Cent. Eur. J. Chem. • 10(3) • 2012 • 802-835 DOI: 10.2478/s11532-012-0037-y
Central European Journal of Chemistry
Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Review Article
Anna Petruczynik
Department of Inorganic Chemistry, Medical University of Lublin, 20-093 Lublin, Poland
Received 29 October 2011; Accepted 27 January 2012
Abstract: Alkaloids are biologically active compounds widely used as pharmaceuticals and synthesised as secondary methabolites in plants. Many of these compounds are strongly toxic. Therefore, they are often subject of scientific interests and analysis. Since alkaloids - basic compounds appear in aqueous solutions as ionized and unionized forms, they are difficult for chromatographic separation for peak tailing, poor systems efficiency, poor separation and poor column-to-column reproducibility. For this reason it is necessity searching of more suitable chromatographic systems for analysis of the compounds. In this article we present an overview on the separation of selected alkaloids from different chemical groups by liquid chromatography thus indicating the range of useful methods now available for alkaloid analysis. Different selectivity, system efficiency and peaks shape may be achieved in different LC methods separations by use of alternative stationary phases: silica, alumina, chemically bonded stationary phases, cation exchange phases, or by varying nonaqueous or aqueous mobile phase (containing different modifier, different buffers at different pH, ion-pairing or silanol blocker reagents). Developments in TLC (NP and RP systems), HPLC (NP, RP, HILIC, ion-exchange) are presented and the advantages of each method for alkaloids analysis are discussed. Keywords: Alkaloids • Thin layer chromatography • High performance liquid chromatography • Normal phase system • Reversed phase system © Versita Sp. z o.o.
1. Introduction they are often subject of scientific interests andanalysis. Since alkaloids are basic compounds that appear in Most of naturally occurring substances in their structure aqueous solutions as ionized and unionized forms, they have one or more acidic or basic groups. Such are difficult for chromatographic separation for peak compounds appear widely in different areas, such as the tailing, they have poor system efficiency, poor separation environment, food, plant extracts, biological fluids, and and poor column-to-column reproducibility. Reversed- drugs [1,2]. Therefore, it is of crucial importance to develop phase (RP) chromatography continues to dominate efficient methods for the analysis of these compounds applications of high-performance liquid chromatography in several domains such as clinical analysis, quality (HPLC). The majority of silica based stationary phases control, therapeutic monitoring, toxicological analysis, are produced by reacting porous silica particles with an and metabolism studies. Among these compounds appropriate silane. Silanol groups (-Si-OH) on the silica are alkaloids, which are weak organic bases. Alkaloids gel surface are bonded in this reaction but steric effects are pharmacologically active compounds widely used prevent the reaction of only part of all the silanols. Further as pharmaceuticals and synthesised as secondary reaction with a short silane (endcapping) eliminates metabolites in plants. Many of these compounds are the most accessible silanol groups remaining from the strongly toxic. For diagnosis and prognosis of such initial bonding but typically does not substantially alter poisonings, analytical methods for detection and the total concentration of unreacted silanols. These quantification of the respective toxic alkaloids are residual silanols can then interact with basic compounds, required in clinical and forensic toxicology. Therefore, frequently leading to inferior separations, peak symmetry
* E-mail: [email protected] 802 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
and systems efficiency [3]. Protonated basic compounds are regarded as rich sources of tropane alkaloids. The can interact with residual silanol groups of the stationary principal alkaloids of medicinal interest in this group are phase, as shown in the equation: scopolamine and hyoscyamine which are anticholinergic agents in parasympathetic nervous system and they are XH+ + SiO-Na+ ↔ Na+ + SiO-XH+ (1) used as mydriatics and spasmolytics. Phenethylamine alkaloid group is derived Because of that ionic analytes’ retention mechanism biosynthetically from the amino acids tyrosine and is mixed and composed of ion-exchange mechanism with phenylalanine. Alkaloids belonging to phenethylamine the show kinetics and mass transfer and hydrophobic derivatives constitute an important class of natural interactions with much faster kinetics and mass transfer. products due to their structural similarity to many It gives rise to peak tailing [4]. For this reason, it is neurotransmitters. Alkaloids from the group act as necessary to search for more suitable chromatographic stimulants (ephedrine) or hallucinogens (mescaline). systems for analysis of theses compounds. A great Ephedra alkaloids are generally not used alone, but variety of analytical techniques have been applied rather as part of herbal formulas, and are known to the determination of different alkaloids, and liquid to induce pharmacological effects beyond their chromatography is the most frequently used method sympathomimetic activities such as anti-inflammatory, nowadays. The so-called silanol effect on silica based anti-anaphylactic, anti-microbial, anti-histaminic, and stationary phases has still been one of the major topics hypoglycemic effects. Ergot alkaloids are secondary of chromatographic studies even after the development metabolites produced by fungi of the species Claviceps. of advanced stationary phases that were supposed to Toxic effects after consumption of contaminated grains provide symmetrical peaks for basic compounds. have been described since mediaeval times. Colchicine is currently being investigated for potential use as an anti-cancer drug. 2. Occurrence and medical Isoquinoline alkaloids, biogenetically derived from significance of some alkaloids tyrosine, represent a manifold class of alkaloids within the plant kingdom. Isoquinoline alkaloids are spread Indole is an aromatic heterocyclic organic compound. It mainly in the Papaverales, Rutales, Ranunculales, has a bicyclic structure, consisting of a six-membered Geraniales, Plumboginales, Myrtiflore and Rosales benzene ring fused to a five-membered nitrogen- species. Among them benzylisoquinoline alkaloids form containing pyrrole ring. Indole alkaloids are biogenetically an important group with different potent pharmacological derived from tryptophan. These alkaloids contain two activity, including analgesic compounds of morphine, nitrogen atoms, one of which is contained within the antitussives of codeine and noscapine and anti-infective five-membered part of indole nucleus. agents of berberine, palmatine, and magnoflorine. Indole alkaloids constitute an important class of Papaverine serves as muscle relaxant. Thebain is natural products which include a large number of worked up by pharmaceuthical industry to produce biologically important substances such as antitumor semi synthetic compounds such as the analgesic alkaloids (vinblastine, vincristine, ajmaline and oxycodone and the opiate antagonists naloxone and reserpine), cardioarrithmic alkaloid (ajmalicine) the naltrexone. Opium containing isoquinoline alkaloids: blood pressure lowering substances (reserpine), and morphine, codeine, noscapine, papaverine, tebaine, hallucinatory lysergic acid and its derivatives. Some laudanozine, retykuline has strong narcotic properties indole alkaloids are strongly toxic (strychnine), or are and demonstrates analgesic, spasmolytic, antitussive psychoactive substances (psylocibine, bufotenin). and obstructive properties. Tropane alkaloids are an important class of Quinoline alkaloids are based on a bicyclic system in structurally related compounds having in common the with benzene and a pyridine ring are fused together. Most azabicyclo[3.2.1]octane-3-ol skeleton, with usually of them occur in the plant family Rutaceae, especially are estrified with various organic acids: (-)-S-tropic, rute. Quinoline alkaloids have also been identified in apotropic, cinnamic, tiglic, angelic, isovaleric and members of Malvaceae, Acanthaceae, Saxifragaceae α-truxillic. and Zygophyllaceae families. Cinchonidine and quinine Tropane alkaloids mainly occurs in Solanacae, from the bark of the cinchona tree (Cinchona officinalis) Erythroxylacae and Convolvulacae plant families, but are well known for their antimalarial properties. they occur also sporadically in a number of other families The structures of pyridine alkaloids contain a e.g. Proteaceae, Rhizophoraceae plants. Genuses pyridine ring together with a pyrrolidine ring (in nicotine) Atropa, Datura, Duboisia, Hyoscyamus and Scopolia or a piperidine unit (in anabasine), the latter rings arising
803 804 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
from ornithine and lysine respectively. The alkaloids are salts. Samples containing a large number of water naturally occurring in the solanaceous family. Nicotine, soluble compounds (e.g. phenols, tannines) should be the main alkaloid in the group, in small doses can act as extracted with organic solvents immiscible with water a respiratory stimulant, though in larger doses it causes after addition of alkali to obtain the alkaloids in the respiratory depression. Nicotine is being used by former organic solvent as free bases. smokers who wish to stop the habit. Imidazole alkaloids of pilocarpine type are derived 3.1. Indole alkaloids biosynthetically from histidine. Pilocarpine has the Various methods are used for extraction of indole muscarinic actions of acetylcholine. It is used as a miotic alkaloids from plant material. Generally in liquid-solid in the treatment of the open-angle glaucoma. systems acidic extractants are used. The following The xanthine alkaloids are a widely used group mixtures of solvents were used: MeOH with HCl (5%)
of alkaloids as they are constituents of popular daily [5], or 2% [6], MeOH with 1% CH3COOH [7], H2O with
beverages such as tea and coffee. These alkaloids TFA (0.1%) [8], n-hexane with 1% HCl [9], MeOH/H2O
stimulate the central nervous system, respiratory with HCl (1%) [10], 2-propanol/H2O with lactic acid (1%)
system, muscles and heart. They have also therapeutic [11], MeCN/H2O with 1% CH3COOH [12], water with properties such as acting as an analgesic, diuretic, or 10% acetic acid [13], water with 2% sulfuric acid [14]. bronchodilator. The extraction of indole alkaloids was performed Pyrrolizidine alkaloids are derived biosynthetically also without addition of acids, for example extraction from the amino acid ornithine. They are spread in the with pure MeOH [15-17], EtOH [18-21], dichloromethane
Boraginaceae, Fabaceae and Composite plant families. [15], acetone [15] or MeOH/H2O [23] was reported. Their toxicity has drawn a lot of attention. Sometimes extraction was performed in extractant at
Diterpene alkaloids have a diterpene skeletal basic pH, e.g. MeOH/H2O with addition of ammonia structure. The group of alkaloids comprises highly toxic [24], EtOH with ammonia [25]. The MeOH extract compounds: aconitine, mesaconitine and hypaconitine. was acidified with 10% acetic acid to pH 2.8, and then The toxicology of these alkaloids derives from activation dissolved in water. The aqueous solution was extracted
of the sodium channel of excitable cell membranes with CH2Cl2, while the aqueous solution was made leading to rapid paralysis of cardiac, muscular and alkaline with 25% ammonia to pH 8.5, and extracted
neural tissues. again with CH2Cl2 [26]. Ergot alkaloids from rye flour or grounded rye were extracted by adding 100 mL of dichloromethane/ethylacetate/methanol/ammonia 3. Sample preparation (25%), (50/25/5/1, v/v/v/v) [1]. The macrolactam-type indole alkaloids from Ipomoea Sample preparation is the crucial first part in a natural obscura were extracted with methanol. The solvent was product analysis because it is necessary to extract the evaporated under reduced pressure at 40°C, the residue desired chemical components from the material, dissolve re-dissolved in 2% aq. tartaric acid and extracted with the analyte in a suitable solvent and remove as many ethyl acetate. After evaporation of the organic solvent, interfering compounds as possible from the solution. the residue was dissolved with methanol [27]. Another Application of chromatographic techniques, especially procedure of extraction of terpenoid indole alkaloids HPLC, requires preliminary sample preparation from Catharanthus pusillus was applied. The plant providing a sample free of components that may material was mixed with absolute ethanol, homogenised, deteriorate the column. Various methods of extraction centrifuged and the ethanolic extract was transferred are used for isolation of different alkaloids from plant into a round bottom flask. The pellet was re-extracted material, pharmaceutical formulations and biological in a similar fashion and the combined ethanolic phases samples. In the extraction and isolation of alkaloids one concentrated to dryness under reduced pressure. For the has to consider that alkaloids usually occur in plants as extraction of vindoline, the plant material was mixed with salts of organic or inorganic acids, sometimes exist as buffer (composed with glycine, NaCl and NaOH) at pH tannin complexes, and often together with non-alkaloidal 10 and dichloromethane. The mixture was homogenized compounds. The procedure of extraction depends on and centrifuged. The organic liquid phase was taken the class of alkaloids and ballast substances coexisting and transferred to a round bottom flask. The slurry was with the alkaloidal fraction. Natural samples with a extracted again by addition of dichloromethane [28]. high concentration of nonpolar compounds (e.g. lipids) SPE method involves selective extraction of the should preferably be extracted with water containing analytes from liquid samples onto solid support of acids to obtain the alkaloids in aqueous solution as different varieties and types (e.g. silica gel, alumina,
803 804 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
