State Transportation Electrification Scorecard Bryan Howard, Shruti Vaidyanathan, Charlotte Cohn, Nick Henner, Ben Jennings
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The State Transportation Electrification scorecard Bryan Howard, Shruti Vaidyanathan, Charlotte Cohn, Nick Henner, Ben Jennings RESEARCH REPORT FEBRUARY 2021 EV SCORECARD © ACEEE Contents About the Authors ..............................................................................................................................iii Acknowledgments ..............................................................................................................................iii Glossary of Frequently Used Terms ................................................................................................ iv Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................... vi Chapter 1. Introduction, Methodology, and Results ...................................................................... 1 Scoring Methodology .............................................................................................................. 3 State Actors ............................................................................................................................... 7 Metrics Not Included ............................................................................................................... 9 Results ...................................................................................................................................... 10 Chapter 2. Planning and Goal Setting ............................................................................................ 15 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 15 Results and Key Takeaways ................................................................................................. 15 Unscored Metrics ................................................................................................................... 22 Chapter 3. Incentives for EV Deployment ..................................................................................... 23 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 23 Results and Key Takeaways ................................................................................................. 24 Unscored Metrics ................................................................................................................... 36 Chapter 4. Transportation System Efficiency ................................................................................ 37 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 37 Results ...................................................................................................................................... 37 Unscored Metrics ................................................................................................................... 42 Chapter 5. Electricity Grid Optimization ....................................................................................... 43 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 43 Results ...................................................................................................................................... 44 i EV SCORECARD © ACEEE Unscored Metrics ................................................................................................................... 48 Chapter 6. Equity ............................................................................................................................... 50 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 50 Results ...................................................................................................................................... 51 Unscored Metrics ................................................................................................................... 54 Chapter 7. Transportation Electrification Outcomes .................................................................... 57 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 57 Results and Key Takeaways ................................................................................................. 57 Unscored Metrics ................................................................................................................... 62 Chapter 8. Conclusions ..................................................................................................................... 63 References ........................................................................................................................................... 65 Appendix A. Full State Scores ......................................................................................................... 73 Appendix B. Planning and Goal-Setting Metrics .......................................................................... 88 Appendix C. Incentives for EV Deployment Metrics ................................................................... 94 Appendix D. Transportation System Efficiency Metrics ........................................................... 134 Appendix E. Electric Grid Optimization Metrics ........................................................................ 138 Appendix F. Equity Metrics ........................................................................................................... 147 Appendix G: Transportation Electrification Outcomes Metrics ............................................... 152 ii EV SCORECARD © ACEEE About the Authors Bryan Howard oversees work related to research, technical assistance, and implementation of energy efficiency policy at the state level. Prior to joining ACEEE, Bryan worked as the legislative director for the U.S. Green Building Council, where he played a key role in enacting legislation to modernize federal disaster response programs, tax incentives, education and training, and government building efficiency. Before joining the Council, he served as a legislative aide in the U.S. House of Representatives. Bryan holds a bachelor of arts in political science from Mesa State College. Shruti Vaidyanathan oversees research on vehicle efficiency and systemwide transportation efficiency. She has 10 years of experience in transportation efficiency issues, and her work has most recently focused on passenger and freight mobility best practices at the state and local levels and the role of emerging mobility options and autonomous vehicles in sustainable urban transportation systems. Shruti holds a master of science in public policy and management from Heinz College at Carnegie Mellon University and a bachelor of arts in economics and environmental studies from Grinnell College. Charlotte Cohn conducts research and analysis on utility energy efficiency policy. Prior to joining ACEEE, she worked with the Vermont Law School Institute for Energy and the Environment on building community solar projects for low- to moderate-income communities in New Hampshire. She holds a master’s degree in energy regulation and law from the Vermont Law School and a bachelor’s degree from the University of Vermont. Nick Henner conducts research and analysis on clean energy finance strategies, working within ACEEE’s state policy program and collaborating with teams across the organization. Before joining ACEEE, Nick worked at the City and County of Honolulu’s Office of Climate Change, Sustainability and Resiliency, where he focused on energy efficiency and equity projects. Nick earned a master of science in sustainability management from American University and a bachelor of science in finance from the University of Arizona. Ben Jennings assists ACEEE’s transportation program with various projects including research tasks related to ACEEE’s City Scorecard and International Scorecard. Prior to joining ACEEE, Ben interned with the City Bureau of Planning in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, where he helped to research, write, and edit the city’s Municipal Operations Climate Action Plan. Ben holds a bachelor of arts in environmental studies and politics from Oberlin College. Acknowledgments This report was made possible through the generous support of Xcel Energy, Consolidated Edison, and the Merck Family Fund. The authors gratefully acknowledge the external reviewers, internal reviewers, colleagues, and sponsors who supported this report. We also thank the many individuals from national and regional organizations who participated in our advisory group and provided input on the methodology, including most of the external expert reviewers listed here. External review and support do not imply affiliation or endorsement. These include, in no particular order, Nick Nigro (Atlas Public Policy), Phil Jones (Alliance for Transportation Electrification), Jeanette Shaw (Forth), Steve iii EV SCORECARD © ACEEE Kalland (NC Energy Tech Center), Katherine Stainken (Plug In America), Terry Travis (EVNoire), Erin K. Falquier (Chicane Labs), Grace Relf (Hawaii Public Utility Commission), Camille Kadoch (Regulatory Assistance Project), Larissa Koehler (Environmental Defense Fund), Matt Rogotzke (National Governors Association) Annie Gilleo (Greenlots),