R. William Franklin Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Western New York, United States of America

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

R. William Franklin Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Western New York, United States of America R. William Franklin Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Western New York, United States of America In this essay, I reflect on the identity and tasks of my episcopate; my reflection is rooted in my historical studies of the nineteenth-century American bishop Charles Chapman Grafton (1830–1912) and in my scholarship and research on the Oxford or Puseyite Movement in the Church of England (1833–82). My becoming a bishop is closely related to my previous life as a scholar and teacher of the nineteenth century and to the contemporary demographic and economic challenges to the Anglican tradition in my region of the United States, the Episcopal Diocese of Western New York. In the spring of 1969, I came to the Episcopal Diocese of Fond du Lac in Wisconsin as a Northwestern University undergraduate to do research on Bishop Charles Chapman Grafton in the diocesan archives. My subject was the Belgian Old Catholic communities in Door County with specific reference to Grafton’s deposition of the later wandering archbishop, J. Rene Vilatte. I was attracted to Fond du Lac by clerical scandal, but I went back to Northwestern transfixed by Grafton’s vision of the mission of a bishop in changing times. A seed was planted within me: Grafton’s definition of the mission of a diocese and of a diocesan bishop, particularly in times of crisis, and how that is applicable to the crises of the Episcopal Church in the twenty-first century. I studied next at Harvard University, where my Anglo-Catholicism was nurtured, as was Grafton’s. Grafton was born in Boston in 1830. At the age of fourteen, he was attending the Church of the Advent, which became the principal centre of the Oxford Movement in New England. The Tractarian who most deeply influenced Grafton was E. B. Pusey, one of the leaders of the Oxford Movement, and in 1850 Grafton had already purchased and embraced Pusey’s Paradise of the Christian Soul. Dr. Pusey was also a focus of my PhD dissertation at Harvard and of many of the books and articles I wrote as a seminary professor until 2002. My scholarship acknowledge that from September 1833 John Henry Newman fashioned the Oxford Movement’s Tracts for the Times into instruments for a second, and catholic, reformation. In the Tracts, Newman revived the notion of a communal dimension of the church as the firmest bulwark against ‘all-corroding, all-dissolving skepticism’.1 Yet I wanted church people of our time to recall the many actions that Dr. Pusey took from September 1833 until 1882 to express this recovered communal dimension of Anglicanism through a revival of Eucharistic worship linked to a campaign for building and sustaining parish churches in the new industrial cities of England. For adherents of Pusey, soon known as Puseyites, the Eucharist gave new significance to earth as well as to eternity, to matter as well as to spirit. In Puseyite parishes justice began to flow from the Eucharist: funds for workers’ compensation, funds for worthy burial and distribution centres for clothing, food and other necessities. From 1840 to 1889, the bond between worship and social justice was dramatized in Puseyite parishes in commercial districts. In 1865, Grafton went to England to learn this missional model of Puseyism, which he believed to be the new effective way to operate a parish in an industrial, democratic society and to insure its survival. Grafton discovered the Christian humanism of Puseyism. He wrote, ‘The Movement, of which Dr. Pusey was the center, sought the elevation of mankind and, filled with the love of God, it glowed with an enthusiasm for humanity.’2 Bishop Grafton brought Puseyism to the Diocese of Fond du Lac and to Wisconsin in 1889. As a college senior in 1969, the words and actions of Grafton attracted me as a revolutionary Christian response to an age of revolution. I use this term ‘revolution’ because in 1969 I was right in the midst of the age of the Vietnam War. I was facing the draft and I did not know if I would be shipped far from home. Our great American cities were burning. Even Harvard blew up in the student occupation of University Hall, the police bust of Harvard Yard and all of the chaos that followed. Much that I held to be sacred seemed to be falling apart: the university, and our nation. And yet the Episcopal Church seemed a 1. R. W. Franklin, ‘Pusey and Worship in Industrial Society’, Worship, 57.5 (1983), pp. 386–411. 