2012 Sleg Day59.Pdf

1153

Senate Journal

Second Regular Session of the Fifty-third Legislature of the State of Oklahoma Fifty-ninth Legislative Day, Monday, May 21, 2012

The Senate was called to order by Senator David.

Roll Call:

Present: Adelson, Aldridge, Allen, Anderson, Ballenger, Barrington, Bass, Bingman, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, Crain, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Halligan, Holt, Ivester, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Mazzei, McAffrey, Newberry, Nichols, Paddack, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Sparks, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.—48.

Senator David declared a quorum present.

The prayer was offered by Dr. Dennis Clark, First Christian Church, Guthrie, the guest of Senator Griffin.

REPORT OF ENGROSSED AND ENROLLED MEASURES

SCR 41 was correctly engrossed, properly signed and ordered transmitted to the Honorable House for consideration.

SB 1001 and SCRs 23, 28 and 40 were each correctly enrolled, properly signed and ordered transmitted to the Honorable House for signature of the Speaker.

SR 58 was correctly enrolled, properly signed and ordered transmitted to the Secretary of State. 1154 Senate Journal

UNANIMOUS CONSENT REQUEST MOTION TO RECONSIDER VOTES

Senator Schulz asked unanimous consent, which was granted, to suspend the provisions of Rule 12-21A and that all motions to reconsider votes be disposed of on the same day such notice is served.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on SB 1336 was adopted upon motion of Senator Branan.

SB 1336, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill and emergency, the vote resulted as follows:

Aye: Aldridge, Allen, Anderson, Ballenger, Barrington, Bass, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, Crain, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Halligan, Holt, Ivester, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Paddack, Russell, Schulz, Simpson, Sparks, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--43.

Excused: Adelson, Bingman, Mazzei, McAffrey and Shortey.--5.

The bill and emergency passed.

SB 1336, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered transmitted to the Honorable House.

MOTION TO RECONSIDER VOTE

Senator Justice moved to reconsider the vote whereby HJR 1119 failed, which motion was declared adopted upon roll call as follows:

Aye: Aldridge, Anderson, Barrington, Branan, Brinkley, Brown, Childers, Coates, Crain, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Griffin, Halligan, Holt, Johnson (R), Justice, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Paddack, Russell, Schulz, Simpson, Sparks and Stanislawski.--28.

Nay: Allen, Ballenger, Brecheen, Burrage, Garrison, Ivester, Johnson (C), Laster, Lerblance, Wilson and Wyrick.--11.

Excused: Adelson, Bass, Bingman, Jolley, Mazzei, McAffrey, Shortey, Sykes and Treat.--9.

Fifty-ninth Legislative Day, Monday, May 21, 2012 1155

THIRD READING

HJR 1119 was read for the third time at length.

On the question of passage of the resolution, the vote resulted as follows:

Aye: Aldridge, Anderson, Barrington, Bingman, Branan, Brinkley, Brown, Coates, Crain, David, Eason McIntyre, Fields, Ford, Griffin, Halligan, Holt, Johnson (R), Justice, Marlatt, Mazzei, Newberry, Nichols, Russell, Schulz, Simpson and Stanislawski.--26.

Nay: Allen, Ballenger, Bass, Brecheen, Burrage, Childers, Ellis, Garrison, Ivester, Jolley, Laster, Lerblance, Paddack, Sparks, Sykes, Treat and Wyrick.--17.

Excused: Adelson, Johnson (C), McAffrey, Shortey and Wilson.--5.

The resolution passed.

HJR 1119 was properly signed and ordered returned to the Honorable House.

Senator Schulz moved that the Senate recess to the call of the Chair, which motion was declared adopted.

The Senate reconvened with Senator David presiding.

Senator David questioned the presence of a quorum and ordered the roll called, following which a quorum was declared present.

SCs NAMED

Upon motion of Senator Schulz, Senate conferees were appointed as follows:

SB 929  Newberry, Brinkley, Halligan, Ford, Ballenger, Eason McIntyre

MESSAGES FROM THE HOUSE

Returning the following bill, together with conference committee report thereon, advising adoption of conference committee report and passage of measure as amended:

SB 259 - coauthored by Hardin of the House

The above numbered measure, as amended in conference, was referred for enrollment. 1156 Senate Journal

Advising fourth reading of and transmitting for signature Enrolled HB 3148 and HJR 1124.

The above-numbered enrolled measures were, after fourth reading, properly signed and ordered returned to the Honorable House.

