Language and Identity on a Male Erotic Hypnosis Messageboard
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works All Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects 9-2019 ‘Its Something You Do Bro’: Language and Identity on a Male Erotic Hypnosis Messageboard Eric Chambers The Graduate Center, City University of New York How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/gc_etds/3443 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] ‘ITS SOMETHING YOU DO BRO’: LANGUAGE AND IDENTITY ON A MALE EROTIC HYPNOSIS MESSAGEBOARD by ERIC NICHOLAS CHAMBERS A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty in Linguistics in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, The City University of New York 2019 © 2019 ERIC NICHOLAS CHAMBERS All Rights Reserved ii 'Its something you do bro': Language and Identity on a Male Erotic Hypnosis Messageboard by Eric Nicholas Chambers This manuscript has been read and accepted for the Graduate Faculty in Linguistics in satisfaction of the dissertation requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Date Cecelia Cutler, Chair of Examining Committee Date Gita Martohardjono, Executive Officer Supervisory Committee: Cecelia Cutler (Chair) Jillian Cavanaugh Michael Newman THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK iii ABSTRACT 'Its something you do bro': Language and Identity on a Male Erotic Hypnosis Messageboard by Eric Nicholas Chambers Advisor: Cecelia Cutler Drawing on a seven-year corpus of data (total words N = 86,881) on a publicly-accessible messageboard on which self-identified gay men discuss their experiences undergoing erotic hypnosis, this study applies Critical Discourse Analysis methods to understand how posters understand their sexual identities and those of others. This study identifies the emergence of two main identity-types at-play on OnYourKnees: the jock and the coach. Jocks are generally characterized by a focus on sports and body-consciousness, a disinterest or inability to engage in scholarly/academic pursuits, and a desire to be submissive to others to achieve sexual pleasure. Coaches, on the other hand, are characterized by wisdom, dominance, and a desire to hypnotize others. Using Fairclough’s (1992) three-axis methodology for analyzing the relationships among language, ideology, and power, this study analyzes how participants on OnYourKnees simultaneously overlap numerous ideological frames, each with their own conceptions of power, onto their senses of Self and Other. On one level, jocks and coaches engage in identity practices largely congruent with ideologies of Americanized hegemonic masculinity, which stress the development of a single type of masculinity that is seen as paramount to all others. Through this framework, self-identified jocks and coaches create and maintain a binary-structure system that places some men (coaches) in positions of power, and others (jocks) in positions of willing subordination. This is demonstrated through an in-depth qualitative analysis of posts on OnYourKnees, the development of a specific ‘direct’ style of hypnotic trance that places listeners in positions of limited agency, and the deployment of orthographic tools that index self-identified jocks and coaches (analyzed using Halliday and Mathiessen’s [2004] Systemic-Function Linguistics). On the other hand, participants simultaneously align with a bondage/discipline/sadism/masochism (BDSM) ideology that stresses the importance of consent among all participants involved, and places both jocks and coaches on ideologically equal footing. Ultimately, this study demonstrates how Critical Discourse Analysis-inspired methodologies can be used to identify how multiple ideologies can be interwoven with identity construction to create and maintain complex subject positions. iv Table of Contents: INTRODUCTION......................................................................................................................... 1 CHAPTER 1: BACKGROUND RESEARCH ......................................................................... 10 Sociolinguistic conceptions of identity: ...................................................................................... 11 Critical Discourse Analysis: ....................................................................................................... 26 CHAPTER 2: DATA AND METHODS .................................................................................... 60 CHAPTER 3: JOCKS, COACHES, AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF IDENTITY .......... 67 Adequation and distinction: ....................................................................................................... 70 Queer Linguistics and Hegemonic Masculinity: ...................................................................... 74 The Jock: contours of identity ................................................................................................... 92 Coaches and OnYourKnees: The representation of dominant identities by dominant posters ..................................................................................................................................................... 124 A quantitative analysis of lemmas JOCK and COACH on OnYourKnees: ........................ 129 Conclusion: ................................................................................................................................ 139 CHAPTER 4: BDSM AND THE DECONSTRUCTION OF SEXUALITY ....................... 141 BDSM ......................................................................................................................................... 144 OnYourKnees and links with BDSM activity: ....................................................................... 155 Tactics of intersubjectivity on OnYourKnees: ........................................................................ 168 Consent: ..................................................................................................................................... 173 Cockiness and Dumbness: The Negotiation of Jock Identity ................................................ 177 Pushing the limits of consent – authorization and illegitimation on OnYourKnees: .......... 185 Conclusion: ................................................................................................................................ 202 CHAPTER 5: THE GENRE OF THE TRANCE .................................................................. 205 Genres, modality, and transitivity within CDA and Systemic-Functional Linguistics: ..... 207 v Hypnosis as a genre: ................................................................................................................. 217 The trance on OnYourKnees: .................................................................................................. 230 Evaluations of trances: ............................................................................................................. 247 Conclusion: ................................................................................................................................ 260 CHAPTER 6: JOCK AND COACH ORTHOGRAPHY ON ONYOURKNEES ............... 262 Process types: ............................................................................................................................ 265 Orthography in action: ............................................................................................................. 285 Orthography and identity ........................................................................................................ 286 Data collection and discussion: ................................................................................................ 292 DJ, CM and the tranced jock: ................................................................................................. 317 Conclusions:............................................................................................................................... 329 CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSION................................................................................................. 332 APPENDIX 1: OCCURRENCES OF YOU WITHIN (9 (CHAPTER 4)), AND RELEVANT MATERIAL PROCESSES: ..................................................................................................... 341 WORKS CITED: ...................................................................................................................... 344 vi List of images: Image 1-1: accompanying image to homepage of OnYourKnees (name of messageboard redacted)…………………………………………………………………………….……………5 Image 3-1: Keanu Reeves (left) in Bill &Ted’s Excellent Adventure (1989) and Seann William Scott (right) in American Pie (1993)…………………………………………...…...108 List of tables: Table 2-1: Average number of posts and words per post among three groups…………….65 Table 3-1: list of uses of lemma JOCK and COACH among all posters on OnYourKnees………………………………………………………………………………….132 Table 3-2: most common modifiers with nominal JOCK among all three groups……..…134 Table 3-3: most common modifiers with nominal COACH among all three groups……..137 Table 5-1: occurrences of you within (10), and relevant material processes………………237 Table 6-1: all instances of JOCK and relevant process types………………………………269 Table 6-2: COACH and relevant processes………………………………………………….279 Table 6-3: Total words conforming to standard American English spelling