DOCSLIB.ORG

Corporate Governance and Financial Fraud of Wirecard

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Corporate Governance and Financial Fraud of Wirecard RESEARCH ARTICLE European Journal of Business and Management Research www.ejbmr.org Corporate Governance and Financial Fraud of Wirecard Hoje Jo, Annie Hsu, Rosamaria Llanos-Popolizio, and Jorge Vergara-Vega ABSTRACT This paper examines the antecedents and consequences of the collapse of Wirecard AG, in June 2020, the “German Enron.” Specifically, we Submitted: January 22, 2021 investigate how the Wirecard’s ineffective corporate governance under the Published: March 25, 2021 German’s financial regulatory system fails to serve their stakeholders, and how its management’s unethical behavior of earnings manipulation ISSN: 2507-1076 contribute to significant financial collapse for the company, and lead to the DOI: 10.24018/ejbmr.2021.6.2.708 destruction of shareholders’ value. This paper examines how the internal and external governance and monitoring mechanisms failed to uncover the Hoje Jo* vast fraud at the German payments group at a much earlier stage. PhD in finance, University of Florida, Furthermore, we find evidence consistent with the hypothesis that the USA. continuous pressure of meeting or exceeding consensus on earnings (e-mail: hjo@ scu.edu) estimates, management’s performance compensation based on the growth Annie Hsu of Wirecard’s stock price, and the lack of proper supervision from the MBA in finance, Santa Clara University, board of directors ultimately create the opportunities for management to USA. manipulate earnings without being uncovered for several years. Such (e-mail: achsu scu.edu) course of action has caused significant financial corporate misconduct for Rosamaria Llanos-Popolizio Wirecard and led to the destruction of firm value. MBA in finance, Santa Clara University, USA. Keywords: Corporate governance, earnings manipulation, corporate (e-mail: rllanospopolizio scu.edu) misconduct, financial scandal, German financial regulatory system, the German Jorge Vergara-Vega Enron, Wirecard. MBA in finance, Santa Clara University, USA. (e-mail: jvergaravega scu.edu) *Corresponding Author The purpose of this paper is to examine Wirecard’s I. INTRODUCTION corporate governance (CG) and understand how they failed to prevent the financial fraud from taking place. This paper Wirecard AG, Wirecard or the Company, (ticker: WDI further examines Wirecard’s financial misconduct which Germany), one of the Germany’s leading financial significantly impacted shareholders’ value and resulted in technology companies in providing digital platforms for substantial financial losses. This paper starts with a synopsis financial commerce, filed for insolvency in June 2020 after of the Company and its financial scandal. Then, it investigates revealing €1.9 billion of cash on its balance sheet had gone the causes behind Wirecard’s financial scandal as a way to missing and shortly after its Chief Executive Officer (CEO) gain additional insights on corporate scandals in international got arrested on charges related to market manipulation and countries. Following, this paper examines Wirecard’s CG false accounting. In September 2018, Wirecard became the structure and explains how the internal and external fastest growing fintech firm listing in Germany’s stock monitoring mechanisms failed to serve its shareholders, and exchange, and outed Germany’s second largest lender, how its management’s unethical behavior to manipulate Commerzbank AG. However, on June 25, 2020, Wirecard earnings contributed to the destruction of shareholders’ value. became the first sitting member of Germany’s blue-chip Lastly, this paper further examines the challenges that fintech DAX index to file for court protection from creditors at a poses to the financial regulation in Germany and determines Munich court. Since then, the Company’s share price has if it needs to be reformed in order to reduce accounting plunged over 90%, falling from €104.50 on June 17, 2020 to malpractice, strengthen the CG system, and as result enhance €1.28 on June 26, 2020. This corporate scandal has exposed Germany’s economy. certain financial flaws in Germany’s regulatory environment and has posed numerous questions for the European fintech industry. The