Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Inner Ring Road Project Public Disclosure Authorized
VOL. 6
Resettlement Action Plan Public Disclosure Authorized
1. Policy Framework
2. Implementation Plan
3. Longxi Maintenance Depot
4. Pipeline Transfer Policy Public Disclosure Authorized
5. Pipeline Transfer Implementation Plan
Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office Public Disclosure Authorized February 1998 Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Inner Ring Road Project
Resettlement Action Plan
Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office February 1998 Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Inner Ring Road Project
Resettlement Policy
Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office
February 1998 f IRR Resettlement Policy Final Report
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Table of Contents List of Appendices List of Tables Acronyms, Abbreviation and Units
1. Preface 1.1 Objectives of Resettlement Policy And Resettlement Action Plan 1.2 Explanation of Resettlement Policy of Inner Ring Road Project 1.3 Definition of Project Affected Persons (PAPs) 1.4 Entitlement of the Project Affected Persons 1.5 Definition of Resettlement 1.6 Definition of Rehabilitation 1.7 Definition of Compensation 1.8 Complementary Explanation for Resettlement, Rehabilitation and Compensation
2. Introduction 2 2.1 Project Background 2.2 Necessity and Significance of the Inner Ring Road Project 2.3 Relationship of Inner Ring Road, Resettlement Policy and Resettlement Action Plan 2.4 Institutions Involved in Preparing Resettlement Policy, Their Responsibilities and Preparation Measures 2.5 Institutions Involved in Preparing Resettlement Action Plan, Their Responsibilities and Preparation Measures 2.6 Institutions Involved in Implementing RAPs 2.7 RAP Budget for Each Phase
3. Objectives and Principles of Resettlement 9 3.1 Objectives 3.2 Principles 3.3 Explanation
4 Classification and Summary of Project Impacts 11 4.1 Classification of Project Impacts 4.2 Summary of the Project Impacts
5. Resettlement Policies for Inner Ring Road Project 19 5.1 Legal Framework in China , 5.2 Existing Resettlement Policies in Guangzhou 5.3 Compatibility of the Existing Resettlement Policies in Guangzhou IRR ResettlementPolicy ii Final Report
With OD 4.30 5.4 Insufficiencies of the Existing Resettlement Policies in Guangzhou 5.5 Inner Ring Road Resettlement Policy
6. Institutional Framework for Land Acquisition, Demolition and Resettlement and Related Institutions 43 6.2 Guangzhou City Planning Bureau 6.3 Guangzhou City Land and Housing Administrative Bureau 6.4 Guangzhou City Labor Bureau 6.5 Independent Monitoring Organization 6.6 Census Unit 6.7 Production Teams and Neighborhood Committees/Streets 6.8 GREEO: Implementation Agency for Land acquisition and Resettlement
7. Experience Lesson and Improvement of GREEO 47 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Experience and Lesson of GREEO 7.3 Improvement of GREEO
8. Participation and Consultation 57 8.1 Census 8.2 Standards of Living Surveys 8.3 News Media 8.4 Public Consultation Meetings 8.5 Resettlement Information Brochure 8.6 Conclusion of Resettlement Compensation Agreement
9 Grievance and Appeals 60
10 Monitoring and Evaluation 61 10.1 Internal Monitoring 10.2 Independent Monitoring
11 Cost and Budget 67 11.1 Explanation for Cost and Budget for Land Acquisition and Resettlement for the Inner Ring Road Project 11.2 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Cost for IRR (Phase I) 1 1.3 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Cost for IRR (Phase II) 11.4 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Cost for IRR (Phase III) 11.5 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Cost for IRR (Phase IV) 11.6 Estimate Cost for the IRR and the Flow of Fund
( IRR Resettlement Policy iii Final Report
LIST OF TABLES Table 4.2.3.1 General Table of Demolition Amount of IRR for Phases I & II of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Table 4.2.3.2 Table of Census of Phase III of the IRR Table 4.2.3.3 Table of Census of Phase IV of the IRR Table 11.2.1 Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expense of IRR for * Phases I and II Table 11.2.2 Resettlement Expense of Phase I of the IRR Table 11.2.3 Resettlement Expense of Phase II of the IRR Table 11.3.1 Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expense of IRR for Phase III Table 11.3.2 Resettlement Expense of Phase III of the IRR Table 11.4.1 Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expense of IRR for Phase IV Table 11.4.2 Resettlement Expense of Phase IV of the IRR
ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS GCCTPO Project Office of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project GMG Guangzhou Municipal Government- GREEO Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office GURCC Guangzhou Urban and Rural Construction Commission IMO Independent Monitoring Organization IRR Inner Ring Road PAPs Project Affected Persons Phase I, II, III, IV) The First, Second, Third, Fourth Phase of Project RAP Resettlement Action Plan Rd. Road SLS Standards of Living Surveys Str. Street
UNITS m meter m2 square meter km kilometer RMB Renminbi (Yuan)(approx. 8.7 RMB/USD) mu area; l5mu=1ha 1. PREFACE
1.1 Objectives of Resettlement Policy and Resettlement Action Plan
The Resettlement Policy for Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects Inner Ring Road Project and the Resettlement Action Plan for Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects Inner Ring Road Project have been prepared according to the resettlement and land acquisition laws and regulations of PRC, Guangdong Province, Guangzhou; and the Operational Directive 4.30for Involuntary Resettlement of the World Bank. Our objective of developing these documents is to work out a resettlement and rehabilitation policy and specific implementation plan for the project affected persons (PAPs), to ensure that they will benefit from the project, and their living standards will be improved or at least restored to their original levels.
1.2 Explanation of Resettlement Policyfor Inner Ring Road Project
(1) The basic contents of the Resettlement Policy for Inner Ring Road Project have been concluded in the first draft of the Resettlement Action Plan for Inner Ring Road Project (Phase I) submitted to the World Bank in November, 1995 and the revised version submitted on February 15, 1996. According to the suggestions of the resettlement specialists of the World Bank, we have divided the original RAP into Resettlement Policy document and detailed action plan for each phase of Inner Ring Road Project.
(2) The Resettlement Policy document has taken in the suggestions of the resettlement specialists of the World Bank and the conference agreements reached by both sides. The document also states in detail the problems concerned by the World Bank.
(3) The Resettlement Policy will be carried out throughout the whole InnierRing Road Project, including those which are not loan projects of the World Bank. The resettlement objectives. resettlement principles, resettlement policies, resettlement implementation organizations and principles of grievance & appeal, consultation & participation, monitoring & evaluation wlhicilare stipulated in the Resettlement Policy will be kept unchanged in the later phases of Reselzlemenl Action Plan for Inner Ring Road Project. The demolition amount and the number of affected persons for each phase of IRR are shown in detail in the table of section 4.2.3.:
(4) The specific compensation standards set in the RAP of every phase will be adjusted according to the price fluctuation index during resettlement implementation.
1.3 Definition of Project Affected Persons (PAPs)
Project affected persons (PAPs) refer to all persons that will be adversely affected due to the implementation of the project. The categories of Project affected persons (PAPs) are as follows: l. All permanent or temporary owners and users, regardless of residence status, of the real estate (housing, land, structure, facility) demolished due to the implementation of the project. 2. Those whose resident environment and living environment are affected due to the implementation of the project. IRR ResettlementPolicy 2 Final Report
3. Those whose business place (private and public enterprises) and business environment are affected due to the implementation of the project. 4. Those whose occupation and working environment are affected due to the implementation of the project.
1.4 Entitlement of the Project Affected Persons (PAPs)
All project affected persons (PAPs) are entitled to resettlement, rehabilitation and compensation which are at least equivalent to their loss. The project will strive to improve the living (business) standards of the project affected persons, and make the project affected persons benefit from the implementation of the project.
1.5 Definition of Resettlement
Resettlement refers to a restoration and replacement of the living structures and environment (residence), business places (shops, market places, etc. ), job of the project affected persons as well as the restoration and replacement of the road, transport, public facilities of living environment.
1.6 Definition of Rehabilitation
Rehabilitation refers to a restoration of PAPsi capacity and resources to continue with productive activities or standard of living at a level equal or higher to that before the project. This could be skills training for new business & jobs, credit, and counseling for the elderly. Transportation and moving expenses to the new locations will be provided.
1.7 Definition of Compensation
Compensation means payment in cash or in kind for loss of property, assets and income of persons, at the replacement cost without depreciation.
1.8 Complementary Explanation for Resettlement, Rehabilitation and Compensation
Explanation: From section 1.6, 1.7, 1.8, the definitions of the Resettlement, Rehabilitation and Compensation have some overlap. In order to avoid misunderstanding these terms during reading our Policy and RAP, we further explain them here. The new explanations below cover the overall connotations of the three terms in the Chinese versions of Policy and R2AP.
Resettlement: It means that restoration/replacement of the dweller housing, business places(shops, markets) and jobs. It is a physical replacement and the owner, user or beneficiary is definite.
Rehabilitation: It means that restoration/replacement of the living environment, business environment, work environment and the recovery of the PAPs' psychology. That owner, user and beneficiary here are in a broad sense and indefinite, such as those of road, traffic, public facilities in the living environment, etc. This kind of the restoration/replacement is intangible, such as technical training, consolation and moving assistance, etc.
Compensation: It means the compensation for the assets without depreciation of the PAPs and for their incomes as the original level. Here only refer to compensation in cash but not in kind. IRR ResettlementPolicy 3 Final Report
2. INTRODUCTION
2.1 Backgroundof GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Projects
2.1.1 A series of improvementand administrativemeasures have beentaken in GuangzhouCity in recent years in orderto improvethe transportcapacity in the center, reducetraffic accidents and alleviatethe transporttension. The transportin the center has been improvedto a certain degree by unremittingefforts. However,there are still some problemssuch as shortageof supplyand dis- synchronismbetween managementand development. So at present the problem of trafficjams is still serious, and the transportpressure of the centeris still very heavy.
2.1.2 In March 1993, GuangzhouMunicipal Government began to use the grants of the World Bank to developthe researchproject of i°GuangzhouUrban TransportStudyj ± . This research project is a strategyresearch on transportplanning of Guangzhoucity (shortedin Strategy Research below). It was requiredby the Bankto search the ways to solvethe transportproblems of Guangzhou,and put forwardthe importanceof the loan for Guangzhoumunicipal traffic facilities. In July 1994, the achievements of this research project have been approved by the Guangzhou MunicipalGovernment, the WorldBank and the domesticand foreignexperts. The development strategy of Guangzhouurban transport recommended by the Strategy Researchwill becomethe guiding principlefor the future implementationof GuangzhouTransport Planning.
2.1.3 The the World Bankmission visited Guangzhouand talked with the missionof Guangzhou ( MunicipalGovernment in July, 1994,considered tentatively that the Researchof "GuangzhouCentral Area Traffic ImprovementScheme Implementation" which shouldcontinue after the "Strategy Research",would be the importantcomponent of the feasibilitystudy on ensuringthe Guangzhou City Center TransportProjects as the loan projectof the WorldBank . Both sides affirmedthe contents and sub-projectsof the GuangzhouCity Center TransportProjects as follows:
I . Traffic ManagementAnd Safety; 2. Constructionof Road Infrastructure; 3. Public Transport Improvement; 4. PollutionControl of MotorVehicles; 5. TechnicalAssistance.
2.1 .4 The Project Officeof the GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Projects was set up by GuangzhouMunicipal Government, whose leaderwas the vice mayor in charge of urban construction. The office is in charge of daily administrativework and organizesall responsible bureausto prepare the scheme designsand feasibilitystudies of the sub-projects.
2.1.5 In December1994, the GuangzhouUrban and RuralConstruction Commission formally entrustthe MVA Asia Limitedto start the research on the issue of "GuangzhouCentral Area Traffic ImprovementScheme Implementation". This researchand the feasibilitystudies of all the sub- projects have been completed in June, 1995,and passed the appraisalof domesticexperts, and have been approved by GuangzhouMunicipal Government.
/, IRR ResettlementPolicy 4 Final Report
2.1.6 The main contents of the "Guangzhou Central Area Traffic Improvement Scheme Implementation"include:
1. FunctionalRoad Hierarchy; 2. Public TransportPriority RoadNetwork; 3. Bicycle and PedestrianRoad Network; 4. Traffic Management and Improvement Measures; 5. Traffic signaland Area TrafficControl SystemReview; 6. TrafficManagement Schemes associated with the Constructionof the Metro; 7. On-StreetParking Review; 8. TrafficEngineering Design for the IRR; and 9. InstitutionalStrengthening and Staff Training.
2.1.7 The GuangzhouMunicipal Government plans to carry out the "GuangzhouCentral Area Traffic Improvement Scheme Implementation" to improve the transport in the city center by using the loan of the Bank.
2.2 Necessity and Significance of the Inner Ring Road Project
2.2.1 The Inner Ring Road project is an important sub-project of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects. The Inner Ring Road is a ring road built in the central area. It can alleviate the transport pressure in the center and cushioned the center transport through setting up transport defenses in accordance with the principles of functional road hierarchy, system channelization. The Inner Ring Road is necessary to suit the needs of the rapid development of Guangzllou economy and to improve the transport in the center.
2.2.2 The scheme of the overall layout, alignment, interchanges and ramps of the lnlner Riln Road is a conceptual design of transport engineering, which was further developed on the basis of the achievements of Strategy Research. The estimated total investment of the Inner Ring Road project is over 5 billion RMB which is more than two thirds of the investment of GuangzhiotuCity Center Transport Projects. A lot of traffic of the center will be redistributed due to the I nnierRing Road completion. The average vehicle speed in the center will be increased by 30-50 percents and the waste gas of vehicle will be decreased by at least 50 percents. Each index of envirollmelntal assessment (compared with the situation without the Inner Ring Road project) will be improved to different degrees. The Inner Ring Road project will play an important role to reduce the environment pollution in the center and improve the soci-economic benefits.
2.2.3 The Inner Ring Road will change the traffic situation of the center. The more convenient transport will shorten the travel time from the peripheral areas to the center. The planned population redistribution will drop the population density of the center and give impetus to economic development of these zones, create good social and economic benefits and new boom. Transport benefit within the center is obvious. Looking from the road layout of the Inner Ring Road and the radial roads, the peripheral areas which benefit most are:
1. Northwestem part of Guangzhou such as Luochongwei, Tongdewei, Xinshi, Huangshi 2. Northeastern part of Guangzhou such as Tianpingjia, new Guangcong Highway 3. Southern part of Guangzhou such as Yanzigang and the tail of Industry Avenue 4. Eastern part of Guangzhou such as Yuanchun, Chigang 5. Westem part of Guangzhou such as Fangcun district IRR ResettlementPolicy 5 Final Report
2.3 Relationship of Inner Ring Road and Resettlement Policy, Resettlement Action Plan
2.3.1 There are a lot of factors constricting the construction of the Inner Ring Road in the city center. Although some measures have been adopted, such as utilizing existing or planned alignment in the course of the design as far as possible, constructing elevated roads over original main roads around the city center and connecting with the roads outside center to improve traffic capacities. The different extent impact still exists along the alignment of the Inner Ring Road (especially in the section of elevated roads). Certain degree of impact on the original economic, cultural and social structure are unavoidable too in the course of demolishing some housing and infrastructure, displacing some persons from the place of study and work to a different one. So some protection measures will be adopted so as to minimize the project impact.
2.3.2 In order to minimize the adverse impact of the project, make the living standards of PAPs unaffected, and assure that PAPs will benefit from the project or at least restore their original living standards, Resettlement Policy for Inner Ring Road Project has been prepared in accordance with the laws and regulations of PRC, Guangdong Province, Guangzhou; and the Operational Directive 4.30 for Involuntary Resettlement of the World Bank. According to the schedule by phases, the Resettlement Action Plan for Inner Ring Road Project for each phase will be also worked out before the implementation of each phase project.
2.4 Institutions Involved in Preparing Resettlement Policy, Their Responsibilities and Preparation Measures
2.4.1 The following institutions participated in preparing the Resettlement Policy
1. Project Office of the Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects 2. Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office 3. 3.Affected Streets Neighborhood Committees, Township Governments and Rural Production Teams. 4. Relative academic bodies.
2.4.2 Functions of the Institutions
I. Project Office of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects (GCCTPO): * To be responsible for coordinating the activities of all involved units and the activities of the related institutions. * To collect the feedback about the resettlement policies from the affected streets. neighborhood committees, township governments and rural production teams. * To listen to the opinions of the related experts and related academic bodies * To direct the resettlement policies in principle.
2. Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office (GREEO): * To be responsible for preparing the whole Resettlement Policy in accordance with the resettlement laws and regulations of PRC, Guangdong Province, Guangzhou; and OD4.30 of the World Bank and collecting opinions from every side. IRR ResettlementPolicy 6 Final Report
3. Affected Township Governments, Streets Neighborhood Committees, and Rural Production Teams: * To get feedback from residents, farners and units, and report to GCCTPO and GREEO based on the actual situation affected within the areas under their jurisdiction, so that GREEO can prepare Resettlement Policy according with the facts.
4. Related academic bodies * To organize related experts, put forward the opinions for the resettlement policies, examine & evaluate whether the resettlement policies are reasonable and legal.
2.4.3 Measures of Preparing the Resettlement Policy
1. Base on the national, provincial and municipal resettlement policies 2. Carry on reciprocal resettlement and rehabilitation according to differential categories, degrees, and combining with the requirements of the Operational Directive 4.30 for Involuntary Resettlement of the World Bank (to improve the living standards of PAPs or at least restore their original level.) 3. Collect the opinions of every side and put them into the Resettlement Policy. 4. Establish the principles, objectives and policies of resettlement, implementation institutions, principles of public participation and consultation, grievance and appeals, monitoring and evaluation.
2.5 Institutions Involved in Preparing Resettlement Action Plan, Their Responsibilities and Preparation Measures
2.5.1 The following institutions involved in Preparing the RAP
1. Project Office of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects 2. Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office 3. Invited population research institute 4. Invited Independent Monitoring organization 5. Affected Streets Neighborhood Committees, Township Governments and Rural Production Teams.
2.5.2 Functions of the Institutions
I. Project Office of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects (GCCTPO) * To be responsible for coordinating the activities of all involved units and the activities of the related institutions. * To direct the Resettlement Action Plan in principle and organize experts to examine & evaluate the RAP.
2 Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office (GREEO) * To be responsible for preparing the whole RAP and helping the invited population research unit to conduct the census of PAPs of each phase of the Inner Ring Road Project. * To prepare Resettlement Action Plan in accordance with Resettlement Policy and the results of census. IRR ResettlementPolicy 7 Final Report
3. Invited Population Research Institute * To be responsible for the census among the households, shops, enterprises and institutions which will cover all affected units and individuals, and the census will provide basis for later implementation of the resettlement and rehabilitation.
4. Invited Independent Monitoring Unit * To raise advice during preparation of the RAP and ensure the participation and consultation of PAPs and that their ideas and opinions are fully incorporated in the RAP. * To monitor the implementation of the Resettlement Policy and the Resettlement Action Plan.
5. Affected Streets Neighborhood Groups, Township Governments and Rural Production Teams. * Under the leadership of the Municipal Government and the guidance of the GCCTPO, to help to complete the activities of the census, hold meetings with and report the opinions of the PAPs.
2.5.3 Measures for Preparing the RAP
1. To design the census questionnaires according to the demands of land acquisition and resettlement and the Banki -s requirements, to conduct detailed census for the affected housing, land, residents, shops, enterprises, farmers and public facilities, and normally classify the PAPs.
2. According to the census results and categories of the PAPs and resettlement policy, to choose resettlement sites and determine compensation standard and to prepare detailed schemes of the resettlement action, that is RAP.
3. To make the terms of reference and tables for monitoring and organize public participation including all affected units, neighborhood committees and individuals, widely listen to their opinions and incorporate them into the RAP.
4. With the constant perfection of the design scheme, the RAP will be perfected constantly during the implementation of the resettlement activities.
2.5.4 Timetable of Submitting Updated Census and Socio-Economic Survey for each Phase of IRR to the World Bank
I. Phases I and 1I submitted in October 1997. 2. Phase III will be submitted in June, 1998 or no later than six months prior to the start of construction for the phase. 3. Phase IV will be submitted in June, 1999 or no later than six months prior to the start of construction for the phase.
2.6 Institutions Involved in Implementing RAPs
I . Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Office 2. Guangzhou City Planning Bureau IRR ResettlementPolicy 8 Final Report
3. Guangzhou City Land and Housing Administrative Bureau 4. Guangzhou City Labor Bureau 5. Independent Monitoring Organization 6. Census Unit 7. Rural Production Teams and Streets Neighborhood Groups 8. Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office
2.7 RAP Budget for Each Phase
Phase Cost (Yuan) Source of Financing Initial _ Municipal 1 0 457,669,452 Municipal 677,162,845 Municipal III 1,101,708,113 Municipal IV 848,702,974 Municipal Total 3,085,243,384
Note: The figures are estimates. The funds for the resettlement will be counterpart funding from the project and will come from the Guangzhou Urban and Rural Construction Commission under the Municipal Government. IRRResettlement Policy 9 * Final Report
3. OBJECTIVES AND PRINCIPLES OF RESETTLEMENT
3.1 Objectives
The objectives are to ensure the PAPs will get the compensations for all the loss of their assets and share the benefits of the project through reasonable resettlement and good rehabilitation, be compensated for their temporary difficulties. Their income standard and living level and the capability of production of enterprises and profit-making will be improved, or at least restore to the former level.
3.2 Principles
I . The design of the alignment of the Inner Ring Road will be modified appropriately to avoid the densely populated districts or multi-storied building, high-rise building, and to reduce the affected range of land acquisition and demolition as far as possible so as to minimize the involuntary resettlement. See Section 4.2.4.1 for details.
2. The principle of reciprocal compensation will be carried out. Namely, that losses will be compensated with replacement cost.
3. The living space will be enlarged and the necessary facilities will be provided. The houses will be constructed with reinforced concrete structure. All the necessary facilities will be well provided at the resettlement sites with convenient transport and life environment.
4. The affected shops, enterprises and institutions will maintain the original scale and function of their housing. The former business environment will be rehabilitated as far as possible. The loss of temporary closure and temporary business in different place will be compensated.
5. While acquiring collective land all the loss will be compensated reasonably. The compensation fees will be paid to the representative units only for developing collective economic activities, but cannot be diverted to any other purpose. Non-agricultural jobs and pensions will be arranged for those farmers.
6. The affected public facilities will be demolished after replacement.
7. The development resettlement will be planned to create full employment. So that the persons can adapt themselves to the resettlement sites' environment and be self-reliant in economic activities in a short time. The responsibility of the resettlement will be transferred in time from resettlement units to the resettled persons.
8. The vulnerable groups (households of the elderly without living with the adult sons/daughters, widows, single-parent, the disable, the chronically ill and the poor) will be given special favorable policies such as reasonable care for their dwelling houses and employment.
9. The displacement in the range of demolition and resettlement will be implemented in groups to keep the completeness of the original community. IRR ResettlementPolicy 10 Final Report
10. People will be assisted with transportation in the move.
11. The resettlement, rehabilitation and compensation will be monitored. The PAPs will participate in all the process of the resettlement. There will be a special mechanism established to respond to the grievance of the PAPs.
12. To ensure the benefits of PAPs, do the overall management well, try to reduce the compensation cost, and resettlement cost as far as possible through the PAPs' self-reliance. It is in accordance with the interests of all the people in Guangzhou City.
3.3 Explanation
1. The objectives and principles of resettlement will be implemented in Resettlement Policy and Resettlement Action Plan. The Resettlement Policy will set up the objectives and principles of resettlement. The Resettlement Action Plan will be specific reflection of the objectives and principles of resettlement.
2. The Resettlement Policy will apply to all phases of the IRR Project including those sections implemented by funding from the Guangzhou City.
3. For the private developers and other units, their resettlement work can be completed in two ways. One is that the resettlement is implemented by themselves but under the monitoring of GREEO and GCCTPO to ensure the compliance of our policies. The other is that the resettlement is implemented by the GREEO but financed by themselves.
4. The Policy will apply to other non-bank financed urban projects gradually on the basis of this project.
5. According to the objectives and principles of resettlement above, we shall adopt proper resettlement and compensation plans for different categories of PAPs. So we shall classify the project impacts in detail first. IRRResettlement Policy 1I Final Report
4 CLASSIFICATION AND SUMMARY OF PROJECT IMPACTS
4.1 Classificationof ProjectImpacts
To build a broadInner Ring Road in Guangzhoucity center,involuntary resettlement is inevitable. There are several categoriesof PAPs:
1. Residentialhouseholds includinghouseholds with or without residentialregistration certificateof GuangzhouCity, who are residingalong the alignmentof Inner Ringroad. 2. Enterprises,units and their staffs. 3. Rural productionteams and farmers
The loss of the PAPs can be classifiedinto followingcategories:
1. Housingand attachment. 2. Livingcommunities and businessenvironment. 3. Infrastructure. 4. Land, land facilitiesand attachment.
The categoriesand degreesof the loss of the PAPs differ.
4.1.1 AffectedResidential Households
There are two types of impactson residentialhouseholds: 1. Livingenvironment 2. Housing
4.1.1.1 LivingEvironment
Becauseof the change of residence,community resources such as hospital,school, recreation facilitieswill alter after moving out fromthe originalcommunity.
4.1.1.2 Housing
There are the followingways of acquiringthe right of use of the housingby resident:
1. Housingof their own a. Private housing the owner is domesticresident; b. Housingof overseasChinese the ownershipis of overseasChinese or his housing inheritors,or the house is purchasedwith overseasremittance; c. Reformedhousing-the unitsi housingor apartmentis purchasedat favorableprice by urban residents in accordancewith related reform policies; Note: the price of reformedhousing is about 800 Yuan/m2, while current marketprice is 3000 Yuan/m2 . d. Housingof householdplots-built on the land whichis allotted to township(town) farmersto solve their residentialproblem (the ownershipof the land belongsto the originalrural productionteams). IRR ResettlementPolicy 12 Final Report
2. Low rent housing where residents rent houses at low rent. a. These housing are government-owned housing, units' housing, private housing or housing of overseas Chinese and all the housing are with legal property rights. b. The rent length of residence is long term or lifelong. c. The rent is as low as 2 Yuan/m2 /month in 1997.
3. Market rent housing (high - price) where residents rent houses at market rents. a. These housing with legal property rights may be units' housing, private housing, housing of overseas Chinese and housing of household plots, or temporary housing built by some units. b. The rent length of residence is short (several months to several years). c. The market rent in 1997 was about 15-70 Yuan/m2 /month
4. Illegal structures where residents build housing on state-owned land illegally. a. The construction of the structures is illegal. b. Length of living in this kind of residence is short.
4.1.1.3 Explanation
Though with the type of impact on households is the same, their loss is quite different due to their ways of acquiring the use rights of the housing. Their original living communities are not same so that the impacts are different too.
4.1.2 Affected Enterprise Units and Their Staff
The categories and degrees of impacts on enterprise units is different due to their differences in profession, business environment, trade and scope. Therefore we classify the affected enterprise units in five categories:
I . Shops commercial enterprises and mini processing units relied on convenient transport and floating people and local residents, such as retail, wholesale, food and drink service, other service, repair and mini processing.
2. Institutions enterprises and institutions which occupy large area of land, such as industrial and agricultural enterprises, organizations, schools, hospitals. Their feature is only part of their housing will be demolished and they will not be fully relocated.
3. Public facilities small scale non-commercial units such as kindergartens, clinics, and units related to the living of local residents, such as post offices, grain shops, coal shops and public toilets. Their feature is that they will be fully relocated.
4. Industrial enterprises industrial enterprises which will be fully relocated.
5. Infrastructure. IRR ResettlementPolicy 13 Final Report
4.1.2.1 Affected shops
There are two types of impact: 1. Business environment. 2. Housing for business.
4.1.2.1.1 Business environment
1. The customers of the shops and their quantities will vary due to the location of the shops. Moreover the degrees of impacts of shops even in the same site is different due to their trade types.
2. Difference of business environment will affect the business of shops and profit, hence affect the income of their staff.
4.1.2.1.2 Housing for business
There are following ways for shops to acquire the use rights of housing for business: 1. Self-owned housing: housing owned by the shop manager. 2. Low rent housing: housing rented by the shop manager at low rent (price in 1997 was 20-40 Yuan/m 2 /month). Note: These shops are generally owned by the government. 3. Market rent housing: housing rented by the shop manager at market (high-price) rent (price in 1997 was 100-800 Yuan/m2 /month). a. Some of these shops are permanent buildings with legal property rights, others are temporarily built structures/shops without legal property rights. b. See the Appendix I for details about temporarily built shops.
4.1.2.1.3 Explanation
Loss of shops is different due to their trade and ways of acquiring the use rights of housing for business. Another reason affecting the degrees of loss of shops is: entire relocation or partial demolition.
4.1.2.2 Partially affected institutions
Since institutions will not be entirely relocated, there is only one type for affected institution: Housing and attachment. If the affected parts are residences and shops affiliated to the institutions, they will be classified as residences, shops and public facilities respectively.
4.1.2.3 Affected public facilities
There are two types of impact on public facilities: l. The communities being served. 2. Housing all are self-owned or low rent housing. 3. People being served the residents who are not relocated will be affected due to the demolition of original public facilities. IRR ResettlementPolicy 14 Final Report
4.1.2.4 Fully affected industrial enterprises
There are following types of impacts on industrial enterprises: 1. Housing. 2. Equipment. 3. Transport.
Another feature of the impacts on industrial enterprises is: long closure duration.
4.1.2.5 Infrastructure
The impact of these enterprises is only the relocation and loss of some facilities and equipment rather than relocation of housing and persons. There are following categories of impacts: I . Pipelines of communication, power supply, water supply, gas. 2. Civil air defense facilities. 3. Drainage facilities. 4. Trees and lawns. 5. Public transit facilities. 6. Road facilities.
4.1.3 Affected Rural Production Teams and Farmers
Since Inner Ring Road is in the city center of Guangzhou, no farm land will be acquired for road construction. Land acquisition of the project is for the construction of resettlement sites. This kind of land acquisition features in small quantity (about 20-200 mu for one zone), which will not cause the relocation of a whole village (the land area of a natural village in Guangzhou is about 2000 mu). Acquisition of farm land will cause loss of property and productive material, as well as problem of job creation for farmers. Such as: * Acquiring collective farm land * Housing of household plots * Other type housing * Power and water supply facilities * Standing crops * Farmers
Note: if the owners of housing of household plots have got residential registration certificate of Guangzhou City, they will be classified as residential households in section 4.1.
4. 1.4 Explanation for Categories of Project Impacts
1. As stated above, the project impacts can be classified in following seven categories: a. Residential households b. Shops c. Partially affected institutions d. Public facilities e. Fully affected industrial enterprises f. nfrastructure g. Rural production teams and farmers :( " / //Cu¢ngtheu I Rd / N~~~~~Luh i 1l I?o S'rl:- Iu,tV C
Na'Rd E - _ A D-On1_tnqRd. E.
A i-- before 1997
\~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~v it;y ISki\ ,),OGSl \ _f # I _ 111 S4-O47-r
/ \~ ~ ~ ~~______+*. 1f*a 3 *ti6.E= U 4?" 1dR 4-27-OI-l/4 _ IRR ResettlementPolicy 15 Final Report
2. Resettlement policy will be made according to the seven categories of impacts and different : ,/ degrees. 3. RAP will make different plans of resettlement, rehabilitation and compensation to the seven categories of impacts.
4.2 Summary of the Project Impacts
4.2.1 Range and characteristic of the Land Acquisition and Demolition for the Inner Ring Road Project
The recommended alignment has been determined according to comprehensive evaluation and selection after taking all the factors into consideration. It starts from Liu'ershan Road, goes along Huangsha Avenue, Nan'an Road, goes eastwards through Huanshi'xi Road and Huanshi'zhong Road, reaches Yongfu Road along Henfu Road, turns southwards to Meidong Road joined to Zhongshanyi Road, then goes west-southwards along Zhongshanyi Road to cross Dongshankou, then divides into two parts, reaches the east of the planned Baogangbei Road (T13) in Haizhu district respectively through Jiangwan Bridge and Haiyin Bridge, then arrives at Industry Avenue through the planned Nantian Road or the west part of TI 3 Road, turns backwards to Renmin Bridge, then encloses at the start point of the road. The total length of the Inner Ring Road is about 26 km. (See Fig. 4.2.1.)
1. The section of the south ring (from Renmin Bridge to the entrance of Huangsha tunnel ). The whole section is called Liu'ershan Road with the present width of 24-28m (including arcade) and the planned width of SOm. The present width will be extended by 22-26m from the present roadside line. The total length of this section is about I km. There are houses for business on both sides of the first floor facing street and dwelling houses in the back and 3nd floor above. Most of the houses of this section are three-floor.
2. The middle section of the west ring (from the entrance of Huangsha Tunnel to Xichang Interchange ). All the sections comprise of the whole Huangsha Avenue and Nan'an Road. The present width of Huangsha Avenue is 40-50 m and the planned width is 50m. That is, the present width will be extended by 10-14m from the present roadside Inies. The present width of Nan'an Road is 36-50 m, so the present width will be extended by 0-14 m from the present roadside lines. The total length of this section is about 4 km. The majority of the buildings on both sides are enterprises and houses for business. There are a lot of low buildings on west side, but the majority on east side are multi-storied buildings.
3. The north section of the west ring (from Xichang Interchange to the entrance of Guangyuanxi Road). All the sections are in the Huangshixi Road. The present width is 44 m and the planned width is 50 m, so it will be extended by 6m. The total length of this section is about 2.3 km. Most of the buildings in the section are reinforced concrete houses for business and enterprises. In order to decrease the amounts of demolition, demolishing the ground floor will be adopted, with arcades in the 3m cross-depth (keep the framework and demolish the wall of non-bearing force).
4. The west of the north ring section (from the entrance of Guangyuanxi Road to the Color TV Center of Guangzhou City). In the section of Huanshi Road (inner circle), it is 2 km length with a present width of 44m and'a planned width of 50 m, so the present width will be extended by 6m. In the section from the entrance of Guangyuan Road to the entrance of IRR ResettlementPolicy 16 Final Report
Zhanqian Road (about 0.6km), most of them are houses for business on both sides, so the first floors on both sides will be demolished as arcades with 3m cross-depth.
In the section from Zhanqian Road to Dabei Overpass(about 0.6 m), there are the station square and the flinching places of high-rise buildings, so only parts of the enclosing walls will be demolished.
In the section from Dabei Overpass to the Color TV Center of Guangzhou City (about I km), there are only few buildings with Yuexiu Mountain and Railways on both sides. This section will not be extended because of using the original one. The one-way viaduct of three lanes will be built in this section. However, all the business buildings of occupying roads will be demolished.
5. The middle section of north ring (from the Color TV Center of Guangzhou City to the entrance of Luhu Road). The total length is about 2 km. In the section from the Color TV Center to the entrance of Xiaobei Road (about I km), the railways and Yuexiu Mountain and parts of the buildings with the flinching places lie on both sides. So few buildings need to be demolished. The present width of the section is 44m and the planned width is 50m.
The section from Xiaobei Road to the entrance of Luhu Road (about I km), starts from the entrance of Xiaobei Road, crosses the railways and then reaches the entrance of Luhu Road in parallel along the north of the railways, then goes to Henfu Road. Most of the houses to be demolished are the business building of occupying roads.
6. The east section of north ring (from the entrance of Luhu Road to the interchange at Henfu Road and Yongfu Road). The total length is about 2.7km and the original width is 40m. The place of the interchange will be extended to 50m by making use of the original width. There are few houses to be demolished.
7. The north section of east ring(from the Henfun Road Interchange to the east entrance of Huanshixi Road). The total length is about 2.6 km. The old railways will be used. There need to demolish parts of dwelling houses and many temporary buildings in the north of Xianlie Road. Parts of illegal buildings will be demolished in the section along the zoo from the south of Xianlie Road to the entrance of Huanshidong road, too.
8. The middle section of east ring (Meidong Road from the entrance of Huanshidong Road to Zhongshanyi Road). The total length is about I km. Only parts of the temporary buildings in the streets need to be demolished.
9. The south section of east ring( Zhongshanyi Road from the entrance of Meidong Road to Jiangwan Bridge and Haiyin Bridge). The total length is about 4 km. The present width of most sections has already reached 50 m. The width of other sections is 35 m. Parts of the dwelling houses of the Railway Bureau in the first section from Zhongshanyi Road to the east of Meidong Road, parts of dwelling houses along the route from Dongshankou to the Donghuadong Interchange and parts of houses in the places of Jiangwan Bridge approach, need to be demolished. Moreover, parts of the private houses and a few shops will be demolished. Junyi Court will be rebuilt in order to get through the Junyi Court and a part of Donghu Road which will be built in future. IRR Resettlement Policy 17 Final Report
10. The east section of south ring (Baogangbei Road which extends eastwards to Haiyin Bridge). The total length is about 1 km. The new road will be built in resident areas according to the planning and in the east section of Baogangbei Road, the new road with a width of 36m will be built. The areas of the houses to be demolished cover more than 30,000m2. A lot of private houses need to be demolished, same as the situations of the middle section.
11. The middle section of south ring (south of Jiefang Bridge from planned Nantian Road to Industry Avenue). The total length is about 3 km. The new road will be set up in the dwelling areas because of no original road. In the section of Nantian Road, the road with a width of 36m need to be built and the areas of the houses to be demolished cover 70,000 m2. In this section, most houses are dwelling houses with 1-2 floors. So there are a lot of houses to be demolished.
12. The west section of south ring (from Nantian Road to the north of Renmin Bridge). The total length is about lkm. The old road with full width can be used. Only parts of the houses in the Hongde Road Interchange need to be demolished.
4.2.2 Total Amount Estimate of Land Acquisition and Demolition for the Inner Ring Road Project
4.2.2.1 According to the determninedalignment of the Inner Ring Road, the estimated total amount of floor space demolition is about 440,143m2 and the number of project affected persons PAPs is estimated to be 32,089.
4.2.2.2 Although farmland will not be acquired for road construction because the alignmenitof the 2 Inner Ring Road is around the center, the total farmland of 110,520m (namely. 165.8 mu) will be acquired for the resettlement sites, in which 55,467 m2 is in Fangcun district for Guocun Quarter (having basically completed the land acquisition), 50,000 m2 is in Dongpu Quarter ot Tianhle district (not starting the land acquisition), 18,855 m2 covering land (in which only 5.053 2nfarmllland ) in Haicheng Garden (originally named Yuan'an Street Quarter) of Haizhu district (having already completed land acquisition).
Explanation: The housing in the resettlement sites is planned to be used during the third and fourtlh phases of the Inner Ring Road Project. The time of the first and second phase is so pressing and short that low- profit housing equipped very well will be purchased as resettlement housilln.
4.2.2.3 A lot of pipes and other infrastructure need to be demolished and resettled in the Innier Ring Road Project. IRRResettlement Policy 18 Final Report
4.2.3 Estimate of Demolition Amounts of Each Phase
The Inner Ring Road Project will be completed in four phases.
Phase Resettlement Road Floor Area of Number of Length of Source of (date) Construction Demolition PAPs IRR Financing (start date)* (m2 ) (m) Initial 05/96--07/97 10/96 49,610 4669 2100 Municipal I 08/97--10/97 10/97 66,037 4025 3800 Municipal 11 01/98--06/98 06/98 95,213 6138 5200 WB/Municipal III 10/98--04/99 04/99 128,670 9912 10384 WB/Municipal IV 09/99--01/00 01/00 100,613 7345 5205 WB/Municipal Total 440,143 32,089 26,689 __
*Note: 1. Constructionwill begin in areaswhere no resettlementis required. Where PAPsare involved they will be given a minimumof two monthsto resettlebefore demolitionactivities take place. 2. The total amount/numbereverywhere excludes the initialphase if not specialexplanation.
The details are seen in table 4.2.3.1,4.2.3.2, 4.2.3.3.
4.2.4 Measures Taken to Minimize the Amounts of the Demolition
4.2.4.1 To minimize demolition we utilize the present roads and expand them in the design of the alignment of the Inner Ring Road. Such as Nantian Rd. vs. T13 . see the table below:
Floor Areaof Numberof Affected Numberof Demolition Households/units PAPs (m 2 ) T13 121,206 3,026 14,719 NantianRd. 54,317 1,543 6.043 Reduced 66,889 1,483 8,676
4.2.4.2 To the first floor of the multi-storied buildings which cover pedestrian lanes a little, we will get through it as arcade to reduce the demolition amount in the implementation process. There are three such buildings in Phase I & II. So the total demolition of 18,000 m2 and 30 houselholdswill be saved.
4.2.4.3 We will make use of the civil work time differential to closely corporate the process of the project. Moreover, we will construct the resettlement sites very well in order that the affected households can live in the quarters equipped very well. The duration of closure of the affected shops and enterprises will be reduced as short as possible. Table 4.2.3.1: General Table of Demolition Amount of IRR for Phases I and 11of Guangzhou City Centre Transport Project
Phase I Phase II South of North of Sub-Total Huangsha Guangyan Xichang Sub-Total TOTAL 2 Donghuadong Donghuadong Zone Interchange Interchange Demolition Area(m') 2,924.9 13,921.90 16,846.8 16,120.22 9,719.23 14,507.60 40,347.05 57,193.03 Shops Number of Resettled 73 218 291 223 215 187 625 916 Houses (Household) Number of the affected 230 832 1,062 782 605 777 2,164 3226 Persons (Person) 2 Institutions & Demolition Area(m') 293.71 8,707.41 9,001.12 3,739.32 3,034.7 199.61 6,973.63 15,974.75 Enterprises Number of Resettled 6 22 28 24 21 6 51 79 Houses(Househotg) Residential Demolition Area(m ) 23,509.87 13,611.42 37,121.29 20,670.17 17,793.6 8,729.11 47,192.88 84,314.17 Housing Number of Resettled 407 277 684 522 469 185 1,176 1,860 Houses (Household) Number of the affected 1,781 1,065 2,846 1,842 1,492 571 3,905 6,751 Persons (Person) Public Facilities Demolition Area(m ) 1,212 1,856.29 3,068.29 . 700 700 3,768.29 Number of Resettled 1 3 4 I 1 5 Houses (Household) _ Number of the affected 23 94 117 69 69 186 Persons (Person) - Total DemolitionArea(m ) 27,940.48 38,097.02 66,037.50 40,529.71 30,547.53 24,136.36 95,213.56 161,251.06 Number of Resettled 2,034 1,991 4,025 2,624 2,097 1,417 6,138 10,163 Houses (Household) _ _ Start Year of the Project 1997 1997 - 1998 1998 1998 1 Finish Year of the Resettlement 1997 1997 1998 1998 1998 2 2 2 Note:Data in the table includetemporary residential housing 9123 m temporaryshops 5766,1 m in Phase1; temporary shops 20672.45 m in Phase 11. (~~~'
TABLE4.2.3.2
Table 4.2.3.2: Table of Census of the Phase III of IRR
Section Railway station Overpass Huanshi Luhu Hengfu Rd Meidong Haiyingna Shushe East Secti Gongye Av. Renming Zhen'an Total |(DabeiRamp) zhong Rd. ~OverpassOverpass Overpass Overpass Overpass Of NantianRd Bridge&Ho Overpass
Length (M) 1539 1338 902 1280 1719 688 610 472 811 795 230 10384 Demolition Area(m2) 0 0 0 17348 5901 6122 5228 18610 2467 21983 5300 82959 Residential housing Number of the Resettled Household 0 0 0 434 147 153 105 372 49 440 106 1806 Number of the affectedPersons 0 0 0 1519 514 536 368 1303 172 1539 371 6322 Demolition Area(m2) 0 0 627 10910 2570 1160 2326 476 1326 6223 1835 27453 Shops Number of the Resettled Household 0 0 11 182 43 19 39 8 22 104 31 459 Number of the affectedPersons 0 0 63 109 257 116 233 48 133 622 184 1756 Institutions Demolition Area(m2) 0 0 0 8920 1207 570 2000 823 0 4738 0 18258 and Enterprises Number of the Resettled Household 0 0 0 25 3 2 6 3 0 14 0 53 Number of the affectedPersons 0 0 0 892 120 57 200 82 0 474 0 1825 Demolition Area(m2) 0 0 627 37178 9678 7852 9554 19909 3793 32944 7135 128670 Total Number of the Reseftled Household 0 0 11 641 193 174 150 383 71 558 137 2318 Number of the affectedPersons 0i 0 63 2520 891 709 801 1433 305 2635 555 9912 1 Start Year of the Project April, 1999 Jun-99 Apr-99 Jun-99 Apr-99 Apr-99 Jun-99 Jun-99 Apr-99 Jun-98 Apr-999
End of Resettlement jApril, 1999 Jun-99i Apr-99' Jun-991 Apr-99 Apr-99 Jun-99 Jun-99 Apr-99 Jun-98 Apr-99 / (~~~~~ TABLE4.2.3.3
~~~I -. . 1 .. .- . -. - --. ….1...,__ Table 4.2.3.3: Table of Census of Phase IV of IRR
Section Liu er'san Rd.Section of Huangsha Av. Section of Hengfu ection of Meidong Middle and West Total Rd. bei Rd Sectionof Nantian Rd. Length (M) 1560 998 1008 1639 5205 Demolition Area(m2) 46724 0 3748 40000 90472 Residential housing Number of the ResettledHouses (Househol 934 0 75 800 1809 Number of the affectedPersons (Person) 3269 0 262 2800 6331 Demolition Area(m2) 5271 . _ 0 70 2000 7341 Shops Number of the ResettledHouses (Househoi 88 0 2 33 123 Number of the affectedPersons (Person) 527 0 7 200 734 Institutions Demolition Area(m2) 1800 0 0 1000 2800 and Enterprises Number of the ResettledHouses (Househol 5 0 0 3 8 Number of the affectedPersons (Person) 180 0 0 100 280 'Demolition Area(m2) 53795 0 3818 43000 100613 Total Number of the ResettledHouses (Househol 1027 0 77 836 1940 INumber of the affectedPersons (Person) 3976 0 269 3100 7345 Start Year of the Project .Jan-001 Jan-00 Apr-99 Jan-00 / Final Year of the Resettlement Jan-00 Jan-00 Apr-99 Jan-00 / IRRResettlement Policy 19 Final Report
5. RESETTLEMENT POLICIES FOR INNER RING ROAD PROJECT
ResettlementPolicies for Inner Ring RoadProject are formed in accordancewith the national, provincialand municipallaws and regulationsand OD 4.30.
5.1 Legal Frameworkin China
The laws and regulationsof land acquisitionand resettlementhave been developedinto 3 levels. The first one involvesthe basic policyframework and the national rules as well as the guidingprinciples issued by the central government.The secondone includesthe regulationsof overallor specific project issuedby the provincialgovernment to implementnational laws and regulations.The third one is municipalstipulations applied to specificperiod or project issuedby the city or country government.
There followinglaws and regulations: I . Land ManagementLaw of Peoplej s Republicof China. 2. ImplementationMeasures of GuangdongProvincial Land Management. 3. CompensationStandards of AgriculturalLand Acquisitionin Guangzhou. 4. Regulationsof Urban HousingDemolition & RelocationManagement. 5. GuangzhouCity Ordinancesof Urban HousingDemolition:& Relocation Management 6. ImplementationDetails of Urban HousingDemolition & RelocationManagement and Compensation(shorted in ImplementationDetails). 7. Regulationsof Urban HousingDemolition & RelocationManagement and Compensations.. 8. Regulationsof OverseasChinese Owned Urban HousingDemolition Affected in Land Acquisitionfor State Project in GuangdongProvince. 9. TemporaryMeasures of Land Acquisitionfor Traffic InfrastructureConstruction in GuangdongProvince.
5.2 Existing Resettlement Policiesin Guangzhou
In order to set out the entitlementof the PAPs clearly,we shall generalizethe whole existing resettlementpolicies in Guangzhouin tables based on the main contents of 9 items above. There following4 types of resettlementpolicies: I . dwellinghouses------resettlement policies for affectedfamilies 2. non- dwellinghouses-----resettlement policies for affected shops,institutions, public facilities,industrial enterprises 3. land---- resettlementpolicies for rural productionteams. 4. infrastructure------resettlement policies for affectedinfrastructure.
Note: I . Resettlementpolicies for affectedshops, institutions,public facilities,industrial enterprises are not classifiedclearly in national,provincial and municipallaws and regulations,and put underthe categoryof non-residence,so we shall not classifyclearly in this section too. We slhallsupplement the contentsin section 5.5. 2. The ExistingResettlement Policies in Guangzhou(summarized in Policy Table)is presented in the table below. EXISTING RESETTLEMENT POLICIES IN GUANGZHOU
Affected Affected Compen- Resettlement Policies, Compensation Rates and Entitlements of theh ImplementMion tmpleffen Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs ,, t p l'o0
1. 1. 1. 1. Objects of housing resettlement: Finalizing before GREEO Article 34, 35 of Dwelling Household Houses signing the "Implementation houses A. The users of relocated houses refer to the citizen who have resettlement Measures of Urban regular residence registrations and actually live in the house within agreement Housing Resettlement the resettlement area before the notice of resettlement activities is Management in issued by Guangzhou Housing Administrative Bureau. Guangzhou" B. In case that one couple whose wife/husband's residence (shortened in registration is out of urban district, they couple will enjoy "Implementation resettlement of two persons. Measures" below) C. The persons who are one of the original housing users but now Article 7 of "Details of have moved due to service in army, reeducation through labor, Urban Housing serve a sentence, enter school, enter nursery. The person whose Resettlement and urban residence registration have been logged-down for the sake Compensation in of serving in prisons are not included. Guangzhou" D. Only son/daughter who has received only-child-certificate will (shortened in enjoy the resettlement of two persons. "Resettlement Details" E. the elderly widow will enjoy the resettlement of two persons. below)
F. After the notice of resettlement activities is issued, the registered members of a household changes because of birth, death, marriage and other legal reason, the resettlement will be actually increased or
1. I1. I1. Decreased numbers. Finalizing before Same as Idem Dwelling Household Houses G. The baby who is not born but receiving the certificate of signing the above houses permitted birth within the period of resettlement deadline resettlement stipulated by the notice of resettlement activities, will enjoy agreement resettlement of one person but not enjoy the policy of only child.
2. Thledwelling house to be demolished will be relocated in Conducting while Article 37 of accordance with the original living space; In case that the living signing agreement "Implementation space less than 5m2/person will be resettled as 5 m2 /person Measures"
IRR Resettlement Policy 20 Final Report -~ ~ I
Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the Implementation Implement- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date aton
Categories ___ _ :_____.:______.'Agencies. _._L,,":___,_;,:''__,, 3. The self-built living attic in the original house with clearance at Conducting while Article 40 of top no less than 2.2m or clearance at bottom no less than 2.2m, if signing agreement "Implementation structure is integrated, can be compensated based on ownership Measures" after the ownership is checked and proved.
4. To the persons to be resettled who live below 6 floor (including Conducting while Article 39 of 6 floor) and will be resettled above 7 floor without elevator, the signing "Implementation living space will be increased at the rate of 5 percent per floor agreement Measures" starting from 7 floor.
5. To the persons to be resettled who will be moved from urban Conducting while Article 39 of center to outside areas, the extent to additional area will be defined signing "Implementation in accordance with the provisions below: agreement Measures", Order of No.130 (93)issued 1. 1. 1. A: To the persons moved from urban center to other urban areas, Conducting while Same as by Guangzhou Dwelling Household Houses the additional area is 5%---20%. signing above Housing houses B: To the persons moved from urban center to the urban- agreement Administrative suburban intersection areas, the additional area is 20%--35%. Bureau, namely, C: To the persons moved from urban center to the suburban or "Regulations of outer suburban areas, the additional area is 35%--50%. Increasing Resettled Area Regarding Permanently Moved From Urban Center" to Outside Zones 1. Subsidy for moving After signing Article 41 of agreement and "Implementation The subsidy for moving of the households to be resettled will be paying in full once Measures", Order of determined in accordance with the number of the householders. In within 5 days after No.131(93) issued by case that the number of persons to be resettled is less than 5 moving out of the Guangzhou Housing (including 5), the subsidy is 450 Yuan per household, in case that original house Administrative the number of persons to be settled is above 5 , the subsidy is 600 Bureau, namely, Yuan per household. "Notices of Adjusting the Payment Standards of Moving and Temporary Moving due to Relocation"
[RR Resettlement Policy 21 Final Report Affected Affected Compen- Resettlement Policies, Compensation Rates and Entitlements of the Implementation [mplement- Legal Basis Categories Persons Cation PAPs Dat itiol .
______~~Categories______v~nls ______2. Temporary moving allowance During the period idem To the persons who find temporarily relocated housing by of temporary themselves, their temporary moving allowances are revised as follows:
A. In case that the average living space of the persons to be Relocation, Settling resettled is below 5 m2 (including 5 m2), the moving allowance is GREEO department 90 Yuan/month per person; In case that the average living space is distribute once per (GREEO) above 5 m2 , the moving allowance is 15 Yuan / m2 in accordance quarter or half with floor area of the original house. year. B. In case that the persons to be resettled are tenants of the house, moving allowance will be deducted by an amount of the original rent base on the standards above.
3. Transportation allowance: Idem Idem
The persons in the temporary resettlement sites who live far from the place of work or study and don't have transportation subsidies in his/her employed units, will receive the money as a monthly ticket of public traffic per month per person distributed by Settlement Department.
4. Payment of moving for telephone, cable TV, gas conveyor After signing Payment of moving telephone is 1000 Yuan per unit. agreement, paying Payment of moving for cable TV is 350 Yuan per household. in full once within Payment of moving for gas conveyor is 1500 Yuan per household. 5 days after the persons moved out of the original house. 2. I. I. The houses of floor area equivalent to the original one will be Settling accounts Article 27, 28 of Dwelling Owner of Ownership paid in accordance with the area of legal ownership recorded in the and paying in full "Implementation houses tittle of housing ownership certificate regardless of once while Measures", Article 23 signing agreement. o
IRR Resettlement Policy 22Final Report (A
Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the Implementation Implement- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date Mien Categories ______._;_____-e.-:j.: 1. 2. public or private owned houses. The settling department will settle Settling accounts Settling of "Act of Urban Dwelling Owner of Ownership accounts with owners of title without account for structure price and paying in full department( Housing houses tittle of housing difference. In case that repaid floor area exceeds the original one once while GREEO) Management" in within 5 m2, close accounts will be conducted at construction cost. signing P.R.C To the part of exceeding 5 m2, close accounts will be conducted at agreement. commodity price. For the part of repaid floor area below the original one, close accounts will be conducted at replacement cost without depreciation.
2. That for exceeded area less than 5 m2 the settling accounts be Conducting while Article 9 of conducted at construction is applicable to the following cases: signing "Implementation agreement. Details" A. The original average living space is less than 5 m2 /person so as to need to increase repaid area. B. In case that the repaid house is separated with difficulty so as to need to increase repaid area.
3. For the persons to be resettled moved from developed zones to Conducting while Article 9 of less developed zones or from a unit below 6th floor(including 6th signing agreement "Implementation floor) to a unit above 7th floor without elevator, so the relocation Details" area needed to be increased,
1I 2. In accordance with the related provisions, while settling accounts Conducting while Dwelling Owner of Ownership and exchanging ownership, the increased will not be evaluated. signing houses tittle of housing agreement. 4. Except the houses owned by overseas Chinese, if the houses have been rented to others, the rent relationship cannot be changed because of movement. The house owners do not need to be resettled.
IRR Resettlement Policy 23 Final Report Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the Implementation I mplement- LegalBasis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date atlon Categories .. ______en.i;; 5. The houses owned by overseas Chinese to be demolished will Conducting while be conducted in accordance with specific provisions of Housing signing agreement Owned by Overseas Chinese Demolition Management in Guangdong Province.
1. The situation suitable for regulations of Housing Owned by Overseas Chinese Compensation is as follows:
A. The legal private houses owned by alien Chinese or Chinese citizen living abroad . B. The legal private houses owned by returned overseas Chinese . C. The private houses brought using overseas remittance after liberation. D. The inherited private houses by overseas Chinese in accordance with laws before the notices of resettlement activities is issued. E. The legally inherited houses owned by overseas Chinese. F. the legal private houses owned by countrymen in Hongkong, Macao, Taiwan 2. Measures of demolition of rent houses owned by overseas Settlement Article 16 of Chinese: Department "Implementation A. In case that of demolition of rent houses owned by overseas Details" Chinese, the relocated house of original tenant
2. 1. will be arranged by the Settlement Department, or find solution Settlement Article 16 of Dwelling Owner Ownership through consulting with the employed unit of original tenant. In Department "Implementation houses case that one of tenant family members has houses arranged by Details" their units, or has bought houses, their resettlement will not be conducted again, or the area of relocated house will be decreased. B. In case there is no rent relationship before or the relationship established after the notice of resettlement activities being issued, no resettlement will be conducted
IRR Resettlement Policy 24 Final Report ('
Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the Implementation Implement- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date ation Categories i_.____.___;.:_._r Ageniies 5. In the case of the reformed houses to be demolished and the Conducting while Article 6 of compensation in accordance with exchange ownership, the signing "Implementation agreement will be sign between owner of title and Settlement agreement, paying Details" Department. The agreement document with record the area of in full once. original reformed house (including the area which will be increased for permanently relocated houses ), will be informed of the original units which sold the houses. During the implementation of ownership exchange, the owners will pay costs of the exceeded area to the Settlement Department at the standards of 300 Yuan/ m2 for multi-storied buildings and 400 Yuan/ m2for high-rise buildings because the area exceeding to the original houses is public area such as stairs and corridors.
2. 1 6. To the residential land house to be demolished, in case that the Conducting while Dwelling Owner Ownership housing owner with the residential land signing houses agreement. Certificate has had a urban residence registration, the ownership exchange will be conducted in accordance with the above related regulations for private houses.
2. 1. The compensation costs required by the owner will be paid in Conducting while Article 3 of "Some Compen- accordance with the legal area recorded in ownership certificate, signing Regulations", Article 3 sation at regardless of public or private houses. In case that the Settlement agreement, paying of "Resettlement costs Department or the affected persons choose the legal costs in full once or Details" evaluated by the Administrative Department of Real Estate to twice compensate, the compensation at costs will be paid in accordance with the evaluated costs. But the compensation for rent houses wvillnot be paid at costs in principle.
2. The houses owvnedb) ovcrseas Chinese will be demolished in While signing Article 3 of "Some accordance with specific provisions of "Overseas Chinese Housing agreement, paying Regulations", Article Demolition in Guangdong Province". In case that the owners in full once or 19 of "Resettlement require compensation at costs, the Settlement Department will twice Details" compensate at the costs which are legally evaluated by Administrative Department of Real Estate in accordance with the area recorded in ownership certificate.
IRR Resettlement Policy 25 Final Report Affected Affected Compen- Resettlement Policies,Compensation Rates and Entitlements of the Implementation Implement- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date Oiatit Categories Agences ______: 3. To the affected reformed houses to be demolished, In case that While signing Article 6 of "Some the owners require compensation at costs, the agreement will be agreement, paying Regulations" signed by the Settlement Department, the units of selling houses in full once or and the owners. The compensation at costs will be paid in twice accordance with the related housing- reform policies.
4. To the affected houses of housing plots, in case that the owners Idem with housing plot certificate have had a urban residence registrations and the owners require the compensation at costs, it will be paid in accordance with the above related regulations about private houses.
I. 2. 3. 1. The basic living facilities such as patio, grounds, garden to be Idem Settlement Article 7,8 of "Some Dwelling Owner of Other demolished will not be conducted at the method of ownership Department Regulation", Article 5 houses title compen- exchange, but the compensation will be paid at 50 percent of of "Resettlement sation actual area equivalent to the original one. The compensation at Details" costs will be paid in accordance with the costs evaluated by the Administrative Department of Real Estate.
2. The affected public area/facilities of stairs and corridors owned Idem Article 6 of "Some by the original units can only be compensated at costs by the Regulations" Settlement Department. 2. 1. I. 1. The non-dwelling houses to be demolished will be relocated in Conducting while Settlement Article 29 of "Act of Non- Users Houses accordance with the original floor area. signing agreement Department Resettlement dwelling Management" issued houses by state council 2. To the affected houses moved from developed zones to less Idem "Regulations of developed zones, the additional area will be calculated in Increasing Relocated accordance with the above related regulations. Area Regarding Permanently Moved from Urban Center to Outside Zones in Guangzhou"
IRR Resettlement Policy 26 Final Report Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the lmplementation: Implement-:: Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date .aton Categories : Agebeles 3. The illegal or temporary shops will not be relocated. During the period Referring to Article of implement 26, section 2 of activities "Implementation Measures", Article 13 of "Implementation
______~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Details 4. To the houses of the owner of overseas Chinese housing, the Conducting while Referring to Article rent relationship will be stopped between the owner and the tenant. resettlement 16, section 3 of The Settlement Department will settle a non-dwelling house for "Resettlement Details" the tenants.
2. 5. To the affected persons who receive business license after the Idem Article 48 of Non- Users Houses notices of the resettlement activities are issued, or receive business "Implementation dwelling license before the notices issued but do not have business while the Measures" houses notices are issued, their houses will be relocated in accordance with the natures before the notices are issued
6. The business houses such as grain and oil shops, coal shops, Conducting while Settlement Article 49 of post offices and public lavatories, will be relocated near prior to resettlement Department "Implementation demolition . Measures" 7. The enterprise housing for production and auxiliary facilities, Conducting while Article 11 of will be compensated at the method of relocation/reconstruction, resettlement "Resettlement Details" combination and moving.
As the method of relocation/reconstruction, the houses will be reconstructed in accordance with the standards of current workshops and the compensation will be calculated in accordance with the same price standards. Compensation for the production land will be paid referring to the compensation measures of the auxiliaries in dwelling houses. The compensation for hospitals, schools, kindergarten, will be paid in accordance with the above measures.
2. 1 8. The other buildings such as embassy/consulate, military Conducting while Article 22 of Non- Users Houses installations, church, temple, Taoist school, culture relic, houses resettlement "Implementation dwelling owned by foreigner or overseas Chinese, will be demolished in Measures" houses accordance with related laws and regulations
IRR Resettlement Policy 27 Final Report Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the Implementation Imphment- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Dato '5 itlo; Categories gcei 9 2. 1. lossof stoppage of production. Conducting while Settlement Article 44, 45 of Other signing Departmet "Implementation compen- A. State owned or collective shops agreement, paying Measures" sations To the state owned houses for business, the loss of stoppage of per quarter production due to no temporary resettlement houses, will be paid per month, from the date of stopping production to the month of relocation. The compensation is 50% of the sum of the monthly wages, welfare, retirement allowances and taxed profits of a year before the demolishing notices are issued. B. Private houses for business. The loss of stoppage of production due to no temporary resettlement houses or removal, will be paid per month, from the date of stopping production to the month of relocation. The Settlement Department will calculate the compensation in accordance with the 50 percent of the first 6 months disposable average profits before the demolishing notices are issued. In case that the compensation is less than 100 Yuan/month per person (including the staff in register) will be paid at 100 Yuan/ month until the month of completing resettlement.
2. 1. 2. To the stall occupied street or sidewalk, the original unit which Conducting while Settlement Article 44,45 of Non- Users Other permit the license will be responsible for demolition, will have to signing Department "Implementation dwelling compen- relocate them within the stipulated time. The Settlement agreement, paying Measures" houses sations Department will not pay any compensation. per quarter C. The temporarily built houses permitted by planning department, will not be relocated by the settlement Department. But withinthe planied service life, theloss of stoppage of productioii vill be compenisatedto the fixed year in accordance with the calculating measuiresin above section A and B. The houses vi icihare out of the fixed year or have no planned service life. will not be compensated.
IRR Resettlement Policy 28 Final Report ('~~ *
Affected Affected Compen- Resettlement Policies, Compensation Rates and Entitlements of the implementation Implement- Legal Basis . Categories Persons sation PAPs Date atlon ______Categories ______~ gnis. 2. Loss of business in different places. Conducting while Article 46 of The business loss due to permanent relocation in different places, signing "Implementation will be compensated once in accordance with the actual situation. agreement, paying Measures" The compensation for each person is from 100 Yuan to 600 Yuan in full once per day in accordance with zone-difference, and the number of the affected persons is in accordance with business persons in register. The period of compensation is 12 months.
2. 1. 2. 3. Movement allowance Conducting while Settlement Non- Users A: The once-movement allowance for private shop is 600 Yuan. signing Department dwelling Oother B: In case that the users require the Settlement Department to agreement, paying houses compensati move for them, the Settlement Department will meet the in full once ons requirement but not pay the movement allowance. C. The state owned and collective enterprise, will be paid through mutual discussion in accordance with specific categories and quantities of goods of the affected units.
4. Payment of telephone moving The moving of non-public telephone will be compensated by the Settlement Department in accordance with the standards stipulated by telecommunication department.
2. 2. . 1. The ownership exchange of the non-dwelling houses will be Conducting while Settlement Non- Owner Exchange conducted in accordance with the specific provisions of.the signing agreement Department dwelling ownership ownership exchange of the dwelling houses. houses 2. The affected houses permitted for business, will be Idem Article 15 of compensated in accordance with the price difference between the "Implementation business house and the dwelling houses valued by City Real Estate Details" Exchange
2. 2. . The payment of stoppage of production for 36 months will be paid Idem Settlement Article 15 of Non- Owner Exchange at 70 percent of first 12 months' disposable average profits before Department "Implementation dwelling ownership the notices of resettlement activities are issued. Details" houses _
IRR Resettlement Policy 29 Final Report ( 0)
Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the IImplementation[mpenient- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date aton Categories Agencies ______:: 3. The rented houses will be paid at not only above stipulated Conducting while Article 5 of price difference but also 8 years' loss of the stoppage of rent signing, paying in "Implementation (deduct the related tax) once by the Settlement Department in full once Details" accordance with rent difference between business housing and dwelling houses stipulated by Guangzhou Land and Housing Administrative Bureau. To the persons who have rented business houses, the Settlement Department will calculate the payment of stoppage of production at 70 percent of first 12 months' disposable average profits before the notices of resettlement activities are issued.
2. 1. In case that the owner of the non-dwelling houses, require Conducting while Compensati compensation at costs, the Settlement Department will meet the signing agreement on at requirement. The compensation at costs will be paid in accordance housing with the related policies and regulations of dwelling houses with costs ownership.
3. 1 I 1. The acquired paddy field will be paid at 3 to 6 times average Paying as two Land Article 14, section I of Agricul- Farmer in Payment for annual output value of 3 years prior to acquisition. The vegetable times after Land acquisition "Implementation tural land township, loss of land plot, nonirrigated farmland, garden area, piscina, will be paid at 3 acquisition unit Measures of Land village and to 5 times average annual output value of 3 years before agreement is Management in farmer for acquisition. The average annual output value are in accordance signed, last time Guangdong Province" planting with the annual report of the most basic unit and the unit-price paying is before (shorted in "Land approved by price administrative department. handing over Law" below) 2. The acquired garden area which have crops without harvests, land. will be compensated in accordance with 2 to 4 times average annual output value of 3 years of the same crops in near area and growing situation before acquisition. 3. The other acquired land will be compensated at less than 50 percent of average annual value of local non-irrigated farmland in 3 years.
IRR Resettlement Policy 30 Final Report Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the Implementation Implement- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date ation Categories . ....P P1 :e; x....Age Payment of The crops which live in short time, will be paid in accordance with Paying as two Land Article 14, section 2 of loss of one-year output value. The crops which have lived for several times after Land acquisition "Guangdong Province standing years, will be compensated properly in accordance with their. acquisition unit Land Law" crops living period. The loss of artificial weald and scattered trees will agreement is be compensated at their actual values. The non-artificial weald, signed, last time artificial weald self-cut by the affected unit, or the rush planted paying is before crops after initiating discussion for land acquisition, will not be handing over land compensated
3. 1. 3. 1. The unit owned or private housing auxiliaries to be demolished Paying as two Land Article 14, Section 3 Agricul- Farmer in Compen- for land use for state project, will be paid in accordance with the times after Land acquisition of "Guangdong tural land township, sation of related national regulations, or the local unite standards of acquisition unit Province Land Law" village and appurtenanc production price. In case that the housing owner want the agreement is farmer for es ownership back, the construction unit will repay the same quality signed, last time planting house in accordance with the original floor area. paying is before 2. To demolish the private houses owned by overseas Chinese, handing over land countrymen in Hong Kong, Macao, Taiwan, will be submitted municipal people's government for approval, the compensation will be paid in accordance with related national, provincial regulations. 3. Well, tombs and other appurtenances will be properly compensated in accordance with actual situation. The rush-built appurtenances after initiating discussion for land acquisition will be not paid. 4. The compensation standards of loss of the appurtenances will be in accordance with the evaluated price.
5. Compensation for housing of household plots A. In case that the owner of the housing of household plots has had a urban residence registration, the compensation will be conducted based on the stipulation of demolishing the housing with residential land certificate (item 1.2.1.6 of the table) B. In case that the residence registration of the owner of housing of household plots is still rural, the compensation will be conducted in accordance with the stipulation of item 3.1.3.5.A of the table, or rebuilt by land acquisition unit.
IRR Resettlement Policy 31 Final Report 0 r0
Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the _Implementation Implement- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Dat atlon. Categories _A:C..i , __if______*______.____ 4. 1. The allowance for acquired plough for state project will be paid Idem Land Article 15,16 of "Land Allowance at 50 percent of the compensation for land in accordance with the acquisition Law in Guangdong for number of persons to be resettled. In specific case, allowance for unit Province", Article relocating relocating plough can be properly improved, but the total of 28,29,30,31 of labor compensation for arable land and allowance for relocation per mu "National Land will not exceed 20 times average output value. Management Law" 2. To the residential land and land without tax, the allowance for relocation will be not paid. 3. Surplus labor due to land acquisition will be relocated through initiating some sideline activities, developing township and village enterprises. The Land Administrative Departments above country government are responsible for organizing the unit of acquired land, the land use unit and the related unit.ln case that there still are surplus labor to be
relocated, the Labor Administrative Department will provide jobs in land use unit and arable units. The allowance for relocation will transfer to the labor absorbed units respectively.
