Investigations of the Endangered Kanab Ambersnail: Monitoring of Translocated Populations and Surveys of Additional Habitat
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INVESTIGATIONS OF THE ENDANGERED KANAB AMBERSNAIL: MONITORING OF TRANSLOCATED POPULATIONS AND SURVEYS OF ADDITIONAL HABITAT Clay B. Nelson, Nongame Wildlife Specialist Jeff A. Sorensen, Nongame Wildlife Specialist Nongame Branch, Wildlife Management Division Arizona Game and Fish Department Technical Report 200 Nongame and Endangered Wildlife Program Program Chief: Terry B. Johnson Arizona Game and Fish Department 2221 West Greenway Road Phoenix, Arizona 85023-4399 May 2002 CIVIL RIGHTS AND DIVERSITY COMPLIANCE The Arizona Game and Fish Commission receives federal financial assistance in Sport Fish and Wildlife Restoration. Under Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, the Age Discrimination Act of 1975, Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, the U.S . Department of the Interior prohibits disc1imination on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, age, sex, or disability. If you believe you have been discriminated against in any program, activity, or facility as described above, or if you desire further infom1ation please write to: Arizona Game and Fish Department Office of the Deputy Director, DOHQ 2221 West Greenway Road Phoenix, Arizona 85023-4399 and The Office for Diversity and Civil Rights U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service 4040 North Fairfax Drive, Room 300 Arlington, Virginia 22203 AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT COMPLIANCE The Arizona Game and Fish Department complies with all provisions of the Americans with Disabilities Act. This document is available in alternative format by contacting the Arizona Game and Fish Department, Office of the Deputy Director at the address listed above or by calling (602) 789-3290 or TTY 1-800-367-8939. RECOMMENDED CITATION C.B. Nelson, and J.A. Sorensen. 2002. Investigations of the Endangered Kanab Ambersnail: Translocated Population Monitoring and Additional Habitat Surveys. Nongame and Endangered Wildlife Program Technical Report 200. Arizona Game and Fish Department, Phoenix, Arizona. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank the following individuals for their contributions in the field : Dan Adikes, Laurie and Roy Averill-Murray, Joe Bailey, Dave Baker, Ken Baker, Ken Bartlett, Jeff Behan, Sandy Bernstein, Tom Blackledge, Catherine Bland, Steve Bledsoe, Laurie Bonham, BJ. Boyle, Nikolle Brown, Bill Burger, Kirk Burnett, Karla Burnley, Joe Busch, Lita Byerly, Roger Cogan, Tim Dale, Necia Davidson, Brian Dierker, Brad Duncan, Rachael Earle, Stan Faeth, Bill Fagan, Matt Ferris, Kay Fielding, Ayoola Folarin, Chris Franke, Melinda Frankus, Maria Fruin, Josh Gilman, Robert Glennon, Dan Godec, Mark Gonzales, Kenton Grua, Sara Hatch, Brenda Healy, Joy Hernbrode, Stephanie Hettinger, Jim Hoffman, Joel Huettig, Lil Jonas, Christine Karas, Bruce Keller, Krissie Killoy, Chris Klug, Keith Kohl, Dennis Kubly, Steve Lamphear, Margie Latta, Elaine Leslie, Mike Mallett, Jerry Martinez, Vicky Meretsky, Verma Miera, Becky Muller, Neibert Niemi, Bob Nelson, Lance Nelson, Eric North, Flo1ia Parker-Jones, John Perez, Marianne Porter, Barb Ralston, Mike Randolph, Jessamy Rango, Beth Roeser, Tom Ryan, Elda Sanchez, Maaike Schotborgh, Mike Seidman, Jim Shurtliff, Thorry Smith, Della Snyder, John Sorensen, Candan Soykan, Dave Speas, Tara Sprankle, Michelle Starr, Lew Steiger, Eric Swanson, Matt Sweeney, Harlan Taney, Melinda Thompson, Brent Uilenberg, Bill Vercammen, Susan Young, Eric Wallace, Melaine Webb, Guy Webster, Dave Wegner, Pete Weiss, Patrick Whitesell, Terri Williams, Bob Wilson, Bob Winfree, and Cathy Wise. Logistical and administrative support was provided by: Tony Morton and Tom Scoville (U.S. Bureau of Reclamation); Ralph Swanson (Central Utah Project Completion Act Office); Debra Bills and Larry England (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service); Carol Fritzinger, Steve Gloss, Barry Gold, and Jake Tiegs (Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center); Larry Stevens (Grand Canyon Wildlands Council); Anne Hagele and RV. Ward (National Park Service); Linda Allison, Mike Demlong, Jim Hatten, Ed Jahrke, Terry Johnson, Alicia Jontz, Bill Persons, and Richard Winstead (Arizona Game and Fish Department). Cover image by Dan Godec. PROJECT FUNDING Funding for this project was provided by: Voluntary contributions to Arizona's Nongame Wildlife Checkoff; the Arizona Heritage Fund; U.S. Bureau of Reclamation Grant No. 01-FG- 40-4870, Central Utah Project Completion Act Cooperative Agreement No. 7-FC-CU-AZ0 10, and ESA Section 6 Federal Aid. Logistical support provided by Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center. File: NGTR 200 KAS Translocation Update.20020508.doc EXECUTIVE SUMMARY To alleviate operational restrictions on Glen Canyon Dam and further recovery objectives for the endangered Kanab ambersnail (Succineidae: Oxyloma haydeni kanabensis Pilsbry), the Arizona Game and Fish Department partnered with the Central Utah Project Completion Act Office, the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation Upper Colorado Region, and the National Park Service to establish an additional wild population of the snail in Grand Canyon National Park. State, federal, tribal, and private cooperators affiliated with the Kanab Ambersnail Working Group and the Glen Canyon Technical Work Group participated in the environmental compliance process. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service issued a Biological Opinion in 1998 authorizing this translocation effort. In mid-September 1998, 450 Kanab ambersnails (::c; 5 mm in shell size) were collected from Vaseys Paradise as founding stock for translocation efforts. These snails were collected from the lower vegetated zone, an area frequently inundated by river flows of 30,000 cfs (849.9 m3/s) or less. Translocated snails were released at 3 sites (150 snails/site) in Grand Canyon National Park. The 3 sites ("KeyHole Spring" at 47.1 mi, Upper Elves Chasm at 116.6 mi, and Lower Deer Creek Spring at 136.1 mi) were selected following a National Environmental Policy Act review. In July 1999, another 450 snails were translocated in an effort to augment population densities and maintain genetic variability at each of the new sites (also 150 snails/site). In July 2000, a minor translocation of 30 Kanab ambersnails from Vaseys Paradise were moved to 2 of the 3 sites (20 snails to Upper Elves Chasm and 10 snails to Lower Deer Creek Spring) to help maintain genetic variability of new populations. No ambersnail were translocated to "KeyHole Spring" in July 2000 due to dry habitat resulting from the continued drought. The results of the ambersnail translocation and seasonal monitoring from October 1998 through August 2001 are summarized in this report. No mortalities of ambersnails occurred during transit from Vaseys Paradise to the 3 translocation sites in each translocation effort. No parasites were detected in any of the translocated snails. Resident native landsnails at the translocation sites were documented when encountered Catinella sp. at "KeyHole Spring" and Lower Deer Creek Spring, and Zonitoides sp. at Upper Elves Chasm. Densities and distribution of resident landsnails at these sites did not appear to be affected by ambersnail translocation. Of the 3 sites, Upper Elves Chasm continues to harbor numerous translocated Kanab ambersnails, and appears to be establishing a new population under the draft criteria for determining establishment success for Kanab ambersnails (Sorensen and Nelson 2000, 2001). Successive surveys at this site have consistently found live Kanab ambersnails and successful recruitment. In addition, this population is slowly increasing in abundance and is surpassing densities that are observed at Vaseys Paradise. Ambersnail translocations to "KeyHole Spring" and Lower Deer Creek Spring appear to be unsuccessful after 3 years and 2 attempts at releasing founding stock (September 1998 and July 1999). Observations of live ambersnails were sporadic and limited to a few individuals at each site during the first 2 years. No live Kanab ambersnails or shells were found in 2001 at either "KeyHole Spring" or Lower Deer Creek Spring. However, periodic sampling may be useful to detennine if any remnant ambersnails from prev10us translocations in 1998 and 1999 survived the last 2 years of drought. Continued monitoring of Upper Elves Chasm is highly warranted, since this new population has full protection under the Endangered Species Act. In addition to achieving recovery objectives, the ambersnail population at Upper Elves Chasm and its occupied habitat can be included in mitigation decisions regarding the operation of Glen Canyon Dam and incidental take statements for Kanab ambersnails at Vaseys Paradise, and allowing for more flexibility with regards to future Beach/Habitat-Building Flows. TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Sumn1ary ......... ............ .. ..... ................. ... .. ....... .. .... ............................. ...... ...... ................. i Introduction .... ................ ........................ .. ...... ................. .. ...... .. .. ..... ....... .. ......................... ...... ....... 1 Methods ........................................................... ........................... .................................... ................. 2 Environmental Compliance ...................................... .. ... .. ..... .................. ..................................... 2 Habitat Evaluation ............................ ... .................... ....................... .. ... .............. .... ..... ................. 2 Collection and Trans location of KAS ..................................................................