collapse of Wirecard has also prompted II. HYPOTHESES members of the German Parliament to conduct an investigation in the Company (now being called “the German Strong CG is crucial to create a corporate culture of Enron”) and to examine the German regulations over its transparency, accountability, and disclosure. Jo and Harjoto financial system. The European Commission has also [1] suggest that the internal board of directors and external demanded its market watchdog to investigate Germany’s stakeholders including government regulators, shareholders, financial regulator, BaFin (the Federal Financial Supervisory creditors, auditors, and analysts play an important role in the Authority in Germany) over the fall of Wirecard. CG and monitoring mechanisms of a business organization to oversee the action of management and resolve the conflicts of DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejbmr.2021.6.2.708 Vol 6 | Issue 2 | March 2021 96 RESEARCH ARTICLE European Journal of Business and Management Research www.ejbmr.org interests between shareholders and management to maximize Supervisory Board had breached its duty of care as they failed the long-term value of the company. Jensen [2] and Miller [3] to conduct their independent internal investigation of the further maintain that the collapse of many multinational allegations relating to Wirecard’s accounting malpractices public corporations, including the energy giant Enron Corp., and also failed to prevent management from wrongdoing. highlighted the importance of information transparency and Although it is in the interest of shareholders and management managerial incentives as they typically limit the effectiveness to maximize the company’s intrinsic value in the long-term, of CG in public corporations. As it is difficult for the board it is not necessarily true for short-term investors who would of directors to directly observe the actions of managers who prefer management to focus on actions increasing the current act in the interest of shareholders, managers’ compensation is stock price. often directly related to the performance of the company. As further described under inflation of revenue and profit, However, this arrangement could potentially create an Wirecard used the “round tripping” fraud scheme to incentive for management to manipulate earnings [1], [4]-[6]. artificially overstate revenue and cash over the course of Jo, Kim, and Park [5] suggest that financial managers have an several years. Management was under significant pressure for incentive to manipulate earnings around seasoned equity meeting Street’s expectations, which were developed based offering (SEO) when the quality of underwriter is sub-par, on the significant growth experienced by Wirecard over the while Jo and Kim [6] find that managers have an incentive to past years (refer to Company’s financial highlights). inflate earnings around SEO and abruptly increase disclosure One of the most widely cited papers that investigates the frequency when they want to increase the SEO offer price. A effect of executive compensation plans on accrual decisions corporate culture within Wirecard of always meeting and accounting choice is Healy [8]. Healy hypothesizes that analysts’ earnings expectations and stakeholders’ interests a manager has an economic incentive to manipulate earnings ultimately created the incentive to manipulate earnings in order to increase their cash compensation. Healy [8] results. proposes the following hypotheses: In the case of Wirecard, management manipulated its a. If earnings before discretionary accruals are less than numbers on the financial statements and hid the Company's the manager's lower bound threshold, the manager has losses from being shared with the public in an effort to an incentive to select income-decreasing discretionary maintain the growth of the stock price. German regulators accruals. have placed high reliance on the idea of self-regulation and b. If earnings before discretionary accruals exceed the on the relationship of stock ownership by management, and manager's lower bound threshold, but not the upper reliability on a company's trustworthiness. “Documents show bound, the manager has an incentive to select income- that the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority, or Bafin, increasing