2. C. C. Grafton, Pusey and the Church Revival (Milwaukee, WI: Young Churchman, 1902), pp. 280–281. solid rock. We had 3,615,643 members and we were growing. This is no longer true. At the present time we have fewer than two million members. Bishop Ian Douglas writes, ‘Seemingly innumerable congregations are struggling with declining membership while precariously eating away at their endowments in order to maintain buildings and programs that serve increasingly fewer and fewer people.’3 When I was elected Bishop of Western New York in 2010, I arrived to find a diocese that had lost 40 per cent of its members in the previous decade. The diocesan staff had been reduced to four full-time and two part-time officers. Fewer than half of our parishes are served by a full-time priest. I have sought to translate Bishop Grafton’s vision of how a bishop and a diocese can respond to such a crisis, a vision he brought to America from the Puseyite Movement in England into three goals for the Diocese of Western New York: 1. Be Sustainable: The primary mission of the diocese is the parishes, their growth in membership and their financial survival through Christian stewardship. 2. The Web of Grace: While dedicated to serving the parishes, the primary community of the church is the diocese itself, its parishes and congregations make up one family. This family must be engaged in the social and economic welfare of all who inhabit our region. The Bishop is Chief Evangelist and Chief Social Missioner. 3. Tell the Story: The glory of Anglicanism is our vernacular tradition. We must worship and preach in language that our contemporaries can understand. The Bishop aims to inspire such cultural translation. What in Grafton’s ministry as bishop speaks to the identity and the tasks of an episcopal bishop in the second decade of the twenty- first century? Grafton felt that his call to Fond du Lac in 1889 was imperative to what was practically a missionary district, not unlike Dr. Pusey’s mission field in the East End of London or to industrial Leeds, but the situation was worse than that. We speak today of the ‘missional church’ at a time of economic and demographic decline of the Episcopal Church. This is exactly what the Diocese of Fond du Lac 3. Ian Douglas in Dwight Zscheile, People of the Way (New York: Morehouse Publishing, 2012), pp. xiv–xv. faced in 1889. Out of thirty-three clergy, only eighteen were actively engaged in ministry. Twenty parishes or missions were without clergy. In the whole diocese only nine parishes were self-supporting. In a number of small towns, missions no longer held services at all, and no one seemed to care that services be resumed. There were two reasons for this disaster. First, as Grafton wrote, ‘poverty was everywhere’.4 The diocese was in a region of economic decline. Once a great centre of the lumber industry, the pine trees of Fond du Lac had mostly been cut down, and the lumber industry was moving west. Lumber interests had built up the small Wisconsin towns, with their little episcopal churches, but now the ‘timber kings’ departed, taking their money with them and leaving behind poverty. Second, the people had lost hope in the church. Many lumber barons had paid for and run the small episcopal churches. There was little or no tradition of the people’s stewardship, so when the lumber barons left, the remaining population focused on their own business enterprises and their struggle for family maintenance. Grafton wrote, ‘The duty and privilege of giving to God, in the way of supporting His Church, was little appreciated.’5 These two points still today almost completely describe the economic and demographic context of my diocese of Western New York, faced with the decline of the steel and car manufacturing industries in the once great industrial city of Buffalo and the loss of shipping traffic on the Erie Canal over the last sixty years. With the collapse of the economy, there grew up a reluctance to contribute financially to an Episcopal Church that seemed to be losing its identity and disappearing in our region. In the nineteenth century, Grafton responded to these challenges in two ways. First, he reshaped the structure of the church’s worship and social justice witness, connecting to those outside the Episcopal Church. He was aware that 70 per cent of the population of the Diocese of Fond du Lac was made up of recent immigrants to the United States. He was willing to develop liturgical parallel developments to reach out to and attract these groups into the Episcopal Church. Former Roman Catholics, mostly Belgians, in Door County, Wisconsin, had broken from the Roman Catholic Church and had become Old 4. C. C. Grafton, A Journey Godward of a Servant of Jesus Christ (Milwaukee, WI: Young Churchman, 1910), p. 154. 5. Grafton, A Journey Godward of a Servant of Jesus Christ, p. 163. Catholics. Grafton permitted the use of the Old Catholic liturgy used in Switzerland in these Belgian parishes that formed a sort of Uniate Church within the Diocese of Fond du Lac.
