DOCSLIB.ORG

Investigating Contemporary Performance As a Temporal Medium Manninen, Saini Liina Annikki

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Investigating Contemporary Performance As a Temporal Medium Manninen, Saini Liina Annikki View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Queen Mary Research Online Duration Materialised: Investigating Contemporary Performance as a Temporal Medium Manninen, Saini Liina Annikki The copyright of this thesis rests with the author and no quotation from it or information derived from it may be published without the prior written consent of the author For additional information about this publication click this link. http://qmro.qmul.ac.uk/jspui/handle/123456789/8572 Information about this research object was correct at the time of download; we occasionally make corrections to records, please therefore check the published record when citing. For more information contact [email protected] Duration Materialised: Investigating Contemporary Performance as a Temporal Medium Saini Liina Annikki Manninen Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Queen Mary, University of London September 2013 1 ABSTRACT Theatre and performance have historically been thought of in terms of the temporal while visual arts have been consigned to the field of spatial representation. Performance’s temporality, the fact that it happens in time, is highlighted in many discourses as performance’s greatest asset. This thesis investigates what we can find out about performance’s temporality by examining the material conditions of production and reception. By placing the focus off the event of performance and exploring issues around labour, work and leisure time; the art historical and economic relationship of performance and visual art; and the material remains of performance, the thesis seeks to reveal how performance’s temporality functions within a capitalist society. The research sets performance’s duration against different economies of time. It does this within a framework of cultural materialism and the materiality of performance while also situating the work art historically. It investigates the sites of negotiation between performance and the capitalist economy’s temporal logic and interrogates how cultural understandings of time affect experiences of attending to performance’s temporality. In focusing on performance work of both extremely long and short duration, as well as more traditionally staged, theatrical performance, the thesis maps out a genealogy of performance interested in making its temporality visible and often tangible. Placing different art forms alongside performance allows for a symbiotic relationship and thus facilitates new and productive ways of thinking about temporality and duration. Such an approach also makes it possible to identify any blind spots in the theorisations of the temporal in performance studies. The thesis thus proposes a re-evaluation of the terms used in discussion on temporality in performance with a focus on the social, economic and material relations within the production and reception of performance. 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The work presented here was done while living in two cities and my debts of gratitude are due to people in both. In London, I would like to thank my supervisors Dr Nicholas Ridout and Dr Dominic Johnson for their generous reading of the work and their astute feedback which helped me articulate my ideas. Thanks, too, to all my fellow PhD students and the academic staff at the drama department at Queen Mary University of London which is a genuinely inspiring place with the most supporting company I have had the pleasure of working in. Some of the ideas presented in this thesis have been tested in class with some of my undergraduate students and I thank both my students and my colleagues for facilitating such testing. In Bristol, artist collective Residence was the perfect place to do the early work and I benefited greatly from the support I got from my fellow members. I would especially like to thank our book club members for listening to and encouraging my ideas. Also in Bristol, Stephen Robins has been a constant presence and his detailed feedback for some of the work has been invaluable. Heart-felt thanks to Jo Bannon, a friend who always says the right thing. Closer to home (although still quite far away), I must thank my parents for keeping me afloat and never asking me to get a real job. Finally, my biggest thanks to James Dixon who was there at the beginning and who is still there at the end. His intellectual, practical and emotional support has been vital throughout, although his greatest contribution is the continuing realisation of his life’s ambition to make me laugh every day. 3 CONTENTS Introduction ................................................................................................................. 6 1 Begin to begin....................................................................................................... 6 2 Temporalities ........................................................................................................ 9 3 Early avant-garde and Gertrude Stein ................................................................ 14 4 Literature review and genealogy of terms .......................................................... 17 5 Space and time .................................................................................................... 23 6 Materiality, labour and precarity ........................................................................ 27 7 Chapter outlines .................................................................................................. 33 Chapter 1 ................................................................................................................... 38 From Phobia to Philia: Debating Time in the Art of the 1960s................................ 38 1 Beginning time ................................................................................................... 38 2 Temporality, theatricality and stage presence .................................................... 47 3 Present and future in the work of Andy Warhol and Barnett Newman .............. 58 4 End of endlessness: Beginning performance ...................................................... 69 5 Restaging the 1960s ............................................................................................ 79 Chapter 2 ................................................................................................................... 84 Stay a While: Performance’s Wasteful Duration ...................................................... 84 1 24 Hour Society .................................................................................................. 