florisil, kieselguhr, reversed-phase sorbents such as: obtained by conventional solid-liquid extraction but in a octyl, octadecyl, diol, cyano, amino, ion-exchange more efficient manner. sorbents). The sample is directly passed through The pressurized liquid extraction (PLE) was used previously conditioned cartridges filled with a given for cocaine and benzoylecgonine extraction from coca sorbent and analytes are directly collected, whereas leaves [37]. Mroczek et al. optimized PLE conditions for co-extractives are retained on the sorbent. It can be extraction of l-hyoscyamine and scopolamine from thorn performed another way in which a sample is applied in apple leaves [35]. solvent of low elution strength. The analytes adsorbed El-Shazly et al. [38] applied SELLP procedure for are eluted with solvent of higher elution power. Extraction isolation of pure alkaloidal fractions from Hyoscyamus of indole alkaloids from Rauwolfia serpentina tissue sp. The basified aqueous extract was applied into was performed on SCX cation-exchanger [29]. Tissues dry ExtrelutTM column, and the liquid was completely were extracted with methanol. After filtering, the extract absorbed by the kieselguhr. Tropane alkaloids free was evaporated to dryness. Extract was dissolved in bases which are exposed on the surface of the methanol and acidified with 0.1 M HCl. Acidified solution kieselguhr particles are eluted by organic solvents such was extracted with SCX cation –exchanger. as chloroform. In some cases liquid-liquid extraction were used for 3.2. Tropane alkaloids isolation of tropane alkaloids. At first the acidic extract Due to thermal instability and sensitivity to strong acidic is extracted with chloroform in a separation funnel and basis conditions of tropane alkaloids the method of to remove acidic co-extractives. Then the remaining solid-liquid extraction should be carefully selected. The extract is alkalized with ammonia solution to pH about first step of extraction should be with diluted acids like 5% 9-9.5 and extracted with non-polar organic solvents such
HCl, 5-10% acetic acid or 0.01% H2SO4 [30-32]. Jia et as chloroform, benzene, toluene, or dichloromethane al. [33] found the extraction of Datura alkaloids the most [39,40]. efficient at pH 2-3. When alkaloid free bases are to be SPE of tropane alkaloids was usually performed on extracted, alkaline organic phases are used. Fliniaux et RP-18 columns. The procedure was applied for plant al. compared the efficiencies of both acidic and alkaline extracts, blood serum, urine and egg yolk samples solutions for the extraction of tropane alkaloids from plant [41-43]. material. They used: 0.2 M sulphuric acid, methanol-0.1 Keiner and Dräger [44] applied cation-exchange M HCl (24:1, v/v), methanol-27% ammonia (24:1, v/v), SPE for isolation of calystegines from plant samples, methanol-chloroform-27% ammonia (24:1, v/v) [34]. where they were retained by charge of the secondary Similar results were obtained by all procedures. amino group. Kintz et al. have extracted of scopolamine from children hairs. After liquid–liquid extraction with 5 mL of 3.3. Isoquinoline alkaloids a mixture of methylene chloride/isopropanol/n-heptane Various methods are used for extraction of isoquinoline (50/17/33, v/v/v) and evaporation of the organic phase alkaloids from different natural samples. Usually to dryness, the residue was reconstituted in 100 μL of simple techniques of extraction were applied. It was methanol. maceration or percolation at room temperature with Mroczek et al. [35] analysed the content of aqueous extractants or alcohols [45-48]. For liquid- l-hyoscyamine and scopolamine extracted from thorn solid extraction of isoquinoline alkaloids, aqueous acidic apple’s leaves. When 1% tartaric acid in methanol solutions were often applied [49,50]. Acidified methanol o was used at 90 ± 5 C on heating mantle for 15 min, or ethanol with HCl or H2SO4 was also used [51,52]. the highest amounts of scopolamine were measured Sometimes organic solvents are used for extraction also in comparison to more sophisticated methods such as methanol and dichloromethane, methanol and such as UAE (ultrasound assisted extraction) or PLE chloroform or dichloromethane [53-55]. The extraction (pressurised liquid extraction). However, the amounts was often assisted by shaking or ultrasonification of l-hyoscyamine were comparable to USE at 60oC and [56-58]. lower than PLE procedures. For cocaine and benzoylecgonine extraction from 3.4. Phenylethylamine alkaloids coca leaves, microwave-assisted extraction (FMAE) The following procedure was used for isolation of was optimised with respect to the nature of the extracting phenylethylamine alakloids from Colchicum crocifolium. solvent, the particle size distribution, the moisture of the Dried plant material was extracted with MeOH in a sample, the applied microwave power and radiation Soxhhlet apparatus for 3 h. The solvent was evaporated time [36]. FMAE generated extracts similar to those under reduced pressure to yield a MeOH-extract, which
805 806 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
was fractionated [59]. Briefly, the MeOH-extract was 2-phenylimidizole, 5% antifoam/phenol red solution, dissolved in 5% acetic acid and extracted with light 30% ammonia, and dichloroethane and mixed by petroleum, after which the aqueous acid residue was gentle inversion for 1 min. The solution was centrifuged re-extracted three times with diethyl ether. The acidic 15 min using a Microfuge. The supernatant was discarded aqueous residues were made alkaline (pH 9) with 10% and the clear bottom layer was placed into a tube and
NH4OH followed by extraction three times with CH2Cl2. dried under N2 gas. The sample was reconstituted
The aqueous residues were then adjusted to pH 12 with with HPLC buffer (30 mM citric acid, 30 mM KH2PO4, 10% NaOH, and then extracted three times with diethyl 3.65 g L-1 triethylamine, 0.6 g L-1 1-heptanesulfonic acid, -1 ether and finally three times with CH2Cl2. 90 mL L acetonitrile, pH 4.8) was added. A sonification extraction was usually used for Hair samples containing tobacco alkaloids were separation of ephedrine alkaloids. The sonification washed three times with 3.0 mL of dichloromethane and microwave extraction were used for isolation of by vortex-mixing. After drying, the samples were ephedrine alkaloids from Ephedra natural products digested with 1.0 mol L-1 NaOH for 14 h at 50oC and [60]. Sonification was performed by use solvent then centrifuged. Afterwards, the clear supernatant was containing methanol or a mixture of hydrochloric acid diluted with an equal volume of a buffer of ammonium and methanol (0.8:99.2, v/v)) at different temperatures acetate + ammonia (pH 10.0) [67]. (room temperature, 40 or 50oC) for 15 min. Regarding In another procedure serum samples containing microwave extraction, a weighed amount of ground nicotine and its metabolites were prepared by SPE sample (0.25 g of E. vulgaris aerial parts) was extracted method [68]. Serum sample was added to internal with 5mL of solvent (methanol or a mixture of hydrochloric standard solution, water and 25% (w/v) trichloroacetic acid methanol (0.8:99.2, v/v)) by using a monomode acid to remove proteins. The solutions were centrifuged microwave apparatus with a closed vessel system and at 10,000 g for 5 min after vortexing. The supernatant subjected to different temperatures for different times of was applied to SPE cartridges. An Oasis MCX cartridge irradiation (40oC for 15 min or 60oC for 4 min or 80oC (Waters) was conditioned with 1mL of methanol and for 1 min). The comparison between sonication and 1 mL of water. Serum samples were loaded and allowed microwave extractions indicated that sonication was the to flow by gravity. Cartridges were washed with 1mL most efficient procedure, allowing the highest yield of all water and 1 mL methanol, and dried for 5 min. Analytes considered analytes in a short time. were eluted with freshly prepared 1 mL methanol with 1% ammonia (v/v). Eluates were evaporated to dryness 3.5. Quinoline derivatives under a nitrogen stream at 50°C. Samples were The extraction of major alkaloids from Cinchona bark is reconstituted in acetonitrile with 0.1% formic acid (v/v). usually performed after preliminary pulverizing, grinding, The acidified plasma supernatant and urine sieving and drying of the bark at 110oC followed by containing nicotine and its metabolites were then treatment with alkali and Soxhlet extraction in hot subjected to solid-phase extraction (SPE) using a toluene [61], benzene or methanol [62]. combination of Oasis HLB and Oasis MCX mixed mode Quinine and quinidine are extracted from plasma or cartridges [69]. The SPE cartridges for both plasma urine also by making the sample basic with, for instance and urine were conditioned with methanol followed by sodium or aqueous ammonia, and extracting into an 10% aqueous trichloroacetic acid for plasma and 5 mM organic solvent such as dichloromethane or diethyl aqueous ammonium formate (pH 2.5) for urine. The ether [63,64]. samples were loaded onto the cartridges and the target For determination of quinine in plasma, samples analytes were subsequently eluted with 2 mL methanol were subjected to protein precipitation with acetonitrile. containing 5% concentrated aqueous ammonium The mixture was finally centrifuged at 4oC for 10 min. hydroxide (v/v). 1% concentrated aqueous hydrochloric The supernatant was transferred into a polypropylene acid in methanol (v/v) was added prior to evaporation tube and evaporated to dryness under nitrogen at room of the eluent. Extracts were evaporated to dryness temperature. The solid residue was reconstituted in and residues were reconstituted in initial mobile phase MeOH/ammonium formate 20 mM 1:1 adjusted to pH conditions. 4.0 with formic acid, vortex-mixed and centrifuged again SPE procedure was also used for extraction of [65]. tobacco alkaloids [70]. SPE column was pre-washed with methylene chloride, methanol, and finally with water. 3.6. Pyridine and piperidine alkaloids After the acidified sample was loaded onto the column, Nicotine and cotinine were extracted from rat plasma the column was washed with acetic acid and dried under
[66]. Plasma was added to a centrifuge tube containing positive pressure N2. The column was then washed with
805 806 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
hexane and then of hexane-ethyl acetate (1:1), followed submitted to the following extraction step. Extractions by methanol. After washing, the analytes were slowly were carried out on a multi-frequency ultrasonic bath eluted with 2×3 mL of methylene chloride/isopropanol/ operating at 25 kHz at 100% intensity output. After ammonium hydroxide (78:20:2). The final extract was the last extraction, supernatants were combined and dried in the vacuum evaporator without heat, and the brought up with water and an aliquot was collected, residue was reconstituted in methanol with 0.1% formic which was filtered through 0.2-m nylon syringe filter acid for the analysis. before the HPLC analysis. Piperine analogues were extracted from plasma by SPE [71]. The various steps involved in the recovery 3.9. Pyrrolizidine alkaloids procedure were: (a) conditioning of SPE cartridge C18 Isolation of pyrrolizidine alkaloids was obtained by SPE with 1.0 mL methanol, followed by 1.0 mL water, (b) using C18 cartridges [76]. loading of diluted (1:4, v/v) plasma samples (1.0 mL) For extraction of pyrrolizidine alkaloids from onto cartridge and drying under positive pressure, and Boraginaceae species, the plant organs or cultured (c) samples were washed with 2 mL of water followed by roots were washed with tap water, dabbed dry, weighed, elution with 2 mL of methanol. and ground in a mortar with liquid nitrogen and sea sand before they were extracted twice for 30 min with 3.7. Imidazole alkaloids methanol containing 1% HCl (25%) and centrifuged [77]. Arecoline alkaloids were prepared from cord serum, or The supernatant of the combined methanol extracts urine with 10 internal standards and NH4Cl saturated was evaporated. The resulting residue was dissolved in solution at pH 9.5 added, were transferred to a screw- methanol. capped glass tube with chloroform/isopropanol In another procedure, the sample preparation internal (95:5, v/v) [72]. The tubes were placed in a horizontal standard was added to serum and mixed well before shaker for 5 min. After centrifugation, the organic being deproteinized with 6% HClO4 (v/v) [78]. Then layer was transferred to another screw-capped glass KH2PO4–KOH (1 M; pH 8.1) was added. The mixture tube, and back-extracted with 0.5M HCl for 5 min. was vortex mixed and centrifuged. The supernatant was After centrifugation, the acidic layer was neutralized applied to a C18 solid phase extraction (SPE) cartridge with NaOH, or ammonia solution. Re-extraction with which had been conditioned with methanol followed by chloroform/isopropanol (95:5, v/v) was finally conducted water. Each cartridge was then washed with water and for 10 min. The organic phase was evaporated to 1% ammoniated methanol (v/v). They were evaporated dryness under a stream of nitrogen at 40°C. The dried to dryness under a flow of nitrogen in a heating block residue was dissolved in 10 mM ammonium acetate at 40°C. The residue was dissolved by initial mobile (pH 4.3) solution. phase. Alakloids from Pilocarpus sp. Were extracted with 10% ammonia; after 15 min extraction is carried out 3.10. Quinolizidine alkaloids Alkaloid extraction procedure was proposed by Wink 3 times with CHCl3; the pooled organic extracts are et al. [79]. According to this method, plant material re-extracted twice with 2% H2SO4; the pooled acid was homogenized in 0.5 M HCl. After 30 min at room extracts are adjusted to pH 12 with NH4OH and extracted temperature, the homogenate was centrifuged for twice with CHCl3 [73]. 10 min at 10 000 x g. The supernatant was made alkaline 3.8. Xanthine alkaloids by adding ammonia or 2 M NaOH and was applied to
Caffeine from traditional Chinese medicinal prescriptions Extrelut columns. Alkaloids were eluted with CH2Cl2 and which contain Theae folium was extracted by SPE the solvent evaporated in vacuo. [74]. In the procedure, the SPE C18 cartridges were Liu et al. used SPE for extraction of quinolizidine washed with water and then dichloromethane was alkaloids from dog plasma [80]. The sample was vortexed used to elute the compounds. The eluate was collected for 30 s and extracted with OASIS HLB Extraction and concentrated under reduced pressure to dryness. Cartridges under reduced pressure. Activation of the Finally, the residue was dissolved in 50% methanol. cartridges was achieved by sequential washing with The sequential extraction of samples containing methanol and distilled water. The cartridges loaded with caffeine was applied [75]. First samples with 50% the samples were firstly washed with 2% acetonitrile methanol, than with 75% methanol, and finally with 100% solution and then were eluted with acetonitrile. The methanol for 20 min at 60°C were extracted. After each eluate was reduced to dryness using a centrifugal extraction step, the sample was centrifuged at 10°C vacuum concentrator. The residue was reconstituted in for 10 min and the supernatant collected and the solid mobile phase.
