COACH BETSY KNOWS BEST
Vol. 1, No. 11 • April 1, 2015 Uniting the Community with News, Features and Commentary Circulation: 14,500 • $1.00 See Page 16 Accused Revere Teacher Reinstated By SUE PASCOE Editor aul Revere Middle School teacher Steven Carnine was reinstated to the Pclassroom on Thursday. He had been pulled from his job on Monday because a family filed a lawsuit alleging racism. On March 23 close to 400 students, par- ents and teachers rallied in front of Paul Revere before school to protest the suspen- sion of the 27-year-veteran at the school, who teaches sixth-grade English/history and eighth-grade U.S. History. The following morning LAUSD held a meeting for parents about racism and ini- tially denied parents the right to speak, until parent and noted urban planner Doug Suisman claimed his right, and spoke, fol- lowed by others. That afternoon on the popular John and Ken show on KFI 640 radio, the pair dis- cussed LAUSD’s lack of common sense in suspending Carnine without thoroughly vetting a lawsuit filed by a Shawn B. on be- half of his daughter, Maggie B., seeking un- At Paul Revere Middle School on March 23, more than 400 students, parents and teachers showed support for suspended teacher specified damages. Steven Carnine before school, calling the alleged racist remarks untrue. Photo: Sue Pascoe According to the suit filed in Los Angeles Superior Court, the plaintiff is under 18 and is half black and half white. She started attending Paul Revere School in 2013 as a Support Autism Fundraising April 12 seventh-grade student and had been in By SUE PASCOE Meche Salon (Guy Riggio), Pacific Palisades children,” Sabin said. “Recently, a parent Carnine’s eighth-grade class for seven days Editor Pediatric Dentistry, Palisades News, The Yo- spoke to me about her initial experience, in January when race and stereotypes were gurt Shoppe, Wieder Dermatology, Work- and said that within 48 hours of her son re- addressed. pril is Autism Awareness month. To ing With Autism and Yogi Girl Yogi Guy. ceiving an autism diagnosis, Autism Speaks According to the suit, “In discussing the honor families who have someone All proceeds will benefit Autism Speaks, had mailed the ‘100-day kit,’ which in- [Fergurson] incident, Carnine said that Aaffected by an autism spectrum the world’s leading autism science and ad- cluded all of the information necessary at the guy was a thug and he got what he de- disorder, the third annual “Go Blue or Go vocacy organization, which is dedicated to that point to help her understand and plan served,” according to the suit, which alleges Home” event will be held from 11 a.m. to 3 funding research into the causes, preven- (Continued on Page 3) that the teacher also said, “Black people are p.m. on Sunday, April 12, at the Palisades tion, treatments and a cure for autism. judged for not being smart because they are Recreation Center. The public is invited. Yogurt Shoppe co-owner Jennifer Sabin not smart. A lot of them are just athletes.” There will be food trucks, a moon bounce, founded Working with Autism, Inc. in PAPA Seeks a The lawsuit alleges that Carnine said if carnival games, a Boba truck and a DJ, 1997, and is the executive director (visit: he was walking alone at night and there sponsored by the Apartment Market Group, workingwithautism.com). She initially be - Parade Theme were two black men behind him, he was Black Ink, Branches, Carly K, Elyse Walker, gan working with children on the autism “immediately going to be scared and think Friendship Circle, Gerry Blanck Martial spectrum under Dr. Ivar Lavaas at UCLA, Ever since American Legion Post 283 re- they are either going to steal from me or Arts, Helen’s Cycles, Jaimie Geller Jewelry, while earning her psychology degree. vived the Pacific Palisades Fourth of July pa- hurt me,” and “We all know Jews like to Jonathan & George Salon, Juice Crafters, “My experience with Autism Speaks is rade in 1961, a theme has helped define the hoard their money.” Kier Design, Liberty Mutual Insurance, they provide immediate and individual parade. This year is no different, and PAPA The suit also stated that Carnine, dur- Maemae Jewelry, Marc Michel Eyewear, support to the parents of newly diagnosed (Palisades Americanism Parade Associa- ing a lecture on the Civil War, stated that tion) is asking your help to pen a clever, “people didn’t like Lincoln because he was witty, poignant or memorable theme. a (N-word) lover,” and that Carnine was
Postal Customer Postal Last year’s winner was Kim Traenkle’s “staring and smirking” at the plaintiff when entry, “Star-Spangled Palisades.” he made the remark. Submit your best idea(s) to info@ pali - Katie T., who was in the class, posted
**************ECRWSSEDDM************* sadesparade.org, by Friday, April 3. The these remarks on the online Save Mr. Car- winner will be selected at the next PAPA nine petition that garnered 500 signatures meeting on April 6. in 24 hours: “Mr. Carnine said that stereo-
Permit #422 Permit If your theme is selected, in addition to Pasadena, CA Pasadena, types were wrong, but sadly they are still in
PAID bragging rights, you can also ride in the our world today. He was discussing these U.S. Postage U.S. parade aboard a fire engine (with selected stereotypes with us in order to help us un-
Presorted Standard Presorted family members) and Pali sades News will derstand history and how different races feature you in a story. (Continued on Page 9) Page 2 Palisades News April 1, 2015
ANTHONY MARGULEAS “Realtor with a Heart” 310.293.9280 Happily donating 10% from each sale to our clients’ favorite charities Recent Donations
The Kitchen Community - impacts school children daily with 200 Learning Gardens - on behalf of Chuck T.