discretionary accruals. saw Wirecard’s former CEO, now under criminal c. If the bonus plan contains an upper bound and earnings investigation, as more trustworthy than his critics because he before discretionary accruals exceed that limit, the bought a large chunk of shares in the Company at a key manager has an incentive to select income-decreasing moment” [7]. German regulators failed to realize Wirecard’s discretionary accruals. insolvency because no one trustworthy like regulators and Based on Healy [8] and an incentive for management to external auditors raised any flags, even when in suspicions of manipulate earnings [1], [4]-[6] as management has access to fraud. information not available to shareholders and the decision- Additionally, studies found that an effective CG “realigns making process is substantially under their control, we management’s incentives to maximize shareholders’ value postulate that under a corporate culture of always meeting instead of to manipulate earnings for their own personal Street’s expectations would develop a strong incentive to benefit” [4]. It is necessary
Load more

Recommended publications
  • VISA Europe AIS Certified Service Providers
    Visa Europe Account Information Security (AIS) List of PCI DSS validated service providers Effective 08 September 2010 __________________________________________________ The companies listed below successfully completed an assessment based on the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS). 1 The validation date is when the service provider was last validated. PCI DSS assessments are valid for one year, with the next annual report due one year from the validation date. Reports that are 1 to 60 days late are noted in orange, and reports that are 61 to 90 days late are noted in red. Entities with reports over 90 days past due are removed from the list. It is the member’s responsibility to use compliant service providers and to follow up with service providers if there are any questions about their validation status. 2 Service provider Services covered by Validation date Assessor Website review 1&1 Internet AG Internet payment 31 May 2010 SRC Security www.ipayment.de processing Research & Consulting Payment gateway GmbH Payment processing a1m GmbH Payment gateway 31 October 2009 USD.de AG www.a1m.biz Internet payment processing Payment processing A6IT Limited Payment gateway 30 April 2010 Kyte Consultants Ltd www.A6IT.com Abtran Payment processing 31 July 2010 Rits Information www.abtran.com Security Accelya UK Clearing and Settlement 31 December 2009 Trustwave www.accelya.com ADB-UTVECKLING AB Payment gateway 30 November 2009 Europoint Networking WWW.ADBUTVECKLING.SE AB Adeptra Fraud Prevention 30 November 2009 Protiviti Inc. www.adeptra.com Debt Collection Card Activation Adflex Payment Processing 31 March 2010 Evolution LTD www.adflex.co.uk Payment Gateway/Switch Clearing & settlement 1 A PCI DSS assessment only represents a ‘snapshot’ of the security in place at the time of the review, and does not guarantee that those security controls remain in place after the review is complete.
    [Show full text]
  • It-Tlettax-Il Leġiżlatura Pl 1947
    IT-TLETTAX-IL LEĠIŻLATURA P.L. 1947 Dokument imqiegħed fuq il-Mejda tal-Kamra tad-Deputati fis-Seduta Numru 137 tal-4 ta’ Lulju 2018 mill-Ispeaker, l-Onor. Anġlu Farrugia. ___________________________ Raymond Scicluna Skrivan tal-Kamra 11th Parliamentary Intelligence Security Forum 2 July 2018 Berlin, Germany Hon Anglu Farrugia, Speaker Parliamentary Delegation Report to the House of Representatives. Date: 2nd July 2018 Venue: Berlin, Germany. Maltese delegation: Honourable Anglu Farrugia, President of the House of Representatives. Programme: At the invitation of the US Member of Congress, Robert Pittenger, Chairman of the Congressional Taskforce on Terrorism and Unconventional Warfare and Han. Johannes Salles M.P. from the Bundestag, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, Parliament of Malta, Honourable Anglu Farrugia, was invited to participate at the meeting of the 11'h Parliamentary Security-Intelligence Forum. Participation of Speaker Anglu Farrugia at the 2018 Parliamentary Intelligence Security Forum, co-hosted by Congressman Robert Pittenger and Honourable Member of the German Bundestag, Johannes Salles MP, held on the 2nd July 2018. The forum was opened by opening statement by Congressman Pittinger and Han. Stephan Mayer who is the Parliamentary State Secretary of the German Federal Ministry of the Interior followed by Han. Volkmar Klein. There were six panels which I attended them all. The first panel was about the FlU perspective with regards to terrorism financing and tax evasion. The panel was addressed among other keynote speakers Bruno Kahl, President of the Federal Intelligence Service and Andreas Frank who is advisor to the Council of Europe for Anti Money Laundering Directive.