An Inquiry Into the Socio-Spatial Production of Local Food
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
! ! ! ! "#$%&'(%&)*!%+,!-&%./!0)!&)1#&2.!&)%3!%+,!43-&3546(%&($!6237#-%&3)!38!$3-($!8337! ! "#! ! $%&'()*!+,!-.(/012! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 3!4')5%5!56"7%44)8!%/!9(.4%(*!:6*:%**7)/4!1:!4')!.);6%.)7)/45!:1.!4')!8)<.))!1:! ! ! =1&41.!1:!>'%*1519'#! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! =)9(.47)/4!1:!?1&%1*1<#! @/%A).5%4#!1:!3*").4(! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! B!$%&'()*!+,!-.(/012C!DEDE! ! ! ! ""! 094%2(-%! ! Once considered out of place in cities, urban agriculture is an increasingly common practice. This dissertation considers questions of urban agriculture and local food through a “production of space” lens. F'%5!:.(7%/<!(**125!:1.!(/!)G9(/8)8!)79%.%&%57C!19)/%/<!69!4')!%/A)54%<(4%1/!1:! 6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!41!%/&*68)!(!&1/5%8).(4%1/!1:!59(4%(*!9.(&4%&)5C!*%A)8!)G9).%)/&)5C!(/8!A(.%)8! .)9.)5)/4(4%1/5,!H/!(88%4%1/!41!4')1.%0%/<!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!4'.16<'!(!9.186&4%1/!1:!59(&)!*)/5C! 4'%5!8%55).4(4%1/!8.(25!1/!76*4%9*)!;6(*%4(4%A)!7)4'185C!%/&*68%/<!%/4).A%)25C!9(.4%&%9(/4! 1"5).A(4%1/5C!(/8!5)*:I)4'/1<.(9'#C!41!8)A)*19!(/8!&1/4.%"64)!41!(!51&%1I59(4%(*!7(99%/<!1:!*1&(*! :118!59(&)!%/!J871/41/,!F'.16<'!4')5)!7)4'185C!4'%5!8%55).4(4%1/!&1/4.%"64)5!41!(!")44).! 6/8).54(/8%/<!1:!4')!&179*)G!9.1&)55)5!(/8!8%A).5)!7)(/%/<5!%/A1*A)8!%/!4')!9.186&4%1/!1:! 6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!59(&),!K(4').!4'(/!:1&65%/<!1/!(!5%/<6*(.!5%4)!1:!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)C!H!&1/5%8).! %45!9.186&4%1/!(4!A(.%165!5&(*)5C!:.17!6."(/!:(.7!41!&%4#I.)<%1/C!)G(7%/%/<!4')!9(.4%&6*(.5!1:!)(&'! &(5)!(/8!4')!.)*(4%1/5'%95!")42))/!4')7!4'.16<'!4')1.)4%&(*!8%5&655%1/,!F')!8%55).4(4%1/! &1/&*68)5!"#!%/4.186&%/<!4')!&1/&)94!1:!4')!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!%7(<%/(.#C!)79'(5%5%/<!4')!2(#5! %/!2'%&'!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!)G%545!(5!(!5#7"1*%&!*(/85&(9)!L!(!5)4!1:!2%8)*#!&%.&6*(4)8! .)9.)5)/4(4%1/5!(/8!%8)(5!("164!4')!9.(&4%&)!4'(4!.)&(545!4')!&%4#!%/!8%::).)