Perspectives

The art of medicine Black —rising above invisibility

The voice and agency of Black women health professionals is still awarded by the American Nursing Association to have been systematically neglected, despite progress honour nurses who have advanced nursing opportunities towards egalitarianism in medicine. The relationship of to members of minority groups. Black women to medicine has historically included unethical As Black women have increasingly expanded their roles treatment, dismissal, invalidation, and other harms with in society, including being the backbone of US democracy roots in structural and racial stereotyping. This history by consistently voting and galvanising voters, they have has present-day consequences that must be understood as had to wrestle with their invisibility in most corners of the foundational to a representative recognition of Black women democracy. After emancipation from chattel , the in medicine. There needs to be a restructuring of the systems era of Reconstruction, which represented some structural that have been complicit in the silencing of Black women and legislative progress for previously enslaved persons, and reducing their value to a diversity quota checkbox. was replaced with the oppressive policies and practices History has shown us that when Black women are given the of the southern Jim Crow laws as well as federal and state opportunity, despite limited resources and systemic barriers, policies that legalised and supported racial segregation they add immeasurable value. Two historical examples from nationwide. Paralleling the larger racially oppressive the USA cast light on such contributions. forces in US society, access to the medical profession The first African American woman physician in the USA, was generally withheld from Black people by the white Rebecca Lee Crumpler, graduated from the New England establishment, requiring the creation of Black educational Female Medical College in , MA, in 1864. She institutions as segregation offered few other options for overcame barriers rooted in both and racism in Black women interested in medicine. It is striking that Further reading her efforts to build on her nursing background to qualify desegregating higher education by removing structural Alegría M, Fukuda M, as a physician. Crumpler worked for the Freedmen’s barriers along the pipeline into medicine has produced Lapatin Markle S, NeMoyer A. Bureau which was based in the southern states, where relatively small gains, as evidenced by the continued under- Mentoring future researchers: advice and considerations. about 4 million freed Black people, as well as poor whites, representation of Black women in medicine. Am J Orthopsychiatry 2019; required access to public health systems after the American Despite exceptional merits and accolades, today there still 89: 329–36 Civil War. The bureau was harshly segregated, underfunded, exists a cognitive dissonance when a Black woman physician Ayyala MS, Skarupski K, and had insufficient personnel, resulting in limited access to is in a leadership position. In medical institutions, evidence Bodurtha JN, et al. Mentorship is not enough: exploring health care for freed Black people. One of Crumpler’s many of this can be subtle; the consulting team might request to sponsorship and its role in career pioneering efforts included the creation of a community speak to the attending physician and then communicate advancement in academic guide for doctoring in the post-Civil War period, A Book of through verbal and non-verbal behaviours their surprise at medicine. Acad Med 2019; 94: 94–100 Medical Discourses: in Two Parts, which provided citizens in discovering that the attending physician is a Black woman. Association of American Medical impoverished communities with information to support Colleges. Percentage of full-time the health and wellbeing of women, infants, and children. U.S. medical school faculty by sex Crumpler’s contributions are not generally taught in medical and race/ethnicity, 2018. https://www.aamc.org/data- schools or residency training programmes, representing an reports/workforce/interactive- erasure in history and present-day consciousness. data/figure-16-percentage- The contributions of African American nurses have also full-time-us-medical-school- faculty-sex-and-race/ been largely overlooked. Mary Eliza Mahoney was the ethnicity-2018 (accessed first Black professional licensed nurse in the USA. Born in Jan 31, 2021) 1845 to former slaves, she worked as a cook and janitor Beech BM, Calles-Escandon J, before enrolling in a 16-month nursing programme at the Hairston KG, et al. Mentoring New England Hospital for Women and Children in Boston. programs for underrepresented minority faculty in academic Due to immense racism in the US public nursing sector in medical centers: a systematic this period, Mahoney sought employment in the private review of the literature. Acad Med sector, and advocated for the rights of Black nurses. As 2013; 88: 541–49 many Black nurses were not welcomed into national or state Blackstock U. Why Black doctors like me are leaving academic nursing organisations, the National Association of Colored medicine. STAT, Jan 16, 2020, Graduate Nurses (NACGN) was formed in 1908. In 1909, https://www.statnews. Mahoney delivered the welcome address at the first NACGN com/2020/01/16/black-doctors- leaving-faculty-positions- conference in Boston. The Mary Mahoney Award, originally FLHC 90/Alamy Stock Photo academic-medical-centers/ started at NACGN to honour distinguished Black nurses, Mary Eliza Mahoney (1845–1926) (accessed Jan 31, 2021)

