DOCSLIB.ORG

Being Transgender in Belgium

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Being Transgender in Belgium Mapping the social and legal situation of transgender people Being transgender in Belgium Mapping the social and legal situation of transgender people Being transgender in Belgium Publisher: Institute for the equality of women and men Rue Ernest Blerot 1 B-1070 Brussels T +32 2 233 41 75 – F +32 2 233 40 32 [email protected] www.iewm.belgium.be Authors: Joz Motmans (University of Antwerp - Policy Research Centre for Equal Opportunities) in collaboration with Inès de Biolley & Sandrine Debunne (Cap-Sciences Humaines, nonprofit organisation - Université Catholique de Louvain) Supervisors: Prof. Josse van Steenberghe (University of Antwerp - Policy Research Centre for Equal Opportuni- ties) Ada Garcia (Cap-Sciences Humaines, nonprofit organisation - Université Catholique de Louvain) Policy Research Centre for Equal Opportunities (consortium University of Antwerp - Hasselt University) Lange Nieuwstraat 55, B-2000 Antwerp www.steunpuntgelijkekansen.be Cap-Sciences Humaines, nonprofit organisation - Université Catholique de Louvain Avenue de l’Espinette 18, B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve www.capscienceshumaines-ucl.be Final editing: Geraldine Reymenants Hildegard Van Hove Institute for the equality of women and men Translation: Intrasoft International S.A. Revision: Ryan Combs Graphic design: Gevaert Graphics Responsible editor: Michel Pasteel - Institute for the equality of women and men File number: D/2009/10.043/14 Deze publicatie is eveneens in het Nederlands beschikbaar. Cette publication est également disponible en français. Being transgender in Belgium Mapping the social and legal situation of transgender people Joz Motmans in collaboration with Inès de Biolley Sandrine Debunne 2010 Contents Foreword 12 1. General introduction 14 1.1. Social and scientific context 14 1.2. Research questions 15 1.3. Reader’s guide 16 Notes 17 2. The ‘discovery’ of trans* 18 2.1. The history of trans* in the sciences 18 2.2. The current medical paradigm 20 2.2.1. Transvestitism/transvestism 20 2.2.2. Transsexualism 22 2.2.3. Transgenderism 23 5 2.2.4. WPATH Standards of Care 23 2.3. Critical reflections 25 2.3.1. The paradox of naturalness 26 elgium B in 2.3.2. Sex, gender and sexual orientation 27 2.3.3. The future: towards greater tolerance? 28 2.4. Discussion of the terminology: guidelines 28 transgender Notes 31 eing B 3. Prevalence of trans* 36 3.1. Lack of data 36 3.2. Prevalence of transsexualism in the specialist literature 37 3.2.1. Figures from Belgian gender teams 37 3.2.2. Different calculations of prevalence 38 3.3. Data from the National Register 40 3.3.1. Numbers per year 40 3.3.2. Gender distribution 41 3.3.3. Age distribution 42 3.3.4. Regions 43 3.3.5. Civil status 44 3.4. Conclusion 45 Notes 46 4. Legal position of transgender people 48 4.1. Human rights 49 4.1.1. Jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights 49 4.1.2. Belgian law of 10 May 2007 on transsexuality 51 4.1.3. The Yogyakarta principles 55 4.2. Discrimination on the basis of gender 57 4.2.1. The legal provisions at the European level and the jurisprudence of the European Court of Justice 57 4.2.2. Belgian law of 10 May 2007 with a view to combat discrimination between women and men 59 Notes 62 5 The situation of transgender people in different spheres of life 64 5.1. Employment 64 5.1.1. Importance of work 64 5.1.2. Status 65 5.1.3. Sectors 65 5.1.4. Unemployment figures 65 5.1.5. Coming out and harassment 66 5.2. Health care 67 5.2.1. Trans-specific health care 67 5.2.2. General health care 68 5.3. Education 68 5.3.1. Gender conformity ‘stronger’ than heteronormativity 69 5.3.2. Lack of information causes problems 70 5.4. Image formation 71 5.5. Social networks 71 6 5.5.1. Community