Submission to Regulatory Authorities in and the EU

for Documentation and Information relating to MANDATORY INGESTION OF FLUORIDE THROUGH ARTIFICALLY FLUORIDATED DRINKING WATER & ASSOCIATED BEVERAGES & FOODS for citizens and residents of the

DECEMBER 2017

1

FOR THE ATTENTION OF:

Mr. Jerry Grant Managing Director, Irish Water Mr. Michael McNicholas Chairman, Irish Water. Mr Mike Quinn Chief Executive Officer, Ervia Mr. Brendan Murphy Group Commercial Regulatory Director, Ervia Ms. Angela Lloyd Regulatory Affairs Manager, Irish Water Mr. Jamie Burke Senior Regulatory Affairs Specialist, Irish Water Dr Tony Holohan Chief Medical Officer, Department of Health. Dr Pamela Byrne CEO Food Safety Authority of Ireland Dr Graham Love Chief Executive of the Health Research Board. Professor Mark W. J. Ferguson Chief Scientific Advisor to the Ms. Laura Burke Director General, EPA Dr . T.D. Department of the Mr. Martin Fraser Secretary General to the Government Mr. Simon Harris. T.D. Minister for Health Mr. Jim Breslin General Secretary, Department of Health Mr. Minister for Housing, Planning and Local Government Mr. John McCarthy General Secretary, Dept Environment, Community & Local Gov Ms. T.D Minister for Children and Youth Affairs Mr. T.D. Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine Mr. T.D Minister for Communications, Climate Action &Environment Mr. Andrew Doyle T.D Minister of State with responsibility for Food, Forestry & Horticulture Mr. Jim Daly T.D Minister of State with responsibility for Mental Health & Older People Ms. Catherine Byrne T.D Minister of State at the Department of Health Mr. Michael Harty T.D Chair, Committee on Health Ms. Roisin Shortall T.D. Chair, Oireachtas Committee on the Future of Healthcare Mr Seamus Neely Chair LASNTG Water Services Training Group Mr Tom Kirby Secretary, LASNTG Water Services Training Group Ms. Emily O’Reilly European Ombudsman Ms. Emily Logan Chief Commissioner of Irish Human Rights & Equality Commission Dr Bernhard Url, Executive Director, European Food Safety Authority Dr Michael Winter European Food Safety Authority

2

1. Introduction Directive 2003/4/EC of the and of the Council of 28 January 2003 on public access to environmental information requires public authorities, as well as non-public bodies carrying out a public function, to make available and disseminate environmental information to the general public to the widest extent possible. The definition of environmental information encompasses information in any form on the state of the environment, including water, and measures including administrative measures, such as policies, legislation, plans, programmes, environmental agreements, and information on the state of human health and safety, including the contamination of the food chain and conditions of human life in as much as they are, or may be, affected by water quality as well as information pertaining to cost-benefit and economic analyses. Without prejudice, upon request, public authorities shall reply to requests for information as soon as possible, or at the latest within one month after receipt of the applicants request or within two months after the receipt of the request by the public authority if the volume and the complexity of the information is such that the one-month period cannot be complied with. In such cases, the applicant shall be informed as soon as possible, and in any case before the end of that one-month period, of any such extension and of the reasons for it. In addition to this Directive, the EU approved the Aarhus Convention in 2005 (Council Decision 2005/370/EC of 17 February 2005). The Aarhus Convention recognises that every person has the right to live in an environment adequate to his or her health and well-being, both individually and in association with others, to assert this right and observe this duty, citizens must have access to information, be entitled to participate in decision-making and have access to justice in environmental matters for the benefit of present and future generations. This includes information on the state of the environment and/or on human health issues as well as information on policies and measures taken. Ireland ratified the Aarhus Convention on 20 June 2012. On the 11th May 2016, a request for information by Mr Waugh was submitted to Irish Water and other regulatory agencies in Ireland to provide specific information pertaining to fluoridation of drinking water supplies.1 This request was submitted by registered post and copied to the Food Safety Authority, Environmental Protection Agency, the Health Research Board, Ministry of Health, Minister for Local Government, and the Department of the Taoiseach as well as other members of the Oireachtas. The request has been met with silence. Of relevance to this previous correspondence we now note that Irish Water, through the Local Authority Services National Training Group (LASNTG), have currently tendered for a contract for the development of a training manual, course material and training course on the fluoridation of drinking water in Ireland. The training manual and associated training course is aimed at ensuring that those staff responsible for the delivery of safe and secure drinking water to Irish Water consumers will be adequately trained on the principles, practicalities and risk-based approach to fluoridating drinking water supplies. Considering the above tender, the specific requests for information that were previously sought in 2016 are repeated overleaf.

.

1 Correspondence to Irish Water and its parent company Ervia; Chief Medical Officer , Department of Health; Chief Executive Food Safety Authority of Ireland; Chief Executive of the Health Research Board; Chief Scientific Advisor to the Government of Ireland; Director General, EPA; Department of the Taoiseach; Secretary General to the Government; Minister for Health; General Secretary, Department of Health; Minister for Local Government; General Secretary, Department of Environment, Community and Local Government; Minister for Children and Youth Affairs; Minister for Justice and Equality and others. Dated 11th May 2017. 3

➢ A declaration that Irish Water have complied fully with the requirements of EC 1907/2006. This declaration shall include evidence of specific hazard assessments, including chemical toxicological and metabolic studies, eco-toxicological studies, reproductive toxicity, medical data including medical surveillance data, epidemiological studies on general population, skin sensitivity studies and allergenicity studies, carcinogenicity studies, mutagenicity studies, sub chronic toxicity studies and other measures taken by Irish Water to ensure the safety of water fluoridation chemicals used in drinking water supplies. ➢ A declaration that Irish Water have complied fully with the requirements of EC 178/2002. This shall include evidence that food products are properly labelled allowing consumers to identify where fluoridated drinking water supplies have been used in the manufacture and processing of food products or how the addition of fluoridated water to raw or unprocessed food may alter its fluoride content. ➢ A declaration that Irish Water have determined the probable immediate and/or short-term and/or long-term effects of foods that have been processed using fluoridated water including the probable cumulative toxic effects. This must include details of any risk assessment addressing chronic infant exposure due to reconstitution of powdered infant formula with fluoridated tap water as well as adult cumulative exposure to other dietary sources of fluoride including tea, beer, wine, marine fish, processed foods or fluoridated medications. ➢ A declaration that artificial fluoridation of drinking water does not pose any risk to neurological health and wellbeing of infants. ➢ A declaration that artificial fluoridation of drinking water does not impair or disrupt endocrine function in infant, adolescents or adults. ➢ A declaration that artificial fluoridation of drinking water does not contribute to abnormal bone protein synthesis that may contribute to chronic disease in humans. ➢ A declaration that artificial fluoridation of drinking water does not contribute to cardiac toxicity in humans. ➢ A declaration that artificial fluoridation of drinking water does not contribute to systemic or chronic inflammation among infants, children, adolescents or adults. ➢ A declaration that Irish Water have evaluated the effects of combined toxicity of fluoridated water and lead in drinking water for neurotoxicity, carcinogenicity, immunotoxicity, endocrine dysfunction and bone health and that water fluoridation does not pose any health risk for consumers that may have lead contamination in their water. ➢ A declaration that Irish Water have evaluated the effects of combined toxicity of fluoridated water with aluminium exposure for neurotoxicity, immunotoxicity, carcinogenicity, endocrine dysfunction and bone health and that water fluoridation does not pose any health risk for consumers. This declaration shall include evidence of toxicological studies addressing chronic infant fluoride exposure and the co-toxicity of fluoride with increased aluminium exposure from vaccines and milk based powdered infant formula. ➢ A declaration that artificial fluoridation of drinking water will not contribute to potentially harmful cumulative fluoride exposure or enhanced toxicity among consumers residing in communities with artificially fluoridated drinking water who are also prescribed fluoridated medications by a medical practitioner. ➢ A declaration that Irish Water have indemnity insurance to cover any liabilities should any member of the public suffer any injury, illness or medical disorder because of the contribution of artificial water fluoridation to cumulative exposures.

4

2. Precautionary Principle and Safeguarding Public Health In addition to the previous requests for information, we wish to draw your attention to the recent findings published in the peer reviewed journal Environmental Health Perspectives by a team of investigators at the University of Toronto, McGill, the Harvard School of Public Health, and other institutions found an association between fluoride exposure in pregnancy and lower measures of intelligence in children.2 This longitudinal study, funded by the US Government's National Institutes of Health, was carried out over a period of 12 years and controlled for a wide range of covariates and sensitivity variables and found that a 0.5 mg/L increase in urinary fluoride concentration was associated with a statistically significantly lower IQ in her offspring. On the 27th September last, concerns regarding the findings of this study and their relevance to Ireland were communicated in writing by Mr Waugh to the Minister for Health, the Taoiseach, other cabinet members and elected TD’s.3 The results of this study are clearly important, more so considering that tea consumption in Mexico is among the lowest in the world at < 0.1 kg per year.4 Tea has long been acknowledged as a major source of dietary fluoride since the 1930s and 1940s.5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12 In 1983, UK researchers from the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food and the Laboratory of the Government Chemist reported that the fluoride content in brands of tea infusions in the UK ranged from 2.0-4.7 mg/L.13 The authors reported that tea was the main source of dietary fluoride exposure in the UK population and that while less tea is consumed in the UK than in the 1950s, the fluoride content in tea infusions is higher. In 1984, researchers at the Food Science Division of the Ministry of Agriculture in the UK reported that for high tea consumers the fluoride intake from tea would be about 6.4 mg/day and that fluoridated water would add another 2 mg/day to this.14 In 1991, another UK study examining fluoride intake and its safety reported that among heavy tea drinker’s fluoride intake by adults would be in the region of 9.0mg/day.15 The WHO (1994) reported that tea infusions may contain up to 8.6mg/L depending on the infusion time and amount and variety of tea.16 Despite this, no effort has been made by the Department of Health or the Food Safety Authority to educate or inform medical practitioners or the general public, of the health risks of chronic fluoride intoxication posed by excessive or habitual tea consumption and

2 Bashash M, Thomas D, Hu H, Martinez-Mier EA, Sanchez BN, Basu N, et al. Prenatal fluoride exposure and cognitive outcomes in children at 4 and 6-12 years of age in Mexico. Environ Health Perspect. 2017;125(9):097017. Available from: https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/EHP655.alt_.pdf 3 Correspondence to Taoiseach Dr. Leo Varadkar TD; Minister of Health Mr Simonm Harris; TD, and cabinet colleagues, Mr. Jim Daly TD; Ms. Katherine Zappone T.D; Mr. Finian McGrath T.D; Mr. Pascal Donohoe T.D; Mr. Richard Burton T.D; Mr. Charlie Flanagan T.D. Ms Francis Fitzgerald T.D; Mr. T.D; Ms. T.D; Mr. Michael Creed T.D; Mr. Denis Naughten T.D; Mr. T.D; Mr. Eoghan Murphy T.D; Mr. T.D; Ms Regina Dohety T.D; Mr. Paul Kehoe T.D; Mr. Joe McHugh T.D and Ms. Mary Mitchell O’Connor T.D. Repeal of Health (Fluoridation of Water Supplies) Act, 1960 (No. 46 of 1960), as adapted by the Health Order 1997 (S.I. No. 308 of 1997) and Fluoridation of Water Supplies Regulations 2007 (S.I. No. 42/2007). Dated 22nd September 2017. 4 Beresniak A, Duru G,Berger G, et al. Relationships between black tea consumption and key health indicators in the world: an ecological study. BMJ Open 2012;2:e000648. 5 Reid E. The fluorine content of some Chinese food materials. Chin. J. Physiol. 1936; 10:259–272 6 McClure FJ. Fluorides in food and drinking water. Natl Inst Health Bull. 1939;172:1. 7 Cheng LT, Chou TP. The fluorine content of foodstuffs in Scechnan. Chinese J of Physiol. 1940;15:263. 8 Lawrenz M, Mitchell HH. The relative assimilation of fluorine from fluorine bearing minerals and food (tea) and from water and food. J. Nutrition. 1941;22:621. 9 McClure FJ. Ingestion of Fluoride and dental caries. Am J. Diseases Children 1943;66:365 10 Clifford PA. Report on fluorine. Assoc. Off. Agri. Chem. 1945;28:277. 11 McClure FJ. Fluorine in foods: Survey of recent data. U.S. Pub. Health Repts. 1949:64:1061-1074. 12 Harrison MF. Fluorine Content of Teas Consumed in New Zealand. British Journal of Nutrition, 1949;3 (2-3):162–166. 13 Walters CB, Sherlock JC, Evans WH, Read JI. Dietary Intake of Fluoride in the United Kingdom and Fluoride Content of some Foodstuffs. J. Sci, Food Agric. 1983;34:523-528. 14 Sherlock JC, Corr MI. Fluorides in Foodstuffs and the Diet. Perspectives in Public Health. 1984 February;104(1):34-36. 15 Jenkins GN. Fluoride intake and its safety among heavy tea drinkers in a British Fluoridated city. Proceedings of the Finnish Dental Society, 1991;87: 571–579. 16 World Health Organization, Fluoride and Oral Health. Report of a WHO Expert Committee on Oral Health Status and Fluoride Use. WHO Technical Report Series 846. Geneva 1994. 5

no studies were ever undertaken by the authorities to measure the fluoride content in teas for consumption in Ireland. In 2006, the USA National Research Council (NRC) of the National Academies of Science (NAS) in their review of fluoride in drinking water noted that just half a cup of brewed tea with a fluoride concentration of 3.3 mg/L equals the total background intake of fluoride from all other food sources.17 The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) reported that drinking just 2 cups of tea per day (with a fluoride content of 5 mg/L), combined with an average consumption of fluoridated drinking water and the use of fluoridated tap water in the preparation of food, but excluding all other sources (including solid foods, toothpaste and dental products), would provide a daily dietary intake of 6 mg fluoride per day.18 In the EU, the Tolerable Upper Intake Level (UL) for fluoride has been established at 1.5 mg/day for children aged 1–3 years, 2.5 mg/day for children up to the age of eight years, 5 mg/day for children aged 9 to 14 years and 7 mg/day for children older than 15 years and healthy adults.19 The Adequate Intake (AI) for healthy adult males and females over 18 years of age is 3.4 mg and 2.9 mg per day respectively. Knowledge of the fluoride content in tea beverages is therefore essential to all health care professionals especially in a country such as Ireland where most of the population drink tea daily and drinking water supplies are artificially fluoridated in accordance with national legislation. The adjusted fluoride content in drinking water would depend on an accurate assessment of the current fluoride intake habits by the population. Given that for almost a century Ireland has had the highest consumption of tea in the world the need for studies that examine the fluoride content in commercially available tea products and reporting of the findings of such studies is obvious. Despite an extensive body of literature from the 1930s highlighting that tea is a major source of dietary fluoride intake, the Irish State and its institutions in their enthusiasm to promote and protect the policy of mandatory water fluoridation have demonstrated an astonishing display of ignorance, incompetence and complacency in not addressing cumulative exposures to fluoride and dietary exposure to fluoride from tea consumption in Ireland. Paradoxically, when Ireland commenced water fluoridation, fluoride intake from tea was not even considered by the Department of Health. In 1963, per capita consumption of tea in Ireland was approximately 4.54 kg per person per year, compared to 0.31 kg per person in the USA. In 2003, per capita consumption was 3.43 kg per year in Ireland and 0.33 kg per year in the USA. Since 1968, some fifteen studies have been conducted by different researchers in the UK alone measuring the fluoride content in teas as well as examining dietary intake from tea. During this period comprehensive studies have also been conducted in the Australia, Argentina, Brazil, Ethiopia, China, Chile, Canada, Germany, Gaza, Hong Kong, Iran, Iraq, India, Israel, Indonesia, Japan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Malaysia, Norway, Poland, Pakistan, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, South Africa, Senegal, Sri Lanka, Sweden, Taiwan, Turkey and the USA. Clearly, the Department of Health cannot claim ignorance of the fact that tea was a major source of fluoride given that the Principal Dental Surgeon of the Eastern Health Board and dental researchers at the School of Dental Science at Trinity College published a review specifically addressing the dental significance of fluoride in tea in the Journal of the Irish Dental Association in 1998.20 In this review, the authors noted that it has long been accepted that fluoride accumulates in the leaves of the tea plant and that Ireland has the highest per capita consumption of tea in the world. As noted

