Book Reviews

Book Reviews . Michael A. Lange, Meanings of Maple: An Ethnology of Sugaring. Cheryl Morse 87 Willard Sterne Randall, Unshackling America: How the War of 1812 Truly Ended the American Revolution. Paul Searls 89 A. Wilson Greene, A Campaign of Giants: The Battle for Petersburg. Volume 1: From the Crossing of the James to the Crater. John T. Broom 91 National Park Service and Vermont Division for Historic Preservation, Matthew Cohen, principal author, Middletown Springs Historic District. National Register of Historic Places. Robert McCullough 93 Matthew M. Thomas, Maple King: The Making of a Maple Syrup Empire. Jane Kolodinsky 96 Glenn A. Knoblock, Images of America: Hope Cemetery. Glenn M. Andres 98 Judy Chaves, Secrets of Mount Philo: A Guide to the History of Vermont’s First State Park. Kathryn Gohl 100 Rick Winston, Red Scare in the Green Mountains: Vermont in the McCarthy Era, 1946-1960. James Ralph 102 Elizabeth Dow and Lucinda B. Cockrell, How to Weed Your Attic: Getting Rid of Junk without Destroying History. Jacqueline Calder 104 More About Vermont History Compiled by Paul A. Carnahan 107 Book Reviews . Meanings of Maple: An Ethnography of Sugaring. By Michael A. Lange (Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Press, 2018, pp. ix, 191, $69.95; paper, $27.95). ichael Lange’s Meanings of Maple is an ethnography of the produc- M tion of maple syrup. It is a cultural journey that traces the connections between identity, place, and practice in Vermont. It is also an explo- ration of some of the most important themes in nature-culture theory through a relatively humble agricultural product from a small state. As he explains in the book’s introduction, Lange aimed to use maple as a means to “delve into the many and varied ways that humans make meaning with the objects and processes in their lives” (p. xv). Yet Lange achieves more than that, as the book also demonstrates how a place- based narrative is created, travels beyond its original borders, and comes to define both a place and its residents. For readers interested in the di- verse environmental and social values present in contemporary rural Ver- mont, this book will offer some beautiful and penetrating insights. How- ever, historians may be disappointed that Lange’s research is not historical. The theoretical conclusions Lange produced would have been richer if he had developed them from the social history of sugaring, scholarship on the rise of agriculture-based tourism, and Vermont’s environmental history. That said, Lange is clear that his work is squarely centered on the contemporary meanings of maple. Because Lange treats multiple meanings of maple, the book’s scope is quite broad. In fewer than two hundred pages, he considers maple from economic, culinary, geographic, ecological, agricultural, and heritage perspectives. Treating each in a separate chapter, Lange puts sugarmaking practices in dialogue with the associated (mainly anthropological) theory in each field. For example: In the economics chapter the reader is intro- . Vermont History Vol. 87, No. 1 (Winter/Spring 2019): 87-106. © 2019 by the Vermont Historical Society. ISSN: 0042-4161; on-line ISSN: 1544-3043 88 . duced to some of the anthropological literature on exchange value; in the culinary chapter food anthropologists explain foodie culture; and in the ecological chapter Lange uses the perspectives of leading political ecolo- gists and science studies scholars to frame how sugarmakers interact with forests. Many readers, myself included, will admire Lange’s extensive en- gagement with these many perspectives. However, in order to deal with each category of meaning in turn, Lange sometimes repeats descriptions of the processes involved in sugaring: checking lines, running the reverse osmosis machine and vacuum pumps, boiling, and marketing. Perhaps the book could have begun with a short primer on how sugaring is conducted, placing the readers amidst the din of noisy motors and the warm steam coming off the evaporator, and giving them the feel for ducking under saplines as they make their way up a slippery hillside. Lange has a knack for evoking a sense of place that would make this easy work for him. Sub- sequent chapters could have drawn out the finer points of the meaning that is produced from that sugaring—as an artisanal product, a landscape that is stewarded, and an economic commodity. As noted, a history of sugaring and indigenous sugaring practices is absent from Lange’s research. While he acknowledges that indigenous peoples shaped the landscape of what came to be Vermont for specific purposes, and that they shared sugaring practices with settlers, Lange’s story of the meaning of maple begins with settler farmers. Contempo- rary Abenaki sugarmakers might have other meanings to add to this narrative. Scholarship on New England environmental histories and the story of Vermont’s intentional