623 South Wabash Avenue
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
COLUMBIA COLLEGE CHICAGO CAMPUS PRESERVATION PLAN Volume X 623 SOUTH WABASH AVENUE Submitted by McGuire Igleski & Associates, Inc. June 2005 COLUMBIA COLLEGE CHICAGO CAMPUS PRESERVATION PLAN VOLUME I: SUMMARY AND PRIORITIZED RECOMMENDATIONS VOLUME II: DESCRIPTION OF ARCHITECTURAL STYLES, HISTORIC BUILDING PRESERVATION GUIDELINES AND GLOSSARY VOLUME III: 72 EAST 11TH STREET VOLUME IV: 33 EAST CONGRESS PARKWAY VOLUME V: 600 SOUTH MICHIGAN AVENUE VOLUME VI: 624 SOUTH MICHIGAN AVENUE VOLUME VII: 1014 SOUTH MICHIGAN AVENUE VOLUME VIII: 1306 SOUTH MICHIGAN AVENUE VOLUME IX: 731 SOUTH PLYMOUTH COURT VOLUME X: 623 SOUTH WABASH AVENUE VOLUME XI: 1104 SOUTH WABASH AVENUE ii Columbia College Chicago: Campus Preservation Plan McGuire Igleski & Associates, Inc. 623 South Wabash Avenue 2005 TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME X: 623 SOUTH WABASH AVENUE Introduction........................................................................................... Research, Evaluation and Building Classification................ Building Zones........................................................................ Survey and Assessment of Elements and Features............. Building Information, History and Classification................................. 6 Documentation....................................................................... 0 Statement of Significance..................................................... 0 Architectural Significance...................................................... 1 Design 2hilosophy................................................................ 0 Description............................................................................ 2 Zone Numbers and Descriptions....................................................... Detailed Zone Descriptions 6 Zone : 2reservation.......... 7 Detailed Zone Descriptions 6 Zone 2: 2reservation.......... 8 Detailed Zone Descriptions 6 Zone 3: Rehabilitation........2 Detailed Zone Descriptions 6 Zone .: Free........................26 Bibliography........................................................................................21 Appendices A: Zoned Floor 2lans B: Survey Data C: Lighting Consultant Report D: Mechanical Electrical and 2lumbing Consultant Survey Notes iiiiiiiii Columbia College Chicago: Campus Preservation Plan McGuire Igleski & Associates, Inc. 62 South Wabash Avenue 2005 INTRODUCTION Register or City of Chicago Landmark listing This report contains the results of the research, survey and assessment CLASS 5 – A building 50 years old or older that has not been of 623 South Wabash Avenue. Evaluation of the building was completed evaluated for National Register or City of Chicago Landmark eligibility in three stages beginning with a broad historical and architectural assessment for landmark eligibility, continuing with the classification of CLASS 6 – 45-50 Pending. A building 45-50 years old that is not eligible for the National Register or City of Chicago the building into zones and concluding with the survey and assessment Landmark listing, but with the passing of time may become of individual architectural elements. eligible and needs re-evaluation CLASS 7 – A building which has been determined to be ineligible for Research, Evaluation and Building Classification the National Register or City of Chicago Landmark listing The building was researched and evaluated to determine its eligibility for CLASS 8 – Non-Historic landmark status based on the classification levels listed below. The classification identifies buildings of outstanding architectural quality or Research was performed to identify the following general information: associative value, and distinguishes them from buildings of lesser Building Name/Historic name importance. The building has been evaluated based on the National Address Type Register of Historic Places’ criteria, assessing the building’s significance Architectural Style/Description and the level of significance, (i.e. local, state, or national). In the text NR Age/Date of Construction Uniqueness refers to National Register and CL refers to Chicago Landmarks. The Site Context building classification levels are: Use Condition Modifications CLASS 1 – A building listed, or eligible for listing, as a National Historic Historical Associations/Significance Landmark. Size Existing documentation CLASS 2 – A building on, or eligible for, the National Register at the References in publications and reports National significance level CLASS 3 – A building on, or eligible for, the National Register at the Building Zones State or Local significance level or City of Chicago Landmark listing Areas of the building were surveyed, assessed and assigned zone designations. Zoning divides the building