17 United States National Research Council, Review of Fluoride in Drinking Water, United States National Research Council, 2006. 18 European Food Safety Authority. Scientific Opinion on Dietary Reference Values for fluoride, EFSA Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition, and Allergies. EFSA J. 2013, 11, 3332–3378. 19 Scientific Committee on Food, Scientific Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies. Tolerable Upper Intake Levels for Vitamins and Minerals, European Food Safety Authority, 2006 20 Kavanagh D, Renehan, J. Fluoride in Tea—Its Dental Significance. J. Ir. Dent. Assoc. 1998, 44, 100–105. 6

by the authors, the assessment of the fluoride content in tea has been the subject of much research in the UK and elsewhere. Notably, the authors reference a UK study which found that the upper limit of fluoride intake by heavy tea drinkers in a fluoridated city in the UK was 9.9 mg fluoride per day.21 In their conclusion, the Principal Dental Surgeon reported that as no data is available on the fluoride levels in teas in Ireland and as Ireland has the highest per capita consumption of tea in the world research should be carried out to measure the fluoride levels in teas available on the Irish market. Astonishingly, despite this recommendation, the very first risk assessment of fluoride intake from tea and quantification of fluoride levels in tea products available to consumers in Ireland was not conducted until almost two decades later. This study, of which Mr Waugh was a co-author, was published in the peer reviewed International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health in 2016 [22].22 This risk assessment was undertaken by the authors without funding, for the benefit of public health and the advancement of scientific education in the fields of health promotion and disease prevention. In addition to excessive fluoride levels in tea, the study found that water fluoridation was a significant contributor to fluoride intake as tea and other beverages are prepared using fluoridated tap water. This poses many obvious questions, specifically;

➢ Given that Ireland has both the highest per capita consumption of tea in the world and mandatory water fluoridation, why was no risk assessment undertaken by the State or its institutions responsible for food safety and public health when they were aware that tea was a significant source of fluoride?

➢ Why does the Department of Health via local authorities, the EPA and Irish Water spend millions of taxpayer’s monies annually purchasing fluoridation chemicals, operating water fluoridation plants, inspecting and monitoring water fluoride levels to ensure that fluoride levels in drinking water are strictly maintained between 0.6 and 0.8 mg/L, yet, at the same time tea products consumed by infants, children and over 90% per cent of the adult population remain unregulated and unmonitored when they contain significantly higher fluoride levels than permitted in drinking water or bottled water?

➢ Clearly, water fluoridation plants are expensive to construct; buildings must be ventilated, temperature controlled, hazard safety precautions must be maintained to protect operators and alarms systems must be installed to prevent exceedances to protect public health as the chemical used for fluoridation is a hazardous chemical. Yet the costs of planning, engineering, design, construction, operation, inspection and maintenance remain concealed. When the regulatory authorities and Department of Health are requested to provide detailed costs, they are either not provided or only the costs of fluoridation chemicals are provided, which do not accurately reflect the official costs in accordance with maintaining this policy, which clearly run into the tens of millions annually.

➢ Why has there been no biomonitoring of the general population to accurately establish the long-term exposure to fluoride and total body burden in the general population?

21 Jenkins GN. Fluoride intake and its safety among heavy tea drinkers in a British Fluoridated city. Proceedings of the Finnish Dental Society, 1991;87, 571–579. 22 Waugh DT., Potter W., Limeback H., Godfrey M, Risk assessment of fluoride intake from tea in the republic of Ireland and its implications for public health and water fluoridation. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2016 Feb 26;13(3). pii: E259 7

In an effort to thoroughly examine and understand the relationship between fluoride intake, cumulative exposures and total body burden of fluoride in the population, it is important to consider the following. A study performed in Finland in 1985 found that bone fluoride concentrations were typically 3-fold higher in adult subjects (mean age 60yrs) who had resided in a fluoridated community for approximately 20 years compared with subjects from non-fluoridated areas.23 In men, the highest concentration was 2750 ppm. In women, the highest concentration of F in bone was found in a subject with impaired renal function (3890 ppm). According to the NRC (2006) these bone fluoride levels lie within the range known to be associated with skeletal fluorosis.24 However, it is important to note that tea consumption is uncommon in Finland and the subjects had not ingested fluoridated water throughout their lifetime. Moreover, the study would not have included exposure from fluoridated toothpaste, which only became widely available from the 1980s onwards. More recently a study conducted in Canada found that the rate of increase in bone fluorine content per year was 3-fold higher for tea drinkers compared to non-tea drinkers.25 As noted previously per capita consumption of tea in Ireland was 3.43 kg per person in 2003. For the same period, per capita consumption in Canada and Finland was 0.59 and 0.18 kg per person respectively. In other words, per capita consumption of tea in Ireland is five-fold higher than Canada and eighteen-fold higher than Finland. Considering that public water has been artificially fluoridated in Ireland since 1964 (53 years compared to 18 years in the Finland study) and per capita intake of tea in 1963 was even higher at 4.54 kg per person per year, evidence strongly suggests that chronic fluoride intoxication is a major undocumented health burden in the Irish population. It is important to be aware that the NRC (2006) in their review of fluoride in drinking water identified subpopulations that might be particularly susceptible to the effects of fluoride including people with high activity levels (e.g. athletes and workers with physically demanding duties); pregnant or lactating women; individuals with renal disease, because of their high fluid intakes and compromised ability to excrete fluoride which can result in greater accumulation of fluoride in their bodies; the elderly, because of their long-term accumulation of fluoride into their bones; and individuals with medical conditions associated with high water intake or that can make people more susceptible to the effects of fluoride, such as individuals with thyroid disorders or individuals with compromised immune systems. Moreover, the NRC recommended a wide range of additional epidemiology, toxicology, clinical medicine, environmental exposure, and biomonitoring assessments that need to be undertaken in order to fill data gaps. Further studies were recommended in identifying sources of fluoride and determining bone, soft tissue, plasma, and urinary fluoride levels and further studies to clarify the relationship between fluoride intake, fluoride concentration in bone, clinical symptoms of skeletal fluorosis, and other factors that may influence the risk of bone fractures. The NRC also recommended that carefully conducted studies of exposure to fluoride and emerging health parameters of interest (e.g., endocrine effects and brain function) should be performed in populations exposed to various concentrations of fluoride. Further studies were recommended to investigate the effects of fluoride on brain, kidney, liver, and immune system function as well as in vivo human genotoxicity studies in the USA population or other populations with nutritional and sociodemographic variables similar to those in the United States. Additional studies were also recommended to investigate the association between fluoride intake and thyroid disease, calcium

23 Arnala I, Alhava EM, Kauranen P. Effects of fluoride on bone in Finland: Histomorphometry of cadaver bone from low and high fluoride areas. Acta Orthopaedica, 1985;56(2), 161–166. 24 United States National Research Council, Review of Fluoride in Drinking Water, United States National Research Council, 2006. 25 Mostafaei F, McNeill FE, Chettle DR, Wainman B. C,.Pidruczny AE, Prestwich WV. Measurements of fluorine in contemporary urban Canadians: A comparison of the levels found in human bone using in vivo and ex vivo neutron activation analysis. Physiological Measurement, 2015;36(3):465–487. 8

metabolism, pineal function, and development of glucose intolerance and diabetes. Among their other recommendations the NRC recommended that the USA Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) update its fluoride risk assessment to include new data on health risks and better estimates of total exposure.26 Given the findings and recommendations of the NRC report, this raises another obvious question:

➢ Notably, why have there been no epidemiology, toxicology, clinical medicine, environmental exposure, or biomonitoring assessments to measure bone, soft tissue, plasma, and urinary fluoride levels in the Irish population and why have there been no human health studies to investigate the effects of fluoride on brain, kidney, liver, and immune system function as well as in vivo human genotoxicity studies in the Irish population?

In follow up, to the NRC 2006 report; an exposure assessment was conducted by the US EPA in 2010, which concluded that the use of fluoridated water for commercial beverage production and the increase of fluoride in solid foods because of fluoridated commercial processes have likely resulted in increased dietary fluoride intake adding to the risk for overexposure.27 Recently, due to potential concerns associated with cumulative fluoride exposure and to ensure a high level of consumer protection, the USA Public Health Service (PHS) finalized a recommendation for lowering the levels of water fluoridation programs to 0.7mg/L for the whole USA.28 Implementation of the new recommendation is expected to lead to a reduction of approximately 25% in fluoride intake from drinking water alone and a reduction of approximately 14% (range 5%–29%) in total fluoride intake.29 This poses further important questions; namely;

➢ If Public Health Bodies in the USA consider that cumulative exposures to fluoride are a public health problem, and have accordingly reduced the permitted fluoride levels in drinking water to 0.7 mg/L; how can Irish Water or the Irish State, consider that fluoridation of drinking water is safe in a country where the per capita consumption of tea is ten-fold higher than the USA? ➢ Why has no action has been taken in Ireland to address cumulative exposures, as required by the General Food Law (Regulation (EC) No 178/2002)? Considering the total lack of adequate biomonitoring studies in Ireland regarding either fluoride exposure or fluoride accumulation in the general population, Irish Water are requested to provide rigorous and quantifiable evidence to demonstrate that fluoridation of drinking water is not contributing to chronic fluoride poisoning of the population.

26 United States National Research Council, Review of Fluoride in Drinking Water, United States National Research Council, 2006. 27 United States Environmental Protection Agency, Fluoride: Exposure And Relative Source Contribution Analysis. Washington:EPA, Office of Water, Health and Ecological Criteria Division, 2010, https://www.epa.gov/dwstandardsregulations/fluoride-risk-assessment-and-relative-source-contribution 28 United States Department of Health and Human Services,“Press release. HHS issues final recommendation for community water fluoridation,” 2015. http://www.hhs.gov/news/press/ 2015pres/04/20150427a.html. 29 Gooch BF. U.S. public health service recommendation for fluoride concentration in drinking water for the prevention of dental caries. Public Health Reports, 2015;130(4):318–331 9

This brings us back to the current study, which found an association between maternal fluoride intake in pregnancy and cognitive impairment in children in Mexico City. This study affirms that prenatal fluoride toxicity is an entirely preventable problem and that by working to reduce exposure and by reducing its unnecessary use, it is possible to remove fluoride exposure as a factor that limits children’s opportunities to reach their full potential. In this regard, it is disheartening to acknowledge studies by Lynn and Vanhanen (2002 & 2006) which found that the average national intelligence quotients (IQ) for the population of Ireland when assessed by the progressive matrices was significantly lower than the European average.30,31 According to the authors, the three countries with the highest IQ scores in Europe were Italy, Germany and . Due to cumulative exposures from water fluoridation and the consumption of tea in Ireland. it is obvious that dietary fluoride intake in mainland Europe is significantly lower than the Republic of Ireland. For example, in 2003, per capita consumption of tea in Italy, Germany, Austria was 0.1, 0.29, 0.2 kg per person respectively, compared to 3.43 kg per person in the Republic of Ireland. Whether fluoride intake and cumulative exposures are contributing to measurable long-term differences in children’s cognitive outcomes in Ireland remains uncertain, but given that the difference in mean IQ between Ireland, Italy, Germany and Austria was in the order of 15 IQ points, this suggests that the burden of cumulative fluoride exposures and toxicity may be directly and permanently affecting intellectual and neurobehavioral development in Irish children. Given the ongoing international policy debate on water fluoridation and mounting evidence that fluoride is a developmental neurotoxin this is a topic of major public health significance. In the meantime, no research has been conducted in Ireland to assess the relationship between biomarkers of exposure to fluoride and cognitive health. In ending, as noted in previous correspondence by Mr Waugh of 11th May 2016, no economic evaluation or cost benefit analysis of community water fluoridation has ever been conducted in Ireland. Considering the recent findings of Ko and Thiessen (2014) - A critique of recent economic evaluations of community water fluoridation32; Irish Water were requested in May 2016 to provide a cost benefit analysis of water fluoridation in Ireland. The following points were requested to be included in the analysis. A comprehensive breakdown and assessment of the economic costs for provision of building infrastructure; equipment costs, installation costs; monitoring and surveillance; health and safety infrastructure costs; chemical costs; maintenance and auditing costs; plant and equipment replacement costs; insurance costs including possible injury litigation costs for workers as well as pollution incidences and public liability costs associated with the storage and use of hazardous chemicals used for fluoridation of drinking water supplies. Moreover, in light of current evidence of potential harm posed by water fluoridation, the cost benefit analysis was requested to include likely costs associated with the potential contribution of water fluoridation to neurological disorders in children (cognitive impairment and behavioural disorders such as ADHD), as well as wider health disorders associated with fluoride intoxication including chronic musculoskeletal disorders, chronic pain, chronic kidney disorders and endocrine dysfunction. As with the additional requests for information no reply or acknowledgement was forthcoming from Irish Water. Clearly, such an analysis along with population exposure data is of the greatest public relevance and should be conducted before any more taxpayer’s money is spent on promoting and reinforcing water fluoridation in Ireland. We the undersigned look forward to your reply.

Mr. Declan Waugh BSc. CEnv. MCIWEM. MIEMA EnviroManagement Services

30 Lynn,R.,Vanhanen,T. 2002. IQ and the Wealth of Nations. Praeger, Westport, CT. 31 Lynn, R., Vanhanen,T. 2006.IQ & Global Inequality. Washington Summit Publisher, Augusta, GA. 32 Ko L, Thiessen KM. A critique of recent economic evaluations of community water fluoridation. Int J Occup Environ Health. 2015;21(2):91-120. doi: 10.1179/2049396714Y.0000000093. 10

CO-SIGNATORIES TO THIS LETTER INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING INDIVIDUALS. All NAMED PERSONS HAVE READ AND RECEIVED A COPY OF THIS LETTER AND HAVE AUTHORIZED MR WAUGH TO USE THEIR NAME FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS COMMUNICATION AS CO-SIGNATURES TO THIS CORRESPONDENCE. NOTE: ALL SIGNATURES WERE OBTAINED BETWEEN DECEMBER 1ST AND 17TH DECEMBER INCLUSIVE. ADDRESSES OF CERTAIN PUBLIC FIGURES OR RECORDING ARTISTS ARE WITHHELD ON PRIVACY GROUNDS.

