Archaeological Investigations of Revolutionary War Fort Billingsport
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
May 2009 Prepared for: Plains All American LLP Houston, Tx Archaeological Investigations of Revolutionary War Fort Billingsport Paulsboro, Gloucester County, New Jersey Prepared by: Burlington, New Jersey Archaeological Investigations of Revolutionary War Fort Billingsport Paulsboro, Gloucester County, New Jersey Prepared for Plains All American LLC 333 Clay Street, Suite 1600 P.O. Box 4648 Houston, Texas 77210-4648 Prepared by Douglas B. Mooney, Principal Investigator, and Ingrid Wuebber URS Corporation 437 High Street Burlington, New Jersey 08016 May 2009 ARCHAEOLOGICAL INVESTIGATIONS OF REVOLUTIONARY WAR FORT BILLINGSPORT Abstract The following report documents the methodology and findings of a combined historical and archaeological investigation of the former Revolutionary War–era redoubt known as Fort Billingsport. URS Corporation (URS) was contracted to perform this study on behalf of Plains All American LLP, owners of the Paulsboro, New Jersey, Oil Storage Terminal, within which the former fort was believed to be located. Plains All American LLP undertook these investigations in cooperation with members of the Fort Billingsport Homeland Security Preservation Committee, an organization created by the mayor and council of the borough of Paulsboro. This investigation was initiated in association with the planned construction of a series of new storage tanks within the Paulsboro Terminal property, and in order to address concerns borough officials raised about possible surviving remnants of the fort being impacted in the process. More specifically, this study was undertaken to determine whether or not any portion of Fort Billingsport might still be preserved within a small (approximately 3-acre) parcel of undeveloped ground at the far northwestern corner of the terminal property. These investigations involved the conduct of both intensive historical background research and limited archaeological investigations. Historical research determined conclusively that the site of Fort Billingsport was contained within the limits of the current Paulsboro Terminal facility; however, efforts to pinpoint the location of the fort within this larger property reached uncertain conclusions. Archaeological investigations involved the use of ground-penetrating radar (GPR), metal detecting, and limited shovel-testing methodologies. Field testing uncovered no evidence of subsurface features or artifact deposits that could be associated with the fort, and indicated that the entire study area had been extensively disturbed over recent years. Based on the findings of this investigation, it is URS’ opinion that neither preserved remnants of Fort Billingsport or intact associated artifact deposits are likely to be preserved within the Paulsboro Terminal property. While some features related to the fort may have survived into the nineteenth century, the extensive reworking of this site throughout the twentieth century has likely destroyed any of those once-surviving traces. At the conclusion of this investigation, URS researchers communicated their findings to members of the Fort Billingsport Homeland Security Preservation Committee and Plains All American LLP staff (March 5, 2008) via a detailed presentation and discussion. This report restates those earlier findings and determinations in a somewhat more refined form. i ARCHAEOLOGICAL INVESTIGATIONS OF REVOLUTIONARY WAR FORT BILLINGSPORT Table of Contents Abstract.......................................................................................................................... i List of Figures.............................................................................................................. iii Acknowledgements........................................................................................................v 1 Introduction........................................................................................................................1 Project Overview...........................................................................................................1 Research Plan.................................................................................................................2 Archaeological Study Area Description ........................................................................3 Organization of This Report ..........................................................................................4 2 The Historical Development of the Fort Billingsport Property.....................................5 Fort Billingsport during the American Revolution........................................................5 Billingsport and the New Nation .................................................................................18 Sale and Subdivision of the Fort Billingsport Tract ....................................................21 Country Retreats..........................................................................................................22 The Waterman’s Lot....................................................................................................24 Lincoln Park.................................................................................................................24 3 The Military Defenses of Fort Billingsport....................................................................37 The Kosciuszko Defenses............................................................................................37 The Redesigned Redoubt .............................................................................................38 Associated Structures...................................................................................................39 Location of Military Defenses within the Fort Billingsport Property..........................39 Fort-Related Archaeological Potential of the Present Study Area...............................40 4 Fort Billingsport in Historical Memory.........................................................................42 Lincoln Park Era Accounts (1889–Circa 1916)...........................................................43 Oil Tank Farm Era Accounts (1928–Present)..............................................................45 The Study Area Pit or Crater .......................................................................................47 5 Field Investigations and Findings...................................................................................48 Methodology................................................................................................................48 Testing Results.............................................................................................................50 6 Summary and Conclusions..............................................................................................53 References Cited ................................................................................................................55 Appendix A: Report Figures Appendix B: Fort Billingsport Chains of Title Appendix C: Lincoln Park Inventory Appendix D: Qualifications of Key Project Personnel ii ARCHAEOLOGICAL INVESTIGATIONS OF REVOLUTIONARY WAR FORT BILLINGSPORT List of Figures See report figures in Appendix A. Figure 1 Project location map 2 1972 survey of the study area 3 Aerial photographs of the study area showing changing conditions between 1965–1999 4 Overview of the study area looking north 5 Overview of the study area looking south 6 Soil piles lining the western study area margins, at the top of the riverside scarp 7 Overview of the supposed Fort Billingsport related hole or pit at the north end of the study area 8 Detail of the hole/pit showing backfilled debris, trash, and truck tires 9 Detail of the hole/pit showing partially backfilled tree trunks 10 Du Coudray plan of Fort Billingsport, 1777 11 Hunter map of Fort Billingsport, 1777 12 Billingsport in the defense of Philadelphia 13 British military plan of Fort Billingsport, 1777 14 Wangeheim plan of Fort Billingsport, 1777 15 Villefranche map of Fort Billingsport, 1779 16 Devault’s sketch map of government land at Billingsport 17 Survey of Billingsport Road in 1830 18 Fort Billingsport 96-acre tract 19 U.S. Coast Survey of Billingsport in 1842 20 U.S. Coast Survey of Billingsport in 1848 21 Division of Garrott Clark’s estate iii ARCHAEOLOGICAL INVESTIGATIONS OF REVOLUTIONARY WAR FORT BILLINGSPORT 22 Nineteenth-century subdivisions of the Fort Billingsport tract 23 Lincoln Park property 24 The former Salomon/Gibbs house in Lincoln Park 25 Lincoln Park tower, connected to the Gibbs House 26 Lincoln Park poster 27 Detail of former Gibbs house in Lincoln Park 28 Shoot the chute in Lincoln Park 29 British plan of Fort Billingsport showing the dimensions of the original redoubt, based on the included scale 30 Approximate estimated location of the Fort Billingsport defenses with respect to the present Paulsboro Terminal property 31 Fort Billingsport maps depicting features associated with a possible gorge or ravine entering the fort from the riverbank 32 Lincoln Park poster, showing the locations of possible fort-related features described in articles and recollections 33 Overlay of the 1896 Sanborn Insurance Map of Lincoln Park and 1972 CES survey of the study area, showing the relationship between the shoot-the-chute ride and the pit or crater in the north end of the study area 34 Field crew conducting Ground Penetrating Radar investigations of the study area 35 Field crew performing metal detector sweeps of the study area 36 Results