DOCSLIB.ORG

Aalborg Universitet INOPS Technical Report a Study of Contracting out Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Aalborg Universitet INOPS Technical Report a Study of Contracting out Of Aalborg Universitet INOPS Technical Report A study of contracting out of park and road maintenance in Denmark, Sweden, Norway and United Kingdom Lindholst, Andrej Christian Publication date: 2017 Document Version Også kaldet Forlagets PDF Link to publication from Aalborg University Citation for published version (APA): Lindholst, A. C. (2017). INOPS Technical Report: A study of contracting out of park and road maintenance in Denmark, Sweden, Norway and United Kingdom. Department of Political Science, Aalborg University. General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. ? Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. ? You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain ? You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ? Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us at [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Downloaded from vbn.aau.dk on: November 29, 2020 TECHNICAL REPORT Innovationer i det offentlige-private samspil (INOPS) (Innovations in the organization of public-private relations) A study of contracting out of park and road maintenance in Denmark, Sweden, Norway and United Kingdom Andrej Christian Lindholst Department of Political Science Aalborg University Aalborg January 2017 INOPS Technical report Contents 1 FOREWORD ............................................................................................................................. 10 2 INTRODUCTION TO THE PROJECT .................................................................................... 13 2.1 Relevance and policy context .............................................................................................. 13 2.2 Research aim and key questions .......................................................................................... 16 2.3 Methods ............................................................................................................................... 17 2.4 Reading guide to the technical report .................................................................................. 20 3 EARLIER RESEARCH ON CONTRACTING OUTCOMES ................................................. 21 3.1 Park maintenance: Ten studies ............................................................................................ 21 3.2 Road maintenance: one study .............................................................................................. 33 3.3 Short summary .................................................................................................................... 34 3.4 Methods for literature search ............................................................................................... 34 4 ANALYSIS – COUNTRY CONTEXTS ................................................................................... 37 4.1 Denmark .............................................................................................................................. 37 4.2 Sweden ................................................................................................................................ 45 4.3 Norway ................................................................................................................................ 58 4.4 The United Kingdom ........................................................................................................... 70 5 ANALYSIS – REASONS FOR USING PRIVATE CONTRACTORS ................................... 90 5.1 Purposes for using private contractors ................................................................................ 90 5.2 Explanations for variations in purposes ............................................................................ 101 6 ANALYSIS – ORGANIZING CONTRACTING OUT .......................................................... 118 6.1 Managing and organizing contracting out ......................................................................... 118 6.2 Managing contracting out .................................................................................................. 122 6.3 Organization of contractual relations ................................................................................ 126 1 INOPS Technical report 6.4 Explanatory analysis of contract frameworks ................................................................... 159 6.5 International Comparisons ................................................................................................ 165 7 ANALYSIS – OUTCOMES .................................................................................................... 173 7.1 Outcomes from the use of private contractors ................................................................... 173 7.2 Cost effects ........................................................................................................................ 178 7.3 Exploring differences in cost effects ................................................................................. 180 7.4 Explanatory analysis of cost effects .................................................................................. 191 7.5 Comparing cost effects across Denmark, Sweden, Norway and UK ................................ 194 7.6 Performance evaluations ................................................................................................... 206 7.7 Exploring differences in performance ............................................................................... 