ALL CORRESPONDENCE IN REPLY TO THIS COMMUNICATION IS TO BE FORWARDED TO MR. DECLAN WAUGH, ON BEHALF OF ALL SIGNATURES TO THIS LETTER.

CORRESPONDENCE ADDRESS: Declan Waugh EnviroManagement Services 11 Riverview, Doherty’s Rd, Bandon Co. Telephone: 023-8841933 Email: [email protected]

Dr Kathleen Thiessen Ph.D. Dr Hardy Limeback Ph.D. Senior Scientist Emeritus. Professor, and Former Head of Oak Ridge Center for Risk Analysis, Inc. Preventive Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, 102 Donner Drive, University of Toronto, Canada. Oak Ridge, TN 37830 USA (Former member of the U.S National (Former member of the U.S National Research Council of the National Research Council of the National Academies of Medicine and Science Academies of Medicine and Science Scientific Committee on Fluoride in Scientific Committee on Fluoride in Drinking Water and co-author of Int J Drinking Water). Environ Res Public Health. 2016 Feb 26;13(3). pii: E259)

Dr Michael Godfrey MBBS. Dr William Potter Ph.D. Bay of Plenty Environmental Health, Professor Chemistry and Biochemistry 1416A Cameron Road, Tauranga 3012, University of Tulsa, New Zealand Tulsa, OK 74104-3189, USA’ (Co-author of Int J Environ Res Public (Co-author of Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2016 Feb 26;13(3). pii: E259.) Health. 2016 Feb 26;13(3). pii: E259.)

Dr Vyvyan Howard MB. ChB. PhD. Dr Paul Connett Ph.D FRCPath. Emeritus. Professor of Environmental Emeritus. Professor, Chemistry & Toxicology Centre for Molecular Biosciences St. Lawrence University University of Ulster New York Coleraine, BT52 1SA

Dr Ivor Browne Dr Angela Savage Ph.D Professor Emeritus of Professor Emeritus Psychiatry at University School of Chemistry College Dublin. Former Chief National University of Ireland Psychiatrist of the Eastern Health . Board.

11

Dr Piotr Hajduk MD., PhD Dr Christian Kerskens Paedriatric Surgeon Trinity College Institute of Neuroscience Our Ladys Childrens Hospital & Trinity Centre for Bioengineering Crumlin Lloyd Institute, Dublin

Dr Neville Wilson. BA., MB,ChB, D.Obs, Dr Elizabeth Cullen, MB.BCh. B.A.O.Ph.D D.Fam.Med, MSc. Thomastown Clinic, Maynooth, Kilcullen Co Kildare Co Kildare

Dr Philip Michael, MB., BCh Dr Stephen Gascoigne MB., Ch.B., Dip. Castlebernard, C.H.M., C.Ac. (Shanghai) Bandon, Heron Court Co Cork Bandon, Co. Cork

Dr Colin Waugh MB., BCh., MRCP(Ire), Dr Elizabeth Waugh MB., BCh., BAO FRNZCGP. MICGP, FRACGP. UCC Graduate & Irish Citizen UCC Graduate & Irish Citizen Christchurch, Adelaide, New Zealand Australia

Dr Joe McAuliffe MICGP Dr Saundra Stephen B.A., H.D.Ed., M.A., Rochestown M.Sc. PhD in Health Science Cork 36, The Pines, Road, Co. Cork , Dublin 5

Dr Martin Lane MB MA. DCH MRCGP Dr Mike Murphy. BSc Medical Science, MICGP. BSc and PhD in Applied Psychology. New Rd School of Applied Psychology Bandon, University College Cork Co. Cork Cork

Dr Deirdre Duff Ph.D Cell and Molecular Louise Daly Reg. Ps.S.I. DPP. Ed. MPhil. Biology, BSc. Biochemistry. BSc.Senior Educational Psychologist, , Brothers of Charity, Southern Services, Lemybrien, Lota, , Co. Cork

Dr Denise Kelly Ph.D Dr Mary Helen Hensley DC Kildallogue, Cam, Brideswell Strokestown, Athlone Co. Roscommon Co Roscommon

Ms. Erica Murray B.Soc.Sc, MH, Ir Ms. Carina Harkin BHSc. Acu. BHSc. Nat. Master Medical Herbalist & Iridologist BHSc. Hom 21 Craiglands, 24 Waterlane Ardeevin Road, Bohermore, Galway , Co. Dublin Co Galway

Ms. Jean O Hanlon BSc. HD Psych, Dip. Mr. Anthony Hughes B.Sc, Dip. Chem. Eng. CBTI, Certified Health & Wellness Coach, 1 Drive, 14 Marian Park, Blackrock, Pouladuff Road, Co. Dublin Cork 12

Ms. Karolina Plachta Ms. Alison Kingston. Health Coach & Nutritional Therapist Health Coach & Nutritional Therapist Castleside Drive, Crossmahon, , Bandon, Dublin 14 Co. Cork

Elke Hasner RM SECM IBCLC CIMI Ms. Bridget Sheeran RM SRN IPEN, Community Midwife Registered Midwife, Registered General Toames Baltimore Co. Cork. Co Cork.

Ms. Yvonne Teskey Healy RM Aisling Kearney RM RGN Midwife & Health Care Practitioner Registered Midwife Kilnamona Lackamore, Ballingarry Lahinch, Co. Co. Clare

Ms. Brenda Campion O Toole RM Ms. Sarah Masterson RM Registered Midwife Registered Midwife Lauragh Lodge, Mornington Road, Mountmellick, , Co Laois Dublin 6

Ms. Anne Marie Falk RM Ms. Bridget Heavey Registered Midwife Nurse, Midwife & Health Care Practitioner , Newbridge W12 P620 Co. Cork. Co Kildare

Ms. Jill Kenny Ms. Fiona Collins Sonaheal- complementary Healing Clinic Chartered physiotherapist Kilmoyley, Bandon Tralee, Co Kerry Co. Cork

Nicola Winters LLM Human Rights Law Ms. Patsy Puttnam Development Educator Community Activist and Cork Person of the 20 Manor Place, Year 2013. , , Dublin7 Co. Cork

Senator Frances Black Senator David Norris Leinster House. Leinster House. Kildare Street. Kildare Street. Dublin 2. Dublin 2.

Mr. Mr. Jeremy Irons, Folk singer, songwriter, guitarist and Actor, Producer and Director recording artist.

Mr. Jim Sheridan Mr. David Puttnam CBE, HonFRSA, Irish playwright, screenwriter, film director HonFRPS, MRIA and producer Film Producer and Educator

Mr. Glen Hansard Mr. Paul Brady Songwriter, musician, actor, singer and Singer, songwriter, musician and recording artist. recording artist 13

Ms. Mr. Declan Sinnott Folk singer and recording artist. Musician and recording artist.

Ms. , Ms. Mary Coughlan Musician and recording artist. Jazz, blues and folk singer.

Mr. Declan O Rourke Mr. Damien Dempsey Singer, musician, songwriter, and Singer, musician, songwriter and recording artist recording artist.

Mr. Luka Bloom Mr. Paddy Casey Singer, songwriter, musician and Singer, songwriter, musician and recording artist recording artist

Mr. Liam Ó Maonlaí Mr. Fiachna Ó Braonaín Singer, musician, songwriter and Singer, musician, songwriter and recording artist. recording artist.

Mr. Jim Corr Mr. Steve Wall Musician and recording artist. Musician, songwriter and recording artist

Mr. Steve Wickham Mr. Paul Linehan Musician and recording artist. Songwriter, musician, Frank & Walters

Mr. Ashley Keating Mr. Cian Corbett Musician, Frank & Walters Musician, Frank & Walters

Ms Vyvienne Long Juliet Feeney Composer, Musician and recording artist Composer, singer, musician & recording artist

Mr. Sacha Puttnam Ms. Rachel Pilkington Concert pianist, composer and conductor Irish Actress

Mr. Dónal Lunny (Edmond Enright) Folk singer, producer and recording artist Irish singer, songwriter and recording artist

Ms. Edel Griffith Mr. Ronan Browne Composer, Arranger and Sound Engineer Irish musician and composer

Mr. Patrick McCabe Mr. Niall Stokes Playwright and novelist Editor, Magazine

Mr. Jon Kenny Mr. Aidan Killian Comedian/Actor Comedian

Mr. Theo Dorgan Mr. Macdara Woods Irish Poet Irish Poet

Mr Pat Boran Mr. Joe Woods Irish Poet and Editor Irish Poet, writer and editor

Mr. Patrick Dillon Ms. Enda Wyley Irish Poet Irish Poet and Author

14

Professor Fintan Cullen Mr. Turtle Bunbury Historian and writer Historian and writer

Ms. Katherine Waugh Mr. Mike Mannix Curator, writer and filmmaker Editor - Publisher

Ms. Kathy Sinnott Ms. Darina Allen Former Member of European Parliament Chef, author, food entrepreneur Ballymaloe Cookery School Co Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Domini Kemp Ms. Peaches Kemp Chef, food writer, author, and Director Chef, food writer, author and Director ITSA Food Company ITSA Food Company Dublin 18 Dublin 18.

Mr. Con McLoughlin Ms. Karen Austin Lettercollum Kitchen Project Lettercollum Kitchen Project Timoleague Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Kevin Waugh Mr. Kieran Dunne Director Managing Director Brewing Company National Organic Products Ltd Baltimore Bunalun Organics Co. Cork Co. Wicklow

Ms. Colette Waugh Mr. Michael Waugh Colette Waugh Commissioner of Oaths Eastham Road Curragh Bettystown Skibbereen Co. Meath Co. Cork

Ms. Serena Ni Chorcorain Ms. Aileen Waugh 11 Riverview 20 The Hawthorns Bandon Skibbereen Co Cork. Co. Cork

Ms. Irene Tanner Ms. Aisling Fitzgibbon Pulla, Ring, 45 Lioscarrig drive, , Caherslee, Tralee Co Waterford. Co Kerry.

Mr. Sam Mc Nicholl Mr. Declan McCarthy Publican and Musician Lightfort House Connolly’s of Leap Poundlick Leap Skibbereen Co. Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Anne Cullinane Mr. John O Flynn 4 Scartagh, Farren, , Co. Cork Co Cork

15

Mr. Brendan McCarthy Ms. Sandrine McCarthy Poundlick Poundlick Skibbereen Skibbereen Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Brendan McCarthy (Sr) Ms. Eithne McCarthy Lightfort House Lightfort House Poundlick Poundlick Skibbereen Skibbereen Co. Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Suzanne McCarthy Ms. Cliodhna McCarthy 54 Mardyke Street 54 Mardyke Street Skibbereen Skibbereen Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Kieran McCarthy Ms. Mary O' Donoghue 3 Cork Road 3 Cork Road Skibbereen Skibbereen Co. Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Grainne McCarthy Mr. Gerard McCarthy Irish Citizen Irish Citizen 3 Olympic Mews 1909 11th Ave Wandsworth San Francisco London SW18 2AA Ca 94116-1334

Mr. Enda Buckley Ms. Kellie O Gorman Gortbrac 31 Willowgrove Old Cork Road, Skibbereen Limerick Co. Cork Co. Limerick

Ms. Rachel Connolly Mr. Mark Wicks Cobweb Cottage 61 Rockenham, , Greystones Ferrybank, Co.Wicklow Waterford

Mr. Ciaran D Smith Mr. Richard Deegan 1, Marlborough Rd. 70 Abbeyfield Ballitore Co. Dublin Co. Kildare

Mr. Mick Daniels Mrs Patricia ONeill Olivers Hill 76, Watson Pk. Kilotteran . Waterford Co Dublin.

Ms. Sorcha Van Dessel Mr. Stephen Kerr 5 Knapton Terrace, Monkstown, Co.Dublin. Co Mayo

16

Mr. Dave Grey Mr. David Jennings, Gurraun Sunnyhill, Firies Clancool More Killarney Bandon Co Kerry Co. Cork

Ms. Sabrina Mckeever Ms. Joanna Franczak 62 killegland, 84 Grande Central Ashbourne , Co Meath Dublin 18

Ms. Brigid Brennan, Ms Jeanie Frampton Crooksling Lodge, 29 Clonmel Rd Brittas, Callan, Co Dublin Co Kilkenny

Ms Anna Felton Ms. Georgette D’Arcy, Violet Bungalow, 18a Martello Court, Shankill, , Co Dublin Co Dublin.

Mr Gerald Griffin Mr. Sean Doyle, 19 Blackrock Grove 2 Ashbrook Easton Rd Eden, Leixlip Blackrock Cork. Co Kildare

Ms. Deirdre McCarthy, Mr. Donogh O ‘Loghlin, Annagh, Rathbarry, Castlebar Clonakilty, Co. Mayo Co. Cork

Ms. Mary Powell Ms Julie Warde Lambe 9 Kilbarron Drive 135 Rathlodge Ashbourbe, Dublin 5 Co. Meath

Ms. Juliet Kelly Ms. Marianne Slevin, The Deeps, The Funny Little Gallery, , Luogh North, Doolin, Co. Co. Clare

Mr. Vincent Kearns Ms. Marion Roache. 6 kilcarrig green Knockshanvalley Fettercairn Straide Dublin 24 Co Mayo

Mr. Michael Tanner Mr. Walter Ryan-Purcell Donemark, Lough Farm Co. Cork Co. Cork

17

Mr. Peter Mc Granaghan, Ms Michell Kittel 58 The Park Blue Cedars, 98 Blackcastle Lodge, Ballybofey, Flowerhill, Navan. Co, Donegal Co. Meath

Mr. Antoin O’hEocha, Ms Mary Kelly Godley 18 Parnell Street, Sallowglen, , Tarbert, Co.Dublin Co. Kerry

Mr. Jim Kelly Mr. Larry McCarthy 70 Southbury road, 58 Fiodh Mor, Wilton, Ferrybank, Cork City Waterford.

Ms Tracy Rawlings Ms. Jennifer Mortell Lissminton, 86 Castleland Court, Ballintra, , Donegal Co. Dublin

Mr. Mark Reid Ms. Jennifer Morton, 41 Cnoc na Greine View 19 St Fintans, Kilcullen North St, Drogheda Swords, Co, Louth Co. Dublin.

Mr. Jeff Rudd Mr. Shane Kelly, 31 Beaulieu View, Carraignamuck Greenbatter, Knockananna Drogheda, Arklow Co. Louth Co.Wicklow

Ms. Joanne Foynes Ms. Laura Notari Brocca Rosewood, Clonaslee Ballylangley, Portlaoise Bandon. Co Laois Co. Cork

Ms. Linda Biggins Ms. Caroline Bardon 22 Ormond Close Main Street, Kilanerin Swords Co. Dublin Co. Wexford

Ms. Sarah Mc Loughlin Ms. Martha Brassil Cleggan Beach House 45 Lioscarrig Drive Cleggan Caherslee Connemara Tralee Co. Galway Co Kerry.

