Distal Humerus Nonunion After Failed Internal Fixation: Reconstruction with Total Elbow Arthroplasty Dawn M
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
(aspects of trauma • an original study) Distal Humerus Nonunion After Failed Internal Fixation: Reconstruction With Total Elbow Arthroplasty Dawn M. LaPorte, MD, Michael S. Murphy, MD, and J. Russell Moore, MD ABSTRACT onunion occurs in 2% ing treatment option. In the 1980s, In nonunion after distal humerus to 5% of distal humerus TEA for nonunion with tightly con- fracture, osteoporosis, devas- fractures.1 The condition strained or custom prostheses had cularized fracture fragments, is difficult to treat, and fair to moderately good results but and periarticular fibrosis limit Nno single treatment modality has a high complication rates (4/7, 57%6; potential reconstructive options. high success rate with few compli- 5/14, 36%10). According to a recent We assessed pain relief, func- 2-6 11 tional gains, and complications cations. Without intervention, the review, however, 31 (86%) of 36 in 12 patients whose long-stand- patient is left with a painful, unstable, patients had a satisfactory result with ing, painful nonunions after previ- and often flail extremity and with a semiconstrained prosthesis, and ous treatment with rigid internal limitations in activities of daily liv- only 7 (19%) of the 36 patients had fixation were reconstructed with ing. Frequently, there is an associ- complications. a semiconstrained total elbow ated ulnar neuropathy. Osteoporosis, In the current study, we assessed arthroplasty, frequently with a devascularized fracture fragments, outcomes (complications, symptoms, triceps-sparing approach and and periarticular fibrosis limit poten- function) after semiconstrained anterior ulnar nerve transposition. tial reconstructive options for long- TEA for long-standing distal humer- At mean follow-up of 63 months, 11 patients had good pain relief and standing distal humerus nonunions. us nonunions. a good or excellent functional result: Current treatment modalities for mean flexion/extension, 134° to 18°; distal humerus nonunion include brac- MATERIALS AND METHODS mean total arc of motion, 117°; mean ing and mobilization, open reduc- pronation/supination, 74° to 69°. tion and internal fixation with bone Patient Population Despite the 75% rate of compli- graft, resection arthroplasty, allograft, With the approval of the institution- cations (8), semiconstrained total arthrodesis, and total elbow arthro- al review board, we retrospectively elbow arthroplasty provides a viable plasty (TEA). Each has its disad- reviewed one institution’s patient data- treatment for this difficult problem. vantages. In 2 studies,2,6 secondary base to identify patients who, between osteosynthesis was associated with an 1989 and 1997, had been treated with Dr. LaPorte is Assistant Professor, unsatisfactory result more than 50% a semiconstrained TEA for painful, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, The of the time; in a more recent study, 5 long-standing (>14 months) dis- Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, (71%) of 7 patients with nonunion had tal humerus fracture nonunion. We Maryland. Dr. Murphy is Assistant Professor, a good or excellent result with autolo- excluded patients with painless non- Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, The gous bone graft, stable fixation, and union, patients with nonunions treated Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, capsulectomy.5 Resection arthroplasty initially with arthroplasty, and patients Maryland, and Faculty, Curtis National Hand Center and The Greater Chesapeake leaves the patient with a flail extrem- treated with arthroplasty for an indica- Hand Specialists, Lutherville, Maryland. ity that may still require splinting. For tion other than nonunion. Dr. Moore is Faculty, Curtis National Hand some patients with substantial bone We identified 12 consecutive Center and The Greater Chesapeake Hand Specialists, Lutherville, Maryland. loss, osteoarticular allografts are a sal- patients who met the study crite- vage option, but the complication rate ria. All 12 distal humerus fractures Address correspondence to: Dawn M. (infection, instability, graft resorption) had been treated initially with rigid LaPorte, MD, c/o Elaine P. Henze, BJ, 7,8 ELS, Medical Editor, Department of is high, and results usually are poor. internal fixation. Mean age of the Orthopaedic Surgery, Johns Hopkins Elbow arthrodesis is technically dif- 4 male and 8 female patients at the Bayview Medical Center, 4940 Eastern ficult, has a high complication rate, time of arthroplasty was 61 years Ave, A672, Baltimore, MD 21224-2780 (tel, 410-550-5400; fax, 410-550-2899; e- and is associated with a low patient (range, 36-81 years), mean duration mail, [email protected]). satisfaction rate.9 of nonunion was 28 months (range, Because of such high complica- 14-96 months), and mean number of Am J Orthop. 