Ethnicity and the Second Generation Italian-Canadian Woman in Toronto
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Cmcible of Culture: Ethnicity and the Second Generation Italian-Canadian Woman in Toronto Elena Pieuo A Thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Gradoate Department of Education University of Toronto 8 Copyright by Eiena Pieuo 1997 Master of Arts National Library Bibtiothéque nationale I*I of Canada du Canada Acquisitions and Acquisitions et Bibliographie Services services bibliographiques 395 Wellington Street 395. nie Wellington Ottawa ON KIA ON4 Ottawa ON KIA ON4 Canada Canada Our iUe Narre retérence The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accordé une licence non exclusive licence allowing the exclusive permettant à la National Library of Canada to Bibliothèque nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, distribute or sell reproduire, prêter, distribuer ou copies of this thesis in microform, vendre des copies de cette thèse sous paper or electronic formats. la fome de microfiche/film, de reproduction sur papier ou sur format électronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propriété du copyright in this thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protège cette thése. thesis nor substantial extracts fiom it Ni la thèse ni des extraits substantiels may be printed or othenvise de celle-ci ne doivent être imprimés reproduced without the author's ou autrement reproduits sans son permission. autorisation. The Crucible of Culture: Ethnicity and the Second Generation Italian-Canadian Woman in Toronto Master of Arts 1997 Elena Piezzo History and Philosophy Graduate Department of Education University of Toronto This essay examines the nature and persistence of ethnicity among a group of university educated. second generation Italian Canadian women. It explores those factors, both external and internai. that contribute to the formation and maintenance of their ethnic identity. While no two women had identicai expenences or views. as a whole they feel at odds with the duality of cultures they are forced to balance because they lack a sense of belonging to either their native community or their ethnic community. Those of the second generation have no definable place as they are not immigrants, and they do not feel themselves Canadian beyond their legal citizenship. As ltalian Canadian women. they are reduced to mythological constructs of society's imagination. Ultimately. they are labelled "typical Italian women". indicatins both a feeble attempt at understanding and conternpt for a "foreign" çroup. The "crucible". both a meltinç pot for metal. and a trial. is a metaphor for the Italian Canadian woman expected to assirnilate into one culture or another. Unable to assimilate she faces judgement and condemnation to a social role she may not otherwise have chosen. Chapter One explores the relationship between art and literature of the ethnic community and their perceived identity. Chapter two examines the creation of an ltalian community in Toronto and the impact of social, geographic and economic forces on the ethnicization of the second generation. Chapter three discusses the Italian immigrant rnother and her relationship with her Canadian bom daughter. Chapter four presents the results of the inte~ewsconducted wiih second seneration women. Acknowledgements Fur my mother ajzdfarher who cmrageozdj irttdertook the voyage ami cotititnre foaccompty my sister mzd 1on otw own. cm III> grande more pimo di untore. speratze. e forza per le loro mie. Heurifeh fhrh to Linab "Owen" ChiaravuIIot i. Vince Tomei ami Lucy Zurnpetta who offered their vahabie tinte. as a labotu of love, in w~dertakitzgthe fusks of editors. commentators. and iypists. LMutïyrhatzks are ouvd fo professor O& Tropet-for his guidailce aild bzvaft~ubIecomrnettts on earlier editïoizs of this work. Table of Contents Introduction Chapter One: ldentity and lntellectualism C hapter Two : Postwar Toronto Italians and the Process of Et hnicizat ion Chapter Three: The Italian Mother Chapter Four: The "Typical" Italian-Canadian Woman and Man Conclusion Epilogue Endnotes Bibliogaphy INTRODUCTION For the most part, Italian immigration to Canada is considered from a masculine mindset. Males lefi their homes as sojoumers, or as permanent settlers to establish a life in North Amen'ca. They were humbled, exploited, resourcefùl and at times. even rebellious. In al1 of this there is an underlying presumption that fernales were subordinate, and not real actors in the decision to immigrate. They were summoned, called over, to join their husbands who had already finished the work of establishing a home. They were the last fixtures on the immigrant stage. However, women were often leading actors in the process of immigration. Once settlernent was established, it