Mr. Gef Dickson Mr. John M. Keating Mawmore 67 Caisleán Ná Rí Enniskeane Cashel Co Cork Co. Tipperary

18

Mr. Daniel Baillieul. Ms. Christine Dunne Bazigou Aldridge, Duncannon, 58, Graham's Court, , Ballyguilbeg, Co. Wexford Wicklow Town

Mr. Leslie Winters Mr. Dermot O' Dowda Ballinacarrick 8 Distillery Court Doochary Blackpool Co Donegal Cork City

Ms. Margaret Power Ms Catherine Caulwell Springmount Bohard, Dungarvan Dromcollogher, Co, Waterford. Co. Limerick

Mr. Ian Foy Ms. Pam Bergin 2 Applewood Mews, Treascon Swords, Portarlington Co. Dublin Co. Offaly

Mr. Simon Kavanagh Mr. Mark O Rourke Parklands Lower An Rinn Dungarvan Co. Wexford Co Waterford

Ms. Sabrina Ginesi, Mr. Tony Doherty 14 Belclare View, Tirhoran , Clonmany Dublin 11 Co.Donegal.

Ms. Gillian Murphy Mr. Philip Kelleher 4 Grafton Hall, 5 Glenconnor, Aungier St, Clonmel, Dublin 2 Co. Tipperary

Ms. Jane McLaughlin Mr. Stephen Biggins 48 Lakelands 22 Ormond Close Bridgetown Swords Co Wexford Co. Dublin

Ms. Edel Marie Meehan, Mr. , 9 College View Whitefield, Mountmellick Tinahely, Co. Laois. Co. Wicklow

Mr. Liam O'Brien Ms. Jessica Burke, Port-a-chee, 21 firgrove lawn, Crooke, Bishopstown, Co Waterford Cork

Mr. Daniel Wilson Mr. Dermot Aughney Gortroe, 53 Donard Rd Newcastle West, Co. Limerick Dublin 12

19

Ms. Marie Burns, Ms Angelin Byrne Cosmona, 48 Acorn Downs, Loughrea, Newbridge, Co. Galway Co Kildare

Ms. Martina Weldon Ms. Amanda Duke 48 Channel Road 6 Town Park, Rush Bandon Co. Dublin Co Cork.

Mr. Dylan Brady Ms. Bridget Dillon Indigo Ardbrack 26 Walnut Court, Scilly Kennedy Park, Co Cork Limerick

Ms. Michele Mr. Terry Doherty Cork Road, Main Street , Ferns Co. Cork Co.Wexford

Mr. Nathan Smith. Ms. Caroline Butler 16 O'Connor Park, 115 the coppice Masseytown, Woodfarm acres Macroom. , Co.Cork Dublin 20

Ms. Virginia Thomas, Ms. Siobhan Rice Ballinlough, 78 Slade Castle Ave Cork City. Co. Dublin

Ms. Tara Kileen Ms. Catherine McCormack 11 Dun Carraig Ceibh 39 Ardlo Manor, Leitrim village Mullagh, Co. Leitrim Co.

Paul Mangan Mr. Maurice Dodd Belpatrick 45 Charlesland Wood Ardee Greystones Co. Louth Co. Wicklow

Ms. Bridie Hickey-Racey, Ms Charlie Mc Dyer 21 Corran Fionn Barra, Donegal Road, Carrickmacross, Ballybofey, Co. Monaghan Co. Donegal

Ms. Emily Daines, Ms. Rita Brown, Cappanaboha, Abbeymahon Leap Timoleague, Co. Cork Bandon, Co Cork

Mr. Fergus Patrick Lynam Ms. Antonia Leslie Columcille, Trinity House , The Barrack Hill, Thomastown, Glaslough, Co.Kilkenny Co, Monaghan

20

Ms. Jean Crosbie Ms. Bernadette Bushe Killaha East 10 OldCourt Close Kenmare Co Kerry Dublin 24

Ms. Danielle Gavin Mr. Jordon O Donovan , 60 Belmont Place, Dublin, 13 Co, Cork.

Ms. Maureen Mc Dermott Ms. Sarah Tubridy 25. The moorings, 5 The Malthouse Quay Rd, Ballina, Kinsale Co. Mayo Co. Cork

Ms. Simone Marquis Ms. Roma Rosborough, 2 Saint Mary's Avenue 6 Cedarwood Road, Rathfarnham Waterpark, , Dublin Cork

Ms. Cathy Bowes Mullins Mr. Michael O Connor Quarry Road, Cappataggle Ballyferriter Ballinasloe Tralee Co. Galway Co Kerry

Ms. Carmel Daly, Ms. Cariosa Cullen 40 Newbridge Park, 6 Eldred Terrace, Skibbereen Cork City Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. James Herlihy, Mr. William DeTuncq Freahanes Cooragurteen , Skibbereen Co.Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Éamonn (Ed) Ó Ríordáin, Mr. Ruairí Coogan , Rathdrina, Beauparc, Bandon Navan, Co. Cork Co. Meath.

Mr. Jeremy Franco Ms. Michelle Barrett, 24 Waterlane, Bohermore 9 Cuirt Phairais, Galway Ballyferriter, Co Galway Co. Kerry

Mr. Peter O Connell Mr. Eoin Burns 46 Killcarrig crescent 29 Lighthouse Village Fettercairn Fenit Tallaght Tralee Dublin Co. Kerry

Mr. Enda Craig Ms. Anne Keohane Carnagarve 16 Connolly Street Moville Bandon Co Donegal Co. Cork 21

Mr. Pat Kenrick Ms Suzanne Mahon 24 Stenson Park Coolyhune Farranshone Graignamanagh Limerick Co Kilkenny

Ms Nicola Barry Mr. Ross Jackson 41 Lios Ard, Silverwood, , Rochestown Co. Clare Cork

Mr. Mike Daly Ms. Layla Daly 58 O'Callaghan Ave 58 O'Callaghan Ave Kileely Kileely Limerick Limerick

Mr. Anthony Corrigan Mr. Arthur Nevin. 72 Suncroft drive Legnanara Road, Kentstown, Tallaght Navan, Dublin 24 Co.Meath.

Mr. Flor O Mahony Ms. Aoife Harkness, 13 The German road. Lacken St Johns Park, Waterford Co. Wexford

Mr. Trevor Harkness Ms. Aoife Kelleher Lacken 6 Whitethorn Grove Duncormick Bandon Co. Wexford Co. Cork

Mr. Ciaran O Dochartaigh Ms. Deirdre O'Sullivan Loughanstown 9 The Botanic Knockdrin Prospect Hill Mullingar rd Co Westmeath Dublin 11

Mr. Kieran Cunnane, Ms. Caroline Farren Letteragh Cottage, 64 The Oaks Rahoon H91H7DA, Ridgewood Galway Swords.

Mr. Shane Clarke Ms. Michelle Gill 11 Carraig Craobh Drumliffen, Rahan Kilclare Letterkenny Carrick on Shannon, Co. Donegal Co.Leitrim

Mr. Sten Bjorsell Ms. Ewa Bjorsell New road New road Macroom p12n209 Macroom p12n209 Co. Cork. Co. Cork.

22

Ms. Louise Hall Ms. Genna Patterson Tincurry Drumkeen, Ballycarney black Hill road, Enniscorthy Ballinabarney, Co. Wexford Wicklow

Ms. Tricia O Connor Vincent Gill Jnr 36 Ashgrove Drumliffen, Ballyvelly Kilclare, Tralee Carrick on Shannon Co.Kerry Co. Leitrim

Ms. Leonora McAteer, Ms. Niclas Beckman April Cottage, 14 Seaview Avenue , Carrigaline Co. Dublin. Cork

Ms. Anne O Connor, Ms. Margaret Malone 65 Calderwood Road 39 Beaumont Drumcondra Crescent D09 W7T2 Dublin 9

Mr. Nick Beckman Mr. Simon English 14 Seaview Avenue Springfield Carrigaline Enniscorthy Co. Cork Co. Wexford

Mr. Graham McClean Mr. Paul Holmes 5 Church Street Ardan View, Finglas Tullamore, Dublin 11V4K8 Co. Offaly

Ms Ann Marie O Connell Ms Virginia Heneghan, 128 Vernon Avenue, Drumconlon Close, Clontarf, Castlebar, Dublin 3 Co. Mayo

Ms. Mary O'Regan Mr. Brendan Ringwood 11 Glincool Grove 8 Eagle Park Co.Cork Dublin

Mr. Tom Kelly Ms. Maire Harrington c/o 46 Caragh Avenue, Captains Boreen Caragh Avenue, Kilmoney Caherdavin Park Carrigaline Limerick Co Cork

Ms. Siobhán O’Neill Ms. Emer McCudden 10 Vavasour Square 61 Carrick Court Portmarnock Dublin D13K229

23

Ms. Sharon Davis Ms. Maria A Martinez 397 Cypress Gardens, 51 Lioscarrig Drive Bayestate, Caherslee. , Tralee. Co Louth. Co Kerry

Mr. Jason Kehoe Ms. Gill Quinn 56 The Oaks, The Back Gate Lodge, Belgard Heights, Grangecon, Dublin 24 Co. Wicklow,

Mr. Niall Murphy Ms. Brianna Campbell 16 Fernwood Ave, 85 Merchants Road Springfield, Dublin 24 Dublin 3

Ms. Fiona Ryan Ms. Ciara Coyne, Belmont Square, 3 Knights Park, , Castlebar, Dublin 5 Co Mayo.

Ms. Grace Daly Ms. Saoirse de Brún 47 Collins Place 19 Riverview Drive, Finglas east Ballineen, Dublin 11 Co. Cork.

Ms. Carolyn Reddin Ms. Sharon Boyle 244 Charlesland Court, 43 Conquer Hill rd, Greystones, Clontarf Co. Wicklow Dublin 3

Mr. Tom Mc Cleary Mr. Peter Jones 13 Knockbrogan Terrace, St Martins Bandon, Glenmore Co. Cork. Co Kilkenny

Ms. Shikha Meier Ms. Julia Lane 24 Ardan Glas 11 Cremore Close, Portlaoise Grange Manor, Co Laois Waterford

Ms. Clodagh Kelly Ms. Kathleen Blye 68 Glenina 40 Redbarn Cottage Gort Road, Ennis Redbarn Co Clare Co. Cork

Mr. David Delaney Ms. Mary Rose McQuinn Belmont Square, 7 Pine Cove Raheny, Dublin 5 CoWaterford.

Ms. Gemma Kingston Ms. Rubina khan 16 Glasslynn 14 Seaview avenue Bandon Carrigaline Co. Cork Co. Cork 24

Mr. Aedín Tynan Mr Proinsias Barrett Mount Odell 108 Manor Court, Carriglea Western Distributor Road, Dungarvan Knocknacarra, Galway, Co. Waterford Co. Galway.

Ms. Patricia Cantwell, Ms. Fiona Beresford 39 The Croft Cuan na Greine, Whitehouse, Clarinwood Suncroft, Tramore, The Curragh, Co. Waterford Co. Kildare

Ms. Natasha Doyle Mr. Mark Kingston 49 Keatingstown, 16 Glasslynn Wicklow Town, Bandon Co. Wicklow Co Cork

Ms. Philippa Callery Ms. Monica Villa 35 Ard Aoibhinn Springfield, Eden Road, Greystones. Co. Wexford Co. Wicklow

Mr. Albert Koka Ms. Karolina Koka 22 Riverwood Hall 22 Riverwood Hall Carpenterstown Carpenterstown Dublin 15 Dublin 15

Ms. Blazenka Herman Jackie Askew, 68 North Street, apt.3 2 Bow Lane, Skibbereen Ennistymon, Co Cork Co. Clare

Mr. Paul Connaughton Mr. Larry Reynolds Ballinglanna, 104 Park Clonakilty, Lucan Co. Cork Co. Dublin

Ms. Jackie McMahon Ms. Andrea Long, 54 Granville Park 5 Cherry Grove, St.Patrick's Road , Limerick Dublin 12

Mr. Leo Staples Ms. Niamh Mooney Forth View, 135 Whitehall Road Cregg, Ballycogly, Co. Wexford Dublin 12

Mr. Rupert Housden Ms. Laura Murphy Euterpe, , Abbeyleix Rd, Clonakilty, Portlaoise, Co. Cork Co. Laois

25

Mr. Luke Butler Mr. Declan McIntyre 16 Beechfield Close, Marion Avenue, Walkinstown, Glencolmcille, Dublin 12 Co. Donegal

Mr. Paul Flinter Ms. Caroline.Kelleher 17 Friarsgreen, "Erindale" 2 Gully Upper Tullow road, Castle Road Carlow, Bandon Co. Carlow Co Cork

Ms. Aoife MC Grath. Mr. Reg Plunkett, 7 Mountain View, 250 Roseberry Hill, Marlfield, Rickardstown, Clonmel, Newbridge, Tipperary Co. Kildare

Ms. Fiona Loxley Mr. Ben Butler 13 Radcliff Hall 1 New Ireland Court, St. John's Road New Ireland Road, Sandymount Rialto, Dublin 4 Dublin 8

Mr. Mark Morby, Ms. Caroline Petrassi Derrynaneal, 146 Redford park Greystones Feakle, Co Wicklow Co Clare Ireland

Ms. Teresa Whelan Mr. Peter Cooling 21 The Showgrounds, Knocknagow Old Court road Rathdowney, Bray Co. Laois Co Wicklow

Mr. Danny Forde Eithne O' Shea, 37 Glenbrook Gortnabla, Road Togher, Wexford Ballinasloe, Co. Roscommon.

Mr. Roger Lamb Mr. Ger Reddy 15 Lambourne Park, 11, Priory Way, Beaverstown Road, St. Raphaels Manor, , , Co. Dublin Co. Kildare

Ms. Lorraine Scanlon, Ms. Anne Quirke 16 Willowgrove, Cloonadra Coolroe Heights, Ballyleague Ballincollig. Lanesboro Co. Cork. Co. Roscommon.

Mr. Tins Keatinge Ms. Catherine Mc Inerney Barraderry West 13 Beech Park, Kiltegan Oranmore, Co. Wicklow Co. Galway 26

Ms. Denise Clifford. Ms. Michele Kennedy Rock St., 139 Drominbeg , Rhebogue Co. Cork. Co. Limerick

Ms. Geraldine Fleming Mr. Lez Connolly Ardnacarrig, Ardgehane Cobweb Cottage Timoleague Blacklion Bandon Greystones Co Cork Co.Wicklow

Ms. Wendy Keating Mr. Eoin Gallagher 200 the Willows, 200 the Willows, Ballincollig Ballincollig Co Cork. Co. Cork.

