DOCSLIB.ORG

The Cosmic Fugue: Exploring Musical Metaphors in Astronomy

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Cosmic Fugue: Exploring Musical Metaphors in Astronomy The Cosmic Fugue: Exploring Musical Metaphors in Astronomy (Webb, 2013) Lydia Kooistra Master Thesis Comparative Cultural Analysis Thesis Advisor: Murat Aydemir Student number: 6138772 7 May, 2016 1 Table of Contents Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 3 Examples of musical metaphors in media for the dissemination of astronomy .................. 5 Sonic phenomena ............................................................................................................. 6 The Big Bang ..................................................................................................................... 7 The spectrum of electromagnetic radiation ..................................................................... 8 String theory ..................................................................................................................... 9 Ornamental musical metaphors ....................................................................................... 9 Chapter 1: Conceptual Metaphor Theory .............................................................................. 11 Linguistic form or conceptual metaphor ............................................................................ 11 MIP and MIPVU .................................................................................................................. 12 Conventionalized grammar or specific situations of usage ................................................ 13 Determining the similarities ............................................................................................... 15 Primary and complex conceptual metaphors .................................................................... 16 Discourse metaphors ......................................................................................................... 17 Chapter 2: Cosmos case study ................................................................................................ 19 Description case study ....................................................................................................... 19 Analysis Cosmos case study ............................................................................................... 24 Identifying source and target domains .......................................................................... 24 Grammar or usage? ........................................................................................................ 27 Identifying the conceptual metaphor ............................................................................. 28 Chapter 3: Case Study String Theory ...................................................................................... 30 Description case study ....................................................................................................... 30 Analysis String Theory case study ...................................................................................... 32 Identifying source and target domains .......................................................................... 32 Grammar or usage? ........................................................................................................ 34 Identifying the conceptual metaphor ............................................................................. 35 Chapter 4: Comparison case studies ...................................................................................... 37 Summary ............................................................................................................................ 37 Comparison ........................................................................................................................ 37 Discourse Metaphor Approach .......................................................................................... 38 Chapter 5: Harmony of the Spheres ....................................................................................... 41 Origins of Harmony of the Spheres .................................................................................... 41 The Scientific Revolution .................................................................................................... 43 2 Kepler’s Harmonic Law ....................................................................................................... 46 Music as a model at the beginning of modern science ...................................................... 49 Conclusion .............................................................................................................................. 52 Summary ............................................................................................................................ 52 Music’s Sublime Quality ..................................................................................................... 53 Topics for further research ................................................................................................. 56 Bibliography ........................................................................................................................... 