Arxiv:1907.07583V2 [Hep-Ex] 14 May 2020 Contents
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The XYZ states: experimental and theoretical status and perspectives Nora Brambillal,m, Simon Eidelmanb,k,h, Christoph Hanhartf,∗, Alexey Nefedievh,i,j, Cheng-Ping Shene,a,∗, Christopher E. Thomasd, Antonio Vairol, Chang-Zheng Yuang,c aSchool of Physics and Nuclear Energy Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, China bBudker Institute of Nuclear Physics, SB RAS, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia cUniversity of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China dDAMTP, University of Cambridge, Wilberforce Road, Cambridge CB3 0WA, UK eKey Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Ion-beam Application and Institute of Modern Physics, Fudan University, Shanghai 200433, China fInstitute for Advanced Simulation, Institut fur¨ Kernphysik and Julich¨ Center for Hadron Physics, Forschungszentrum Julich,¨ Julich¨ D-52425, Germany gInstitute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China hP.N. Lebedev Physical Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Leninskiy Prospect 53, Moscow 119991, Russia iMoscow Institute of Physics and Technology, Institutsky lane 9, Dolgoprudny, Moscow Region 141700, Russia jNational Research Nuclear University MEPhI, Kashirskoe highway 31, Moscow 115409, Russia kNovosibirsk State University, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia lPhysik Department, Technische Universitat¨ Munchen,¨ Garching D-85748, Germany mInstitute for Advanced Study, Universitat¨ Munchen,¨ Lichtenbergstrasse 2 a, Garching D-85748, Germany Abstract The quark model was formulated in 1964 to classify mesons as bound states made of a quark-antiquark pair, and baryons as bound states made of three quarks. For a long time all known mesons and baryons could be classified within this scheme. Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), however, in principle also allows the existence of more com- plex structures, generically called exotic hadrons or simply exotics. These include four-quark hadrons (tetraquarks and hadronic molecules), five-quark hadrons (pentaquarks) and states with active gluonic degrees of freedom (hy- brids), and even states of pure glue (glueballs). Exotic hadrons have been systematically searched for in numerous experiments for many years. Remarkably, in the past fifteen years, many new hadrons that do not exhibit the ex- pected properties of ordinary (not exotic) hadrons have been discovered in the quarkonium spectrum. These hadrons are collectively known as XYZ states. Some of them, like the charged states, are undoubtedly exotic. Parallel to the experimental progress, the last decades have also witnessed an enormous theoretical effort to reach a theoretical under- standing of the XYZ states. Theoretical approaches include not only phenomenological extensions of the quark model to exotics, but also modern non-relativistic effective field theories and lattice QCD calculations. The present work aims at reviewing the rapid progress in the field of exotic XYZ hadrons over the past few years both in experiments and theory. It concludes with a summary on future prospects and challenges. Keywords: Quarkonium, exotic hadrons, B factories, LHC experiments, BES, potential models, effective field theories, lattice QCD arXiv:1907.07583v2 [hep-ex] 14 May 2020 Contents 1 Introduction 3 1.1 Some generalities . .3 1.2 Remarks on the naming scheme of the Particle Data Group . .6 ∗Corresponding author Email addresses: [email protected] (Nora Brambilla), [email protected] (Simon Eidelman), [email protected] (Christoph Hanhart), [email protected] (Alexey Nefediev), [email protected] (Cheng-Ping Shen), [email protected] (Christopher E. Thomas), [email protected] (Antonio Vairo), [email protected] (Chang-Zheng Yuan) Preprint submitted to Physics Reports May 15, 2020 2 Experiments 7 2.1 Experiments at e+e− colliders . .8 2.1.1 The Belle experiment . .8 2.1.2 The BaBar experiment . .9 2.1.3 The CLEO(-c) experiment . .9 2.1.4 The BESIII experiment . 10 2.2 Experiments at proton-antiproton colliders . 12 2.3 Experiments at proton-proton colliders . 13 2.3.1 The LHCb experiment . 13 2.3.2 The ATLAS and CMS experiments . 13 3 Exotic hadron candidates 14 3.1 Isoscalar states . 14 3.1.1 Neutral X states . 14 3.1.2 The Y states . 28 3.1.3 Searches for glueballs with exotic quantum numbers . 41 3.2 Isovector states . 41 3.2.1 The X(5568) state . 41 3.2.2 Charmonium-like charged Zc states . 43 3.2.3 Bottomonium-like charged Zb states . 59 3.3 Isospin-half states . 64 3.3.1 Searches for multi-quark states with strangeness . 64 3.3.2 Pentaquark states . 64 4 Theoretical foundations 67 4.1 Threshold effects without new states . 68 4.2 The quark model . 70 4.3 Phenomenological approaches to exotic hadrons . 81 4.3.1 Hybrids . 81 4.3.2 Hadroquarkonium . 86 4.3.3 Compact tetraquarks . 88 4.3.4 Hadronic molecules . 91 4.3.5 Sum rules . 101 4.4 Effective field theories for QCD . 103 4.4.1 Heavy Quark Effective Field Theory . 