1, 2016 Issn 1829-3824
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ISSN 1829-3824 (), 1, 2016 EDITORIAL BOARD Honorary Chief of Ruben MIRZAKHANYAN - chancellor of the Armenian State Pedagogical University after Khachatur the Editorial Board Abovyan, honorary member of Armenian Philosophical Academy, doctor of sciences (in history), profes- sor Editor-in-Chief Hasmik HOVHANNISYAN - doctor of sciences (in philosophy), full member of the Armenian Philosophical Academy, chairperson of the Philosophy and Logic Department at Armenian State Pedagogical University after Khachatur Abovyan, scientific general secretary of International Academy for Philosophy Phone: +374 10 597 065 E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] Associate Editor Hovhannes HOVHANNISYAN - PhD in philosophy, associate professor of the Philosophy and Logic De- partment at Armenian State Pedagogical University after Khachatur Abovyan and YSU, scientific general secretary of the Armenian Philosophical Academy, head of the Chair of Humanities and Social Sciences at French University of Armenia, chairman of the Committee of Civil Society Development of Public Council of RA Advisory Editors Eduard DANIELYAN - head of the Ancient History Department at the Institute of History and Archeology of NAS RA, doctor of sciences (in history), professor Srbuhi GEVORGYAN - vice chancellor education quality and distant learning of the Armenian State Peda- gogical University after Khachatur Abovyan, full member of Armenian Philosophical Academy, doctor of sciences (in psychology), professor Hasmik HOVHANNISYAN - professor of philosophy at Armenian State Pedagogical University after Khachatur Abovyan Peter KEMP - professor of the Department of Education at the University of Aarhus (Denmark), head of the Centre of Ethics and Law, member of the International Academy for Philosophy Hans KÖCHLER - professor (em.) of Philosophy, University of Innsbruck (Austria), president of the Inter- national Progress Organization, co-president of the International Academy for Philosophy Armen T. MARSOOBIAN - professor and the chairperson of the Philosophy Department at Southern Con- necticut State University, New Haven (USA), editor-in-chief of the journal Metaphilosophy Karen MOMJYAN - head of the Chair of Social Philosophy at the Moscow State University, doctor of sci- ences (philosophy), professor Yevangelos MOUTSOPOULOS - honorary rector of the University of Athens, doctor of sciences (in philos- ophy), academician Kadzhik OHANYAN - professor of the Chair of Sociology at the Saint Petersburg State University of Eco- nomics, foreign member of the Armenian Philosophical Academy, doctor of sciences (in philosophy) Barry STROUD - Willis S. and Marion Slusser professor of philosophy, University of California (USA), Berkeley, co-president of the International Academy for Philosophy Vyacheslav STYOPIN - Doctor of philosophy, professor, full member of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Honorary director of the Institute of philosophy, Russian Academy of Sciences Arkadiy URSUL - director of the Center of Global Studies, professor of the Faculty of Global Processes at the Russian State University after Mikhail Lomonosov, founder and honorary president of the Russian Academy of Cosmonautics after Konstantin Tsiolkovsky, academician of the Academy of Sciences of Mol- dova, president of the International Academy of Noosphere - MANUR, member of the International Academy for Philosophy, head of the Department of Ecology and Environmental Management Branch Russian Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation, doctor of sci- ences (in philosophy) Igor ZASLAVSKI - corresponding member of NAS RA, full member of Armenian Philosophical Academy, doctor of sciences (in physics and mathematics) Managing Editor Ashot GEVORGYAN - associate professor of the Philosophy and Logic Department at Armenian State Pedagogical University after Khachatur Abovyan, PhD in philosophy Book Review Editor Robert DJIDJIAN - professor of the Philosophy and Logic Department at Armenian State Pedagogical Uni- versity after Khachatur Abovyan, academician of International Academy for Philosophy, doctor of scienc- es (in philosophy) Literary Editors John MASON - professor of Hollins University (USA) Tigran MIKAELYAN - PhD in philology, dean of the Faculty of Foreign Languages of Armenian State Peda- gogical University after Khachatur Abovyan Marie-Luisa FRICK - professor of the Department of Philosophy of Innsbruck University, doctor of scienc- es (in philosophy) Editorial Assistant Satenik KUZANYAN - PhD student of the Philosophy and Logic Department at Armenian State Pedagogi- cal University after Khachatur Abovyan, specialist of the same department S C I E N T I F I C J O U R N A L Published by the Decision of the Scientific Board of Armenian State