JOURNAL
OF THE ROYAL VICTORIAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS
Vol. )(XXVIII. Melbourne, August-September, 1940 No. 4
CONTENTS
STONES OF ATHENS ... ... FRONTISPIECE
AIR RAID PRECAUTIONS 79
NOTES OF GENERAL INTEREST ... 81
R.V.I.A. VICTORIAN STREET ARCHITECTURE MEDAL 82
HEIDELBERG TOWN HALL AND MUNICIPAL OFFICES 83
THE I.E.S. AWARD FOR LIGHT IN ARCHITECTURE, 1940 84
DESIGN AWARDED FIRST PRIZE ... 85
DESIGN AWARDED SECOND PRIZE 86
DESIGN AWARDED THIRD PRIZE 87
CONTEMPORARY RESIDENTIAL SHOP DESIGN ... 88
NEW BUILDING FOR THE ROYAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED 90
LOUDON SAINTHILL ... 92
PUBLISHED MONTHLY FOR THE ROYAL VICTORIAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS
REGISTERED OFFÍCE: 53-55 COLLINS PLACE, MELBOURNE, C.1
journal Committee HORACE J. TRIBE (Chairman) ALAN L. FILDES LESLIE M. PERROTT D. C. WARD ROY K. STEVENSON W. R. GODFREY Managing Editor— JOHN B. ISLIP
This Journal is set up and printed by G. W. GREEN & SONS PTY. LTD. 458 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne Subscription Rates, £1/1/- per year COPYRIGHT "WATERLOO" FIRE DOORS To Fire Underwriters' Specifications
•
Are manufactured to any size and erected to your entire satisfaction by WORMALD BROS. PTY. LTD. Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne Telephone: MX 3121
FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEERS SINCE 1889
• "Calcimo" is the perfect wall and ceiling finish — it has set the standard for quality among kalsomines in Australia for over 40 years! It's easy to mix—easy to use—made ready for application by the simple admixture of cold water. "Calcimo" is durable, economical, and enables the most beautiful, distinctive colour harmonies to be achieved at minimum cost. CALCIMO Sole Victorian DECORATIVE WALL COATING Distributors: BROOKS J MU R/1 LO * PROCESSI ROBINSON PTY. LTD. Now made in Australia by: MURALO 59 Elizabeth Street, COMPANY (Australia) Pty. Ltd. Melbourne Port Adelaide + Melbourne + Sydney
xvi.
~~oraei otAhevm
JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL VICTORIAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS + AUGUST-SEPTEMBER, 1940 JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL VICTORIAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS
Vol. XX XVIII. Melbourne, August-September, 1940 No. 4 AIR RAID PRECAUTIONS THE PROVISION OF AIR RAID SHELTERS IN VICTORIA
T the request the State EmergencyJ Council shelter, and have been adopted as the basic type A or Civil De,offence the A.R.P. oint Com- for all areas except specially vulnerable areas of mittee of the Royal Victorian Institute of limited extent, for three main reasons, viz.:— Architects and of the Institution of Engineers, (a) Small bomb-proof shelters are so excessively Australia, Melbourne Division, has prepared a costly as to be impracticable. report regarding the provision of Air Raid Shelters (b) Large bomb-proof shelters in which the cost in Victoria. per head can be reduced to practicable limits The report deals in a comprehensive manner are unsuitable for use in this country, where with the question of obtaining shelter protection the density of population is -relatively low. in Greater Melbourne and the urban centres of (c) In the event of larger bombs being used than the State and examines the relative costs. The those provided against, the efficiency of large document is of such length that it is not possible bomb-proof shelters is doubtful. to publish it here in full: a summary of the con- "Since it has been found unduly costly to pro- clusions and recommendations contained in the vide by structural means lateral protection above report, however, is set out hereunder. ground equivalent to that provided by solid earth, The recommendations are based upon the as- the trench type of shelter wholly sunk into the sumption that in the event of Victoria being raided ground has been recommended for use, wherever from, the air complete evacuation of the popula- practicable. tion is not a practicable policy, owing to the vital "The recommendations for the structural design need in wartime to maintain war production and of covered trënch shelters have been based upon civil organisation. This problem, together with a the factors of efficiency and cost. The 9 in. re- number of other difficulties inherent in any whole- inforced concrete wall adopted as a basis provides sale evacuation scheme, has led the Committee to high efficiency in relation to cost. The detailed adopt a plan which provides for the evacuation costs given in Appendix B show that the efficiency of all non-essential persons from congested areas of heavier construction increases at a lower rate and the provision