2019 Annual Report Us Well Placed to Adapt to These Changing Market and Financial Statements
Annual Report and Financial Statements 2019
Contents
2019 Performance Review Governance Report
Chairman’s overview...... 4 Viability statement...... 42 Chief Executive’s overview...... 6 Directors’ Report...... 51 Audit & Risk Committee Report...... 53 Nominations Committee Report...... 55 Strategic Report Directors’ Remuneration Report...... 56 Directors’ biographies...... 72
Business model...... 8 Competitive advantage...... 9 Financial Report Business units and processes...... 11 Ethics and conduct...... 16 Independent Auditors Report...... 74 Our people...... 18 Financial Statements...... 82 Communities and social review...... 21 Notes to the Financial Statements...... 92 Environment, health and safety...... 22 Risk management...... 27 Additional Information Financial review...... 38
Officers and advisors...... 144 Glossary...... 145 Chairman’s overview
I am pleased to present footprint and wide range of leading technologies leave our 2019 annual report us well placed to adapt to these changing market and financial statements. conditions.
I am delighted and IQE has established and has continued to maintain a honoured, after two and significant technological and process advantage in the a half years on the Board, high-volume manufacture of large diameter (150mm) to have taken over the wafers for vertical cavity surface emitting laser (VCSEL)
2019 Performance Review chairmanship of IQE products that form the heart of a rapidly-growing in April 2019. IQE is an trend for optical sensing applications, such as facial exciting and innovative recognition and authentication, where we command a company and I am significant global market share. committed to supporting and championing a In 2019, we completed the infrastructure phase of culture of innovation, our substantial capacity expansion. Our new ‘Mega growth and inclusion. Foundry’ in Newport is a state-of-the-art facility capitalising on 30 years of compound semiconductor I am particularly proud of the response of all of the experience. The first batch of tools are now in staff and leadership of IQE in the extremely difficult production, with space for a ten-fold expansion to circumstances resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. address the 3D sensing market which is forecast for The implementation of measures to keep our teams exceptional growth. We also increased our capacity working safely whilst keeping vital operations active, in Taiwan for advanced wireless products based on to support our customers and partners, has been GaAs (Gallium Arsenide) by 40% and consolidated achieved through the dedication of our teams and the our Wireless GaN (Gallium Nitride) capacity in support of their families. Massachusetts. These Wireless expansions are key enablers to grow market share as 5G networks, IQE is the world’s leading supplier of advanced infrastructures and solutions roll out globally. semiconductor material solutions that underpin and will enable the 21st century economy. We innovate, IQE has a unique opportunity as a leading technology develop and manufacture compound semiconductor manufacturer to ensure that our culture, practices and wafers and complementary material technologies that procedures support minimal environmental impact. are at the heart of the digital revolution. We continue to strive for the highest standards in our environmental practices. I am proud to say that our Our compound semiconductor technologies play new Newport facility is built to the highest technical an increasingly important role in shaping the way standards with energy saving features built in by we live, work and spend our leisure time. Our design. innovative materials will play a key role in enabling next generation solutions in communications technology, Furthermore, we recognise the technologies we security, privacy and artificial intelligence. This includes develop and manufacture can have a huge positive powering connected devices, healthcare solutions, impact towards a sustainable world. The advanced smart energy, autonomous vehicles, big data and ultra- properties of materials like GaN are capable of high-speed connectivity including 5G, and the latest providing highly-efficient power switching for a wide evolution of cloud and hyper-scale data centres. range of industrial and consumer uses. The use of GaN in 5G networks has the potential to revolutionise IQE is a global technology leader operating in a connectivity in rural areas, as well as the sustainable dynamic and competitive market. Our compound use of power resources in urban areas. Our VCSEL- semiconductor materials offer significant performance based photonics provide greater security and advantages and functionality over silicon-based are likely to play a key role in the safety of future semiconductors in terms of higher speed, lower power autonomous vehicles. Our research and development consumption, and more efficient RF capabilities; but into lasers for environmental and health monitoring perhaps most importantly, compound semiconductors has the potential to transform the way we all live. lie at the heart of the expanding photonics industry. As energy infrastructure transitions to renewables and smart grids and as ultra high-speed, low latency During 2019 the global market for compound communication networks roll out, IQE has a real and semiconductors experienced significant disruption as exciting opportunity to make a genuinely positive a result of the global geo-political situation, including difference to society and the environment. trade tensions between the US and China. However, in the medium and long term, IQE’s broad geographic
4 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Board and management changes Summary
Godfrey Ainsworth stepped down as Chairman and 2019 was a year in which IQE’s financial performance Interim CFO in April 2019. I would like to take this was adversely affected to a material extent by the opportunity to thank Godfrey for his long service to global geo-political environment. In 2020, the world IQE. I am delighted to be taking over as Non-Executive is dealing with the significant uncertainty created by Chairman, having served on the Board since late 2016 the spread of Coronavirus. However, I believe IQE is as a Senior Independent Director. well placed to adapt to rapidly changing global market conditions and to withstand near term uncertainty. A key milestone for IQE over the last year was the IQE has a unique breadth and depth in compound appointment of Tim Pullen who joined IQE as Chief semiconductor material solutions, unrivalled Financial Officer in February 2019. Tim, whose intellectual property and strength in a diverse global appointment was announced in October 2018, was manufacturing footprint. With the investments we have most recently Chief Financial Officer of ARM Limited, a made in new technologies and manufacturing capacity, global semiconductor and software design company combined with recent evolutions in our Board and owned by Softbank Group. His appointment as CFO Executive Management personnel, the company is well 2019 Performance Review is strongly aligned with the aim of having a Board with placed to grow in the coming years. the appropriate balance of skills and expertise to steer the Company through the next exciting phase in our I would like to thank my fellow Directors and all the evolution. management and staff of IQE for their hard work in the challenging circumstances of the past year as well In May 2019, Carol Chesney joined IQE as a Non- as their ongoing professionalism and dedication in Executive Director and Chair of the Audit Committee. current uncertain times. I would also like to thank our A Chartered Accountant, Carol is an experienced shareholders for their continued support and belief Non-Executive Director, currently serving as a Non- that the IQE team will capitalise on the significant Executive Director and Chair of the Audit Committee market opportunities that will emerge following these of Renishaw plc since October 2012, in addition to challenging years. serving as a Non-Executive Director and Chair of the Audit Committees of Hunting PLC since April 2018 and Biffa PLC since July 2018.
During the year, we also announced the formation of the Executive Management Board. This evolution of the senior management structure ensures we are extremely well positioned and resourced to execute Phil Smith our strategy and to make the changes necessary to Chairman, IQE Plc. scale and adapt the business as we grow. This followed 28 April 2020 the announcement of the retirement of Dr Howard Williams who was a founding member of EPI in 1988 (which became IQE in 1999) and who was appointed to the Board of IQE as Chief Operating Officer in 2004. Dr Williams has been an integral part of the growth of IQE and remains engaged with the Group on a part time basis as a consultant advisor.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 5 Chief Executive’s overview
2019 in review emerging high-growth markets. By far the largest single expansion has been our new epi 2019 proved to be a Mega Foundry in Newport which was initiated very challenging year for by IQE in September 2017. The 30,000m2 IQE, primarily due to the building was acquired by the Cardiff Capital considerable uncertainty Region and subsequently leased by IQE. Since created by the changes taking on the lease of the building as an empty in the geo-political shell, IQE has completed the first phase of landscape and the construction of cleanrooms and services for
2019 Performance Review ensuing effects on global up to 20 MOCVD tools. The first ten tools have technology markets. been installed and nine are now production ready with six of these in full mass production. Of particular importance When fully occupied, the Newport facility will to IQE was the impact have the capacity to house up to 100 high- of trade disputes on volume production tools. the market for smartphone handsets and volumes ordered by IQE’s supply chains in the second half of The continuation of progress on Research and the year. These changes proved disruptive to short- Development programmes in 2019, including term sales volumes, materially impacting our revenues Radio Frequency (RF) Filters and Switches, Long and profitability in 2019. Wavelength VCSELs, Distributed Feedback (DFB) lasers and Quasi Photonic Crystals (QPC) Overall, IQE posted a 10% reduction in revenues for wafer level optics using our Nano-Imprint versus 2018 figures, which was in line with Lithography (NIL) technology. During the year semiconductor industry norms during the 2019 we enhanced our New Product Introduction downturn in the semiconductor cycle. In IQE’s case, (NPI) process to strengthen governance for this was predominantly the result of reductions in bringing new technologies to market and revenue from two key customers, one in the Wireless optimising returns on investment. segment, with orders being impacted by changes in global markets, and one in the Photonics segment due to technical issues outside of IQE’s control. IQE The formation of IQE’s Executive Management is confident it has not lost share with either of these Board which continues to make good customers and remains very well positioned to partner progress in driving the Company’s approach with them in future growth opportunities. to increasing profitability, with specific responsibilities assigned for programs on Growth in 3D Sensing (3DS) revenues was slower than operational execution, new technology hoped as Android adoption of the technology was introduction, revenue expansion through limited to very high-end handsets which sell in lower customer proximity and diversification, and volumes. Additionally, there were no additional content strong cost management. gains – where IQE could benefit from a greater number of compound semiconductors being used in devices as they become ever more technologically advanced – During the second half of 2019, the management team in our existing major supply chain. However, broader took steps to reduce costs and capital expenditure adoption by Android is still anticipated and IQE is following the completion of the infrastructure phase confident of maintaining its number one position and of capacity expansion. We remain in a strong position benefiting from potential content gains in the existing to grow revenues and profits in future periods, due to major supply chain in 2020 and beyond. the broad market opportunity we face and the high operating leverage of the Group. Despite the challenging market conditions in 2019, IQE made significant business progress in the year. This As we entered 2020 there were positive signs that included: forecasts from our key customers and markets were returning to growth. However, these positive signs are tempered by the increasing uncertainty created by the global spread of Coronavirus. At the time of this The completion of the infrastructure phase report, our current production has been unaffected. of a significant capacity expansion project, We also have a strong balance sheet with access to including the go-live of production at our material additional debt facilities should we need Mega Foundry in Newport, South Wales, a them. This means we are well positioned to withstand 40% increase in capacity in Taiwan and the the current uncertainty and when this period is over, centralisation of our US GaN capability in we look forward to an exciting future. Massachusetts following the New Jersey site closure. Our investment in capacity expansion As the multi-year 5G mega-replacement cycle gathers is focussed on servicing a number of new and
6 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 pace, we anticipate strong growth for our business continue to work closely with both suppliers and in future years. 5G will provide a significant growth customers to manage our resilience against potential driver for IQE in GaN technologies for mobile network disruption. infrastructure and for GaAs technologies for mobile handsets. Photonics will continue to grow with content These are unprecedented times across the world. growth and higher levels of handset penetration, During this challenging period, our primary objective for 3D sensing VCSEL based products. The rapidly is to keep our staff and their families safe and well. increasing data content of 5G backhaul and front By focussing on this, by managing our business with haul fibre optic networks and hyperscale datacentres prudence and discipline and with the assurance of will drive demand for our DFB lasers and high-speed access to sufficient debt facilities should we need detector products. In addition, increasing adoption of them, I am confident we can navigate potential Infrared technologies for sensing applications, in space near-term challenges. Moreover, with our first- and defence, and in future adoption in consumer class workforce, strong underlying demand for our devices for environmental and healthcare monitoring products and an exciting future product roadmap, will continue to strengthen our position in this market. I am convinced we will emerge from this an even stronger company, ready to tackle the future and the 2019 Performance Review opportunities it will present. 2020 outlook
After a challenging year in 2019, predominantly due to the impact of geo-political tensions, further challenging conditions are expected in 2020 due to the rapid global spread of Coronavirus. Dr Drew Nelson OBE The impacts of the virus on people’s lives has already President and Chief Executive Officer, IQE Plc. been significant at the date of this report, with many 28 April 2020 regions of the world in ‘stay at home’ lockdowns and healthcare systems stretched to maximum capacity and beyond. At IQE we are aware of the uncertainty this creates and are working as proactive members of the communities in which we operate, to help where we can.
Despite the uncertain environment, trading for the first quarter of 2020 was slightly above our expectations. The smartphone handset market has seen the launch of new models from several OEM’s and 5G communications infrastructure deployments, are showing signs of growth.
Whilst at the time of this report IQE’s business has been largely unaffected by the spread of Coronavirus, there remains a risk of a global economic downturn which could in turn adversely affect near-term demand for IQE’s products.
An economic downturn with an associated reduction in business and consumer spending, could reduce demand for smartphones. However, at a time of social distancing and self-isolation, with many thousands of people continuing to work at home, demand for smartphone handsets may withstand an economic downturn better than many other sectors. Furthermore, the Group considers it likely that Governments will pursue 5G infrastructure deployments as part of economic stimulus packages as they emerge from the health crisis. There is already some evidence of this in Asia.
There also remains a risk of disruption to production at IQE sites or at those of our customers or suppliers. However, the Group’s operations are geographically diversified across nine different sites in three continents, significantly lessening the impact of potential disruption at any single site. In addition, we are classified as a critical manufacturing business in many of the countries in which we operate. We
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 7 Our business model Strategic Report
IQE’s core business is the design and manufacture of compound semiconductor wafers or “epiwafers” using a process called epitaxy. IQE’s epiwafers are used in advanced electronic and photonic components that provide the essential enabling technologies across a broad portfolio of today’s high-tech products.
The importance of IQE’s world leading technologies is increasing, driven by the macro trends of 5G communications and connected devices. These trends require the superior performance of compound semiconductor technologies to operate at higher frequencies, higher power ranges and to emit and detect light. We believe the future demand for compound semiconductors will underpin significant growth for IQE, enabling the company to deliver significant shareholder value.
Delivering shareholder value
Research New products Manufacturing Customer Mass & development capacity qualification production
Expanding margins and cash generation
8 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Competitive advantage Strategic Report
IQE has established a strong leadership position in the compound semiconductor markets for both Wireless and Photonics epiwafers. Our leadership is built around our unparalleled breadth of intellectual property (IP). Our close collaboration with our customers ensures that our processes are highly integrated and embedded within our supply chains.
Our customers value IQE’s focused innovation and New Product Introduction technical expertise through which we develop and retain long-term relationships with all our major IQE’s long-term success relies on enabling customers customers. We believe that our broad product through new, innovative products. In order to ensure portfolio, multi-site operations, extensive process that the right products are developed and introduced, know-how, advanced materials patent portfolio, IQE uses a rigorous phase-gate governance superior quality, unit economics and deep customer framework. This framework ensures that all relevant relationships represent a powerful competitive functional groups of the company such as our advantage. Business Units, Technology, Operations, Finance and Quality, contribute their expertise ensuring that New Product Introduction is efficient and effective enabling Research & Development significant growth and return on investment.
IQE is committed to technological leadership through research and development. In addition to our intellectual property portfolio and process know- how, we add further value by offering innovative new products and technologies that enhance our customers’ competitive advantages.
Through both organic growth and acquisition, IQE has established clear technology leadership which continues to attract the brightest and best talent in our industry.
IP Portfolio
IQE’s leadership as a materials solutions provider is underpinned by a comprehensive IP portfolio born out of 30 years of experience. IQE actively patents its technology when appropriate and in accordance with IP strategy. IQE’s patent portfolio focuses on protecting the Group’s key Technology Platforms which are applicable across a broad range of markets. The portfolio consists of approximately 175 patents (both granted and pending) but is expanding every year. Due to the central importance of IP, IQE has a dedicated Technology Group that manages the business’ rapidly expanding IP portfolio.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 9 Global Manufacturing Capacity
IQE manufactures across three continents using both Metal Organic Chemical Vapour Disposition (MOCVD) and Molecular Beam Epitaxy (MBE) technologies. This unique global footprint enables the Company to forge links with academic institutions and research establishments worldwide and provides close proximity to our global customers, while ensuring security of supply for these customers. In 2019 our geographical revenues were approximately 55% from the US, 10% from Europe and 35% from Asia. Strategic Report
USA Bethlehem, PA Greensboro, NC Spokane, WA Asia Taunton, MA Taiwan EUROPE Singapore CSDC Cardiff, UK CSC Milton Keynes, UK Newport, UK
10 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Key business units Strategic Report
The Group has established three external market facing business units within the organisation. Each of our business units has a clear product, technology and customer focus and is supported by a world-class technology group focussing on product introductions for new and emerging technology markets. Our business units are:
Wireless The fastest growing segment of the wireless chip The wireless market covers electronic radio-frequency market over the past few years has been for high (RF) devices that enable wireless communications. performance filters. Although the primary materials Our markets include, but are not limited to, mobile technology for filters (aluminium nitride AlN) is communications (smartphones), base stations, mobile made from compound semiconductor elements, the networks, WiFi, smart metering, satellite navigation, wafers have to date been fabricated using a much and many other connected devices. less sophisticated “sputtering” process. IQE’s cREOTM process provides a unique opportunity to overcome For the last two decades, compound semiconductors many of the challenges in producing single crystal AlN have been the key enabling technology for mass wafers for 5G filter applications and we are engaged market applications such as smartphones, WiFi and with multiple customers with this potentially disruptive wirelessly connected devices thanks to their high- high-performance solution. speed and high-performance capabilities. Our products will play an increasingly important role in Whilst the Wireless sector offers strong future growth enabling 5G systems and connected devices globally. potential, due to the disrupted global supply chains and consequent inventory run down in 2019, our After the first smartphone was launched in 2007, wireless sales declined 22.5% year-on-year. The sector the wireless market enjoyed several years of double- accounted for 48.5% of the Group’s sales in 2019. digit organic growth as the launch of newer, faster and more powerful devices enticed consumers to Photonics upgrade to the latest models. However, since 2013 The photonics market covers applications that either the innovation cycle has slowed and handset market transmit or sense light (both visible and Infrared). growth has tailed off. According to industry analyst Photonics products made using IQE’s advanced IDC, overall smartphone shipments has stagnated semiconductor materials enabling a wide range of since 2016 with handset shipments in 2019 remaining end markets in consumer, commercial and industrial relatively flat year-on-year. applications.