life 71 5.5.2. Family 72 5.6. Partner relationships, sexual orientation and parenthood 72 elgium 5.6.1. Partner relationships and sexual orientation 72 B in 5.6.2. Parenthood 74 5.7. Self-help organisations 78 transgender 5.8. Sport 79 eing B Notes 81 6 The online survey 86 6.1. Methodology 86 6.2. Response: numbers 89 6.3. Socio-demographic variables: description of the survey group 89 6.3.1. Sex 89 6.3.2. Age 90 6.3.3. Civil status 90 6.3.4. Children and desire to have children 92 6.3.5. Regional distribution and language 93 6.3.6. Nationality 95 6.3.7. Education and employment 96 6.4. Identity and lifestyle 99 6.4.1. Gender, gender identity and self-identification 99 6.4.2. Becoming aware of gender identity 102 6.4.3. Living according to gender identity: openness, obstacles and consequences 103 6.4.4. Seeking help in connection with gender identity 106 6.4.5. Sexual orientation 110 6.5. Experiences and reactions of acquaintances 112 6.5.1. General 112 6.5.2. Family and friends 114 6.5.3. School 117 6.5.4. Work 120 6.5.5. Health care 123 6.5.6. Police and the justice system 127 6.5.7. Official change of identity 129 6.5.8. Rights and anti-discrimination 136 6.6. Representativeness of the study 138 Notes 139 7 The case study: transgender people in the job market 140 7.1. Focus groups 140 7.2. Unions 144 7.3. Employment agencies 145 7.4. Good practices in business: IBM 146 7.5. Good practices: drawing up information brochures and codes of conduct 148 Notes 151 8 Summary and policy recommendations 152 7 8.1. The legal position 152 8.1.1. Right to gender reassignment 152 8.1.2. Protection of the right to marry and family life 153 8.1.3. Need for appropriate anti-discrimination legislation 154 elgium B in 8.2. Education and employment 154 8.2.1. Need for information and mediation agency 155 transgender 8.2.2. Need for gender changes on diplomas and certificates 155 eing 8.3. Health care 156 B 8.4. Education 157 8.4.1. Lack of proper information and training 157 8.4.2. Specific guidelines about transgender youth at school 158 8.5. Image formation 158 8.6. Support of organisations 158 Notes 159 9 Appendices 160 1. Trans Survey questionnaire 160 2. Questionnaire for employment agencies and unions 184 3. Topic list interview ‘Good practices’ 188 10 Bibliography 190 List of tables Table 1 Type classifications on Harry Benjamin’s Sexual Orientation Scale 19 Table 2 The prevalence of transsexualism and sex ratios in the three regions 38 Table 3 Inherent prevalence of SRS in Belgium 40 Table 4 Active prevalence of SRS in Belgium 40 Table 5 Active prevalence of SRS in relation to population figures for 2008 40 Table 6 Number of official change of sex registrations per year 41 Table 7 Number of official change of sex registrations per year by sex at birth 42 Table 8 Numbers by age at the time of the official change of sex registration 42 Table 9 Average age at the time of the official change of sex registration, by year 43 Table 10 Numbers by region at the time of the official change of sex registration 43 Table 11 Numbers by region and sex at birth at the time of the official change of sex registra- 44 9 tion, and sex ratio by region Table 12 Numbers by civil status at the time of the official change of sex registration 44 Table 13 Civil status at the time of the official change of sex registration before and after the 45 elgium adoption of the law on gay marriage of 13 February 2003 (Belgian State Gazette 28 B in February 2003) Table 14 Summary of the number of requests for information lodged with the Institute for the 60 transgender equality of women and men in relation to trans* eing Table 15 Number of respondents 89 B Table 16 Birth gender 90 Table 17 Birth gender and language 90 Table 18 Age breakdown 90 Table 19 Civil status 91 Table 20 Civil status by birth gender 91 Table 21 Family circumstances 92 Table 22 Number