Municipal New To the vegetable land in uptown to be acquired, the land use Paying while Land Article 27, Section 3 vegetable vegetable department will pay new vegetable land establishment funds in conducting land acquisition of "National Land office land accordance with the related national regulations. acquisition unit Management Law" establish- ment funds 4. The compensation for relocation of electric & communication Paying in two Settling Various Various Ccosts of lines, TV cable, wvaterpipes, gas conveyor to be resettled, will be times after signing department public units pipeline settled accounts according to the quota standards of national agreement facilities owning engineering. pipelin_ _ 2. Compensati The roadside trees and flowers to be resettled or cut down will be Owner of on for compensated in accordance with the prices of various specific trees the trees roadside and flowversstipulated by Guangzhou Gardens Administrative and lawns trees and Bureau. flowers
IRR Resettlement Policy 32 Final Report (* 0
Affected Affected Compen- ResettlementPolicies, Compensation Rates and Entitlementsof the Implementation Implement- Legal Basis Categories Persons sation PAPs Date atJon Categories."-.::.Aece.;:.".... 3 Compensati The traffic facilities to be moved, will be compensated in Transport on for accordance with their formats, quantities, qualities, through police unit traffic discussion between the Settlement Department and transport police facilities department.
4. Compensati The people's air defence facilities will be compensated according Civil air on for civil to the formats and quantities of demolished facilities, by defence air defence discussion between the Settlement Department and civil air unit facilities defence department.
5. Compen- The affected dockage will be compensated in accordance with Shipping sation for their formats and quantities through discussion between the unit dockage Settlement Department and the shipping department. facilities
IRR Resettlement Policy 33 Final Report IRR ResettlementPolicy 34 Final Report
5.3 Compatibility of the Existing Resettlement Policies in Guangzhou with World Bank OD 4.30
5.3.1 The objective of the Operational Directive for Involuntary Resettlement (OD4.30) of the World Bank, is to ensure that the populationdisplaced by a projectreceive benefits from it and are assisted in their effortsto improvetheir former living standards,income earning capacity,and production levels, or at least to restorethem. Particularattention should be paid to the needs of the poorest groups and other PAPs in vulnerablegroups to be resettled.
5.3.2 The existingresettlement policies in Guangzhouare in accordancewith the objectiveof Bank's resettlementpolicies. It is stated as follows:
1. Dwellinghousing, PAPs are the urban residents.According to the specificprovisions of the j0GuangzhouCity Ordinancesof Urban HousingDemolition & RelocationManagementij and the l'ImplementationDetailsi±, the PAPs are ensuredto improve or at least restore their former livingstandards:
a. The area of new resettlementhousing will be not less than the originalone. PAPs who move from better zonesto worse zones will receive properly larger livingspace than original. b. All compensationfor housingwill be paid in cash at replacementcost without depreciation,or be made at the method of exchangeproperty rights without structure price difference. c. All paymentof Compensationfor land acquisitionand resettlementwill be paid prior to housingdemolition. d. Preferentialpolicy will be givento the vulnerablegroups such as the orphans,the widows,the old, the poor and the householdswhose living spacesare less than 5m2 /person.
2. Businesshousing. PAPs are the enterprises,shops and concernedworkers. There are specific provisionsof the i°GuangzhouCity Ordinancesof Urban Housing Demolition& Relocation Managementi and the ;°lmplementationDetails i± stipulated: a. Affected enterprisesand shops will receive compensationat replacementcost witlhout depreciation,or be compensatedwith new housingwithout structure price difference. b. Movingfees and loss of closure of business and productionwill be paid, the loss of business in differentplaces will be paid too.
3. Agriculturalland. PAPs are the township,the village and the farmers. Article 29 of the i 0LandManagement Lawi± stipulatesthat the compensationstandards of land acquisition and resettlementcan be properlyimproved and compensationrate can ilcrease up to 20 times of the annual output value of the affected land after approvedby provincialgovernment if the compensationfor land acquisitioncannot maintainPAPsj former productiveand living level.
4. Infrastructure.PAPs are the infrastructure.According to Article6, Section6 of the i TemporaryMeasures of Land Acquisitionfor Traffic InfrastructureConstruction j±, GREEOwill settle accountswith the units with property rights based on the actual scales and (, quantitiesof dismantled/resettledinfrastructure in accordancewith national construction IRR ResettlementPolicy 35 Final Report
engineering quota of infrastructure such as pipeline and traffic facilities and so on. The (~IIJ infrastructureof originalscale will be reconstructedbefore demolition.
Note: The resettlement and compensation policies for the temporary building such as temporarily built shops are not within the scope of general stipulation. It has been stipulated in 10Existing Policy Tableji, and will be narrated in section 5.5.
5.4 Insufficiencies of the Existing Resettlement Policies in Guangzhou
Although the existing resettlement policies and standards in Guangzhou are consistent with OD4.30 of the World Bank, they still have following insufficiencies:
1. They under-estimate the impacts caused by resettlement on the living communities and business environments of the PAPs. This is mainly reflected on that the principles for setting up resettlement sites are not very clear and mainly on physical aspects. 2. They classify all enterprises, units and their staff as non-residential. The general classification will cause difficulties in planning and implementation. 3. The users of the temporary and illegal shops are not always resettled properly.
Therefore we now make necessary supplement on the Guangzhou existing resettlement polices by Guangzhou Inner Ring Road Resettlement Policy.
5.5 Inner Ring Road Resettlement Policy
Inner Ring Road resettlement policy has been worked out according to OD4.30 of the World Bank, resettlement policies and laws of China and the objectives and the categories of project impacts of the Inner Ring Road project. It is a supplement of the existing resettlement policies on the basis of OD4.30 of the World Bank.
5.5.1 Resettlement Policies for the Affected Households
5.5.1.1 Policy for residence classed in section 5.2 Policy Table will be implemented
I. Residence users will be entitled to housing resettlement and other relevant compensations. a. Housing resettlement standards include: calculation method of housilg area, population and rent etc. b. Other relevant compensations include: temporary relocation fee if temporary relocation takes place, moving fee, compensation for house facilities etc. 2. Residence owners will be entitled to housing compensation and other relevant compensations. a. Housing compensation standards include: standards of housing property right exchange or compensation standards for relinquishing property right. b. Other relevant compensations include: compensations for flower gardens, courtyard and other attachments. 3.Those who are both owners and users are entitled to both compensations listed above. IRRResettlement Policy 36 Final Report
5.5.1.2 Located principle for residential resettlement sites
1. Residential resettlement sites will be located in the areas which will benefit from the construction of the Inner Ring Road Project. 2. Residential resettlement sites must have complete municipal public facilities such as road, water and power, communication, post service and other necessary facilities such as schools, hospitals/clinics, commercial buildings/markets, parks, recreation. 3. Distribution of the residential resettlement sites should be located according to the distribution of the demolition areas, to ensure the resettlement sites close to the original areas. 4. The transport of the residential resettlement sites will be thoroughly considered. Adopting the rehabilitation measures, such as at least two routes of buses connecting resettlement sites to the city center. According to the long-range plan of the metro system, our resettlement sites are within the scope of the beneficial area.
5.5.1.3 Resettlement Principle for Persons Without Residential Registration Certificates of Guangzhou
I. They will be considered as PAPs. 2. Those who are living with legal residents who have residential registration certificates (provisional guests or short-term dwellers) will go with legal residents. 3. Those who are living in the housing to be dismantled with legal property right or legal lease, which is arranged by their working units, will be resettled in the resettlement housing compensated to their working units by the project. The working units must resettle these persons in the resettlement housing or in other ways. The resettlement sites are the same as the resettlement sites for ordinary households. 4. Those who are living in temporary housing or illegal building to be dismantled, which is arranged by their working units, will be resettled by the units themselves. Since these people are necessary to their working units, the units will of course resettle them. the GCCTPO and the GREOO will monitor these units to resettle this kind of PAPs properly through grievance mechanism. 5. Those who rent houses at market rent (high price)will be compensated. The project will compensate resettlement housing to the owners. The renters can choose whethlerto keep their lease with the owners or not, and they will be compensated with moving fee. 6. If they can not find suitable housing by themselves, GCCTPO and GREEO will be responsible for helping them to find ones with same quality and same rent.
5.5.1.4 Other Resettlement Policies
I1. All PAPs will have the right to choose one from all the resettlement sites. 2. Compensation for housing in cash will be calculated at local replacement price without depreciation. 3. The courtyards, flower gardens will be compensated at 50% of the replacement price of housing of the same site. 4. Other attachments, enclosing walls and flower beds will be compensated at construction cost without depreciation. 5. Local schools must accept the children of the PAPs who need to transfer their schools. Possible transfer fee will be paid by the GREEO. 6. The GREEO will send trucks and staff to help the PAPs who are unwilling to accept the 0J moving fee to move by themselves. IRR ResettlementPolicy 37 Final Report
7. The PAPs will be given two day holidays by their working units to move. They will also be compensated for their salaries deducted due to moving by the GREEO. 8. Price difference compensation will be given to the PAPs whose fitting-up standards of their houses are higher than that of the resettlement housing. The fitting-up materials can be removed by and be given to the PAPs under the prerequisite that this will not affect the safety of the housing.
5.5.1.5 Special rehabilitation measures for the vulnerable groups (households of the elderly without living with the adult sons/daughters, widows, single-parent, the disable, the chronically ill and the poor)
Besides the resettlement standards and rehabilitation measures listed above, the vulnerable groups will be entitled to following rights:
I. They will be relocated to the zones close to the city center (unless they are willing to choose other resettlement sites). 2. By special permission of the government, their resettlement will have area amplifier, even if their original living sites are in the same level of city region with the resettlement sites (see Policy Table). 3. Poor people among the vulnerable groups will be resettled on the first floor (if any). They will be permitted to open stores to earn their own livings. 4. The old, ill and disable among the vulnerable groups will be resettled in low-storied houses.
5.5.2 Resettlement Policies for the Affected Shops
5.5.2.1 Policy for non-residence in 5.2 of the Policy Table will be implemented
I. The users of shops will be entitled to housing resettlement and other relevant compensations a. Housing resettlement standards will be based on the floor area. If they are resettled at the same place, the floor area will not be increased, otherwise it can be increased same as residence. b. Other relevant compensations: compensation for loss of business due to closure, compensation for loss of profits due to operation in different areas. 2; The owners will be entitled to housing compensation and other relevant compensations, which are the same as those of residence . 3. Those who are both owners and users are entitled to both compensations listed above.
5.5.2.2 Principles for shop resettlement and location of commercial resettlement sites
L. Resettlement principles for shops a. We will keep the integrity of the shops, i.e., to maintain the original framework of the shops, rather than break them, to ensure the employment of the original staff of the shops. b. We will try our best to keep the community association of the original shops to maintain the original business environment of the shops. c. Classify the trade of the shops. We will collectively resettle the slhopsof the same trade, to form large scale business. 2. Location principle for the resettlement sites of the shops c 9a. , Business of the shops depends on the following two business environments: IRR ResettlementPolicy 38 Final Report
First: the quantity and purchase power of local residents and floating population, e.g. food and drink service and daily goods stores etc. Second: large scale business and convenience of transport rather than local residents and floating population, such as building materials, automobile parts, industrial products, durable goods for family use, electrical appliances for family use and furniture (different kinds of super markets of building materials, automobile parts and electrical appliances for family use in Guangzhou have such characteristics: they are relatively far from the city center, but they are in large scale (several hundred shops in one market) and have convenient transport). b. Shops which depend on residents and floating population will be resettled in the following regions: Residential resettlement sites: in the residential resettlement sites, shops will be resettled according to the quantity of the residents. These shops can go on with their business and act as the commercial facilities of the residential resettlement sites. According to the urban planning of Guangzhou, every residential zone should have commercial facilities whose area are not less than 8% of the total area of the zone. Resettled at the original place: some shops will be resettled at the periphery land. This can solve the resettlement of some shops and avoid the commercial loss of the resettlement sites. c. Shops which depend on large scale business and convenient transport will be resettled at the areas which will benefit from the Inner Ring Road Project. Shops of same or similar trade will be resettled in the same resettlement zone, to achieve large scale business.
5.5.2.3 Other resettlement policies for shops with legal property rights
I . compensation in cash a. Those who are both owner and manager of the shops can choose to be compensated for the shops in cash. b. The compensation will be calculated according to the replacement price witlhout depreciation. c. Compensation for other housing attachments will be calculated according to the standards for residence. 2. Compensation for loss of business due to closure: shops' business loss due to closure during the relocation process will be compensated. a. Compensation including the total of salaries of the staff, salaries of retired staff, welfare funds, after-tax profits will be paid to the enterprises too. Then the enterprises pay the staff. Period of closure will be calculated according to actual closure'period. The project will supervise the compensation of salaries and welfare funds. b. Those self-employed shops which do not have a statement of profit and lose but only an after-tax sales will be compensated according to their legal sales x current average profit of the trade. c. To some commercial enterprises in deficit, if the salaries of the staff are lower than the minimum salary stipulated by the Municipal Govemment at that time, the project will compensate according to the total sum of the minimum salaries. 3. Compensation for loss of business in different areas due to relocation: shops which are moved to other places will be compensated for the loss of business of relocation according to the degree and period of loss. 4. Compensation for moving expenses: shop moving expenses will be paid by the project. IRRResettlement Policy 39 Final Report
5. Compensation for fitting-up: for commercial enterprises whose fitting-up work have been ratified by the Construction Committee, if the fitting-up standard is higher than that of the resettlement housing, compensation for price difference will be paid. The fitting-up materials can be dismantled by PAPs and given to the owner under the prerequisite that this does not affect the safety of the house. 6. For managers who rent their shops at market rent(high price), they will be given equivalent resettlement and compensation. The owner of this kind of shops will be compensated according to the loss of rent income too. 7. If the project can not give the shop managers its own shops at once (such as shops which will be resettled on the periphery land), the project will rent shops in some special markets for transition, and to lower the shopsF loss of business due to closure and the expense of project itself. 8. Shorten the transition period so as to shorten the affected period and lower the compensation paid by the project for loss of business due to closure. There two kinds of measures: a. Dismantle the housing on the periphery land in advance, which can be used to construct permanent commercial multi-purpose buildings and start the construction of permanent commercial multi-purpose buildings as soon as possible. b. Other shops will not be dismantled until the lands are needed by the project. For some sections where the project can be started later (such as the Apollo Restaurant on Duobao Road), the shops can be relocated after the commercial buildings have been built. Therefore the affected period of the shops as a whole are shortened. c. For the shops to be resettled back to the original sites,-the GREEO should not resettle back the affected shops until the commercial buildings are ready for business. 9. The project will take into consideration the specialty of the operation of individual shops, and give reasonable care in the planning of resettlement. 10. The affected shops will have a preparation period for 2 months before movinug.
5.5.2.4 Principles for resettlement and location of resettlement sites for temporary shops
I. Compensation principle for the constructor (owner) of temporary shops Since temporary shops are not permanent buildings and have fixed duration contracts (generally two years), and the owners have promised to dismantle them when the contracts expire, no compensation will be paid to the owners for expired temporary shops. For temporary shops with contract remaining, the owners will be compensated according to construction cost at market price and time limits.(seen in Appendix I) 2. Resettlement and compensation principles for the users of temporary shops a. The users of temporary shops will be given equivalent resettlement in kind, or be introduced to other special markets in city (commence city). The users have priority to rent the shops and will be given 10% discounts in rent. b. Users of the temporary shops with contracts period remaining will be compensated for loss due to relocation (see 5.5.2.4(2)). c. Users of temporary shops will be compensated for the moving expenses. 3. Location principle of resettlement sites for users of temporary shops a. Temporary shops will be built on the periphery land along the alignment of the Inner Ring Road, which are not suitable to build permanent housing, as resettlement sites. b. Existing different kinds of large scale markets in the city. c. Users of the temporary shops will be resettled in classes according to their trades.
5.5.2.5 Resettlement of the illegally built shops IRR ResettlementPolicy 40 Final Report
C For illegally built shop, users will be compensated as above (5.5.2.4)
5.5.3 Resettlement Policies for Partially Affected Institutions
The impacts of the project on institutions are partial. Normally the whole institution does not have to be entirely relocated (see 5.2(2)). However if the affected part of the institution is a relatively independent unit(such as residences, shops etc.), it will need a entire relocation of the unit. Therefore the resettlement policy for affected institutions should be decided according to the categories of impacts.
5.5.3.1 Resettlement policy for entire relocation of relatively independent units of an institution
I. Residences of institutions are affected: 5.5.1 resettlement policy for resident households will be implemented. 2. Shops of institutions are affected: 5.5.2 resettlement policy for shops will be implemented. 3. Public facilities of institutions are affected: 5.5.4 resettlement policy for public facilities will be implemented. 4. Infrastructures of institutions are affected: 5.5.6 resettlement policy for infrastructure will be implemented.
5.5.3.2 Resettlement policy for affected non-independent parts
I . Only the real estate of the institutions are affected, and will not cause the whole institutions to close: the project will only compensate for the real estate. Compensation will be paid according to the type of the real estate without depreciation. 2. Besides the real estate being affected, the whole institution has to close: the project will compensate for both the real estate and the actual loss due to closure. 3. Land acquisition: The lands of most institutions were allocated to them by the government, and they have not paid land using fee to the government. Therefore land acquisition will not be compensated. For some institutions which have paid land using fee, the money paid will be paid back.
5.5.4 Resettlement Policies for the Affected Public and Cultural Facilities
After the demolition of the public and cultural facilities because of the project, not only their units and staff, but also the users (beneficiaries) of the public and cultural facilities, will be affected. Therefore some special measures must be taken by the subject to minimize the impact of the demolition of these facilities. Resettlement policies for the affected public and cultural facilities are listed below:
I. Resettlement policies stipulated in the Policy Table will be implemented. 2. Considering the business facet of these units, resettlement policies for slhopsin 5.5.2 will be implemented for the resettlement of public and cultural facilities themselves. 3. Special policies: a. We will decide the resettlement sites of public and cultural facilities(units) according to communityi s demand for these units and the urban planning of Guangzhou City. To ensure that the necessary public and cultural facilities of the original communities are not IRR ResettlementPolicy 41 Final Report
affected, we will set up necessary public and cultural facilities for the new communities at this opportunity of resettlement. b. We will strive to assure no closure of the public and cultural facilities, so as to ensure the operation of the public welfare network of the original communities and the installation of the planning of the public welfare of the new communities. c. The specialties of public and cultural facilities will be considered by the project in the RAPs.
5.5.5 Resettlement Policies for Fully Affected Industrial Enterprises
Here affected industrial enterprises refer to the factories and enterprises which will be entirely relocated. For factories and enterprises which are only partially affected by the project, the resettlement policies for institutions in 5.5.4 will be implemented for their resettlement. Following resettlement policies will be implemented for the resettlement of factories and enterprises:
1. Resettlement policies stipulated in Policy Table will be implemented. 2. The original real estates of the factories and enterprises, such as land, housing, structure, road, power supply, power network etc., will be compensated at replacement price or restored to their original scales. 3. The loss, installation of equipment and the adjustment fee due to relocation will be compensated. 4. Loss of production due to relocation will be compensated. 5. The project will resettle the factories and enterprises to the new industry zones according to the overall industrial arrangement planning of Guangzhou city. The project will ensure transport, power supply, gas supply and sewage, which are necessary for production, and that the production cost of the enterprises will not increase due to relocation. 6. The original institutional framework will be restored to ensure employment of the staff. 7. The moving fee of the factories and enterprises will be paid by the project.
5.5.6 Resettlement Policies for Affected Infrastructures
I . Resettlement polices stipulated in Policy Table will be implemented, i.e. all facilities will be restored to their original scale and compensated first. 2. Communication, power supply, water supply, pipeline of gas etc. will be restored before demolition, to avoid impact on all beneficiaries(users). 3. Civil air defense will be compensated at its construction replacement price. 4. Drainage facilities will be kept or reconstructed in the process of civil work. 5. Trees and lawns will be compensated at replacement price. 6. Public facilities will be restored by the project. 7. Road and transport facilities will also be restored by-the project. 8. Other facilities will be restored and compensated.
5.5.7 Resettlement Policies for Affected Rural Production Teams and Farmers
All property loss of the affected rural production teams and farmers will be compensated. Also jobs wili be created for the farmers to avoid impact on their living standards. IRR ResettlementPolicy 42 Final Report
5.5.7.1 Resettlement policies of property compensation for rural production teams (villages) and farmers
1. The compensation for land, standing crops, water conservancy facilities will be implemented according to the stipulation in Policy Table. 2. All kinds of housing and facilities of rural production teams (villages) will be compensated at replacement price. 3. Enterprises belonging to rural production teams (villages) and farmers will be resettled according to the stipulation stated in 5.5.2 and 5.5.5 4. For housing of household plots, following policies will be implemented: a. The owners have rural residential registration certificate: they will be compensated at replacement price. According to village planning, local governments will re-allocate lands close to the living area of villages for re-construction. b. The owners have urban residential registration certificate: resettlement policies stipulated in 5.5.1 will be implemented.
5.5.7.2 Policies for job creation and living security for farmers
I . The project will strive to maintain the original ratio of labors of the affected production teams (villages) over land, to ensure the living standard of other farmers whose land will not be acquired. 2. The project will create jobs for the labors who become superfluous due to land acquisition. Jobs will be created for men aging from 16 to 55 and women aging from 16 to 45. 3. The project will pay for training of the superfluous farmers to enable them to do non- agricultural work. 4. Ways of resettling superfluous labors: a. According to stipulations of Guangzhou municipal policies, the project will preserve 8% of the land acquired for the production teams (villages) to develop non-agricultural production, which will absorb the superfluous labors. The project will pay labor resettlement subsidy to the production teams (villages) according to the superfluous labors absorbed. b. The project will pay labor resettlement subsidy to the state-run enterprises and township enterprises which can absorb superfluous labors. The standard is listed il the Policy Table. c. Farmnerswho have skills can find jobs themselves (such as working for cooperative ventures, joint ventures and foreign fund enterprises). The project will pay one-time subsidy to these farmers. The compensation standard will equal to that of labor resettlement subsidy. d. The project will pay old age pension to men older than 55 and women older than 45. The pension equivalent to labor resettlement subsidy will be given to the farmers througl township governments.
5.5.8 Other Detailed Standards of Resettlement Policies
Other detailed resettlement policies and compensation standards for PAPs will be stipulated according to the current price index at that time in the RAPs of each phase. IRR ResettlementPolicy 43 Final Report
O 6. INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR LAND ACQUISITION, DEMOLITION AND RESETTLEMENT AND RELATED INSTITUTIONS
The chart of the main procedure and relationship of the resettlement activities for Guangzhou City Inner Ring Road Project is detailed in the next page. The roles and responsibilities of the various institutions are described below.
6.1 GuangzhouCity CentreTransport Project Office
1. To be responsible for the internal monitoring of the implementation of Resettlement Policy and RAP of GREEO, define job responsibilities of the various institutions and the schedule. Indicatorsto be monitoredwill includethe following: * Paymentof compensationto PAPs/units * Allotmentof flats * Relocationof PAPs * Rehabilitation of PAPs and vulnerable groups * Replacement of infrastructure and public facilities * Restoration of affected enterprises * Scheduling of above activities * Conformity of the above activities with the provision's of the RAPs and OD4.30 * Adequate and proper consultation and participation with PAPs during preparation and implementation * Adequate staffing, training, work schedule and effectiveness of GREEO, IMO and other agencies/institutions involved in resettlement
2. To examine the progress of the implementation of the Resettlement Policy and RAP, it will carry out the following: * To examine and discuss the internal monitoring reports prepared by GREEO and the external monitoring reports submitted by IMO. * To examine the independent reports prepared by various relative implementation institutions or related departments of Guangzhou City Government.
3. To help solve the problems found during the implementation of Resettlement Policy and RAP, if there are any, to assign to a certain institution to implement them.
4. To examine the progress of the implementation put forward in the previous meeting.
5. To discuss and coordinate the group's next steps related to the report of the IMO.
6. To make decisions on the measures to be adopted that are not taken in the Resettlement Policy and RA4Pto meet the resettlement objectives. To put the measures into the supplement of Resettlement Policy and the next phase of RAP.
7. To examine whether the various adverse impact has been properly compensated and the living standards of PAPs restored to their original level after relocation. IRR ResettlementPolicy 44 Final Report
The Framework of the Main Procedure and Relationship
|Fulfilling the fee of | | Overall plan, monitor, | GCCTPO l
Survey in sites, count the fee Unit of census Participatethe research of engineering survey |Public participation J feasibility,compile the Plan&Task (Demolitionand resettlement£=
Compile the RAP Guangzhou City Carryout the PlanningBureau ConductLicense of LandUse for resettlement houses Construction,License for Land Use, License for Housing Relocation Guangzhou City Land
ix- . -n_ and Housing Administrative Bureau
GuangzhouCity Acquiring farm land ob creation for surplus Labor Bureau IChprk-sms slrt he] compensation fee
GREEO(duty unit)
Demolishing houses Sign the agreement of u ecte units an persons
Hand over landfol lll construction lll
Check and accept, summary
IlThe IMO Evaluation after resettlement IRR ResettlementPolicy 45 Final Report
Q 6.2 GuangzhouCity PlanningBureau To confirm the land acquisition range of the project, and issue the "License for Planned Land Use" and inform Guangzhou Housing and Land Administrative Bureau, based on the report of "applying for planning license for land use" raised by the GCCTPO and the Municipal Administrative Bureau and the approval papers of the preliminary design.
6.3 Guangzhou City Land and Housing Administrative Bureau
To carry out internal consultation, ratification and confirmation for the scope of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement, according to the "License for Planned Land Use" issued by City Planning Bureau and the report of "applying for planning license for land use" raised by the Municipal Administrative Bureau and GCCTPO, then issue the "License for Construction Land Use", the "Housing Demolition Notice", the "License for Housing Relocation". fter completion of demolition and relocation of the project, which will be checked and conform to the related regulations of land use, issue the "License for Land Use".
6.4 Guangzhou City Labor Bureau
In accordance with the "License of the Planned Land Use" issued by Guangzhou City Planning Bureau and the report of "applying for the job creation for surplus labor", submitted by GREEO, to examine, consult, confirm the number of surplus labors and the guidelines of job creation, conduct all procedures ofjob creation for surplus labors, then issue the "License of Job Creation for Land Acquisition" to the GREEO, with which GREEO will apply to the Municipal Land &Housing Administrative Bureau for the "License of Land Use for Construction".
6.5 Independent Monitoring organization
In accordance with the Bank's requirements of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement for the Inner Ring Road Project, independent monitoring organization will be invited. It is responsible for the followings:
I. o monitor the proper land acquisition for the Inner Ring Road Project, including: * land acquisition for the resettlement sites of the project. * Situations of job creation of rural labor affected by the land acquisition. * Agreement of the land acquisition is followed. 2. To ensure that public consultation and participation of PAPs is adequately and properly undertaken. 3. To develop and conduct baseline Standard of Living Surveys (SLS) during project preparation. The SLS will be repeated one year after RAP implementation for each phase and a final one at the end of the project. 4. To monitor the production arrangement of the affected enterprise. 5. To monitor the arrangement of the affected households. 6. To monitor the progress and quality of the housing construction in resettlement sites and the movement and reconstruction of public facilities 7. To monitor affected shops and their profit-making capabilities. 8. To evaluate the plan of fund allocation and application and its effect. IRR ResettlementPolicy 46 Final Report
The indicators for monitoring include the following: * Payment of agreed compensation to PAPs and units * Proper allocation of flats * Timely preparation and adequacy of resettlement sites * Timely relocation of PAPs * Rehabilitation of PAPs, especially vulnerable groups * Relocation/replacement of infrastructure * Proper enterprise relocation and compensation * Other agreed allowances (e.g., transportation, moving subsidy, loss of income/wages, transitional business location, etc.) are provided and in a timely manner * Adequate and proper public consultation and participation with PAPs. * PAPs' grievances are heard and solved * Conformnityof resettlement activities with Resettlement Policy for the IRR Project.
6.6 Census Unit
To be responsible for the census for the affected residents, shops and enterprises in each phase of the Inner Ring Road Project and for the conduct of the census data, and to send the report of census to GREEO.
6.7 Production Teams and Neighborhood Committees/Streets
Production teams will be responsible for reporting the property, area of the land and the ratio of land/labors; to take part in the land acquisition, demolition and resettlement activities directly, including survey, planning for resettlement and reconstruction and treatment of arguments etc.; to allocate the compensation fee. The Neighborhood Committees/Streets are responsible for assisting the activities of the affected residents, obtaining their opinions and reporting their complaints.
6.8 GREEO: Implementation Agency for Land acquisition and Resettlement
6.8.1 Responsibilities
I. To prepare the Resettlement Policy based on the national, provincial and municipal laws and regulations and OD 4.30. 2. To prepare RAP in accordance with Resettlement Policy and the result of the census . 3. To implement the RAP 4. To guide the census. 5. To make out the budget of the land acquisition, demolition and resettlement in accordance with the information of census provided by the census unit. 6. To put forward the possibilities of reducing the quantities of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement as far as possible, to save the expense utmost during the course of the resettlement activities. To make up the plan for land acquisition, demolition and resettlement and the schedule for action. 7. To be responsible for the construction of the resettlement housing and the reasonable assignment of the sources of resettlement housing. 8. To be responsible for the relocation and compensation of various pipes and lines 9. To be responsible for housing demolishing within the property line and ground leveling which will be submitted to construction company for construction. IRR Resettlement Policy 47 Final Report
7. EXPERIENCE, LESSON AND IMPROVEMENT OF GUANGZHOU ROAD EXPANSIONAND ENGINEERING OFFICE (GREEO)
7.1 Introduction
I . GREEO has been engaged in the resettlement activities for road construction for 18 years, with abundant experience on land acquisition, demolition and resettlement of hundreds of municipal projects and tens of important municipal projects such as Expansion Engineering of Dongfeng Road and Jiefang Road, North Ring Expressway Project, strictly carrying out the specific provisions of national laws and municipal regulations of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement and enjoying good prestige. 2. It boasts over 170 registered staff members, and about 50 ones of them engaged in the land acquisition, demolition and resettlement activities directly. A number of over 100 staff can be organized to deal with the land acquisition, demolition and resettlement activities directly in case of emergency. Moreover, there are more over 80 technological persons. 3. In order to meet the requirements of the World Bank, do well the activities of the resettlement of the IRR and keep the PAPs' benefit better, GREEO summarizes the experience and reforms the organization, improves the working procedure and trains the persons.
7.2 Experience and Lessons of GREEO
7.2.1 Existing Organization of GREEO
There are 9 departments in GREEO. There are 4 working groups in the demolition and removal department. The framework of the organization is as follows:
GREEO(Leading Office)
Secretary & Plamian DRemovlbn i Ppln esne Engineenng Housing Financial sinOfc
Deparmenta &epamint &Removai Deppartment Departmemt &Transportation Management Affairs DesignOffce Department Department Department Dprmn Deatmt Department Department Department
Section 1 of Demolition Section 2 of Demolition Section 3 of Demolition Section 4of Demolition &Removal &Removal &Removal &Removal IRR ResettlementPolicy 48 Final Report
7.2.2 Existing Procedure of Land Acquisition, Demolition and Resettlement of GREEO
1. Distributing tasks and initiating activities. After receiving the approval of land acquisition, the property line drawings for land acquisition and the plane design drawings, the Demolition & Removal Department will put the tasks into effect. The activities to be fulfilled are given in the following:
2. Produce catrastal maps, check property right, hold housing consultation, submit the scheme of the land acquisition, demolition and resettlement and compensation, and distribute the Housing Demolition Notice.
3. Census a. Census for the affected households - Organize persons to the administrative department of register residence and the housing management department, and register the residence and the situation of the real estate within the property line so as to preliminarily understand the affected households within the property line. - Organize persons to drop in and record in detail the situation of the house, population, economic, commuting and the requirement of the affected houselholds, prepare for the next step of plan and resettlement. b. Census for the affected enterprises and units - To the enterprises and units within the property line, drop in and conduct census, understand the characteristic of the affected enterprises and units and the degree of impact, classify according to the categories of the project impacts. - Record the situation of the real estate, business, staff and workers, assessment of loss, prepare for the next step of plan and resettlement. c. Census for the affected infrastructures - For the pipelines within the property line, first, determine the character of the pipelines and their owner units; second, collect all owner units and tell them the situation of the project and provide the plane figures to thiem, require them provide the materials of the pipelines in 15 days after receiving the plane figures. - For other infrastructures, we will record in actual situation. d. Census for land acquisition - To measure the land, check and register the appurtenances - To measure and register the houses on the land - To record the economic situation of the farmers - To record the loss of power and water conservancy due to land acquisition. - To register other loss
4. Making up scheme. preparing budget, carrying out collective reviews. After census, according to the results, GREEO will make up the preliminary scheme for land acquisition, demolition and resettlement and compensation, which will be discussed and permitted by the Demolition & Removal department, Pipeline department, Plan & Examination department and GREEO's heads. The budget activities will be implemented following the below procedures: the Demolition & Removal Department puts forward the payment in accordance with the compensation standards. After examined and verified by the Plan & Examination department and verified and discussed collectively, the Planning & IRR ResettlementPolicy 49 Final Report
Budget Section works out the total budget in accordance with results of collective discussion, 0J then the Examine& Verify Officechecks again. At last submittingto the Urban Construction Division of Urban and Rural Construction Commission for examination & approval. Initiating to implement the land acquisition, demolition and resettlement activities based on the scheme and budget.
5. Consulting resettlement and compensation with the PAPs After determining the plan and scheme, consult resettlement and compensation with all kinds of PAPs. Consultation is conducted according to the different categories of impacts and based on the laws and regulations of demolition and removal. a. Affected household - Consult the resettlement sites, floors, directions, areas, moving fee and the compensation of inner facilities. If the owner require and the house can be given up the property, we shall consult the price of the house, quantities, form of paying. To the households that need to be temporarily moved, consult the housing and the compensation for the temporary movement. b. Affected enterprises and units - To the units that need to be resettled, consult resettlement sites, floors, areas, losses of closure, losses of business in different places, compensation for inner facilities and moving fee; To the units that need to be temporarily moved, consult the formnof transition and the resettlement and compensation during the period of transition. - To the units that do not need to be resettled, consult the compensation and rehabilitation measures of the affected housing, structures, equipment and facilities. c. Infrastructure (public utilities) - Report to different administrative units of the infrastructures, conduct the procedures of the demolition and removal, consult the scheme of the removal with the administrative units, consult the coordination between the construction of the infrastructures that need to be moved and the construction of the roads and bridges, compensate after determining the scheme in accordance with construction quota. d. Land acquisition - Consult the compensation of the land, crops, powers, irrigation and rehabilitation measures of all kind of rural infrastructures with the production teams(village). - Consult the compensation of the affected houses and appurtenances with production teams, farmers and other units. - Consult the condition of farming residence changing non-farmilg residence, their job train with the production teams (village) - Check the decreased land, agricultural population of the production teams (village) and correspondingly decrease the agricultural taxes. - Consult the resettlement and compensation with the rural enterprises.
6. Signing the agreement of resettlement and compensation with all PAPs accordilg to the results of the consultation and the laws and regulations of demolition and resettlement, send to examination and apply for approval.
7. Applying for Approval. To the agreements of compensation for land/pipeline acquisition and resettlement, handler fills out the submitted table, through the Examine & Verify Office and the duty director of GREEO raising suggestion and recommendation, at last the director of GREEO reviews and IRR ResettlementPolicy 50 Final Report
approves them. Apart from a copy of effective agreements is sent back to the affected persons (units), others are handed over to the GREEO for record.
8. Implementing the agreements The PAPs will be compensated, resettled and rehabilitated in accordance with the contents of the agreements. a) - get the agreed housing, which will be sent by the housing management department of GREEO, and conduct the procedures of the housing rent or the housing use. b) get all the agreed compensation, the payment will be paid by the Finical Affairs departmnentof GREEO. c) conduct all related procedures that government stipulated.
9. Conducting Property Right Exchange. After the procedures of relocation and compensation fulfilled sufficiently, GREEO will initiate to implement the activities of resettlement and compensation for housing property right, sign the agreements of compensation for public and private housing with the owners and conduct the related procedures of property right exchange in the Housing Administrative Department.
10. Pipeline Temporarily restored. To the pipelines to be temporarily restored within property Jine, arrange the construction team to demolish them.
11. Applying for Certificate for Land Use When the related documents are all ready, GREEO will go to the Housing Administrative Department applying for the "Certificate for Land Use" or the "Certificate for Temporary Land Use".
12. Summarization and records. After the relocation is completed, GREEO settles accounts and the main handlers write the summarization and submit to the related department and to the heads of GREEO for review. After the land acquisition and resettlement activities are finished, the related documents will be sent to the secretary section of GREEO in order to keep records.
7.2.3 Procedure of Transition Housing Construction of GREEO
1. Applying for Land Use. In accordance with investment and the purpose of road expansion, opting for relocation sites, applying for the property line, initiating to make preliminary feasibility study to the purposed land use.
2. Setting up the Project. After obtaining the property line drawings for land use, the Planning Section of GREEO will set up the project.
3. Land Acquisition, Demolition and Resettlement, Receiving the "Certificate for Land Use". Based on the established project, the Relocation Group of Transition Housing makes the plan of resettlement and rehabilitation, applies to the Municipal Housing Administrative IRR ResettlementPolicy 51 Final Report
Department for the relocation permission, completes the activities of land acquisition and resettlement, finally receive the "Certificate for Land Use".
4. Design. After acquiring the "Certificate for Land Use", apply for the focal points of the design, entrust the Planning and Design Institute to survey the topographic map and do geological drilling activities, design the planning scheme, design the drawings of applying construction and the construction drawings after applying and approval, lay off and check the alignment.
5. Three-open ( water, electric, road) and land leveling. After the planning scheme being approved, water, power and road are available and land is levelled based on the preparatory conditions.
6. Construction. Prepare and review the budget based on the construction drawings, sign construction contracts, hold the meeting of the inspection of the construction drawings. During the period of construction, the Engineering Administrative Department will be responsible for guideline and management. After the projects being fulfilled, checked and accepted, GREEO will apply to the Construction and Management Branch of Municipal Planning Administrative Bureau for check and acceptability, receive the license for check/acceptability. After closing accounts, respectively submit the related documents to the secretary section of GREEO ,------and the Municipal File House to keep in the record.
7. Transferring Houses . The transition housing, after being checked and accepted, will be handed in the Housing Management department of GREEO, which will be managed as a whole.
8. Rebuilding Housing. After the housing has been completed and transferred to the Property Station, when it is necessary to modify the original housing arrangement of the plane or the stereoscopic section, the Resettlement Department must directly apply for the modifying activities to the Property Station. The Design Office checks and verifies the design process and applies for construction in accordance with rebuilding tasks from the Planning Section. The construction management of rebuilding project will be carried out in accordance with article 6 of the procedure.
7.2.4 Experience of GREEO
In the light of the previous work procedures and organization framework of GREEO, just mentioned above, main experiences are given as follows:
I . Publicizing and explaining to the affected persons/units perfectly. 2. Investigating in the field, mastering the situations of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement exactly. 3. Making up the schemes of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement and compensation perfectly, drafting up the plan of costs & budget. IRR ResettlementPolicy 52 Final Report
4. Reviewing strictly the schemes of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement, saving the (,,J costs of the project effectively. 5. Assigning tasks to each person, signing the responsibility contracts with each basic unit, carrying out the specific provisions of the national and municipal laws & regulations of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement strictly, conducting the activities of land acquisition, demolition and resettlement perfectly, ensuring to finish the task on the deadline. 6. Making great efforts to implement the compensation for land acquisition, demolition and resettlement, ensuring the legal rights and profits of the affected persons. 7. Bearing distinctly responsibilities for the work of each organization, practicing strictly scientific management, ensuring the affairs of preceding and following land acquisition, demolition and resettlement, finalizing entirely each task in the style of high quality and efficiency. 8. Summarizing activities, keeping documents and agreements in the record carefully. 9. Designing the resettlement sites for residents fairly and reasonably.
7.2.5 Lesson of GREEO
1. During the period of census survey, GREEO pay much attention to record the loss of the property, but the survey of the economic situation of the affected households and living, business environment is not enough.
2. There are not a whole plan for single-parent families and the vulnerable groups such as the old and the sick/disable, only specific clerks take care of them in the process of the activities.
3. The municipal projects are public affairs, different from the develop corporation, so all the resettlement sites are distributed unifiedly by the City Government. Then the affected households/units unifiedly transfer to the resettlement sites which are farther from the urban center, although perfectly equipped with auxiliary facilities.
4. The agencies of external independent monitoring are lacked.
5. The design of the commercial resettlement sites is not enough.
7.3 Improvement of GREEO
In order to adapt to the demand of the resettlement activities of the IRR, GREEO will improve the original organization and working procedure and train the staff according to the requirements of the World Bank.
7.3.1 Institutional Framework of Resettlement Institutions and Agencies
According to the requirements of the World Bank, we shall perform the system of project responsibility and set up special headquarters to coordinate the whole activities of the project.
7.3.1.1 Institutional Framework of Resettlement Institutions and Agencies (shown in the framework table below) IRR Resettlement Policy 53 Final Report
FrameworkFlowchart of Organization
Project Leading Group
GCCTPO Intemal Monitoring
Plan &Examination Department I GREEO Financial Affairs G Department
Demolition &Removal Headquarters of IRR of -- Coordinating Department GREEO
Property Pipeline Demolition Buiness of Demolition Engineering Section &Removal Section &Removal Section Section
Working Groups classifiedby resettlement classification IRR ResettlementPolicy 54 Final Report
O 7.3.1.2 Staff Compositionand Duty Division 1. Inner Ring Road Project Resettlement Headquarters of GREEO a. Staff composition: - One office leader (held by the director of GREEO) - One leader of resettlement administration - One indoor service administration leader - One secretary - Three coordinating members b. Duty: - To be responsible for directing and coordinating all the resettlement activities of the Inner Ring Project.
2. Business Department of Resettlement a. Staff composition: - One resettlement department leader (held by the leader of Resettlement Headquarters) - Three resettlement coordinating members b. Responsibilities: - To be responsible for the internal and external coordination activities of the Business Department of Resettlement as well as those of the housing source for resettlement and the planning and statistic activities of the entire project.
3. 5 Work Groups and one ownership work groups under the leading of Resettlement business department. a. Staff composition: - To be organized by the staff of the Resettlement Department of GREEO. There will be a group leader. Specific working staff members in clhargeof the resettlement activities amount to 50 or so. b. Responsibilities: - To be responsible for land acquisition, demolition and exchange ownership activities along the alignment of the Inner Ring Road
4. Special departments are supposed to set up as follows: conveyor/pipeline relocation department, property management department, engineering department a. Staff composition: - To be organized by professional staff assigned from related departments of GREEO. b. Responsibility: - To be responsible for the following activities: conveyor/pipeline relocation, property management of resettlement housing, checking and verifying the resettlement agreements, modifying the space of the housing source, housing demolition work.
5. The agency staff are: Certain staff take certain responsibilities and try to depend mainly on the handy agencies and staff. Those belonging to headquarters, resettlement department and coordination department are professional staff, and other departments are attached to the IRR ResettlementPolicy 55 Final Report
main body of GREEO. To the staff who conduct specific demolition and resettlement, the I,> S office will take such way as assigningand trainingbatch by batch.
7.3.2 Trainingof the AgencyStaff
GREEOnow has 98 qualifiedstaff who had beentrained by GuangzhouLand & Housing AdministrativeBureau(GLHAB) and had passed the examination.They are still arrangedto attend land acquisition,demolition and resettlementtraining class held by GLHABannually. The working staff of resettlementactivities will usuallyexchange working experiences and hold communication meetingsof workingexperience of land acquisition,demolition and resettlementregularly at least twice per year. We set up the followingtraining plan for the staff from the agenciesof GREEO,in order to make properlythe land acquisition,demolition and resettlementactivities of the Inner Ring Road Project to meetthe requirementof the Bank's resettlementactivities.
I . Trainingplan for staff dealingwith resettlementactivities directly * Educationon laws and regulationsof resettlement * Educationon OD 4.30 * Principlesand strategiesof negotiation/participation/consultation * Analysisof resettlementcases and simulationdrill * Practicaltraining
2. Trainingplan for resettlementadministrators * Laws and regulationsof resettlementactivities and tactics of negotiation * Professiontheory of managementscience * Seminaron cost control and resourceallocation. * Urban planning * Databasemanagement * Visitsto successfulresettlement project * Participationand consultation * Monitoringand evaluation
7.3.3 Measuresto intensifythe capacityof the institutionsand agencies
We will take the followingsteps to intensifythe capacitybesides the professionaltraining and educationon professionaltraining and educationon professionmoral for the agency staff, to ensure thietimely completionof resettlementactivities of the Inner Ring Road Project.
]. To motivatethe staff's activity by reasonablejob divisionand scientificpraising treatment---- the more you've done, the more you'll earn.
2. To take advancingscientific managementsystem. To managethe informationof resettlement activitiesand sourcesof relocatedhouses throughcomputer system, set up the database.
3. All the related departmentsof GREEOare supposedto assist the activitiesof the Settlement Departmentof the InnerRing Road Project actively. IRR ResettlementPolicy 56 Final Report
7.3.4 Rationalizationof working procedure
1. Census: According to the requirement of the World Bank, we shall design the questionnaire of survey in detail, conduct rational classification based on chapter 4. Especially, we shall invited the experts of population so as to make up the original shortcoming of the census of the population and economic.
2. Scheme: determine more detailed scheme of resettlement, rehabilitation and compensation based on the results of the census and the classification in chapter 4, and perform the scheme strictly. We shall conduct public participation activities during the period of making up the scheme and implementation, and absorb the opinions of affected persons so as to improve our works.
3. Determine special resettlement scheme for vulnerable groups.
4. Pay attention to the rehabilitation of the living environment and business environment, chose the resettlement sites (transition houses) and construct (purchase) the houses scientifically.
5. Conduct the following-up works well after the resettlement, and cooperate the internal and external monitoring.
6. Record the materials of the affected persons well. IRR ResettlementPolicy 57 Final Report
8. PARTICIPATION AND CONSULTATION O In order to safeguardthe legalrights and interestsof the PAPs and make their living standards improve or at least maintain the original level and benefit from the project, it is very important to conduct widespread activities of participation and consultation. The PAPs actively participate in the planning and implementation of resettlement activities, which will alleviate their resistance. So that the resettlement activities and the entire program can go on smoothly.
During the preparation of Resettlement Policy (hereafter Policy) and RAP of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects, the PAPs are encouraged to take part and their opinions are considered into the plan to be implemented. The participation and consultation of the PAPs will run through the whole project circle.
Propaganda of the resettlement information and collection of the feedback from the PAPs are achieved mainly through the following ways.
8.1 Census
The purpose of census is to get the true and first-hand materials by face-to-face interviews with the PAPs, and to be the basis of preparation of the Policy and RAP as well as next-step implementation of resettlement. Moreover, it offers a good opportunity for the public to participate, so that we can come into contact with the PAPs face to face as many as possible. During census, the trained enumerators introduce the significance and summary of the Inner king Road Project, compensation standards, related resettlement policies, preliminary resettlement arrangement and implementation schedule to the PAPs and answer their questions, find out their attitudes, preference and requirements, and write down their requirements for resettlement in detail in questionnaires.
8.2 Standards of Living surveys (SLS)
The SLS, a sampling survey based on census, which is carried out by the Independent Monitoring Organization (IMO), mainly reflects the indicators of living standards. As an important measure of monitoring and evaluation, SLS combines quantitative and qualitative method. Comparing with census, it pays more attention to learn the view, feeling and preference of the public. The IMO gains first-hand materials by SLS, and reports feedback from the PAPs to the GCCTPO without delay. Meanwhile, the IMO puts forward some reasonable proposals to ensure that living standards of the PAPs will be improved after resettlement or at least be maintained at the pre-project level.
The baseline SLS will be carried out in a month after each phase of the census is finished. The SLS will repeat a year after accomplishing resettlement for each phase. A final SLS to be conducted at the end of the project. Each SLS will encourage the public to participate, so as to ensure that the PAPs act an important role in their rehabilitation process.
8.3 News Media
News media is an important tool for information dissemination of participation and consultation. We release related information about the project by news media so that the public can understand our job. At the same time, we are able to obtain feedback from the public in time by the sensitivity of news media to improve our job. News media can not only make the PAPs show their opinions freely, but also make those who will not be adversely affected take active part in and give them a chance to express their views freely from the impartial and objective point of view and evaluate any aspect of IRR ResettlementPolicy 58 Final Report resettlement activities. It is another advantage of news media. If necessary, the GCCTPO will open special columns with TV stations, Broadcasting stations and newspapers to propagandize resettlement policies such as compensation standards, and seek the opinions of the public before implementing 0f resettlementactivities. After finishingresettlement activities, the news media can find out the living and employment condition of the PAPs by pursuing interviews. If there is any insufficiency in resettlement activities, news media will urge the project units to adopt remedial action. Issuing the information of the project has been started by the news media before census.
8.4 Public Consultation Meetings
8.4.1 Formal and Official Public Consultation Meetings Organized by the GCCTPO and GREEO
This kind of meeting is held by the GCCTPO irregularly. The topic, scope and invited persons will be changed according to need. Each meeting will be monitored by IMO. The representatives of vulnerable groups (women in particular) will be invited to these meetings. The meetings have been started before preparing the Policy and RAP so that the public opinions can be incorporated into the Policy and RAP.
8.4.2 Public Consultation Meetings and Interviews organized by IMO
It is not only one of important duties of IMO to conduct activities of participation and consultation, but also one of important ways to monitor the resettlement activities independently. The IMO will hold regular (at least once every two months) and small scale meetings according to different categories and areas, such as affected household consultation meetings, affected shops consultation meetings and focus groups discussion meetings (semi-structured interviews of small groups composed by gender, age, income levels, interests and vulnerability, etc.). The topic, scale and attendance of meetings will be correspondingly changed. Each meeting the representatives of vulnerable groups (if any), women in particular, will be invited to attend. Staff of the GCCTPO and the GREEO will participate in regular meetings. Besides regular consultation meetings, IMO will visit the PAPs irregularly to get some new information and feedback if necessary.
The IMO will report the result of participation and consultation activities to the GCCTPO without delay. During resettlement implementation, the IMO will have a chapter to report the activities of participation and consultation in the M&E report, and hand in to the GCCTPO every two months and to the World Bank every half a year in written form.
8.5 Resettlement Information Brochure
After the final Policy and RAP are ratified by the World Bank, the GREEO will post all related materials in detail, which include project impacts, resettlement site description (including picture materials), resettlement policy such as compensation standards and grievance procedure etc. The GCCTPO and the GREEO will prepare Resettlement Information Brochure (RIB) which contains the summary of entitlements and interests of the PAPs and description of grievance procedure too. The brochure will be distributed to all PAPs. It includes the following contents:
I. Synopsis of the project 2. Classification of project impacts 3. Compensation for all categories of project impacts (resettlement policy) 4. Information of public facilities within and near the resettlement sites, such as schools, hospitals, police stations and public transits, etc. IRR ResettlementPolicy 59 Final Report 5. Organization list which make the entitlements and interests of PAPs come into effect 6. Conformity of the schedule between all the implementation of the Resettlement Compensation Agreement and the civil work 7. Channels for participation and consultation of the PAPs 8. Detailed procedure for grievance and appeal 9. Resettlement Information Brochure will be distributed to all the PAPs in phase I in a month after negotiation with the World Bank finish. The RIB will be distributed to all PAPs in other phases before the negotiation with the PAPs.
8.6 Signing of Resettlement Compensation Agreement
The GREEO will hold the mobilization meetings in different areas with the GCCTPO before signing Resettlement Compensation Agreement with the PAPs. The PAPs will be organized to visit resettlement sites and all types of resettlement houses to understand the environment, traffic, commerce, schools, communication, hospitals/clinics and sanitation and other necessary facilities in the resettlement sites, so that they can carefully make their personal choices. The organizer will collect opinions and suggestions of the PAPs in order to improve RAPs.
The demolition and removal working staff will directly pay visits to the PAPs to sign the Resettlement Compensation Agreement and will have a full consultation with them. If the PAPs raise a objection to resettlement scheme and have enough reasons, the resettlement scheme can be further adjusted to satisfy them as much as possible.
(\. IRR ResettlementPolicy 60 Final Report
9. GRIEVANCES AND APPEALS Qg Since widespreadactivities of participationand consultationwill be carriedout duringthe entire project circle, it is expectedthat no major grievanceissue will arise. However,to more adequately protect the legal rights of the PAPs, a grievancemechanism will be set up so that the PAPs will have avenuesfor redressingtheir grievancesrelated to any aspect of the resettlement. The mechanismis designedto be easy, accessible,transparent, fair and effective. The purpose is to solve grievances effectivelyat the project levelwithout resortingto complicatedformal channels, so that the progress of the project will be more effectivelyascertained.
To simplifythe grievanceprocedures for the PAPs,a GrievanceAcceptance Group will be set up underthe IMO. The GrievanceGroup will be composedof 5 members(3 from the IMO, I from the GCCTPO,and I fromthe GREEO)and the directorof the IMO will be also the head of the GrievanceGroup. The GrievanceGroup will open to the public two weeks before the Resettlement CompensationAgreements are signed. Hotlinetelephone and mail box will be availableto accept inquiriesand complaintsfrom the public. Detailedprocedures are as follows:
Stage 1: If any person is aggrievedby any aspect of the resettlementand rehabilitationprogram, he/she can lodge an oral or written grievancewith the GrievanceGroup. In case an oral complaint is made, it will be written and arrangedin detail on paper by the staff of the GrievanceGroup. The GrievanceGroup will categorizeall grievancesand discuss them with the relative responsible agencies. The GrievanceGroup will resolvethe issue withintwo weeks.
r> ~~~Stage2: If the aggrievedperson is dissatisfiedwith the decision made by the GrievanceGroup, he can bringthe complaintin written form to the GuangzhouUrban and RuralConstruction Commission (GURCC)----thehigher authorityof the resettlementimplementation agency (GREEO)within one month from the date of the receipt of the decisionin Stage 1. The GURCCwil i reach a decision on the complaintwithin three weeks.
Stage 3: If the aggrievedperson is dissatisfiedwith the decisionof the GURCC,he can bring the complaint in written form to the GuangzhouMunicipal Government within one month from the date of the receipt of the decision in Stage 2. The Mayor Mailboxwill receive the grievance letters. The GMG will reach a decisionon the complaintwithin three weeks.
Stage 4: If the aggrievedperson is still dissatisfiedwith the decisionmade by the GuangzhouMunicipal Government,he can appealto the PeoplesCourt in accordancewith the;°Civil Procedure Acti-within 15 days from the date of the receiptof the decision in Stage 3.
PAPs can redress their grievanceson any aspect of the resettlementand rehabilitationprogram, includingpayment of compensationand allotmentof flats. The detailed proceduresfor redressal of grievancesand the appealprocess will be widely publicizedduring the participationand consultation meetingsand posted in the offices of the GREEO and the GrievanceGroup. They will be incorporatedin the ResettlementInformation Brochure to be distributedto all affected persons. IRR Resettlement Policy 61 Final Report
10 MONITORING AND EVALUATION Q1 GuangzhouCity Center TransportProject will displaceor adverselyaffect the standardsof livingof people currently living and conducting economic activities in the location where the Inner Ring Road will be constructed. To ensure that the PAPs maintain or improve their current standard of living, GREEO and GCCTPO have prepared a Policy and a RAP for Phase I & II. The RAP of each phase will be implemented by GREEO. In order to ensure that the implementation of resettlement and rehabilitation will be carried out in accordance with the provisions of the Policy and the RAP, both;°intemali±andi°independent;+monitoring will be carried out. The whole process of monitoring can be simply described as follows:
Resettlement Indicators Verification Activities INPUTS * developpolicy . satisfactorypolicy * internalreports; review framework(based on by WB census) * prepareresettlement * satisfactoryRAP . internalreports; review action plan (basedon by WB census) . providetraining for . capablestaff . internalreports staff * obtainfunding . funds available . internalreports; observationsby WB . commitmentfrom * facilitatework & funds . internalreports; managernent flow observationsby WB
PROCESS(activities) * census . censusdata . reports fromcensus unit . baselineSLS . surveydata/analysis * external(IMO)reports . settingup database a database . internalreports * informationto PAPs * informationsheets (e.g. * internal/externalreports RIB,news, articles): informedPAPs . consultationwith . meetingsat various . internal/external reports; PAPs levels & with different . interviewsby WB groups a participationof PAPs . differentPAPs . internal/external reports; committees interviewsby WB . capacitybuilding of . capablePAPs in the . internal/external reports PAPs committees . signingResettlement . RCAaccepted by two . internal/external reports Compensation sides Agreement * set up grievance * grievancemechanism in . internal/external reports procedures operation IRR Resettlement Policy 62 Final Report Resettlement Indicators Verification Activities OUTPUTS * acquire land * land acquired * internal reports 0 * build /buy new * buildingsand . internalreports; buildings and apartments available observations by WB apartments * relocate/replace . relocated/replaced . internal reports; infrastructure infrastructure observations by WB . compensate PAPs . PAPs are compensated * internal/external reports as agreed and on time * relocate PAPs . PAPs are relocated * internal/external reports satisfactorily * rehabilitate PAPs * PAPs get rehabilitation * internal/external reports . compensate shops * shops are compensated . internal/external reports as agreed and on time . relocate shops . shops are relocated . internal/external reports satisfactorily . rehabilitate shops * shops get rehabilitation . internal/external reports . compensate industrial . enterprises are . internal/external reports enterprises compensated as agreed and on time . relocate enterprises a enterprises are relocated . internal/external reports satisfactorily . rehabilitate enterprises * enterprises get * internal/external reports rehabilitation . - * compensate partially a compensated as agreed . internal/external reports affected institutions and on time * compensate public & . public & cultural . internal/external reports cultural facilities facilities are compensated as agreed * relocate public & and on time . -internal/external reports cultural facilities * public & cultural facilities are relocated * rehabilitate public & satisfactorily a internal/external reports cultural facilities . public & cultural facilities get rehabilitation
RESULTS * SLS during project . PAPs are earning . external reports (one year after incomes resettlement) . shops & enterprises are . external reports * SLS after project earning incomes . PAPs; incomes . external reports restored or increased a incomes of shops & . external reports enterprises restored or increased . living standards are . external reports restored or better IRR ResettlementPolicy 63 Final Report 10.1 Internal Monitoring O) The effectivenessand impact of the Policy and the RAP will be monitoredinternally by the GCCTPO. Internal Monitoring of the complete resettlement organization will be undertaken by the GCCTPO to ensure that all the responsible units follow the schedule and comply with the provisions of the Policy and the RAP. The purpose of this monitoring mechanism is to maintain the satisfactory functioning of the resettlement organization during the implementation process.
10.1.1 Indicators to be Monitored: The GCCTPO will be responsible to monitor the following indicators:
* Payment of compensation to the PAPs / units. * Allotment of flats.(including resettlement site, floor, area, etc.) * Relocation of PAPs. * Resettlement and rehabilitation of the vulnerable groups. * Rehabilitation/replacement of infrastructure and public buildings. * Resettlement, compensation and restoration of affected enterprises. * Scheduling of the above activities. * Conformity of the above with the provisions of the Policy and the RAP and OD. 4.30. * Adequate and proper participation and consultation with the PAPs during preparation and implementation. - Adequate staffing, training, work schedule and effectiveness of GREEO.
10.1.2 Staff for conducting internal monitoring and the implementation procedure
The GCCTPO will collect and verify information every two months in fixed formats from the GREEO during resettlement implementation to ensure that the implementation activities will be carried out by GREEO in accordance with the provisions of the Policy and the RAP and the principles of the O.D. 4.30. Based on the census of the PAPs and their assets, they will supplement new data and maintain a continuous information flow to monitor continuously. The GCCTPO will maintain the data base and monitor the progress in resettlement preparation and implementation through a 100% monitoring of the activities with the assistance of the GREEO. Relevant sections of the database will be shared with the GREEO.
10.1.3 Reporting of Monitoring
The internal monitoring reports will be prepared every 2 months in the fixed formats. The GCCTPO will discuss the problems and issues of the resettlement and rehabilitation with tile GREEO immediately in order to take necessary steps to ensure the progress and quality of resettlement implementation.
The internal monitoring reports will be submitted to the World Bank every 6 montlhsduring the resettlement implementation. The first internal monitoring report will be submitted in the seventh month from the starting date of resettlement implementation. After the implementation is completed, the internal monitoring on remaining resettlement issues will be reported by January 31 of each year. IRR ResettlementPolicy 64 Final Report 10.2 Independent Monitoring
The Independent Monitoring Organization (IMO) will monitor and assist the responsible resettlement organization in achieving the objectives of the RAP as well as to ensure that the PAPs take an active part in the process of their own rehabilitation. The IMO will undertake the independent monitoring of the resettlement component to observe and report on the following:
1. the functioning of the resettlement network including the GCCTPO; and 2. the adjustment of the PAPs to their new lifestyles.
The IMO will be responsible to conduct evaluation of the implementation process and the measurement of the standards of living of the PAPs.
The purpose of independent monitoring is to provide an evaluation of resettlement by an organization independent of the Project Office, looking at the overall implementation from a broader, long term point of view. The IMO will follow the resettlement activities to evaluate whether the goals of resettlement are achieved through:
1. the application of the Laws of PRC including provincial and municipal laws pertaining to resettlement; 2. compliance with the principles of the World Banki s OD. 4.30 on Involuntary Resettlement; and 3. an improvement in the standards of living of the PAPs or at-least maintaining the pre-project levels of well-being.
10.2.1 Responsibilities of the IMO
IMO will act as an independent advisor to the GCCTPO in evaluating the resettlement performance and suggesting alternative courses of action in case problems are anticipated in the achievement of the stated goals of the Policy and the RAP. Specifically the IMO will undertake the following activities:
10.2.1.1 Standards of Living Surveys
IMO will develop and conduct baseline Standards of Living Surveys (SLS) oina randoimnsample of PAPs and a control group within I month from the completion date of census before the beginling of the resettlement implementation. SLS will be repeated a year after each phlaseof resettlement to measure the change in the standards of living of the PAPs. A final SLS will be conducted at the end of the project. This activity will be one of several approaches to determine the changes in the living standards of the PAPs. To conduct SLS, IMO will need:
I . Development and testing of the questionnaire The questionnaire for the SLS will be developed considering the material and cultural factors of the locality to capture the quantitative and qualitative measures of standards of living. After the questionnaire is prepared it will be tested in practice surveys to determine its effectiveness as a measurement tool and will be revised on the results.
0 IRR ResettlementPolicy 65 Final Report 2. Training of the enumerators The enumerators will be trained in the application of the questionnaire in training exercises using the revised questionnaire.
3. Procedures for editing, coding the surveys Enumerators will be supervised by team leaders who will edit all the completed questionnaire in the presence of the enumerators on the same day the questionnaire are completed.
4. Sample size of different groups of PAPs and the Control Group The size of the random sample that will be taken from the census data will be as follows:
* Households of PAPs 10% * Affected shops 25% * Affected enterprises 10% * Vulnerable groups 25% * Proportion of households of PAPs to Households of Control Group 1:1
10.2.1.2 Open ended interviews
Open ended interviews with the PAPs and observational methods will also be utilized to supplement and guide the structured interview format. The methods will include: focus group discussion, interviews of affected persons, interviews of experts knowledgeable about the people/area, and participant observation.
10.2.1.3 Consultation
1MO will organize consultation meetings respectively with the PAPs on a regular basis (at least once every two months) according to different categories of PAPs and sections of IRR. The representatives of vulnerable groups (women in particular) will be invited in all related meetings. By monitoring these meetings IMO will evaluate the effectiveness of the PAPs' participation, and the incorporation of the PAPs' concerns into the RAP and its implementation. IMO will also consult with the PAPs to understand the knowledge, inclination and the wishes of the PAPs in restoring their livelihoods and report its findings to the GCCTPO. These activities will continue before, during and after the implementation of resettlement. Staff of the GCCTPO and the GREEO will participate in these consultation meetings regularly organized by the IMO. Official and formal meetings organized by GCCTPO will be monitored by the IMO.
10.2.1.4 Grievance Issues
The Grievance Acceptance Group under the IMO will open to the public two weeks before the Resettlement Compensation Agreements are signed. Hotline telephone and mail box will be available to accept complaints from the PAPs.
The IMO will regularly visit resettlement sites and inquire about the grievance issues by interviewing the implementing organization, receiving the grievances and also by interviewing the PAPs, and if necessary, suggestions will be made for possible changes in the procedures to make the process more effective. IRR ResettlementPolicy 66 Final Report 10.2.1.5 Other Responsibilities
OA The IMO will also advise the GCCTPOduring the preparationand implementationof the RAP and monitor the following indic'iors:
* Payment of agreed compensation to PAPs and units. * Proper allocation of flats(including resettlement site, floor, area, etc.). * Timely preparation and adequacy of resettlement sites. * Timely relocation of PAPs. * Rehabilitation of the vulnerable groups. * Infrastructure relocation/replacement. * Adequate and proper enterprise and business relocation and compensation. * Other agreed allowances (e.g., transportation, moving subsidy, loss of income/wages and other transitional allowances) are provided and in a timely manner. * Adequate and proper participation and consultation with PAPs * PAPs grievances are heard and solved * Conformity of resettlement activities with the resettlement policy * Organization of the resettlement network. * Accuracy of the Internal Monitoring Reports.
10.2.2 Staff for conducting independent monitoring
The IMO will be directed by a director who has at least five years of experience in conducting population surveys and in monitoring project activities. The organizations should have the capability of data management, statistical analysis, beneficiary assessment and social assessment as well as experience in qualitative surveys.
10.2.3 Reporting of monitoring and evaluation (M & E)
The M & E report will be submitted to the GCCTPO every 2 months and to the World Bank every 6 months by the IMO during resettlement implementation. The first M & E report will be submitted to the World Bank in the seventh month from the starting date of resettlement implementation. The survey report will be submitted to the GCCTPO and the World Bank by the IMO after each SLS.
10.2.4 Follow up on monitoring reports
The GCCTPO will discuss with the GREEO, the IMO and other relative units after the submission of the report. Necessary directions for follow up action will be given based on the problems and issues identified in the M & E reports. Each M & E report will:
1. Report progress on the follow up of problems and issues identified in the previous report. 2. Report the action taken on directions issued by the respective agencies after discussion of the previous report. IRRResettlement Policy 67 Final Report
11. COST AND BUDGET Q The cost of land acquisitionand resettlementare includedin the overall budgetof the Inner Ring Road project, during the implementation of land acquisition and resettlement and compensation. The Project Office will promise to meet the need of cormpensationfor land acquisition and resettlement of the Inner Ring Road project by receiving funds on the specified schedule, to complete the project on the purposed date. Funding for resettlement will be counterpart funding and will come from the Guangzhou Urban and Rural Construction Commission under the Municipal Government.
11.1 Explanation for Cost and Budget of Land Acquisition and Resettlement for the Inner Ring Road Project
The Research Center for Market Economy and Population Development of Zhongshan University was responsible for the census for Phase I & II of the IRR. The census was conducted in Dec., 1995 and Jan., 1996. After that, we have analyzed the census data in details and estimated the costs of land acquisition and resettlement. The costs of Phase III & IV of the IRR are worked out based on the data of preliminary census.
1. Estimate of the demands of resettlement housing and costs.
The estimate is in accordance with the total demolition areas and the affected households. Seven factors of affecting resettlement areas are considered.on the basis of the following items: living conditions of the affected residents, population structure, housing structure, etc. Then with previous experience data, the areas to be needed are worked up. Because the project is urgent, it is impossible to solve all the resettlement housing by building many quarters in a short time. So the method of buying resettlement housingrfrom developers and constructing resettlement sites for the Inner Ring Road Project will be adopted. The resettlement sites will be selected in Baiyun Garden, Guocun Quarter. Tongde Quarter. Xiaogangwan Quarter, Dongpu Quarter, Haijing/Yuan'an Street Quarter and Nan'an Building. The affected shops will be reconstructed near the original land, or bYrebuilding some commercial buildings on the peripheral land and relocating the shops to the resettlement sites. We have drafted the funding plan in accordance with the housillg price of the purposed resettlement sites.
2. Compensation for institutions and temporary shops.
According to housing structure and construction cost of existilg housing, we have established the housing compensation standards.
3. Compensation for Others affected.
Apart from the compensation for resettlement houses, other compensations are chiefly given as follows: * Compensation for the closure of business, auxiliary facilities, telephone relocation, loss of business in different places, etc. * Compensation for moving fees of residential households, relocation of telephones and cable TV, reward for moving ahead of time, etc. * Compensation for facilities such as pipelines, transport facilities, civil air defence projects, trees and lawns and other related administrative fees. IRR ResettlementPolicy 68 Final Report According to related trade stipulations, policies, regulations and experience data, we estimated the costs. (:11) 4. Costs of land acquisitionfor Phase I of the IRR
Due to fact that the Inner Ring Road will be built in the center, it doesn't need to acquire farmland for road construction, but some farmland is still required for resettlement housing. We have acquired 7.58 mu in Haijing/Yuan'an Street, with the compensation of 1,364,400 Yuan, 83.20 mu in Guocun, with the compensation of 10,400 thousand Yuan. Now, the activities of land acquisition have been completed. Predictably, HaijinglYuan'an Street Quarter and Guocun Quarter will have been partially completed by the end of 1998. They will be used for the resettlement housing of Phase III. The cost of land acquisition is included in the basic costs of resettlement housing of Phase III, but its fund investment is put into Phase I.
5. Contingency
* The design schemes of Phase I & II have basically been determined, and detailed census has been conducted. Thus the contingency rate is determined to be 5%. * Since unexpected alteration may be made to the design schemes for Phase III & IV, and the demolition amount calculated according to the preliminary census may have omitted something, compensation may be increased. Thus the contingency rate is determined to be 10%.
6. Administrative fees
According to government regulations, Administrative fees = (Basic Costs + Contingencies) jA3%.
7. The cost and budget above is calculated in accordance with the unchanged price in march,1997(in all the tables). So the resettlement expenses need to be adjusted according to inflation rate in following years.
8. The resettlement expenses in 1997 has not any increment than in 1996.
11.2 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for Phase I of the IRR
I. Basic costs of resettlement housing and compensation is 234,512,302 Yuan (see in Tab. 11.2.1) (invest in 1997). 2. Compensation for the affected institutions, temporary shops and buildings is 7,747,708 Yuan (see in Tab. 11.2.2) (invest in 1997). 3. Other resettlement compensation is 180,920,251.62 Yuan (see in Tab. 11.2.3). 4. Contingencies: (1I+2+3)iA5%=21,159,013.08 Yuan. 5. Administrative fees: (1+2+3+4)iA3% = 13,330,178.24 Yuan. 6. The total costs above are 457,669,452.94 Yuan.