Whilst smartphone sales volumes may have stagnated, IQE is a world leader in photonics technologies with a the relentless increase in data traffic continues to product and intellectual property portfolio including drive the need for more sophisticated wireless chip Vertical Cavity Surface Emitting Lasers (“VCSEL”), solutions in handsets. It is anticipated that this will Indium Phosphide (InP) and Infrared products. drive the market towards 5G connectivity sooner VCSELs are the key enabling technology behind a rather than later, which provides significant upside number of high growth markets including 3D sensing potential for IQE’s wireless business as the transition for face-recognition, data communications, data will require much more complex material technologies. centres, gesture-recognition, environmental and Furthermore, infrastructure applications such as health monitoring, cosmetics, illumination and heating base stations, radar and CATV are likely to become applications. an increasingly important part of IQE’s wireless business as the superior performance of our materials Optical communications and sensing applications technology continues to displace the incumbent silicon depend on the ability to emit or detect light and LDMOS technology.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 11 emitters include laser and LED based devices. Lasers both technically and in developing commercial broadly further sub-divide into edge emitters and relationships in the supply chain. The power switching surface emitters. Edge-emitting lasers represent the market alone is approximately 3-4 times the size of base technology that has been traditionally used in the current wireless power amplifier chip market, applications such as optical communications and CD/ and represents an exciting future opportunity for our DVD storage devices. Surface emitting lasers are business. IQE’s patented technology, cREOTM, provides highly complex epitaxial structures that allow light to a potentially significant competitive advantage in this be emitted vertically rather than horizontally. space.
IQE is the market leader for outsourced VCSEL Silicon integration Strategic Report materials, which has been achieved by virtue of its The CMOS++ (“Compound Materials on Silicon”) technology leadership and track record for mass business unit focusses on advanced semiconductor market delivery. This includes the demonstration of materials related to silicon including the combination VCSELs with industry leading performance and yield for of the advanced properties of compound production on diameters up to 150 mm. IQE has been semiconductors with those of lower cost of silicon successful at enabling its customers to reduce the unit technologies. cost of chips which will help to accelerate the adoption of this technology. The key advantages of compound semiconductors are that they: Complementing the VCSEL business is a long- established InP capability. Whilst 2019 saw a reduction are much more efficient at emitting and in sales of InP lasers due to technical issues at a · processing high-speed wireless signals; significant customer that were outside of IQE’s control, future growth is anticipated for this technology driven are much more efficient at emitting and by the need for higher speed, higher capacity fibre · sensing light; and optic systems to address continuing growth in data traffic. operate at much higher speeds and · lower power consumption In addition to VCSEL and InP applications that operate in the near-infrared part of the electromagnetic It is these advanced properties which underpin our spectrum, short and mid-wave infrared applications product portfolio in our Wireless and Photonics continue to show solid performance. This “Infrared” Business Units. photonics business is largely driven by safety, security and defence applications that deploy indium Future semiconductor technology architectures antimonide (InSb) and gallium antimonide (GaSb) are showing some trends of moving toward hybrid engineered materials to enable high resolution integrated chips using a combination of traditional infrared systems. CMOS based chips with compound semiconductor chips, all built on a silicon base wafer. This provides the IQE is the undisputed global leader in the supply market with the significant performance advantages of of InSb and GaSb wafers for advanced Infrared compound semiconductors at a cost point nearer that technology such as “see in the dark” defence of silicon, whilst allowing the CS industry to utilise the applications. huge investment already made in large-scale silicon Our continued investment in the development of chip manufacturing. As a result, this greatly increases photonics products includes the development of lasers the available market for compound semiconductors for environmental and health monitoring with exciting and the potential demand for epitaxy. IQE has growth opportunities in both industrial and consumer developed multiple routes to delivering this powerful markets. Overall revenues from the Photonics new hybrid. With the addition of cREOTM and other IP, Group increased year-on-year by 4.5% to £69.8m. IQE is well placed to play a key role in this integration The proportion of sales generated from photonics over the medium to long term. IQE is involved in products accounted for 50% of the Group’s sales in multiple development programmes, which are 2019. developing the core technologies from which future new revenue streams are anticipated to emerge over the coming years. New and emerging technologies The CMOS++ Business Unit grew by 31% year on year IQE’s primary commercial activities currently fall into to £2.1m, accounting for 1.5% of the Group’s sales in the wireless and photonics business categories but 2019. a number of emerging business opportunities relate to energy/power applications and the integration of compound semiconductors with silicon.
Energy/Power Gallium Nitride on Silicon (GaN on Si) and Silicon Carbide (GaN on SiC) material technologies are driving a shift in the multi-billion dollar power switching and LED markets. IQE has continued to push the technology boundaries and is making solid progress
12 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Business processes Introduction of advanced management · systems; and Customer qualification The global semiconductor industry operates to Attraction and retention of the best exacting standards, requiring the ultimate product · industry talent. quality with uncompromising reproducibility and repeatability. In order to meet customers’ The outsource model drives significant financial requirements, it is usual to demonstrate beyond business value for IQE’s chip manufacturing customers question that production processes are optimised, because of the superior unit economics generated reliable and repeatable with 100% accuracy. Any by IQE’s investments in mass production. As volumes Strategic Report failures at the start of the process can have a grow, IQE’s operational gearing affords significant catastrophic impact further along the supply chain and scope for margin expansion and cash generation. as a result quality must be guaranteed.
Each of our advanced epitaxy tools has to be Innovation: research, development and “qualified” in order to be released for production in intellectual property any supply chain. This is because the complexity of the technology creates an inherent risk of microscopic Technology leadership lies at the heart of IQE’s strategy variations between wafers in the same production run, and this is supported by a culture of innovation. as well as from run-to-run. Any process or product It is widely accepted that advanced materials are variations can have dramatic and costly implications needed to overcome fundamental challenges to the downstream. For each new product, it is necessary to semiconductor industry. IQE is ideally positioned to qualify raw materials, equipment and processes and meet these challenges. procedures, and each qualification process can take many months to complete, with products being fully IQE has built an enviable global reputation in the tested across multiple platforms and downstream industry for the breadth and depth of its materials processes. technologies and capabilities. It is evident from IQE’s many engagements with leading universities, start-ups, Whilst there are significant IP barriers in being able leading chip-makers and established global electronics to produce advanced semiconductor materials, there giants, that IQE has succeeded in establishing itself is an equally challenging IP barrier of controlling as the ‘go to’ place for advanced materials for both variations to be able to repeatedly and reliably current customers and new entrants. produce high quality materials in high volume which enable high yields down stream. Additionally, the IQE’s leadership as a materials solution provider is qualification processes require significant investment underpinned by knowhow born out of 30 years of from all parties including IQE and our customers, but experience. IQE also actively patents its technology once proven, the process is fixed for the life of that when appropriate and due to the central importance product and becomes another major barrier to entry of IP, IQE has a dedicated Technology Group that for competitors. manages the business’ rapidly expanding IP and patent portfolio. The growing strength of IQE’s IP is reflected Mass Production in how its relationships within the supply chain have As a materials specialist, IQE also offers its customers evolved. Historically, IQE was primarily engaged with the advantage of economies of scale. IQE has created chip makers, whereas it now regularly engages directly a competitive advantage through superior quality, with a number of Tier 1 OEMs. scale and a strategy of serving the entire market as a materials solution provider. Achieving low-cost chip To maintain its IP leadership position, IQE continues production necessitates high quality wafers. Wafer to innovate through focused internal and external defects translate into lost capacity and low yields for research and development (R&D) programmes. These chip makers. programmes are funded through a combination of This is evident across the Company’s global footprint internal cash generation, customer funding, and grant and in particular at IQE’s recently constructed ‘Mega funding. IQE’s R&D is geared towards next generation Foundry’ in Newport and the expanded Wireless applications as well as process improvements leading facility in Taiwan, both of which have a significant ability to greater throughput, higher-quality products, better to scale. IQE is investing in these mass production manufacturing yields and increased production capabilities to meet increasing demands for compound uptime. IQE’s ability to support cutting edge R&D semiconductor epiwafers through: through to high-volume manufacturing makes it the premier choice as an advanced materials provider. Investments in facilities and equipment · to create manufacturing capacity;
Development of superior products · through a commitment to R&D and NPI;
Development programmes to introduce · standardised systems and processes;
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 13 Innovation through collaboration In addition, Cardiff University was awarded £10 million Building high-tech clusters by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Collaboration is a powerful tool in accelerating Council (EPSRC) to lead the EPSRC Manufacturing innovation. The benefits are even greater when whole Hub in Future Compound Semiconductors that will ecosystems “cluster” in geographically close locations, combine and connect the UK research excellence in breaking down the barriers created by geography compound semiconductors, with translational facilities and time zones. Indeed, Silicon Valley in California is at the new CSAC Catapult to provide a pathway from a prime example of how the benefit of clustering can research through to device and application testing and propel an industry to a global platform. qualification. Strategic Report
It is the benefits of collaboration and clustering that During 2019, the Compound Semiconductor Centre underpin IQE’s strategic rationale for its joint venture (CSC) won a number of contracts and awards to in the UK and its highly successful Open Innovation participate in research and development programmes Programme (openiqe.com). Moreover, IQE has for next generation applications that are expected to been at the heart of establishing a new CS Cluster in lead to future volume manufacturing opportunities South Wales, UK, which is the first of its kind globally. for IQE and other partners in the growing Welsh This new cluster is accelerating research into novel compound semiconductor cluster. technologies, product development, innovation and prototyping. The CS cluster, which is branded Projects announced during 2019 included the HEMAN as CS Connected (csconnected.com), is the result consortium that reported on developments in VCSEL of collaboration across government, industry and technologies for delivering cheaper, faster VCSEL academia, as well as significant private and public devices that will drive tomorrow’s sensing technologies. sector investment to establish top-class facilities The CSC joint venture also led the GANTT gallium and infrastructure to support activities along the nitride power consortium awarded through ‘The road technology development chain from blue-sky research to zero emission vehicles’ competition sponsored by to high-volume production. OLEV (the Office for Low Emission Vehicles).
The journey started in 2015, when Cardiff University Another significant programme in which CSC was announced an investment of around £75 million in awarded a role in during 2019, was the £9.8m ESCAPE the Institute of Compound Semiconductors (ICS). The project to create a complete end-to-end supply chain announcement was followed by a £24 million joint for next generation Power Electronics, which is a key venture between IQE Plc and Cardiff University to form component to be used in all electric vehicles. More the Compound Semiconductor Centre (CSC), allowing recently, CSC announced its participation in a UK businesses and academics to demonstrate production- £36.7m UK government programme “Drive the Electric ready CS materials reducing time-to-market and cost. Revolution” aimed at pushing the UK to net zero The facilities at the CSC are being complemented by carbon growth by 2050. new materials research, fabrication and testing at the ICS. The collaborative environment fosters strong working relationships to encourage sharing of knowledge and 2016 saw the announcement by Innovate UK of a ideas and the organisations involved are enthusiastic £50 million investment to establish the Compound about the future. CS Connected is open for business. Semiconductor Applications Catapult (CSAC), located in South East Wales; a world-class, open-access Open Innovation R&D facility to support businesses across the UK in IQE is classified by the Welsh Government as an exploiting novel CS technologies in key application “Anchor Company” in acknowledgement of its status areas. as an exemplar in terms of its global leadership. As an Anchor Company, IQE was invited by the In addition to IQE, other organisations in the region Welsh Government to run an Open Innovation pilot include Newport Wafer Fab (an open access chip programme which has been highly successful in foundry), and SPTS who design, manufacture and establishing new technology networks to identify long- support a range of wafer processing tools for the term opportunities. semiconductor and microelectronics industries. Downstream capabilities include Microsemi’s Advanced IQE’s open innovation programme, ‘OpenIQE’ is actively Packaging business, delivering novel solutions helping to boost regional economies by collaborating for miniaturised electronic circuits with wireless with industrial and academic partners to identify connectivity. supply chain opportunities within Wales and across Europe. The Open IQE programme benefits IQE by In September 2017, IQE, Welsh and UK Governments raising the Company’s profile throughout multiple and the Cardiff Capital Region City Deal ratified the supply chains and helps embed IQE’s technology within development agreement for building the Group’s new and emerging markets. Mega-Foundry in Newport, South Wales. This was funded by the Cardiff Capital Region (CCR) Regional Further details about IQE’s open innovation Cabinet via a contribution of £37.9 million from the programme can be found on a dedicated website: CCR City Deal’s Wider Investment Fund which is repaid www.openiqe.com by IQE over an eleven year lease, including an option to purchase.
14 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 CoInnovate IQE actively participates in major industry events and frequently chairs, hosts and presents technical papers at international conferences. A product of IQE’s open innovation programme “CoInnovate” was launched in 2016 and has become a major event in the Welsh conference calendar. The conference is organised by IQE and jointly sponsored by the Welsh Government, academic partners as well as IQE and industrial partners including Airbus and General Dynamics.
The next CoInnovate UK conference is scheduled for late 2020 following Strategic Report last year’s event that attracted around 300 delegates from a mix of large businesses, SMEs and academics.
In May 2019, CoInnovateCS was launched in the US and was co-located with the industry-wide CS-Mantech conference. Following the success of CoInnovateCS in 2019, the second US conference was planned to be hosted alongside CS-Mantech in Tucson, Arizona in May 2020 but has been postponed due to the global COVID-19 pandemic.
All conference plans are under constant review in light of the ongoing pandemic.
More information can be found at the CoInnovate conference website (www.coinnovate.co.uk) and the CoInnovateCS conference website (www.coinnovatecs.com).
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 15 Business ethics & conduct Strategic Report
We are committed to acting professionally, fairly In our relationships with employees and other and with integrity in all our business dealings and stakeholders relationships. In our dealings with customers we strive to: Ensuring employment practices · throughout the Group are fair and in full Be open and honest about our products compliance with employment legislation; · and services and communicate with customers all appropriate information Working with and supporting local and they need to make informed decisions; · national charities;
Ensure that any issues or problems are Encouraging volunteer work in · dealt with efficiently, with fairness and in · community activities; a timely manner; Supporting local academic Working closely with customers and · establishments; and · potential customers to help us improve the value of the products and services we Participating in voluntary business offer them; and · advisory services via professional bodies.
Ensuring that we benchmark and We encourage everyone to report any behaviour which · evaluate what we do in order to may be in breach of the UK Corporate Governance continuously improve products and Code, is unethical or illegal. This is achieved by services in the marketplace. fostering a culture of openness and accountability, and by providing a clear procedure that enables any In our dealings with suppliers individual to raise breaches of policy or malpractice directly at the highest level. Identifying and selecting suppliers using · fair and reasonable methodologies; The opportunities and challenges we manage within our own business also extend to our global supply Identifying and using suppliers who chain, which we view as an extension of our business. · operate to ethical business standards; For this reason we are committed to ensuring the same responsible business standards and ethical Identifying and using local suppliers behaviours we expect of ourselves are upheld by the · where possible; hundreds of suppliers in our supply chain. In order to uphold our high standards of ethical procurement Working closely with suppliers to help all our supply chain staff are regularly trained in the · us improve the value of the products IQE Code of Business Ethics and Conduct. In 2019, and services we offer customers to the training modules focussed on key topics for anti- benefit of the supply chain. bribery and corruption, conflicts of interest, corporate responsibility and respect in the workplace.
Delivering IQE’s vision of being the global number one provider of advanced semiconductor materials and improving our positive social impact is not something we can achieve on our own. We recognise that a large
16 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 proportion of our innovations are linked to working Bribery Act with our strategic supply chains which is why we invest in long-term mutually beneficial relationships with our We implement and enforce effective systems to key suppliers, in order to share capabilities and co- uphold our zero-tolerance approach to bribery and innovate for growth. corruption. To ensure we only work with third parties whose standards are consistent with our own, all We regularly evaluate and feedback the performance agents and third parties who act on behalf of the of our key suppliers in order to maintain our Group are obliged by written agreement to comply competitive advantage. Our three main criteria are with such standards. A programme of supplier audits Quality, Competitiveness and Technology Leadership exists to ensure suppliers adhere to IQE’s standards. and we firmly believe that having supply chain Strategic Report partners that continually strive to drive continuous improvement in these areas creates the differentiation Human Rights and Modern Slavery that IQE offers to its customers. IQE is committed to respecting the human rights of all those working with or for us. We do not accept Confidentiality any form of child or forced labour and we will not do business with anyone who fails to uphold these Our business conduct policy emphasises the standards. The Modern Slavery Act addresses the role essential need for confidentiality in all of our dealings. of businesses in preventing modern slavery within their Maintaining confidentiality is engrained in our culture. organisation and in their supply chains. Our policy and practice ensures that all staff fully understand what constitutes confidential information The Company has a zero-tolerance approach to and restrict internal access on a need to know basis. modern slavery and is committed to acting ethically Information relating to third parties is not disclosed and with integrity in all of its business dealings and without the third parties’ written consent. relationships and to implementing and enforcing effective systems and controls to ensure modern slavery is not taking place anywhere in its business or Data protection in any of its supply chains.