of shelter accommodation for than the costs of such construction. all those remaining in populous or dangerous "In areas of low density of population, with areas. The Committee points out that the report relatively few shelters, the probability of bombing does not deal with the question of the billeting and the risk of near hits on a number of shelters of evacuees nor the provision of buildings for such are less than in congested areas and these factors a purpose. have been considered to justify some reduction in CONCLUSIONS the strength of construction used in shelters in In summarising its conclusions, the Committee such areas. states that "consideration of the type of shelter "The nature of the earth into which the shel- accommodation to be provided for the unevacu- ters are sunk also affects their efficiency. Various ated population has entailed examination of the strengths of structure have, therefore, been recom- relative merits of bomb-proof shelters and blast mended for use according to density of population and splinter resisting shelters. and the nature of the ground. "After detailed examination of the data avail- "Where suitable buildings are available, shelters able, blast and splinter resisting shelters have been in buildings may be used. The construction of such considered to be preferable to the bomb-proof shelters is intended to be such that they give ap-
79 i►'--, ^~
proximately the same amount of protection as the covered trench shelter. Stones o[_/dtheni In view of the relatively low cost of gas-proof- Mr. Max Collard (A.), a winner of the ing measures in shelters and in view of the pos- Robert and Ada Haddon Travelling Scholar- sible use of gas, it has been considered desirable ship of the R.V.I.A., has captured an unusual that all shelters should be completely gas-proof. angle of the Parthenon in the camera study It should be noted, however, that the provision of which forms the frontispiece of this issue of gas-proof shelters will not render the use of in- the Journal. The photograph was taken by dividual gas masks unnecessary. Gas masks will be Mr. Collard during his recent tour overseas. essential for all persons to ensure that they can enter and leave a shelter in the presence of gas. "For reasons of economy and efficiency, it is recommended that all external shelters should be in public gardens, open spaces and in streets, par- mechanically ventilated, and, where possible, ticularly secondary streets. This will allow shel- should be capable of accommodating not less than ters to be properly distributed according to the 25 persons. distribution of population with a minimum travel- time for the occupants of each shelter. The maximum capacity of any one external "It is clear that the construction of such shel- shelter has been fixed at 100 persons, since a ters, the majority of which will be located on smaller shelter (of say 50 persons as adopted in public property and roads, can be efficiently under- England) adds considerably to the cost. Internal taken only by some Government Authority with shelters accommodating more than 100 persons adequate powers to control the matters of design, should be sub-divided with blast and splinter re- location and construction of shelters. sisting partitions, so that no section will contain "While the shelter-construction scheme outlined more than 100 persons. In all other details, the in this report is not comparable in scale or in recommendations made in regard to shelter design total cost with any of the main social services are, in principle, the same as those adopted in such as railways, sanitation or power supply, it is England. nevertheless a very large programme. It could not "English recommendations for surface area per be efficiently nor economically carried out under person and air volume per person have been used emergency conditions. It is essential, therefore, in this report to determine the capacity of shelters. that all necessary preparations should be made and These figures may require modification owing to the work carried out before an emergency arises." the difference between English and Victorian climatic conditions. Any such modification will RECOMMENDATIONS not, however, affect the general recommendations "It is recommended that— in this report. "1. The scheme of protection most suitable for "It is essential, before any final shelter designs Melbourne and the rural centres of Victoria is a are made, that a specimen shelter should be built combination of evacuation and the provision of and tested under a variety of weather conditions shelter accommodation. to determine the surface area and air volume re- "2. All children and non-essential persons quired per person