DOCSLIB.ORG

Recommend Authorization to Amend the Norfolk Southern Operating Access and Amtrak Access and Storage Agreements

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Recommend Authorization to Amend the Norfolk Southern Operating Access and Amtrak Access and Storage Agreements Agenda Item 9-F Action Item To: Chair Bennett-Parker and the VRE Operations Board From: Rich Dalton Date: July 16, 2021 Re: Recommend Authorization to Amend the Norfolk Southern Operating Access and Amtrak Access and Storage Agreements Recommendation: The VRE Operations Board is asked to recommend the Commissions authorize the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) to execute an amendment to the Norfolk Southern Operating Access Agreement and Amtrak Access and Storage Agreement to reflect the Transforming Rail in Virginia (TRV) Service Plan. The Service Plan includes post-acquisition train schedule changes for the VRE Manassas and Fredericksburg line trains anticipated in September of 2021 or soon thereafter. Summary: This action will incorporate the post-acquisition schedule from the TRV Service Plan as an exhibit to the existing agreements similar to previous actions taken by the Commissions for the Passenger Rail Operations and Access Agreement with Virginia Passenger Rail Authority (VPRA) and the Amended and Restated Operating Access Agreement with CSX Transporation. Background: VRE has an Operating Access Agreement with Norfolk Southern Railway Corporation permitting VRE operations in the Manassas to Washington, DC Corridor. VRE also has an Access and Storage Agreement with the National Railroad Passenger Corporation (Amtrak). These agreements, in part, establish several train operating criteria including train schedules. In December of 2020, the Commissions authorized the VRE CEO to execute the Passenger Rail Operations and Access Agreement with the VPRA. As part of this Agreement, the parties agreed to an enhanced service plan (the post-acquisition schedule) for VRE and Amtrak trains to be implemented soon after the acquisition of the right-of-way from CSX Transportation. Also included in the service plan are additional train slots for VRE post- acquisition, after completion of phased Planned Infrastructure Improvements and train slots for weekend service. In May of 2021, the Commissions authorized the VRE CEO to execute the Amended and Restated Operating Access Agreement with CSX Transporation. The TRV Service Plan, including the post-acquisition schedule, was included as an exhibit in this agreement as well. The recommended amendments to the agreements with Norfolk Southern and Amtrak will incorporate into each existing agreement, schedule enhancements for VRE Manassas Line trains in accordance with the TRV post-acquisition schedule only. The use of additional trains slots and the final service plans following the Planned Infrastructure Improvements and weekend service will be included in future annual budget discussions and approvals by the Commissions. Fiscal Impact: There is no fiscal impact to these amendments. 2 Virginia Railway Express Operations Board Resolution 9F-07-2021 Recommend Authorization to Amend the Norfolk Southern Operating Access and Amtrak Access and Storage Agreements WHEREAS, VRE has an Operating Access Agreement with Norfolk Southern Railway Company effective April 2014; and, WHEREAS, VRE has an Access and Storage Agreement with Amtrak effective July 2020; and, WHEREAS, the Operating Access Agreement and Access and Storage Agreement, in part, identify train schedules for the VRE Manassas and Fredericksburg line trains as exhibits; and, WHEREAS, as part of the Passenger Rail Operations and Access Agreement with the Virginia Passenger Rail Authority , the parties agreed to an enhanced service plan affecting VRE and Amtrak trains as part of Transforming Rail in Virginia ; and, WHEREAS, this action will incorporate the post-acquisition train schedules as exhibits to the respective agreements; and, WHEREAS, implementation of the post-acquisitions schedules is anticipated to occur in September of 2021 or soon thereafter: NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT, the VRE Operations Board does hereby recommend the Commissions authorize the Chief Executive Officer to execute an Amendment to the Operating Access Agreement with Norfolk Southern Railway Company to modify the VRE Manassas Line train schedules in a form approved by legal counsel; and, LET IT BE FURTHER RESOLVED THAT, the VRE Operations Board does hereby recommend the Commissions authorize the Chief Executive Officer to execute an Amendment to the Access and Storage Agreement with Amtrak to modify the VRE Manassas and Fredericksburg Line train schedules in a form approved by legal counsel. Approved this 16th day of July 2021 _______________________________ Elizabeth Bennett-Parker Chair ____________________________ James Walkinshaw Secretary 3 .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Amtrak's Rights and Relationships with Host Railroads