104 4.4.2 Non Relativistic QCD . 106 4.4.3 Potential Non-Relativistic QCD . 109 4.4.4 Born–Oppenheimer EFT . 116 4.4.5 Effective field theories at the hadron level . 124 4.5 Lattice QCD . 131 4.5.1 Charmonia and related flavour-exotic channels . 133 4.5.2 Bottomonia and related flavour-exotic channels . 136 4.5.3 Static quark potentials . 138 5 Summary and future prospects 139 5.1 Ongoing and future experiments . 140 5.2 Issues and opportunities in experiments . 146 5.3 Issues and opportunities in theory . 148 2 1. Introduction 1.1. Some generalities Hadrons are described in the Standard Model by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the theory of the strong interactions. QCD is based on the gauge symmetry group SU(3), whose quantum number is called ‘color’. At the most fundamental level its degrees of freedom are quarks (q)1, antiquarks (¯q) and gluons (g), the last ones being the SU(3) gauge bosons [1]. The fact that SU(3) is a non-Abelian group makes QCD a very different theory from Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), the theory of the electromagnetic interactions, and accordingly the phenomenology of hadrons is very different from the one of atoms. Gluons, in contrast to photons, carry a (color) charge, self-interact, antiscreen the vacuum, and are at the origin of such highly nontrivial phenomena in QCD as asymptotic freedom and color confinement. Asymptotic freedom guarantees that high-energy properties of QCD can be computed in weak- coupling perturbation theory [2,3]. On the other hand, color confinement, which implies that all detected hadrons are singlets (neutral) under color SU(3), sets in at low energies, where weak-coupling perturbation theory fails. Both energy scales are relevant for the formation of heavy hadrons. The simplest color-singlet quark combinations that can be formed areqq ¯ and qqq. For a long time, all known hadrons could be explained in terms of the quark model where mesons are bound states of a constituent quark and antiquark, and baryons are bound states of three constituent quarks. However, the requirement of color neutrality still allows for more complicated structures, as was already recognised by Gell-Mann in one of the first publications on the quark model [4], likeq ¯qqq¯ ,q ¯q¯qqqq¯ ,qqqqq ¯ , and so on. In QCD additional states are, in principle, possible like hybrids whose quantum numbers are determined by their quark, antiquark and gluon content: as gluons carry a color charge they can play a much more active role in the formation of a state than photons in atoms. One even expects ‘glueballs’ whose quantum numbers are determined exclusively by their gluonic content. We will refer to any state which does not appear to fit with the expectations for an ordinaryqq ¯ or qqq hadron in the quark model as ‘exotic’. Some of these exotics have quantum numbers that cannot be reproduced by ordinary hadrons. In this case, the identification of these states as exotic is straightforward. In the other cases, the distinction requires a careful analysis of experimental observations and theoretical predictions as will be also discussed in some detail in this review. There are various candidates for exotics in the light-quark sector, e.g., the light scalar mesons. Nevertheless, at the beginning of the century, no candidates for states beyond ordinary hadrons containing heavy quarks had been found. This was even more the case for mesons made of a heavy quark and a heavy antiquark, called quarkonia: The quark model showed excellent agreement with the data both in the charmonium (¯cc quarkonia) and in the bottomonium (bb¯ quarkonia) sectors. The situation changed dramatically in 2003 when Belle observed a structure in the ππJ= final state [5], the X(3872). The properties of the new state did not fit those of an ordinary quarkonium, although it definitely contained a charm-anticharm pair. The assumption that the X(3872) contains the charm-anticharm pair observed in the final state is motivated by the strong suppression of the heavy quark-antiquark pair creation within QCD. After the discovery of the X(3872), many more hadrons were found in processes with final states containing a heavy quark and antiquark, but with properties at odds with those expected for ordinary quarkonia. Among these new states, those that carry an electric charge stick out. Since they must contain, in addition to a heavy quark-antiquark pair, at least a light quark-antiquark pair, they immediately qualify as exotics. For states that from their quantum numbers could be quark-antiquark mesons, but show properties inconsistent with expectations from established quark models, sometimes the term crypto-exotic is used. The candidates for exotic states were dubbed by the experimental collaborations either X(mass), or Y(mass), or Z(mass), and are usually referred to collectively as XYZ states. Y(mass) is usually used for exotics with vector quantum numbers, i.e., JPC = 1−− where J is the spin, P is the parity and C is the charge-conjugation quantum number.