was immigrant women who were entnisted with giving life to the existence their spouses had etched out of Canada. They were the primary agents of socialization in the home, ofien linking economic su~valwith a veritable social existence. They were also forced to contend with narrow personas created for them in the drama of immigration. Cast as subrnissive beings, trapped in traditions, and denied access to the language and culture of the new world, they were charactenzed by stereotypical preconceptions of the immigrant, set against the backdrop of an anglophone world. This stereotypical view becarne projected ont0 subsequent generations-giving rise to the "typical Italian woman", a stock character of sorts with exaggerated, traditionai mannerisms and antiquated beliefs. For second generation Italian-Canadian women seeking to gain meaningfùl ownership or partnership in Canadian society, this typecast has served to rnarginalize them both by gender and culture. They have found thernselves waging a conscious battle against the image of the "typical Italian woman" on two battlefields: one controlled by the anglophone, host society and the other, on the "no man's land of the Mo-Canadian society. This study seeks to explore the impact that immigration and ethnicization has had on Canadian-bom daughters of Italian parents. While for the first generation the immigrant expenence is characterized by the struggle for economic survival and CO-dependencyon fellow immigrants, for their children, immigration meant reconciling the duality of cultures in which they were raised. The choices these women made were shaped both by their family's concepts of the host society and the host society's concept of immigrant daughters. For sons and daughters their experiences were markedly direrent. For wornen, being part of the Italian community was characterized primarily by a struggle for social power. This essay will examine ethnicization and identity arnong second generation Italian- Canadian women in four parts: first, an analysis of their self-expression in language, art, and Iiterature; second, an examination of the factors which caused the establishment of an Italian immigrant community in Toronto; third, an examination of immigrant women, or the mothers of the women studied; fourth, an examination of the socialization and acculturation of second seneration Italian-Canadian women and, an analysis of their self-perception as Italian-Canadian women. or identity, as reflected in mamage, education and careers. Finally, there will be a bief comparison to their male counterparts. Who is an Italian-Canadian? This is not easily answered. In the case of Italian-Canadians. where cultural duality is clearly prevaient, one cannot simply ask, do you feel part of this group or that group, and expect to receive a definitive answer. Self-identification involves a significant pattern of cultural penistence and identity. Social trends in the ltalian community continue to show the tenacity of Itaiiat~itain Toronto, a p henomenon that has outlived waves of Itdian immigration. Moreover, Toronto has seen the rearing of a second, and now a third generation of Itaiian-Canadians who differ significantly fiom their immigrant parents, yet still resonate their parents' immigrant experiences. It is the intent of this audy to examine second generation Italian- Canadian wornen based on an informal sample of oral intewiews and observations.' It will explore the nature of ethnicity among these second generation Italian-Canadian women between the ages of 25-40 who are university educated and raised in Toronto. Its conclusions are not so much definit ive as tentative and speculative. Italian-Canadian women wage a constant battle for ernpowerrnent and equity in the social and professional world. Not only must they prove their cornpetence, but they must also disprove ethnic stereotypes. At the same time they must balance the duality of cultures in the perpetuation of ItaIimiità. Complete enfranchisement in the socio-political Canadian structure requires being viewed as a Canadian. One cannot become an actor in the Canadian community if one is not viewed as a Canadian. Deliberately, this study focuses on university educated women, who have inevitably been exposed to universal notions of "Canadianess". Yet, as children of immigrants, they are still not completely Canadian. Effectively, Canadianess cornes in degrees. There are different types of Canadians, and they are not equal; an implied ethnic inferiority is pervasive. Ethnicization created a classification scheme for immigrant groups that makes them intelligible and socially manageable for outsiders. The label "typical", when placed as an adjective in front of the noun Italian signals not only the stereotyping of the Italians, but a mythological ascription. In an interview, one