Latent Developmental Potential to Form Limb-Like Structures in Fish Fins Revealed by Mutations in the Vav2/N-WASP Pathway
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Latent Developmental Potential to Form Limb-Like Structures in Fish Fins Revealed by Mutations in the Vav2/N-WASP Pathway The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Hawkins, Michael Brent. 2020. Latent Developmental Potential to Form Limb-Like Structures in Fish Fins Revealed by Mutations in the Vav2/N-WASP Pathway. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. Citable link https://nrs.harvard.edu/URN-3:HUL.INSTREPOS:37365806 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA "#$%&$!'%(%)*+,%&$#)!-*$%&$.#)!$*!/*0,!".,12".3%!4$056$50%7!.&!/.78!/.&7!9%(%#)%:!1;! <5$#$.*&7!.&!$8%!=#(>?@2AB4-!-#$8C#;! ! ! B!:.77%0$#$.*&!+0%7%&$%:! 1;! <.68#%)!D0%&$!E#C3.&7! $*!! F8%!'%+#0$,%&$!*G!H0I#&.7,.6!#&:!J(*)5$.*�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`! ! Z`Z! B++%&:.US!45++)%,%&$#)!<#$%0.#)! ! Z`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a**)*I;! T#,%7!E#&3%&O!C8*!I#(%!,%!#!8*,%!1#7%!.&!H0I#&.7,.6!#&:!J(*)5$.*�!D.*)*I;!#$!E#0(#0:! M&.(%07.$;!C8.)%!#)7*!I.(.&I!,%!$8%!G0%%:*,!$*!+5075%!+0*L%6$7!#60*77!$8%!0.(%0!#$!E#0(#0:! <%:.6#)!468**)!XE<4YR!E%!#)7*!I#(%!,%!$8%!I0%#$!&.63&#,%!bF8%!'53%Rc! F8.7!+0*L%6$!C*5):!&*$!8#(%!1%%&!+*77.1)%!C.$8*5$!$8%!$0%,%&:*57!0%7*506%7!60%#$%:!1;! *$8%0!I0*5+7!.&!$8%!,*57%!#&:!W%10#G.78!6*,,5&.$.%7R!H$8%0!)#17!I0#6.*57);!78#0%:!).&%7!$8#$! +0*(.:%:!3%;!.&7.I8$7!.&$*!,;!7$5:;R!@%.)!4851.&O!F%$75;#!@#3#,50#O!#&:!B&:0%C!d%803%!*G!$8%! M&.(%07.$;!*G!N8.6#I*!78#0%:!C.$8!,%!$8%!E*UZ[!N9V4-9!,5$#&$!).&%7O!#&:!<#0.%2B&:0e%! B3.,%&3*!*G!$8%!M&.(%07.$;!*G!H$$#C#!78#0%:!$8%!.&:.7+%&7#1)%!#&:!1%#5$.G5)!E*UZ[!0%+*0$%0! ).&%7R!V!#,!.&!:%1$!$*!<#$$8%C!A#0,#&!#$!D*7$*&!N8.):0%&f7!E*7+.$#)!XDNEY!H0$8*+%:.6! 9%7%#068!#&:!E<4!d%&%$.67!G*0!%).&I!,%!$*!%U$%&:!,;!:.77%0$#$.*&!0%7%#068!.&$*!,*57%! ,*:%)7R!T*#&#!"*+%W!$0#.&%:!,%!.&!,#&;!,*57%!$%68&.K5%7!#&:!7#(%:!,%!G0*,!G%%).&I!).3%!#! W%10#G.78!*5$!*G!C#$%0!C8%&!C*03.&I!.&!$8%!,*57%!8*57%R!V!8#(%!#)7*!$*!$8#&3!457#&!<#63%,!*G! ! (.! $8%!@#$.*&#)!V&7$.$5$%7!*G!E%#)$8O!H).(.%0!-*50K5.e!#&:!T;*$.!9#*!*G!E<4!#&:!D0.I8#,!#&:! A*,%&g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h*7$#:.