Master Thesis2 Revised VIII
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE TRICK OF THE TALE: DECONSTRUCTING JOHANN WEYER’S DE PRAESTIGIIS DAEMONUM by JAMES ROBERT ALLEN Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Arlington in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN HISTORY THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT ARLINGTON MAY 2012 Copyright © by James R. Allen 2012 All Rights Reserved ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Many thanks to Dr. Steven Reinhardt for his advice, guidance and our many interesting conversations during researching and writing this master’s thesis. Dr. Reinhardt introduced me to Weyer’s text and I immediately realized the potential for research upon first glance of the book. Likewise, many thanks to the committee of Dr. Elisabeth Cawthon and Dr. Sarah Davis-Secord for their comments and suggestions for improving and clarifying the thesis, and for allowing for some flexibility with my unorthodox methodology. The genesis of this project grew out of several European readings and research courses through my years as a graduate student. Additionally, I applied many of the concepts and ideas from Dr. Reinhardt’s Theory and Methodology course in writing this thesis. However, overall there is not one particular course that formed the basis of this thesis, but rather it is the cumulative result of many reading seminars and research that I have conducted both as a student and individually. Also, thanks to my wife and family for support in this process. !!!!!!!!!!April 5, 2012 iii ABSTRACT THE TRICK OF THE TALE: DECONSTRUCTING JOHANN WEYER’S DE PRAESTIGIIS DAEMONUM James R. Allen, M.A. The University of Texas at Arlington, 2012 Supervising Professor: Dr. Steven Reinhardt This thesis is an intellectual history of early modern European beliefs in witchcraft. Most research and scholarship on this period has focused on understanding the “witch hunts” and the collective phenomenon known as the witchcraze. Historians have focused more the social and political conditions that contributed to witch-hunting. These studies have tended to focus on the institutions that existed to facilitate witchcraft prosecutions. Comparatively, the writings of “demonologists” or intellectuals during the early modern period have been studied to a lesser extent.1 Early modern authors like Johann Weyer are often interpreted as either a skeptic or believer in witchcraft. Most studies of Weyer have interpreted him as an early skeptic of witchcraft and an advocate against the witch trials. One of the reasons for this interpretation is that it fits within the historical narrative of the rise of the scientific method in the early modern period. However, by looking at a demonological text through the lens of its own language, historians gain a much sharper understanding of how intellectuals shaped early modern ideas: we understand what they believed and why. Moreover, the work that has been conducted on demonological texts that has produced the most promising results has been an examination of the language and these texts. By understanding what early modern intellectuals believed and why allows for a more 1 See Jonathan Pearl, The Crime of Crimes: Demonology and Politics in France, 1560-1620 (Waterloo, Canada: Wilfrid Laurier University, 1999), 7-9. iv nuanced perspective on the phenomenon of early modern witchcraft. The significance of this thesis is that it is a window into the beliefs of Johann Weyer; we experience the intellectual process that Weyer engaged in to formulate his treatise and opinion of witches. Accordingly, Weyer’s text is a snapshot of a process in flux and undergoing transformation from an older medieval period and towards early modern thought. In short, by engaging with Weyer in his text on his terms, we understand not only what conclusions he reached about witchcraft, but more importantly the logic by which he arrived at those conclusions. We see more clearly the complexity of historical change and the complexity which forged the transition into the period known as the age of reason. This study reveals the cross-section of religion, science and magic and how these beliefs functioned in sixteenth-century European thought. v TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ..............................................................................................................iii ABSTRACT ......................................................................................................................................iv Chapter Page 1. INTRODUCTION ..........................................................................................................................1 1.1 Historiography of Johann Weyer .........................................................................................6 1.2 The Medical Man and Enlightenment Myth ......................................................................10 1.3 Romanticism and The Margaret Murray Thesis ................................................................12 1.4 Social Science and Interdisciplinary Models of Witchcraft Research ...............................18 1.5 Legal Interpretations of Johann Weyer ..............................................................................23 1.6 Women and Witchcraft ......................................................................................................24 1.7 The Linguistic Turn............................................................................................................ 31 1.8 Mythology and Carlo Ginzburg’s Micro-History ..............................................................39 2. THE EPISTEMOLOGY OF THE DEVIL ..................................................................................45 2.1 Source Material................................................................................................................ ..46 2.2 The Origins of the Devil ....................................................................................................51 2.3 The Aims of the Devil........................................................................................................ 54 2.4 The Powers of the Devil ....................................................................................................63 3. ZAUBERERS AND LAMAIE ......................................................................................................67 3.1 Magicians of Ill-Repute .....................................................................................................69 3.2 Magical Books and Objects ...............................................................................................76 3.3 Lamaie................................................................................................................................ 83 vi 3.4 Cumulative Concepts of Magic....................................................................................... ...86 3.4.1 The Witches’ Sabbath and Flight...............................................................................86 3.4.2 Metamorphosis..........................................................................................................91 4. THE MEDICAL GAZE OF WITCHCRAFT .............................................................................97 4.1 The Paracelsian Chemical Philosophy ...............................................................................99 4.2 The Weyer-Bodin-Scot Debate ........................................................................................102 4.3 Possession and Witchcraft Affliction ...............................................................................107 4.4 Treatment of Witchcraft ...................................................................................................110 4.5 Natural Magic ..................................................................................................................116 4.6 Treatment of Possession ..................................................................................................121 4.7 Exorcism ..........................................................................................................................128 5. THE PUNISHMENT OF MAGICIANS AND WITCHES........................................................ 140 5.1 Kingship, Witchcraft and the Law ...................................................................................140 5.2 “Thinking With Women” .................................................................................................152 5.3 The Insanity Defense .......................................................................................................161 6. CONCLUSION ..........................................................................................................................175 REFERENCES ...............................................................................................................................183 BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION ..............................................................................................191 vii CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION What is truth? A mobile army of metaphors, metonyms and anthromorphisms—in short, a sum of human relations, which have been enhanced, transposed, and embellished poetically and rhetorically, and which after long use seem firm, canonical and obligatory to a people: truths are illusions about which one has forgotten that this is what they are metaphors Friedrich Nietzche, “On Truth and Lies” Knowledge in general cannot be reduced to science, nor even to learning. Learning is the set of statements which to the exclusion of