11.3 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for Phase II of the IRR
I . Basic costs of resettlement housing and compensation is 343,055,102 Yuan (see in Tab. 11.2.1)(investin 1997). IRR ResettlementPolicy 69 Final Report 2. Compensation for the affected institutions, temporary shops and buildings is 9,075,632.4 Yuan (see in Tab. 11.2.2)(invest in 1998). 3. Other resettlement compensation is 258,483,821.88 Yuan (seen in Tab. 11.3.3)(invest in 0 1998). 4. Currency inflation:(2+3)x5.8%=15,518,448.35 Yuan 5. Contingencies: (1+2+3+4)iA5% = 31,306650.23 Yuan. 6. Administrative fees: (1+2+3+4+5)iA3% = 19,723,189.65 Yuan. 7. The total costs above are 677,162,844.5OYuan.
11.4 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for Phase m of the IRR
1. Basic costs of resettlement housing and compensation is 719,211,390 Yuan (see in Tab. 11.4.1) (invest in 1998). 2. Other resettlement compensation is 209,634,018Yuan (see in Tab. 11.4.2) (invest in 1999). 3. Currency inflation: I x5.8%+2x(1+5.8%)x5.5%=53,912,864.13 Yuan 4. Contingencies: (1+2+3)iA10% = 98,275,827.21 Yuan. 5. Administrative fees: (1+2+3+4)iA3% = 32,431,022.98 Yuan. The total costs above are 1,113,465,122.3Yuan.
11.5 Estimate of Land Acquisition andResettlement Costs for the Phase IV of the Inner Ring Road Project
1. Basic costs of resettlement housing and compensation is 593,503,67OYuan(see in Tab. 11.5.1)(invest in 1999). 2. Other resettlement compensation is 120,105,284Yuan (see in Tab. 1 1.5.2)(invest in 1999). 3. Currency inflation: I x5.8%+2x(1+5.8%)x5.5%=41,524,905.03 Yuan 4. Contingencies: (1+2+3)iA1 0% = 75,513,385.9OYuan. 5. Administrative fees: (1+2+3+4)iA3% = 24,919,417.35 Yuan. The total costs above are 855,566,662.28Yuan.
11.6 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for the Inner Ring Road Project and the Flow of Fund
The total cost of land acquisition and resettlement for the Inner Ring Road Project is estimated to be about 3,103,864,082.02 Yuan. (See table below.) C0 0
Table of Total Fund Flow of Inner Ring Road Project
Unit: Yuan
Fund Amount June 1997 Dec 1997 June 1998 Dec.1998 June 1999 Dec 1999 June 2000 Ist Phas 457,669,452.94 234,512,303 223,157,149.94
2nd Phase 677,162,844.50 343,055,102.00 334,107,742.50
3rd Phase 1,113,465,122.30 419,211,390.00 300,000,000 394,253,732.30
4th Phase 855,566,662.28 593,503,670.00 200,000,000 62,062,992.28
Total 3,103,864,082 234,512,303 566,212,251.94 753,3 19,132.50 300,000,000 987,757,402.30 200,000,000 62,062,992.28 0 0~~~~ Table 111.2.11:Resettlement Housing DemandEstimate and Expenseof [RRfor PhasesI and 11of GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Project
Increment% Demandfor, ~Unit Price iSum of' oLessthan Ade ttcRsettlement PhaeScton rigna Aral re increasUtiliz.Ratio IndivisableAffiliated Overseas 5m2/Person Examined& Gran-d- Housing (Yluan/m2) Funds(Yuan) (m2) 1transferring t New/OldHos'gChinese ______Approved by Total (m2)_
Northof Don 13,611.42 20 15 20 10 __ 0 lb 10 ____90 25,861.70I
ISouth of Don 148.7 -2 15 20--10 5 20 10 100 28,773.74 T Total 27,99?8-.29'/ /i I - - II/5654 ,0 7,3,0 Households Huangsha -20,670.171 15 10 20 10 ___01 - 5 3,7.0II
1I XichangInte 8,729.11 110 2- 10 _ 515 0 ___ - 15,275.94F
- GuangyuanI 17,793.601 15 10 20 -10 5 - 20 0 80 32,028.48I
Total 47,192.88 II - I ___F/F
Total 75,191.17 I III -II____ I ___ 138,112.66 3,200 441,960,512
North of Don 4,661.69/ 20 25/ I -I______45 6,759.45I____ shop-sqow ne-r- I --- Sout-h-of D o-n 29-8.06 3 20 - -25/ -- I __ 45 432.14/ ship) entirely - To-tal 4,959.72I ./ /______7,19-1.5-9 -5 35_,95_7,950 _de-m_oli-shed Huangsha 2,034.1 -1 25VI--- - I- ---- __-_--40 ,4.8 andtere- 11 Xi chfianginte 1 847 .09__ /--/ ___ 4 255.3I ___ located to -Guangyuani1 1,316.79/ 15 25 I/ __/ _ 40 1,843.51 other sites- - Total . 5,198.06/ .I I F. 7,277.29 5,000 36,386,450 Total 1017.78 _ fj I II__ 14,468.88 5,000 72,344,400 __
Northof Don 3,441.14I25 / I-- --- _25 4,301.43// shops(owner- I Southof Don 1324.29 25 /I 25 1,655.36 I ship)entirely Total 4,765.43/ -//i _ 5,956.79 1,800 10,722,222 demolished Huanga 2.54 I 5 I /I/25 18/18 andio be-re- 11 kicfianglinte 5,7113.73 25/ I -/ 25 7,142.116/------located.on the GuangyuanlI 1,468.88/ 25 / / _ - I25 1,836.10/ - peripheryland Total 7,421.15/I -I/ /__ - - __ 9,644180 66132 Total 12,186.58 iI//I- I 15,224.23 1J,80027,403,614__
; Northof Don! 172.08/ 251/ / -- 25 2151/6- /. Shops I Southof Don! 74.66/ 25/1 25 93.33/ partially Total 246.74 / 1JI I/ ~ /2 308.43 1,800 555,174 demolished ~ Huangsha 4,020.631I 251/ / . 257 5,025.76/ and to be re- II Xichiang Inte! 752.96!/ 25!// , 2 4./- locatedon the! [Guangyuanl'; 314.37/ 25j 25. 392-.96 peripheryland! ITotal 5,087.94/ ,I! . -6,3-5-9-.92 1 ,80 11,447,316 Total 5,334.68;II/I II . 6,668.35 1,800 12,003,030
Northof Don: 919.43, . //- 919.43/ I iSouth of bon' i68.55;/ .1 -- -88.55/ i The owner- iTotal 1,I07.98I/II' 1,107.98- 5,00 559o0
Ship reliin- Huangsha 699.261/ // ___ 6999.26T GuangyuanI 344.45 /-/// ___ 344.45/- -/
Total 1,967.46//j _ Total ,7.4-IF __ 1 1,6.6 5,37,000 ,3,0 PaaeIlof 2 Increment % Demand for Unit Price Sum of Housing of Less than Added Attic .Resettlement Phase Section Original AreaArea increas Utiliz.Ratio Indivisable AffiliatedmOverseasP -5m2iPerson Examined8& Grand Housing uan7m2) Funds(Yuan) (m2) transferring t .New/OldHousing I IChinese Approvedby Total (m2) INorthof Don, 1,856.29 / 2541 I/ 25 2,320.36 Public I I South ofDon. 1,212.00j 25/ I .._ 25 1,515i I and culturai ITotal 3,068.291/ / /j i ij _ _.__ _ _ 3,835.36 1,80 6,903,648 facilities Huangsha 025 Ii I . - ___ 0 / to be restorate 11 Xichang Inte 700/ 25 / / -- 25.______2 875 I _ on the Guangyuan I Ol/ 25 i i . ___ _2 _o __ _ original land Total i00/ i . . . - / 875 1,800 1,575.00
Total 3,768.291j I I . I -_ _ I _ 1 4710.36 1,800 8,478,648 GrandT'otal of the First Phase . / . 23 0.2 Grand Total of the Second Phase / - - i |* i / _./ ___ 234,512,302 ______Grand Total of Allt . i | i i ------343,055,102 Grand___Totai __of_Ali__j _/_I_____/ I, ______._____- 577,567,404 ______0 0~~~~
Tablel11.2.2:Resettlement Expense of PhaselIofthe iRRofGua'ngzhoucity Centeir Tr'an"sp-ortProject ProjectName Items DemolitionAmount UnitPrc- f iofiiet Cmesto
iCompensation Expense Expense(Yuan) ______lEntirely Compensationfor Closureof Productio10,805.72m2 I ___ 34,078,644.00 Demolished Paymentfor Auxiliary Facilities I ,8- 05 .7- 2m 2 -50VYiiuan/m 2 1 540,286.00 IShop withOwnership Lossof Businessin Other Place 4,959.72m2 - ~200Yuan/m2*mon 1 5,951,644.00 MovingFee 10,805.72mn2 15 Yuan/m2 1 162,085.80
Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 161Houses 1,000Yuan/House 1 161,000.00 __
Sub-Total I -40,893,679.80 __
Sho-ps ~ Partially Compensationfor Closureof Productio274.1 6m2 -I-- 0 __15400 Dem- olished Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 274.16mn2 50OYuan/m2 1 13,708.00 Shopwith Ownership Lo-ssoof Busitnes'sin OtherPlace 274.16m2 - ______0_ _ MovingFee 274.16m2 … 15Yuan/m2 __1 4,112.40
Total __ 173,220.40 __ Temporary Compensationfor Closureof Productio5,766.1 m2 I ___1 2,344,909.00 Stru-c-tures - MovingFee 5,766.1m2 15 Yuanlm2 1 86,491.50 - -. - ~~~~~~Paymentfor Telephone Transfer 127Houses -1,000 Yuan/House 1 127,000.00___ Sub-Total 1 I-- 2,558,400.50_
MovingFee 684 Ho-uses 600 Yuani/Hiouse--- Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 342 Houses 1,000 Yuan/House 1 342,000.00 Residential Paymentfor CableTV 61 Hous-es 3:50Yuan/House 1 215,600.00 Housin-g Rewardfor MovingAhead of Time i684 Houses un/os 10 547,200.00 Sub-t-otal /155200
Public Compensationfor Closureof Productio13,068.29m2 200 Yiu,anfrm2*n_o_n 1- 7-,35_3,_8 96. 00 - andCultural Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 13,068,29m2 100 Yuan/m2 1 306,829.00 Facilities Pay'ment for TelephoneTransfer 114Houses 1,000Yuan/m2 2 8,000.00 MovingFee 3,068,29m2 115Yuan/A - 6,024.35i ~Sub-Total I - 7,2-4,7490.3-5
HousingOwned Compensationfor Closureof Productio9,001.12m2 1100Yuan/m2*monl 1 900,112.00 by MovingFee 9,001.12m2 15 Yuanlm2 1 ~ 068 Institutions Paym'entfor TelephoneTransfer 28 Houses 1,000Yuan/House . 28,000.00 ,Payment for AuxiliaryFacilities 9,001.12m2 50 Yuan/rn2 1 450,056.00
~Sub-Total .1,513,184.80
I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~------
Page 1 of 2 0 0 o
Project Name Items Demolition Amount Unit Price of LCoefficient Compensation .CompensationE-xpense Ei_xpense(Yuan) Payment for Pipes & lines / I 1 112,997,721.00
Payment for Payment for Traffic Facilities 3.8 km 300 thousand Yua - 1 _ 1,140,000.00 Facilities Payment for Civil Air Defence Facilities / / 1 7,800,000.00 Trees of Roadside and Lawns 1800Trees 400 Yuan/Tree I- 320,000.00 ______Sub-Totai 122,257,721.00
Payment for Relocation management 65,351.69m2 5 Yuanm2 1 326,758.45 Other Related Payment for Reiocation Niotarization 1,007 Houses 100 Yuan/House 1 100,700.00 Payments Payment for Relocation/Acquisition Re 1,007 Houses 170 Yuan/fHouse 30% 51,357.00 ______Payment for SanitationiPublic Security 1,007 Houses 54 Yuan/House 1 54,378.00 Payment for Litigation/Arbitration 1,007 Houses 1,500_Yuan/House 15% 226,575.00 Sub-Total 759,768.45
Payment for Payment for Residential Housing Reloc 684 Houses 600Yuan/House 1 _. 410,400.00 Employment Payment for Relocation Non-Residenti 323 Houses 2,000 Yuan/House 1 646,000.00 ___ __ Sub-Total 1,056,400.00 __0_
House Removal, Sludg 63,351.69m2 28 Yuan/m2 1 1,829,847.32 Rebuilding of Concrete 7,976m2 80 Yuan/m2 1 638,080.00 Sub-Total 2,467,927.32
Total 180,747,031.22
Page 2 of 2 0~~~~~
Table 11.2,3: Resettlement Expense of Phase 11of the IRR of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project
Project Name Items Demolition Amount Unit Price of pCoefficient Compensation ICompensatio n Expense iExpense(Yuan)- _-_----_- .- _ Entirely ICompensation for Closure of Productio 14,021.34m2 _1 46,180,284.00 Demolished ;Payment for Auxiiiary Facilities 14,021.34rm2 50 Yuan/m2 _. 1 701,067.00 jShops withOwnership Loss of Business in Other Place 5,198.06m2 200 Yuan/m2*mon 1 6,237,672.00 |Moving Fee 1i,02i.34mauam2 15_ua/m_ 1 210,320.10 Payment for Telephone Transfer 179 Houses __ 1,000 Yuan/House 17______179,000 00 Sub-Total / . 1 53,508,343.10
Shops Partially Compensation for Closure of Productio 5,653.26m2 . __ __ 50% 5,242,902.00 Demolished Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 5,653.26m2 _ 5Yuan/m2 T 1 282,663.00 Shops withOwnership Loss of Business in Other Piace 5,653.26m2 _-_ ____ 1 _____ 0 . i Moving Fee 5,653.26r2 15 Yuanim2 1 - 84,798.90 Sub-Total ! / =: 5,610,363.90
Temporary Compensation for Closure of Productio 20,672.45m2 . 1 2,803,240.00 Structures Moving Fee 20,672.45m2 15 Yuan/m2 1 310,086.75 Payment for Teiephone Transfer 415 Houses 1,000 Yuan/House A 415,000.06 ~Sub-Total i - - - __ .. __ .______.____3,528,326.75 tTotal / / ._. . . _ _. . _ 0 0/_62,647,033.75
Moving Fee 1,176 Houses 600 Yuan/House 1 705,600.00 Residential Payment for Telephone Transfer ,554 Houses 1,000 Yuan/House 1 554,000.00 Housing Payment for Cable TV 926 Houses 350 Yuan/House 1 324,100.00 Reward for Moving Ahead of Time 1,176 Houses 800 Yuan/House 1 940,800.00 Sub-Total / _ 2,524,500.00
Public ,Compensation for Closure of Productio 700m2 200 Yuan/m2*month 1 1,680,000.00 and Cultural Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 700m2 100 Yuan/m2 1 70,000.00 Facilities Payment for Telephone Transfer 4 Houses 1,000 Yuan/m2 2 8,000.00 Moving Fee 700m2 115Yuan/m2 1 10,500.00 Sub-Total / I . . 1,768,500.00
Housing Owined !Compensation for Closure of Productio 6,973.63m2 1100Yuan/m2*month 1 697,363.00 by IMoving Fee 6,973.63m2 '15 Yuan/m2 1 104,604.45 Institutions Payment for Telephone Transfer 51 Houses 1,000Yuan/House 1 51,000.00 Payment for Auxiliary Facilities i6,973.63m2 '50 Yuan/m2 1 348,681.50 ISub-Total . ,201648.95
Page 1 of 2 0 0
Project Name Items Demolition Amount Unit Price of iCoefficient Compensation Compensation Expense IExpense(Yuan) Payment for Pipes & lines / I 1 169,496,581.70 Payment for Payment for Traffic Facilities 5.7 km 300 thousand Yuan/km 1 1,710,000.00 Facilities Payment for Civil Air Defence Facilities// 1 11,700,000.00 |Trees of Roadside and Lawns 1,200 Trees 400 Yuan/Tree 1 480,000.00 Sub-Total 183,386,581.70
Payment for Relocation management 95,213.56m2 5 Yuan/m2 1 476,067.80 Other Related Payment for Relocation Notarization 1,853 Houses 100 Yuan/House 1 185,300.00 Payments Payment for Relocation/Acquisition Re 1,853 Houses 170 Yuan/House 30% 94,503.00 Payment for Sanitation/Public Security 1,853 Houses 54 Yuan/House 1 100,062.00 Payment for Litigation/Arbitration 1,853 Houses 1,500 Yuan/House 15% 416,925.00 Sub-Total 1,272,857.80
Payment for Payment for Residential Housing Reloc 1,176 Houses 600 Yuan/House . 705,600.00 Employment Payment for Relocation Non-Residenti 677 Houses 2,000 Yuan/House 1 1,354,000.00 Sub-Total 2,059,600.00
Housing Removal, Stud 95,213 56m2 28 Yuan/m2 1 2,665,979.68 Rebuilding of Concrete 11,964m2 80 Yuan/m2 1 957,120.00 Sub-Total 3,623,099.68
Grand Total . 258,483,821.88
Paae 2 of 2 Table 11.3.1: ResettlementHousing DemandEstimate and Expenseof IRR for Phase IlI of Guangzhou city CenterTransport Project
Increment% Demandfar UnitPrice Smo HusnofAdded Attic Resettlement Classification Section OriginalArea Area increas'Utifiz.Ratioof indivisaDleAffilliated Overseas < 5M21 Examined Grand Housing (Yan/m2) Funds(Yuan)
______m2__transferring t!New/Old Housing Ciee Pro Apovdb Ttl (m2) ______Railwaystation Overpass (Daibi 0l 20 15 20 10 0 10 10 850/
HuanshizhongRd. 0' 20 15 20 10 _0 10 10 85 0/
Households LuhuOverpass 0 20 15 20 10 0 10 ___ 10 85 0 / HengfuRd.Overpass 17348 20 15 20 10 0 10 10 85 32093.8I MeidongO verpass(East part of, 5901 20 15 ~ 20. 10 -0 15 - -1-0 - -90 11211.9I Haiyi.nnaiOverpass i 6122 20 15 20 10 0 ------5 5 80 11019.6I ShusheOverpass 5228 20 15 20 10 5 5 5 80 9410.4 / EastSection of Nantian Rd. 18610 15 15 20 10 5 0 5 70 31637// Zhen'anOverpass 5300 20! 15 ~ 20 10 10 10 10io 95 10335/ I RenmingBridge and HongdeRI 21983 -- --20 15 20 10 5 5 5 80 39569.4// GongyeAv. 2467 20 15 20 10, 55 5 80 4440.6 // Sub-Total 82,959 i 497`17.7 3200 479,096,640
Railwaystation Overpass (DaibOI 20 25/ I// 45 0/
HuanshizhongRd. 0 / 201 25 / /I/ --- 45 - 0/ I Shops LuhuOverpass I627 / 20: 25/ /// 45 909.15/ 'HengfuRd.Overpass 10910I 20, 25/ /// 45 15819.5/ MeidongOverpass(East part oflI 2570 / 20 ~ 25 / /I/45 3726.5// HaiyinnaiOverpass 1160~/ 20 25 /// 45 1682/ ShusheOverpass 23261..201 25/ 45 3372.7/ 'Eastof Nantian Rd. 476/ 20' 25/ 45 690.2/ !Zhen'an Overpass 1835/ 201 25/ // 45 2660.75// RenmingBridge and Hongde R: 6223 /20 251/ /// 45 9023.35/ !GongyeAv. 1326/ 20 ~ 25/V 45 1922.7/ !Sub-Total 27,453// / //// 39806.85 5000 199,034,250
Page1 of 2 Increment% Demandfor UnitPrice Sum of Housingof AddedAttic Resettlement
Classification Section OriginalArea Area increasUtiliz,Ratio of Indivisable Affiliated Overseas <5m2/ Examined Grand Housing _ (Yuan/m2) Funds(Yuan)
. | (m2) transferring tjNew/Old Housing 1 Chinese Person Approved b Total (m2) Railwaystation Overpass (Daibl 0/ 1 25 / I I I 25 0 I HuanshizhongRd. I 01/ 25 .. / _ _ _ 25 _0 Institutions LuhuOverpass 0./ 25 I_ 25 0/_ andUnits HengfuRd.Overpass 89201/ 25 I I- 25 1150_/ MeidongOverpass(East part of 1207|/ 25 I I I I I 25 1508.75I I HaiyinnaiOverpass 570j/ 25/ i _ / 25 712.5_ / ShusheOverpass 20001/ 25 I I . / 25 2500/_
EastSection of NantianRd. 8231/ 25 I / I - _ / 25 1028.8_/ Zhen'anOverpass 0I/ 25/ I / / . 25 0 I RenmingBridge and Hongde R 4738 I 25 I I I 25 5922.5_ / GongyeAv. 0 i 251/ I .I I 25 _ 0 Sub-Total 18,258 / I I / / / / / 22822.5 1800 41,080,500
|Total 128,670 I/ I /I i . / __..__ 414,694 __ _ 719,211,390
Page2 of 2 Table 11.3.2: ResettlementExpense of PhaseIll of the IRR of GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Project
ProjectName Items DemolitionAmount I UnitPrice of Coefficient Compensation ______CompensationExpens Expense Fee of temporarymovement 82959M2 15lYuanI M2.Month I OE 2,488,770
Paymentfor Transfer 1806households 600 Yuan/household ___ 1 1,083,600
Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 1806households 1000Yuan/household 70V __ 1,264,200 ResidentialHousing Paymentfor CableTV 1806households 350Yuan/household 1 632.100
Rewardfor Pre-Transfer 1806households ___ BOYuan/household 50EV 722,400 Gas and pipeline 1806households 150OYuan/household I OE 270,900 Sub-Total 6,461,970 Compensationfor Closureof Production/Business 27453M2 100OYuan/M2 1 27,453,000 Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 27453M2 SOYuan/M2 1 1,372,650 Shops Lossof Businessin Other Place 27453M2 200Yuan/M2.Month 50% 16,471,800 Paymentfor Transfer 27453M2 15SYuan/M2 1 411,795
Sub-Total ____45,709,245 Compensationfor Closureof Production/Business 18258M2 100OYuan/M2 1 18,258,000 Enterprisesand Units Paymentfor Auxif,aryF acilities i8258 M2 lOOYuanJM2 1 1,825,800 Paymentfor Transfer 18258M2 15SYuan/M2 1 273,870 Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 53 Households 100OYuan/M2 1 265,000
Sub-Total / / _ 20,622,670 Paymentfor Pipelines 10384M 10000,00OYuan/KM 1 103,840,000 Infrastructures Paymentfor TrafficFacilities 10384M 200,00OYuan/KM 1 2,076,800 Paymentfor Civil Air DefenceFacilities 10384M 2000,00OYuan/KM 1 20,768,000 Treesof Roadsideand Lawns 10384M 400Yuan/tree 1 1,661,440 ISub-Total / /128,346,240 ,Payment for Relocationmanagement 1124877 M2 5Yuan/ M2 1 624,385 OtherRelated !Payment for RelocationNotarization ,2318Households l OOYuan/household 1 231,800 Compensation Paymentfor Relocation/AcquisitionReview ~ 23l8househoulds 17OYuan/household 1 394,060 Paymentfor Sanitation/PublicSecurity 23l8househoulds 54Yuan/household 1 125,172 Paymentfor Litigation/Arbitration ;2318househoulds 15OYVuan/household 15% 521,550I !Sub-Total ///1,896,967~ Paymentfor 'Paymentfor ResidentialHousing Relocated l806households 600Yuan/household 1 1,083,600 Employment !Payment for RelocationNon ResidentialHousing !512households 1500Yuan/household 1 768,000 Sub-Total I//1,851,600 HouseRemoval, Sludge Removal 124877M2 :28Yuan/M2 1 3,496,556 Rebuildingof ConcreteFloor and 124877M2 l OOYua-n/M2 10% -1,248,77-0 EnclosedWall 'Sub-Total 4745,326Al/
Total ______209,634,018
Page1 of I 0~~
Table 111.4.11:Resettlement Housing DemandEstimate and Expenseof IRR for Phase IV of GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Project
Original Incrmn eadfr Ui Price Sum of Housing_of__ AddedAttic Resettlement classification Section Area ,Area increasUtiliz. Ratio of IndivisableAffiliated Overseas <5m2/ Examined Grand Housing (Yuan/m2) Funds(Yuan)
______(m2) transferring t New/Old Housing ___ Chinese Person Approved b Total (m2)______Sectionof HengfuRd. 0 15 15 20 10 0 5 5 70 0/
Sectionof MeidongbeiRd. 3748 .20 - 5S 20 10 5 5 10 85 6933.8I Residential Middleand West Sectionof Na 40000 15 151 20 10 5 0 5 70 68000I/ housing Liu'er'sanRd. Huangsha Av. 46724 20 15 20 10 10 10 10 95 91111.8/ Sub-Total 90472II// / /I 166,046 3200 531,345,920
Sectionof HengfuRd. 0/ 201 25/ 45 0/
Sectionof MeidongbeiRd. 70 / 20 25 I _45 101.5/I Shops IMiddleand West Sectionof Na 2000 /20 25 I //I45 2900I iuer'sanRd. Huangsha Av. 5271 I20 25 I /II45 7642.95I_
iSub-Total 7341/ /I- .- - _- - 10,644 5000 53,222,250
Sectionof HengfuRd. 9 25;/ / I/ 25 0/ Sectionof MeidongbeiRd. 0/ 25/ /I/ 25 0/ Institutionsand Middleand West Section of Na 1000I 25L I/ 5 15 Units ~ Liu'er'sanRd. Huangsha Av. 100,/ 25 // /// 25 2250// Sub-Total 28001/ I 3500 1800 6,300,000
Total / // - I/ _____ 180,190 _____ 590,868,1701
/ ______A_ 0 (3 0 -w--f Table 11.4.2: Resettlement Expense of Phase IV of the IRR of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project
Project Name Items Demolition Amount Unit Price of Coefficient Compensation Compensation Expens Expense )Fee of temporary movement 90472 M2 15Yuan/ M2.Month 10£M 27,141,600 Residential housing Payment for Transfer 1809 household 600 Yuan/household 1 1,085,400 ,Payment for Telephone Transfer 1809 household 1000 Yuan/household 70£Y 1,266,300 Payment for Cable TV 1809 household 350 Yuan/household 1 633,150 Reward for Pre-Transfer 1809 household 800Yuan/household 50£) 723,600 Gas and pipeline 1809 household 1500Yuan/household 1OE ___ __ 2,713,500 Sub-Total / . / 33,563,550 Compensation for Closure of Production/Business 7341 M2 1OOOYuan/ M2 _ 1 __ 7,341,000 Shops Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 7341 M2 5OYuan/ M2 1 367,050 Loss of Business in Other Place 7341 M2 200Yuan/ M2.Month ____50% 5 4,404,600 Payment for Transfer 7341 M2 15Yuan/ M2 1 110,115 Sub-Total / . / / __ 12,222,765 Compensation for Closure of Production/Business 12800M2 lOOOYuan/M2 1 ______2,800,000 Enterprises and Units Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 2800 M2 1OOYuan/ M2 1 280,000 Payment for Transfer |2800 M2 15Yuan/ M2 1 42,000 Payment for Telephone Transfer 8household IOOOYuan/ M2 1 40,000 Sub-Total !/ / _ 3,162,000 Payment for Pipelines 5205 M 1OOOOOOOYuan/ KM 1 52,050,000 Infrastructures Payment for Traffic Facilities 5205 M 200,00OYuan/ KM 1 1,041,000 Payment for Civil Air Defence Facilities 5205 M 2000,000/Yuan KM 1 1,041,000 Trees of Roadside and Lawns 5205 M 400Yuan/tree 1 832,800 Sub-Total / / / 54,964,800 Payment for Relocation management 100613 M2 15Yuan/ M2 1 503,065 Other Related !Payment for Relocation Notarization 1940household ,1OOYuan/household 1 194,000 Compensation Payment for Relocation/Acquisition Review 1940household 17OYuan/household I 1 329,800 :Payment for Sanitation/Public Security 1940household 54Yuan/household I 1 104,760 Payment for Litigation/Arbitration 1940household 150OYuan/household 15% 436,500 Sub-Total 1,568,125 Payment for Payment for Residential Housing Relocated 1809household 60OYuan/household 1 1,085,400 Employment Payment for Relocation Non Residential Housing 131household 150OYuan/household 1 196,500 Sub-Total / / '/ 1,281,900 House Removal, Sludge Removal 100613M2 -28Yuan/ M2 1 2,817,164 Rebuilding of Concrete Floor and Enclosed Wall 100613M2 IOOYuan/M2 10% 1,006,130
,Sub-Total 1 _3,823,294 Total __.______.____ 110,586,434 Q Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Inner Ring Road Project
Resettlement Implementation Plan
Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office February 1998 IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan Final Report
Q TABLEOF CONTENTS Table of Contents List of Appendices List of Tables Acronyms,Abbreviation and Units
1. Preface 1.1 Backgroundof GuangzhouCity Center TransportProjects 1.2 Necessityof the Constructionof Inner Ring Road 1.3 Impactsof the Constructionof Inner Ring Road 1.4 ResettlementPolicy and ResettlementAction Plan of IRR 1.5 Explanationfor ResettlementAction Plan for the 'IRR 1.6 Institutions Involved, Their Responsibilities and Methods Used in the Preparation of the RAP 1.7 Objectives and Principles of Resettlement 1.8 Classification of Project Impacts 1.9 Resettlement Policy
2. Resettlement Plan & Rehabilitation Measures for Affected Households 3 2.1 Affected Household 2.1.1 Introduction of the Affected Households 2.1.2 Situations of the Dwelling Houses 2.1.3 Economic Situations of the Households 2.1.4 Population Structure and Household Classification 2.1.5 Commuting Situations of the Dwellers 2.1.6 Vulnerable Groups 2.1.7 Analysis of Benefit and Loss 2.1.8 Conclusion 2.2 Description of Residential Resettlement Sites 2.2.1 Xiaogangwan Quarter 2.2.2 Guocun Quarter 2.2.3 Tongde Quarter 2.2.4 Baiyun Guarden 2.2.5 Dongpu Quarter 2.2.6 Nan'an Road Building 2.2.7 Haijing Garden (Yuan'an Street Quarter) 2.2.8 Decoration of the Above Housing and Administration of the Quarters 2.3 Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures 2.3.1 General Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures 2.3.2 Supplement to the General Resettlement Standards and the Rehabilitation Measure 2.3.3 Special Rehabilitation Measures for the Vulnerable Groups IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan ii Final Report
2.3.4 Resettlement of the Affected Persons without Residential Registration 2.3.5 Certificates 2.3.5Other Rehabilitation Measures 2.4 Resettlement Implementation Plan 2.4.1 Principles and Standards of Setting up Resettlement Sites and Allocation of Housing Areas 2.4.2 Principles and Standards of Resettlement Sites and Allocation of Housing Areas of the Vulnerable Groups 2.4.3 Resettlement Timetable
3. Resettlement Plan and Rehabilitation Measures for the Affected Shops 26 3.1 The Affected Shops 3.1.1 Introduction 3.1.2 Status of the Shops' Ownership 3.1.3 Distribution of the Shops 3.1.4 Situation of the Property Rights and the Structure of the Housing to be Demolished 3.1.5 Category Composition of the Trades of the Shops 3.1.6 Region Distribution of the Working Staff's Families of the Shops 3.2 Description of Commercial Resettlement Sites -- 3.2.1 Periphery Land Feasible for Multi-purpose Commercial Building and Available Area 3.2.2 Shops in the Resettlement Sites 3.2.3 Periphery Land Feasible for Temporary Shops But not for Multi-purpose Commercial Buildings 3.2.4 Distribution and Amount Chart of Multi-purpose Commercial Buildings 3.3 Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures for the Shops 3.3.1 Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures for the Entireiv Demolished Shops with Property Rights 3.3.2 Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures for the Partialkx Demolished Shops with Property Rights 3.3.3 Compensation Standards and Rehabilitation Measures for the Temporary Shops
4. Affected Institution and Resettlement Standard and Rehabilitation Measure 39 4.1 Status of the Impacts 4.2 Rehabilitation Measures and Principles 4.3 Compensation Standards
5. Affected Public and Cultural Facilities 41 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Details of the Impacts 5.3 Rehabilitation Measures 5.4 Compensation Standards IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan iii Final Report
6. Land Acquisition and Compensation Rate and Job Creation 43 0! 6.1 Introductionto the AcquiredLand 6.2 Compensation Rate of Land Acquisition 6.3 Job Creation
7. Affected Infrastructure and Compensation Rate and Rehabilitation Measure 45 7.1 Affected Infrastructure 7.2 Compensation Rates for the Affected Infrastructure 7.3 Rehabilitation Measures for the Affected Infrastructure
8. Cost and Budget 49 8.1 Explanation for Cost and Budget of Land Acquisition and Resettlement For IRR 8.2 Estimates of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for the IRR
9. Institutions and Agencies of Land Acquisition, Demolition and Resettlement 52 9.1 Management of Land Acquisition, Demolition and Resettlement and Related Institutions 9.2 Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office
10. Participation and Consultation 54 10.1 Participation and Consultation Activities Were in Progress 10.2 Effects Produced by Participation and Consultation Activities 10.3 Next Step Plan for Participation and Consultation Activities
11. Monitoring and Evaluation 57 11.1 Internal Monitoring 11.2 Independent Monitoring
LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix I: Census Questionnaire for PAPs affected by Land Requisition or Housing Demolition of IRR Appendix II: Sample Survey Questionnaire of the Baseline SLS Conducted by the IMO Appendix III: Sample Survey Questionnaire for Affected Shops of IRR Appendix IV: Sample Survey Questionnaire for the Affected Enterprises by Land Acquisition or Housing Demolition of IRR IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan iv Final Report
O>.LIST OF TABLES Table 2.1 .2.1A Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP Table 2.1.2.1B Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP Table 2.1.2.1C Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP Table 2.1.2.3A Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1.2.3B Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1.2.3C Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1 .2.4A Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Houses with More Than 5m2/person Living Space along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases 1, II of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1 .2.4B Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Houses with More Than 5m2/person Living Space along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1.2.4C Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Houses with More Than 5m2/person Living Space along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1.2.5A Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Houses with Less Than 5m2 /person Living Space along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and 11 of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1.2.5B Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Houses with Less Than 5m2/person Living Space along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1.2.5C Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Houses with Less Than 5m2 /person Living Space along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Table 2.1.3.1A Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Life Necessities Table 2.1.3.1 B Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignmenit of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Life Necessities Table 2.1.3.1 C Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Life Necessities Table 2.1.4. IA Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Population Structure Table 2.1.4.1 B Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Population Structure Table 2.1.4. IC Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Population Structure Table 2.1 .5A Resident Commuting along the Alignments of the IRR for Phases I and 11of GCCTP Table 2.1 .5B Resident Commuting along the Alignments of the IRR for Phase III of C GCCTP IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan v Final Report
Table 2.1.5C Resident Commuting along the Alignments of the IRR for Phase IV of t f ~~~~GCCTP Table 2.4.3A Land Acquisition and Resettlement Implementation Plan of the IRR for Phase I Table 2.4.3B Land Acquisition and Resettlement Implementation Plan of the IRR for Phase II Table 2.4.3C Land Acquisition and Resettlement Implementation Plan of the IRR for Phase III Table 2.4.3D Land Acquisition and Resettlement Implementation Plan of the IRR for Phase IV Table 3.1.2.1 A Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1.2. IB Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1.2. IC Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1.2.2A Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1.2.2B Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1 .2.2C Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1.2.3 Shop Classification and Distribution of the Partially Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and 11of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1 .2.4A Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the [RR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1 .2.4B Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignmenitof the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1.2.4C Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Ownership Table 3.1.5.1 A Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and 11of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1.5.1B Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1.5. IC Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1.5.2A Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and 11of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1.5.2B Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1.5.2C Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Main Trade IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan vi Final Report
Table 3.1.5.3 Classification and Distribution of the Partially Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1.5.4A Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1.5.4B Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1.5.4C Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Main Trade Table 3.1 .6A Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Ships with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP According to Owner's Address Table 3.1.6B Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Ships with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Owner's Address Table 3.1.6C Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Ships with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Owner's Address Table 8.2.1 Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expense of IRR for Phases I and II of GCCTP Table 8.2.2 Compensation for the Affected Institutions and Temporary Shops of IRR for Phase I and II of GCCTP Table 8.2.3 Resettlement Expense of Phase I of the IRR of GCCTP Table 8.3.3 Resettlement Expense of Phase II of the IRR of GCCTP Table 8.4.1 Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expense of IRR for Phase III of GCCTP Table 8.4.2 Resettlement Expense of Phase III of the IRR of GCCTP Table 8.5.1 Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expense of IRR for Phiase IV of GCCTP Table 8.5.2 Resettlement Expense of Phase IV of the IRR of GCCTP IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan vii Final Report
O ILIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2.1.2.1 Residential Demolished Region Figure of the IRR Project and Shops Demolished Region Figure of Inner Ring Rd. Project Figure 2.2.1.1 Distribution Figure of Resident Resettlement Sites of the IRR Figure 2.2.1.2 Xiaogangwan Detailed Location Figure Figure 2.2.1.3 Xiaogangwan Overall Layout Figure Figure 2.2.1.4 Xiaogangwan Room Specification Figure Figure 2.2.2.2 Guocun Quarter Detailed Location Figure Figure 2.2.2.3 Guocun Quarter Overall Layout Figure Figure 2.2.2.4 Guocun Quarter Room Specification Figure Figure 2.2.3.2 Tongde Quarter Detailed Location Figure Figure 2.2.3.3 Tongde Quarter Overall Layout Figure Figure 2.2.3.4 Tongde Quarter Room Specification Figure Figure 2.2.4.2 Baiyun Garden Detailed Location Figure Figure 2.2.4.3 Baiyun Garden Overall Layout Figure Figure 2.2.4.4 Baiyun Garden Room Specification Figure Figure 2.2.5.2 Dongpu Quarter Detailed Location Figure Figure 2.2.6.2 Nan'an Road Building Detailed Location Figure Figure 2.2.6.3 Nan'an Rd. Building Room Specification Figure Figure 2.2.7.1 Haicheng Guarden Detailed Location Figure Figure 2.2.7.2 Haicheng Garden Overall Layout Figure Figure 2.4 Relationship Figure of Demolished Residential Regions and Residential Resettlement Sites of Inner Ring Rd. Project Figure 3.2 Distribution Figure of Shops Relocation Sites and Relationship Figure of Shops Demolished Regions and Shops Relocation Sites
ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS
GAG Grievance Acceptance Group GCCTPO Project Office of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project GMG Guangzhou Municipal Government GREEO Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office IMO Independent Monitoring Organization IRR Inner Ring Road PAPs Project Affected Persons Phase 1 II, 111,IV The First, Second, Third, Fourth Phase of Project RAP Resettlement Action Plan Rd. Road Str. Street
UNITS
mn meter rn2 square meter km kilometer RMB Renminbi (Yuan) (approx. 8.7 RMB/USD) 0 1. PREFACE
1.1 Background of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects
In order to make a thorough improvement of the transport status of Guangzhou city center, Guangzhou Municipal Goverment started a research project of Guangzhou Urban Transport Study in March, 1993. On this basis, research on the subject of Guangzhou Central Area Traffic Improvement Scheme Implementation was started in December, 1994. In July, 1995, the scheme passed the appraisal of domestic specialists. Specialists agreed that the scheme would improve the transport of Guangzhou city center effectively. Therefore, Guangzhou Municipal Goverment decided to carry out Guangzhou Central Area Traffic Improvement Scheme Implementation utilizing loans from the World Bank.
1.2 Necessity of the Construction of Inner Ring Road
Inner Ring Road project plays an important role in Guangzhou Central Area Traffic Improvement Scheme Implementation. Inner Ring Road is a ring road constructed in the city center. According to the principles of Functional Road Hierarchy, system channelization, it is constructed as a shield of city center transport to alleviate the pressure on city center transport, and redistribute city center transport. Inner Ring Road is necessary to improve city center transport and to meet the demand of the rapid growth of Guangzhou economy.
1.3 Impacts of the Construction of Inner Ring Road
There are a lot of factors restricting the construction of the Inner Ring Road in city center. Although some measures have been adopted, such as utilizing existing or planned alignment in the course of the design as far as possible, constructing elevated roads over main roads around the city center and connecting with the roads outside center to improve traffic capacities. The different extent of impact still exists along the Inner Ring Road (especially in the section of elevated roads). Certain degree of impact on the original economic, cultural and social structure are unavoidable, in the course of demolishing some houses and infrastructure, removing some persons from the place of study and work to a different one.
1.4 Resettlement Policy and Resettlement Action Plan of Inner Ring Road Project
In order to reduce the adverse effect of the project, we hope to ensure that the living standards of the affected persons will not be affected, and the affected persons will benefit from the project or their living standards will at least be restored to their original levels. According to resettlement laws of P.R.C., Guangdong, Guangzhou and the Operational Directive 4.30 for Involuntary Resettlement of the World Bank, we have worked out Resettlement Policyfor the Inner Ring Road Project. To ensure the implementation of the Resettlement Policy, we will make census of the affected persons before the implementation of different phases of the Inner Ring Road Project according to the progress of the project. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 2 Final Report
1.5 Explanation for Resettlement Action Plan for the Inner Ring Road Project
This Resettlement Action Plan has been worked out on the basis of the Resettlement Policy. The resettlement objectives, resettlement principles, resettlement policies, resettlement implementation organizations and the principles of grievance and appeal, participation and consultation, monitoring and evaluation are involved in this Resettlement Action Plan.
1.6 Institutions Involved and Their Responsibilities and Methods used in the Preparation of the RAP
I. Census Unit and Independent Monitoring Organization
a. The Research Center for Market Economy & Population Development of Zhongshan University conducted the census for the affected persons of the Inner Ring Road. b. The Guangzhou Academy of Social Sciences as the independent monitoring organization of the resettlement work of the Inner Ring Road.
2. Institutions Involved in the preparation of Resettlement Action Plan
a. Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Office b. Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office c. Research Center for Market Economy and Population Development of Zhongshan university--census unit d. Guangzhou Academy of Social Sciences--independent monitoring organizatioln e. Affected Neighborhood Committees and streets, Township Government and Rural Production Teams
3. Responsibilities of institutions involved (see Resettlement Policy para 2.5.2).
4. Preparation methods (see Resettlement Policy para 2.5.3).
1.7 Objectives and Principles of Resettlement
See Resettlement Policy para 3.
1.8 Resettlement Policy
See Resettlement Policy para 5.
1.9 Resettlement Implementation Plan
The following pages contain information from census and socio-economic data for Phases l, ll, III, and IV. Detailed description of the implementation process is provided for Phases I and 11. The same detailed process will be followed for Phases III and IV. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 3 Final Report
2. RESETTLEMENT PLAN AND REHABILITATION MEASURES FOR 0 AFFECTEDHOUSEHOLDS
2.1 Affected Households
2.1.1 Introduction of the Affected Households
Within the range of the first and second phase of the Inner Ring Road Project, the area of 74,841.17m2 dwelling houses need to be dismantled, and 1,752 households with 6,236 persons. This number doesn't include the buildings and persons mentioned in 2.1.1.2 and 2.1.1.3. Because some have been resettled by private developers and others do not stay long in their work. The units will be compensated for housing.
2.1.1.2 Independently Living Persons without residential registration certificates
Persons independently living without residential registration certificate who don't live with the normal residents, mainly are two categories:
I . Labors from other provinces and employed by some enterprises, whose dorms also are arranged by the enterprises.
The two enterprises which arrange the dorms for the labors coming from other province were found in the census: Yangcheng Railway General Company and the Environmental Sanitation Bureau in Dongshan district.
a) There are 5 two-floor warehouses temporarily built and owned by Yangchelig Railway General Company in the old platform of the original railway station which locates at Donghua'nan Rd., which now have been reformed as dorms. The floor area covers 9,123m 2, in which are 130 labors coming from other provinces. The company has agreed with the Municipal Government 3 or 4 years ago that they will resettle people iiving in the area in exchange for building two 30 storied buildings. In addition, there are the 107 households with 378 persons waiting for resettlement in buildings currently being built by the company.
b) There is a dorm owned by the Environmental Sanitation Bureau in Dongshan district in No.35 of Nan'anxiang on Donghuadong Rd.. The floor area covers 350 m2 , in which are 82 labors coming from other provinces.
2. Labors coming from other provinces who rent living rooms at market rent (highlprice) in Guangzhou City.
It is not found that the labors coming from other provinces rent rooms for living at market rent (high price) in Phase I and II of the Inner Ring Road Project. This part of buildings and persons will not be discussed in this chapter, their resettlement and compensation will be clearly described in the section of 2.3.4. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 4 Final Report
O 2.1.1.3 Landsdeveloped by developers
There are 3 blocks near the common boundary of the highway of Guangzhou to Jiulong and Donghuadong Rd. developed by Dongshan Urban Construction & Develop Corporation, with 51 households within the scope of the property line of the Inner Ring Road. The floor area is 3923.869m2. The PAPs have been resettled properly in accordance with the related regulations and laws of China and will not be discussed later.
2.1.2 Situations of the Dwelling Houses
2.1.2.1 Distribution of dwelling houses
1. In accordance with the density of the residential zones, it will be divided into five zones within the scope of the first and second phase of the Inner Ring Road Project: zone to the north of Donghuadong Rd. and zone to the south of Donghuadong Rd.. belong to the first phase; Huangsha zone, Xichang Interchange zone, GuangYuan Interchange zone, belong to the second phase. The scope of each zone is about 2 km. The purpose of dividing zones is to establish the resettlement quarters so that the affected persons can be easily resettled in the nearby area.
(Note: the area below refers to the floor area of dwelling houses. The number of households refers to the family number of dwellers.)
Situations of each zone are described in the below table:
Zone Area (m2 ) Household Number Persons North of Donghuadong Rd. 13,611.42 277 1,067 (Phase I) South of Donghuadong Rd. 14,036.87 299 1,189 (Phase 1) Huangsha 20,670.17 522 1,832 (Phase 11) Xichang Interchange 8,729.11 185 596 (Phase II) GuangYuan Interchange 17,793.6 469 1.552 (Phase 11) -_
The detailed distribution situations are shown in Table 2.1.2.1. Information for all four phases are shown below.
Road Floor Space Number of Length of Phase Resettlement Construction Acquisition People Inner Ring (date) (start date) (m2 ) Affected Road (m) Initial 05/96-07/97 10/96 49,610 4,669 2,100 1 10/97-03/98 12/97 66,037 4,025 3,800 II 01-06/98 06/98 95,213 6,138 5,200 HII 10/98-04/99 04/99 128,670 9,912 10,384 IV 09/99-01/00 01/00 100,613 7,345 5,205 Total 440,143 32,089 26,689 Shin"iStation J // / // FIGUR 2.1.2.1 RsidentialDemolishied Region Figure of the IRR Project (Phase I, II) D0o"n and Shp eoistdRgo Figure of Inner Ring Rid. Project(P"hase
JA(
Oa'YtAirporl f I i )I-* )~~~~' Jacha~~~~~~ngRoad(~~h
Xicltang~Iitcciti ~~ ~~7 I, 'a
,GLiangzh i-a.* r
PearIR~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Inh ptsCrr shan~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ahd
xichllpititcli -li net,oitlI)tl )td)4!Ri -PAL'6 Chu'liangxin~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~RIERI -~~~~~~~ r ~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~t D~~~~~~~~~
Paz au~~~~~~~~ Das IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 5 Final Report
Q DistributionChart of the Floor area of Dwellinghouses
80000 70000 74,841 60000_ 50000 A-HuangshaRegion ______/B-Xichang_ Interchange 40000 - C-GuangyuanInterchange 30000n D-NorthofDonghuadong 20,670 17,793 Rd. 20000 7 E-SouthofDonghuadong -Rd. u F-GrandTotal
Areaof Residential Housing
2. Analysis a) This distribution situations of dwelling houses determine the selection of the resettlement sites, so we have to select the quarters within the scope of Fangcunl.Tongdew ei. Huangshi Road and Xiaogangwan, etc. b) Some quarters are selected for the east line(phase 1). They locate at the nearby of New Guangcong Highway and Xiaogangwan Quarters, which have convellienittransport and be well equipped with the facilities. Fangcun zone and Tongdewei zone are selected as resettlement sites for the west line (phase 11)so that the affected persons can be relocated nearby. The specific situations of these resettlement sites are given in the section of 2.2.
3. Notes: There may be the persons without residential registration certificate living in the normal families. Because the dwellers understand the national policies of resettlement, they don't report these persons as PAPs. So the persons without residential registration certificate are temporarily living with the local persons as their guests.
4. The detailed distribution situations of households are given in Table 2.1.2.1. Table 2.1.2.IA: Dwelling House Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and 11
Govern- Housing Owned by Housing Reform Section Data ment Private Housing Overseas Chinese Owned Housing Others Grand Housing by Units Total Content Rent Self- Rent Self- Rent Rent Self- Self- Rent Living Living Living Living North of Housing Number 72 52 5 3 0 114 29 2 0 277 Donghuadong Person Number 256 241 29 12 0 404 118 7 0 1067 Floor Area(m2) 2358.88 4707.44 169.50 146.75 0.00 4757.85 1273.67 197.34 0.00 13611.42 South of Housing Number 139 60 27 II 15 39 2 4 2 299 Donghuadong Person Number 522 274 104 46 58 157 8 12 8 1189 Floor Area(m2) 4504.43 4254.19 967.22 1124.38 652.04 1904.06 119.32 487.85 32.38 14036.87 Huangsha Housing Number 168 56 9 2 0 255 20 6 6 522 Region Person Number 585 276 30 4 0 806 94 27 10 1832 Floor Area(m2 ) 458.35 4236.11 693.14 145.04 0.00 9690.27 885.16 224.49 197.61 20670.17 Xichang Housing Number 10 4 2 0 2 162 5 0 0 185 Interchange Person Number 35 28 8 0 6 502 17 0 0 596 Region Floor Area(m') 404.42 264.11 96.64 0.00 75.22 751.73 369.99 0.00 0.00 8729.11 Guangyuan Housing Number 21 0 2 1 2 412 31 0 0 469 Interchange Person Number 59 0 13 5 9 1326 140 0 0 1552 Region Floor Area(m2) 670.93 0.00 161.28 34.89 100.06 15411.73 1414.72 0.00 0.00 17793.60 Housing Number 410 172 45 17 19 982 87 12 8 1752 Grand Person Number 1457 819 184 67 73 3195 377 46 18 6236 Total Number Floor Area(ml) 12537.01 13452.85 2087.78 1451.06 827.32 39282.63 4062.86 909.68 229.99 74841.17 0 0 o Table 2.1.2.1 B: Dwelling Housing Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase Ill of GCCTP According to Ownership
Section Content Govt-- HousingOwned by Housing Retormed Section Conent Housina PrivateHousing vesa;Cns Owe by Hus1lnfl OthersToa Total Rent Self-living Rent Self-living Rent Rent Self-living Self-living Rent RailwayStation HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Overpass(Dabei Ramp) Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HuanshizhongRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (M 2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 LuhuOverpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 155 62 90 0 0 62 65 0 0 434 Population 535 225 307 0 0 225 228 0 0 1519 2 FloorArea (m) 5207 2599 1738 0 0 4334 3470 0 0 17348 MeidongOverpass HouseholdNumber 77 0 0 0 0 41 29 0 0 147 Population 260 0 0 0 0 151 103 0 0 514 FloorArea (m2) 2658 0 0 0 0 1472 1770 0 0 5901 HaiyinnanOverpass HouseholdNumber 41 12 11 0 0 28 0 61 0 153 Population 137 51 30 0 0 104 0 214 0 536 2 FloorArea (m) 1227 915 615 0 0 1221 0 2143 0 6122 Zhen'anOverpass HouseholdNumber 24 24 19 0 18 5 16 0 0 106 Population 77 90 59 0 71 19 56 0 0 371 2 FloorArea (m) 1063 1322 798 0 1057 265 795 0 0 5300 RenminBridge Expansion HouseholdNumber 91 63 47 69 41 41 88 0 0 440 & HongdeRd. Population 311 228 157 234 151 151 308 0 0 1539 2 FloorArea (m) 4400 3294 2201 3300 2195 2195 4397 0 0 21983 IndustryAvenue HouseholdNumber 10 9 0 5 2 15 7 0 0 49 Population 29 40 0 12 14 46 31 0 0 172 2 FloorArea (m) 373 614 0 126 244 620 490 0 0 2467 ShusheOverpass HouseholdNumber 19 13 0 0 8 18 0 47 0 105 Population 58 52 0 0 21 71 0 166 0 368 2 FloorArea (m) 787 781 0 0 264 1043 0 2353 0 5228 Eastpart of NantianRd. HouseholdNumber 77 71 40 16 22 71 0 74 0 372 Population 264 258 133 62 68 258 0 261 0 1303 2 FloorArea (M) 3725 3719 1864 928 934 3719 0 3722 0 18610 Total HouseholdNumber 494 254 207 90 91 282 205 183 0 1806 Population 1670 943 685 308 326 1024 726 641 0 6322 2 ______FloorArea (m) 19441 13245 7216 4354 4694 14869 10922 8217 0 82959 Table 2.1.2.IC: 0 Dwelling Housing Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase lV of GCCTP According to Ownership0~~
ziovt -H-ousing owned by Housing -Re-form-e-d Section Content Housina PrivateHousing Oversea Ownedby oung by Housing Others Total Rent Self-living Rent Self-living Rent Rent Self-living Self-living Rent Liu'ersanRd. & HouseholdNumber 190 231 143 0 184 47 140 0 0 934 HuangshaAvenue Population 657 814 493 0 651 163 490 0 0 3269 2 FloorArea (m ) 9348 11678 7012 0 9342 2336 7009 0 0 46724 HengfuRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. HousehoidNumber 14 16 0 7 5 22 12 0 0 75 Population 42 63 0 16 23 69 49 0 0 262 FloorArea (i 2) 565 934 0 190 372 940 747 0 0 3748 Middle& West HouseholdNumber 123 117 0 0 43 157 0 360 0 800 Partsof NantianRd. Population 423 417 0 0 143 557 0 1260 0 2800 2 FloorArea (M ) 6003 5997 0 0 2003 7997 0 18000 0 40000 Total HouseholdNumber 327 363 143 7 231 225 152 360 0 1809 Population 1122 1294 493 16 817 789 540 1260 0 6331 FloorArea (m2) 15916 18609 7012 190 11717 11273 7755 18000 0 90472 ~~~~~T-41 A Vi l,: *,kD1.;. 1,
1rmrr< . 5t.~~~~~~~~~~l w ;=i\I -!7k
1 m r 9 #2 9S2.2..26fi Xaoaga eaid oa;nFgr .1FIUE2212 -- ~~~~~AJ'W. -A ~~~~~~~*t-x';h ;C l
e , __,.._ IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 6 Final Report
Q1 2.1.2.2 Ownershipof Dwellinghouses 1. The houses to be demolished are included in the below table:
Ownership Area (m2)
Housingowned by government 12,537.01 Private housing 15,540.63 Housing owned by overseas Chinese 2,278.38 Housing owned by units 39,282.63 Reformedhousing 4,062.86 Housing of household plots 1,139.67
2. The houses to be demolished are included in the below table:
HousingNumber PersonNumber Floor Area Nature (houses) (persons) (m2 ) Self-LivingHouse 288 1,309 19,876.45 RentedHouse 1,464 - 4,927 54,964.73
3. Analysis a) The housing whose impacts are the largest in this resettlement action are owned by units and government, covering 69.24%. The private housing are 30.76%. b) The area of the rent houses is 73.44%, with other 26.56% of the self-living houses. c) Due to the specific national policies, the owner of the housing of overseas Chinese will be the biggest beneficiaries. Parts of persons renting private housing will become the households of renting housing owned by the government, and the beneficiaries of reformed housing. d) The ownership and tenure of the dwelling houses are described in Table 2.1.2.1.
2.1.2.3 Situations of living space and basic living facilities
1. Situations about basic living facilities of the houses
a. The situations of basic living facilities refer to whether the facilities such as kitchens, toilets and balconies in the houses are independently used by the residents. i) Completely equipped condition refers that residents use all kitchens, toilets and balconies alone. There are 266 households with 1,023 persons, which is 15.18% of total households. The floor area is about 10,828.82m2. ii) Incompletely equipped condition refers that the residents use two items of kitchens, toilets and balconies alone. There are 433 households with 1,168 persons, which is 24.71 % of total households. The floor area is about 13,566.20m2. iii) Baldly equipped condition refers that the residents use one item of kitchens, toilets and balconies alone. There are 764 households with 2,590 persons, which is 43.61 % 0 of total households. The floor area is 28,168.74m2 . IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 7 Final Report
iv) Worse equipped condition refers that the residents can not use any of kitchens, toilets 0J and balconiesalone. There are 289 householdswith 1,752persons, which is 16.5% of total households. The floor area is 8,550.94m2.
Ratio Table of the Situations about Basic living facilities
Compretely E CorrpletelyEiuipped Worse Equipped Equipped * IncorrpletelyEuipped - Badly Equipped - !WorseEqupped
Incompletely Equipped
BadlyEup
b. Analysis: In the quarters of the resettlement sites, all the kitchens, toilets and balconies of the resettlement housing are used alone by the dwellers. In the light of the necessaries, the dwellers cover 84.82% of the households whose basic living facilities are improved. The situations of the basic living facilities of the residents are giveln in Table 2.1.2.3.a.
2. Situations of living Space of Households
i) The situation of living space is difficult( namely, an area of lounge and room is less than 5m2 /person): There are 418 households with 1,964 persons. The floor area covers 11,614.96 mi2 . ii) The situation of living space is not difficult (namely, an area of lounge and room is not less than 5 m2person): There are 1340 households with 4.272 persons. and the floor area covers 41,396m2. iii) Analysis: iv) According to the resettlement policies, the average area of lounge and room must be more than 5 m2 /person. To the households transferring from the urban center to the uptown or to the merging place of urban and town/country, their living space will be increased. As far as the living space is concerned, about 23.86% has been great improved in this relocation, and the other 76.14% has been commonly improved. v) The situations and the distributions of the dwellers' living space are clearly described in Table 2.1.2.3b and Table 2.1.2.3c.
3. Introduction of Living Situations
The living situations are classified into four categories in accordance with the situation of the 0 living space and the basic livingfacilities: better, general,worse, and worst. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 8 Final Report
a. The better living situations are: an average area of lounge and room is more than 5 0 m2 /personand the basic livingfacilities are equipped. There are 230 householdswith 810 persons with the floor area of 15,388.40 m2. b. The general living situations are: an average area of lounge and room is more than 5 m2 /person and the basic living facilities are not well equipped. There are 1113 households with 3,462 persons, and the floor area is 47,837.81 m2 . c. The worse living situations are : an average area of lounge and room is less than 5 m2 /person but the basic living facilities are well equipped. There are 36 households with 213 persons, and the floor area is 1501.97 m2. d. The worst living situations are: an average area of lounge and room is less than 5 m2 /person and the basic living facilities are not well equipped. There are 376 households with 1,751 persons, and the floor area is 10112.99 m2.
Ratio Chart of Living Situations
1
Better Worst BeBtte - r i; ~~~~~~~~~~~~~3_ Better *General _ Worse Worse 0Worst General
In this resettlement action, the living situations of 376 households are great improved, 36 households largely improved, 1113 houselholdsless largely improved and 283 houselholds commonly improved.
General Living Situations of Dwellers are shown in Table 2.1 .2.3b and Table 2.1 .2.3c.
2.1.2.4 Situations of dwelling house structures
I. There are 208 households with 831 persons living in the houses of frame structure, with the total floor area 10602.62 m2. 2. There are 1330 households with 4575 persons living in the houses of mixed structure, with the total floor area 53999.53 m2. 3. There are 214 households with 830 persons living in the houses of post and panel structure, with the total floor area of 10236.02 m2.