Closely linked to our policies on confidentiality is the The company has developed and implemented policies way that we treat personal data. IQE complies with to comply with the requirements of the UK’s Modern the requirements of data protection legislation and Slavery Act. Reference to the policy may be found on continues to undertake a range of activities including the corporate website at www.iqep.com. group-wide training, data audits and risk assessments pursuant to the new General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR) that came into force on 25 May 2018 and the Data Protection Act 2018.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 17 Our people Strategic Report
Values policy, support this aim and are available online to all employees. IQE’s strength lies in the expertise and diversity of our workforce. Over the years we have been fortunate IQE recognises that gender diversity remains an to retain leading industry experts by being a market ongoing issue for the semiconductor industry and the leader and through successful acquisitions. As a result, gender diversity of IQE’s Board now stands at 16.6% we recognise that our teamwork and collaboration female with the appointment of Mrs Carol Chesney in is a powerful competitive advantage that keeps us at May 2019. For more information on how the Board the cutting edge of technology and drives constant considered diversity in 2019 please see page 45. improvement throughout our organisation. This is supported by our culture of integrity, accountability, excellence, valuing people and teamwork. Code of conduct
Integrity: We behave ethically, safely, The day-to-day conduct requirements of IQE · honestly and lawfully employees and contractors is defined in our Business Conduct Policy (“the Policy”) which sets out expected Accountability: We work to clear and standards in line with IQE’s values and business · mutually accepted responsibilities, principles. Upholding the Policy is the responsibility of hands-on decision management and all IQE employees and staff are also required to ensure decision making that they comply with all relevant laws and regulations of the countries in which we operate and do business. Excellence: We strive for excellence in · all we do with a focus on continuous The Policy contains guidance on avoiding conflicts of improvement interest, confidentiality, adherence to export controls, our approach to gifts and hospitality, bribery and Valuing People: We treat people with corruption and managing relationships with third · respect and dignity; We communicate parties. In addition, the Policy sets out how employees with clarity and honesty; We provide should report concerns or a breach, including opportunities for people to reach their anonymously if they are not comfortable reporting to potential their line manager or the HR Department directly.
Teamwork: We work collaboratively All those working for or on behalf of IQE are required · towards common goals to confirm that they have read and understood the Policy, a copy of which is accessible to all employees.
Equality and diversity Communication and engagement IQE believes that all global employees should be free from discrimination regardless of race, nationality, We believe that effective and timely communication gender, age, marital status, sexual orientation, disability is an essential part of positive employee engagement. and religious or political beliefs. We pursue equality We strive to ensure that our internal communication of opportunity in all employment practices, policies meets our needs as a diverse global business and procedures and are committed to creating a operating throughout the UK, US and Asia. work environment where everyone is treated with dignity and respect. Our human resources policies, Quarterly Town Halls are held at each site to ensure including our employee handbook and Dignity at Work understanding of strategy, alignment of goals and
18 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 objectives and the cascade of important information. A new Learning Management System called ‘the Vault’ These are critical forums for the engagement of our was also launched in 2019. Starting in the UK this staff. Information cascade is reinforced through regular e-learning platform has now gained a global audience team meetings. and is available to all worldwide employees. There are currently 71 courses in total on the Vault, and IQE’s annual Leadership Conference brings together 30 e-courses that have been created in-house, in our global Leaders, Executive Management Board addition to new resources and learning aids which are and Non-Executive Directors. At this important event, regularly updated. Our training materials cover our internal networks are forged and a critical appraisal is UK engineering suite, UK health and safety courses, made of the execution of our strategy. A key output essential information and news about IQE as well as a Strategic Report is the alignment of goals and objectives for the year whole host of personal development and leadership ahead. and management programmes. Engagement has been high with over 2700 course completions to date. We have also set up internal committees to engage employees in decision-making. At the beginning of Ultimately, the Vault will support our employees in 2019 we established the Employee Pensions & Benefits their development and will: Governance Committee ‘EPBGC’. This Committee’s members were chosen by IQE staff and represent transform how IQE trains through the interests of the staff in all decisions concerning · embracing digital training methods and employee benefits. The Committee is chaired by IQE’s agile learning; independent Non-Executive Director and Chair of the Audit & Risk Committee, Carol Chesney. shape the company culture whilst · embracing technology to simplify and create access for all to learn within an Learning and development agile work environment;
IQE recognises that our continuing commercial provide new and innovative links with success is dependent upon our ability to attract, · learning materials from experts around retain, motivate and nurture the best talent in our the world. industry. As the foundation for this, we aim to support all employees to develop their full personal and professional potential and enjoy a rewarding and Taking training beyond IQE fulfilling career at IQE. We are committed to promoting an environment and culture that provides for agile In the UK we have secured funding from the Welsh and life-long learning and IQE is building a world-class Assembly for our external training and forged links engineering and leadership Academy with the following with the Compound Semiconductor cluster. In aims: working collaboratively with the CS Cluster, local training providers and higher education institutions, we transform how we train our people, have instigated various opportunities and options for · embracing digital training methods and both internal and external training. This relationship agile learning; allows us to share our best practice as well as provide a variety of alternative training opportunities for IQE ensure our engineering and technical staff. · staff have defined training pathways and we can demonstrate visibility around As part of our STEM ambassador work we engage training execution and evaluation; with a number of local schools, colleges, universities, science museums and careers fairs to actively promote shape the culture whilst embracing and encourage the take up of science, technology, · technology to simplify and create engineering and maths (STEM) subjects through these access for all to learn in an agile work initiatives. environment; We also welcome local academics to share in their align our Learning Management System expertise as well as offer placement opportunities · with our Quality Management System for research and development where appropriate. to ensure the effective management of We hope to further develop this in the form of competence. apprenticeships during 2020, working in partnership with local training providers and the CS Cluster to offer During 2019 IQE launched an Employee Competence further opportunities. Framework and from that a Competence Management System. These have been supplemented with an updated Training and Development Policy, a new formal Training and Assessment Process and various new training and development forms, plans and logs. Training processes are now communicated with other departments and formalised via our document control systems.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 19 Performance management IQE operates an employee education programme to support our staff making healthy lifestyle choices. This IQE aims to bring personal development “to life” and programme offers healthy lifestyle support and advice, promotes a culture of learning and development. and encourages better health and wellbeing for all During 2019 we reviewed how our employees tracked employees. It aims to support individuals in making and managed their performance and starting from small sustainable changes to improve wellbeing and 2020 we have implemented a new performance to improve sustainability by working in groups and review process. We recognise the importance of our making events fun. In 2020 wellbeing meetings are employees setting personal objectives that support being held monthly at IQE’s Newport site with the aim the achievement of our organisational goals, and being that learnings can be shared with other IQE locations. Strategic Report provided with fair, balanced and constructive feedback in real-time. Remuneration A comprehensive online system called “Performance Hub” was selected for implementation in early 2020 to IQE follows a remuneration strategy to attract and simplify and standardise the goal setting and tracking retain talented individuals. As well as competitive base process. The system allows an individual to align salaries, IQE operates an annual cash bonus plan and their personal objectives with those of the company long-term incentive share plan. to ensure there is an alignment of purpose with the strategic goals of the business. Performance Hub will Senior employees participate in our bonus plan, which also provide employees and managers with a platform is designed to reward high levels of performance. to share transparent and honest feedback on an The plan rewards the achievement of clearly defined ongoing basis, further supporting the personal and financial targets and personal objectives. career development of IQE employees. In addition to this formal award process, IQE operates a ‘spot award’ programme which involved awards Employee wellbeing being issued monthly to any employee who has gone “above and beyond” their duties for the benefit of the At IQE the physical and mental health of our Company. They represent a means of providing timely employees is paramount and we routinely promote recognition and promoting a culture of excellence. In wellbeing and provide wellness support to our staff. 2019 40 spot awards were awarded. We have a designated mental health first aid officer on site and to assist our employees to be proactive about All of IQE’s global employees participate in a long- their health we also provide regular health checks, and term incentive share plan (“LTIP”). The plan ensures all offer access to medical assistance through a number employees are incentivised and motivated to grow the of programmes. value of the Company over the medium to long term. Performance based vesting criteria ensures the plan creates value for shareholders. For more information on how the LTIP operated in 2019 please see page 59.
20 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Communities and social review Strategic Report
Supporting our communities Educational institutions
As a significant employer in many of the locations IQE engages with a number of schools, colleges and in which we operate, we recognise the opportunity universities around the world and is actively promoting we have to make a positive contribution to our local and encouraging the take up of science, technology, communities. Therefore, we seek to contribute to the engineering and maths (STEM) subjects through a economic, social and environmental sustainability of number of initiatives. In the UK, IQE is engaged with our local communities through a range of activities and STEMNET, where IQE STEM Ambassadors participate initiatives. in a variety of educational events with a particular emphasis on addressing the gender imbalance in We encourage this to be driven “bottom-up”, to ensure engineering disciplines. that our efforts are relevant to our employees and what is important to the local communities in which As part of our STEM ambassador work we engage they operate. Through this approach, we are seeking with a number of local schools, colleges, universities, to support our employees in their efforts to give science museums and careers fairs to actively promote something back to their communities. and encourage the take up of science, technology, engineering and maths (STEM) subjects through these The IQE social committee has been hard at work initiatives. and have organised a number of events, not only to support employee wellbeing and engagement but also to raise funds for local communities. Corporate Social Responsibility Individual employees have spent their time and effort on personal fundraisers for the foundation or As a company trading on AIM, a market operated by chosen STEM charities, with our employees running, The London Stock Exchange plc, IQE is not eligible to climbing and swimming to make a difference to participate in the London Stock Exchange FTSE4Good their communities. IQE’s staff are also encouraged programme, but nevertheless maintains standards to participate in various events including through and applies the principles of this index. The Group also volunteering work at holiday soup kitchens, raising actively engages with a number of industry groups, money for the Special Olympics and blood donations educational bodies and charities to promote science facilitated at IQE sites. and technology and to help contribute to community causes.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 21 Environment, health and safety Strategic Report
At IQE, the health and safety of our staff, partners and the communities in which we operate is our number one priority. We have implemented safety systems, processes and procedures to ensure we comply with legislation and minimise the risk of harm. IQE’s employees take an active role in ensuring that their working environment is a safe place to work and visit by reporting all safety observations and incidents, being involved in safety audits, risk assessments and regular awareness training sessions.
The Environment, Health & Safety (EHS) group has a The EHS group continues to be actively involved detailed ongoing continued professional development in industry-wide initiatives, working with industry plan including training and accreditation of competent associations and proactively registering under EHS professionals. These include Regional EHS regulatory directives such as REACH and GHS-based Managers and site-based EHS Managers, Engineers Hazard Communication. The group also monitors and Coordinators (hereafter termed Site Safety global chemical control activities (e.g. RoHS, TSCA) to Appointed Persons (‘SSAP’)). The Regional EHS Manager ensure continued customer confidence and supply- appointments provide for high-level advisory roles, chain compliance. identification of global best-practice and adoption of strategic EHS initiatives for all applicable legislative requirements, wherever the Group operates. The site- Safety and Environmental Teams & Reporting specific SSAP roles are directly responsible for localised EHS program implementation and operations at each The EHS Group is organised to effectively promote and IQE Site. increase the awareness of Safety and Environmental issues, directives and legal obligations, advising each The Regional EHS Managers work directly and with group subsidiary company and the Board accordingly. the relevant Site General Manager or SSAPs in order to implement those best-practices identified from Daily EHS activities and reporting at local sites, strategic initiatives to: managed by the localised safety roles, are fed into general site management for effective control. minimise risks of injury at work; Regular analysis and discussion are an agenda item · at periodic site management meetings. Localised EHS ensure legislative compliance; roles prepare regular site performance metrics for · dissemination at a Group-level. assist in creating and monitoring safety · practices. EHS Regional Managers oversee site trend analyses and undertake regular conference calls to discuss In addition, localised and specialist Safety Advisors, major issues and site developments. Regional face-to- with the appropriate expertise to support in specific face meetings and data collation culminate in periodic areas of activity, support in areas such as Local EHS Board Reports, demonstrating major trends in Exhaust Ventilation (LEV) and Pressure Systems EHS activities and comparisons with industry best- legislation. practice and National Statistical averages.
22 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Regional Managers and the Director responsible for EHS drive strategic initiatives, agreed at Board level, IQE is committed to: through each organisation to promote Group best- practice, thus ensuring conformance to global, regional Providing safe and healthy working and local regulations and directives. Initiatives are · conditions for the prevention of work- designed to fulfil the Group’s objectives of maintaining related injury and ill health; at or beyond state-of-the-art EHS Management. Ensuring health and safety A full and comprehensive presentation of occupational · considerations are integrated into the trends, accidents, safety and environmental incidents, business planning and decision-making Strategic Report together with compliance with all regulatory processes; requirements, Group and local objectives are published in the Annual EHS Report to the Board. Fulfilling any legal and other · requirements, identifying and implementing best practice wherever practicable; Health & Safety Policy Statement Eliminating hazards and reducing · occupational health and safety risks; IQE Senior Management are Providing all employees, contractors committed to ensuring a high · and visitors with relevant information, level of health and safety operational controls and regular training on safety requirements to enable them performance in all of its to conduct their activities safely;
activities and recognise effective Providing a positive safety culture in health and safety management · which every employee, contractor and visitor feels free to speak up about non- contributes to the overall conformances or unsafe situations or any other health and safety related issue; success of the business. Consultation and participation of IQE’s policy for conducting its business in a safe and · workers, and their representatives, on healthy manner is embodied in its global Health & occupational safety and health and Safety Policy Statement: process safety matters;
“The Company’s approach to health and safety will be Continual improvement of the based on the identification, control, and, where possible, · occupational health and safety elimination of risk to persons and the environment. management system. This policy provides a framework for the setting of occupational health and safety and process safety objectives by senior management, in consultation with workers. These objectives are intended to ensure the organisation’s continual improvement in health and safety performance, striving to be incident and injury free.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 23 Safety Performance 2019
As outlined on previous page, IQE closely monitors safety performance. In 2019, the UK and Singapore Sites experienced no RIDDOR reportable injures or dangerous occurrences as well as no lost work or restricted activity days. The US and Taiwan sites both report to OSHA bodies in their respective countries. No incidents were experienced in Taiwan. The Massachusetts site experienced a single incident resulting in three OSHA recordable events during 2019. For all incidents, an incident reporting system was used to document the investigation and root cause as well as identify and implement corrective actions to prevent reoccurrence.
Strategic Report RIDDOR/OSHA Reportable/Recordable Accidents 2019
RIDDOR OSHA 5 Reportable Recordable accidents accidents 4
3
2
1
0 U U U U S U U U U U T A K K K K in S S S S S a L g A A A A A iw L C C N M a a a e il p M N N P W a rd rd w t o a e o e a n i i p o re ssa w rt n sh ff ff o n h n Ke Je syl i (E (S rt c rse C n U i yn hu a va g ) ) ro to e se y n n s tt lin ia s a
Note: The UK sites report all minor accidents, not merely those reportable, and constitute minor cuts, slips etc. US reports feature only OSHA 300 recordable incidents (c.f. RIDDOR in the UK).
IQE acknowledges receipt in October 2019 of a set of The Environment citations from OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) in the United States relating to an IQE is committed to protecting local and global inspection at the company’s Massachusetts facility. environments and endeavours to ensure that our This followed on from a single incident at the plant in activities and manufacturing operations are conducted April 2019. IQE fully cooperated with OSHA throughout in an environmentally responsible manner. its inspection and the majority of the issued citations were successfully defended and subsequently We are committed to minimising the environmental withdrawn. IQE worked with OSHA to fully resolve the impact of our operations by encouraging all employees citations, and the installation of OSHA’s Process Safety to promote and adopt ways of modifying their Management (PSM) program will be finalised during behaviour to reduce the impact on the environment. 2020. This includes reducing waste, recycling, restricting unnecessary travel, saving water and reducing energy The safety of all of our employees has always been usage. IQE’s highest priority and the company has consistently maintained a robust workplace safety program and state of the art safety technology. We are proud of our strong safety record across our global manufacturing operations and are confident that our safety processes will continue to be strengthened through our cooperation with OSHA.
24 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Environmental Policy Statement Environmental Management
ISO 14001 is a global standard for environmental IQE senior management are management which was developed to help committed to ensuring a high level organisations reduce their environmental impact. It provides a framework for organisations to of environmental performance demonstrate their commitment to preserving and protecting the environment by: in all of its activities and Reducing harmful effects on the Strategic Report recognises effective environmental · environment, and management contributes to the Providing evidence of continual overall success of the business. · improvement of environmental management IQE’s policy for conducting business in an environmentally responsible manner states that the All of IQE’s continuously operating facilities have company will ensure that: successfully completed independent third-party audits of our compliance with the ISO 14001:2015 We fully integrate environmental standard. These audits were very successful with no · considerations into the business planning material deficiencies recorded. Our operating facilities and decision-making processes; clearly demonstrate a commitment to environmental compliance, reducing waste, recycling materials, energy Compliance obligations are identified and conservation and risk management where appropriate, · our operations must be conducted in complementary to our commercial objectives of accordance with these obligations; reducing costs and improving operational efficiency.