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Potential for Prepaid Cards
    Global Potential for Prepaid Cards Overview of Key Markets September 2018 © Edgar, Dunn & Company, 2018 Edgar, Dunn & Company (EDC) is an independent global financial services and payments strategy consultancy EDC - Independent, Global and Strategic EDC Office Locations Founded in 1978, the firm is widely regarded as a trusted advisor to its clients, providing a full range of strategy consulting services, expertise and market insight, and M&A support EDC has been providing thought leadership to its client base working with: More than 40 European banks & card issuers/acquirers London Frankfurt Most of the top 25 US banks and credit card issuers San Paris Istanbul All major international card associations / schemes & Francisco many domestic card schemes Many of the world's most influential mobile payments providers Many of the world's leading merchants, including Sydney major airlines Office locations Shaded blue countries represent markets where EDC conducted client engagements EDC Key Metrics Financial services and payments focus +1,000 projects completed Six office locations worldwide +250 clients in 40 countries & 6 continents Independent - owned and controlled by EDC Directors Confidential 2 EDC has deep expertise in across seven specialist practice areas M&A Practice Legal & Travel Regulatory Practice Practice Fintech Retail Practice Practice Issuing Acquiring Practice Practice Confidential 3 A global perspective of prepaid from a truly global strategy consulting firm Countries where Edgar, Dunn & Company has delivered projects Confidential 4 The global prepaid card market is expected to reach $3.7 trillion by 2022 - a growth of 22.7% from 2016 to 20221 $3.7tn size of global prepaid market by 2022 Confidential 1Allied Market Research 2017 5 What we will cover today….
    [Show full text]
  • How Mpos Helps Food Trucks Keep up with Modern Customers
    FEBRUARY 2019 How mPOS Helps Food Trucks Keep Up With Modern Customers How mPOS solutions Fiserv to acquire First Data How mPOS helps drive food truck supermarkets compete (News and Trends) vendors’ businesses (Deep Dive) 7 (Feature Story) 11 16 mPOS Tracker™ © 2019 PYMNTS.com All Rights Reserved TABLEOFCONTENTS 03 07 11 What’s Inside Feature Story News and Trends Customers demand smooth cross- Nhon Ma, co-founder and co-owner The latest mPOS industry headlines channel experiences, providers of Belgian waffle company Zinneken’s, push mPOS solutions in cash-scarce and Frank Sacchetti, CEO of Frosty Ice societies and First Data will be Cream, discuss the mPOS features that acquired power their food truck operations 16 23 181 Deep Dive Scorecard About Faced with fierce eTailer competition, The results are in. See the top Information on PYMNTS.com supermarkets are turning to customer- scorers and a provider directory and Mobeewave facing scan-and-go-apps or equipping featuring 314 players in the space, employees with handheld devices to including four additions. make purchasing more convenient and win new business ACKNOWLEDGMENT The mPOS Tracker™ was done in collaboration with Mobeewave, and PYMNTS is grateful for the company’s support and insight. PYMNTS.com retains full editorial control over the findings presented, as well as the methodology and data analysis. mPOS Tracker™ © 2019 PYMNTS.com All Rights Reserved February 2019 | 2 WHAT’S INSIDE Whether in store or online, catering to modern consumers means providing them with a unified retail experience. Consumers want to smoothly transition from online shopping to browsing a physical retail store, and 56 percent say they would be more likely to patronize a store that offered them a shared cart across channels.