Helping Hands Orphanage - provides shelter and care for those in need - on behalf of Krishna N.
St. Paschal Baylon School - encourages students to be self-motivated learners - on behalf of Suzanne D.
Palisades Village Green - helps maintain the Village Green in the center of town
The Children’s Bureau - nurtures children & prevents child abuse - on behalf of Mark & Liza-Mae C. Will your favorite charity be next?
Available Properties 1630 AMALFI DRIVE 13535 LUCCA DRIVE 733 EL MEDIO
7 Bed, 10 bath, 11K sq ft, 18,629 sq ft lot 6 bd, 5.5 bth + guest house, 4,976 sq ft, 20.877 lot 5 Bed, 5.5 bath, 4,364 sq ft $13,899,000 $8,150,000 $3,850,000
1615 MICHAEL LANE The Marguleas Team
WWW.AMALFIESTATES.COM
3 Bed, 2.5 bath, 1,857 sq ft $1,280,000 Contact Anthony now if you are thinking of buying or selling a home. 310.293.9280 [email protected] CalBRE#01173073 April 1, 2015 Palisades News Page 3 Autism (Continued from Page 1) for the appropriate support and therapies. “The strength of Autism Speaks is in the wealth of resources that an organization such as this has, and the individual support, which is provided to the families at a time of need,” Sabin said. According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), about 1 in 68 children have been identified with an autism spectrum disorder, which means those diagnosed can range from bright, verbal and autistic to mentally retarded and non-verbal. Parents who have a child with ASD tend to notice a developmental problem before the child’s first birthday. Autism is almost five times more com- mon among boys than girls. Studies have shown that among identical twins, if one child has ASD, then the other will be affected about 36 to 95 percent of the time, too. Parents who have a child with autism have a 2 to 18 percent chance of having a second child who is also affected, and chil- Locals participating in last year’s Autism Speaks fundraiser were (left to right) Frankie Sabin, Sirena Warren, Colette Taheri and dren born to older parents are at higher risk Holland Mueller. Photo: Kevin Sabin for the disease. interventions and parental involvement are have been affected by autism. The goal is which include medication, behavioral and CDC notes that autism commonly co- significant factors in determining the child’s to create the world’s largest database of se- psychological interventions. occurs with other developmental, psychi- progress. Equally important, the earlier that quenced genomic information of Autism The organization believes that vaccines atric, neurologic, chromosomal and genetic a parent can detect these areas of concern, run on Google’s cloud-based genome have been shown to be safe for most children diagnoses. The co-occurrence of one or the earlier the intervention is started, the database, Google Genomics. and support vaccinations to prevent serious more non-ASD developmental diagnoses better the chance of a positive outcome.” Autism Speaks works towards improv- diseases such as measles and mumps. is 83 percent. Sabin says one of the most “common mis- ing diagnosis and the possible therapies, Visit: autismspeaks.org. “The label of autism should not inhibit conceptions is that individuals with autism parents from striving to maximize their are unable to build social relationships.” child’s potential,” Sabin said. “There is a great Autism Speaks raises money to support deal of variability within the autism diag- research to look at the genetic and environ- Eggstravaganza at Rec Center nosis, and the right combination of quality mental factors that may cause autism, in- The Palisades Recreation Center will imal petting zoo will be open. At noon cluding susceptibility genes, environmental host its annual Eggstravaganza from 10 there will be an egg hunt for children up toxins and maternal viral infections. It a.m. to 1 p.m. on Saturday, April 4 at the to 8 years of age (bring your own basket). Volunteers funds the Autism Genetic Resource Ex- park, 851 Alma Real Dr. The cost is $5 per At 12:45 p.m. there will be a puppet show change, a DNA repository and family reg- child (please bring cash). Sought to Help istry of genotypes and phenotypes. Activities include two large bounce by the Franklin Haynes Marionettes. Since last year, that organization has houses (one for toddlers and one for big- Hot dogs, drinks and snacks will be With Parade partnered with Google on Mssng to collect ger kids), crafts and face painting. From sold. The Easter Bunny will arrive via Fire The next volunteer meeting for PAPA and study the DNA of 10,000 families that 10 a.m. to noon, the Reptacular farm an- Truck around 10:45 a.m. (Palisades Americanism Parade Associa- tion) will be held at 7 p.m. on April 6 at the American Legion when a theme will be selected. The public is invited. Return to It is not too early to start thinking about parade entries. “We would love new en- The 1860s trants,” said Daphne Gronich, second-term PAPA president. “It’s more interesting for residents to see different bands and floats At Marquez in the parade, and we encourage people to Marquez fourth grade teacher put them together.” Theresa Chaides alerted the A search is on for a parade grand