Analysis:
So far as the dwelling houses structure concerned, 88.13% of the dwellers live in the unsafe houses of post & panel structure and mixed structure. They will be relocated to the houses of
shown in Table 2.1 .2.3a. 0~~
Table 2.1.2.3.A: DwellingHouse Classification and Distribution along the Alignment oftiheIRR for Phases iandlII of GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Projects According to Housing Necessaiiies-(-Ki-tc-h-e.n-,Toile-t-a-n-d -Bal-c-o-ny-)-
1 2,3,4 5 6 7 8 0 11 12_ 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Housing Section ouseN loor(rn2.Area of H Pop No. of Floor Areaof Total No. ot Floor Area of No. ouse N tal Area f Hall an Populatusehol FloorAre Total Hal Pop Structure (Location) seof o se of Tw se of on (none)[ House (m2) Iall/Rm(mi No. House (m2) all/Rm(m Pop llRm( HalflRoorn(rn2) and Rm(m2)
HuangshaRegion 25~ 1,112 701 107 17~ 874 642 55 32 1.186 _727 98 0 - -0 74 3,173 2,071 260 ReinforcedXichang Interchange Region 10 718 4271 311 31 145 13 10 0 0 0 0-0 1 6 4 41 ConcreteStruc Guangyuan Interchange Region 7 334 197 17 21 92 58 7 2 60 40 9 1 32 21 1 12 517 316 34 Northof DonghuadongRegion 7: 771 492 38 3j 120 66 22 33 1,174 729 127 5 174 117 20 48 2,239 1,405 207 Southof Donghuadong Region 6 749 452 261 9 929 521 39 38 1,706 1,123 188 8 430 236 36 61 3,815 _2,330 289 Total 55 3,684 2,269 219~ 34 2,160 1,401 133 .105 .4,12.6 -2,620- 422 14 637- 374- 57 208. 1-0,606 6,663, _831
jHuangsha Region , 43, 2,681 1.705 164 791 4,377 2,828 303 199 6,473 -4,498 673 80 2,119 __1,498 255 401 15,651 10,530 1395 Bikad IX hn necag ein 141 1,014 650 47 74J 3,601 2,150 247 48 1,914 1,281 162 24 628 418 51 160 _7,`157 4,499 507
Concrete GuangyuanInterchange Region 80 3,492 2,198 300 1051 3652 1 21279 382 253 _9,559 5,382 791 16 464 325 38 454 17,168 10,183 1511 Structure Northof DonghuadongRegion I 40 3,036 1,901 152 47 2:562I1,644 2012 62 2,349 1,555 206 22 __673_ -550_ _68 171 -8,620 5,651 628 Southof DonghuadongRegion 81 523 412 27 27, 1,228I 809 106 27 1,152 786 86 82 2,501 1,654 315 144 _5,404 3,661 534
Total 185' 10,746 6,865 690 3321 15,420 9,709'1240 589 1,448 13,503 1918 224 6,385 4,446 727 1330 54,000 34.523 4575 HuanshaRegon 0, 17, 1 7 791 17 HuangshaRegion0 - - I ~~~ ~~~~720 ~~~~578 ~~~~~~~86 - 6 ~~~~210 ~~24172 12 47 1,847 1,425 17 Brickand XcaInecageir 0 - o 9'1 593 317 32 3 117 162 16 0 - - 0 12 710 478 48
Tile Gunya necange Region 21 79 48 4t ii 30 17 3 0 - -0 0 0 3 109 64 7 Frame :Northof Donghuadong 1' ,75 690 6. 14 653 430 681 21 778 531 71 10 147 119 24 58 2,753 1,770 232
Structure Southof Donghua Rd. E. Region 11; 1,207, 957 41 26: 1,459 1,018 113 22,, 980 619 77 -35 1,172 918 135 _94 4,818 3,512 366 !Total 26 2,460 1,695 114' 67 3,651 2,457 295, 70~ 2,595 1,890, 250 51 1,529 1,209 171 214 10,236 7,250 830
GrandTotal .2661 16,890,,10,829 1,023 433 21,231 13,566 1,668 764 8,169 18,012 2,590 289 8,551 6,029 955 1,752 74,841 48,436 6,236
Coding:. 1 'No. of householdswith sole use of all of the following:kitchen, toilet and balcony 8 Grandnumber of persons 15 TotalArea of Hall & Rm (mn2) 2 Floorarea (m2) of hholdswith sole use of two of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony' oseodNI Number Nubr fPp (person) 3 Total area(m2) of hall& room-with sole use of one of the foil.: kitchen,toilet &balcony I 10 FloorArea (m2)I' 17 Total HouseholdNumber 4 No. of people with sole use of none of the following: kitchen, toilet and balcony 11 Total Area of Hall & Room(m2) 18 TotalFloor Area (m2) 5 ~Grandhousehold number 12 Number of Pop (person) 19 Total Area of Hall & Rm (m2) 6 Grandfloor area (m2) , I ~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~13Household Numbe 20 Numberof Pop (pesn
7 Grandtotal area of halland room(m2) '14I____ FloorArea- (m) -m 0 IRR for Phase IlIlof GCCTP According to Housing Necessities Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of 0 Table 2.1.2.313: Dwelling Housing
Housing Section 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 | 15 16 17 18 19 20
Structure HH No rArea( all & R opulati HH No rArea( all & R Pop holdN rArea( all & R Pop HH No rArea( all& R Pop - Reinforced RailwayStation Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Concrete HengfuRd. Overpass 86 4153 2571 269 17 791 435 55 20 791 475 55 20 857 475 77 143 6592 3955 456 Structure MeidongOverpass 40 1770 1062 134 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 40 1770 1062 134 HaiyinnanOverpass 23 1148 689 44 6 291 174 12 2 92 55 4 0 0 0 0 31 1531 918 59 7 519 305 25 4 233 121 11 2 74 51 6 3 233 159 15 16 1060 636 57 0 0 0 0 43 2242 1539 148 23 1231 893 74 22 923 646 86 88 4397 3078 308 IndustryAvenue 7 442 257 22 4 249 157 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 11 691 414 36 ShusheOverpass 11 675 405 36 10 498 309 29 5 267 160 19 5 338 192 20 32 1778 1067 103 EastPart of NantianRd. 45 2792 1675 130 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 45 2792 1675 130 Sub-total 219 11500 6964 659 84 4304 2736 269 52 2455 1633 156 50 2351 1472 198 404 20609 12805 1282 Brick& RailwayStation Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Concrete HengfuRd. Overpass 38 1488 934 110 73 2706 1664 225 46 1759 1055 139 26 812 406 104 182 6766 4059 577 Structure MeidongOverpass 59 2301 1381 190 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 59 2301 1381 190 HaiyinnanOverpass 22 808 485 56 19 727 436 50 0 0 0 0 13 485 291 55 54 2020 1212 161 12 613 357 39 12 685 411 41 10 360 216 33 6 144 97 23 40 1802 1081 136 58 3192 1857 183 51 2805 1683 170 38 2031 1219 139 34 1644 1045 139 180 9673 5804 631 IndustryAvenue 0 0 0 0 9 426 256 31 0 0 0 0 8 363 218 29 17 789 474 60 ShusheOverpass 12 621 361 23 8 395 237 18 11 546 316 22 7 320 215 18 38 1882 1129 81 EastPart of NantianRd. 70 3573 2144 205 60 3216 1929 182 22 1251 750 76 19 893 536 123 171 8933 5360 586 Sub-total 271 12597 7519 807 231 10961 6617 717 126 5947 3557 408 112 4662 2807 490 741 34166 20500 2423 Brick & Tile RailwayStation Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Frame HengfuRd. Overpass 0 0 0 0 37 1516 986 175 34 1357 830 151 38 1117 778 160 109 3990 2594 486 Structure MeidongOverpass 0 0 0 0 13 530 318 49 20 823 483 76 15 476 296 65 49 1829 1098 190 HaiyinnanOverpass 0 0 0 0 24 720 463 90 23 977 586 98 21 874 494 85 69 2571 1543 273 0 0 0 0 21 1097 644 74 13 .707 424 48 15 634 395 63 50 2438 1463 185 0 0 0 0 60 2691 1614 210 65 3166 2042 228 46 2058 1092 162 172 7914 4748 600 industryAvenue 0 0 0 0 9 395 237 31 6 296 178 23 6 296 178 22 22 987 592 76 ShusheOverpass 0 0 0 0 15 732 439 49 18 878 502 56 13 481 314 43 46 2091 1255 147 EastPartof Nantian Rd. 0 0 0 0 29 1336 802 132 45 2291 1298 211 72 2736 1718 316 146 6363 3818 659 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 208 9017 5502 810 226 10494 6343 891 227 8672 5264 916 661 28183 17110 2617 Total 490 24097 14483 1466 523 24282 14855 1796 404 18896 11533 1455 389 15684 9544 1604 1806 82959 50415 6322 Coding: Useof all of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Use of one of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 1 No.of households 9 No. of households 17 Total HouseholdNumber 2 Floorarea (m2) of households 10 Floorarea (m2) of households 18 TotalFloor Area (m2) 3 Total area(m2) of halland room 11 Total area(m2) of hall androom 19 TotalArea of Hall and Room(m2) 4 No.of people 12 No. of people 20 Numberof Population(person) Useof two of the following:kitchen, toilet & balconv Use of noneof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 5 No.of households 13 No. of households 6 Floorarea (m2) of households 14 Floorarea (m2) of households 7 Total area(m2) of halland room 15 Total area(m2) of hall androom 8 No.of people 16 No. of people Ta e 2.1.2.3C: Dwelling Housing Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRRD~~ for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities
Housing Section 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Structure HH No r Area( all & R opulati HH No r Area( all & R Pop holdN r Area( all & R Pop HH No r Area( all & R Pop Reinforced Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 64 4579 2691 216 32 2056 1065 98 20 654 449 49 24 2056 1402 127 140 9345 5607 490 Concrete HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Structure MeidongbeiRd. 11 672 390 33 6 378 239 22 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 1049 630 55 Middle& West Partsof Na 86 5168 3101 274 77 3808 2366 220 38 2040 1224 141 38 2584 1469 149 240 13600 8160 784 Sub-total 161 10419 6182 523 115 6242 3671 340 58 2694 1673 190 62 4640 2871 276 397 23994 14397 1329 Brick& Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 106 5401 3145 341 110 6037 3622 353 85 3177 1906 282 53 1271 858 200 355 15886 9532 1177 Concrete HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Structure MeidongbeiRd. 0 0 0 0 14 648 389 48 0 0 0 0 12 552 331 44 26 1199 720 92 Middle& West Partsof Na 92 4752 2765 179 60 3024 1814 136 81 4176 2419 166 55 2448 1642 136 288 14400 8640 616 Sub-total 199 10153 5910 520 184 9708 5825 536 166 7353 4326 449 120 4271 2830 380 668 31486 18891 1885 Brick & Tile Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 0 0 0 0 184 9672 5674 641 119 6233 3740 416 136 5588 3482 545 439 21493 12896 1602 Frame HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Structure MeidongbeiRd. 0 0 0 0 14 600 360 47 10 450 270 35 10 450 270 33 33 1499 900 115 Middle& West Partsof Na 0 0 0 0 87 4200 2520 462 109 5040 2880 532 76 2760 1800 406 272 12000 7200 1400 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 285 14472 8554 1150 237 11723 6890 983 222 8798 555 984 744 34992 20995 3117 Total 360 20572 12093 1043 584 30422 18050 2026 461 21770 12888 1622 404 17708 11253 1640 1809 90472 54283 6331
Coding: Useof all of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Useof oneof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 1 No. of households 9 No.of households 17 Total HouseholdNumber 2 Floorarea (m2) of households 10 Floor area(m2) of households 18 Total FloorArea (m2) 3 Totalarea (m2) of hall and room 11 Totalarea (m2) of hall and room 19 TotalArea of Hall and Room(m2) 4 No.of people 12 No. of people 20 Numberof Population(person) Useof twoof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Useof noneof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 5 No.of households 13 No.of households 6 Floorarea (m2) of households 14 Floorarea (m2) of households 7 Total area(m2) of hall and room 15 Totalarea (m2) of hall androom 8 No.of people 16 No.of people Table 2.1.2.4A: Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Houses with More Than 5m2/personLiving Space along the Alignment of the IRR for Phase I and 11 of Guangzhou City CenterTransport Projects According to Housing Necessaties
1 32 1 4 1 5 6 7 8 ~~~~1011 1 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Housing (Kitchen,!(Kitchen, T (Kitchen,T (Kitche No. of1------
Structure Section HouseholiFloor Area(l Total Area Pop HousehFloor Are TotalAre Pop HousehFloor Are TotalAre Numbe HousehFloor Are TotalAre Numbe Total H Total Flo Total Hal Pop
HuangshaRegion 20~ 885 551 70 151 818 607 46 29 1,114 704 88 0 -0 64 2.818 1,862 204
Reinforced XichangInterchange Region 10 718 427 31 3 145 113 10 0 - - 0 0 -- 0 13 862 540 41 Concrete lGuangyuanInterchange Regio 7j 334 197 17' 2 92 58 7 1 -32 22. 4 1 32 21 1--11 489 -298 --- 29
Northof DonghuadongRegion 6 725 6 31~ 0 -I 0 26 935 590 82 3 102 71 9 35 1,762 1.128 122 Structure Southof DonghuadongRegion 6 749 452 26 7 870 492 26 22 1,200 811 90 5 340 170 19 40 3,159 1,928 161 Total 49 3,410 2,097 175 27 1,924 1,270 89 78 3,282 2,127 264 9 474 262 29 163 9,091 5,752 557
HuangshaRegion 401 2,567 -~1,834 146 75 4,262 2,754 283 134 4,891 3,481 372 40 1,438 1,054 115 289 13,155 8,923 918 Brickand XichangInterchange Region 14~ 1,014 650 47 64 3,286 1,959 199 35 1,556 1,057 104 18 513 348 32 131 6.368 4,014 382 Concrete GuangyuanInterchange Regio 61 2,827 1,808 195 69 2,535 1,610 215 209 8,230 4,496 563 15 433 307 32 354 14,025 8,221 1005 Northof DonghuadongRegion 33 2,755 1,715 112 36 2,173 1,4041 148 51 2,020 1,351 150 21 651 536 65 143 7,599 5,005 475 Structure Southof DonghuadongRegion 8 523 412 27 16 895 610 57 23 1,055 724 67 45 1,679 1,138 147 92 4,151 2,884 298 Total 1561 9,686 6.218 527 262 13,151 8,337 902 452 17,752 11,110 1256 139 4,712 3,382 391 1009 45,300 29,047 3076
Huangsha - - 16, 903 -668 74 17 582 483 57 5 20 163 10 38 1,684 1,313 141
Brickand XichangInterchange Region 01 - - 0 8~ 371 308 30 3 117 162 16 0 -- 0 11 489 470 46
Tile GuangyuanInterchange Regio 2!, 79 48 4 11 30 17 3 0 - -0 0 -0 3 109 64 7 Northof DonghuadongRegion 121 1,007 676 63 10! 503 354 48 20 760- 518 68 -4 82 78 9 46 2,352 1,827 188 Structure ISouthof Donghuadong Region 11! 1.20 957, 41 231 1,349i 945 95 14 ' 724 509 45 22 922 713 76 70 4,202 3.124 257 Total 25 2,293 1,681 108, 58~ 3,156 292 20j 54 2,184 1,671 186 31 1,204 94 9 6 ,3 ,9 3
Grand Total i 230115,388 19 810 3471 18,2311 11,898 1,241 584 23,217 14,908 1,706 179 6,390 4,598 515 1,340 63,226 41,397 4,272
Coding: 9 HoshlNubr- -7 otlHueod umr 1 'No. of households with sole use of all of the following: kitchen, toilet and balcony 9 HueodNme 7 TtlHueodNme 2 'Floor area(m2) of householdswith sole use of two of the following:kitchen, toilet, bloy10 FloorArea (mn2)j.18 TotalFloor Area (mn2 3 'Total area (m2) of hall and room - with sole use of one of the folloWing:kitchen, toilet, balcony 11 Total Area of Hall and Room(m)19 Toa- rao-Hl m(2 4 iNo. of people with sole use of none of the following: kitchen, toilet andbloy12 Number of Population(person) 20- Number of Pop (person)
5 Grandhousehold number .i13 Household Number 6 Grand floor area(mn2) . - 14 FloorArea (m2) j
7 Gr~andtotal areaof halland room(m2) - . - TotalArea of Hall and Room(m2) C) 0 2 Table 2.1.2.4B: Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Housing with More Than 5m /person Living Space along the Alignment of IRR for Phase Ill of GCCTPAccording to Housing Necessities
Housing Section 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Structure HH No r Area( all & R opulati HH No r Area( all & R Pop hold N r Area( all & R Pop HH No orArea( all & R Pop - Reinforced RailwayStation Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Concrete HengfuRd. Overpass 73 3845 2352 213 10 554 313 28 17 554 344 38 14 497 321 40 114 5450 3330 320 Structure MeidongOverpass 27 1381 829 77 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 1381 829 77 HaiyinnanOverpass 11 895 537 18 3 208 127 6 1 74 46 2 0 0 0 0 15 1177 710 26 4 322 188 10 2 187 97 5 1 46 28 3 2 138 101 6 8 692 414 24 0 0 0 0 34 1701 1229 98 17 868 558 49 14 554 406 41 65 3123 2193 188 IndustryAvenue 4 377 218 7 2 144 89 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 521 307 11 ShusheOverpass 9 594 357 22 7 348 217 17 4 213 126 12 3 236 115 4 23 1393 814 55 East Partof NantianRd. 27 2289 1357 87 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 2289 1357 87 Sub-total 155 9703 5837 434 58 3142 2071 159 51 1620 1493 156 33 1425 943 92 285 16025 9954 788 Brick & RailwayStationOverpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0_0 0 0 0o0 0_0 0 Concrete HengfuRd. Overpass 31 1191 747 77 56 2194 1282 152 38 1402 833 90 19 585 292 74 144 5371 3154 393 Structure MeidongOverpass 46 2154 1276 118 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 46 2154 1276 118 HaiyinnanOverpass 15 630 373 34 7 509 301 25 0 0 0 0 6 147 108 15 29 1286 782 74 10 551 321 28 6 479 300 25 8 303 178 22 4 86 58 12 29 1420 857 86 49 2754 1654 138 40 2376 1396 119 28 1662 885 75 18 956 771 73 135 7748 4706 405 IndustryAvenue 0 0 0 0 7 341 202 19 0 0 0 0 3 174 100 7 10 515 302 26 ShusheOverpass 8 478 276 11 7 332 201 11 8 378 238 9 3 150 103 4 26 1339 818 35 East Partof NantianRd. 57 3216 1929 153 47 2684 1632 124 16 875 583 40 14 616 407 83 134 7391 4551 400 Sub-total 217 10975 6577 558 171 8915 5314 474 98 4620 2717 236 67 2715 1840 268 553 27225 16448 1536 Brick& Tile RailwayStation Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 7 0 o 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 07 Frame HengfuRd. Overpass 0 0 0 0 31 1061 637 129 27 1181 682 115 30 905 660 129 88 3147 1979 373 Structure MeidongOverpass 0 0 0 0 8 371 226 24 14 626 367 54 9 269 186 34 31 1266 779 112 HaiyinnanOverpass 0 0 0 0 21 532 378 69 18 823 496 75 8 412 258 30 47 1767 1132 174 0 0 0 0 17 878 515 55 11 617 352 37 12 570 355 38 40 2065 1222 130 0 0 0 0 47 2249 1359 157 57 2706 1681 173 41 1893 986 135 145 6848 4026 465 IndustryAvenue 0 0 0 0 4 237 147 17 4 225 135 12 4 243 142 11 12 705 424 40 ShusheOverpass 0 0 0 0 f 566 3S1 32 15 748 43 43 8 231 151 14 35 1564 933 89 East Part of NantianRd. 0 0 0 0 23 1002 577 93 40 204 1187 185 5 2142 1365 265 122 5185 3129 543 Sub-total___ 0 0 0 160 216 16 4190 576 226 4 2 6 20 77116 6665 4104 440 225481 6251925 Total 372 20678 12414 992 391 18973 11576 1209 403 18896 H234 1455 271 1805 6887 800 1358 65798 40026 4249 C;oding: I___ Useof all of the following,kitchen, toilet & balcony Useof one of the follow kh tt l I No.of households 9 No of households 17 Total HouseholdNumber 2 Floorarea (m2)of households 10 Floorarea (m2) of households 18 Total FloorArea (m2) 3 Totalarea (m2)of hall androom 11 Totalarea (m2) of halland room 19 TotalArea of Hall and Room(m2) 4 No.of people 12 No. of people 20 Numberof Population(person) Use of twoof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Useof noneof the chen,toilet & balcony 5 No. of households 13 No.of households 6 Floorarea (m2) of households 14 Floorarea (m2) of households 7 Totalarea (m2) of hall androom 15 Totalarea (m2) of hall and room Q KIA Mf -- 1. 1i Nn nf nanrni 0 2 Table 2.1.2.4C: Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Housing with More Than 5m lperson Living Space along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities
Housing Section 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Structure HH No r Area( all & R opulati HH No r Area( all & R Pop holdN r Area( all & R Pop HH No r Area( all & R Pop Reinforced Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 64 4579 2691 216 18 1192 618 49 8 307 211 20 15 1234 855 61 106 7312 4375 346 Concrete HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Structure MeidongbeiRd. 9 537 344 20 4 264 167 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 802 511 33 Middle& West Partsof Na 58 4338 2561 184 31 2614 1665 92 24 1346 808 85 38 2584 1469 149 151 10882 6502 510 Sub-total 131 9454 5595 419 53 4070 2450 154 32 1654 1019 104 54 3818 2324 210 270 18996 11388 888 Brick& Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 50 4321 2548 184 86 4829 2898 212 41 2192 1163 136 19 585 395 61 196 11927 7003 593 Concrete HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Structure MeidongbeiRd. 0 0 0 0 3 330 198 10 0 0 0 0 5 265 159 11 7 595 357 21 Middle& West Partsof Na 84 4277 2488 107 49 2498 1493 76 39 2506 1452 60 40 1889 1283 65 212 11170 6715 308 Sub-total 134 8598 5036 291 137 7658 4588 298 80 4698 2614 195 64 2739 1836 137 415 23692 14075 922 Brick & Tile Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 0 0 0 0 144 7544 4426 397 66 3989 2393 167 118 5029 3134 377 328 16563 9953 941 Frame HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Structure MeidongbeiRd. 0 0 0 0 11 480 288 20 7 360 216 19 2 216 130 7 20 1055 633 46 Middle& West Partsof Na 0 0 0 0 52 2982 1789 231 60 3528 2074 255 0 0 0 0 112 6510 3863 486 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 207 11006 6503 649 133 7877 4683 441 120 5245 3263 383 460 24128 14449 1473 Total 18052 10632 711 397 22734 13542 1101 245 14229 8316 740 238 11801 7423 731 1145 66816 39913 3283
Coding: Useof all of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Useof one of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 1 No. of households 9 No.of households 17 Total HouseholdNumber 2 Floorarea (m2)of households 10 Floorarea (m2) of households 18 Total FloorArea (m2) 3 Totalarea (m2) of halland room 11 Totalarea (m2)of hall androom 19 TotalArea of Hall andRoom (m2) 4 No.of people 12 No.of people 20 Numberof Population(person) Useof two of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Useof noneof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 5 No.of households 13 No.of households 6 Floorarea (m2)of households 14 Floorarea (m2) of households 7 Totalarea (m2) of halland room 15 Totalarea (m2)of hall androom 8 No.of people 16 No.of people Table 2.1.2.5A: Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Houseswith Less Than 5m2lpersonLiving Spacealong the Alignment of the IRR for PhasesI and 11 of GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Projects According to Housing Necessatles
13 2 4 5 6 7 8~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~9ji11 12 13 14 5 1 17 18 19 20
Housing (Kitche(Kitchen, (Kitchen,(Kitche Grand :Grand Grand GrandTotal - Structure Section Househ,Floor Are TotalAre Numbe Househ,Floor Are TotalAre Numbe HousehFloor Are TotalAre Numbe HousehFloor Are TotalAre Numbe Total H Total Flo TotalAre Pop
HuangshaRegion 5 227 150 37' 2 56 36 9 3 72 23 10 0 - 0 10 355 208 56
Reinforced XichangInterchange Region 0 - - ~ 0 0] - 0 0 - 0 0 -0 0 - 0
Concrete GuangyuanInterchange Region 0 - - 0 Oj - 0 1 27 18 5 0 -- 0 1 27 18 5 Northof DonghuadongRgion 1 46 26 7 3 120 66 22 7 239 139 45 2 72 46 11 13 477 278 85
Structure Southof DonghuadongRegion 0 - - 0 2 60 29 13 16 506 312 98 3 90 66 17 21 656 407 128 Total 6 274 176 44 7 235 131 44 27 844 492 158 5 162 112 28 45 1,515 911 274
HuangshaRegion 31 114 71 18 4~ 116 74 20 65 1,582 1,017 301 40 683 445 140 112 2,496 1,607 479
Brickand XichangInterchange Region 0 - - 0 10 315 191 48 13 358 223- 58 ___6 115- 70 19 29 789 -- 485- 125 19 36569 6349139086 22 3 1 10 3,143 1,963 506 Concrete GuangyuanInterchange Region 19 665 390 10 1,117 66 6,4 132 8 2 31 - -
Northof DonghuaRd.E Region 7~ 281 186 40 9! 389'1 241' 54 11 329 205 56 1 22 14 3 28 1,021 646 153 Structur Rd.E.South fegion Dongha o- 0 li~ 333 198 49 4 97 62 19 37 822 518 168 52 1,253 776 236 Total 29i 1,0611 647i 70* 2,269 1,372 338 137 3,696 2,394 662 85 1,674 1,063 336 321 8,700 5,476 1499
HuangshaRegion Oj - O 1 14 81 51 0 138 95 29 1 i 9 2 9 162 112 36
Brickand XichangInterchange Region ' 0 01 1: 221 9 2~ 0 - 0 0 -0 1 221 9 2
Tile IGuangyuanlInterchangeRegion 0 -I 0 0! o~ - - 0 0 - 0 0 -- 0 0- 0 Northof Donghua Rd.E. Region 1 168 14, 6 4! 150 76 20~ 1] 18 13 3 6 65 41 15 12 401 144 44
Structure ,Southof DonghuaRd. E. Region! 0 - - 3 110 73i 18' 8 256 i11 32 13 249 205 59 24 616 388 109 iTotal 1 168! 14; 6 9 495 165 45~ 16 412 218 64 20 325 255 76 46 1,400 652 191
Grand Total 36 1,502 837 '213 86 3,000 1,668 427 180 4 I5 3,104 884 110 2,161 1,431 440 412 11,615 7,040 1,964 0 2 Table 2.1.2.5B: Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Housing with Less Than 5m /person Living Space along the Alignment of IRR for Phase Ill of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities
Housing Section 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Structure HH No r Area( all & R opulati HH No r Area( all & R Pop hold N r Area( all & R Pop HH No r Area( all & R Pop Reinforced Railway Station Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Concrete Hengfu Rd. Overpass 13 308 219 56 7 237 122 26 3 237 131 17 6 360 154 37 29 1142 625 136 Structure Meidong Overpass 12 389 234 57 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 389 234 57 Haiyinnan Overpass 12 253 152 25 3 83 47 6 1 18 9 1 0 0 0 0 15 353 208 33 4 197 117 15 2 47 24 6 2 28 23 3 1 96 58 9 8 368 222 33 0 0 0 0 9 541 310 50 6 363 335 25 8 369 240 45 23 1274 885 119 Industry Avenue 3 65 39 15 2 104 68 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 170 107 25 Shushe Overpass 2 81 49 14 3 149 93 12 1 53 34 7 2 101 77 16 8 385 252 48 East Part of Nantian Rd. 18 502 318 43 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 18 502 318 43 Sub-total 64 1796 1127 225 26 1162 665 110 12 700 531 53 17 926 528 106 119 4584 2852 494 Brick & Railway Station Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Concrete Hengfu Rd. Overpass 7 298 187 33 17 512 382 73 8 357 222 48 7 227 114 30 38 1394 905 184 Structure Meidong Overpass 12 147 105 72 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 147 105 72 Haiyinnan Overpass 7 178 112 23 11 218 135 25 0 0 0 0 7 338 183 40 25 734 430 87 2 61 36 12 6 205 111 16 2 58 38 11 2 58 39 12 11 382 224 50 9 438 203 45 10 429 287 51 10 369 334 64 16 688 274 66 45 1925 1098 226 Industry Avenue 0 0 0 0 2 85 54 13 0 0 0 0 5 189 118 22 7 274 171 34. Shushe Overpass 4 143 85 13 1 63 36 7 3 168 78 13 4 170 112 13 12 543 311 46 East Part of Nantian Rd. 13 357 214 52 13 532 297 58 6 376 167 37 5 277 129 40 37 1542 808 187 Sub-total 54 1622 942 250 61 2045 1303 243 28 1327 840 172 45 1947 967 222 188 6941 4052 887 Brick & Tile Railway Station Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Frame Hengfu Rd. Overpass 0 0 0 0 6 455 349 46 7 176 148 36 8 212 118 31 21 843 615 114 Structure Meidong Overpass 0 0 0 0 5 159 92 26 6 198 116 22 6 207 110 31 17 563 319 78 Halyinnan Overpass 0 0 0 0 3 188 85 21 5 154 90 24 13 462 236 55 22 804 411 100 0 0 0 0 4 219 129 19 2 90 72 12 3 63 39 25 10 373 240 56 0 0 0 0 13 442 255 53 8 460 361 55 5 165 106 27 27 1066 722 135 Industry Avenue 0 0 0 0 5 158 90 14 2 71 43 11 2 53 36 11 10 282 168 35 Shushe Overpass 0 0 0 0 3 146 88 17 3 130 71 13 5 250 163 29 11 527 321 59 East Part of Nantian Rd. 0 0 0 0 6 334 224 39 5 250 111 26 13 594 353 51 24 1178 688 116 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 46 2101 1312 235 40 1528 1012 198 56 2007 1161 260 141 5636 3485 692 Total 118 3419 2069 475 132 5308 3280 587 80 3555 2383 423 118 4879 2657 588 448 17161 10388 2073 Coding: Useof all of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Use of one of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 1 No.of households 9 No. of households 17 Total HouseholdNumber 2 Floorarea (m2) of households 10 Floorarea (m2)of households 18 TotalFloor Area (m2) 3 Total area(m2) of halland room 11 Totalarea (m2) of halland room 19 TotalArea of Hall and Room(m2) 4 No.of people 12 No. of people 20 Numberof Population(person) Useof two of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Use of noneof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 5 No.of households 13 No. of households 6 Floorarea (m2) of households 14 Floorarea (m2)of households 7 Totalarea (m2) of halland room 15 Totalarea (m2) of halland room 8 No. of people 16 No. of people 0 0 0 Table 2.1.2.5C: Classification and Distribution of the Dwelling Housing with Less Than 5m2lperson Living Space along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Housing Necessities
Housing Section 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Structure HH N r Area( all & R pulati HH No r Area( all & R Pop holdN r Area( all & R Pop HH No r Area( all & R Pop Reinforced Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 0 0 0 0 14 863 447 49 11 347 238 29 9 822 547 66 34 2032 1232 145 Concrete HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Structure MeidongbeiRd. 2 134 47 13 2 113 72 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - 0 4 248 119 22 Middle &West Partsof Na 29 830 540 91 46 1194 702 127 15 694 416 56 0 0 0 0 89 2718 1658 274 Sub-total 31 965 587 104 62 2171 1221 185 26 1040 654 86 9 822 547 66 127 4998 3008 441 Brick & Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 56 1080 598 157 24 1207 724 141 44 985 743 147 34 686 463 139 159 3959 2529 584 Concrete HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Structure MeidongbeiRd. 0 0 0 0 11 317 190 38 0 0 0 0 7 287 172 33 18 604 363 71 Middle& West Partsof Na 8 475 276 71 12 526 322 60 42 1670 968 106 14 559 359 70 76 3230 1925 308 Sub-total 65 1555 874 228 47 2050 1237 239 86 2655 1711 253 56 1532 994 243 254 7793 4816 963 Brick & Tile Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha 0 0 0 0 41 2128 1248 243 52 2244 1346 250 19 559 348 168 111 4931 2943 661 Frame HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Structure MeidongbeiRd. 0 0 0 0 3 120 72 27 3 90 54 15 7 234 140 27 13 444 266 69 Middle& West Partsof Na 0 0 0 0 35 1218 731 231 49 1512 806 277 76 2760 1800 406 160 5490 3337 914 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 78 3466 2051 501 104 3846 2207 542 102 3553 2289 601 284 10864 6546 1644 Total 95 2520 1461 332 187 7687 4508 925 216 7541 4572 882 166 5907 3829 909 664 23656 14371 3048
Coding: Useof all of the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Useof oneof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 1 No.of households 9 No.of households 17 Total HouseholdNumber 2 Floorarea (m2) of households 10 Floorarea (m2)of households 18 TotalFloor Area (m2) 3 Totalarea (m2) of hall and room 11 Totalarea (m2) of halland room 19 TotalArea of Hall and Room(m2) 4 No.of people 12 No.of people 20 Numberof Population(person) Useof twoof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony Useof noneof the following:kitchen, toilet & balcony 5 No.of households 13 No.of households 6 Floorarea (m2) of households 14 Floorarea (m2) of households 7 Total area(m2) of hall and room 15 Totalarea (m2) of halland room 8 No.of people 16 No. of people IRRResettlement Implementation Plan 9 FinalReport
O 2.1.3 EconomicSituations of the Households 2.1.3.1 Situations of electrical appliances
1. 1047 households have a very good economic situations (having air conditioners or telephones). 2. 430 households have a better economic situations (without air conditioners and telephone, but have TV sets). 3. 275 households have common economic situations (without air conditioners, telephone and TV sets). The detailed situations are shown in Table 2.1.3.1.
2.1.3.2 Of the 275 households with electrical appliances, 197 households have better or general living situations, and the other 78 houses have worse or worst living situations.
2.1.3.3 Income situations of the households:
1. Of the households whose situations of owning electrical appliances are very good, there isn't any household whose income is less than 200Yuan/person. 2. Of the households whose situations of owning electrical appliances are better, there isn't any household whose income is less than 200Yuan/person.. 3. Of the 275 households whose situations of owning electrical appliances are general: a. Of the 197 households with better or general living situations: There are 9 households whose income is less than 200Yuan/person. b. Of the 78 households with worse or worst living situations: There are 28 households whose income is less than 200Yuan/person.
2.1.3.4 Analysis
To all the affected residents, 275 households without air conditioners, telephones and TV sets, cover 15.7% of the total households. Only 37 households under the poverty-line, cover 2.11% of the total households (the poverty-line is only calculated by the baseline wages of Guangzhou City employed population). These vulnerable groups need our specific care.
2.1.4 Population Structure and Household Classification
2.1.4.1 Population structure of residents
I. The number of the old above 60 is 916, covering 14.69% of the total population. 2. The number of the persons from 18 to 59 is 4246, covering 68.09% of the total population. 3. The number of the persons from I to 17 is 1074, covering 17.22% of the total population. The details are described in Table 2.1.4.1
2.1.4.2 Categories of the households
I. The households of single-parent: There are 11 households covering 0.63% of the total households, with 29 persons covering 0.47% of total population (including the households of Q) single-father). 0 0
Table 2.1.3.IA: Dwelling Housing Classification and Distribution Along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and 11
of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects Accordirng to Life Necessatiese s -
7 8 , ______1_ _ 1 2 J 3 4 5 6
AC No AC Living Section Data Content Tel No Tel Tel No Tel Space(M2/Person) Cable TVs o Cable TV Cable TVs o Cable TV Cable TVs No Cable TV Cable TVs No Cable TV
Household Number 23! 3 9 2 20 __ 3 27 44 131 Huangsha Floor Area(M2) 663.761 64.85 190.03 31.47 575.94 74.15 611.96 800.36 3012.52 Region Number of Population(person) 1141 13 35 6 104 14 115 170 571 Xichang 'Household Number 81 0 2 0 7 0 4 9 30 Interchange Floor Area(M2) 246.011 0 47.53 0 222.16 0 295.37 198.76 1009.83
Region Number of Population(person) 381 0 6 0 35 0 15 _ 33 127
Guangyuan Household Number 28 1 9 0 19 _ ._ 3 40 1 101 The occupation Interchange FloorArea(M2) 899.631 30.1 256.79 0 631.11 91.64 1238.16 22.5 3169.93 hall & room Region Number of Population(person) 1401 6 41 0 101 14 206 3 511 is less than Nonrth of Household Number 14: 0 4 2 15 4 6 8 53 5m2/person. Donghuadong Floor Area(M2)(M2) 653.381 0 119.1 73.07 586.23 112.49 144.65 208.92 1897.84 Region INumberof Population(person) 78 0 19 15 90 16 25 39 282 South of Household Number I 151 0 5 0 25 6 30 16 97 ,Donghuadong Floor Area(M2) 407.63 0 160.52 0 732.86 139.03 783.19 301.62 2524.85 Region Number of Population(person) 72 0 32 0 125 27 142 75 473
Household Number 88 4 29 4 86 16 107 78 412 TOTAL 'Floor Area(M2) 2870.41 94.95 773.971 104.54 2748.3 417.31 3073.33 1532.16 11614.97 Number of Population(person) 442 19 1331 21 455 71 503 320 1964
! ______;Household Number 116 4 31 21 64 13 99 62 391 Huangsha FloorArea(M2) 6285.68 217.41 1061.89 57.561 314269 723.06 3944.4 2224.96 17657.65 Region Numberof Population(person) 418 12 82 6, 228 57 304 154 1261 'Xichang Household Number 36 4 14' 1 33 3 38 26 155 Interchange Floor Area(M2) 2055.69 164.87 761.44 43.481 1728.347 120.3 1670.86 1174.17 7719.28 Region Numberof Population(person) 108 11 49 31 133 130 92 , 469 Guangyuan Household Number 94! 4? 47 4 74 5 93 47 368 Interchange FloorArea(M2) , 3533.82 134 1629.54 130.48 4482.54 147.39 3140.42 1425.49 14623.68 0
The occupation Region Number of Population(person) 297 11 131 11, 236 11 265 79 1041 hall & room .Nonrth of Household Number 82 2 1515 5 43 10 32 35 224 is more than !Donghua Floor Area(M2) 5070.32 63.341 540.56 194.95 2443.4 416.08 1218.73 1766.21 11713.58 5m2/person. Region Number of Population(person) 3001 61 43 19 166 40 100 III 785 South of !Household Number j 47 2 9 2 41 13 61 27 202 Donghua IFloorArea(M2) 3923.86 170.04 423.75 58.83 2621.46 491.26 2523.95 1298.87 11512.02 Region !Number of Population(person) 215 10 30 6 172 43 174 66 716
|Household Number 375 16 1616 14 255 44 323 197 1340 TOTAL Floor Area(M2) 20869.371 749.661 4417.18 485.3 14418.437 1898.09 12498.36 7889.7 63226.21 Number of Population(person) 1338 50 335 45 935 164 935 470 4272
!Household Number 4631 201 1645 18 341 60 430 275 1752 GRANDTOTAL!FloorArea(M2) 23739.781 844.611 5191.15 589.84 17166.737 2315.4 15571.69 9421.86 74841.18 Number of Population(person) 17801 69 468 66 1390 235 1438 _. _ 790 6236
Coding: 1 With air-conditioners,telephones and cableTV 2 Withoutair-conditioners, telephones and cableTV 3 VWith telephonesand cableTV 4 1 Withouttelephones and cableTV
5 CableTV . I 6 Noncable TV 7 CableTV 8 Non cable TV _ _ 0 o 0 Table 2.1.3.1B: Dwelling Housing Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase ll of GCCTP According to Life Necessities
LivingSpace Section Content AC No AC Total (m2/person) Tel No Tel Tel No Tel Cable TVs No Cable TVs Cable TVs No Cable TVs Cable TVs No Cable TVs Cable TVs No Cable TVs Areaof hall& room RailwayStation Overpass HholdNo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 is morethan Sm2/person Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Floor Area (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HuanshizhongRd. HholdNo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 LuhuOverpass HholdNo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass HholdNo 107 0 97 0 69 17 45 10 346 Population 326 0 293 0 228 54 141 43 1085 2 FloorArea (m ) 4470 0 4051 0 2933 698 1397 419 13968 MeidongOverpass HholdNo 42 0 20 0 29 0 14 0 105 Popufation 123 0 58 0 86 0 40 0 307 FloorArea(m) 1920 0 912 0 1344 0 624 0 4801 Haiyinnan Overpass Hhold No 50 0 15 0 22 0 4 0 91 Population 151 0 49 0 66 0 8 0 274 FloorArea(m2) 2327 0 719 0 1015 0 169 0 4231 Zhen'an Overpass Hhold No 25 0 8 0 31 0 5 7 77 Population 77 0 29 0 98 0 17 19 240 Floor Area (m) 1379 0 501 0 1754 0 292 251 4177 RenminBridge HholdNo 207 0 28 0 110 0 0 0 345 & HongdeRd. Population 646 0 85 0 328 0 0 0 1059 FloorArea(m 2) 10986 0 1595 0 5139 0 0 0 17719 IndustryAvenue HholdNo 17 0 2 1 8 0 1 0 28 Population 46 0 5 2 22 0 2 0 77 FloorArea (m2) 1044 0 122 35 487 0 52 0 1741 ShusheOverpass HholdNo 27 0 4 0 39 0 13 0 84 Population 55 0 9 0 86 0 29 0 178 FloorArea (m) 1375 0 215 0 2019 0 687 0 4296 Eastpart of NantianRd. HholdNo 229 0 0 0 54 0 0 0 283 Population 845 0 0 0 185 0 0 0 1030 2 Floor Area (m) 12041 D 0 0 2824 0 0 0 14865 SubTotal HholdNo 703 0 174 1 363 17 82 17 1358 Population 2267 0 528 2 1098 54 237 63 4249 FloorArea (m7) 35541 0 8115 35 17517 698 3222 670 65798 Area of hall & room is RailwayStation Overpass HholdNo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 lessthan 5m2/person Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ______Floor Area(m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Table 2.1.3.1B: Dwelling Housing Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IlIl of GCCTP According to Life Necessities.0
HuanshizhongRd. Hhold No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 Floor Area(M 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 LuhuOverpass HholdNo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass Hhold No 20 0 5 0 41 0 16 5 88 Population 100 0 26 0 204 0 82 22 434 FloorArea (m2) 777 0 203 0 1588 0 642 169 3380 Meidong Overpass Hhold No 20 0 4 2 12 0 0 5 42 Population 95 0 21 8 58 0 0 25 207 2 Floor Area (m ) 506 0 110 44 308 0 0 132 1100 Haiyinnan Overpass Hhold No 25 0 5 0 24 0 9 0 62 Population 88 0 18 0 83 0 31 0 219 FloorArea (M)} 757 0 151 0 719 0 265 0 1891 Zhen'anOverpass HholdNo 9 0 3 0 12 0 3 2 29 Population 46 0 17 0 58 0 11 7 138 2 Floor Area (m ) 370 0 135 0 472 0 90 56 1123 RenminBridge HholdNo 49 0 8 0 27 0 4 8 95 & HongdeRd. Population 250 0 38 0 130 0 19 43 480 Floor Area (m) 2217 0 384 0 1109 0 171 384 4264 IndustryAvenue HholdNo 12 0 2 0 6 0 1 0 21 Population 58 0 8 0 26 0 4 0 95 2 FloorArea (m ) 443 0 65 0 189 0 29 0 726 ShushezhiStreet HholdNo 15 0 2 0 10 0 3 2 32 Population 70 0 8 0 49 0 17 8 153 Floor Area (m) 684 0 58 0 466 0 175 73 1455 Eastpart of NantianRd. HholdNo 40 0 0 0 28 0 8 4 79 Population 173 0 0 0 121 0 35 17 346 Floor Area (mi) 1611 0 0 0 1128 0 322 161 3222 Sub Total Hhold No 191 0 29 2 159 0 43 25 448 Population 880 0 135 8 729 0 199 122 2072 _ Floor Area(M) 7366 0 1106 44 5977 0 1693 975 17161 Total Hhold No 894 0 203 2 523 17 125 42 1806 Population 3147 0 663 10 1827 54 435 184 6322 Floor Area (m2) 42907 0 9221 79 23494 698 4915 1644 82959 0 0 o Table 2.1.3.iC: Dwelling Housing Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Life Necessities
LivingSpace Section Content AC No AC Total (m2/person) Tel No Tel Tel No Tel CableTVs No Cable TV CableTVs No CableTVs CableTVs No Cable TVs CableTVs No CableTVs Areaof hall& room Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha HouseholdNo 202 0 69 0 258 0 44 57 630 is morethan 5m2/person Population 601 0 225 0 770 0 132 150 1879 2 FloorArea (m ) 11815 0 4296 0 15037 0 2506 2148 35802 HengfuRd. HouseholdNo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. HouseholdNo 24 0 3 1 11 0 1 0 40 Population 60 0 7 2 28 0 3 0 100 FloorArea (m2) 1471 0 172 49 687 0 74 0 2452 Middle& West HouseholdNo 152 0 24 0 223 0 76 0 475 Partsof NantianRd. Population 404 0 65 0 626 0 209 0 1303 2 FloorArea (m ) 9140 0 1428 0 13424 0 4570 0 28562 Sub-total HouseholdNo 378 0 96 1 493 0 121 57 1145 Population 1066 0 298 2 1424 0 343 150 3283 2 .______FloorArea(m ) 22426 0 5896 49 29147 0 7150 2148 66816 Areaof hall& roomis Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha HouseholdNo 97 0 33 0 128 0 27 18 304 lessthan 5m2/person Population 459 0 167 0 584 0 111 70 1390 2 FloorArea (m ) 3604 0 1311 0 4587 0 874 546 10922 HengfuRd. HouseholdNo 0 0 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 Population 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 .______FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. HouseholdNo 21 0 3 0 10 0 1 0 35 Population 99 0 13 0 44 0 6 0 162 FloorArea (m 2) 790 0 117 . 0 337 0 52 0 1296 Middle& West HouseholdNo 153 0 16 0 104 0 36 16 325 Partsof NantianRd. Population 688 0 75 0 479 0 165 75 1497 2 FloorArea (m ) 5376 0 458 0 3660 0 1373 572 11438 Sub-total HouseholdNo 271 0 53 0 242 0 65 35 664 Population 1246 0 255 0 1106 0 282 144 3033 FloorArea (m 2) 9771 0 1885 0 8584 0 2298 1118 23656 Total HouseholdNo 649 0 148 1 734 0 186 91 1809 Population 2311 0 552 2 2530 0 625 295 6322 2 ______FloorArea (in ) 32196 0 7781 49 37732 0 9448 3266 90472 0 0~~
Table 2.1.4.1A: Resident Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and i | of Guangzhou City Center Projects According to Population Structure
1 2 1 3 4 1 5 1 6 7 . 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 I . I Ijj, _. _ _ _ ._ __ __.___.__.
W/Old Per W/oOld Person , __= Section INo of Hhol!No of Oldp. No of ChildNo of Adults, TotalNo Noof Hhol Noof ChildNo of Adult TotalNo No of Hhol Noof Old Noof Chil Noof AdultsPopulation HuangshaRegion loll 153! 1071 222 482 189 120 487 607 290 153 227 709 1089 With Air- Xichangelnterchang 33' 53 21 80j 154 75 47 195 242 108 53 68 _ 275 396 ConditionerGuangyuan Intercha 961 125 60 216| 401 192 104 494 598 288 125 164 710 999 Telephone Northof Donghuadn 61 97 53 1661 316 135 82 394 476 196 97 135 560 792 Southof Donghuado 961 139| 981 2591 4961 69 41 195 2396 165 139 139 454 732 TOTAL 387 567 339 943 1849' 660 394 1765 4319 1047 567 733 2708 4008
. . . 0 I a.0 _. _ = 0 ..... ______-_ WithoutAir HuangshaRegion 82 110 44 1481 3021 150 82 359 441 232 110 126 507 743 ConditionerXichange Interchang 20 23 6 341 631 57 16 12i 137 77 23- 22 155 200 Telephone GuangyuanIntercha 621 88 38 109, 235' 119 47 271 318 181 88 85 380 553 ,Northof Donghuado 221 331 16 481 97j 59 29 149 178 81 33 45 197 275 |Southof Donghuado1 641 951 40 133 268' 70 23 166 . 189. 134_ 95 63 299 457 TOTAL 2501 3491 1441 4721 965. 455 197 1066 1263 705 349 341 1538 2228
GRANDTOTAL 637 916' 483' 1415 2814 1115 5911 2831 5582 - 1752 916 1074, 4246 6236 0 Table 2.1.4.iB: Resident Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase ill of GCCTP According to Population Structure
With OldPerson WithoutOld Person Total HH No Id Perso Child Adult Total HH No Child Adult Total HH No Id Perso Child Adult Pop With AC or Tel RailwayStation Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass 100 185 64 223 471 257 157 602 759 358 185 221 824 1230 MeidongOverpass 44 85 26 85 196 85 46 207 253 129 85 72 292 449 HaiyinnanOverpass 41 64 25 96 185 100 65 204 269 141 64 91 300 454 32 55 13 61 129 57 38 156 195 89 55 52 217 324 154 221 87 292 601 274 194 682 876 429 221 281 975 1477 IndustryAvenue 14 20 10 33 62 33 24 80 104 47 20 33 113 166 ShusheOverpass 26 55 8 58 122 71 25 130 155 97 55 33 188 277 EastPart of NantianRd. 126 212 77 248 537 224 149 639 787 350 212 225 887 1324 Sub-total 537 897 310 1095 2303 1102 698 2700 3398 1639 897 1008 3796 5701 WithoutAC & Tel RailwayStation Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass 20 40 14 64 118 57 35 135 170 76 40 49 199 289 MeidongOverpass 6 13 3 11 27 13 9 28 37 18 13 12 39 65 HaiyinnanOverpass 5 6 2 8 16 8 4 19 23 12 6 5 28 39 6 9 4 10 22 11 7 25 32 17 9 11 35 54 4 10 3 12 25 8 6 31 38 11 10 9 43 62 IndustryAvenue 1 1 1 1 3 1 0 3 3 2 1 1 4 6 ShusheOverpass 5 10 2 11 23 13 5 25 30 18 10 7 36 53 EastPart of NantianRd. 4 7 2 10 19 8 5 28 33 12 7 7 38 52 Sub-total 50 96 31 127 253 117 72 295 367 167 96 102 422 620 Total 587 993 341 1222 2556 1219 769 2995 3764 1806 993 1110 4218 6322 0 0 Table 2.1.4.IC: Dwelling Housing Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRRfor PhaseIV of GCCTPAccording to Population Structure
With Old Person WithoutOld Person Total HH No Id Perso Child Adult Total HH No Child Adult Total HH No Id Perso Child Adult Pop With AC or Tel Liu'ersanRd. & HuangshaAven 284 477 117 526 1120 504 332 1354 1686 788 477 449 1880 2806 HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. 22 30 15 50 95 51 36 122 158 72 30 51 172 253 Middle& WestParts of Nantian 181 467 70 493 1030 491 210 1097 1307 672 467 280 1589 2337 Sub-total 487 975 202 1069 2245 1045 578 2572 3151 1532 975 780 3641 5396 WithoutAC & Tel Liu'ersanRd. & HuangshaAven 53 74 32 83 189 94 60 213 273 146 74 93 296 463 HengfuRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. 1 2 1 2 5 2 1 4 5 3 2 2 6 9 Middle& West Partsof Nantian 37 85 17 90 192 91 46 210 256 128 85 63 300 448 Sub-total 91 161 50 175 386 186 107 427 534 277 161 157 602 920 Total 577 1136 252 1244 2631 1232 685 3000 3685 1809 1136 937 4243 6322 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 10 Final Report
2. The households of the old without living with adult sons/daughters: There are 32 households 0,) covering 1.83%of the total, with 74 personscovering 1.19%of the total population( including the old without husband/wife of non-children or without living with their children). 3. The households of the old living with adult sons/daughters: There are 65 households covering 34.53% of the total, with 2740 persons covering 43.94% of the total population. 4. Other households: There are 1104 households covering 63.01% of the total, with 3393 persons covering 54.4% of the total population.
2.1.4.3 Analysis
There are 41 households, including the households of the single-parent and the old without living with adult sons/daughters. These are the vulnerable groups who need our specific care.
2.1.5 Commuting Situations of the Dwellers
2.1.5.1 Affected Persons
Among the affected 6236 persons, there are 3787 commuting persons for work, covering 60.73% of the affected persons. The commuting persons' working sites distribute in the following 8 districts, the details are shown in the following table:
2.1.5.2 The commuting ways of the commuting persons are given as follows
Commuting Person (person) 1197 1324 442 Haizhu District Tianhe Dongshan Fangcun Liwan Huangpu Yuexiu Baiyun 214 out of districts 132
Commuting Way Commuting Person (person) Walking 894 Bicycle 1359 Motorcycle 137 Bus Owned by Units 211 Public Bus 538 Way of non-decision 648
The detailed situations of commuting are shown in Table 2.1.5. 0
Table 2.1.5A: Resident Commuting along the Alignment of the IRR for Phases I and 11of Guangzhou City Centre Transport Project
Working Sites(Region) Grand Total
Section Way of Commuting Dongsha Liwan Yuexiu Ulaizhu Tianhe Fangchun Huangpu Baiyun Other Person Number
Walking 0 315 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 315 Bicycle 29 219 57 33 3 20 0 16 3 380 Huangsha Motocycle 5 9 12 0 1 0 4 I . 33 Region Unit Shift Bus 0 6 0 4 10 7 7 18 7 59 Bus 13 38 33 14 17 10 5 12 4 146 Uncertain 5 59 4 5 2 4 1 19 31 130 Total Number 52 646 106 56 2 42 13 69 46 1063 Walking 0 64 0 0 33 0 0 0 0 64 Bicycle 14 72 16 12 0 1 0 7 0 124 Xichang Motocycle 0 6 5 0 2 0 0 T 0 13 Interchange Unit Shift Bus 8 I 0 1 0 0 2 5 2 19 Region Public Bus 6 12 12 1 I 0 1 2 1 46 Uncertain 1 28 . 0 0 0 0 0 14 44 Total Number 29 183 34 24 4 1 3 15 17 310 Walking 8 152 40 0 0 0 0 1 0 193 Bicycle 72 164 45 22 7 7 0 21 4 342 Guangyuan Motocycle 3 5 5 0 2 1 0 1 0 i7 Interchange Unit Shift Bus 2 6 4 4 5 0 7 20 2 50 Region Public Bus 31 38 5 1 18 5 3 2 11 3 162 Uncertain 3 30 5 0 1 1 0 1 24 65 Total Number III 395 150 44 20 12 9 55 33 829 Walking 178 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 178 Bicycle 101 32 34 16 7 2 1 9 2 214 Northof Motocycle 10 I 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 14 Donghuadong Unit Shift Bus 6 3 0 7 0 4 6 . I 28 Rd. Region Public Bus 7 14 10 3 9 3 4 6 1 57 Uncertain 100 2 4 0 5 I 2 2 3 119 Total Number 402 52 49 20 28 6 21 25 7 610 Walking 144 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 144 Bicycle 159 23 39 36 18 4 0 19 1 299 South of Motocycle 9 S 31 7 0 0 I 6 1 60 Donghuadong Unit Shiit Btis 5 I 2 5 23 2 7 7 3 55 Rd. Region Public Bus 32 17 26 16 8 I 4 16 7 127 Uncertain 254 2 5 8 1 0 1 2 17 290 Total NLrmber 603 48 103 72 50 7 13 50 29 975 Grand Total Person Number 1197 1324 442 216 135 68 59 214 132 3787 r0 Table 2.1.5B: Resident Commuting along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IlIlof GCCTP
Section Way of Commuting WorkingSites(Region) TotalPersons Dongshan Liwan Yuexiu Haizhu Tianhe Fangchun Huangpu Baiyun Other RailwayStation Overpas Walking 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bicycle 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Motorcycle 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 UnitShiftBus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Uncertain 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HuanshizhongRd. Walking 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bicycle 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Motorcycle 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Unit ShiftBus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Uncertain 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 LuhuOverpass Walking 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bicycle 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Motorcycle 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Unit ShiftBus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Uncertain 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass Walking 51 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 51 Bicycle 74 0 55 0 52 0 0 4 0 184 Motorcycle 0 32 27 25 43 61 0 38 0 225 UnitShift Bus 0 0 0 0 0 102 149 67 0 317 Bus 0 46 26 28 31 25 0 0 8 164 Uncertain 25 0 23 0 16 0 0 0 18 82 Sub-total 150 77 131 53 141 187 149 109 26 1024 MeidongOverpass Walking 70 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 70 (eastpart of ZhongshanyBicycle 22 0 29 0 22 0 0 0 0 73 Motorcycle 0 12 10 9 16 22 0 14 0 83 Unit ShiftBus 0 0 0 0 0 14 10 6 0 30 Bus 11 20 8 10 0 8 8 8 4 76 Uncertain 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Sub-total 102 31 47 19 38 45 17 29 4 332 HaiyinnanOverpass Walking 0 0 0 88 0 0 0 0 0 88 Bicycle 13 0 7 9 0 9 0 0 2 39 Motorcycle 14 18 12 9 9 18 5 0 0 85 Unit ShiftBus 0 0 0 0 14 18 21 9 0 62 Bus 9 12 8 6 5 13 0 0 0 52 0 Table 2.1.5B: Resident Commuting along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IlIlof GCCTP
Uncertain 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Sub-total 35 29 27 113 28 58 26 9 2 327 Zhen'anOverpass Walking 0 38 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 45 Bicycle 8 13 15 16 0 19 0 0 0 70 Motorcycle 4 0 0 7 9 13 0 8 0 40 UnitShift Bus 0 0 0 0 10 16 4 21 0 50 Bus 6 7 8 5 0 7 0 9 2 43 Uncertain 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 3 Sub-total 18 58 30 30 18 54 4 39 2 252 RenminBridge Expansio Walking 0 0 0 92 0 0 0 0 0 92 Bicycle 0 47 19 37 0 9 0 0 0 112 Motorcycle 39 22 28 31 45 39 0 0 0 204 UnitShift Bus 0 0 0 10 43 32 0 17 0 102 Bus 39 62 46 117 29 33 0 0 0 326 Uncertain 0 110 46 27 0 0 0 0 0 183 Sub-total 78 241 139 314 117 112 0 17 0 1018 IndustryAvenue Walking 0 0 0 19 0 0 0 0 0 19 Bicycle 0 4 4 7 0 2 0 0 0 16 Motorcycle 3 2 2 4 3 3 0 0 0 17 UnitShift Bus 0 0 0 2 6 8 3 0 0 20 Bus 4 5 5 3 0 5 0 8 0 29 Uncertain 0 5 6 4 0 0 0 0 0 15 Sub-total 7 15 18 39 9 18 3 8 0 117 ShusheOverpass Walking 0 0 0 25 0 0 0 0 0 25 Bicycle 7 3 8 13 0 0 0 0 0 31 Motorcycle 3 4 3 2 3 4 1 0 0 20 Unit ShiftBus 0 0 0 7 12 14 5 11 0 49 Bus 8 15 6 7 6 6 0 9 0 56 Uncertain 17 0 9 16 0 0 0 0 0 42 Sub-total 36 22 26 69 21 23 7 20 0 224 Eastpart of NantianRd. Walking 0 0 0 93 0 0 0 0 0 93 Bicycle 26 45 22 36 0 0 0 0 0 130 Motorcycle 36 47 34 23 30 43 0 0 0 213 UnitShift Bus 0 0 0 0 40 33 32 70 0 176 Bus 39 51 67 48 0 36 0 0 0 241 Uncertain 0 44 30 0 0 0 0 0 74 Sub-total 101 187 123 230 70 112 32 70 0 926 TotalPersons 526 661 542 866 441 608 238 301 33 4218 0 Table 2.1.5C: Resident Commuting along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP
Section Way of Commuting Working Sites (Region) | Total Persons .______Dongshan Liwan Yuexiu Haizhu Tianhe Fangchun Huangpu Baiyun Other Liu'ersanRd. & HuangshaA Walking 0 329 63 0 0 0 0 0 0 392 Bicycle 73 110 128 134 0 165 0 0 0 609 Motorcycle 31 0 0 59 77 111 0 70 0 348 Unit ShiftBus 0 0 0 0 83 135 35 183 0 435 Bus 48 59 67 41 0 59 0 81 15 370 Uncertain 0 0 0 22 0 0 0 0 0 22 Sub-total 153 498 257 256 159 470 35 334 15 2176 HengfuRd. Walking 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bicycle 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Motorcycle 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 UnitShift Bus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bus 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Uncertain 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Sub-total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. Walking 0 0 0 28 0 0 0 0 0 28 Bicycle 0 5 6 10 0 3 0 0 0 25 Motorcycle 5 3 4 6 4 5 0 0 0 27 UnitShift Bus 0 0 0 4 9 12 5 0 0 30 Bus 6 7 8 5 0 7 0 12 0 44 Uncertain 0 8 10 6 0 0 0 0 0 23 Sub-total 11 23 28 59 13 27 5 12 0 178 Middle& West Partsof Nant Walking 0 0 0 208 0 0 0 0 0 208 Bicycle 61 29 69 106 0 0 0 0 0 265 Motorcycle 27 36 24 19 24 31 10 0 0 170 UnitShift Bus 0 0 0 58 100 116 46 96 0 416 Bus 66 123 47 61 52 47 0 76 0 472 Uncertain 147 0 79 133 0 0 0 0 0 359 Sub-total 301 188 219 585 176 194 56 171 0 1889 TotalPerson Number 465 709 504 899 348 691 96 517 15 4243 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 11 Final Report
2.1.5.3 Analysis
1. Since the resettlement sites are in Fangcun district, Baiyun district and Haizhu district, there are different impacts on the commuting time in different sites. As soon as the resettlement sites are well selected, the commuting time of some dwellers will be shortened. 2. To the 348 persons who use motorcycles or buses owned by units to go to work, their commuting time will not be changed. 3. To the 3439 persons with other commuting ways, the commuting time will be changed as follows:
PresentLiving WorkingSite ResettlementSites Commuting Time Changed Zone Persons Liwan Guocun 631 Increased Huangsha Yuexiu Xiaogangwan 94 No-changing Others Tongde, 246 Decreased Liwan Guocun 176 Increased Xichang Yuexiu Xiaogangwan 29 No-changing Interchange Others Tongde,Baiyun 73 Decreased Garden. GuangYuan Liwan BaiyunGarden 384 Increased Interchange Yuexiu Xiaogangwan 141 No-changing Others Tongde 237 Decreased Dongshan Xiaogangwan 386 Increased North of Yuexiu,Tianhe, Baiyun,Tongde, 86 No-changing Donghuadong Rd. Huangpu Dongpu Others Guocun 96 Decreased Dongshan Xiaogangwan 589 Increased South of Yuexiu,Tianhe, Baiyun,Tongde, 102 No-changing Donghuadong Rd. Huangpu Dongpu Others G uocun 169 Decreased
Note: The details of resettlement site are given in section 2.2
Shownias the above table: Due to the relocation, there are 2166 persons whose commuting time will be increased, with 57.20% of the total persons. There are 800 persons whose commuting time will not be changed, with 21.2% of the total. There are 821 persons whose commuting time will be shortened, covering 21.68% of the total. Because of transferring to other schools, the commuting time of the students will not be affected.
2.1.6 Vulnerable Groups
The vulnerable groups refer to the following households such as poor households, single-parent households and the households of the old without living with the adult sons/daughters. There are 67 households of the vulnerable groups (2 households are not only poor but also single-parent; 9 hiouseholdsare not only poor but also the old without living with adult sons/daughters). hese )householdswill receive specific care. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 12 Final Report
C Note: There is not any conflict of 67 households of the vulnerable groups and the 37 poor households, 41 households which are single-parent or old without living with adult sons/daughters, it is overlapping of single item.
2.1.7 Analysis of Benefit and Loss
1. All the relocated housing are of reinforced concrete structure. The average living space will be more than 5 m2/person. With well equipped basic facilities of the kitchens, toilets and balconies. The housing will have areas increased. 2. As far as the living space and the basic civic facilities are concerned, there are 376 households with 1751 persons who are great improved, 1149 households with 3675 persons who are largely improved, 230 households with 810 persons who are generally improved. 3. As far as the structure of dwelling houses are concerned, there are 1544 households with 5405 persons who will transfer from the dim and unsafe mixed structure and the post & panel structure to the light and safe houses of reinforced concrete structure. 4. Commuting situations of dwellers will be affected by moving into different places. 5. The special national policies of employment decide that the affected persons will not lose their jobs due to the change of the living places. 6. We will give specific care to the vulnerable groups and resettle them in the resettlement sites near downtown (Haijing Guarden, namely, Yuan'an Str., and Nan'an Building).
2.1.8 Conclusion
I . The living situations in China are difficult now, and the resettlement for the ImnerRing Road Project will improve the living situations and living environment of the affected persons in great extent, and quicken the steps of implementation of the dwelling house construction and planning. The resettlement plan is a scheme emphasizing on the improvement of the living environment in developing countries.
2. Although some movement will have great impacts on the commuting and recreation activities of dwellers in a short time, these will be rapidly improved, attained or exceeded the original levels. All the resettlement sites are in the living zones of the Guangzhiou municipal master planning. They are constructed in accordance with the residential zoning planlling of 21 st century in China, in which there are perfect basic civil facilities such as education, recreation. medical treatment, municipal and public utilities, gardens & lawns, environmental sanitation. With the implementation of Gungzhou City Centre Transport Projects and Guangzhou City Transport Planning, these resettlement sites will be located near the places of the municipal high-speed/expressway transport system. Shortages produced by the distance will be improved greatly in near future.
0 IRRResettlement Implementation Plan 13 Final Report
O 2 2.2 Descriptionof ResidentialResettlement Sites
2.2.1 Xiaoguangwan Quarter
2.2.1.1 Location
1. It locates in the west of the 40m radical road Dongxiao Rd, between Dongyue and Xiyue of Shaxi, near the south of Industry Ave.. 2. Distance to the booming area: In the north, there is a planned road straight to booming Jiangnan Ave.(about 4 km.). There are many living quarters under developing around it. It is a new type of living quarter for selling about low density and key development in Guangzhou municipal planning. 3. Distance to the demolished area: It distances 3.5km from the zone of south of Donghuadong and 4km from the zone of north of Donghuadong . 4. Time to the demolished area: It takes 15 minutes to go to the zone of south of Donghuadong and about 20 minutes to go to the zone of north of Donghuadong by bus. It respectively will take about 12 minutes and 17 minutes to go to the above two zones after Inner Ring Road being constructed.
2.2.1.2 Transport Conditions
I . There are five bus routes (the two terminals inside Xiaoguangwan) to Beijing Rd., Nangfang Building, Baiyun Rd., Guangzhou Railway Station. 2. After the construction of the planned road and the living quarters around it, the transport will be very convenient.
2.2.1.3 Surrounding Public Facilities
I . Hospital: There are 4 hospitals within the scope of 3km, Zhujiang Hospital, Oral Cavity Hospital, No.2 of Guangzhou Hospitals and Shixi Chinese Hospital( only 1 km distance). 2. School: There are No. 45 Middle School within the scope of 1km, Luibao primary school only 500m. 3. The market of daily life commodities & agricultural products lies Ikm from the Quarter. 4. Shops: There are one of the most booming commerce zone in Guangzhou (Middle of Jiangnan Ave.) within the scope of 4km, Nanfeng Shop, Haizhu Business Center.
2.2.1.4 Planning of Quarter
I. Scale: The land is about 250 thousand m2 . The floor area are 600 thousand m2 , including 70 multi-floor buildings(50 have been built), 15 high rise buildings with 30 floors. All the quarter will be completed in the 1997. 2. Quarter Basic living facilities a. Medical treatment: No. 2 Guangzhou Hospital will set branch. b. School: The primary school will be handed to use in the end of 1997. c. Entertainment Center: The large business groups came into the quarter in May, 1996.. d. Other Living Facilities: There are markets, post offices and gas pipelines. e. Property management: The company of property management will be responsible for Q clearing,management and protection ,_t 'J L-t --
2 ) U" SIlrn\tUnDtilI 2 .2.2. 1.1 t s =JZ - x A5 4 FIGURE 2.2.1.1 Distribution Figule of Resident Resettlement Sites of ,§ I\ -; l ,x,,ln.!ty ,,/., . , { the IRR(PIJASE ~~~1,11) 57.v... }
JI'~~~~~~~~~J ! t . tkxl-lr 1t28 4 FR { j~ ~ ~~~~p *'. *~i j~ ti~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i
*B',' VI, sSp' w t fIiA,1 *:
t i \a 11i'iQo Lt ) r r~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I Y r d c (
< j¢"(lQl.:mrterwu,>, tMino. Rod.,cangS;t i: _~sssI 'g~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A N.:5_~ p,., t,ijaangzhouha;hea Shahef 1 'S0 i ryviw~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ibh ' Ii 1 at Centre rshait Mernorm,lHall *O V
Zhong' * ' i 1 J~X'mno;k Gongyus an - wii YUg~tanc',n \ Changho &jg Jt ZoGuang2h
e""iu,eI -Iinl Huananlu s .Guioctin Qu!rterigiunliai IZIxIU
HU~~~dIW8.1~ ~ ~ ~~ Zhonestia~~P" R-1 1`11, SI.pdpO Xinho AltsZhoesh," U... vers(nzht,De,o v .ept -j -. I 1--1%PK' n A f ! I PEARL
Guangzhou Iron, &sieel Plant
\-- a m~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~2.2.1.3 IPflPAtt4AR-Sa14i JMtjj FIGORE 2.2.1.3 Xiaognngwan Overall LayoutFigure
%111~~~~~~~~~* "00 3400 2400 3400 II00l
Cl - C6
3700 2900 290 370
02 X S 2X;t -
Sfo ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'u IS 0 04 05~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~?04 03
[-11 X ~m If 0e S
03'.P <=TWl 0 6 {, A1-3, A 04 L~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ M rrr1D 0 ___ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~05
3400~~ 3900 3400~' 2400 Al-3, A5 F.~L~ii
3 3 0 B 200 B 4200 4500 1Y7
~~~~~~~~ ~ ~~,03 w n ga ng Xia o 2 .1 U R E FI G 0
ELI07~~ '9" 2. 1.4 HMAR n
4SIO 100 100 9,00 ~~~~~~~~~~FIGURE2.2.1.4 Xiaogangwan Room Specification Figure '3
rompA ismilicI Mtti 4ift f, a r t a
Ar :10 r' if J' t_ A I A st=ft
n iow ......
J It C. iti I AL ..4
son as. S=APEKR 'X :Jr..
ivw
Ili4Ci !-, -7
vv-
ii M
RM4
41
T#
4l
O*pg
*Ab It ma-5,
44 EY; MK: mvir im
2. 2. 2. 2 %#4N 9-if ig Location Figure FIGURE k2.2.2 Guocun Quarter Detailed ...... ---F-- --v- *1 - --11-..' '''''''-- -IfMJ ...... \2 . DA1...------/ t>20 |ISteaS~~~7 IRRResettlement Implementation Plan 14 Final Report
O 2.2.1.5 Quarter Prospects: With the development of economic in Guangzhou, more and more will choose to avoid the crowded downtown. The development of the Xiaogangwan Quarter and other quarters around it, is fitting for the demand for Guangzhou's people. Its location is very convenient: near the city centre and has good environment, distance to Panyu Bridge and Luoxi Bridge is 1.5km and Ikm. There are 3 key highways nearby, it is very convenient to Panyu, Shunde . It will be a high standard and pre-level zone with convenient transport, existing working places and perfectly equipped facilities.
2.2.1.6 Location of the Quarter
Location of the Quarter is shown in Figure 2.2.1.1 (details are shown in Figure 2.2.1.2), specific arrangement in Figure 2.2.1.3 (including 4 individual quarters) room specification (temporarily regulated) in Figure 2.2.1.4.
2.2.2 Guocun Quarter
2.2.2.1 Location
I. It locates between the Inner Ring Road and South Ring Expressway and in the north of Fangcun District in Guangzhou, which crosses the nearby 50m- wide Fangcun Ave. . It connects with Foshan City very conveniently. 2. Distance to the booming area: It lies in the 3km place from the center of Fangcun zone and only 4km from the center of Liwan District, Zhongshanba Rd. and Shangxiajiu Rd.. 3. Distance to the demolished area: It distances 5-6km from Huangsha zones and 3-4km from Xichang Interchange zones . 4. Time to the demolished area: It takes 15 minutes to go to Huangsha Zone, about 10 minutes to go to Xichang Interchange and about 15 minutes by bus. It respectively will take about1 0 minutes, 5 minutes and 10 minutes to go to the above three zones after Inner Ring Road being constructed.
2.2.2.2 Transport Conditions
I. There are three bus routes (the two terminals inside Guocun Quarter) within the scope of 500m from Guocun Quarter to Zhongshanba Rd., Dongfengdong Rd., Renmin Rd., Guangzhou Railway Station. 2. After No.1 line of Subway is built in 1998 , Guanggang Subway station(distanlceto Guocun Quarter 2.5km) will be a large transport hub of Guangzhou railway & road , which has 15 public routes, I vehicle terminal, 10 coach terminals and be the west-passenger station of Guangzhou-Zhuhai Railway in 2000 as well as be the merging station of Guangfu Light-Rail Railway and Guangzhou Subway.
2.2.2.3 Surrounding Public Facilities
I. Hospital: There are two large scale of worker hospitals owned by Guangzhou Producing Ship Plant and Guangzhou Iron-Steel Plant within the scope of 3km. Fangcun Zone's hospital lies 2km from Guocun Quarter. 2. Middle School: There are Peiying Middle School, Zhenguang Middle School and Jindao 0J . Middle...... Schoolnewly-built within the scope of 2km. 0 0~~
309q-4 f-4"" i N" I000I I I
o~~~~~~~~~w110~I 4-5 00 30+200 000 3°-1- °1- 4500) 1 3COO000 4500 24D1300 d 32
___ _ I I IC I 1D|lD300' 0CO|4SOXO 5O 13013010O A1 QO
00o 0101 IS50 34.ao 33 3(o soIlo311001 301001001 3300 9 3CWI00 I3300i2 llll
i S 2. 2. 2.4 _8JEfi
XtTt. e0 e d______4 . - . . IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 15 Final Report
3. The market of daily life commodities & agricultural products lies lkm from the Quarter. 0<_)4. Other kinds of entertainmentfacilities are within the scope of 3km. 2.2.2.4 Planning of Quarter
1. Scale: The land is about 55096 m2. The total floor area is 137740 m2, in which the area of residential housing is 96044 m2 (high-rise residential housing: 56577 m2, multi-floor housing: 39467 m2). The area for business and other facilities is 41900 m2. Note: high rise housing means buildings above 9 floors; multi-floor housing means buildings under 9 floors(including 9 floors) 2. Quarter Basic living facilities a. Primary School: It covers an floor area of 3800 m2, with the occupied land of 6500 m2 (accommodating 24 classes about one thousand students, being completed in Oct., 1997). b. Kindergarten: It covers an floor area of 1500 m2, with the occupied land of 1500 m2 (accommodating 8 classes about 300 students, being completed in Oct., 1997). c. Market: The built-up area is 31900 m22 . d. Neighborhood Committee: the floor area is 300 m2. e. Entertainment Center: The built-up area is 1500 m2. f. Other Living Facilities: The floor area is 400 m2. g. Parking Lot: The floor area is 2352.41 m2 . h. Central Park & Green Belt: The area is 13000 m2.
2.2.2.5 Quarter Prospects:
Guocun Quarter is a special quarter for solving the resettlement of the IRR by GREEO, locates in Dongsha Economic Developing Zone, which is the comprehensive economic developing zone approved by Guangzhou Municipal Government. It will be a new economic zone concerning with Guangzhou modem constructing metropolis, stepping after Tianhe Hi-Tech Industry Developing Zone and Guangzhou Economic Technology Developing Zone, and will be an open-door of Guangzhou going through Pearl River Delta. It will provide lots of working chances for residents in Guocun Quarter. It will be a high standard and pre-level zone with convenient transport, existing working places and perfectly equipped facilities.
2.2.2.6 Location of the Quarter
Location of the Quarter is shown in Figure 2.2.1.1 (details are shown in Figure 2.2.2.2), specific arrangement in Figure 2.2.2.3, room specification (temporarily regulated) in Figure 2.2.2.4.
2.2.3 Tongde Quarter
2.2.3.1 Location
I. It lies between the Inner Ring Road and the North Ring Expressway, and in the southwest of Tongdewei Zone, near the 40m wide Xiwan Rd.. 2. Distance from the booming area: It lies in 2.5km away from Huanshixi Rd. and 4km away Qn from the Railway Station. , ?2.2. 3.2 it 4N (if__s / ~~~~~~~FIGURE2.2.3.2 Tongde Q'uarter DetailedLocation Figure
-~~ P~Tongde I
Z4. zfn '-)\~Ym-a~aa M~'
/~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~41 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 16 Final Report
3. Distance from the demolished area: It is 2-3km away from GuangYuan Zone, 4-5km away from Xichang and 10-1 1km away from the north of Donghuadong Rd.. 4. Time to the demolished area: It takes about 10 minutes to go to GuangYuan Zone by bus, about 15 minutes to go to Xichang Interchange, about 35 minutes to go to the north of Donghuadong Rd.. It will take separately about 6 minutes, 8 minutes and 20 minutes to the above three zones after the Inner Ring Road being completed.
2.2.3.2 Transport Conditions
1. There are the three bus stations of Route No. 17, No. 212 and No.228 within the scope of around 300m of the quarter to Huanshixi Rd. and Guangzhou Railway Station, etc.. 2. Before 1998, there will be three more bus routes to the around downtown of Tongde Quarter.
2.2.3.3 Surrounding Public Facilities
There are following public facilities: schools, hospitals, shops and other public facilities within the scope of 2km.
2.2.3.4 Planning of the Quarter
I. Scale: TongdeYuan will be submitted to use before June 1998. The floor area is 250 thousand m 2 . 2. Basic living Facilities TongdeYuan is the center of Tongde quarter. There are a middle school, a primary school and two nurseries, stadiums, hospitals and fairs, etc.
The facilities are given as follows: a. Market: The floor area is about 20 thousand m2 . b. Cinema: The floor area is about 150 m2 . c. Post & Telecommunication: The floor area is about 450 m2. d. Bookshop: The floor area is about 100 m2 . e. Entertainment Centre: The floor area is about 1400 m2. f. Underground Parking Lot: The floor area is about 540 m2. g. Bicycle Parking Lot: The floor area is about 1500 m2. h. Neighborhood Committee: The floor area is about 109 m2 . i. Central Park & Greenland: The area is about 5200 m2.
2.2.3.5 Quarter Prospects
Tongdewei in construction has an floor area of 14000 thousand m2. 50 multi-storied dwelling houses have been built about 1000 thousand m2. There are quite a few multi-function groups, including commercial and residential zone, resettlement zone for subway demolition, resettlement zone for impoverishment, resettlement zone for teachers. The population will amount to about 200 thousand in the future. All kinds of the auxiliary facilities set up in succession will supply a good circumstance of living, entertainment and study. It takes only 15 minutes to go to the urban centre by bus. The coming Inner Ring Road locating in the scope of about 1.5km, will be much convenient for shift.
2.2.3.6 Location of the Quarter O 0
The 30m Wide PlanningRd.
U\
C~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ cli ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~c~
lI 2. 2. 3.33Ji.4tjf FIGIJIIE 2.2.3.3 Tongde Quarter Overall Layout Figure o 0
1* ~~ ~ ~~~~~~~0908
-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1 13 12<4 ft~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~T
>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Lm' o0
ATr '' 07 -- ; - (3 E 1
v 1 > 1 8 8 si03 04 05 006
-t' H I ere ' I e 88,,_f O
20XY0,2fs2tYZ S 2. 2. 3.4 HAE
I,lels 1 1i1i;. lI,;lih,',-d I,;ll?I.I I,frM.i7sIThflMs l;IGURE 2.2.3.4 t .t TongdeJI. l, Quarter Room Specification Figure IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 17 Final Report
0 The undergroundlocation of the quarter is shown in Figure2.2.1.1, the details in Figure 2.2.3.1, overall arrangement in Figure 2.2.3.2, room specifications (temporarily regulated) in Figure 2.2.3.3.
2.2.4 Baiyun Garden
2.2.4.1 Location
1. It lies in the west of New Guangchong Road and in the section of Meifu Garden. Looking from east, there is Baiyun Mountain. It is near the south of the Huangshi Road. 2. It reach the centre straight by through New Guangchong Road, Guangchong Road or Airport Road, distancing only 6km away from railway station. It takes about 10 minutes to go to Tongxi Road and the centre of Huanshi Road by bus. So There is very convenient transport. 3. Distance away from the demolished area: It lies in about 8km away from GuangYuan Interchange zone, about I Okm away from the north of Donghuadong Road and from the south of Donghuadong Road. 4. Time to the demolished area: It takes about 20 minutes to go to GuangYuan Interchange zone, about 30 minutes to go to the north of Donghuadong Road, about 35 minutes to go to the south of Donghuadong Road. It will takes 15-20 minutes to go to the above areas after the Inner Ring Road being completed.
2.2.4.2 Transport Conditions
I1. There are many bus stations straight to Tongxi Road, Railway Station, Guangwei Road and Panfu Road within the scope of 5Om in Baiyun Garden. 2. It closely links with the periphery expressway of Guangzhou, and is convenient to go to Shenzhen, Fuoshan, Huadu and Chonghua, etc..