marketing of itself as a pastoral vaca- tionland would have added important evidence for Lange’s assertions about the connections between farming landscapes, food products, and cultural identity. I am grateful to Lange for paying close attention to the production of maple syrup as an economic and material activity that creates emotional attachment to place. Lange carefully skirts tropes of the rural ideal and staunchly refuses to present sugaring as a quaint activity that is a remnant of the past. He explains that sugarmakers regard making syrup primarily as an economic activity that relies on global markets and emerging tech- nologies and is vulnerable to climate change. Lange forces readers to look at modern sugaring with clear eyes. Yet while he is careful to avoid romanticizing sugaring, he demonstrates a deep respect for the liveli- hoods and landscapes made possible by the work of sugarmakers. His scholarship reveals to us how contemporary sugarmaking contributes to shared meanings about our state: 89 . Externally, maple acts as a vehicle for the state’s identity. Internally, it serves the same purpose, or nearly the same purpose, as maple is used by Vermonters to communicate to and among themselves who they are (p. 169). Indeed, Meanings of Maple encourages readers to contemplate how following a rural practice can open up a world of meaning. Cheryl Morse Cheryl Morse is an Associate Professor of Geography and a member of the Environmental Program and the Food Systems Graduate Program at the Uni- versity of Vermont. She has published on the close connections between landscape, place, and identity among Vermonters. Unshackling America: How the War of 1812 Truly Ended the American Revolution By Willard Sterne Randall (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2018, pp. 458, paper, $29.99). his latest book by Willard Sterne Randall, professor of history at T Champlain College, is an argument for the importance of the War of 1812 in the establishment of the United States as a truly indepen- dent nation, and as a significant player on the world stage. Randall’s mission is to give readers a new perspective on the process by which America acquired what he sees as full political and economic independence from Great Britain. The book is subtitled “How the War of 1812 Truly Ended the American Revolution,” and its dust jacket proposes that it will challenge “the persistent fallacy that Americans fought two separate wars of independence.” Randall instead sets out to argue that the Revolution and War of 1812 constituted a single “unrelenting struggle” for economic and political independence from Britain, after the Revolution produced only “partial political autonomy” and even less economic independence. To accomplish this, Randall begins the book by recounting the colonial crises of the 1760s and 1770s, culminating in the start of the Revo- lution. There follows a brief survey of the Revolution in a chapter ti- tled “For Cutting Off Our Trade.” Randall then jumps ahead to an overview of the personal and party rivalries of the Washington, Ad- ams, and Jefferson administrations, with special emphasis on trade, treaties, and issues surrounding the impressment of sailors. Randall’s 90 . account of the War of 1812 occupies the final two thirds of the book, with the action switching back and forth between sections on the war on the coast, on the ocean, and in Trans-Appalachia. In the interior of the continent Randall focuses almost wholly on action around the Great Lakes. In terms of fulfilling Randall’s ambitious goal of giving a new perspective on the War of 1812, the book is at its strongest when it di- rectly addresses issues related to the American economy in general, and more specifically to transatlantic trade. His portrayal of economic issues stretching from the colonial crises of the 1760s to the terms of the Treaty of Ghent, when taken together, paint a portrait of a nation battling to establish a sense of itself as free of undue outside intervention in its de- cision making. The eventual benefits of that status were as much ideo- logical, about the growth of Americans’ pride in their nation, as they were practical. What emerged at the conclusion of the War of 1812 was, Randall asserts, a nation that had passed through “a defining moment” that established it as “a major maritime power” and a “sovereign nation with worldwide commercial networks” (p. 406). Randall’s conclusion is that the War of 1812 should be understood to be “the War of American Economic Independence, the last chapter of the American Revolution” (p. 406). The book is written in a breezy, enjoyable tone; Randall is a very good storyteller. Academic historians might find new details in his treatment of such familiar topics as attacks on Federalists by American Anglo- phobes, the Chesapeake affair, and the creation of Tecumseh’s Native American tribal alliance.

Load more