We validate our fulfilment of compliance · obligations by means of documented Environmental Legislation Compliance periodic review; Compliance with environmental legislation is critical We employ best practice to reduce the to our global businesses and is assured through the · environmental impact of our operations, employment of appropriately qualified and competent prevent pollution, minimise waste and managers, reporting through to the Chief Operating maximise the efficient use of energy and Officer. These managers have access to third-party resources to protect the environment; professional advisors as required.
We will work with IQE supply chain to IQE maintains membership of a number of · minimise their environmental impacts; professional bodies which provide a good source of reference and support, enabling it to keep up-to-date We continually improve our with continually evolving legislation. This includes · environmental management system and regular updates from: British Safety Council, British its performance by setting measurable Standards Institution, Institute of Environmental objectives and reviewing them on a Management and Assessment in the UK, the US regular basis; National Safety Council, the US National Fire Protection Agency and the US Federal Register. We provide suitable information and · training to all employees, and interested As a Company trading on AIM, a market operated parties to ensure that the aims of the by The London Stock Exchange plc, the Companies environmental management system are Act 2006 (Strategic Report and Directors’ Reports) achieved; Regulations 2013, relating to the disclosure of greenhouse gas emissions and other environmental Appropriate resources will be made matters, does not apply to IQE. · available to ensure this policy can be implemented.
In addition, each of our sites will supplement this policy to meet local requirements.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 25 Environmental Performance 2019
IQE closely monitors environmental compliance. In 2019, IQE experienced one minor external environmental incident involving a bolt in a sump which caused an elevated lead level. Below is a detailed presentation of the environmental near miss incidents and regulatory reportable incidents that were recorded at IQE’s global facilities. For all incidents, an incident reporting system was used to document the investigation and root cause as well as identify and implement corrective actions to prevent reoccurrence.
Environmental Incidents 2019
Strategic Report Reporta le and near m ss nc dents
10
9 Reportable Near miss 8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 U U U U S U U U U U T A K K K K in S S S S S a L g A A A A A iw L C C N M a a a e il p M N N P W a rd rd w t o a e o e a n i i p o re ssa w rt n sh ff ff o n h n Ke Je syl i (E (S rt c rse C n U i yn hu a va g ) ) ro to e se y n n s tt lin ia s a
A Near Miss Incident is an accident or incident properties only. InP, as a substance, is a very low that results in no injury, no property damage or proportion of IQE’s product range, providing feedstock environmental release/spill, but has the potential for InP ingots and wafers produced by some of its to cause harm or consequence. Near Miss incident customers. IQE’s dominant business – the supply of examples include trips/slips/falls with no resulting custom-designed mass-manufactured III-V epiwafers injury, human error and false fire alarms (equipment – involves the supply of InP and GaAs epiwafers as factor related). IQE treats Near Miss Incidents seriously articles. Consequently, all IQE epiwafers are classified and has developed a reporting process for continuous as articles under REACH and CLP legislation, and are improvement activities in order to ensure that shipped in a non-hazardous form. hazards in the workplace are identified and to prevent future occurrence. This is a 5D investigative process comprising of an initial incident description, timing Recycling and Energy Conservation and containment measures, a follow-up investigation, an analysis of root-causes, listing of corrective and At each of our global sites we operate continuous preventative actions, any additional recommendations improvement programmes to reduce waste and to and finally a close-out and sign-off process. recycle and re-use wherever practicable. Currently, at each site we recycle: plastics, steel, aluminium, paper, cardboard and process by-products where the Global Chemical Control & Legislation opportunity to do so safely exists.
As a result of its commitment to global chemical IQE also closely monitors the consumption of control legislation, since the end of 2019 IQE became electricity, gas and water at all facilities and have the REACH registrant for InP as a substance. Given the targeted environmental improvement programs as low tonnage band (1-10 tonnes) manufactured, the part of ISO14001 to reduce carbon dioxide emissions required REACH dossier was restricted to physical and the depletion of natural resources. & chemical, toxicological and eco-toxicological
26 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Risk management Strategic Report
IQE employs risk management techniques to identify, evaluate and prioritize Health, Safety & Environmental risks followed by application of resources to minimize, monitor, and control the probability or impact of unfortunate events. IQE’s risks may be inherent to the business or come from a variety of sources including engineering or administrative control failures, accidents, incidents and/or natural causes.
IQE performs regular risk management evaluations at The Executive Management Board is accountable to its sites and identifies the highest potential risks and the Board for delivery of the Annual Business Plan. opportunities. A summary of the mitigation, likelihood The Executives report performance against the plan and impact of the risks identified is included on pages on a monthly basis, which includes detailed analysis of 27-37. budgetary variances and updated financial projections.
To provide a framework for the delivery the Group’s Principal Risks and Uncertainties strategy and plans, the Executive Management Board has developed an organisational structure with clear The Group has an established process for the roles and responsibilities, and clear lines of reporting. identification and management of risk as part of the The Group’s Senior Leadership Team are responsible governance framework. Management of Corporate to the Executive Management Board for the risk is the responsibility of the Board of Directors and development and delivery of the detailed action plans is a key focus of the Audit and Risk Committee. which underpin the Group’s Annual Business Plan.
The Board’s role in risk management includes: Each Executive Management Board member is responsible for identifying and managing the risks promoting a culture that emphasises relating to their respective areas of responsibility, · integrity at all levels of business including the risks relating to strategy, the Annual operations; Business Plan, and day-to-day business.
embedding risk management within the Risk management within the business involves: · core processes of the business; identification and assessment of · individual risks; · approving appetite for risk; determining the principal risks; design of controls and operational · · processes to mitigate the risks; setting the overall policies for risk · management and control; testing of controls through internal · review and audits; ensuring that the above are · communicated effectively across the conclusion on the effectiveness of the business. · control environment in place.
The Board reviews and approves an Annual Business Plan prior to the start of each financial year. The Annual Business Plan sets out the key strategic, operational and financial objectives for the year, together with a detailed financial budget.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 27 In addition to day-to-day risk management, the Executive Directors formally assess the major business risks and evaluate their potential impact on the Group.
The principal risks affecting the Group are identified by the Group Executive team within their functional areas of responsibility and reviewed by the Audit & Risk Committee.
In identifying risks, we analyse risks across four key areas:
strategic risk;
Strategic Report · · commercial risk; · operational risk; and · financial risk. The Board has put in place a framework of internal controls to manage the risks faced by the Group, and the Audit & Risk Committee has responsibility to review, monitor and make policy recommendations to the Board upon all such matters.
The principal risks are described below.
Principal Risk: HEALTH, SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENT
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Medium Risk of harm from IQE operates in a COMAH and PPC Regulated environment materials and employs the highest levels of technical and engineering control measures to prevent and reduce the Risk of harm to possibility of a failure event occurring. personnel Only trained and competent persons are permitted to (Unchanged) Risk of failure to work with potentially harmful materials. comply with H&S Potential impact: legislation Operation under ISO14001. Highly qualified environmental High professionals operating within the organisation are trained and certified to Lead Auditor Standard by BSI. Effect: Reputational We continuously audit and monitor environmental damage, business performance and management systems, driving interruption, continuous improvement across all facilities by sharing increase in costs, best practice. Systems and processes at all sites are loss of sales, externally assessed by BSI/BV – up to twice annually. adversely affecting profitability
28 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Principal Risk: BUSINESS INTERUPTION
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: High Risk of a natural IQE operates multiple global manufacturing facilities, which disaster, public helps to mitigate against the impact of major incidents health emergency or events on IQE. Similarly, many of our larger customers or other have multi-site production to mitigate their risk. Strategic Report major incident (Increased) disrupting Our active programme to dual source most of our critical production at supplies mitigates an element of supplier risk. Commodity Potential impact: an IQE site or at based items are protected wherever possible through High that of one of Long-Term Supply Agreements that allow our supply IQE’s suppliers or chain to plan ahead and mitigate commodity fluctuations Effect: customers through hedging and/or buying ahead. Loss of production volumes and Loss of key IQE maintains appropriate business interruption insurance profitability production data including for natural catastrophe. However, as is usual in such policies, pandemic health emergencies are excluded from cover.
IQE’s production data is appropriately stored and backed- up with IT system recovery plans in place.
Coronavirus Management Board are conducting enhanced levels of communication with all staff. We will continue to take At the time of preparing this report, there are appropriate measures to protect our people. significant impacts globally around the outbreak of the Coronavirus (CoV). The spread of the virus has Secondly, there is an increased risk of business impacted the health of thousands of people worldwide disruption at any of IQE’s global sites or at one or and has resulted in millions of people staying at home more of our suppliers or partners. IQE has continued in necessary lockdowns imposed by governments. It to operate during the pandemic and we have is inevitable that Coronavirus will negatively impact implemented appropriate social distancing measures, Global GDP and significantly affect macroeconomic enhanced cleaning regimes and shift segregation conditions in 2020. measures at all of our global sites where appropriate. Only staff who are essential to production are working IQE has implemented a Business Continuity sub- on-site with all other staff working from home. In the committee to respond to this evolving situation. The US, IQE is classified as acritical infrastructure supplier sub-committee is monitoring risk indicators and in all four states in which we operate, enabling us external guidance and has formulated policies and to continue operations during lockdown. In the UK, potential actions in readiness for different scenarios. It the government classes manufacturing as a critical is also ensuring regular and clear communications with part of the economy and there are no restrictions our staff and other stakeholders. being placed on it. Similarly, in Taiwan and Singapore, governments are supportive of production continuing There are three key risks to IQE from the Coronavirus during the pandemic. As at the date of this report, pandemic being considered and constantly monitored there have been no suspensions to production due to by the sub-committee. Coronavirus at any of our global sites and the Business Continuity sub-committee continues to monitor the Firstly, there is an increased risk to the health of our situation and that of our suppliers and customers very staff during this period. The safety of our people closely. remains our primary objective. During the early phases of the spread of the virus in 2020, we implemented Thirdly, there is an increased risk of a fall in demand travel restrictions and enhanced health and safety for IQE’s products resulting from a global economic measures to reduce the risks. The approach of the downturn due to the pandemic. However, trading sub-committee has been to follow government advice for the first quarter of 2020 was slightly above our and guidance in all of the regions in which it operates. expectations and there are no signs of a material As the virus continued to spread and governments reduction in demand at the date of this report. The issued updated advice, the sub-committee acted swiftly Business Continuity sub-committee continues to to communicate changes and implement appropriate monitor markets and liaise with our customers closely. measures. Throughout this period, the Executive
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 29 Principal Risk: INFLUENCE OF MARKET CONDITIONS
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Medium Risk of product Global technological markets are dynamic and change obsolescence occurs at a fast pace. As new technologies are introduced, due to changes in mature technologies can become displaced and eventually end-markets become obsolescent. (Increased) Strategic Report Risk of loss of IQE’s products appear in a wide variety of end-use access to markets applications and are essential to the operation of devices resulting from such as the smart phone. Potential impact: the geo-political High environment As technologies evolve, IQE manages its product roadmap to ensure it has a portfolio of current and future products Effect: Risk of downturn that will continue to enable many technological markets. Loss of sales in end markets and reduction in profitability or general IQE’s R&D programme and NPI governance process are macro-economic designed to ensure the Company drives a return on weakness investment from product development and introduction.
IQE develops intellectual property locally across all of its global manufacturing sites to underpin its ability to serve markets globally. The Company complies with all relevant export control legislation.
IQE is well positioned to adapt to changes in global technology markets and the company has the ability to leverage its global manufacturing footprint by qualifying tools in multiple production locations worldwide.
IQE is working to diversify its products and customer base to reduce the impact of changes in specific markets, as evidenced by IQE’s development of 3DS products and growth in Wireless products for infrastructure as well as handsets. IQE’s Taiwan site expansion, which was completed in Q2 2019, increased wireless capacity by 40%.
30 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Principal Risk: CUSTOMER CONCENTRATION
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Medium Risk of loss of IQE experienced a significant loss of volume from two key share and/or customers in 2019; one in the Wireless market (GaAs Power volume from a Amplifiers) and one in the photonics segment (InP lasers). major customer These two customers account for the majority of the
reduction in IQE’s revenues year on year. (Increased) Strategic Report The wireless sector is highly concentrated with the top Potential impact: 5 Radio Frequency (RF) Chip companies accounting for Medium the vast majority of the wireless market. IQE’s strategy is to embed itself as a significant supplier of advanced semiconductor materials with all of the major RF chip Effect: companies in order to reduce the potential impact of Reduction in sales swings in market share between these companies. volumes and profitability Indeed, as Global markets changed in 2019, IQE experienced an acceleration in customer diversification. Whilst share was maintained with US RF Chip companies, IQE is working to expand share with Taiwanese RF Chip foundries.
Similarly, share with IQE’s major InP laser customer is not lost and future revenue opportunities are possible. In addition, customer diversification is possible with an expanding market opportunity for InP lasers in Asia becoming more evident. Here a change in business model, with the development of generic full service Distributed Feedback (DFB) lasers provides IQE with a diversification opportunity.
As 3DS proliferates into Android handsets and even beyond the handset, customer concentration in this segment will also reduce.
IQE continues to enjoy steady growth in other Infrared markets, notably the military market where IQE’s technological expertise, customer-centricity and high quality products ensure a strong market share. This segment contains a number of different customers to the other parts of IQE’s business.
IQE is also working to further diversify its product range and customer diversification by bringing new products to market, including long-wavelength VCSELs and RF Filters and Switches.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 31 Principal Risk: FINANCIAL LIQUIDITY
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Low Risk of not The Group prepares regular financial forecasts to evaluate maintaining its funding and liquidity requirements for the foreseeable sufficient funding future. These forecasts are reviewed and approved by and liquidity the Board. Based on the forecasts, appropriate funding
Strategic Report to meet its and liquidity solutions are put in place to ensure that obligations as appropriate headroom and covenant compliance is (Unchanged) they fall due. maintained. Potential impact: At the 31 December 2019 year-end, the Group had net High debt of £16m (excluding lease liabilities). Effect: In August 2019, the Group secured additional funding in Financial liquidity the form of a new £30m asset financing facility with HSBC, and reputational maintaining the previously agreed £27m revolving credit damage facility with HSBC as a committed line. This increased total facilities to £57m. IQE has a long-standing and trusted relationship with our bankers HSBC who remain supportive of the Company. We are in close ongoing dialogue regarding the evolving effects of Coronavirus on supply chains and markets. In the context of the Coronavirus pandemic, IQE management have considered severe but plausible downside financial forecasts and projections, prepared with significant reductions to future forecast revenues. The Group has discussed the Group’s severe but plausible downside financial forecasts with the Bank in order to agree the relaxation of certain banking covenants at 31 December 2020 and 30 June 2021 as a precautionary measure designed to increase headroom and availability of cash funding under the terms of the Group’s committed bank facilities. The Company is focussed on strong working capital management and capital expenditure can flex to low levels if prevailing market conditions are poor, aiding cash preservation if required.
32 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Principal Risk: LEGAL COMPLIANCE
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Medium Risk of failure IQE is a global manufacturing business, operating in a to comply with diverse range of jurisdictions around the world. applicable laws and regulations IQE continually informs and educates its staff on the
latest legislative and regulatory requirements including Strategic Report export control, anti-bribery & corruption, data protection (Unchanged) and other matters. The Company’s values underpin the operation of all staff with honesty and integrity and a zero Potential impact: tolerance approach is taken to non-compliance with IQE’s Medium high ethical standards. Effect: IQE complies with all relevant export control legislation Financial loss globally. The Company operates a system of internal and reputational controls to ensure all transactions are classified damage appropriately and that any required licenses are obtained prior to shipping. The Company liaises closely with customers to identify the ultimate consignee of shipments.
IQE engages a network of external advisors and expert advisors to ensure it is aware of changes to the legal and regulatory environment and that it responds effectively to these.
Principal Risk: LOSS OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Medium Risk of IQE operates in a competitive industry. In order to protect infringement of its intellectual property IQE maintains strict confidentiality IQE patents by controls and a system of non-disclosure agreements with third parties staff, customers and suppliers.
Risk of loss of IQE protects its technology by strategically patenting in key (Unchanged) trade secrets to areas. third parties Potential impact: Where IQE becomes aware of potential infringement of Medium Risk of claims IQE’s IP by others, or receives a claim alleging infringement alleging IQE has on a third party’s IP, IQE will use appropriate legal Effect: breached third resources to defend its position and its intellectual Financial losses, party intellectual property portfolio. This is evidence in 2019 by the reputational property rights successful outcome of an arbitration hearing related to an damage infringement claim against IQE. Whilst the related Court process is not complete, the arbitration outcome validates IQE’s strategy of defending its intellectual property.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 33 Principal Risk: COMPETITION
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Medium IQE has developed a leading market position through Risk of loss of development of technology, superior product quality market share and investment in manufacturing capacity and customer qualification. IQE’s competitive advantages are discussed Risk of loss further on page 9. The risk of competition has increased Strategic Report of share with in 2019 due to two key factors. Firstly, the changing (Increased) a significant geo-political environment, which has favoured certain customer competitors in the short-term. Secondly, the attractiveness Potential impact: of new markets such as 3DS to new entrants. High Risk of excessive price erosion Despite the increase in risk, IQE continues to secure a Effect: due to predatory substantial share in the markets in which it operates and Loss of market pricing from a remains well placed to adapt to changes in global markets. share, reduced competitor sales volumes and IQE maintains close relationships with customers and profitability Risk of entry of a suppliers to become the “materials partner of choice” new competitor by forming multilevel partnerships from material design stage to pilot and volume production. This helps us to monitor the activity of our competitors and demonstrate to our customers the advantages offered by IQE. We also continue to invest in product development to ensure competitive advantage.
