolong water con- tent, alter viscosity, alter pH, achieve certain sensations, and prevent bacterial contamina- Providing counsel to patients tion.7 The addition of these substances, how- Patients often seek advice on how to choose ever, will alter osmolality and pH balance of

46 OBG Management | June 2021 | Vol. 33 No. 6 mdedge.com/obgyn TABLE 1 Commonly available nonhormonal vaginal moisturizers formulations Osmolality Formulation and Approximate Product Ingredients pH7,18 (mOSm/kg)7,18 use price RepHresh Vaginal gel Purified water USP, 3.4 1,439 – 1,914 Prefilled 4 applicators glycerin, polycarbophil, applicator used (12 days) carbopol 974P, every 3 days $26.49 ethylparaben sodium, methylparaben sodium, propylparaben sodium, sodium hydroxide Replens Long-Lasting Purified water, glycerin, 2.95 – 3.0 1,177 – 2,011 Prefilled 8 applicators Vaginal Moisturizer mineral oil, polycarbophil, applicator used (1-month supply) carbomer homopolymer every 3 days $22.49 type B, hydrogenated palm oil glyceride, sorbic acid, sodium hydroxide Luvena Water, propanediol, PEG- Unavailable Unavailable Prefilled 6 applicators for 20, xanthan gum, PEG- applicators, use $19.99 20M, simmonsia every 3 days as chinensis (Jojoba) moisturizer or seed oil, vaccinium lubricant macrocopon (cranberry) fruit extract, lysozyme, lactoferrin, lactoperoxidase, lactic acid, potassium thiocynanate, glycogen, mannose, tocopherol (vitamin E) Canesintima Intimate Aqua, glycerin, glyceryl 5.63 846 Pump bottle 50 mL pump Moisturizer polymethacrylate, cap- bottle for $33.49 ryloyl glycine, sorbitol, acrylates/C10-30 alkyl acrylate crosspolymer, sodium hyaluronate, so- dium benzoate, sodium hydroxide, galactoara- binan, butylene glycol/ camellia japonica leaf/ flower extract, tetrasodi- um EDTA, P-anisic acid, levulinic acid Ah! Yes Vaginal Aqua (water), linum 3.8 – 4.2 260 – 290 Flip top bottle $14.99 for flip top Moisturizer usitatissimum (flax) (100 mL); prefilled bottle, $53.89 for extract, aloe barbadensis applicators used 30 applicators leaf juice powder (aloe every 3 days vera), ceratonia siliqua (locust bean gum), cy- amopsis tetragonolo- bus (guar gum), sodium chloride, xanthan gum, potassium sorbate, citric acid, phenoxyethanol

CONTINUED ON PAGE 48 mdedge.com/obgyn Vol. 33 No. 6 | June 2021 | OBG Management 47 Choosing the right vaginal lubricant or moisturizer for your patient

CONTINUED FROM PAGE 47

TABLE 1 Commonly available nonhormonal vaginal moisturizers formulations (continued) Osmolality Formulation and Approximate Product Ingredients pH7,18 (mOSm/kg)7,18 use price Sylk Natural Intimate Purified water, kiwifruit 4.47 877 3 fluid oz flip top $22.95 Moisturizer plant extract, citrus seed tube extract, xanthan plant extract, vegetable glycer- ine, citric acid, potassium sorbate, sodium citrate HyaloGyn Vaginal Hydeal-D® (hyaluronic 4.88 1,336 – 1,729 30 g tube with 10 $27.00 Hydrating Gel acid derivative), propyl- applicators ene glycol, carbomer (30-day supply) (carbopol 974P), methyl p-hydroxybenzoate, pro- pyl p-hydroxybenzoate, sodium hydroxide, puri- fied water Revaree Vaginal 2-g vaginal insert Unavailable Unavailable 10 vaginal $55.00 Moisturizer contains 5 mg of hyal- suppositories uronic acid sodium salt (30-day supply) in a base consisting of a mixture of semi-synthetic glycerides, which help it retain its shape. (Full ingredient list not listed.) K-Y Liquibeads Vaginal Dimethicone, dimethi- Unavailable Unavailable 6 vaginal ovules $22.79 Moisturizer conol, gelatin, glycerin