84 2 Durational performance ...................................................................................... 88 3 Work time ........................................................................................................... 91 4 Marina Abramović and the rhythm of Fordism ................................................ 103 5 Techching Hsieh and passing the time ............................................................. 119 Chapter 3 ................................................................................................................. 130 Instances: On Consuming Encounters .................................................................... 130 1 What to do with a minute? Taking part in Carpe Minuta Prima ..................... 130 2 The material conditions of performance ........................................................... 135 3 One to one performance ................................................................................... 147 4 What does it sell? Museums and galleries ........................................................ 155 5 Gift, giving, time .............................................................................................. 162 Chapter 4 ................................................................................................................. 167 Space and Pure Duration: Looking for Qualitative Time ....................................... 167 4 1 Henri Bergson and pure duration ..................................................................... 167 2 Goat Island and waiting, still ............................................................................ 175 3 Einstein on the Beach and climatic time .......................................................... 190 4 The wrong place ............................................................................................... 212 Chapter 5 ................................................................................................................. 216 The Art of Leftovers: Memory, Matter and Decay .................................................. 216 1 Performance vanishes ....................................................................................... 216 2 Alistair MacLennan: actuation as archive ........................................................ 222 3 Materiality of things ......................................................................................... 230 4 Memory and re-enactment ................................................................................ 242 5 Repetition and iconic images ............................................................................ 248 6 Decasia and decay ............................................................................................ 253 Conclusion............................................................................................................... 257 On and on ...........................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Performance Is a Genre in Which Art Is Presented "Live," Usually by the Artist but Sometimes with Collaborators Or Performers
    QUICK VIEW: Synopsis Performance is a genre in which art is presented "live," usually by the artist but sometimes with collaborators or performers. It has had a role in avant-garde art throughout the 20th century, playing an important part in anarchic movements such as Futurism and Dada. Indeed, whenever artists have become discontented with conventional forms of art, such as painting and traditional modes of sculpture, they have often turned to performance as a means to rejuvenate their work. The most significant flourishing of Performance art took place following the decline of modernism and Abstract Expressionism in the 1960s, and it found exponents across the world. Performance art of this period was particularly focused on the body, and is often referred to as Body Art. This reflects the period's so- called 'dematerialization of the art object,' and the flight from traditional media. It also reflects the political ferment of the time: the rise of feminism, which encouraged thought about the division between the personal and political; and anti-war activism, which supplied models for politicized art 'actions.' Although the concerns of performance artists have changed since the 1960s, the genre has remained a constant presence, and has largely been welcomed into the conventional museums and galleries from which it was once excluded. Key Points The foremost purpose of Performance art has almost always been to challenge the conventions of traditional forms of visual art such as painting and sculpture. When these modes no longer seem to answer artists' needs - when they seem too conservative, or to enmeshed in the traditional art world and too distant from ordinary people - artists have often turned to Performance in order to find new audiences and test new ideas.
    [Show full text]
  • Modernism 1 Modernism
    Modernism 1 Modernism Modernism, in its broadest definition, is modern thought, character, or practice. More specifically, the term describes the modernist movement, its set of cultural tendencies and array of associated cultural movements, originally arising from wide-scale and far-reaching changes to Western society in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Modernism was a revolt against the conservative values of realism.[2] [3] [4] Arguably the most paradigmatic motive of modernism is the rejection of tradition and its reprise, incorporation, rewriting, recapitulation, revision and parody in new forms.[5] [6] [7] Modernism rejected the lingering certainty of Enlightenment thinking and also rejected the existence of a compassionate, all-powerful Creator God.[8] [9] In general, the term modernism encompasses the activities and output of those who felt the "traditional" forms of art, architecture, literature, religious faith, social organization and daily life were becoming outdated in the new economic, social, and political conditions of an Hans Hofmann, "The Gate", 1959–1960, emerging fully industrialized world. The poet Ezra Pound's 1934 collection: Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum. injunction to "Make it new!" was paradigmatic of the movement's Hofmann was renowned not only as an artist but approach towards the obsolete. Another paradigmatic exhortation was also as a teacher of art, and a modernist theorist articulated by philosopher and composer Theodor Adorno, who, in the both in his native Germany and later in the U.S. During the 1930s in New York and California he 1940s, challenged conventional surface coherence and appearance of introduced modernism and modernist theories to [10] harmony typical of the rationality of Enlightenment thinking.
