Journal of Mormon History Vol. 38, No. 3, Summer 2012
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of Mormon History Volume 38 Issue 3 Article 1 6-13-2012 Journal of Mormon History Vol. 38, No. 3, Summer 2012 Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/mormonhistory Part of the Religion Commons Recommended Citation Journal of Mormon History, Vol 38, Summer 2012: Iss. 3. This Full Issue is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at DigitalCommons@USU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Mormon History by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@USU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Journal of Mormon History Vol. 38, No. 3, Summer 2012 Table of Contents CONTENTS LETTER --Fitz John Porter’s Letter William P. MacKinnon, vii ARTICLES --Mormonism in Cultural Context: Guest Editors’ Introduction J. Spencer Fluhman, Steven C. Harper, and Jed Woodworth, 1 --A Charmed Life Claudia L. Bushman, 5 --The Hermeneutics of Generosity: A Critical Approach to the Scholarship of Richard Bushman Stuart Parker, 12 --To Mend a Fractured Reality: Joseph Smith’s Project Philip L. Barlow, 28 --The Language of Heaven: Prolegomenon to the Study of Smithian Translation Samuel Morris Brown, 51 --“The Wars and the Perplexities of the Nations”: Reflections on Early Mormonism, Violence, and the State Patrick Q. Mason, 72 --Zion in America: The Origins of Mormon Constitutionalism Mark Ashurst-McGee, 90 --Joseph Smith as the Philosopher King: Neoplatonism in Early Mormon Political Thought Stephen J. Fleming, 102 --LDS Understandings of Religious Freedom: Responding to the Shifting Cultural Pendulum Mauro Properzi, 128 --Joseph Smith, Romanticism, and Tragic Creation Terryl L. Givens 148 God, the World, and the Long Journey to Divinity: Mormonism and German Romantic Idealism James M. McLachlan, 163 --Early Mormonism and the Re-Enchantment of Antebellum Historical Thought Jordan T. Watkins, 187 --“Reasonings Sufficient”: Joseph Smith, Thomas Dick, and the Context(s) of Early Mormonism Benjamin E. Park, 210 --After the Golden Age Richard Lyman Bushman, 225 REVIEWS --Robin Scott Jensen, Richard E. Turley Jr., and Riley M. Lorimer, eds. Revelations and Translations, Volume 2: Published Revelations. Volume 2 of the Revelations and Translations series of The Joseph Smith Papers Joe Geisner, 232 --Andrew H. Hedges, Alex D. Smith, and Richard Lloyd Anderson, eds. Journals, Volume 2: December 1841– April 1843. Volume 2 of the Journals series of The Joseph Smith Papers. Series editors: Dean C. Jessee, Ronald K. Esplin, and Richard Lyman Bushman Brian C. Hales, 236 --Devery Scott Anderson, ed. The Development of LDS Temple Worship, 1846–2000: A Documentary History John-Charles Duffy, 254 --Richard V. Francaviglia. Go East, Young Man: Imagining the American West as the Orient Christine Talbot, 259 --John S. Dinger, ed. The Nauvoo City and High Council Minutes Robin Scott Jensen, 262 --Sherman L. Fleek, Called to War: Dawn of the Mormon Battalion, and Sherman L. Fleek, War in the Far West: The March of the Mormon Battalion Paul A. Hoffman, 268 BOOK NOTICES Richard H. Bullock, Ship Brooklyn’s Saints, 274 James V. D’Arc, When Hollywood Came to Town: A History of Moviemaking in Utah, 276 Andrew H. Hedges and Richard Neitzel Holzapfel, Within These Prison Walls: Lorenzo Snow’s Record Book, 1886–1897, 278 This full issue is available in Journal of Mormon History: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/mormonhistory/vol38/iss3/ 1 JOURNAL OF MORMON HISTORY SUMMER 2012 Cover illustration: Clint Whiting, Piazza della Radio, egg tempera on board, 50 cm x 50 cm, 2011. The Mormon History Association The Mormon History Association (www.mormonhistoryassociation.org) is an independent non-profit 501(c)3 organization devoted to all aspects of the Mor- mon past. It strives to be the preeminent catalyst and forum worldwide for en- couraging the scholarly study of Mormon history. It pursues its mission by spon- soring annual conferences; encouraging the highest quality research and publica- tion; and awarding book, article, and other prizes. Its official periodical, the Journal of Mormon History, fosters the publication of independent, scholarly re- search. Membership in the Association is open to all. © 2012 Mormon History Association. Printed in the United States of America. ISSN 0194–7342 Copies of articles may be made for teaching and for research purposes free of charge and without securing permission, as permitted by Sections 107 and 108 of U.S. Copyright Law. For other uses, permission must be obtained from the au- thor(s). All statements of opinion are the authors’ own and not necessarily those of the Mormon History Association, its officers, directors, editors, and/or members. Authors alone are responsible for the factual