LOK SABHA DEBATES (English Version)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Eleventh Series, Vol. XIII, No. 2 Tuesday, April 22, 1997 Vaisakha 2, 1919(Saka) LOK SABHA DEBATES (English Version) r PARUAMENT UHSASY*~>‘ i R o . : 1 Fourth Session taw (Part-Ill) (Eleventh Lok Sabha) (Vol. XIII contains Nos. 1 and 2) LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI Price : Rs. 50.00 EDITORIAL BOARD Shri S. Gopalan Secretary-General Lok Sabha Shri Surendra Mishra Additional Secretary Lok Sabha Secretariat Shri RC. Bhatt Chief Editor Lok Sabha Secretariat ShriY.K. Abrol Senior Editor Shrimati Kamla Sharma Editor Shri Balram Suri Shri S.C. Kala Assistant Editor Assistant Editor [O riginal E nglish proceedings included in E nglish Version and O riginal H indi proceedings included in Version will be treated as authoritative and not the translation thereof] Corrlgvida to I>c^ Sabha D<abatMi (Bnglirti Veralcn) • • • TUMdtay# April22, 1997/ Vaisakha 2, 1919 fSaka) • « «> Col./lin* For R«d 11/13 need heed 10/18 here have CONTENTS [Eleventh Series, Vol. XIII, Fourth Session, (Part-Ill), 1997/1919 (Saka)] No. 2, Tuesday, April 22, 1997/Vaisakha 2, 1919 (Saka) Subject Columns ANNOUNCEMENT RE: SITTINGS OF THE H O U SE.................................................................................... 1,147— 148 INTRODUCTION OF M INISTERS................................................................................................................ 1 PAPERS LAID ON THE T A B L E .................................................................................................................... 2 PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE Eighth, Ninth, Tenth, Eleventh and Twelth Reports — P resented ................................................... 2 COMMITTEE ON PETITIONS Minutes of the First to Sixth Sittings — Laid....................................................................................... 3 STANDING COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS Tenth, Eleventh and Twelth Reports — Presented ............................................................................. 3 STANDING COMMITTEE ON DEFENCE Third and Fourth Reports — Presented ............................................................................................. 3 STANDING COMMITTEE ON ENERGY Tenth, Eleventh, Twelth and Thirteenth Reports — Presented .......................................................... 4 STANDING COMMITTEE ON EXTERNAL AFFAIRS Second, Third and Fourth Reports — P resented ............................................................................. 4—5 STANDING COMMITTEE ON RAILWAYS Sixth Report and Minutes — Presented ............................................................................................. 5 STANDING COMMITTEE ON URBAN AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT Eighth, Ninth, Tenth, Eleventh and Twelth Reports and Minutes — Presented ................................ 5 STANDING COMMITTEE ON HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT Fifty-sixth, Fifty-seventh, Fifty-eighth, Fifty-ninth, Sixtienth, Sixty-first and Sixty-second Reports — L a id................................................................................... 6 STANDING COMMITTEE ON SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY ENVIRONMENT AND FORESTS Forty-third, Forty-fourth and Forty-fifth Reports — L a id................................................................... 6 —7 MOTION OF CONFIDENCE IN THE COUNCIL OF M INISTERS................................................................ 7— 147 Shri I.K. Gujral................................................................................................................................ 7— 13,141—14/ Shrimati Sushma S w a ra j................................................................................................................... 14—24 Shri Sharad P a w a r............................................................................................................................. 24—34 Shri Somnath C hatterjee................................................................................................................... 34—45 Shri Mulayam Singh Y adav................................................................................................................ 45—56 Shri Madhukar Sarpotdar................................................................................................................... 56—63 Shri G.G. S w e ll.................................................................................................................................... 63—64 Col. Rao Ram S in g h .......................................................................................................................... 64—71 Shri G. Venkat Swamy.......................................................................................................................... 