mar- Palisades News, “All fourth- shal, as well as a headline band for the eve- graders are stepping back in ning concert at Palisades High, which was time to the 1860s on Thursday attended by 7,000 people last year. and are attending school in full Lawyer, Palisades resident and concert or- pioneer garb. It’s always neat to ganizer Keith Turner said that he has already see them coming to school in heard from local bands that would like the long skirts, hats and boots.” opportunity to play on the second stage. Elena Roby (left) and Sophie The day, which also features the 5/10K Davidson find out how bonnets Will Rogers Run, a parade, a concert and worked as natural sunblocks fireworks, is made possible by volunteers and while Archie Galbraith used a community donations. If you would like to “backpack from the 1860s.” volunteer or donate, and are unable to at- Photos: Tom Hofer tend the meeting, visit: palisadesparade.org. Page 4 Palisades News April 1, 2015 Galvez Recognized by Palisades Optimists By SUE PASCOE was faced with a new challenge: waking up He cites his favorite classes as AP Human Editor at 5 a.m. to drive to Pacific Palisades five Geography and English. “My favorite days a week. teacher is Ms. Korbonski, because she was alisades High School senior Daniel Palisades News spoke to Galvez in mid- the one who understood when I could not Galvez was recognized as Pacific Pal- February. “I have had the worst two weeks turn in an assignment because of what Pisades Optimist Club Student of the of my life,” Galvez said. “It all started out was happening.” Month. The College Center recommended with my car breaking down on the freeway. The commute makes it hard for Galvez him because “He is a kid that doesn’t give The gas pump failed and I was left strand - and his sister to do after-school activities. up, even in difficult circumstances. He just ed by Palmdale on the freeway shoulder.” “My sister had to give up lacrosse because puts his head down and keeps going.” Without a car, he and his sister missed the traffic back home was way too bad,” said When Galvez’s father lost his job in early next day of school. Galvez, who also plays the guitar and likes winter as an apartment manager in West A week later another catastrophe hit. to long board. Hollywood, the young man served as his “My camera bag [Canon 60D], my most Galvez has been accepted into UC Irvine father’s headhunter. (His mom Dora is a prized possession, was stolen from me at and CSUN, but was waiting to hear about house manager in Sherman Oaks.) school,” Galvez said. “It had my lenses and financial aid. “I plan on possibly taking the “I began searching on Craigslist and microphone along with the camera body. Santa Monica College route if aid doesn’t other job-searching websites, but quickly I had worked for every single penny of it come,” Galvez said. realized everyone asked for a resume and and it was just stolen away from me as if it (Editor’s note: A Pacific Palisades “angel” cover letter,” Galvez said. “So I made both were nothing. I had over $2,000 of equip- heard about Galvez’s stolen film equipment of them, with my dad along my side. Once ment in my bag. and has offered to help him replace it. Galvez we had those, I started looking for apart- “It was the camera I shot all my films was speechless and then said, “Thank you. ment manager jobs, mostly on Craigslist.” Daniel Galvez was the January Optimist with and did my school photo projects, That is so amazing.”) “When I was applying for jobs for my Student of the month. Photo: Rich Wilken too. I had to file a police report and I’ve dad, there were a couple that were closer to live, but since Galvez and his sister, a junior, been trying to see who could’ve possibly PaliHi but they didn’t call back. Then, I who also attends PaliHi and didn’t want stolen it and see if fliers would work to get found an ad for a job in Glendale,” Galvez to transfer, they didn’t consider it. it back,” he said. Posters describing the DRB Meeting Cancelled said. “This was one of the last ads I applied Galvez said his dad got a call one day equipment were hung around the school. The Pacific Palisades Village Design Re- to before we were basically being kicked before they had to move out. “Once my Galvez, who attended elementary school view Board has cancelled its regularly sched- out of our old apartment by the new build- dad went over for the interview, he got the in West Hollywood and then Paul Revere uled meeting on April 8 at 7 p.m. at the ing owner.” job and keys to the new apartment.” Middle School, said he had taken various Pacific Palisades Chamber of Commerce. Earlier, the family had visited Glendale Although the stress and anxiety of pos- jobs like cat sitting and saved his money for The next regularly scheduled meeting is and thought it would be a great place to sibly being homeless was now gone, Galvez years in order to buy the equipment. April 22.
ELLEN MC CORMICK FEATURED LISTINGS
631 Baylor St., 3 BR, 2 BA 16156 Alcima Ave., 4 BR, 3 BA Offered at $1,595,000 | www.631Baylor.com Offered at $1,975,000 | www. 16156Alcima.com
ELLEN MCCORMICK
Distinguished representation of the Westside since 1984.