of respondents with children 92 Table 23 Child(ren) living with the respondent 92 Table 24 Living with partner’s/house-mate’s child(ren) 93 Table 25 Desire to have children by age 93 Table 26 Distribution by province 93 Table 27 Province/region and original survey language 94 Table 28 Province/region and town or country 95 Table 29 Nationality of the respondents 95 Table 30 Nationality of the parents 96 Table 31 Mother tongue 96 Table 32 Highest educational level attained 97 Table 33 Current employment status 97 Table 34 Type of contract 97 Table 35 Full-time or part-time 98 Table 36 Sector of employment 98 Table 37 Number of subordinants 98 Table 38 Number of colleagues 99 Table 39 Number of contacts with clients, pupils, students, patients, etc. 99 Table 40 Gender identity and birth gender 100 Table 41 Self-identification and birth gender 101 Table 42 Identity types 102 Table 43 Longevity of gender identity (all respondents) 102 Table 44 Longevity of gender identity (GI) and identity type 103 Table 45 Average age at which respondents became aware of gender identity (GI) 103 Table 46 Living according to gender identity (all respondents) 103 Table 47 Living in the desired gender identity: with whom and for how long 104 Table 48 Desire to live according to gender identity in the future 104 Table 49 Obstacles to living in the desired gender identity 104 10 Table 50 Respondent has had suicidal thoughts 105 Table 51 Number of suicide attempts 105 Table 52 Consequences of and reactions to the desired gender identity 105 elgium B Table 53 Consequences of and reactions to living or not living in gender identity 106 in Table 54 Contact with organisation or self-help group 106 Table 55 Sought help by identity type 107 transgender Table 56 Sought help: differences between transgenderists and transsexual people 107 eing B Table 57 Reasons why respondents did not seek help 108 Table 58 Reasons why respondents want help but did not seek help 108 Table 59 Transition
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Attraction and Sex Symbol of Males in the Eyes of Malaysian Male-To-Female Transsexuals
    International Journal of Social Science and Humanity, Vol. 3, No. 2, March 2013 Attraction and Sex Symbol of Males in the Eyes of Malaysian Male-to-Female Transsexuals Amran Hassan and Suriati Ghazali they are female in emotion but „trapped‟ in the male bodies. Abstract—Male-to-female transsexual issues, especially their sexual orientation, has become complicated due to their tendency to regard themselves as women, and are exclusively II. REVIEW OF LITERATURE attracted to men. This paper explores one group in male-to-female transsexuals, which is homosexual transsexuals, Research on male-to-female transsexuals‟ sexual attraction and their attraction towards homosexual and heterosexual men. towards men is still scarce. One among a few is by [7], who The objective of this paper is to identify aspects of sexual discovered that attraction to Male Physique was positively attraction in the body or nature of the men that attract correlated with Sexual Attraction to Males among homosexual transsexuals to develop romantic relationship with Autogynephilic transsexuals. It is possible that attraction to them. Qualitative methods were used in gathering the data. This includes in-depth interviews that have been carried out on six the male physique could develop along with the secondary homosexual transsexuals, which were selected using purposive emergence of attraction to males that [5] describes. and snowball sampling. The location of the fieldwork was Port Transsexual research in Malaysia generally focuses on Dickson, Negeri Sembilan, Malaysia. The result shows that factors leading to transsexualism and issues around it, rather facial appearance, specific body parts such as chest, calves and than sexuality and sexual attraction.