into spaces based on the CLASS 4 – A building that is potentially eligible for the National Phase I historic documentation and landmark evaluation and takes into 1 Columbia College Chicago: Campus Preservation Plan McGuire Igleski & Associates, Inc. 623 South Wabash Avenue 2005 consideration historic context, architectural significance, changes over means preserving a space as it was originally designed, including its time, style, materials, and features. scale, ornament, and materials. Spaces in this zone represent the highest degree of detail and finish. Zoning recognizes that the building has different spaces holding varying degrees of historic value. This hierarchy of spaces includes primary Level 2: Preservation Zone facades, secondary facades, highly ornamented public spaces, plainly Areas exhibiting distinguishing qualities, original materials or elements; detailed public spaces, and non-public / support spaces. Zones or representing examples of skilled craftsmanship define the Level 2 transcend delineation by floor; it is typical that the zones divide public Preservation Zone. Level 2 zones are less rich in historic materials and from private and private from utilitarian spaces. Stairways for example, detail compared to spaces in a Level 1 zone, nonetheless; the space is are zoned vertically. considered important to defining the unique character of the building. The zone level assigned to a space influences the degree of Every effort should be made to maintain and preserve the character and preservation treatment recommended for that space. Zoning is used to qualities of this zone. Preserving the character of a zone means apply restoration standards to significant areas and determine areas preserving the space as it was originally designed, including its scale, that are open to greater degrees of modification. Definitions of the six ornament, and materials. different zones follow. Level 3: Rehabilitation Zone Level 1: Preservation Zone Areas which are modest in nature, not highly ornamented but Areas exhibiting unique or distinctive qualities, original materials or nonetheless, may be original, with historic features which have been elements; or representing examples of skilled craftsmanship; the work maintained at an acceptable level define this zone. This zone includes of a known architect or builder; or associated with a person or event of secondary and tertiary spaces and areas generally out of public view. preeminent importance define the Level 1 Preservation Zone. Level 1 areas are distinguished from Level 2 areas by a higher concentration of Work in this zone should be undertaken as sensitively as possible; finish material and detail. however, contemporary methods, materials and designs may be The character and qualities of this zone should be maintained and selectively incorporated. The characteristics of this zone contribute to preserved as the highest priority. Preserving the character of a zone the historic appearance, date to the period of historic significance or 2 Columbia College Chicago: Campus Preservation Plan McGuire Igleski & Associates, Inc. 623 South Wabash Avenue 2005 represent later, sensitive repair or replacement work, which should be Level 6: Impact Overlay Zone preserved and maintained. New work in this zone should respect the An impact overlay zone has been assigned in conjunction with one of the existing historic fabric. zones 1-4 described above. Level 4: Free Zone Areas insensitively adapted resulting in a loss of significant historic Areas whose modification would not represent loss of character, code fabric or elements define this overlay zone. Examples include large violation or intrusion to an otherwise historically significant structure stylistically distinctive public spaces which have been inappropriately define this zone. This zone may include undistinguished repetitive or altered or subdivided into smaller spaces resulting in loss of character. recently constructed areas and additions. An impact overlay zone can also be applied to exterior façades. Treatments, while sympathetic to the historic qualities and character of Deficiencies in this zone should be corrected and loss of fabric or the building, may incorporate extensive changes or total replacement historic elements mitigated when possible. through the introduction of contemporary methods, materials and designs. Evaluation of Integrity Each space identified as a Level 1 or Level 2 Preservation Zone was also Level 5: Cautionary Zone Overlay evaluated for integrity. The integrity was ranked as High, Medium, or A cautionary zone overlay has been assigned in conjunction with one of Low based on the description of integrity as defined in the National the zones 1-4 described above. Register Bulletin No. 16: Guidelines for Completing the National Register Nomination Form,