807 808 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
4. Thin layer chromatography (TLC) Centrifugal TLC (silica, MeOH/CHCl3 or AcOEt/hexane/ ammonia) was successfully applied for isolation of TLC is a chromatographic method widely used for alkaloids from Kopsia species [85]. Subramaniam qualitative rather than quantitative analysis of alkaloids, et al. have analyzed monoterpenoid indole alkaloids isolation of individual substances from multicomponent from Kopsia singapurensis by centrifugal TLC by use mixtures, and preparative-scale isolation. TLC provides different mobile systems [86]. Monoterpenoid indole a chromatographic plant extract and drug fingerprint. alkaloids in Catharanthus roseus extract are separated Multiple samples can be analyzed at the same time on by TLC (on silica plates and eluent containing: ethanol
a single TLC plate, reducing the time of analysis and (EtOH), CHCl3, ammonia) and identified based on
solvent volume used per sample. TLC with densitometry their Rf values, as well as on their chromogenic is the method most frequently applied for quantitative reaction to ceric ammonium sulfate spray reagent analysis of biological samples, e.g. plant extracts. [87]. TLC was applied for micropreparative isolation of Advances in instrumental high-performance thin-layer indole alkaloids from Rauvolfia yunnanensis [88]. The chromatography (HPTLC) have resulted in increasing authors used preparative silica plates and a mixture application of planar chromatography in quantitative of AcOEt, MeOH and diethylamine (DEA) as mobile analysis. The possibility of separation of components phase. Micropreparative TLC was used for isolation present in a mixture and the simultaneous handling of of ervatamine-type indole alkaloids from Ervatamia
a large number of samples has led to extensive use of officinalis in system: silica gel as adsorbent and CHCl3/ HPTLC for analysis of natural samples. TLC is the easiest MeOH as eluent. TLC method was applied to purification technique with which multidimensional separations can of isolated alkaloids on silica plates in eluent systems:
be performed. Particularly valuable separation results CHCl3/MeOH or petroleum ether/AcOEt/DEA [89]. On can be achieved when using various stationary and preparative silica gel plates with mixtures of MeOH and
mobile phase systems as an advantage over different dichloromethane or CHCl3 and AcOEt/hexane fractions separation mechanism. TLC coupled with densitometry of plant extract from Strychnos cathayensis were can be used for quantitative analysis of investigated purified [90]. For isolation of henricinols (indole alkaloids compounds. TLC also was often used for preparative obtained from Melodinus henryi) silica preparative
isolation of alkaloids, purification of multicomponent plates and mixture of AcOEt and CHCl3 was used [91]. samples and control of the separation efficiency of the The alkaloidal fraction obtained from Tabernaemontana different chromatographic methods. Nowadays, HPTLC catharinensis was analyzed on silica plates by use
is a routine analytical technique. mixture of MeOH and CHCl3 [92]. Isolated alkaloids Most TLC procedures for analysis of indole alkaloids were identified by UV-ViS or IR spectra. Silica gel plates use an adsorbent stationary phase such as silica gel, were applied for purification of indole alkaloidal fraction often with fluorescence agent added, since all indole obtained from leaf extracts of Rauvolfia bahiensis [93]. alkaloids adsorb UV light and mobile phase containing The alkaloidal extract of Vinca herbacea was purified by
strongly polar modifier (methanol, ethanol), medium preparative TLC on neutral Al2O3 in toluene/AcOEt/DEA or weakly polar diluent (toluene) and addition of basic solvent system [26]. Two curarizing quaternary indole compounds such as ammonia. Clavine and ergoline alkaloids from Strychnos quianensis were analyzed alkaloids were identified on silica gel as stationary on silica gel plates in eluent system containing MeOH,
phase and in chloroform (CHCl3), methanol (MeOH), Me2CO and MeCOONa [94]. Purification of extract from
ammonia mixture or ethyl acetate (AcOEt), MeOH, H2O, Strychnos moandaensis was performed on preparative
dimethyloformamide (DMF) as mobile phases [81]. TLC silica gel plates in mixtures of MeOH/CHCl3 as eluent separation of monoterpenoid oxindole alkaloids was [95]. For isolation of antileishmanial active indole
achieved on silica gel with CHCl3 and acetone mixture alkaloids from Aspidosperma ramiflorum preparative
as eluent [82]. Two indole alkaloids, 12-methoxykopsine silica gel plates and mixtures of MeOH/CHCl3 or CHCl3/ and danuphylline B, were obtained from the leaf extract AcOEt/MeOH/triethylamine were applied [96]. For of the Malayan Kopsia species, K. arborea, and isolated separation of indole alkaloids by TLC, gradient elution on silica plates by centrifugal TLC method with mobile was successfully used. Components of plant extract
phases containing: CHCl3/MeOH, AcOEt/Hexane, or from Cicer arietinum were separated on silica gel in
diethyl ether (Et2O)/hexane/ammonia [83]. Fractions eluent gradient system containing CHCl3/MeOH/H2O of Alstonia angustiloba plant extract, containing indole with increasing polarity [97]. Gradient TLC elution was alkaloids, were re-chromatographed by centrifugal used for separation of monoterpene indole alkaloids TLC using different nonaqueous eluent systems [84]. from Psychotria stachyoides [98]. Mixtures containing
807 808 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
CH2Cl2/MeOH/NH4OH as eluent with increasing polarity been employed for the analysis of alkaloid extracts from were applied. Aspidosperma and Hunteria type indole Hyoscyamus niger [113], Solanum tuberosum [114], alkaloids were separated on silica gel with AcOEt/ Ceropegia juncea [115] and Erythroxylum emarginatum hexane [99]. Lundurines, cytotoxic indole alkaloids [116]. Bringmann et al. have separated alkaloids from Kopsia tenuis, were isolated initially by column from Erythroxylum zeylanicum plant extract using chromatography, followed by re-chromatography using preparative silica gel plates and eluents containing, e.g. centrifugal TLC with mixtures: Et2O/hexane, Et2O/ MeOH/CH2Cl2, MeOH/AcOEt/ammonia, and MeOH/
MeOH, CHCl3/MeOH as eluents [100]. Centrifugal TLC CHCl3/water [117]. The procedure of separation and method was used for re-chromatography of partially quantification of tropane alkaloids from Datura species resolved fractions containing macroline indole alkaloids by TLC has been described by Mroczek et al. [118]. from Alstonia angustifolia [101]. Solvent systems used Alkaloids were separated on silica gel HPTLC plates for separation of the alkaloids were mixtures containing with two mobile phase systems: acetone/MeOH/water/
MeOH, EtO2, CHCl3, and hexane saturated NH3. ammonia and MeCN/MeOH/HCOOH. Fig. 1 presents Fractions of Ambelania occidentalis plant extract were densitograms of the plates obtained for separation of purified on preparative silica gel plates using AcOEt/ mixture of alkaloid standards and Datura fastuosa plant
CHCl3 or MeOH/CHCl3 [102]. Monoterpenoid indole extract. The authors compared quantitative results for alkaloids from Catharanthus roseus plant extract were investigated alkaloids obtained by HPLC and HPTLC separated on silica gel with various solvent systems and received good correlation between both methods. and the radioactivity was visualized and quantified by Singh et al. proposed a TLC densitometric method for exposure of the TLC to a storage phosphor screen the determination of scopolamine in chromatographic
[103]. Mixtures of CH2Cl2 with MeOH, acetone or hexane system: silica gel HPTLC plates and aqueous mobile were applied as eluents on silica gel for separation of phase - acetone/MeOH/water/ammonia [119]. indolo[2,3a]quinolizine alkaloids [104]. Indole alkaloids TLC of mescaline was carried out on silica gel plates from Kopsia arborea were initially isolated by column in the eluent system: CHCl3/BuOH/ammonia [120]. Fast chromatography followed by re-chromatography of determination of colchicine from pharmaceuticals and partially resolved fractions using centrifugal TLC in vegetal extracts was performed by TLC-densitometry solvent systems containing Et2O/hexane or AcOEt/ [121]. The extract was separated on silica gel layers hexane saturated NH3 [105]. Indole alkaloids from with a mixture of acetone/CHCl3/DEA as a mobile phase. different cyanobacteria were isolated on preparative HPTLC determination of colchicine in a pharmaceutical silica gel plates with mobile phase containing AcOEt/ formulation has been reported [122]. Analysis was
MeOH/H2O [106]. The quantification of yochimbine in performed on silica gel plates with MeCN/AcOEt/water Pausinystalia yochimbe was performed on silica HPTLC /HCOOH. Ephedra alkaloids from Sida species were plates with mixture of toluene/AcOEt/DEA [107]. Thoden determined on nano silica HPTLC plates with toluene/ et al. proposed the use of centrifugal TLC for fractionation AcOEt/DEA as eluent [123]. of Crotalaria species plant extracts containing pirolizidine Opium alkaloids were chromatographed on silica alkaloids [108]. As eluent mixtures of MeOH and CH2Cl2 gel plates with nonaqueous eluent containing toluene/ and silica gel plates were used. acetone/EtOH/ammonia [124]. Samples containing Silica gel plates and nonaqueous eluents were alkaloids were analyzed by TLC, subsequently by HPLC commonly used for analysis of tropane alkaloids. and additionally identified by MS (Fig. 2). Dimeric tropane alkaloids were analyzed in normal Piperine was determined on silica plates by use of phase system containing silica gel as stationary phase petroleum ether, CH2Cl2 and HCOOH [125]. The plates and mixture of MeOH/CHCl3 as mobile phase [109]. were saturated in eluent vapors for 20 minutes before On silica gel plates tropane alkaloids from Merremia developing of chromatograms. genus plant extracts in eluent containing CHCl3/ A simple spectrophotometric-TLC method was used MeOH/ammonia were isolated [110]. TLC separation for determination of colchicine in Colchicum species of alkaloids from Schizanthus litoralis was performed [126]. Analysis was performed on silica gel plates with on silica gel with mixtures of CHCl3/Me2CO or CHCl3/ eluent consisting with acetone/CH2Cl2/DEA. Ellington et
Me2CO/ammonia and on aluminum oxide with Et2O/ al. have separated colchicine from genus Androcybium
EtOH [111]. Brachet et al. described separation of on preparative silica gel plates with MeOH/CH2Cl2 in an tropane alkaloids from Erythroxylum lucidum on silica ammonium-saturated atmosphere [127]. gel with use of Me2CO/ammonia and on aluminum In TLC especially on plates with polar bonded oxide using Et2O/EtOH [112]. TLC on silica gel plates phases (CN-, Diol-, and NH2-silica), two-dimensional and eluents containing MeOH/CHCl3/ammonia have separations can be realized using NP adsorption
809 810 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
(a) systems with non-aqueous eluents and RP partition systems with aqueous eluents, which allows for better or full separation of complex mixtures. The method can be applied during the analysis of complex plant mixtures and allows selected compounds to be identified by retention coefficients in two directions. The application of the most selective systems in 2D-TLC separation of standards’ mixture of isoquinoline alkaloids and alkaloid extracts from herb of Fumaria officinalis is presented in Fig. 3 [128]. Special modes of developing a TLC chromatogram (b) such as automated multiple development (AMD) were also used for analysis of alkaloids. AMD is an instrumental technique of planar chromatography which uses an eluent gradient starting from the most polar to the least polar. The migration is performed by successive steps and at each new development the proportions of the eluent constituents change; so the polarity is decreasing when the distance increases. Gradient development with a linear eluotropic profile leads to a band re-concentration improving the separation. A successful separation depends mainly on the choice of the solvent components and optimization of the Figure 1. HPTLC-densitometric assay of the mixture of (1a) scopolamine–N-oxide (Sk–NO), scopolamine–N-methyl shape of the gradient. The stepwise movement of the bromide (Sk-Me), l-hyoscyamine (H) and scopolamine elution front and the repeated developments increase (Sk). Stationary phase: silica gel 60 F254 HPTLC plates, 20×10 cm, 0.25 mm thickness; mobile phase: the resolution. AMD has proved to be an efficient planar (a) acetone–methanol–water–25% ammonia chromatographic technique that provides increased (82:5:5:8, v/v), then after evaporation of the solvents; (b) acetonitrile–methanol–85% formic acid (120:5:5, separation for compounds with neighboring structures. v/v). Scan was recorded at 205 nm [35]; and (1b) of Pothier and Galand applied AMD for separation of l-hyoscyamine (H) and scopolamine (Sk) in the extract opium alkaloids by using different solvents as eluents from seeds of Datura fastuosa purified by SPE procedure. Details as in Fig. 1a [35]. (Fig. 4) [129].
Table 1. Methods used for TLC of alkaloids.
Alkaloids Source Stationary Eluent Detaection Ref. phase
Fluorinated synthesis SiO MeOH/CH Cl UV [139] quinine alkaloids 2 2 2 Quinoline UV and Dragendorff synthesis SiO Toluene/AcOEt [140] alkaloids 2 reagent The plates were sprayed with 10%
Quinine Khaya anthotheca SiO2 Me2CO/hexane H2SO4 reagent (in [141] EtOH) and heated for detection.