/4!2(#5,! ! ! ! """! :2,8(-,! ! M1**12%/<!4')!9(9).I"(5)8!:1.7(4!1:!4')!M(&6*4#!1:!-.(86(4)!?468%)5!(4!4')!@/%A).5%4#!1:! 3*").4(C!4'%5!8%55).4(4%1/!%5!1.<(/%0)8!(.16/8!4'.))!56"54(/4%A)!&'(94).5,!J(&'!1:!4')5)!&'(94).5! '(5!"))/!56"N)&4!41!(!9.1&)55!1:!(&(8)7%&!9)).!.)A%)2!(/8!'(5!"))/!96"*%5')8!%/!(!.)964("*)! (&(8)7%&!N16./(*!1.C!%/!4')!&(5)!1:!+'(94).!F21C!(/!)8%4)8!"11O,!+'(94).!F21!%5!96"*%5')8!%/! !"#$%&'()#*+#$,-.*/&&0$&1$,#.23$4#1#/52#6$!"#$73(8$-.*$92/-.$:&;3#(8$P-.(/012!Q!?'%)*85C! DERST,!+'(94).!F'.))!%5!96"*%5')8!%/!4&;-)$<.532&.=#.(6$!"#$>.(#2.-(3&.-)$?&'2.-)$&1$?'@(3;#$ -.*$:'@(-3.-/3)3(8!P-.(/012!Q!U1/)5C!DEDET,!M%/(**#C!+'(94).!M16.!%5!96"*%5')8!%/!4')!?&'2.-)$&1$ A+23;')('2#B$C&&*$:8@(#=@B$-.*$7&=='.3(8$D#5#)&E=#.(!P-.(/012!Q!V)&O%)C!DERST,!J(&'!1:! 4')5)!4'.))!&1/4.%"64%1/5!'(5!"))/!&1I(64'1.)8!2%4'!7)7").5!1:!7#!569).A%51.#!&177%44))C! .):*)&4%/<!4')!&1**("1.(4%A)!%8)(*5!1:!7#!.)5)(.&',!M1**12%/<!4')!M(&6*4#!1:!-.(86(4)!?468%)5! <6%8)*%/)5C!H!(7!4')!:%.54!(64'1.!1/!)(&'!1:!4')!4'.))!&'(94).5!(/8!'1*8!9.%7(.#!.)591/5%"%*%4#!:1.! (**!&1/&)946(*%0(4%1/C!(/(*#5)5C!%/4).9.)4(4%1/C!(/8!2.%4%/<,!M%/(**#C!5)&4%1/5!1:!4')!%/4.186&4%1/! (.)!4(O)/!:.17!(!51*1I(64'1.)8!(.4%&*)!F-03.+$!3=#$-.*$:E-;#$(&$G2&H6$!"#$:E-(3&(#=E&2-)$ I&)3(3;@$&1$92/-.$A+23;')('2#!2'%&'!'(5!"))/!(&&)94)8!9)/8%/<!.)A%5%1/5!%/!4')!?&'2.-)$&1$ 7')('2-)$G#&+2-E"8,! ! H!2(5!:%.54!%/4.186&)8!41!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!4'.16<'!7#!A1*6/4)).%/<!(4!>.(%.%)!@."(/!M(.7! %/!4')!59.%/<!1:!DERW,!>.(%.%)!@."(/!M(.7!%5!(!A1*6/4)).I*)8!&1776/%4#!:(.7!*1&(4)8!1/!(!5)&4%1/! 1:!@/%A).5%4#I12/)8!(<.%&6*46.(*!.)5)(.&'!*(/85!%/!4')!&)/4.)!1:!J871/41/C!3*").4(,!34!4'(4!4%7)C! H!2(5!%/!4')!9.1&)55!1:!8)A)*19%/<!(!8%55).4(4%1/!9.1915(*!)G(7%/%/<!<'154!412/5!%/!2)54)./! +(/(8(!4'.16<'!(!.6%/(4%1/!*)/5!P5))!-.(/012C!DERXY!$('C!DERDT,!35!H!")&(7)!71.)!%/A1*A)8! 2%4'!>.(%.%)!@."(/!M(.7C!H!")<(/!41!*%/O!7#!(&(8)7%&!%/4).)545!2%4'!7#!A1*6/4)).%/<C!4'%/O%/<! ("164!4')!51&%1I59(4%(*!(59)&45!1:!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.),!F'%5!216*8!)A)/46(**#!*)(8!41!(!&'(/<)!%/! ! "#! .)5)(.&'!419%&,!H4!2(5!(/!6/)G9)&4)8!5'%:4C!:1.!14').5!(5!2)**!(5!7#5)*:,!Z14!1/*#!8%8!%4!5))7! 6/2%5)!41!&'(/<)!.)5)(.&'!4.(N)&41.%)5!2)**!%/41!4')!