Recommended publications
  • 1907 Journal of General Convention
    Journal of the General Convention of the Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America 1907 Digital Copyright Notice Copyright 2017. The Domestic and Foreign Missionary Society of the Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America / The Archives of the Episcopal Church All rights reserved. Limited reproduction of excerpts of this is permitted for personal research and educational activities. Systematic or multiple copy reproduction; electronic retransmission or redistribution; print or electronic duplication of any material for a fee or for commercial purposes; altering or recompiling any contents of this document for electronic re-display, and all other re-publication that does not qualify as fair use are not permitted without prior written permission. Send written requests for permission to re-publish to: Rights and Permissions Office The Archives of the Episcopal Church 606 Rathervue Place P.O. Box 2247 Austin, Texas 78768 Email: [email protected] Telephone: 512-472-6816 Fax: 512-480-0437 JOURNAL OF THE GENERAL CONVENTION OF THE -roe~tant epizopal eburib IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Held in the City of Richmond From October Second to October Nineteenth, inclusive In the Year of Our Lord 1907 WITH APPENDIcES PRINTED FOR THE CONVENTION 1907 SECRETABY OF THE HOUSE OF DEPUTIES. THE REV. HENRY ANSTICE, D.D. Office, 281 FOURTH AVE., NEW YORK. aTo whom, as Secretary of the Convention, all communications relating to the general work of the Convention should be addressed; and to whom should be forwarded copies of the Journals of Diocesan Conventions or Convocations, together with Episcopal Charges, State- ments, Pastoral Letters, and other papers which may throw light upon the state of the Church in the Diocese or Missionary District, as re- quired by Canon 47, Section II.
    [Show full text]
  • CSJ Parish Magazine January 2018
    COWLEY ST JOHN PARISH MAGAZINE £1.50 January 2018 COWLEY ST JOHN PARISH MAGAZINE JANUARY 2018 PARISH DIRECTORY The Ministry Team: The Revd. Phil Ritchie The Revd. Ben Williams 07590514884 (preferred) 07540784156 [email protected] [email protected] 01865 242396 The Revd. Dr Sabina Alkire (Associate Priest): 07792505847 The Revd. Susannah Reide (Associate Priest) The Revd. Graeme Napier (Associate Priest): [email protected] The Revd. Canon Robert Wright LVO (Associate Priest) Mrs. Petronella Spivey (Licensed Lay Minister): 01865 724430 Churchwardens: • Mrs. Rosy Hancock (St. Mary & St. John): 01865 242957, [email protected] • Mrs. Zoe Randall (St. Alban): 07818066685, [email protected] Sacristans: • Miss Verona Harris (St. Mary & St. John): 01865 723090 • Mrs. Zoe Randall (St. Alban): see contacts above 2 COWLEY ST JOHN PARISH MAGAZINE JANUARY 2018 Music Directors: • Hilary Davan Wetton (St. Mary & St. John): 07932150822, [email protected] • Susanna Gimson (St. Alban): 01865 793008, [email protected] Parish Treasurer and Administrator: • Mr. Alan Baker (Office in St. Mary & St. John Church) • Office Hours: Tuesday – Thursday, 9:30am – 2:30pm • Tel: 01865 792717 • Email: [email protected] Websites for Cowley St. John Parish: • Main website: www.cowleystjohn.co.uk • Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/cowleystjohn.parish/ • St. Mary & St. John Churchyard Project: www.ssmjchurchyard.org.uk • ‘Home’, an experimental Christian Community in Oxford: www.home-online.org • Magazine issues: http://cowleystjohn.co.uk/parish-magazine Church Street Addresses: • St. Mary & St. John Church, Cowley Road, OX4 1UR • St Alban the Martyr, Charles Street, Oxford, OX4 3AH • Bartlemas Chapel, Cowley Road, Oxford, (turn down the lane next to the vicarage at 271 Cowley Road, OX4 2AJ, and you will reach the chapel at the heart of Bartlemas Village).
