Gravitational Microlensing by Exoplanets and Exomoons
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INTERNATIONAL SPACE SCIENCE INSTITUTE SPATIUM Published by the Association Pro ISSI No. 45, May 2020 Gravitational Microlensing by Exoplanets and Exomoons 200216_Spatium_45_2020_(001_016).indd 1 16.05.20 11:11 Editorial Since Copernicus (1473–1543) was world view abruptly. They seemed not able to measure brightness not to be inhabited as previously Impressum variations of the stars due to Earth’s assumed, and life appeared not to revolutionary motion around the be a matter of course. Astrophys- Sun, he inferred that stars must be ics and interdisciplinary science ISSN 2297–5888 (Print) very far away from Earth. During recognised the very special condi- ISSN 2297–590X (Online) the 16th and 17th Centuries schol- tions required to create life. More- ars began gradually to realise that over, these conditions need to be Spatium the Universe, i.e., the sphere of very selective and restricting, de- Published by the fixed stars enclosing our Solar pending not only on physical and Association Pro ISSI System, might not be finite but chemical parameters but particu- infinite. Philosophical arguments larly on stable and stabilising hab- by Thomas Digges (1546–1595) or itable environments in space and Giordano Bruno (1548–1600) sup- on ground. ported this view. Galileo (1564– Today, the existence of extra-ter- Association Pro ISSI 1642) provided evidence from ob- restrial life seems to be quite likely Hallerstrasse 6, CH-3012 Bern servations of the Milky Way using for statistical reasons. However, it Phone +41 (0)31 631 48 96 his telescope. is very hard to find evidence from see In his Cosmotheoros posthumously bio-markers identified in exoplan- www.issibern.ch/pro-issi.html published in 1698, Christiaan Huy- etary spectra as long as it is not clear for the whole Spatium series gens (1629–1695) estimated the dis- what life actually is. Furthermore, tances to the fixed stars by compar- our Solar System and particularly President ing the apparent magnitudes of the our Earth-Moon System have a Prof. Dr. Adrian Jäggi, Sun and Sirius. He found Sirius to special history resulting from a University of Bern be 27 664 times farther away from series of very unlikely events that Earth than the Sun. Already in 1690, happened successively in an assor- Editor he speculated about the existence of tative and even choreographic way. PD Dr. Andreas Verdun planets orbiting other stars than the Thereby it is supposed that the CH-3086 Zimmerwald Sun carrying extra-terrestrial life. Moon is ascribed a critical role for He thus may be considered the the origin and evolution of life on Printing “ inventor” of extrasolar planets. Earth. Stämpf li AG During the 17th and 18th centu- The topic of this issue is based on CH-3001 Bern ries, the value of the solar parallax the talk “Exoplanets: In Search of was measured using Mars opposi- Terra-2” by Prof. Dr. Joachim tions and transits of Venus with Wambsganss held on October 31, increasing accuracy. At least since 2018, in the Pro ISSI seminar se- that time it was realised that our ries. He pointed out that gravita- solar system and the cosmos must tional microlensing takes the po- be huge. As a reaction to this “hor- tential not only to detect Earth-like ror vacui” every celestial body was exoplanets, but even Moon-like thought to be inhabited, even the exomoons. He referred to results Title Caption Sun and the stars. The “plurality published by Liebig and Wambs- Simulation of the caustic structure of the worlds” became an estab- ganss (2010), from where material (magnification pattern) resulting from lished world picture prevailing un- was used for this issue. the configuration consisting of a host til the 20th century. star (left), exoplanet (right, larger structure), and exomoon, (right, Space probes sent out to almost all Andreas Verdun smaller structure within the exo- solar system bodies demolished this Zimmerwald, December 2019 planet’s caustic structure). SPATIUM 45 2 200216_Spatium_45_2020_(001_016).indd 2 16.05.20 11:11 Gravitational Microlensing by Extrasolar Planets and Moons By Prof. Dr. Joachim Wambsganss, Astronomisches Rechen-Institut (ARI), Zentrum für Astronomie der Universität Heidelberg (ZAH) and International Space Science Institute (ISSI), Bern Light Curve bly enhance the probability for the Figure 1 presents the observational discovery of extra-terrestrial life. data of the microlensing event Anomalies The role and importance of our OGLE-2005-BLG-390 – the dis- Moon for the origin of life on covery of a cool 5.5 Earth mass Earth was analysed by Benn (2001). exo planet (Beaulieu et al. 2006). He points out five possible criteria The signal of the exoplanet is The first time an extrasolar planet that may trigger and influence the super imposed on the light curve (or exoplanet) was discovered with evolution of life: (1) stabilisation of produced by the host star, a small- the method of gravitational micro- the planet’s rotational axis, (2) amplitude blip at day 10; it