In the Suburbs

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

In the Suburbs EAL IN THE SUBURBS A History of the ...jelt Town Program 1935 -195>4 $10.00 THE NEW DEAL IN THE SUBURBS A History of the Greenbelt Town Program, 1935-1954 by Joseph L. Arnold For as long as man has been building cities, families wealthy enough to arrange it have sought to escape the clangers and discomforts of urban life by removing themselves to the suburbs. As early as the 1820s, American real estate firms were advertising suburban homes for the commuter who wished to combine the advan­ tages of life in the country with the conveniences of the city; and throughout the nineteenth cen­ tury, extensive suburban settlements grew up around every American city. By the end of the period, indeed, settlements that had once marked the outer limit of the urban fringe had been passed over by newer waves of refugees, all in eager pursuit of the new and inevitably larger homes that had become accessible as a result of the steady extension of the rail and trolley lines. Unfortunately, the once bucolic residences abandoned by the wealthy turned rather quickly into wretched slums. A tangle of telephone poles replaced the once luxuriant trees; factories and stores usurped the few remaining open spaces; and the old, spacious houses of the suburbanites were subdivided into smaller quarters intended for less affluent dwellers. In the 1930s, during the administration of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, the federal gov­ ernment undertook a major project in city plan­ ning that was designed to alter, radically and dramatically, what had become a wasteful and unhealthy pattern of urban growth. The plan was to establish, at locations separated at a consider­ able distance from the sprawling and crowded (Continued on back flap) The New Deal in the Suburbs THE NEW DEAL IN THE SUBURBS A History of the Greenbelt Town Program 1935-1954 JOSEPH L. ARNOLD OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY PRESS Standard Book Number: 8142-0153-9 Library of Congress Catalogue Card Number: 74-141494 Printed in the United States of America Copyright © 1971 by the Ohio State University Press All Rights Reserved TO MY MOTHER AND TO THE MEMORY OF MY FATHER CONTENTS Acknowledgments ix Introduction xi CHAPTER 1 Suburbs and New Towns before the New Deal 3 CHAPTER 2 Origins of the Suburban Resettlement Program 24 CHAPTER 3 Conflicts in the Formation of the Greenbelt Town Program 36 CHAPTER 4 Land Acquisition 54 CHAPTER 5 Planning of the Greenbelt Towns 83 VII VUi CONTENTS CHAPTE K 6 Unemployment Relief: Construction of the Towns 110 CHAPTE R 7 The Decision to Retain Federal Ownership 124 CHAPTE R 8 Tenant Selection 136 CHAPTE R 9 Federal Management 148 CHAPTE R 10 Building a Democratic and Cooperative Community 162 CHAPTE R 11 New Frontier or Federal Menace 191 CHAPTE R 12 The War Years 218 CHAPTER 13 Greenbelt Towns for Sale, 1945-1954 229 Conclusion 243 Bibliography 247 Index 265 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This study could not have been completed without the help of dozens of individuals. The greatest debt I owe is to Pro­ fessor Robert H. Bremner, who directed the original project at the Ohio State University. His helpful suggestions, kind en­ couragement, and deep scholarly interest in my work made the entire task as pleasurable as it was instructive. The librarians and archivists with whom I worked were with­ out exception helpful and cheerful in response to my many de­ mands. Particularly helpful were Miss Ruth Erlandson and Mr. Roger Horn, of the Ohio State University Library, who obtained many scattered materials for me. Miss Helen Finneran of the National Archives, Dr. Jacquelen Bull and Miss Clair McCann of the University of Kentucky Library, Miss Elizabeth B. Drew­ ery of the Franklin D. Roosevelt Library, and Mr. Ralph J. White of Records Division of the Public Housing Administra­ IX X ACKNOWLEDGMENTS tion gave me substantial aid in locating materials in their respec­ tive libraries and repositories. I was fortunate in receiving essential information from former administrators of the Resettlement Administration. John S. Lansill of Lexington, Kentucky, gave me complete access to the papers of the Suburban Division, which he fortunately took with him from Washington and placed in the University of Ken­ tucky Library, and also to those papers he retained in his per­ sonal possession. Without his papers the history of the green­ belt town program could not have been written. Other former officials who gave me their smaller collections of papers and pa­ tiently answered all my questions were Tracy Augur, Tilford Dudley, Warren Vinton, C. B. Baldwin, and Albert Mayer. Fi­ nally, I am indebted to a number of citizens in each of the three greenbelt towns who shared with me their remembrances of local events. In preparing this study for publication, I have been aided by a research grant from the University of Maryland Baltimore