Interim Report of the NABA Names Committee
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Jeffrey Glassberg Jeffrey Interim Report of the NABA Names Committee Scientific Names Subcommittee: Michael Braby, Marc Epstein, Jeffrey Glassberg (ex officio), Peter W. Hall, Yu-Feng Hsu, Torben Larsen, David Dave Hanson 1 2 Lohman, Naomi Pierce, Malcolm Scoble, John Tennent, Dick Vane-Wright Ken Kertell (Chair/Secretary), Angel Viloria, Shen-Horn Yen English Names Subcommittee: Alana Edwards, Jeffrey Glassberg (Chair/ Secretary), Fred Heath, Jim Springer, Julie West This is the first report of the reconstituted NABA Names Committee. For more Glassberg Jeffrey 3 4 information about the Committee, including Hitherto known only from Mexico south to Glassberg Jeffrey Costa Rica, this species has now been recorded aims, principles and procedures, please from North America by Dave Hanson, of Mission, visit www.naba.org/ftp/NABA_names_ Texas, who encountered and photographed a committee_2012.pdf single individual of this butterfly on April 13, 2003 at Bentsen Rio Grande Valley State Park. “NABA-NC 2013-01 Phocides belus What was thought to be the same individual Phocides belus Godman & Salvin, 1893, was seen at the same location several times the species new to list etfollowing al. day, and photographed and videoed by a number of people (Hanson, 2003; Hanson Scientific Names Subcommittee , 2003). According to Reese (2003), the Phocides belus Godman & Salvin, 1893: 293, pl. butterfly stayed in the same area for at least another six days.belus Jeffrey Glassberg Jeffrey 5 6 The only taxonomic question appears to be 76, figs 17, 18. Type locality Mexico: Durango, Phocidesthe status pigmalion of (type locality Mexico) as a full Four, of the eighteen, species of beamers. The forewing spots, especially the postmedian forewing ForrerVeracruz and Tamaulipas. Image of one of the species in its own right, or as a subspecies of spots, on Phocides belus, photos 1-3, are larger than on other beamers. Some populations of original type series (from Ventanas, 2000 ft, leg. Atlas of Neotropical (Cramer,Lepidoptera 1779:, P. belustype locality Phocides pigmalion, photo 4, come close. ) available at www.butterfliesofamerica. Surinam), as accepted by Evans (1952). In the Phocidescom/L/t/Phocides_belus_a.htm pigmalion belus Godman & Salvin; is regarded as specifically distinct (Mielke, 2004). 1: First (and only) Big-spotted Beamer reported from the United States. Apr. 13, 2003. Bentsen- Mielke (2005) noted 23 publications since 1952 Rio Grande Valley State Park, Hidalgo Co., TX. Evans, 1952: 13. in which it was treated as a separate species, Phocides belus et al. 2: Big-spotted Beamer. Dec. 12, 2000. Cd. Colima, Colima, Mexico. against 11P. inpigmalion which it. was listed as a subspecies. Godman & Salvin; Mielke, 2004: The current NABA Checklist (Cassie , 2001) 3: Big-spotted Beamer. Feb. 10, 1999. Above Candelaria Loxicha, Oaxaca, Mexico. 37; Mielke, 2005: 294; Vane-Wright & Glassberg, includes 4: Phocides pigmalion. Oct. 22, 2014, Apuya, Napo, Ecuador. 2012: 54 (fig.); Glassberg, 2012: 279. It is not clear who,pigmalion post Evans and (1952), belus 5: Teal beamer, Phocides urania. Sept. 3, 2003. La Estanzuela, Nuevo Leon, Mexico. was the first person to give a soundet argument al. 6: Bell’s beamer, Phocides metrodorus. Oct. 22, 2014. Apuya, Napo, Ecuador. for the separationPhocides of pigmalion and P. belus as separate species. However, Janzen (2011) 26 American Butterflies,Winter 2014 27 indicate that Jeffrey Glassberg (2) Glassberg Jeffrey Paradise Skipper co-occur in the Guanacaste National Park. (as a group name): Hoskins, Although apparently notet alreliably separable by A. DNA barcodes, they are stated to be separable Group Name. by phenotype (Janzen ., 2011: fig. 6) and There are about 2500 species of skippers in habitat — in other words, on present evidence, the Americas and, if one were to give them all the two are sympatric but allotopic sibling English names equivalent to XX Skipper, it would Scientificspecies. Name Discussion be impossible to give them meaningful names . One member offered the following comment: As stated in policy number 4, in the Introduction Phocides pigmalion — in my view we need more to the First Edition of the Checklist, groups evidence to reject the hypothesis of a single species of species that form identifiable assemblages and accept the alternative hypothesis of two species should be givenPhocides a group name.Phocides (i.e. belus is specifically distinct). There may well There are 18 currently recognized species 7 8 be two species in the complex, but the available in the genus . GivingPhocides a group evidence (1 phenotypic character, 1 ecological name allows one to differentiate them by Turquoise Longtails have much turquoise above, especially on their thoraxes. Their long tails are character) is weak. name. Paradise Skipper for appears to often lost. have been recently coined by Adrian Hoskins, In Central and continental South America has been rarely used (see above) and creates 7. The first Turquoise Longtail reported from the United States. Dec. 6, 2003. National Butterfly (especially, e.g., in Peru) these two skippers are confusion with two olderAbantis existing paradisea names., 1. If Center, Hidalgo Co., TX. one googles Paradise Skipper, the first entry considered hard to separate. Some form of mimicry 8. Turquoise Longtail. Nov. 2, 2010. National Butterfly Center, Hidalgo Co., TX. may be a factor but, even if so, the evidence is Wikipedia entry for for their specific status is indeed rather weak. an African skipper that looks vaguely like a However, the modern consensus, post Evans, Phocides. 