    [Show full text]
  • BISHOP GRAFTON 'Greatness of Heart' R.""" ,.• ' " T!
    August 22, 2010 livingchurch.org THE LIVINGCHURCH CATHOLIC EVANGELICAL ECUMENICAL BISHOP GRAFTON 'Greatness of Heart' r.""" ,.• ' ! _" t - Imag ine if all 930 bishops of the Anglican Communion . ... read the same high~quality magazine , week in and week out, and thought of that magazirie as their own. We at THE LIVING CHURCH have decided to make this our goal, through the GIVE A BISHOP TLC project . By making a tax­ bishop . deductib~e contribution to THE LIVING CHURCH for a bishop of the Anglican Communjon, you □ 1 BISHOP==$110 can help us send this vital source of teaching and □ 5 BIS.HOP;S ==$558 encouragement to leade rs in every corner of our . □ 10 BISHO'PS== $1 ,000 □ 25 BIS,HOPS::: $2,500 worldwide family. Please lhdioate any preference far a particular bish.op , province, er region (e .g., Africa , Asia, BISHOP EngJandJ}, er indicate no prefe rence. Name '-- ---=----- ---- - Ad ciress'-- _ __ __ -=-..;_ ____ _ TLC City __ ---'----'--- --- -- - State ___ ____ _ .Zip _ _ _ _ Phone( _ )____ _ __ _ __ _ $110 Emdil _ __ ~- - --- - --- Ma k-eG::M eoks payable t0: The Living Church $550 Faundatian, P.O, Box.514036,Milwauke-e, WI 53208--3436 $1,000 □ €neck □ Mt/VISA. $2,500 Card # ___ ~--- ----- Exp. Dote ___ 3-d igit CGGie Of'rl back__ NOTE:Co st includes international postage Credit Cmd Billing Ad<:lress (if different from abo ve): We will inform you and your Addres s~ -~-------- ~ ­ bishop(s} of your connection, Cit:i,-- - --'----='------- - - - State _____ ___ Zip ___ _ so that you may hold one another in prayer.
    [Show full text]
  • The Episcopate in America
    4* 4* 4* 4 4> m amenta : : ^ s 4* 4* 4* 4 4* ^ 4* 4* 4* 4 THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES GIFT OF Commodore Byron McCandless THe. UBKARY OF THE BISHOP OF SPRINGFIELD WyTTTTTTTTTTTT*'fW CW9 M IW W W> W W W W9 M W W W in America : : fTOfffiWW>fffiWiW * T -r T T Biographical and iiogtapl)icai, of tlje Bishops of tije American Ciwrct), toitl) a l&reliminarp Cssap on tyt Historic episcopate anD 2Documentarp Annals of tlje introduction of tl)e Anglican line of succession into America William of and Otstortogmpljrr of tljr American * IW> CW tffi> W ffi> ^W ffi ^ ^ CDttfon W9 WS W fW W <W $> W IW W> W> W> W c^rtjStfan Hitetatute Co, Copyright, 1895, BY THE CHRISTIAN LITERATURE COMPANY. CONTENTS. PAGE ADVERTISEMENT vii PREFACE ix INTRODUCTION xi BIOGRAPHIES: Samuel Seabury I William White 5 Samuel Provoost 9 James Madison 1 1 Thomas John Claggett 13 Robert Smith 15 Edward Bass 17 Abraham Jarvis 19 Benjamin Moore 21 Samuel Parker 23 John Henry Hobart 25 Alexander Viets Griswold 29 Theodore Dehon 31 Richard Channing Moore 33 James Kemp 35 John Croes 37 Nathaniel Bowen 39 Philander Chase 41 Thomas Church Brownell 45 John Stark Ravenscroft 47 Henry Ustick Onderdonk 49 William Meade 51 William Murray Stone 53 Benjamin Tredwell Onderdonk 55 Levi Silliman Ives 57 John Henry Hopkins 59 Benjamin Bosworth Smith 63 Charles Pettit Mcllvaine 65 George Washington Doane 67 James Hervey Otey 69 Jackson Kemper 71 Samuel Allen McCoskry .' 73 Leonidas Polk 75 William Heathcote De Lancey 77 Christopher Edwards Gadsden 79 iii 956336 CONTENTS.