>'=!9.1<.(7C!"64!H!2(5!(*51!A)/46.%/<!%/41! 517)2'(4!6/O/12/!(&(8)7%&!4)..%41.#,![%4'!"(&O<.16/8!%/4).)545!%/!51&%(*!4')1.#C!&6*46.(*! 5468%)5C!(/8!6."(/!5468%)5C!H!2(5!*(.<)*#!6/:(7%*%(.!2%4'!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!(/8!:118!5#54)75! .)5)(.&',!F'%5!5)4!7)!1/!&16.5)!:1.!(/!6/656(*!:1.(#!%/41!4')5)!419%&5,! ! M.17!4')!")<%//%/<!H!(99.1(&')8!4')!;6)54%1/!1:!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!(/8!*1&(*!:118!:.17! 9).59)&4%A)5!.114)8!%/!59(4%(*!4')1.#!(/8!&6*46.(*!5468%)5,![').)(5!76&'!.)5)(.&'!'(5!&1/5%8).)8! 4')!7).%45!1:!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!(5!(/!(*4)./(4%A)!:118!5#54)7C!H!5)4!164!(5O%/<!2'(4!%4!216*8!*11O! *%O)!41!&1/5%8).!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!4'.16<'!(!51&%1I59(4%(*!*)/5,!['(4!81)5!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!*11O! *%O)!2')/!&1/5%8).)8!(5!(!2(#!1:!&1/&)%A%/<!1:C!9.(&4%&%/<C!(/8!%7(<%/%/<!6."(/!59(&)!(/8!4')! &%4#\!['%*)!7#!%/%4%(*!%/4).)54!2(5!59(.O)8!"#!7#!9(.4%&%9(4%1/!%/!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!4'.16<'! >.(%.%)!@."(/!M(.7C!%4!2(5!".1(8).!4')1.)4%&(*!;6)54%1/5!(/8!%/4).)545!4'(4!6*4%7(4)*#!*)8!41!4')! &'(/<%/<!1:!7#!.)5)(.&'!419%&,!F'%5!:16/8(4%1/(*!4')1.)4%&(*!(/8!)G9*1.(41.#!%/4).)54!%5!.):*)&4)8C! /14!1/*#!%/!4')!&1/4)/4!1:!)(&'!1:!4')!4'.))!&'(94).5!4'(4!&179.%5)!4'%5!8%55).4(4%1/C!"64!(*51!%/!4')! 59)&%:%&!2(#!H!'(A)!&'15)/!41!".%/<!4')5)!&'(94).5!41<)4').,! ! 3/!)(.*#!9.1915(*!:1.!4'%5!.)5)(.&'!%/A1*A)8!(!&.155I&1/4)G4!&179(.%51/!1:!6."(/! (<.%&6*46.)!%/%4%(4%A)5!%/!$1/4.)(*C!=)4.1%4C!V).*%/C!(/8!J871/41/,!H4!2(5!(/!(7"%4%165!9*(/C!"64! :(&)8!9.(&4%&(*!*%7%4(4%1/5C!%/&*68%/<!;6)54%1/5!1:!(&&)55C!:6/8%/<C!(/8!4%7),!H/!&1/5%8).%/<!4')! &'(**)/<)5!%/A1*A)8!2%4'!1.<(/%0%/<!(/!%/4)./(4%1/(*C!&179(.(4%A)!9.1N)&4!1/!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)C!%4! ")&(7)!(99(.)/4!4'(4!H!/))8)8!41!P1/&)!(<(%/T!<1!"(&O!41!4')!8.(2%/<!"1(.8,!35!H!<.(99*)8!2%4'! ;6)54%1/5!1:!2').)!41!<1!(/8!2'%&'!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!%/%4%(4%A)5!41!5468#C!(!&177%44))!7)7").! 56<<)54)8!H!J'@(!@(-2($H"#2#$>$-=!(/8!"6%*8!7#!8%55).4(4%1/!:.17!4').),!F'%5!5%79*)!9%)&)!1:! (8A%&)!')*9)8!7)!&'(**)/<)!(!'%88)/!