Advising fourth reading of and returning Enrolled SB 1001.

The above-numbered enrolled measure was referred to the Governor.

Advising the signing of and returning Enrolled SCRs 23, 28 and 40.

The above-numbered enrolled measures were transmitted to the Secretary of State.

Advising rejection of CCR to the following bill, requesting further conference and naming same House conferees as follows:

HB 2523 - GCCA

MESSAGE FROM THE HOUSE CONFERENCE COMMITTEE REPORTS

Transmitting the following bills, together with conference committee reports thereon, advising adoption of conference committee reports and passage of measures as amended:

HB 2535 HB 2607

Conference committee reports were read on the above-numbered bills.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on SB 456 was adopted upon motion of Senator Mazzei.

SB 456, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill and emergency, the vote resulted as follows:

Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Mazzei, Newberry, Nichols, Paddack, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--43.

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, McAffrey and Sparks.--5.

The bill and emergency passed.

SB 456, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered transmitted to the Honorable House.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on SB 1235 was adopted upon motion of Senator Mazzei.

SB 1235, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill, the vote resulted as follows:

Aye: Adelson, Aldridge, Allen, Ballenger, Barrington, Bass, Bingman, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Holt, Ivester, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Mazzei, Newberry, Nichols, Paddack, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--43.

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, McAffrey and Sparks.--5.

The bill passed.

SB 1235, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered transmitted to the Honorable House.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on SB 1464 was adopted upon motion of Senator Mazzei.

SB 1464, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill and emergency, the vote resulted as follows:

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, McAffrey, Sparks and Wyrick.--6.

The bill and emergency passed.

SB 1464, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered transmitted to the Honorable House.

EXECUTIVE NOMINATIONS

The following executive nominations have been approved by the Committees named:

Atwood, Malcom J., Norman, to the Oklahoma State Athletic Commission, to serve a three year term ending June 30, 2014, succeeding himself. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Jonathan Nichols.

Blankenship, L. Steven, Broken Bow, to the Board of Trustees for the McCurtain County Higher Education Program, to serve a nine year term ending June 30, 2021, succeeding Gloria Gulley. (Education Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Jerry Ellis.

Brock, John A., Tulsa, to the Oklahoma Capital Investment Board, to serve an unexpired term ending December 31, 2013, succeeding himself. (Finance Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Gary Stanislawski.

Fair, Michael E., Oklahoma City, to the Oklahoma Employment Security Commission, to serve a six year term ending July 2, 2017, succeeding Susan Stoll. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Greg Treat.

Ficken, Richard N., Tulsa, to the Oklahoma State Credit Union Board, to serve a four year term ending October 11, 2016, succeeding Richard Forshee. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Gary Stanislawski.

Gibson, Aulena S., Oklahoma City, to the Quartz Mountain Arts and Conference Center and Nature Park, to serve a seven year term ending June 30, 2019, succeeding Jane Godlove. (Education Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Greg Treat.

Gibson, Jeremy D., Tulsa, to the Oklahoma Board of Private Vocational Schools, to serve an unexpired term ending July 1, 2015, succeeding Andrew Moore. (Education Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Mike Mazzei.

Griesel, David K., El Reno, to the Environmental Quality Board, to serve a five year term ending January 31, 2017, succeeding himself. (Energy Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Ron Justice.

Fifty-ninth Legislative Day, Monday, May 21, 2012 1159

Harrold, Patricia A., Edmond, to the State Textbook Committee, to serve a three year term ending March 1, 2015, succeeding Vicki Vaughan. (Education Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Clark Jolley.

Holt, John R., Chickasha, to the Oklahoma Used Motor Vehicle and Parts Commission, to serve an unexpired term ending June 30, 2014, succeeding Roy Burch. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Ron Justice.

Huckabay, Gary C., Yukon, to the Council of Bond Oversight, to serve a two year term ending September 26, 2014, succeeding Carl Packwood. (Finance Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Rob Johnson.

Mather, Timothy A., Oklahoma City, to the Oklahoma Science and Technology Research and Development Board, to serve a four year term ending June 30, 2015, succeeding himself. (Energy Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Cliff Branan.

Mosley, Johnny R., Chickasha, to the Oklahoma Real Estate Commission, to serve a four year term ending July 1, 2016, succeeding himself. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Ron Justice.

Neville, Robert M., Oklahoma City, to the Oklahoma Securities Commission, to serve an unexpired term ending July 27, 2013, succeeding William Johnstone. (Finance Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Cliff Branan.