    [Show full text]
  • Support for Trans Asylum Seekers and Refugees
    Refugiadxs trans son bienvenidxs aquí! Les réfugiés trans sont les bienvenus! Trans Refugees are Welcome to Stay! Транс* беженцы, добро пожаловать! SUPPORT FOR TRANS ASYLUM SEEKERS AND REFUGEES For more information about how you can find these groups and how they can support you, go to tgeu.org/asylum Forms of Support Name of group Country – City Website Email Phone number legal psychological health housing community TransX Austria – Vienna www.transx.at [email protected] 0043 680 241 4748 x x Queer Base Austria – Vienna www.queerbase.at/ 0043 6646 5941 71 x x Genres Pluriels Belgium – Brussels www.genrespluriels.be/ [email protected] 0032 (0) 487 63 23 43 x x x x Merhaba Belgium – Brussels www.merhaba.be [email protected] 0032 (0)487 55 69 38 x x x x Together Finland – Helsinki www.heseta.fi/together [email protected] 0035 845 121 0026 x Acceptess-T France – Paris www.accepptess-t.fr [email protected], [email protected] 0033 142292367 x x x Ardhis France – Paris www.ardhis.org/WP3/ [email protected] 0033 619 6403 91 x [email protected]; Kuchus - Berlin Day Center for LGBTI refugees Germany – Berlin www.schwulenberatungberlin.de/startseite 0049 30 44 66 88 0 x x [email protected] Quarteera Germany – Berlin www.quarteera.de [email protected] - x x x Rainbow*Refugees Munich LGBTIQ+ supporters Germany – Munich www.rainbowrefugeesmunich.de [email protected] 0049 163 8433040 x x x Greek Transgender Support Association Greece – Athens www.transgender-association.gr/ [email protected]
    [Show full text]
  • 1. Debbie Abrahams, Labour Party, United Kingdom 2
    1. Debbie Abrahams, Labour Party, United Kingdom 2. Malik Ben Achour, PS, Belgium 3. Tina Acketoft, Liberal Party, Sweden 4. Senator Fatima Ahallouch, PS, Belgium 5. Lord Nazir Ahmed, Non-affiliated, United Kingdom 6. Senator Alberto Airola, M5S, Italy 7. Hussein al-Taee, Social Democratic Party, Finland 8. Éric Alauzet, La République en Marche, France 9. Patricia Blanquer Alcaraz, Socialist Party, Spain 10. Lord John Alderdice, Liberal Democrats, United Kingdom 11. Felipe Jesús Sicilia Alférez, Socialist Party, Spain 12. Senator Alessandro Alfieri, PD, Italy 13. François Alfonsi, Greens/EFA, European Parliament (France) 14. Amira Mohamed Ali, Chairperson of the Parliamentary Group, Die Linke, Germany 15. Rushanara Ali, Labour Party, United Kingdom 16. Tahir Ali, Labour Party, United Kingdom 17. Mahir Alkaya, Spokesperson for Foreign Trade and Development Cooperation, Socialist Party, the Netherlands 18. Senator Josefina Bueno Alonso, Socialist Party, Spain 19. Lord David Alton of Liverpool, Crossbench, United Kingdom 20. Patxi López Álvarez, Socialist Party, Spain 21. Nacho Sánchez Amor, S&D, European Parliament (Spain) 22. Luise Amtsberg, Green Party, Germany 23. Senator Bert Anciaux, sp.a, Belgium 24. Rt Hon Michael Ancram, the Marquess of Lothian, Former Chairman of the Conservative Party, Conservative Party, United Kingdom 25. Karin Andersen, Socialist Left Party, Norway 26. Kirsten Normann Andersen, Socialist People’s Party (SF), Denmark 27. Theresa Berg Andersen, Socialist People’s Party (SF), Denmark 28. Rasmus Andresen, Greens/EFA, European Parliament (Germany) 29. Lord David Anderson of Ipswich QC, Crossbench, United Kingdom 30. Barry Andrews, Renew Europe, European Parliament (Ireland) 31. Chris Andrews, Sinn Féin, Ireland 32. Eric Andrieu, S&D, European Parliament (France) 33.