207 7.8 Explanatory analysis of performance in Denmark ............................................................ 211 7.9 Comparing performance across Denmark, Sweden, Norway and UK .............................. 217 8 ANALYSIS – CASE STUDIES .............................................................................................. 222 8.1 Case overview ................................................................................................................... 222 8.2 The ‘standard’ municipality .............................................................................................. 224 8.3 Five Danish cases of change in contractual arrangements ................................................ 233 9 REFERENCES......................................................................................................................... 243 2 INOPS Technical report List of Tables Table 1. Chronological overview on studies on outcomes from contracting out maintenance services in parks and green spaces. ..................................................................................................................................... 22 Table 2. Characteristics of Danish municipalities ........................................................................................................... 40 Table 3. The use of different provider types for provision of parks and road maintenance services ................................ 43 Table 4. Current distribution (un-weighted) of parks and roads maintenance budgets between different types of service providers ................................................................................................................................. 44 Table 5. Municipal typology according to SALAR (2011). ............................................................................................ 46 Table 6. National administration agencies within green and technical areas ................................................................... 51 Table 7. Institutional frameworks and support systems for tendering in green and black areas ...................................... 55 Table 8. Importance of purposes for using in-house provision and private contractors .................................................. 96 Table 9. Importance of purposes for using private contractors in four countries............................................................. 99 Table 10. Differences in purposes of the importance of the purposes for using private contractors across five administration regions.............................................................................................................................. 102 Table 11. Differences in purposes for using private contractors for road and park maintenance between respondents with and without operational responsibilities .............................................................................. 103 Table 12. Differences in purposes for using in-house provision for road and park maintenance between respondents with and without operational responsibilities .............................................................................. 104 Table 13. Differences in purposes for using private contractors between municipalities with higher and lower levels of political support for contracting out road and park maintenance ........................................... 106 Table 14. Differences in purposes for using private contractors between municipalities with higher and lower levels of administrative support for contracting out road and park maintenance .................................. 107 Table
Load more

Recommended publications
  • University of Copenhagen
    Geographical Variation in Opioid Use in Elderly Patients with Dementia A Nationwide Study Jensen-Dahm, Christina; Zakarias, Johanne Købstrup; Gasse, Christiane; Waldemar, Gunhild Published in: Journal of Alzheimer's Disease DOI: 10.3233/JAD-190413 Publication date: 2019 Document version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Document license: CC BY-NC Citation for published version (APA): Jensen-Dahm, C., Zakarias, J. K., Gasse, C., & Waldemar, G. (2019). Geographical Variation in Opioid Use in Elderly Patients with Dementia: A Nationwide Study. Journal of Alzheimer's Disease, 70(4), 1209-1216. https://doi.org/10.3233/JAD-190413 Download date: 01. Oct. 2021 Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease 70 (2019) 1209–1216 1209 DOI 10.3233/JAD-190413 IOS Press Geographical Variation in Opioid Use in Elderly Patients with Dementia: A Nationwide Study Christina Jensen-Dahma,∗, Johanne Købstrup Zakariasa, Christiane Gasseb,c and Gunhild Waldemara aDanish Dementia Research Centre, Department of Neurology, Rigshospitalet, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark bDepression and Anxiety/Psychosis Research Unit, Aarhus University Hospital Psychiatry, Aarhus N, Denmark cNational Centre for Register Based Research, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark Handling Associate Editor: Alba Malara Accepted 8 June 2019 Abstract. Background: We recently reported frequent use of opioids among elderly with dementia. Discrepancies in clinical practice may in part explain the higher use of opioids in elderly with dementia, which geographical variation may be able to clarify. Objective: To investigate geographical variation in opioid use in elderly with dementia compared to elderly without dementia. Methods: Register-based cross-sectional study in the entire elderly (≥65 years) population of Denmark in 2015.