Et2O/hxane/ Piperine standards SiO2 UV [142] CH3COOH Curcuma longa,
Piperine Capsicum annuum, SiO2 Benzene/EtOH/water/CH3COOH UV [143] Piper nigrum
Piperine Polyherbal formulation SiO2 Toluene/AcOEt UV [144] CHCl /CH Cl / Methylxanthines Different types of tea SiO 3 2 2 UV [145] 2 iPrOH Caffeine, n-buthanol/water/ Coffea arabica cellulose Radioactivity [146] trigonelline CH3COOH
CHCl3/EtOH/acetone/water/ Caffeine Energy drinks SiO2 UV-Wis [147] CH3COOH
809 810 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Over Pressured Layer Chromatography (OPLC) is 5. High Performance Liquid nearly equivalent to HPLC. It is a planar chromatographic Chromatography (HPLC) method using a pressured chamber in which the vapor phase above the sorbent is practically eliminated. In recent years there has been a remarkable The eluent is pushed through the sorbent layer and development in the format of the chromatographic continuous development can be performed by a pump. columns and stationary phases, as well as highly The method was applied by Mincsovics for separation specialized organization of HPLC components. Currently of xanthine alkaloids in black tea [130]. The separation HPLC is the most versatile and most widely applied was performed on silica layer with eluent containing technique in the analysis of natural products including toluene and CH3COOH. Fig. 5 presents schematic alkaloids. In most cases, compounds are detected with diagram of bilateral band compression – the method ultraviolet (UV) detectors or photodiode array detectors used in this study. Bilateral band compression has been (DAD). Sophisticated coupled techniques like HPLC- used to increase the sensitivity of detection of minor mass spectrometry (LC-MS) and HPLC-molecular components of a mixture. magnetic resonance (HPLC-NMR) are increasingly Recently, TLC method was conducted with mass used in the analysis of alkaloids. HPLC is also useful for spectrometry (MS). The TLC/MS combination has the quantification of alkaloids for pharmacokinetic studies. potential to provide low-level, highly specific detection of targeted compounds and molecular mass and structure 5.1. Normal-phase LC determinations for unknowns. TLC/MS has been NP-HPLC is rarely applied in separation of alkaloids. employed for the analysis of xanthine alkaloids. Caffeine However, the use of these systems for the analysis of was analyzed in Ilex vomitoria extract on C18 plates with alkaloids is sometimes reported. Usually silica column mixture of MeOH and water as mobile phase by TLC/MS and strongly polar modifier (acetonitrile) and medium [131]. Aranda and Morlock described determination of polar diluent (dichloromethane) are used for these caffeine in pharmaceuticals and energy drink samples purposes. For the analysis of indole alkaloids from by TLC coupled with MS [132]. Schematic diagram Haraldiophyllum species, a chromatographic system of the interface components is presented in Fig. 6. containing cyanopropyl stationary phase and mixture of Analysis was performed on silica gel plates with eluents 2-propanol/hexane as mobile phase was used [148]. containing MeOH/formate buffer at pH 4.0. The TLC/MS Rarely, for analysis of alkaloids, silica stationary was also applied for determination of caffeine, codeine phase coated with metal ions was used. Piperine isomers and ephedrine on C18 plates and eluent consisting with were separated on a silver-modified cation-exchange MeOH and water [133]. ligand-covered silica material as stationary phase with Shariatgorj et al. have applied thin-layer eluent system containing MeCN/iPrOH/hexane [149]. chromatography/laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry for facile separation and identification 5.2. Reversed-phase LC of quaternary protoberberine alkaloids from Berberis The optimization of alkaloids’ analysis in RP systems barandana [134]. The silica gel TLC plates were consists in reducing of ion-exchange interactions developed with buthanol, water and CH3COOH. between basic analytes and residual surface silanols. A further field of application of TLC is the purification There are several methods to achieve the reduction of of chromatographic fractions. Tood et al. described the ionic interactions such as: using a mobile phase separation of tropane alkaloids from Convolvulus at low pH (suppression of silanols’ ionization); using arvensis on preparative silica gel plates using eluent a mobile phase at high pH (suppression of alkaloids’ consisting with MeOH/CHCl3/water/ammonia [135]. The ionisation); addition of ion-pairing reagent to mobile extract from Datura stramonium was chromatographed phase (formation of non-polar, non-charged ion-pairs on preparative TLC silica gel plates [136]. Alkaloids with analyte); addition of relative strong bases to eluent were eluted with mixture of CHCl3/DEA. The alkaloidal playing the role of silanol blockers and/or alkaloids fractions from Erythroxylum species were separated on ionization suppressants; selecting a stationary phase. preparative silica gel plates in eluent system containing Some alkaloids were separated in RP system with
MeOH/CHCl3 [137]. Mixture of MeOH/CHCl3/ammonia eluents containing only organic modifier and water. was applied on silica gel preparative plates for purification The ergot alkaloids, fungal secondary metabolites of of Mandragora officinarum plant extract [138]. significant toxicological and pharmacological activities, Table 1 covers some selected TLC methods for were successfully analysed on C18 stationary phase analysis of alkaloids from different classes. with a gradient of 20-70% MeCN in water [150]. The
811 812 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Figure 2. Thin layer chromatography (TLC), high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS) analyses of latex: (a) TLC of three families indicates the presence of the novel salutardine band not seen in the control. The track labeled standards includes reticuline, codamine and laudanine in order of increasing distance from the origin; (b) HPLC confirmed the novel accumulating alkaloid as salutaridine, the salutaridine peak is clearly present at just under 7.6 min retention time, and is absent in the control sample [124]. analyses of alkaloids from Psychotria leiocarpa were Rarely, indole alkaloids were chromatographed in carried out using C18 column and mixture of MeOH / eluent system containing buffer at neutral pH. Mixture water as eluent [151]. The eluent containing only MeOH of MeOH and phosphate buffer at pH 7.0 was applied and water was applied for separation of indole and for separation of oxindole alkaloids from leaves of carbazole alkaloids in Glycosmis montana plant extract Mitragyna inermis [161]. Tang et al. used for analysis of [152] and from Alstonia scholaris [153]. catharanthine and vindoline from Catharanthus roseus Xanthine alkaloids were often successfully analysed an eluent system containing MeCN and phosphate on RP columns in simple eluent systems containing only buffer at slightly acidic pH (6.0) [162]. Eluent system organic modifier and water. Caffeine, theophylline and containing buffer at pH 6.5 has been employed for the theobromine were determined in food samples by HPLC analysis of colchicine in a human specimen [163]. Mobile in eluent system containing MeCN and water [154-156] phase containing mixture of MeOH and water was or MeOH and water [157-159]. The use of a monolithic applied for determination of nicotine [164]. The addition column provided excellent and rapid separation of of ammonium carbonate to the mobile phases was caffeine from the endogenous sample components often used for analysis of ergot alkaloids. Separation of and from structurally similar compounds in less than a these compounds from Claviceps purpurea was carried minute [160]. on C18 column with eluent containing MeCN/water/
811 812 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Figure 3. Videoscans of chromatogram (a) for standards of alkaloids scanned at 366 nm and 254 nm. Eluent systems: I direction: 60% MeOH in water + 2% ammonia; II direction: 10% MeOH in diisopropyl ether + 2% ammonia; and (b) of Fumaria officinalis herb extract scanned at 366 and 254 nm. Eluent systems: I direction: 60% MeOH in water + 2% ammonia; II direction: 10% MeOH in diisopropyl ether + 2% ammonia [128].
(NH4)2CO3 [165-168]. Wang et al. have used for analysis phosphate buffer and (NH4)2SO4 [173]. Nicotine, cotinine of ergot alkaloids the mobile phase consisting of MeCN, and related alkaloids were determined in human urine water and CH3COONH4 [169]. Ergot alkaloids were also and saliva by LC-MS on C18 column with MeOH and analysed with mobile phase containing MeCN/water/ aqueous solution of HCOONH4 [174]. tartaric acid/ammonium chloride [170]. Zhang et al. described LC/ESI-MS method for Quinine was determined on C18 column with eluent determination of isoquinoline alkaloids from Tinospora containing MeOH, MeCN, water and ammonium formate sagittata and Tinospora capillipes [175]. Separation of [171]. Ammonium acetate was added to mixture of alkaloids was performed on C18 column with eluent MeOH and water for separation of nicotine and related consisting of MeOH, MeCN, water and ammonium alkaloids in human plasma [172]. The simple method acetate. should be useful for monitoring tobacco exposure, for The mobile phase containing MeCN/water/ nicotine pharmacokinetic studies, and for determining CH3COONH4 has been employed for determination the usefulness of nicotine biomarkers, including of hepatotoxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids in a medicinal metabolite ratios. Nicotine was also analyzed on C18 plant - Symphytum officinale on C18 column by LC-MS column with multicomponent eluent containing MeOH, [176]. The eluent containing addition of HCOONH4 to a
813 814 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Figure 4. HPTLC chromatogram by AMD of opium extract and standard alkaloids of opium: (1) morphine; (2) codeine; (3) thebaine; (4) papaverine; (5) noscapine; (6) opium extract; eluent used was universal gradient: methanol 100, methanol–dichloromethane 50/50, dichloromethane 100, dichloromethane 100, hexane100; derivatization by Dragendorff reagent [129].
mixture of MeOH and water was used for determination of quinolizidine alkaloids matrine and oxymatrine in rat blood and derma by LC-MS [177]. Swainsonine, a polyhydroxy alkaloid, was chromatographed by LC-MS/MS on C18 column with the
mobile phase containing MeOH, water and CH3COONH4 [178]. Often, particularly in toxicological investigation, there is a need for simultaneous determination of alkaloids belonging to different chemical groups in complex matrices. Plant alkaloids from different classes in serum and urine were separated on C18 column in eluent system MeCN/phosphate buffer at pH 6.5 (Fig. 7) [179].
5.2.1. Mobile phases at acidic pH The use of mobile phase at acidic pH by addition of appropriate buffers or acids suppresses the ionization of free silanol groups on silica surface, which reduces ion exchange mechanism of retention. In the acidic mobile phases, decreases of retention of alkaloids, more symmetrical peaks and increases in system efficiency were often obtained. Indole alkaloids were often analysed on C18 column in eluent systems containing addition of acid or buffer at Figure 5. Schematic diagram of bilateral band compression. acidic pH. In these conditions, alkaloids are in ionic form, A, initial period of the process; B, final stage of the but dissociation of free silanol groups is suppressed. C8 compression. 1, foam to transfer the mobile phase for band compression; 2, mobile phase fronts. Arrows stationary phase and mobile phase containing MeOH, represent eluent movement for band compression; the water and trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) was used for arrow with curly brackets at the end indicates the effect on minor component [130]. separation of alkaloid brachycerine from callus cultures
813 814 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Table 2. Methods used for HPLC of alkaloids with mobile phase at acidic pH.
Alkaloids Source Stationary Eluent Detection Ref. phase
Cinchonine, MeOH/water/CH COONH / synthesis C18 3 4 ESI-MS [211] cinchonidine CH3COOH MeCN/MeOH/water/CH COONH / Fluorescence Quinine tablets C18 3 4 [212] perchloric acid (pH3.0) detection MeCN/MeOH/water/sodium Fluorescence Quinine gels C18 [213] perchlorate/perchloric acid (pH 2.5) detection MeCN/MeOH/water/CH COONH / Fluorescence Quinine pellets C18 3 4 [214] perchloric acid (pH3.0) detection Quinine alkaloids
and their Human plasma C18 MeCN/water/HCOONH4/HCOOH ESI-MS [65] metabolites MeCN/MeOH/water/CH COONa/ Cotinine Serum, urine C8 3 UV [215] CH3COOH/citric acid/TEA (pH4.4)
Nicotine Mushroom C18 MeOH/water/CH3COONH4 (pH 3) UV [216] Nicotine and Human plasma and PFP MeOH/water/ CH COONH /HCOOH MS [69] metabolites urine 3 4 Nicotine, cotinine, trans- 3’hydroxycotinine and norcotinine Human plasma C18 MeCN/water/ CH3COONH4/HCOOH MS/MS [217]
Piperine and its Urine CN MeOH/water/CH COOH MS/MS [218] metabolites 3 Piperine Rat plasma C18 MeCN/water/HCOOH MS/MS [219] Neonantal biological Arecoline C18 MeCN/water/CH COONH (pH 4.3) MS [72] matrices 3 4 Pilocarpine Ocular hydrogels C18 MeCN/water/TFA UV [220] MeCN/water/HCOONH / HCOOH Pilocarpine Pilocarpine species C 2 4 MS/MS [73] (pH 4) Steroidal alkaloids Sarcococca coriacea C18 MeCN/water/HCOOH MS/paraxanthine 3 Carbonated Caffeine C18 MeCN/water/phosphate buffer at pH 3 UV [223] beverages, soft drinks
Caffeine Coffea arabica C18 MeOH/water/H3PO4 UV [224] Caffeine, Jugular vein and
theophylline, cerebral spinal fluid C18 MeCN/THF/water/Na[2HPO4 UV [225] theobromine dialysates
Caffeine Coffee C18 MeOH/water/CH3COOH UV [226]
Caffeine Water samples C18 MeCN/water/ CH3COOH (pH 2.8) MS [227]
Caffeine Camellia sinensis C18 MeCN/water/ CH3COOH UV [228] Caffeine Coffee C18 MeOH/water/HCOOH PDA [229] Caffeine Tablets C18 MeCN/phosphate buffer (pH4) UV [230] Caffeine, Plasma C18 MeOH/water/HCOOH MS/MS [231] theophylline Caffeine, theophylline, Saliva, plasma, urine C18 MeCN/water/HCOOH MS/MS [232] paraxanthine Caffeine Dietary suplements C18 MeCN/MeOH/water/TFA UV [233]
Purine alkaloids Camellia sinsnsis C18 MeCN/water/CH3COOH/EDTA UV [234] Pyrrolizidine Phalaenopsis hybrids C18 MeCN/water H PO UV [235] alkaloids 3 4 Pyrrolizidine Boraginaceae species C18 MeCN/water H PO UV [77] alkaloids 3 4 Pyrrolizidine Pittocaulon species C18 MeCN/water/TFA UV [236] alkaloids Pyrrolizidine Echium glomeratum C18 MeCN/water/HCOOH MS [237] alkaloids
815 816 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
ContinuedTable 2. Methods used for HPLC of alkaloids with mobile phase at acidic pH.