Ms. Joanne Addie Mr. Peter Glennon Ballyburley Ballyburley Rhode Rhode Co Offaly Co Offaly

Ms. Rose Addie Mr. Terry Irwin Whispering Wind 4 Empress Villas Fahy Hill St Lukes Rhode Cork City Co. Offaly Co. Cork

Ms. Gillian McDaid Mr. Andrew Loughhran Tullyarvan, Westbrook 80, Bruach na hAbhainn Quin Rd.,Ennis, Co. Donegal Co. Clare

Mr. Mark Wicks, Ms. Katie Neary 61 Rockenham Castleburn Ferrybank, Ballymote Waterford Co Sligo

Mr. Gareth Farr, Ms. Bernie Farr, 65, Ladys Cross, 65, Ladys Cross, Cloheen, Cloheen, Clonakilty, Clonakilty, Co. Cork Co, Cork

Mr. Patrick Farr, Ms. Tania Murphy, 65, Ladys Cross, Summer Rain, Cloheen, Shippool, Clonakilty, Innishannon. Co, Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Robert Daly, Ms. Shirley Griffin 10 Ard Na Gréine, 1 Chestnut Crescent , Classes Lake Bandon, Ballincollig Co Cork Co Cork

27

Ms. Shirley Ms. Christine O Meara Kingston. 5 Loch Luatha Crossmahon, Mount temple Bandon, Moate Co.Cork Co Westmeath

Ms. Vivian Fogarty, Ms. Sinead Cusack Kiskeam , Bruach na Habhainn, Coolfadda , Quin Rd, Bandon Ennis Co. Cork Co. Clare

Ms. Dawn Ellis Mr. Aaron Roche, 15 Richmond Court, Anchor house, Bandon, Ballyclemock, , Co. Cork Co. Wexford

Mr. Eamonn Jones Ms. Ann Jones St Martins St Martins Glenmore Glenmore Co Kilkenny Co Kilkenny

Ms. Janine Murphy. Ms. Angela Brown 73 Lady's Cross, Desert, Clonakilty Clonakilty, Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. David Ryan, Mr. Paddy Hughes Brownstown, 7 Ballbrigan Rd The Curragh, Skerries Co Kildare Dublin

Ms. Ann Marie O Connell Mr. Trevor harkness 128 Vernon Avenue, Lacken Clontarf, Duncormick Dublin 3 Co Wexford

Ms. Deirdre McCarthy Ms. Orla Coutin Butlerstown 50 Lus na Meala, Bandon Banduff road, Co Cork Cork City

Mr. Damien Byrne Ms. Geraldine fleming An Caireal, Ardnacarrig, Ardgehane Old Timoleague Road, Timoleague Clonakilty, Bandon Co. Cork Co Cork

Ms. Kathleen Considine Mr. Vincent Campellone 29 Fearnog Kellsgrange, Shannon Kells Co, Clare Co, Kilkenny

28

Ms. Aisling Byrne Ms. Valerie Roche, Kinvara New Ross, Co. Galway Co. Wexford

Mr. Vincent Roche Ms. Louise Pollock 1 Flinters Close Greystones,Ashgrove Pk Athy Bishopstown Co. Kildare. Co. Cork Mr. Owen Atkinson Ms. Alice Glendinning Rockfield East, An Caireal, Firies, Old Timoleague Road, Killarney, Clonakilty, Co Kerry Co. Cork

Ms. Tamas Notari Ms. Emma Hogan Kedward, Rosewood 28 The Park, Ballylangley Dunboyne Castle, Bandon Dunboyne, Co. Cork Co Meath

Mr. Christopher Atkinson, Ms. Lily Atkinson Rockfield East, Rockfield East, Firies, Firies, Killarney, Killarney, Co Kerry Co Kerry

Ms. Maura Duignan Ms. Pia McCarthy Knocknahur North Annagh, Ransboro Castlebar, Co. Sligo Co.Mayo

Ms. Heather Pabiou Mr. Gerry Dalton Lower Inchafune Ardglassan, Lisbealad Crossakiel, Kells Co Cork Co. Meath

Mr. Dan Arnold, Ms. Audrey Stamp, "Regina Pio" Ballymoteymore, Bartlemy, The Ballagh, Fermoy, Enniscorthy, Co. Cork Co. Wexford.

Ms. Vickie Bryan Mr. Frank Bryan Mcswiney quay, Mcswiney quay, Bandon. Bandon, Co. Cork Co. Cork.

Ms. Harley Devlin, Mr. Ryan Harkin Silver Manor, road Ballinlough, Cork Co. Cavan

29

Ms. Rosaleen Griffin Mr. Cathalk O’Donohue 61 Westfields 16 Whitehall Limerick Road Tullamore Ennis, Co. Clare Co. Offaly

Mr. Jason Denman Ms. Noelle O'Callaghan, 56 the grey square 7 St Lelia Place, Dublin Road, Co Dublin Limerick

Mr. Malachy Harty Ms. Florence Vion, Jamesbrook, Ballymacowen, , Clonakilty, Co. Cork. Co Cork

Mr. Shane Daly Ms. Hazel Stakem Dingle Cystal Green st. Belvedere Hills Dingle Mullingar Co. Kerry Co Westmeath

Mr. Cathal O Donohue Ms. Carol Grace Tullamore 41 Dean Place Co. Offally Kilkenny

Ms. Síle Reeves Mr. Andrew O Connor 16 Rosehill 17 Lake Edge Carysfort Ave Kilminchy Blackrock Portlaoise Co.Dublin Co.Laois

Mr. Paul Cullen Ms. Ann nolan Creggane lodge, Kilcarl Rosscarbery, Monacurragh Co. Cork Carlow

Ms. Blinne Loughran, Ms. Mary Murphy College st, Abbeyleix Rd Ballyshannon, Portlaoise Co Donegal Co. Laois

Mr. Eoin Ward Mr. Devin Kehoe 5 Thornhill Gardens, 10 Carrigmore Avenue Celbridge, Citywest, Co Kildare. D24

Ms. Eileen Crowley Ms. Claire Calvey Dromahair Kinvara Co. Leitrim Co Galway

Ms. Jeanette Lambert Mr. Pat Kehoe 2 Greanafarnagh, 13o the meadows east Ballinagleara, Belgard heights Co.Leitrim Dublin D24

30

Mr. Greg Bradley Ms. Catherine Mc Carthy, Ballymacowen, Annagh. Clonakilty, Castlebar, Co Cork Co Mayo

Ms. Gemma Phelan Ms. Faith Reilly 171 Oakcourt Drive, White Castle Lawn Palmerstown, Athy, Dublin 20. Kildare

Mr. Christopher McLaughlin Ms. Jane Loughran Churchtown, Brookfield, Carndonagh, Mullingar, Co. Donegal Co. Westmeath

Ms. Trea Heapes, Mr. Kevin Heapes, Pure Camping Eco Camping Site, Pure Camping Eco Camping Site, Querrin, Querrin, Co. Clare Co. Clare

Ms. Elaine Mac Ginty Ms. Honor Heffernan 38 Elmwood Downs 54 Carnew Street Letterkenny Stoneybatter Co. Donegal Dublin 7

Ms. Phyllis Lagan Ms. Breda Cooney Mossgrove Cross, Bandon. Clonakilty Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Malachy Keenan Ms. Noeleen Keenan, 244 The Rise 244 The Rise Belgard Heights, Belgard Heights, Tallaght, Tallaght, Dublin 24. Dublin 24.

Ms. Deborah Keenan Mr. Kevin Dundon, 5 St. John's Avenue, 5 St. John's Avenue, Pimlico, Pimlico, Dublin 8 Dublin 8

Mr. Anthony Corrigan, (Senior) Ms. Rachel Whelan 13 Chapel Street 142 abbey drive Ballymore Eustace, Navan road Co. Kildare Dublin 7

Ms. Paulina Bialolecka Ms. Charlotte Bruen 402 An ri rua eastham road Larchill Bettystown Loughrea Co.Meath Co Galway

Mr. Raymond Lambert, Ms. Naomi Jackson 129 Square, 3 Rosewood Lawn, Rd Bandon Dublin 8 Co. Cork 31

Mr. Tom Pierozek Ms. Yvonne Dunne 47 mount st joseph 148 Meadowbank hill Ratoath, Co Cavan Co. Meath.

Ms. Edelle Nolan Ms. Rebecca Atkinson, 47 Springfields Rockfield East, Waterford Road, Firies, Kilkenny City, Killarney, Co. Kilkenny Co Kerry

Mr. Vasco Pires Vaz, Mr. Mike Mannix Apt 84 block A, The Dale, Grande Central, Rockbrook, Woodpark, Sandyford, Dundrum Dublin 1 Dublin 16

Ms. Silja Harms Mr. David Kavanagh Tominearly, Drumoney, , Virginia, Enniscorthy, Cavan, Co Wexford Co Cavan

Ms. Susan Montgomery Ms. Deirdre MacMahon Gortnagrenane 'Bamenda' Castkefreke Rathuard Clonakilty Ballysheedy Co. Cork Co Limerick

Mr. Barry O’Brien Mr. Dermot Murphy Lispatrick Lower, 55 the Park, Old Head, Lakepoint Park, Kinsale, Mullingar, Co. Cork Co Westmeath.

Mr. Oisín Halpin Mr. Francis Thoma 147A Richmond Road, Coromandel Waterfall Court, Killaha East Fairview, Kenmare Dublin 3 Co.Kerry

Ms. Geraldine Stafford Ms. Anna Skrzydlewska Birchwood 9 Holywell Gardens, Waterford City Swords, Co. Waterford Co. Dublin.

Ms. Larisa Moroz Mr. Tomasz Pierozek 6 Bremore Meadows, 47 mount st Joseph, Balbriggan, Kingscourt, Co Dublin Co Cavan

Ms. Karen Delaney Mr. Mack Daly, 6 South Green, Stonegrange,Upper Green, Belfast, Kilcoole, BT11 8JF Co Wicklow 32

Ms. Tara O Donoghue Mr. Trevor Jackson 14 glór no dtonn 3 Rosewood Lawn, Garrettstown Bandon Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Barry Murray Ms. Lorna Jean Bolster 7 Gurteen North 30 Laureston Crescent Annasacual Tower Co Kerry Co Cork

Ms. Sinead Morris Ms. Kirsty Stewart The Stone Cottage, 2 Rockboro Terrace, Humphreystown, Old Blackrock Rd, Valleymount, Ballintemple Blessington, Cork City Co. Wicklow. Co. Cork

Ms. Mirka Szymanska Ms. Trich Deeney, 33the Oak “Sin é”, Parkview Ard Chleire, Stepaside Schull, Dublin 18 West Cork.

Mr. Trevor Eivers Ms. Mary Hillary, 14 Arlington Grove, St. Raphaela's, Blackthorn Hills, Upper Road, Ferrybank, , Waterford. Co. Dublin

Ms.Sarah Meally Ms. Marianne Moore Sinnott Garrons, 45 Greenoaks Stradbally, Ferrybank Portlaoise, Waterford Co Laois Co. Waterford.

Mr. Ian Read Mr. Duncan Blair 24 Cruise Park Walk, 32 Our Lady's Drive, , Aughrim, Dublin 15. Co. Wicklow . Ms. Michelle Fogarty Ms. Simon Ó Faoláin, Lispatrick Lower, An Tigh Thuas, Old Head, An Cnoicín, Kinsale An Daingean, Co. Cork Co. Chiarraí

Mr. Damien O Donoghue Mr. Laurence Reddin 15 Brookwood 244 Charlesland Court Ballyvolane, Greystones Cork City Co Wicklow

Mr. Paul Hendrick Mr. Jonathan Hayes 266 Beechdale, Kilbride, Dunboyne, Glenmore, Co. Meath. Co Kilkenny. 33

Ms. Miriam Theijsmeijer, Ms. Sar'anne O'Rourke Home Farm, Gortnadiha Upper Clogher, An Rinn , Dungarvan Co. Mayo Co Waterford

Mr. Charles Murphy Ms. Traci Gradiner Shippool 12 the Orchards Innishannon. Co.Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Susie Horan Mr. Michael Smith MSc Terrafirma Quillside Ardoginna Quill Road Ardmore Kilmacanogue Co Waterford Co, Wicklow

Mr.Michael Meally Ms. Rieke Garrons, Colleras Stradbally, Portlaoise, Skibbereen, Co. Laois Co. Cork

Mr. Tim Singleton Ms. Baerbel Schulz-Voss Colleras The old Rectory Goleen Goleen Skibbereen, Skibbereen, Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Matthew Brown Ms. Patricia Weston Abbeymahon, Piercetown Timoleague, Skerries Co. Cork Co. Dublin

Ms. Denise Monahan Ms. Miranda Daly, 22 The Crescent Peacehaven, Millbrook Lawns Shepperton, Tallaght Skibbereen, Dublin 24 Co. Cork

Ms. Nicola Reeves Mr. Ronan Tansey, 47, Tivoli Terrace East 9 Fullers Road, Dun Laoghaire Cork City Co. Dublin Co. Cork

Mr. Gianluca Tarallo, Mr. Jamie Clabburn. Pope's Hill, Derrymannin, Pope's Road, Knockmore, Cork City, Ballina, Co. Cork Co. Mayo.

Ms. Fiona Maria Fitzpatrick Mr. Albert Forde No. 3, The Carraige House, 134 Baunoge Mount Pleasant, , Loughrea, Co. Cavan Co Galway 34

Ms. Lorna Fitzpatrick Gaule Mr. Noel Gaule Corronagh Corronagh Virginia Virginia Co. Cavan Co. Cavan

Mr. John Patrick Beirne Ms. Joan Hanrahan 11 Lurgan Park 21 Church Rd, Renmore Dalkey, Co. Galway Co. Dublin.

Ms. Niamh Cooper Ms. Siobhain Burke, Massford 5 Knapton Terrace, Castlecomer Dun Laoghaire, Co. Kilkenny Co. Dublin

Ms. Elizabeth Tanner Ms. Ann Marie O'Neill, Convent of Mercy, Primrose Cottage, Boherboy Rd. School Road, Lotabeg Estate Lower Churchlands, Mayfield Tinahely, Cork Co. Wicklow.

Ms. Marike Dunk Ms. Karina Charles 1, Goat st Close Greaghrahan Dingle Co. Kerry Co.Cavan

Ms. Michelle Anderson, Mr. Richard Walsh. Ballinacarrow, 8 Alexandra Villas. Ballymote, St.Lukes. Co. Sligo Cork.

Mr. Eimhin David Shortt, Ms. Lia Santry Environmental PPN representative with 3 The Avenue Offaly LCDC, Dun Eala Barrack St, Duntaheen Road Crinkle, Birr, Fermoy Co.Offaly. Co. Cork

Mr. Fergus Tighe Ms. Deirdre Coleman 4 Bow Lane, 13 Birch Avenue Ennistymon, Caherdavin Co. Clare, Limerick

Mr. John Sturman Ms.Brigid Sinnott St. Josephs St. Josephs Ballinbearna Ballinbearna Ballinhassig Ballinhassig Co. Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Sarah Fischer Mr. Gary Courtney 68 The Hibernia Building Carnadragher Heuston South Quarter Tullyvin St Johns Road West Cootehill Dublin 8 Co. Cavan 35

Ms. Niamh McKinney Ms. Kay Davin Ballinaclea 21 Abbey Park View Brittas Bay Clane Co. Wicklow Co Kildare

Ms. Carol Newburn Mr. Rowan Lovett 10 Frankfort Park 30 Dun an Oir, Dundrum Loughrea, Dublin 14 Co. Galway.