County, and by the excellent typing services of Mrs. Laura J. Justice of the Secretarial Center. Evelyn Smith, my student assistant at U.M.B.C., helped to prepare the index. Mr. Weldon A. Kefauver, director of the Ohio State University Press, has been most helpful and considerate. Mrs. Susan B. Collins of the editorial staff made many excellent suggestions and saved me from a number of difficult tasks during the various stages of preparation. The entire process has left me with the deep desire to pro­ duce a finished work worthy of the labors of so many kind and dedicated people. Any errors of insight or accuracy are, of course, my own responsibility. J.L.A. October, 1970 INTRODUCTION As long as mankind has been building cities, wealthy families have been escaping the resultant dangers and discom­ forts by removing themselves to suburbs. Suburban estates sur­ rounded the Summerian city of Ur, Imperial Rome, Renaissance Florence, and Elizabethan London. By the 1820s, American real estate firms were advertising suburban houses for com­ muters who wished to combine the advantages of the country­ side with the conveniences of the city. Extensive suburban set­ tlements developed during the nineteenth century—infiltrating nearby villages, creeping out along highways and rail lines, and gradually filling in the open fields. By the end of the century many of these settlements on the urban fringe had been passed over by new waves of suburbanites seeking newer and larger homes now available through the extension of railroads and trol­ ley lines. Increasing numbers of old suburban settlements had XI XU INTRODUCTION degenerated into slums—the trees replaced by telephone poles, the remaining open spaces filled with factories and stores, the old spacious houses subdivided for new, less affluent residents. A few settlements, like Greenwich Village or Georgetown, sur­ vive as quaint (and now very popular) islands in the concrete vastitude; but most were completely submerged. The gasoline engine and superhighway, the enormous growth of urban popu­ lation, and the desire for more and yet more space has greatly accelerated the rate of urban expansion. The cycle of expansion and decay spiraled rapidly and covered much larger areas. The affluent now remove themselves deeper into the countryside, remote from the city and from each other. Central cities and old suburbs are converted into super-slums and ghettos on a scale undreamed of at the turn of the century. In spatial terms alone, the rich and poor have never been so far apart. This study describes one major city planning project under­ taken by the federal government in the 1930s in the hope that it would force a fundamental shift in the wasteful and un­ healthy pattern of urban growth. The greenbelt towns were built to demonstrate that urban expansion by the construction of complete new towns would provide superior safety, conven­ ience, beauty, and a deep sense of community spirit—all at a new low cost. These new suburban towns would therefore pro­ vide a superior environment for families heretofore condemned to live in urban slums. New towns would stop urban decay and end the economic segregation of the suburbs. They would, above all, restore to all classes the warm community life of the rural village without sacrificing the economic advantages of a metropolitan location. This new deal in the suburbs failed. The Roosevelt adminis­ tration never completed the project, and the three half-finished towns were thereby robbed of their full impact. The real estate and construction industry remained unmoved by the greenbelt town demonstration. The federal government washed its hands of new towns until 1968 when it authorized a few very modest aids to new town developers. Why did the New Deal abandon INTRODUCTION Xlll the greenbelt town program? Why did the towns elicit so little response from the public and such a negative one from the real estate and construction interests? Was it the nature of the par­ ticular program under which the towns were built or was it something about the towns themselves? Was the central prob­ lem perhaps the habits of mind of those who saw the towns? To answer these questions requires an analysis of the interac­ tion between the New Deal, city planners, and the welter of interest groups and individuals comprising the American peo­ ple. The specific issue appeared to involve only a few small sub­ urban communities; but the larger implications of the program escaped few of the interested parties. An established pattern of urban life was being challenged. Understanding the history of the greenbelt town program provides a broad hint as to why the suburban developers of the 1970s offer us little more than was offered suburbanites fifty or one hundred years ago. The New Deal in the Suburbs 1 # SUBURBS AND NEW TOWNS BEFORE THE NEW DEAL The men who laid out the greenbelt towns in the 1930s drew on a rich international heritage of town planning theory and experimentation.
