Neodiprion Sertifer)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PHENOTYPIC VARIATION IN HOST QUALITY OF PINES FOR THE EUROPEAN PINE SAWFLY (NEODIPRION SERTIFER) DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Rodrigo A. Chorbadjian, B.S., M.S. ***** The Ohio State University 2009 Dissertation Committee: Dr. Daniel A. Herms, Advisor Approved by Dr. Pierluigi Bonello Dr. Luis Cañas __________________________ Dr. P. Larry Phelan Advisor Graduate Program in Entomology ABSTRACT Phenotypic variation in host quality can affect ecological and evolutionary interactions between plants and herbivores. Effects of phenotypic variation in host quality of woody-plants for leaf feeding insects were investigated in three studies: (1) phenological variation of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) needle quality for the European pine sawfly (Neodiprion sertifer (Geoffroy)) as a test of the "phenological window of host susceptibility hypothesis", (2) effects of fertilization on the expression of defoliation-induced resistance of Austrian pine (P. nigra Arnold) to European pine sawfly, and (3) manipulation of growth/defense trade-offs in paper birch (Betula papyrifera Marsh.) and Austrian pine through application of the plant growth regulator paclobutrazol and fertilization, separately and in combination, as well as resulting effects on resistance to gypsy moth (Lymantria dispar L.), forest tent caterpillar (Malacosoma disstria Hübner), whitemarked tussock moth (Orgyia leucostigma (J. E. Smith)), and European pine sawfly. Consistent with the predictions of the phenological window hypothesis, larval growth and survival decreased as host-insect phenological synchronicity was modified. As current-year shoots and needles elongated, total nitrogen, free amino acids, and soluble carbohydrates concentrations decreased, while mono-, sesqui- and ditepenoid concentrations increased in previous-year needles. Strong correlations between the concentrations of nutrients, and terpenoids and larval growth suggest that this insect can ii tolerate plant defenses only if nutrients are relatively high with respect to chemical defenses. As foliar quality declined, insects ate more in an attempt to compensate but were less efficient at converting consumed foliage to body mass. A slow increase in host quality occurred late in season as mature foliage once again became suitable. The survival of an experimentally-generated second generation of larvae manipulated to emerge in September was only 20% on current- or previous-year foliage; however survival was 80% the following spring. Hence, even though Scots pine foliage is present throughout the year, phenological variation in foliar nutrients and defensive chemistry restricts the life-cycle of European pine sawfly to a narrow window of host susceptibility on previous-year needles in early to mid spring. This phenological window of host susceptibility appears to constrain the evolution of a second generation. The expression of defoliation-induced responses of Austrian pine to European pine sawfly larvae varied with level of fertilization. In the nutrient-rich environment, previous defoliation improved host quality for European pine sawfly larvae, which may promote insect outbreaks through positive density dependent (Allee) effects on population growth. However in the low nutrient treatment, host quality rapidly decreased following defoliation, which is thought to generate negative density dependent effects on population growth thus stabilizing population density. Austrian pines tolerated defoliation through compensatory growth responses, an effect that was independent of the fertilization level and that was evident two growing seasons after the defoliation. The iii concentration of monoterpenes strongly increased one year after the defoliation and across fertility levels. These results are inconsistent with predictions of the carbon nutrient balance hypothesis, which proposes that physiological constraints prevent defoliation-induced accumulation of carbon-based secondary metabolites in evergreens. These phenotypic responses of Austrian pine may represent adaptive plasticity to defoliation that enhances fitness. In nutrient-poor soils Austrian pines would be expected to express rapid induced resistance that would help limit outbreaks and thus defoliation, while compensatory growth responses would enhance competitive ability. Applications of the plant growth regulator paclobutrazol slowed the growth of paper birch and Austrian pine with no effect on photosynthesis. Consistent with the predictions of the growth-differentiation balance hypothesis, application of paclobutrazol increased the concentration of defensive chemicals (tannins) and resistance of paper birch to gypsy moth and whitemarked tussock moth. However, this