CONTRIBUTI SCIENTIFICI

Coprolite specimens from (lower Cretaceous, Southern ): morphological analysis by scanning electron microscopy

G. Russo,1 P. Raia,2 M. Lauteri1

1Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR), Istituto di Biologia Agroambientale e Forestale (IBAF) - Porano (TR), Italy 2Università degli Studi Napoli Federico II, Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra, dell’Ambiente e delle Risorse, , Italy

Corresponding author: Giuseppe Russo Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR), Istituto di Biologia Agroambientale e Forestale (IBAF), Via Guglielmo Marconi 2, 05010 Porano (TR), Italy Tel. +39.0763.37491; Mobile: +39.320.5758929. E-mail: [email protected] only Summary The excavation in the palaeontological site of Pietraroja (, Italy) allowed to discover a large number of coprolites, though a precise stratigraphy would be only conceivable. The microscopic analysis of theuse samples provided valid elements to identify the producer and the palaoenvironment of the icno-fossilization, through the identifications of the inclusions and the possible causes of preservation. The final part of this study presents elements to identify the producer comparing the microscopical evidences of the coprolites with rests of associated fauna, in particular the plausible dental apparatus of a Notagogus pentlandi.

Key words: coprolites, cretaceous, palaeoenvironment, fossils, fish, SEM.

Introduction fossil traces. Though found in beyond 20 countries and from a wide temporal range (Palaeozoic- The Civita di Pietraroja (lat. 41.35; long. 15.55; Quaternary), often the coprolites without inclu- alt. 832 a.s.l.) is a locality on the commercialeastern sions of bones were ignored in spite of the high mountains, 70 km northeast of Naples (Southern paleoecological information about the environ- Italy) (Figure 1). Since the 18th century, the area ment related to. Most of the literature is about cre- was known for the beautiful fossil fish, exquisitely taceous coprolites derived from dinosaurs, proba- preserved in marly limestone,Non that are called itti- bly herbivorous, as in the cases of India (Prasad et oliti (Italian, for fish-stones). The Civita di al., 2005) or the Two Medicine formation in Pietraroja locality is actually a fossil Lagerstätte, Montana, USA (Chin, 2007). In the European dated to the Lower Cretaceous. The area of the Cretaceous some cases evidenced small copro- main fossil site is loosely fenced, several buildings lites as in Portugal (Friis et al., 2004) or the ter- have been built on the fringes of the ’official‘ fossil mite coprolites in France (Colin, 2011). Fish site, including a football field and a never complet- coprolites from Morocco were studied (Lamboy et ed hospice for elder persons and two water reser- al., 1994) and, considering the paleogeography of voirs. All of these buildings were built upon layers Cretaceous, this represents the nearest scenario of fossiliferous limestone, thus hampering to Pietraroja site: a tropical lagoon with the contri- research and recovery of fossils (Signore, 2004). bution of a submarine channel (Carannante et al., The coprolites are icnofossils, members of a 2006). group of fossil traces that includes regurgitalites (dejections from the oral cavity) and colalites Materials and Methods (intestinal content fossilized in situ). Hunt (1992) utilized the term bromalites to include all these The specimens from the Pietraroja site are not

53 Marzo 2015 microscopie CONTRIBUTI SCIENTIFICI

linked to a precise stratigraphy; unfortunately, the Corporate, Oregon, USA), at the CISME center of excavation of the site has presented many prob- the Federico II University of Naples. lems (Signore, 2004) and the coprolites are a sort of remains, both for technical and preconception reasons, in spite of the potential palaeo-informa- Results and Discussion tions that they can provide. It is more plausible that these fossils came from the more massive cat- The first question could be: are the samples astrophic layer, most possibly developed by rapid coprolites? In fact, the samples could be simple and catastrophic events of submarine slides sedimentary phosphates. The nature of coprolites (Signore, 2004) because the specimens including is suggested by their large quantities in a paleoen- coprolites were often associated with dental bat- vironment identified as water-based, the probable teries coming from durophagous fish, most possi- nature of inclusions (Figures 2-5) as vegetables bly Coelodus sp. (Signore, 2004). The specimens (the coprolites of herbivorous presents an elevat- analyzed, about 1-4 cm long, are several but the ed degree of conservation; Hill, 1976) and the only considered were those without macroscopic presence of phosphate: actually the causes of inclusions (bones, unidentified rests) and includ- phosphatization process are not known but the ing eventual microscopic details. Observations by coprolites represent the main site of enucleation Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) were made for the precipitation ofonly the apatitic sediment (Ece, on specimens, previously metalized by a vacuum 1990). The external morphology of the observed evaporator JEE 4B (Jeol USA Inc.), and coated by coprolites does not permit to identify the fecal 10-20 mg of gold. Specimens were subsequently producer or to classify easily the icnofossil observed under a Quanta 200 ESEM (FEI according touse a discrimination about polarity. In

commercial

Non

Figure 1. The Lagerstätte of Pietraroja (Italy).