Recommended publications
  • Raymond Unwin (1863 – 1940)
    Raymond Unwin (1863 – 1940) Raymond Unwin was born on 2nd November 1863 in Whiston, Rotherham, the younger son of William Unwin, a tutor at Balliol College, Oxford and his wife Elizabeth Sully. He considered entering the Church of England, as his elder brother William did, but he was diverted, to his father's disappointment, into a life of social activism. Unwin was educated at Magdalen College Choir School, Oxford, where he became aware of the Socialist principles of John Ruskin and William Morris. In 1883, he settled in Chesterfield as an engineering apprentice at the Staveley Coal and Iron Company, and came into contact with the Socialist philosopher Edward Carpenter at Millthorpe, Sheffield. In 1885 he obtained a post as an engineering draughtsman in Manchester where he was the local secretary of William Morris's Socialist League, writing articles for its newspaper 'Commonweal'. In 1887 he returned to the Staveley Coal and Iron Company in Barrow Hill as a draughtsman, and although he had no training in architecture, he was working primarily as an architect and was part of the Company team who designed housing at Barrow Hill, Duckmanton and Poolsbrook. At one point, he “offered to resign if bathrooms were not provided to dwellings at Allport Terrace, Barrow Hill.”i Unwin married his cousin, Ethel Parker, in 1893, the same year that he received his first major architectural commission - to build St Andrew’s Church at Barrow Hill. This was completed largely alone, with some collaboration with his brother -in-law, (Richard) Barry Parker. Parker, was staying with the Unwins at Chapel- en-le-Frith when Unwin was building St Andrew’s, and designed a mosaic glass reredos for it.
    [Show full text]
  • The Work of Clarence S Stein, 1919-1939
    W&M ScholarWorks Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects 1977 The Work of Clarence S Stein, 1919-1939 Prudence Anne Phillimore College of William & Mary - Arts & Sciences Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wm.edu/etd Part of the Architecture Commons, History of Art, Architecture, and Archaeology Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Phillimore, Prudence Anne, "The Work of Clarence S Stein, 1919-1939" (1977). Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. Paper 1539624992. https://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21220/s2-thx8-hf93 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects at W&M ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects by an authorized administrator of W&M ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE WORK OF CLARENCE S. STEIN 1919 - 1939 A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Department of History The College of William and Mary in Virginia In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts by Prudence Anne Phillimore 1977 APPROVAL, SHEET This thesis is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts f t . P t R u Autho r Approved, May 1977 1 8 Sii 7 8 8 \ TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE ABSTRACT ....................................................................................... iv INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................... 2 CHAPTER I STEIN'S EARLY LIFE AND THE INFLUENCES ON HIS WORK................... 10 CHAPTER II STEIN’S ACHIEVEMENTS IN HOUSING LEGISLATION IN NEW YORK STATE.. 37 CHAPTER III REGIONAL PLANNING: AN ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION TO THE HOUSING PROBLEM...................................