    [Show full text]
  • Service Provider Name Region AOC Date Assessor DESV
    A company’s name appears on this Compliant Service Provider List if (i) Mastercard has received a copy of an Attestation of Compliance (AOC) by a Qualified Security Assessor (QSA) reflecting validation of the company being PCI DSS compliant and (ii) Mastercard records reflect the company is registered as a Service Provider by one or more Mastercard Customers. The date of the AOC and the name of the QSA are also provided. Each AOC is valid for one year. Mastercard receives copies of AOCs from various sources. This Compliant Service Provider List is provided solely for the convenience of Mastercard Customers and any Customer that relies upon or otherwise uses this Compliant Service Provider list does so at the Customer’s sole risk. While Mastercard endeavors to keep the list current as of the date set forth in the footer, Mastercard disclaims any and all warranties of any kind, including any warranty of accuracy or completeness or fitness for any particular purpose. Mastercard disclaims any and all liability of any nature relating to or arising in connection with the use of or reliance on the Compliant Service Provider List or any part thereof. Each Mastercard Customer is obligated to comply with Mastercard Rules and other Standards pertaining to use of a Service Provider. As a reminder, an AOC by a QSA provides a “snapshot” of security controls in place at a point in time. Compliant Service Provider 1-60 Days Past AOC Due Date 61-90 Days Past AOC Due Date Service Provider Name Region AOC Date Assessor DESV “BPC Processing”, LLC Europe 03/31/2017 Informzaschita 1&1 Internet SE (1&1, 1&1 ipayment, Europe 05/08/2017 Security Research & Consulting GmbH ipayment.de) 1Shoppingcart.com (Web.com Group, lnc.) US 04/29/2017 SecurityMetrics 2138617 Ontario Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • FINANCIAL CRIME DIGEST July 2020
    FINANCIAL CRIME DIGEST July 2020 Diligent analysis. Powering business.™ aperio-intelligence.com FINANCIAL CRIME DIGEST | JULY 2020 ISSN: 2632-8364 About Us Founded in 2014, Aperio Intelligence is a specialist, independent corporate intelligence frm, headquartered in London. Collectively our team has decades of experience in undertaking complex investigations and intelligence analysis. We speak over twenty languages in- house, including all major European languages, as well as Russian, Arabic, Farsi, Mandarin and Cantonese. We have completed more than 3,000 assignments over the last three years, involving some 150 territories. Our client base includes a broad range of leading international fnancial institutions, law frms and multinationals. Our role is to help identify and understand fnancial crime, contacts, cultivated over decades, who support us regularly integrity and reputational risks, which can arise from a lack in undertaking local enquiries on a confdential and discreet of knowledge of counterparties or local jurisdictions, basis. As a specialist provider of corporate intelligence, we enabling our clients to make better informed decisions. source information and undertake research to the highest legal and ethical standards. Our independence means we Our due diligence practice helps clients comply with anti- avoid potential conficts of interest that can affect larger bribery and corruption, anti-money laundering and other organisations. relevant fnancial crime legislation, such as sanctions compliance, or the evaluation of tax evasion or sanctions We work on a “Client First” basis, founded on a strong risks. Our services support the on-boarding, periodic or commitment to quality control, confdentiality and respect retrospective review of clients or third parties. for time constraints.
    [Show full text]
  • DUE DILIGENCE LESSONS for the ASSET MANAGEMENT INDUSTRY 1 the Implosion of Wirecard Is One of the Most Stunning Corporate Failures in Recent Years
    WIRECARD: DUE DILIGENCE LESSONS FOR THE ASSET MANAGEMENT INDUSTRY 1 The implosion of Wirecard is one of the most stunning corporate failures in recent years. The high flying company was the prestigious symbol of corporate Germany’s pivot to fintech and a darling of the EU technology industry. In 2018 the firm joined the 30 companies in Germany’s DAX stock index with a capitalization of €25bn, with the fintech payments processing company symbolically replacing “old economy” Commerzbank. Now Wirecard has the reputation of being the only member of the DAX ever to go into liquidation. Castle Hall has identified four themes from the Wirecard debacle which are relevant to the asset management industry. As investors conduct due diligence, be it on hedge funds, private equity, real estate, infrastructure or long only funds, Wirecard provides valuable insights which can be applied to our own industry. Perhaps the most obvious lesson of Wirecard is the one investors should always remember – if it looks too good to be true…it probably is. 1 AUDIT FAILURE The starting point has to be the increasing likelihood that Wirecard may be one of the most stunning audit failures in financial history. Castle Hall’s senior team includes qualified accountants and ex-auditors. We certainly recognize that an audit is not infallible and that a testing and sample based review of transactions may fail to uncover a sophisticated fraud, especially when there is collusion between the company and third parties / counterparties. An audit is also subject to materiality – so small transactions may fall within the cracks, even if they are fraudulent.