2.2.4.3 Surrounding Public Facilities
1. Hospital: There are many commune hospitals, clinics, medical treatment & medicine shops around. 2. School: There are Huangshi Middle School, Female Masha Middle School and Guangzhou Foreign Language College nearby. 3. Fair for Agricultural Products, Market and other Facilities: There are meat & vegetable shops, grain & oil shops, department stores, restaurant, banks, post offices around.
2.2.4.4 Planning of the Quarter
1. Scale: Baiyun Garden covers 150 thousand m2 , witll floor area of 250 tlhousand m2 . The area of green land is 46.84% of the total. 2. Basic living facilities a. School: There are some basic living facilities such as a primary school (6000 m2). a kindergarten (2000 m2 ) and two nurseries (total 800 m2 ). b. Hospital: Besides some healthy facilities will be built, there will be a public health branch(100 0 _i m 2 ), a commune hospital(200 m2 ) and a shop of Chinese Traditional Medicine & West ta e X - 4 E 11 S ~~2. 2. 4. 2 t2M FIGURE 2.2.4.2 Baiyun Garden Detailed Location Figure
O2 2 R V X ,: Lighl rail line 2 Depot:
Dongguancun The euT a~~~~~~~~~~~~tf
g jId I - - /7/t
41,~ ~~aStton2g
- )~~~~pngrii,an ehan
L .L
/~~~~~~~~~~~~~ego-- :W~~~~~~~~n" .7~~~~~~~~~~~~ay
~~~~19*C
-,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~h ~~~~~~~~~~J~~~~~~~~~Pie~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~TU¶ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~!f 2.2.4.3 u ,lM FIGURE 2.2.4.3 Baiyun Garden OverallLayout Figure
+'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I
_I_ _ _ 0 0 I~32.2.4.4 0 *. 1 ;X- m------I| -. .±.FIGlIRE 2.2.4.4 BIaiyun Garden Room Specification Figure
' I- ' I I l I 1_ _ 0 Ml t wo:.Om
, ...: _ ~..._ .I,;0A* R t lni~1"z " 0_tiozolt 1. * tP I: 8~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ t e 60 .o 36°l0000 * 0Z9t 2005 w~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 40o55 574_15.79 I ftIIA N 11 ff 1E1m:C A N! ft T 41A Ell lig ^* dU'-l 1It90, I -'- T t l l ot T - l m M S ' . 55-70 S58 I S 55 .. ,^ 40U5U 57415.00 u9 . __ ...... ,t (fi h '!."st 418h Sel i oi il, 30Dtt98 210 I, ,! i lif1 1: 4,i.ifl ,-:l: I1r. 'tlli ;1;. I ibi I I'1Gl ( ',. t; 'tt F! 1; ,b: 141 7F 2/13 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 18 Final Report Medicine, a comprehensive hospital which will be cooperative supervised by Xiehe 0J Hospital of Hongkongand a first level hospitalin Guangzhou. It will ensures that the residents of Baiyun Garden enjoy advanced, urgent and convenient medical treatment services and health services. c. Entertainment: There are a cinema, culture housing, culture station, gam station, swimming pool, park and many other facilities of physical culture and entertainment inside Baiyun Garden. d. Communication: There are some telecommunication/postal service administration and service sites such as the telecommunication station and the post office. e. Public security: The fire protection station, the policy station, the neighborhood committee will be set up in order to ensure a good social environment inside Baiyun Garden. f. Transport: There are the additional four bus routes to straight go to Yuexiu Park, Railway Station, Dashatou and Airport, etc.. 2.2.4.5 Baiyun Garden Prospects It is near the beautiful Baiyun Mountain, locating inside the Developing Region of Travel and Holiday of the South Lake. There is a good environment around such as air clear, no noise and beautiful scene. It is an unified dwelling houses zone with multi-function (convenient transport, commercial service, residential housing and perfectly equipped services ). It is looked forward to living for modern metropolis persons. The location of Baiyun Garden is shown in Figure 2.2.1.1. The details is seen in Figure 2.2.4.1, specific arrangement in Figure 2.2.4.2, room formats (temporarily regulated) in Figure 2.2.4.3. 2.2.5 Dongpu Quarter 2.2.5.1 Location 1. It lies in Dongpu town of Tianhe district, locates between the 50m radical road Zhollgslhan Ave. and Huangpu Ave., nearby the Huangnan Ave.(under construction). 2. Distance to the booming area: It lies in the 3km place from the center of new city zone: Zhujian New City, Tianhe Sport Center, Teem Plazas and East Railway Station of Guangzhou. 3. Distance to the demolished area: It distances 5 km from Donghuadong zones and 7km from east section of north ring and the east section of south ring. . 4. Time to the demolished area: It takes 20 minutes to go to east ring, about 30 minutes to go to east section of north ring and the east section of south ring by bus. It respectively will take about 15 minutes, 20 minutes to go to the above zones after Inner Ring Road being constructed. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 19 Final Report O . 2.2.5.2 TransportConditions I. There are seven bus routes within the scope of 500m from Dongpu Quarter to the center of Tianhe District, Dongshan District and Yuexiu District. 2. With the construction of Hua'nan Ave. and Zhujiang New City, the transport condition will be more convenient. 2.2.5.3 SurroundingPublic Facilities 1. Hospital: There are No.3 Hospital of Zhongshan Medicine University, Attached Hospital of Ji'nan University within the scope of 3km. Dongpu hospital lies 1.5km from the Quarter. 2. School: There are 3 universities: South China University of Technology(SCUT), South China Moral and Education University(SCMEU), Ji'nan University; 5 Schools: Attached School of SCUT, Attached School of SCMEC, Attached School of Ji'nan University. No.13 Middle School and No.59 Middle School and some primary schools. 3. Markets: There are Dongpu market of daily life commodities & agricultural products and No. 3 market of agricultural products with the scope of I km from the Quarter. 4. Shops: There are Shipai Shop with the scope of 1km, and the Teem Plazas are within the scope of 3km. 2.2.5.4 Planning of Quarter 1. Scale: The land is about 50000 m2 . The total floor area is 200000 m2 . in whicih the area of residential housing is 160,000 m2. The area for business and other facilities is 40000 rn2. 2. Quarter Basic living facilities a. Primary School: It covers an floor area of 4500 m2, with the occupied land of 5000 ni b. Kindergarten: It covers an floor area of 2800 m2 , with the occupied land of 3000 111-. c. Market: The floor area is 26300 m2 . d. Neighborhood Committee: the floor area is 200 m2. e. Entertainment Center: The floor area is 1000 mi2 . f. Post offices: The floor area is 200 m2. g. Market: The floor area is 5000 m2 . 2.2.2.5 Quarter Prospects Dongpu Quarter lies in Tianhe District which is the main direction of city development witlh the eastward movement of city center and the construction of Zhujiang New City. it will provide lots of working chances for residents in Dongpu Quarter. It will be a high standard and pre-level zone with convenient transport, existing working places and perfectly equipped facilities. Chp. ~ ~~~~~FUICURE2.2.5.2 Dongpu Quarter Detailed Location Figure rt -t~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~b~ IRth 0:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ icha~~~~~~~~" ;1jz~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 20 Final Report O\ 2.2.6 Nan'an Road Building 2.2.6.1 Location 1. It lies in the skirt of the Nan'an Road, near the wide 50m Inner Ring Road. 2. Distance from the booming area: It is about 5km away from Railway Station, and merely 500m away from Zhongshanba Road in the center. 3. Distance from the demolished area: It is about 3km away from Huangsha area, about 2km away from GuangYuan area and about I km away from Xichang Interchange. 4. Time to the demolished area: It takes about 10 minutes to go to GuangYuan area, about 5 minutes to go to Xichang Interchange and about 15 minutes to go to Huangsha area. It will separately take about 8 minutes, 4 minutes and 10 minutes to go the above three zones. 2.2.6.2 Transport Conditions It lies by the Inner Ring Road. It is a transport hub of the center with convenient transport. There are bus stations nearby such as Xijiao Bus Station, Guangzhou Coach Station and Guangfu Bus Station, etc. 2.2.6.3 Surrounding public facilities It closely nears to the centre, well equipped with all kinds of auxiliary facilities. C) 2.2.6.4 Scale I. All the buildings are available to the users, with the floor area of 45000 m2 . 2. Basic civic facilities: a. Market: The floor area is about 8000 m2 . b. Residential Committee: The area is 80 m2. c. Other Living Facilities: The floor area is 300 mn2 . d. Parking Lot: The area is 6000 m2 . 2.2.7 Haijing Garden (Yuan'an Street Quarter) 2.2.7.1 Location I . It lies in the south side of Haiyin Bridge in the centre, close to the 50m wide IRR. 2. Distance from the demolished area: It lies about I km away from the south of Donghuadong Road and about 2km away from the north of Donghuadong Road. 3. Time to the demolished area: It takes about 3 minutes to go to the southl of Donghluadong Rd., about 5 minutes to go to the north of Donghuadong Rd.. 2.2.7.2 Transport Conditions It lies nearby the Inner Ring Road, locating at the transport hub line of linkage of the centre with the two banks of Zhujiang River, with convenient transport. 0 C.--- X :- , :! g 2. 2. 6. 2 Location Figure 2.2.6.2 Nan'an Road Building Detailed -& uFIGUREL -- ~ -\ N-- ti::D~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~C + %8 . , it\ A i N1t 71RA N. it _~ 8^ - 's ; "' r s / - - ;- o _ i b tv Pl ~~~~~~~.j e-N = -;_t_ - + t~- nt;*.. 1*r1;i,1~ N7 -t- URt -) tt gUsc~ ~ ~~~~~~-~ . ,, - -~. -it~~~~~~~~~~~~~t .*~~~~~~~~~4 ' -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Z N. 4OF~ ~~~~* ~~~~~~~~~iii~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0 0 0 ~~~~~~~0~ N ,0 IWO 1600160 2600IWO 360 Iw 100 f i t O 160 Ijo 160 Iwo 1100 ffi Ao i 9!L 1 r E - ITF bt anFIG1JR2.2.6.3 Nan'an Rd. BuildingRoom Specificstion Figure M.2...... 2 6 3 fl 3 9 4:: , ;^ S2. 2. 7. 1 X g , i j;: Figur( HIaijing GuardenDetailed Location =% (X)m~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~---~rl XW X~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~_ _~~~0E f ,: '.+ ,,,. Ft R~~ ~ ~~~a (D u '^::.>!r._W_~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A -- [ W f ,-- t9KFFt j4A-zcFlS 81 8t # =;-20 t <, (->~ 18rls-Wz*tFFgZt!'24!- ;1|{-"!! ~/ Elirll. l~Tllq;FEA *ltz4E!gRtllSkFiS, S;;F7W1|. *_, > r <3¢> \ / H. ij ingGarde ll 3Et45fXttE _ +,il-.,, : > ;_- Pt1s/ ,^P~_is' CiVm.! c-. X0LA. <~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A .0. .17 ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~9 33EZ as,~~~~~~~~~~ 9P 9 9~~~~~~~~~~~~qc IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 21 Final Report It is well equippedwith the public facilitiesaround, within the scope of I km, such as medical treatment facilities, schools, kindergartens, fairs of agricultural products, large whole-sale markets, electric fairs and entertainment facilities. 2.2.7.3 Planning of quarter 1. Scale: The land is about 18855 m2 . The total floor area is 66585 m 2 , in which the area of resident houses is 42016 m2 .(high rise buildings: 28338 m2, multi-floor houses: 13678 m 2 ). The area for business and other facilities is 24569 m2 2. Basic civic facilities: a. Playing room of primary school: 350 m2 b. Nursery: 500 m2 c. Neighborhood committee, Cultural facilities: 100 m2 d. Public toilet.: 100 m2 e. Business: 22985 m2 f. Green area: 3869 m2 2.2.7.4 Quarter Prospects It is an advanced resident quarter locating in downtown. The location of Haijing Garden is shown in Figure 2.2.1.1. The details is seen in Figure 2.2.71, specific arrangement in Figure 2.2.7.2. 2.2.8 Decoration of the above Housing and Administration of the Quarters 2.2.8.1 Decoration The houses with reinforced concrete structure will be decorated with the second category of the first class. The outer wall is decorated with the mosaics, and the inner wall is decorated withi the supper latex paints. Grounds of the kitchen and toilet are decorated with smooth-proofed ceramic tiles, and walls below 1.5m with ceramic tiles . Grounds of the room and the lounge are decorated with cement, leaving the position for the telephone cables and the cable TV connections. 2.2.8.2 Administration of the quarter 2.2.9 Housing Space Available Dec. 1997 June 1998 April 1999 Feb. 2000 Total Floor Area(m ) Xiaogangwan 25000 25000 80000 130000 Guocun 20000 10000 23000 53000 Tongde 34000 34000 Baiyun 50000 20000 107000 100000 277000 Dongpu 0 0 80000 80000 Nan'an 3000 0 3000 Haicheng(Yuan'an 1000 0 1000 Street) Total 99000 89000 210000 180000 579000 IRRResettlement Implementation Plan 22 Final Report Q Notes: 1) Thearea aboveinclude that of residences,shops and necessary attachments. 2) This table only reflectsthe housingspace availableof the 7 resettlementsites for each phase beforethe civil work of the IRR. It doesn't refer to the optionsof the resettlementsites for PAPs of eachphase. To ensurethere are 3 optionsfor eachPAP of eachphase, the resettlementhousing amountof the aboveresettlement sites is a little largerthan the demand. 2.3 Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures 2.3.1 General Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures 2.3.1.1 All the affected households will be relocated to the 7 resettlement sites mentioned above. Before November, 1997, the GREEO and the developers need to complete the construction of the resettlement housing in accordance with the planning of quarters, and to accomplish the municipal and public facilities such as road, water & power, communication facilities and the basic civic facilities such as education, sanitation, business, gardens/parks, recreation. Making the affected persons adjust in the relocated houses as soon as they move into the resettlement housing is a requirement. 2.3.1.2 The users of dwelling houses can receive the compensation for the houses and related compensation. I . Resettlement Standards include the method to calculate the housing area, the population and the rent, etc.. 2. Other related compensations include temporarily relocation payment, the payment for moving and the compensation for the facilities in the houses, etc.. 2.3.1.3 The owner of housing title can gain the housing compensation and other related compensation. I . The housing compensation standards include the compensation standards of exchanging property rights and the standards of relinquishing property rights. 2. Other related compensation include the compensation for garden, courtyard, patio and other attachments. 3. The affected persons who are both users and owner can receive the above 2 compensations. 4. The above resettlement policies and compensation standards are shown in Resettlement Policy 5. 2.3.2 Supplement to the General Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures I . Compensation for affected houses and buildings to be compensated in cash will be paid at local replacement rates without depreciation. In the zones of Huangsha and Xichang Interchange, the floor area will be compensated at 3000 Yuan/m2. In GuangYuan zone, it will be compensated at 3200 Yuan/ m2. In the zones of the south and the north of Donghuadong Road, it will be compensated at 3600 Yuan/ m2 2. The floor area will be compensated at 1500 Yuan/ m2 if the affected households who rent houses owned by government or overseas Chinese give up resettlement. 3. Land of the affected patio, courtyards and gardens will be compensated at 50 percents of the replacement rates. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 23 Final Report 4. The affected enclosing walls, flower pools and other attachments will be paid at the present (J cost of constructionwithout depreciation. 5. The local school must receive the affected persons' children who require to transfer, and the expenses will be paid by the GREEO. 6. If the affected persons don't want the moving fee to move by themselves, the GREEO will send vehicles and workers to move for them. 7. Vacation of 2 days will be given by the units if the affected persons move their houses. The compensation of 50 Yuan will be paid for their deducted wages because of moving houses. 8. The households with the old above 65 (or sick, cripples) will be relocated in the houses less than 5-floor. 9. The compensation of cost difference will be paid to the affected persons for the higher fitting-up standards than their resettlement housing. With ensurance of safety, the materials demolished by the affected persons will be owned by themselves. 2.3.3 Special Rehabilitation Measures for the Vulnerable Groups Besides the resettlement standards and rehabilitation measures which are shown in the section 2.3.1 and 2.3.2, the vulnerable groups will be entitled as follows: I. They will be resettled in two urban quarters (Haicheng Garden and Nan'an Building), unless they would like to choose other sites. 2. Although their original living sites is the same grade as the resettlement sites, they will receive an area-extension coefficient (only different grades of urban quarters have the area- extension coefficient according to the laws, shown in the Chapter 5 of the Resettlement Policy for the details). 3. The poor households will manage shops to self-rely through being resettled in the first floor( If there are such kinds of shelters). 2.3.4 Resettlement of the Affected Persons without Residential Registration Certificates 1. They will remove with the local residents living with them. 2. To the affected persons without residential registration certificates who were arranged by their units in the legal houses to be demolished, the units will receive payment for housing- compensations from the GREEO. The affected units must resettle these persons in resettlement housing or other houses, and the resettlement sites are as same as the general households'. 3. To the affected persons who are arranged by the unit in the temporary or illegal structures to be demolished, the unit will be responsible for the resettlement. Because of their necessity for their units, the units must resettle them. 4. To the affected persons without residential registration certificates who rent houses at market price(high rent), the GREEO will give the housing compensation to the owner. The affected persons without residential registration certificates can opt for keeping the leases with the owner. The GREEO will pay compensation at 8 Yuan/m2 (floor area) to the affected persons without residential registration certificates as moving fee. If they can not find suitable housing, the GREEO will help them to find housing with same quantity and same rent. 5. The affected persons without residential registration certificates who live in the illegal self- built buildings haven't been found uring the census of Inner Ring Road (Phase I & 11).If they are found later, the GREEO will register them and give equivalent compensation. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 24 Final Report O, 2.3.5 Other RehabilitationMeasures I . The affected residents have 60-day preparation period before move. 2. The GREEO will minimize the destruction to the community structure. The residents who live in the same area, especially in the same units, buildings and streets, have priority to move to the same quarter to keep the original community structure. 3. The GREEO together with the local government and street office will set up the neighborhood committees or administrative offices of the quarters again to be responsible for safety and sanitation in the quarters and other daily life problems. Parts of daily life necessary shops will be placed in the quarters to meet the needs of their daily life ( 4. In spite of the present good transport of the quarters, if necessary, additional bus routes will be discussed with the public transport departments to establish more convenient transport between the center and the resettlement quarters. 5. The GREEO will still make efforts to minimize the resettlement during the implementation process. With assurance of safety, the buildings which seem to must be demolished entirely at present will be considered to be demolished partially together with engineering experts. 2.4 Resettlement Implementation Plan 2.4.1 Principles and Standards of Setting up Resettlement Sites and Allocation of Housing Areas 0 Accordingto the originalresidential zone of the affectedpersons and the time and quantity of the housing supplied in the resettlement sites, we make a general allotted principle below. Phase I: Completion in December 1997 (unit m2 ) Original Original Area Increasing Demand of Resettlement Resettlement Residential Zone to be Coefficient of Resettlement Sites Amount Demolished Area Housing North of 13611.42 20% 25861.70 Baiyun Garden 20000.00 Donghuadong Xiaogangwan 5861.70 Quarter South of 14036.87 20% 28073.74 BaiyunGarden 14073.74 Donghuadong Xiaogangwan 14000.00 ______Qu arter 0 cn oepol x !<~cAi l) ; j /Tantgecun ) \ ~~Shim 2.4 il« X s-SI' P3; m "ft ui @ , 11 ~ShgmuStation+; i 8 I"2. 4 Relationship Figure of DemolishedResidential Regions and Residential Sii a //) !:I /FIGURE>S 2.4 Resettlement Sites of Inner Ring Rd. Project(Phase 1,11),, -Y-11%NK f Ip, *r / T Z l/ :4 '/ 0 t tlg g J/ 4h~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4 >>,~~~~~~~~~~~;1pinn^ litiec ll R Huaant Iu .t. "~;~ 91 ~-g Tong(lLjige ade W~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ - v - jUiangpn Kengkou-~~~~~~~~ Yu~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ as -, nn.anRd-Bui1t1ingiruie,Guoc In~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I't II) Iji,ng~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 25 Final Report Q Phase II: Completion in June 1998 (unit m2) Original Original area Increasing Demand of Resettlement Resettlement Residential Zone to be Coefficient of Resettlement Sites Amount Demolished Area Housing Huangsha Zone 20670.17 15% 36172.80 Guocun Quarter 17072.8 Xiaogangwan 19100.00 Quarter Xichang 8729.11 15% 15275.94 Guocun Quarter 7270.00 Interchange Tongde Quarter 8005.94 Guangyan 17793.6 15% 32030.40 Tongde Quarter 15000.00 Interchange Baiyun Garden 17030.40 Note: 1. The demandof the resettlementhousing is not equal to Originalarea to be demolished jAlncrementcoefflcient of area. Detailsare shown in Table8.2.1. The increasingcoefficient is a preferentialpolicy. We will providethe opportunityfor choosingif somebodyrequire to move into anotherquarter. Theresidents in Huangsha,Xichang and GuangYuanzones will all receivethe area-extension coefficientof 15%regardless of the resettlementsites. In the two quartersof DonghuadongRd, it is 20%. 2.4.2 Principles and Standards of Setting up Resettlement Sites and Allocation of Housing Area of the Vulnerable Groups 1. The residents in the two quarters of Donghuadong Rd. will be resettled in the resettlement quarter of Yuan'an Street with the area-extension of 15% and requiring area of 680 m2 . (The above resettlement sites are only used for the vulnerable groups) 2. The vulnerable groups in Huangsha, Xichang Interchange and GuangYuall Interchange zones will be resettled in the building of Nan'an Road with the area-extension coefficient of 15% and requirement area of 2200 m2 . 3. The vulnerable groups can require to move to the resettlement quarters of general hiouseholds with the area-extension of 20%. 2.4.3 Resettlement Timetable The details are shown in Table 2.4.3. and Table 2.4.4. *0 0o O Table 2.4.3A: Land Acquisition and Resettlement Implementation Plan of IRR for Phase I Activities 1995 1996 1997 1998 Nov. Dec. Feb. April June Aug. Oct. Dec. Feb. April June Aug. Oct. Dec. Feb. 1. Conduct social & economic census - survey of the PAPs 2. Apply for and gain the planning land use certificate for resettlement _ sites and road construction 3. Apply for and gain Housing Demolition Notice _ 4.Update census and socio-economic survey of the PAPs and their assets 5. Determine the compensation standards and detailed resettlement - plan 6. Purchase or construct the resettlement housinig 7. Sign Resettflmcnt Compensation Agreements and initiate compensationl activities 8. Resettle the PAPs to new housing 9. Dismantle housing and level road construction sites 1O.Start road construction_ 0O0 0 Table 2.4.313: Land Acquisition and Resettlement Implementation Plan of IRR for Phase II Activities 1995 1996 1997 1998 Nov Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug, Oct Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug 1.Conduct social & economicsurvey of the PAPs 2. Applyfor andgain the planning land usecertificate for resettlementsites and roadconstruction 3. Applyfor andgain Housing Demolition Notice 4.Updatecensus and socio-economic surveyof the PAPsand their assets 5.Determinethe compensation standards anddetailed resettlement plan _ _ _ _ 6. Purchaseor constructthe resettlement housing ______7. SignResettlement Compensation Agreementsand initiate compensation _ activities 8. Resettlethe PAPsto newvhousing _ _ = =_= __ __=__ 9. Dismantlehousing and level road constructionsites _ 10.Start road construction 0 0 Table 2.4.3C: Land Acquisition and Resettlement Implementation Plan of IRR for Phase III Activities 1997 = = = 1998 = = . 1999 Feb. April June Aug. Oct. Dec. Feb. April June Aug. Oct. Dec. Feb. April June Aug. 1. Coiiductsocial & economiccensus survey of the PAPs 2. Apply for and gain the planning land use certificatefor resettlement - - - sites and road construction 3. Apply for and gain Housing DemolitionNotice 4.Updatecensus and socio-economic survey of the PAPs and their assets 5.Determinethe compensation standardsand detailed resettlement - plan _ 6. Purchaseor construct the resettlementhousing = ___ _ 7. Sign ResettlementCompensation Agreementsand initiate compensationactivities I 8. Resettlethe PAPs to new housiig 9. Dismal1tleh1ousing and level road constructionsites 10. Start road construction_ 0 0 Table 2.4.3D: Land Acquisition andIResettlement Implementation Plan of IRR for Phase IV Activities 1997 1998 _ 1999 _ 2000 Feb. April June Aug. Oct. Dec. Feb. April June Aug. Oct. Dec. Feb. Apri June Aug. Oct. Dec. Feb. 1. Conduct social & economic census survey of the PAPs = ___ _ 2. Apply for and gain the planning land use certificate for resettlement sites and road construction 3. Apply for and gain Housing Demolition Notice _ _ 4.Update census and socio-economic survey of the PAPs and their assets _ _ _ _ 5.Determine the compensation standards and detailed resettlement plan 6. Purchase or construct the resettlement housing 7. Sign Resettlement Compensation Agreements and initiate compensation activities 8. Resettle the PAPs to new housilig 9. Dismantle housinIgand level road construction sites 10. Start road construction IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 26 Final Report 3. RESETTLEMENT PLAN AND REHABILITATION 0> MEASURES FOR THE AFFECTED SHOPS 3.1 TheAffected Shops 3.1.1 Introduction 3.1.1.1 Amountand Categories 1. There are altogether916 shopsto be relocatedin the first and secondphase of the Inner Ring Road Project. The floor area accountsto 57193.03m 2, with 3226 staff involvedin and 12,740,000Yuan of closureloss monthly. 2. These shops can be divided into three sorts: * Entirely demolishedshops with propertyright; * Partially demolishedshops with propertyright; * Temporallybuilt shops. 3. As to the differentrehabilitation measures and resettlementcompensation standard of the three sorts of shops,we'll describethem respectively. Notes: * These shops includesome smallenterprises. * The area refers to floorarea, the staff refersto that in-serviceemployee. 3.1.1.2 Classificationaccording to the shop's propertyright, affectedextent and the total amount I. Entirelydemolished shops with propertyright There are 340 shopswith area 24,827.06m 2, 1,335staff, 6,688,244Yuan montlhlyloss. 2. Partiallydemolished shops with propertyright There are 34 shops with area 5927.4 m2 ,107 staff, 899.717Yuan inonthlyloss. (If they are complete closure.) 3. Temporaryshops There are 542 shopswith area 26,438.55m 2, 1784staff, 5,148,149Yuan monthlyloss. 3.1.2 Statusof the Shops' Ownership 3.1.2.1 Situationof the all shop's ownership 1. 65 state-ownenterprises, 14590.06 m 2 area, 348 staff, 2,303,632Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 2. 436 collectiveenterprises, 28,914.12 m 2 area, 1,725staff, 7,553,685Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 3. 3 joint venture enterprises,423.53 m2 area, 13 staff, 178,121Yuan monthlyloss due to closure. 4. 317 private enterprises,8,598.85 m 2 area, 822 staff, 2,361,867Yuan monthlyloss due to 0 J closure. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 27 Final Report 5. 95 others(referring to those with a mixed ownership and those with unclear ones), 4,666.31 m2 area, 282 staff, 338,805 Yuan monthlyloss due to closure. Details are showed in Table 3.21.;1 3.1.2.2 Situation of the ownership of the entirely demolished shops with property rights 1. 3 state-own enterprises, 6,197.82 m2 area, 186 staff, 1,105,217 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 2. 169 collective enterprises, 12,849.16 m2 area, 717 staff, 4,465,748 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 3. Joint venture enterprises: none 4. 117 private enterprises, 4,374.13 m2 area, 324 staff, 940,528 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 5. 31 others, 1,405.95 m2 area, 108 staff, 176,751 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. The details are shown in Table 3.1.2.2 3.1.2.3 Situation of the ownership of the partially demolished shops with property rights 1. 9 state-own enterprises, 1,396.91 m2 area, 28 staff, 375,219 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 2. 22 collective enterprises, 4,369.38 m2 area, 67 staff, 505,601 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 3. Joint venture enterprises: none 4. Private enterprises: none. 5. 3 others, 161.3 m2 area, 12 staff, 18,897 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. Details are showed in Table 3.1.2.3 3.1.2.4 Situation of the ownership of the temporary shops 1. 33 state own enterprises, 6,915.33 m2 area, 170 staff, 823,196 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 2. 245 collective enterprises, 11,695.75 m2 area, 947 staff, 2,582,336 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 3. 3 joint venture enterprises, 423.53 m2 area, 13 staff, 178,121 Yuan monthly loss due to closure. 4. 200 private enterprises, 4,224.72 m2 area, 498 staff, 1,421,339 Yuan montlhly loss due to closure. 5. 61 others, 3,099.22 m2 area, 162 staff, 143,157 monthly loss. Details are shown in Table 3.1.2.4 0 0 0 0) Table 3.1.2.1A: Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phases I and II of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project According to Ownership I'ypesof Ownership Section Content State Collective Joint Venture Private (tlhers (-irand Total HlouseholdNumber 13 IX( 7 22 223 Huangsha Working Staff Tr 446 3 205 - 8 782 Lossot Closureof Production/Business 347119 IU94773 146415 3U673V9 1U8626 2UU3672 Floor Area 45T6.54 8210.8X8 345.UU 2UI2.81 ITU3.UUT 1612U.22 HouseholdNumber 1 97 1 187 Xichang Working Statt 374 7 2U6 9 777 Interchange Lossof Closureof Production/Business 763594 2799555 17UUU 461873 21U6362 I:loor Area 752.22 5183.73 49.83 1T361.39 g7-.43 145U7.6U I-louseholdNumber 9 86 U 79 4 215 Guangyuan Working Statt-2 283 084 6U 11 5 Interchange Lossot Closureof l'roduction/Business 31378 869355 494955 6Z4Z6 1458114 Floor Area 8461/.U U.UU 261.52 2U3.24 9719. llousehold Number 2117 I 65 15 218 North of Donghuadong Working Staff 509 3 15843 Road Lossot Closureot Production/Business 1U11638 2406880 14706 386161 13T5435 3954ZU Floor Area 165U.8 9627.09 28.70 1524.7U IU9U1Y 0 C0 Iypes of Ownership Section Content State (Collective Joint Venture Private (thersi (iUra-nd Total I 1ouseholdNumber 2 U 33 Southof Donghuadong WorkingStaff 30 113 0 69 - I3U Road Lossof Closureot Production/Business -- T1499UT 3X3122 0 712139 10712 I255X76 Floor Area 4199 1275.60 O.MU 1U87.45 120U.6 291T4U9 HouseholdNumber 436 3 X22 95 91- Grand Working Statt - - T 1 /25 1X gZ22 3226 Total Lossot Closureot Production/Business Z3U363Z 7553685 178121 2361X67 33XU5 IZ73611U Floor Area 1459U. 2X914.29 423.53 8598.85 4666.31 57193.03 0 0 Table 3.1.2.1B: Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRRfor Phase IIl of GCCTP According to Ownership Section Content Typesof Ownership Total State Collective JointVenture Private Others RailwayStation Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 HuanshizhongRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 LuhuOverpass HouseholdNumber 0 4 0 7 0 11 WorkingStaff 0 36 0 27 0 63 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 81030 0 34965 0 115995 FloorArea (m) 0 438 0 189 0 627 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 19 28 0 135 0 182 WorkingStaff 7 9 0 93 0 109 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 680256 829632 0 584832 0 2094720 FloorArea (m) 3543 4321 0 3046 0 10910 Meidong Overpass Household Number 6 11 2 24 0 43 (east part of Zhongshanyi Rd. Working Staff 37 67 46 107 0 257 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 168400 136800 102000 106800 0 514000 2 Floor Area (m ) 842 684 510 534 0 2570 Haiyinnan Overpass Household Number 0 8 0 11 0 19 Working Staff 0 87 0 29 0 116 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 0 182120 0 87000 0 269120 Floor Area (m2) 0 785 0 375 0 1160 Zhen'anOverpass HouseholdNumber 2 5 1 22 1 31 WorkingStaff 46 51 24 51 12 184 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 99078 124215 26460 19992 9849 279594 FloorArea (m2) 674 845 18 136 67 1902 Renmin Bridge Expansion & Household Number 6 5 2 91 0 104 WorkingStaff 182 241 89 110 0 622 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 271002 384648 175398 326430 0 1157478 Floor Area (m) 1457 2068 943 1755 0 6223 Industry Avenue Household Number 3 6 0 13 0 22 Working Staff 49 40 0 44 0 133 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 114840 64944 0 82764 0 262548 Floor Area (m2) 580 328 0 418 0 1326 Shushe Overpass Household Number 1 1 0 35 2 39 Working Staff 69 47 0 56 61 233 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 136080 1831201 01 169260 68880 557340 -Floor Area (m2) 648 872 0 806 328 2654 Table 3.1.2.1 B: Shop Classification and Distribution along thelignment of IRR for Phase IlIlof GCCTP According to Ownership NantianRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 8 0 8 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 48 0 48 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 66164 0 66164 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 476 0 476 Total HouseholdNumber 37 68 5 346 3 459 WorkingStaff 390 578 159 565 73 1765 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 1469656 1986509 303858 1478207 78729 5316959 FloorArea (m2) 7744 10341 1633 7735 395 27848 Table 3.1.2.1C: Shop Classification and Distribution along the ignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Ownership Section Content Types of Ownership Total State Collective JointVenture Private Others Liu'ersanRd. & HuangshaA HouseholdNumber 4 9 2 69 4 88 WorkingStaff 173 132 56 148 18 527 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 377472 332352 180864 102528 18816 1012032 FloorArea (mi2 ) 1966 1731 942 534 98 5271 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 2 0 2 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 7 0 7 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 18970 0 18970 2 FloorArea (mi) 0 0 0 70 0 70 Middle& West Partsof Nant HouseholdNumber 2 4 0 21 6 33 WorkingStaff 43 57 0 59 41 200 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 147917 107525 0 57970 60588 374000 2 FloorArea (m) 791 575 0 310 324 2000 Total HouseholdNumber 6 13 2 92 10 123 WorkingStaff 216 189 56 214 59 734 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 525389 439877 180864 179468 79404 1405002 2 FloorArea (m ) 2757 2306 942 914 422 7341 0 0 0 Table 3.1.2.2A: Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phases I and 11 of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project According to Ownership I ypes of Ownership Section Content State Collective Joint Venture Private Others (irand I'otal Household Number 2 2T4 U 26 59 Huangsha Working Statt 6 122 U 76 33 237 Lossotf Closure ot Production/Business ---- U- 132676 157427 5X63U 34X733 I'loor Area 1U7.16 15Z0.8 0.00 6XU.5U0675 2525.24 Household Number X 36 14 64 Xichang Working Statt 112 14U U 4U - TT 3U9 Interchange Loss ot Closure ot ProductionfBusiness 65T4U4 Z352195 U 94U74142X 310U301 Floor Area 51Y6.X 23X179W 0.UU 612.2Z 2UX.IU X4U0.91 Household Number T 2X 1 56 Guangyuan Working Statt 5 9U 64 - 1X- Interchange Loss ot Closure of Production/Business - T378 143X2 U 195Z37 43327 392323 'loor Area 114.12 IU31.4U U.UU 1383.X4 565.83 3U95.19 Household Number IT 69 34 114 North of Doiighua Working Stat 40 3U- 93 2 464 dong Road Loss of Closure ot Production/Business 3223T 1637X4Z - 2436XX 62226 ZZ6064 Floor Area 455.40 72XU.6U U.UU 947.2U 319.94 9U031T 0 0 t ypes ol Ownership Section Content State lollective Joint Venture Private Others (irand Iotal Household Number 4 IZ U 26 _ 4 South of Working Statt 23 56 51 13 143 Donghuadong Road Loss ot Closure ot Production/liusiness 12291T 1T97653 25UIU2 31767 573X23 P loor Area 324.34 65 U.UU 7538 18340258 Household Number 9TT 31 34U Grand Working Statl 6 717 324 IUX 1335 Total Loss ot Closure ot Production/Business I IMU5 446574X 0 9472X 176751 668X244 Floor Area 6197.82 12X9.1 OU.U0 4374.13 14U5.96 24821.06 0 0 Table 3.1.2.2B: Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IlIlof GCCTP According to Ownership Section Content Typesof Ownership Total State Collective Joint Venture Private Others RailwayStation Overpass(D HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (mi ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Huanshizhong Rd. Household Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m 2 ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 LuhuOverpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Hengfu Rd. Overpass Household Number 0 0 0 0 _ 0 Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongOverpass(east part HouseholdNumber 6 11 2 24 0 43 WorkingStaff 37 67 46 107 0 257 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 168400 136800 102000 106800 0 514000 Floor Area (m2 ) 842 684 510 534 0 2570 Haiyinnan Overpass Household Number 0 8 0 11 0 19 Working Staff 0 87 0 29 0 116 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 182120 0 87000 0 269120 FloorArea (2 0 785 0 375 0 1160 Zhen'an Overpass Household Number 2 . 5 1 22 1 31 WorkingStaff 46 51 24 51 12 184 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 99078 124215 26460 19992 9849 279594 2 FloorArea (m ) 674 845 180 136 67 1902 RenminBridge Expansion & HouseholdNumber 6 5 2 91 0 104 WorkingStaff 182 241 89 110 0 622 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 271002 384648 175398 326430 0 1157478 2 FloorArea (m ) 1457 2068 943 1755 0 6223 Industry Avenue Household Number 3 6 0 13 0 22 Working Staff 49 40 0 44 0 133 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 114840 64944 0 82764 0 262548 2 FloorArea (m ) 580 328 0 418 0 1326 ShusheOverpass HouseholdNumber 1 1 0 35 2 39 WorkingStaff 69 47 0 56 61 233 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 136080 183120 0 169260 68880 557340 2 Floor Area (m ) 648 872 0 806 3281 26541 C S S~~~~~~~C Tabe3.1.2.2B: Shop Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demol Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase III of GCCTP According to Ownership NantianRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 8 0 8 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 48 0 48 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 66164 0 66164 Floor Area(m2) 0 0 0 476 0 476 Total HouseholdNumber 18 36 5 204 3 266 WorkingStaff 383 533 159 445 73 1593 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 789400 1075847 303858 858410 78729 3106244 FloorArea (m2) 4201 5582 1633 4500 395 16311 0 0 Table 3.1.2.2C: Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops 0 with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTPAccording to Ownership Section Content Typesof Ownership Total State Collective JointVenture Private Others Liu'ersanRd. & HuangshaA HouseholdNumber 4 9 2 69 4 88 WorkingStaff 173 132 56 148 18 527 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 377472 332352 180864 102528 18816 1012032 2 FloorArea(m ) 1966 1731 942 534 98 5271 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Floor Area (m2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Middle& West Partsof Nant HouseholdNumber 2 4 0 21 6 33 WorkingStaff 43 57 0 59 41 200 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 147917 107525 0 57970 60588 374000 2 FloorArea (m ) 791 575 0 310 324 2000 Total HouseholdNumber 6 13 2 90 10 121 WorkingStaff 216 189 56 207 59 727 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 525389 439877 180864 160498 79404 1386032 FloorArea (m 2) 2757 2306 942 844 422 7271 00 0 Table 3.1.2.3: Classification and Distribution of the Partially Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phases I and II of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project According to Ownership Types of Ownership Section Content State Collective Joint Venture Private Others Grand Total Household Number 3 17 0 0 2 22 Huangsha Working Staff 9 56 0 0 7 72 Loss of Closure of Production/Business 318223 458742 0 0 10997 787962 Floor Area 672.58 3675.33 0.00 0.00 119.43 4467.34 Household Number 4 4 0 0 0 8 Xichang Employment People 14 8 0 0 0 12 Interchange Loss of Closure of Production/Business 38996 42992 0 0 0 81988 Floor Area 491.87 344.75 0.00 0.00 0.00 836.62 Household Number 0 I 0 0 0 1 Guangyuan Working Staff 0 3 0 0 0 3 Interchange Loss of Closure of Production/Business 0 3867 0 0 0 3867 Floor Area 0.00 349.30 0.00 0.00 0.00 349.30 Household Number 1 0 0 0 1 2 North of Donghuadong Working Staff 2 0 0 0 5 7 Road Loss of Closure of Production/Business 0 0 0 0 7900 7900 Floor Area 149.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 41.70 191.20 00 Types of Ownership Section Content State Collective Joint Venture Private Others Grand Total Household Number I 0 0 0 0 South of Donghuadong Working Staff 3 0 0 0 0 3 Road Loss of Closure of Production/Business 18000 0 0 0 o 18000 Floor Area 82.96 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 82.96 Household Number 9 22 0 0 3 34 Grand Working Staff 28 67 0 0 12 107 Total Loss of Closure of Production/Business 375219 505601 0 0 18897 899717 Floor Area 1396.91 4369.38 0.00 0.00 161.13 5927.42 ~~~~~~0 0~~~~~~~~~~~~~0C Table 3.1.2.4A: Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase I and II of Guangzhou City Centre Transport Project According to Ownership Types of Ownership Section Content State Collective Joint Venture Private Others Grand Total Household Number 8 67 1 53 13 142 Huangsha Working Staff 32 268 3 129 41 473 Loss of Closure of Production/Business 28896 503355 146415 149312 38999 866977 Floor Area 3736.80 3014.71 345.00 1332.31 698.82 9127.64 Household Number 5 57 1 47 5 115 Xichang Working Staff 35 226 7 166 12 446 Interchange Loss of Closure of Production/Business 73194 404368 17000 367799 11978 874339 Floor Area 1836.55 2455.19 49.83 749.17 179.33 5270.06 Household Number 7 57 0 62 32 158 Guangyuan Working Staff 22 190 0 120 88 420 Interchange Loss of Closure of Production/Business 23000 720106 0 299718 19100 1061924 Floor Area 342.36 3236.30 0.00 1228.68 1467.41 6274.75 Household Number 12 48 1 31 10 102 North of Working Staff 77 200 3 65 16 361 Donghuadong Road Loss of Closure of Production/Business 689104 769038 14706 142473 65535 1680856 Floor Area 1045.93 2346.49 28.70 577.50 728.94 4727.56 0 o0 Types of Owvnership Section Content State Collective Joint Venture Private Others Grand Total Household Number 1 16 0 7 1 25 South of Working Staff 4 57 0 18 5 84 Donghuadong Road Loss of Closure of Production/Business 9002 185469 0 462037 7545 664053 Floor Area 33.69 643.06 0.00 337.07 24.72 1038.54 Household Number 33 245 3 200 61 542 Grand Working Staff 170 941 13 498 162 1784 Total Loss of Closure of Production/Business 823196 2582336 178121 1421339 143157 5148149 Floor Area 6995.33 11695.75 423.53 4224.72 3099.22 26438.55 0-Table 3.1.2.4B: TemporaryShop Classification and Distributionalong the Alignmentof IRRfor PhaseIll of GCCTPAccording to Ownership0 Section Content ______Types of Ownership ______Total State Collective JointVenture Private Others RailwayStation Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 (DabeiRamp) WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) ______0 0 _____ 0 0 0 0 Floor Area (Mn) _____0 ____ 0 ____ 0 0 0 0 Huanshizhong Rd. Household Number ______0 _____ 0 _____ 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff _____0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) ______0 0 0 0 0 0 ______~~FloorArea (M ) _ _ _ __0 0 0 _ _ _ _ 0 0 0 LuhuOverpass HouseholdNumber ______0 4 0 7 0 11 Working Staff ______0 36 0 27 0 63 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(Yuan) 0 81030 0 34965 0 115995 ______~~~FloorArea (M) __ _ _ 0 438 0 189 0 627 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 19 28 0 135 0 182 Working Staff ______7 9 ______0 93 0 109 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 680256 829632 _____ 0 584832 0 2094720 ______~~FloorArea (in) 3543 4321 _____0 3046 0 10910 Meidong Overpass Household Number 0 0 _____ 0 0 0 _____ 0 (east part of Zhongshanyi Rd.) Working Staff 0 0 ______0 0 0 ______ Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 _____ 0 0 0 0 ______~~~~Floor Area (M) 0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ 0 0 __ _ _ _0 HaiyinnanOverpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 Working Staff 0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ 0 0 _ _ _ _ 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 _____ 0 0 0 0 0 Floor Area(M) 0 _____0 0 0 0 0 Zhen'an Overpass Household Number 0 _____ 0 0 _____ 0 0 _____ 0 Working Staff __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ 0 0 __ _ _ _0 0 _ _ _ _ 0 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) ______0 0 0 _____ 0 0 ______0 Floor Area(m 0 __ _ _ 0 0 __ _ _ _0 0 __ _ _0 Renmin Bridge Expansion & Hongde Household Number 0 _____0 0 _____0 0 ____ 0 Working Staff 0 _____0 0 _____0 0 ____ 0 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 0 _____ 0 0 _____ 0 0 ______0 Floor Area (M) 0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ 0 0 __ _ _ _0 Industry Avenue Household Number 0 _____ 0 _____ 0 _____ 0 0 _____ 0 Working Staff 0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ 0 0 _ _ _ _ 0 Loss of Closure of Production/Business (yuan) 0 _____ 0 _____ 0 0 0 _____ 0 ______~~~~FloorArea(m 0 __ _ _ _0 __ _ _ 0 __ _ _ 0 0 __ _ _ _0 Shushe Overpass Household Number 0 _____ 0 _____ 0 _____ 0 0 _____ 0 Working Staff 0 _____0 _____0 0 0 ____ 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0[ 0 0 0 0l 0 ______~~~~FloorArea (M) 0 0 0l 0l 0 0 O 0 Table 3.1.2.4B: Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IlIlof GCCTPAccording to Ownership NantianRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 a 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Floor Area (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total HouseholdNumber 19 32 0 142 0 193 WorkingStaff 7 45 0 120 0 172 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 680256 910662 0 619797 0 2210715 Floor Area (m2) 3543 4759 0 3235 0 11537 Table 3.1.2.4C: Classification and Temporary Shop Distribution al the Alignment of IRRfor Phase IV of GCCTPAccording to Ownership Section Content Typesof Ownership Total State Collective JointVenture Private Others Liu'ersanRd. & HuangshaA HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Floor Area(m2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff. 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 2 0 2 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 7 0 7 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 18970 0 18970 Floor Area (mi2 ) 0 0 0 70 0 70 Middle& West Partsof Nanti HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 Floor Area (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 2 0 2 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 7 0 7 Lossof Closureof Production/Business(yuan) 0 0 0 18970 0 18970 FloorArea (m2) 0 0 0 70 0 70 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 28 Final Report Distribution Chart of Areas of Shops Judging from the above proportion chart, state-own and collective enterprises suffer the most loss. Shops with asset rights will receive compensation and resettlement. Because the shops owned by the state and collective have the higher-level companies, the unemployment situation will be not occurred according to the special employment policies in China. We will make great efforts to offer the business sites for other shops with ownership. f) ~~Detailsare shown in 3.3 )/ 3.1.3 Distribution of the Shops L'.1.. Distribution of allshops Region Numberof Shop s Fert amol I ) North of DonghuadongRd. (PhaseI) 128 13,921.90O S) South of DonghuadonsRd. (Phase1) 73 2,924.09 3) Huancsha (Phse 11) 223 w 16,120.22 4) XichannInterchanl e (Phase 11) 1p7 14,507.60 5) Guanso yuan nterchanoe (Phase11) 215 9,719.23 Details are shown in Table 3.1.2.1 3.1.3.2 Distribution of Entirely Demolished Shops With Property RigSt Region Numberof Shop Floor area (m2) 1) North of Donghuadong Rd. (Phase I) 14 3,921.90 2) South of Donghuadong Rd. (Phase 1) 47 1,802.58 3) Huangsha (Phse 11) 2259 2,525.24 4) Xichang Interchange (Phase II) 64 8,400.91 5) Guangyuan Interchange (Phase 11) 56 3,095.19 Details are shown in Table 3.1.2.2 IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 29 Final Report C 3.1.3.3 Distribution of Partially Demolished Shops With Property Rights Region Number of Shop Floor area 1)North of DonghuadongRd. (PhaseI) 2 191.20 2) Southof DonghuadongRd. (Phase1) 1 82.96 3) Huangsha (Phse II) 22 4,467.34 4) Xichang Interchange (Phase II) 8 836.620 5) Guangyuan Interchange (Phase II) 1 349.30 Details are shown in Table 3.1.2.3 3.1.3.4 Distribution of Temporarily Built Shops Region Number of Shop Area (mi) I) North of Donghuadong Rd. (Phase 1) 102 4,727.56 2) South of Donghuadong Rd. (Phase 1) 25 1,038.54 3) Huangsha (Phse 11) 142 9,127.64 4) Xichang Interchange (Phase 11) 115 5,270.06 5) Guangyuan Interchange (Phase 11) 158 6,274.75 Details are shown in Table 3.1.2.4 3.1.3.5 Distribution Chart of Floor area Distribution Chart of Floor area 60O000 50000 40000:. 20000. C 10000 - - EU NI :V n-i-Total Notes: I---Huangsha, 1l---Xichang Interchange, III---Guangyuan Interchange, IV---North of Donglhuadong Rd., V---South of Donghuadong Rd. A---Temporary Shops' Area, B---Shops' Area With Property right, C---Grand Total of Shop's Area. (Unit of Area: m2) 03 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 30 Final Report O j_m =EW^'SiL'SEdSSS o n PA 1~ Such a distribution of the shops' area is the basis of thinking of utilizing the periphery land to build permanent commercial multi-purpose building and the choice of arranging temporary shops. It is also the basis of selecting the Guocun Quarter and Tongde Quarter(Phase 11)and the Xiaogangwan Quarter, Baiyun Garden(phase I) as parts of our permanent commercial resettlement sites. Our plan of the commercial resettlement sites is basically according to the above distribution. 3.1.4 Situation of the Property Rights and the Structure of Housing to be Demolished Housing Item Enterprise- Government Private Overseas GrandTotal Structure Owned -Owned Chinese Reinforced Household 10 17 2 1 30 Concrete Area(m2) 684.59 1,257.65 70.65 13.19 2,023.38 Mixed Household 55 82 13 1 151 Structure Area(m2) 6,842.26 6,228.53 626.70 25.80 13,723.28 Brick and Household 42 137 12 2 193 Wood Area(m2) 2,798.68 11,719.83 369.44 116.85 15,004.81 Grand Household 107 236 27 4 374 Total Area(m2) 10,325.53 19,206.32 1,066.79 155.84 30,754.48 Note: Referring to the shops with property right. Obviously, most shops' property right belongs to the state and enterprises, covering 93.02% of all shops. Among the shops with property right, the reinforced concrete housing and the brick and wood housing cover 28,728.10 m2 with 93.41%. So, based on the structure, 93.41% of shops will obtain benefits from the project. 3.1.5 Category Composition of the Trades of the Shops 3.1.5.1 Category of Trades Shop groups are composed in accordance with the category of trades. Therefor, shops are put into the Q following categoriesby the dominanttrades as: generalmerchandise (such as clothes, daily use IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 31 Final Report articles), electron & electrical appliance (such as household electrical appliance), services (the tertiary industry such as haircutting, cosmetology, credit cooperative, bank. etc.), industrial products, construction materials, agricultural products(such as crops, vegetables and aquatic products, etc.), fitting of automobile and motors, maintenance of automobiles, foods (all kinds of manufactured food products), mini-processes(small-sized processed, such as small hardwires), diets, bicycles, maintenance of motors and other trades (those which are not included in the above). Detailed distributions of trade of shops are shown in Table 3.1.5.1, 3.1.5.2, 3.1.5.3 and 3.1.5.4. 3.1.5.2 Main Income Source and Trades of the Shops There are mainly three sources affecting the income of shops. They are: residents, floating population, status of scale management and traffic. 1. The trade categories of shops mainly based on the residents: daily use articles, agricultural products and services. 2. The trade categories of shops mainly based on the floating population: food, diets, repair & maintenance of bicycles, electron & electric equipment and small processes. 3. The trade categories of shops mainly based on the scale management: construction materials, automobile fittings, industrial products' sale and automobile maintenance. 3.1.5.3 The amount of floor area of the above three kinds of shops among all shops AGeneral Nerchandise * Bectron and Bectric 0 Service 10-idustrial Product Sailing .ConstructionMaterial iAgricultural Product _ Autornobiland Mator Fitting -ategor Resident Floating Sc.Autorleobilintenance r T : -oM- ---i 0M>W; ~;- / - Food - - -\ /\//2 l l l i\ ./-: ZSmSrral Processi . -: . : -Q l l-.- g 8~~E3Bicycle/Motor Mai.ntenance - :: - - - - -:- <_ - - ; : .~~ Others Category Resident Floating Scale Others Grand Total Population . Entirely Demolished shops 3,847.76 2,702.41 7,823.01 10,453.89 24,827.07 with property right Partially Demolished shops 900.42 1,319.14 1,452.59 2,255.27 24,827.07 with property right Temporary shops 9,979.05 3,989.86 6,035.66 6,433.98 49,634.14 Q9 Grand Total 14,727.23 8,011.41 15,311.26 19,143.14 99,308.28 Table 3.1.5.11A: Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of iRR for Phases Iand II of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects According to Main Trade (Classified by Types of Commodity Or Business) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 i 1 31 Section IContent ' GeneralM Electronic Service Industrial ConstructAgricultur Automobil Automobi Foodstuff Small Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others GrandTotal Household 14; 101 35. 44 5 6 3 1 20 0 10 5 _ 71 223 Huangsha Working Staff 28 ~41 128 169 23 9 - -430 3 6 26 78 Loss of Closure(Yuan) 51982 62609 28174 279809 45743 2684 13305 135 888 __ 927 065870 __2-003672 Floor Area(-m2) 381.2 349.581 502-4.04- 197 8. 8 6 503.94 -0 1-3-8.2-9 -9.A44 602.39 0 1803.8 133.06 5066.7 16120.22 Households 16 61 22~ 36 39 0 5 3 5 3 1 7 44 187 ichang WorkingStaff 46 13 73 18 38 0 18 1 19 -116 2 23 _ 777 interchangeLoss of Closure(Yuan) 161041 592 2011187457121III0 2869 30950 3700 22037 0 30920 1903699 4063628 FloorArea(mn2) 659.74 395.7 2749.3 1671.82 1848.9 0 186.19 97 169.62 108.87 170.37 88.96 636.17 14507.6 Households' 28 10 31 37 13 b 5 8 2 15 4 -di __ _ 215_ uangyuan Working taff 66 29 7 0 3 4 2 2 09 215 0 Inter-chan-ge Loss of Closure(Yuan) 122134- 33345 173491 204340 82867 0 22945 4710 35939 4367 130144 20735 623097 - 1458114 HloueoldAra(2679.95 _3113J 114611.0111568.07~ 343.53 0- 296.2624.89 18. 2-6.97 15-6-1.2-57.03 3~2_08.16 __ 719.23 Ho-u -se- hod-s33 17 38 25 11 0 34 1 10 1 3 _1 44218 Northof workin g-S-taff 124 60 106 107' 37 0 122 2 25 -- 2 16 1 -- 230 -- 832 Donghua Lossof Closure(Yuan) 359925 255766 924820 2573591160442 0 465590 4610 89572 3050 36675 2275 1394736 - 3954820 iRd. E. Floor Area(m2) 126934 698.3 6. -2-02-0.8-4 978 021 280.0-9 0 3897.53 270.42 312.11 7.67 3779.2 3.49 3804.89 13921.9 Households 3, 5 10 21 5 0 183 6_0 - 6 0 3 41-7 -- 73 Southof WorkingStaff 71 18 27 6i 36 0 - 53 0 12- _0_ 4 1-8 __ 4-6 230 64 3 Donghua Lossof Closure(Yuan) 18855 9 5i 151786, 100041128163 0 573760- 0 22635 0 -41700 36788 202802 1255876 Rd. E. FloorArea(m2) 109.63 114.941 243.21 66.371 320.5 ol 831.12 0 2002 0 5.26 7.7 722 940 Households . 94' 48' 136. 144 73' 6' 651 6 49 6 32 21 237 916 Grand iWorkingStaff 271~ 161 409; 563 273 9~ 2131 18 121 17 -98-- 1007 - 3226 Total Loss of Closure(Yuan) 7113937~ 472247: 1752560 1870482 874336 26814; 11024691 42005 272631 29454 501791 -111I083 496_1842 127-36-11-0 'FloorArea(m2) 3099.86 1872.28 11498.4 6263.14 3297~ 0 5349.391401.75 1462.8 14351 75717 3161.11 1-f3_418.1 W719a4 Coding: 1 General Merchandise 9 Foodstuff 2 Electronic Product and Appliance 10 Small Process 3 Service 11 Diet . 4 Indlustrial Product Sale 12 Bicycle/Motorcycle Maintenance 5 'ConstructionMaterial Sale 13 Others 6 AgriculturalProduct 7 Automobileand MotorcycleFitting 8 l~Automobile Maintenance ______Table3.1.5.1 B: Shop Classification and Distribution along the§ignment of IRRfor Phase Ill of GCCTPAccording to Main Trade Section Content 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 General Electronic Service Industrial ConstructAgricultur Automobi Automobil Foodstuff Small Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others GrandTotal RailwayStation Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (Dabei Ramp) Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0O 0 0 0_ a 0 0 0o 0 0 0 0 0 Huanshizhong Rd. Household Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorAreaM) (m0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Luhu Overpass Household Number 2 0 __ 21 0 0 0 __ 4 __ 0 0 __ 0 2 1 0 11 Working Staff 7 0 9 0 0 0 36 0 0o o0 6 5 0 63 Lossof Closure(yuan) 8695 0 11470 0 0 0 81030 0 0 o0 9990 4810 0 115995 FloorArea (m) 47 0 62 0 0 0 438 0 0 0 54 26 0 627 Hengfu Rd. Overpass Household Number 1 0 2 3 0 0 169 1 0 2 1 1 2 182 Working Staff 4 0 9 9 0 0 43 17 0 11 r6 3 7 109 Lossof Closure(yuan) 5568 0 7872 7296 0 0 1962432 74688 0 5760 9216 3264 18624 2094720 FloorArea (m2 ) 29 0 41 38 0 0 10221 389 0 30 48 17 97 10910 Meidong Overpass Household Number 2 1 3 2 0 11 14 2 1 1 2 1 3 43 (eastpart of Zhongshanyi WorkingStaff 19 4 13 21 0 38 11l 21 8 61 9 3 4 257 Lossof Closure(yuan) 48200 15800 8400 49400 0 94800 190800 68200 7800 8600 17400 1400 3200 514000 2 FloorArea (m ) 241 79 42 247 0 474 954 341 39 43 87 7 16 2570 HaiyinnanOverpass HouseholdNumber 3 2 2 1 1 5 0 0 1 1 0 2 1 19 WorkingStaff 17 17 19 16 17 13 0 C_ 7 4 0 4 2 116 Lossof Closure(yuan) 38512 28072 26448 26448 255201 27840 0 0 23664 25056 0 26216 21344 269120 FloorArea (m 2) 166 121 114 114 110C 120 0 0 102 1081 0 113 92 1160 Zhen'anOverpass HouseholdNumber 4 2 2 1 0 1 . 0 0 2 2 13 0 4 31 WorkingStaff 17 6 8 6 0 7 0 0 9 4 109 0 18 184 Lossof Closure(yuan) 17640 3528 3822 5586 0 6909 0 0 7203 13965 210798 0 10143 279594 2 .____ _FloorArea (m ) 120 24 26 38 0 47 0 0 49 95 1434 0 69 1902 RenminBridge Expansion HouseholdNumber 8 7 8 2 24 11 5 7 3 0 20 2 7 104 WorkingStaff 145 86 38 19 65 21 16 67 17 0 124 7 622 Lossof Closure(yuan) 278256 243660 63240 35154 151032 44640 24180 91140 15996 0 195486 5766 8928 1157478 FloorArea (mi) 1496 1310 340 189 812 240 130 490 86 0 1051 31 48 6223 industry Avenue Household Number 1 1 3 0 8 0 0 0 2 1 3 1 2 22 Working Staff 9 6 17 0 45 0 0 0 11 4 29 5 7 133 Lossof Closure(yuan) 17622 8316 9702 0 113058 0 0 0C 12078 5346 86130 4158 6138 262548 Floor Area (m) 89 42 49 0 571 a0 C0 61 271 435 21 31 1326 Shushe Overpass Household Number 3 7 2 1 4 10 0 0 3 1 3 2 3 39 WorkingStaff 11 20 31 13 16 26 0 0 1 5 78 7 1 233 Lossof Closure(yuan) 26670 39690 103950 39480 25410 59430 0 36540 20160 177660 10710 17640 557340 FloorArea (mn) 127 189 495 188 121 283 0 0 174 96 846 51 84 2654 Table 3.1.5.1B:Shop Classification and Distribution along theignment of IRR for PhaseIlIl of GCCTPAccording to MainTrade NantianRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 5 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 8 WorkingStaff 36 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 4 0 48 Lossof Closure(yuan) 56573 0 2224 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5421 1946 0 66164 FloorArea (m) 407 0 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 39 14 0 476 Total HouseholdNumber 29 20 25 10 37 38 192 10 12 8 45 11 22 459 WorkingStaff 265 139 147 84 143 105 206 105 68 34 366 38 65 1765 Lossof Closure(yuan) 497736 339066 237128 163364 315020 233619 2258442 234028 103281 78887 712101 58270 86017 5316959 FloorArea (m) 2722 1765 1185 814 1614 1164 11743 1220 511 399 3994 280 437 27848 Coding: 1 GeneralMerchandise 2 ElectronicProduct and Appliance 3 Service 4 IndustrialProduct Sale 5 ConstructionMaterial Sale 6 AgriculturalProduct 7 Automobileand MotorcycleFitting 8 AutomobileMaintenance 9 Foodstuff 10 SmallProcess 11 Diet 12 Bicycle/MotorcycleMaintenance 13 Others Table 3.1.5.1C: Shop Classification and Distribution along thegnment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Main Trade Section Content 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 General Electronic Service Industrial ConstructAgricultur Automobil Automobi FoodstuffSmall Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others GrandTotal Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha HouseholdNumber 14 18 6 2 4 27 0 0 7 4 3 3 0 88 WorkingStaff 136 57 71 19 89 42 0 0 26 22 55 10 0 527 Lossof Closure(yuan) 220224 82944 21888 23232 27264 347904 0 0 24576 19008 235008 9984 0 1012032 FloorArea (m2) 1147 432 114 121 142 18121 0 0 128 99 1224 52 0 5271 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0o 0 0 2 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 C0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 a0 0 0 0 18970 C_0 0 C 0 0 0 18970 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 70 C0 0 0 0 0 0 70 Middle& West Partsof Na HouseholdNumber 3 1 3 2 1 13 0_ 0 3 1 2 2 2 33 WorkingStaff 41 6 10 21 8 51 0 0 11 2 39 6 5 200 Loss of Closure(yuan) 30668 12342 29359 37213 43010 100045 0 0 15334 8976 80784 5610 10659 374000 FloorArea (Mi) 164 66 157 199 230 535 0 82 48 432 30 57 2000 Total HouseholdNumber 17 19 9 4 5 40 2 0 10 5 5 2 123 WorkingStaff 177 63 81 40 97 93 7 0 37 24 94 16 5 734 Loss of Closure(yuan) 250892 95286 51247 60445 70274 447949 18970 0 39910 2798 31579 15594 10659 1405002 FloorAea ( 1311 498 271 320 372 2347 70 0 210 147 165 82 57 7341 Coding: 1 General Merchandise 2 Electronic Product and Appliance 3 Service 4 Industrial Product Sale 5 Construction Material Sale 6 Agricultural Product 7 Automobile and Motorcycle Fitting 8 Automobile Maintenance 9 Foodstuff 10 Small Process 11 Diet 12 Bicycle/Motorcycle Maintenance 13 Others .Table 3.1.5.2A: Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownershipalong the Alignmentof IRRfor PhasesI and II of Guangzhou City Center Transport ProjectsAc c-or-ding t-oMa-inTra-d-e - 1 2 3 4 5 6[ 7 8 9 ---l I1 -12 13 1 Section Content General Electronii Service i IndustrialConstruc Agricultur AutomobiAutomobi Foodstuf Small Pr Diet Bicycle/ Others Total Household 1 o 1 0 2 1 0 5 0 3 2 _26 59 Huangsha WorkingStaff 2I 0 2 53 0 21-- 1._..,0_ 10 0 4 ___11 125 237 Lossof Closure(Yuan) 2170 0 41657 522731 0 11996 8315- 0 20599 - 0_ 2450 11360 197913 348733 FloorArea(m2) 10.04 0 202.98 925.5_5 0 29.9 75.12 0 92.12 0 98.89 46.71 1043.92 2525.24 Household 6 2 8 12 10 0 _1_ 1 1 206 kichang WorkingStaiff1 5 25 52...0.1 0 2 4 14 30 IntercangLos ofClosure(Yuan) 35715 23400 50155 964155 258502 0 14260 0 108 46 02 789 170 FloorArea(rn2) 177.04 130.52 682.91 626.5 690.27 0 93.86 0 138.74 26.92 170.37- 14.2 5649.58 8400.91 Households 6 23 021 25 GiuangyuanWor,king S-ta-ff- 12 10 27 31 8 0 6 2 12 3 -~10 7 54 182 InterchangLoss of Closure(Yuan) 21134 1564 55432 5894 766 0 6945 470 131 46 74 83 309 322 FloorAream2 161.45 117.37 955.75 356.75 43.25 0 27.11 24.89 114.56 9.9 417.45 30.87 835.84 3095.19 Household 14 7 14 13 4 0 31 031 __ 2 1 __ 24 114 Northof Working S-taff 611 .24 37 74 13 0 -117 0 - 12 2 11 - 1 112 464 DonghudoLos of Cosure(Yuan)1 1434441 52534 564390 173508 4077 0 5054- 0 338 _3050 ~308 -2 275 -7 i96 2-266064 Rd Foor Area(mn2) 488.06I274.741 811.491 738.94' 93.52 0 892 -6 99.1 7.76 3187 3.49 2338.04 9003.14 Household 21 4~ 101 1 3~ 0 1 0 5 _ 0 3 3 15 47 Southof WorkingStaff 21 15 271 6 251 0 40 11 0 4 8 41 143 bonghuado Lossof Closure(Yuan) 1`13101 589901 1517861 8441 790611 b 30 0 19998 - 0 41711 22124 176802 573823 Rd. FloorArea-(m2) 84.911 82371 243.21 27.07 259.561 0b 11i.4 -0 188.13 0 257.26 62.17 586.52 _1802,58 Household 29. 16i 48 49, 20. 2; 36 1 18 3 12 9 97 340 Grand WorkingStaff 92., 54 145 216i 78! 2 138 2 57 8 35 31 47- 13 Total Lossof Closure(Yuan)l 213773, 150569 863420'12567711. 386006: 11996148337 4710 111072 11584 122085 64914 3007970 6688244 FloorArea(m2) 921.5 605' 2896.33 2674.81 1086.61 29.93i 4036.72 24.89 632.74 44.58 1262.75 157.44 10453.9 24827.06 Coding: .1 GeneralMerchandise 7 Automobileand MotorcycleFitting I2 ElectronicProduct and Appliance i8 -Automobile Maintenance 3 Service 9 Foodstufj - 4Industrial ProductSale T10 SmallProcess___I 5 ~~ConstrucionMaterial Sailing D1iet~~ 6 ~~AgriculturalProduct,.. 12 -Bicycle/Motorcycle Maintenance -- 13 Ohr - Tabl .1 .s.2B: Classification and Distribution of the Fully Demolished Shops wth Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IlIl of GCCTP According to Main Trade Section Content 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 General Electronic Service IndustrialConstruct Agricultur Automobi Automobil Foodstuff Small Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others GrandTotal RailwayStation Overpass( HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 ____ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 _ l 0 0 0 0 HuanshizhongRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 LuhuOverpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 _ . 0 0 0t0 0 0t 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m 2) 0 C 0 .O. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0C 0 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0_ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m) 0 _ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .0 0 0 0 MeidongOverpass HouseholdNumber 2 1 3 2 0 11 14 2 1 1 2 1 3 43 (eastpart of Zhongshanyi WorkingStaff 19 4 13 21 0 38 111 21 8 6 9 3 4 257 Lossof Closure(yuan) 48200 15800 8400 49400 0 94800 190800 68200 7800 8600 17400 1400 3200 514000 2 FloorArea (m ) 241 79 42 247 0 474 954 341 39 43 87 7 16 2570 HaiyinnanOverpass HouseholdNumber 3 2 2 1 1 5 0 0 1 1 0 2 1 19 WorkingStaff 17 17 19 16 17 13 0 0 7 4 0 4 2 116 Lossof Closure(yuan) 38512 28072 26448 26448 25520 27840 0 0 23664 25056 0 26216 21344 269120 FloorArea (m 2) 166 121 114 114 110 120 0 0 102 108 0 113 92 1160 Zhen'anOverpass HouseholdNumber 4 2 2 1 0 1 0 0 2 2 13 0 4 31 WorkingStaff 17 6 8 6 0 7 0 0 9 4 109 0 18 184 Loss of Closure(yuan) 17640 3528 3822 5586 0 6909 0 0 7203 13965 210798 0 10143 279594 2 FloorArea(m ) 120 24 26 38 __ 0 47 0 0 49 95 1434, 0 69 1902 RenminBridge Expansion HouseholdNumber 8 7 8 2 24 11 5 7 3 0 20 2 7 104 WorkingStaff 145 86 38 19 65 21 16 67 17 0 124 7 17 622 Lossof Closure(yuan) 278256 243660 63240 35154 151032 44640 24180 91140 15996 0 195486 5766 8928 1157478 FloorArea (m 2) 1496 1310 340 189 812 240 130 490 86 0 1051 31 48 6223 IndustryAvenue HouseholdNumber 1 1 3 0 8 0 0 0 2 1 3 1 2 22 WorkingStaff 9 6 17 0 45 0 0 0 11 4 29 5 7 133 Loss of Closure(yuan) 17622 8316 9702 0 113058 0 0 0 12078 5346 86130 4158 6138 262548 FloorArea(m) 89 42 49 0 571 0 0 0 61 27 435 21 31 1326 ShusheOverpass HouseholdNumber 3 7 2 1 4 10 0 0 3 1 3 2 3 39 WorkingStaff 11 20 31 13 16 26 0 0 16 5 78 7 10 233 Loss of Closure(yuan) 26670 39690 103950 39480 25410 594301 0 0 36540 20160 177660 10710 17640 557340 FloorArea(Mi) 127 189 495 188 121 283 0 0 174 96 846 51 84 2654 Tabe .2B: Classification and Distribution of the Fully Demolished Shop ith Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IlIl of GCCTPAccording to Main Trade NantianRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 5 0 1 0 0 0 0 a 0 1 . 0 8 WorkingStaff 36 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 4 0 48 Loss of Closure(yuan) 56573 0 2224 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5421 1946 0 66164 FloorArea (m 2) 407 0 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 39 14 0 476 Total HouseholdNumber 26 20 21 -7 37 38 19 9 12 6 42 9 20 266 WorkingStaff 254 139 129 75 143 105 127 88 68 23 354 30 58 1593 Loss of Closure(yuan) 483473 339066 217786 156068 315020 233619 214980 159340 103281 73127 692895 50196 67393 3106244 FloorArea (mi) 2646 1765 1082 776 1614 1164 1084 8311 511 369 3892 237 340 16311 Coding: 1 GeneralMerchandise 2 ElectronicProduct and Appliance 3 Service 4 IndustrialProduct Sale 5 ConstructionMaterial Sale 6 AgriculturalProduct 7 Automobileand MotorcycleFitting 8 AutomobileMaintenance 9 Foodstuff 10 Small Process 11 Diet 12 Bicycle/MotorcycleMaintenance 13 Others Tab.1.5.2C: Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Sh along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to n0 rade Section Content 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 General Electronic Service Industrial Construct Agricultur Automobil Automobi Foodstuff Small Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others Grand Total Liu'ersan Rd. & Huangsha Household Number 14 18 6 2 4 27 0 0 7 4 3 3 0 88 WorkingStaff 136 57 71 19 89 42 0 0 26 22 55 10t 527 Lossof Closure(yuan) 220224 82944 21888 23232 27264 347904 0 0 24576 19008 235008 9984 0 1012032 Floor Area (m2) 1147 432 114 121 142 1812 0 0 128 99 1224 52 0 5271 Hengfu Rd. Overpass Household Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0C0 0 Meidongbei Rd. Household Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0C 0 Loss of Closure (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Middle &West Parts of Na Household Number 3 1 3 2 1 13 0 0 3 1 2 2 2 33 WorkingStaff 41 6 10 21 8 51 0 0 11 2 39 6 5 200 Lossof Closure(yuan) 30668 12342 29359 37213 43010 100045 0 0 15334 8976 80784 56101 10659 374000 FloorArea (mi2) 164 66 157 199 230 535 0 0 82 48 432 30 57 2000 Total HouseholdNumber 17 19 9 4 5 40 0 0 10 5 5 5 2 121 WorkingStaff 177 63 81 40 97 93 0 0 37 24 94 16 5 727 Lossof Closure(yuan) 250892 95286 51247 60445 70274 447949 0 0 39910 27984 315792 15594 10659 1386032 2 Floor Area (m ) 1311 498 271 320 372 2347 0 0 210 147 1656 82 57 7271 Coding: 1 General Merchandise 2 Electronic Product and Appliance 3 Service 4 Industrial Product Sale 5 Construction Material Sale 6 Agricultural Product 7 Automobile and Motorcycle Fitting 8 Automobile Maintenance 9 Foodstuff 10 Small Process 11 Diet 12 Bicycle/Motorcycle Maintenance 13 Others 00 Table 3.1.5.3: Classificationand Distributionof the PartiallyDemolished Shops with Ownershipalong the Alignmentof IRR for PhasesI and 11 of GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Projects According to MainTrade 1 2 3 4 1 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 jGeneralM Electronic Service IndustrialConstructi Agricultura Automobil Automobil Foodstuff Small Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others Total Household 0 0 8 1 2 01 0 2 0 0 0 Huangsha WorkingStaff 0 251 3 9 0 3 0 _10 - 0 -- 0 0_ . Lossof Closure(Yuan) 0: 0 164755, 2190 132331 0 4990 0 128746 ° 0 0 0 FloorArea(m2) 0 o 900.42 60.67i 398.31 0 48.34 0 1126.55 0 0 0 Household 0 2j 0 1 3! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Xichang WorkingStaff 0. 4 0! 3 9 0 0 0 ° 0 ° 0 Interchang Lossof Closure(Yuan) 0 21996 0 3996 389961 0 . 0 - °0 0_ 0- 0 FloorArea(m2) 0 192.59 0 331 15 264.821 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Household 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 GuangyuanWorking Staff 0o 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Interchang Lossof Closure(Yuan) 0 o0 0 3867 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea(m2) 0 01 0! 349.3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Household 0 °l °- ---° - o - °--- Northof WorkingStaff 0 01 01 0° 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Donghuado'Loss of Closure(Yuan)l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Rd. IFloorArea(m2) 0 0 0° 0 0 o- o o o 0 Household 0 0 0 0 0 0 °0 °0 0 Southof {WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0' 0 0 0 0 0 DonghuadoLoss of Closure(Yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0! 0! 0 0 0 0 0 Rd. FloorArea(m2) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Households 0 2 8 3 5 0 1 0 2, 0 0 0 Grand WorkingStaff 0 4 25 9 18 0 3 0j 101 oi o Total 'Loss of Closure(Yuan) 0 21996 164755 10053 52229 0 49901 0 128746[ 0i 0 0 FloorArea(m2) 0 192.59 900.42 741.12 663.13 0 48.34 0! 