2. GlassbergDrephalys (2007). has used the is overwhelmingly in favor of recognizing two group name paradise-skipper for the grass- NABA-NC 2013-02 Urbanus evona skipper genus species. When you also take into account the P. yokhara Urbanus evona Evans, 1952, species new to Beamer refers to the radiating iridescent great phenotypic difference between P. pigmalion is not English, provides no information about list okeechobee in Florida, and the phenotype blue (orange on ) “beams” radiating the butterflies, and is arguably of uncertain out from the base of the forewing. Many species encountered in Texas and dealt with so far as P. Jemadia Phocides pronunciation.” ; “Big-spotted Beamer” is more Scientific Names Subcommittee of blue-colored firetips, especially in the genus belus, for North America at least, it seems very descriptive of the actual butterfly markings Urbanus evona , are very similar to but are sensible to keep them as separate species (even than is beautiful beamer. If we can utilize actual Champion). though it is possible of course that view might have readily distinguishable by the absence of the markings wherever possible in our common Evans, 1952: 90, pl. 18, fig. 8. beams. Once learned, the group name beamer names, it will likely make field identification to be revised in future). The more likely change, http://butterfliesofamerica.com/urbanus_evona_Type locality Guatemala: Zapote ( allows one to easily recognize this group of easier. “; “I am not comfortable with Beautiful. as suggested by one committee member, is that Phocides types.htmType material. in BMNH. Image of holotype at butterflies in the field. The two species of okeechobee may come to be regarded as a separate Calling the butterfly Beautiful suggests to me Urbanus evona species (most likely as a subspecies of P. batabano that are resident in the United States, that it is somehow more beautiful than the (Lucas, 1857)). Guava Skipper and Mangrove Skipper, both have other beamers. “ Another said “Even if it [the Evans; Steinhauser, 1981: “beams.” west-Mexican population] turns out to be an 8–10, 25, figs 21,22, 40, 55; Mielke, 2004: 41; Scientific Name Decision undescribed species, it could easily be given a Mielke, 2005: 388; Glassberg, 2004; 2012: 286; Phocides belus, 3 Species Name. different appropriate name.” Vane-Wright & Glassberg, 2012: 54 (fig.). Beautiful is the name that has heretofore been First recorded from USA at NABA International Votes cast: 8Phocides in favor pigmalionof . used in a few NABA publications. Glassberg We attempted to interview Stephen Foster to Butterfly Park, Mission, Hidalgo Co., Texas, on abstentions,Phocides belus 1 vote in favor of re-interpretation (2007) used Big-spotted Beamer as a name for learn his view of not using beautiful beamer as December 6, 2003, by J. Glassberg, D. Hanson & to consider Phocides West-Mexican populations of beamers that some the name for this species, but were unable to G. Quintanilla. (Glassberg, 2004; Vane-Wright & is adopted by NABA as the believed represent a separate species. However, Englishreach him. Name Decision Glassberg, 2012: 54). There have been at least scientific Phocidesname for belus the recorded from to date, wePhocides are unaware belus of. any publications two more sightings since (NABA South Texas, Texas by: Hanson, D. 2003 (April 17). Beautiful providing evidence for this and these may best 2004).Urbanus No other evona name appears to pertain to this Beamer ( ). First U.S. Record. www. Englishbe treated Name Discussion Votes cast for group name: 5 in favor of beamer, species. Mielke (2005) listed over 25 references Englishnaba.org/chapters/nabast/bbeamer.html Names Subcommittee 0 for paradise-skipper, 0 for skipper. to , with no other combination, Phocides Votes cast for species name: 0 cast for Beautiful, subspecies or synonyms indicated. Comments by committee members included: “I 0 cast for Belus, 5 cast for Big-spotted. Beautiful Beamer Scientific Name Decision English names already in use for this species: like calling the group Beamers. I think . Votes cast: 9 in favor of Urbanus evona, 3 : Glassberg, 2007, Glassberg, it does have more meaning than skipper because Phocides belus Belus Skipper: abstentions. 2012; Reese, 2003. ‘skipper’ can be so many genera and because Big-spotted Beamer is adopted as the 28 American Butterflies,Opler et al.Winter 2014 ‘skipper’ is just not as interesting. “; “Belus NABA name for 29 Jeffrey Glassberg Jeffrey Urbanus evona is adopted by NABA as the Achalarus tehuacana scientific name for theUrbanus recorded from NABA International Butterfly Park, Mission, Rhabdoides was originally Hidalgo Co., Texas, by: J.