    [Show full text]
  • River Restoration
    1 Tøsbæk/Spånbæk brook, Dybvad. Spawning grounds; current concentrators; weed clearance 2 Pump station, Gjøl. Eel pass 3 3 Lerkenfeld stream, Østrup. Examples from Falls ® riffles; spawning grounds the Danish 4 River Storå, Holstebro. Completed watercourse Bypass riffle counties 5 Idom stream, Idum. New course Editor: 6 Rind stream, Herning. Hans Ole Hansen New course; ochre removal rehabilitation projects 7 River Gudenå, Langå. Spawning ground All 14 Danish counties and many of the In this chapter, staff from 12 County 8 Lilleå stream, Hadsten. Falls ® riffles; spawning grounds; municipalities have undertaken a wide Councils describe 24 watercourse bypass riffle; current concentrators variety of different watercourse rehabilita- rehabilitation projects undertaken in 9 Lammebæk brook, Daugård. tion projects over the last decade. These different parts of the country. The Culvert lamellae range from simply laying out large stones, examples provide a good impression of 10 Kvak Møllebæk brook, Skibet. to major projects that remeander water- the variety of solutions and methods Bypass riffle; spawning grounds courses and involve the whole river valley. employed to improve watercourses and 11 River Brede, Løgumkloster. their environment. New course; water table raised; river valley; ochre removal 12 River Brede, Bredebro. Falls ® riffles 13 River Odense at Ejby Mølle, Odense. Falls ® riffles; historical project 24. Jutland 14 River Odense at The Seahorse, Odense. 1 Falls ® riffles; spawning grounds; . historical project .2 Bornholm 15 Lindved stream at Hollufgård, Odense. New course; prehistoric landscape; lakes; sand trap 16 Holmehave brook at Borreby Mill, Odense. .3 New course; spawning grounds; historical project 7 4 17 Esrum stream, Lake Esrum. ..8 Spawning grounds; current 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Co-Creating with the Homeless.Pages
    Brian Benjamin Hansen and Carsten Høy Gemal Conjunctions. Transdisciplinary Journal of Cultural Participation, vol. 1, no. 1, 2014. ISSN 2246-3755 !1 Brian Benjamin Hansen and Carsten Høy Gemal Conjunctions. Transdisciplinary Journal of Cultural Participation, vol. 1, no. 1, 2014. ISSN 2246-3755 Keywords Participatory citizenship; postmodern administration; homelessness; political philosophy © 2014. B.B. Hansen and C.H. Gemal. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License (http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/), permitting all non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. https://doi.org/10.7146/tjcp.v1i1.18603 !2 2 Brian Benjamin Hansen and Carsten Høy Gemal Conjunctions. Transdisciplinary Journal of Cultural Participation, vol. 1, no. 1, 2014. ISSN 2246-3755 Introduction In the fall of 2013, a group of homeless people occupied a central site in the Danish town of Aarhus. Having chosen a site just next to Godsbanen (“the old freight train station”), which opened in March 2012 as a new main center for cultural production in Aarhus, the occupation made quite a stir among local politicians, local media, and citizens. Furthermore, as an alderman from the town council turned in the occupants to the police, this triggered a wide-reaching public debate on topics from homelessness to the cultural policy of Aarhus. Over the period from December to 2013 to March 2014, which we will be focusing on in this article, the case of the homeless metamorphosed further, as the above-mentioned alderman altered his conviction, new groups joined the group of homeless, and new action was taken by the city’s body of public administration.
    [Show full text]
  • Telemedicin Hospitalsenheden Vest
    Press release 14 June 2013 Columna Citizen is part of large Danish telemedicine trial Large Danish telemedicine trial is examining the quality of standard blood pressure checks carried out at patients' GP clinics compared to telemedicine blood pressure checks carried out by patients in their own homes. More than 1 million Danes are estimated to have high blood pressure. This group is increasingly made up of elderly citizens who can find it inconvenient and difficult to physically meet up at their GPs for a check- up. It is a paradox that there are not enough check-ups and treatment for high blood pressure because many complications resulting from high blood pressure can be avoided through simple treatment. Increase quality of life by staying at home Region Hospital Holstebro and Holstebro Municipality are carrying out a large telemedicine trial. The study of citizens with high blood pressure in the age group 55-64 years aims to determine if their treatment based on blood pressure measurements carried out using telemedicine equipment is a better way of controlling their illness and delivering a higher quality of life in comparison to citizens whose treatment is based on readings carried out during a check-up at their local GPs. "All of the participants in the trial will be seen and treated by their GP as normal," explains researcher and doctor Nikolai Hofmann-Petersen from the Medical Research Department at Region Hospital Holstebro. "We are dividing the participants into two groups. One group will measure blood pressure at home using the telemedicine equipment and send the results electronically to their GP.