    [Show full text]
  • Commencement Issue \ ) Of
    Commencement Issue \ ) Of Goodby Now Till Next Year ^ THE BREEZE VOLUME VI HARRISONBURG, VIRGINIA, JUNE 9, 1928 NUMBER 35 A VERY HEARTY WELCOME TO ALL ALUMNAE Final Exercises Alumnae Dinner Recital Is An Baccalaureate Business Meeting Monday Morning To Be Held Tonight Excellent One Sermon Preached Held This Morning Tomorrow . The final Commencement exercises The annual Alumnae dinner is to Last night the students of Music This morning the Alumnae Asso- I will be held in the auditorium of be held tonight in Blue Stone dining and Expression gave an entertain- ciation held its annual meeting in Walter Reed Hall Monday morning at hall. All of the returning alumnae, ing recital at Walter Reed Hall. The The Commencement Service ser- Alumnae Hall. The meeting was nine o'clock. The Commencement ad- together with the members of the following program was presented. mon will be preached Sunday morn- called to order at 9:30 and the re- ,S dress this year is to be delivered by Senior and Sophomore classes who Valse in C Sharp minor ..-. Chopin ing at 11 o'clock in Walter Reed Hall, gular business brought up. The af- Dean W. S. Gray, Ph. D., of the Uni- are graduating, will attend the din- Nelson Chapman by Bishop A. R. Clippinger D. D., of fairs for the past year and those con- versity of Chicago. ner. This social function is always The Nightingale Has a Lyre of Gold the Church of the United Brethren cerning the coming year were dis- n of th high spots of Com in Christ, Dayton, Ohio.
    [Show full text]
  • From York to New Earswick: Working-Class Homes at the Turn of the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Northumbria Research Link From York to New Earswick: working-class homes at the turn of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Cheryl Buckley School of Arts and Social Sciences Northumbria University Newcastle-upon-Tyne England NE1 8ST Work +44 (0) 191 227 3124 - Mob: 07792194339 Home +44 (0) 1325 484877 – Mob: 07814 278168 [email protected] [email protected] word count 3,844 1 How to improve the lives of the working class and the poor in Britain has been a key concern for social reformers, architects and designers, and local and national governments throughout twentieth century, but the origins of this were in the preceding century. From the middle of the nineteenth century, reformers had understood the necessity of improving the living conditions, diet and material environment of those with low incomes. Housing, at the core of this, was increasingly a political issue, but as this case study of the development of a garden village in the North of England demonstrates, it was also a moral and aesthetic one. Moving home from poor quality housing in York city centre to the garden village of New Earswick begun in 1903 symbolised not only a physical relocation a few miles north, but also an unprecedented change in social and material conditions. Life in New Earswick promised new opportunities; a chance to start afresh in carefully designed, better equipped housing located in a rural setting and with substantial gardens. Largely unexplored
    [Show full text]
  • Sir Raymond Unwin Barry Parker Collaborative Work
    Heritage Statement Design and Access Statement PROJECT ‘Sevenways’ 1 College Road, Buxton, Derbyshire, SK17 9DZ Mr N Sheikh 16th April 2018 Revision C Sevenways, 1 College Road, Buxton CONTENTS PAGE INTRODUCTION 3 01 - HERITAGE STATEMENT 4 02 - HERITAGE IMPACT ASSESSMENT 21 03 - DESIGN & ACCESS STATEMENT 28 04 - PLANNING POLICY STATEMENT 31 Sevenways, 1 College Road, Buxton INTRODUCTION This report has been prepared to accompany the The current owners bought ‘Sevenways’, application for planning listed building consent approximately 15 years ago. They were for the property known as ‘Sevenways’ 1 College passionate about owning a house designed by Road, Buxton. Parker and Unwin and they have researched and understood the significance of the architects and The proposals are for a change of use from the house. current single dwelling, previously used as a bed and breakfast, into 4 apartments. The proposals At the time of purchase, the house was in poor also enhance the Grade II listed building. condition following little maintenance since the conversion. Aside from the division of The house is a three storey semi-detached rooms and major changes, all woodwork and property, with cellar and was constructed in 1886. internal stone was covered by modern paint. The house was designed by Barry Parker and During maintenance they have sympathetically Raymond Unwin. Two architects of the Arts and removed these inappropriate finishes, such as Craft movement renowned for their work within the stone column to the hall. However the clients Litchfield Garden City and Hampstead Garden wish to return the house holistically to a more Suburb. sympathetic condition.