    [Show full text]
  • Early History of the Concept of Autogynephilia
    Archives of Sexual Behavior, Vol. 34, No. 4, August 2005, pp. 439–446 (C 2005) DOI: 10.1007/s10508-005-4343-8 Early History of the Concept of Autogynephilia Ray Blanchard, Ph.D.1,2,3 Received August 4, 2004; revision received November 27, 2004; accepted November 27, 2004 Since the beginning of the last century, clinical observers have described the propensity of certain males to be erotically aroused by the thought or image of themselves as women. Because there was no specific term to denote this phenomenon, clinicians’ references to it were generally oblique or periphrastic. The closest available word was transvestism. The definition of transvestism accepted by the end of the twentieth century, however, did not just fail to capture the wide range of erotically arousing cross-gender behaviors and fantasies in which women’s garments per se play a small role or none at all; it actually directed attention away from them. The absence of an adequate terminology became acute in the writer’s research on the taxonomy of gender identity disorders in biological males. This had suggested that heterosexual, asexual, and bisexual transsexuals are more similar to each other—and to transvestites—than any of them is to the homosexual type, and that the common feature in transvestites and the three types of non-homosexual transsexuals is a history of erotic arousal in association with the thought or image of themselves as women. At the same time, the writer was becoming aware of male patients who are sexually aroused only by the idea of having a woman’s body and not at all by the idea of wearing women’s clothes.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Just and Accurate Representation of Transgender Persons in Research and the Clinic
    Portland State University PDXScholar Community Health Faculty Publications and Presentations School of Community Health 3-2014 On the Just and Accurate Representation of Transgender Persons in Research and the Clinic Alexis Dinno Portland State University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/commhealth_fac Part of the Community Health Commons Let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y Citation Details Dinno, Alexis, "On the Just and Accurate Representation of Transgender Persons in Research and the Clinic" (2014). Community Health Faculty Publications and Presentations. 40. https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/commhealth_fac/40 This Presentation is brought to you for free and open access. It has been accepted for inclusion in Community Health Faculty Publications and Presentations by an authorized administrator of PDXScholar. Please contact us if we can make this document more accessible: [email protected]. ON THE JUST & ACCURATE REPRESENTATION OF TRANSGENDER PERSONS IN RESEARCH & THE CLINIC March 27, 2014 ALEXIS DINNO, SCD, MPM, MEM built on a collaboration with Molly C. Franks Jenn Burleton Tyler C. Smith About me and why I am here… Transgender Transsexual Drag performer Epidemiologist Social justice activist My collaborators are likewise: sexual and gender minorities public health professionals motivated by social justice We desire just representation of transgender persons. Photograph of Alexis Dinno http://ww4.hdnux.com/photos/10/30/12/2196119/5/628x471.jpg by Lea Suzuki of the SF Chronicle, © 2002 Aside: basics of epidemiology Epidemiology is the study of health and disease in populations with the aim of improving health in those populations.
    [Show full text]
  • Ballrooms, Voguing, Houses
    ANALYSE FPS - 2020 Ballrooms, Voguing, Houses : un bout de culture queer Ballrooms, Voguing, Houses : un bout de culture queer – FPS 2020 Eléonore Stultjens Secrétariat général des FPS Chargée d’études [email protected] Photo de couverture : POSE de BBC/FX Éditrice responsable : Noémie Van Erps, Place St-Jean, 1-2, 1000 Bruxelles. Tel : 02/515.04.01 2 Ballrooms, Voguing, Houses : un bout de culture queer – FPS 2020 Introduction Aujourd’hui être transgenre implique encore une multitude d’obstacles, que ce soit en Belgique ou ailleurs dans le monde1. Ceux-ci peuvent prendre des formes diverses : discrimination à l’emploi, comportements haineux, violences ou encore stigmatisation dans le secteur de la santé2. En tant que mouvement féministe, progressiste et de gauche nous prônons l’égalité dans le respect des identités de genre de chacun·e. Afin d’apporter une pierre à cet édifice de l’inclusion, nous souhaitons visibiliser dans cette analyse la culture spécifique des ballrooms, espaces d’émancipation et de pouvoir. Par ce biais, nous voulons également mettre en lumière les combats des personnes transgenres. Au travers d’une description de la culture des ballrooms dans le contexte étasunien, nous aborderons la problématique de l’appropriation culturelle de la danse voguing. Nous verrons que ce phénomène d’appropriation à des fins commerciales efface les discriminations plurielles et intersectionnelles subies par les communautés latino-noire transgenres et, en même temps, nie complètement les privilèges des américain·e·s blanc·he·s cisgenres. Ensuite, nous ferons un arrêt historique sur les luttes LGBTQIA+ et le combat contre le VIH pour appréhender la façon dont les luttes transgenres sont perçues au sein d’un mouvement plus large, entre des dynamiques d’inclusion et d’exclusion.