Reid, Karl N. Jr., Stillwater, to the Oklahoma Science and Technology Research and Development Board, to serve a four year term ending June 30, 2015, succeeding himself. (Energy Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Frank Simpson on behalf of Senator Jim Halligan.

Rhines, Steven P., Ardmore, to the Oklahoma Science and Technology Research and Development Board, to serve a four year term ending June 20, 2016, succeeding Galynn Beer. (Energy Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Frank Simpson.

Root, P. David, Canute, to the Oklahoma Liquefied Petroleum Gas Board, to serve a four year term ending June 30, 2016, succeeding himself. (Energy Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Mike Schulz.

Ross, Stephen E., Choctaw, to the Oklahoma Used Motor Vehicle and Parts Commission, to serve a six year term ending June 30, 2018, succeeding himself. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Charlie Laster.

Savage, Teresa, Oklahoma City, to the Environmental Quality Board, to serve a five year term ending January 31, 2017, succeeding herself. (Energy Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Cliff Branan.

1160 Senate Journal

Shreve, Terrence L., Barnsdall, to the Oklahoma Used Motor Vehicle and Parts Commission, to serve a six year term ending June 30, 2018, succeeding himself. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Eddie Fields.

Siegfried, Kerry B., Broken Arrow, to the Oklahoma Used Motor Vehicle and Parts Commission, to serve a six year term ending June 30, 2018, succeeding himself. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Mike Mazzei.

Sims, Billy G., Mountain View, to the Environmental Quality Board, to serve an unexpired term ending January 31, 2014, succeeding Sandra Rose. (Energy Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Mike Schulz.

Smith, Terry L., Oklahoma City, to the Oklahoma State Athletic Commission, to serve a three year term ending June 30, 2015, succeeding himself. (Business and Commerce Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Anthony Sykes.

Williford, A. Hearne III, Tulsa, to the Commission on Marginally Producing Oil and Gas Wells, to serve a three year term ending December 31, 2014, succeeding himself. (Energy Committee) Motion to confirm made by Senator Gary Stanislawski.

Motions to confirm the above-named executive nominations were declared adopted upon roll call as follows:

Aye: Adelson, Aldridge, Allen, Ballenger, Barrington, Bass, Bingman, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Holt, Ivester, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Mazzei, Newberry, Paddack, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--42.

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, McAffrey, Nichols and Sparks.--6.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on HB 2684 was adopted upon motion of Senator Ford.

HB 2684, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill and emergency, the vote resulted as follows:

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, McAffrey and Sparks.--5.

The bill and emergency passed.

HB 2684, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered returned to the Honorable House.

GENERAL ORDER

HJR 1116 by Liebmann of the House and Justice of the Senate was called up for consideration.

Senator Justice moved that HJR 1116 be advanced, which motion was declared adopted.

THIRD READING

HJR 1116 was read for the third time at length.

On the question of passage of the resolution, the vote resulted as follows:

Aye: Adelson, Aldridge, Allen, Ballenger, Barrington, Bingman, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Holt, Ivester, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Mazzei, Newberry, Nichols, Paddack, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--42.

Nay: Bass.--1.

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, McAffrey and Sparks.--5.

The resolution passed.

HJR 1116 was properly signed and ordered returned to the Honorable House.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on HB 2390 was adopted upon motion of Senator Bingman.

HB 2390, as amended in conference, was read at length.

1162 Senate Journal

On the question of passage of the bill and emergency, the vote resulted as follows:

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, McAffrey and Sparks.--5.

The bill and emergency passed.

HB 2390, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered returned to the Honorable House.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on HB 2391 was adopted upon motion of Senator Bingman.

HB 2391, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill, the vote resulted as follows:

Aye: Adelson, Aldridge, Allen, Ballenger, Barrington, Bass, Bingman, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Holt, Ivester, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Paddack, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--42.

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, Mazzei, McAffrey and Sparks.--6.

The bill passed.

HB 2391, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered returned to the Honorable House.

UNANIMOUS CONSENT REQUEST DIRECT TO CALENDAR

Senator Brecheen asked unanimous consent to refer SCR 22 direct to the Calendar for consideration, which was the order.

Fifty-ninth Legislative Day, Monday, May 21, 2012 1163

GENERAL ORDER

SCR 22 by Brecheen of the Senate was called up for consideration.