is lensing was in 2004. In 2006, a elimination of primordial atmo- zoomed out in the extra diagram cool planet of 5.5 Earth masses sphere, (3) generation of the plan- on the top right side of the dia- was discovered with this method et’s magnetic field, (4) generation gram. This light curve illustrates (Figure 1, Beaulieu et al. 2006). of large tides, and (5) generation of the difficulty of the detection of Micro lensing is a very sensitive longer-period tides. These aspects exomoons. In order to be able to technique for detecting exoplanets certainly support the conditions of detect the much less significant with (projected) distances between life, so exomoons may play an es- microlensing effects caused by an roughly 0.5 and 10 AU from their sential role for the origin and evo- exomoon, tiny deviations in the host stars and with masses between lution of life on their host exo- structure of the light curve need roughly Earth mass and 10 Jupiter planets. This is why searching for to be identified, which is only pos- masses. Very frequent photometric microlensing effects through exo- sible if the resolution in time and measurements with observation moons might be an important is- photometric magnitude is much rates of about one frame per sue for the quest of extra-terrestrial higher than in this example (which 15 minutes and visual photometric life. was state of the art at the time). precision of about 20 mmag (milli- magnitudes)1 may in the future even allow to detect microlensing Figure 1: The light curve of the OGLE-2005-BLG-390 microlensing event events caused by extrasolar moons (differently coloured data points from different observatories) and best-fit model (or exomoons). This means that not plotted as a function of time. (Credit: Beaulieu et al. 2006) only the light curve of a micro- lensing host star and the deviation of this light curve caused by an exo planet have to be considered, but also anomalies superimposed on the exoplanet’s signal caused by its moon (or moons) have to be an- alysed. Simulations of convolved caustics and magnification patterns resulting from microlensing effects by exoplanets and exomoons sug- gest that massive extrasolar moons can in principle be detected. The detection of exomoons orbiting exoplanets of Earth-like masses in habitable zones would considera- 1 The (visual) brightness of a star is measured in “magnitudes”. By definition, 0 mag is the brightness of the star Vega (a Lyrae). SPATIUM 45 3 200216_Spatium_45_2020_(001_016).indd 3 16.05.20 11:11 Classical trast in brightness or magnitude planet applies to the spectroscopic between exoplanet and its host star. method. Here (projected) radial Methods In addition, such telescopes are not velocities are extracted from intended to be scheduled for sur- Doppler shifted spectral lines of to Detect vey or monitoring observation the order of a metre per second (or campaigns. smaller). To be successful, the host Extrasolar star must be bright enough in or- Planets der to produce a high enough flux Astrometry for an extremely high resolution spectrum containing a sufficient The gravitational pulls of exoplan- number of spectral lines, so that the Let us briefly summarise the ad- ets acting upon their host star force Doppler shifts can be analysed vantages and limits of the five clas- the star to move on a Keplerian or- properly. Although this method sical methods to detect exoplanets, bit around the barycentre of the was and still is very successfully in particular with respect to the exo system. If only one exoplanet used for the detection of exoplan- possibility of the detection of is present, the star’s motion is quite ets, it seems unimaginable that it exomoons. regular and can be measured (at will be able to detect exomoons: least with the Gaia satellite) if the The effect of the barycentre mo- exoplanet’s mass is of the order of tion of exoplanet plus exomoon Direct Imaging the mass of Jupiter. However, if cannot be disentangled into those more than two exoplanets are or- two components. Radial velocity By about 2025 (hopefully) three biting their host star, this motion measurements are most sensitive new ground-based optical tele- can become quite complicated. for exoplanets with very small scopes will become operational: Since the gravitational effect of an semi-major axes to their host stars The Giant Magellan Telescope exomoon upon the host star is van- because then their gravitational (GMT), the Thirty Meter Tele- ishingly small, there is no chance pull is strongest on the stars’ scope (TMT), and the European for this astrometric method to de- velocity. Extremely Large Telescope (ELT). tect exomoons at all. The ratio be- Equipped with newest generation tween the masses of host star and of advanced and dedicated techno- exomoon is so large that the angu- Transit logy in active and adaptive optics, lar resolution needed to detect a it is expected that these telescopes variation in the host star’s position The transit method uses the sim- will provide images in the optical would not be sufficient in any case.