57 3 Introduction Music and astronomy are seemingly unrelated subjects that, at first glance, have no overlap in academia or in our day-to-day lives. The study of astronomy and the study of music (whether practical or theoretical) have no shared discourse. Indeed, these two studies could be regarded as representatives of the ‘two cultures’. The theory of ‘two cultures’ describes the gap between the sciences and the humanities and how the intellectuals of these fields have such different approaches, methods and behaviors that it is as if they belong to different cultures (Snow, 2012). Despite this lack in overlap between these two subjects, an interesting and contradicting trend can be observed in media meant for the dissemination of astronomy like documentaries, nonacademic articles, TED talks and educational YouTube videos. This trend involves the recurrent use of musical metaphors to explain complex astronomical concepts or phenomena to audiences unfamiliar to the field. For example, string theory is rarely explained to laymen without the use of the metaphor of a guitar or violin string that when plucked produces musical notes that represent the elementary particles that are produced by the frequency of the vibration of elementary strings. Apart from that, documentaries and nonacademic articles about astronomy are shot-through with terms like ‘celestial symphony’, ‘planetary orchestra’, ‘soundtrack of the universe’, and ‘space rings like a drum’. This metaphorical trend raises a number of questions. What is it about these musical metaphors that is particularly functional in this context? Does this trend have a basis in culture or history, or does it arise from a predisposition in human cognition that links these two subjects? What does this metaphorical trend imply about how we value music? Ultimately, the question I will try to answer in this thesis is as follows: why has the metaphorical trend that explains astronomical concepts in musical terms manifested itself in astronomy dissemination? By answering this question, I aim to be able to draw conclusions about the implications of this metaphorical trend for how music is viewed and valued in society. I aim to answer the question by analyzing two case studies that make use of musical metaphors in the context of astronomy dissemination. The analysis of these two case studies is useful to gain a comparative perspective. One of the case studies is a novel 4 example of a musical metaphor that is used in an episode of the popular 1980s astronomy series produced by Carl Sagan, Cosmos: A Personal Voyage (1980). Throughout this thesis, I will refer to this cast study as the Cosmos case study. This novel case study is relevant in relation to my second case study which will deal with a more general and consistently used example of a musical metaphor. It has been drawn upon by many scientists in many different sources over a period of almost 30 years. This is the string theory metaphor that I have mentioned previously, which is used to explain string theory in terms of the strings of a violin or guitar. I will discuss the general use of this metaphor, but I will pay special attention to a passage in the source that popularized this metaphor. I will refer to this case study as the the String Theory case study. The comparison of these very different types of case studies is helpful for determining if, despite their differences, they have a similar basis and, if so, whether this basis is historical, cultural or conceptual. I have identified Conceptual Metaphor Theory (CMT) as a useful theory through which to analyze the musical metaphors in these case studies. This hermeneutic approach focuses on the role metaphor plays in conventional language rather than its ornamental use in literature and poetry. Furthermore, CMT not only shows how metaphors structure everyday conventional language, but also thought. This theory was established in 1980 with linguist George Lakoff’s and philosopher Mark Johnson’s groundbreaking book Metaphors We Live By. I will draw upon their work as well as work by other linguists and metaphor theorists such as Gerard Steen, Zoltán Kövecses, Joe Grady, Jörg Zinken, Iina Hellsten and Brigitte Nerlich who amongst others, have formalized, criticized, and developed this theory throughout the years. The first chapter of this thesis will be devoted
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Cosmos: a Spacetime Odyssey (2014) Episode Scripts Based On
    Cosmos: A SpaceTime Odyssey (2014) Episode Scripts Based on Cosmos: A Personal Voyage by Carl Sagan, Ann Druyan & Steven Soter Directed by Brannon Braga, Bill Pope & Ann Druyan Presented by Neil deGrasse Tyson Composer(s) Alan Silvestri Country of origin United States Original language(s) English No. of episodes 13 (List of episodes) 1 - Standing Up in the Milky Way 2 - Some of the Things That Molecules Do 3 - When Knowledge Conquered Fear 4 - A Sky Full of Ghosts 5 - Hiding In The Light 6 - Deeper, Deeper, Deeper Still 7 - The Clean Room 8 - Sisters of the Sun 9 - The Lost Worlds of Planet Earth 10 - The Electric Boy 11 - The Immortals 12 - The World Set Free 13 - Unafraid Of The Dark 1 - Standing Up in the Milky Way The cosmos is all there is, or ever was, or ever will be. Come with me. A generation ago, the astronomer Carl Sagan stood here and launched hundreds of millions of us on a great adventure: the exploration of the universe revealed by science. It's time to get going again. We're about to begin a journey that will take us from the infinitesimal to the infinite, from the dawn of time to the distant future. We'll explore galaxies and suns and worlds, surf the gravity waves of space-time, encounter beings that live in fire and ice, explore the planets of stars that never die, discover atoms as massive as suns and universes smaller than atoms. Cosmos is also a story about us. It's the saga of how wandering bands of hunters and gatherers found their way to the stars, one adventure with many heroes.