    [Show full text]
  • Media Literacy Policy in Flanders •Fi Belgium. from Parliamentary
    L. Van Audenhove, I. Mariën & H. Vanwynsberghe / Journal of Media Literacy Education 2018 10(1), 59 - 81 Available online at www.jmle.org The National Association for Media Literacy Education’s Journal of Media Literacy Education 10 (1), 59 - 81 Media Literacy Policy in Flanders Belgium: From Parliamentary Discussions to Public Policy Leo Van Audenhove Mediawijs.be & iMEC-SMIT-Vrije Universiteit Brussel University of the Western Cape Ilse Mariën iMEC-SMIT-Vrije Universiteit Brussel Hadewijch Vanwynsberghe Mediawijs.be ABSTRACT Media literacy has gained in importance in policy discussions on media, digital media and the Internet in many countries. How do these policies develop and what can be learned? This case study explores the factors contributing to the successful formulation and implementation of media literacy in Flanders-Belgium. By examining the trajectory of policy debates and policy formulation, this research highlights the development of the concept of mediawijsheid (media literacy), the organization, the Knowledge Center for Media Literacy, and the role of the public service broadcaster in relation to media literacy policy. This case study shows that media literacy has been supported through three coalition governments in Flanders Belgium as different political parties rallied around media literacy as a common denominator for the challenges posed by the changing digital media environment. In particular, the empowerment view on media literacy seems to charm the left, middle, and right of the political spectrum, a finding that may inspire other actors in other countries as they attempt to move media literacy onto the national political agenda. Keywords: media literacy, media education, policy, Flanders, Belgium Over the last decade, media literacy has gained in importance in policy discussions on media, digital media and the Internet in many countries.
    [Show full text]
  • A Report on the 20 Years of the Flemish
    A REPORT ON THE 20 YEARS OF THE FLEMISH South Africa Cooperation SUSTAINABLE AND DYNAMIC, ENGAGING AND ENJOYABLE INSIGHTS AND CONCLUSIONS AFTER 20 YEARS OF BILATERAL COOPERATION ON YOUTH (WORK) POLICY BETWEEN SOUTH AFRICA AND THE FLEMISH GOVERNMENT Report of the Flemish Steering Group March 2020 Prof. Dr. Guy Redig, VUB Jan Vanhee, Department of Culture, Youth and Media CONTENTS JOINT FOREWORD 6 South African Minister Maite Nkoana-Mashabane Flemish Minister for Youth, Benjamin Dalle PREFACE: FRAMEWORK AND APPROACH 8 STATUS & OBJECTIVE OF THE PAPER 8 LESSONS LEARNED 9 FOR WHOM 9 STRUCTURE OF THIS PUBLICATION 9 THE EMERGENCE, THE ZEITGEIST 12 WHY SOUTH AFRICA FROM FLANDERS? 11 OLD AND RECENT MOMENTA 11 CHANGING TIMES 15 WHY YOUTH WORK 16 GENERAL CONCLUSIONS ON THIS COOPERATION 18 ON THE STRUCTURES OF THIS COOPERATION 18 ON THE SIDE OF THE FLEMISH GOVERNMENT 18 COOPERATION AND COMMUNICATION 24 ABOUT THE CONTEXT AND SCOPE OF THE COOPERATION 26 THE OVERALL SOCIO-ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL SITUATION 26 DIVERGENT TERMS 27 POLICY, GOVERNMENT ... GOVERNMENT POLICY 27 YOUTH, YOUTH WORK, YOUTH DEVELOPMENT 28 SOCIAL AND TERMINOLOGICAL CONFUSION? 31 SETTING PRIORITIES 31 PARADOXICAL OBJECTIVES 31 4 5 VOLUNTEERS AND VOLUNTEERING 34 NO CHOICE, BUT RAPPROCHEMENT 35 UNDERSTANDING AND MUTUAL INSPIRATION 35 EVOLUTION OF THE BUDGETS OF THE FLEMISH GOVERNMENT 39 FOR COOPERATION WITH SOUTH AFRICA ON YOUTH THEMATIC EMPHASES OVER THE YEARS 40 JOINT DETERMINATION 40 EVOLUTION OF THE THEMATIC EMPHASES 40 BRIEF DISCUSSION OF THE SUCCESSIVE THEMATIC EMPHASES 42 TRAINING
    [Show full text]
  • The Psychopathology of “Sex Reassignment” Surgery Assessing Its Medical, Psychological, and Ethical Appropriateness