    [Show full text]
  • Controversial Business Practices in 2020
    Retrospective Controversial Business Practices in 2020 Inrate Analyst Team January 22, 2021 Zurich Office Geneva Office Memberships Partner Inrate AG Inrate SA Binzstrasse 23 Rue de Berne 10 CH-8045 Zürich CH-1200 Genève Tel. +41 58 344 00 00 Tel. +41 58 344 00 00 [email protected] [email protected] www.inrate.com www.inrate.com Executive Summary The food processing industry proved to be especially vulnerable to the COVID-19 outbreak. Inrate manages a database with more than While several companies came under scrutiny for 16’000 controversial business practices of over mismanagement and neglect of occupational safety measures during the pandemic, the Tyson 3’000 companies of major indices such as MSCI Foods case stood out due to its extent. The Developed Markets, MSCI Emerging Markets and company’s negligent behavior had severe the Swiss Performance Index collected over ten consequences for local communities as it was years. News articles are screened on a daily responsible for several outbreaks by ignoring basis, recorded, categorized as well as evaluated basic hygiene standards resulting in a large in detail. number of infections and a considerable death toll. As the year comes to a close, we have taken One of the biggest accounting frauds occurred in some time to reflect upon controversial business 2020 when Wirecard filed for bankruptcy shortly practices of 2020 and have compiled a list of five after it was published that EUR 1.9 billion in controversies that caught our attention the most balances were missing. These revelations were during the last twelve months. Every chosen followed by the arrest of the chief executive officer example is unique in nature, albeit for different and an international manhunt for the former chief reasons.
    [Show full text]
  • Letter from Berlin
    LETTER FROM BERLIN THE MAGAZINE OF INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC POLICY 220 I Street, N.E., Suite 200 Washington, D.C. 20002 202-861-0791 www.international-economy.com Germany’s Wirecard Scandal [email protected] The largest accounting fraud in the country’s postwar history. By Klaus C. Engelen hile all of Europe broke. When Wirecard took the place of the world electronic payment trans- is still in the grip of Commerzbank AG in the DAX in action services as well as the issuing of of the worst pan- September 2018, the fintech’s shares physical cards. According to its promo- demic in a century, were worth about €20 billion. tion material, Wirecard authorized and Germany’s po- Its Austrian CEO Markus Braun, processed payments for about 280,000 Wlitical and financial establishments are who owned 7 percent of Wirecard, merchants, issued credit and prepaid also haunted by the Wirecard AG scan- was a billionaire. Now Braun (51) is in cards, and provided technology for dal. It is turning out to be the largest detention awaiting trial with two other contactless smartphone payments. case of accounting fraud in the coun- company executives. His second-in- Clients included German discounters try’s post-war history. The sad story is command Jan Marsalek (40), also Aldi and Lidl as well as nearly one that most of the political and financial Austrian, who was in charge of the hundred airlines. Since January 2006, establishments at all levels aided and company’s Asian business, has van- the group included a bank with a full abetted the mega-fraud.