    [Show full text]
  • Kino, Carol. “Rebel Form Gains Favor. Fights Ensue.,” the New York Times, March 10, 2010
    Kino, Carol. “Rebel Form Gains Favor. Fights Ensue.,” The New York Times, March 10, 2010. By CAROL KINO Published: March 10, 2010 ONE snowy night last month, as New Yorkers rushed home in advance of a coming blizzard, more than a hundred artists, scholars and curators crowded into the boardroom of the Museum of Modern Art to talk about performance art and how it can be preserved and exhibited. The event — the eighth in a series of private Performance Workshops that the museum has mounted in the last two years — would have been even more packed if it weren’t for the weather, said Klaus Biesenbach, one of its hosts and the newly appointed director of the P.S.1 Contemporary Art Center. After seeing the R.S.V.P. list, he had “freaked out,” he said, and worried all day about overflow crowds. As it was, he and his co-host, Jenny Schlenzka, the assistant curator of performance art at the museum, were surrounded at the conference table by a Who’s Who of performance-art history, including Marina Abramovic, the 1970s performance goddess from Belgrade whose retrospective, “The Artist Is Present,” opens Sunday atMoMA; the much younger Tino Sehgal, whose latest show of “constructed situations,” as he terms them, just closed at the Guggenheim Museum; Joan Jonas, a conceptual and video art pioneer of the late 1960s who usually creates installations that mix performance with video, drawing and objects; and Alison Knowles, a founding member of the Fluxus movement who is known for infinitely repeatable events involving communal meals and foodstuffs.
    [Show full text]
  • The Art of Performance a Critical Anthology
    THE ART OF PERFORMANCE A CRITICAL ANTHOLOGY edited by GREGORY BATTCOCK AND ROBERT NICKAS /ubu editions 2010 The Art of Performance A Critical Anthology 1984 Edited By: Gregory Battcock and Robert Nickas /ubueditions ubu.com/ubu This UbuWeb Edition edited by Lucia della Paolera 2010 2 The original edition was published by E.P. DUTTON, INC. NEW YORK For G. B. Copyright @ 1984 by the Estate of Gregory Battcock and Robert Nickas All rights reserved. Printed in the U.S.A. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without permission in writing from the publisher, except by a reviewer who wishes to quote brief passages in connection with a review written for inclusion in a magazine, newspaper or broadcast. Published in the United States by E. P. Dutton, Inc., 2 Park Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10016 Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 79-53323 ISBN: 0-525-48039-0 Published simultaneously in Canada by Fitzhenry & Whiteside Limited, Toronto 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 First Edition Vito Acconci: "Notebook: On Activity and Performance." Reprinted from Art and Artists 6, no. 2 (May l97l), pp. 68-69, by permission of Art and Artists and the author. Russell Baker: "Observer: Seated One Day At the Cello." Reprinted from The New York Times, May 14, 1967, p. lOE, by permission of The New York Times. Copyright @ 1967 by The New York Times Company.