    The Psychopathology of “Sex Reassignment” Surgery Assessing Its Medical, Psychological, and Ethical Appropriateness Richard Fitzgibbons, M.D., Philip M. Sutton, and Dale O’Leary Abstract. Is it ethical to perform a surgery whose purpose is to make a male look like a female or a female to appear male? Is it medically appropri- ate? Sexual reassignment surgery (SRS) violates basic medical and ethical principles and is therefore not ethically or medically appropriate. (1) SRS mutilates a healthy, non-diseased body. To perform surgery on a healthy body involves unnecessary risks; therefore, SRS violates the principle primum non nocere, “first, do no harm.” (2) Candidates for SRS may believe that they are trapped in the bodies of the wrong sex and therefore desire or, more accurately, demand SRS; however, this belief is generated by a disordered perception of self. Such a fixed, irrational belief is appropriately described as a delusion. SRS, therefore, is a “category mistake”—it offers a surgical solution for psychological problems such as a failure to accept the goodness Richard Fitzgibbons, M.D., a psychiatrist, is the director of Comprehensive Coun- seling Services outside Philadelphia. Philip Sutton, Ph.D., is a psychologist in private practice in South Bend, Indiana; he also works in elementary schools in the Diocese of Fort Wayne–South Bend and at Sacred Heart Major Seminary in Detroit. Dale O’Leary is the author of One Man One Woman: A Catholic’s Guide to Defending Marriage and The Gender Agenda: Redefining Equality. © 2009 The National Catholic Bioethics Center 97 THE NATIONAL CATHOLIC BIOETHICS QUARTERLY SPRING 2009 of one’s masculinity or femininity, lack of secure attachment relationships in childhood with same-sex peers or a parent, self-rejection, untreated gender identity disorder, addiction to masturbation and fantasy, poor body image, excessive anger, and severe psychopathology in a parent.
    [Show full text]
  • Transgenderism in Buddhism RELIG ST 4H03 Carolynn Chennery 12.09.15
    Destroying the Binary: Transgenderism in Buddhism RELIG ST 4H03 Carolynn Chennery 12.09.15 If doctrines and medical texts of Buddhism show a relationship between the third gender and a bodhisattvas being that achieves nirvana, why is there discrimination towards transgenderism and how can we explore it to understand it? Buddhism is a religion that seeks peace and an escape from rebirth of suffering for every being, regardless of their biological sex. Despite Buddhism’s origins in a patriarchal society like most religions, it offers both men and women the ability to achieve enlightenment, viewing them as equal like in the Lotus Sutra, one of Buddhism’s most important literature pieces. Not much is written or known about the third transgendered being though in regards to how they are accepted within Buddhism and their abilities to achieve nirvana. Being transgendered is a seemingly taboo identity and invites controversy in many societies, but key scriptures of Mahayana Buddhism such as the Lotus Sutra and Vimalakirti Sutra demonstrate that the third gender is far from problematic in achieving nirvana. Therefore, this research paper will strive to look at why the third gender is discriminated against in Buddhism despite its relationship to scriptures and achieving enlightenment. First it will focus on Buddhist sutras and then extend into medical texts that are relevant within Buddhist origins and finish by leading into how the transgender being is accepted socially in the sangha. By looking at both doctrines and medical texts one will be able to see the relevancy of the body both scripturally and medically and thus begin to understand it culturally within modern day religious law and societal acceptance.