ellenmccormick.com (310) 230-3707 | [email protected] CalBRE# 00872518 ©2015 An Independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC. April 1, 2015 Palisades News Page 5 Gottesman, Masi Win Teen Contest aniel Gottesman and Danika Masi were named Mr. and Miss Pali sades at the 56th Annual Teen Contest, celebrating Dyouth in Pacific Palisades on March 26 in Mercer Hall at Palisades High. Chamber of Commerce Executive Director Arnie Wishnick, who has been on the organizing committee for 36 years, said: “The kids were fabulous—any one of them could have won.” Gottesman and Masi, who both attend PaliHi, each received a $2,000 cash prize and food for a year at Palisades Garden Café, plus the opportunity to ride in the Fourth of July parade and on the firetruck with Santa Claus at the Chamber’s Ho!Ho!Ho! celebration. Thursday’s show opened with a performance by The Filharmonic, a six-member boy band. The emcee was Christian Saglie (Mr. Palisades 1996). Masi, a junior, competed against eight other girls: Zoe Dutton (Harvard-Westlake senior), Audrey Kailer (Westmark sophomore), Shaler Williams (Viewpoint sophomore) and Pali students Makayla Michelini (junior), Kimara Velez (junior), Miya Eber lein (senior), Sophia Eberlein (sophomore) and Cleo Hoffman (junior). Gottesman, only a freshman, competed against Brett Schneid (Crespi sophomore), Evan Epstein (Brentwood freshman) and Pali students Gabriel Galef (sophomore), Noah Alcus (junior) and Algimantas Leitz inger (junior). The contestants, in addition to performing a talent, were judged on extracurricular activities, honors, community service and poise in speaking. Masi, who dances at Fancy Feet and is a member of “Acapali” (PaliHi’s a capella group), sang a song from In the Heights for her talent. Gottesman, a member of the PaliHi concert, marching and jazz band, and director of fundraising for the PaliHi rocketry team, played the French horn, before going to the piano to play and sing Danika Masi and Daniel Gottesman, Miss and Mr. Palisades 2015. Photo: Shelby Pascoe Stevie Wonder’s “Sir Duke.” Page 6 Palisades News April 1, 2015
Heard ANN CLEAVES About Town Theatre Palisades Youth I went to the Theatre Palisades Youth performance of Doo-Wop Wed Widing Hood, and I laughed so hard. Someone should give Dorothy Dillingham Blue an award—those kids are directed so well, they even know the little facial expres- sions to make. Urban Decibel Ordinance I don’t understand why an urban deci- bel ordinance can’t be passed. If a motor- cycle is too loud, the owner should have to make changes. Do spot checks like they do for sobriety checks and it would help get all the noisy ones off the road. Control Streetside Clutter There’s a new free magazine out about Westside real estate (what else?) called Digs, and a new box has been installed close to the mailbox on Antioch, directly across from the Chamber. They likely have installed other boxes willy-nilly. Doesn’t the City enforce the placement of boxes? (Editor’s note: Councilman Mike Bon- VIEWPOINT Thought to Ponder in’s office directed the reader to check with “Go placidly among the Street Services Investigation & Enforcement noise and haste, and re- Division, Attn: Newsrack Section, 1149 S. Loving Children Equally member what peace there Broadway, 3rd Floor, Los Angeles, CA may be in silence.” 90015, [213] 847-6000.) By BARBARA GOULD treated differently—but equally. You may need “Desiderata,” a 1927 to speak differently to them to get your point poem― by Max Ehrmann irls growing up today can aspire to be across. But however you do it, you must instill Dog Pick-up Law a scientist, astronaut, doctor, inventor them with your values in a way that they will There are dog walkers who habitually or even President of the United States G take them into adulthood. violate Los Angeles County Code Sec. and have a reasonable expectation of meeting My girlfriend, Lila, whom I’ve known for 45 10.40.060. “Defecation—Persons walking those goals. years, said that when her children got to be Founded November 5, 2014 a dog on any property other than their Not so in my generation. If we went to col- ——————— own must carry a suitable bag or container lege, we most likely became teachers. When I adults, she asked each one privately if they felt 15332 Antioch Street #169 for the purposes of removing feces and to turned 18, I moved out of my parents’ house. she had a favorite child. Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 Jeff answered that being the first-born he was (310) 401-7690 immediately remove any feces once de- I tried to work part-time and stay in school, www.PalisadesNews.com posited by their dog.” Please obey this law. but I couldn’t support myself with a part-time the favorite—but don’t worry, “we were treated ——————— so equally that no one would have known.” Publisher job, so I never finished college. I had always Scott Wagenseller Ugliest Cell Tower wanted to get married and have a family: that David said that Jeff was kind of difficult and [email protected] The town should have a contest and de- was really important to me and it happened. I as he, David, was very easy going, he was the Editor favorite—but don’t worry, “we were treated so Sue Pascoe cide whether the ugliest cell phone tower have three sons, all of whom I can proudly say [email protected] is the new one on Sunset (near Capri) as are Eagle Scouts. equally that no one would have known.” Graphics Director you drive through the Riviera section. All My oldest son, Russell (born 1965), is married Richard was sure it was him because he was Manfred Hofer along the route are charming old-style the youngest—but don’t worry, “we were treated Digital Content and Technology with two sons. But if I ran into them on the Kurt Park street lamps, in contrast to this large silver street, I would not recognize them because he so equally that no one would have known.” Advertising pole with a light sticking out. Or would has decided not to be a part of our