Alkaloids Source Stationary Eluent Detection Ref. phase
Senkirkine, Tussilago farfara C18 MeCN/water/HCOOH MS [74] senecionine Longitarsus jacobaeae, Oreina Pyrrolizidine cacaliae, C18 MeCN/water/TFA MS [239] alkaloids and O. speciosissima Quinolizidine Caulophyllum C18 MeOH/MeCN/water/H PO DAD [240] alkaloids robustum 3 4 Quinolizidine Rat plasma C18 MeCN/water/HCOOH MS [241] alkaloids Diterpene alkaloids Rat plasma C18 MeCN/water/HCOOH DAD/TOFMS [242] MeCN/water/HCOONH / Diterpene alkaloids Human blood plasma C18 4 MS [243] HCOOH Aconitine, hypaconitine, Aconitum carmichaeli C18 MeCN/water/TFA UV [244] mesaconitine Diterpene alkaloids Human plasma C18 MeOH/water/HCOOH MS/MS [245]
Figure 6. Schematic diagram of the interface components and the two positions of the six-port valve TLC/ESI-MS [132].
of Psychotria brachyceras [180]. Similar eluent system speciosa [183]. Volk developed a HPLC-RP method for containing TFA was used for analysis of psychollatine, separation of manifold biologically active indole alkaloids a major indole alkaloid glucoside from Psychotria by using a mobile phase consisting of MeOH and acetate umbellata [181]. Mobile phase containing 0.1% of buffer at pH 3.2 [184]. Schliemann et al. separated formic acid was applied for analyses of terpenoid indole indole alkaloids on C18 column in eluent containing alkaloids from Catharanthus roseus hairy root cultures MeCN/water and acetic acid or phosphoric acid [185]. [182]. Ammonium formate buffer at pH 3.0 was added to Chromatographic analyses of the monoterpene indole mobile phase containing MeCN and water for analysis alkaloid psychollatine were performed using a gradient of mitragynine, an indole alkaloid occurring in Mitragyna based on MeOH/water/acetic acid [186]. Gonzalez-Vera
815 816 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Table 3. Methods used for HPLC of alkaloids with mobile phase at basic pH.
Alkaloids Source Stationary Eluent Detection Ref. phase
Nicotine, cotinine Human serum C8 MeCN/water/ammonia MS [254] Nicotine, cotinine, MeCN/water/CH COONH / meconium C18 3 4 MS/MS [255] 3-hydroxycotinine NH4OH Diterpene alkaloids Aconitum carmichaeli C18 MeCN/water/ammonia MS [70] MeCN/water/ammonium Diterpene alkaloids Aconitum C18 UV [256] bicarbonate/ammonia Aconite-type MeOH/ammonium acetate buffer at Aconitum carmichaelii C8 DAD, MS [257] alkaloids pH 8.9 Brucine, Strychnine, Ephedrine, MeCN/water/ammonium Body fluids C18 DAD [258] Aconitine, bicarbonate/ammonia (pH 10.5) Colchicine
Figure 7. HPLC–UV standard chromatogram of the selected alkaloids in acetonitrile (1.0 lg mL-1) at 205 nm (1: cytisine, 2: anabasine, 3: nicotine, 4: cotinine, 5: codeine (IS), 6: scopolamine, 7: brucine, 8: atropine, 9: colchicine, 10: strychnine, 11: harmine, 12: yohimbine, 13: ibogaine, 14: aconitine). Chromatographic separation was achieved on an EC NUCLEODUR Sphinx RP-C18 HPLC column using a mobile phase mixture of ACN and 0.01 M phosphate buffer pH 6.5 [179]. et al. have satisfactory analysed indole alkaloids using C18 column with eluent containing MeCN/ eluents consisting of MeCN/water/TFA [187]. Ajmalicine water/HCOOH have been utilized for separation of and tetrahydroalstonine in Catharanthus cells were hyoscyamnine and scopolamine from Datura inoxia plant measured by HPLC in eluent system containing the extract [191]. Analysis of withanolides,tropane alkaloids, addition of TFA [188]. Fernandez et al. have determined was achieved on C18 column with uses of MeOH/water/ indole alkaloids from plant species of Papua New Guinea CH3COOH as mobile phase [192]. The mobile phase and Australia using MeOH/water/TFA as mobile phase at pH 3.0 was applied for investigation of tropane on C18 column [189]. HPLC analysis of indoloquinoline alkaloids from Atropa beatica [193]. The quantification alkaloids was performed by using eluent containing of hyoscyamine and scopolamine was performed on MeOH/water/ formic acid [190]. C18 column with MeCN/phosphate buffer at pH3.0
817 818 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Figure 8. Total ion chromatograms of methanolic extract of Aconitum carmichaeli (a) and 15 authentic standards (b) by RRLC/TOFMS with a fragmentor voltage of 120V in positive ion mode. Chromatographic separation was carried out on an Agilent Zorbax Extend C18 column. The mobile phase consisted of 10mM ammonium acetate buffer solution adjusted to pH at 9.6±0.2 with 28% ammonia solution and ACN [253].
[194]. Tropane alkaloids from Schizanthus grahamii [202]. The deactivated and encapped C18 column was were successfully analyzed on graphitic carbon column applied for analysis of colchicine with eluent containing with eluent consisting MeCN/water/HCOOH [195]. The MeOH/water/HCOOH [59]. Eluent system with addition same acidic eluent system was applied for separation of acetic acid has also been used for separation and of antimuscarinic tropane alkaloids in plasma [196]. quantification of ergot alkaloids [203]. For the analysis of Bieri et al. separated alkaloids from the same plant ergot alkaloids, Lolium perenne and Neotyphodium lolii, by using carbon capillary column and acidic aqueous eluent containing MeCN/water/HCOOH was used [204]. mobile phase containing acetic, formic or trifluoroacetic Dong et al. were examined mobile phases at different acids [197]. Basic eluents on the column containing acidic pH (3.6 - 5.6) for analysis of ephedra alkaloids ammonium formate were used also. For quantitative [205]. analysis of hyoscyamines, C18 stationary phase and Principal opium alkaloids were determined on C18
mixture containing MeOH/water/HCOOH was applied stationary phase with MeOH/water CH3COOH [206]. [198]. Buffers for acidification of mobile phase acidic pH Phosphoric acid was added to acidification of mobile were rarely applied. Tropane alkaloids in animal plasma phase for analysis of opium alkaloids [207]. were analyzed on C18 column with eluent containing Many authors have described procedures for phosphate buffer at pH 3.1 [199]. quantification of degradation of nicotine in tobacco by The acidic eluents with addition of acetic acid [126] or microorganisms. Zhong et al. conducted the analyze TFA [200, 201] were used for analysis of colchicine. TFA in chromatographic system: C18 – stationary phase,
was added to mobile phase containing MeCN/water for MeOH/water/KH2PO4 (pH 3) [208]. analysis of another phenethylamine alkaloid mescaline
817 818 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Table 4. Methods used for HPLC of alkaloids with mobile phase containing ion-pairing reagents.
Alkaloids Source Stationary Eluent Detaection Ref. phase
MeCN/water/ Quinine tablets C18 UV [293] H3PO4/hexylamine MCN/THF/H PO / Fluorescsnce Quinine nanocapsules C18 3 4 [294] TEA detection Chloroquine, MeCN/MeOH/water/ Blood samples C18 UV [295] deethylchloroquine DEA MeOH/water/H PO / Nicotine Nicotiana tabacum C18 3 4 UV [296] TEA MeOH/water/KH PO / Nicotine saliva C18 2 4 UV [297] TEA Nicotine tobacco C18 MeCN/water/TEA UV [298]
Pilocarpine standard C18 (monolitic) MeOH/water/H3PO4/TEA DAD [299] Pilocarpus Pilocarpine C18 MeOH/water/H PO /TEA UV [300] microphyllus 3 4 MeCN/water/CH COOH/ Diterpene alkaloids Genus Aconitum C18 3 MS/MS [301] TEA Aconitine-type MeCN/water/CH COOH/ Aconitum Carmichaeli C18 3 MS/MS [302] alkaloids TEA Aconitine, hypaconitine, Urine C18 MeCN/water/TEA DAD [303] mesaconitine Palmatine and its Rat urine C18 MeOH/water/TEA MS/MS [304] metabolites
Beyer et al. determined toxic alkaloids belonging to mixture of MeCN and MeOH with addition of (NH4)2HPO4 different chemical classes in human blood plasma on (pH 7.3) [180]. Verma et al. applied a mixture of MeCN, RP column with eluent containing MeCN and formate MeOH and ammonium acetate buffer as mobile phase buffer at pH 3.5 [209]. for separation of indole alkaloids from Catharanthus Xanthine alkaloids were often analyzed in acidic roseus [181]. Quantification of ajmalicine from shoot eluent containing addition of phosphoric acid to aqueous- cultures of Catharanthus roseus was performed on C18 organic mobile phase [75,210]. stationary phase and in eluent containing methanol Eluent systems at acidic pH were often applied for and diammonium hydrogen phosphate [182]. Lactam analysis of pyrrolizidine alkaloids in different samples ergot alkaloids in sclerotia of Claviceps purpurea were (see Table 2). Most eluent systems for analysis of analysed on C8 stationary phase using a mixture of quinolizidine alkaloids by RP-LC contained the addition MeCN/water/(NH4)2CO3 as mobile phase [183]. The good of different acids such as formic and phosphoric separation of these alkaloids was obtained in a short (Table 2). time of analysis. A similar eluent system was applied for analysis of ergot alkaloids on C8 stationary phase [184]. 5.2.2. Eluents at basic pH Good separation of aconite alkaloids from the roots of Silanol interaction can be reduced by using a high pH Aconitum carmichaeli was obtained by LC coupled with mobile phase, when free silanols are in ionized form but time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOFMS) in positive ionization of alkaloids is suppressed. The use of mobile mode (Fig. 8) [185]. The mobile phase consisted of phases at more basic pH, allowing effective suppression MeCN, water and acetate buffer at pH 9.6. of analyte dissociation, is possible only by using specially Other applications of chromatographic systems prepared, high pH resistant stationary phases. containing eluent at basic pH are presented in Table 3. Lopez et al. have successfully separated vindolin and catharanthine on C18 stationary phase with mobile 5.2.3. Eluents with addition of ion-pairing reagents phase containing acetonitrile and acetic acid-ammonia Ion-pair chromatography (IPC) is often used in analysis buffer at pH 10 [178]. Indole alkaloids from Catharanthus of ionic samples. These are several hypotheses of ion- roseus were analyzed on C18 column with mobile phase pairing in IP-RP systems and the mechanism is still containing MeCN/water with addition of ammonia [179]. discussed [259-263]. The first model assumes formation The pharmacologically important terpenoid indole of ion-pair in polar liquid phase and adsorption of non- alkaloids from Catharanthus roseus hairy roots were charged pair on the adsorbent surface [264-266]. The analysed on C18 column in eluent system containing second model supposes ion-exchange mechanism with
819 820 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Figure 9. HPLC separation of the extracts of Rauvolfia serpentina x Rhazya stricta hybrid cell cultures (R x R17M) at day 5 after treatment with methyl jasmonate. The solvent system employed was: acetonitrile, sodium dihydrogen phosphate (3.9 mM) and hexanesulphonic acid (1.25 mM) at pH 2.5; (b) acetonitrile: sodium dihydrogen phosphate (3.9 mM) and hexanesulphonic acid (1.25 mM) at pH 5.5; and (c) acetonitrile:sodium dihydrogen phosphate (39 mM) and hexanesulphonic acid (2.5 mM) at pH 2.5 [272].
adsorption of counter-ion on the hydrophobic adsorbent and Rhazya stricta on C18 column using eluent surface and formation of ion-exchange layer [267-270]. containing MeCN, sodium dihydrogen phosphate and The next model is connected with dynamic process of hexanesulphonic acid as ion pairing reagent [272]. The formation of ion-exchanger with double electric layer effect of the ion-pairing reagent or buffer concentrations on the adsorbent surface and dynamic equilibrium of and the pH of the mobile phase on the retention were analytes’ ions competing for the access to the layer [271]. examined (Fig. 9). Good results, symmetric peaks and good separation Due to ionic character of tropane alkaloids and their selectivity were obtained in eluent systems containing tendency for strong interactions with free silanol groups addition of ion pairing reagents. Gerasimenko et al. have on surface silica matrix of the RP type stationary phases, separated indole alkaloids from Rauvolfia serpentina ion-pair reagents are frequently used. Cardillo et al.