    [Show full text]
  • How Cultural and Natural Heritage Can Strengthen Climate Change Adaptation CONTENS
    2019 Combatting climate change culturally How cultural and natural heritage can strengthen climate change adaptation CONTENS Climate and culture – a complex relationship ...............................................................................................................3 Why include heritage in climate projects? ......................................................................................................................4 Coast 2 Coast – Climate Challenge ....................................................................................................................................6 The United Nations sustainable development goals and heritage ..................................................................7 Climate change – a major societal challenge of our time .....................................................................................8 Talanoa Dialogue ............................................................................................................................................................................9 Addressing climate change through heritage ............................................................................................................10 Actors in climate & heritage projects ...............................................................................................................................12 Marcy Rockman, International Council on Monuments and Sites Cultural Heritage as a Source of Creativity for Climate Change ............................................................14
    [Show full text]
  • Certification Information for Annex I of Commission Regulation (EC) No 798/20081
    Certification information for Annex I of Commission Regulation (EC) No 798/20081 POULTRY, HATCHING EGGS, DAY-OLD CHICKS, SPECIFIED PATHOGEN-FREE EGGS, MEAT, MINCED MEAT, MECHANICALLY SEPARATED MEAT, EGGS AND EGG PRODUCTS ISO code Code of Description of third country, territory, zone or compartment Veterinary certificate Spec Specific conditions Avian Avian Salmon and third ific influen influen ella name of country, Model(s) Addition cond Closing Opening za za control third territory, al ition date a date b surveill vaccin status country zone or guarante s ance ation or compart es status status territory ment 1 2 3 4 5 6 6A 6B 7 8 9 Whole country SPF BE-0 EP, E, N Whole country excluding BE-2 WGM POU, RAT N BE-1 BPP, BPR, DOC, N A DOR, HEP, HER, SRP, SRA, LT20 BE- BE-2 Area compromising: Belgium The municipalities Ledegem, Menen, Wervik and Wevelgem and those parts of WGM P2 26.11.2020 26.12.2020 the municipalitiy of Izegem, Zonnebeke, Komen, Kortrijk, Kuurne, Lendelede, Moeskroen, Moorslede and Roeselare contained within a circle of a radius of 10 POU, RAT N BE-2.1 kilometres, centered on WGS84 dec. coordinates long 3.126743 lat 50.820040 P2 and beyond the area described in the protection zone BPP, BPR, DOC, A DOR, HEP, HER, SRP, SRA, LT20 Those parts of the municipalitiy of Menen, Moorslede, Wervik and Wevelgem WGM P2 18.11.2020 26.12.2020 BE-2.2 contained within a circle of a radius of three kilometers, centered on WGS84 dec. coordinates long 3.126743 – lat 50.820040 POU, RAT N 1 References to European Union legislation within this document are references to direct EU legislation which has been retained in Great Britain (retained EU law as defined in the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018).
    [Show full text]
  • Iodine, Inorganic and Soluble Salts
    Iodine, inorganic and soluble salts Evaluation of health hazards and proposal of a health-based quality criterion for drinking water Environmental Project No. 1533, 2014 Title: Editing: Iodine, inorganic and soluble salts Elsa Nielsen, Krestine Greve, John Christian Larsen, Otto Meyer, Kirstine Krogholm, Max Hansen Division of Toxicology and Risk Assessment National Food Institute, Technical University of Denmark Published by: The Danish Environmental Protection Agency Strandgade 29 1401 Copenhagen K Denmark www.mst.dk/english Year: ISBN no. Authored 2013. 978-87-93026-87-2 Published 2014. Disclaimer: When the occasion arises, the Danish Environmental Protection Agency will publish reports and papers concerning research and development projects within the environmental sector, financed by study grants provided by the Danish Environmental Protection Agency. It should be noted that such publications do not necessarily reflect the position or opinion of the Danish Environmental Protection Agency. However, publication does indicate that, in the opinion of the Danish Environmental Protection Agency, the content represents an important contribution to the debate surrounding Danish environmental policy. Sources must be acknowledged. 2 Iodine, inorganic and soluble salts Content CONTENT 3 PREFACE 5 1 GENERAL DESCRIPTION 6 1.1 IDENTITY 6 1.2 PRODUCTION AND USE 6 1.3 ENVIRONMENTAL OCCURRENCE AND FATE 7 1.3.1 Air 7 1.3.2 Water 7 1.3.3 Soil 8 1.3.4 Foodstuffs 10 1.3.5 Bioaccumulation 11 1.4 HUMAN EXPOSURE 11 2 TOXICOKINETICS 15 2.1 ABSORPTION 15