IQE maintains an absolute focus on product quality, value and customer service with technology leadership and complimentary value added solutions that enhance our customers’ competitiveness.
IQE provides superior unit economics to our Customers through superior product quality and yields combined with superior unit economics from our approach to mass production. In some cases, customers seek second source supply arrangements to meet their own business continuity planning policies, but our multiple site capabilities provide suitable mitigation against this risk for some customers.
The qualification process represents a significant investment for IQE and our Customers, both financially and in time so once a product and relationship are established, this becomes a significant barrier to entry for competitors.
Contractual commitments from customers are also used in some cases to maintain share.
34 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Principal Risk: TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Low Risk of a IQE is at the leading edge of technological advancement. disruptive Due to their inherent characteristics, compound technological semiconductors have superior performance characteristics. change that surpasses In order to minimise the risk of other technologies Strategic Report compound surpassing compound semiconductors, IQE invests in (Unchanged) semiconductors research and development and manages a New Product Introduction (NPI) process to ensure it has a pipeline of Potential impact: leading edge, commercially viable products and solutions. High
Effect: Reduction in sales volume and profitability
Principal Risk: KEY PERSONNEL
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Low Risk of loss of key Attraction of talented staff and the retention and personnel development of IQE’s workforce is critical to the long-term success of the Group. Risk that IQE may fail to attract the IQE’s people are the heart of the business. In order to best industry promote the development and retention of its staff, IQE (Reduced) talent offers career progression, personal development and a range of benefits and incentives. Of paramount importance Potential impact: Risk of attrition in is keeping our people safe. IQE is committed to investing in Medium skilled employees advanced safety systems in its facilities, in H&S training and in maintaining robust safety policies and procedures. Effect: Quality issues, In addition, IQE operates a highly effective quality production issues, management system across all of its operations. This increased costs of system ensures that all key data and procedures are operation fully documented, reflecting IQE’s “learning organisation” philosophy.
IQE’s commitment to personal development is evidenced by the implementation of the Training Academy in 2019. For more information please see page 19.
IQE’s leadership communicates regularly with staff, including at quarterly Town Halls.
IQE’s remuneration policy, including performance-based bonus and long-term incentive share plan are also key to retaining staff.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 35 Principal Risk: INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
Business Risk Mitigation: Likelihood: Low Risk of loss of IT IQE has invested in appropriate cyber security defences network or service and employs a third-party specialist to monitor IQE’s network. Cyber security mitigation plans in place to protect Risk of loss of key key information assets.
Strategic Report data, confidential information All staff are required to complete highly effective cyber (Reduced) or intellectual security training and IT policies are in place to ensure staff property use assets appropriately. Potential impact: Medium A risk framework with plans for the management, mitigation and resolution of device failures is in place. Effect: Additional costs Hardware and software systems have in-built resilience and reputational including redundant elements. We continuously invest in damage and improve IT resilience.
Data is appropriately stored and backed-up with IT system recovery plans in place.
Tax compliance IQE believes there will be two possible impacts on IQE’s business from a financial perspective. In previous years IQE has disclosed Tax Compliance as a principal risk. This risk has now been assessed, based 1. IQE reports in GBP and earns the majority on current conditions, as having a low likelihood of of its revenues in USD, so is exposed to occurrence and a low potential impact. As such, it is no exchange rate fluctuations which may be longer considered a principal risk. amplified by Brexit. 2. Access to grant funded research and development projects is likely to be adversely Brexit affected by Brexit and there is some uncertainty over the grant funding landscape The management team’s view continues to be that the in the UK post-Brexit. This predominantly UK leaving the European Union (commonly referred affects IQE’s Compound Semiconductor to as ‘Brexit’) will have no significant impact on IQE’s Centre (CSC) joint venture with Cardiff business operations. In making this assessment the University given the nature of its strategy to following factors have been considered. bridge the gap between academic research and mass production. 1. The Group operates and trades globally, with Asia and the USA representing the Group’s IQE does not foresee any scenarios where Brexit dominant markets. will have a significant impact on the Group’s ability 2. The Group sources input materials from to access workers with requisite skills. Nor does it various global suppliers, including dual-source envisage any circumstances in which a party might gain or multi-source arrangements for volume a competitive advantage over IQE as a result of Brexit. items. 3. Safety stock holding of critical supply items have been increased for UK operations to mitigate potential customs delays. 4. The financial impact of World Trade Organisation tariffs has been evaluated as being de minimis. 5. IQE Europe Limited and IQE Silicon Compounds Limited applied for and have been granted an OGEL (Open General Export Licence) for exporting dual use goods to EU member States.
36 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Section 172(1) Statement – Stakeholders Throughout 2019, IQE has maintained very active dialogue with a wide range of customers and The Directors have given due regard to the matters suppliers and also major end-use OEMs. Guidance set out in section 172(1)(a) to (f) when performing from end customers on future volume and technical their duties under Section 172 of the Companies Act. requirements for photonics applications has driven They have considered the long-term consequences of investment decisions on capacity and also on decisions, matters affecting the Company’s employees metrology requirements critical to maintaining position and other stakeholder relationships, and the need to as supplier of choice for major consumer applications. act fairly between members of the Company. Engagement with our Wireless customers’ customers is Strategic Report Recognising that companies are run for the benefit of more limited due to the preference of our customers their shareholders, but that the long-term success of for us to act through them, not around them. a business is dependent on maintaining relationships Nevertheless, we actively monitor our customers’ with stakeholders, the Board continuously reviews customers via their public data releases, analysts’ which relationships support the generation and reports and applicable conferences. Feedback from preservation of value in the Company. These all sources is carefully weighted, verified and evaluated relationships include those with customers, suppliers, internally with cross-referencing to other IQE Business employees, academic and research institutions, Units with like customers and markets. industrial partners and public bodies. The key relationships are those that are essential to achieving Other examples of decisions and strategies that have IQE’s vision and strategy: been affected by regard to stakeholders in 2019 include: IQE’s vision is to maintain and grow our · established position as the leading global consideration of culture as the basis of provider of advanced semiconductor · decision making within the business has materials – the global “go to” compound underpinned the decision to undertake semiconductor materials specialist; the process of revisiting our vision and strategy, redefining our values and to realise this vision requires the ability creating an overarching brand for our · to deliver “enabling technology”, which people strategy; meets the performance and price points needed for adoption, and which can be decisions concerning financial capital delivered reliably, on-time, every-time · allocation, including investment in R&D with the ability to scale rapidly; and and manufacturing capacity to ensure an ability to generate and preserve value to the effectiveness of its business model over the longer term; · as described in this Strategic Report on previous page. consideration of employee benefits · which have resulted in the establishment The Directors have directly engaged with these key of the EPBGC and a change of pension stakeholders or through senior representatives of the provider; Group - including those responsible for procurement, planning, operations and quality who interact with working with various industry bodies their counterparts at other organisations - who report · in the region to support a bid to the directly to the Directors with a view to understanding Strength in Places fund led by UK the relevant issues through a number of methods. Research and Innovation to support the These methods include: growth of a compound semiconductors cluster in the South Wales region. face-to-face meetings; · In 2019, as in the previous year, IQE’s Directors attendance at industry conferences as have also considered the need to act fairly between · described further on pages 14 to 15; members of the Company when explaining to those of IQE’s major shareholders that are loaning their stock, regularly reading relevant publications, the difficulty that such loaning of stock creates for the · journals and reports; Company.
workers council, town hall and Employee · Pensions and Benefits Governance Committee (EPBGC) meetings as described in this Strategic Report on pages 18 to 19.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 37 Financial review Strategic Report
The Group reports financial performance in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards adopted by the European Union (‘IFRS’) and provides disclosure of additional alternative non IFRS GAAP performance measures to provide further understanding of financial performance. Details of the alternative performance measures used by the Group including a reconciliation to reported IFRS GAAP performance measures is set out in note 5 to the financial statements.
Consolidated revenues declined by 10.4% to £140.0m % growth was driven by demand from the Group’s (2018: £156.3m), primarily as a result of (i) a fall in existing VCSEL supply chain and initial volumes from demand from a major Wireless customer due changes Android supply chains. Infrared revenues accounted in global technology markets resulting from a changing for circa 30% of total Photonics revenues in 2019 with geo-political context and (ii) a fall in demand from a growth rates consistent with historic growth being major Photonics customer due to technical matters driven primarily by defence applications. outside of IQE’s control. Wireless wafer revenues were down 22.4% to £68.2m Segmental information has been restated in the (2018: £87.9m). The decline in Wireless revenue financial statements to reflect changes in the Group’s reflects the global market changes related to the geo- operating and reporting structure following the political landscape, including the impact of a significant establishment of an Executive Management Board decline in volume from one of the Group’s major that has consolidated responsibility for the Group’s GaAs Power amplifier customers, despite maintaining primary markets and operating segments under the previous share of that customers business. GaAs the leadership of an Executive VP, Global Business wafers account for circa 70% of Wireless revenues in Development, Wireless and Emerging Products and an 2019, with GaN wafers accounting for circa 30%. Executive VP, Global Business Development, Photonics & Infrared. This change to the Group’s operating and Gross profit declined from £37.5m to £21.4m. reporting structure has resulted in the consolidation Adjusted gross profit, which excludes the charge for of the previously disclosed Infrared segment into share based payments, decreased from £36.8m to Photonics and the reclassification of certain revenues £20.9m resulting in an adjusted gross margin decline and associated costs pertaining to a specific site, which on wafer sales from 23.9% to 14.9%. The decline in has shared production, between the Wireless and adjusted gross profit margin reflects under-utilisation Photonics segments. of assets in a period where revenue has declined and additional manufacturing capacity has been installed at Photonics represents the largest proportion of the the Group’s manufacturing sites in Group’s revenue accounting for 49.8% (2018: 42.7%) Newport (UK), Hsinschu (Taiwan) and Massachusetts of total wafer sales with Wireless representing 48.7% (US). (2018: 56.2%) and CMOSS++ representing 1.5% (2018: 1.1%) on a restated basis. Other income declined from £1.1m to £nil. The decrease in other income relates to the net insurance Photonics wafer revenues were up 4.4% to £69.8m proceeds received in 2018 following the death of the (2018: £66.8m) despite a significant loss of volume former Chief Financial Officer, Phillip Rasmussen. The from an Indium Phosphide customer that experienced net insurance income was excluded from the adjusted technical issues with an end customer that were profit measures in 2018 as the income did not relate outside the Group’s control. Photonics demand, to underlying trading. especially for VCSEL and Infrared products continued to grow in 2019. VSCEL revenues accounted for circa Selling, general and administrative (‘SG&A’) expenses 50% of total Photonics revenues in 2019. Single digit increased from £29.9m to £36.3m. Adjusted
38 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 SG&A, which excludes adjustments for share based The charge for taxation increased from £5.6m to payments, amortisation of acquired intangibles, £10.2m reflecting increases in non-cash deferred tax restructuring costs, patent dispute legal costs and charges. Increased deferred tax charges principally certain non-current asset impairments increased from relate to the reversal of previously recognised £20.7m to £25.8m reflecting an increase in non-cash US deferred tax assets, deferred tax associated amortisation charges, an increase in corporate costs with accelerated capital allowances in excess of as the business primes itself for growth and exchange depreciation, reflecting the significant recent capital rate movements. investment in the business partially offset by the recognition of deferred tax assets on current year Restructuring costs totalling £0.8m (2018: £3.3m) taxable losses in the UK. The largest component of Strategic Report relates to site-specific employee related restructuring the deferred tax charge relates to the partial reversal of £0.6m (2018: £nil) and additional costs of £0.2m of previously recognised US deferred tax assets. A (2018: £3.3m) associated with the closure of the forecast shift in the balance of the Group’s projected Group’s manufacturing facility in New Jersey. Patent manufacturing production and hence profits between dispute legal costs of £4.3m (2018: £1.3m) relate to a the US and rest of the world has resulted in lower confidential legal dispute. The associated arbitration projected utilisation of US deferred tax assets in future hearing ruled entirely in favour of IQE. In a related years resulting in the partial reversal of previously Court process, in which the counterparty has stated recognised US deferred tax assets with a tax impact of it is considering appealing the award, the case is not ~£9.6m. yet fully resolved. This means that whilst IQE can maintain its position that the eventual outcome will The tax charge on adjusted items of £1.8m and the not be adverse, any potential positive impacts cannot associated low effective tax rate principally reflects the currently be estimated. Non-current asset impairments non-deductible nature of certain asset impairments, totalling £9.5m (2018: £nil) relates to the impairment the tax treatment of the equity accounted CSC loss of certain intangible, right of use and non-current absorption and the impact of the effective tax rate financial assets detailed in note 5. arising on the tax credit associated with the share- based payment credit. The tax credit associated Operating profit decreased from £8.7m to a current with share-based payments principally reflects the year loss of £18.8m. Reflecting the adjustments reduction in future tax deductions associated with the noted above, adjusted operating profit decreased decrease in share price and a reduction in the number from £16.0m to an operating loss of £4.7m. The of options where performance criteria are expected to segmental analysis in note 4 reflects the adjusted be achieved. operating margins for the primary segments (before central corporate support costs). Wireless adjusted Cash invested remained consistent with the prior operating margins declined from c.18.8% to c.9.7%, period at £42.1m (£42.4m) as the Group has primarily reflecting declines in volume and associated completed the infrastructure phase of its capacity underutilisation of manufacturing capacity. The expansion programme. Capital expenditure has decline in adjusted Photonics operating margins from remained broadly consistent at £31.9m (2018: £30.4m) c.15.3% to c.1.9% primarily reflects increased non-cash related to the investments in the new Mega Foundry amortisation charges and increased cost associated in Newport, focused on the 3D sensing market, the with the Group’s newly commissioned Newport expansion of the Group’s wireless (GaAs) capacity in foundry where volumes continue to ramp. Taiwan and the consolidation of the Group’s wireless GaN capacity in Massachusetts. Share of losses in joint ventures of £4.7m (2018: £2.0m) reflects payments of £0.7m made on behalf of Investment has continued in technology and the Group’s joint venture, CSDC, in the period prior to intellectual property. Technology based development its acquisition on 10 October 2019 and the application expenditure totals £8.4m (2018: £10.4m). of the loss absorption requirement of IAS28.38 resulting in a charge of £4.0m following reassessment Investment in capital and technology development has of the recoverability of the Group’s preference share partially been funded by debt. The Group’s net debt debt due from CSC to long term during the year (see position of £16.0m (2018: £20.8m net funds), excluding note 5). lease liabilities arising on implementation of IFRS 16 compares to committed bank borrowing facilities of The acquisition of CSDC was for a nominal cash £57.0m (2018: £nil). consideration of £5 and by taking control of the loss- making operation, the Group is well placed to take the necessary steps to restructure the operation and pursue various Asian market sales opportunities for MBE-based products to return the operation to profitability.