    [Show full text]
  • MA-2013 07 the New Yorker
    Allen, Emma. “The Rapper is Present,” The New Yorker, July 11, 2013 JULY 11, 2013 THE RAPPER IS PRESENT POSTED BY EMMA ALLEN Three years ago, when the performance artist Marina Abramović sat in the atrium of the Museum of Modern Art for seven hundred and fifty hours, many of the people who had waited in long lines to sit across from her melted down in her presence. Abramović remained silent and still, enduring thirst, hunger, and back pain (and speculation as to how, exactly, she was or was not peeing), while visitors, confronted with her placid gaze, variously wept, vomited, stripped naked, and proposed marriage. But the other day, at the Pace Gallery in Chelsea, where Jay-Z was presenting his own take on Abramović’s piece—rapping for six hours in front of a rotating cast of art-world V.I.P.s—viewers’ primary response was to get up and dance. Jay-Z (or Shawn Carter, or Hova, as he’s alternately known) was continuously performing “Picasso Baby,” the second song on his new album, “Magna Carta… Holy Grail,” to a succession of visual artists, museum directors, gallerists, Hollywood folk, and Pablo’s granddaughter Diana Widmaier Picasso. These guests took turns on or near a wooden bench positioned across from a low platform on which the rapper stood, except when he was prowling around. A crowd of less famous art-world denizens and cool-looking people (some of whom had been specially cast) loitered along the walls of the gallery, except when they were invited to scurry right up to Jay-Z.
    [Show full text]
  • Art 381 Repeat Perform Record
    Sculpture 381 Fall 2013 T/Th 1-4 Repeat, Perform, Record Billy Culiver E.A.T. 9 Evening in Art and Technology A Class Exploring the Intersection Between Theater, Dance and Visual Art The studio art course, Repeat, Perform, Record we will consider the dynamic of live bodies in physical spaces and read critical text and philosophical ideas about performance art. You will have 3 assignment: 1. Work Ethic-Duration/Record, 2. Work Ethic Labor and a collaborative work done with dancers, 3. Spaces Created by Action/Action Created by Spaces. Each assignment is directly aligned to a set of readings and visiting artists who will join the class. In this class, I attempt to honor the radical roots of Performance Art, with its history of expanding notions of how we make art, how we witness art, and what we understand the function of art to be. Performance art in the studio art context emerged from the visual and plastic arts rather than the traditional categories of dance and theater. From the beginning “Performance” was part of the modernist movements such as Futurism, Dada. With the emergence of Fluxus, Situationalism, Happenings, and Conceptualist practices the correspondence with the conscious use of space, time and process became central to Performance Art. With in the last decade, the concept of space, time and process have blended to expand Performance Art, making it a contemporary tool for expression with diverse directions of visual art, theater, dance, music and social practices. Contemporary live art now employs many different forms of experimentation diminishing the known or rehearsed dynamics of performance by opening it to improvisation and chance operations.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction to Art Making- Motion and Time Based: a Question of the Body and Its Reflections As Gesture
    Introduction to Art Making- Motion and Time Based: A Question of the Body and its Reflections as Gesture. ...material action is painting that has spread beyond the picture surface. The human body, a laid table or a room becomes the picture surface. Time is added to the dimension of the body and space. - "Material Action Manifesto," Otto Muhl, 1964 VIS 2 Winter 2017 When: Thursday: 6:30 p.m. to 8:20p.m. Where: PCYNH 106 Professor: Ricardo Dominguez Email: [email protected] Office Hour: Thursday. 11:00 a.m. to Noon. Room: VAF Studio 551 (2nd Fl. Visual Art Facility) The body-as-gesture has a long history as a site of aesthetic experimentation and reflection. Art-as-gesture has almost always been anchored to the body, the body in time, the body in space and the leftovers of the body This class will focus on the history of these bodies-as-gestures in performance art. An additional objective for the course will focus on the question of documentation in order to understand its relationship to performance as an active frame/framing of reflection. We will look at modernist, contemporary and post-contemporary, contemporary work by Chris Burden, Ulay and Abramovic, Allen Kaprow, Vito Acconci, Coco Fusco, Faith Wilding, Anne Hamilton, William Pope L., Tehching Hsieh, Revered Billy, Nao Bustamante, Ana Mendieta, Cindy Sherman, Adrian Piper, Sophie Calle, Ron Athey, Patty Chang, James Luna, and the work of many other body artists/performance artists. Students will develop 1 performance action a week, for 5 weeks, for a total of 5 gestures/actions (during the first part of the class), individually or in collaboration with other students.