effect was only observed in the second growing season following application of paclobutrazol. Conversely, paclobutrazol had no effect on foliar defensive chemistry (tannins, phenolics and monoterpenes) of Austrian pine or its resistance to European pine sawfly larvae. Although it has been suggested that paclobutrazol generally enhances tree resistance to insects, it was found here that its effect on tree resistance to leaf-feeding insects was species-specific and time-sensitive. iv Dedicated to my parents for educating me and for their example v ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I thank the guidance of my professors: Dan Herms, Larry Phelan, Luis Cañas and Pierluigi (Enrico) Bonello. Dan, my advisor, provided me with fruitful ideas that resulted in these series of studies, taught me his philosophy of research and helped me during all these years. His classes on the Nature and Practice of Science have been and will be very helpful in my academic development. Also, many thanks to the members of my advisory committee, Larry, Luis and Enrico, whose words of encouragement were always there at the right moment, and whose excellent comments improved earlier versions of this dissertation. Larry’s expertise, advice and his classes on Insect Behavior and Chemical Ecology and Metabolomics were especially significant for me and for the development of this research in general, and in particular for Chapter 2. I thank Bryant Chambers, Diane Hartzler, Alieta Eyles, Alejandro Chiriboga, Matt Solensky, Jamie Imhoff, Rachel Neiswander, Limbania Aliaga, Ilka Gomez, Bryson Mosley, Nate Kleczewski, Duan Wang, Sheldon Steiner, Kelly Hendricks and others that contributed to this research through data collection and/or inquisitive questions that motivated interesting discussions that improved the experiments. I have special appreciation for Bryant and Diane who gave me a warm welcome into the lab and made me feel at home. I thank Nathan Kleczewski for measuring root density and Bruce Birr for conducting nitrogen and phenolics analyses. vi I am grateful to Brenda Franks and Shirley Holmes for their administrative support and their every-day smile. I thank Judy Smith and James Hacker for their help in the greenhouse experiments and for their friendship. Special thanks to Rosa Raudales who was my lovely companion and provided support during these years. I thank the Cañas’ family; Nuris, Luis and Luis Jr., whose friendship and hospitality always made me feel welcome. To Nuris for her continuous help and support, from identifying insects to those unforgettable great dinners at her house. I thank all my fellow grad-students in the Department of Entomology for making my everyday life more fascinating. I thank my friends Claudia Kuniyoshi and Karla Medina for sharing the good and the bad moments of grad-student life. I also thank Vanessa Muilenburg for her friendship. I also thank many friends for being part of my everyday life: Murillo, Menira, Gabriel, Felix, Alejandro, Alfred, Ana, Vero, Mavi, Christian, Cathy, Samuel, Alejandra, Nate, Sandra, Justin, Alex, Sanja, Ronald, Loren, Ale, Priya, and many others. Salaries and research support provided in part by USDA National Research Initiative Competitive Grants Program No. 2004-35302-14667 and by State and Federal funds appropriated to the Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center, the Ohio State University. Funding for Experiment 2 in Chapter 3 was provided by the OARDC Research Enhancement Competitive Grants Program, Research Funds for Grad-Students. vii Research on paclobutrazol was funded in part by Tree Fund and Rainbow Tree care Scientific. viii VITA October 2, 1973………….. Born – Santiago, Chile 1997……………………… BS, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile 2000……………………… M.S., Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile 2002 to present…………… Assistant Professor, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile 2004 to present…………… Graduate Research Associate, The Ohio State University PUBLICATIONS Barto, K., Enright, S., Eyles, A. Wallis, C., Chorbadjian, R., Hansen, R., Herms, D. A., Bonello, P., and Cipollini, D. 2008. Effects of fertilization and fungal and insect attack on systemic protein defenses of Austrian pine. Journal of Chemical Ecology 34: 1392-1400. Wallis, C., Eyles, A., Chorbadjian, R., McSpadden Gardener, B., Hansen, R., Cipollini, D., Herms, D. A., and Bonello, P. 2008. Systemic induction of phloem secondary metabolism and its relationship to resistance to a canker pathogen in Austrian pine. New Phytologist 177: 767-778. Eyles, A., Chorbadjian, R., Wallis, C., Hansen, R., Cipollini, D., Herms, D., and Bonello, E. 2007. Cross-induction of systemic resistance between Sphaeropsis sapinea and Neodiprion sertifer in Austrian pine over a fertility gradient.