819 820 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
performed HPLC analysis and quantification of tropane are responsible for blocking of free silanols, leading to alkaloids from Brugmansia candida on RP column with a decrease in the analyzed alkaloids’ retention, and, MeOH/water containing octanesulfonic acid as ion pair at higher concentrations, they cause an increase in reagent [273]. Octanesulfonic acid sodium salt was alkaloid retention because of the suppression of the also used in addition to mobile phase for separation of basic compounds’ retention. hyoscyamine and scopolamine [274]. Triethylamine was added to eluent containing MeOH, Kotzagiorgis et al. have determined pergolide, a MeCN and aqueous ammonium acetate for separation of semi-synthetic ergot alkaloid, by IPC in eluent system indole alkaloids from Catharanthus roseus [281]. Eluent containing MeCN/water/sodium octanesulphonate system containing addition of triethylamine was used [275]. They have used the method for determination for separation of alkaloids from Hordeum species [282]. of photo degradation products of the alkaloid. Ephedra Triethylamine was added to mobile phase for separation alkaloids from Ephedra sinica and Citrus aurantium of alkaloids from Catharanthus roseus [283,284]. Yang et were analyzed with eluent system containing addition al. described separation of vindoline, catharanthine and of SDS to aqueous mobile phase [276]. Eng et al. have vinblastine from Catharanthus roseus [285]. Separation also used an eluent system with addition of SDS for was performed in an eluent system containing a mixture determination of ephedrine in medicinal plants [277]. of MeOH/MeCN/DEA/H3PO4 (pH7.5). HPLC system IPC was also used for separation of opium alkaloids consisted of C18 stationary phase and a mixture of
[278]. Opium samples were analyzed on C18 column MeOH/MeCN/CH3COONH4/TEA has been employed with mobile phase containing MeCN, water, H3PO4 and for the analysis of monoterpenoid indole alkaloids from heptane-1-sulfonic acid as ion-pairing reagent. Catharanthus roseus [286]. Quinine and 3-hydroxyquinine were determined in Tropane alkaloids from Erythroxylum vacciniifolium human plasma by IPC in eluent system: MeOH, MeCN, were determined on C18 column in eluent system water, potassium dihydrogen phosphate and perchloric containing addition of TEA [287]. DEA was added to acid [279]. The method is simple, rapid, selective, eluent for analysis of tropane alkaloids from hairy roots reproducible and cost-effective. The method is also of Anisodus acutangulus [288]. suitable for pharmacokinetic studies of quinine and Hong et al. were separated of ephedra alkaloids 3-hydroquinine. from Ephedra herb on polar-RP column with mixture Cotinine, the main metabolite of nicotine in the human of MeOH/water/phosphoric acid/TEA or MeOH/water/ body, is widely used as a biomarker for assessment of phosphoric acid/dibuthylamine [289]. direct or passive exposure to tobacco smoke. Yang et al. To suppress free silanol groups, an addition of ionic have determined the alkaloid in urine samples by IPC on liquids (IL) to mobile phases can also be applied. Their C18 column with eluent containing MeCN/acetate buffer usefulness for analytical chemistry can be due to their (pH 3.1)/sodium heptanesulfonate [280]. favorable physicochemical properties, such as the lack A simple and highly selective method, based upon of vapor pressure, good chemical and thermal stability, solid-phase extraction (SPE), IPC and UV absorbance as well as very good dissolution properties regarding detection, was developed and validated by Liu et al. both inorganic and organic compounds. The retention to determine alkaloids: lamivudine, oxymatrine and its mechanism using IL additives is very complex, since active metabolite matrine in dog plasma [80]. They have both the anion and the cation contribute to the retention performed analysis of alkaloids on C18 column with of analytes. On the one hand, cations of ionic liquids mixture of MeCN/water/H3PO4/sodium heptanesulfonate coat the surface of the stationary phase to suppress as eluent system. free silanols and thus improve peak shape. On the other hand, part of the ionic liquids move with mobile phase 5.2.4. Eluents with addition of silanol blockers and interact with the analytes – the anions of ionic liquids Systems containing amines in eluents, which play the paired with the cations of analytes to make the analytes role of silanol blockers, are more effective. Thus the more retentive, whereas the cations of ionic liquids improvement of peak symmetry and the efficiency repulse the positively charged alkaloids to reduce their is noticed with narrow and very symmetric peaks. retention [290]. The more basic compound can strongly interact with An ionic liquid-based aqueous two-phase system residual silanols allowing the less basic compound to has been developed as a new pretreatment strategy for interact solely with the alkyl ligand of the stationary the analysis of opium alkaloids in Papaver papaveris phase. The addition of basic silanol blocking agents plant extract [291]. The authors examined the effect of causes two effects depending on the concentration of IL concentration on an alkaloid’s retention. the blocking molecules: at lower concentrations they
821 822 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
the possible ion-pairing with the cationic solutes. The two effects were beneficial on the chromatographic separation. The eluent systems containing the addition of silanol blockers such as TEA or DEA were often applied for analysis of diterpene alkaloids and alkaloids from different groups (see Table 4).
5.2.5. Selecting of stationary phases Good results were obtained by selecting a stationary phase. Optimization of the stationary phase for analysis of alkaloids is mainly achieved by minimizing the interaction between analyte and residual silanols. The specific surface area of stationary phases depends on the chemical structure of the adsorbent and on the technology used in its manufacturing. Because of the solubility of alkaloids in aqueous and aqueous- organic modifier solvents, separation of alkaloids have been accomplished mainly on reversed-phase bonded silica gel. Silica supports are still superior to other supports in terms of efficiency, performance and rigidity. However, protonated alkaloids can interact with residual silanol groups on the stationary phases by ion- exchange mechanism. Thus, in addition to the typically reversed-phase retention mechanism, the ion-exchange mechanism also occurs, which often results in asymmetry of peaks, irreproducible retention, low performance of chromatographic systems and worse separation selectivity. Recently, polar-endcapped and polar- embedded RP phases with incorporated carbamate, amide or urea groups have moved to the center of interest. Besides the commonly used n-alkyl-type reversed-phase columns based on the immobilization of n-alkyl-type ligands onto a silica support, alternative hybrid RP-type phases providing additional interaction sites and properties due to embedded functional groups have become widely accepted and have gained Figure 10. Chromatograms of HPLC separations of quinines and quinidines on different stationary phases: a RP, b cSCX, increased importance. Alternatively, the introduction c PSE-A. Didehydroquinidine (1), Didehydroquinine of hydrophobic π - π active aromatic moieties to the (2), Quinidine (3), Quinine (4), Dihydroquinidine (5), Dihydroquinine(6). Eluents: 5% ACN in water, 0.1% common n-alkyl chain RP-sites generates a concerted
FA (RP), 37.5 mM NH4OAc in MeOH (cSCX), 12.5 mM π - π reversed-phase retention mechanism, which, as NH4OAc in MeOH (PSE-A). UV detection at 254 nm [312]. a consequence of the new functionality, diversifies the common RP-interaction properties. In another study, Bian et al. performed a separation For example, atropine and scopolamine were of marine-type alkaloids on C18 column with mobile successfully determined on pentafluorophenyl (PFP)
phases containing addition of different ILs [292]. The stationary phase with MeCN/water/CH3COONH4 as authors examined the mechanism of separation of mobile phase [305]. The influence of concentration of
alkaloids in eluent systems with ILs additives. Influence CH3COONH4 on retention and separation selectivity was of mobile phase pH, concentration of buffer, the effect of investigated. The PFP column with the same mobile concentration of ILs and the length of ILs alkyl groups phase allowed an excellent separation of ephedrine were also investigated. They have ascertained that alkaloids [306]. The authors optimized concentration
the cations mostly interacted with the stationary phase of CH3COONH4 and column temperature for the best silanol groups, and the anions were responsible for analyte separation in a short time. The peaks’ symmetry
821 822 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
and theoretical plate number obtained for investigated compounds. Zhang et al. investigated the influence of alkaloids were also examined. The proposed method temperature on retention of caffeine [315]. They have was applied for the phytochemical analysis of a variety described the determination of caffeine on different RP of Ephedra samples including plant material. Santana et columns at high temperature. al. carried out a satisfactory separation and quantitative determination of ephedra akaloids – positional isomers 5.3. Chiral separations p-synephrine and m-synephrine in bitter orange- The HPLC enantiomeric separation of racemic indole containing supplements - on PFP stationary phase with alkaloids - tacamonine and related compounds was a mobile phase containing MeOH/water/CH3COONH4 performed using Chiralpak AD and Chiralcel OD as [307]. chiral stationary phases and 2-propanol/hexane as Determination of colchicine was performed on mobile phase [316]. Chiralpak AD column was used for phenyl stationary phase with MeOH/water/ammonium separation of enantiomers of meloscine [317]. acetate [308]. Phenyl column was useful for separation Different tropane alkaloid enantiomers also vary of opium alkaloids [309]. The eluent system contained pharmacokinetically, so that actual blood levels will result MeOH, water and addition of ammonium acetate. from dosing, different turnover and excretion kinetics. The phenyl-hexyl column was used for analysis of For this reason, separation and quantification of tropane ergot alkaloids from Claviceps purpurea with a mixture alkaloid isomers are necessary. Simultaneous analysis of MeCN, water and ammonium carbamate as eluent of R- and S- hyoscamine was performed on chiral AGP [1]. The peaks obtained in the chromatographic system column with eluent system containing MeCN/water/ were symmetrical and well separated. HCOONH4 [198]. Separation of siniquici alkaloids in human serum For separation of ephedrine enantiomers, a chiral after oral intake of a Heimia salicifolia extract were stationary phase of molecularly imprinted polymer (MIP) performed on phenylpropyl stationary phase using and mixture of MeCN/water/CH3COOH was successfully eluent containing MeCN/water/HCOOH [310]. applied [2]. The recognition and binding of template Purine alkaloids from Camellia species were molecules were based on interactions between amino separated on amide-C16 column [311]. HPLC separation and hydroxyl groups of the template and the carboxyl was performed by gradient elution. Mobile phase was group of methacrylic acid, a host molecule in the MIP. composed of MeCN, water and H3PO4. Separation of polycyclic indole alkaloids was Different stationary phases – C18, chiral SCX and performed by Lock and Waldmann on chiral stationary racemic strong cation exchanger PolySulfoethyl-A phase using mixture of tetrahydrofuran (THF) and (PSE-A) - and different chromatographic modes –RP n-hexane [318]. were applied for separation of quinine alkaloids (Fig. 10) [312]. 5.4. UPLC Rarely, for separation of alkaloids, diol stationary Recently UPLC technique was used for separation phase was used. Heavner et al. have determined of alkaloids. UPLC allows better resolution, largely nicotine and their major metabolites in urine on diol due to the small particle size and, with flow rates that column using 100% MeOH as eluent [313]. approach common HPLC (0.1–1 mL min-1), UPLC offers Zhu et al. determined caffeine and theophylline on fast separations. These advantages are important for ionic liquids-based monolithic column with mobile phase sensitivity improvement and sample separation. consisting aqueous solution of NaH2PO4 [314]. The An ultra-performance liquid chromatography/ion authors comprised results obtained on non-ILs based mobility quadruple time-of-flight mass spectrometry monolithic column and ILs-based monolithic column and (UPLC/IM-QTOF-MS) method was developed for they obtained improvement of separation selectivity for profiling the indole alkaloids in yohimbe 319 bark[ ]. ILs-based column. Mobile phase consisted of MeCN, water and aqueous ammonia. 5.2.6. Temperature UPLC was applied for analysis of scopolamine with Temperature is another factor, which can be taken eluent consisting of MeCN/formate buffer at pH 3.0 into account for the optimization of chromatographic [320]. Rapid analysis of ergot alkaloids was carried by separation. Temperature changes also caused changes UPLC with MeOH/water/ammonia [321]. Sachin et al. in retention, system efficiency and peak symmetry. determined piperine analogue using UPLC-gTOF-MS/ For ionizable compounds such as alkaloids, a change MS method [71]. The analysis was performed on C18 of temperature, not only changes the retention that column with MeOH/water as mobile phase. The method can be observed, but also changes the pKa values of was used for a pharmacokinetic study.
823 824 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Zhou et al. proposed a rapid UPLC-MS/MS method bromide (CTAB) at a concentration higher than the critical for the determination of toxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids in micellar concentration, so that a part of the surfactant is plant extracts from Parasenecio and Senecio species present in the form of molecular aggregates – micelles. [322]. UPLC analysis was performed on C18 stationary The retention of compounds is caused by the distribution phase. The mobile phase was composed of MeCN and of the molecules of analytes between aqueous mobile ammonia solution in water. phase, the hydrophobic stationary phase and the UPLC also has been applied for chromatographic micellar pseudo phase [266]. The use of addition of analysis of isoquinoline alkaloids from Chelidonium organic modifier causes increase of peak symmetry and majus [323]. Stationary phase in the method was system efficiency, reduces retention times, and changes C18 column and mobile phase containing MeCN and the separation selectivity. Nicotine was determined in aqueous solution of ammonium acetate adjusted to pharmaceuticals and biological fluids by the method pH 3.0 with acetic acid. Norisoboldine, one of the main on C18 column with a mobile phase containing SDS,
bioactive isoquinoline alkaloids in Linderae radix, was penthanol and aqueous solution of NaH2PO4 and KCl determined by UPLC in chromatographic system C18 with electrochemical detection. MLC method was also column- MeCN/water/HCOOH [324]. used for analysis of piperine in different plant extracts UPLC-MS/MS has been used for analysis of aconitine [267]. The analysis was conducted on C18 stationary in plasma samples on C18 column where the acidic phase in eluent system containing propanol, water,
mobile phase was MeCN, water and HCOOH [325]. NaH2PO4 and SDS. In another study, aconitine was determined by UPLC- MS/MS in basic eluent system consisting of MeCN and 5.6. HILIC aqueous solution of ammonia (pH 11.0 – 11.2) [326]. Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) is a liquid Ibrahim et al. applied a capillary liquid chromatography chromatography technique that uses polar stationary (µHPLC) to separation of quinoline alkaloids using a phases – silica or a polar bonded phases in conjunction
mixture of MeOH, MeCN, water and CH3COONH4 as with a mobile phase containing an appreciable quantity eluent [327]. µHPLC was also used for determination of water combined with a higher proportion of a less of quinine and chloroquinine in human serum This work polar solvent (often acetonitrile). HILIC is important for reports the separation of two alkaloids on µHPLC with the separation of highly polar substances. Good results laser-induced fluorescence detector, the shortest time have been obtained especially for alkaloids with small of analysis within 3 min and the lowest LOD (<2 fmol). molecules, which are weakly retained in RP-LC mode. A UPLC method for the identification and quantification The benzodioxole-indole alkaloids from Narcissus of pharmaceutical preparations, containing paracetamol were determined by HPLC-MS on HILIC column with and/or acetyl salicylic acid, combined with anti- the linear gradient of mobile phase containing MeOH/ histaminics (phenylephrine, pheniramine maleate, MeCN/aqueous 1 mM ammonium acetate [332]. diphenhydramine, promethazine) and/or alkaloids, Vuppala et al. have described analysis of mitragynine in quinine sulphate, caffeine or codeine phosphate, rat plasma on UPLC HILIC column with a mobile phase
was developed (Fig. 11) [328]. The identification and consisting of MeCN/HCOONH4/HCOOH [333]. The quantification of these compounds was performed on method showed excellent sensitivity, linearity, precision, C18 column by use an eleunt containing MeOH, water accuracy and was successfully applied to evaluate and ammonium acetate (pH4.0). the pharmacokinetic parameters after intravenous Separation of nicotine and related alkaloids was administration of mitragynine to rats. carried out on HILIC column [329]. Mobile phase For separation of cocaine and their metabolites, consisted of MeCN, water, formate buffer at pH 3.0. Giroud et al. achieved HILIC mode separation with
The authors obtained good chromatographic results MeCN/CH3COONH4 at pH 4.5 as eluent [334]. especially as coupled with short run times allowed by Iwasaki et al. presented a sensitive and specific UHPLC and very good chromatographic performance, method HILIC-MS/MS method for the simultaneous peak shape and enhanced sensitivity associated with quantification and detection of nicotine and its HILIC mode. metabolites in human maternal and cord sera [68]. The separation was achieved on HILIC column with mobile 5.5. MLC phase containing MeCN, water and HCOOH. Some alkaloids were analyzed by use of micellar liquid chromatography (MLC). MLC differs from RP mode by 5.7. ICE the mobile phase, which contains a surfactant such as Different retention mechanism in ion-exchange sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), cethyltrimethylammonium chromatography (ICE) often leads to quite different
823 824 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Figure 11. Chromatograms of HPLC separations of pharmaceutical preparations. HPLC was performed on an Acquity UPLC TM system. The gradient was performed on Acquity BEH C18 column, starts at 95% ammonium acetate buffer pH 4 and 5% methanol. The initial conditions are kept for 1 min, before going to a plateau of 50% buffer and 50% methanol in 9 min [328].
