A Publication of the University of Chicago Divinity School
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
VOLUME 51 NUMB ER I C RITERION A Publication of the University of Chicago Divinity School AUTUMN 2 0 1 6 Dear Alumni and Friends — C RITERION This issue begins with texts delivered at a Wednesday Lunch on February 18, 2015. At this Dean’s Forum, Professors Wendy Doniger, (the Mircea Eliade VOLUME 51 | NUMBER I Distinguished Service Professor of the History of Religions), and Brook A. Ziporyn, (Professor of Chinese Religion, Philosophy, and Comparative Thought), Anthony C. Yu 1 Contents & List of Contributors Martin E. Marty discussed the groundbreaking work of Anthony C. Yu, Carl Darling Buck Fairfax M. Cone the Carl Darling Buck Distinguished Service Professor Distinguished Service Distinguished Service Emeritus: Journey to the West. Professor Emeritus 2 Dean’s Forum on Anthony Professor Emeritus of the We continue with texts from a panel discussion event Journey to the West History of Modern held to commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the Wendy Doniger C. Yu’s Christianity Civil Rights march on Selma, Alabama. Mircea Eliade Distinguished 2 Anthony C. Yu Service Professor of the David Tracy This issue also contains texts from the June 2, 2015 6 Wendy Doniger reception in honor of Dean Margaret M. Mitchell, the History of Religions Andrew Thomas Greeley Shailer Mathews Professor of New Testament and Early 8 Brook A. Ziporyn and Grace McNichols Brook A. Ziporyn Greeley Distinguished Christian Literature, on the occasion of her return to the full-time teaching faculty. Professor of Chinese Service Professor Emeritus Religion, Philosophy, and 10 Letters from Selma of Catholic Studies and Our issue closes with a sermon—on the theme ‘how Comparative Thought Professor of Theology and did I get here?’—delivered in Bond Chapel by Maggie 12 Franklin I. Gamwell the Philosophy of Religions Potthoff (MDiv’15). Franklin I. Gamwell 15 Jane Dailey Many of our public events are made available for Shailer Mathews Paul Mendes-Flohr online viewing. You can watch the Wednesday Lunch 17 Martin Marty Distinguished Service Dorothy Grant Maclear and the Selma panel discussion by visiting http:// Professor Emeritus of Professor of Modern Jewish divinity.uchicago.edu/multimedia. Religious Ethics, the 20 Honoring Dean Margaret History and Thought My thanks to Ken Janssen, designer, for his work on Philosophy of Religions, this issue. and Theology M. Mitchell Richard B. Miller 20 David Tracy Laura Spelman Rockefeller I hope you enjoy this issue. Jane Dailey Professor of Religious Ethics Associate Professor of 21 Paul Mendes-Flohr Terren Ilana Wein, Editor American History 22 Wendy Doniger 24 Richard B. Miller 26 Open Space: How Did I Get Here? Maggie Potthoff 30 Alumni News CRITERION 1 ...a sudden plunge into deep currents with scant knowledge or experience of swimming, an act of fools diving in where gods and demons fear to swim. of Change. Beginning in November with one unbroken wayward Daoist priests, actually animal spirits, by making Dean’s Forum on line, the trigram adds another line each month until them drink his—and his companions’—urine as holy January. One commentary on this trigram says: three lines water. Arthur Waley’s translation of this and other selected of yang reverts to prosperity. portions of the novel almost seventy years ago was justly Anthony C. Yu’s Because I want to leave as much time as possible for my praised for conveying the rollicking humor—often colleagues and questions from the floor, I will offer only a scatalogical—of the original. But his abridgment also brief remark that easily falls into three parts. leaves out parts that are crucial to one’s understanding of My formal education up to my taking the doctorate the story here. If one looks at my version of the same Journey To the West here at Chicago was focused entirely on Western languages, episode now excerpted in Vol. II of the new Norton literatures, and thought, and my knowledge of my own Anthology of World Religions, one will find that the Chinese tradition derived narrative is dramatically punctuated by four sets of almost entirely from hilarious limericks. Monkey declaimed two of them in familial and private brazen mockery against the Daoist Trinity and their Journey to the West by Anthony C. Yu (1938-2015), initially published in 1983 (new mentoring. The deviant disciples, and his declamations bookend two other knowledge of English limericks chanted by the animal spirits to plead for the gift edition, University of Chicago Press, 2014) introduced English-speaking audiences was enlarged progressively of holy water. Granted due attention, the four slapstick to the classic Chinese novel in its entirety for the first time. Written in the sixteenth by modern and ancient poems present a hilarious mimicry of religious and ritual European languages, but poetry. The clipped brevity metrical rhythm (mostly four century, Journey To the West tells the story of the fourteen-year pilgrimage of the monk their use (including syllables) and rhyme no less than the