    Amtrak’s Rights and Relationships with Host Railroads September 21, 2017 Jim Blair –Director Host Railroads Today’s Amtrak System 2| Amtrak Amtrak’s Services • Northeast Corridor (NEC) • 457 miles • Washington‐New York‐Boston Northeast Corridor • 11.9 million riders in FY16 • Long Distance (LD) services • 15 routes • Up to 2,438 miles in length Long • 4.65 million riders in FY16 Distance • State‐supported trains • 29 routes • 19 partner states • Up to 750 miles in length State- • 14.7 million riders in FY16 supported3| Amtrak Amtrak’s Host Railroads Amtrak Route System Track Ownership Excluding Terminal Railroads VANCOUVER SEATTLE Spokane ! MONTREAL PORTLAND ST. PAUL / MINNEAPOLIS Operated ! St. Albans by VIA Rail NECR MDOT TORONTO VTR Rutland ! Port Huron Niagara Falls ! Brunswick Grand Rapids ! ! ! Pan Am MILWAUKEE ! Pontiac Hoffmans Metra Albany ! BOSTON ! CHICAGO ! Springfield Conrail Metro- ! CLEVELAND MBTA SALT LAKE CITY North PITTSBURGH ! ! NEW YORK ! INDIANAPOLIS Harrisburg ! KANSAS CITY ! PHILADELPHIA DENVER ! ! BALTIMORE SACRAMENTO Charlottesville WASHINGTON ST. LOUIS ! Richmond OAKLAND ! Petersburg ! Buckingham ! Newport News Norfolk NMRX Branch ! Oklahoma City ! Bakersfield ! MEMPHIS SCRRA ALBUQUERQUE ! ! LOS ANGELES ATLANTA SCRRA / BNSF / SDN DALLAS ! FT. WORTH SAN DIEGO HOUSTON ! JACKSONVILLE ! NEW ORLEANS SAN ANTONIO Railroads TAMPA! Amtrak (incl. Leased) Norfolk Southern FDOT ! MIAMI Union Pacific Canadian Pacific BNSF Canadian National CSXT Other Railroads 4| Amtrak Amtrak’s Host Railroads ! MONTREAL Amtrak NEC Route System
    [Show full text]
  • Summary of the 2018 – 2022 Corporate Plan and 2018 Operating and Capital Budgets
    p SUMMARY OF THE 2018 – 2022 CORPORATE PLAN AND 2018 OPERATING AND CAPITAL BUDGETS SUMMARY OF THE 2018-2022 CORPORATE PLAN / 1 Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................................. 5 MANDATE ...................................................................................................................................... 14 CORPORATE MISSION, OBJECTIVES, PROFILE AND GOVERNANCE ................................................... 14 2.1 Corporate Objectives and Profile ............................................................................................ 14 2.2 Governance and Accountability .............................................................................................. 14 2.2.1 Board of Directors .......................................................................................................... 14 2.2.2 Travel Policy Guidelines and Reporting ........................................................................... 17 2.2.3 Audit Regime .................................................................................................................. 17 2.2.4 Office of the Auditor General: Special Examination Results ............................................. 17 2.2.5 Canada Transportation Act Review ................................................................................. 18 2.3 Overview of VIA Rail’s Business .............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • RIDE Magazine | May 2014 1 DESTINATION for a LIFETIME
    RIDE Magazine | May 2014 1 DESTINATION for a LIFETIME 2175 Potomac River Blvd., Potomac Shores, VA 22026 | Toll-free 855.808.6051 | PotomacShores.com Features and products vary by community. Price, offers, financing and availability are subject to change without notice. See a Sales and Marketing Representative for details. RIDE Magazine | May 2014 3 VRE HOSTS OLI AT QUANTICO FOR THEIR “SEE TRACKS, THINK TRAIN” CAMPAIGN FROM THE CEO DOUG ALLEN 7 Chief Executive Officer recently attended a meeting in New York City held for leaders of commuter railroads where Federal Railroad Administrator Joseph Szabo CONTENTS discussed the importance of safety as a way of life in all facets of our RIDE MAGAZINE | MAY 2014 Iindustry. As I was sitting in the meeting, I was heartened to be surround- ed by my colleagues who all seemed to understand, as I do, how important safety is in our business how important it is to aggressively pursue a deeply | rooted culture of safety. 04 95 EXPRESS LANES EDUCATIONAL CAMPAIGN Although commuter rail boasts an exceptional safety record, we at TRAVELERS ENCOURAGED TO “MAKE A PLAN” TO VRE do not accept that record as an invitation to be complacent about our PREPARE FOR NEW TRANSPORTATION OPTION shared responsibility with you to make your ride as safe as possible. I expect and empower each VRE and Keolis employee to always be mindful of any | VRE OPERATIONS BOARD MEMBER 05 situation that would affect their or your safety as we work diligently every MEET SUHAS NADDONI day to assure you arrive safely to your destination.