in this climate. should be evacuated from all areas which are "The size and type of shelter adopted control to densely populated or adjoin specific targets. a large extent the method of carrying out the con- "3. Where the population density, in any par- struction programme and the question of location. ticular area, after evacuation, equals or exceeds "Since the basic type of external shelter recom- say five (5) persons to the acre, shelter accom- mended is the covered trench type and accom- modation should be provided in order to give, as modates 25 or more persons, shelters must gen- far as possible, an equal degree of immunity for erally be sited in open ground or in streets, and all persons. must be available to the public. "Except in the case of areas adjoining specific "While it is realised that the siting of shelters targets, shelter provision is not considered essen- in any given area will depend upon a variety of tial where the population density, after evacuation, special local conditions, it is recommended in is small [say less than five (5) persons to the general principle that shelters should be located acre]. [Continued on page 94 80 NOTES OF GENERAL INTEREST
Mr. Arnold Ernest Cr. John S. Gawler (F.) has been elected Mayor Bridge has been ad- of the City of Box Hill. Cr. Gawler has been a mitted to Associate- member of the Box Hill Council for several years ship of the Institute and has given active service in the development after having com- of the municipality. pleted a qualifying examination. M r. In appreciation of his services in arranging the Bridge attended the construction of the King Edward VII. statue at Williamstown High Geelong, Mr. Percy Everett (F.) has been pre- School for the pur- sented with a framed and inscribed photograph pose of secondary of the unveiling ceremony. The presentation was education and then made by Cr. L. Hirst who was Chairman of the completed articles Mr. Arnold E. Bridge Parks and Gardens Committee when the statue of pupilage in the was presented to Geelong. office of Mr. H. V. Gillespie, architect. He studied architecture at the Swinburne and Melbourne At a recent meeting of the Housewives' Associ- Technical Colleges and later at the University of ation Mrs. P. D. Phillips (A.) gave an address Melbourne Architectural Atelier. Mr. Bridge is a describing community housing work overseas. member of the architectural staff of the State Sav- ings Bank of Victoria. Mr. John D. Fisher (A.) has been admitted as an associate of the firm of Messrs. Stephenson & Mr. John F. D. Scarborough (A.) has been Turner, architects, of Melbourne and Sydney. appointed Chairman of the Board of Architectural After obtaining the Diploma of Architectural Education of the R.V.I.A. for the ensuing year. Design of the Melbourne University and winning the Robert and Ada Haddon Travelling Scholar- Mr. Geo. R. King, an Honorary Fellow of the ship of the R.V.I.A., Mr. Fisher returned last year Institute, has been appointed a Vice-President of from an extensive trip abroad during which he the Council of Public Education. studied hospital architecture and modern indus- trial and housing work. Mr. Fisher has been a member of the staff of Messrs. Stephenson & Tur- At the annual meeting of the Town Planning ner for the past six years and has been entrusted Association of Victoria held in the reception room with the carrying out of important building works of the Melbourne Town Hall on the 4th Septem- both locally and in New Zealand. Recently he was ber Mr. Leslie M. Perrott (F.) delivered an ad- appointed by his firm to take charge of the Gov- dress entitled "Some Observations from the recent ernment Military Hospital project at Yaralla, New Town Planning Conference at Stockholm." South Wales. Messrs. Percy Everett (F.) and Geo. R. King (Hon. F.) were re-elected Vice-Presidents of the The Institute Council has approved a proposal Association for the ensuing year and Mr. Frank of the R.V.I.A. Students' Society to establish a Heath (A.) was re-appointed Honorary Secretary. class of "Associate membership" to embrace Other members of the Institute who were ap- students who are interested in the study of archi- pointed to the Council of the Association were tecture but who are not necessarily attending re- Messrs. S. C. Brittingham, Kingsley A. Hender- cognised courses. The Council has expressed the son, Arthur Peck, Leslie M. Perrott, F. C. Purnell opinion that the extension of the activities of the (Fellows), Harold Bartlett, E. Keith Mackay, E. J. Students' Society in this manner will perform a Walker, Donald C. Ward and Ronald J. Wilson valuable service in widening public interest in the (Associates) . 4 work of the profession.