    [Show full text]
  • Town Planning in Practice
    Table of Contents E-Book Original PDF Introduction 2 Beginning Credits 3 Preface 3 14 Chapter 1 Of Civic Art As The Expression of Civic Life 4 28 Chapter 2 Of The Individuality Of Towns, With A Slight 12 42 Sketch Of The Ancient Art Of Town Planning Chapter 2 Part 2 24 Chapter 3 Of Formal And Informal Beauty 34 152 Chapter 4 Of The City Survey 41 177 Chapter 5 Of Boundaries And Approaches 48 191 Chapter 6 Of Centers And Enclosed Places 52 212 Chapter 7 Of The Arrangement Of Main Roads, Their 67 272 ……………………..Treatment And Planting Chapter 8 Of Site Planning And Residential Roads 82 326 Chapter 9 Of Plots And The Spacing And Placing Of 93 356 ……………………..Buildings And Fences Chapter 10 Of Buildings, And How The Variety Of Each Must 104 397 Be Dominated By The Harmony Of The Whole Chapter 11 Of Co-Operation In Site Planning, And How 113 412 Common Enjoyment Benefits The Individual Chapter 12 Of Building Byelaws 119 423 End Credits 119 1 Introduction This e-book is a direct transcript of the audiobook version of Town Planning in Practice. Images from the original book were not included, however a PDF version of an original scan of the 1909 version of this book can be found at http://raymondunwin.com. This e-book is meant as a companion to the audiobook and a bridge to the images. We hope you enjoy it. Produced by The Overhead Wire Media, 2020 2 Beginning Credits 00:00 The Overhead Wire media presents Town Planning in Practice: An Introduction to The Art of Designing Cities and Suburbs by Raymond Unwin, original publication by T Fisher Unwin London, 1909.
    [Show full text]
  • Garden-Cities-List97-1.Pdf
    JANETTE RAY RARE & OUT OF PRINT BOOKS Tel: 01904 623088 Fax: 01904 620814 Email: [email protected] Website: www.janetteray.co.uk 8 Bootham, York YO30 7BL UK Handlist 97 The Garden Cities Movement 1. ALLEN, Gordon. The Cheap Cottage and Small House London B T Batsford nd 1919 Sixth revised edition enlarged. x +142 + [2]pp illustrated with 107 b/w plates including line ills and photographs. Green pictorial cloth using image drawn by the author. Bright copy in slightly worn dust wrapper. Some scattered foxing on end papers. Useful source for garden city houses with illustrations of lesser known garden suburbs including Hull Garden Village, Gretna Green and many others. Draws together contemporary thinking at the time on the design of small cottage homes, including ideas of the Ministry of Works, Raymond Unwin and others. [19066] £38 2. BALLIE SCOTT, M. H. Houses and Gardens London George Newnes Limited 1906 xvi + 247pp + (3)pp illustrated with 17 colour and many b/w plates. Some spotting on end papers and prelims. Decorated end papers. Gilt lettered green cloth. Cloth uniformly darkened else a very good copy of this the first edition of Ballie Scott's study of house design. Includes his own designs from the main period of his career. [Ref: 19176] £380 3. BERSFORD PITE, A(rthur). A Sketch of Town Planning and of Procedure under the Town Planning Act of 1909 Civic Arts Association 1918 20pp, 8vo paper wrappers, title + Civic Arts Association logo on the upper. Spine a little worn at spine else a very good copy.
    [Show full text]
  • Berkeley Planning Journal Volume 20
    UC Berkeley Berkeley Planning Journal Title Roosevelt and Rexford: Resettlement and its Results Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/1277865c Journal Berkeley Planning Journal, 20(1) ISSN 1047-5192 Author Perkins, Kristin L. Publication Date 2007 DOI 10.5070/BP320111906 Peer reviewed eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California 25 Roosevelt and Rexford: Resettlement and its Results Kristin L. Perkins Abstract The Greenbelt Towns program emerged in the late 1930s as a novel demonstration of suburban town planning in three communities: Greenbelt, Maryland; Greendale, Wisconsin; and Greenhills, Ohio. This paper discusses the scattered federal programs and policies from which the Greenbelt Towns emerged and briefly describes two other new town precedents, Ebenezer Howard’s Garden City and the Regional Planning Association of America’s involvement in Radburn, New Jersey. It further examines the physical and social development of the Greenbelt towns, the demonstration’s eventual failure, and how the program influenced and continues to shape government involvement in urban development and housing. Introduction The United States emerged from the boom years of the 1920s to face the Great Depression and hardship it had never known. By 1933 nearly a quarter of the nation’s population was unemployed and up to 60 percent lived in poverty. Cities were in crisis as unemployed and impoverished people constructed shantytowns in public spaces and pleaded for government relief. City planning had yet to achieve prominence and, in the face of economic collapse, was viewed by some as a less than critical task. Though many planners were un- and underemployed in the early 1930s, President Roosevelt’s New Deal provided sudden opportunities for planners to address the country’s economic problems through both urban and rural programs.