    [Show full text]
  • Everyday Meal Preparation for People with Dementia
    Indsæt nyt ikon Bring ideas to life VIA University College hvis Everyday meal preparation for Indsæt hjælpelinjer til people with dementia Højre klik udenfor slidet BENDTSEN Trine Vase, cand scient Human Nutrition IVERSEN Mette K. F., cand scient Human Nutrition NEJSUM Hanne Lindberg, Master in Humanities and Health Skriv titel på præsentation Introduction When people are diagnosed with dementia everyday activities like meal preparation will gradually become more difficult – Meal preparation to maintain identity – Weight loss and malnutrition as central nutritional issues Genoe, R., Dupuis,S. L., Keller, H. H., Martin, L. S., Cassolato, C. and Edward, H. G. (2010) J AgingStud 24: 181-193 Volkert, D., Chourdakis, M., Faxen-Irving, G., Früwald, T., Landi, F., Suominen, M.H…..Schneider, S.M. (2015) Clin Nutr, 34, 1052-1073 Aim of the project To develop a guide to increase the possibility for people with dementia to continue everyday life through participating in meal preparation Method – from Action Research to Design Based Research How can we make sure that the solution will be useful in practice? – Considerations regarding target group – Use of experience and research – Our influence as researchers – Iterations – Both methods are person-centered, application-specific and practicable Co-operation with people with dementia and their caregivers Observations Theory and workshop Development Theory and test of recipes Theory Development and test of product Final product Preliminary Results Personalization of product – Lifestory with meal preparation as center – Use of utensils e.g. scale, oven, hot plate – Activity analysis – Attention regarding nutritional needs Design of recipes Next step – Tests of guide and recipes – Compose the final product – End of project December 2017 Thank you for your attention Funded by: Thanks to collaborators from Favrskov Municipality, Viborg Municipality, Aarhus Municipality and Holstebro Municipality and people with dementia and relatives we visited in their private homes.
    [Show full text]
  • Bi-Annual Progress Report IV ELENA-2012-038 June 15Th 2016 to December 15Th 2016
    Bi-annual Progress Report IV ELENA-2012-038 June 15th 2016 to December 15th 2016 Table of Contents 1 Work Progress ............................................................................................ 2 1.1 Staff and recruitment ................................................................................... 2 1.2 Progress meetings with the municipalities .................................................. 2 1.3 Progress meetings within the Project Department ...................................... 2 1.4 Conferences and courses ........................................................................... 3 1.5 Task Groups ................................................................................................ 3 1.6 Cooperation with the other Danish ELENA projects ................................... 3 1.7 Secondments .............................................................................................. 4 1.8 Steering Committee ..................................................................................... 4 1.9 Advisory Group ............................................................................................ 5 1.10 New initiatives ............................................................................................. 5 2 Current status – implementation of the investment program ............... 6 2.1 The leverage factor ..................................................................................... 6 3 Identified Problems and Risks for Implementation ................................ 8 3.1
    [Show full text]
  • Annex 2: Project Description for Thor Offshore Wind Farm