Finance costs increased to £1.5m from income of £0.1m in 2018 reflecting the Group’s utilisation of its borrowing facilities to fund capital expansion and the unwind of discounting associated with lease liabilities following the implementation of IFRS 16 ‘Leases’.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 39 KPI dashboard
Operating profit (£M) Cash from operations (£M) OperatingOperatingSales profit (£M) profit (£M) (£M) CashCash from from operations operations (£M) (£M) SalesSales (£M) (£M) (before exceptional items (before exceptional cash flows) (before(before exceptional exceptional items items (before(before exceptional exceptional cash cash flows) flows)
160 30 40 £154.6m £156.3m 160160 3030 £26.5m 4040 £140.0m 23 £132.7m 130 £22.1m 30 2323 £19m Strategic Report 130130 3030 £114.0m £16.0m 15 1510015 20 100100 20208 8 8 70 10 - £4.7m 0 7070 1010 0 0 40 -8 0 4040 -8-8 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 0 0 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15FY15 FY16FY16 FY17FY17 FY18FY18 FY19FY19 FY15FY15 FY16FY16 FY17FY17 FY18FY18 FY19FY19 FY15FY15 FY16FY16 FY17FY17 FY18FY18 FY19FY19
Operating profit (£M) Cash from operations (£M) OperatingSales (£M) profit (£M) Cash from operations (£M) Sales (£M) (before exceptional items (beforeAdjusted exceptional Diluted EPS cash (pence) flows) Leverage (£M) Gearing (%) (before exceptional items Adjusted(beforeAdjusted exceptional Diluted Diluted EPS EPS cash (pence) (pence) flows) LeverageLeverage (£M) (£M) GearingGearing (%) (%)
160 30 40 3.38p 53 160 30 40 Net debt Deferred consideration 30 533.853 2.89p NetNet debt debt DeferredDeferred consideration consideration 3030 3.8233.8 £31.1m 3.0 2.45p 35 13023 30 20 130 3.0303.0 352.335 £24.3m 1.38p 2020 2.3152.3 £22.6m 1.5 18 15 10 100 1.51.5 201818 100 20 £17.0m £16.5m 0.8 -2.46p 8 10100 8 0.80.8 0.00 0 0 70 0.00.0 -0.810 -18 70 100 0 0 0 -0.8-0.8 -18-1.5-18 -10 -35 -1.5-1.5 -2.3 -10-10 40 -8 -35-350 40 -8 -2.3-2.30 -3.0 -20 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 -53 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 -3.0-3.0 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 -20-20 FY15 FY16 -53-53 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15FY15 FY16FY16 FY15FY15 FY16FY16 FY17FY17 FY18FY18 FY19FY19 FY15FY15 FY16FY16 FY17FY17 FY18FY18 FY19FY19 FY17FY17 FY18FY18 FY19FY19
Adjusted Diluted EPS (pence) Leverage (£M) Gearing (%) Adjusted Diluted EPS (pence) Leverage (£M) Gearing (%)
£23.2m £39.5m 53 30 3.853 30 Net debt Deferred consideration 3.8 Net debt Deferred consideration 22.1% 3.0 35 17.6% 3.0 35 20 2.3 20 £17.1m £16.0m 2.3 18 1.518 1.5 -£45.6m -£20.8m 10 5.7% 0.8 10 0.8 0 -18.8% -7.3% 0.00 0.0 0 -0.8 -180 -0.8 -18 -1.5 -1.5 -10 -2.3 -10-35 -2.3 -35 -3.0 -20 -3.0 -20-53 -53 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY17 FY18 FY19
Going concern
After making enquiries and considering the available In reaching this conclusion, the Board has considered resources, the financial forecasts together with the magnitude of potential impacts resulting from available cash and committed borrowing facilities to uncertain future events or changes in conditions, enable them to consider the future prospects of the the likelihood of their occurrence and the likely Group, the Directors have formed a judgement that effectiveness of mitigating actions that the Directors there is a reasonable expectation that the Company would consider undertaking. and the Group have adequate resources to continue operating for the foreseeable future and therefore the going concern basis has been adopted in preparing these financial statements.
40 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726
Long-term viability
Governance Report statement
The Directors have considered the viability of the Group over a three-year period to December 2022, taking account of the Group’s current position and the potential impact of the principal risks and uncertainties described in the Strategic Report on page 27.
In making this statement the Directors have considered the resilience of the Group, taking account of its current position, the principal risks facing the business in severe but reasonable scenarios, and the effectiveness of any mitigating actions.
The Directors have determined that the three-year period to December 2022 is an appropriate period over which to provide its viability statement as it reflects a period of time over which information and forecasts concerning demand for development, qualification and production of wafers, is considered reasonably reliable. In making their assessment, the Directors have taken account of the Group’s ability to raise new finance in most market conditions and other potential mitigating actions.
Whilst there are emerging levels of uncertainty regarding the impact of Coronavirus on the world economy, the Directors are confident that the overall market in compound semiconductors will continue to grow over the medium to long term. To ensure IQE continues to be well positioned to exploit this growing market in the longer-term, IQE has developed a technology roadmap and continues to invest in research and development. We have also made strategic investments to provide additional manufacturing capacity at sites in the UK, US and Asia and space for further expansion at our site in Newport, South Wales. Further, we have secured additional funding in the form of a new £30m asset financing facility with HSBC, maintaining the previously agreed £27m revolving credit facility with HSBC as a committed line. This increased total facilities to £57m.
Based on this assessment, the Directors have a reasonable expectation that the Company will be able to continue in operation and meet its liabilities as they fall due over the period to December 2022.
This Strategic Report is approved by the Board of Directors and signed on its behalf by:
Phil Smith Chairman, IQE Plc. 28 April 2020
42 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Directors’ Report Governance Report
The directors present their annual report and the audited consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2019.
In accordance with section 414C(11) of the Companies Dividends Act, the Company has chosen to include in the Company’s Strategic Report, certain information which The directors do not recommend the payment of a would otherwise be required by Schedule 7 of the dividend (2018: £nil). ‘Large and Medium-sized Companies and Groups (Accounts and Reports) Regulations 2008’ to be contained in the Director’s Report. Cross references to Directors such information in the Strategic Report are included below. The directors in office at 31 December 2019 and throughout the year and their beneficial interests in the company’s issued ordinary share capital and share Activities options are set out in the Remuneration Report on page 56. The principal activity of the Group during the year was the development, manufacture and sale of advanced semiconductor materials. The principal activity of the Company is that of a holding company for the Group, the provision of services to subsidiary companies, and the research, development and provision of engineering consultancy services to the compound semiconductor industry. Those branches of the Group outside of the United Kingdom are described in the Strategic Report on page 9.
Business review
A review of the Group’s trading during the year and its position at the year-end is provided on pages 38 to 40. The review includes key performance indicators as detailed in the Five Year Financial Summary. The principal risks and uncertainties facing the Group are set out on pages 27 to 37. The future outlook for the Group is set out on page 42. Details of any important events and likely future developments affecting the Company and subsidiaries since the end of the financial year are also included in the Strategic Report.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 43 Substantial interests in shares
As at 31 March 2020 the company had been notified pursuant to the Companies Act of the following substantial interests in the shares of the company as defined by the Listing Rules in addition to those disclosed for the directors:
Shareholder/beneficial owner Shares IC% Invesco (OppenheimerFunds) 140,000,000 17.58 T Rowe Price International 76,244,643 9.57 Hargreaves Lansdown Asset Mgt 51,949,363 6.52 T Rowe Price 43,955,961 5.52 Governance Report Dr Andrew W Nelson 31,536,777 3.96 Schroder Investment Mgt 30,941,283 3.88 Interactive Investor 30,763,608 3.86 AXA Investment Mgrs 26,259,570 3.30 Barclays Wealth 25,804,421 3.24
Source: EQUINITI Investor Analytics
IQE has not acquired any of its own shares during 2019.
Research and development transactions are not permitted. The significant treasury policies relate to Interest rates, foreign currency and The Group incurred costs in respect of research liquidity are detailed in note 22. and development during the year of £9,280,000 (2018: £11,202,000) of which £8,123,000 (2018: £10,559,000) has been capitalised in accordance Insurance and Indemnities with IAS 38 (“Intangible assets”). The remaining research and development costs totalling £1,157,000 We have purchased and maintain appropriate (2018: £643,000) have been charged to the income insurance cover in respect of directors’ and officers’ statement, net of grant funding of £nil (2018: liabilities. The Company has also entered into qualifying £617,000). third-party indemnity arrangements for the benefit of all its Directors in a form and scope that comply with the requirements of the Act. These indemnities were Payment terms in force throughout the year and up to the date of this Report and Annual Accounts. The Group seeks to agree favourable credit terms with its suppliers where possible, and adhere to the agreed terms. The Group’s average number of days’ Provision of information to auditors purchases outstanding in respect of trade creditors at 31 December 2019 was 58 days (2018: 82 days). As far as the Directors are aware, there is no relevant audit information of which the Company’s auditors are unaware. The Directors have taken all the steps that Employment policies ought to have been taken as directors in order to make themselves aware of any relevant audit information A review of the Group’s employment policies is and to establish that the Company’s auditors are aware provided on page 18. of that information.
Principal risks and uncertainties Approved by the Board of Directors and signed on behalf by: Details of the principal risks and uncertainties impacting the Group have been included in the Strategic Report on pages 27 to 37.
Treasury Phil Smith IQE operates a central treasury function, which acts in Chairman, IQE Plc. accordance with specific board policies. Speculative 28 April 2020
44 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Statement of Compliance with the UK Corporate plans based on merit and objective criteria Governance Code (including the promotion of diversity of gender, social and ethnic backgrounds, cognitive The Board of Directors believes in high standards and personal strengths) as required by the of corporate governance and is accountable to new Code. As part of its consideration of shareholders for the Group’s performance in this developed succession plans, the Nominations area. Furthermore, IQE is a company trading on AIM, Committee will consider the linkage of its a market operated by The London Stock Exchange plc, diversity objectives with company strategy and since September 2018, the AIM rules expressly and the gender balance of those in senior require companies to recognise and apply a corporate management and their direct reports. governance code of practice.
The performance of the Directors is assessed Governance Report For many years, the Board of Directors has chosen to on an ongoing basis. For example, the Chief apply the UK Corporate Governance Code (the “Code”) Executive reviews the performance of the and to provide corporate governance disclosures Executive Directors on a periodic basis and similar to those that would be required of a premium- reports to the Remuneration Committee at listed company. The Group has applied the 2018 least annually. However, IQE has not carried edition of the Code in respect of its financial year out a formal and rigorous annual evaluation of ending 31 December 2019. Each edition of the Code the performance of the Board, its Committees, is available on the website of the Financial Reporting Chair and individual Directors to the extent Council (FRC) at: www.frc.org.uk. as required by the Code. It is intended that a formal review process will be implemented This statement is structured according to the five during 2020 and thereafter, but that this will sections of the updated 2018 Code, namely: Board probably not require external facilitation. Leadership and Company Purpose; Division of Companies outside the FTSE 350 such as Responsibilities; Composition, Succession & Evaluation; IQE are encouraged, but not required, to Audit, Risk and Internal Control; and Remuneration. consider the use of externally facilitated board evaluations. The Company is a smaller company for the purposes of the Code, and as such, certain provisions of the Code either do not apply to the Company or are judged to The Remuneration Committee has be disproportionate or less relevant in its case. Where responsibility for determining the policy the Company does not comply with any specific code and setting remuneration for the Executive provision then this is highlighted and explained in this Directors and the Chairman. It also has statement below. responsibility to recommend and monitor the level and structure of remuneration for senior IQE has identified the following main areas of non- management. However, the Remuneration compliance with the new Code: Committee does not currently determine the policy and set the remuneration for senior management and the Company Secretary as The Company’s Articles of Association do not required by the Code. provide that Directors are subject to annual re-election as prescribed by the new Code. The Board has previously considered the Board Leadership and Company Purpose The Group is headed by an effective and FRC’s guidance to companies outside the entrepreneurial Board that is collectively responsible FTSE 350 to consider the annual re-election of for the long-term sustainable success of the Group, all Directors, and considered that this would generating value for shareholders and contributing to be overly burdensome for the nature of the wider society. The Strategic Report sets out how the Group. Now that the new Code removes the Board has recently engaged with: exemption for small companies, the Board will
give due consideration to a potential change to the Company’s Articles of Association during 2020. Any change will be subject to opportunities and risks to the future shareholder approval at the AGM following · success of the business; a decision.t The Board will also consider the requirement of the new Code to set out in the the sustainability of the Group’s business papers accompanying the resolution to elect · model; each Director the specific reasons why their contribution is, and continues to be, important delivery of the Group’s strategy; to the company’s long-term sustainable · success. its aims of creating shareholder value · and contributing to wider society.
IQE does not currently maintain a succession All directors act with integrity, lead by example plan for the Company Secretary or all and promote the desired culture of innovation, management immediately below Board collaboration, valuing people, integrity, accountability level, but IQE is working to develop such and constant improvement. Workforce policies and
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 45 procedures, including in relation to investing in and The Head of Investor Relations also maintains the rewarding its workforce, are consistent with the Group’s IR website, which provides details of the company’s culture and values and support its long Group’s business including its strategy, technologies, term sustainable success. The Board actively engages operations and products. The website provides news with the workforce including through its Employee about the Group, share price information, and financial Benefits and Pensions Governance Committee, reports including the annual and interim reports. Hard Workers Counsels and ‘town hall’ meetings. Through copies of annual reports are also available on request. this activity and engagement, the Board is satisfied The website can be found at www.iqep.com. that the Group’s purpose, values and strategy (set out in the Strategic Report) are aligned with a culture The Company will advise shareholders attending the of innovation, collaboration, valuing people, integrity, AGM of the number of proxy votes lodged in respect accountability and constant improvement. of each resolution, split between ‘For’, ‘Against’, ‘at the Governance Report Chairman’s discretion’ and ‘abstentions’. These are Through its budget processes and consideration of advised after the resolutions have been dealt with strategic projects, each of which include presentations on a show of hands, providing that a poll has not to the Board from leaders of business units and been called for or is required. In accordance with the functions, the Board establishes the Group’s objectives, recommendations of the new Code, when announcing ensures that necessary resources are in place to meet results of votes where 20% or more have been cast those objectives and measures performance against against the board recommendations for a resolution, those objectives. These are complimented by the the Company will explain what actions it intends to Audit & Risk Committee’s responsibility to consider take to consult shareholders in order to understand risk management as set out in the Strategic Report on the reasons behind the result. An update on the views pages 27 to 37. received from shareholders and actions taken will then be published no later than six months after the As required under its Terms of Reference and the shareholder meeting. A final summary on what impact Code applicable to 31 December 2019, the Audit and the feedback has had on the decisions the board has Risk Committee recently reviewed and refreshed a taken and any actions or resolutions now proposed policy on whistleblowing that is applicable across the will be included in the annual report and if applicable, Group’s global operations. This sets out the means in the explanatory notes to the resolutions at the next by which the workforce should raise concerns and shareholder meeting. how they may do so in confidence and if they wish, anonymously. Further information is provided on The Chairman is available to meet with major page 18 of the Strategic Report. Pursuant to the institutional shareholders as needed throughout the requirements of the new Code, moving forward, year to consult on corporate governance matters the full Board shall not only consider reports arising and performance against the strategy. The Senior from its operation, but will also routinely review the Independent Director is also available to consult on arrangements in place for the proportionate and governance matters and to provide an independent independent investigation and follow-up action as set view of the position and prospects of the Group. out in the whistleblowing policy. The Non-Executive Directors, having considered The Board regards regular communications with the Code, are of the view that this approach to shareholders as one of its key responsibilities. The shareholder communication remains appropriate Chief Financial Officer, Chief Executive Officer and for the Group. However, should shareholders have Chairman meet with institutional investors on a concerns which they feel cannot be resolved through regular basis to discuss the Group’s performance, the normal shareholder meetings, the Senior Independent shareholders’ views, and to ensure that the strategies Director and the remaining Non-Executive Directors and objectives of the Group are aligned and well may be contacted through the Company Secretary. understood. As described further in the Section 172(1) Statement The Chief Executive Officer and Chairman keep on page 37, the interests of the Company’s other key the Board fully informed of any significant matters stakeholders have also been considered in recent discussed with shareholders and of shareholders’ Board discussions and has influenced the Board’s views. Furthermore, all members of the Board receive decision-making. The Board continuously reviews the copies of any analysts’ reports of which the Company is effectiveness of its engagement with stakeholders and made aware. the mechanisms that facilitate such engagement.