81 621/_9-2 VICTORIAN STREET ARCHITECTURE MEDAL
O N the recommendation of the Victorian The award of the Street Architecture Medal is Street Architecture Medal Jury of the R.V.I.A., offered annually by the R.V.I.A. for the design of the Council of the Institute has awarded the Medal a building of outstanding merit completed in Vic- for the year 1939 to Messrs. Peck & Kemter and toria during the previous three years, its purposes A. C. Leith & Bartlett, in recognition of the being to encourage excellence of design in street exceptional merit of the Heidelberg Town Hall architecture and to increase public interest in the and Municipal Offices, Upper Heidelberg Road, work of the architectural profession. Ivanhoe, the architects named, in conjunction, hav- The personnel of the Jury which examined the ing been responsible for the design and construc- merits of the buildings nominated for this year's tion of the selected building. award was as follows:—
The President of the Institute (Mr. W. O. McCutcheon) ; The Chief Architect of the Department of Public Works (Mr. Percy Everett The Director of the National Gallery (Mr. J. S. MacDonald) ; The Art Inspector of the Education Department (Mr. W. R. Dean) ; Seven Architects appointed by the Institute Council, viz.:— Messrs. Edward F. Billson, John R. Freeman, Geo. R. King, E. Keith Mackay, Marcus W. Martin, P. H. Meldrum and Roy K. Stevenson.
In recommending the award the Examining unity of design in colour and texture, has provided Jury reported as follows:— an excellent example of the monumental results which can be achieved by the intelligent use of "The building possesses good architectural broad masses of good brickwork. massing, complete unity of design and a digni- "The design generally is of strong character fied expression of purpose. and represents a fine type of modern architecture, "The planning is expressed clearly in the main and in setting a high standard of design for muni- elevation, the principal mass of the Hall being cipal buildings of the future, it should be fur- effectively related to the Municipal Offices wing ther distinguished by an award of architectural by the placing of the Clock Tower. merit." "Judicious restraint is evidenced in the detail It is intended that the Medal together with a consideration of the elevations, the chief interest Diploma signed by the Examining Jury should be being centred around the triple metal-grilled open- presented to the successful architects at a General ings of the Hall block. Meeting of the Institute and that a bronze plaque "The use of brickwork throughout the eleva- recording the award should be affixed to the tions is commendable, and besides producing a selected building.
82 THE HEIDELBERG TOWN HALL AND MUNICIPAL OFFICES FOR WHICH THE VICTORIAN STREET ARCHITECTURE MEDAL, 1939, HAS BEEN AWARDED
✓ deoociaied. _ rch.itecti: PECK & KEMTER and A. C. LEITH & BARTLETT
83 Jhe I.E.S. AWARD /or LIGHT IN ARCHITECTURE, 1940
HE Illum inating Engineering Society of the Illuminating Engineering Society) , and Alan Australia (Victoria) has presented the 1940 J. Ralton (A.) and Horace J. Tribe (A.) (repre- Award for Light in Architecture to Messrs. senting the R.V.I.A.) . A. S. & R. A. Eggleston, Architects, of 360 Col- In their report the assessors state that "the first lins Street, Melbourne. I.E.S. Award for Light in Architecture attracted Inaugurated this year, the award is to be offered fifteen entrants. While it was expected that the annually to members of the R.V.I.A., architects field would be more competitive—there being registered under the provisions of the Architects seventy-five names on the preliminary register— Acts of Victoria and students attending schools of the average standard was of high quality, and architecture in this State. Its objects are "the ad- showed evidence of intensive research into modern vancement of the arts and sciences of Architecture practices in illumination. It is significant that prac- and Illumination