825 826 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
separation selectivity of ionic compounds. High preparative column in gradient eluent system containing efficiencies and symmetrical peaks can be obtained by MeCN and water [342,343]. Two monoterpene indole IEC using relatively simple eluents (buffer or organic/ alkaloids were separated on preparative C18 column buffer mixtures). Retention of compounds in this method using MeOH and water eluent system [344]. Sarker et depends primarily on the kind of stationary phases, the al. have separated methanolic extract from Centaurea ionic strength of eluent (kind and concentration of buffer), cyanus on C18 preparative HPLC column using as pH and in some cases the addition of organic modifiers. eluent mixture of MeOH and water [345]. Cytotoxic Nakamura et al. performed determination of atropine and bisindole alkaloids from Melodinus fusiformis were scopolamine on strong cation exchange (SCX) column isolated by preparative RP-HPLC with aqueous
with mixture containing MeCN/water/KH2PO4/H3PO4 as methanolic eluent [346]. Semi-preparative C18 DB
mobile phase [335]. A mixture of MeCN/water HNO3 column was applied for final purification of alkaloidal was used as eluent for separation of ephedra alkaloids fractions obtained from Penicillium crustosum [347]. by ion chromatography [336]. The authors studied the Mixture of MeOH and water was used for purification of
effect of concentration of MeCN or HNO3 on retention extract fractions obtained from Neonauclea sessilifolia of analyzed alkaloids. The method has been applied [348], Uncaria villosa [349], Bupleurum chienese [350], successfully to the determination of these compounds Aspergillus fumigatus [351], Isatis indigotica [352], and in Ephedra herbs and in pharmaceutical preparations. Candida albicans [353]. The eluent containing MeOH/ Good separation and symmetrical peaks were THF/water was applied for purification of alkaloidal obtained for alkaloids belonging to phenylethylamine fractions from Alstonia angustiloba [354]. Mixture of derivatives by IEC method. HPLC separation and MeCN and water composed mobile phase was used for quantification of psychoactive herbal phenylethylamine preparative separation of (bis)indole alkaloids isolated alkaloids in human plasma was performed on SCX from Aplysinopsis reticulata [355]. The preparative HPLC column with mobile phase containing MeCN/water/ method has also been used for purification of alkaloidal
HCOONH4/HCOOH at pH 3.0 [107]. fraction obtained from Gelsemium elegans [356]. The Morgan et al. analyzed quinine and quinidine on eluent in this method consisted of a mixture of MeOH SCX column using eluent containing MeOH, water and and water with addition of DEA. The purification of plant ammonium perchlorate [337]. The high efficiencies, good extract obtained from Alstonia pneumatophora was peak shapes and fast analysis times were obtained. carried out in eluent at acidic pH (MeOH/water/TFA) Cation exchange column was applied for analysis [357]. A similar eluent system containing MeCN/water/ of pilocarpine [338]. Mixture of MeOH and aqueous TFA has also been used for purification of alkaloidal
solution of HCOONH4 was used in the method as the fractions obtained from Alstonia macrophylla [188]. mobile phase. Preparative HPLC C18 column with eluent of
MeOH/water/H3PO4 was applied for purification of 5.8. Preparative HPLC alkaloid fractions obtained from Merremia genus plant Preparative HPLC method was used for purification of extracts [358]. Separation of alkaloids from Datura indole alkaloidal fractions of plant extracts [339]. The metel was performed on preparative C18 column with isolation of indole alkaloids on semiprepartive scale was a mixture of MeOH and water as mobile phase [359]. performed by HPLC. Eluents used in preparative HPLC Ephedra alkaloids from a traditional Chinese for isolation or purification of different indole alkaloids medicinal herb – Ephedra sinica – were isolated in often consisted of a mixture of organic modifier (usually a chromatographic system: silica gel column as a
MeOH) and water without addition of buffers or other stationary phase and MeOH/CHCl3 as an eluent [360]. reagents. Ma et al. have isolated alkaloids from Uncaria Tetrahydrobenzylisoquinoline alkaloids were isolated rhynchophylla plant extract on C18 preparative column by preparative HPLC in RP system [361]. Casale et al. using mixture of methanol and water as eluent [340]. have performed preparative isolation of opium alkaloids Purification of Mitragyna inermis plant extract fraction on C18 column with eluent consisting of MeCN/water/ containing oxindole alkaloids was performed on silica TFA [362]. column with dichloromethane and acetone as mobile Nyshiyama et al. used preparative HPLC for phase [161]. Gradient elution on preparative C18 separation of tertiary isoquinoline alkaloids from Xylopia column was used for purification of alkaloidal fraction parviflora [363]. Separation was performed on C18 from Cortinarius brunneus [341]. The alkaloidal fraction column with mobile phase containing MeCN, water and
obtained from Malassezia furfur was purified on C8 HClO4.
825 826 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
6. Conclusions pH silanol ionization is suppressed, then it could lead to a decrease of retention, improvement of peak shape Alkaloids from different chemical groups have been and system efficiency. Rarely, for separation of alkaloids widely analyzed by different LC methods. Several mobile phases at basic pH were used when ionization separation and detection methods have been developed of investigated compounds is suppressed. Good and applied for the qualitative and quantitative analysis symmetry of peaks and good separation selectivity has in plant materials, extracts, dietary supplements, body been obtained in eluent systems containing addition of fluids and other natural samples. ion pairing reagents. Very good results were received Most TLC separation often coupled with densitometry in many cases when silanol blockers, such as amines, is carried out on silica gel plates with nonaqueous were added to eluents. Good results were also obtained eluents consisting of mixtures of MeOH, CHCl3, AcOEt, by selecting a stationary phase. Optimization of the
CH2Cl2, and Me2CO. Addition of ammonia or amines such stationary phase for analysis of basic compounds, such as DEA or TEA to mobile phase was often applied for as alkaloids, is achieved by minimizing the interaction improvement of spot shape and separation selectivity. between analyte and residual silanols. Good separation of alkaloids and system efficiency was Use of UPLC methods for analysis of some alkaloids obtained by use of special development TLC technique allows for better resolution and significant decrease of such as 2D TLC or AMD. analysis time. In most cases, HPLC analysis of alkaloids is performed Alternative HPLC methods such as HILIC and ICE in RP systems. Some alkaloids (tropane, xanthine) were have gained increasing attention and have been applied successfully determined in eluent systems containing to the selective and rapid analysis of selected alkaloids. only organic modifier and water or buffer at neutral pH, The high efficiencies, good peak shapes and fast but most alkaloids in such eluent systems are poorly analysis times were obtained by using these methods. separated and peaks obtained on chromatograms are LC-hyphenated techniques such as LC-MS and very asymmetrical. Therefore, eluents at acidic pH, LC-NMR are especially attractive providing both obtained by addition of acids or appropriate buffers, were chromatographic and, at least, partial structural often applied in analysis of alkaloids from all groups. If information simultaneously.
References
[1] C. Müller, H.S. Klaffke, W. Krauthause, [10] G. Laus, D. Brossner, K. Keplinger, R. Wittkowski, Mycotoxin Research 22, 197 (2006) Phytochemistry 45, 855 (1997) [2] K. Balamurugan, K. Gokulakrishnan, T. Prakasam, [11] J. Wang, C. Machado, D.G. Panaccione, H.-F.Tsai, Arabian Journal of Chemistry (2011) (In press) C.L. Schardl, Fungal Genet.Biol. 41, 189 (2004) doi:10.1016/j.arabjc.2011.06.024 [12] F. Berthiller, M. Sulyok, R. Krska, R. Schuhmacher, [3] D. Sykora, E. Tesarova, M. M. Popl, J. Chromatogr. Int. J. Food Microbiol. 119, 33 (2007) A 758, 37 (1997). [13] H. Takayama, Y. Matsuda, K. Masubuchi, A. Ishida, [4] T. Fornstedt, G. Zhong, G. Guichon, M. Kitaima, N. Aimi, Tetrahedron 60, 893 (2004) J. Chromatogr.A. 741, 1 (1996) [14] R. Pilarski, H. Zielińsk, D. Ciesiołka, K. Gulewicz, [5] J. Wang, Y. Zheng, T. Efferth, R. Wang, Y. Shen, J. Ethnoparmacol. 104, 18 (2006) X.Hao, Phytochemistry 66, 697 (2005) [15] J. Zhang, Y. Yu, D. Liu, Z. Liu, Phytomedicine 14, [6] B. Hemmateenejad, A. Abbaspour, H. Maghami, 50 (2007) R. Miri, M.R. Panjehshahin, Anal. Chem. Acta 575, [16] V. Fragoso, N.C. do Nascimento, D.J. Moura, 209 (2006) A.C.R. Silva, M.F. Richter, J. Saffi, A.G. Fett-Neto, [7] J. Penelle, P. Christen, J. Molgo, M. Tits, V. Brandt, Toxicology in Vitro 22, 559 (2008) M. Frederich, L. Angenot, Phytochemistry 58, 619 [17] S. Uhling, D. Petersen, Toxicon 52, 175 (2008) (2001) [18] J.C.A. Tanaka, C.C. da Silva, I.C.P. Ferreira, [8] K. Keplinger, G. Laus, M. Wurm, M.P. Dierich, G.M.C. Machado, L.L. Leon, A.J.B. de Oliveira, H. Teppner, J. Ethnopharmacol. 64, 23 (1999 Phytomedicine 14, 377 (2007) [9] Y.D. Rattmann, M.R. Terluk, W.M. Souza, [19] I. Brondz, D. Ekeberg, K. Høiland, D. S. Bell, C.A.M. Santos, M.W. Biavatti, L.B. Torres, A.R. Annino, J. Chromatogr. A 1148, 1 (2007) S. Mesia-Vela, L. Rieck, J.E. da Silva-Santos, [20] W.-F. Fong, C. Wang, G.-Y. Zhu, C.-H. Leung, M.C.A. de Marques, J. Ethnopharmacol. 100, 268 M.-S. Yang, H.-Y. Cheung, Phytomedicine 14, 160 (2005) (2007)
827 828 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