    [Show full text]
  • THE RED DECADE by EUGENE LYONS
    THE RED DECADE By EUGENE LYONS THE WE AND DEATH OF SACCOAND v ANZE'ITI Moscow CARRoUSEL Six Sovrsr PLAYS (ed.) WE CoVER THE WoRLn (ed.) AssIGNMENT IN UTOPIA STALIN, CZAR OF Au. THE RusSIAS \ THE RED DECADE The Stalinist Penetration of America ,/ r Eugene Lyons I<! ?~tdi 1 n. ~ ~ 11 __..._,~t..4..i THE BOBBS-MERRILL COMPANY PUBLISHERS INDIANAPOLIS NEW YORK COPYRIGHT, 1941, BY THE BOBBS-MERRILL COMPANY FIRST EDITION PRINTED AND BOUND BY THE COUNTRY LIFE PRESS CORP. G,ARDEN CITY, N. Y., U.S. A. TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER PAGE INTRODUCTION: IN DEFENSE OF RED-BAITING • 9 I THE FIVE AGES OF THE COMMUNIST INTERNATIONAL. 20 II A PARTY Is BoRN • • • • • 29 III BORING FROM WITHIN • • • • 37 IV THE Moscow SoLAR SYSTEM • • 47 v THE AMERICAN PARTY Is PURGED 53 VI A Mn.QUETOAST TAKES COMMAND • 63 VII THE RED DECADE DAWNS • • • 70 VIII FASCISM HAs THE RIGHT OF WAY • 82 IX THE CULT OF RussIA-WoRSHIP. 92 x THE LmERALS INVENT A UTOPIA • • 102 XI APOLOGISTSDo THEIR STUFF • • 114 XII THE RED CULTURAL RENAISSANCE. 128 XIII MoRE PLANETS ARE LAUNCHED • • 141 XIV Moscow Aoor-rs THE TROJAN HoRSE. 158 xv COMMUNISM BECOMES AMERICANISM• 170 XVI THE INCREDIBLEREVOLUTION SPREADS 183 XVII AMERICAN LEAGUE FOR SOVIET w AR MONGERING• 195 XVIII STALIN's CHILDREN'S HoUR IN THE U.SA .. 204 XIX STALIN MUSCLES IN ON AMERICAN LlBOR. • 219 xx RussIAN PURGES AND AMERICAN LIBERALS . 235 XXI HOORAY FOR MURDER! • • • • •• • 246 XXII "FRIENDS OF THE G.P.U." • • • • • 257 XXIII CoCICTAn.s FOR SPANISH DEMOCRACY. 268 XXIV REVOLUTION COMES TO HOLLYWOODAND BROADWAY • 284 xxv AMERICA'S OWN POPULAR FRONT GOVERNMENT 298 XXVI THE TYPEWRITER FRONT • • .