Ms. Zlatoslava Suhina Mr. Merlin Lovett 30 Dun an Oir, 13 Old Blackrock Road, Loughrea, co. Galway, Cork City, H62 VY82 Cork

Ms. Sarah Power Ms. Clare Troy 67 Richmond Park, 5 Hampton Wood Way Bray Finglas Co Wicklow Dublin 11

Anne Foley Ms. Julie Nicholson, Mapstown 30 Dún Eoin Meadows, Springmont Ballinrea Rd. Dungarvan Carrigaline, Co Waterford Cork

Mr. Jamie O'Sullivan, Ms. Linda Lovett, Maglass, 30 Dun an Oir, Ballymacelligott, Caheronaun, Trailer, Loughrea, Co. Kerry. Co Galway

Ms. Evelin Peenar, Mr. Jared Browne 1 Killard 1 Killard Annascaul Annascaul Co. Kerry Co. Kerry

Ms. Janis Farrell Ms. Francine Walsh Riverchapel Wood, 4 Old Connell Gate , Newbridge Co. Wexford. Co. Kildare

Mr. Jake O'Mahony Ms.Sabine Grosperrin 7 Mountain view, 15 Belmont drive Marlfield Aikens village Clonmel, Stepaside Co. Tipperary Dublin 18

Mr. Ronan Duke Ms. Markwin Kobus 3 O Mahoney Ave Lisbarreen Bandon Bodyke Co.Cork Co. Clare

36

Ms. Suzanne Daly Ms. Dette Mc Loughlin 105 Corrach Bui 46 Portacarron, Rahoon Knocknacarra, Co. Galway Co. Galway

Ms. Marianne Whelan, Ms. Faye Clague, Kilmagemogue, 4 Scartagh, Kilmeaden, Clonakilty, Co. Waterford. Co. Cork

Ms. Olga Sluinskaja, Mr. Graham Rea 19 Birch drive, 31 La Verna Johnstown wood, Grange Road, Navan, , Co.Meath Dublin 13

Ms. Jo Cornally Phelan Ms. Eileen Geoghegan Lahinch Camus Iochtair Clara Connemara. Co.offaly Co Na Gaillimhe

Ms. Maria Tanner Cohen Ms. Jacqueline O'Reilly Knockenpower Lower, 23 Grange Downs Ring Rathfarnham Co Waterford Dublin 14

Ms. Rachel Lunt Ms. Anita Copperthwaite 2 Lacarroe Upper, 22 Elm Grove Feakel, Kells, Co. Clare Co Meath

Ms. Eilis Coughlan Ms. Tina Fordha, 119 Charlesland Park 25 New Estate, Greystones Clarinbridge, Co. Wicklow Co. Galway

Mr. Diarmuid Lyng Mr. Richard O Shaughnessey, Ardrinnane 45 Lioscarrig Drive , Annascaul Caherslee, Tralee Tralee, Co Kerry. Co Kerry.

Ms. Anna Campbell Ms. Linda O Flaherty Pine lodge 2 St Mary's Terrace Knockfadda Midleton Roundwood Co Cork Co Wicklow

Ms. Polly Bell Mr. Ronan Halpin Kilbronogue Keel, Schull . Co.Cork Co Mayo.

37

Ms. Cathriona Naughton, Mr. Thomas Chalan, 1 De Burgh Rd. 25 Cappanaveagh, Infirmary Rd, Salthill, Dublin 7 Galway

Ms. Mary Naughton, Mr. Michael Naughton, Belisker Brickens, Belisker Brickens, , Claremorris, Co. Mayo Co. Mayo

Ms. Leslie Coffey Ms. Melissa Nolan, 36 The Heights, Golf Course road, Woodpark, The Kerries, , Tralee, Dublin 16 Co Kerry.

Ms. Rachel Giles Ms. Dolores Corry 19 Aran Avenue 30 Cill Chais, Shannon, Co. Dublin Co. Clare

James Fordham, Mr. Adrian Kelly 25 New Estate, 25 New Estate Clarinbridge, Clarinbridge, Co Galway Co Galway

Sinead Moloney Ms. Debbie Devane Palmgrove cottage Oak Brook Lodge Ballycahane Acragar Croom Mountmellick Co Limerick Co Laois Ms.

Mr. Jack Lunt Ms. Ciara Goodwin, 81 Wellpark Grove, Kildwan, Wellpark, Bunmahon, Galway Co Waterford

Ms. Sandra Nash Ms. Catherine Weitbrecht 27 Shancastle AVE Tullynagreana Quarryvale Letterbarrow Donegal Town. Dublin 22 Co. Donegal

Ms. Jahne romer Mr. Stephen Glackin, 184 Castle Lawn Heights 1 Cranamore, Headford Road Aileach rd. Galway City Buncrana, Co. Galway Co. Donegal

Ms. Sarah Loughran Ms. Keith Gilligan, Prospect 127 Heatherhill Avenue, Mullingar Graiguecullen, Co.Westmeath Co. Laois.

38

Ms. Kelly CS Johnson Mr. Tp Niland The Burrow, Dublin Rd Ballyvaughan, Tuam Co Clare Co Galway.

Ms. Siobhan Hosie Ms. Sarah Dawson The cottage knockanes Proudstown rd Carron Navan Ennis Co. Meath Co Clare

Mr. Rok Stajnko Ms. Claire Callan 27 Chamley Gardens Irish Citizen Swords Rd 46-14 Skillman Ave Sunnyside Queens Co. Dublin New York

Ms. Lisa Kearney Ms. Bernie O’Shea 27 Chamley Gardens 32 Knocklyne Valley Swords Rd Sunhill Malahide, Killorglin Co. Dublin Co. Kerry

Ms. Nadine Cunningham Mr. Ian Hall 9 Ferndale Court 9 Ferndale Court Bray Bray Co Wicklow Co Wicklow

Ms. Aoife Griffin, Ms. Amanda Farrelly Malahide Readstown Fingal Trim. Co. Dublin Co.Meath.

Ms. Sharon Lynch Ms. Helena Randles 89 the glade, Ross Road, Athenry, Killarney, Co Galway Co Kerry

Mr. John Stokes Ms. Anne Hennessy Inchiknappa, , Ashford, Moycullen, Co Wicklow. Co Galway.

Ms. Deirdre lindy Mr. David Carroll Ballintlea 55 The Mills Mullinavat Skibbereen Co Kilkenny Co. Cork

Ms. Jo Smiddy, Mr. Simon Craigie Cluain Ard, 14 The Quarry brook lodge, Carrickhill Road Upper Glanmire, Portmarnock Co. Cork Dublin 13

39

Ms. Arjen Stofberg Ms. Mairéad McKeon 14 Middleton st. 4 Keekill Cottages Cobh, Headford Co. Cork Co. Galway

Ms. Noreen Carroll Mr. Paudie Kenny, 55 The Mills Caherslee Road, Skibbereen Tralee Co. Cork Co. Kerry

Ms. Suzanne Black Ms. Karen Kelleher 88 fort hill 4 Primrose Street, Moneygurney , Co. Cork Dublin 7

Mr. Matt Whelan. Mr. Niall Smiddy, Johnstown 8 Sunny Beach, Duncormick Ballinskelligs, Co Wexford Co. Kerry

Mr. Joe Thorpe, Mr. Brian Shortall 46 Clanmaurice Road, 13 Oldbridge Court , Lucan Dublin 5 Co. Dublin

Mr Ross Crowley, Ms. Sinéad Mc Mahon 20 Suttons Buildings, Inagh Co Cork. Co Clare

Ms. Hannah Moran Ms. Helen Moran Derrygorman Derrygorman Westport Westport Co Mayo Co Mayo

Mr. Cathal Stack Ms. Marie Clifford 5, Saint Patrick's Park, The Spa Clondalkin, Tralee Dublin 22. Co Kerry

Mr. Noel Hanley Ms. Denise Brassil 21 Seville grove, 33 Clougher faili, Margaretsfield, Lioscarrig, Callan rd, Kilkenny, Caherslee, Tralee Co. Kilkenny Co Kerry

Ms. Loz-Ann McCarthy Ms. Mary Kennedy Keel 8 Cross Avenue Castlemaine Blackrock Co Kerry Co Dublin

Ms. Adrienne Donaghy Ms. Eileen Conneely 11 Ratra Road, 76 Park Navan Road, Manorhamilton Dublin D07 Co.Sligo 40

Mr. Jakobus Smit Ms. Dave Guiry, 76 Clooneen Park 3 Chapel Close, Manorhamilton Newcastle West, Co.Sligo Co. Limerick.

Ms. Marie Loftus Mr. Keith Berigan 13 Greenhills Est 37 Castle Riada Drive Ballina Lucan Co Mayo Co Dublin

Ms. Fiona Moran Ms. Rina Whyte, Derrygorman Punchestown Upper Westport Kilteel Co Mayo Co.Kildare

Ms. Lynn Byrne Ms. Anne Hughes St Ninian’s 19 Kincora Park Clontarf, Co. Wexford Dublin 3

Ms. Ann Moran Ms. Joanna Moran Derrygorman Derrygorman Westport Westport Co Mayo Co Mayo

Ms. Marta Torre Ms. Miranda O'Brien 46 Beaufield Park Elton Stillorgan Knocklong Co. Dublin Co. Limerick

Ms. Gemma Kingston Mr. Malachy Ward 16 Glasslynn 35 Gleann Noinin, Bandon College Road, Co. Cork Galway City

Mr. Mike Malone, Ms. Bernie Molloy, Cloonadra, 7 Lee Park, Ballyleague, Shannon, Co. Roscommon Co. Clare

Ms. Lucy McLoughlin Mr. Alf Smiddy 24 Lower Grattan ok diseart, clay castle Greystones Youghal, Co.Wicklow Co. Cork

Mr. Eoin Smiddy, Ms. Caitriona Smiddy, 8 Copley terrace, 40 ring street, Copley street, Ichicore, Cork Dublin 8

Mr. Paddi O'Sullivan, Mr. Trevor Mcguirk Hillside, 52 Tubberclaire Meadows Tawnies, Athlumney Clonakilty, Navan Co. Cork Co. Meath 41

Mr. David Malone Ms. Muireann O'Neill, Lehery 75 Sweetmount Ave, Lanesborough Dundrum, Co Longford. Dublin 14.

Ms. Mairead Whelan Ms. Marie O Mahony Killofin Pike road, Labasheeda Fermoy. Co Clare Co. Cork

Mr. Paul O’ Neill Ms. Fiona Montague, 1 The Close, 2 The Green, Glenveigh, Johnstown Manor, Boyne Road, Navan, Johnstown Co. Meath. Co. Kildare

Marina Levitina Jonathan Callaghan Clearview Lodge Gortagrenane, Kiltrasna Castlefreke Headford Clonakilty Galway Co. Cork

Mr. Ms. Eilish Fitzgerald 24 Merton Drive 4 Church St., Ranelagh Tipperary Town Dublin 6 Co. Tipperary

Rachel Kerr. Rhona Fitzpatrick 16 Church Ave, Woodmancote, Eden Gate, Killiney Hill Road, Delgany, Killiney, Co. Wicklow Co. Dublin

Ms. Barbara Conway Ms. Anna O'Leary 18 Temple Court The White Cottage Palatine Square Ash Grove Arbour Hill Listowel, Dublin 7 Co. Kerry.

Ms. Geraldine Convery Ms. Mairead Smith 11 The Woodlands, 92 Red Arches Road, Castletown, The Coast, Celbridge, Baldoyle, Co. Kildare Dublin 13.

Mr. Karl Kendellen Ms. Grainne Gallwey 92 Red Arches Road, 91 Eaton Wood Grove Baldoyle, Shankill Dublin 13. Co Dublin

Ms. Alison hopkins Mr. Adrian Hopkins Ballyea South Ballyea South Inagh, Inagh, Co Clare Co Clare

42

Mr. Josh hopkins Ms. Grainne Gallwey Ballyea south 91 Eaton Wood Grove Inagh Shankill Co Clare Co Dublin

Ms. Elaine McDonagh Mr. Jamie Rooney, 33 Bulfin Road Gortogher, Inchicore Cloghans, Dublin 8 Ballina, Co. Mayo

Ms. Rowena O’Brien Ms. Catherine FitzMaurice 18 Geraldine Place Kilbrogan House Albert Road Bandon, Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Ciaran wood Ms. Bernie Smyth, 98 Dunan, 16 An Tobairin Thomastown Clonakilty Co. Kilkenny Co. Cork

Ms. Barbara Bolger, Ms. Ruth Trimble. Gardenhill, Cloonadra Castleconnell, Ballyleague Co Limerick Co. Roscommon

Ms. Jessica Barrett Ms. Patricia Barrett St davids well St davids well Ballinaslaney Ballinaslaney Oylegate Enniscorthy Enniscorthy Co Wexford Co Wexford

Ms. Rhona Fitzpatrick Ms. Cathy Walsh Woodmancote, 10 Calderwood Circle, Killiney Hill Road, Donnybrook, Killiney, Douglas, Co. Dublin Co. Cork,

Ms. Maria Svensson Ms. Lorraine McCarthy, The Old Farmhouse, Hillview, Baile na Saor, Knockeragh, Annascaul, Tiernaboul, Tralee, Killarney, Co Kerry Co.Kerry.

Ms. Sinead Mitchell , Mr. Cionnaith Ó Súilleabháin, killabrick, An Tobairín, Carrickmacross, Cloch na gCoillte, Co. Monaghan. Co. Chorcaí

Ms. Sharron Toner Ms. Siobhán Tanner, 37 Canon's Wood, Annascaul, Bandon, Tralee, Co. Cork. Co Kerry

43

Ms. Linda de Courcy Ms. Michelle Lowe 17 Newlands Manor Pk, Cortober, Dublin 22 Carrick-on-Shannon, Co. Dublin Co Roscommon

Ms. Deirdre Lane Ms. Ali Howarth 56 College Park Shippool Newbridge Innishannon Co.Kildare Co. Cork

Mr. Brian McCarthy, Mr. Paul O'Driscoll, Hillview, The Old Farmhouse, Knockeragh, Baile na Saor, Tiernaboul, Annascaul, Killarney, Tralee, Co.Kerry Co Kerry.

Ms. Mary Naughton Ms. Bairbre Crowley 68 Dewberry The Orchard Mount Oval Western Road Rochestown Clonakilty Co. Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Finbar O' Connor, Ms. Bernie Stubbs Mahanagh, 15 Atlantic Coast Apartments Drumshanbo, Tramore Co. Leitrim. Co. Waterford

Ms. Roisin Collins Ms. Liam Canavan, 40 Ballyroan Road. Droumavalla, Rathfarnham. Tralee, Dublin 16 Co Kerry

Ms. John Barrett Ms. Jamie Barrett St Davids Well St Davids Well Ballinaslaney Ballinaslaney Oylegate Oylegate Enniscorthy Enniscorthy Co Wexford Co Wexford

Ms. Susan Walsh Ms. Maria O'Brien Derryloughane east 17 Longfield Way, Furbo Cashel Road, Co Galway Clonmel, Co.Tipperary

Mr. Micheal O'Cleirigh Ms. Siobhan Kinane, 34 Raymond Street Kilshane. Dublin 6 Co. Tipperary.

Ms. Ethna Mc Dermott Ms. Caitriona Conway Ardsallaghmore Beaghmore, Roscommon Belclare, Tuam, Co. Roscommon Co. Galway.

44

Mr. Paul Mackey Mr. Greg Doran (Irish Citizen) 6 Vernon Crescent 19 Pinebrook Drive Westburry White Plains, NY 10605 Corbally USA Co Clare

Ms. Margaret Rybicki Ms. Eileen Flynn, Willow Cottage 21 Ascal Emer, Mullanyduff The Ferns, Castlegal Blackrock. Co Leitrim Co. Louth

Mr. Ray O’Farrell Mr. Pat Hayes Quarry Rd, 18 Thornfields , Monaleen Co. Cork. Co limerick

Mr. Tony O’Leary Ms. Jannicke-Marie Johansen PO Box 822 12 Richmond House, Cork Central DO Richmond Hill, Togher Monkstown, Cork Dublin

Ms. Emer Barry Ms. Naomi Deegan Mahanagh, 13 Tamarisk Heights, Drumshanbo, Kilnamanagh, Co. Leitrim Dublin 24

Mr. David Power Ms. Sarah Power 67 Richmond Park, 67 Richmond Park, Bray Bray Co Wicklow Co Wicklow

Ms. Ella Power Mr. Joseph James Sullivan, 67 Richmond Park, 12 Park, Bray Artane, Co Wicklow Dublin 5.