microscopie Marzo 2015 54 CONTRIBUTI SCIENTIFICI

fact no kind of morphology or remark of lamina- cannot detect carbon and nitrogen. Moreover the tion is identifiable; then the analysis of inclusions association in the fossil record allows the copro- only can be predictive. In spite of these consider- lites to be related to the fish-fauna, because dental ations, the preservation of the fossil gives general apparatuses from durophagous and carnivorous information about the producer: the preferential fish were discovered in the same paleoenvirmo- preservation of the coprolites is the diet. Bradley nent. The group of the observed fibers (Figure 2a; (1946) suggested that calcium phosphate of the Figure 3; Figure 4) exhibiting a spiral pattern is carnivorous diet can be the best permineralizant consistent with materials digested and dejected by agent. Ca and Si are the most frequent elements in evolved fish groups (Kapoor et al., 1975), though the samples as recognized by the SEM probes, the inclusion would be considered as compressed. most likely these elements compose the grain and The pores, identified at higher magnification the matrix of the specimens; the same instrument (Figures 2b; 5 a-d), appear bended if compared

only use

Figure 2. Single vegetable fiber (a);commercial detail of a presumptive stomatal evidence (b). Bar: 50 μm (a); bar: 1 μm (b). Non

Figure 3. High concentration of vegetable fibers. Figure 4. Single vegetable fiber present in the Bar: 500 μm. matrix of a coprolite. Bar: 100 μm.

55 Marzo 2015 microscopie CONTRIBUTI SCIENTIFICI

with the length of the structure and in a serial suc- some higher plants adapted to xeric climate cession. This could implicate that the pores are (Schimper, 1903). The great quantity of preserved stomata, thus excluding that the inclusions might fishes in a lagoon of lower Cretaceous, the mor- be algae; furthermore algae were never found in phology of dejection and the absence of residual the fossil record of Pietraroja site. Initially, these bones suggest that the coprolite producer were vegetable fragments were supposed to belong to herbivorous fishes. the Gymnosperm group (which is present in the Another hypothesis deals with the entomologic Pietraroja paleoflora), but the traits observed nature of inclusions as tracheas of insect, dorsal would place the inclusions among the primitive vessels or crustacean esocuticle. The tracheas of Angiosperms, whose presence is not well docu- insects have a typical spiral structures (Strelin, mented in the fossil record though rests are cited 2012), but they do not resemble the observed in literature (Bartiromo et al., 2006). This could be inclusions, whereas the vessels which are made of consistent with the large diffusion of Angiosperms a soft tissue could hardly be fossilized or pre- since the lower Cretaceous at lower latitudes served; the inclusions found actually exhibit the (Hughes, 1994). The only doubtful feature is the rhomboidal forms as the scales of some crus- too small size of stomata (about 3 μm), though an taceans (Euphasiacea, Anfipodia) with pores epidermal accretion could make them less visible resembling stigma, but these crustacean taxa are and the typical sunken structure is similar as in absent in the fossil recordonly of Pietraroja. Thus, this use

commercial

Non

Figure 5. Details of a vegetable fiber with stomatal evidence. Bar: 20 μm (a); bar: 4 μm (b-d).