    [Show full text]
  • ON PAIN in PERFORMANCE ART by Jareh Das
    BEARING WITNESS: ON PAIN IN PERFORMANCE ART by Jareh Das Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of PhD Department of Geography Royal Holloway, University of London, 2016 1 Declaration of Authorship I, Jareh Das hereby declare that this thesis and the work presented in it is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, this is always clearly stated. Signed: Date: 19th December 2016 2 Acknowledgments This thesis is the result of the generosity of the artists, Ron Athey, Martin O’Brien and Ulay. They, who all continue to create genre-bending and deeply moving works that allow for multiple readings of the body as it continues to evolve alongside all sort of cultural, technological, social, and political shifts. I have numerous friends, family (Das and Krys), colleagues and acQuaintances to thank all at different stages but here, I will mention a few who have been instrumental to this process – Deniz Unal, Joanna Reynolds, Adia Sowho, Emmanuel Balogun, Cleo Joseph, Amanprit Sandhu, Irina Stark, Denise Kwan, Kirsty Buchanan, Samantha Astic, Samantha Sweeting, Ali McGlip, Nina Valjarevic, Sara Naim, Grace Morgan Pardo, Ana Francisca Amaral, Anna Maria Pinaka, Kim Cowans, Rebecca Bligh, Sebastian Kozak and Sabrina Grimwood. They helped me through the most difficult parts of this thesis, and some were instrumental in the editing of this text. (Jo, Emmanuel, Anna Maria, Grace, Deniz, Kirsty and Ali) and even encouraged my initial application (Sabrina and Rebecca). I must add that without the supervision and support of Professor Harriet Hawkins, this thesis would not have been completed.
    [Show full text]
  • Guggenheim Museum Archives Reel-To-Reel Collection “Post Object Sculpture” with Jack Burnham, 1967 Good Afternoon, Ladies An
    Guggenheim Museum Archives Reel-to-Reel collection “Post Object Sculpture” with Jack Burnham, 1967 MALE 1 Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the third in a series of lectures on contemporary sculpture, presented by the museum on the occasion of the Fifth Guggenheim International Exhibition. Today’s lecture is by Mr. Jack Wesley Burnham. Mr. Burnham is an individual who combines the extraordinary qualities of being both artist and scientist, as well as writer. He was born in 1931 in New York City. He studied at the Boston Museum School, at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. He holds an engineering degree. He holds the degrees of Bachelor of Fine Arts and Master of Fine Arts from Yale University, at which institution he was on the faculty. [00:01:00] And he’s at present a professor at Northwestern University. He is the author of a major new study of modern sculpture, to be published next year by Braziller in New York, entitled Beyond Modern Sculpture. His lecture today is entitled, “Post-Object Sculpture.” After the lecture, there will be a short question-and-answer period. Mr. Burnham. JACK BURNHAM Mr. [Fry?], I’d like to thank you for inviting me. And I’d like to [00:02:00] thank all of you for being here today. I’m going to read part of this lecture, and part of it will be fairly extemporaneous. But I’d like to begin by saying that I find the task of speaking on post- object sculpture difficult for two reasons. First, because the rationale behind object sculpture and the art form itself have developed to such a sophisticated degree in the past two years.