accuracy of their articles, including quotations, citations, and all other uses of source materials. Articles are abstracted and indexed in Historical Abstracts and America: History and Life, published by ABC-CLIO. The Journal of Mormon History is published by the Mormon History Association and is distributed to association members. Annual dues are: Regular, $55; Spouse/ Partner, $65; Student, $25; Institution, $75; Sustaining, $125; Patron, $250; and Donor, $500. For subscriptions outside the United States, DVDs of back issues, in- dividual back issues, and all questions, see www.mormonhistoryassociation.org, or contact (801) 521–6565. Digital copies of back issues are available at EBSCO and Utah State University Digital Commons: http://digitalcommons.usu.edu/ mormonhistory. Members are asked to notify the association immediately if they change their membership mailing address, including their email address. The Journal of Mormon History Publisher: Mormon History Association (founded 1965) President: RichardL.Jensen President-Elect: Glen M. Leonard Past President: William P. MacKinnon Executive Director: Ronald O. Barney Executive Director/Business Manager: Marilyn S. Barney Directors: Curtis Atkisson (2012) Andrea Radke-Moss (2012) Christopher C. Jones (2013) Grant Underwood (2013) Barbara Walden (2013) Polly Aird (2014) Gary James Bergera (2014) Executive Staff Production Staff Editor: Martha Taysom Copy Editor: Lavina Fielding Anderson Board of Editors: Production Manager: Brent Corcoran Ruth Knight Bailey Art Director: Thayne Whiting Matthew Bowman Book Review Editor: Boyd Jay Petersen Keith A. Erekson Advertising Manager: Steve Eccles Scott C. Esplin Electronic Initiatives Coordinator: Sarah Barringer Gordon Connie Lamb David Hall Digital Commons: Noel A. Carmack David J. Howlett Editorial Staff: Hollis R. Johnson Elizabeth Ann Anderson Jennifer L. Lund Laura Compton Susanna Morrill Linda Wilcox DeSimone Christopher A. Newton Sherman Feher Jonathan A. Stapley Zachary R. Jones Linda Lindstrom Craig Livingston H. Michael Marquardt Rene Romig Jerilyn Wakefield Manuscripts dealing with any aspect of the Mormon past are welcome. Pri- mary consideration is given to manuscripts that make a significant contribution to the knowledge of Mormon history through new interpretations and/or new in- formation. Acceptance is based on originality, literary quality, accuracy, and rele- vance. Reprints and simultaneous submissions are not accepted. Submissions should be sent to [email protected] in Word. The author’s name and contact information should be located on a page separate from the manuscript. All illustrative materials, including maps, charts, and graphs, should be attached in a separate file(s), and not embedded in the elec- tronic document. All such illustrative materials must be supplied by the author. The Journal’s style guide, based on the Chicago Manual of Style and the LDS Style Guide, including specifications for illustrative materials, is available at www. mormonhistoryassociation.org. The peer-reviewed evaluation process usually takes three to six months. JOURNAL OF MORMON HISTORY VOLUME 38, NO. 3 SUMMER 2012 CONTENTS LETTER Fitz John Porter’s Letter William P. MacKinnon vii ARTICLES Mormonism in Cultural Context: Guest Editors’ Introduction J. Spencer Fluhman, Steven C. Harper, and Jed Woodworth 1 A Charmed Life Claudia L. Bushman 5 The Hermeneutics of Generosity: A Critical Approach to the Scholarship of Richard Bushman Stuart Parker 12 To Mend a Fractured Reality: Joseph Smith’s Project Philip L. Barlow 28 The Language of Heaven: Prolegomenon to the Study of Smithian Translation Samuel Morris Brown 51 “The Wars and the Perplexities of the Nations”: Reflections on Early Mormonism, Violence, and the State Patrick Q. Mason 72 Zion in America: The Origins of Mormon Constitutionalism Mark Ashurst-McGee 90 Joseph Smith as the Philosopher King: Neoplatonism in Early Mormon Political Thought Stephen J. Fleming 102 iv CONTENTS v LDS Understandings of Religious Freedom: Responding to the Shifting Cultural Pendulum Mauro Properzi 128 Joseph Smith, Romanticism, and Tragic Creation Terryl L. Givens 148 God, the World, and the Long Journey to Divinity: Mormonism and German Romantic Idealism James M. McLachlan 163 Early Mormonism and the Re-Enchantment of Antebellum Historical Thought Jordan T. Watkins 187 “Reasonings Sufficient”: Joseph Smith, Thomas Dick, and the Context(s) of Early Mormonism Benjamin E. Park 210 After the Golden Age Richard Lyman Bushman 225 REVIEWS Robin Scott Jensen, Richard E. Turley Jr., and Riley M. Lorimer, eds. Revelations and Translations, Volume 2: Published Revelations. Volume 2 of the Revelations and Translations series of The Joseph Smith Papers Joe Geisner 232 Andrew H. Hedges, Alex D. Smith, and Richard Lloyd Anderson, eds. Journals,