    [Show full text]
  • Nashotah House
    NASHOTAH HOUSE AN ANGLICAN UNDERSTANDING OF THE THEOLOGY AND PRACTICE OF SANCTIFICATION IN THE THOUGHT OF CHARLES CHAPMAN GRAFTON SECOND BISHOP OF FOND DU LAC A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF NASHOTAH HOUSE IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SACRED THEOLOGY BY THE REVEREND JOHN BERNARD PAHLS, JR, B.MUS., M.DIV. NASHOTAH, WISCONSIN MAY, 2005 With undying love and gratitude to the memory of my parents John Bernard Pahls and Mary Louise Johnson Pahls who never lost faith in their son and gave him unfailing support in all his struggles et soli Deo gloria Copyright ©2005 by John B. Pahls, Jr. All rights reserved. Reproduced online through Anglicanhistory.org 2011 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS THE WRITER wishes to acknowledge the Trustees and Administration of Nashotah House, especially The Very Reverend Gary W. Kriss, D.D., XVII Dean and President, for the revival in 1991 of the summer S.T.M. program which provided him the venue and welcome opportunity for undertaking this project. Thanks are due The Reverend E. Charles Miller, Jr, D.Phil. (Oxon), sometime Associate Professor of Historical and Ascetical Theology in the Michael and Joan Ramsey Chair, the original director of thesis studies, who offered much initial encouragement in the pursuit of the project; The Reverend Charles R. Henery, Th.D., William Schaff Helmuth Professor of Ecclesiastical History and John Maury Allin Distinguished Professor of Homiletics, for his welcome guidance as director following Father Miller’s departure from the faculty of the House, having served originally as second reader; and Canon Joseph A.
    [Show full text]
  • Joseph-Rene Vilatte (1854-1929)
    Joseph-Rene Vilatte (1854-1929) Some aspects of his life, work and succession JOHN KERSEY The WESTERN ORTHODOX UNIVERSITY http://www.thedegree.org COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA MMX ANNO DOMINI 2 The Western Orthodox University The Western Orthodox University, founded in 1945 under Mar Georgius of Glastonbury and since 1977 a constituent part of the Apostolic Episcopal Church, has an ongoing mission to promote research into the smaller Apostolic communions. The University is accredited by the Pontificia Accademia Tiberina, Rome. Website: http://www.thedegree.org 3 This book is respectfully dedicated to: Archbishop Professor Bertil Persson, without whose pioneering research it would not have been possible and Archbishop Francis Spataro, who through the Vilatte Guild has done so much to keep the legacy of Vilatte alive. A.M.D.G. First published in 2011 by European-American University Press Third edition, second impression, published by Lulu Enterprises, 2017. The Western Orthodox University Press, 8, Copthall, Roseau Valley, Commonwealth of Dominica 00152. 4 COPYRIGHT NOTICE This work has been prepared solely for nonprofit educational purposes. This work may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in an effort to advance understanding of educational, religious, historical and social issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in United States Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material in this work is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
    [Show full text]
  • Wisconsin Magazine of History
    (ISSN 0043-6534) WISCONSIN MAGAZINE OF HISTORY The State Historical Society of Wisconsin • Vol. 68, No. 3 * Spring, 1985 ^^^fe^KKjjs THE STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF WISCONSIN RICHARD A. ERNEY, Director Officers WILLIAM C. KIDD, President WILSON B. I'HIEDE, Treasurer NEWELL G. MEYER, First Vice-President RICHARD A. ERNEY, Secretart MRS. L. PRENTICE EAGER, JR., Second Vice-President THE STATE HISTORICAL SOCIEIV OF WISCONSIN is both a state agency and a private membership organization. Founded in 1846—two years before statehood—and chartered in 1853, it is the oldest American historical