    [Show full text]
  • Library Development Review 2019–2020
    2 6 12 18 22 24 26 28 31 34 35 36 ROBIN A. BEDENBAUGH University Libraries, editor-in-chief CATHY JENKINS University Libraries, art director SHELLY O’BARR University Libraries, 38 42 photographer MARTHA RUDOLPH University Libraries, contributing editor DONNA SPENCER UT Creative Communications, copy editor 44 CHRISTINE WHITE University Libraries, Scholarly works managing editor 46 Endowments The Library Development Review is published annually for 50 supporters of the University of Tennessee Libraries and all members of the Volunteer family. Advancement Marketing and Communications 54 University of Tennessee Libraries 1015 Volunteer Boulevard John C. Hodges Society Knoxville, Tennessee 37996-1000 56 ON THE COVER: You Cannot Put a Fire Out, by Susan Lowdermilk n the UT campus, the libraries are In ordinary times, a steady stream of library-hosted both the cornerstone of teaching events introduce students to our collections and and learning and a hub of everyday services or simply engage students—personally, socially, student life. Our connections with and academically—with college life. We cohost events students, faculty, and campus and workshops with many campus partners that—like partners have served us well over the libraries—are focused on student success. The Judith this past year, as the COVID-19 pandemic changed the Anderson Herbert Writing Center, for instance, is a library landscape in profound and unforeseen ways. frequent cosponsor of events such as our end-of-term Writing Blitz. To protect the health of the student population, the university asked students to stay home after the 2020 Our growing suite of nontraditional learning spaces— spring break and participate in online classes from their eventually to include the Medbery Makerspace and primary residences.
    [Show full text]
  • Hiding from the Light Free Ebook
    FREEHIDING FROM THE LIGHT EBOOK Barbara Erskine | 528 pages | 19 Feb 2009 | HarperCollins Publishers | 9780007288632 | English | London, United Kingdom DIY cabinet lighting (and how to hide it!) from Thrifty Decor Chick The episode explores properties of light, cameras, the scientific methodand the composition of the universe. The episode includes a look at the contributions of the 10th century physicist Ibn al-Haythamdescribed as the "father of the Hiding from the Light scientific method". The episode was received positively by critics, with many remarking on the brilliant visuals of the end sequence completed with Rhapsody in Blue "showcasing the same image Hiding from the Light New York City, viewed through the filters of various wavelengths of light: visible, infrared, ultraviolet, X-ray, gamma ray, microwave, and even a radio image". This episode explores the wave theory of light as studied by mankind, noting that light has played an Hiding from the Light role in scientific progress, with such early experiments from over years ago involving the camera obscura by the Chinese philosopher Mozi. Tyson describes the work of the 11th century Arabic scientist Ibn al-Haythamconsidered to be one of Hiding from the Light first to postulate on the nature of light and optics leading to the concept of the telescopeas well as one of the first researchers to use the scientific method. Tyson proceeds to discuss the nature of light as discovered by mankind. Work by Isaac Newton using refraction through prisms demonstrated that light was composed of the visible spectrumwhile findings of William Herschel in the 19th century showed that light also consisted of infrared rays.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Exploring the Cosmos: the Rhetoric of Successful
    EXPLORING THE COSMOS: THE RHETORIC OF SUCCESSFUL SCIENCE TELEVISION By ALEXANDREA MATTHEWS A THESIS PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS IN MASS COMMUNICATION UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2015 1 © 2015 Alexandrea Matthews 2 To my mom, Dina Matthews, for the never-ending love, encouragement, and support 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I thank my chair, Dr. Debbie Treise, who not only guided me through my thesis but my entire graduate school experience. She has been patient and always accommodating, answering my many questions by e-mail almost immediately, even on weekends, and always found time for me despite her busy schedule. Through the research, coding, and analysis, she has always offered me invaluable insight and editing. I could not be more grateful to have had such a caring, supportive, and experienced thesis chair, advisor, and professor. Thank you for always going above and beyond in these roles. I also thank my other two committee members, Dr. Johanna Cleary and Dr. Elizabeth Lada. They have been supportive and enthusiastic about my research from the beginning and have offered me guidance that really shaped my methodology and research. Dr. Cleary gave me insight from her expertise in telecommunications and offered many great suggestions. Dr. Lada helped me from her expertise in astronomy, as both a committee member and a professor, who gave me the knowledge to approach my thesis from a more informed perspective. I am so thankful to have had such an experienced, diverse committee which could offer me guidance from multiple areas.