    [Show full text]
  • Separation, Integration and Citizenship, Reply to Glenn
    Dit artikel uit Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy is gepubliceerd door Boom juridisch en is bestemd voor anonieme bezoeker R&R 2006 / 3 Separation, Integration and Citizenship, reply to Glenn Rik Pinxten* Introduction Patrick Glenn’s paper in this volume offers a reasoned attack on the notions of separation and integration in western tradition. In my view there is a way out, indeed, but the old dichotomy between extreme right separatism and fuzzy multiculturalist integration fogged the panorama to the extent that we did not even begin to look for another option. In this contribution as else- where1 I advocate for an inclusive form of citizenship. Separation and exclusivist society models I have a lot of sympathy for Glenn’s analysis of separation thinking (and act- ing),especially in assessing it as a deep-seated attitude in western tradition. As an anthropologist I claim that separation and dichotomisation is not only a feature of western thinking,2 but also of its way of organizing society and the world. The idea that we as westerners would be in the lead position of a unidi- rectional historical line of development, which encompasses humankind as a whole, and that hence we have the mission to ‘develop’ all others by bringing them our civilization,is a queer one for a comparative anthropologist. How can we sustain a claim like that? Is the mere amount of material goods of the past three centuries or the temporary supremacy by military means sufficient argument? What about aesthetics, or morality, or the level of happiness ema- nating from this culture? Anyhow, the format which allows for this claim is that of ‘us’ against ‘them’, or in Glenn’s terms, that of separation.
    [Show full text]
  • Open Letter of Concern to the 4Th I-DSD Symposium by Persons Concerned, Partners, Families, Friends and Allies
    Open Letter of Concern to the 4th I-DSD Symposium by Persons Concerned, Partners, Families, Friends and Allies I-DSD Dr Jillian Bryce Section of Child Health University of Glasgow Royal Hospital for Sick Children – Yorkhill Glasgow, G3 8SJ 4th International Symposium on Disorders of Sex Development Sir Charles Wilson Building Kelvin Way Glasgow, G12 8QQ SDSD Office 9th Floor QM Tower Yorkhill Hospital Dalnair Street Glasgow, G3 8SJ Royal Hospital for Sick Children – Yorkhill Dalnair Street Glasgow, G3 8SJ University of Glasgow University Avenue Glasgow, G12 8QQ Glasgow, June 7 2013 Dear Board, Scientific Committee and Members of I-DSD Dear Speakers, Chairpersons and Participants of the 4th International DSD Symposium Dear Scottish Disorder of Sex Development Managed Clinical Network (SDSD) Dear Royal Hospital for Sick Children Yorkhill Dear University of Glasgow As survivors of non-consensual childhood genital surgeries, as well as persons concerned grateful for having escaped such surgeries, as partners, family members and friends of persons concerned, and as allies, we are deeply saddened and concerned that an appar- ently overwhelming majority of the speakers, chairpersons and involved institutions at the 4th International DSD Symposium seems to refuse to listen to their former patients, and in- 1 stead continue to advocate, justify and/or perform medically not necessary, irreversible cosmetic genital surgeries on children with ‘atypical’ sex anatomies, no matter what the consequences for these children. A few representative examples: • Faisal Ahmed, John Achermann, Gerry Conway, Nils Krone, et. al.: Clin Endocrinol (Oxf). (2011) July; 75(1): 12–26.1 (Note how the ethics paper by Wiesemann, Ude- Koeller et.
    [Show full text]