incongruous pairing translation activities) was of classic and demotic diction deliberately parody lines of Xuanzang, one of China’s most famous religious heroes, and his three supernatural limited only to short the Classic of Poetry, one foundational text of ancient pieces or fragments as Confucianism, the prosodic patterns of which were mimed disciples, in search of Buddhist scriptures. At a Dean’s Forum Wednesday Lunch on needed by critical writing by both Daoist and Buddhist liturgical texts and for class or later performance. In this manner, the comic narrative actually February 18, 2015, Wendy Doniger, Mircea Eliade Distinguished Service Professor of professional work. Deciding to translate entirely this huge satirizes all three religions. late Ming novel was thus a sudden plunge into deep Religion brings me to my second point: the story’s one History of Religions, and Brook A. Ziporyn, Professor of Chinese Religion, Philosophy, currents with scant knowledge or experience of swimming, human protagonist. A devout and courageous Buddhist an act of fools diving in where gods and demons fear to monk defied imperial prohibition and went from the and Comparative Thought, discussed this work. Professor Yu, the Carl Darling Buck swim. The deep water analogy is warranted because there ancient capital Chang’an to India, mostly on foot, to is no option for other means of support or staying afloat. acquire more Buddhist scriptures. Xuanzang left China in Distinguished Service Professor Emeritus, also spoke. Whereas a student writing on some foreign text may pick the early seventh century as a treasonous criminal subject and choose what portion accommodates a person’s level of to immediate execution if caught, but his triumphant comprehension and labor, a plenary translation of any text return seventeen years later was marked by imperial faculty.* Finally, tomorrow happens to be new year’s day Anthony C. Yu offers no such choice. That is why Professors David Tod pardon, unbroken patronage, and continuous service to for the lunar calendar, ushering in the Chinese Year of the Roy, Doniger, and I all affirm that our kind of translation the court as revered cleric and renowned translator. The am honored to have been invited by Dean Mitchell for Goat, Sheep, or Ram, the animal—whether male, female, likely makes the most severe demand on one’s ability to modern view of this classic novel began with the this forum on most likely the last major work of my or kid—that rhymes with one of the two fundamental read a text. unquestioned assumption in the early twentieth century career, and I am doubly grateful for my two forces (i.e., Yin and Yang) governing the ancient Chinese I’d hasten to add that close reading is not the only that it was about an actual Buddhist priest, Xuanzang of Icommentators here—one who is now my oldest active cosmos. Today’s event is an auspicious one, because the difficult demand of such translation, because another the sixth century CE. animal yang, a homophone of yang, that rhythmic dynamic colleague and one who is among the newest that I am aspect of the labor requires rigorous attention to such If Xuanzang’s journey and accomplishment were well energizing the universe, is further symbolized by an meeting for the first time. A second happy coincidence is other features as rhetoric, style, tone, and an educated known, the question that sorely baffled modern scholars unbroken line in the trigram system of Yijing or the Classic that Professor Wendy Doniger, as many of you know, is calculation of comparably intended effects in two was how and why the novel’s presentation of his familial the first person featured on the University website’s write- * Finding new life in world’s classics languages. I’ll give one example by citing the famous background, upbringing, and undertaking of his pilgrimage up this February celebrating scholarly translations by http://www.uchicago.edu/features/translation/ episode when the mischievous Monkey hero made fun of would stray so far from attested events and circumstances 2 AUTUMN 2016 CRITERION 3 I did not share this opinion, but I could find no alternate argument. The multiplicity of allegory already richly funded the syncretistic usurpation of Zen Buddhist discourse. in both secular and ecclesiastical histories. Concerning the explain this array of bewildering details, most modern imperial commission of his famous mission, and exciting reformulate its teaching on mental discipline as an integral priest’s background, the novel drew on strands of fiction scholars found answers in a rather simplistic assessment of accompaniment of four supernatural attendants. The path to alchemical self-realization. Formation of the inner that related Xuanzang’s father as a Confucian scholar of the unknown or putative author: yes, he was a gifted writer historical pilgrimage of a solitary unknown cleric now has elixir in one’s body with implications for attaining the highest rank who married a prime minister’s daughter, of great wit and linguistic wizardry, second to none in his the emperor himself as bond-brother and partner.