    [Show full text]
  • Hiding from the Light Free
    FREE HIDING FROM THE LIGHT PDF Barbara Erskine | 528 pages | 19 Feb 2009 | HarperCollins Publishers | 9780007288632 | English | London, United Kingdom Hiding in the Light - Wikipedia Goodreads helps you keep Hiding from the Light of books you want to read. Want to Read saving…. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Other editions. Enlarge Hiding from the Light. Error rating book. Refresh and try again. Open Preview See a Problem? Details if other :. Thanks for telling us about the problem. Return to Book Page. Preview — Hiding in the Light by Rifqa Bary. Hiding in the Light by Rifqa Bary. Rifqa Bary grew up in a devout Muslim home, obediently following her parents' orders to practice the rituals of Islam. But God was calling her to freedom and love. He was calling her to true faith. He was calling her to give up everything. Leaving Islam for Christianity cost her more than she imagined but gave more than she could have dreamed. Hiding in the Light is the st Rifqa Bary grew up in a devout Muslim home, obediently following her parents' orders to practice the rituals of Islam. Hiding in the Light is the story of Rifqa's remarkable spiritual journey from Islam to Christianity. It is also the untold story of how she ran from her father's threats to find refuge with strangers in Florida, only to face a controversial court case that reached national headlines. Most of Hiding from the Light, it is the Hiding from the Light of a young girl who made life-changing sacrifices to follow Jesus-and who inspires us to do the same.
    [Show full text]
  • Neil Degrasse Tyson, Answers Our Questions About the 'Cosmos
    RocketSTEMVol. 2 • No. 2 • March 2014 • Issue 6 Neil deGrasse Tyson, answers our questions about the ‘Cosmos’ Spitzer turns 10: Gets a new life An engineer’s work: Boeing’s V-22 Osprey Bigelow envisions a future of inflatable space habitats And much more inside... Photo: Mike Killian NASA launches third generation communications satellite Photo: Mike Killian NASA’s Tracking and Data Relay Satellite L (TDRS-L), the 12th spacecraft in the agency’s TDRS Project, is safely in or- bit after launching January 23 aboard a United Launch Alli- ance Atlas V rocket from Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. Ground controllers report the satellite – part of a network providing high-data-rate communications to the Internation- al Space Station, Hubble Space Telescope, launch vehicles and a host of other spacecraft – is in good health at the start of a three-month checkout by its manufacturer, Boeing Space and Intelligence Systems of El Segundo, Calif. “TDRS-L and the entire TDRS fleet provide a vital service to America’s space program by supporting missions that range from Earth-observation to deep space discoveries,” said NASA Administrator Charles Bolden. The mission of the TDRS Project, established in 1973, is to support NASA’s space communications network. This net- work provides high data-rate communications. The TDRS fleet began operating during the space shuttle era with the launch of TDRS-1 in 1983. Of the 11 TDRS space- craft placed in service to date, eight still are operational. TDRS-M, the next spacecraft in this series, is on track to be ready for launch in late 2015.
    [Show full text]
  • Methods, Theoretical Frameworks and Hope for Knowledge Organization
    358 Knowl. Org. 43(2016)No.5 D. Martínez-Ávila and J. Beak. Methods, Theoretical Frameworks and Hope for Knowledge Organization Methods, Theoretical Frameworks and Hope for Knowledge Organization Daniel Martínez-Ávila* and Jihee Beak** * São Paulo State University—UNESP, Graduate School of Information Science, Av. Hygino Muzzi Filho, 737, Marília, São Paulo, Brazil, 17525-900, <[email protected]> ** University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee (UWM), Office of Assessment and Institutional Research, 2310 E. Hartford Ave., Milwaukee, WI 53211, USA, <[email protected]> Daniel Martínez-Ávila is Assistant Professor at the Department of Information Science, São Paulo State Uni- versity (UNESP), Marília, Brazil. He is a member of the Theoretical Foundations of Information and Infor- mation Organization (Formação e Atuação Profissional em Organização da Informação, FAPOI) research groups. He also collaborates with the Satija Research Foundation for Library and Information Science (SRFLIS), India, and the Institute for Gender Studies (IEG) at the University Carlos III of Madrid, Spain. Jihee Beak has a PhD in information studies from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. She is a member of the Knowledge Organization Research Group, School of Information Studies, University of Wisconsin Mil- waukee, and Assistant to the Editor-in-Chief of Knowledge Organization. Her major research area is knowledge organization including metadata, children’s information seeking behavior, domain analysis, social tagging, sub- ject headings, classification theory, etc. Her dissertation is a child-driven metadata schema based on children’s book selection behavior study. Martínez-Ávila, Daniel and Jihee Beak. 2016. “Methods, Theoretical Frameworks and Hope for Knowledge Organization.” Knowledge Organization 43: 358-366.