    [Show full text]
  • CP's North American Rail
    2020_CP_NetworkMap_Large_Front_1.6_Final_LowRes.pdf 1 6/5/2020 8:24:47 AM 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Lake CP Railway Mileage Between Cities Rail Industry Index Legend Athabasca AGR Alabama & Gulf Coast Railway ETR Essex Terminal Railway MNRR Minnesota Commercial Railway TCWR Twin Cities & Western Railroad CP Average scale y y y a AMTK Amtrak EXO EXO MRL Montana Rail Link Inc TPLC Toronto Port Lands Company t t y i i er e C on C r v APD Albany Port Railroad FEC Florida East Coast Railway NBR Northern & Bergen Railroad TPW Toledo, Peoria & Western Railway t oon y o ork éal t y t r 0 100 200 300 km r er Y a n t APM Montreal Port Authority FLR Fife Lake Railway NBSR New Brunswick Southern Railway TRR Torch River Rail CP trackage, haulage and commercial rights oit ago r k tland c ding on xico w r r r uébec innipeg Fort Nelson é APNC Appanoose County Community Railroad FMR Forty Mile Railroad NCR Nipissing Central Railway UP Union Pacic e ansas hi alga ancou egina as o dmon hunder B o o Q Det E F K M Minneapolis Mon Mont N Alba Buffalo C C P R Saint John S T T V W APR Alberta Prairie Railway Excursions GEXR Goderich-Exeter Railway NECR New England Central Railroad VAEX Vale Railway CP principal shortline connections Albany 689 2622 1092 792 2636 2702 1574 3518 1517 2965 234 147 3528 412 2150 691 2272 1373 552 3253 1792 BCR The British Columbia Railway Company GFR Grand Forks Railway NJT New Jersey Transit Rail Operations VIA Via Rail A BCRY Barrie-Collingwood Railway GJR Guelph Junction Railway NLR Northern Light Rail VTR
    [Show full text]
  • Baker & Miller Pllc
    301783 ENTERED BAKER & MILLER PLLC Office of Proceedings March 19 2021 Part of 2401 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE, NW S U I T E 3 0 0 Public Record WASHINGTON, DC 20037 ( 2 0 2 ) 6 6 3 - 7 8 2 0 ( 2 0 2 ) 6 6 3 - 7 8 4 9 William A. Mullins Direct Dial: (202) 663 - 7 8 2 3 E - M a i l : [email protected] March 19, 2021 VIA E-FILING Ms. Cynthia T. Brown Chief, Section of Administration Office of Proceedings Surface Transportation Board 395 E Street, S.W., Room 1034 Washington, DC 20423-0001 Re: FD 36472 CSX Corporation and CSX Transportation, Inc. – Control and Merger – Pan Am Systems, Inc., Pan Am Railways, Inc., Boston & Maine Corporation, Maine Central Railroad Company, Northern Railroad, Pan Am Southern LLC, Portland Terminal Company, Springfield Terminal Railway Company, Stony Brook Railroad Company, and Vermont & Massachusetts Railroad Company FD 36472 (Sub-No. 5) Pittsburg & Shawmut Railroad, LLC d/b/a Berkshire & Eastern Railroad – Operation of Property of Rail Carrier Pan Am Southern LLC – Pan Am Southern LLC and Springfield Terminal Railway Company Reply Comments of Norfolk Southern Railway Company Dear Ms. Brown: Norfolk Southern Railway Company (“NSR”) hereby submits the following comments in reply to the Application (the “Application”) filed by CSX Corporation (“CSX”) and CSX Transportation, Inc. (“CSXT”) (collectively, the “Applicants”). NSR supports the proposed transaction as submitted. Baker & Miller PLLC Ms. Cynthia T. Brown March 19, 2021 Page 2 of 4 NSR initially had some concerns about possible adverse anticompetitive effects that would arise from an unconditioned transaction,1 but CSXT and NSR have discussed and worked through those concerns.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix 6-B: Chronology of Amtrak Service in Wisconsin