Senator Brecheen moved to amend SCR 22, Page 2, Line 8 ½, by inserting the following: ―THAT, the Chickasaw Nation shall not place the property in trust for the Chickasaw Nation or any other sovereign nation and any action by the Chickasaw Nation to do so shall cause the property to automatically revert to the Oklahoma Tourism and Recreation Department and/or the State of Oklahoma.‖ and by amending the title to conform, which amendment was declared adopted.

SCR 22 was adopted upon motion of Senator Brecheen and referred for engrossment.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on HB 2689 was adopted upon motion of Senator Ellis.

HB 2689, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill and emergency, the vote resulted as follows:

Aye: Adelson, Aldridge, Allen, Ballenger, Barrington, Bass, Bingman, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Holt, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--40.

Excused: Anderson, Crain, Halligan, Ivester, Mazzei, McAffrey, Paddack and Sparks.-- 8.

The bill and emergency passed.

HB 2689, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered returned to the Honorable House.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF HAs

HAs to SB 1866 were concurred in upon motion of Senator Newberry.

SB 1866, as amended by the Honorable House, was read at length.

1164 Senate Journal

On the question of passage of the bill, the vote resulted as follows:

Aye: Adelson, Allen, Ballenger, Barrington, Bass, Bingman, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Holt, Ivester, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--40.

Excused: Aldridge, Anderson, Crain, Halligan, Mazzei, McAffrey, Paddack and Sparks.--8.

The bill passed.

House amendments were properly signed and the above-numbered bill was referred for enrollment.

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The CCR on SB 110 was adopted upon motion of Senator Coates.

Representative Fields asked to be removed as coauthor to SB 110, which was the order.

SB 110, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill, the vote resulted as follows:

Aye: Adelson, Aldridge, Allen, Ballenger, Barrington, Bass, Branan, Brecheen, Brinkley, Brown, Burrage, Childers, Coates, David, Eason McIntyre, Ellis, Fields, Ford, Garrison, Griffin, Holt, Ivester, Johnson (C), Johnson (R), Jolley, Justice, Laster, Lerblance, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Russell, Schulz, Shortey, Simpson, Stanislawski, Sykes, Treat, Wilson and Wyrick.--40.

Excused: Anderson, Bingman, Crain, Halligan, Mazzei, McAffrey, Paddack and Sparks.--8.

The bill passed.

SB 110, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered transmitted to the Honorable House.

Fifty-ninth Legislative Day, Monday, May 21, 2012 1165

PENDING CONSIDERATION OF CCR

The 2ND CCR on SB 1887 was adopted upon motion of Senator Russell.

SB 1887, as amended in conference, was read at length.

On the question of passage of the bill, the vote resulted as follows:

Excused: Anderson, Bingman, Crain, Halligan, Mazzei, McAffrey, Paddack and Sparks.--8.

The bill passed.

SB 1887, together with the conference committee report thereon, was ordered transmitted to the Honorable House.

ELECTRONIC DISTRIBUTION

Pursuant to the provisions of Senate Rule 5-6, copies of the Conference Committee Substitute for SB 1159 have been made available electronically, via e-mail to all Senators and Executive Assistants.

CONFERENCE COMMITTEE REPORTS SUBMITTED

Conference committee reports were read on the following bills:

SB 194 SB 397 SB 1102 - coauthored by Casey SB 1159 - coauthored by Mazzei SB 1320 - coauthored by Simpson SB 1618 - remove Brown and substitute Stanislawski as principal Senate author, and coauthored by Brown of the Senate and Moore of the House

1166 Senate Journal

PENDING SENATE ACTION HOUSE REQUEST FOR CONFERENCE

Upon motion of Senator Schulz, the request of the Honorable House for further conference was ordered granted and change in Senate conferees as follows:

SB 671 – Newberry, Jolley, Johnson (Rob), Ballenger, Sykes and Bass.

CHANGE IN CONFEREES

Advising change in Senate conferees as follows:

SB 1419 – remove GCCA and add Shortey, Jolley, Allen, Childers, Paddack and Laster.

MESSAGES FROM THE HOUSE CONFERENCE COMMITTEE REPORTS

Transmitting the following bills, together with conference committee reports thereon, advising adoption of conference committee reports and passage of measures as amended:

HB 1985 - coauthored by Scott and Ritze of the House HB 2510 HB 2563 - coauthored by Scott of the House HB 2582 - coauthored by Scott of the House HB 2646 HB 2647 HB 2683 HB 2787 HB 2939 HB 3134 - coauthored by Scott of the House

Conference committee reports were read on the above-numbered bills.