    [Show full text]
  • Cosmos Quest Episode 5
    Quests and Discussions! for Students, Episode 5 Written by Ann Druyan Produced by Cosmos! Studios Overview Episode 5, “Hiding in the Light,” is about the various meanings of light and enlightenment – curiosity about light as a motive force in discovery and the critical role of free inquiry in the !history of science. Grade Levels !6-12 Episode Summary The keys to the cosmos have been lying in plain sight all along. Light, itself, holds so many of them, but we never realized they were there until we learned the basic rules of science. A quirk of light may have moved us to paint our first pictures in pre-historic times. The natural phenomenon of the camera obscura is explained. Our earliest experiments with light begin with a two thousand year old Chinese movie described by the ancient philosopher, Mozi. The violent suppression of his work, free thought and speech by China’s first emperor make us an eyewitness to history’s first book- burning. We visit the Europe and North Africa of the 11th century, to the golden age of Islam, when Arabic was the language of science. While there, we encounter Ibn al-Hazen, the physicist who first understood and demonstrated experimentally how we see and how light travels. These are epochal achievements to be sure, but by no means al-Hazen’s greatest. al- Hazen devised a machine for making countless other discoveries – the scientific method. It is also the true fairy tale of the 19th century penniless Bavarian orphan who was rescued by a prince from the rubble of a house where he labored in indentured servitude.
    [Show full text]
  • Advancing Sylvia Wynter's Reimagination of the Human And
    University of Denver Digital Commons @ DU Electronic Theses and Dissertations Graduate Studies 1-1-2017 Advancing Sylvia Wynter's Reimagination of the Human and Counter-Poetics: A Critique of Contemporary Western Science Discourse in Cosmos—a Spacetime Odyssey, with Host Neil deGrasse Tyson Claire E. Slattery-Quintanilla University of Denver Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd Part of the African American Studies Commons, American Studies Commons, and the Philosophy of Science Commons Recommended Citation Slattery-Quintanilla, Claire E., "Advancing Sylvia Wynter's Reimagination of the Human and Counter- Poetics: A Critique of Contemporary Western Science Discourse in Cosmos—a Spacetime Odyssey, with Host Neil deGrasse Tyson" (2017). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 1253. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd/1253 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Studies at Digital Commons @ DU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ DU. For more information, please contact [email protected],[email protected]. Advancing Sylvia Wynter’s Reimagination of the Human and Counter-poetics: A Critique of Contemporary Science Discourse in Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey with Host Neil deGrasse Tyson A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of Social Sciences University of Denver In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts by Claire E. Slattery-Quintanilla June 2017 Advisor: Dr. Armond R. Towns ©Copyright by Claire E. Slattery-Quintanilla 2017 All Rights Reserved Author: Claire E. Slattery-Quintanilla Title: Advancing Sylvia Wynter’s Reimagination of the Human and Counterpoetics: A Critique of Contemporary Science Discourse in Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey With Host Neil deGrasse Tyson Advisor: Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Extra Credit Opportunities
    FRONTIERS IN ASTRONOMY — AST 25 Extra Credit Opportunities About Extra Credit—the Rules Extra credit is a great way to give your class grade a boost. It is also an opportunity for you to explore subject matter in ways that are impossible in the classroom. Take advantage of this chance! Each extra credit has an assigned point value that you will receive if you complete the project to my complete satisfaction. Less-excellent projects will be awarded fewer points. All extra credit assignments must be complete—you cannot hand in an incomplete extra credit and hope for partial points. Rule #1: All extra credit projects must be handed in to me in class, by the deadline indicated on the General Schedule of Activities. Rule #2: You can earn up to 15 extra credit points (equivalent to 5%, or half a grade point). Rule #3: Point limitations may apply to each type of project. See comments for each extra credit category. Rule #4: I grade all answers on factual correctness, but also on grammar, logic, and presentation. Extra Credit #1: Homework overcharge—varies per/semester Each of the homework assignments is worth a certain number of points. However, some may include extra, optional questions for points. There is no penalty for the wrong answer on such questions. Extra Credit #2: Literature report—5 points each Read an online news article (less than 3 months old) with significant content related to the concepts described in this class. The article should be at least 500 words long. Answer the following questions clearly. Each answer should be 30-50 words, although I am not a stickler on this point.