1126.55 ol 0 0 0 0 Table 3.1.5.4A:Temporary Shop Classification and Distributionalong the Alignmentof IRR for PhasesI and II of GuangzhouCity CenterTransport Projects -Accordin-g to M-ainTra-dei 1 2 3 4 5 ~~ ~~7 ~~891 ~~ ~~~~~6 I 12 134 Section Content GeneralM lElectronic Service IndustrialConstructi AgriculturTAutomobil Automobil Foodstuff Small Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others Total Househol-d-3 10~ 19 32 3W 4 i 1 15 0 5 2 37 142 Huangsha WorkingStaff . 261 411 74 113 14 7 2 --1 ___ 33 0 18 - 5-- -139 473 Loss of Closure(Yuan) 49812 62609~ 753331 225346 32510 14818 0 1753 68186 0 162076 9005 165547 _ 866977 FloorArea(m2) 371.161349.58, 3920.64 992.64k105.63 99.06 14.83 9.44 510.27 0 578.31 86.35 2089.73 9127.64 Household 10 21 14 23 26 0 4 3 3 2 0 6 22 115 Xichang WorkingStaff 31 4 48; 133 971 0 8 13 7 8 0 18 79 446 Interchange Loss of Closure(Yuan) 125326 10196 1705631 150819 159623 0 12609 30950 17683 17870 0 20200 158500 874339 FloorArea(m2) 482.7 72,59 2066.39 714.17 893.77 0 92.33 _97 30.88 -81.95 0 74.76 663.53 -5270.06 Household 22 7 3 24 10 0 3 5 -- 11224 58 Guangyuan Working Staff 54 1-9 48 56 31, 0 -- I8 0 -- 10 1. ---- 30 2 161 420 Interchange Lossof Closure(Yuan)l 101000 17700 118059 142079 75200 0 16000 0 16578 0 83000 2300 490008 1061924 Floor Area(m2) I 1. 9.3 552 62.021 308 l269.15 0 34 1.714.1 2.62372.33 6274.75 Household ' 19 10 -24 12' 7 0 - 3 1 7 0…6 18 102 Northof WorkingStaff 631 36~ 691 33j 24 01 5 2 13 0 5 0 ill 361 DonghuadoniLoss of Closure(Yuan)~2164811~ 203232 360430Q 83851 1119666 0 15336 4610- 56486 0 5895 0 614869 1680856 Rd. !Floor Area(m2) 78.8 2'210.5 239.081 186.57 68.3 270.42 212.92 0 60.37 0 1275.65 4727.56 Household I Ii 1 QI 1: 2 0, 17 0 1 0 0 1 1 25 Southof ZWrIkingStaff 5: 3 0 3 11' 0; 49 0 1 0 0 10 2 - 84 Donghuadon1LosoClse(an 755 5950 6000~ 49102 0' 570160 0 2637 - 0 0 14664 8000 664053 Rd. !FloorArea(m2) I 24.72' 32.57 0 39.31 61.02 0819.72 0 20 64 32.74 1038.54 IHousehold 65 30 80 92 48 4~ 281 5 31 3 18 11 127 542 Grand WvorkingStaff 179' 103. 239! 338 177 7~ 721 16 64 9 53 35- 492 1784 Total Lossof Closure(Yuan) 500164' 299682 724385:608095' 436101 1481816141051 37313 161570 17870 250971 -46169 1436924 5148149 FloorArea(m2) 2178.3611074.69 7701.64 2847.21 1547.27 99.06112-64.33[ 3'76.-8 6 830.0-9 -9-902-1-7- 8-2.3-9" 2-03.67 6433.98- 2-6438.55 0 0 Table 3.1.5.4B: Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IlIlof GCCTP According to Main Trade Section Content 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 General Electronic Service Industrial ConstructAgricultur Automobil Automobil Foodstuff Small Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others GrandTotal Railway Station Overpass( Household Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 Floor Area(m ) 0 0 0 0 0 _ 0a0 0 0 0 0 0 0o 0 Huanshizhong Rd. Household Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0o 0 Loss of Closure (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 Floor Area(m ) 0 0 0 0 0 C0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 Luhu Overpass Household Number 2 0 2 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 2 1 0 11 Working Staff 7 0 9 0 f0 0 36 f0 0 0 6 5 0 63 Loss of Closure (yuan) 8695 0 11470 0 _0 0 81030 0 0 0 9990 4810 0 115995 Floor Area (m) 47 0 62 0 0 0 438 0 0 0 54 26 0 627 Hengfu Rd. Overpass Household Number 1 0 2 3 0 0 169 1 0 2 1 1 2 182 Working Staff 4 0 9 9 0 0 43 17 0 11 6 3 7 109 Lossof Closure(yuan) 5568 0 7872 7296 0 0 1962432 74688 0 5760 9216 3264 18624 2094720 Floor Area (m) 29 0 41 38 0 0 10221 389 0 30 48 17 97 10910 MeidongOverpass(east pa HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 ____ 0 0 ____0 0 ____0 0 0 0 j____ Working Staff 0 0 0 0 _ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0C0 0 0 0 Haiyinnan Overpass Household.Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 a0 0 0 o0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure (yuan) 0 0 _ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Zhen'an Overpass Household Number 0 0 0 0 0 0' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 o0 0 0 0 _ a0 0o 0 0 2 FloorArea (m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o0 0 0 0 0 0o 0 Renmin Bridge Expansion Household Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o00 0 0 0 o0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o0 0 0 IndustryAvenue HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0o 0 Working Staff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure (yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 Floor Area(m ) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 ShusheOverpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0a 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 o o0 0 o0 o0 0 0 IlIlof GCCTPAccording to Main Trade0~~ Table 3.1.5.4B:0 Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along the Alignment of IRR for Phase NantianRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 o 0 0 0_ 0 0_ C 0 0 0 0a a WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ° FloorArea (m 2) 0 0 0 o 0 0 00 0 0o o0 Total HouseholdNumber 3, 0 4 3. 0 0 173 1 0. 2 3 2 2 193 WorkingStaff 11 0 18 9 0 0 79 17 0 11 12 8 7 172 Loss of Closure(yuan) 14263 0 19342 7296 0 0 2043462 74688 0 5760 19206 8074 18624 2210715 FloorArea (m 2) 76 0 103 38 0 0 10659 389 C 30 102 43 97 11537 Coding: 1 General Merchandise 2 Electronic Product and Appliance 3 Service 4 Industrial Product Sale 5 Construction Material Sale 6 Agricultural Product 7 Automobile and Motorcycle Fitting 8 Automobile Maintenance 9 Foodstuff 10 Small Process 11 Diet 12 Bicycle/Motorcycle Maintenance 13 Others Table 3.1.5.4C: Temporary Shop Classification and Distribution along he Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Main Trade Section Content 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 General Electronic Service Industrial ConstructAgricultur Automobi Automobi FoodstuffSmall Pro Diet Bicycle/M Others GrandTotal Liu'ersanRd. & Huangsha HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 C0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .. ______FloorArea(m) 0 0 0 0 0 C0 0 C 0 __0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass HouseholdNumber 0 0 O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 C 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 FloorArea (M) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 __ 0 0 0 _ _ 0 0 0 _____0 MeidongbeiRd. HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 C 0 0 7 0 0 0 _ 0 0 ..... 7 Loss of Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 18970 0 0 0i 0 0 _ _ 18970 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 70 __ 0 0 0 0 0 0 70 Middle& WestParts of Na HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Loss of Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Floor Area(m2) 0 C 0 0 0 0 C 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 0 Total HouseholdNumber 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 . 0 0 0 O 2 WorkingStaff 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 0 00 0 0 7 Lossof Closure(yuan) 0 0 0 0 0 0C 18970 0 0 0 0 0 18970 FloorArea (m) 0 0 0 0 0 0 700 0 0 0 0 70 Coding: I General Merchandise 2 Electronic Product and Appliance 3 Service 4 Industrial Product Sale 5 Construction Material Sale 6 Agricultural Product 7 Automobile and Motorcycle Fitting 8 Automobile Maintenance 9 Foodstuff 10 Small Process 11 Diet 12 Bicycle/Motorcycle Maintenance 13 Others IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 32 Final Report .20001 '6S D Enitrely[Dnmishedwith ~~ AOOO-~~~~ *Par6tiy Deniolstid W.ithi Onershi DTerrporar)(CCntUction 0 - e r Trade 3.1.5.4 Analysis 1. As to the shops' trade characteristics, we are to have the scale management trades resettled centralizedly, and have the trades closely related to the life of residents resettled in the residential quarters as the necessary facilities required. 2. In the scale management trades area, sale of construction materials and industrial products in the shops with property right in the zones of Huangsha and Xichang Interchiange,amounts to 3,297.27 m2 and 3,840.63 m2 of automobile fitting trades in the southi and the nortlhof Donghuadong Rd. These two figures are respectively up to 35.55% and 41.41% of the scale management shops with property right. Thus, they can be resettled centralizedly into the shops in Fangcun and Baiyun Garden. 3. The categories of the trades of shops also help us caring for their business circumstances when we arrange the transition of temporary shops and shops with property rights. 3.1.6 Region Distribution ofthe Working Staff's Families ofthe Shops 3.1.6.1 Family region distribution 1. The family distribution of the working staff of the entirely demolished shops with property righit is shown in Table 3.1.3. 2. The family distribution of the working staffof the temporarily built shops is showil il Table 3.1.3. 0 o 0or T able 3.1.6A: Classification and Distribution of the Entirely Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phases I and 11 of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project According to Owner's Address Household Address Ownership Section Dongshan Liwan Yuexiu Haizhu Tianhe Fangchun Huangpu Baiyun Others Grand Total Huangsha I 181 20 17 1 0 0 6 1 237 With Xichang Interchange 22 242 11 II 3 1 0 4 15 309 Ownership Guangyuan Interchange 5 130 18 10 1 4 0 13 1 182 North of Donghuadong Rd. 238 44 41 52 36 0 4 32 17 464 South of Donghuadong Rd. 105 9 13 6 2 1 0 6 1 143 Grand Total 381 606 103 96 43 6 4 61 35 1335 Huangsha 38 263 41 56 9 23 4 11 28 473 Xichang Interchange 17 285 35 16 13 27 1 24 28 446 Temporary Guangyuan Interchange 11 326 15 13 10 7 0 15 23 420 Shops North of Donghuadong Rd. 219 36 21 18 29 1 2 11 24 361 South of Donghuadong Rd. 43 13 15 7 1 0 0 5 0 84 Grand Total 328 923 127 110 62 58 7 66 103 1784 Grand Total 709 1529 230 206 105 64 11 127 138 3119 o ~~~~0 Ta 6B: Classification and Distribution of the Fully Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase Ill of GCCTPAccording to Owner's Address Ownership Section Family Address (by district) Total Dongshan Liwan Yuexiu Haizhu Tianhe Fangchun Huangpu Baiyun Others With Ownership Railway Station Overpass(Dabei Ramp) 0 0 0 0 0 C0 0 0 o o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00o 0 _ 0 0 _ 0 0 0 Hengfu Rd. Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 C a __ a MeidongOverpass 48 15 18 12 29 27 39 42 27 257 Haiyinnan Overpass 14 21 26 7 3 4 0 28 13 116 6 58 18 29 12 7 16 32 6 184 31 106 87 142 49 74 12 89 32 622 Industry Avenue 7 46 3 51 6 2 2 16 0 133 Shushe Overpass 29 37 21 83 10 9 22 16 6 233 East Part of Nantian Rd. 0 0 0 481 0 0 0 0C 0 48 Sub-total 135 283 173 372 109 123 91 223 84 1593 Temporary Shop Railway Station Overpass(Dabei Ramp) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 31 11 2 6 12 0 0 0 1 63 Hengfu Rd. Overpass 47 2 39 3 9 1 3 1 2 107 Meidong Overpass 0 0 0 0 _ 0 0t 0 0 0 0 Haiyinnan Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 oo00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0C0 0 0 Industry Avenue 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Shushe Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 East Part of NantianRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Sub-total 78 13 41 9 21 1 3 1 3 170 Total 213 296 214 381 130 124 94 224 87 1763 Table 3.1.6C: Classification and Distribution of the Fully Demolished Shops with Ownership along the Alignment of IRR for Phase IV of GCCTP According to Owner's Address Ownership Section FamilyAddress (by district) Total Dongshan Liwan Yuexiu Haizhu Tianhe Fangchun Huangpu Baiyun Others With Ownership Liu'ersanRd. & HuangshaAvenue 37 197 104 86 44 39 18 2 0 527 HengfuRd. Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Middle& West Partsof NantianRd. 4 6 18 147 5 17 3 0 0 200 Sub-total 41 203 122 233 49 56 21 2 0 727 TemporaryShop Liu'ersanRd. & HuangshaAvenue 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HengfuRd. Overpass 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 MeidongbeiRd. 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 7 Middle& West Partsof NantianRd. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Sub-total 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 7 Total 46 203 122 233 49 56 21 2 2 734 IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 33 Final Report O 3.2 Descriptionof CommercialResettlement Sites 3.2.1 Periphery land Feasible for Multi-purpose Commercial Building and Available Areas Area of periphery Area of multi- Fields land (m2 ) purpose commercial building (m2) 1. In the northeastcorner merging fields of Duobao 630 3,000 Road and HuangshaAvenue. 2. In the northwest corner merging fields of Duobao 610 3,000 Road and HuangshaAvenue. 3. In the boundaryfield of HuangshaAvenue and 650 3,200 Zhujiang Bridge. 4. XinguangRestaurant nearby fieldin Nan'an Road. 1,200 6,000 5. The southeastcorner field of Nan'an Roadand 750 3,700 Dongfengxi Road _ 6. No. 508 in DonghuadongRoad 340 1,700 7. The northeastcorner field in the boundaryof 1,200 6,000 DonghuadongRoad (There are 300 m2 building neededto be removedextremely, excluded from the total amount of the resettlement). 8. No. I Yongshenzhongshain DonghuRoad. 100 500 Total 5,480 27,100 Detailed geology distribution of the above eight periphery lands is shown in Fig. 3.2.1. Explanation: The usage of the periphery land aims to resettle shops possibly on the original sites to keep the same commercial advantages and management environment, and to benefit from the project with intensifying location advantages from the construction of the Inner Ring Road. 3.2.2 Shops in the Resettlement Sites 3.2.2.1 Shops in Guocun Quarter located in Fangcun District which abounds of households with a convenient transport. That will much benefit the management of industrial products, such as construction material. 3.2.2.2 Shops in Banyun Garden, lie near the New Guangcong Highway, whichl is a key highway from Guangzhou to Conghua with an immense flow of vehicle. That will much benefit the management of automobile fittings. 3.2.3.1 Locations of these sites and details are described in section 2.2.1 and related figure . 0 N1II7,Sh. Cun~ Lk0 ' ShimStation */ ' 3.2 igP4 =MJ mNii8g i,*w . A-M, Ah t/ },,- ! \{ FIGURE 3.2 Distribution Figure of Shops Relocation Sites and RelationshipFigure). '3Q(leEbE§;3atI ~1 ,KtK \ I °ofShops Demonlished Regions and Shops Relocation Sites e t i\-T) Distribution Figure of ShopS-DemolishedRegion Figure of Inner Ring '\L'';'"'''6;h"' (< E" \to A'|J o:;I EMIl I~~~~~~:M ric4um Eg WIRivOrcl4a5i '~~G~ocunQurter Ip h-u IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 34 Final Report (D 3.2.3 PeripheryLands Feasible for TemporaryShop but not for Multi-purposeCommercial Buildings. 1. The periphery lands in the southeast and southwest corner fields in the boundary of Duobao Road and Huangsha Avenue, is about 1,500 m2 2. The periphery land along the Nan'an Road and Huanshixi Road nearby Xichang Interchange, is about 600 m2 3. The periphery land inside Guangyuan Interchange is about 1,500 m2 4. The periphery land of the two sides of the unblocked ends of Donghu Road, is about 500 m2 5. The periphery land in Caiyuandong and Caiyuanbei, is about 200 m2 6. The above periphery land amount to 4,300 m2. They are available for building up about 8,600 m2 temporary shops to resettle the shops which rent temporary structure. 3.2.4 Distribution and Amount Chart of Multi-purpose Commercial Building Distribution of the Multi-purpose Commercial Building and Temporary Building -Huangsha4 -' -----'' . Vchakng-_IiXl S\EruWiA::se:l G ) 2&L_._*Synthetic - (;uangyuan Building .]Terrporary Building North and South of Donghuadong - 1OO02O0O0300040O05000600070008o0900o10000l Area(m2) 3.3 Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures for the Shops 3.3.1 Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures for the Entirely Demolished Shops with Property Rights. 3.3.1 .1 General resettlement standards and rehabilitation measures for the entirely demolished shops witlh property rights l. The users of the shops will receive the compensation for housing arrangement and other related compensation. * The resettlement standard is based on their floor area. Those which will be relocated on the original site, won't have an increased area. Those which will be relocated in different Q place, will have the same incrementstandard as the dwellinghouses'. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 35 Final Report The other related compensations such as closure loss compensation and compensation of business in different places. 2. The owners of the shops will receivia me ascompensation for the housing resettlement and other related compensations. It is just as same as that of the dwelling houses(See 2.3.2). 3. Those who are both owners and users will receive the two above compensations. Detailed regulations of the compensation standard are shown in the Section 5.2 of Resettlement Policy. 3.3.1.2 Rehabilitation measures for the entirely demolished shops with property rights I. The GREEO will try its best to keep the composition of the original shop groups. It will build up temporary shops and resettle them in the suitable sites while focusing on the resettlement of the shops with property rights. Furthermore, it will classify the shops according to their main trades, and overall arrange the shops with property right and temporary shop groups. 2. Whether the shops run well or not is depended on the following two conditions: * One depends on residents and floating population, such as diet and small articles of daily use. * The other one does not depend too much on residents and floating population, but mainly depends on scale management and convenient transport such as construction material, automobile fitting and sales of industrial product. So we decide to relocate the trades which depend on residents and flowing sale clerks in the big buildings built at the periphery lands. The trade of construction material will be resettled in Guocun Quarter, and the automobile fitting trade in Baiyun. To those private shops behind which are dwelling houses, we will relocate parts of them in residential quarters, managing daily necessaries. 3. We will shorten the transition duration as far as possible, to shortenithe affected duration, and to reduce the compensation for closure loss paid by the GREEO. There are two methods: * To demolish the houses in the sites suitable for building the multi-purpose commercial building at the periphery land in advance, and to build the building as sooInas possible. * To demolish other shops when the emergency of land acquisition for the project occur. To those located at the sites of the project which are not needed at once(such as the Apollo restaurant in Duobao Road), they will be removed until the multi-purpose commercial building is completed. Thus, judging from thle overall affected shops, the transition duration will be shortened. 4. During the transition duration of the shops, the GREEO will rent some special markets and resettle the affected shops to have their transitional business. The GREEO will pay compensation to those which will really have a decreasing income due to the relocation, to reduce the compensation of closure loss reasonably. 5. The GREEO will fully consider the specialties of the private shops, and take reasonable care of them in the layout of the commercial building. 6. There will be 60 days to prepare for the relocation for the affected shops. 7. To the shops which want to move back, the GREEO will allow them back after the 0 / commercialbuilding is ready for business. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 36 Final Report Q 3.3.1.3 Complementon resettlementstandards and rehabilitationmeasures I . Compensation for housing in cash is paid at replacement price without depreciation. The three standards are used in the following zones. They are: a. 4000Yuan/ m2 (floor area) in Huangsha, Xichang Interchange, b. 4500Yuan/ m2 in Guangyuan Interchange c. 5000Yuan/ m2 in Donghuadong Rd.. 2. Compensation for other attachments is conducted in accordance with the same standards of the dwelling houses. 3. Compensation of closure loss for the enterprises is the total amount of the wages of working staff and the pension for the retired, welfare expense and the profit after tax. The enterprises will receive the compensation and then pay to the individuals. Duration of closure of production is calculated according to the actual time. 4. Some private shops have no records of the loss and profit, but only the sum of sales of legal taxing. Their closure loss will be compensated by the below formula: Legal sum of sale x average trade profit rate. The average trade profit rates are: Generalmerchandise 20% Services 30% Maintenance 35% Agriculturalproduct 15% Constructionmaterial and industrialproduct 10% Automobilefitting 15% Others 20% Gross Profit Rate of Vary Trades Gross Pofit i: - -- : *30%' |fr 20% - :;. . : - 0 0 C Tride 5. Closure loss compensation of 100 Yuan/person monthly is given to the private shops with income less than 100 Yuan/person. 6. Compensation for the loss of business in different places: IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 37 Final Report * The manager who have to do business in different places (relocated in quarters), will 0 ) receive one year compensationat 50% of the loss of closureof production. * To the managers with transitional business, the compensation is based on the average turnover per square meter in the transitional market comparing with the original turnover. If the difference is negative, the compensation is calculated as: difference x average profit rate. 7. The moving fee is paid as 15 Yuan/ m2 (floor area). 8. There are 15 days of closure period during the relocation for compensation of the closure loss. 9. Decoration compensation: To the decoration after being reported and built, compensation of price difference will be paid to the commercial enterprises if the decoration standard is higher than that of the resettlement housing. The fitting up materials can be demolished and owned by the owner in case that it doesn't affect the safety of the housing. 10. To those who rent the shops at a high market-price, because they can rent other shops in the original site at the same rent, actually the relocation will not affect them. So the rent loss of the owner will be compensated to them. 3.3.1.4 Allocation principles and standards of the resettlement sites and the area of the entirely demolished shops 3.3.1.4.1 Allocation principles of resettlement sites I. Shops managing construction materials or industrial products will be relocated in Guocun Quarter. 2. Shops managing automobile fittings will be relocated in Baiyun Garden. 3. The private shops behind which is dwelling houses of the owner will be relocated in various residential quarters 4. Other trade shops will be relocated in the nearby multi-purpose commercial buildings on the periphery lands. 5. Allocation principles of the shops in the building are: 1-3 stories are shops. the above are offices of some shops and warehouses. 3.3.1.4.2 Resettlement standard of housing area 1. The area of the shops relocated in quarters will be enlarged by 15%. 2. Shops relocated into the multi-purpose commercial buildings on the periphery land will not have an increment area. 3.3. 1.4.3 The resettlement timetable is shown in Table 2.4.3 3.3.2 Resettlement Standards and Rehabilitation Measures for the Partially Demolished Shops with Property Rights 3.3.2.1 The resettlement standards for the shops is shown in Resettlement Policy 5. 3.3.2.2 Those which have to be closed will receive the compensation at the standard shown in Resettlement Policy. Those which will be affected during the course of partial demolition will be Q compensated at the following formula: sum = reduced turnover x average trade gross profit rate. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 38 Final Report O>3.3.2.3 The shopswhich will be partiallydemolished for the pedestrianlanes, will be restoredafter completing the project. The demolished parts are allowed to be additionally built or relocated into the nearby multi-purpose commercial building on the periphery land. 3.3.3 Compensation Standards and Rehabilitation Measures for the Temporary Shops 3.3.3.1 The temporary shops emerged in the planned regions only when the local economic development had the demand but could not develop due to fund(or when there are conflict between building permanent housing and the planning). Generally, they are built by the land-using units and then are rent to the shop manager at a high market price. (Rent of the temporary shops in Huangsha Avenue is 250-300 Yuan/month per square meter of floor area). Therefore, they will not be much affected during the demolition. See the Appendix I of the Resettlement Policy for details. 3.3.3.2 The temporary shops' managers are responsible for organizing the relocation, because they all have promised in the lease contact that " We will move without any presupposition if it is required by the municipal project". 3.3.3.3 Though the managers of temporary shops are responsible for organizing the relocation and have no any resettlement housing and compensation with the same treatment as the shops with property right, the GREEO will offer the following assistance to those who have some difficulties in relocation, to avoid great damage to the local commercial structure. 1. The temporary shops will be built on the periphery land which are not suitable for building permanent housing and the priority will be given to the managers to be resettled at an unchanged rent. 2. To introduce markets in the downtown for the managers and offer them a priority in renting with 10% rent discount. 3. To the large scale units who are able to build temporary shops along the alignment, they will be permitted but the priority must be given to the mangers to be resettled. 4. If the managers can not find shops for business any longer, we will be responsible for finding equivalent shops for them. 5. The moveming fee and suitable compensation will be paid. 3.3.3.4 The GREEO will not pay any compensation to the owners of those temporary shops whose contracts expire. But to those with contract period remaining, the GREEO will pay by the combination of construction costs and the period remaining. 3.3.3.5 The users of the temporary shops whose contracts expire, will not have any compensation. The users with contract period remaining will be provided with temporary management sites with 10% rent discount of the local market rate. 0 IRRResettlement Implementation Plan 39 Final Report 4. AFFECTED INSTITUTIONS AND RESETTLEMENT STANDARDS 0 AND REHABILITATION MEASURES 4.1 Statusof the Impacts 4.1 .1 The institutions refer to those big government units and enterprises along the alignment. The cross-depth of this big institutions is up to 50-200 m while single-side expansion width is only 5-10 m along the alignment in the first and second phase of the Inner Ring Road Project, so 5-10 m's road occupation won't have too much impact to make the big institutions relocated entirely. 4.1.2 The compensation for the affected dwelling houses and shops owned by institutions had already been described in the former chapters. Impacts described here refer to the other housing and facilities except for the houses of dwellings and shops. Because these houses and facilities are connected to main body of their institutions, and not suitable for being moved to other places, these houses and facilities are generally supposed to be restorated by rebuilding after retreating. 4.1.3 Along the alignment of the first and second phase of the Inner Ring Road Project, The followings are to be relocated: 1. 15,974.75 m2 houses belonging to 79 institutions 2. 7,340 m2 enclosing wall 3. 12,600 m2 cement ground 4. 15 industrial distillation tanks 5. 20,000 m2 land acquired from the institutions 4.1.4 Among 15974.75 m2 housing area, there are: I . 4,211.07 m2 reinforced concrete houses 2. 6,591.03 m2 brick and concrete houses 3. 2,414.60 m2 brick and tile houses 4. 2,758.05 m2 simple houses 4.2 Rehabilitation Measures and Principles 4.2.1 Generally, the institutions are very large and the houses to be relocated with an average area of 200 m2/unit, so they will be rebuilt after demolition. It is easy for them to adjust inside, instead of closure of business or suffering any damage. 4.2.2 But to the Guangzhou Condiment Works located at Huasha Avenue, which has 15 industrial distillation tanks to be relocated and will have to stop production of the entire Works. In order to minimize the loss of closure of production as far as possible, the staff who are in charge of the relocation of the Works will acquire the backward land for it and to install the tanks first. The loss of closure of production will be compensated during the period of closure of production. 4.2.3 Principles of the institutions' relocation are fully as same as those of the shops'. 0 IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 40 Final Report (I) 4.3 CompensationStandards 4.3.1 Compensation standards of houses and facilities 1. Reinforced concrete houses 1,000 Yuan/m2 2. Brick and concrete houses 800 Yuan/m2 3. Brick and tile houses 600 Yuan/m2 4. Simple houses 300 Yuan/m2 5. Enclosing walls 80 Yuan/m2 6. Cement ground 80 Yuan/m2 Other attachments will be compensated based on their construction cost. 4.3.2 Land acquisition The municipal project won't compensate for land acquisition to the institutions, for most of the land of institutions were allocated historically by the state, without handing in any payment before. But for those who had paid, they will be paid back in accordance with the original standard. 4.3.3 Compensation for the institutions' loss of closure of production The institutions' loss due to closure of business/production will be compensated based on the actual impacts and the closure period. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 41 Final Report Q 5. AFFECTED PUBLIC AND CULTURAL FACILITIES 5.1 Introduction There are altogether four units of public and cultural facilities affected by the first phase of the Inner Ring Road Project. Namely, Junyi SportCourt in Dongshandistrict, Traditional Chinese Medicine Clinic of Acupuncturein Dongshandistrict, Caiyuandong Kindergarten, the third Kindergartenof YangchenRailway General Company. There is one unit of public and cultural facilitiesaffected by the secondphase of the Inner Ring Road Project:Kangning Hospital. Note: The Public and culturalfacilities here mean that the units are needed to be moved entirely; Someto be partially demolished,such as DongshanDistrict Hospital, are very large and not be moved entirely so that the classificationof impactsbelong to the categoryof affected institutions and units (seen in 4 of the RAP). 5.2 Details of the Impacts 1. Junyi Sport Court in DongshanDistrict. Land area is 5,745 m2 and the floor area with ownershipis 240.00 m2. 2. TraditionalChinese Medicine Clinic of Acupuncturein Dongshandistrict. The floor area of the house rent from overseasChinese is 680 m2. There are 43 workingstaff and 10 retired staff. The wages for the staff are 42,100 Yuan/monthand 11,000Yuan/month for the retired 0~\; staff. 17,843Yuan/ month profit after tax and about 2,400patients/month are existing. 3. Caiyundongkindergarten. There are floor area of 936.29m2in three-story reinforced concrete structurewith ownership,a coveringarea of 190.4m2,51 workingstaff and 18 retired ones. 51,115 Yuan/monthis paid for the working staff and 9,640 Yuan/monthfor the retired ones, about 200 childrenin the kindergarten. 4. The third Kindergartenof YangchenRailway General Company. There are floor area of 1,212m2of temporarystructure, 335m2 ceiling area, 23 staff. 7,360 Yuan/monthis paid for the staff and about 250 childrenare in the kindergarten. 5. KangningHospital in Liwan district.There are 700m2floor area withiownership, 69 working staff, 22 retired ones, 71,059Yuan/month is paid for the working staff, 11,151Yuan/month for the retired ones, 18,000Yuan/month profit after tax and2,500 patients per month. 5.3 RehabilitationMeasures I. Junyi Sport Court in Dongshandistrict will be allocatedto DongshanDistrict Government throughthe MunicipalGovernment and will be bid, developedand rebuilt. Its physical training facilitieswill be restoredby DongshanDistrict Government. 2. TraditionalChinese Medicine Clinic of Acupuncturein Dongshandistrict will be relocated into the permanentcommercial multi-purpose building on the periphery land to be required. It is not to be closed. If the project need to acquirethe land in emergency,the GREEO will rent suitable spaces in the scope of 2 km nearbyto support its practice. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 42 Final Report 3. Caiyuandong Kindergarten will be located into the permanent commercial multi-purpose building on the periphery land to be required or rebuilt at the original sites. In case that it need to be removed before construction for the project, the GREEO rent the housing within the nearby range of 1 km to ensure the studying of the children. 4. The third Kindergarten of Yangcheng Railway General Company will be restored by Yangcheng Railway General Company in the buildings of the company. 5. Kangning Hospital in Liwan district will be relocated into the permanent commercial multi- purpose building on the periphery land to be acquired. It can not be closed and the GREEO will provide the transition site. 6. The resettlement housing for the two hospitals/clinics and the two kindergartens will be well sound-isolated. 7. The above units will move back to the original sites within 2 years after demolition. 5.4 Compensation Standards 1. The two hospitals will receive the equivalent resettlement and compensation to the original area. 2. Caiyuandong Kindergarten will have an extra compensation of 95m2 indoors activity court, except a compensation of 936.29m2 area. 3. The damnageto the medical facilities will be compensated due to move. 4. The transition site for the three units will be rented by the GREEO. 5. All the moving work will be completed by the GREEO. 6. The removed attachments of the three units will be compensated and restored by the GREEO. 0 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 43 Final Report 6. LAND ACQUISITION AND COMPENSATION RATE AND JOB CREATION The alignment of the Inner Ring Road Project is inside the city with no agricultural land involved in. Agricultural land acquisition is only used to build resettlement housing. 1. Guocun quarter in Fangcun district will be acquired 83.20 mu totally. 2. Haijing Garden/Yuani an Street quarter in Haizhu district will be acquired 7.58 mu totally. 6.1 Introductionto the AcquiredLand Table 6.1 shows the situation of the acquired lands: Table 6.1 The Situation of Township/District Land for the Inner Ring Road Project(Phase 1, II) Township Totalof the Land Agricultural HouseholdPlots Factoryand Business /District to be Acquired Land Sites Mu Affected Mu Affected Mu House- Person Mu Plant Worker Person Person hold Guocun 83.2 65 70 32 0.56 4 I 9.64 1 22 Haijing 7.58 25 5.61 11 1.97 5 14 0 0 0 /Yuani an Street Total 90.78 90 75.61 43 2.53 9 25 9.64 I 22 Note: Only 5053 m2 is farm land in the area 18855m2 of HaijingGarden (Yuan'an Street) 6.2 Compensation Rate of Land Acquisition The corresponding compensation policies were prepared particularly to ensure all kinds of the above impacts can be compensated and resettled properly. 6.2.1 Land acquisition of the collective land Details of the resettlement and compensation of the two resettlement sites are shown in Table 6.2.1 below. Item Basiccompensation Compensationfor Compensationfor Compensationfor for land laborarragement standingcrops power supply and irrigationworks Standard 7 110,000- 30,00OYuan/person 3,00OYuan/mu Replacementcost 130,00OYuan 0 IRRResettlement Implementation Plan 44 Final Report 6.2.2 The explanations and the main purposes of the various payment for compensation are: 1. Basic payment for land is 110,000--130,00OYuan/mu,which include that for the collective and private structures on the land. It is mainly used to develop the economic latent capability based on agriculture of the production teams. 2. Job creation allowance is 30,000 Yuan/person. It is mainly used for economic rehabilitation and resettlement of the affected labors due to the project by means of non-agriculture arrangement. There are details in 6.3. 3. Compensation for the loss of standing crops is 3,000 Yuan/mu, given to the farmers through the Township Government. 4. Compensation for the loss of irrigation works is based on the actual quantities and formats on the agricultural land to be required. The land acquisition units will compensate them at replacement cost through the Township Government. 6.2.3 For the affected township & village enterprise and the farmers' housing on the household plots, the land acquisition unit will reapply for rebuilding the houses in the original range from the Municipal Planning Department. Their compensation standards of temporary transition and closure of production are based on the specific provisions of the j0lmplementation Measures of Housing Demolition and Management in Guangzhoui± and the i 0lmplementation Details i±. 6.2.4 The policies and the compensation standards of the land acquisition and resettlement for the affected township, villages and planting farmers are shown in Resettlement Policy 5. 6.3 Job Creation 6.3.1 Non- agriculture based Rehabilitation Options 1. The number of surplus labors is calculated as follows: the affected land is divided by the average land/labor ratio before acquisition. Persons eligible refer to those between 16 and 55 years of age for males and 16 and 45 years for females, while those above age limits will be provided of old age pension. 2. The land/labor ratio after the converting of the residential registration certificate of the surplus labors from rural to urban, therefore will remain unchanged. 3. Units who employ the surplus labors can be paid by the land acquisition units of job creation compensation which are not allowed to be merged by township or production teams. 6.3.2 Subsidy of self-employment Those who possess some technical/production skills have the option of self employment. They then will get an one-time resettlement subsidy. The standards of such subsidy are: 30,000 Yuan/worker paid one-time by the land acquisition units through local Township or Village Government. 6.3.3 Payment of old age pension The old who are above the age of 55 for males and 45 for females will receive old age pension amounting to 30,000 Yuan/person one-time from the land acquisition units through local Township or Village Govemment. 0 IRRResettlement Implementation Plan 45 FinalReport 7. AFFECTED INFRASTRUCTURE AND COMPENSATION RATE 0) AND REHABILITATIONMEASURES 7.1 Affected Infrastructure 7.1.1 Of the various infrastructure facilities, the removal of pipes and lines is the most evident impact on residenti s life. So the GREEO specially appointed professionals to conduct detailed baseline surveys to ownership unit of pipelines along the alignment of IRR and put forward their schemes and opinions for resettlement. The statistics of the survey in the first and second phase of IRR are illustrated in table 7.1 .1. 7.1.2 Besides pipes and lines, there are other infrastructure facilities such as roadside trees and flowers, communication facilities, civil air defence facilities, dockage facilities. 7.2 Compensation Rates for the Affected Infrastructure 7.2.1 The compensation fees for the pipeline relocation will be discussed and decided by the GREEO and the units of title in accordance with the drawings provided by the units. The standard of national engineering quota and market price of the pipes and lines will be applied to calculate the replacement price in accordance with the former grade, format, quality and scale (without depreciation). 7.2.2 The standard of national engineering quota and market price will be applied to calculated the compensation amounts of other infrastructure for resettlement in accordance w itlhthe amoulnitsand standards of the actual moving, cutting and demolishing. 7.3 Rehabilitation Measures for the Affected Infrastructure 7.3.1 The affected infrastructure facilities will be relocated as few as possible in accordance with tlle drawings of pole location and the construction drawings of the elevated roads of the Inner Ring Road, and the principle is that the facilities have not affect the civil work. 7.3.2 To ensure that no adverse impacts on the normal life of the residents along the alignmllenit (including the residents who will not be needed to move), the affected pipelines will be rebuilt or removed by the GREEO before being demolished. r * IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 46 Final Report Table 7.1 .1 STATISTIC TABLES OF THE BASELINE SURVEYS OF THE PIPES AND LINES OF THE INNER RING ROAD PROJECT (PHASE 1, 11 ) UINITSOF NATUREOF STANDARD AMOUNTS LOCATIONAND IMPACTON SCHEMIEAND OPINION OF TITLE PIPESAND (m) THEPRINCIPAL PART THERELOCATION LINES 1. Municipal 1. Principal gas DN400 2,550 Located at Huanshixi Road All pipes locate in the Coal Gas pipes (Dongfeng Road to South projection lines of the Corporation China Cinema). The elevated roads (Inner Ring principal pipes are buried in Road) to affect the 0.8-1.2 m deep and under the construction of pole original pavement of the foundation, so need to be high-speed lanes, 6-8 m removed. away from the pedestrian lane. DN300 2,100 Located at Nan'an Road idem (Zhongshanba Road to Dongfeng Road). The principal pipes are buried in 0.8-1.2 m deep and under the original pavement of the high-speed lanes, 1-5 m away from the pedestrian lane. 2. Branch gas DN100 1,000 0.8- 1.0 m deep. enter the Need to be rebuilt if the level pipes users through the branches. of the pavement is dropped. 3. Coal gas / 46 Most of them distribute in well the branches. Little impact on the principal part of the elevated roads. 2. Yangcheng 1. Cable pipes 2-8 holes 29,900 The whole overhead systems The sections which can Railwav of Huangshixi Road are affect poles foundations such General across four railway as sections of Huangsha, Corporation, maintenance squads and Ruyifang, will be removed or Guangzhou locate in the range of the rebuilt first, the other Section of property lines of the land sections will be removed as Electric & acquisition. few as possible in Power accordance with the Department drawings of the pole 2. Cables in HEQ 21x4 520 The pipes and lines needed location and the construction pipes to Pipelines HEQ 23x4 1,460 be removed/rebuilt are about drawings if they haven't HEQ 27x4 4,140 0.8-1.2 m deep from forrmer influence on the construction. HEQ212x4 3,770 pavement. In the section of HESYEL 3.310 Huangsha and Ruyifang, the 2217x4 communication nets locate in the centre of the former HQ2 4,250 roads and the green belt. So ______(30-800P) the impacts are great. IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 47 Final Report lNITS OF NATURE OF STANDARD AMOUNTS LOCATION AND INMPACTON SCHEME AND OPINION OF TITLE PIPES AND (m) THE PRINCIPAL PART THE RELOCATION LINES HYAT 2,040 (30-600P) 3. Overhead HYAT 150 cables (300P) 4. TV trans- / 150 mission lines 2. Yangcheng 5. Signal cable / 12,000 Railway with 48 cores General 6. Roadside / 12 number Corporation, signal machines Guangzhou _ Section of 7. Roadside / 4 number Electric Power main signal machines 8. Roadside 0 sections 3. Troop 8700 1. Symmetry HEQ- 2,040 The lines locate in the hold the mixed lane of the of Guangzhou cable of long 2527x4 pedestrian lanes from new roads and need to be Air Force distance call Zhujiang Bridge to relocated, because of laying Dongfeng Road. straight ways, advise to use 2. Cable of HQ2-2040 0 protection way. local call 4. Baiyun l. Pipelines for / 91,800 The impact on principal part Branch of communication of the viaducts vary with the Municipal different sections. For Telephone example, Office 2. District of I 21 number The drop of new road surface distribution of have great impact on the lines lines. 3. Communi- 8 standards 13,950 cation cables 5. Centre 1. High tension 2,499 The holes of the high tension The high tension cables and Power Supply cables cables locate in present small open holes need to be Bureau pedestrian lanes. This cables protected or reformed at 2. Open holes 416 may not affect the principal original plots because of for cable body of the project by unknown levels. The watching the drawings. The pipelines across roads need low tension cables locate in to be relocated by watching 3. Pipelines of / 0 the range of property lines, the drawings because the cables so they have some impact on pole locations are uncertain. the project. The low tension lines need to 4. Low tension / 0 be relocated temporarily or lines permanently, because they are within the property lines IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 48 Final Report UNITS OF NATURE OF STANDARD AMOUNTS LOCATION AND IMPACT ON SCHEME AND OPINION OF TITLE PIPES AND (m) THE PRINCIPAL PART THE RELOCATION ______LINES 6. Municipal 1. Used for / 40 number Mainly locate in interchange Road Lamp installing 25- sites Station 30m high lamp 2. Installing 1,086 need to demolish former 8m iron pole lamps and install new lamps lamps and along the route from under-bridge Huangsha Avenue to lamps Huanshixi Road. 7. Liwan Communication 0 The resources are under Branch of lines collection. They all affect Telephone the principal body of the Office project by watching the drawings. 8. Power High and low 0 Idem Supply Bureau tension lines of West Zones and pipe-holes 9. Power Substation / 0 Idem Supply Bureau of East Zones I10. Water Water supply I0dem Corporation pipelines Total / 180,065 Idem 0 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 49 Final Report C 8. COST AND BUDGET The cost of land acquisitionand resettlementare includedin the overallbudget of the Inner Ring Road project. During the implementationof land acquisitionand resettlementand compensation,the Project Office will ensurethe funds for land acquisitionand resettlementof the Inner Ring Road project on the specifiedschedule so as to completethe projecton the purposeddate. 8.1 Explanationfor Cost and Budgetof LandAcquisition and Resettlementfor the Inner Ring RoadProject The Research Center for Market & Economyand Populationof ZhongshanUniversity was responsiblefor the census of Phase I & II of the Inner Ring Road. The census have been finishedon 29 Dec., 1995. Afterthat, we have analyzedthe census data in detailsand estimatedthe costs of land acquisitionand resettlement. 1. Estimateof the demandof resettlementhousing and costs. The estimate is in accordance with the total demolition areas and the affected households. Sevenfactors of affectingresettlement area are consideredon the basis of the following items: livingconditions of the affectedresidents, population structure, housing structure, etc. Then with previousexperience data, the areasto be needed:areworked out. Becausethe project is very urgent, it is impossibleto solveall the resettlementproblem by buildingmany quarters in a short time. So the methodof both buyingcommercial housing and constructing resettlementsites duringthe InnerRing Road Project will be adopted. The seven 0J resettlementsites will be selectedin BaiyunGarden, Guocun Quarter, Tongde Quarter, XiaogangwanQuarter, Dongpu Quarter, Haijing Garden/Yuan'anStreet Quarterand Nani an Building. The affectedshops will be rebuilt on the original land, or by rebuilding somemarkets on the periphery land and relocatingthe shops in the residentialquarters. We have drafted the plan of funds in accordancewith the price of the purposedresettlement housing. 2. Compensationfor institutionsand temporaryshops. Accordingto housingstructure and constructioncost of existinghousing, we have establishedthe housingcompensation standards. 3. Compensationfor Others affected. Apart from the compensationfor resettlementhousing, other compensationsare chiefly given as follows: a. Compensationfor the closureof business,auxiliary facilities, telephone relocation, loss of business in differentplaces, ect.. b. Compensationfor moving,relocation of telephonesand cable TV, rewardfor moving ahead of time, etc.. c. Compensationfor facilitiessuch as pipelines,transport facilities, civil air defence projects, trees/lawnsand other related administrativefees. 'O IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 50 Final Report According to related trade stipulations, policies, regulations and experience data, we (D estimatedthe costs. 4. Costs of land acquisition for the first phase of the Inner Ring Road Project Due to the fact that the Inner Ring Road will be built in the centre, it doesn't need to acquire farmland for road construction, but some farmland is still acquired for resettlement houses. We have acquired 7.58 mu in Haijing Garden/Yuan'an Street, with the compensation of 1,364,400 Yuan, 83.20 mu in Guocun, with the compensation of 10,400 thousand Yuan. Now, the activities of land acquisition have been completed. Predictably, Haijing Garden/Yuan'an Street Quarter and Guocun Quarter will have been partially completed by the end of 1998. They will be used as the resettlement housing for the second and third phase of IRR, the cost of land acquisition is included in the basic costs of resettlement housing in the second and third phase. 5. Contingencies The first and second phases of Inner Ring Road Project.The scheme has basically been determined, and has been investigated in detail. Thus the contingency rate is determined to be 5%. 6. Administrative fees. According to government regulations, Administrative fees = (Basic Costs + Contingencies)iA3%. 7. The cost and budget above is calculated in accordance with the unchanged price in march,1 997(in all the tables). So the resettlement expense need to be adjusted due to inflation in the second phase of resettlement activities in 1998. 8. The resettlement expense in 1997 has not any increment than in 1996. 8.2 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for Phase I of the Inner Ring Road Project 1. Basic costs of resettlement housing and compensation is 234,512,302 Yuan (see in Tab. 8.2.1) (invest in 1997). 2. Compensation for the affected institutions, temporary structures is 7,747,708 Yuan (see in Tab. 8.2.2) (invest in 1997). 3. Other resettlement compensation is 180,920,251.62 Yuan (see in Tab. 8.2.3) (invest in 1997) 4. Contingencies: (1+2+3)jA5%=21,159,013.08 Yuan. 5. Administrative fees: (1+2+3+4)pA3% = 13,330,178.24 Yuan. 6. The total costs above are 457,669,452.94 Yuan. 0 Q ~~ ~~~~~TA2.1Q Table 8.2.11:Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expenseof IRR (Phase1, II) of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects_ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 -9 - ______12 'Incre DemaUnit Sum of Resettlement___Funds Phase Section OriginalArea(m2i,Area ilUtiliz Indivi Afii ousi Less t de Total Housing(m2) (Yuan/m2) (Yuan) I Northof DonghuadongRd. 13,611.421 20 15 20 10 0 15 -- 10 90 25,861.70i I Southof DonghuadongRd. 14,386.87 20' 151 20 10 5 20 10 100 28,773.74I I ~~~~~Sub-Total 27I 998 29/ I I/ 54,635.44 __ 3,200 174,833,408 Households' Huangsha 20,670.17 15 10] 20 10 0 15 5 75 36,172.80I_ - I !II XichangInterchange 8,729.11 15 101 201 10 5 15 6 75 -15,275.94/ GuangyuanInterchange 17,793.60 151 10 201 10 5 20 0 80 32,028.48 Sub-Total 47,192.88 / '1I 1 I 83,477.22 _ _3,200 267,127,104 Total 75,191.17I I I I I . . -138,112.66 3,200 441,960,512 Northof DonghuadongRd. 4,66169/ 20' 25 I / . 45 6,759.45I Shops(ownI Southof DonghuadongRd. 298.03 I 20, 25/ 45 -432.14I-I ship)entirely Sub-Total 4,959.72I . - 7,191.59 5 35,957,950 demolished iHuangsha 2,034.18/ iS 25!/ I/ I 40 2,847.85i and to be r 11 IXichangInterchange 1,847.09i/ 1511 251/ I/ I 40 2,585.93I located to !Guangyuan Interchange 1136.9 .i21 1/ 40 ,84.5 othersites Sub-Total 5,198.06 / I I 7,277.29_ 5,000 36,386,450 Total 10,157.78I I I . 14,468.88_ 5,000 72,344,400 Northof DonghuadongRd. 3,441.14/ 25 / I I I I25 4,301.43/ Shops(ownI Southof DonghuadongRd. 1,324.29I 25 I 251 1,655.36I ship)entirely Sub-Total 4,765.43/ i5967 1,80 10,2,2 demolished Huangsha 238.54 I 25/ I / I I 25~ 289.18II and to be r 11 XichangInterchange 5,713.73/ 25 I I 25 7,142.16// locatedon the ,GuangyuanInterchange 1,468.88/ 25 I . 25 1,836.10I - peripheryland Sub-Total 7,421.15 / / I9,267.44 - 1,800 16,681,392 Total 12,186.58I I / 1 I } 15,224.23 _1,800 27,403,614 ' TA0 2.1 Northof DonghuadongRd. 172.08/ 25 / I I I I 25 215.1 / i Shops I Southof DonghuadongRd. 74.66 / 25 1 I 1 1 ; 25 93.33 / / partially Sub-Total 246.74 / 1 I 1 / l / ' 308.43 1,800 555,174 demolished Huangsha 4,020.61 / 25t I I I I 25 5,025.76 I/_ and to be r II Xichang Interchange 752.96 / 25/ 1 I / 25 941.2 / / locatedon the GuangyuanInterchange 314.37 / 25 1 1 I / -- 25 392.96 peripheryland I Sub-Total I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~5,087.94/ I I !/ 1 I/ / I-- - 6,359.92 1,800 11,447,316 Total 5,334.68/ ;/ / I I / 6,668.35 1,800 12,003,030 North of DonghuadongRd. 919.43'/ .1 / I I / / 919.43 / . South of DonghuadongRd. 188.55lI I I I :1 / 188.55/ - The owner-i Sub-Total 1,107.981 ,107.98 _ 5,000 5,539,900 Shiprelin- jHuangsha 699.26/ i I / 1/ - ' - - 6999.26/ _ _ quishedsh III XichangInterchange 923.75 / I5 . ' 927 I GuangyuanInterchange 344.45/ Sub-Total 1,967.46/ Ii I I 1 / / / 8,267.46 5,000 9,837,300 Total 3,075.44I / I I 'I I / 9,375.44 I 15,377,200 'North of DonghuadongRd. I 1,856.29j/ 25./ I I I I 25 2,320.36/ I Public li ISouth of DonghuadongRd. 1,212.00|/ 25/ 1 / I I I 25 1,515 / and cultural Sub-Total 3,068.29I I I I /. I I / 3,835.36 1,800 6,903,648 facilities Huangsha 0/ 25/1 1 / / / 25 . 0/ to be restor91 Xichang Interchange 700: 25 1 1 .1 I I 25 875/ / on the GuangyuanInterchange - 0/ 25 / I I I 25 0/ originalland Sub-Total 700/ I I I / , . / 875 1,800 1,575.00 Total 3,768.291 1 1 1 4,710.36 1,800 8,478,648 - i GrandTotal 1,153,560,843 1 Original Area 8 Lessthan 5m2/Person 2 IncrementFactors of the ResettlementHousing(%) - Area increaseof transferringto other sit 9 AddedAttic Examinedand Approvedby Administration 3 Demandfor UtilizationRatio of New/OldHousing 10 GrandTotal 4 1 Unit Price Indivisable 11 ResettlementHousing(m2) 6 Sum of Affiliated 12 R(Yuantm2)| .i. . 7 HousingOwned by OverseasChina 13 Funds(Yuan) 0 S 0 Table 8.2.2: Compensation for the Affected Institutions and Temporary Shops of IRR for Phases I and II of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Phase Phase I Phase If Total Sort Classifiedby Area(mZ) Compensation Unit Price Compensation Area(m 2) Compensa- Unit Price Compensation Structure Ratio(%) (Yuan/m2) Funds(Yuan) tion Ratio (Yuan/m2) Sum(Yuan) Institution Frame 1,810 100 1,000 1,810,000 2,401.07 100 1,000 2,401,070 / Housing Structure Mixed 3,180 100 800 2,544,000 3,411.03 100 800 2,728,824 Structure Simply 1,334 100 600 800,400 1,424.05 100 600 854,430 / Structure Brickand 839 1000 400 335,600 575.6 100 400 230,240 Wood GrandT otal 7,163 5.490,000 7,811.75 6,214,564 11,704,564 Temporary Frame 115.32 20 1.000 23,064 413.45 20 1,000 82,690 _ Shops Structure Mixed 12,006.05 20 800 1,920,968 10,336.23 20 800 1,653,796.8 / Structure Simply 2,306.44 20 600 276,772.8 8,268.98 20 600 992,277.6 _ Structure 13rickand 461.29 20 400 36.903.2 1,653.8 20 400 132,304 / Wood GrandT'otal 14.889,1 2.257.708 20.672.46 / 2,861,068.4 5,118,776.4 Grand TIotal / 7.747.70)8 9,075,632.4 16,823,340.4 T 2.3 ol~~~ l 0 Table 8.2.3: Resettlement Expense of the First Phase of the IRR of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects ProjectName Items Demolition Unit Priceof Coefficient Compensation Amount CompensationExpense Expense(Yuan) Entirely Compensationfor Closureof Prod 10805.72m2 I 34,078,644.00 Demolished Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 10,805.72m2 50 Yuan/m2 1 540,286.00 Shopwith Ownership iLoss of Businessin OtherPlace 14,959.72m2 200 Yuan/m2*m 1 5,951,644.00 |MovingFee 110,805.72m2 15 Yuan/m2 - 1 162,085.80 Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 161 Houses 1,000Yuan/Hou 1_ 161,000.00 Sub-Total I I . 40,893,659.80 Shops Partially |Compensationfor Closureof Prod 1274.16m2 / 50%0 155,400.00 'Demolished !Payment for AuxiliaryFacilities 274.16m2 50 Yuan/m2 . 1 13,708.00 Shopwith Ownership Lossof Businessin OtherPlace 1274.16m2 I 1 0 MovingFee 1274.16m2 15 Yuan/m2 1 4,112.40 i Sub-Total ,l l 173,220.40 Temporary Compensationfor Closureof Prod 5,766.1m2 / 1 2,344,909.00 Structures MovingFee .5,766.1m2 15 Yuan/m2 1 86,491.50 Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 1127Houses 1,000Yuan/Hou 1 127,000.00 Sub-Total 2,558,400.50 Total / I 43,625,280.70 MovingFee 684 Houses '600 Yuan/Hous 1 410,400.00 Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 342 Houses 1,000Yuan/Hou 1 342,000.00 Residential Paymentfor CableTV 616 Houses 350 Yuan/Hous 1 215,600.00 Housing Rewardfor MovingAhead of Time .684Houses 800 Yuan/Hous 1 547,200.00 i Total / . 1,515,200.00 Public Compensationfor Closureof Prod 3,068.29m2 200 Yuan/m2*m 1 7,363,896.00 and Cultural Paymentfor Auxiliary Facilities 3,068.29m2 ;100Yuan/m2 i 306,829.00 Facilities Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer ,4 Houses 11,000Yuan/m2 I 2 8,000.00 MovingFee 3,068.29m2 15Yuan/m2 I 1 46,024.35 Total I i 7,724,749.35 HousingOwned Compensationfor Closureof Prod 9,001.12m2 100 Yuan/m2*m| _1 900,112.00 TA 2.3 by MovingFee 9,001.12m2 15 Yuan/m2 1' 135,016.80' Institutions Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 28 Houses 1,000Yuan/Hou 1 28,000.00 Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 9,001.12m2 50 Yuan/m2 1 450,056.00 Sub-Total 1,513,184.80 Paymentfor Pipes& lines ;/ / 1 112,997,721.00 Paymentfor Paymentfor Traffic Facilities 3.8 km 300 thousandY 1 1,140,000.00 Facilities !Payment for Civil Air DefenceFacil / / 1 7,800,000.00 Trees of Roadsideand Lawns 800 Trees 400 Yuan/Tree 1 320,000.00 Sub-Total 122,257,721.00 Paymentfor Relocationmanagem 65,351.69m2 5 Yuan/m2 1 326,758.45 OtherRelated Paymentfor RelocationNotarizatio 1 1,007Houses 100 Yuan/Hous 1 100,700.00 Payments | Paymentfor Relocation/Acquisitio1,007 Houses 170 Yuan/Hous 30% 51,357.00 Paymentfor Sanitation/PublicSec 1,007Houses 54 Yuan/House 1 54,378.00 Paymentfor Litigation/Arbitration 1,007Houses 1,500Yuan/Hou 15% 226,575.00 Sub-Total 759,768.45 Paymentfor Paymentfor ResidentialHousing 1684Houses 600 Yuan/Hous 1 410,400.00 Employment !Payment for RelocationNon-Resid 1 323 Houses 2,000Yuan/Hou 1 646,000.00_ Sub-Total 1,056,400.00 HouseRemoval, Sludge Removal 63,351.69m2 28 Yuan/m2 1 1,829,847.32 Rebuildingof ConcreteFloor and EnclosedWall 7,976m2 80 Yuan/m2 1 638,080.00 Sub-Total 2,467,927.32 Total 128,055,001.57 Entirely Compensationfor Closureof Prod 14,021.34m2 / 1 46,180,284.00 'Demolished Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 14,021.34m2 150Yuan/m2 1 701,067.00 ShopswithOwnership Loss of Businessin OtherPlace 5,198.06m2 '200 Yuan/m2*m . _ 1 6,237,672.00 MovingFee 114,021.34m2 15 Yuan/m2 1 210,320.10 Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 1179Houses 1,000YuanlHou 1 179,000.00 Sub-Total / I 1 53,508,343.10 Shops Partially Compensationfor Closureof Prod 5,653.26m2 / 50% 5,242,902.00 Demolished Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 5,653.26m2 50 Yuan/m2 1 282,663.00 ShopswithOwnership Lossof Businessin OtherPlace 5,653.26m2 / 1 0 MovingFee 5,653.26m2 15 Yuan/m2 1 84,798.90 Sub-Total ./ / / 5,610,363.90 iTemporary Compensationfor Closureof Prod .20,672.45m2 / 1 2,803,240.00 Structures MovingFee i20,672.45m2 15 Yuan/m2 1 310,086.75 Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 415Houses 1,000Yuan/Hou 1 415,000.00, TA 2.3 Sub-Total I I I 3,528,326.751 Total I I 62,647,033.75 MovingFee 1,176Houses 600 Yuan/Hous 1 705,600.00 Residential Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer !554 Houses 1,000Yuan/Hou 11 554,000.00 Housing I !Payment for CableTV 1926Houses 350 Yuan/Hous 1 324,10000 Rewardfor MovingAhead of Time 11 76 Houses 800 Yuan/Hous 1 940,80000 Total l/ i/ 2,524,500.00 Public ICompensation for Closureof Prod 700m2 200 Yuan/m2*m 1 1,680,000.00 and Cultural Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 1700m2 100 Yuan/m2 1 70,000.00 Facilities I Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 4 Houses 1,000Yuan/m2 . 2 8,000.00 MovingFee 700m2 15 Yuan/m2 1 10,500.00 Total / , , 1,768,500.00 HousingOwined Compensationfor Closureof Prod16,973.63m2 100Yuan/m2*m 1 697,363.00 by MovingFee 16,973.63m2 15 Yuan/m2 1 104,604.45 Institutions Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 151Houses 1,000Yuan/Hou 1 51,000.00 Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 6,973.63m2 50 Yuan/m2 1 348,681.50 Sub-Total 1,201,648.95 !Payment for Pipes& lines / / 1 169,496,581.70 Paymentfor 'Payment for Traffic Facilities 5.7 km 300 thousandY 1 1,710,000.00 Facilities Paymentfor Civil Air DefenceFacil / / 1 11,700,000-00 'Trees of Roadsideand Lawns 11,200Trees 1400Yuan/Tree 1 480,000.00 e Sub-Total 183,386,581.70 Paymentfor Relocationmanagem 95,213.56m2 '5 Yuan/m2 1 476,067.80 OtherRelated Paymentfor RelocationNotarizatio 1,853 Houses 100 Yuan/Hous 1 185,300.00 Payments Paymentfor Relocation/Acquisitio1,853 Houses 170 Yuan/Hous 30% 94,503.00 Paymentfor Sanitation/PublicSec 1,853Houses 54 Yuan/HouseI 1 100,062.00 Paymentfor Litigation/Arbitration 1,853Houses 1,500Yuan/Houi 15% 416,925.00 Sub-Total 1,272,857.80 Paymentfor Paymentfor ResidentialHousing 1,176Houses 600 Yuan/Hous 1 705,600.00 Employment Paymentfor RelocationNon-Resid 677 Houses 2,000Yuan/Hou 1' 1,354,000.00 Sub-Total 2,059,600.00 HousingRemoval, Sludge Removals 95,213.56m2 28 Yuan/m2 1 2,665,979.68 Rebuildingof ConcreteFloor and EnclosedWall 111,964m2 80 Yuan/m2 1 957,120.00 Sub-Total 3,623,099.68 Total . i 191,543,788.13 0 0 0 Table 8.3.3: Resettlement Expense of Phase 11 of the IRR of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Project Name Items Demolition Unit Price of Coefficient Compensation Notes Amount Compensation Expense Expense Compensation for Closure of 14,021.34m2 1 46,180,284.00 According to the census results, the Entirely Production/Business duration of compensation is one year Demolished Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 14,021.34m 50 Yuan/mi 1 701,067.00 Shops with Loss of Business in Other Place 5,198.06m4 200 Yuan/m2*month 1 6,237,672.00 Market of automobile fitting, Ownership construction material and industrial products will be relocated to other sites pertnanently. Moving Fee 14,021.34mL 15 Yuan/ml 1 210,320.10 Payment for Telephone Transfer 179 Houses 1,000 Yuan/House 1 179,000.00 Total / / 1 53,508,343.10 Shops Compensation for Closure of 5,653.26m/ 50% 5,242,902.00 According to the census results, the Partially Production/Business duration of compensation is one year Demolished Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 5,653.26m2 50 Yuan/rm 282,663.00 Shops with Loss of Business in Other Place 5,653.26mx / 1 0.00 They will be restored on original land Ownership or be relocated close to the existing housing, but not be resettled in other sites Moving Fee 5,653.26mL 15 Yuan/m' 1 84,798.90 Total / / / 5,610,363.90 Compensation for Closure of 20,672.45m / 1 2,803,240.00 According to the census results, the Temporary Production/Business duration of compensation is one month Structures Moving Fee 20,672.45mn 15 Yuan/mt 1 310,086.75 Payment for Telephone T1ransfer 415 Houses 1,000 Yuan/House I 415,000.00 Total / / / 3,528,326.75 Grand Total / / / 62,647,033.75 Moving Fee I, 176 Houses 600 Yuan/House 705,600.00 Residential Payment for Telephone Transfer 554 Houses 1,000Yuan/House 1 554,000.00 Housing Payment for Cable TV 926 Houses 350 Yuan/House 1 324,100.00 Reward for Moving Ahead of 1.176 Houses 800 Yuan/House 1 940,800.00 _____I ______Tim e Grand Total / / / 2,524,500.00 Compensation for Closure of 70Om2 200 Yuan/mL*month 1 1,680,000.00 According to the census results, the Public Production/Business _ _2 duration of compensation is one year and Cultural Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 700m2 100 Yuan/mL 1 70,000.00 Facilities Payment for Telephone Transfer 4 Houses 1,000 Yuan/m4 2 8,000.00 I__ _ _ _ Moving Fee 70Om' 15Yuan/m1 10,500.00C GrandTotal /_/ _,768,500.001__1 Table 8.3.3 (Continue): The RlesettlemeniitCompensation for IRR of Pliase It of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Project Name Items Demolitioni Unit Price of Coefficient Compensation Notes Amounlt Compensation Expense(Yuan) Expen ,e Compensation for Closure of 6,973.63m 100 Yuan/m *month 1 697,363.00 The duration of compensation is one l ousinlgOwined Production/Business n month by Moving Fee 6,973.63m- 15 Yuan/nm 1 104,604.45 Institutions Payment for Telephone 51 Houses 1,000Yuan/House 1 51,000.00 Transfer 2 _ Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 6,973.63m 50 Yuan/in 1 348,681.50 Total 1,201,648.95 Payment for Pipes & lines / 1 169,496,581.70 According to the costs/budget provided by Pipeline Department Payment for Payment for Traffic Facilities 5.7 km 300 thousand 1 1,710,000.00 Estimated Yuan/km Facilities Payment for Civil Air Defence 1 11,700,000.00 Facilities Trees of Roadside and Lawns 1,200 Trees 400 Yuan/Tree 1 480,000.00 _ __ Total 183,386,681.70 Payment for Relocation 95,213.56m 5 Yuan/mr 1 476,067.80 management Other Related Payment for Relocation 1,853 Houses 100 Yuan/House 1 185,300.00 Notarization Payments Payment for 1,853 llouses 170 Yuan/House 30% 94,503.00 Relocation/Acquisition Review Payment for Sanitation/Public 1,853 Houses 54 Yuan/House 1 100,062.00 Security Payment for 1,853 Ilouses 1,500 Yuan/lHouse 15% 416,925.00 F___ _Litigation/Arbitration _ I Total 1,272,857.80 Payment for Residential 1.176 Hiouses 600 Yuan/House 1 705,600.00 Payment for Housing Relocated Employment Payment for Relocation Non- 677 Hlouses 2,000 Yuan/llouse 1 1,354,000.00 Residential Housing Total 2,059,600.00 HousingRemoval, Sludge Relovals | 95,213.56mrI 28 Yuan/m | 1 2,665,979.68 Rebuilding of Concrete Floor and Enclosed Wall I1,964m| 80 Yuan/mi 1 957,120.00 Grand Total 258,483,821.88 IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 1 Final Report 8.3 Estimateof Land Acquisitionand ResettlementCosts for Phase II of the Inner Ring Road Project 1. Basic costs of resettlement housing and compensation is 343,055,102 Yuan (see in Tab. 8.2.1) (invest in 1997). 2. Compensation for the affected institutions, temporary structurs is 9,075,632.4 Yuan (see in Tab. 8.2.2)(invest in 1998). 3. Other resettlement compensation is 258,483,821.88 Yuan (see in Tab. 8.3.3) (invest in 1998). 4. Currency inflation:(2+3)x5.8%= 15,518,448.35 Yuan 5. Contingencies: (1+2+3+4)iA5% = 31,306650.23 Yuan. 6. Administrative fees: (1+2+3+4+5)iA3% = 19,723,189.65 Yuan. 7. The total costs above are 677162844.50Yuan. 8.4 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for Phase III of the IRR 1. Basic costs of resettlement housing and compensation is 719,211,390 Yuan (see in Tab. 11.4.1) (invest in 1998). 2. Other resettlement compensation is 209,634,018Yuan (see in Tab. 11.4.2) (invest in 1999). 3. Currency inflation: lx5.8%+2x(1+5.8%)x5.5%=53,912,864.13 Yuan 4. Contingencies: (I +2+3)iA 10% = 98,275,827.21 Yuan. 5. Administrative fees: (I +2+3+4)iA3% = 32,431,022.98 Yuan. The total costs above are 1,113,465,122.3Yuan. 8.5 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for Phase IV of the Inner Ring Road Project I. Basic costs of resettlement housing and compensation is 593,503,67OYuan(see in Tab. ] 1.5.1)(invest in 1999). 2. Other resettlement compensation is 120,105,284Yuan (see in Tab. I 1.5.2)(invest in 1999). 3. Currency inflation: 1x5.8%+2x( 1+5.8%)x5.5%=41,524,905.03 Yuan 4. Contingencies: (1+2+3)1 A1 0% = 75,513,385.90Yuan. 5. Administrative fees: (1+2+3+4)iA3% = 24,919,417.35 Yuan. The total costs above are 855,566,662.28Yuan. 8.6 Estimate of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs for the Inner Ring Road Project and the Flow of Fund The total cost of land acquisition and resettlement for the Inner Ring Road Project is estimated to be about 3,103,864,082.02 Yuan. 0 Table 8.4.1: Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expense of IRR for Phase IlIl of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Increment % Demand for Unit Price Sum of Housing of Added Attic Resettlement Classification i Section Original Area Area increas Utiliz.Ratio of Indivisable Affiliated Overseas < 5m2/ Examined Grand Housing (Yuan/m2) Fundss(Yuan) (m2) transferring t.New/Old Housing Chinese Person Approved b Total (m2) |Railway station Overpass (Daib, 0, 20 15 201 10 0 10 10 85 0/ / IHuanshizhong Rd. 0 20' 15 20 10 0 10 10 85 0/ / Households Luhu Overpass 0i 20 15 20- 10 0 10 10 85 0 . HengfuRd. Overpass 173481 201 151 201 10 0 10 10 85 32093.8 / / ,Meidong Overpass(East part of 59011 20i 15, 20 10 0 15 10 90 11211.9_ Haiyinnai Overpass 6122 20, 15, 20| 10 0 5 5 80 11019.6/ / Shushe Overpass 52281 20: 15; 201 10 5 5 5 80 9410.4/ _ East Section of Nantian Rd. 18610i 15 15 20 10 5 0 5 70 31637 / / Zhen'an Overpass 5300j 20! 15, 20 10 10 10 10 95 10335 _ Renming Bridge and Hongde RI 21983 20 15 201 10 5 5 5 80 39569.4 / / Gongye Av. 2467! 201 15i 201 10 5 5 5 80 4440.6 / , Sub-Total 82,959 1/ i I / / / / 149717.7 3200 479,096,640 jRailway station Overpass (Daib 0/ 20 25/ / / , 45 0 / I HuanshizhongRd. 0~/ 20 2511/ 45 0 // Shops !Luhu Overpass , 627 / 20 25/ / I / 45 909.15 I HengfuRd. Overpass 10910 / 20 25/ / / / 45 15819.5 / / Meidong Overpass(East part of 2570 / 20 25/ / / / 45 3726.5 / / Haiyinnai Overpass 1160 / 20 251/ / I/ 45 1682 Shushe Overpass 2326 / 20 25 1 i/ / / 45 3372.7 / / East of Nantian Rd. 476 / 20 25 / I I I/ 45 690.2 I Zhen'an Overpass 1835 / 20 25 / I1 I 45 2660.75 I . Renming Bridge and Hongde R 6223 / 20 25 1 1 1 I 45 9023.35 / / Gongye Av. 1326 / 20 25 1 1 , 45 1922.7 , Sub-Total 27,453 / 1 i I / I/ // 39806.85 5000 199,034,250 Increment % Demand for Unit Price Sum of Housing of Added Attic Resettlement Classification Section Original Area Area increas Utiliz,Ratio of Indivisable lAffiliated Overseas <5m21 Examined Grand Housing (Yuan/m2) Funds(Yuan) (m2) transferring t New/Old Housing _ Chinese Person Approved b Total (m2) !Railway station Overpass (Daib 0 / 25/ | / I 25 0/ / lHuanshizhong Rd. 0/ 25/ / - - 25 _ 0 Institutions ,Luhu Overpass 0 / 25 . 25 0I and Units IHengfuRd. Overpass 8920 / 251, / / ___ 225 5 1150. Meidong Overpass(East part of 1207 i 251 / / /_ 25 1508.75 / / Haiyinnai Overpass 570 / 251/ / / / 25 712.5 / / 'ShusheOverpass 2000/ 251/ /_. 25 2500 . ____ East Section of Nantian Rd. 82 / I / _ _ 25 1028.8 . Zhen'an Overpass 0!/ 251/ / . . / . 25 - 0/ _ RenmingBridgeandHongdeR| 47381/ 251/ / / / 25 5922.5/ / GongyeAv. l/ 25 I / / 25 0/ / Sub-Total 18,258 I IS I / / - / / 22822.5 1800 41,080,500 . 4 ~ - ~I I ------.- -.------Total 128,670 I/ 1/ |/ I/_ I//_/ _ 414,694 719,211,390 Paoe 2 of 2 ~~~~~ ~~~~Table 8.4.2: Resettlement Expense of Phase III of the IR of Guangzhou City Center Transport ProJectr Project Name Items Demolition Amount , Unit Price of Coefficient Compensation Compensation Expense Expense Fee of temporary movement 182959M2 15Yuan/ M2.Month 10£? 2,488,770 Payment for Transfer 1806 households 600 Yuan/household 1 1,083,600 iPayment for Telephone Transfer 11806 households 1000 Yuan/household 70£Y 1,264,200 Residential Housing Payment for Cable TV 1806 households 350 Yuan/household 1 632,100 Reward for Pre-Transfer 1806 households 800Yuan/household 50£Y 722,400 Gas and pipeline 1806 households 150OYuan/household 10EV 270,900 Sub-Total 6,461,970 Compensation for Closure of Production/Business 127453M2 1OOOYuan/ M2 1 27,453,000 Payment for Auxiliary Facilities '27453 M2 50Yuan/ M2 1 1,372,650 Shops Loss of Business in Other Place 127453 M2 200Yuan/ M2,Month 50% 16,471,800 Payment for Transfer |27453 M2 15Yuan/ M2 - - 1 - 411,795 |Sub-Total l 45,709,245 Compensation for Closure of Production/Business 18258 M2 1OOOYuan/M2 1 18,258,000 Enterprises and Units Payment for Auxiliary Facilities 1i8258 M2 10OYuan/ M2 1 1,825,800 Payment for Transfer 18258 M2 15Yuan/ M2 1 273,870 'Payment for Telephone Transfer '53 Households 1OOOYuan/M2 1 265,000 .Sub-Total l / I 20,622,670 Payment for Pipelines !10384M 10000,00OYuan/KM 1 103,840,000 Infrastructures Payment for Traffic Facilities 10384 M 200,00OYuan/ KM 1i 2,076,800 Payment for Civil Air Defence Facilities 110384M 2000,00Yuan/ KM 1 20,768,000 Trees of Roadside and Lawns 10384 M 400Yuan/tree 1 1,661,440 Sub-Total I / I 128,346,240 Payment for Relocation management '124877 M2 5Yuan/ M2 1 624,385 Other Related Payment for Relocation Notarization 231BHouseholds lOOYuan/household 1 231,800 Compensation Payment for Relocation/Acquisition Review 2318househoulds 17OYuan/household 1 394,060 Payment for Sanitation/Public Security 2318househoulds 54Yuan/household 1 125,172 Payment for Litigation/Arbitration 2318househoulds |150OYuan/household 15% 521,550 Sub-Total I l I 1,896,967 Payment for Payment for Residential Housing Relocated 1806households |600Yuan/household 1 1,083,600 Employment Payment for Relocation Non Residential Housing 512households 150OYuan/household 1 768,000 Sub-Total / I . 1,851,600 House Removal, Sludge Removal 124877 M2 28Yuan/ M2 1 3,496,556 Rebuilding of Concrete Floor and 1124877 M2 10OYuan/M2 10% 1,248,770 Enclosed Wall Sub-Total / I 4,745,326 Total _ 209,634,018 Page 1 of 1 : I i .. . . I. .. 1. . 