    [Show full text]
  • Clifford Owens, Anthology (Nsenga Knight) , 2011
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE 14 January 2014 Image credit: Clifford Owens, Anthology (Nsenga Knight) , 2011. Image courtesy of the artist. Clifford Owens: Better the Rebel You Know Cornerhouse, Manchester, UK, 10 May – 17 August 2014 Curated by Daniella Rose King This summer Cornerhouse in Manchester will host the first major European show by American conceptual artist Clifford Owens, across all three of its galleries. Owens ’ work explores the intersection of photography, video, text and performance. His practice seeks to challenge the boundaries of performance, and the possibilities of interaction between artist and audience. The exhibition will include an exclusive UK iteration of Owens’ work Anthology , which debuted at MoMA PS1’s eponymous exhibition in New York in 2011. The work originated from a series of 28 performance 'scores': short, diverse sets of instructions (some specific, others open to interpretation) solicited by Owens from a selection of African American artists, from established to emerging figures. Owens said: “This project originated over a decade ago. In 2000, my thesis research failed to find adequate evidence of black artists’ investment in performance art since the 1950s, but this clearly wasn’t due to a lack of involvement. Rather than lament the lack of historical interest in US-based black artists and performance art, I chose to imagine my own history. “The artists who contribute the scores drive the emotional ‘gestalt’ represented in Anthology ; I am the conduit for transmitting profoundly powerful messages from a group of enormously talented artists. My body is attached to this body of work; it is the container and conveyor of its meaning.
    [Show full text]
  • The Next Gen Art Collectors 2021
    COLLECTORS 1 THE NEXT COLLECTORS REPORT 2021 3 LARRY’S LIST is pleased to present The Next Gen that have not yet been acknowledged or made visible For us, size wasn’t a main consideration. Indeed, not a blue-chip artist will most likely generate more “likes” FOREWORDArt Collectors Report. Here, we continue our mission on a global scale. We want to share their stories and everyone listed has a large collection; charmingly, the than an unknown artist in an equally brilliant interior of monitoring global happenings, developments and thoughts. Next Gen often have collections in the making. The setting. But we still try to balance it and set aside any trends in the art world—particularly in the contemporary We also consider LARRY’S LIST as a guide and tool process is a development that happens over years care about the algorithm. art collector field—by looking extensively at the next for practitioners. We share and name collectors, those and so a mid-20-year-old collector may not yet be at generation of young art collectors on the scene. Over people who are buying art and contributing to the the same stage in their collection as someone in their Final words the past few months, we have investigated and profiled art scene. The Next Gen Art Collectors Report is a late 30s. I would like to express my gratitude to all the collectors these collectors, answering the questions central to this resource for artists, galleries, dealers, a general art- The end result of our efforts is this report listing over we exchanged with in the preparation of this report topic: Who are these collectors founding the next art interested audience and, of course, peer collectors.
    [Show full text]
  • Art History 1
    Art History 1 ART HISTORY Professors Farès El-Dahdah Contact Information Joseph Manca Art History Associate Professors https://arthistory.rice.edu/ Graham Bader 103 Herring Hall Leo Costello 713-348-4276 Gordon Hughes Graham Bader Fabiola López-Durán Department Chair Lida Oukaderova [email protected] Assistant Professors Sophie Crawford-Brown The Department of Art History offers a wide range of courses in Farshid Emami European, American, Latin American, Middle Eastern/Islamic, African/ Olivia Young African diaspora and Asian art history. The major in Art History is For Rice University degree-granting programs: structured to expose students to the chronological, geographical, and To view the list of official course offerings, please see Rice’s methodological breadth of the field of scholarship. Students in the Course Catalog (https://courses.rice.edu/admweb/!SWKSCAT.cat? program may pursue the BA degree with a major in Art History. The p_action=cata) department also offers a minor in Art History. To view the most recent semester’s course schedule, please see Rice's Bachelor's Program Course Schedule (https://courses.rice.edu/admweb/!SWKSCAT.cat) • Bachelor of Arts (BA) Degree with a Major in Art History (https:// Art History (HART) ga.rice.edu/programs-study/departments-programs/humanities/art- HART 100 - AP/OTH CREDIT IN ART HISTORY history/art-history-ba/) Short Title: AP/OTH CREDIT IN ART HISTORY Department: Art History Minor Grade Mode: Standard Letter Course Type: Transfer • Minor in Cinema and Media Studies (https://ga.rice.edu/programs- Credit Hours: 3 study/departments-programs/humanities/cinema-media-studies/ Restrictions: Enrollment is limited to Undergraduate, Undergraduate cinema-media-studies-minor/) Professional or Visiting Undergraduate level students.
    [Show full text]