ANTHRO-AT-LARGE Bulletin of the Federation of Small Anthropology Programs (Formerly FOSAP Newsletter)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ANTHRO-AT-LARGE Bulletin of the Federation of Small Anthropology Programs (Formerly FOSAP Newsletter) Volume 12, Number 1 Spring 2005 Co-Chairs Report: Minutes of the FOSAP Business academic positions: placing departmental job ads in Meeting at the 103rd AAA meetings the AN, and electronically, as well as providing a Atlanta, Georgia, Dec. 17, 2004 booth at the national meetings for interviewing. In attendance: Kathleen noted that AAA offers to community Matthew Amster, Gettysburg College, colleges a modified and lower cost ($100) plan than Clare Boulanger, Mesa State College, “regular” departments. For this fee, they can use the Cate Cameron, Cedar Crest College, AAA list serve and they get a discount on ads. She is Mike Coggeshall, Clemson University, willing to consider a fee reduction to small programs Pam Frese, College of Wooster, and, as importantly, adapt the timing of signing up for John Gatewood, Lehigh University, DSP to later in the summer. She said the current Jen Jones, University of Minnesota – Duluth, cost to non-community colleges is $250. She asked John Lowe, Cultural Analysis Group, FOSAP to generate a reasonable estimate for its Bob Myers, Alfred University, members. John Rhoades, St. John Fisher College The DPS budget is already set for 2005, but she The meeting was attended by 10 people, an will take our requests to the AAA for 2006. FOSAP exceptional turnout given the low attendance overall is willing to establish a policy with the AAA on DSP at the AAA. The meeting was brought to order at regarding the appropriate fee, application date, and 6:30 by the co-chairs, Bob Myers and Cate Cameron. the best kind of modified service, but needs some Minutes from 2003 were approved as amended. Cate feedback from members on this. [Please send and Bob reported on the 2004 GAD Board Meeting on comments to the c-chairs: Cate Cameron Thursday December 16, 2004: Cate reported that [email protected], or Bob Myers GAD members approved $800 for two issues of the [email protected].] FOSAP Newsletter and $400 for travel to regional Discussion of materials to advertise anthropology: meetings. Kathleen was asked if the AAA has any recent This year, John Rhoades invited Kathleen Terry- materials in the form of brochures or posters that Sharp of program services at the AAA to the would be useful for promoting anthropology as an business meeting to talk about how the AAA could undergraduate major or minor. She said that the better serve small programs. There was discussion of AAA does not have much recent material, but would two topics: How the Departmental Services Program be willing to produce print material, which could then (DSP) of the AAA could be better adapted to those be distributed as requested. Because her department of us in small programs; and, Whether the AAA could is under-staffed, she asked if AAA members could generate materials that would help advertise generate the content for brochures or posters. anthropology as a major and minor for small (and Posters or highly appealing visual material should be large programs). developed which explain “What is Anthropology?” and Discussion of Departmental Services Program: “What are job opportunities for an anthropology The AAA advertises Departmental Services major?” Marketing our discipline ought to be one of Program (DSP) to departments for a variety of the high priority roles of the AAA-DPS. FOSAP can functions. Its main use seems to be for advertising help co-ordinate the effort, to some extent. If you have produced materials that would be useful to secretary next year. Paul and John graciously agreed others or are willing to put together some text and to continue the newsletter. images, or generally, have some ideas for the The name of the newsletter was changed to marketing of anthropology, contact Kathleen Terry- Anthro-at-Large Sharp or the FOSAP co-chairs, Myers and Cameron. Bulletin of the Federation of Small Anthropology [Ed. note: Kathleen has reported that many Programs. suggestions have been received and to keep them Respectfully submitted, coming. Bob Myers and Cate Cameron Brainstorming ensued. Some suggestions: Compiling quotes from famous people who majored in anthropology would be an eye-catching, effective way ¨¨ to market anthropology. FOSAP members are BEYOND THE EXOTIC OTHER: POPULAR requested to send in names, quotes and suggestions CULTURE AND CRITICAL THINKING IN to the DSP (for example, Michael Crichton, Jon TEACHING ANTHROPOLOGY Krakaur, Kurt Vonnegut, George Lucas, etc). Organizers: Paul Grebinger (RIT) and Bob Myers Kathleen left the meeting and new matters were (Alfred) discussed. Those present considered how to publicize Chair: Bob Myers (Alfred) what FOSAP does. FOSAP members could represent Those of us who teach service courses