Ms. Dia Silverstein Ms. Rosaleen Butler 60 Caislean Drive 3 Summerhill Road Ballincollig Trim Cork Co. Meath

Mr. Richard Colson Ms. Geraldine De Courcy Derryrush Kindlestown Hill Rosmuc Delgany Co. Galway Co. Wicklow

Mr. Jonathan Neilan Ms. Eilis burgess, 31 Durham Road 32 the village gate, Sandymount Dalkey, Dublin 4 Co. Dublin

45

Ms. Carol Barrett, Ms. Elaine Franklin Sean bhaille, Corelish Moycullen, Pallasgreen Co Galway Co Limerick

Mr. David Kavanagh Ms. Kelda Clermont 1 Francis Villa, 8 Glenbourne Ave, Grange Heights, Leopardstown, Waterford City. Dublin 18

Ms. Amandine Mege Ms. Marie Burdis-Laffan. 40, Seafield Court Lower Commons Rd. Killiney Baldonnell. Co. Dublin Dublin 22

Ms. Nóra Ní Loingsigh Ms. Suzanne Keogh 11 Cúirt na dTúdarach Sunrise Bóthar an Inbhir South Shore Road Mullach Íde Rush Co. Átha Cliath Dublin

Ms. Suzanne Nelson, Ms. Verena Diamond 61 Oaklawn Estate, 21 Glencairn Park Leixlip, Bishopstown, Co. Kildare, Cork

Mr. Niall Diamond Ms. Helena Murphy 21 Glencairn Park Droum South Bishopstown, Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Gerard Brennan Mr. Dylan Murphy Droum south 17 shamrock road, CastletownBere Douglas, Co. Cork Cork

Ms. Deirdre Neilan Mr. Brendan Johnston 31 Durham Road Milltown, Sandymount Kilmacow Dublin 4 Waterford

Ms. Sarah McCarthy Ms. Susi Coveney Annagh, Cnocan Rua Castlebar, Moycullen Co.Mayo Co. Galway

Ms. Courtney Tyler Ms. Jenny McElvaney Chapel Lane 50 Portersgate Heights Glenealy Co. Wicklow Dublin 15

Mr. Jim Neary Ms. Bonnie Neary Carnmore Cross Carnmore Cross Oranmore Oranmore Co. Galway Co. Galway 46

Mr. Steven Carruthers Ms. Nikki Carruthers 24 Glencairn Ave, 24 Glencairn Ave, The Gallops, The Gallops, Leopardstown, Leopardstown, Dublin 18 Dublin 18

Ms. Annie Keelty Mr. Kieron Keelty Ballinvreena Ballinvreena Martinstown Martinstown Kilmallock Kilmallock Limerick Limerick

Ms. Eleanor O'Sullivan, Ms. Andrea Yeomans 25, Poplar Avenue, Kilvine Fota Rock, Irishtown , Claremorris Co.Cork Co Mayo

Ms. Lorna Carr Mr. Pablo Eakins 12 Distillery Court 45 Chalfont Road, Westport Malahide, Co Mayo Co. Dublin

Mr. Mr. Patrick James Healy Green Ave, Walnut Rise Newlands, Griffith Avenue Naas, Drumcondra Co Kildale Dublin 9.

Mr. Patrick Bryan Mr. Michael Mc Gloin 10 haverty road 3 Beech Park Ave, Marino Coolock village, Dublin 3 Dublin5

Mr. Setanta Mc Gloin Mr. Sam Mc Gloin 3 Beech Park Ave, 3 Beech Park Ave, Coolock village, Coolock village, Dublin5 Dublin 5

Mr. Ivan McCutcheon Ms. Joan Power Clancoolmore, 3 Beech Park Ave, Bandon, Coolock village, Co. Cork Dublin 5

Ms. Helen Bryan Ms. Margaret O'Rathaille 10 Haverty Rd 215 Viewmount Marino Waterford City Dublin 3 Co. Waterford

Ms. Brigid Power-Ryce Mr. Chris Grace 2 Galway Coast Cottages Mount Eland House Barna Johns Avenue Co.Galway Waterford

47

Ms. Clodagh Bryan Ms. Mary White 115 Timbermill 4 Killiney Terrace Kilmore Rd Breffni Road Artane Dublin 5 Co Dublin

Ms. Áine Ní Cheannabháin Mr. Mike Tully Aill na Brón 71 Sandyvale Lawn, Cill Chiaráin Galway, Conamara Co. Galway Co. na Gaillimhe.

Ms. Anne Hennessy Ms. Anne Agnew Kyle, 35 Berystede, Killea. Leeson Park, Templemore. Ranelagh, Co Tipperary. Dublin 6

Mr. Kevin O'Kane Ms. Iris Powell 64 Rokeby Park Corcullen Lucan Bushy Park Co. Dublin Co. Galway

Mr. Kevin Higgins Mayca Fernandez Toscano Midleton 111 Hazelbury Park Cork Dublin 15

Ms. Linda Madeira Mr. Stephen Flynn Emlagh, Emlagh, Ballyferriter Ballyferriter Dingle, Dingle, Co Kerry Co Kerry

Mr. James Moore Ms. Jessica Peel Yates 48 Monalea Grove 48 Monalea Grove Fihouse Fihouse Dublin 24 Dublin 24

Mr. Noel O'Sullivan, Ms. Helen Pinoff, 80 Woodside, Aughnaha, Rathfarnham, Rossinver, Dublin 14 Co Leitrim

Ms. Paula O'Sullivan Ms. Anne Carroll 43, Burgage Manor, Emper Blessington, Ballynacargy Co. Wicklow Co. Westmeath

Ms. Caitriona Fitzgerald, Ms. Catherine Molloy Daraheen, Glenburgh Townspark, Dargle road Lismore Bray Co.Waterford Co. Wicklow

48

Mr. Jeroen Stofberg Ms. Kathleen Nugent Artigallivan, 3 Shanganagh Wood, Headford, Shankill, Killarney, Dublin 18 Co. Kerry

Ms. Barbara Callaghan Mr. Breandan O Currain Nead Na Greibhe Baile an Reannaigh Tinnock Crossroads Baile and Fheirtearaigh Gorey Tra Li Wexford Co. Chairrai

Ms. Carol-Ann Reynolds. Ms. Rebecca Bristow 29 Regency Court. 14 Avondale Crescent Friary Street. Killiney Kilkenny Co Dublin

Ms. Aoife Moore Ms. Emer Mullarkey, 35 Elm Mount Court Taugheen, Beaumont Claremorris Dublin 9 Co. Mayo

Ms. Nicola Barnes, Ms. Suzanne Daly Ballinruan, 105 Corrach Bui Crusheen, Rahoon Co Clare Co. Galway

Ms. Aine Douglas Ms. Helena O Dwyer 6 Gleann na Coille 46 Rochestown Rise Barna road Rochestown Road Galway, Cork City Co. Galway Co. Cork

Ms. Linda Kilkenny Mr. Robin Rae-Fraser 34 Leicnin Village Kopple Turlough Knockataggart Castlebar Skibbereen Co. Mayo Co. Cork

Ms. Alexandra Albu Ms. Aisling Murray, 63 Charlesland Grove, Feaugh, Greystones, Poles, Co Wicklow. Co. Cavan

Mr. Garie Beattie, Ms. Alison Burnard 22 Bunree Road, Upper Main Street, Ballina. Glin, Co. Mayo. Co. Limerick

Mr. Shane flynn Mr. Sean Lowde, 21 kerins park 27 The Weir, Tralee Co. Kerry Dublin 20 49

Ms. Claire Butler Mr. Ben O'Dwyer Courtview, 121 Deerpark Lifford, Friar's Walk Ennis, Cork, Co. Clare Co. Cork

Ms. Maresa Forde, Mr. John Mitchell 3 Emmett street, 22 cherry orchard ave, Mountmellick, , Co. Laois Dublin 10.

Mr. Conor Tuite Ms. Anneli Watson flat 2 Cooloughra 5-6 upper castle street Rd Tralee Westport Co. Kerry Co. Mayo

Ms. Sally Horn Ms. Claire Ni Fhearghail Aughris, Drominagh Wood Rocky Valley Terryglass Kilmacanogue Nenagh Co. Wicklow Co. Tipperary

Mr. Jim Mr. Tom Corcoran The Forge, 5 Loch Luatha, Lisheenageeha, Mount Temple, Headford, Moate, Co. Galway Co Westmeath

Ms. Anne Noonan, Mr. Kevin Noonan, 152,West Ave., 152,West Ave., Parkgate, Parkgate, Frankfield, Frankfield, Co. Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Marina Bilak, Ms. Suzanna O'Coineen, 1 Dundela Crescent, "Rathoe" Dun Laoghaire, 12 Rosmeen Gardens, Co. Dublin Dun Laoghaire

Ms. Nuala Malone Mr. Robert Tracey 14 Cloontuskert 49 Rivervalley Grove Lanesboro Swords Co Roscommon Co.Dublin

Ms. Fiona Tracey Ms. Aine Parkes, Ballough 19 Caheroyan Drive, Lusk Athenry, Co. Dublin Co. Galway

Ms. Siobhán O'Reilly Mr. Graham Mc Allister 9 Parkwood Lawn, 18 The elms Aylesbury, Beaufort place Tallaght Navan Dublin 24. Co Meath 50

Ms. Sioban Fawl , Ms. Tanya Weir Knockeneen, 95 Castlemoyne Ennis , Co. Clare Dublin 13

Mr. Andrew Weir Ms. Josephine McDonnell 95 Castlemoyne 15 Crofton Avenue Balgriffin Dún Laoghaire Dublin 13 Co Dublin.

Ms Sinead Flannery Ms. Helen Postma 56 The Grey Square, 7 Brighton Vale Portrane, Donabate, Monkstown Co. Dublin Co. Dublin

Ms. Geraldine Dempsey Ms. Lorcan Doyle Sheeran "Djouce" Clonulty, Saint John's Well Ballydangan, Ballinrea Road Athlone, Carrigaline Co Roscommon Co. Cork

Ms. Anushka Power Ms. Ann Saunders, 42 Larkfield Grove, 99 Tudor Grove, Harold's Cross Ashbourne, Dublin Co Meath

Mr. Ray Doyle, Ms. Audrey Byrne Craddenstown , 16 Berwick Drive Raharney Swords Co Westmeath. Co. Dublin

Ms. Corina Hanrahan, Ms. Jeff Gonet 2 The hawthorns, Hollyhill South Skibbereen, Ballineen Co Cork Co Cork Ms. Julie Piper-Roche, Ms. Cathy Piper, The White Cottage, The White Cottage, Killoughter, Killoughter, Newcastle/Greystones, Newcastle/Greystones, Wicklow Wicklow

Mr. Joe Healy, Ms. Mary O'Sullivan, 37 Glasslyn, 37,Glasslyn, Bandon. Bandon Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Timothy O'Sullivan, Ms. Ellen O'Sullivan, 4,South Lodge, 4,South Lodge, Douglas, Douglas, Cork Cork

51

Mr. Ronan McKeon Mr. Mark Twomey, Edenmore, 25, Poplar Avenue, Sion Road, Fota Rock, Glenageary, Carrigtwohill, Co. Dublin Co. Cork

Mr. Anthony. Fagan. Ms. Erin Fagan. 1 Blackthorn Ave, 1 Blackthorn Ave, Beaufort Place, Beaufort Place, Navan. Navan. Co. Meath Co. Meath

Ms. Patricia Cronnelly Ms. Caitriona Migieu Coade 1 Lumiera, 131 Bracken Court Rocky Valley Road, Donnybrook Kilmacanogue, Douglas Co Wicklow Co Cork

Mr. Gerard O Gorman Mr. David Geoghegan 10 Monaloe Court Derrymoyle Blackrock. Oughterard Co. Dublin. Co Galway

Mr. Martin Nolan Mr. Tony Adams, 56 Árd Fraoígh, Teeraveen Clybaun. Lissarda Galway Co. Cork

Ms. Erin Ashworth Ms. Leslie Blair Newtown 50 Albert Rd Bantry, Uppr Glenageary Co. Cork Co Dublin

Mr. John Townsend, Mr. Seamus Talbot 3 Rye River Walk, Kilteevan Kilcock, Co. Roscommon. Co. Kildare.

Mr. David Sherlock Ms. Lynda Piper-Roche, 26 priory drive, The White Cottage, Eden gate, Killoughter, Delgany Newcastle/Greystones, Co Wicklow, Wicklow

Ms. Eoin. Fagan. Mr. Niall. Fagan. 1 Blackthorn Ave, 1 Blackthorn Ave, Beaufort Place, Beaufort Place, Navan. Navan. Co. Meath Co. Meath

Ms. Ann O Sullivan Mr. Colman O Sullivan The Farm The Farm Gaggin Gaggin Bandon Bandon Co. Cork Co. Cork 52

Mr. Marton O Gorman Ms. Róisín Ni Gháirbhith, Ardpatrick An Taisce, Kilmallock Environmental Education Officer. Co Limerick

Ms. Sue Corcoran Mr. Keith Buckley 6 Cluaindonn 6 Cluaindonn Ballycasey Ballycasey Shannon Shannon Co. Clare Co. Clare

Ms. Marie Fagan. Ms. Leslie. Fagan. 1 Blackthorn Ave, 1 Blackthorn Ave, Beaufort Place, Beaufort Place, Navan. Navan. Co. Meath Co. Meath

Ms. Mairéad O'Donovan, Mr. Tim Clarke Ahaglaslin, Emlach Slat, Castlefreke, Ventry, Clonakilty, Tralee, Co. Cork Co Kerry

Mr. Paul Devins Ms. Deirdre Sherry Coosan Eile Coosan Eile Breeogue Breeogue Ransboro Ransboro Co. Sligo Sligo

Mr. Damien. Fagan. Ms. Fiona. Fagan. 1 Blackthorn Ave, 1 Blackthorn Ave, Beaufort Place, Beaufort Place, Navan. Navan. Co. Meath Co. Meath

Ms. Michelle Davern Mr. Thomas Heneghan 188 Quarry Road Tullaughan Cabra Dublin 7 Co Mayo

Mr. David McGuinness Ms. Joan Power 74 Grangebrook Avenue, 3 Beech Park Avenue Dublin 16 Dublin 5

Ms. Elizabeth Dodd Ms. Eamonn Doran, 67 James Everett park Main Street Bray, Kilanerin Co. Wicklow Co Wexford

Ms. Andrea Manley Ms. Denise Sheridan 45charlesland wood 32 Glenariff Rd Greystones Navan Rd Co. Wicklow D 7

53

Ms. Catherine Ryan Mr. Michael Martin 26 Clonard Park 19 Crowe Abbey, Ballybeg Delgany, Waterford Co. Wicklow.

Mr. Damien Fitzgerald Ms. Grace Gilroy, 23 Castletimon Green 17 William street, Kilmore west Wexford town, Dublin 5 Wexford.