    Appendix 6-B: Chronology of Amtrak Service in Wisconsin May 1971: As part of its inaugural system, Amtrak operates five daily round trips in the Chicago- Milwaukee corridor over the Milwaukee Road main line. Four of these round trips are trains running exclusively between Chicago’s Union Station and Milwaukee’s Station, with an intermediate stop in Glenview, IL. The fifth round trip is the Chicago-Milwaukee segment of Amtrak’s long-distance train to the West Coast via St. Paul, northern North Dakota (e.g. Minot), northern Montana (e.g. Glacier National Park) and Spokane. Amtrak Route Train Name(s) Train Frequency Intermediate Station Stops Serving Wisconsin (Round Trips) Chicago-Milwaukee Unnamed 4 daily Glenview Chicago-Seattle Empire Builder 1 daily Glenview, Milwaukee, Columbus, Portage, Wisconsin Dells, Tomah, La Crosse, Winona, Red Wing, Minneapolis June 1971: Amtrak maintains five daily round trips in the Chicago-Milwaukee corridor and adds tri- weekly service from Chicago to Seattle via St. Paul, southern North Dakota (e.g. Bismark), southern Montana (e.g. Bozeman and Missoula) and Spokane. Amtrak Route Train Name(s) Train Frequency Intermediate Station Stops Serving Wisconsin (Round Trips) Chicago-Milwaukee Unnamed 4 daily Glenview Chicago-Seattle Empire Builder 1 daily Glenview, Milwaukee, Columbus, Portage, Wisconsin Dells, Tomah, La Crosse, Winona, Red Wing, Minneapolis Chicago-Seattle North Coast Tri-weekly Glenview, Milwaukee, Columbus, Portage, Wisconsin Hiawatha Dells, Tomah, La Crosse, Winona, Red Wing, Minneapolis 6B-1 November 1971: Daily round trip service in the Chicago-Milwaukee corridor is increased from five to seven as Amtrak adds service from Milwaukee to St.
    [Show full text]
  • Virginia Railway Express
    VIRGINIA RAILWAY EXPRESS ADDING CAPACITY IN CORRIDORS OF STATEWIDE SIGNIFICANCE (COSS) Commonwealth Transportation Board July 28, 2016 Doug Allen Chief Executive Officer Virginia Railway Express 1 WHO WE ARE Commuter rail 2 Commissions, 9 Jurisdictions Safe, Reliable, High Customer Satisfaction 4.5 million riders per year 2 On a typical weekday VRE draws ridership from 39 Virginia Jurisdictions 3 Source: 2015 Virginia Railway Express Master Agreement Survey WHAT WE DO We add peak capacity… Currently 5,400 peak seats/hour …in corridors of statewide significance… I-66, I-95 & I-395 …for longer-distance commuters… Travelers that would otherwise drive on highways* …using non-highway rights-of-way CSXT, NS & Amtrak 4 * Source: Texas A&M Transportation Institute Congestion Relief Provided by Virginia Railway Express VDOT EFFORTS …I-95/395 Express Lanes… Opened in 2014, south/north extensions in 2018 … I-66 inside beltway… Complete in 2020 …I-66 outside the beltway… Two Express lanes/direction open in 2020 … total value… $2.5B 5 VRE BENEFITS TO CoSS “…contribution to congestion relief is significant…” “…much greater congestion benefit in the evening peak period…” “…contributes to a delay reduction of between 8 and 18%...” 6 Full TTI report available at http://www.vre.org/about/studies-and-reports/ VRE BENEFITS TO CoSS “…[VRE] provides capacity for about 5,000 persons per hour…” “…would require adding at least one freeway lane in each direction in both VRE corridors…” “…total estimated construction cost required to provide [freeway] capacity to carry VRE passengers is over $1 billion.” 7 Full TTI report available at http://www.vre.org/about/studies-and-reports/ VRE SYSTEM PLAN 2040 .