71—79 Shri P. Chidambaram.......................................................................................................................... 80—83 Shri Sukh Lai Kushw aha.................................................................................................................... 83—85 Prof. Prem Singh Chandumajra.......................................................................................................... 86—92 Shri Brahamanand M andal................................................................................................................. 92—97 Shri Chandra S h e k h a r....................................................................................................................... 99— 103 (i) 103-105 Subject 105-108 ShriChittaBasu. ■ ■ ■ ■ 108-110 Shri Pramothes Mukherjee 110-112 Dr.ArvindSharma- ■ • 112-115 Shri Surender Singfi . 115-116 Shri E. Atiam ed .......... 116-118 ShriP.C.Ttiomas ■ ■ 118-120 Shri Sultan Salahuddin Owaisi 120-128 Shri Shibu S o re n ............ Shri Sontosh Mohan Dev. • • 128-140 S hri AtalBihari Vajpayee . ■ LOK SABHA DEBATES LOK SABHA 11.04 hrs. PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE Tuesday, April 22, 1997/Vaisakha 2, 1919 (Saka) Resignation of Council of Ministers [English] The Lok Sabha met at SECRETARY-GENERAL : I beg to lay on the Table Eleven of the Clock, a copy each of the following papers : (1) Letter dated the 11th April, 1997 from the [M r . S p e a k e r in the Chair] Prime Minister (Shri H.D. Deve Gowda) to the President tendering his own resignation ANNOUNCEMENT RE : SITTING and that of his Council of Ministers. OF THE HOUSE (2) Letter dated the 12th April, 1997 from the [English] President to the Prime Minister Shri H.D. Deve Gowda accepting his resignation and MR. SPEAKER : Hon. Members, yesterday, we had a meeting of the Business Advisory Committee as well the resignation of his colleagues from the as the leaders of the political parties. The decision Council of Ministers and requesting him to taken is that the Confidence Motion will be immediately continue Office till alternative arrangements taken up and the Prime Minister will reply at five o’clock, are made. if not earlier, so that we are able to finish it by six o’clock. Secondly, today, we will adjourn the House to meet 11.04V2 hrs. on 30th of April, 1997 to transact urgent Government business, that means the financial business and the PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE House will continue till 16th May, 1997. These are the two major decisions that we had taken yesterday. Eighth to Twelfth Reports Will the Prime Minister like to introduce some more Ministers—I am told—those who could not be introduced [English] yesterday? DR. T SUBBARAMI REDDY (Visakhapatnam) : I beg to present the following Reports (Hindi and English versions) of the Public Accounts Committee : 11.03 hrs. (1) Eighth Report on Action Taken on 104th Report of Public Accounts Committee ( 10th INTRODUCTION OF MINISTERS Lok Sabha) on Modvat Scheme—fraudulent availment of credits. [English] (2) Ninth Report on Action Taken on 105th Report THE PRIME MINISTER (SHRI I.K. GUJRAL) : Mr. of Public Accounts Committee ( 10th Lok Speaker, Sir, you will kindly recall that I had introduced some of my worthy colleagues yesterday and some, Sabha) on follow up on Audit Reports. unfortunately, were not a\/a\\ab\e,..(Interruptions). (3) Tenth Report on Action Taken on 109th Report SHRI PR. DASMUNSI (Howrah) : What about Shri of Public Accounts Committee (10th Lok P Chidambaram? ...(Interruptions). Sabha) on injudicious leasing of aircraft. SHRI I.K. GUJRAL : Well, I hope it is a sign of (4) Eleventh Report on Union Government coming events,...(Interruptions). Appropriation Accounts (1994-95) Postal Sir, I introduce my colleagues. Services and Minutes of the sittings of the Committee relating thereto. Cabinet Minister : (5) Twelfth Report on lower categorisation Shri Janeshwar Mishra leading to loss of Rs. 352.30 lakhs and Minister of State : Minutes of the sittings of the Committee Shri Saleem Iqbal Shervani. relating thereto. Committee APRIL 22. 1997 Reports 11.04V4 hrs. 11.0514 hrs. COMMITTEE ON PETITIONS STANDING COMMITTEE ON ENERGY Tenth, Eleventh, Twelfth and Thirteenth Reports Minutes of the First to Sixth Sittings [English] [English] SHRI JAG MOHAN (New Delhi) : Sir, I beg to present SHRI DILEEP SANGHANI (Amreli) : I beg to lay on the following Reports (Hindi and English versions) of the Table of the House the Minutes (Hindi and English the Standing Committee on Energy : versions) of the First to Sixth sittings of the Committee (1) Tenth Report on Action Taken by the on Petitions. Government on the recommendations contained in their First Report (Eleventh Lok Sabha) on Demands for Grants (1996-97) of Department of Atomic Energy. 11.05 hrs. (2) Eleventh Report on Action Taken by the STANDING COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS Government on the recommendations