    [Show full text]
  • English Version
    Sources: 14.08.20; 10:00 Isaan News (https://isaan-news.com) and some confidential sources English Version The Wirecard "Club" nobody wants to know anything more. The urgently and legally correct demanded investigation committee by the opposition parties, is been blocked with references to strange confidentiality regulations. Who are the real brains behind Wircard and a Fraud that has been planned for over 15 Years, by people who knew each other. The Munich public prosecutor's office ("coincidentally the same public prosecutor who investigated Wirecard for money laundering 10 years ago") is keeping a low profile and supposedly does not want to know anything. The German TV show Aktenzeichen XY is looking for the supposed super brain of the scandal - Jan Marsalek - must be a Joke . Missing Wirecard exec escaped to Russia and 'has close ties to Russian government officials and possibly organized crime,' intelligence sources say.. The German TV show Aktenzeichen XY is looking for the supposed super brain of the scandal - Jan Marsalek - must be a Joke ...Why? Isaan News has learned from confidential sources in an Asian country that the German BKA and the BND know exactly where Jan Marsalek is. It is also said that Marsalek has a list of 30,000 - 300,000 names and dates from accounts that they have held at the various Wirecard banks. Accounts in Germany, which were either used for money laundering, or Visa card payment accounts which were used for the pornographic network of websites that Wirecard hosted on its data servers in Germany. Customers from the upper social classes are assumed to be customers on this list, as well as high-ranking politicians from many countries.
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution of Banking: a Flexible Fiduciary Duties Approach Will Help Better Protect Mobile Banking Consumers
    THE EVOLUTION OF BANKING: A FLEXIBLE FIDUCIARY DUTIES APPROACH WILL HELP BETTER PROTECT MOBILE BANKING CONSUMERS Isabel Peres TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Introduction ......................................................................................... 212 II. Background ......................................................................................... 215 A. Current Regulation of Mobile Financial Services ....................... 215 B. What are the Characteristics of the Mobile Financial Industry and the Unique Risks to Consumers ............................................ 217 1. What Exactly Are Mobile Financial Service: Mobile Banking and Mobile Payments .............................................. 217 2. Participants in the Mobile Banking and Mobile Payment Industries ................................................................ 219 3. Unique Risks for Consumers in the Mobile Financial Services Industry ................................................................... 220 a. Third Party Risks ............................................................ 221 b. Malware Threats ............................................................. 223 c. Fraud and Security Risks ................................................ 223 C. Fiduciary Duties and Banks ......................................................... 225 1. The Fiduciary Duty Obligation in a Bank-depositor Relationship ........................................................................... 226 a. Cases Supporting Fiduciary Duties for Banks ................ 227
    [Show full text]
  • NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY Follow the Money: Transparency
    NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY Follow the Money: Transparency, Risk, and Financial Regulation in the Age of Terror A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS for the degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Field of Sociology By Anna Hanson EVANSTON, ILLINOIS June 2017 2 © Copyright by Anna Hanson 2017 All Rights Reserved 3 ABSTRACT After 9/11 there was a shift in the rhetoric surrounding counter-terrorism. Suddenly, the language of risk, security and prevention was being utilized to justify a new set of global financial regulations headed up by international organizations such as the United Nations, The Financial Action Task Force, and the IMF/World Bank. This project sits at the nexus of finance and security, and argues that the fight against terrorism financing has important implications not just within the security realm, but for everyday financial practices and the ways in which global financial flows are understood and governed. In other words, how do regulators and financial actors govern, monitor, and hopefully prevent the financing of terrorism, without hindering the facilitation of global financial flows? From a broader perspective, analyzing the shift to the use of financial data in order to help fight terrorist financing touches upon much broader themes; the relationship between transparency, liberalization and re-regulation of financial markets, the proliferation of privatized power and the relationship between freedom and security. This dissertation adopts the governmentality (Foucault 2007) approach in order to analyze how terrorism financing is governed, or in this case prevented, through the monitoring and eventual determination of whether basic financial activities can be considered ‘normal’ or ‘suspicious’, and what are the unintended consequences of such a system that ultimately comes to view everyone as suspicious? 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS There are several people who provided insight, guidance, support and friendship throughout this dissertation process, and I want to take a moment to thank them.
    [Show full text]