    [Show full text]
  • Rail Plan 2005 - 2006
    Kansas Department of Transportation Rail Plan 2005 - 2006 Kathleen Sebelius, Governor Debra L. Miller, Secretary of Transportation Kansas Department of Transportation Division of Planning and Development Bureau of Transportation Planning – Office of Rail Affairs Kansas Rail Plan Update 2005 - 2006 Kansas Department of Transportation Division of Planning and Development Bureau of Transportation Planning Office of Rail Affairs Dwight D. Eisenhower State Office Building 700 SW Harrison Street, Second Floor Tower Topeka, Kansas 66603-3754 Telephone: (785) 296-3841 Fax: (785) 296-0963 Debra L. Miller, Secretary of Transportation Terry Heidner, Division of Planning and Development Director Chris Herrick, Chief of Transportation Planning Bureau John Jay Rosacker, Assistant Chief Transportation Planning Bureau ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Prepared by CONTRIBUTORS Office of Rail Affairs Staff John W. Maddox, CPM, Rail Affairs Program Manager Darlene K. Osterhaus, Rail Affairs Research Analyst Edward Dawson, Rail Affairs Research Analyst Paul Ahlenius, P.E., Rail Affairs Engineer Bureau of Transportation Planning Staff John Jay Rosacker, Assistant Chief Transportation Planning Bureau Carl Gile, Decision Mapping Technician Specialist OFFICE OF RAIL AFFAIRS WEB SITE http://www.ksdot.org/burRail/Rail/default.asp Pictures provided by railroads or taken by Office of Rail Affairs staff Railroad data and statistics provided by railroads 1 Executive Summary The Kansas Rail Plan Update 2005 - 2006 has Transportation Act (49 U.S.C. 1654 et seg). Financial been prepared in accordance with requirements of the assistance in the form of Federal Rail Administration Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) U.S. Department (FRA) grants has been used to fund rehabilitation of Transportation (USDOT), as set forth in federal projects throughout Kansas.
    [Show full text]
  • The Virginia Railway Express 2040 System Plan Review Report
    REPORT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF RAIL AND PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION The Virginia Railway Express 2040 System Plan Review Report TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF VIRGINIA HOUSE DOCUMENT NO. COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA RICHMOND 2016 VRE 2040 System Plan Review Final Report December 2016 December 7, 2016 The Honorable Aubrey L. Layne, Jr. Secretary of Transportation Post Office Box 1475 Richmond, Virginia 23218 The Honorable Chris S. Jones, Chairman House Appropriations Committee General Assembly Building, Room 948 Richmond, Virginia 23219 The Honorable Thomas K. Norment, Co‐Chair Senate Finance Committee General Assembly Building, Room 626 Richmond, Virginia 23219 The Honorable Emmett W. Hanger, Co‐Chair Senate Finance Committee General Assembly Building, Room 326 Richmond, Virginia 23219 The Honorable Ronald A. Villanueva, Chairman House Transportation Committee General Assembly Building, Room 503 Richmond, Virginia 23219 The Honorable Charles W. Carrico, Chairman Senate Transportation Committee General Assembly Building, Room 330 Richmond, Virginia 23219 Dear Chairmen, Attached for your review is the requested report as required by Item 436 Subsection N of the 2016 Acts of Assembly. It directs the Commonwealth Transportation Board’s rail subcommittee to: “. .review the long range service plan and financial analysis of Virginia Railway Express and assess the conclusions of that analysis with respect to the long‐term financial viability of the service, their ability to maintain appropriately costed‐services to maintain and expand market share, and the Virginia
    [Show full text]
  • Accessible Transportation Options for People with Disabilities and Senior Citizens
    Accessible Transportation Options for People with Disabilities and Senior Citizens In the Washington, D.C. Metropolitan Area JANUARY 2017 Transfer Station Station Features Red Line • Glenmont / Shady Grove Bus to Airport System Orange Line • New Carrollton / Vienna Parking Station Legend Blue Line • Franconia-Springfield / Largo Town Center in Service Map Hospital Under Construction Green Line • Branch Ave / Greenbelt Airport Full-Time Service wmata.com Yellow Line • Huntington / Fort Totten Customer Information Service: 202-637-7000 Connecting Rail Systems Rush-Only Service: Monday-Friday Silver Line • Wiehle-Reston East / Largo Town Center TTY Phone: 202-962-2033 6:30am - 9:00am 3:30pm - 6:00pm Metro Transit Police: 202-962-2121 Glenmont Wheaton Montgomery Co Prince George’s Co Shady Grove Forest Glen Rockville Silver Spring Twinbrook B30 to Greenbelt BWI White Flint Montgomery Co District of Columbia College Park-U of Md Grosvenor - Strathmore Georgia Ave-Petworth Takoma Prince George’s Plaza Medical Center West Hyattsville Bethesda Fort Totten Friendship Heights Tenleytown-AU Prince George’s Co Van Ness-UDC District of Columbia Cleveland Park Columbia Heights Woodley Park Zoo/Adams Morgan U St Brookland-CUA African-Amer Civil Dupont Circle War Mem’l/Cardozo Farragut North Shaw-Howard U Rhode Island Ave Brentwood Wiehle-Reston East Spring Hill McPherson Mt Vernon Sq NoMa-Gallaudet U New Carrollton Sq 7th St-Convention Center Greensboro Fairfax Co Landover Arlington Co Tysons Corner Gallery Place Union Station Chinatown Cheverly 5A to