the product, which may be of clinical conse- products remains poorly understood. None- quence. Silicone- or oil-based products do theless, products with a pH of 3 or lower are not contain water and therefore do not have not recommended.18 Concerns about osmo- a pH or an osmolality value. lality and pH remain theoretical, as a study of Hyperosmolar formulations can theoret- 12 commercially available lubricants of vary- ically injure epithelial tissue. In vitro studies ing osmolality and pH found no cytotoxic have shown that hyperosmotic vaginal prod- effect in vivo.18 ucts can induce mild to moderate irritation, Vaginal moisturizers and lubricants while very hyperosmolar formulations can contain many inactive ingredients, the most induce severe irritation and tissue damage controversial of which are parabens. These to vaginal epithelial and cervical cells.19,20 The substances are used in many cosmetic prod- WHO recommends that the osmolality of a ucts as preservatives and are weakly estro- vaginal product not exceed 380 mOsm/kg, genic. These substances have been found in but very few commercially available products breast cancer tissue, but their possible role meet these criteria so, clinically, the thresh- as a carcinogen remains uncertain.21,22 None- old is 1,200 mOsm/kg.17 It should be noted theless, the use of paraben-containing prod- that most commercially available products ucts is not recommended for women who exceed the 1,200 mOsm/kg threshold. Vaginal have a history of hormonally-driven cancer products may be a cause for vaginal irritation or who are at high risk for developing cancer.7 and should be considered in the differential Many lubricants contain glycerols (glycerol, diagnosis. glycerine, and propylene glycol) to alter vis- The normal vaginal pH is 3.8–4.5, and cosity or alter the water properties. The WHO vaginal products should be pH balanced recommends limits on the content of glycer- to this range. The exact role of pH in these ols in these products.17 Glycerols have been

48 OBG Management | June 2021 | Vol. 33 No. 6 mdedge.com/obgyn associated with increased risk of bacterial of L crispatus, which may predispose to irrita- vaginosis (adjusted odds ratio [aOR], 11.75; tion and infection.27 Nonetheless, the effect of 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.96–70.27), and the vaginal products on the vaginal microbi- can serve as a food source for candida spe- ome and vaginal tissue remains poorly stud- cies, possibly increasing risk of yeast infec- ied. Vaginal moisturizers and lubricants, while tions.7,23 Additionally, vaginal moisturizers often helpful for patients, also can potentially and lubricants may contain preservatives such cause irritation or predispose to infections. as chlorhexidine, which can disrupt normal Providers should consider this when evaluat- vaginal flora and may cause tissue irritation.7 ing patients for new onset vaginal symptoms after starting vaginal products.

Common concerns to be aware of Bottom line Women using vaginal products may be con- Vaginal products such as moisturizers and cerned about adverse effects, such as wors- lubricants are often effective treatment options ening vaginal irritation or infection. Vaginal for women suffering from genitourinary syn- moisturizers have not been shown to have drome of menopause and may be first-line increased risk of adverse effects compared treatment options, especially for women with vaginal estrogens.9,10 In vitro studies have who may wish to avoid estrogen-containing shown that vaginal moisturizers and lubri- products. Vaginal moisturizers can be recom- cants inhibit the growth of Escherichia coli mended to any women experiencing vaginal but may also inhibit Lactobacillus crispatus.24 irritation due to vaginal dryness while vaginal Clinically, vaginal moisturizers have been lubricants should be recommended to sexually shown to improve signs of bacterial vagino- active women who experience dyspareunia. sis and have even been used to treat bacterial Clinicians need to be aware of the formulations vaginosis.25,26 A study of commercially avail- of these products and possible side effects in able vaginal lubricants inhibited the growth order to appropriately counsel patients. l