MESSAGES FROM THE HOUSE

Advising rejection of CCR to the following bill, requesting further conference and naming same House conferees as follows:

HB 2396 - Conference Committee on Public Safety, Judiciary and Military Affairs

Fifty-ninth Legislative Day, Monday, May 21, 2012 1167

Advising passage of and returning the following Engrossed bill:

SJR 91 - coauthored by Scott of the House

The above-numbered measure was referred for enrollment.

Senator Schulz moved that when the clerk's desk is clear, the Senate stand adjourned to convene Tuesday, May 22, 2012, at 10:00 a.m., which motion prevailed.

SECOND READING

The following were read for the second time and referred to committee as indicated:

SB 1988  Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget SB 1989  Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget SB 1990  Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget SB 1991  Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget

COMMITTEE REPORTS

The following were reported by the committees named, ordered printed and placed on the Calendar:

DO PASS:

SB 1960  Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Jolley, Justice, Marlatt, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Wilson

House: Ayes: Armes, Cox, Dorman, Peters, Billey, Dank, Liebmann, Sears, Blackwell, Denney, Martin (Scott), Brown, DeWitt, Nays: McPeak

DO PASS AS AMENDED:

SB 1968 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Wilson, Justice, Jolley

1168 Senate Journal

House: Ayes: Armes, Dank, Liebmann, Peters, Billy, Denney, Martin (Scott), Sears, Blackwell, DeWitt, Nelson Nays: Brown, Cox, Dorman, McPeak

SB 1973 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Justice, Jolley Nays: Wilson

House: Ayes: Armes, Cox, DeWitt, Nelson, Billy, Dank, Dorman, Peters, Blackwell, Denney, Liebmann Nays: Brown, Martin (Scott), McPeak, Sears

SB 1974 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Justice, Jolley Nays: Wilson

House: Ayes: Armes, Dank, Dorman, Nelson, Billy, Denney, Liebmann, Peters, Cox, DeWitt, Martin (Scott), Sears Nays: Blackwell, Brown, McPeak

SB 1975 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Justice, Jolley, Bingman Nays: Wilson

House: Ayes: Armes, Dank, Liebmann, Peters, Billy, Denney, Martin (Scott), Sears, Cox, DeWitt, Nelson Nays: Blackwell, Brown, Dorman, McPeak

SB 1979 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Wilson, Justice, Jolley, Bingman

Fifty-ninth Legislative Day, Monday, May 21, 2012 1169

House: Ayes: Armes, Dank, Liebmann, Sears, Billy, Denney, Martin (Scott), Brown, DeWitt, Nelson, Cox, Dorman, Peters Nays: Blackwell, McPeak

SB 1980 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Wilson, Justice, Jolley, Bingman

House: Ayes: Billy, Dank, Martin (Scott), Sears, Blackwell, DeWitt, McPeak, Brown, Dorman, Nelson, Cox, Liebmann, Peters Nays: Armes, Denney

SB 1983 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Wilson, Justice, Jolley, Bingman

House: Ayes: Armes, Cox, Dorman, Nelson, Billy, Dank, Liebmann, Peters, Blackwell, Denney, Martin (Scott), Sears, Brown, DeWitt, McPeak

SB 1984 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Wilson, Justice, Jolley

House: Ayes: Armes, Cox, Dorman, Nelson, Billy, Dank, Liebmann, Peters, Blackwell, Denney, Martin (Scott), Sears, Brown, DeWitt, McPeak

SB 1985 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Wilson, Justice, Jolley

House: Ayes: Armes, Dank, Liebmann, Sears, Billy, Denney, Martin (Scott), Blackwell, DeWitt, Nelson, Cox, Dorman, Peters Nays: Brown, McPeak

1170 Senate Journal

SB 1988 – Joint Committee on Appropriations and Budget Senate: Ayes: Branan, Brinkley, David, Ford, Griffin, Marlatt, Newberry, Nichols, Stanislawski, Sykes, Wilson, Justice, Jolley

House: Ayes: Armes, Dank, Liebmann, Peters, Billy, Denney, Martin (Scott), Sears, Cox, DeWitt, Nelson Nays: Blackwell, Brown, Dorman, McPeak

MESSAGE FROM THE GOVERNOR

Advising her approval May 21, 2012, of Enrolled SBs 1108, 1131 and 1865.

Pursuant to the Schulz motion, the Senate adjourned at 4:55 p.m. to meet Tuesday, May 22, 2012, at 10:00 a.m.