www.thelancet.com Vol 397 February 13, 2021 573 Perspectives

Such invalidation, microaggressions, and macroaggressions Institutions and departments also need to encourage Chayer M. Mary Eliza Mahoney. are glaring, and their repetitions can contribute to chronic intentional sponsorship of Black women physicians they Am J Nursing 1954; 54: 429–31 stress for Black women in medicine. Obstacles faced by seek to recruit and retain. Sponsorship is needed to support Crenshaw K. Mapping the Black women are unique because they are both Black and margins: intersectionality, career advancement. Sponsors actively clear the road ahead identity politics, and violence women, making initiatives focused only on gender diversity for the beneficiary. This can be in the form of nomination against women of color. and inclusion insufficient for addressing these interpersonal for an award, a talk, or leadership position. Those in senior Stanford Law Rev 1991; and institutional dynamics. Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw’s leadership positions must make additional efforts to sponsor 43: 1241–99 concept of intersectionality is important here to describe the Black women to support their success. And structures need Crenshaw K. Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: dual identity of race and gender, as well as other intersecting to be in place at institutional and departmental levels to ease a black feminist critique of factors including sexuality, class, and disability, which present the process of finding sponsors. antidiscrimination doctrine, daily in the lived experiences of Black women. The burden of Formal leadership training and professional coaching feminist theory and antiracist politics. Univ Chic Leg Forum constantly proving themselves in workspaces while facing at all levels of training are also important for advancing 1989; 1: 8 covert and overt racism takes both a physiological and Black women to leadership positions in medicine. Leaders, Hegewisch A, Tesfaselassie A. psychological toll, and also potentially threatens the pipeline we know, are made. How can we lead effectively if we are The gender wage gap: 2018; of Black women physicians into academia. not trained? Formal leadership training and professional earnings differences by gender, race, and ethnicity. IWPR #C484. Increasing diversity among health-care leadership has coaching provide tools and frameworks to solidify core Institute for Women’s Policy positive impacts on institutional culture and also improves values, practise authenticity, build confidence, and construct Research, September, 2019. patient outcomes. However, Black women comprise a small an armamentarium of resources to weather crises. https://iwpr.org/iwpr-general/ the-gender-wage-gap-2018- proportion of health-care leaders in the USA: only about 2% Another component often overlooked is compensation. In earnings-differences-by-race- of US medical faculty are Black women. Institutions expend the USA, Black women are undercompensated for their work. and-ethnicity/ (accessed energy on diversity training yet little attention is placed Black women have the additional burden of the diversity or Jan 31, 2021) on revealing, dismantling, and challenging the structures minority tax. They are often asked to lead equity committees Herrin J, Harris KG, Spatz E, et al. and stereotyped distortions that require these trainings in Hospital leadership diversity and or teach others about the inequities they face without strategies to advance health the first place. Implicit and explicit racial attitudes, beliefs, additional compensation. This, in addition to oppressive equity. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf and stereotypes converge to distort perceptions about work environments, can lead to frustration, burn-out, and 2018; 44: 545–51 Black women, undermining their access to inclusive work might cause them to leave the field of medicine altogether. Hine DC. Mahoney, Mary Eliza. environments and leadership opportunities. To have lasting Institutions must acknowledge wage disparities using Oxford African American Studies Center. Dec 1, 2006 impacts, especially within racial justice efforts, racism must disaggregated data beyond only gender and adequately History, A&E Television be combated at both societal and institutional levels. compensate Black women for their time and their work. Networks. Freedmen’s Bureau. Dismantling barriers to leadership and increasing Broader efforts to address structural racism and inequality Oct 3, 2018. https://www. visibility must be accompanied by adequate support and an include having just and transparent processes to address racist history.com/topics/black- history/freedmens-bureau inclusive leadership culture. To improve health outcomes and discriminatory actions that emphasise accountability, (accessed Jan 31, 2021) for all patients, including Black women, there should also recompense, and possible reconciliation. Increasing public Koehn N. Real leaders are formed be hospital-based policies and actionable goals aimed at discourse on racial injustice can also foster focused dialogue in crisis. Harv Bus Rev, increasing recruitment, visibility, retention, and promotion on generating solutions across multiple sectors and inspire April 3, 2020 of Black women physicians, especially in leadership roles. the political will necessary for protective workplace policies. Lewis JA, Neville HA. Construction and initial This can be done through mentorship, sponsorship, and an These efforts can help turn the tide on the structured validation of the Gendered Racial assessment of mechanisms of racism within organisational invisibility, lack of recognition, and pervasive racial and Microaggressions Scale for Black culture, including hiring and promotion policies and gender stereotypes that erect barriers to realising the women. J Couns Psychol 2015; 62: 289–302 practices. Holding hospital leadership accountable for quality potential of Black women in medicine. Black women have Markel H. Celebrating improvement metrics for patient outcomes, especially for a legacy of advocacy and activism in USA, and despite Rebecca Lee Crumpler, first Black women and other racialised minorities, is also necessary this, their needs are constantly overlooked while they face African-American woman to combat racism. In addition, the creation of databases persistent inequities. The increased visibility of Black women physician. March 9, 2016. that track mentorship, sponsorship, and promotion of https://www.pbs.org/newshour/ fighting for racial justice and equity for all communities gives health/celebrating-rebecca-lee- Black women in medical institutions is required to address a voice to those who have been silenced for centuries. Black crumpler-first-african-american- inequities in diversifying hospital leadership. women will continue to rise, instil hope, and contribute to physician (accessed Jan 31, 2021) Black women are often undermentored in medicine. the changing tides in the medical community. Olayiwola JN, Choo E. Successful mentorship has been shown to create career Seven more things organisations should be doing to combat satisfaction, advancement, and productivity. Mentorship is *Onyinyechi Eke, Onyeka Otugo, Jessica Isom racism. Lancet 2020; 396: 593 needed at all career stages but is especially important early in Department of Emergency Medicine, General Torres MB, Salles A, Cochran A. one’s career. Too often, when Black women physicians seek Hospital, Boston, MA 02114, USA (OE); Department of Emergency Recognizing and reacting to mentorship, they may be faced with excuses; the question Medicine, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, MA, USA (OO); microaggressions in medicine Codman Square Health Center, Boston MA, USA (JI) and surgery. JAMA Surg 2019; should be put forward, if a non-Black woman or man 154: 868–72 requested similar mentorship, what would the response be? [email protected]

574 www.thelancet.com Vol 397 February 13, 2021