References 1. Castelo-Branco C, Cancelo MJ, Villero J, et al. Management 8. Van der Lakk JAWN, de Bie LMT, de Leeuw H, et al. The of postmenopausal vaginal atrophy and . effect of Replens on vaginal cytology in the treatment Maturitas. 2005;52(suppl 1):S46-S52. doi: 10.1016/j. of postmenopausal atrophy: cytomorphology versus maturitas.2005.06.014. computerized cytometry. J Clin Pathol. 2002;55:446-451. doi: 2. Crandall C, Peterson L, Ganz PA, et al. Association of 10.1136/jcp.55.6.446. breast cancer and its therapy with menopause-related 9. Nachtigall LE. Comparitive study: Replens versus local symptoms. Menopause. 2004;11:519-530. doi: 10.1097/01. estrogen in menopausal women. Fertil Steril. 1994;61:178- gme.0000117061.40493.ab. 180. doi: 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)56474-7. 3. Bornstein J, Goldstein AT, Stockdale CK, et al. 2015 10. Bygdeman M, Swahn ML. Replens versus dienoestrol ISSVD, ISSWSH, and IPPS Consensus Terminology and cream in the symptomatic treatment of vaginal atrophy in Classification of Persistant Vulvar Pain and . J Sex postmenopausal women. Maturitas. 1996;23:259-263. doi: Med. 2016;13:607-612. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2016.02.167. 10.1016/0378-5122(95)00955-8. 4. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. ACOG 11. Mitchell CM, Reed SD, Diem S, et al. Efficacy of vaginal Practice Bulletin No. 141: management of menopausal or vaginal moisturizer vs placebo for treating symptoms. Obstet Gynecol. 2014;123:202-216. doi: postmenopausal vulvovaginal symptoms. JAMA Intern Med. 10.1097/01.AOG.0000441353.20693.78. 2018;178:681-690. doi: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.0116. 5. Faubion S, Larkin L, Stuenkel C, et al. Management of 12. Chen J, Geng L, Song X, et al. Evaluation of the efficacy and genitourinary syndrome of menopause in women with or safety of hyaluronic acid vaginal gel to ease vaginal dryness: at high risk for breast cancer: consensus recommendation a multicenter, randomized, controlled, open-label, parallel- from The North American Menopause Society and the group, clinical trial. J Sex Med. 2013;10:1575-1584. doi: International Society for the Study for Women’s Sexual 10.1111/jsm.12125. Health. Menopause. 2018;25:596-608. doi: 10.1097 13. Jokar A, Davari T, Asadi N, et al. Comparison of the /GME.0000000000001121. hyaluronic acid vaginal cream and conjugated estrogen used 6. Herbenick D, Reece M, Schick V, et al. Women’s use and in treatment of vaginal atrophy of menopause women: a perceptions of commercial lubricants: prevalence and randomized controlled clinical trial. IJCBNM. 2016;4:69-78. characteristics in a nationally representative sample of 14. Herbenick D, Reece M, Hensel D, et al. Association of American adults. J Sex Med. 2014;11:642-652. doi: 10.1111 lubricant use with women’s sexual pleasure, sexual /jsm.12427. satisfaction, and genital symptoms: a prospective daily 7. Edwards D, Panay N. Treating vulvovaginal atrophy/ diary study. J Sex Med. 2011;8:202-212. doi: 10.1111/j.1743- genitourinary syndrome of menopause: how important is 6109.2010.02067.x. vaginal lubricant and moisturizer composition? Climacteric. 15. Sutton KS, Boyer SC, Goldfinger C, et al. To lube or not to 2016;19:151-116. doi: 10.3109/13697137.2015.1124259. lube: experiences and perceptions of lubricant use in women CONTINUED ON PAGE 58

mdedge.com/obgyn Vol. 33 No. 6 | June 2021 | OBG Management 49 Choosing the right vaginal lubricant or moisturizer for your patient

CONTINUED FROM PAGE 49

with and without dyspareunia. J Sex Med. 2012;9:240-250. esters of p-hydroxybenzoic acid (parabens) in human breast doi: 10.1111/j.1743-6109.2011.02543.x. tumours. J Appl Toxicol. 2004:24:1-4. doi: 10.1002/jat.957. 16. Jozkowski KN, Herbenick D, Schick V, et al. Women’s 22. Darbre PD, Alijarrah A, Miller WR, et al. Concentrations of perceptions about lubricant use and vaginal wetness during parabens in human breast tumous. J Appl Toxicol. 2004;24:5- sexual activity. J Sex Med. 2013;10:484-492. doi: 10.1111 13. doi: 10.1002/jat.958. /jsm.12022. 23. Brotman RM, Ravel J, Cone RA, et al. Rapid fluctuation of 17. World Health Organization. Use and procurement of the vaginal microbiota measured by Gram stain analysis. Sex additional lubricants for male and female condoms: WHO Transm Infect. 2010;86:297-302. doi: 10.1136/sti.2009.040592. /UNFPA/FHI360 advisory note. 2012. https://www.who. 24. Hung KJ, Hudson P, Bergerat A, et al. Effect of commercial int/reproductivehealth/publications/rtis/rhr12_33/en/. vaginal products on the growth of uropathogenic and Accessed February 13, 2021. commensal vaginal bacteria. Sci Rep. 2020;10:7625. 18. Cunha AR, Machado RM, Palmeira de Oliveira A, et 25. Wu JP, Fielding SL, Fiscell K. The effect of the polycarbophil al. Characterization of commercially available vaginal gel (Replens) on bacterial vaginosis: a pilot study. Eur J lubricants: a safety perspective. Pharmaceuticals. 2014;6:530- Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol. 2007;130:132-136. doi: 10.1016/j. 542. doi: 10.3390/pharmaceutics6030530. ejogrb.2006.01.007. 19. Adriaens E, Remon JP. Mucosal irritation potential of personal 26. Fiorelli A, Molteni B, Milani M. Successful treatment of lubricants relates to product osmolality as detected by the bacterial vaginosis with a polycarbophil-carbopol acidic slug mucosal irritation assay. Sex Transm Dis. 2008;35:512- vaginal gel: results from a randomized double-bling, 516. doi: 10.1097/OLQ.0b013e3181644669. placebo controlled trial. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol. 20. Dezzuti CS, Brown ER, Moncla B, et al. Is wetter better? An 2005;120:202-205. doi: 10.1016/j.ejogrb.2004.10.011. evaluation of over-the-counter personal lubricants for safety 27. Fashemi B, Delaney ML, Onderdonk AB, et al. Effects of and anti-HIV activity. PLoS One. 2012;7:e48328. doi: 10.1371 products on the vaginal mucosal biome. /journal.pone.0048328. Microb Ecol Health Dis. 2013;24. doi: 10.3402/mehd. 21. Harvey PW, Everett DJ. Significance of the detection of v24i0.19703.