(556794%1/!4'(4C!%/!1.8).!41!.)5)(.&'!517)4'%/<! ! #! 56&&)55:6**#!#16!7654!<1!41!4'15)!9*(&)5!2').)!%4!%5!1&&6..%/<!7154!1"A%165*#!1.!%/4)/5)*#,!]:! 4')!:16.!&(5)5!%/%4%(**#!9.1915)8C!J871/41/!54118!164!(5!4')!*)(54!*%O)*#!&'1%&),![').)(5!)(&'!1:! 4')!14').!&%4%)5C!%/!9(.4%&6*(.!=)4.1%4!(/8!V).*%/C!'(8!(*.)(8#!(44.(&4)8!76&'!.)5)(.&'!(/8!2.%4%/<C! J871/41/!2(5!&1/59%&6165*#!1::!4')!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!7(9,!!?1!2'#!5468#!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)! "#2#!%/!J871/41/\!['#!&'115)!(!5))7%/<*#!"1.8).*%/)!(/8!7(.<%/(*!&(5)!(5!7#!(/(*#4%&(*! :1&65\!$#!8)&%5%1/!2(5!8.%A)/!*(.<)*#!"#!421!:(&41.5,!M1.!1/)C!H!2(5!(*.)(8#!%/A1*A)8!%/!6."(/! (<.%&6*46.)!9.(&4%&)!%/!J871/41/!4'.16<'!7#!.)<6*(.!A1*6/4)).!21.O!(4!>.(%.%)!@."(/!M(.7,! K):*)&4%/<!1/!7#!&177%44))!7)7").^5!(8A%&)C!H!5(2!4'(4!@(-2(3.+$H"#2#$8&'$-2#$%5!/14! /)&)55(.%*#!(!/)<(4%A)!&179.17%5)C!"64!(!9155%"*)!(/8!1:4)/!A).#!9.186&4%A)!2(#!:1.2(.8Y!%4!%5! (*51!(!.)&1</%4%1/!4'(4!%/!4')!5)(.&'!:1.!(/!%8)(*!&(5)!1.!.)5)(.&'!9.1N)&4C!#16!.%5O!7%55%/<! %/4).)54%/<!4'%/<5!'(99)/%/<!%/!#16.!"(&O#(.8,!F1!54(.4!2').)!#16!(.)!%5!(!&(**!41!54(.4!9(#%/<! (44)/4%1/,!?)&1/8*#C!%/!2.)54*%/<!2%4'!7#!.)5)(.&'!<1(*5!H!:16/8!4'(4!7#!7(%/!%/4).)54!2(5!%/! 6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)!(5!59(&)!41!4'%/O!4'.16<'!L!4'(4!%5C!(5!(!5)4!1:!%8)(5C!9.(&4%&)5C!(/8!%7(<%/(.%)5,! H/:*6)/&)8!"#!_)/.%!`):)"A.)C!(/8!%/!9(.4%&6*(.!'%5!2.%4%/<5!1/!4')!9.186&4%1/!1:!59(&)!PRSSRTC! (5!2)**!(5!56"5);6)/4!21.O!1/!.)*(4%1/(*!59(&)!(Fuller and Löw, 2017; Massey, 2005; Soja, 1989), 51&%(*!59(4%(*%5(4%1/!P?'%)*85C!RSSRC!DERWTC!(/8!4')!6."(/!%7(<%/(.#!Pa6O%/!)4!(*,C!RSSbY! =1/(*8C!RSSSTC!H!5)4!164!41!&1/4.%"64)!41!.).)(8%/<!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.),!?468#%/<!6."(/!(<.%&6*46.)! %/!4')!6/8).I)G(7%/)8!&1/4)G4!1:!J871/41/!9.1A%8)8!(/!1991.46/%4#!41!c.)(8!:1.!8%::).)/&)d! P-%"51/I-.('(7C!DEEeT,!35!-%"51/I-.('(7!/14)!%/!4')%.!%/4.186&4%1/!41!I&@(;-E3(-)3@($I&)3(3;@f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c6."(/d!(/8! c(<.%&6*46.)d!%5!(!5%79*)!"64!912).:6*!71A)!4'(4!'(5!&(946.)8!4')!%7(<%/(4%1/5!1:!9)19*)!%/!&%4%)5! (.16/8!4')!21.*8,!g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