microscopie Marzo 2015 56 CONTRIBUTI SCIENTIFICI

hypothesis is unlikely. Furthermore, studies on Elements to hypothesize Notagogus pentlan- the activity of fish digestive enzyme demonstrated di Agassiz as the coprolite producer that the chitinous material is completely degraded A remarkable case of association with the (Gutowska, 2002), while less than half of the plant coprolite samples is constituted by the discovery material ingested by an herbivorous fish is assimi- of a dental apparatus (Figure 6a-b); a similar struc- lated (Targett and Targett, 1990). The mechanisms ture was never found in the fossil record of of fossilization are attributable to permineraliza- Pietraroja site and, although the correspondence tion process with tridimensional conservation of producer-production can only be hypothesized, it tissues, if early diagenesis occurs, the precipita- offers the basis for an investigative approach. The tion of mineral takes place in the first phases of most similar dental apparatus present in the fossil anaerobic fermentation, without the complete record of Pietraroja belongs to Notagogus pent- obliteration of the structures of vegetable cells landi (Agassiz, 1835; Figure 6c) that presents (Perkins, 1976). The presence of Si and Ca, as about 10 teeth on the mandible (Bravi, 1994). The demonstrated by SEM, would confirm this process analyzed dental apparatus (about 0.5 cm in length, during which the permineralized inclusions were eterodontic and with a small number of teeth) not compressed by the NH3-releasing decomposi- tion. The presence of a more basic environment would facilitate CaCO3 precipitation inside the only decomposing tissue as in the case of Santana Formation (Brasil), where the francolite perminer- alized the tissues (Martill, 1988). The fish digestive systems differ according to use the diet: it is short and rectilinear in the carnivo- rous species or long and convoluted in the herbiv- orous ones (Helfman et al., 2009); the presence and orientation of the vegetable fibers in the coprolites seem to be more compatible with her- bivorous fish. This makes it likely that hypotheti- cal producer could be an herbivorous fish living in a changeable water-based environment with prim- itive Angiosperms (riparian?). The fossil record, though rich of examples, does not permit to recog- nize the changes in the marine environmentcommercial or the interactions and the behaviour of predator and herbivorous fishes. The hypothesized riparian ecosystem, in which the producer deposed its dejection, is plausibly Non characterized by turbidity due to the grazing activity and floods, with a reduced photosynthesis. In coastal settings there is a great complexity if compared to basin and riverine wetlands: the latter is subjected to inun- dation with salt water, disturbance regimes and other environmental gradients (Hunter, 2000). Because of fluctuating water regimes, there is a dynamic interface between aerobic and anaerobic conditions, causing leaf abscission and the conse- quent favorable conditions for fossilization. The presence of vegetable inclusions is linked to a cer- tain abundance and probably a lower index of bio- Figure 6. Dental apparatus of discovered in associa- diversity. These aspects characterize the riparian tion with the coprolite specimens (a). Detail of a as extreme salty zone, favorable to species able to conic tooth (b). Rest of dental apparatus of Notagogus pentlandi found in Pietraroia site (c). adapt their habits to a specific diet.

57 Marzo 2015 microscopie CONTRIBUTI SCIENTIFICI

would indicate rubble habits of the fish. Two Tlayua Quarries would be associated to cliff envi- groups of teeth are present: long incisive (number ronment, though a massive presence of fresh- not well defined) and three triangular teeth, water fauna. Furthermore in the Mexican speci- almost conical, with a large basis (Figure 6a). The mens of Notagogus a spiral digestive tract was fos- groups are equidistant, including the final teeth, silized, except for two species with straight one, characterized by three groups of conical teeth of confirming the herbivorous habits of the fish. The two each. It is plausible an increase of thickness presence of animals in the intact enterolites (crus- of dental basis in the distal position of the appara- taceans, mollusks and rests of fishes) identifies tus. The dimensions of the sample could be too the genera as carnivorous but it was hypothesized low than cited in literature, but D’Erasmo (1914), that Notagogus can vary its diet according to the describing Notagogus, attributes a certain intra- period in which trophic resources were poor: it specific variability, that previously caused mis- was hypothesized that Notagogus could even eat takes in the classification. The presence of a white plancton (Gonzalez-Rodriguez and Reynoso, extremity at the top of a conical tooth would 2004). establish that the fish belong to the Osteichthyes, The lower Cretaceous site of Pietraroja was and recent studies in a Morocco area similar to therefore comparable with an actual tropical Pietraroja site clearly suggest the family lagoon with fresh-water channels, i.e. an environ- Macrosemiidae (Murray and Wilson, 2009); in par- ment favorable to the preservationonly of herbivorous ticular the observed specimen could be premaxil- coprolites. The nature of the coprolite producer is lary teeth. Bartram (1977) describes the teeth of identifiable with an herbivorous fish of a plausible Notagogus as mammaliform, and evidence of riparian paleoenvironment, maybe a species able barbed or promiscuous teeth in the species dis- to change the diet accordinguse to the environmental covered at the Tlayua Quarries site in Central scenery at the moment. SEM analysis of coprolites Mexico (Gonzalez-Rodriguez et al., 2004) would and their inclusions can provide useful evidence indicate a similarity with the present case of study. about the paleoenvironment (producer species, The characteristics of the Mexican site are similar products and trophic dynamics), as in the case of to Pietraroja (fish limestones), with presence of the present study, even when referring stratigraph- Notagogus pentlandi and also, in a lower number, ic data are lacking. Further investigations about Notagogus helenae. Stratigraphic information sug- the coprolites in Pietraroja will include chemical gests a double migration of the family from its analyses, a more precise stratigraphy and a statis- original distribution in Tethys Ocean to the west, tical analysis on the quantitative data. following the aperture of the northern part of the Atlantic Ocean until Mexico (Gonzalez-Rodriguezcommercial and Reynoso, 2004). It is the only European species of Macrosemiidae present in South Acknowledgements America. In , the Macrosemiidae as Notagogus are often associatedNon to both cliff and The authors thank all the researchers that sup- fresh-water environments. The specimens of ported the present study.