The Company employs an Investor Relations Manager Under Article 117 of IQE plc’s Articles of Association, who supports the Directors with day-to-day investor if a Director or a person closely connected to them relations. Together, they respond to investor enquiries has an interest in a transaction or arrangement of throughout the year. the Company, such Director is required to declare such interest in accordance with company law. Save The Committee Chairs engage with shareholders in certain defined circumstances described in Article on significant matters related to their areas of 118, a Director should not be counted for quorum responsibility at AGMs and other shareholder meetings or voting purposes in respect of any transaction as required. or arrangement where they have an interest. The Directors give due consideration to any circumstances in which a potential conflict of interest may arise or
46 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 may be perceived to arise, including in connection with Under the direction of the Chairman, the Company significant shareholdings and ensure that the influence Secretary facilitates good information flows within of third parties does not compromise or override the Board and its Committees and between senior independent judgement. management and Non-Executive Directors. The Company Secretary is also responsible for advising Where Directors have any concerns about the the Board through the Chairman on all governance operation of the Board or the management of the matters. All Directors have direct access to the company that cannot be resolved, their concerns advice and services of the Company Secretary who are recorded in the minutes of Board Meetings. On is responsible for ensuring that Board procedures resignation, a Non-Executive director should provide are followed, and are allowed to take independent a written statement to the Chairman for circulation to professional advice if necessary, at the Company’s the Board, if they have any such concerns. expense. Pursuant to Article 134 of IQE Plc’s Articles of Governance Report Association, both the appointment and removal of the Division of Responsibilities Company Secretary is a matter for the whole board. Mr Phil Smith took over the role of Non-Executive Chairman on 1 April 2019 from Dr Godfrey Ainsworth Tom Dale, General Counsel, was appointed as FCA who retired as Executive Chairman. Company Secretary of IQE plc with effect from 19 March 2020. Tom’s appointment follows the Executive Director Dr Howard Williams, Chief resignation of Jason Howells who left the Company on Operations Officer, retired from the Board on 1 August 20 December 2019. Link Company Matters Limited, 2019. a specialist company secretarial and corporate administration services provider, was appointed as The Board comprises the Non-Executive Chairman, Mr Company Secretary during the transition period. Phil Smith, the Executive President and Chief Executive Officer, Dr Drew Nelson, the Executive Chief Financial At Board meetings, the Chairman ensures that all Officer, Mr Tim Pullen and three independent Non- Directors are able to make an effective contribution Executive Directors. Throughout the year ending 31 throughout meetings and every Director is encouraged December 2019 and since, at least half of the Board, to participate and provide their perspective and excluding the Chairman, have been Non-Executive opinions. The Chairman always seeks to achieve Directors. unanimous decisions of the Board following due discussion of agenda items. The Board is supported by an Executive Management Board. The Board has a formal schedule of matters referred to it for decision, this list includes appropriate strategic, The Board considers that the four Non-Executive financial, organisational and compliance issues, Directors, Mr Phil Smith, Sir David Grant, Sir Derek including the approval of high-level announcements, Jones and Mrs Carol Chesney who have each held circulars, reports and accounts and certain strategic office for less than nine years, to be independent in and management issues. Examples of such items accordance with the Code, and free from any business include, but are not limited to: or other relationship which could materially interfere with the exercise of their independent judgement. Mrs the approval of interim and annual Carol Chesney most recently joined the board as Non- · results, Executive Director on 14 May 2019. This followed the appointment of Sir Derek Jones on 29 November 2017 the approval of the annual budget, and the appointment of Mr Phil Smith on 19 December · 2016. · approval of acquisitions or disposals, The Board recognises the special position and role of approval of major items of capital the Chairman under the Code, and it has approved · expenditure, the formal division of responsibilities between the Chairman and Chief Executive. The Chairman is approval of changes to corporate or responsible for the leadership of the Board and · capital structure, ensuring its effectiveness. The Chief Executive manages the Group and has the prime role, with financial issues, including changes the assistance of the Board, of developing and · in accounting policy, the approval of implementing business strategy. dividends, bank facilities and guarantees, and The Board meets regularly through the year - at least six times and additionally on an ad hoc basis the approval of significant contracts. as is required to discharge its duties effectively. It is · provided with appropriate strategic, operational and financial information prior to each meeting together with reports to enable it to monitor the performance of the Group. The number of meetings of the Board, Committees and individual attendance by Directors is set out in the annual report each year.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 47 The Non-Executive Directors scrutinise and hold (b) Audit & Risk Committee to account the performance of management The Audit & Risk Committee consists of the and individual executive directors against agreed Non-Executive Directors, Sir Derek Jones, performance objectives. To facilitate this, the Sir David Grant and Mrs Carol Chesney. The Chairman and Senior Independent Director ensure Committee meets at least twice a year under that meetings of Non-Executive Directors without the the chairmanship of Mrs Carol Chesney. Executive Directors present are held. These include meetings of the Nominations, Remuneration and Audit The Audit & Risk Committee’s main duties & Risk Committees as described further below. are described on page 50. They include monitoring internal controls throughout the One of the roles of the Non-Executive Directors is to Group, approving the Group’s accounting undertake detailed examination and discussion of policies, and reviewing the Group’s interim Governance Report the strategies proposed by the Executive Directors results and full year financial statements to ensure that decisions are in the best long-term before submission to the full Board. The Audit interests of shareholders and take proper account of & Risk Committee also reviews and approves the interests of the Group’s other stakeholders. the scope and content of the Group’s annual risk assessment programme and the annual The Senior Independent Director, Sir David Grant, audit, and monitors the independence of the is recognised as the independent Board member external auditors. who acts as an independent sounding board for the Chairman and serves as an intermediary for the A report on the activity of the Audit & Risk other directors if needed. Furthermore, the Senior Committee during 2019 is included on pages Independent Director is available to discuss any 53 to 55. concerns of shareholders and/or employees which have not adequately been resolved by the Executive (c) Remuneration Committee Directors, or for which such contact is inappropriate, The Remuneration Committee consists of the such as concerns of any suspected impropriety. These Non-Executive Directors, Mr Phil Smith, Sir concerns can be conveyed in private and investigated Derek Jones, Sir David Grant and Mrs Carol as required by the Code. Chesney. Sir David Grant is Chairman of the Committee. The Committee meets at least The Non-Executive Directors have not formally twice a year. met without the Chairman present to appraise the Chairman’s performance. However, this was not The Chief Executive attends meetings of specifically required under the Code as applicable in the Remuneration Committee by invitation the year ending 31 December 2019. to respond to questions raised by the Committee, but he is excluded from any When making new appointments, the Board takes matter concerning the details of his own into account other demands on Directors’ time and remuneration. significant appointments are required to be disclosed with an indication of the time involved. Pursuant to the The Remuneration Committee is responsible new Code, since 1 January 2020, additional external for setting salaries, incentives and other appointments should not be undertaken without prior benefit arrangements of Executive Directors. approval of the Board, with the reasons for permitting It scrutinises the performance of individual significant appointments explained in the annual Executive Directors against agreed report. No full time Executive Director has more than performance objectives. one non-executive directorship in a FTSE 100 company or other significant appointment. A report on the activity of the Remuneration Committee during 2019 as well as the The Board has four sub committees, the Executive Company’s Remuneration Policy is included Committee, the Remuneration Committee, the on pages 56 to 71. Nominations Committee and the Audit & Risk Committee. The Board has delegated special (d) Nominations Committee responsibilities to these committees as follows: The Nominations Committee consists of the four Non-Executive Directors, namely Mr Phil (a) Executive Committee Smith, Sir Derek Jones, Mrs Carol Chesney and The Executive Committee consists of the is chaired by Sir David Grant. Executive Directors under the chairmanship of Dr Drew Nelson and is responsible for the The Board has delegated responsibility for development of strategy, annual budgets and nominations to this Committee, which has operating plans linked to the management a prime role in appointing and removing and control of the day-to-day operations of executive directors. the Group. The Chief Executive attends meetings of the The Executive Committee is also responsible Nomination Committee by invitation. for monitoring key research and development programmes and for ensuring that the Board A report on the activity of the Nominations policies are carried out on a Group-wide Committee during 2019 is included on page basis. 55.
48 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Terms of reference for the Remuneration Committee, inspection upon request to the Company Secretary. Nominations Committee and Audit & Risk Committee The Nominations Committee is responsible for the are available from the Company Secretary or on the Board’s policy on diversity. The Board recognises the corporate website (www.iqep.com). benefits of diversity. Diversity of gender, social and ethnic backgrounds, cognitive and personal strengths, Composition, Succession and Evaluation skills, international and industry experience and Rules concerning the appointment and replacement knowledge are amongst many other factors taken into of Directors and Secretaries of the Company are consideration when seeking to appoint new Directors contained in the Articles of Association (“Articles”). to the Board. Notwithstanding the foregoing, all Board Amendments to the Articles must be approved by a appointments will always be made on merit. special resolution of the shareholders. IQE and its Nominations Committee do not usually Governance Report Under the Articles, all Directors are subject to election use open advertising and/or an external search by shareholders at the first Annual General Meeting consultancy for the appointment of the Chair and Non- following their appointment, and to re-election Executive Directors, but does so when appropriate thereafter at intervals of no more than three years. and in such event will include a statement about any connection it has with Company or individual Directors The Articles provide that the Company Secretary shall in the annual report. be appointed by the Directors for such term, at such remuneration and upon such conditions as they may An account of the activities of the Nominations think fit and any Company Secretary so appointed Committee during the year ending 31 December 2019 may be removed by them. If thought fit, two or is included in the Nominations Committee Report on more persons may be appointed as joint company page 55 secretaries or an assistant or deputy company secretary may be appointed by the Directors. Any By way of induction to the Group, new Directors person so appointed by the Directors may also be meet with the existing members of the Board, removed by the Directors. senior managers and business function leaders as appropriate and at least annually all Directors receive The Nominations Committee, which consists of Sir presentations from senior managers and business David Grant, Chair, Mr Phil Smith, Sir Derek Jones function leaders and receive professional independent and Mrs Carol Chesney, reviews the Board structure, training and advice as necessary from time to time at leads the process for Board appointments and the Company’s expense. makes recommendations to the Board, including on succession planning. Due consideration is given to the Audit, Risk and Internal Control length of service of the Board as a whole and the need The Board views maintaining high standards in its to ensure its membership is regularly refreshed. governance and management of the affairs of the Group as a fundamental part of discharging its All Directors are appointed by the Board following a stewardship responsibilities. Accordingly, both the formal, rigorous and transparent selection process Board and the Audit & Risk Committee continue and recommendation by the Nominations Committee. to keep under review the Group’s whole system of Board appointments are made on merit, against internal control, which comprises not only financial criteria identified by the Nominations Committee controls, but also operational controls, compliance having regard to the benefits of diversity on the Board, and risk management. This process accords with the including gender. Guidance on Risk Management, Internal Control and Related Financial and Business Reporting. Pursuant to its Terms of Reference (available from the Company Secretary and at www.iqep.com), The Audit & Risk Committee consists of the three the Nominations Committee is required to give full independent Non-Executive Directors named above, consideration to succession planning for Directors and whose biographies are included on pages 72 to 73. other senior executives in the course of its work, taking The Board is satisfied that the Audit & Risk Committee into account the challenges and opportunities facing has competence relevant to the sector in which the the company, and the skills and expertise needed on company operates. the Board in the future.
The Nominations Committee meets regularly during the year and is instrumental in determining the requirement and process for the identification and subsequent appointment of Directors. The Nominations Committee evaluates the balance of skills, knowledge and experience on the Board and, in the light of this evaluation, prepares a description of the role for new appointments. In identifying potential candidates for positions as Non-Executive Directors, the Committee has full regard to the principles of the Code regarding the independence of Non-Executive Directors. The terms and conditions of appointment of the Non-Executive Directors are available for
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 49 The main responsibilities of the Audit & Risk The Audit & Risk Committee meets regularly during Committee are as follows: the year. The meetings are also attended by senior members of the finance team and representatives reviewing the effectiveness of the of the Group’s external auditors by invitation. At · Company’s financial reporting, internal meetings attended by the external auditors time is control policies and procedures for the allowed for the Audit & Risk Committee to discuss identification, assessment and reporting issues with the external auditors without management of risk; being present.
reviewing significant financial reporting The Board reviews the effectiveness of the Group’s · issues and judgements; risk management and internal controls on a continuing basis and has recently extended the Governance Report monitoring the integrity of the Company’s Terms of Reference of the Audit Committee so that · financial statements and any formal the Committee now has extended oversight for such announcements relating to the matters. Terms of reference for the Audit & Risk company’s financial performance; Committee are available from the Company Secretary or on the corporate website (www.iqep.com). keeping the relationship with the auditors · under review, including their terms of The work of the Audit & Risk Committee is set out engagement, fees and independence; in the Audit & Risk Committee Report on page 53. The Board and its Audit & Risk Committee’s recent necessity to establish dedicated internal consideration of risk management and internal · audit; controls is described further in the Strategic Report on pages 27 to 37. advising the Board on whether the · Committee believes the annual report A statement regarding the Directors’ responsibility for and accounts, taken as a whole, is fair, preparing the annual report is set out in the Board balanced and understandable and Report on page 52. provides the information necessary for shareholders to assess the Company’s The Board’s robust assessment of the Company’s performance, business model and emerging and principal risks and a description of the strategy; procedures it has in place to identify and manage risks is set out in the Strategic Report on pages 27 to 37. conducting the tender process and · making recommendations to the board, The Board’s most recent considerations of the about the appointment, reappointment adoption of the going concern basis of accounting and and removal of the external auditor, and its assessment of the long-term viability of the business approving the remuneration and terms are set in the Strategic Report on page 52. of engagement of the external auditor; Remuneration reviewing and monitoring the external The Group’s policy and practices on Directors’ · auditor’s independence and objectivity; remuneration and the activities of the Remuneration Committee are described in the Director’s reviewing the effectiveness of the Remuneration Report on pages 56 to 71. · external audit process, taking into consideration relevant UK professional The Executive Directors have responsibility for and regulatory requirements; determining the remuneration of senior management and the company secretary in accordance with policies developing and implementing policy developed through consultation with the Group’s · on the engagement of the external Human Resources advisors and Remuneration auditor to supply non-audit services, Committee. As with all employees, senior management ensuring there is prior approval of non- are eligible to receive share option awards and to an audit services, considering the impact annual bonus (each subject to personal as well as this may have on independence, taking Group financial performance). Further information in into account the relevant regulations relation to IQE’s Bonus Plan and Share Option Plan are and ethical guidance in this regard, provided on page 58 of the Director’s Remuneration and reporting to the board on any Report. improvement or action required; and Directors exercise independent judgement reporting to the board on how it has and discretion when authorising remuneration · discharged its responsibilities outcomes, taking account of Company and individual performance as well as wider circumstances. Directors do not participate in decisions concerning their own remuneration.
50 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Board Report Governance Report
Contribution of the Directors
The Board’s goal is to ensure that its membership and the membership of its committees should have the appropriate combination of skills, experience and knowledge (including experience and knowledge of IQE’s business). Biographies of the Directors are set out on pages 72 to 73 and on IQE’s website (www.iqep.com). These show the range of business and financial experience upon which the Board is able to call and why each director’s contribution is and continues to be important to the company’s long-term sustainable success.
The number of meetings held during 2019 by the Board, the Audit & Risk Committee, the Nominations Committee and the Remuneration Committee are as shown below. The number of meetings attended by the Executive and Non- Executive Directors where they are a member is also shown below:
Board Audit & Risk Remuneration Nominations Committee Committee Committee1 Number of meetings in 2019 10 4 2 0 Attendance Executive: Dr G H Ainsworth2 4 N/A N/A N/A Dr A W Nelson 8 N/A N/A N/A Dr H R Williams3 6 N/A N/A N/A Mr Tim Pullen4 6 N/A N/A N/A Non-Executive: Mr P Smith5 10 2 2 N/A Sir D Grant 10 4 2 N/A Sir D Jones 9 4 2 N/A Mrs Carol Chesney6 5 3 0 N/A
N/A – Not a member of the Committee or not required to attend meetings. 1 There were no meetings of the Nominations Committee in 2019. Any decision requiring the Nominations Committee were made by the full Board in 2019. 2 Dr Godfrey Ainsworth retired from the Board on 25 June 2019. 3 Dr Howard Williams retired from the Board on 1 August 2019. 4Tim Pullen was appointed to the Board on 4 February 2019 and attended all Board meetings after that date except for 3 December 2019 (see note 7.) Tim Pullen attended all the Audit Committee meetings but is not included in the table above as he is an attendee, rather than a member of that committee. 5 Mr Phil Smith was a member of the Audit & Risk Committee before his appointment as Chairman on 25 June 2019. 6 Mrs Carol Chesney was appointed to the Board on 13 May 2019 and attended all Board and committee meetings after that date except for the Board meeting on 3 December 2019 (see note 7.) 7 A Board meeting was held on 3 December but this comprised only three directors as it was approving the allotment of new employee shares in IQE plc. As appropriate, Directors that are unavailable to attend a meeting are consulted and their views are made known in advance or at the meeting. Such directors receive a briefing on matters discussed as soon as possible following the meeting. IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 51 Statement of Directors’ responsibilities in respect The Directors have decided to prepare voluntarily a of the financial statements Directors’ Remuneration Report in accordance with The Directors are responsible for preparing the Annual Schedule 8 to The Large and Medium-sized Companies Report and the Group and parent Company financial and Groups (Accounts and Reports) Regulations statements in accordance with applicable law and 2008 made under the Companies Act 2006, as if regulations. those requirements applied to the company. The Directors have also decided to prepare voluntarily a Company law requires the Directors to prepare Corporate Governance Statement as if the company Group and parent Company financial statements were required to comply with the Listing Rules and for each financial year. Under the AIM Rules of the the Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rules of London Stock Exchange they are required to prepare the Financial Conduct Authority in relation to those the Group financial statements in accordance with matters. Governance Report International Financial Reporting Standards as adopted by the European Union (IFRSs as adopted by the EU) Under applicable law and regulations, the Directors are and applicable law and they have elected to prepare also responsible for preparing a Strategic Report and a the parent Company financial statements on the same Directors’ Report that complies with that law and those basis. regulations. The Directors are responsible for the maintenance Under company law the Directors must not approve and integrity of the corporate and financial information the financial statements unless they are satisfied that included on the Company’s website. Legislation in the they give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of UK governing the preparation and dissemination of the Group and parent Company and of their profit financial statements may differ from legislation in other or loss for that period. In preparing each of the jurisdictions. Group and parent Company financial statements, the Directors are required to: We consider the annual report and accounts, taken as a whole, is fair, balanced and understandable and Select suitable accounting policies and provides the information necessary for shareholders · then apply them consistently; to assess the Group’s position and performance, business model and strategy. Make judgements and estimates that are · reasonable, relevant and reliable; Approved by the Board of Directors and signed on behalf by: State whether they have been prepared · in accordance with IFRSs as adopted by the EU;
Assess the Group and parent Company’s · ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going concern; and Phil Smith Use the going concern basis of Chairman, IQE Plc. · accounting unless they either intend 28 April 2020 to liquidate the Group or the parent Company or to cease operations, or have no realistic alternative but to do so.
The Directors are responsible for keeping adequate accounting records that are sufficient to show and explain the parent Company’s transactions and disclose with reasonable accuracy at any time the financial position of the parent Company and enable them to ensure that its financial statements comply with the Companies Act 2006. They are responsible for such internal control as they determine is necessary to enable the preparation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and have general responsibility for taking such steps as are reasonably open to them to safeguard the assets of the Group and to prevent and detect fraud and other irregularities.