CONTINUED ON PAGE e1

58 OBG Management | June 2021 | Vol. 33 No. 6 mdedge.com/obgyn CONTINUED FROM PAGE 58

TABLE 2 Commonly available nonhormonal lubricants Osmolality Formulation Approximate Product Ingredients pH7,17,18 (mOSm/kg)7,17,18 and use price K-Y Jelly Water, glycerin, 3.5 – 4.49 2,007 – 3,631 2 and 4 oz flip $4.99 – $7.59 Water Based hydroxyethylcellulose, top bottle Lubricant chlorhexidine, gluconate, gluconolactone, methylparaben, sodium hydroxide Astroglide Gel Purified water, glycerin, 4.38 6,100 4 oz flip top tube $6.79 Lubricant hydroxyethylcellulose, chlorhexidine gluconate, methylparaben, glucono delta lactone, sodium hydroxide ID Glide Water, glycerin, propylene glycol, 5.20a 3,200a Multiple $3.49 – 159.99 Lubricant cellulose gum, EDTA, carbomer, PEG-90M, tetrahydroxypropyl ethylenediamine, methylparaben, sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate Wet Original Water (aqua), glycerin, 5.9 3,679 5 – 32 oz bottles $8.33 – $39.51 Gel Lubricant carboxymethylcellulose, pentylene glycol, potassium sorbate Durex Play Feel Purified water, propylene glycol, 5.48 1,563 50 mL flip top $8.99 Pleasure Gel hydroxyethylcellulose, benzoic acid, bottle sodium hydroxide Good Clean Organic aloe barbadensis leaf 4.73 240 4 oz flip top tube $11.99 Love Almost juice, xanthan gum, agar, lactic Naked Organic acid, potassium sorbate, sodium Personal benzoate, natural flavor Lubricant H2O Sliquid Purified water, plant cellulose 4.0 – 4.4 Unavailable 4.2 or 8.5 oz $12.00 – $19.00 Naturals (from cotton), cyamopsis (guar bottles conditioners), potassium sorbate, citric acid Pjur Med Aqua (water), glycerin, xanthan gum, 4.41 >2,000 100 mL bottle $15.95 Natural Glide benzyl alcohol, sodium benzoate, Personal potassium sorbate, citric acid Lubricant Pjur Women Aqua (water), propylene glycol, 4.42 >2,000 100 mL bottle $34.99 Nude Lubricant ethoxydiglycol, hydroxypropyl guar hydroxypropyltrimonium chloride, hydroxyethyl cellulose, sodium saccharin, citric acid Ritex Senstiv Aqua, glycerin, butylene glycol, 4.04 >2,000 100 mL tube $48.99 Gel hydroxyethylcellulose, sodium lactate, lactic acid Simply Slick Castor oil, purified water, jojoba oil, 6.68 >2,000 2 oz bottle $17.77 Personal vegetable glycerin, pectin, Stevia, Lubricating Optiflo H370VF Lotion

mdedge.com/obgyn Vol. 33 No. 6 | June 2021 | OBG Management e1 Choosing the right vaginal lubricant or moisturizer for your patient

CONTINUED FROM PAGE e1

TABLE 2 Commonly available nonhormonal lubricants (continued) Osmolality Formulation Approximate Product Ingredients pH7,17,18 (mOSm/kg)7,17,18 and use price Ah! Yes Aqua (water), aloe barbadensis 4.08 154 1.7 – 5.1 oz flip $8.49 – $21.99 Water Based leaf juice powder (aloe vera), linum top tubes Lubricant usitatissimum (flax) seed extract, cyamopsis tetragonolobus (guar gum), ceratonia siliqua (locust bean gum), xanthan gum, sodium chloride, potassium sorbate, citric acid, phenoxyethanol Uber Lube Dimethicone, dimethiconol, 4.6 N/A 50 and 100 mL $18.00 – $28.00 cyclomethicone, tocopheryl acetate pump glass (vitamin E) bottle Swiss Navy Cyclopentasiloxane, dimethicone, N/A N/A 4 oz pump bottle $16.49 Silicone tocopheryl acetate Lubricant K-Y True Feel Dimethicone N/A N/A 1.5 oz bottle $13.99 Premium Silicone Lubricant aFormulation of product changed since laboratory testing so pH and osmolality may be different.

e2 OBG Management | June 2021 | Vol. 33 No. 6 mdedge.com/obgyn