References

Bartiromo A, Barone Lumaga MR, Bravi S. First finding microorganisms. Am J Sc 1946;244:215-39. of a fossil fern (Matoniaceae) in the paleontological Bravi S. New observations on the Lower Cretaceous fish site of Pietraroja (Benevento, ). B Soc Notagogus pentlandi Agassiz (Actinopterygii, Paleontol Ital 2006;45:29-34. Halecostomi, Macrosemiidae). B Soc Paleontol Ital Bartram AWH. The Macrosemiidae, a Mesozoic family of 1994;33:51–70. holostean fishes. Bull Br Mus Nat Hist Geol 1977;29: Carannante G, Signore M, Vigorito M. Vertebrate-rich 137-234. Plattenkalk of Pietraroja (Lower Cretaceous, Bradley WH. 1946. Coprolites from the Bridger Southern Apennines, Italy): a new model. Facies Formation of Wyoming: their composition and 2006;52:555-77.

microscopie Marzo 2015 58 CONTRIBUTI SCIENTIFICI

Chin K. The palaeobiological implications of herbivo- Hunt AP, Chin K, Lockley MG. The palaobiology of ver- rous dinosaur coprolites from the upper cretaceous tebrate coprolites. The Palaeobiology of Trace Two Medicine formation of Montana: why eat wood? Fossils. 2004. p. 221-40. Palaios 2007;22:554-66. Hunter ML. Maintaining biodiversity in forest ecosy- Colin JP. Termite coprolites (Insecta: Isoptera) from the stems. University of Cambridge; 2000. Cretaceous of western France: a palaeoecological Kapoor, BB, Smit H, Verighina IA. The alimentary canal insight. Revue de Micropaléontologie 2011;54:129-39. and digestion in teleosts. Adv Mar Biol 1975;13:109- D’Erasmo G. La fauna e l’età dei calcari a ittioliti di 239. Pietraroia (provincia di Benevento). Palaeontogr Ital Martill DM. Preservation of fish in the Santana 1914;20:29-86. Formation of Brazil. Palaeontology 1988;31:1-18. Ece OI. Geochemistry and occurrence of authigenic pho- Murray AM, Wilson MVH. A new late Cretaceous sphate nodules from the Desmionesian cyclic Macrosemiid Fish (Neopterygii, Halecostomi) from Excello epeiric sea of the Midcontinent, USA. Mar Morocco, with temporal and geographical range Petrol Geol 1990;7:298-312. extensions for the family. Palaeontology 2009;52:429- Friis EM, Pedersen KR, Crane PR. Araceae from the 40. Early Cretaceous of Portugal: evidence on the emer- Perkins TW. Textures and conditions of formation of gence of monocotyledons. P Natl Acad Sci USA middle Pennsylvanian coal balls, Central United 2004;101:16565-70. States. The University of Kansas Paleontologycal Gonzalez-Rodriguez K, Applegate SP, Espinosa- Contributions 1976;82:1-13. Arraburena L. A new world Macrosemiid (Pisces: only Prasad V, Stromberg CAE, Alimohammadian H, Sahni A. Neopterygii-Halecostomi) from the Albian of Dinosaur coprolites and the early evolution of gras- Mexico. J Vertebr Paleontol 2004;24:281-9. Gonzalez-Rodriguez K, Reynoso VH. A new Notagogus ses and grazers. Science 2005;310:1177-80. (Macrosemiidae, Halecostomi) species from the Schimper AFW.use Plant-geography upon a physiological Albian Tlayúa Quarry, Central Mexico. Mesozoic basis. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1903. Fishes 3 – Systematics, Paleoenvironments and Signore M. Sample excavations in Pietraroja (lower Biodiversity. In: Arratia G, Tintori A, editors; 2004. p. Cretaceous, Southern Italy) in 2001 and notes on the 265-78. Pietraroja palaeoenvironment. www.PalArch.nl, Gutowska M. Chitinase activity of fishes with varying Vertebrate Palaeontology 2004;2:2. depth distributions. MBARI publications, Annual Strelin GS. Patterns in the spiral formations of insects. Report; 2002. Morfologiia 1993;105:104-14. Helfman G, Collette B, Facey BE, Bowen BW. The Targett TE, Targett NM. Energetics of food selection by Diversity of Fishes: Biology, Evolution, and Ecology. the herbivorous parrotfish Sparisoma radians: roles Wiley; 2009. of assimilation efficiency, gut evacuation rate, and Hughes NF. The enigma of angiosperm origins. algal secondary metabolites. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 1990; Cambridge University Press; 1994. commercial66:13-21.

Non

59 Marzo 2015 microscopie