52 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Audit & Risk Committee Report Governance Report
An annual rolling agenda is used to ensure that all tax accounting, the Committee has reviewed and matters within the Audit & Risk Committee’s Terms of determined whether the provision for tax liabilities, Reference are appropriately covered during the year. and the current and deferred tax accounting is The Committee considers that it has discharged its appropriate. responsibilities as set out in its Terms of Reference to the extent appropriate during the year. The Committee has reviewed the resources available to the Group, taking account of the Group’s trading Through consideration of reports from, and meetings and cashflow forecast together with available funding with, management and the external auditors, the headroom to assess the appropriateness of the going Committee has reviewed and determined the concern assumption. following: At the request of the Board, the Committee also considered whether the 2019 annual report was judgemental areas and whether revenue fair, balanced and understandable and whether it recognition and the provisioning policies have provided the necessary information for shareholders been applied consistently and the level of to assess the Group’s performance, business model provisions remains appropriate; and strategy.
External Auditors whether the expected future cash flows of the The Audit & Risk Committee has developed a formal Group support the carrying value of goodwill, auditor independence policy. In accordance with and whether there are any triggering events this policy, the Committee oversees the relationship which suggest any potential impairment with the external auditors and monitors all services of other intangible assets including the provided by them and all fees payable to them. This valuation of development intangibles and the is to ensure that potential conflicts of interest are capitalisation of development costs; considered and that an independent, objective and professional relationship is maintained. whether the presentation of the financial statements, including the presentation of adjusted performance measures, is The Committee also regularly reviews the nature, appropriate and balanced; extent, objectivity and cost of non-audit services provided by the external auditors. In doing this, the Committee does not approve any contract for whether the accounting for joint ventures additional services from them that would compromise and any related disclosure in the financial their audit independence. Under this policy, the award statements are appropriate. to the Group’s auditors of audit-related services, tax consulting services or other non-audit related Through consideration of reports by independent services in excess of £10,000 must first be approved tax specialists assessing the Group tax affairs in the by both the Chairman of the Audit & Risk Committee UK, the US, Taiwan and Singapore as appropriate, and the Senior Independent Director. The provision and consideration of reports by and meetings of external audit and tax compliance are separated with management assessing current and deferred where possible. Tax advice is provided by independent
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 53 advisors including KPMG, EY, Mazars, Baker Tilly and Bevan & Buckland. The policy also establishes guidelines for the recruitment of employees or former employees of the external auditor.
The nature of the services provided by the auditors and the amounts paid to them are as detailed below:
2019 2018 KPMG LLP £'000 £'000
Fees payable to the company's auditor and its associates for the audit of parent company and consolidated financial statements 185 156 Fees payable to company's auditor and its associates for other services: Governance Report - The audit of company's subsidiaries 27 10 - Audit related assurance services 20 12 - Tax advisory 12 55
- Tax compliance service - - Total KPMG LLP (group auditors) 244 233
2019 2018 Ernst and Young (auditors of MBE Technology Pte & CSDC) £'000 £'000 - Subsidiary company's audit 27 8 - Tax services 9 4 Total Ernst and Young (auditors of MBE Technology Pte & CSDC) 36 12
Total 280 245
The Audit & Risk Committee also monitors the Any system of internal control can only provide effectiveness of the annual audit. Before the end reasonable, but not absolute, assurance against of the financial year, the Committee receives a material misstatement or loss, as it is designed to detailed audit plan from the auditors that identifies manage rather than to eliminate the risk of failing to the auditors’ assessment of the key risks and their achieve the business objectives of the Group. intended areas of focus. This is agreed with the Committee to ensure that the scope and coverage The key procedures that the Directors have of audit work is appropriate. IQE’s management established with a view to providing effective internal also provide the Committee with feedback on the control include the following: effectiveness of the audit and the quality of the audit firm and lead audit partner. a clearly defined organisational structure · and limits of authority; In addition, the Group’s auditors are required to make a formal report to the Audit & Risk Committee annually corporate policies and procedures for on the safeguards that are in place to maintain their · financial reporting and control, project independence and the internal safeguards in place to appraisal, human resources, quality ensure their objectivity. control, health and safety, information security and corporate governance; A resolution to reappoint KPMG will be proposed at the forthcoming Annual General Meeting. the preparation of annual budgets · and regular forecasts which require Internal Audit & Controls approval from both the Group Executive The Audit & Risk Committee has reviewed the Committee and the Board; effectiveness of the Group’s system of internal controls and risk management activities bi-annually as part of the monitoring of performance against the half year and full year public reporting. · budget and forecasts and the reporting of any variances in a timely manner to The system of internal control comprises those the Board; controls established in order to provide assurance that the assets of the Group are safeguarded against regular review and self-assessment of unauthorised use or disposal, and to ensure the · the risks to which the Group is exposed, maintenance of proper accounting records and the taking steps to monitor and mitigate reliability of financial information used within the these wherever possible; business or for publication.
54 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 where appropriate, taking out insurance The Group does not have an independent internal · cover; and audit function, however the Group operates internal audit on an ad hoc peer review basis, with a scope of approval by the Audit & Risk Committee evaluating and testing the Group’s financial control · of audit plans and, on behalf of the procedures. The Committee considers that this Board, receipt of reports on the Group’s remains appropriate for the size and geographical accounting and financial reporting spread of the Group. practices and its internal controls together with reports from the external In completing its review of the effectiveness of the auditors as part of their normal audit Group’s system of internal controls the Audit & work. Risk Committee has taken account of any material developments up to the date of the signing of the most Governance Report This process remained in operation for the year under recent financial statements. In addition, recognition review and as part of that process, management report is given to the external audit findings, which help to any material exceptions to the Audit & Risk Committee. inform the Audit & Risk Committee’s views of areas of increased risk.
Nominations Committee Report
In 2018, with the direction of the Nominations The Board continued to work on the recruitment of Committee, IQE conducted a tender exercise for the an additional Non-Executive Director. This activity led engagement of head-hunters to assist the Board to the appointment of Mrs Carol Chesney on 14 May in recruiting a replacement permanent CFO. The 2019. Mrs Chesney subsequently took over the Chair Board appointed Odgers Berndston head-hunters of the Audit & Risk Committee, which had been chaired in May 2018 and actively engaged with them to by Sir Derek Jones since April 2018. complete a preliminary evaluation and provide a list of potential candidates with the necessary skills and Dr Ainsworth retired from the Board on 25 June 2019. experience. In scoping the search for candidates, each Mr Phil Smith, former Chairman of Cisco who joined Board member was consulted in order to agree the the board in December 2016, became Non-Executive necessary skills and experience of candidates to be Chairman on the retirement of Dr Ainsworth. considered for appointment. Based on these criteria a list of potential candidates was developed, which was The Nominations Committee is also exploring filtered to a short-list of four candidates for interview options for the establishment of an advisory board by the Nominations Committee. Odgers Berndston of experienced and independent individuals to meet has no other connection with the Company and is an twice a year and feedback their advice to the IQE independent provider of services to the Company. Board, as is quite common for technology businesses.
The recruitment process was completed on 15 October 2018 when the Company announced the appointment of Mr Timothy Neil Pullen as Chief Financial Officer. Mr Pullen took up his employment on 4 February 2019.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 55 Directors’ Remuneration Report
Remuneration Committee Chairman’s Statement
Dear Shareholders, Governance Report
On behalf of the Board, I am pleased to present the Remuneration Committee’s report of the Directors’ remuneration for the year ended 31 December 2019 for which we will be seeking shareholder approval at the Annual General Meeting in June 2020.
As an AIM-listed company, IQE is not required to submit a remuneration policy to a shareholder vote. However, to align with best practice remuneration governance, we have voluntarily decided to do so.
We appointed Mercer | Kepler to undertake a review of IQE’s remuneration arrangements and this culminated in IQE’s remuneration policy for the years 2017 to 2020, as set out below. This remuneration policy, along with the annual report for 2016 remuneration was approved at the 2017 AGM, with 99.99% and 99.73% voting in favour respectively. The report for 2017 remuneration was approved at the 2018 AGM with 99.94% voting in favour. The report for 2018 remuneration was approved at the 2019 AGM with 99.16% voting in favour. This annual report for 2019 remuneration will be put to a shareholder vote on a voluntary basis at the 2020 AGM.
Sir David Grant, Remuneration Committee Chairman 28 April 2020
NOTE: This report includes audited and unaudited information, which is identified throughout the report.
56 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Directors’ Remuneration Policy
IQE aims to attract, retain and motivate high calibre executives, whilst recognising the need to be cost effective, and to incentivise significant industry out-performance. The Remuneration Committee established a remuneration policy that balances these factors, taking account of investor feedback and prevailing best practice. This section of the Directors’ Remuneration Report sets out the Policy for Executive Director remuneration which was approved by shareholders at the 2017 AGM.
Policy Table
Function Operation Opportunity Performance metrics Governance Report Base salary Base salaries are Any base salary increases n/a To recognise the reviewed annually, are applied in line with individual’s skills with reference to the outcome of the and experience market levels, individual Remuneration Committee’s and to provide a contribution, the review. competitive total experience of each In respect of existing package. Executive and increases Executive Directors, it is across the Group. Any anticipated that salary adjustments become increases will generally be effective on 1 January. in line with those of salaried employees as a whole. In exceptional circumstances (including, but not limited to, a material increase in job size or complexity, material market misalignment) the Remuneration Committee has discretion to make appropriate adjustments to salary levels to ensure they remain appropriate.
Pension All Executives are Executive Directors receive a n/a To provide an members of the Group pension contribution of 10% opportunity for pension scheme and/or of salary or an equivalent executives to receive a cash pension cash allowance. build up income allowance. on retirement. Salary is the only element of remuneration that is pensionable.
Benefits Executives receive Benefits may vary according n/a benefits which to role and individual To provide non- consist primarily of circumstances. Eligibility cash benefits health cover, private to benefits and the cost which are medical insurance, life of benefits are reviewed competitive in the assurance, long-term periodically. market in which disability insurance The Remuneration the executive is and reimbursement Committee retains employed. for fuel, although may discretion to approve a include other benefits higher cost in exceptional that the Remuneration circumstances (e.g. relocation Committee deems or expatriation) or in appropriate in the circumstances where market circumstances. rates have changed (e.g. cost of insurance cover).
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 57 Function Operation Opportunity Performance metrics
Annual Bonus Performance measures, For Executive Directors, the Performance is assessed on an targets and weightings maximum annual bonus annual basis against financial To incentivise and are set at the start of the opportunity will be 120% and personal / strategic reward strong year. of base salary (100% under objectives set at the start of performance The scheme is based previous policy). each year. against financial on a combination of The bonus pays 0% at Financial measures will be and personal financial performance Threshold and 50% at Target, weighted appropriately each annual targets, and personal objectives. with straight-line vesting year according to business thus delivering At the end of the year, between these levels and priorities, and will represent Governance Report value to the Remuneration Target and Maximum, and no no less than 70% of the annual shareholders and Committee determines vesting below Threshold. plan. Performance vs. targeted being consistent the extent to which Any bonus earned over 100% levels will be measured at with the delivery targets have been of base salary would be paid budgeted FX rates. of the strategic achieved. in the form of stock grants. Personal/strategic objectives will plan. Bonus payments up represent no more than 30% to 100% of salary are of the maximum opportunity delivered in cash or in and will be set annually to the form of stock grants. capture expected individual Clawback (of any contributions to IQE’s strategic bonus paid) may plan. The personal element be applied during will be restricted to 15% of the employment or for 2 maximum opportunity in the years post-termination event the thresholds for two out in the event of gross of the three relevant financial misconduct, material measures are not met. financial misstatement, The Remuneration Committee error in calculation of has discretion to adjust outcomes or in any formulaic bonus outcomes to other circumstance ensure fairness for shareholders that the Remuneration and participants, to ensure Committee considers pay aligns underlying company appropriate. performance, and to avoid unintended outcomes. These adjustments can be either upwards (within plan limits) or downwards (including down to zero). The Remuneration Committee may consider measures outside of the bonus framework to ensure there is no reward for failure. Any adjustment would be carefully considered and fully explained in the Annual Report on Remuneration. Further details of the measures, weightings and targets applicable are provided on page 50 in the Annual Report on Remuneration.
58 IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 Function Operation Opportunity Performance metrics
LTIP Under the long-term The LTIP provides for normal Vesting of LTIP awards is subject incentive plan (LTIP) awards of up to 150% of to achieving performance To drive sustained annual awards of salary (100% under the conditions and continued long-term shares or nil-cost previous policy, but with a 2x employment. performance options may be made multiplier linked to absolute The Remuneration Committee that supports to participants. Award TSR). has the discretion to change the creation of levels and performance In exceptional circumstances, the performance measures shareholder conditions are reviewed including but not limited to for new cycles to ensure that value. before each award cycle recruitment, normal awards they continue to be linked to to ensure they remain may be made up to 200% the delivery of the Company’s Governance Report appropriate. of salary (no change from strategy. Any significant change The Committee has the previous policy) to secure the would be subject to prior discretion to authorise right individual. shareholder consultation. a payment, in shares, Up to 25% of the LTIP will be If no entitlement has been equal to the value of paid for achieving Threshold earned at the end of the dividends which would performance, increasing on relevant performance period, have accrued on vested a straight-line basis to full awards lapse. shares during the vesting vesting for achieving Stretch period. The Remuneration Committee performance. has discretion to adjust Malus (of any unvested outcomes to ensure they fairly LTIP) and clawback reflect underlying performance. (of any vested LTIP) The Remuneration Committee may be applied during also considers environmental, employment or for 2 social, governance and health years post-termination and safety criteria, to ensure in the event of gross there is no reward for failure. misconduct, material financial misstatement, error in calculation of outcomes or in any other circumstance that the Remuneration Committee considers appropriate.
Notes to the policy table Performance measure selection and approach to target setting
The measures used under the annual bonus plan are selected annually to reflect IQE’s main objectives for the year and reflect both financial performance (e.g. EBITDA, cashflow and revenue growth) and personal contributions to delivering the strategic plan.
In terms of the performance conditions for the LTIP, the Remuneration Committee considers Fully Diluted Adjusted Earnings per Share (‘EPS’) to be a key measure of IQE’s long-term bottom line performance, while Total Shareholder Return (‘TSR’) is a measure which strongly aligns management and shareholder interests. Targets applying to the bonus and new LTIP awards are reviewed annually, based on a number of internal and external reference points. Performance targets are intended to be stretching and achievable, and reflect IQE’s strategic priorities and its market opportunities.
Remuneration policy for other employees
All employees are eligible to participate in a discretionary annual bonus and receive awards under the LTIP.
Shareholding guidelines
The Remuneration Committee wishes to encourage Executive Directors to build up a significant shareholding in the Company. Shareholding guidelines are therefore in place to require Executive Directors to acquire a shareholding (excluding shares held conditionally pursuant to LTIP performance) equivalent to 200% of base salary. 50% of any shares vesting (post-tax) under the new LTIP are required to be held until the relevant shareholding level is achieved. Executive Directors are expected to build up the required shareholding within five years of appointment to the Board. Details of the Executive Directors’ current shareholdings are provided in the Annual Report on Remuneration on page 51.
IQE PLC | Report and Annual Accounts 2019 | Company No: 3745726 59 Non-Executive Director remuneration
Non-Executive Director Date of appointment letter
Sir David Grant 1 September 2012 Phil Smith 30 November 2016 Sir Derek Jones 1 December 2017 Carol Chesney 13 May 2019
Governance Report Subject to re-election by shareholders, Non-Executive Directors are appointed by the full Board and retire by rotation in accordance with the Company’s Articles of Association. The remuneration of Non-Executive Directors are matters reserved for the full Board, subject to a limit of £150,000 per annum or such other figure as shareholders may approve plus reasonable expenses in accordance with the Company’s Articles of Association.
The Non-Executive Directors are not eligible to participate in the Company’s performance related bonus plan, long- term incentive plans or pension arrangements. Full terms and conditions for each of the Non-Executive Directors are available at the Company’s registered office during normal business hours and will be available at the AGM for 15 minutes prior to the meeting and during the meeting.
Details of the policy on fees paid to the Company’s Non-Executive Directors are set out in the table below:
Function Operation Opportunity Performance metrics
Fees The fees paid to the Non- Fee levels are reviewed annually, n/a To attract Executive Directors are with any adjustments effective and retain determined by the Board 1 January in the year following Non-Executive (excluding the Non-Executive review. Directors of Directors or group of Non- the highest Executive Directors whose It is expected that increases calibre remuneration is being to Non-Executive Director fee with broad discussed). levels will normally be in line with commercial salaried employees over the life and other Fee levels are benchmarked of this policy. However, in the experience against similar roles at event that there is a material relevant to the comparable companies. misalignment with market or Company. Time commitment and a material change in the time responsibility are taken into commitment required to fulfil a account when reviewing fee non-executive director role, the levels. Board has the power to make an appropriate adjustment to the fee level.
Pay scenarios The charts below provide an illustration of the potential future reward opportunities for the Executive Directors, and the split between the different elements of remuneration under three different performance scenarios: ‘Minimum’, ‘On-target’ and ‘Stretch’.
Dr Andrew Nelson Tim Pullen £2.3m £2.3m £2.0m £2.0m £1.8m £1.8m £1.5m £1.5m £1.3m £1.3m £1.0m £1.0m £0.8m £0.8m £0.5m £0.5m £0.3m £0.3m