– IRSPM 2011 – “Co-Production In Planning And Design: Finding A Balance Between Collective And Individual Responsibility” Co-Production In Planning And Design: Finding A Balance Between Collective And Individual Responsibility Arienne C. Naber1, Bert Enserink1 1Department for Policy Analysis Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management Delft University of Technology PO Box 5015 2600 GA Delft The Netherlands
[email protected],
[email protected] Abstract. Worldwide, the trend in policies and legislation is towards wider citizen participation. This development coincides with a move towards more government deregulation and market liberalization as well as an exponential growth of the Internet and an increasingly better educated and equipped citizenry. These developments together result in a Zeitgeist that profoundly challenges the traditional relationship between government, experts and citizens as established in the 20th century. To study the balance between deliberation and analysis and between collective and individual responsibility, two cases in urban development in the Netherlands are analysed. Both cases experiment with more citizen involvement in planning and design, but each one of them leaves different degrees of freedom for individual action and uses different participatory methods. In Smallingerland, extensive use is made of the Internet to reach out and reap the benefits from the “wisdom of the crowds”. Only two conditions frame the stage: The building location and the concept of sustainability. In Enschede, the master plan is more directive concerning the architecture and use of materials, dividing the new residential area in three different zones according to the construction guidelines. And more traditional participatory methods have been used to invite citizen and expert inputs.