1 .1_ . Table 8.5.1: Resettlement Housing Demand Estimate and Expense of IRR for Phase IV of Guangzhou City Center Transport Project ;~ ~~ Oiia Inrmn % Dead o -:-::-- :--:=-- = -- = = l , Original Increment %Demandfor Unit Price Sum of Housing of Added Attic Resettlement Classification Section Area IArea increas,Utiliz.Ratio of Indivisable Affiliated Overseas < 5m2/ Examined Grand Housing (Yuan/m2) Funds(Yuan) (m2) transferring tlNew/Old Housing Chinese Person Approved b Total (m2) Section of Hengfu Rd. 0 15 | 15 201 10 0 5 5 70 0/_ Section of Meidongbei Rd. 3748; 20 151 20 10 5 5 10 85 6933.8_ I Residential Middleand West Sectionof Na 40000M 15a 10. 20. 10 5 0 5 70 68000 I./ housing Liu'er'san Rd. Huangsha Av. 46724| 201 15i 20 10 10 10 10 95 91111.8 . Sub-Total 90472 /I l/ I I I I 166,046 3200 531,345,920 Section of Hengfu Rd. 0/ 20 25 / I / _45 0/ I Section of Meidongbei Rd. 1 7011 201 25 / / / I 45 101.5 I.____/ _. Shops Middle and West Section of Na 2000 / 20| 25 / / I / 45 2900/ / I ~ ~-f ~~~~.- ~~I. ------, ------__ _------… Liu'er'san Rd. Huangsha Av. 5271 / 20' 25 I / . / 45 7642.95 Sub-Total 7341 I I I / I I I 10,644 5000 53,222,250 Section of Hengfu Rd. 0/ ' 25/ /I I I 25 0/ / Section of Meidongbei Rd. o!/ 25/ 1 I I 25 ._ Institutions and Middle and West Section of Na 1000 I 25,1/ 'I I I 25 1250 I I Units Liu'er'san Rd. Huangsha Av. 1800 I/ 25 / I/ I I 25t 2250 . I Sub-Total 2800/ 11..I I I 3500 1800 6,300,000 Total I I I I I i / I 180,190 590,868,170 P>nnr 1 Af 1 Table 8.5.2; ResettlementExpense of Phase IV of the IRR of GuangzhouCity Center Transport Project ProjectName Items , DemolitionAmount Unit Price of Coefficient Compensation CompensationExpense Expense !Fee of temporarymovement i90472 M2 15Yuan/M2.Month 10£Y 27,141,600 Residentialhousing Paymentfor Transfer 11809household 600 Yuan/household 1 1,085,400 Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 1809household 1000Yuan/household 70EY 1,266,300 Paymentfor CableTV 11809household 350 Yuan/household 1 633,150 'Rewardfor Pre-Transfer 1809household 80OYuan/household 50E_. 723,600 Gasand pipeline 1809household 150OYuan/household10OEY 2,713,500 Sub-Total / . . 33,563,550 Compensationfor Closureof Production/Business 7341M2 IOOOYuan/M2 1 7,341,000 Shops Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 7341M2 5OYuan/M2 1 367,050 Lossof Businessin OtherPlace 7341M2 200Yuan/M2.Month 50% 4,404,600 Paymentfor Transfer 17341M2 15Yuan/ M2 1 110,115 Sub-Total l/ / _ 12,222,765 Compensationfor Closureof Production/Business 12800M2 1000Yuan/M2 1 2,800,000 Enterprisesand Units Paymentfor AuxiliaryFacilities 2800M2 100Yuan/M2 1 280,000 Paymentfor Transfer 2800M2 15Yuan/M2 1 42,000 Paymentfor TelephoneTransfer 8household 1OOOYuan/M2 1 40,000 Sub-Total / / / 3,162,000 Paymentfor Pipelines 5205M 1OOOOOOOYuan/KM 1 52,050,000 Infrastructures Paymentfor TrafficFacilities 5205M 200,00OYuan/KM 1 1,041,000 Paymentfor Civil Air DefenceFacilities 5205M 2000,000/YuanKM 1 1,041,000 ,Trees of Roadsideand Lawns '5205 M 400Yuan/tree 1 832,800 Sub-Total / / / 54,964,800 Paymentfor Relocationmanagement 100613M2 5Yuan/M2 1 503,065 OtherRelated Paymentfor RelocationNotarization 1940household 1OOYuan/household 1 194,000 Compensation Paymentfor Relocation/AcquisitionReview 1940household 17OYuan/household 1 329,800 Paymentfor Sanitation/PublicSecurity 1940household 54Yuanlhousehold 1 104,760 Paymentfor Litigation/Arbitration 1940household 1I uOYuan/household 15% 436,500 Sub-Total 1,568,125 Paymentfor Paymentfor ResidentialHousing Relocated 1809household ,600Yuan/household I 1 1,085,400 Employment Paymentfor RelocationNon Residential Housing 131household !'500Yuan/household 1 196,500 Sub-Total / / / 1,281,900 HouseRemoval, Sludge Removal 100613M2 j28Yuan/M2 1 2,817,164 Rebuildingof ConcreteFloor andEnclosed Wall 100613M2 1OOYuani M2 10% 1,006,130 Sub-Total 3,823,2943 Total ... 1 .. 1 110,586,434 n4X. . X IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 52 FinalReport 9. INSTITUTIONS AND AGENCIES OF LAND ACQUISITION, DEMOLITION AND RESETTLEMENT 9.1 Managementof Land Acquisition,Demolition and Resettlementand Related Institutions 1. Management institutions of Land Acquisition, Demolition and Resettlement and Related Institutions are seen in Resettlement Policy 7. 2. Census Unit and Independent Monitoring Organization of the first and second phase of IRR a. Census Unit of the first and second phase of IRR is Research Center for Market Economy & Population Development of Zhongshan University b. IMO is Guangzhou Academy of Social Sciences c. The responsibility of the Census Unit and the IMO is seen in Resettlement Policy 6. 9.2 Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office - Implementation Agency 1. The situation and responsibilities of the GREEO is seen the Resettlement Policy 7. 2. Working groups According to the characteristics of the IRR, GREEO will divide into several groups based on the categories of project impacts and workload: a. . Resettlement group for residential households: be responsible for the resettlement work of affected households 0 b. Resettlement group for shops and units: be responsible for the resettlement work of affected shops, units of public facilities, enterprises, institutions. c. Resettlement group for temporary shops: be responsible for the resettlement work of the managers of the affected temporary shops. d. Resettlement group for infrastructure: be responsible for the compensation and restoration of the affected pipelines, public facilities and public transit facilities. e. Resettlement group for land acquisition: be responsible for the work of land acquisition for the construction of resettlement housing and be responsible for the related resettlement work of farmers, production teams and their enterprises. f. Group of management of resettlement housing and rear services: be responsible for the construction or purchase of the resettlement housing, their change, management. and other rear services. 3. Training plan for the Agency Staff n order to make properly the land acquisition, demolition and resettlement activities of the Inner Ring Road Project to meet the requirements of the Bank, the training plan is made out as following: a. Training plan for staff dealing with resettlement activities directly * Education on laws and regulations of resettlement * Education on OD4.30 * Principles and strategies of negotiation/participation/consultation * Analysis of resettlement cases and simulation drill * Practical training IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 53 Final Report b. Training plan for resettlement administrators * Laws and regulations of resettlement activities and tactics of negotiation * Profession theory of management science * Seminar on cost control and resource allocation. * Urban planning * Database management * Visits to successful resettlement project * Participation and consultation * Monitoring and evaluation We also have a Technical Assistance and Training Plan which includes detailed TA and training programs for different groups of the staff of the GREEO. It is one part of the TA sub-project of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects. IRRResettlement Implementation Plan 54 Final Report 10. PARTICIPATION AND CONSULTATION At the beginning of identification and preparation period of the Guangzhou City Center transport Projects, the design department, resettlement department and environment protection department get in touch with some units by field visits to introduce the tentative plan of the Inner Ring Road construction. The widespread and formal participation and consultation activities started to be arranged in the later stage of project preparation period. (After the alignment of the IRR has been basically determined.) 10.1 Participation and consultation Activities Were in Progress 10.1.1 Census In Dec.1995 and Jan.1996, based on sufficient preparations, the Research Center for Market Economy and Population Development of Zhongshan University conducted census on1the households, shops, enterprises and institutions, which are all along the alignment of the Phase I & 11 of the IRR, affected by the project. In order to achieve full participation of thie PAPs, the census were conducted according to the principles and measures which were mentioned in the Resettlenient Policy. The questionnaires of the first census can be seen in Appendix 1. Because of lacking conditions to conduct detailed census for the PAPs who live along the other part of the alignment of the IRR, only preliminary census was accomplished at present. Detailed census will be further conducted according to the same principles and investigation measures, and the PAPs are encouraged to take part in actively. 10.1.2 Standard of Living Surveys (SLS) In Feb.1996, based on the result of census, Guangzhou Academy of Social Scienicesran a baseline survey of living standards on the PAPs of the phase I & 11of the IRR and holuselholdsof control groups. The scope of sampling surveys is as follows: * affected households 11% * proportion of affected households to households of control groups 1:0.77 * affected shops 25% * affected enterprises and institutions 10% Guangzhou Academy of Social Sciences prepared a survey report about the result of the baseline SLS. The report was submitted to the World Bank Mission by the GCCTPO in Jan.. 1997. The baseline SLS questionnaires can be seen in the Appendix 11& 111. 10.1.3 Propaganda Activities of News Media At the beginning of spring in 1996, Nanfang Daily, Guangzhou Daily, Yangcheng Evening Paper, Guangdong Construction Paper, Guangzhou construction paper and almost all the provincial and muniicipal TV stations reported the news about the IRR construction. Especially Guangzhou Daily published the relevant articles several times. The Major-level leaders gave TV lectures many times to clarify the significance of the IRR construction, and mentioned that the project will cause inevitable resettlement actions. They hope that the PAPs can actively take part in the resettlement IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 55 Final Report activities and cooperate with the project units, so that the adverse impact of the PAPs can be minimized and the PAPs can live and work happily in the new environment. 10.1.4 Public Consultation Meetings and Field Visits 10.1.4.1 Official and Formal Consultation Meeting Organized by the GCCTPO On June 21, 1996, the GCCTPO presided over a consultation meeting for seeking the public opinions of the IRR construction. Over 70 representatives of the affected units and neighborhood committees along the alignment of the IRR, were invited to the meeting. Staff of the working groups of each sub- project of Guangzhou City Transport Projects attended the meeting too. The general information of the project, the resettlement and environmental impacts, were introduced in the meeting and the questions of the attendance were answered too. The opinions and requirements of the representatives were consulted and some news media reported the meeting. The GCCTPO and relevant working groups of other sub-project held small-scale consultation meetings several times with some specific units, such as the Guangdong Provincial People's Congress, Dongshan People's Hospital, Bingjiang No.2 Primary School and the zoo, to discuss some specific problems. T he meetings achieved good results. The meetings just mentioned above have got a favorable reception of the PAPs who expressed appreciation for the efforts of project units. The GCCTPO will arrange some public consultation meetings in succession to have a full consultation with the PAPs. The scale, topic, attendance of the fAmeetingswill be changed correspondingly. 10.1.4.2 Consultation Meetings and Interviews Organized by the IMO In the whole year of 1996, the IMO had carried on several participation activities for the affected households, shops, enterprises and institutions. The participation and consultation activities, which were conducted in the preceding-period by the I MO, could be seen in the first Survey Report of Living Standard of the PAPs, Business of Sh1ops, Operation of Enterprises and Institutions and the Report-Sumn7ary of the Participation Activities (from Alav to Oct.1996). The two copies have been handed in to the the World Bank missioni by the GCCTPO. 10.2 Effects Produced by Participation and Consultation Activities The activities of participation and consultation offer a good chance to widespreadly propagandize the IRR project and resettlement plan and to get the opinions, preference and feeling of the public. Most of the PAPs support the IRR construction, since the project can improve the present traffic situation in down town, so the entire environment in Guangzhou can be improved. However, the PAPs who will move away from the down town where they have resided and worked for a long time, really face some specific difficulties and hardly adapt themselves to new environment. The PAPs hope that the project units try their best to minimize the involuntary resettlement. If the resettlement cannot be avoided, they hope that all kinds of facilities in the resettlement sites can be perfected, and the reasonable compensation will be given to the PAPs. They hope to strengthen the measures of environment protection for the residents and units which are in the sensitive sites of environment but J unlllecessaryto move, too. Many suggestions of the PAPs have been reflected in the RAP and the IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 56 Final Report Environment Protection Action Plan. Some suggestions have been accepted by the design department. The details are as follows: 1. Revision for the trend of the IRR and ramp setting. For example: a. The ramp in front of the People's Congress of Guangdong Province is moved to the west. The measures of strengthening green operation and lowering noise pollution are done. b. The ramp (S--E) which passes nearby Dongshan District People's Hospital is off. The measures of increasing grass lands and strengthening environment protection are adopted. c. Nantian Road takes place of T13 Road in the south ring of the IRR because of tremendous resettlement amount and poor road construction condition. The demolition amount and the number of PAPs reduced 66,889m2 and 8,676 respectively because of this change. 2. All the resettlement sites are provided with perfect accessory facilities, especially the convenient transport. Taking Baiyun Garden for example, besides public transport routes, the developer is required to provide 14 mini-buses for the residential quarters to connect the down town. Besides the basic accessory facilities, the developer is required to build some public places for entertainment such as bowling center and baby swimming pool to make the residential quarters more attractive. 3. Besides reasonable compensation, all kinds of the measures of resettlement and rehabilitation are used to help the PAPs (vulnerable groups in particular) to maintain the original living standards. The resettlement plan of the project has many better advantages thlan other municipal projects. Such as * Settling down the vulnerable groups in the resettlement sites whichinear down town and make them have the priority to choose flats. Arranging the poor families in the first floor so that they can make a living by business of their stores. * No compensation will be given to the owners of the temporarily built shops with expired contract. The project will compensate moving fee to the users and be responsible for assisting them to find new temporarily built shops and give thlemsome rent discount (according to the rent in rearranged places). 4. To strengthen environment protection measures in the sensitive sites of environiment along the alignment of IRR to minimize the adverse impacts to the PAPs who are unnecessary to move. 10.3 Next-Step Plan for Participation and consultation Activities Participation and consultation activities is now becoming day-to-day work to help us improve the resettlement plan and the implementation activities. The next-step schleduleof the job can be seen in the schedule table of i° Participation and Consultation ;± and i° Monitoring and Evaluation J± below. IRR ResettlementImplementation Plan 57 Final Report 11. MONITORING AND EVALUATION 11.1 InternalMonitoring From the beginningof carryingon the resettlementactivities of GuangzhouCity Center Transport Projects,the wholeprocess has been monitoredby the GCCTPO. In fact, the GCCTPOnot only monitorsall the preparationwork of the resettlementof the IRR, but also helps to coordinatethe work relationshipand contentsbetween the GREEOand each relative units. Besidesthis, the GCCTPO actively participatesin every specificjob of the resettlementactivities including preparation of the Policy and the RAP and solves the problemsencountered in the preparationprocess. During the period of the implementationof the resettlement,the GCCTPOwill go on with internal monitoringconstantly. 11.2 IndependentMonitoring The job of IndependentMonitoring and Evaluationof the resettlementactivities of the first phaseof the IRR is undertakenby the IndependentMonitoring Office of GuangzhouAcademy of Social Sciences. The Office has eight full-timepersons and will add some if need. The members specialize in differentareas such as sociology,economics, laws and philosophy. The IMO has done the work as follows: I. Monitoredthe census on the phaseI & II of the IRR conductedby the ResearchCenter for Market Economyand PopulationDevelopment of ZhongshanUniversity in Jan 1996. 2. Conductedthe baselineSLS along the alignmentof phase I & 11of the IRR in March,1996. 3. Visited twenty shops in the area of Donghuadongin August, 1996. 4. Visited the representativesof householdswho live in the five areas along the alignmentof the phase I & II of the IRR, and held small-scalemeetings in Oct., 1996. The Participationand consultationis a importantmeasure to developMonitoring and Evaluation,so that no distinct line can be drawn betweentwo. The contentof the activities.which are mentionedin the section of " Participationand consultation", are very importantpart of Monitoringand Evaluation as well. So they will not be mentionedhere any more. The next-step scheduleof the P&C and the M&E can be seen in the followilg table in detail. IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 58 Final Report The schedule table of "Participation & Consultation" and "Monitoring & Evaluation" Date Task Place Organization or Remarks Responsible Units Dec.,1995-- Census for Phase I & II Along the Census Unit, Jan.,1996 alignment of Phase GREEO 1&11 Jan., 1996 1. A meeting with 12 owners of Huangsha of Phase IMO temporarily shops II 2. Visited Railway Bureau Dongshan District IMO Hospital and the kindergarten (Phase I) Feb., 1996 Baseline SLS for Phase I & 11 Along the IMO The survey report alignment of Phase was submitted to I & 11 the World Bank mission though GCCTPO in Jan., 1997 June, 1996 Consultation meeting GURCC GREEO, other related units Aug., 1996 Visited 20 shop-owners of the Donghuadong of IMO Automobile Fittings Center (AFC) Phase I for their opinions of the AFC relocation Sept., 1996 1. Visited the kindergarten and the Dongshan District IMO apartment building for staff and (Phase 1) workers of Yangcheng Railway Company for the opinions of the resettlement. 2. A meeting with 12 affected ho Yongsheng IMO useholds for their views and Shangsha of Phase propagandized the resettlement I policies. July, 1997 1. Interviewed 70 households of Districts of IMO the control group for their attitudes Dongshan, Yuexiu, and preferences of moving away Liwan and Tianhe from the down- town 2. Prepare the RIB for Phase I GREEO and GCCTPO Aug., 1997 1. Issue the Housing Demolition Along the The Land and Notice for Phase I alignment of Phase Housing Administration Bureau (LHAB) 2. Mobilization meetings for the Along the Organized by PAPs in different areas alignment of Phase GCCTPO and I GREEO. Monitored by 1MO _ __ _ _ IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 59 Final Report Date Task Place Organization or Remarks Responsible Units 3. Organze the PAPs of Phase II Resettlement sites to visit the resettlement sites for Phase I 4. Distribute the RIB to the PAPs GCCTPO, of Phase I GREEO and IMO From Aug. 1. The GAG will open to the Inside the IMO IMO, GCCTPO to Oct. public two weeks before the office and GREEO 1997 Resettlement Compensation Agreements are signed. Hotline telephone and Mail box will be available to accept complaints from . the PAPs. 2. Propaganda activities of news News media, media GCCTPO, GREEO and IMO 3. Sign Resettlement Along the GREEO The civil work of Compensation Agreements with the alignment of the phase I will begin PAPs in succession and implement phase I in Oct., 1997. the resettlement From Nov., 1. Visit the PAPs of Phase I in Resettlement sites IMO to Dec., resettlement sites for Phase I 1997 2. Consultation meetings for Along the Arranged by different categories of PAPs in alignment of Phase IMO, GREEO different areas of Phase 11 11 and GCCTPO participate 3. Issue the Housing Demolition Along the LHAB Notice for Phase 11 alignmentI_ of Phase 4. Mobilization meetings for the Along the Organized by PAPs in different areas alignment of Phase GCCTPO and 1I GREEO. Monitored by IMO 5. Organze the PAPs along the Resettlement sites alignment of Phase II to visit the for Phase 11 resettlement sites 6. Distribute the RIB to the PAPs GCCTPO. of Phase 11 GREEO and IMO From Jan., 1. Detailed census for Phase Ill Along the Census unit, Census in March, to June, alignment of Phase assisted by submit the RAP for 1998 III GCCTPO and Phase Ill in June, GREEO, 1998 monitored by ______IM O IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 60 Final Report Date Task Place Organization or Remarks Responsible Units 2. Baseline SLS for Phase III Along the IMO Survey in April, alignment of Phase 1998 III 3. Propaganda activities of news News media, media GCCTPO, GREEO and IMO 4. Sign Resettlement Along the GREEO The civil work of Compensation Agreements with the alignment of Phase Phase 11will begin PAPs in succession and implement II June, 1998 the resettlement From July 1. Visit the PAPs of Phase II in the Resettlement sites IMO Submit the reports to Oct., resettlement sites for Phase 11 of Internal 1998 Monitoring and Independent Monitoring and Evaluation to the World Bank in July, 1998 2. Small-scale consultation meetings for the PAPs 3. Consultation meetings for Along the Arranged by different categories of PAPs in alignment of Phase IMO. GREEO different areas of Phase III III and GCCTPO participate 4. Issue Housing Demolition Along the LHAB Notice for Phase IIl alignment of Phase III 5. Mobilization meetings for the Along the Organized by PAPs in different areas alignment of Phase GCCTPO and III GREEO. Monitored by [MO 6. Organze the PAPs of Phase III Resettlement sites to visit the resettlement sites for Phase 111 7. Distribute the RIB to the PAPs GCCTPO, of Phase III GREEO and IMO From Oct., I. Propaganda activities of news News media. Submit the reports 1998 to media GCCTPO, of Internal April,. 1999 GREEO and Monitoring and IMO Independent Monitoring and Evaluation to the World Bank in _Jan., 1999 IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 61 Final Report Date Task Place Organization or Remarks Responsible Units 2. Sign Resettlement Along the GREEO The civil work of Compensation Agreements with the alignment of Phase Phase III will PAPs in succession and implement III begin April, 1999 the resettlement 3. Detailed census for Phase IV Along the Census unit, Census in March, alignment of Phase assisted by submit the RAP for IV GCCTPO and Phase IV in June, GREEO. 1999 monitored by the IMO From April 1. Visit the PAPs of Phase III in Resettlement sites IMO Submit the reports to June, the resettlement sites for Phase III of Internal 1999 Monitoring and Independent Monitoring and Evaluation to the World Bank in July, 1999 2. Small-scale consultation meetings for the PAPs 3. Second SLS for Phase I & 11 Along the IMO Survey in May. alignment of Phase 1999 11and relative resettlement sites 4. Baseline SLS for Phase IV Along the alignment of Phase IV From July. 1. Consultation meetings for Along the Arranged by to August, different categories of the PAPs in alignment of Phase IMO, GREEO 1999 different areas of Phase IV IV and GCCTPO participate 2. Issue Housing Demolition Along the LHAB Notice for Phase IV alignment of Phase lV 3. Mobilization meetings for the Along the Organized b\ PAPs in different areas alignment of Phase GCCTPO and IV GREEO. Monitored by IMO 4. Organze the PAPs along the Resettlement sites alignment of Phase IV to visit the for Phase IV resettlement sites 5. Distribute the RIB to the PAPs GCCTPO, of Phase IV GREEO and IMO IRR Resettlement Implementation Plan 62 Final Report Date Task Place Organization or Remarks Responsible ______XU nits From Aug., 1. Propaganda activities of news News media, Submit the reports 1999 to media GCCTPO, of Intemal Jan.,2000 GREEO and Monitoring and IMO Independent Monitoring and Evaluation to the World Bank in Jan., 2000 2. Sign Resettlement Along the GREEO The civil work of Compensation Agreements with the alignment of Phase Phase IV will PAPs in succession and implement IV begin in Jan., 2000 the resettlement From Feb., 1. Second SLS for phase III Along the IMO Survey in May, to June. alignment of Phase 2000 2000 III and relative Resettlement sites 2. Visit the PAPs of Phase IV in Resettlement sites IMO Submit the reports the resettlement sites for Phase IV of Internal Monitoring and Independent Monitoring and Evaluation to the World Bank in July, 2000 3. Small-scale consultation meetings for the PAPs Nov., 2000 Second SLS for Phase IV Along the IMO of IRR alignment of Phase IV and relative resettlement sites Feb., 2001 Final SLS for Phase I & II Along the IMO Submit the survey alignment of Phase report in July, I & II and relative 2001 resettlement sites May, 2001 Final SLS for Phase III Along the alignment of Phase III and relative resettlement sites Oct., 2001 Final SLS for Phase IV Along the IMO Submit the survey alignment of Phase report in Dec., IV and relative 2001 resettlement sites Note: I. The schedule may be appropriately adjusted according to the progress of the project construction. 2. The frequency and content of the working task will increase according to the requirements. 3. The IMO will take the schedule as outline to make the yearly working plan in detail. Appcnfil CENSUS FORM FOR INIIABITAN'rS AFFIECTED BY LAND REQUISI1TION OR HOUSEIDFMOIATION IN INNI'R CIRCLE' PROJECi' IN GUANGZI()IM(I) ~Jt~{jI.IL-0110-W Plg Serial N(l Nanie ol liow eli>l,ls Ji) Jt_; -t- - ___( _ - . - fS ___i0 bj:I Address Iistrict Road/Sireel N(. lio-.ellhl regmrationPoliceo l'ucin I. ` A,h A A .j A. *4|1 ;t General Inlormiation of alfecied member In 1la iisecltold S, ri-il No ofd ctitcrrpri / ~~~Relation_~~~~~~Xk. _ lt...i ,it41 '-'~'k I Oc 1 .A4th C 1i ofiJil it#11 Ik 1 dhlt-r,: e.oie 11oIbly List Nramel1.151 ol IticuseN~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~al) inlrt'luraleEduationzIale Stlat llusovl Sc g iikStts, VazF,luing Cl..nufn^^;0/lg Ct td;ncuipComn ing|(o holder stalus )L rii g I.il Yudlil.c Level residence l3e at sliild _ lue ype iir klr - r _ _ ___it_ tini - i.P.L X e jd+t4-/ll *JI 1.TaOif.& 1. f * lt ft' Oi- l _ _t ; hosditolder r.ii "" Ek: dlsiric ||, I it 2 h RM4 ICale _$ unmarried -llrierui/ tI liot delcrdled k ttflri iRM1 RM I13 f {l 1,4- ! km minutes iousC nnoo RMIly 2. * _ J1 2. ti 8UX llt,'2"8 registered Ini detail .ddllrcss ,n detail |___ b* i 2. bl 41 children emal date of married 2. r heec I - children priiiiar~~~ | ' 1 #. _ hundred liecclc ! 1. l4 f* birtli 3 &A I iou. itoti- lo3ers school 2. 4 4i f pitn"Iry school grandchiil randeliti m ofrl nievers J4 t'1 uido-el 3'o3. On I' al 2. 4t $ Mnor- -dren widoived ivui~~~~~~~.dg motor-~~~li. 4f ; yea-s l. kh michoo local itidd1lCschloicl cycle I ejitX 4 old divorcedh 4. i'r registered 3. kt |i 3andple3. college | entprie I S.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ndl3.0$4Ilg other nnon- 8. EceA local non-l . ._ ijgraeduat registered 6. Att relat,~ .2 ~ ~ ~ 6.hVWe other 02 1 0° r r _ r _ _ rr 11[Ir r 02 rr r r r I ._ _ m L r_I.LLI. O Jsrrrnr 04 _ _ _rz l - - - - - _ - - - - -LI 1l11 - 06 _ _ . __ AJ _ 07 '- -E--- - - 078 l r r r --i I I __ _- r -l m r r ------. [i -17 - 09 _ r _m- 10 JIIZJJ __ JIDI . .KL1ILLL~ ... il hA Surveyor ______tIA, Supervisor _t liek Larvitr . _ Al l)ae.-. nl 4 ) 9t. ) f'ay. of l ,.,Ex-r1. 1,),, CENSUS FORM FOR PROPERTIES OF ENTERIPRISES OR INSTITUTIONS AFFECTEI) BY LAND)REQUISTTION OR HOUSE DEMOLITION IN INNER CIRCLE PROJECT IN GUANGZHOU _ _$ ±-f* l_-______r_ N(.tal ) NO). I.-gil rRir,c:iiulg lesponsiblfi aulhority Nanic of cnierpri.t or o,smlitutair 0 J+Iji______--4-s- ____ Addrcss D)istrict R;diSircect NO. Scrial NO. of itouschiold 1 {e+r.. , $ $$ { u1 (icjl rai infitrlatint of enterprmc or institution itfectcd 7¶fr6 VI . f&f4 tL .. :S: . . st 6. h- ___ 'iiialp Simi .,htmniniitt ptrtcAt ftr,agit -iolt ,v,ut.it others tkccupationn Inauacltirllr,lig r,p:wroing rcl.d; polxl:>lls nstllin o heri, i I ca'ltI F t * | j a lf dd * 7.1±t l.* 4 |Pnuilon : Ihorinnc * Address _rctaceli eIi _ 1onat: lteirc ll |'Position V'ilbami Address Serial NO. of i Main Othcr Number hassiness licensc Issued by i,usinessb bhusiness of staff I I Payrofl IAficr- r,. pro(i.t ; . ------I' Welrl Payroll of tit rtirCcd persons 7 - 2. + AiA $* ;YL icner:( n l ormrlinftniotiolf otffcd ersi a ,Aft I *24 tt Pi~~ iAA t.ia*±s iPt Ic 4* u -I- it NO. +p Nunbcr Esiate I No. orcfli iof siorcys' Structure rowncrship SpAce Attic Owner titc deed Renter I Fitting I *------:-- -- -_-_.--- _ _._ ___;__ . _ v con,tracc t I | .. W1. 9 idi * k fi gF Ld kt ___ M I.)r - I t 1 Al I; I !toretlo"I 7 4t -_n !-itr Kll-tr!i i0n.t structure dn,i,,.d y_ or . r5i |. Jnin iftl d o M:i bi by self i r t r i I 0 lila-rexlrcel j rsnl j ItiferootItfl rent ~ ~_ ii AMA, )Aadl adott - i-~ *tznJ3i | i u11,si,gpspUice irgis tii ted j brick txining ie rCl Ii7*. rt ovrrsca' utjenrcg,stcrcd ,ftt fl.R fl E 7 l; IF -- i _ I_ _ line ____ r. _._____ 11 ______l[ (r I I. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ffifl J¾i ... i i- J&:i__irr, j Si, ki, , ! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I___Ii -,, .F 4 *.; Dittotid lor refneatioti I ~ ~~~~l | c l hf drjF iiF Attached planc drawing ttcntl.,id tor 1ittit . 5u1cgesirtitt for cetincuitlon L td ittttoa teopys : Jiia-scl . ",' itl dee *t CC i uICt'1i1 j Rsitcslr placec IcontlractiI ;.r;tiigcentrn i 2. .*iieJtdf | . fJh4FILii* || s cn2; moEro-addlnon fr f itting nec.trtrtngc *f || v lri,i,;t1ti ! different plarr ArrangC - t titd jrj fntiinntac p,) ! or ml,{ :a.g4i Arring.iig i l dusii.csslattce p j IF I r., -a MitiProfit otgini nrcc tmtcl -~~~~~~o *L Atir51r($Lt taixiout hulll(s) roorfsl uttilt s) I I ). of legaf X~~~~cii,n,e1'c,etilc Place_pi, .r.ngMcs .d.mmp. tim it ccd-__. Rottrt 'sparc ! .t.< tf ,~~~~~~~_____'tf .1. o u'rvey.c _ _ . lst.t,trvtour _ uo i. if.legalr _ i ta, i)r___ CENSUS FORM FOR ENTERPRISEOR INSiITUTION EMPLOYEES AFFECTED BY 1 ILAND REQUISITION OR HOUSE DEMOILITION IN INNER CIRCLE PROJECT IN GUANGZHOU ^> ou-o-no 4s__ _ £'11 __-;_ ,______nlialNO. I.cgal represrrat.tve Resporslibleauthority Namcof enterpriseor institution i&Jll: _, - 1t _ g(lr) -wtA;; -dr ss District Road/Street NO. SerialNO. of household i. 14. 4 -It 1 4 . nt fti 4 o 4:11 t A *tAa { - g ,' A lE* t il-A1A 1i itti,. i iA A Jt J4tAi A + Marital EducationalSatu I,s of Working Earniings Work N r Name Sex Age sau lcof ComnmutingCommuting Commuting rIt oi eidneDepartment Plosition Chneot Address of family status residenceLe~~cl ~Years motlohneo dsac ie tp ____ dsac ie tp ther incomeOtesklsobicm Nos I. X i L 1.t* 1.:1F A I. I.A _/ _ 1 district ___ f __ t .* __ nale 4,A unattied ll,^X-/ local RMBY Yes 5lit a__E_ km minutes on foot RMBV .Jr- _4 2. ft liC emr- registered 2. {- addressin detail ____ 2. b L.rrale JI j .l. l 2. k -f . 41 No hundred bicycle late married nimrrY non- meters birth: t ~ loalmotor- irth aidoared ann- registered iddteccl, cycl. y diaorced1i A* ear noni enterprise A1Id i11 6ddle bus l nivelsilv ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~6.4t: radoare ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~other J} ___ _ bo E . E _ _ __ JFE ______1_ m _cr 83 _E=4 r r - rrrr rg|I i Se_ . S ______.__E .4 .P oT f~~~~~~_:5 _rEv_ E rE- __r._E rrtr -r E _r r. t_ _E EE _E ___E_ rrw I r lW _ _ . a~~~~~~-__ _ rv r C- r 1I r r . T1 Ir l rT 1T C8~~~~~-f_E < .E r r r L I 1 1 mr rrT I Sr r mIl SI AEsurveyor M A.Supervisor *41tA,Examiner_ A AADate J( t $1.Page of total pages in this table ~1 CENSUS FORM FOR INHABITANTSAFFECTED BY LAND REQUISITION OR HOUSE DEMOLITION IN INNER CIRCLE PROJECT IN GUANGZHOU (I) 9AA4 :17 - 00 - 000r- - 00i P S*d4- Serial NO. N.me of h-oseholder iE:~~~~~r 14 (*) 4+ '1drtif416A 4j :kJ; Addrss District Rload/Street No. Houebolkl registrationi Police s%L.1uW1 2. i -*t General infomation of affected housthold Serial NO. of enterpnse I lttau& 2. 91tL** 3. "*s 4. satl/\ 5. 4*A 6. *41* 7. 8".8 ; Houseownership selfiowned sel oined oversea's private public house ove~rsens enterprise partlyownership ather Owncr Phone Aiddres ti'eprs Pohonar,dcs le ded _ spacebuidin6 1 ofh .jo..s_ (orivdielr E . Phoie1NO ot Nut 5 B 2. N ondiarone2 je No _ House_h- l(i:ehen , LaChines~ house house ?t M ~ Chinee~~e_____, house hoshue tTelr deee Renter~~~~~pcepae Br rdk Inotliherofli No~~~ itcI i1rercnrcsept -sho hoorred ihrecrrOraginsacc sliiieaii- yIi smtOerofl d No di buildnd fo rReot ionrl 5 SenalN0 ot,at conrethos miing hos os os, 11 I I I I FT l ! 11e1 _. AiAk 1 AXS 23.M , 4( X 4 J 1. 5. M'; 2 0 mi it * Lb MT House| KilRentinalr Ren Serial 2.0 ~~)#~ ~~N 2. ~~j*No 4 L 0hk No.cTV CardenAir-1;Z2.J ,I A 31 MLicenseMf os ainle hiM)- M2 Contpensnnwithoor different a IaceOrrnge- i tcren I~~~~~~0 I)R Mlipe Ml l M I M. _loo space rI i7 2. rt&e 2.nre3.siere=oRegister boo inkfomtn & Dem.n7 foIeoe 771 ActaRraogmen Reette p laic oe 5M)21 . R ent ook dsom- Tla fre p |-fi Fam i plannin5rgeeg uiN | Demend; byresidenu66estion *or reloe lon | AddleiIN Phn 2I No _X1 Baleeny Roacm apace 2IO.here II I o cni 2 kr N t,; IAequipmernteet ||2 i etbo i3erb eocto Dean fo reloction48* *iE Dean by residen Sugg itionror reoa Io Adiioa (copy I I diff.rentI 141 rrlne I i til dee I I4 Acep arraengaementhuReetl plc 2e 4L Ren bo oreorFl~A .LVa Si.pernso-______...A t .Liititir lut 2| 1 3224 Arnn6 3. tD *>|Reihastier book Nlearbyre_l_c_t1o6 4.O !A - gA 4; X 1 } | .ttAtd~iferetitc anane " PN$oiS-l'mi'Pinnin6IcmesIe witSsl+* IdI I Le-, it§ Surrm ( fi tJ£ri Suevio .xlrD. altr APPENDIX II Serial Number of Sample Book Sample Survey Questionnaire of the Baseline SLS for IRR Conducted by the IMO Address of census: District Street_ Road No. Type of Census Household (multiple choice): I .Affected household by land acquisition El Ml 2.Affected household by demolition and movement El M2 3.Affected Household of occupation El M3 4. Other affected household a M4 5. Unaffected Household Dl M5 Family Type of Census Household: 1. Permanent Households 2. Temporary Households 3. Collective Households 4. Non-housing Households ( without local registered or the family is not in Guangzhou) Dl M6 Date of Census Signature of Surveyor: Appendix 11 Page I of 6 A: General Inforimiationi oftIlouseClold Al A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 A7 Al AIO List Name Economic types of Relation of the Sex Age House status Occupation Earning Commotion condition household register householder monthly _ Commuting Commuting Commuting type time fee (RMB) hour min. 1. Farming household 1. Householder 1. Male 1. enter-price 1. worker RMB 1. Bicycle 2. Non-farming 2. Spouse 2. Female 2. Rent private 2. Farmer 2. Bus household 3. Children 3. Self-owned 3. Individual trader 3. Motorcycle 4. Parent 4.Share with 4. Cadre 4.Other 5. Grandparents family members 5.Commercial and automobiles 6. Son-in-law 5. Shed catering trade 5.On feet 7.Grandchildern 6. Lodge with attendants 6. Others 8.Brother and sister relative 6. Professional 9. Other relative 7. Dormitory technical personnel I O.Non-relativeand 8. Others 7. Retired personnel collective household 8 . Teacher 9. Student 10. Army man I1. Housework 12.Otheroccupation 13. Otherjobless 02 === 05 =_=____ = 06 07 09 ______1_ Arrnpn,liv It V-1,. -f B. Economic Status of HoLIselhold 201. Family General Iincomeof the WlholeYear_RMB(Y)ZZZEBI in wllicih: Maini occupationi ilncome RMB(Y) --- B2 Sideline income RMB(f) __77B3 Othiersincome RMB(Y) LFE -f_B4 202. Tlle present monthilyexpenditiure of whole family: food (family consumptioni) RMB(Y) 1_ 1 B5 eating outside RMB(Y) ZZZZB6 clothlles ___ (Y) --- B7 dailk constiumergoods RMB(Y) __-IBS 11ouserate, ftuel,water and electricity fee_ RMB(V) : -_B9 transport RMB(RM _ -) l---B0 enitertaiiniienit RMB(V) 11 hBI I eduicationi(books, newspapers, tuitioin,etc.) ____RMB(Y) L B 19 202. It 'o olr familTyowns tlhe followinlg articles, please clhoose 1. If' lot, please chloose 0. I Articles I Yes or No 1B1' bicvclc ______black-and-white_ TV_ IBI electric rice cooker | L316 electric fan _ B 17 refriuerator B3I S camera 131 9 Washingmachine B-20 color TV !.2 I electric ventilator _ 1 -2 HI-FT B B'd tclephone i___4 vidco cassette recorder B325 air condition L326 motorcvcle IB27 video CD . - F3-S imicrov.ave oven B329 1valkie-lookie Appendix II Page 3 of 6 B30 portaphone I B31 automobile C. Dwellinig Conditioll 30 1. Type of yLourhouse 1. buLlgalow 2. apartment 3. detaclhedlouise 4. othiers -C I 302. StruIctuireof youirh1ouse i. frame 2. brick mixinog 3. brick and wood structIl-e 4. simple house 3'03. How mayiv rooms have your h1ouse? _1C2 304. Area of Vour Room M ___C4 305. Area of yoLurGarden M- ---ZZC5 306. Area of VoLr h1ouIsebase _ M -iC6 307. Property nightof your h1oLIse I self-owned 2. enterprise llouse (not buy) . renitprivate 4. othier C7 308. Old deurce of votir hIouse I newv2. middle 3. old ICS 309. Have youlfit tip yotir house? 1. yes 2. lo -C9 3 0. Evaluationiof interior decoration level 1. very good 2. good 3. ordinary 4. bad 5v %ccrbac i.C10 31. IHow aboLIt the uiseof tap wvaterof your hloutseat present ? I. separated tap Nvater 2. tap water shiare iI ulinit 3 lonltap water C I I 12.IH-ow about thie use of kitchienof your housc? Ap pendix' II Page 4 of 6 I. separate 2. shiaredinllUnit3. othiers 4. none IC 12 I3. Howvabotit the use of electricity of 1. no civil electricity 2. lave electricity, but n1osecuLe 3 frequelntelectricity offered -C 13 3 14. How about the uise of sanitary equipment of yotir hotise? I. lave lavatorv and bathroom 2. lave lavatory, no bathiroom 3. latriiie 4. ione 1C14 3 15. Do ou liave cable TV? I. yes 2. no .C 15 3 16. Do you lhavegas installment? I. yes, liave pip gas 2. yes, liave cannedLgas 3 noole IC 16 D. AttittudeSuLrveys vcrv satisfactoso-so dissatisfac vcrv satisfactory rv torV dissatistic 5 4 3 2 torY 1ihotse 5 4 D 2. transport conditioni ot' 5 4 3 2 1 D2 i1ivin,arca 3. medical condition of 5 4 3 2O _D3 hivinmt area 4 convenient deoree of 5 4 3 2 I 1D4 shopping S convenient de(ree of 5 4 3 . I D5 (oinsizto school for children I _ 6. litc in spare time 5 4 |3 2 I ] D6 |7 workingincome 5 4 |3 2 I | D7 S8xv(oriin( condition _ 4 _3 2 I 'DS 19.clationshipwith neighbor S 4 31 2 | I D9 10, The project promotes 54 .' 2 I DIO ithc local social economic Cdevelopment Appendix II Page 5 of 6 I 11. The project raises the 5 4 2 I _DI I I 11iving standard of vour tFamil_ Appendix II Page 6 of 6 APPENDIX III Serial Number of Sample Book Survey Questionnaire for Shops Affected by Inner Ring Road Place: District _Street Residents' committee Name of Shops: Address of Shops: C1 Name Sex Age Surveyor Date Appendix III Page I of 4 101. Ownership of shop 1. state 2. community 3. private 4. individual trader 5. three forms of ventures 6. others Si 102. Types of shop management 1. whole sale and retail 2. service trades 3. catering 4. repairing 5. public services 6. manufactory 7. others (please explain) S2 103. What kind of specific job do you have? S3 104. How long have you occupy yourself in this line of work? month year S4 S4.1 105. How long did your shop be in operation? S5 S6 106. Your shop lies in 1. bustling commercial district 2. main street in city centre or both sides of broad way 3. alleys and inside streets 4. others (please explain) S7 107. What kind of types does your shop belong to? 1. independent shopping centre 2. large-scale trade centre, a booth in market 3. scattered store 4. others (please explain) S8 201. How many workers and staff are there in your unit? S9 202. Monthly average total purchase in the past 12 months in 1995 RMB(Y) S1o 203. Monthly average total sales in the past 12 months in 1995 RMB(Y) S11 204. Monthly average after-tax profit in the past 12 months in 1995 RMB(y) S 12 205. Monthly per-capita income in the past 12 months in 1995 RMB(Y) S13 A Appendix 111Page 2 of 4 3301. How many practical areas of your shop ? M2 S14 302. The type of your shop or the building which the shop belongs to 1. storied house 2. bungalow 3. simple booth 4. others (please explain) S15 303. The building form of your shop belongs to 1. legal building 2. temporary building 3. unregistered building 4. others S16 304. the structure of your shop or the building which the shop belongs to 1. frame 2. mixing 3. brick and wood 4. simple S17 305. Your shop belongs to which form as followings 1. enterprise house 2. self-owned house 3. rent state 4. rent private 5. temporary or unfixed rent S 18 306. Question for tenants. What's the rent of your shop: per square meter monthly? RMB(y) S19 307. Question for tenants. When will your contract come due ? __month year S20S21 308. Have you fit up your shop? I. no 2. yes, it cost RMB(Y) S22S23 309. No matter whether you have the ownership of the shop or not. suppose you had the right of decision now. What's the rent of your shop per square monthly? RMB(Y) S24 If you sold it out, it worth RMB(Y) S25 per square meter monthly. 40 1. What do you think population density around you shop? 1. very dense 2. dense 3. so-so 4. less dense 5. sparse S26 402. What do you think the condition of purchase of your shop now? 1. very convenient 2. convenient 3. so-so 4. inconvenient 5. very inconvenient S27 Appendix III Page 3 of 4 403. How about the quality of customersof your shop at present? 1. much many 2. many 3. so-so 4. a few 5. few S28 404. What do you think the location of your shop? 1. very good 2. good 3. so-so 4. bad 5. very bad S29 405. What do you think the condition of water supply of your shop? 1. very good 2. good 3. so-so 4. bad 5. very bad S30 406. What do you think the using electricity? 1. very good 2. good 3. so-so 4. bad 5. very bad S31 407. What do you think the community service condition of the area around your shop? 1. very good 2. good 3. so-so 4. bad 5. very bad S32 Appendix III Page 4 of 4 APPENDIXIV SerialNumber of Sample Book Survey Questionnaire for the Affected Enterprises by Land Acquisition or House Demolition in Inner Road Project in Guangzhou Name of Unit: Address of Unit: Form A Al A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 Types of Unit Ownership of Industry Type of Number of Monthly Unit Management Stuff Per-Capita income 1. organs 1. state 1. agriculture 1. manufacture 2. institution 2. community 2. industry enterprise 3. enterprise 3. private 3. commerce and 2. commerce 4. individual 4. individual catering trade and trade trader trader 4.architecture and enterprise 5. other 5. three forms transportation 3. private shop (please of ventures 5.education ,science and booth explain) 6. other (please and art 4. public explain) 6. other service services 7. institution and 5. others organization of the Party and Govemment 8. others AppendixIV Page I of 3 Form B Project OccupiedArea (M2) AcquisitionArea (M2) B1 workshop B2 office building B3 residence B4 auxiliaryhouse B5 enclosingwall B6 hardgroundand road B7 others Form C: Evaluation for Accessory Facilities excellent quite good so-so poor worse 5 4 3 2 Tap water supply Cl 5 4 3 2 Electricitysupply C2 5 4 3 2 1 Fireproof C3 5 4 3 2 1 Pollutionremoval C4 5 4 3 2 Communityservice C5 5 4 3 2 1 environment Form D: Employment Information Type Total Number Members Members Membersof changing jobless due to occupation occupationfor removal affected removal DI fixed worker D2 contract worker D3 temporaryworker D4 others D total members of staff and workers AppendixIV Page2 of 3 Form E: Information about Units Reap Profit from Manufacture ( only Filled by Managerial Units) El E2 E3 E4 Total value of liquid Annual output value Annual profit Annual average assets income of staff Filler (or answer) Name Sex Age Occupation AppendixIV Page 3 of 3 Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects Inner Ring Road Project Resettlement Implementation Plan for Longxi Depots Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office Guangzhou Public Utility Administration Bureau February 1998 GCCTP I Depots Longxi and Mengkougang Maintenance Depots and Nanzhou Bus Terminal I. Introduction In order to improve the traffic situation of the city center of Guangzhou, we decide to utilize the World Bank loan to implement the Guangzhou City Center Transport Project, and Public Transport Improvement is one of the important sub-projects. According to the Master Plan of Guangzhou City and Guangzhou City Center Transport project, the total number of public transport vehicles will reach 5,000 in 2010. The maintenance capacity of present depots in Guangzhou only reaches 2,400 vehicles. Obviously, it can not meet the maintenance need of running vehicles. To ensure the good technical condition and safety of the public transport vehicles, the number of maintenance depots must be increased. Meanwhile, with the increase of buses, more waiting and transferring places for passengers will be needed, and more parking space and necessary facilities will be needed for buses off duty, so the number of bus terminals must be increased too. According to the demand for bus maintenance, running, parking, transferring and the distribution of present maintenance depots and bus terminals, we plan to add two new maintenance depots: Longxi depot and Menkougang depot; one Nanzhou Road bus terminal. To build these depots and bus terminal, land acquisition will be needed inevitably, and the living standards of some peopie will be adversely affected. In order to reduce the adverse impact of this project as much as possible, at least maintain the original living standards of the project affected persons (PAPs) and ensure the PAPs can finially benefit from the project, resettlement implementation plans for maintenance depots and bus terminal of GCCTP will be prepared according to the Resettlement PolicY for the Inner Ring Roali Project of GCCTP (hereafter Resettlement Policy). Resettlement Implementation Plansfor Maintenance Depots and Bus Terminal will completelv follow the objectives and principles of the Resettlement Policy, and resettle. rehabilitate. and compensate respectively to the PAPs according to the categories of project impacts in the Resettlement Policy. The standards of resettlement, rehabilitation and compensationiare the same as the stipulations in the Resettlement Policy. 11. Project Impact of Longxi Maintenance Depot Building of Longxi maintenance depot will acquire 48.26 mu of farm land, details of affected persons and asset are as follows: I. Project Affected Persons Thle number of PAPs are 44 affected labors (farmers), among them, 24 are male , 20 are female, thleir ages and education levels are as follows: GCCTP 2 Depots Male Female Total 16-55 Above 55 16-45 Above 45 Professionalschool 2 0 0 0 2 Senior middleschool 9 1 11 1 22 Juniormiddle school 7 1 3 2 13 Elementaryschool 1 2 0 1 4 Illiterate 0 1 0 2 3 Total 19 5 14 6 44 2. Affected Assets a. Land: 48.26 mu b. Perennial fruit trees and standing crops - litchi tree with 35cm diameter: 837 trees - longan Tree with 20cm diameter: 834 trees - longan Tree with I Ocm diameter: 527 trees - standing crops c. Water conservancy facilities - stone drainage ditch with I m2 transverse section: 21 6m - stone drainage ditch with 0.7m2 transverse section: 378.2m d. Agriculture electrical facilities - Electric pole: 6 II. Compensation for Various Assets of Farmers 1. Basic compensation for land: 130,000 yuan/mu. The fee doesn t include thle compensation for buildings owned by the individuals and collective on the land. hliemain purpose of land compensation is to develop the economic potential of productioll team \\ ose economy bases on agriculture. 2. A village investment plan depicting the use of land compensatioii tor tihc benetfitof thie PAPs will has been prepared according to the resettlement policy of the project and it will be 111li0 tored. 3. Compensationi for standing crops: 3,000 yuan/mu to be paid to farmers througLhltownship Toverilmelt. 4. The compensation for the water conservancy facilities has been negotiated with the relevant administration and an agreement has already been reached. 5. Pereninial fruit trees: the compensation to be used in developing the economy of the collective (village). Detailed standards are as follows: C Litchi tree (over 30cm diameter): 3000 yuan/tree GCCTP 3 Depots * Litchi tree (within 10-30cm diameter): 2000 yuan/tree * Longan tree (over 20cm diameter): 2500 yuan/tree * Longan tree (within 10-20cm diameter): 1000 yuan/tree IV. Policies for Job Creation and Life Security I . In order to maintain the living standards of farmers whose lands have not been acquired, the project will try its best to keep the proportion of the land over labor in production teams (villages) whose lands have been acquired. 2. Jobs will be provided by the project to the surplus labors whose lands have been acquired, the ages of labors are between 16-55 in male, between 16-45 in female. 3. In order to help the surplus labors to do non-agriculture jobs, the project will provide necessary professional training for the farmers. a. The project will pay 3,000 yuan towards the training cost of the surplus labors. b. Labor Administration Bureau (LAB) will offer employment to trained laborers, who will have the choice of being employed by a) the Village Administration; b) the LAB; or c) finding their own employment. 4. Job creation: a. The project will pay the production team (village) or the employing enterprise whicl will absorb the surplus labors 30,000 yuan/labor (labor resettlement subsidy). b. Farmers with professional skills and who choose to be self employed or seek his/lher employment (i.e. in a joint venture) will receive a lump sum compensationiof 30,000 yuan (labor resettlement subsidy). c. Pension: the project will pay pension to the male over 55 and the female over 45 affected by the project through township government, the amoun1tis equal to labor resettlement subsidy. V. Cost Estimate for Resettlement of Longxi Maintenance Depot (see Table 1 in the next page for details) * Compensation for land acquisition and resettlement i'3,174.220 yVuani . Fee charged by related government departments 1.737,360 yuan . Contingenicies 1.491,158 yuan * Administrationi fee 492.082 yuan Total 16,894,820 yuan VI. Monitoring Employment of surplus laborers will be monitored in accordance with the policy. GCCTP 4 Depots (-> VII. ResponsibleInstitutions The GCCTPO and GREEO will be responsible for the coordination and monitoring of the resettlement. The Public Utility Bureau will be responsible for the implementation of resettlement. Cost of resettlement will be paid by the project. VII. Implementation Schedule Activities 1997 1998 Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec Social and economic survey of PAPs Preparation of imp]ementation plan Signing Land Acquisition and Resettlement Agreements with PAPs Training for surplus labors = I I I I Job replacement Enterprise development Monitoring _ ( GCCTP 5 Depots Table 1: Cost Estimate for Land Acquisition and Resettlement of Longxi Maintenance Depot Serial Item Quantity Unit Price Amount of No (yuan) Money (yuan) I Compensation for land 48.26 mu 130,000/mu 6,273,800 acquisition 2 Compensation for perennial / fruit trees 2.1 Litchi trees (35cm diameter) 837 trees 3,000/tree 2,511,000 2.2 Longan trees (20cm diameter) 834 trees 2.500/tree 2,085,000 2.3 Longan trees (1Ocm diameter) 527 trees 1,000/tree 527,000 3 Present season standing crops 48.26 mu 3,000/mu 144,780 4 Compensation for labor 33 persons 30,000/labor 990,000 resettlement 5 Pension 11 persons 30,000/peson 330,000 6 Labor training fee 33 persons 3,000/labor 99,000 7 Compensation for water / / / conservancy facilities 7.1 Stone drainage ditch with 216 m 500/m 108.000 transverse section 1m2 7.2 Stone drainage ditch with 378.20 m 200/m 75,640 transverse section 0.7m2 8 Rural electric compensation / / / 8.1 Electric pole and wire 6 strips 5.000/strip 30,000 9 Fee charged by related / / / government departments 9.1 Cultivated land recovery 48.26 mu 16.000/mu 772,160 foundation 9.2 Vegetable field (orchard) 48.26 mu 20.000/mui 965.200 construction foundation 10 Total of above / 14.911.580 11 Contingencies(10%) / 1.491,158 12 Administration fee (3%) / _ 492.082 Total / 16.894,820 Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Inner Ring Road Project Public Utility Relocation Policy Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office January 1998 TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface 1.1 Institutions Involved in Preparing Pipeline Transfer & Compensation Policy 1.1.1 The Following Institutions Participated in Preparing the Pipeline Transfer and Compensation Policy 1.1.2 Functions of the Institutions 1.2 Preparing Method of Pipeline Compensation Policy Introduction 3 1. Pipeline 4 1.1 Use of Pipeline 1.1.1 Definition of Pipeline 1.1.2 Classification of Pipeline 1.1.3 Laying Method of Pipeline 1.1.4 Introduction of Gas 1.1.5 Introduction of Power Supply 1.1.6 Introduction of Communication 1.1.7 Introduction of Drainage 1.2 Administrative Organizations of Pipeline Property Right 1.2.1 Power Supply 1.2.2 Telecommunication 1.2.3 Water Supply 1.2.4 Gas 1.2.5 City Drainage and Raindrop System 1.2.6 Trolley Pipeline 1.2.7 Cable TV 1.3 The Administration Area of Pipeline Responsible Departments 2. Basis for Pipeline Resettlement and Compensation 6 2.1 National or Regional Juristic Documents for Pipelines 2.1.1 Power Supply 2.1.2 Water Supply (Including City Flood Control and Sewage Processing) 2.1.3 Communication 2.1.4 Gas 2.1.5 Cable TV 2.2 Referring Quota Standard for Pipeline Resettlement and Compensation 2.2.1 Standard by Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications 2.2.2 Quota Standard of Guangzhou Region 2.2.3 Army Standard 2.3 Pipeline Resettlement Standard Enforced by GREEO IRR Pipeline Transfer Compensation Policy ii January 1998 2.4 Affection of Relevant Policies on Pipeline Resettlement and Compensation 3. Pipeline Resettlement 9 4. Technical Requirement of Pipeline Transfer 11 4.1 Technical Codes Requirement 4.1.1 Overall Requirement 4.1.2 Power Supply Transfer 4.1.3 Telecommunication Lines 4.1.4 Water Supply Pipelines 4.1.5 Gas Pipelines 4.2 Requirement of Construction Management 5. Safety Requirement of Pipeline Resettlement 13 5.1 Stipulation for Safe operation 5.2 Safety Requirement of the Resettlement Management in-Situ 6. Pipeline Transfer 15 6.1 Stipulation of Safe Operation 6.1.1 Transfer of the Gauges Used by Residents and Shops and of the Communication Facilities 6.1.2 Transfer of the Gauges Used by Units and of the Communication Facilities 6.2 Repeated Transfer 6.2.1 Reason of Repeated Transfer 6.2.2 Attention Items of Repeated Transfer 6.3 Conduct to the Reciprocal Hamper of Pipeline Facilities 6.4 Requirement of the Pipelines Trend 7. Statistics of Pipeline 17 7.1 Principle of the Survey and Statistics of the IRR Pipeline Resettlement 7.2 Cover area of the Survey of the IRR Pipeline Resettlement 7.3 Statistics Depth of the IRR Pipeline Resettlement 7.4 Statistical End 8. Pipeline Facilities involved in the resettlement of Pipelines in the IRR Project 18 9. Relationship of Pipeline Resettlement and House Resettlement 19 9.1 Resettlement of the Buildings above the Pipeline Passages 9.2 The Impact and Rehabilitation to the Enterprises and Residents 9.3 Temporary Resettlement of Pipeline 10. Measures of Proper Pipeline Resettlement 21 10.1 Necessity 10.2 Concrete Measures 11. Compensation for Pipeline Resettlement 22 11.1 Compensation Basis 1 1.1.1 Legal Pipeline IRR Pipeline Transfer Compensation Policy iii January 1998 (7;~>, 11.1.2 Illegal Pipeline 11.1.3 Temporary Pipeline 11.1.4 Historically Handed Down Pipeline 11.2 Manner of Compensation 11.2.1 BudgetlBalance Checking and Examining 11.2.2 Contract Compensation of Monopolizing Everything 11.3 Check & Examination of Compensation 11.4 Case Statistics of Compensation 11.4.1 Requirement for the Types of Material 11.4.2 Storage of Budget and Settlement/Balance ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS GCCTPO Project Office of Guangzhou City Centre Transport Project GMG Guangzhou Municipal Government GREEO Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office GURCC Guangzhou Urban and Rural Construction Commission IMO Independent Monitoring Organization IRR Inner Ring Road PAPs Project Affected Persons Phase 1, II, III, IV The First, Second, Third, Fourth Phase of Project RAP Resettlement Action Plan Rd. Road SLS Surveys of Living Standards Str. Street UNITS m metre m square metre km kilometre kv kilovolt RMB Renminbi (Yuan) (approx 8.7 RMB/USD) mu area; 15mu=lha GCCTP PIPELINE TRANSFER COMPENSATION POLICY Preface 1.1 Institutions Involved in Preparing Public Utility Relocation Policy 1.1.1 The Following Institutions Participated in Preparing the Public Utility Relocation Policy a. Project Office of the Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects b. Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office c. Affected Power Supply Bureaus, Tap Water Corporation, Guangzhou Telecommunication Bureau, Guangzhou Gas Company, Guangzhou Road Lamp Bureau, Troop 87400, Troop 54410, Guangzhou Railroad General Company, Long-distance Telecommunication Bureau, Municipal Maintenance Section, Trolley Company, Guangzhou Marine Transportation Bureau, Municipal & Landscape Bureau, Satellite Ground Station, Cable Central Control Place, Guangdong (Guangzhou) Cable TV Station, Guangzhou Cable Administration Place and affected enterprises, units and residents along the alignment. d. Associated technical institution. 1.1.2 Functions of the Institutions a) Project Office of Guangzhou City Center Transport Projects * To be responsible for coordinating the activities of all participation units. * To heed the opinions of owners of infrastructure. * To collect schemes promoted by technical institutions and experts. * To direct the policies of units whose pipeline to be relocated in principle. b) Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office * To be responsible for rendering pipeline relocation and compensation in accordance with the resettlement & compensation quota and standard of P.R.C., Guangdong Province and Guanigzliou,as well as certain legal basis. * To prepare a set of relatively completed pipeline relocation plan. * To be responsible for preparing rebuilding and compensation plan. N GCCTPPublic Utility Relocation Policy 2 January 1998 c) Affected units of power supply, water supply, communication, gas, road lamp, cable TV and military facilities * To convoke relative units and enterprises with respect to the degree of impact within the range of resettlement. * To collect information and opinions of affected units and report it to GCCTPO and GREEO, so as to formulate feasible detailed compensation policies and measures. d) Associated Technical Institution * To organize associated technical experts and promote opinions on pipeline relocation and compensation policy. * To appraise the reasonability and legality of compensation policy. e. Project will cover the cost of infrastructure(pipeline) rehabilitation. CCTP Construction Company will entrust GREEO with the coordination and supervision of pipeline rehabilitation. Utility owners will undertake implementation through their own professional construction teams. 1.2 Preparing Method of Public Utility Relocation Policy I. In accordance with compensation policies of P.R.C., Guangdong Province and Guangzhou. 2. To conduct drawings and survey in-situ and collection of the submitted pipeline compensation schemes. To work out a deliberate and non-baseless relocation and compensationi schemne, according to the safety degree, technical design and impact degree of pipeline relocation, as well as certain legal compensation standard. 3. To render reasonable and legal compensation to owner units and affected infrastructures, according to relocation range and content, in combination with the guidance prilciple of the Word Bank. To minimize profit loss of affected units and resume their fuLnctiollas soon1as possible and as perfectly as possible. 4. The purpose of the plan is to ensure that all affected utilities will be restored to their original condition. 5. Compensation will be paid at replacement value/price. 6. Negotiations will be held between the project and the owners of infrastructure to reach the final agreement on the compensation amount. GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 3 January 1998 Introduction Guangzhouis a city with long history. Howeverthe alignmentand layout of its pipeline,which is a city infrastructure, is, to some extent, a little backward and not standard according to certain technical requisition. Thus, in orderto meet the requirementof the WorldBank on Inner Ring Road Project, a completed,standardized and feasibleset of technicalscheme shouldbe worked out accordingto a series of reasonableand legal compensationstatue. The municipal facilitiesof a city, includingcity road, bridge,tunnel, drainagepipeline, pump station, sewagetreatment, signalsystem etc., is a subsystemof city infrastructure.The consummationof these facilitiesdirectly affect the developmentof city. Perfect facilitieswill also create a series of conditionsfor open policy, attractingforeign fund and amelioratinginvestment circumstance. Constructionof municipalfacilities will play an importantrole in improvingcity carrier function, promotingcity economicdevelopment. It is hard to assumethat a city withjammed traffic and informationand environmentpollution can meetthe standardfor city economicdevelopment. Thereforein the Inner Ring Road Project, high emphasiswill be laid on the investment,resettlement, technique,compensation and administrationin the aspect of municipalinfrastructure resettlement. We expectthat Guangzhouwill put on a new face of internationalmetropolis on the originalcity developmentbasis, throughthe constructionof Inner Ring RoadProject. ( GCCTPPublic Utility Relocation Policy 4 January 1998 1. Pipeline 1.1 Role of Pipeline Pipeline is an important part of city infrastructure, which is indispensable lifeline of a city. It not only serves the residents, connects the households, but also has countless connections with the whole city. It casts direct influence on the economy, culture and development of a city. It is the base of a modernized city which can never be underestimated. 1.1.1 Definition of Pipeline Pipeline is the carrier for transporting media such as gas, liquid, energy and information. It includes lines and other kinds of equipment. It provide necessary basic materials for households, factories and enterprises. 1.1.2 Classification of Pipeline Classified by function: power supply pipeline, water supply pipeline, communication pipeline, gas pipeline, cable TV pipeline, drainage and raindrop amount, trolley bus line, road lamp, road and traffic control line etc. 1.1.3 Laying Method of Pipeline Laying of pipeline can either be overhead or embedded. Overhead laying can be classified as two imodes: vertical pole and tower. Some overhead pipeline can be laid on the external walls of structures in real need. Embedded laying can be classified as three modes: direct embedding, pipe embedding, prefabricated pit embedding. 1.1.4 Introduction of Gas Gas is a novelty in Guangzhou in recent years. It facilitate the majority of the residents. However it also brings about safety problems, especially in relocation. Safe transmit of gas pipeline has become a question which must be paid attention to. 1.1.5 Introduction of Power Supply Power supply facility is a special business item belonging to power supply department. This business item includes self-governed codes/specification and measures. Power facilities such as overhead power pipeline, power cable pipeline (including overhead, underground, underwater power cable and cable connections), cable pipes, cable conduit form a huge power supply network. which provides light to public and the foundation of economic development. 1.1.6 Introduction of Communication Communication pipeline is an important part of national communication network. The pipeline undertakes domestic and international communication, and plays an important role in socialist modernization construction and national defense. GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 5 January 1998 1.1.7 Introduction of Drainage City drainage facility and its affiliated facilities, including public drainage conduit, ditch, open drain, covered conduit, gutter, raindrop conduit, sewage conduit, urban area rivers for drainage, sewage, flood control and their maintenance territory, pump station, sluice gate, manhole, catch basin, sewage disposition facility and its affiliated structures, is an indispensable facility in city construction. It plays an important role in maintaining the perfection of municipal facilities, promoting city economy and social development. 1.2 Administrative Organizations of Pipeline Property Right Pipeline administrative organizations mean the units which own their property right. They are in charge of the construction, maintenance and operation of the pipelines. They are government administrative department or enterprises and institutions. They will be explained as following according to classification of property right. 1.2.1 Power Supply The administrative department of power supply pipeline and equipment is Guangzhou Power Industry Bureau. According to function and administration area/jurisdiction, it has seven subsidiaries including east district, south district, west district, north district, central district, Fangcun and Huangpu subsidiaries and power transmit station, road lamp administration station and cable administration station. 1.2.2 Telecommunication The administrative department of telecommunication pipeline and equipment is Guangzllou Telecommunication Bureau. According to function and administration area, it has Dongslhan,Yuexiu, Liwan, South district, Shahe, Baiyun, Huangpu, Fangcun subsidiaries and wireless telepholle subsidiary, long-distance telephone subsidiary and business subsidiary. 1.2.3 Water Supply The administrative department of water supply pipeline and equipment is GuanlgzhIouCity Tape Water Company. According to function and administration area, it has Dontslhaln.YuexiLu. Liwan, Soutlhdistrict, Baiyun, Huangpu, Fangcun stations and engineering company, labor service company. 1.2.4 Gas The administrative department of gas is Guangzhou Gas Company. 1.2.5 City Drainage and Raindrop System GuanlgzhoLuMunicipal Maintenance Section, which is a subsidiary of Guangzlhou Municipal & Landscape Bureau, is responsible for maintenance and operation of city drainage and raindrop system of Guangzhou City. GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 6 January1998 1.2.6 Trolley Pipeline Guangzhou Trolley bus Company, which is an enterprise of Guangzhou Public Utility Bureau, is responsible for the operation and maintenance of city trolley bus line of Guangzhou city. 1.2.7 Cable TV Cable TV lines belong to Guangdong Cable TV Company and Guangzhou Cable TV Company respectively, according to property right. The two companies are responsible for maintenance and operation of cable TV lines in Guangzhou. 1.2.8 Other administrative department and other pipeline property units include large-scale manufacturing companies, Guangzhou troops, railroad department and water course bureau. 1.3 The Administration Area of Pipeline Responsible Departments 2. Basis for Pipeline Relocation and Compensation 2.1 National or Regional Juristic Documents for Pipelines In recent years, laws have been made for municipal resettlement. As to public utility relocation. juristic documents for pipelines have been made. In the Inner Ring Road Project, pipeline relocation will be conducted according to relative laws, ordinances and regulations. 2.1.1 Power Supply a) Administration Regulations for City Road Lighting Facilities P.R.C. Constructioll Law No. 21, November 30, 1992 b) P.R.C. Power Supply Law December 28, 1995 c) Ordinance for Power Supply and Usage P.R.C. State Council Order No. 196. April 17. 1996 d) Administration Methods for Power Supply and Usage P.R.C. Ministry of Power Industry Order No.4. May 19, 1996 2. 1.2 Water Supply (Including City Flood Control and Sewage Processing) AdcmninistrationRegulations for Guangzhou Municipal Facilities issued by People's Congress Standing Committee of Guangdong Province, July 1, 1997 2.1.3 Communication Regulationsfor Protection of Communication Pipelines issued by State Council, Central Military Coinmittee[1982]No.28 GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 7 January 1998 2.1.4 Gas a) Safety Administration Regulations for City Gas b) Guangdong Province Gas Administration Regulations 2.1.5 Cable TV a) Order(No.5) by Ministry of Broadcast, Film and TV b) Protection Ordinancefor Broadcast, TV Guangdong Province Government[1991] No. 109 2.2 Referring Quota Standard for Pipeline Relocation and Compensation All pipeline facilities which are included in the property lines of the Inner Ring Road Project will be compensated according to compensation principle and relative quota. 2.2.1 Standard by Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications a) Preparing Method of Rough Estimate, Budget and Norms for Telecommunication Engineering b) Budget Norms for Telecommunication Construction Engineering c) Preparing Method of Rough Estimate, Budget and Norms for Telecomillullication Construction Engineering, [1995]626 d) Alternation of PreparingMethod of Rough EstimatleBudget a1nd/ 0o;,s fOr Telecommunication Construction Engineering. [1995]185 e) Standard for Classification of Telecommunication Construction EnHinecrin g. 11995]945 f) Information Manual of Standard Prices for Telecommunication ConstrLctiolnEngineering. Stanldardand Quota Station 1995 g) Standard of Work-day Price for Engineering Exploration and Desi-nl. Nationiil Plrice Bureau and Ministry of Construction [1992]375 2.2.2 Quota Standard of Guangzhou Region Budget Basic Prices for Common Projects of GuangzlhouRegion 2.2.3 Army Standard Preparing Method of Rough Estimate, Budget for National Defense Telecommunication Enginieerilng 2.3 Pipeline Relocation Standard Implemented by GREEO 2.3.1 In principle, pipeline relocation and compensation is based on the amount of demolition. N GCCTP Public Utility Relocation Policy 8 January 1998 2.3.2 Pipelines will be fully compensated to restore service to pre-project levels. After the full service is restored, pipelines which will be abandoned will also be compensated at a depreciated cost. 2.3.3 The project will be responsible to compensate to restore pipelines to their original standards. There will be non compensation for a change or upgrade in the design of the infrastructure. However, if the change in the design is required by the project, then the cost difference will be covered by the project. 2.3.4 The project will compensate for the pipelines to restore service to pre-project levels. Damage to infrastructure or interruption to power supply due to the mistakes of the civil works contractor will not be paid by the project. Responsibility to correct the mistakes is the responsibility of the contractor. This point will be stipulated in the contracts signed with the contractors. 2.3.5 The income loss of the pipeline owners due to the service interruption caused by the pipeline relocation will be negotiated with all the pipeline owners. 2.4 Impact of Relevant Policies on Pipeline-Relocation and Compensation In principle, pipelines should be transferred according to their design standard (including scale and operation mode) when conditions in-situ are met. New pipelines should meet operation load requirement of the original design. However, in practical implementation, pipeline transfer will contravene with planning, municipal and relevant pipeline codes in some cases. 2.4.1 Impact by planning examination and approval: When pipeline relocation scheme is being examined for approval, the planning department may unreasonably require to alter pipeline operation mode sometimes, e.g. from overhead line to underground line, though the conditionis in-situ are enoughi to resume its original operation mode. Relocation expense is therefore increased. 2.4.2 Impact of municipal fee: Road excavation fee should not be paid wlhellulidergrouLid pipeline transfer is needed due to municipal construction. 2.4. 