family. The Lisa, being the only girl, was sure she was the Jeff Ridgway the ugliest tower be the wood monstros- last time I saw his sons, they were 3 and 1. Now favorite—but don’t worry, “we were treated so [email protected] Grace Hiney ity that has gone up on Via de la Paz at they are 14 and 12. equally that no one would have known.” They, [email protected] Bowdoin. How can they City call either My second son, Ron (born 1968), is married like my children, are all amazing adults. Advisor of these esthetically pleasing? with two daughters, who are 15 and 7. During Bill Bruns (Gould lived in Pacific Palisades from 1957-60. Contributing Writers school vacations Alyce, the oldest, takes the Laura Abruscato, Laurel Busby, Remember to Look Both Ways train from San Diego and spends time here so She and her husband returned to town in 2000 Danielle Gillespie, Libby Motika A young man texting on his phone we can do “girl” things. We visit the mall, go when her parents passed away. For the past 21 Contributing Photographers years, she has worked as a sales representative Wendy Price Anderson, stepped into the middle of the intersection to museums and lunch, and see my elderly Bart Bartholomew, Shelby Pascoe without regard to a car that had started to neighbor who watched her grow up. for a candy distributor.) ——————— turn from Via de la Paz onto Antioch (by My youngest son, David (born 1970), is A bi-monthly newspaper mailed on the first and third Wednesday of each Gelsons). Although pedestrians have the single, but for the last 20 years has been a youth month. 14,500 circulation includes right of way, a near accident was avoided counselor for the San Gabriel Fellowship group. OOPS! zip code 90272 and Sullivan, Man- when the car slammed on the brakes. At a surprise party for his 40th birthday, the deville and Santa Monica Canyons. In our March 18 story about Ogden Online: palisadesnews.com ——————— house was filled with teenagers from his youth Cleaners, the new owner was identified All content printed herein, and in our If you’d like to share something you’ve group, who roasted him in glowing terms. It as Tommy Goullais. His name is actually digital editions, is copyrighted. “heard about town,” please email it to was enough to make his proud mother cry. Tommy Goulla. Our apologies for the error. [email protected] Each child is different, so they need to be Palisades News April 1, 2015 A forum for open discussion of community issues Page 7
VIEWPOINT An Important Victory at Revere By LAURIE ROSENTHAL today’s standards. We cannot change the past, and it Revere community. would be a tremendous disservice to our children to What’s truly criminal is that two months after the e live in a time when the daily news is often try and sugarcoat what truly happened. History isn’t incident, only four kids who were in the class had been bad—political gridlock, melting Polar ice, always pretty, but hopefully by studying it our children interviewed. Four! Many parents at last week’s meeting terrorist attacks—so it felt good to have a W will learn to create a better world. were outraged when this little fact slipped out. And even victory in our part of the world last week. The victory I think LAUSD officials were going to take their time with the outrage, the LAUSD staff did not commit to was not only in swiftly getting Paul Revere Charter investigating the matter, and leave Carnine suspended interviewing ALL the students who were in the classroom Middle School teacher Steven Carmine back into his while doing so, until they were bombarded with letters, when the alleged incident took place. classroom—it was seeing how our community came phone calls, emails, protests and more from students, I’ve been told by a reliable source that the plaintiff together quickly and worked for a common cause. has made similar accusations against the Beverly Hills Carnine was summarily removed from his classroom teachers and parents supporting Carnine. More than 100 parents showed up at a District-sponsored meeting at the Unified School District and a soccer club. after 27 years of teaching at Paul Revere because of a How one unsubstantiated claim could be allowed to lawsuit brought on behalf of a mixed-race student who school on March 24. A Facebook page kept everyone informed. Within a few days, an online petition to save possibly destroy this teacher’s reputation is patently had spent a whopping seven days in his eighth-grade unfair. Apparently the family never even spoke to history class. The lawsuit claims that on January 20, the Carnine’s job—started by a student—gathered over 1,300 signatures. Carnine; they spoke to the principal, who in turn told day after Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Carnine made them to speak to Carnine, standard protocol. (The racist comments, something that all the students in the LAUSD learned we are not sheeple. The powers that be didn’t know what they were up against, and I don’t think assistant principal was also involved.) It seems they class who have come forward vehemently deny. The didn’t like that solution, and voilà, we have a lawsuit. plaintiff is suing for violations of the Unruh Civil the Revere community knew how powerful we could be until we were put to the test. What was happening A prominent local attorney told me that the law of Rights Act, and is demanding a jury trial. the land in England is that if you sue and lose, you was unjust. We were not going to let one student ruin What other students have confirmed is that Carnine have to pay the lawyers’ fees for the winner as well as the reputation of this man who has devoted his life to made statements about race to prove points about racism, your own. Imagine if we had that system here; I doubt teaching our children. I think it’s remarkable that the including slurs against Jews and African Americans. It this family would have been so quick to file a lawsuit. wasn’t that Carnine was saying he believed these things; District completed its investigation in a few days and he was pointing out what some people say and believe. allowed Carnine back into his classroom last Thursday. (Laurie Rosenthal is the former editor of the Santa All the other students seemed to understand that the Kudos should be given to the people who hastened the Monica Mirror and a former staff writer for the Palisadian- best way to get this across was to use words and phrases process; to make it a long, drawn-out episode would Post. Her son, Dylan, is an eighth grader at Paul Revere, that are offensive and deemed politically incorrect by have been divisive and disruptive to the entire Paul and a former student of Steven Carnine’s.) LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