Pedagogical University after Khachatur Abovyan DEPARTMENT OF PHILOSOPHY AND LOGIC W I S D O M 1, 2 0 1 6 YEREVAN – 2016 WISDOM CONTENT EDITORS’ FOREWORD 4 EPISTEMOLOGY, PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, METAPHILOSOPHY, ARGUMENTATION Ana BAZAC 6 The Concept of Social Progress: an Epistemological Moment Robert DJIDJIAN 16 Transformational Logic and Social Transformation Ashot GALSTYAN Epistemological-Motivational Bases of Literary Non-Fiction Genre as Factors Determining the Lin- 21 guistic Structure of Text Ashot GEVORGYAN 29 Advanced Scientometric Databases as an Objective Criterion of Scientific Activities Ernest GRIGORIAN 33 Science and Religion Haig KHATCHADOURIAN 46 The New Design Argument and God Hans KÖCHLER 67 Culture and World Order SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY, SOCIOLOGY Sergey DAVYDOV 72 The Chief and his Sacral Power Hovhannes HOVHANNISYAN, Hasmik HOVHANNISYAN, Astghik PETROSYAN Peculiarities of the Perception of the Phenomenon of the Armenian Genocide on Public Opinion 79 (Comparative Analysis of Sociological Survey Results) Karina OGANYAN Ideological Intersections of Personality’s Analysis in Armenian and Russian Social-Philosophical 87 Thought Will POGHOSYAN 94 The Shy Stalinism Torsten J. SELCK, Lilit BAGHDASARYAN 101 Fractionalization of Unrecognized States in Europe CHAIR OF YOUNG SCIENTIST Bagrat BAGRATYAN The Principle of Separation of Powers in Political Science 108 2 1(6), 2016 2 WISDOM Mane KHACHIBABYAN 118 Modernism and Feminism Representations of Women in Modernist Art and Literature Lilit MELIKYAN 125 Philosophical Foundations of Second Language Acquisition Nelli PETROSYAN 131 Saint Gregory the Illuminator and Canons of Nicene Ecumenical Council IN MEMORIAM Haig KHATCHADOURIAN 136 INSTRUCTIONS FOR AUTHORS 139 THE AUTHORS 142 3 3 1(6), 2016 EDITORS' FOREWORD EDITORS’ FOREWORD EDITORS’ FOREWORD Armenian State Pedagogical University after papers of young researchers to the wide scientific Armenian State Pedagogical University after papers of young researchers to the wide scientific Khachatur Abovyan and the Editorial Board of the community. Khachaturjournal Abovyan “Wisdom” and present the Editorial to the Board scientific of the co m- community.“Wisdom” expands its indexes of availability journalmunity “Wisdom” the current present – sixth to issue.the scientific com- to“Wisdom” the scientific expands community its indexes and of representationavailability munity theThe current current – sixthvolume issue. includes four sections to thethroughout scientific international community electronicand representation platforms. whichThe current comprise volume articles includes devoted four to Metaphiloso sections - throughoutWe internationalhave been involved electronic in platforms.the list of scien- whichphy, comprise Philosophy articles of devotedScience toand Metaphiloso Epistemology- , tificWe periodicalshave been recognized involved in by the the list Supreme of scie n-Certi- phy,Social Philosophy Philosophy, of Science Issues ofand Social Epistemology Transformati, - tific fyingperiodicals Commission recognized of theby theRepublic Supreme of CertArmeniai- Socialons Philosophy, and Progress. Issues of Social Transformati- fyingamong Commission other rated of the periodicals Republic that of addressArmenia fu n- ons and Progress.Both in December 2015 and February 2016, amongdamental other ratedresults periodicals and theses that ofaddress dissertations fun- World’sBoth in philosophicalDecember 2015 community and February suffered 2016, two damental(Doctor results of Science and andtheses Ph.D. of degreedissertations dissert a- World’slosses philosophical of Armenian communityphilosophers: suffered the founder two of (Doctortions). of “Wisdom” Science and is registered Ph.D. degree in Scientific dissert Ia-ndex- lossesInternational of Armenian Academy philosophers: for Philosophy, the founder Founder of - tions).ing “Wisdom”Services (SIS), is registered Journal Impact in Scientific Factor I nde(JIF),x- Eur- InternationalEditor-in- chiefAcademy of “Wisdom”, for Philosophy, Academician Founder Georg- ing Servicesasian Scientific (SIS), Journal Journal Impact Index Factor (ESJI), (JIF), Scientific Eur- EditorBrutian,-in-chief and of member“Wisdom”, of AcademicianInternational GeorgAcademy asianJournal Scientific Impact Journal Factor Index(SJIF), (ESJI),International Scientific Scie n- Brutian,for Philosophy,and member Professor of International Haig Khatchadourian Academy Journaltific ImpactIndexing Factor (ISI), European(SJIF), International Reference ScieIndexn- for for wPhilosophy,ho also had Professor significant Haig contribution Khatchadourian to the pu b- tific theIndexing Humanities (ISI), European and Social Reference Sciences Index(ERIH forPLUS), wholication also had of significantthe journal contribution