    [Show full text]
  • Trotsky in Mexico: Toward a History of His Informal Contacts with the U.S
    1 Trotsky in Mexico: Toward a History of His Informal Contacts with the U.S. Government, 1937-1940 William Chase Published as “Trotskii v Mekcike. K istorii ero neglasnykh kontaktov s pravitel'stvom SShA (1937-1940)” ("Trotsky in Mexico: Toward a History of His Informal Contacts with the U.S. Government, 1937-1940"), Otechestvennaia istoriia, 4 (July/August 1995), 76-102. On 25 May 1933, Leon Trotsky wrote from his home in exile on the island of Prinkipo in Turkey to the United States Consul in Istanbul requesting “authorization to enter the United States and to remain for a period of three months” in order to conduct historical research on a book that would compare the American and Russian civil wars. To allay anxieties about admitting a committed revolutionary like him into the U.S., the 53 year old former leader of the Red Army assured the Consul that “my journey has no relation whatsoever with any political aim. I am ready to undertake the categorical obligation not to intervene, either directly or indirectly, in the internal life of the United States” during his visit.1 The U.S. Consul forwarded Trotsky’s letter to the State Department which, on 23 June 1933, denied his request because of his political views. The U.S. Consulate in Istanbul received the formal denial on 10 July.2 Given that in early July, Trotsky obtained permission to establish temporary residency in France, his disappointment over the American government’s denial was probably fleeting. From his arrival in Mexico in January 1937 until his death in August 1940, the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Heywood Broun, Benjamin Stolberg, and the Politics of American Labor Journalism in the 1920S and 1930S Christopher Phelps in Th
    Accepted for publication in Labor: Studies in the Working-Class History of the Americas (forthcoming 2018). 2017 Christopher Phelps, moral rights of the author have been asserted. No permission to distribute or reproduce without authorization. Draft: Published version will be available in PDF for sale from Duke University Press. Heywood Broun, Benjamin Stolberg, and the Politics of American Labor Journalism in the 1920s and 1930s Christopher Phelps In the two decades from 1919 to 1939, when labor’s fortunes faltered in the Roaring Twenties only to revive in the Great Depression, and when publishers were consolidating the newspaper industry into corporate chains, Heywood Broun (1888-1939) and Benjamin Stolberg (1891-1951) were two of the most prominent American journalists to focus on labor. As first president of the American Newspaper Guild, Broun is the subject of two admiring biographies by fellow journalists who depict him as a gentle, big-hearted, gin-imbibing, lumbering bear of a man, yet his labor writings have received little analysis.1 Stolberg, practically forgotten today, was once so admired that the Socialist standard-bearer Norman Thomas placed him “easily in the front rank” of that “little company of those men and women who both understand the American labor movement and can help explain it to itself and to others.”2 Juxtaposing the lives and writings of Stolberg and Broun will provide insight into American labor journalism’s interwar achievements and dilemmas, particularly the politics of its coverage. The author gratefully acknowledges comments from Tim Barker, Leon Fink, Nelson Lichtenstein, and Jeff Schuhrke, research leave from the University of Nottingham, and the Martin Duberman Visiting Fellowship of the New York Public Library.
    [Show full text]
  • Albert Glotzer Papers
    http://oac.cdlib.org/findaid/ark:/13030/tf1t1n989d No online items Register of the Albert Glotzer papers Finding aid prepared by Dale Reed Hoover Institution Library and Archives © 2010 434 Galvez Mall Stanford University Stanford, CA 94305-6003 [email protected] URL: http://www.hoover.org/library-and-archives Register of the Albert Glotzer 91006 1 papers Title: Albert Glotzer papers Date (inclusive): 1919-1994 Collection Number: 91006 Contributing Institution: Hoover Institution Library and Archives Language of Material: English Physical Description: 67 manuscript boxes, 6 envelopes(27.7 Linear Feet) Abstract: Correspondence, writings, minutes, internal bulletins and other internal party documents, legal documents, and printed matter, relating to Leon Trotsky, the development of American Trotskyism from 1928 until the split in the Socialist Workers Party in 1940, the development of the Workers Party and its successor, the Independent Socialist League, from that time until its merger with the Socialist Party in 1958, Trotskyism abroad, the Dewey Commission hearings of 1937, legal efforts of the Independent Socialist League to secure its removal from the Attorney General's list of subversive organizations, and the political development of the Socialist Party and its successor, Social Democrats, U.S.A., after 1958. Creator: Glotzer, Albert, 1908-1999 Hoover Institution Library & Archives Access The collection is open for research; materials must be requested at least two business days in advance of intended use. Publication Rights For copyright status, please contact the Hoover Institution Library & Archives. Acquisition Information Acquired by the Hoover Institution Library & Archives in 1991. Preferred Citation [Identification of item], Albert Glotzer papers, [Box no., Folder no.
    [Show full text]