March 5, I received the Supreme Court’s decision in Local Attorney’s Case Wins my favor. Woman’s Club President CA Supreme Court Ruling The Supreme Court was concerned with the dual Sends Message to Community A March 5, 2015 California Supreme Court decision edge policy that attorney’s fees provisions: (1) providing It has been my pleasure and privilege to serve the as [Tract 19051 Homeowners Association v. Maurice Kemp] access to justice; and (2) discouraging meritless cases. the president of the Pacific Palisades Woman’s Club was in my client’s favor. In a nutshell, the issue before The Court’s decision was based on logic, fairness and this past year. As I complete my term of service, I want the Supreme Court was a prevailing defendant’s right that the principles of mutuality of remedy applies to to share just how important 2015 is as a milestone in to statutory fees. statutory attorney’s fees provisions. Perhaps an our community. The Woman’s Club is 90 years young My client was being sued by a homeowners’ association oversimplification of the holding: a prevailing defendant in 2015 and continues to be a vital and vibrant part of in the Baldwin Vista area of Los Angeles and 50 or so is entitled to attorney’s fees if the plaintiff would have life in this town. This year also marks the 30th Annual neighbors to stop construction of my client’s home. The been entitled to fees if it had won. Pacific Palisades Home Tour, the 80th anniversary of plaintiffs alleged that my client’s construction violated “First, the trial court’s award of attorney’s fees is the founding of the Junior Women’s Club, the 50th the CC&Rs, which precluded two-story homes. It was a supported by the language of the statute: Plaintiffs’ anniversary of the YMCA, and the 90th anniversary of view community. The plaintiffs alleged that the tract underlying lawsuit was an action to enforce the governing the Palisades Elementary PTA. Each of our organizations was a common interest development under the Davis documents of a common interest development, and has contributed to the character and nature of Pacific Stirling Code, and they sought fees under that statute, defendants were the prevailing party in the action. Palisades. which provides: “In an action to enforce the governing Second, because plaintiffs clearly would have been I am committed to ensuring that the Woman’s Club documents [of a common interest development], the entitled to an award under the statute had they prevailed can continue to offer the community its “living room” as prevailing party shall be awarded reasonable attorney’s in the action, denying defendants an award under the a place to meet, celebrate, learn and grow and that the fees and costs.” We won the case by proving that the statute when they were the prevailing party would club continues to have a valuable and positive influence tract was not a common interest development. unquestionably violate the reciprocal nature of the statute on the Palisades and the generations who live here in This case started for me in April 2008, when I was and thus defeat the evident legislative intent underlying the next 90 years. So, I am asking for your support in retained before litigation was filed, by a title insurance the statute.” three simple ways to make this a reality: company to defend its insured. In other words, as my client liked quoting: “Sauce (Continued on Page 8) I won at the trial court and was awarded 100 percent for the goose is sauce for the gander,” or “Same monks, of attorney’s fees. The Court of Appeal affirmed our same haircuts.” Palisades News welcomes all letters, which may substantive victory but reversed the attorney’s fees award. Please do not hesitate to contact me with any questions be mailed to [email protected]. Please I filed a petition for review of the unpublished decision or comments about the decision or any HOA, CC&R, include a name, address and telephone number so on the attorney’s fees issue, which the California neighbor vs. neighbor or view rights issues. we may reach you. Letters do not necessarily Supreme Court granted. I argued in February and on Keith Turner reflect the viewpoint of the Palisades News. Page 8 Palisades News April 1, 2015
the allegations. To the contrary, I understand that many Letters of her classmates state the allegations were untrue Spring Propagation Tips and/or taken out of context. (Continued from Page 7) The Veterans Garden, the not-for-profit nursery of If no substantiation can be found, I see little risk to Join. Are you a woman who works in, lives in or cares Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden, will host a workshop the school district to permit Mr. Carnine to continue about Pacific Palisades? Did you belong to either the “Spring Propagation Tips” from 10 to 11:30 a.m. on teaching while the litigation continues. This is not an Woman’s Club or Juniors in the past? JOIN TODAY! Saturday, April 11, at the West L.A. VA, 100 Davis Ave. allegation such as child molestation where there is danger Tell us a story. Tell us about how the Woman’s Club The Botanic Garden’s own propagator, Ernesto Alvarado, to the children from his continued interaction with has had an impact on your life, your child’s life, your