    [Show full text]
  • Railroad Engineering 101 Session 38
    Creating Value … … Providing Solutions Railroad Engineering 101 Session 38 Tuesday, February 19, 2013 Presented by: David Wilcock Railroad Engineering 101 . Outline . Overview of the Railroad . Track . Bridges . Signal Systems . Railroad Operations . Federal Railroad Administration . American Railway Engineering and Maintenance Association Railroad Engineering 101 . Overview of the Railroad . Classifications (Types) – Private – Common Carrier . Classifications (Function) – Line Haul – Switching – Belt Line – Terminal Railroad Engineering 101 . Overview of the Railroad . Classifications (Operating Revenues) – Class 1: $250 M or more – Class 2: $20.5 M - $249.9 M – Class 3: Less than $20 M . Classifications (Association of American Railroads Types) – Class I: $250 M or more – Regional: 350 miles or more; $40 M or more – Local – Switching and Terminal Railroad Engineering 101 . Overview of the Railroad . Class 1 Railroads – North America – BNSF – Canadian National – Canadian Pacific – CSX – Ferromex – Kansas City Southern – KCS de Mexico – Norfolk Southern – Union Pacific – Amtrak – VIA Rail Railroad Engineering 101 . Overview of the Railroad . Organization of a Railroad – Transportation » Train & Engine Crews » Dispatching » Operations – Engineering » All Right of Way Engineering – Mechanical » Equipment Maintenance – Marketing Railroad Engineering 101 . Overview of the Railroad . Equipment - Locomotives – All Units rated by Horsepower – Horsepower is converted to Tractive Effort to propel locomotive – Types: » Electric – Pantograph trolley or third rail shoe » Diesel-Electric – self contained electric power plant » Dual Mode – Can use either electric or diesel Railroad Engineering 101 . Overview of the Railroad . Equipment - Freight Cars – Boxcar – Flatcar – Gondola – Covered Hopper – Coal Hopper – Tank Car – Auto Racks – Container “Tubs or Boats” Railroad Engineering 101 . Overview of the Railroad . Resistance – Resistance is important especially for freight operations as they are dealing with heavy loads.
    [Show full text]
  • No. 09-1212 in the NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY
    No. 09-1212 IN THE NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY, Petitioner, BILLY GROVES, individually, d.b.a. Savannah Re-Load, SAVANNAH RE-LOAD, and BRAMPTON ENTERPRISES, LLC, d.b.a. Savannah Re-Load, Respondents. ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT REPLY BRIEF PAUL D. KEENAN KEENAN COHEN & HOWARD P.C. One Pitcairn Place 165 Township Line Road Suite 2400 Jenkintown, PA 19046-3535 (215) 609-1110 [email protected] Attorney for Petitioner COUNSEt PRESS (800) 274-3321 . (800) 359-6859 Blank Page CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT Petitioner’s Corporate Disclosure Statement was set forth at page iii of its Petition for a Writ of Certiorari, and there are no amendments to that Statement. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT .. i TABLE OF CONTENTS .................... ii TABLE OF CITED AUTHORITIES .........111 INTRODUCTION .......................... 1 ARGUMENT ............................... 2 Brampton’s Response Rejects the Eleventh Circuit’s Recognition of a Conflict Among the Third, Seventh, and Eleventh Circuits ..................... 2 Bo Brampton’s Response Minimizes the Adverse Impact of the Eleventh Circuit’s Ruling on the National Freight Rail Network ............................. 6 Brampton’s Argument Relating to Primary Jurisdiction Fails to Address the Eleventh Circuit’s Encroachment Upon the STB’s Exclusive Jurisdiction Regarding Interpretation of Tariff Provisions ............................ 8 Do The Eleventh Circuit’s Decision Imposes an Unclear and Unworkable Rule Upon the Interstate Rail Network ........... 10 CONCLUSION ............................. 13 TABLE OF CITED AUTHORITIES Page CASES Capitol Materials, Inc. - Petition for Declaratory Order - Certain Rates and Practices of Norfolk Southern Railway Company, 2004 STB LEXIS 227, STB Docket No.
    [Show full text]