    [Show full text]
  • Ibn Al-Haytham and Scientific Method
    IBN AL-HAYTHAM AND SCIENTIFIC METHOD A Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of Georgetown University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Islamic Studies By Sohrab Ghassemi, M.A. Washington, DC March 3, 2020 Copyright 2020 by Sohrab Ghassemi All Rights Reserved ii IBN AL-HAYTHAM AND SCIENTIFIC METHOD Sohrab Ghassemi, M.A. Thesis Advisor: Jonathan A.C. Brown, Ph.D. ABSTRACT This examination into the history of Arabic science explores the methods utilized by Ibn al-Haytham for his scientific investigations. Specifically, this study compares and contrasts his approach towards establishing the equal angles law of reflection for light in chapter three of book four of his Kitāb al-Manāẓir, or The Book of Optics, with the approach taken by him in his maqālat-u fī mā'īyat-i al- athar-i alladhī fī wajh-i al-qamar-i, or "Treatise on the Nature of the Marks on the Surface of the Moon." The analysis focuses upon his technical usage of the word i‘tibār, and its variants, in order to arrive at the finding that his most advanced method for inquiry into the natural world did not constitute full experimental testing in the sense of the modern scientific method, but rather can best be understood as a type of controlled observation that yet still goes beyond the ancient Greek idea of empeiría (empiricism). Further, when he was able to utilize instrumentation for his research, he also achieved a science of demonstration (apódeixis) with an emphasis upon the repeatability of his findings.
    [Show full text]
  • Arxiv:2007.15198V2 [Astro-Ph.EP] 15 Dec 2020 Disks Around Stars
    Draft version December 17, 2020 Typeset using LATEX modern style in AASTeX63 Formation of \Blanets" from Dust Grains around the Supermassive Black Holes in Galaxies Keiichi Wada,1, 2, 3 Yusuke Tsukamoto,1 and Eiichiro Kokubo4 1Kagoshima University, Graduate School of Science and Engineering, Kagoshima 890-0065, Japan 2Ehime University, Research Center for Space and Cosmic Evolution, Matsuyama 790-8577, Japan 3Hokkaido University, Faculty of Science, Sapporo 060-0810, Japan 4National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, Mitaka 181-8588, Japan ABSTRACT In Wada, Tsukamoto, and Kokubo (2019), we proposed for the first time that a new class of planets, blanets, can be formed around supermassive black holes (SMBHs) in the galactic center. Here, we investigate the dust coagulation processes and physical conditions of the blanet formation outside the snowline (rsnow ∼ several parsecs) in more detail, especially considering the effect of the radial drift of the dust aggregates. 2 2 We found that a dimensionless parameter α = vt =cs, where vt is the turbulent velocity and cs is the sound velocity, describing the turbulent viscosity should be smaller than 0.04 in the circumnuclear disk to prevent the destruction of the aggregates due to collision. The formation timescale of blanets τGI at rsnow is, τGI ' 70-80 Myr for 6 α = 0:01 − 0:04 and MBH = 10 M . The mass of the blanets ranges from ∼ 20ME to 3000ME in r < 4 pc for α = 0:02 (ME is the Earth mass), which is in contrast with 4ME − 6ME for the case without the radial drift. Our results suggest that blanets 42 −1 could be formed around relatively low-luminosity AGNs (Lbol ∼ 10 erg s ) during 8 their lifetime (.
    [Show full text]