&!-%$0*(O!a#63!"%C.7O!J).W#1%$8! 4%G$*&O!h#.$).&!4#,*68#O!J(#&!h.&I7)%;O!F8*,!4$%C#0$O!-%$%0!A.)$*&O!<#0#!"#7)*O!h#.$);&! A%17$%0O!B,1.3#!h#,#$8O!'#&!9.6%O!#&:!h#0#!/%.).68O!#7!C%))!#7!7**&2$*21%!:*6$*0!4#,#&$8#! 9*;)%R!V!#)7*!,57$!.&6)5:%!#!7+%6.#)!$8#&3!;*5!$*!<#0.#!<%$W)%0O!C8*!75II%7$%:!$8%!,5$#&$!&#,%! '(45"$1R!V!#,!#)7*!$8#&3G5)!G*0!$8%!X#$!$8%!$.,%Y!+*7$:*6$*0#)!G%))*C7!C8*!I5.:%:!,%!*&!,;! +0*L%6$!:%6.7.*&7O!F8*,!4#&I%0O!E.))#0;!<#::%&O!9.6#0:*!<#))#0.&*O!#&:!N85&,%.!".R!! V!*C%!,#&;!$8#&37!$*!,;!6*2#:(.7*0!<#$$8%C!E#00.7!*G!E<4!d%&%$.67!#&:!DNE! H0$8*+%:.6!9%7%#068R!A.$8*5$!8.7!75++*0$!$8.7!C*03!C*5):!&*$!8#(%!1%%&!+*77.1)%R!E%!I#(%!,%! $8%!$**)7O!I5.:#&6%O!#&:!)#$.$5:%!$*!.&(%7$.I#$%!#!C*&:%0G5)!+.%6%!*G!1.*)*I;!$8#$!V!#,!+0*5:!$*! 8#(%!+)#;%:!#!0*)%!.&!%U+)*0.&IR!V!#,!G*0$5&#$%!$*!8#(%!1%%&!$0#.&%:!1;!<#$$!#&:!).(%:!#&:! C*03%:!.&!$8%!G5&!#&:!6*))#1*0#$.(%!)#1!8%!G*7$%0%:R!! <*7$!*G!#))O!V!,57$!%U$%&:!,;!$8#&37!$*!h#$0.&!E%&3%!G*0!78#0.&I!C.$8!,%!8%0!1%#5$.G5)! ,5$#&$7R!F8#$!7568!#,#W.&I!,*&7$%07!6*5):!6*,%!*5$!*G!#!760%%&!.7!#!$%7$#,%&$!$*!$8%!+*C%0!*G! G*0C#0:!I%&%$.67!#&:!$*!h#$0.&f7!$%.$;O!*0I#&.W#$.*&O!#&:!+#.&7$#3.&I!C*03R!! ! (..! '%:.6#$.*&! ! ! F8.7!:.77%0$#$.*&!.7!:%:.6#$%:!$*!B)%U#&:%0!N05W!XZi\Z2>PZ^YR!F8#&3!;*5!G*0!7$#0$.&I!,%! *&!$8.7!C*&:%0G5)!+#$8R! ! (...! !"#$%&'()*(+,%'-./0%1-,( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ! Z! !"#$%&'()*(+,%'-./0%1-,( ! B&.,#)7!6*,+0.7%!#!(#7$!#&:!(#0.%:!#00#;!*G!7+%6.%7!C.$8!:.GG%0%&$!78#+%7O!7.W%7O! +8;7.*)*I.%7O!#&:!1%8#(.*07R!E*C!C#7!$8.7!:.(%07.$;!#1)%!$*!#0.7%!G0*,!#!6*,,*&!#&6%7$*0j!F*! #::0%77!$8.7!K5%7$.*&O!76.%&$.7$7!.&!$8%!G.%):!*G!J(*)5$.*�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j!N#&!:%(%)*+,%&$!+*$%&$.#$%!*0!).,.$!:.(%07.$;j!'*%7!*50! 5&:%07$#&:.&I!*G!:%(%)*+,%&$#)!(#0.#$.*&!#GG%6$!*50!#1.).$;!$*!+0%:.6$!%(*)5$.*�!68#&I%j! F8%7%!#0%!K5%7$.*&7!$8#$!J'D!7$5:.%7!#::0%77!57.&I!#!0#&I%!*G!#++0*#68%7!G0*,!:%760.+$.(%! 6*,+#0#$.(%!,*0+8*)*I;!$*!6*,+5$#$.*&#)!#&#);7.7!*G!7.&I)%26%))!9@B!7%K5%&6.&IR!F*I%$8%0O! $8%7%!#++0*#68%7!6#&!8%)+!57!5&:%07$#&:O!#$!:.GG%0%&$!%(*)5$.*�!$.,%76#)%7!#&:!)%(%)7!*G! 1.*)*I.6#)!*0I#&.W#$.*&O!8*C!$8%!,;0.#:!G*0,7!*G!).G%!#0*7%!*&!J#0$8R!! V&!$8.7!:.77%0$#$.*&O!V!:%,*&7$0#$%!$8%!#1.).$;!*G!:%(%)*+,%&$!$*!+0*:56%!+0*&*5&6%:O!