will share basic tips and techniques. The event is free, but them. Of course, should you do so, I would transfer the neighbors’ lives and our community! TELL US A STORY! please RSVP to (424) 234-0481 or visit [email protected]. student making the allegations into another classroom. Give to preserve the clubhouse. We welcome any The nursery, which carries native plants, is open It seems almost criminal to me that a teacher with amount and place a priority on celebrating all of our Wednesday through Sunday from 10 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. gifts, large, small and in between. GIVE A GIFT! Visit: decades of teaching experience without a blemish can theppwc.org. have his career derailed by one unsubstantiated allegation. With much appreciation for all of your support, The decision to suspend him based upon this Terri Lyman unsubstantiated allegation seems more than unfair. Can Chabad Adds Service you imagine a student making a similar allegation and commencing litigation against you and your being sent In Palisades Village Paul Revere Middle School home to wait for some indeterminate period? Teacher’s Suspension Unfair Worse still, the remaining students in the class are In addition to weekly Shabbat services at the Chabad Jewish Community Center at 17315 Sunset, (Editor’s Note: The following letter was one of many sent being deprived of an excellent teacher and continuity in this course. I would do everything possible to have Rabbi Yekusiel Kalmensohn leads weekly services to LAUSD Superintendent Ramon Cortines. The author at a second location in the Palisades, “Chabad in is a graduate of Harvard Law School, and specializes in him back in the classroom at the end of spring break. the Village.” business law.) Thank you for your consideration. The space for the services, in the former US As the parent of an eighth grade student at Paul Revere, Robert S. Rein Bank building and adjacent to the Mobil Station, I read with dismay about the suspension of Mr. Carnine from his teaching position at Paul Revere. While I under- was generously provided by developer Rick Caruso, stand litigation has been commenced and you of course California Incline whose company owns the property. Each week must follow the advice of your counsel, it seems to me following the prayer service, a lunch and discussion that this would be a relatively easy situation to investigate, takes place, amid friendship and acceptance. at least to the extent to determine whether a suspension Closes April 20 Rabbi Zushe Cunin, executive director for the from teaching is warranted during the litigation. The closure of the California Incline is now slated for Chabad Jewish Community Center, said: “May we It is my understanding that the litigation was filed April 20, message signs alerting motorists have been always celebrate growth, happiness and success, based upon allegations of one student. Assuming that placed along PCH. Once the 1930 bridge is demolished together with the ongoing support of this wonder- there were about 35 students in the class, it should not and removed, construction will start on the new one. ful Palisades community.” require a lot of work to question the other 34 students The project was bid as 365 days of work; construction Visit: chabadpalisades.com. in the class to see whether any of them will substantiate is slated to be completed in the summer of 2016. April 1, 2015 Palisades News Page 9
overall evened out.” On Monday, Zack Blake, also an eighth Rosenthal Launches Latest Book Carnine grader in that class said: “Mr. Carnine was Palisadian Betsy Rosenthal will sign her (Continued from Page 1) telling us how it was, how people thought latest book, An Ambush of Tigers, at 3 p.m. back then.” were treated and sometimes still are. on Sunday, April 12 at Diesel Bookstore, “He said that SOME PEOPLE think that Student after student, parent after parent at the Brentwood Country Mart, 225 26th black people are not smart and only good spoke up on support of Carnine, as KTLA Street, Santa Monica. at sports, and that Jewish people are known 5 and NBC 4 recorded the protest. Illustrated by Jaco, the book was released for being very wealthy. He taught us that Student Leela Gowland said, “He was April 1, by Millbrook Press and targets chil- these stereotypes are wrong and should not one of my favorite teachers ever. I had him dren ages 5 to 9. be used, but there are still many people in a whole year and he would never be racist. Publishers Weekly wrote, “Rosenthal and America who believe these stereotypes. Mr. Carnine is not like that.” Jago’s collaboration stands out for the sheer “Mr. Carnine discussed how many Seventh- and eighth-grade English and inventiveness they bring to the subject. Witty people didn’t like Lincoln, because they journalism teacher Eric Wechsler said, “He’s delights abound as a shiver of sharks bun- claimed he was an n-lover. He did not a great teacher and we want him back. dles up in winter knitwear and a bouquet even use the word; he spelled it out and There’s more than 100 kids today, who of pheasants peers glumly out of a tall vase.” said ‘Excuse my language, I really do not won’t have their teacher because of this.” Visit: betsyrosenthal.com. like using this word, but this is how harshly the African American people were treated.’ Mr. Carnine also said he was Loyola Car Wash Supports Junior Jake Peters completely against the word, but he was oyola, Marymount, Marlborough nesses providing such training. mates in 2016. trying to teach us about the harshness of and Homeboy high schools are hold- When a Homeboy is hurt or shot, the Also on April 11, Loyola High School is slavery before the civil war. It was impor- ing a car wash from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. Homeboys hold a car wash to raise money celebrating its 150th Day of Service in hon - tant to learn about how harsh it really was L on Saturday, April 11, at 100 Venice Way for medical and living expenses of their or of the school’s 150th anniversary by ask- in order to understand this history better. and Pacific Avenue (across from the fallen brother. ing all Loyola students, parents and alumni He did not want to ‘sugarcoat’ it to us, like Erwin Hotel). Students have decided to emulate the to perform a day of service. many other teachers tend to do. This is Loyola’s third bi-annual car wash Homeboys’ philosophy by holding this car Cub volunteers will fan across Los Ange- “Regarding Ferguson: Mr. Carnine said benefiting Homeboy Industries, and also wash in honor of their classmate Jake Pe- les to serve 100 projects at a variety of non- that the man was a ‘t—g,” but he absolutely to benefit fellow Loyola junior Jake Peters. ters, who following baseball practice in De- profit organizations that will benefit shel- did NOT deserve to be harassed like he was. Homeboy Industries was founded in cember 2014, was struck with a rare and ters, centers, soup kitchens and missions. He also mentioned that it was not fair to 1993 by Father Greg Boyle to provide terribly debilitating neurological disease. Loyola students (including many base- have an all-white police squad on the job, meaningful “on-the-job training” for at- Thirty percent of the proceeds will go ball, volleyball and swim team members) because there was bound to be racism, even risk youth and those recently released from to an adaptive technology fund, which will join Marymount and Marlborough though the amount of racist people has incarceration. Currently, Homeboy Indus- will allow Jake to continue his Loyola students to work side-by-side with Home- noticeably decreased and our society has tries runs more than 10 successful busi- studies and graduate with his fellow class- boys to give your car the “wash of your life.” Solar
pekarellis.com Electricity from the Sun
PEKAR/ELLIS REAL ESTATE GROUP
PAUL PEKAR CAROL ELLIS MELISSA ELLIS 310.496.5955 direct 310.496.5947 direct 310.496.5977 direct 310.779.3108 mobile 310.422.7134 mobile 310.963.9826 mobile [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] CalBRE: 00783762 CalBRE: 00454530 CalBRE: 01905986
YOUR PACIFIC PALISADES REALTORS®
A Top 100 Team Nationwide Serving the Westside with more than seven decades combined experience.
“HANDS ON SERVICE” “EXCELLENCE IN REAL ESTATE” When you choose Pekar/Ellis Real Innovative marketing strategies, Estate Group you get Paul Pekar, Carol effective negotiating skills, up-to-date Ellis and Melissa Ellis with meticulous knowledge resulting in smooth and attention to detail. timely transactions. Lighten Your Electric Bill with Solar! We do not use assistants. Your own Palisades Solar Company Free Quote (310) 459-7062 Joyce Brunelle (310) 459-7062 [email protected] www.solarsuntricity.com Licensed, Bonded, Insured 35 yrs in CA Lic #369267, B1, C10, C46 Page 10 Palisades News April 1, 2015 Toppel Takes Reins at Woman’s Club By SUE PASCOE paign to bring this about. Editor “We need to give our clubhouse a facelift and bring it up to today’s standards,” she acific Palisades resident Haldis Top- said. “We need to make an old lady into a pel has long been active in commu- young bride.” Pnity organizations, as evidenced in Another issue Toppel faces is helping 2012 when she received the “Pioneer Wom - members accustomed to a social environ- an of the Year” award from City Council- ment to understand that all money, even man Bill Rosendahl. something as simple as bridge wagers, must At that time, she was president of the be accounted for because of IRS issues. Marquez Knolls Property Owners Associ- “I’m coming in, I’m listening, I’m hear- ation, vice president of the Palisades ing concerns and problems,” Toppel prom- Community Council and a member of ises members. the Palisades Park Advisory Board and the “I would like to bring the Club back to LAPD West Los Angeles Community Po- a central meeting place for women of all lice Advisory Board. levels, from stay-at-home moms to pro- Now she takes on a challenging role as fessional women,” Toppel said, noting that president of the Pacific Palisades Woman’s the club hopes to attract a broader mem- Club on April 1, only the second person bership. “Just as the homes in the Pal- (after Terri Lyman) to hold this position isades have moved away from ranch to since the Junior Women’s Club merged two- and three-story, so has our local with the Woman’s Club in 2013. population changed and we need to serve When Toppel, who was the Club’s com- Haldis Toppel is the new Woman’s Club president. Photo: Bart Bartholomew the current population.” munications director, spoke to Palisades disparate organizations. Club discussed selling the building (lo- She added, “The club is a well-kept se- News at the end of March, she was looking “The Junior Women spent considerable cated on Haverford, below Gelson’s). The cret. More than 1,000 people come through for volunteers from the 180-member body time raising money and donating it to phil- Junior Women, working to save this vital our doors every week with nonprofits and to serve as chairs on various committees. anthropic causes. Often they raised between community meeting place, proposed a other charitable groups to use this facility “The first thing I’m going to tackle in $70,000 and $100,000 a year and then gave merger instead. at a greatly reduced rate.” parallel to bringing on new board mem- it all away. The Woman’s Club was more of It will take an estimated $1.5 million to Organizations such as the Garden Club bers is to serve the community through a social club, but they owned the building.” update and renovate the 1951 building and and AA meet at the clubhouse, and club donations and service,” said Toppel, who The clubhouse had fallen into such a the 1956 addition. One of Toppel’s biggest members and residents alike can participate recalled the difficulties of merging two state of neglect that, in 2012, the Woman’s challenges will be the ongoing capital cam- (Continued on Page 11)