2008;37(10):531-534. Copyright Quadrant HealthCom Inc. 2008. tion rates, prosthetic replacement of additional surgeries after the initial All rights reserved. the elbow provides a more appeal- intervention was 2 (range, 1–5). October 2008 531 Total Elbow Arthroplasty for Distal Humerus Nonunion Table. Patient Data Patient Age at Follow-Up Arc of Motion (°) Elbow Repeat No. Surgery (y) (mo) Flexion Extension Total Pronation Supination Score Complication Surgery 1 51 94 150 0 150 80 80 100 None No 2 36 83 130 –15 115 75 75 80 Ulnar neuropathy No 3 71 40 140 0 140 75 75 90 None No 4 59 64 130 –20 110 75 60 75 Olecranon fracture No 5 61 61 140 –10 130 76 75 90 Superficial infection No 6 63 56 130 –25 105 70 65 75 Triceps weakness No 7 62 43 120 –40 80 60 55 57 Deep infection No 8 59 86 145 –10 135 78 80 90 None No 9 62 70 133 –18 115 75 70 80 Ulnar neuropathy Ulnar nerve transposition 10 64 62 130 –30 100 70 60 70 Triceps avulsion Triceps repair 11 81 36 135 –15 120 78 70 85 Triceps weakness No 12 60 63 130 –30 100 70 68 70 Ulnar neuropathy No Means 61 63 134 –18 117 74 69 80 Procedures Patients were assessed for subjec- The 9 postoperative complications The TEA technique was well tive pain relief and functional gains were ulnar neuropathy (3 cases), triceps described by Morrey and Adams11 at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, weakness (2), triceps avulsion (1), olec- and Morrey and colleagues12 and is and yearly thereafter. Postoperative ranon fracture (1), superficial infection addressed only briefly here. We used ROM was quantified, and in all (1), and deep infection (1). All exten- a standard posterior exposure, exploit- cases radiographs were reviewed sor mechanism complications (triceps ing old incisions when possible, and for evidence of loosening. For each weakness, triceps avulsion) occurred in the Bryan-Morrey triceps-sparing patient, a postoperative performance patients with previous olecranon oste- exposure13 in 8 cases. Complex skel- index, or elbow score, was calcu- otomies. Two patients required addi- etal deformities, often encountered, lated using the method described by tional surgery (1 triceps repair and 1 necessitated minor modifications. In Morrey and Adams.11 ulnar nerve transposition). The other 2 9 cases, release with anterior trans- Mean follow-up after TEA was 63 patients with ulnar neuropathy had reso- position of the ulnar nerve was per- months (range, 36-94 months). ROM lution of their paresthesias in less than 6 formed. Cultures were obtained to and performance index were deter- months. The patient with deep infection rule out infected nonunion. mined at 2-year follow-up. elected to use suppressive antibiotics. “...we agree that a complete release and transposition of the ulnar nerve should be considered in the treatment of any distal humerus nonunion.’’ In all patients, a semiconstrained RESULTS There was evidence of radiographic Coonrad-Morrey prosthesis (Zimmer, After semiconstrained TEA for lucency around the humeral implants Warsaw, Ind) was set in place with long-standing distal humerus non- in 3 patients at 36-month follow-up. third-generation cement, often con- unions in these 12 patients, flexion One implant was clearly infected taining antibiotics. Care was taken to averaged 134° (range, 120°-150°) (same patient just described). The achieve a good cement mantle. Wounds to 18° (range, 0°-40°) of exten- other 2 had asymptomatic lucency were closed over suction drains, and sion, and pronation averaged 74° around the cement mantle on the long-arm splints positioned over the (range, 60°-80°) to 69° (range, humeral and ulnar sides and contin- extremity in 90° of flexion remained 55°-80°) of supination. Mean total ued to be monitored radiographically in place for 10 days. arc of motion was 117°; 11 of 12 each year. patients had a functional total arc At final follow-up, 7 of the 12 Postoperative Care and Assessment of motion (≥100°). Mean perfor- patients reported no pain (Figure), Patients were discharged home mance index (elbow score) was 4 had occasional pain with activity, between postoperative days 2 and 80 points (range, 57-100 points; and 1 had a painful, infected arthro- 4. Active range of motion (ROM) Table). Based on joint function plasty. All but the patient with the was initiated 1 week after surgery in and pain, this index has 100 points infected arthroplasty believed the patients treated with a triceps-sparing assigned to the areas of motion procedure had provided excellent approach. Supervised therapy was (40), pain (35), strength (20), and pain relief and substantial func- not required. stability (5). tional gains. 532 The American Journal of Orthopedics® D. M. LaPorte et al DISCUSSION treated with extensile exposure, mobi- option, especially for low-demand Nonunion of a distal humerus fracture lization and transposition of the ulnar elderly patients with or without is uncommon and difficult to man- nerve, external neurolysis of the ulnar sufficient bone stock.11 For the 36- age. The condition is compounded nerve, anterior and posterior capsulec- year-old patient included in the cur- by the presence of poor bone stock, tomy, reconstruction of intra-articular rent study, the decision to proceed osteoporotic bone, or both, as often is defects, rigid internal fixation, iliac with TEA was based on poor bone found in the elderly.