society to receive coiitiinious public fimding. By statute, it is charged with collecting, advancing, and disseminating knowledge of Wisconsin and of the trans-Allegheny West. Ihe Society serves as the archive ol the State of Wisconsin; it collects all manner of books, periodicals, maps, manuscripts, relics, newspapers, and aural and graphic materials as they relate to North America; it maintains a museum, library, and research facility in Madison as w ell as a statewide system ol historic sites, school services, area research centers, and afliliated local societies; it administers a broad program of historic preservation; and publishes a wide variety of historical materials, both scholarly and popular. MEMBERSHIP in the Society is open to the public. Annual membership is |15, or $12.50 for persons over 65 or members ot affiliated societies. Family membership is S20, or |15 for persons over 65 or members ol affiliated societies. Contributing membership is
    [Show full text]
  • Get Your Grace Vine Electronically!
    The Grace Vine August 2013 Rector’s Writ It seems not many of us are living the reality of that old cliché about how in summer time the “livin’ is easy.” When we look around at the parish family, we don’t see many people just taking it easy. Even in summer, there’s a lot of work and service being done, and we give thanks for that. We also notice changes and transitions going on in life: graduations; college plans; retirement plans; job changes; job plans; people moving from the home they’ve lived in for over 50 years; people looking to make a new home with new beginnings, closer to family. These things take energy and don’t exactly make for easy living either. We notice anniversaries and birthdays with years passing faster than a falling leaf. Sometimes we don’t notice things we should. So God gets our attention by a trip to the ER…or the doctor…or a call from a family member sharing news that’s hard to tell AND hard to hear. Whether we welcome or resist life’s transitions, one thing that helps us through it all is knowing, trusting, believing God is with us. Joining in worship, serving God and one another, ‘bearing one another’s burdens’ (as St. Paul puts it), sharing in fellowship with our Church family…all help us through the changes and chances of this life. Just as we’re helped and strengthened by the grace and love of God, we also count on the prayers and fellowship of our church family to sustain and help us, too.
    [Show full text]
  • Charles C. Grafton, Bishop and Theologian
    Charles C. Grafton, Bishop and Theologian By the Most Rev. Arthur Michael Ramsey Lecture at Nashotah House Theological Seminary, September 26, 1967 Published in Nashotah House Quarterly Review, nd, pp 7-21. ON THE FEAST of S. John the Evangelist 1866 three men took this vow in one another’s presence in the suburb of Oxford known as Cowley. “In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, Amen. I promise and vow to Almighty God, the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, before the whole company of heaven and before you, my fathers, that I will live in celibacy, poverty and obedience as one of the mission priests of S. John the Evangelist unto my life’s end. So help me God.” Two of the men were English, Richard Meux Benson and Samuel Wilberforce O’Neill. One was an American, Charles Chapman Grafton, and it is to him that I am devoting this lecture. I chose this subject partly because his part in the founding of the Cowley Fathers was a significant bond in the history of the Church in England and in America, partly because he had subsequently a creative role in the story of the American Church, and partly because he has things to say to us still as a theologian and a man of God. Charles Grafton was born on April 12, 1830, the son of Major Joseph Grafton and his wife Ann Maria in Boston, and after his early school days he entered the Harvard Law School at the age of twenty-one.
    [Show full text]