and the development of the use tising firms of architects in submitting designs of light as a component element in architectural showed a consciousness of the need for research design." into this new element of architecture and the The award is based on an architectural com- Award Committee's expectations have been fully petition the subject of which for 1940 was the realized in this connection. It had been hoped design of two-storey premises in Collins Street however that a greater number of University East for the display and sale of exclusive millinery students would compete, the period of the com- and frocks. Competitors were to assume that the petition having been arranged especially to co- site had a frontage of 25 feet to Collins Street and incide with their winter vacation. a depth of 80 feet to an open space and service "The bulk of the entries showed a keen appre- access at the rear. ciation of the purpose of the competition, and in The conditions asked that emphasis be made of both interior and exterior treatments many novel the exterior treatment, including the main display and practical lighting ideas were propounded. window, having regard to the publicity value of Fittings and lighting designs were not only prac- the facade both by day and by night. The interior tical and economical from a lighting point of view was to be suitably arranged as a retail shop, fully but effectively combined the technical require- equipped with all the essential facilities of an ments of illumination with sound architectural up-to-date salon specialising in high-class millin- treatment. ery and frocks. Provision was also to be made for "There was no wide variety in the individual mannequin parades which would take place on the facade designs but this may be attributed to cer- floor space normally employed for sales activities. tain limitations implied if not intended by the set Premiums of 50 guineas, 20 guineas and 10 conditions. The shop fronts usually included a guineas were offered for award to the authors of silhouette type sign mostly of free standing letters, the designs placed first, second and third. but in several cases having luminous tubing con- Second and third prizes were awarded respec- cealed behind the lettering. In the show cases tively to Mr. John P. Mockridge, of 279 Domain lighting methods varied between the latest pre- Road, South Yarra, and Mr. John Barry, of 237 war forms of Continental luminous ceiling designs Buckley St., Essendon, both of whom are students and the strong spot light type of contrast so much of the Melbourne University Architectural Atelier. in evidence in American shop window work. The three premiated drawings are published on "The use of fluorescent luminous tubes was very the following pages. general in the interior, thus marking a very decided ASSESSORS' REPORT architectural trend towards this newly established The assessors of the competition were Messrs. type of lighting. In most designs however this Charles E. Serpell (F.) (Chairman), L. D. lighting was used in coves or coffers as basic light- Wright, C. S. Demaine, P. Magnus (representing ing, supplemented by downlights and other forms
84 [Continued on page 94 DESIGN AWARDED FIRST PRIZE
k-4
CdOSS SECTIOM .
ItAS/tCT!YE 200 se pearl a0.. P.(r .Yâr¢
~ Imimuirulmuu1misms V I 6011111011111011112 I ) ,m ill ERVIIIIIMECiE 11111113139f1{1MA 11111CI~pl `_,91111mL~Jfl16~I I~11TR1 L I ÌI'Jlllui lalial0l11YS9I~i 'Biala
LON C ITUOINAL SICT ION
S•ocL Minis
irPlay ilgqh«ngq Oilh lo with e0eubmpf rn opo l ó rrd od nllghlr~. aI 'utr d d hgni 4. s /1bfi o fooklrghl<. lo fellp.noe dleb l fN«c IesK â1plc o~I asK 1l 4 óndln
7-rS p< en Is fmq to Leusrcd d I h:r 'gaffers" ly S 1010410 Dunk 1, f b aqhln .,1F fop el carlem. ceni re •~o01r lamp f m h dhng feble, 92)ranomberk. i7óWl/sp.~iédet ifPma 1 SILtTCH Of lALON
6ROU110 fL006 /LAN L ITT ER-EO ~t4CRIFT1oN
C NpP WINDO~111 Calluler.eailln nAh neasl¢d m~r rad yy loO-Iso ro~,a4rr.11e<•< Muro..d Yaiy baaladparvl