Mr. James O'Sullivan Mr. Cormac Nugent 44 Beech Park, 19 Millford Riverstown, Athgarvan Tramore, Newbridge Co. Waterford. County Kildare.

Mr. Paul O'Halloran-Gomes Ms. Melanie O'Halloran-Gomes Newline, Newline, Maree, Maree, Clarinbridge Clarinbridge Co. Galway Co. Galway

Mr. Brian O’Donoghue . Ms Amanda MacMahon 4 Ardglass , Newtown Baltinglass , Keel, Achill island Co. Wicklow. Co. Mayo

Ms. Michelle Kennedy Mr. Gary Edwards 139 Drominbeg Bulgan Glynn Rhebogue Enniscorthy Limerick Co. Wexford

Ms. Mary Griffin Mr. Stephen Fitzpatrick 23 Carrickbrack Heath 149 Orwell Park View Sutton Dublin Dublin 6w

Mr. Bernard Fleming, Ms. Martina Fleming, 1 Newtown Villas, 1 Newtown Villas, Henry St, Henry St., New Ross, New Ross, Co. Wexford Co. Wexford

Ms. Christine Heyward Ms. Catriona Conway, Tulla Beaghmore, Capparoe Belclare, Nenagh Tuam, Co. Tipperary Co. Galway

Ms. Dorothy Giselsson Ms. Aoife O'Connor Griffin Cornulla 1 Main Street, Gorvagh Malahide, Co.Leitrim Co. Dublin

54

Ms. Natasha Iveson Ms. Sarah Kilkenny 49 Keatingstown Ballinameen Wicklow Town Boyle Co. Wicklow Co Roscommon

Mr. Brian Greham Mr. Donal ó hAnnáin Chico 13 an lár Cartontroy Dargle Road lower Athlone Bray Co. Westmeath Co Wicklow

Mr. Jude Bredin Ms. Ciara Coyle 192 Botanic Ave 3 Knights Park, Castlebar, Dublin 9 Co Mayo

Ms. Sinead Gogarty Ms. Karen B Ni Gheibhea The Cottages, 61 Tower St. Laghy, Rush Donegal Town Fingal, Co. Donegal Co. Dublin

Ms. Ann Greaney Ms. Caoimhe Stewart 50 Home Villas 50 Home Villas Donnybrook Donnybrook Dublin 4 Dublin 4

Ms. Nuala Burke, Ms. Una Ruddock, 10 Benvoirlich Estate, 6 Tullyhall Crescent, Bishopstown, Lucan, Co. Cork. Co. Dublin

Ms. Kathrin Marx Ms. Maria Murray, Ventry Kilmacow Co Kerry Co..Kilkenny

Ms. Laurence Fleming, Ms. Diane Macko. 6 elm court, Caher. Lucan, . Dublin 20 Co. Mayo.

Mr. Fearghal Mac Lochlainn, Mr. David Day. The Woods, White Castle lawns Buncrana Athy Co Donegal Co. Kildare

Ms. Melanin Drea, Mr Alistair Smith, 23 Glenrichards Wood, 4 Fullam Terrace, Gorey, Balbriggan, Co Wexford Co Dublin

Mr. Leslie Dwyer, Mr. Brendan Lane, 18 Dun Na Ri, Roseberry, Carlow Road, Athy, Newbridge Co. Kildare Co. Kildare 55

Mr. Niall Porter, Ms. Debbie Levis Wood Cottage, Higgledy, Ballinacarrig lower, Firkeale, Rathdrum, Co. Wicklow Co Cork.

Ms. Caroline O'Brien Ms. Rosemarie Bronder Crooke Ballinprior Passage East Ardfert Co Waterford Tralee Co. Kerry

Ms. Geraldine King Ms. Aisling Ryan, 19, Father Griffin Road, 46 Westland Row, Galway Dublin 2.

Ms. Annie Askelund Fleming, Mr. Justin Fleming 6 elm court, Curraghgorm, Lucan, , Dublin 20 Co. Cork

Ms. Lauren Guillery Ms. Carla Keegan, Teach Na Feirme Sorrell Hall, Lislevane Ticknock Hill, Clonakilty Sandyford, Co. Cork Dublin 18

Ms. Mary Wedel Ms. Aine Wedel Currane Hill Currane Hill Ballineen Ballineen Co. Cork Co. Cork

Ms. Jean O Hanlon Mr. Ulrike Riedmuller 14 Marian Park The Hollies, Pouladuff Road Enniskeane, Cork Co.Cork

Ms. Olive Finn Ms. Thea van Loon The Olive Branch Annaghbeg, Spillers Lane Glenflesk, Clonakilty Killarney, Co. Cork Co.Kerry

Mr. Pat Sheehy Ms. Mandy kavanagh 13 Taney Manor 66 highthorn park Glenageary Dublin 14 Co. Dublun

Ms. Carmel Downes, Ms. Erica Murray Carmels Health Store 21 Craiglands, 10 Francis Street, Ardeevin Road, Ennis, Dalkey, Co. Clare Co. Dublin.

56

Mr. Patrick J Dooley Ms. Grainne Kealy Coole, 86 Castlefield Woods, Ferbane, Clonsilla, Co. Offaly, Dublin 15.

Mr. Ben Gilroy Ms. Sonja Woods 28 Riverview 1 The Heath Athlumney Abbey Liffey Hall Navan Newbridge Co. Meath Co. Kildare

Ms. Paula Donnelly Mr. Liam Kett, 59 Peck’s Lane 93 Allenview Heights Newbridge Dublin 15 Co Kildare

Ms. Niamh O'Connor Mr. Keith Nolan The Treehouse, 106 sycamore road Rafeenan, Monoy alley Ballinode, Tramore Co. Monaghan Co Waterford

Ms. Dhani Murray Keoghan Mr. Colin Hogg 74 the rectory, No 53 The oaks Stepaside Liscreagh Enniskerry Road Murroe Dublin 18 Co Limerick

Eva Lynch Mr. Jerome Scanlan Ullard Church, Ballydonnell, Borris Feohanagh, Co Kilkenny Co. Limerick

Christine Gordon. Mr. John Patrick Bell 10 Dun Saithne Road, Riverside Cottage Flemington Lane. Moneenshinnagh Balbriggan. Manorhamilton Co. Dublin. Co. Leitrim

Mr. John Lawlor Mr. Jakob Smit 994 Abbeylands, 76 Clooneen Park Castledermot, Manorhamilton Co. Kildare. Co Leitrim

Ms. Edel Gilchrist Ms. Kate McCarthy 97 the links Slieveroe Donabate Headford Co. Cork Co. Galway

Ms. Siobhan Farrell Ms. Karen Fletcher Gleann Rua Cappahard, Irishtown Tulla Rd, Mullingar Ennis, Co Westmeath Co. Clare.

57

Ms. Jane Buggle Ms. Iarla Fox. Stepaside, 19, Father Griffin Road, Dublin 18 Galway

Mr. Sean Rogers Mr. T.J - Thomas Joseph Fay, 69 Latchford Square, 6 Lakeview, Castaheny, , Virginia, Dublin 15. Co Cavan

Ms. Breda Houlihan Mr. Carsten Jasper. Landscape 134 Glenbrook Pallasgreen Old Singland Road Co Limerick Limerick.

Mr. Barry Reid, Ms. Sigune Dueck Ballydonnel, Woodbrook Redcross, via Carrick-on-Shannon Co. Wicklow Co. Roscommon

Mr. Joseph Duggan Mr. Noel Collins 16 Asking raw drive Boher Ard sun croft Carrignavar Co Kildare Co. Cork

Ms. Edel Fortune Ms. Melanie Dunne 22 Eaton Road 147 Branswood Athy, Dublin 6W Co. Kildare

Ms. Catriona Cunniffe Mr. Aidan Byrne 3 The Cuainin 29 Hartlands Point, Bunowen Carrignafoy, Louisburgh Cobh, Co. Mayo Co Cork

Ms. Natalie Sharples Ms. Aleksandra Kane Dromsicane, 35 Killakee grove. , Firehouse. Co Cork Dublin 24

Ms. Ami O'Regan Ms. Agnieszka Marszalek 7 Fairways 1 Edenmore Grove Donabate Raheny Co. Dublin Dublin

Ms. Mirjana Cepic Ms. Stella Andrijevic 192a Cabra Road, 192a Cabra Road, Sycamore court apt 4, Sycamore court apt 4, Dublin 7 Dublin 7

Mr. Luka Plazonic Mr. Frits Huibregtse, 192a Cabra Road, Annaghbeg, Sycamore court apt 4, Glenflesk, Dublin 7 Killarney, Co. Kerry 58

Mr. Damien Bartle Mr. Michael Dorgan 5. St. Patrick's Terrace 25 Ardfield Green, Kinsale Grange, Douglas, Co. Cork Co. Cork

Mr. Damian McCarthy Ms. Siobhán McCarthy 16 Lynn Heights 16 Lynn Heights Mullingar Mullingar Co Westmeath Co Westmeath

Mr. Colin Carden Mr. Stephen Hill 19 Woodville Balgatheran, rd Hill of Rath Ballina Drogheda Mayo Co Louth

Ms. Marian Hogan Ms. Christina o'callafhab 3 Pecks Lane 23 Windsor court, Castleknock view, Dublin15 Limerick

Mr. Mark McAuley, Ms. Ciara Reynolds, 12 Kilbush Lane, 67 The Waterside, Rush. Charlotte Quay, Co.Dublin Dublin 4.

Ms. Eyal Cohen Ms. Samantha Murray knockenpower Lower, 74 The Rectory Ring, Stepaside Co Waterford Dublin 18

Ms. Niamh Cullinane, Ms. Iona Tanner Hayes 82 Radharc an Bhaile, knockenpower Lower, Bandon Ring, Co. Cork Co Waterford

Mr. Patrick Mc Evoy Ms. Lisa Churchward friarstown 20 Castleknock Grove, bohernabreena laurel lodge, tallaght castleknock, Dublin 24 Dublin 15

Ms. Sarah Bills Mr. David Lee Gort Mhaoilir 1 The Belfry Raheen Duleek Athenry. Co Meath

Ms. Madelon Geluk Ms. Rachel Heffernan, The Studio; Shanacloyne, Clogher ; Templemartin Dunmanway; Bandon Co Cork Co cork

59

Ms. Adrienne Colleran Ms. Monika Zakrzewska Parklands Sandymount Avenue Ballyalla 8, Rexdon court Ennis Dublin 4 Co. Clare

Ms. Leila Cotter Mr. Anthony Cotter Ballinvriskig, Ballinvriskig, White’s Cross, White’s Cross, Cork Cork

Ms. Korena O Hara Ms. Louise Tobin Cuilmore , 25 the avenue Gurteen , the highlands Co Sligo Co. Meath

Ms. Aisling Meath Ms. Sinéad Cooper. Cornea Co. Armagh Skibbereen.

Mr. Kieran Walsh. Ms. Eimear Walsh Tully Lodge Shannon View. Tully Tully. Jamestown Jamestown Co Leitrim. Co Leitrim

Ms. Joanna Walsh. Ms. Anna Marie Stack Rivas 3 The Stables. Drewscourt, Oakport. Ballyagran, Coothall. kilmallock, Co Roscommon. Co. Limerick

Ms. Iwona Krassowska Ms. Debbie Walsh Murphy. 17 Merrion Strand Funsinagh. Sandymount Mohill. Dublin Co Leitrim.

Mr. juan Carlos Rivas Garcia Ms. Katarzyna Hoffmann Drewscourt county east, 12 The orchard Ballyagran, Hale street kilmallock, Ardee Co. Limerick Co. Louth

Mr. Adrian Vintila Ms. Tatiana Tanasie, Clonfad, Clonfad, Oldtown, Oldtown, Athlone, Athlone, Co. Roscommon co. Roscommon

Mr. Patrick O' Byrne Mr. Andy Kane 22 Ravensdale Drive 30 Ticknock way Kimmage Sandyford D12 Dublin 18

60

Ms. Diana Laffan Ms. Janice Aherne 28 Rossvale Court 28 Cardy Rock Avenue, Portlaoise Balbriggan, Co. Laois. Dublin.

Ms. Courtney White Ms. Maggie Morrisson Crohane, Fossa Achill Killarney Westport . Co. Mayo

Mr. Kieran Buckley Mr. Jordan O Donovan Crohane, Fossa 60 Belmont Place, Killarney Cobh County Kerry. Co, Cork.

Ms. Christine Gaughran, MA Mr. Val Davin, Maugha Knockduff, Dunmanway, Co. Cork Co. Cork.

Mr. John Ryan Ms. Michele Healy 13 DUN Darragh, 10b Rahanine Manor Longford Rochfortbridge Co. Longford Co. Westmeath

Ms. Catherine O Donoghue Ms. Jiri Hadrava Church Road Church Road Ballydesmond Mallow Mallow Co. Cork. Co. Cork.

Mr. Tucker Egan Mr. Adrienne Buckley , The Whitehouse Seaview, Royal Oak Road Yellow Walls Road. Muinebheag Malahide . Co.Carlow Co Dublin

Ms. Hilary O Keeffe. Mr. Marian Neary Shallee, Ard Cuain, Kilnamona Letterfrack, Ennis Connemara, Co Clare Co Galway

Ms. Pauline Fanning Mr. Tina Kelly 8 Cionn Torc 70 Southbury Road, Castlepollard Wilton Co. Westmeath Co. Cork

Mr. Fintan Whelan Mr. Stephen Wilde 12 Larkhill Road, Raheny Sligo. Dublin .5

61

Mr. Joe Callanan Ms. Glyn Powell, BA FCICM FIEx Dromin Road Corcullen Nenagh Galway Co Tipperary Co Galway

Mr. Michael Ahern Ms. Angela Gilmartin. Ard Cuain, (Irish /citizen) Letterfrack, Apt 15 Cavendish House, Connemara, 26 Ellesmere Road, Co Galway Ellesmere Park, Manchester, UK

Ms. Mary Kinhart, Ms. Lynn Haskins Rusheens, 49 Mayeston green Killala, Finglas Co. Mayo Dublin 11

Ms. Brenda Coller, Ms. Claire Nix, Castlesallagh, Garrybreeda, Donard, Loughrea, Co Wicklow. Co.Galway.

Ms. Karen Coakley Ms. Rosetta Broy 18 Hawthorn Avenue, The Beeches Ballycasheen Rd, Monkstown Valley Killarney, Monkstown Co. Kerry Co Dublin

Mr. Stephan Wilde Ms. Hillary O’ Neill 94 Springdale Road Ballycarnane Woods Raheny Tramore Dublin 5 Co Waterford

Ms. Christine Sherlock Sinéad Nï Chonaill 54 Abbey Grove, 8 Allendale Terrace, Navan Clonsilla, Co. Meath Dublin 15

Ms. Anna Bjorsell Ms. Maria Bjorsell 17 O Mahony Place. 17 O Mahony Place. Clondrohid. Clondrohid. Co.Cork. Co.Cork.

No fixed abode/postal address provided: Confirmation of signature by Email provided Ms. Lorraine Dunne Ms. Ela Ciechanowicz.

Ms. Paula Cummins Ms. Anne Corrigan

Ms. Aryelle Anderson Ms. Cristina del Moral

Ms. Bernadette O Sullivan Mr. Dave Sweeney