3 Impact of relevant pipeline codes: a) Telecommunicationi:fees of telecommunication interruption shotild not be paid for muiLicipal projects( not including long-distance telephone). b) Water supply: fee of water consumption and old pipe compensation should not be paid for municipal projects. Furthermore, during construction period, reparation fee of water pipeline leakage, blasting due to years should not be paid by municipal relocation ulnits. c) Others: wheni pipes are needed to be set for underground pipelines (telecommunicationi or power supply) crossing overpass/interchange or road surface. we shall compensate pipe expense according to amount of operation lines. Other pipe expense should be invested by property units. GCCTPPublic Utility Relocation Policy 9 Januarv 1998 3. Pipeline Relocation 3.1 Operation Procedure of Pipeline Relocation In order to meet the requirement of the World Bank, working system of division of labor with individual responsibility will be carried out for all projects. Association with pipeline owner units will kept to coordinate the process of the whole project. 3.1.1 Pipeline relocation and compensation working procedure of GREEO See Figure 1. 3.1.2 House turnover working procedure of GREEO See Figure 2 and 3. 3.2 Working Procedure of Urban Planning Department See Figure 4. 3.3 Operation Procedure of Pipeline Transfer See Figure 5. GCCTP Public Utility Relocation Policy 10 Januarv 1998 >Fig.N, 1 ProcedureofPipeline Resettlement and Compensation Acceptconsign t blueprintfrom the municipal design in-situ be institution d suveyin-situ -e urbanplanning bureau ______-- _- - _ _ _ _ powersupply i watersupply communication gas cableTV showinforming showdemolition reportto urban files scheme planningbureau submitbudget, settlementbalance 4 showresult of budget,settlementV balance examined& approved byhead of GREEO construction checkand accept after completion Fig.2 Report and Equip Flow of Using Power for Transfer Housing district traffic police section district traffic police section report to involved units | I m c adinstatv _ _| ~~~~municipaladministrative . . : . >\bureau city traffic police department city government below 100kw arrange for drawing budget receive complete completion beaprovxamie * reeive br design and design * check - check * fees and &check _ examine&check examineeeconstruction &examine &examine construct ace . . . . ~~accept...... t ~~~examine&approve by---.. ._ . district buteau I I user apply 4 register survey in- receive and report monitor and equip meters make up ID for to equip check and power _fees transferIICotrolnsftu examine &approve by i city bureau bearexamine & foreceivel fee arrange for drawing budget receive complete completion approve capacity/ | design and * design *H check H check H fees and hecd | examine&check bear p construction &examine I &examine I construct acnept above 1OOkw distrct traffic police section district traffic police section report to involved units i I municipal administrative city traffic police department I b city government Fig.3 Reportand EquipFlow of UsingWater for TransferHousing belowDN50 bearexamine & receivebear arrangefor drawing budget receive complete completion beaprovxamie. receive br designand design - check _ check feesand &check examine&check approve fe .construction &examine &examine construct accept examine&approve by ~- -- districtwater supply section ______. userapply _, register - surveyin receiveand report monitorand equipmeters makeup ID for ontrol'\ situ to equip check andpower fees transfer ~~examine&approve by .--> the group of large ._ household- __ Sbearexamine& foreloa arrangefor J drawing budget receive complete completion beaprovexamca forload- - 'design and --o. design o check -o check fees and &check examine&check approve capacity/ constructionI &examine &examine construct and bear _ accept aboveDN50 Fig.4 Work Procedure of Urban Planning Department unit of applying for construction(proprietor unit) Pipeline demolition and applying for Wconstruction planning, survey &design institute check lines-in-situ urban planning bureau ------_-examine and approve unit of applying for construction(proprietor unit) -I---__- -- ,.complete construction urban planning bureau check and accept, --- -_ ~~ archive ( >! Fig. 5 Operation Procedure of Pipeline Transfer pipeline baseline survey and collect entrust demolition survey in-situ optimize and choose scheme plan to apply for construction examine &check budget and settlementVbalance construction monitor & administration project check and accept archive GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 11 January 1998 4. Technical Requirement of Pipeline Transfer Pipelines in operation provide material basis of normal production and living for enterprises and residents. To reduce adversely impact on economy, living and residents caused by pipeline interruption due to construction accidents, pipeline transfer should be conducted according to technical codes. Working place and construction site should be scientifically monitored. Appropriate and immediate measures should be taken when pipeline break down is found. 4.1 Technical Codes Requirement 4.1.1 Overall Requirement a) Design standard of new pipelines should not be lower than that of old pipelines, to assure operation load requirement. b) National and provincial technical codes should be implemented in pipeline relocation to assure safety. 4.1.2 Power Supply Transfer a) When overhead power supply lines are transferred to underground lines, design standard of new lines should be higher. b) Underground power supply lines must not be directly embedded. Pipes or saps should be used. c) Safe distance between high-volt overhead lines and other lines or structures sliould be kept. High-volt power supply equipment should be installed indoors or enclosed by fence. d) Wheniagreed by power supply administrative department, some undergrounidpower liles wvhosescope of influence is small can be protected at original place instead of transferring to other place. Reasonable construction scheme should be made with power supply administrative department to assure that construction will conform to relevant techllical codes. 4. I .3 Telecommunication Lines a) Underground telecommunication lines must not be directly embedded witlhout pipes and saps. b) Wheniagreed by telecommunication administrative department, some low influenlce-scope underground telecommunication lines can be protected at original place instead of transferring to otlherplace. 4.1 .4 Water Supply Pipelines a) Alignment of water supply conduits in Guangzhou City planning shiouldbe strictly implemented whenitransferring these lines. b) Embedded depth of main water supply pipelines should be no less than 1.2 m. Embedded depth of other water supply pipelines should be no less than 0.8 m. GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 12 January 1998 4.1.5 Gas Pipelines a) Alignment of gas lines in Guangzhou City planning should be strictly implemented when transferring these lines. b) Transferring gas pipelines with gas is forbidden. 4.2 Requirement of Construction Management Relocation site will be scientifically managed. Managing staff should coordinate to solve problems due to crossing construction between pipelines, pipelines and road construction, solve problems between house resettlement and pipelines relocation, take appropriate measures to solve accidents. a) Pipeline relocation sequence should be: underground first, overhead last; road center first, sides last; deeper first, shallower last. b) When pipelines whose corridors are close in horizontal distance are constructed simultaneously, pipelines with deeper embedded depth should be constructed first. c) Before excavating road for construction, the alignment and depth of underground pipelines should be made clear. Before machine excavation, the road should be divided into sections. Exploration holes should be made for every section to make clear that there exists no pipelines before machine excavation. Before constructing bored piles with machines. exploration pile of 1.5 m depth should be made to make clear that there exists no pipelines. d) Pipelines should not be overlapped except for intersection. Wheinoverlapping can not be avoided, in principle, pipelines with lower technical requirement should make way for those with higher technical requirement, small for large, subsidiary for main line, pressure pipe for self-run pipe, soft pipe for stiff pipe, bendable pipe for unbendable pipe. e) If construction of permanent corridor/passage surface of underground pipelines can not be implemented due to house relocation, temporary resettlement should be made. Pernanent relocation to the required corridor place should be made after resettlement of house. Pipelines adhere to buildings and user meters/gauges should be resettled before relocation of houses. f) Construction units should immediately apprise pipeline administrative ulnitsoil any pipeline accidents for reparation. Meanwhile they should inform to GREEO the site, cause of accidents. Pipelines operation should be resumed before analysis, summary and responsibility investigation of accident. t) In principle underground pipelines should not be enclosed in municipal facility structures. However when agreed by pipeline owner units after exploration and survey in-situ, part of pipelines can be enclosed in municipal facility structures after enough protection measures have been taken. For example: high-volt cable or telecommunication cable can be located in piles when enclosed with steel pipes, water supply pipes or gas pipes can be located in drainage box when being water proved. GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 13 January 1998 / 5. Safety Requirement of Pipeline Relocation --2 The pipeline network of Guangzhou City serves for all citizens and provides the absolutely necessary and fundamental warrant for their everyday living. So, it is very necessary to improve safety intention and collectedly maintain the pipeline facilities of Guangzhou city so as to ensure their safety in operation. 5.1 Stipulation for Safe Operation a) When entering the construction sites, water-proof shoes, safety cap, garment with long sleeves and insulated gloves are necessary. b) At the construction sites with power, there must be above 2 staff coming from the Pipeline Section of GREEO. c) Working near the high-volt facilities, the shield barriers should be set. Monitorilg is necessary if the shield barriers need to be moved. d) Working at the electrical facilities with fully or partial stoppage of power, the following measures must be implemented: i) stop power ii) check iii) equip and set the line connecting the ground iv) hang up the waming, card and set up the shield barriers v) to the pipeline facilities that need to be stopped power supply, it is need to disconnlect all switches and have at least one obvious off-switch. e) At construction sites, if any power pipelines without check & proof are fouLnd,they will be treated as pipelines with electricity f) During the construction of new relocated pipelines, pay attentioni to the work of conn1ectincgto the ground. When connect the ground line, the end of connectinigto the groLundinust be connected first, then the other end connecting to the conductor, make sure that the touch is well. The sequence of demolishing the ground line is verse that of connecting. There must be two persons working together with isolated bars and insulating gloves. g) There must be enough safe distance between the persons and the electrified conductors. The safe distance is 0.7m when the voltage is below 10 kilo volt. The distance should be lengthen according to the related stipulation when the tension is above 10 kv. h) Wheniconstructing the pipelines near the high-volt electric equipment, the meshy barriers should be set up in addition. The height of the barriers is not less than I .7m and the mesh area is not less than 40x40 square mm. 0 GCCTPPublic Utility Relocation Policy 14 January 1998 i) Check before using the safety utilities to see whether the surface is clean and not crackled or not. Put them in the dry and ventilated place after use. j) To the flammable liquid gas, liquid conduits and facilities that may cause all kinds of damage by the static sparkle and the force of static field, the measure of connecting to the ground is connecting and forning a continuous body first and then connecting them to the ground. k) When the hoisted job is necessary because of the construction of pipeline transfer or municipal construction, the distance between the crane (including the hoisted objects) and the electrified bodies must be above 1.5m when the voltage is below I kv. The distance should be 2-6m when the voltage is above lkv, otherwise the electrified lines and equipment must be stopped power usage. 5.2 Safety Requirement of Relocation Management in-Situ 5.2.1 The related national, provincial and municipal laws and stipulations of safety protection during working, fire prevention and environment protection must be observed during the period of the construction of pipeline transfer. 5.2.2 Affected by municipal projects, the pipeline units with property right should send the approved files of pipelines and the drawings to the Pipeline Section of the GREEO. 5.2.3 The related pipeline units should be organized before construction and tell the municipal construction units. their real intentions in technology, check the pipeline drawings and the alignments of the pipelines by excavated the probe holes in-situ, set up the sign cards in the corridors of the original pipelines. 5.2.4 To the pipelines near the stake positions and built-substances of construction. the municipal construction units should check the depths and the level positions of the pipelines before conistruction, pay attention to making good protection measures and protect the pipelines well. 5.2.5 In case that the municipal construction units cannot find the alignments of the pipelines and cannot probe clearly, they cause the damage of the pipelines or power breaking-off by their construction without orders, they must be responsible for all obligation. 5.2.6 The municipal construction units should strengthen the safety education to constructinig staff, especially to the no-technical workers from other places. 5.2.7 During the construction of the pipelines, pay attention to the safety check. If some constructioni problems about safety happen, these should be prevented in time and some solved measures should be adopted in-situ. 5.2.8 Some protected barriers and some warning cards/warning lamps should be set up at the alignment of the pipeline construction, to avoid walkers entering by mistake and causing accidents. 5.2.9 When the underground pipelines are intersected, the vertical net-distance of pipelines should be not less than 25cm. To the straight embedded power lines without any protection measures and communication cables, the net-distance from the other pipelines should be not less than 50cm. G GCCTPPublic Utility Relocation Policy 15 January 1998 6. Pipeline Transfer 6.1 Stipulationof Safe Operation Municipalconstruction is that broadeningthe originalroads or changingthe single plane function of the original roads into multi-storied functions of interchange system. While the units and residents within the scope of the property line of the Inner Ring Road need to be resettled, the gauges belong to the pipeline units and the communication units need to be properly resettled too. 6.1.1 Transfer of the Gauges Used by Residents and Shops and of the Communication Facilities a) If the residential houses are entirely demolished, the general water meters and general power meters will be reported to and handed to the owner units by the GREEO. The compensation for telephone and gas meters will paid by the GREEO too. However, the pipeline fees used by the residents themselves will be paid by themselves. b) If the residential houses are partially demolished(half of the houses are demolished), the facilities such as water meters, gas meters, power meters and telephone will be transferred to the reserved positions of the housing by the GREEO, rehabilitated their using function and reported to the units with property right. c) If the residential houses are entirely demolished first and rebuilt later (here refer to the farmers' houses/ houses of housing plots), the GREEO will demolish the gauges and communication facilities first, then conduct applying relocation and stoppage for approval to the units with property right, rehabilitated their using function after rebuilt. 6.1.2 Transfer of the Gauges Used by Units and of the Communication Facilities a) If the units need to be moved to new resettlement sites, the original pipeline facilities used by the units will be demolished and compensated by the GREEO. The gauges will be hanided to the units with property right after demolished. b) If the land of the units is partially acquired, the using function of all kinds of pipelines in the original land must be kept. The groups of water meters and power meters and other gauges (such as changing power, match/switch power) must be transferred to the positiolns pointed by the pipeline units with property right and relocated in accordance witlhthe equipped requirement. The gas meters and the communication facilities will be relocated by the pipeline units with property right (owner units) themselves and the GREEO will compensate for the construction fees due to relocation. All the transfer of the pipelines and the facilities cannot occupied the municipal pavements. The rebuilding or adding of the pipeline facilities will not receive any compensation. c) If the land of the pipeline units is entirely acquired and the units need to be rebuilt in different places, the compensation for the pipelines and facilities will be paid once in accordance with the related laws and stipulations according to the original facilities. GCCTPPublic Utility Relocation Policy 16 January 1998 6.2 Repeated Transfer The pipelines may be transferred more than one time because of the restriction of the environment of the construction sites in the course of the pipeline resettlement. The pipelines need to be relocated repeatedly because the planned requirement cannot be performed and the pipelines cannot be relocated to the planned sites at one time, too. 6.2.1 Reason of Repeated Transfer a) Requirement of the municipal construction: If the pipelines hamper the municipal construction at the construction corridors without everlasting planning of pipelines, the pipelines need to be transferred temporarily to give way for municipal construction, then moved to the planned pipeline corridors forever when all construction condition is obtained. b) Requirement of housing demolition: To some pipelines and facilities that be set in the outer walls of structures, when the structures are demolished, the pipelines and facilities need to be moved from the structures first, then relocated forever after the demolition of the structures based on the requirement of the planning. c) Requirement of the pipeline construction: In the case there are a lot of pipelines in the narrow space so that the construction of all kinds of pipelines at the same time is impossible, the pipelines whose technical grades are lower need to be transferred temporarily, then relocated everlasting after the construction of pipelines whose technical grades are higher is finislhed. 6.2.2 Attention Items of Repeated Transfer a) Evaluate and examine different technical schemes, compare the constructioni fees and construction duration of different schemes repeatedly, adopt the schellmeswhose construction duration is short and construction fees are less than others. b) To the same pipeline that need repeatedly transfer and break off its normal operation more times, take the impact into account so as to decrease the impact of the normal operations as little as possible during construction. The construction of cut and conlect should be conducted in the night time. c) Whenithe pipelines repeatedly transfer, the parts that can be used should be kept and continued to use. The fees of these parts will be got rid from the compensatioll fees. For example, when the high-volt cable move to cable chamfers temporarily first. thell relocate to the open cable tunnels everlastingly, the high-volt cables should be kept to use and thle compensation fees will paid for only one time transfer. 6.3 Conduct to the Reciprocal Hamper of Pipeline Facilities Intersection of some pipelines often occurs during the municipal construction of broadeninigold roads and bridges. The conduct measures are follows when the situation of intersection happen: subsidiary pipelines should make way for main lines, subordinate arteries for main arteries, civil pipelines for the main pipelines of National Defense Department. For example, wlhen a row of main communication pipelines are being constructed in some roads and meeting the match pipelines of water supply, the match pipelines of water supply should make way for the main communication lines and some technical measures should be taken to construction. GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 17 January 1998 6.4 Requirement of the Pipelines Trend According to the requirement of City Planning: the pipelines set along the roads (including overhead) slhouldbe arrayed from the property line to the middle of the roads. The sequence in principle is that subordinate pipelines of water supply, power lines and cables, gas lines, sewage pipelines, drainage pipelines lay in order in the east or west of the roads; the subordinate pipelines of water supply, communication cables, water supply pipelines, hot &forced pipelines lay in order in the north of the roads or in pavement. In the roads whose width is above 40m, the pipelines can be set in two rows. The alignment of the pipelines should be parallel with the central line of the roads. The section of the pipelines traversing the roads should be vertical with the midline of the pipelines as perfect as possible. 7. Statistics of Pipeline 7.1 Principle of the Survey and Statistics of the IRR Pipeline Relocation The statistics of the IRR pipelines should be on the basis of the principle of ownliligproperty rigiht. The ultra jurisdiction of property right should be compensated by another department withl property right and will not be accounted repeatedly. 7.2 Cover area of the Survey of the IRR Pipeline Relocation At this time, the acquired area within the property lines is the controlled area in the survey of the IRR pipeline relocation. All of the pipelines within the property lines are considered to he resettled and will be taken into account. 7.3 Statistics Depth of the IRR Pipeline Relocation There are a large amount of pipelines laying in the 26 kilometer-longed InnierRing, Road. some ot thremcannot be taken into account, such as the lines belong to users/residents. becausc thleyare complicated in direction and intersected, they cannot be accounted one by onleb\ tlhedepartmenlt with property right and will only be taken into account according to experience and occupied densitv. The laying structure of pipelines can be separated into: Arteries---Branclhes---LUsers. The branchi parts are listed (according to the practical survey parts) in the statistical depth. The amounltstatistics of user parts employs a statistical method of average value. Namely. occupied amount of all sorts of pipelines per square meter is accounted according to the experience. (note: empirical formula is supplied by the departments with property right of the pipelines according to dairy accounts.) GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 18 January 1998 7.4 Statistical End 7.4.1 The statistical ends of power supply department are the power supply gauges of users. Namely, the parts from the artery to master branches are accounted according to the practical happening amount; The parts from branches to users are accounted according to the average value method. 7.4.2 The statistical ends of communication part are telephones and fax servers of users. The parts from arteries to branches are accounted according to practical happening amounts, the parts from branches to users are calculated according to the average value method. 7.4.3 Water supply pipe part: the statistical ends are water gauges of users. The parts from arteries to branches are accounted according to practical happening amounts, the parts from branches to users are calculated according to the average value method. 7.4.4 The statistical ends of drainage conduit part are water acceptors of users. The parts from arteries from branches are accounted according to practical lhappeningamounts, the parts from branches to users are calculated according to the average value method. 7.4.5 Gas part: the statistical ends are gas gauges of users. - The parts from arteries from branches are accounted according to practical hiappening amounts, the parts from branches to users are calculated according to the average value method. 8. Pipeline Facilities involved in the Public Utility Relocation in Inner Ring Road Project a) Lines of power supply (lines of output power, lines of switch/match power) b) Pipelines of water supply c) Drainage lines d) Gas lines e) Trolley lines f) Communicationi lines g) High-volt cable center dispatch hi) Long distance communication lines i) Satellite ground station lines j) Railway communication control lines k) Legionary communication lines GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 19 January 1998 1) Marine transportation communication lines m) Roadside lamp lines 9. Relationship of Pipeline Relocation and House Resettlement 9.1 Resettlement of the Buildings in the Pipeline Passages/Corridors Surface The constructive density of Guangzhou city is big and its population is huge. Especially, the space between two buildings in old city proper is small and the roads are narrow. The resettlement for municipal construction will bring about the difficulty of pipeline relocation. In municipal construction, the old city proper should be broadened according to the urban planning. In order to make the municipal construction units to construct smoothly, the pipelines above and under ground should give their position out. New pipeline passages/corridors must be relocated according to urban planning, but some pipeline passages within the property lines are located in the position of old buildings and cannot be resettled. So, in order to resettle the original pipeiines to the positions of new urban planning, the buildings that block the pipeline relocation should be resettled in advance and give their position out. It is not difficult to be found that the houses which block the pipeline relocation should completely be resettled in order to ensure the smooth relocation of pipeline. 9.2 The Impact and Rehabilitation to the Enterprises and Residents 9.2.1 The original municipal infrastructures and public facilities should be reforned and expanded in large scale by municipal construction. The resettlement area of the IRR project includescentral district and the main streets of newly-developing districts in Guangzhou city, it involves six administrative districts of Dongshan, Yuexiu, Liwan, Haizhu, Tianihe and BaivuLn. The roads are the main planning passages/corridors of every pipeline departments with property right. In accordance with the need of engineering constructioni,a large amounltof pipeliles should be resettled in a manner similar to surgical operation. The dairy life and work of the residents will uniavoidably be directly or indirectly affected by the pipeline relocation. a. Direct impact The temporary interruption of urban public facilities such as water, power, gas. communication, trollev, cable TV, etc., bring about inconvenience to the dairy life and entertainmenit of some residents. Some stores, factories, schools and enterprises or administrative units must face witihthe impacts of stopping business and production because of the relocation. Moreover, a few of ullits should be resettled in new resettlement sites, all of these will bring about direct impact to the residents involving resettlement. but the direct impact to the residents by pipeline relocation is temporary. The inconvenience to the dairy life and work of residents can be reduced to a lowest degree by carrving out effective rehabilitation method. b. Indirect impact Municipal construction is necessary for the long-term development of a city. The indirect impact of pipeline relocation to the residents is to make the families and units along the pipeline passages to GCCTPPublic UtilityRelocation Policy 20 January 1998 benefit from the reforming and expanding of all kinds of municipal public utilities. The rehabilitation of old equipment will bring about more effective assurance and convenience to the dairy life and work of the residents. 9.2.2 Rehabilitation Method The rehabilitation of the resettled pipelines must be planned and arranged properly in advance. In actual operation, it should suit measures to local conditions. Safety, high efficiency, timeliness and accuracy should be reached to reduce the adversely impact to the people nearby. Several regulations in the rehabilitation of the resettled pipelines are listed as follows: a) The operation of new pipelines must meet the loading demands. The design grade of new pipelines should be higher than the standard of the old ones. b) The new pipelines muse meet the demands of current technical standard in our country. The backward and out-of-dated equipment should be renewed according to technical standard. c) The new pipelines should be installed completely and put through to the users before the old ones are removed. d) Cutting and connecting should be done in due order when several pipelines are cut and connected at the meantime. Pipeline can be cut and connected only if the cuttilng and connecting of its former one has been finished. e) The pipeline should be repaired and renewed to proper operation if it is damaged accidentally in construction and then the responsibility should be investigated and affixed. f) If the running manner of a new pipeline is changed because of engineerinig requirement, (for example, from overhead to underground), its design grade must be higlier thanlthe standard of the old one. 9.3 Temporary Relocation of Pipeline a) There is contradiction between the relocation of pipeline passages/corridors and the resettled houses, therefore, to ensure that the municipal construction can be completed on time, the original pipeline must give up its way, the original pipeline has no choice but to be resettled temporarily. b) Whenia building has to be demolished, and there is a running pipeiine in the building, in order to ensure the safety of the resettlement of the pipeline and the house, thle pipeline must be resettled temporarily. c) In the course of relocation, all of the pipelines which should be resettled permnanientlymust be constructed according to the construction regulations and standards. The specification of a newly-erected pipeline must not be lower than the standard of its original one. The temporary transition time of erecting of the pipeline for low-voltage cable should not exceed one month. After the building is resettled, a new permanent pipeline should be laid according to the new planning and direction. Then, the original temporary pipeline can be removed. All of these treatments ensure the resettlement of the original pipeline and the erecting of a new-led one does not be broken off because of the block of the buildings. GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 21 January 1998 10. Measures of Proper Pipeline Relocation 10.1 Necessity The government carries out every municipal construct project as planned because the construction fund for every project is limited. In the course of pipeline relocation, in order to reduce the expenses of municipal construction for the country, proper relocation should be carried out so long as it is not contrary to the national planning and the law related to pipeline. All kinds of flexible measures should be taken for the pipelines that affects the project construction little but relocation expenses is large. 10.2 ConcreteMeasures I . The high voltage cables with the condition of overhead passages/corridors should be resettled overhead instead of underground in the suburbs. 2. High voltage cables that pass through interchanges or viaducts should not be resettled in underground if the safe distance can be ensured. 3. As for underground pipelines with large leaping distance and heavy load that pass through rivers, piers should be erected. The pipelines with small leaping distance and light load can pass through along the side of the bridge or in overhead. 4. As for underground pipelines that pass through railways or roads should pass in a manler of top pipeline or embedded pipeline instead of channel box. 5. If underground pipelines block the construction of drainage and rain systems and there is enough position for the passages/corridors, the design schemes of drainage and rain pipes can be altered to make the underground pipelines away. 6. If underground pipelines block the construction of bridge stake or drainage chalnnielbox and the altered design scheme can keep the pipelines away, n1orelocation should be done. If the design scheme cannot solve this problem, the underground pipelines can be sealed inside the stake or chaninel box with the agreement of operation sections of units with property right. 7. If the communication pipelines are removed out of expressway because of road expanding. they should be protected by reinforcement and the whole lies need not be resettled to the new sidewalks. 8. If some parts of the telephone open saps or trough boxes are removed out of the vehicle lines, they can be protected by reinforcement according to the design requirement of vehicle pressure or can be changed into laying pipes, and need not be resettled to the new sidewalks. 9. The underground pipelines should only be partly protected by reinforcement instead of the whiole lie relocation if parts of them cannot meet the requirement of covering design because the level- lheight of pavement is changed. GCCTPPublic UtilityRelocation Policy 22 January 1998 10. As for the relocation of the overhead stretching across pipelines of power supply, the stretching across pipelines cannot be canceled instead of underground treatment if the load of the running power net can be adjusted technically. 11. Compensation for Pipeline Relocation the principle of resettlement compensation of the GREEO in the course of pipeline relocation can be summarized to: Proper relocation and original compensation. There are many concrete and detailed requirements in actual operation. 11.1 CompensationBasis a) Pipelines covered in this document are public facilities operated by public corporations. Compensation for pipelines will be made only to these corporations authorized to operate them. The project will not consider any other claim. b) The project will ensure that all the affected services will be supplied to all the households and units which drew serviced from affected pipelines. If the original service was obtained through unregistered pipelines, then, the households and units which drew such unauthorized service will be required to apply to relevant public corporations for new service. These households or units will be responsible to pay fees for hook-up and service. 11.1.1 Authorized Pipeline a) Registered Pipeline b) All the pipelines belonging to public corporations are registered pipeline. 11.1.2 Unauthorized Pipeline a) Unregistered Pipeline b) These are pipelines which belong to entities other than public utility corporations. Service obtained thorough these pipelines are unauthorized and the owners of the unregistered pipelines do not pay the legally required fees for the services. 11.1.3 Temporary Pipeline The pipelines that should be relocated because of project construction and have not permanenit passages/corridors can be relocated temporarily. If they have permanenltpassages/corridors, GREEO will removed them to the everlasting planned passages/corridors. 1 1.1.4 Historically Handed Down Pipeline It is a long time when the pipelines were constructed(eg. Military communication cables). At that time, there was not urban planning regulations in our country. The GREEO should provide the departments with property right with compensation for the expenses of the original project when these pipelines are resettled. GCCTPPublic Utility Relocation Policy 23 January 1998 11.2 Manners of Compensation There are two manners of compensation for GREEO in the pipeline resettlement: budget/balance checking & examining and contract compensation of monopolizing everything. 11.2.1 Budget/Balance Checking & Examining Budget/balance checking & examining is the main compensation manner for GREEO in the course of pipeline relocation. The checking & examining department checks and examines the construction expenses and budgets according to the national standard of construction quota. The resettlement department provides compensation for the pipeline units with property right according to the checked and examined construction cost. 11.2.2 Contract Compensation of Monopolizing Everything. The manner of contract compensation of monopolizing everything is used for the pipelines with special requirement or the pipelines that had not been applied for approval because of historical reason. Resettlement staffs and auditors check the resettlement amount on-the spot, and negotiate with pipeline departments with property. After making clear the costs shared by two units, contract will be signed according to common agreement. 11.3 Check & Examination of Compensation To the two manners of compensation, the compensation is provided after the clheckinig& examininlg departments check and examine the construction amount, material price and fee-rate anid affirm the pro ject costs. 11.4 Case Statistics of Compensation 1 1.4.1 Requirement for the sorts of materials I . Approval files of property line drawings and their light copies, instructionisof leaders. official letters, summaries of meeting talks, budgetary checking and examination and compelnsation contract sliould be kept properly. The opinions of audit departments, siglnatureoil thle spot (includes sign of newly-added property line, sign of changed property Iine or and sigl for changinigconstruction scheme) should also be kept completely. 2. According to the settlement/balance time, the materials should be put into order and archived in accordance with different specialty. I1.4.2 Storage of Budget and Settlement/Balance. I. The borrowing of the budget and settlement/balance files should be registered. 2. The materials should be classified and put into order during the storage. GCCTPPublic Utility RelocationPolicy 24 January 1998 3. After the project has been finished, project summary should be written and the table of the total costs for compensation statistics should be prepared based on the requirement, and then kept in 'archives after checked and accepted by the administrative departments. gcctp\utility\policy.doc N / ( ) Guangzhou City Center Transport Project Inner Ring Road Project Pipeline Transfer Resettlement Implementation Plan Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office February 1998 (-N TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Preparation Situation of Implementing Pipeline Transfer 1.1 Hardware Preparation Situation of Implementing Pipeline Transfer 1.1.1 The brief introduction to the Pipeline Section of GREEO 1.1.2 Function of the Pipeline Section of the GREEO 1.1.3 The preparation situation of the pre-phase materials of the Inner Ring Road Project 1.2 Software Preparation Situation of Implementing Pipeline Transfer 1.2.1 Attention by the leaders of each levels 1.2.2 Abundance experience is gained by many years transfer work 1.2.3 Good corporation with the pipeline units and construction units is the key of the pipeline transfer implementing 1.3 The working conclusion of the project 2. Implementing Plan of the Inner Ring Road Project 4 2.1 The implementing plans of pipeline transfer of each phase 2.1.1 The first phase (October, 1997-1998) 2.1.2 The second phase (1998-- ) 2.1.3 The third phase (1999-- ) 2.1.4 The fourth phase construction (1999-- ) 2.2 Balance of Compensation Cost for Pipeline Transfer 2.3 Coordination of Pipeline Transfer Working 2.3 .1 The internal coordination 2.3.2 The external coordination 2.4 Timetable of Implementing the Pipeline Transfer 2.4.1 The timetable of implementing the pipeline transfer in Inner Ring Road Project 2.4.2 The correlated facets which influence the time limit of pipeline transfer 3. Guarantee of Fulfilling the Implementing Plan ]1 3.1 Guarantee of the Pipeline Transfer Materials 3.2 Guarantee of the Pipeline Passage 3.3 Guarantee of the Fund Attendance 3.4 Guarantee of Construction Safety 3.5 Conclusion 4. Statistics of the Compensation Cost of Pipeline Transfer 12 4.1 Statistics of the compensation funds of pipeline transfer 4.1.1 The compensation cost table of pipeline transfer by sorts 4.1 .2 Compensation cost table of each administrative district pipeline transfer 4.1.3 Compensation cost table of pipeline transfer by phase 4.1.4 Compensation cost table of pipeline transfer by sorts IRR Pipeline Transfer Resettlement Plan ii October 5, 1997 4.1.5 Gross statistic table of compensation cost 4.2 Original budget of the ownership units 4.3 Conclusion 5. Preservation of the Materials of Pipeline Transfer 16 5.1 Methods of Preserving the Materials 5.1.1 The classification of the materials 5.1.2 Methods of preserving the materials 5.2 Establishment of Material Archives and Search of the Materials 5.2.1 Establishment of material archives 5.2.2 Search of the materials 5.3 Borrowing of the pipeline materials 5.4 Handing over the pipeline materials 5.5 Conclusion 6. Budget of the Pipelines 17 Appendix Original Budgets of the pipelines coming from the ownership units Abbreviations and Acronyms C,CCTPO Project Office of Guang7hou City Centre Transport Project GMG Guangzhou Municipal Government GREEO Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office GURCC Guangzhou Urban and Rural Construction Commission IMO Independent Monitoring Organization IRR Inner Ring Road PAPs Project Affected Persons Phase I. II. III, IV The First. Second, Third, Fourth Phase of Project RAP Resettlement Action Plan Rd. Road SLS Surveys of Living Standards Str. Street I]nits Im metre mI square metre km kilometre kv kilovolt RMB Renminbi (Yuan) (approx 8.7 RMBIUSD) mu area; 15mu=lha / A GCCTP PIPELINE TRANSFER RESETTLEMENT PLAN 1. Preparation Situation of Implementing Pipeline Transfer 1.1 Hardware Preparation Situation of Implementing Pipeline Transfer 1.1.1 The brief introduction to the Pipeline Section of GREEO The pipeline transfer project in Inner Ring Road Project is responsible by Guangzhou Road Expansion and Engineering Office(GREEO) single-handed, the following is the brief introduction. a) Staff The Pipeline Section of the GREEO is the administrative department of the units participated in the pipeline transfer in the Inner Ring Road Project. The Pipeline Section includes two transfer teams, 12 members, in which 6 members are professional technical personnel, 6 members are engineering administers. The number of the persons with over 15 years transferring experience are 9 and the ratio to the total members is 75%. Among the staff, the oldest person is 41 years old and the youngest is 27 years old, the average is 37.3 years old. The department is a progressive team with professional knowledge and abundant experience. b) Equipment The Equipment Statistic Table of the Pipeline Section Motorcycle I ] 486 computer& windows95 3 Eight seats car I AOdrawing large-scale scanner I Surveyapparatus I ColorLaser Printer Telephone 3 Paint Plotter I Beeper 12 Large scale telescope Undergroundprobe 3 Inter phone 2 equipment 1.1.2 Function of the Pipeline Section of the GREEO a) To be responsible for the pipeline transfer compensation, include all the pipelinles. suclh as power supply. water supply, drainage pipeline, gas line, communication line, cable TV and trollev line within the property line in the municipal construction. (Includinig the construction management and coordination in-situ). b) To be responsible for the pipeline transfer in the construction of the resettlement housing, rebuilt housing, temporarily built houses, for the transfer of the temporary and permanent power. supply, water supply, collecting & checking/examining the drawings and monitoring construction quality. GCCTPPipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 2 January 1998 c) To be responsible for check & approval, and applying for the approval of the agreement of pipeline transfer compensation, intercourse official letters and the budget & settlement/balance of the transfer project. d) To be responsible for checking & approving each part of the pipeline transfer compensation funds and beforehand funds of transfer engineering. e) Baseline survey of all the transfer pipelines in the administrative area, preparing the compensation and resettlement plan and organizing to implement it. f) To be responsible for the preliminary checking/examining of the pipeline transfer compensation budget in the parts of the road expansion. g) To be responsible for draft, checking and approval, and dealing with the daily files, reports, agreements and official letters. h) To be responsible for keeping secret, storage, statistic, plan of the materials about the pipeline transfer project. i) To supervise and investigate the authenticity of the pipeline transfer compensationi . j) To be responsible for the task of informing and installing power and water supply in the turnover house. .1.3 The preparation situation of the pre-phase materials of the Inner Ring Road Project According to the pre-phase survey of the Inner Ring Road Project. after collecting several hundreds of pipeline alignment drawings of the Inner Ring Road Project and the enginieerilngbudgets feedback from the owner units, we have established a good foundation for the smootli developmenlt of the pipeline transfer in the later construction. 1.2 Software Preparation Situation of Implementing Pipeline Transfer 1.2.1 Attention by the leaders of each levels The Inner Ring Road Project is an important project in Guangzhou municipal constructioni at present. Tlle project is paid much care and attention by the municipal leaders and other leaders of all levels. Moreover, thev give supports from different ways, so that the pipeline transfer of the Innler Ring Road Project should be carried on smoothly. 1.2.2 Abundance experience is gained by many years transfer work The majority members of the Pipeline Section of GREEO have over 15 years of doing pipeline transfer work, and have participatedin many importantprojects in Guangzhou munlicipal constructioni, such as Airport Road Interchange ,the Expressway Around City, Guangqinig Rd., Dongfeng Rd., Huangsha Tunnel, Xiwa Rd., Donghancong Interchange, ZhonigslhaniAv., Renmin Rd. Viaduct and Jiefang Road etc. Abundance experience has been gained from the pipeline transfer work before. GCCTPPipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 3 January 1998 1.2.3 Good corporation with the pipeline units and construction units is the key of the pipeline transfer implementing Construction and pipeline transfer is a contradictory side in the municipal engineering, the two sides restrict each other, and restrain the progress of the project. The staff in the Pipeline Section have formed a good corporation working way by the contact with the pipeline units and construction units for many years. This good relation will balance the contradiction from the two sides, and make them working smoothly. 1.3 The working conclusion of the project The Pipeline Section of GREEO has made perfect hardware and software preparation for the Inner Ring Road Project. The capability of the Pipeline Section in the pipeline transfer has been demonstrated more times in the past large-scale municipal constructions. With thiecare and attention of each level leaders, the task of pipeline transfer of the Inner Ring Road Project will be implemented timely, reasonably and high-qualifiedly. GCCTP Pipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 4 January 1998 2. Implementing Plan of the Inner Ring Road Project 2.1 The implementing plans of pipeline transfer of each phase According to the city government's requirement, the Inner Ring Road Project will be implemented in three years by four phases from October, 1997 to the end of the 2000. 2.1.1 The first phase (October, 1997-1998) The main part of the first phase of the IRR is Dongshankou Interchange, the region covers from Zhongshan No. I Road to Haiying Bridge, Jiangwan Bridge. The affected pipeline ownership units include the East District Power Supply bureaus, Dongshan Telecommunication Bureau, Tap Water Corporation, Guangzhou Gas Company, Trolley Company, Road Lamp Bureau. Troop 54410, Municipal Maintenance Section, Long-distance Telecommunication Bureau. Guangzliou Railroad General Company, Guangzhou Marine Transportation Bureau, Guangdoni Cable TV Station, Guangzhou Cable Administration Place. T he plan of the pipeline transfer fuLndsis slhowed as Table 1. Table 1: Statistic table of the first phase pipeline transfer in IRR (Yuan) No. Unit Name Artery Branch User Compensation Ratio to Cost Total I East District Power 714285.72 428571.43 285714.29 1428571.43l 4.1 S/O Supply bureaus 2 Tap Water Corporation 6667975.25 4000785.15 2667190.10 333551)5( 38.73% 3 |Gas Company 614817.57 368890.54 245927.03 1229635. 1 33,.57%o 4 Cable Administration 1285714.29 771428.57 514285.71 2571428.57 7.47% Station 5 Road Lamp Bureau 224258.51 134555.10 89703.40 4485 17.01 .(3% 6 Dongshan 5253658.30 3152194.98 2101463.32 105 (1S7316.60 30.51l% ° Telecommunication Bureau 7 Municipal 0 0 0 1) 0 Administrative & Garden Bureau 8 Long-distance 1028571.43 617142.86 411428.57 5057142.86 5.97% Telecommunication Bureau 9 Marine Transportation 476190.48 285714.29 190476.19 952380.95 2.77% Bureau 10 Guanazhou Railroad 1904761.90 1904761.90 5.53% General Company Total 18170233.43 9759282.92 6506188.61 34435704.95 GCCTPPipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 5 January 1998 2.1.2 The second phase (1998-- ) The construction region of the second phase covers from South China Film Center to thle Ruyinfang interchange. he affected pipeline ownership units include the West District Power Supply bureau, the Middle District Power Supply bureau, Liwan Telecommunication Bureau, Baiyun Telecommunication Bureau, Tap Water Corporation, Guangzhou Gas Company, Trolley Company, Road Lamp Bureau, Troop 87400, Municipal Maintenance Section, Long-distance Telecommunication Bureau, Guangzhou Railroad General Company, Guangzhou Sea Transportation Bureau, Guangdong Cable TV Station, Guangzhou Cable Administration Place. The plan of the pipeline transfer funds is listed as Table 2. Table 2: Statistic table of the second phase pipeline transfer in IRR (Yuan) No. UnitName Artery Branch User Compensation Ratio to Cost Total 1 West District Power 19911390.53 11946834.32 7964556.21 39822781.05 23.02% Supply bureaus 2 Tap WaterCorporation 21910234.29 13146140.57 8764093.71 43820468.57 25.33% 3 Gas Company 6432915.91 3859749.55 2573166.36 12865831.82 7.44% 4 Troop 87400 657370.98 394422.59 262948.39 1314741.95 0.76% 5 Road Lamp Bureau 119047.62 71428.57 47619.05 238095.24 0.14% 6 Liwan 22984755.10 13790853.05 9193902.04 45969510.20 26.57% Telecommunication Bureau 7 Municipal 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Administrative& Garden Bureau 8 Long-distance 1983333.34 1190000.00 793333.33 3966666.67 2.29% Telecommunication Bureau 9 Marine Transport-ation 357142.86 214285.71 142857.14 714285.71 0.41% Bureau 10 Cable Administration 10714285.72 6428571.43 4285714.29 21428571.43 12.39% Station Guangzhou Railroad 2857142.86 2857142.86 1.65% General Company ITntal 87927619.18 51042285.79 34028190.53 172998095.5 GCCTP Pipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 6 January 1998 2.1.3 Thethirdphase(1999-- ) The construction region of the third phase covers from Huanshixi Road South China Film Center to the Zhongshan No.1 Road(in which the section of Hengfu Rd. and Meidongbei Rd. will begin at the fourth phase), and the full length is ^ km. The affected pipeline ownership units include the Middle district Power Supply Bureau, the West District Power Supply Bureau, Baiyun Telecommunication Bureau, Yuexiu Telecommunication Bureau, Tap Water Corporation, Guangzhou Gas Company, Troop 54410, Municipal Maintenance Section, Long-distance Telecommunication Bureau, Guangzhou Railroad General Company, Guangdong Cable TV Station, Guangzhou Cable Administration Place. The plan of the pipeline transfer funds as Table 3. Table 3: Statistic table of the third phase pipeline transfer in IRR (Yuan) No. Unit Name Artery Branch User Compensation Ratio to .______Cost Total I East District Power 1500000.0 900000.0 600000.0 3000000.0 2.26% Supply bureau 2 Tap Water Corporation 23301118.18 13980670.91 9320447.27 46602236.36 35.09% Gas Company 226417.66 135850.59 90567.06 452835.31 0.34% 4 Dongshan 6017826.79 3610696.07 2407130.72 12035653.58 9.06% Telecommunic-ation Bureau 5 Road Lamp Bureau 113636.37 68181.82 45454.55 227272.73 0.17% 6 Troop 54410 1626305.68 975783.41 650522.27 3252611.36 2.45% 7 Municipal Administr- 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 ative & Garden Bureau 8 Long-distance 8195454.55 4917272.73 3278181.82 16390909.09 12.34% Telecommunication Bureau 9 Yuexiu Telecommunic- 6017826.79 3610696.07 2407130.72 12035653.58 9.06% ation Bureau 10 Cable Administration 1397727.28 838636.37 559090.91 2795454.55 2.10% Station I I Baiyun Telecommunic- 8023769.05 4814261.43 3209507.62 16047538.10 12.08% ation Bureau 12 center district power 9984367.42 5990620.45 3993746.97 19968734.84 15.04% supply bureau Total 66404449.75 39842669.85 26561 779.9 132808899.5 / GCCTPPipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 7 January 1998 2.1.4 The fourth phase construction (1999-- ) The construction region of the fourth phase includes the section from the north of Industry Av. to Jiangnan Av., the section of Meidongbei Rd. and the Hengfu Rd., and the full length is -^km. The affected pipeline ownership units include the South District Power Supply Bureau, Haizhu Telecommunication Bureau, Tap Water Corporation, Municipal Maintenance Section, Guangdong Cable TV Station, Guangzhou Cable Administration Place. The using plan of the pipeline transfer funds is listed as table 4. Table 4: Statistic table of the Fourth phase pipeline transfer in IRR (Yuan) No. Unit Name Artery Branch User Compensation Ratioto Cost Total South District Power 6090909.09 3654545.45 2436363.66 12181818.20 13.48% Supply bureau 2 Tap Water Corporation 19890409.09 11934245.45 7956163.64 39780818.18 44.03% 3 Road Lamp Bureau 136363.64 81818.18 54545.45 272727.27 0.30% 4 Municipal 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Administrative& Garden Bureau 5 Long-distance 858818.18 394090.91 282727.27 1319890.90 1.40% Telecommunication Bureau 6 Marine Transportation 340909.09 204545.45 136363.64 681818.18 0.75% Bureau 7 Cable Administration 2386363.64 1431818.18 954545.45 4772727.27 5.28% Station 8 Haizhu Telecommunic- 15671423.93 9402854.36 6268569.57 31342847.86 34.69% ation Bureau Total 45173196.65 27103917.99 18069278.68 90346393.32 4 l GCCTPPipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 8 January 1998 2.2 Balance of Compensation Cost for Pipeline Transfer The balance of compensation cost for pipeline transfer is also the balance of the funds. According to the city government's step by step implementing plan of the Inner Ring Road Project, statistics of the pipeline information and the gained experience from past municipal construction, the administrative department of GREEO makes the following plan table to balance the pipeline transfer funds of the project: Table of the pipeline transfer funds (Yuan) A B C D E F Unit -Yuan 1997 1998 1999 2000 TOTAL First Quarter 17301069.77 13279367.64 9033759.18 Second Quarter 51903209.30 39838102.91 27101277.53_ Third Quarter 51903209.30 39838102.91 27101277.53 Fourth Quarter 34447127.46 51903209.30 39838102.91 27101277.53 TOTAL 34447127.46 173010697.67 132793676.37 90337591.77 430589093.27 2.3 Coordination of Pipeline Transfer Working The Pipeline Section must do two aspects of the coordinating work during the pipeline transfer: One is the internal coordination in GREEO, and the other is the external coordination. 2.3.1 The internal coordination It includes following aspects: a) Coordinate the contradiction between the house demolition and pipeline transfer: b) Assist the audit departments to fasten the verify working of the budget and balance/settlement; c) Assist the plan departments to make up the fund plan of the compensation cost for pipeline transfer. 2.3 .2 The external coordination It ilcludes following aspects: a) Coordinate the contradiction of the intersect construction of pipeline transfer and the contradiction between the road construction and the pipeline transfer. b) Fund coordination: According to the devotion funds from nation to the municipal engineering, prepare the reasonable plan of pipeline transfer. c) Coordinate the modification of the design: Make technical evaluation to the modified design made by the Municipal Design Institute if the constructing municipal facilities hampered by GCCTP Pipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 9 January 1998 the pipeline, and if the transfer cost is too much but the modification can solve it, then suggest to modify the design. 2.4 Timetable of Implementing the Pipeline Transfer 2.4.1 The timetable of implementing the pipeline transfer in Inner Ring Road Project. According to the city government's step by step implementing plan of the Inner Ring Road, we prepare the timetable for each phase of pipeline transfer. The figure in the timetable drawn through the statistical amount of pipeline transfer and the past experience, is theoretic number, the actual time limit maybe unfit because of the influence of many facets. a) The first phase timetable of the pipeline transfer First phase (unit: working day) No. I 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Pipeline Power Water Telecommu Gas Cable Trolley Troop Drainage Name Supply Supply -nication TV Bus Time plan 75 60 60 45 20 30 40 120 of transfer b) The second phase timetable of the pipeline transfer Second phase (unit: working day) No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Pipeline Power Water Telecommu Gas Cable Trolley Troop Drainage Name Supply Supply -nication TV Bus Time plan 150 180 180 60 30 30 30 180 of transfer l c) The third phase timetable of the pipeline transfer Thlird phase (unit: working day) No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Pipeline Power Water Telecommu Gas Cable Trolley Troop Drainage Name Supply Supply -nication TV Bus Time plan 150 75 90 30 30 60 180 of transfer GCCTPPipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 10 January 1998 d) The fourth phase timetable of the pipeline transfer Fourth phase (unit: working day) No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Pipeline Power Water Telecommu Gas Cable Trolley Troop Drainage Name Supply Supply -nication TV Bus Time plan 90 60 90 20 20 120 of transfer 2.4.2 The correlated facets which influence the time limit of pipeline transfer The progress of the pipeline transfer project influence the time limit of the total municipal project. To ensure the progress of the project, all the administrative department must make concerted effort to eliminate the disadvantageous facets that influence the time limit of the pipeline transfer. The following disadvantageous facets influence the time limit of the pipeline transfer: a) The influence of funds: The smooth progress is determined by the attendance of funds. Shortage of funds will halt the pipeline transfer project. Delay of funds will bring about malign circle deferring the time limit. So the influence of funds is the most important facet that determine the time limit of pipeline transfer project. b) The influence of informing to construction from the city planning department: The tine length of the new pipeline alignments being approved will influence the timetable of the pipeline transfer project. To ensure the progress of the municipal project. the citN planninig department must promote the working efficiency to shorten the checking & approving time. c) The influence of pipeline accident: During the road construction, a lot of uLnpredictable interruptioni accidents caused by man-made or objective facets will take place because of no enouglh protection. The timetable of pipeline transfer project will be disturb by rush to repairing this accidents. d) The influence of house demolition : If the buildings on the pipeline passages can't be demolished on time, the timetable of pipeline transfer will be deferred too. e) The influence of unpredictable natural facets: Typhoon, storm and pasting bad weather days will defer the timetable. 2.5 Conclusion The data of the Action Plan are calculated based on the original information & materials feedback fiom the pipeline units, and are influenced by many unpredictable facets. Therefore, there are some deviations between the data and the real amount. But the directive function to guide the pipeline transfer can't be doubted. GCCTPPipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 11 January 1998 3. Guarantee of Fulfilling the Implementing Plan K _ 3.1 Guaranteeof the PipelineTransfer Materials The implementationof pipelinetransfer is based on the requirementof road plan and design so that the guaranteeof the pipeline materialsis one of the premises. The required materials includethe plane drawings of plannedproperty lines, the plane drawingsand the fore-and-aftsection drawings for road constructiondesign, the drainageconstruction drawings, the pile arrangementplane drawings etc. The design modificationshould be feed to the PipelineSection of GREEO immediately. 3.2 Guaranteeof the PipelinePassage The pipelinepassages are designedaccording to the city requirement. If the directionsof the pipeline passagesare changed,then the secondarytransfer of pipelineswill occur, whichiwill increasethe transfer costs and be liable to cause accidents. So, it is not permittedthat other objects occupiedthe planned pipeline passages. It is necessarypremise that pipelinepassages are unblockedto fulfill the pipelinetransfer on time. The houses,temporary shops and other buildingson the pipeline passagesmust be demolishedin limitedtime, the other pipelineson the pipelinepassages need to be transferredtoo. 3.3 Guaranteeof the FundAttendance The amount of funds needed in the pipelinetransfer is much. To ensure the smoothiprogress of the pipeline transfer, the fund attendance timely is a necessary premise. Today. Ne are perl roning the market economy, the shortage of fuids will lead to the stoppage of the project and the tfind delay will cause the malign circle of deferring work or holding in work. 3.4 Guarantee of Construction Safety The construction safety is the key of the pipeline transfer. During the municipal constrtiction. the construction space is limited, however road construction, houslingdemolition and pipeline transfer are going on at the same time. So, some taken measures to keep safe construction1is the key of controlling the quality of pipeline transfer. It is very necessary to protect the pipelines in situ durilln the construction. a) It is required that the road construction units should strengthenithe concept to protecting the underground pipeline. Probing sap should be dug before digging the undergrouLidpipelines. If the situation of the underground pipelines is unclear, the constructioni can not be done with blindness. b) The pipelines without clear materials can not be constructed with blindness to avoid the person harmningaccidents. c) Housing demolition can't endanger the pipeline, the pipeline attaching on the house must be transferred before the demolition to avoid the accidents caused by the disruption of the pipelines. GCCTPPipeline Transfer ImplementationPlan 12 January 1998 3.5 Conclusion The guarantee of the pipeline transfer materials, pipeline passages, the fund attendance and construction safety is the key to fulfill the project. The Pipeline Section should not only manage the internal facets such as pipeline passages and the safe construction, but also should get thiematerials of pipelines from other units and urge the fund attendance on time. 4. Statistics of the Compensation Cost of Pipeline Transfer 4.1 Statistics of the compensation funds of pipeline transfer 4.1.1 The compensation cost table of pipeline transfer by sorts a) Power supply Compensation balance table of the pipelines of power supply transfer (Yuan) No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Pipeline East district West Center South Road lamp Cable Total Unit power district district district bureau administra- supply power power power tive bureau bureau supply supply supply bureau bureau bureau Compensa 4465116.28 38896669.86 20433124.02 12465116.28 1182272.43 3 1186046.61 108628345.4 -tion Cost Ratio to 4.11% 35.81% 18.81% 11.48% 1(.(% 28.7% Total b) Telecommunication Compensation balance table of telecommunication pipeline transfer (Yuan) No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Pipeline Donshan Yuexiu Liwan Haizhu Baiyun Long Total Unit substation substation substation substation substation distance telecommu- nication bureau Compensa 22578512.92 12315552.5 44900451.91 32071751.22 16420736.66 24000000 152287005.2 -tion Cost Ratio to 14.83% 8.09% 29.48% 21.06% 10.78% 15.76% 100% T o ta l ______GCCTP Pipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 13 January 1998 c) Water supply Compensation balance table of the pipelines of water supply transfer (Yuan) No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Pipeline Unit Donshan Yuexiu Liwan Haizhu Baiyun Total substation substation substation substation substation Compensation 28843832.56 43265748.84 28843832.56 28873832.56 14421916.28 144219162.79 C o st I_ __I_ _ I _ _ _ I______I______I______Ratio to Total 20% 30% 20% 120% J10% I100%/j d) Gas Compensation Balance table of gas pipeline transfer (Yuan) No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Pipeline Unit Donshan Yuexiu Liwan Tianhe Haizhu Total substation substation substation district district Compensation 4589507.74 3824589.79 3824589.79 2294753.87 764917.96 15298359.14 CostIIIIII Ratio to Total 30.0% 25.00% 25.00% 15.00% 5.00% 100%1 e) Other units Compensation balance table of other pipeline transfer (Yuani) No. 1 2 34 4 Pipeline Unit Troop 87400 Troop 54410 Sea Railroad Total Transporta- General tionBureau Company Compensation 1284166.56 3328253.49 1959965.30 4651162.79 11223548.14 Cost Ratioto Total 11.44% 29.65% 17.47% 4 1.44% 1MO% f) Drainiage. The drainage and raindrop pipeline transfer cost is: Compensationi balance table of drainage pipeline transfer (Yuan) No. 1 2 . 4 5 6 PipelineUnit Donshan Yuexiu Liwan Tianhe Haizhu Total substation substation substation district district Compensation Cost Ratioto Total GCCTP Pipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 14 January 1998 4.1.2 Compensation cost table of each administrative district pipeline transfer (Yuan) No. 2 4 5 6 Pipeline Unit Donshan Tianhe Yuexiu Haizhu Liwan Total substation district district district district Compensation 86117618.65 43058909.33 86117818.65 86117818.65 129176727.98 430589093.27 Cost Ratio to Total 20.00% 10.00% 20.00% 20.00% 30.00% 100% 4.1.3 Compensation cost table of pipeline transfer by phase (Yuan) No. 1 2 3 4 5 Pipeline Unit First phase Second Third phase Fourth phase Total ______ph ase ______Compensa- 34435704.95 172998095.50 132808899.50 90346393.32 430589093.27 tion Cost Ratio to Total 8.00% 40.18% 30.84% 20.96% 100% 4.1.4 Compensation cost table of pipeline transfer by sorts Gross compensation balance table of each kind of pipeline transfer (Yuan) No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Pipeline Power Water Telecommu Drainage Gas Other Total Unit supply supply nication Compensa 108628345.4 144219162.8 1522687005 0.00 14231031.76 11223548.14 430589093.3 -tion Cost Ratio to 25.23% 33.49% 35.37%. 0.00O% 3.31% 2.61% 100% Tota GCCTP Pipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 15 January 1998 4.1.5 Goss statistic table of compensation cost Statistic General Table of Pipeline Transfer of IRR (Yuan) No. Unit Amount Compensation ______Co st I Guangzhou Telecommunication Bureau 128,287,005.21 2 Gas Company 14,231,031.76 3 Troop 54410 3,328,253.49 4 Troop 87400 1,284,166.56 5 East District Power Supply Bureau 4,465,116.28 6 Middle District Power Supply Bureau 20,433,124.02 7 Road Lamnp Bureau 1,182,272.43 8 Tap Water Company 144,219,162.79 9 Municipal Administrative Bureau & Garden Covered in civic engineering Bureau 10 Guangzhou Marine Transportation Bureau 1,959,965.30 1 1 Guangzhou Cable Administration Place 31,186,046.51 12 East District Power Supply Bureau 38,896,669.86 13 Long- Distance Telecommunication Bureau 24,000,000.00 14 South District Power Supply Bureau 12,465,116.28 15 Centre Control Station of Cable 16 Guangzhou Railroad General Company 4,651,162.79 17 Satellite Ground Station 18 Guangdong Province Cable TV 19 GuanzhouCity CableTV 20 Total 430,589,093.27 4.2 Original budget of the ownership units (see the appendix of the budget of the ownership units) 4.3 The conclusion The figures in the above table are calculated according to the original budgets coming from the ownerslhip units. here may be some deviations to the practical transfer compensation. ut with the past experience, the deviation is confined within 15%(discard the facet of price inflation), so the above figures is reliable. Note: The change of compensation cost caused by the change of government's policy. chanige of planninig requirement or the change of the compensation principles, is not involved in the statistic. GCCTP PipelineTransfer Implementation Plan 16 January 1998 5. Preservation of the Materials of Pipeline Transfer 5.1 Methods of Preserving the Materials 5.1.1 The classification of the materials The materials of pipeline transfer can be classified into four types: a) Original materials: including the property line drawings and the road design drawings (plane drawings, longitudinal section drawings, road surface elevation drawings, the pile arrangement drawings, the drainage design drawings, etc), the approved files of Guangzhou City Land and Housing Administrative Bureau and the Guangzhou City Planning Bureau. b) Materials of budget and balance/settlement: including the budget and balance documents that have been verified and approved, the compensation agreements of pipeline transfer. c) Material of engineering: the pipeline direction drawings reached by baseline survey, the pipeline arrangement drawings coming from ownership units, the transfer schemes and plans, the pipeline passage drawings approved by Guangzhou City Planning Bureau, the entrusted documents of the engineering, official intercourse letters and the leaders' instructions. d) Sign materials on the spot: the modification design drawings and official letters, the summary of spot meeting talks, the spot photograph materials, the sign of the scheme on spot. 5.1.2 Methods of preserving the materials The Pipeline Section has established a system that some persons are specially assigned to manage the materials, all the pipeline materials must be handed-over to the managers for a unified management. 5.2 Establishment of Material Archives and Search of the Materials 5.2.1 Establishment of material archives The pipeline material archives are established according to the tine sequences, the specialties and the sorts. The pipeline materials can be classified as power supply, water supply, gas, cable TV. Troop and other kinds. The catalog is prepared by sorts. 5.2.2 Search of the materials The materials can be searched through the catalog. Using the materials need the approval of the deputy director and the material managers are in charge for the search. 5.3 Borrowing of the pipeline materials The pipeline materials is a kind of secret information and can't be revealed to the outside. So borrowing the material is not permitted except for the reason of assisting work. The borrower in the oWnIunit can read the materials after permitted by the Pipeline Section leaders, and must return them immediately after using. The borrower in other units can't borrow the pipeline information materials in principle. If assuredly demanding, they must be approved by the department director and transact certain procedure to borrow them and return them on time after using. GCCTP Pipeline Transfer Implementation Plan 17 January 1998 5.4 Handing over the pipeline materials After finishing the Inner Ring Road Project, the work charger of the project will fill in the report tables of completing project which checked and approved by the director. The report tables and all kinds of fixed materials should be handed over to the archives of the GREEO to preserve. 5.5 Conclusion The materials are the basis of the pipeline transfer project. The Pipeline Section has established scientific methods to manage them, and the methods will promote the efficiency of pipeline transfer. The materials kept in a integrated condition will give convenience for the develop and utilization in future too. 6. Budget Budget of the pipelines is showed in appendices. gcctp\utility\plan.doc