for students and publicize the committee at regional meetings. committed to careers in technology and business, The committee should have a plan for how to do this. often find it easier to engage them in the critical It was discussed that perhaps Mike Coggeshall could insights of anthropology through use of popular represent FOSAP at the Southern Meetings and Cate culture. Many of us have found, and research with Cameron and John Gatewood might attend the student audiences demonstra tes, that anthropological Northeastern meetings. documentaries often reinforce negative stereotypes Suggestions for panels for the AAA in DC in 2005: about “the exotic other,” especially if there is [These were suggestions, not necessarily offers to insufficient context for understanding the subjects organize. Organizers are requested to step forward as fellow humans. In getting beyond the exotic other for 2005 or 2006] through popular culture we are able to engage Clare Boulanger students on what they regard as their own turf. This ?Strategies of Survival for Small Departments. panel was catalyzed by the discussions emerging from ?How to Create a Major the Committee on Teaching (GAD) Teaching Cate Cameron and John Gatewood: Roundtable at AAA Chicago, 2003. When AAA San ?Anthropology Field School Experiences; Francisco 2004 was rescheduled in Atlanta, we ?Institutional Review Boards in Anthropology. decided to go forward with the panel, nevertheless. John Rhoades: Panelists Michael Billig and Karen Porter and ?Workshop on Student Outcomes Assessment Discussants Conrad Kottak and David McCurdy were (the one from this year which was cancelled) unable to attend. Three of us presented our papers, John Gatewood: and we read Billig’s in his absence. In lieu of ?How to Market Anthropology prepared discussion, we opened dialog with the ?How to create a brochure for anthropology audience of thirty. There was lively exchange and a majors. feeling among several of us that such open discussion Jen Jones and John Rhoades: should be a regular feature of sessions at the AAA ?Creative Labs in Small Spaces Annual Meetings. The papers presented in this issue Bob Mye4rs and Paul Grebinger): of “Anthro-at-Large” have been edited to meet ?Among Our Exotic Selves: Teaching and constraints of space. Where large segments of text Reflexivity for Usan Students have been deleted, the deletion is indicated by Offices were discussed. ellipsis. Contact information is provided for readers Cate will contact Peter Peregrine to see if he will who would like the full text of these papers, or to continue as secretary this year and consider serving engage in dialog about the topics discussed. as chair or co-chair next year [ed note: Peter told Cate he is willing]. Jen Jones agreed to serve as ¨ American Pie: Good To Eat, Good To Think? Similarly, teen sex comedies are often referred to as Clare L. Boulanger (Mesa State) “formula pictures”—but what is a formula in this Professors who teach courses on Usan culture instance if not an arrangement of what Lévi-Strauss know how difficult it is to exoticize the familiar. (1963: 211) has called “mythemes”? Even Lévi- Usan college students are frequently aware there is Strauss might blanch at the prospect of analyzing the such a thing as ethnocentrism, but they recognize it structure of an Usan teen sex comedy. I do not only in its obvious manifestations, which they are carry out my analysis with the aim of pleasing the often careful to avoid, at least in an anthropology Master, but merely to convince Usan students that class. But ethnocentrism is a powerful aspect of they are immersed in myth, and that myth in the habitus, à la Bourdieu (e.g., 1977)—one does not have United States, no less than in ancient Greece or the to pronounce one’s own way of life correct and all modern First Na tions of Canada, fashions and others wrong to feel profoundly uncomfortable when continuously supports a version of reality for its an unfamiliar language is spoken or an unfamiliar food devotees. served. One extraordinary aspect of Usan The film I analyze for my US culture course is ethnocentrism is its resilience even in the face of a American Pie, released in 1999. The uncut version I display meant to undermine it. In his introductory show in my class came out in 2000. Lévi-Strauss textbook, Robbins (2001: 21-26) deliberately lays an would claim that plot is only a framework on which to analysis of the Balinese cockfight (Geertz 1972: 1- hang mythemes, but the average Usan, whose tastes 37) alongside one of Usan football (Arens 1976, are oriented to plot, likely needs to know that Montague & Morais 1976), and still I have had American Pie concerns four high school seniors—Kev, students complain to me that there is really no Oz, Finch, and James—who resolve to lose their comparison to be had and they are frankly somewhat virginity before they graduate. insulted to see their favorite sport abused in this .