    Annex 2: Project description for Thor Offshore Wind Farm The English version is a translation of the original in Danish for information purposes only. In case of a discrepancy, the Danish original will prevail. Final Ttender material – Tender for Thor Offshore Wind Farm – September 1 JuneJanuary 20201 Contents 1. About the project description ................................................................................................... 333 2. Main contents of the concession .............................................................................................. 333 3. Routing onshore and grid connection ...................................................................................... 555 4. Preliminary investigations and the environmental assessment process ................................... 666 5. Subsidy scheme for Thor Offshore Wind Farm ....................................................................... 999 6. Defence Command Denmark, radar and UXO ........................................................................ 999 7. Licences ............................................................................................................................. 101010 8. Administrative procedure after award of the concession ................................................... 101010 8.1. EIA approval of the concessionaire's part of the onshore installation etc. ................. 111111 8.2. Licence for preliminary investigations for the offshore installation and environmental impact assessment (EIA), etc. ...........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • A Watercourse Problem We Can Deal with Contents Introduction
    OCHRE A watercourse problem we can deal with Contents Introduction . Page 5 The path to good watercourses . Page 6 What is ochre? . Page 8 Why is ochre harmful? . Page 9 Where does ochre come from? . Page 11 The Ochre Act . Page 12 How is ochre combated? . Page 13 - Raising the water table . Page 13 - Ochre ponds . Page 14 - Winter ponds . Page 17 Are the measures effective? . Page 18 How to get started . Page 20 [3] Title: Ochre. A watercourse problem we can deal with Editor and text: Bent Lauge Madsen Idea and text proposals: Per Søby Jensen, Lars Aaboe Kristensen, Ole Ottosen, Søren Brandt, Poul Aagaard, Flemming Kofoed Translation: David I. Barry Photographs: Bent Lauge Madsen and Per Søby Jensen, Illustrations: Ribe County and Grafisk Tryk Lemvig-Thyborøn Layout and printing: Grafisk Tryk Lemvig-Thyborøn Publisher: Ringkjøbing County, Ribe County, Sønderjylland County, Herning Municipality, Holstebro Municipality Year of publication: 2005 Supported by: Danish Forest and Nature Agency The booklet is available free of charge, see www.okker.dk [4] Introduction Ochre poses an environmental problem in many watercourses in western and southern Jutland (the mainland part of Denmark). The red ochre makes the water turbid in streams and brooks. It covers the bed and coats the plants. Ochre pollution is more than just red ochre, though. It starts with acidic water and invisible, toxic iron that washes out into the watercourses. Neither fish nor macroinvertebra- tes can live in such water. If we are to ensure good-quality watercourses in Denmark it is not sufficient just to treat our waste- water.
    [Show full text]
  • Welcome Future
    WELCOME FUTURE Date: April 2018 Publisher: Aarhus 2017 Foundation Publication Manager and Editor: Rina Valeur Simonsen Monitoring and Research team: Anne Juhl Nielsen, Nana Renee Andersen, Brian Duborg Ebbesen, Maria Hyllested Poulsen Design: Hele Vejen Print: We Produce ISBN: 978-87-999627-7-8 Welcome Future Short-term impact of European Capital of Culture Aarhus 2017 Welcome Future / Intro 2 Aarhus 2017 Contents 4 Selected outcomes 6 Forewords 6 Mette Bock, Minister for Culture 7 Tibor Navracsics, European Commissioner for Education, Culture, Youth and Sport 8 ▪Anders Kühnau, Chair of the Regional Council, Central Denmark Region 9 ▪Jacob Bundsgaard, Mayor, Aarhus and Chair, Aarhus 2017 Foundation 10 ▪Rebecca Matthews, Chief Executive Officer, Aarhus 2017 Foundation 12 Six Strategic Goals and Key Performance Indicators 18 Executive Summary 20 Aarhus in Context 22 Methodology 24 Cultural Impact A stronger and more connected cultural sector 28 ▪A year like no other 36 ▪All art forms and more 44 ▪Something for everyone 48 Selected reviews 53 Local anchoring 56 ▪Grassroots engagement 58 ▪Inviting the world 68 Scaling up the cultural sector 74 Selected awards and nominations Welcome Future / Intro 3 Aarhus 2017 76 Social Impact Active and engaged citizens 80 Engagement through volunteering 90 Cultural community engagement 96 More culture for more people: making art accessible 102 Economic Impact Growth through investment 104 Economic outcome 106 Record growth in visitors 112 Tourist influx by boat and plane 116 Travelling business 118 New
    [Show full text]