[21] A.T. Henriques, S.O. Lopes, J.T. Paranhos, York, 1981) T.S. Gregianini, G.L. Von Poser, A.G. Fett-Neto, [41] B. Drager, A. van Almsick, G. Mrachatz, Planta J. Schripsema, Phytochemistry 65, 449 (2004) Med. 61, 577 (1995) [22] S. Lopes, G.L. von Poser, V.A. Kerber, [42] M. Ylinen, T. Naaranlahti, S. Lapinjoki, F.M. Farias, E.L.Konrath, P. Moreno, M.E. Sobral, A. Huhtikangas, M.L. Salonen, L.K. Simola, J.A.S. Zuanazzi, A.T. Henriques, Biochem. Syst. M. Lounasmaa, Planta Med. 52, 85 (1986) Ecol. 32, 1187 (2004) [43] L. Kursinszki, H. Hank, I. Laszlo, E. Szoke, [23] A.L. de Miranda, J.R. Silva, C.M. Rezende, J. Chromatogr. A 1091, 32 (2005) J.S. Neves, S.C. Parrini, M.L. Pinheiro, [44] R. Keiner, B. Drager, Plant Sci. 150, 171 (2000) M.C. Cordeiro, E. Tamborini, A.C. Pinto, Planta [45] R. Soulimani, C. Younos, S. Jarmouni-Idrissi, Med. 66, 284 (2000) D. Bousta, F. Khalouki, A. Laila, [24] B.R.V. de Aldana, A.G. Ciudad, I. Zabalgogeazcoa, J. Ethnopharmacology 74, 265 (2001) B.G. Criado, Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 93, 169 [46] A.E. Hofmann Jr., C. Sbben, M. Sobral, (2001) J.H.A. Dutilh, A.T. Enriques, J.A.S. Zuanazzi, [25] L. Van De Santos, A.G. Fett-Neto, V.A. Kerber, Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 31, 1455 (2003) E. Elisabetsky, J.-Ch. Quirion, A.T. Henriques, [47] G. Bringmann, C. Günter, W. Saeb, J. Mies, Biochem. System. Ecol. 29, 1185 (2001) R. Brun, L.A. Assi, Phytochemistry 54, 337 (2000) [26] M. Boga, U. Kolak, G.Topçu, F. Bahadori, [48] Q. Zhang, G. Tu, Y. Zhao, T. Cheng, Tetrahedron M. Kartal, N.R. Farnsworth, Phytochemistry Letters 58, 6795 (2002) 4, 399 (2011) [49] H. de Wet, F.R. van Heerden, B.E. van Wyk, [27] K. Jenett-Siems, R. Weigl, M. Kaloga, J. Schulz, Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 33, 799 (2005) E. Eich, Phytochemistry 62, 1257 (2003) [50] J. Potier, N. Galand, J. Chromatogr. A 1080, 186 [28] R. Zarate, C. Dirks, R. van der Heijden, (2005) R. Verpoorte, Plant Sci. 160, 971 (2001) [51] G. Bringmann, F. Teltschik, M. Michael, [29] Y. Sheludko, I. Gerasimenko, M. Unger, S. Busemann, M. Rücker, Phytochemistry 52, 321 I. Kostenyuk, J. Stoeckigt, Plant Cell Rep. 18, 911 (1999) (1999) [52] G. Bringmann, M. Wenzel, M. Rübenacher, [30] H. Strzelecka, Chemiczne metody badania M. Schäffer, M. Rücker, A.A. Laurent, roślinnych surowców leczniczych (Chemical Phytochemistry 49, 1151 (1998) methods of medicinal plants research) 3rd edition [53] L.K. Yang, R.P. Glover, K. Yoganathan, (PZWL, Warsow, 1987) (In Polish) J.P. Sarnaik, A.J. Godbole, D.D. Soejarto, A.D. Buss, [31] M. Dorer, M. Lubej, Deut. Pharm. Ges. 305, 273 M.S. Butler, Tetrahedron Lett. 44, 5827 (2003) (1972) [54] G. Bringmann, K. Messer, K. Wolf, J. Müchlbacker, [32] J. Kuczyński, J. Jusiak, W Gołkiewicz, Method for M. Grüne, Phytochemistry 60, 389 (2002) separation of scopolamine from vegetable raw [55] A. Montagnac, F. Remy, M. Pais, A. Hadi, A. Hamid, material, Polish Patent, PL 157.603 (1973) Phytochemistry 39, 701 (1995) [33] Y. Jia, H. Xie, G. Deng, M. Sun, Zhogguo Zhoggao [56] J. Pothier, N. Galand, C. Viel, J. Planar Chromatogr. Zazhi 198, 480 (1994) 4, 392 (1991) [34] M.A. Fliniaux, F. Manceau, A.J. Dubrenil, [57] L. Krusinszki, A. Sarkozi, A. Kery, E. Szoke, J. Chromatogr. A 644, 193 (1993) Chromatographia 63, S131 (2006) [35] T. Mroczek, K. Głowniak, J. Kowalska, [58] A. Adsersen, B. Gauguin, L. Gudiksen, A.K. Jäger, J. Chromatogr. A 1107, 9 (2006) J. Ethnopharmacol. 104, 418 (2006) [36] A. Brachet, P. Christen, J.L. Veuthey, Phytochem. [59] F.Q. Alali, A. Gharaibeh, A. Ghawanmeh, K. Tawaha, Anal. 13, 162 (2002) N.H. Oberlies, Phytochem. Anal. 19, 385 (2008) [37] A. Brachet, S. Rudaz, L. Mateus, P. Christen, [60] F. Pellati, S. Benvenuti, J. Pharma Biomed. Anal. J.L. Veuthey, J. Sep. Sci. 13, 162 (2001) 48, 254 (2008) [38] A. El-Shazly, A. Tei, L. Witte, M. El-Domiaty, [61] S. Wanwimorluk, S. Wong, H. Hang, P.F. Coville, M. Wink, Z. Naturforsch. C/J. Biosci. 52, 729 J. Liq. Chromatogr. Related Technol. 19, 293 (1997) (1996) [39] The Polish Pharmacopoeia, 4th edition (PZWL, [62] R. Gatti, M.G. Gioia, V. Cavrini, Anal. Chim. Acta Warsaw, 1970) 512, 85 (2004) [40] G.A. Cordell, The introduction to Alkaloids [63] V.F. Samanidou, E.N. Evaggelopoulou, (a Biogenetic Approach) (John Wiley Sons, New I.N. Papadoyannis, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 38, 21
827 828 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
(2005) [84] T.-S. Kam, Y.-M. Choo, Helv. Chim. Acta 87, 366 [64] C. Giround, T. van Leer, R. van der Heijden, (2004) R. Verpoorte, C.E. Heermans, M.W. Niessen, [85] K.-H. Lim, T.-S. Kam, Helv. Chim. Acta 90, 31 J. van der Greek, Planta Med. 57, 142 (1991) (2007) [65] E.M. Hodel, B. Zanolari, T. Mercier, J. Biollaz, [86] G. Subramaniam, Y.-M. Choo, O. Hiraku, J. Keiser, P. Olliaro, B. Genton, L.A. Decosterd, K. Komiyama, T.-S. Kam, Tetrahedron 64, 1397 J. Chromatogr. B 877, 867 (2009) (2008) [66] V.K. Manda, R.K. Mittapalli, K.A. Bohn, [87] M.L. Miranda-Ham, I. Islas-Flores, C.E. Adkins, P.R. Lockman, J. Neurochem. 115, F. Vázquez-Flota, Biochem. Mol. Biol Educ. 35, 1495 (2010) 206 (2007) [67] J. Yang, Y. Hu, J.B. Cai, X.L. Zhu, Q.D. Su, [88] X.-J. Hu, H.-P. He, H. Zhou, Y.-T. Di, X.-W. Yang, Y.Q. Hu, F.X. Liang, Food Chem. Toxicol. 45, 896 X.-J. Hao, L.-Y. Kong, Helv. Chim. Acta 89, 1344 (2007) (2006) [68] Y. Iwasaki, M. Goto, K. Mochizuki, E. Terayama, [89] H. Zhang, J.-M. Yue, Helv. Chim. Acta 88, 2537 R. Ito, K. Saito, N. Sugino, T. Makino, H. Nakazawa, (2005) Biomed. Chromatogr. 25, 503 (2011) [90] J.-J. Chen, Y.-T. Luo, T.-L. Hwang, P.-J. Sung, [69] E.I. Miller, H.-R. K. Norris, D.E. Rollins, S.T. Tiffany, T.-C. Wang, I.-S. Chen, Chem. Biodiversity 5, D.G. Wilkins, J. Chromatogr. B, 878, 725 (2010) 1345 (2008) [70] Y. Xia, M. Xu, R.R. Alexander, J.T. Bernert, [91] Y.W. Zhang, R. Yang, Q. Cheng, K. Ofuji, Helv. J. Chromatogr. B 879, 2142 (2011) Chim. Acta 86, 415 (2003) [71] B.S. Sachin, I.A. Najar, S.C. Sharma, M.K. Verma, [92] C.G. Pereira, M.O.M. Marques, A.S. Barreto, M.V. Reddy, R. Anand, R.K. Khajuria, S. Koul, A.C. Siani, E.C. Fernandes, M.A.A. Meireles, R.K. Johri, J. Chromatogr. B, 878, 823 (2010) J. Supercritical Fliuids 30, 51 (2004) [72] S. Pichini, M. Pellegrini, R. Pacifici, E. Marchei, [93] L. Katoa, R.M. Bragaa, I. Kochb, L.S. Kinoshita, J. Murillo, C. Puig, O. Vall, O. García-Algar, Rapid Phytochemistry 60, 315 (2002) Commun. Mass Spectrom. 17, 1958 (2003) [94] J. Penelle, P. Christen, J. Molgó, M. Tits, V. Brandt, [73] A.C.H.F. Sawaya, B.G. Vaz, M.N. Eberlin, M. Frederich, L. Angenot, Phytochemistry 58, 619 P. Mazzafera, Genet. Resour. Crop. Evol. 58, 471 (2001) (2011) [95] R. Verpoorte, M. Frederich, C. Delaude, [74] Y.-R. Ku, K.-C. Wen, L.-K. Ho, Y.-S. Cheng, L. Angenot, G. Dive, P. Thepenier, M.-J. Jacquier, J. Pharm. Bniomed. Anal. 20, 351 (1999) M. Zeches-Hanrot, C. Lavaud, J.-M. Nuzillard, [75] M.A. Rostagno, N. Manchon, M. D’Arrigo, Phytochemistry Letters 3, 100 (2010) E. Guillamon, A. Villares, A. Garcia-Lafuente, [96] J.C.A. Tanaka, C.C. da Silva, I.C.P. Ferreira, A. Ramos, J.A. Martinez , Anal. Chim. Acta 685, G.M.C. Machado, L.L. Leon, A.J.B. de Oliveira, 204 (2011) Phytomedicine 14, 377 (2007) [76] G. Hosch, H. Wiedenfeld, T. Dingermann, [97] C.-T. Lu, H.-F. Tang, X.-L. Sun, A.-D. Wen, E. Roeder, Phytochem. Anal. 7, 284 (1996) W. Zhang, N. Ma, Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 38, 441 [77] C. Frölich, D. Ober, T. Hartmann, Phytochemistry (2010) 68, 1026 (2007) [98] A.Á.T. Pimenta, R. Braz-Filho, P.G. Delprete, [78] A. Xiong, Y. Li, L.Yang, J. Gao, Y. He, C.Wang, E.B. de Souza, E.R. Silveira, M.A.S. Lima, Z. Wang, J. Pharm. Biomed.Anal. 50, 1070 Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 38, 846 (2010) (2009) [99] H. Tanino, K. Fukuishi, M. Ushiyama K. Okada, [79] Z.H. Wang, D. Guo, Y. He, C.H. Hu, J.Z. Zhang, Tetrahedron 60, 3273 (2004) Phytochem. Anal. 15, 16 (2004) [100] T.-S. Kam, K.-H. Lim, K. Yoganathan, M. Hayashib, [80] X. Liu, L. Li, J. Sun, Y. Sun, T. Zhang, D. Chen, K. Komiyama, Tetrahedron 60, 10739 (2004) Z. He, Chromatographia 63, 483 (2006) [101] S.-J. Tan, W.T. Robinson, K. Komiyama, [81] T. Haarmann, I. Ortel, P. Tudzynski, U. Keller, T.-S. Kam, Tetrahedron 67, 3830 (2011) Chem. Biochem. 7, 645 (2006) [102] S.-E.N. Ayyad, S.A. Basaif, A.T. Al-Saggaf, [82] G.R. Luna-Palencia, C.M. Cerda-Garcia-Rojas, W.M. Alarif, Journal of Saudi Chemical Society M. Rodriguez-Monroy, A.C. Ramos-Valdivia, (2011) (In press) doi:10.1016/j.jscs.2011.02.008 Biotechnol. Prog. 21, 198 (2005) [103] M. Magnotta, J. Murata, J. Chen, V. De Luca, [83] K.-H. Lim, Y.-Y. Low, G.-H.t Tan, T.-S. Kam, Helv. Phytochemistry 67, 1758 (2006) Chim. Acta 91, 1559 (2008) [104] T.M. Lipińska, Tetrahedron 62, 5736 (2006)
829 830 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
[105] K.-H. Lim, T.-S. Kam, Phytochemistry 69, 558 Anal. 15, 27 (2004) (2008) [127] E. Ellington, J. Bastida , F. Viladomat , V. Simanek, [106] R.-B. Volk, J. Appl. Phycol. 18, 145 (2006) C. Codina, Biochem. Sys. Ecol. 31, 715 (2003) [107] J. Beyer, F.T. Peters, T. Kraemer, H.H. Maurer, [128] A. Petruczynik, M. Waksmundzka-Hajnos, J. Mass Spectrom. 42, 150 (2007) T. Michniowski, T. Plech, T. Tuzimski, [108] T.C. Thoden, M. Boppre, J. Hallmann, Pest. M. L. Hajnos, M. Gadzikowska, G. Józwiak, Manag. Sci. 65, 823 (2009) J. Chromatogr. Sci. 45, 447 (2007) [109] A.-U. Rahman, K.F. Khattak, F. Nighat, [129] J. Pothier, N. Galand, J. Chromatogr. A, 1080, 186 M. Shabbir, O. Hemalal, L.M. Tillekeratne, (2005) Phytochemistry, 48, 37 (1998) [130] E. Mincsovics, J. Planar Chromatogr. 23, 190 [110] K. Jenett-Siems, R. Weigl, A. Böhm, P. Mann, (2010) B. Tofern-Reblin, S.C. Ott, A. Ghomian, [131] M. J. Ford, G. J. Van Berkel, Rapid Commun. M. Kaloga, K. Siems, L. Witte, M. Hilker, F. Müller, Mass Spectrom. 18, 1297 (2004) E. Eich, Phytochemistry 66, 1448 (2005) [132] M. Aranda, G. Morlock, Rapid Commun. Mass [111] O. Muñoz, M. Piovano, J. Garbarino, V. Hellwing, Spectrom. 21, 1297 (2007) E. Breitmaier, Phytochemistry 43, 709 (1996) [133] E.L. Harry, J.C. Reynolds, A.W.T. Bristow, [112] A. Brachet, O. Muñoz, M. Gupta, J.-L. Veuthey, I.D. Wilson, C.S. Creaser, Rapid Commun. Mass P. Christen, Phytochemistry 46, 143 (1997) Spectrom. 23, 2597 (2009) [113] P. Rocha, O. Stenzel, A. Parr, N. Walton, [134] M. Shariatgorji, Z. Spacil, G. Maddalo, P.l Christou, B. Dräger, M. J. Leech, Plant Sci. L.B. Cardenas, L.L. Ilag, Rapid Commun. Mass 162, 905 (2002) Spectrom. 23, 3655 (2009) [114] R. Keiner, B. Dräger, Plant Sci.150, 171 (2000) [135] F.G. Todd, F.R. Stermitz, P. Schultheis, A.P. Knight, [115] T.D. Nikam, R.S. Savant, Physiol. Mol. Biol. Plants J. Traub-Dargat, Phytochemistry, 39, 301 (1995) 15, 71 (2009) [136] R. Duran-Patrona, D. O’Hagana, J.T.G. Hamilton, [116] Y. Nishiyama, M. Moriyasu, M. Ichimaru, C.W. Wonga, Phytochemistry 53, 777 (2000) M. Sonoda, K. Iwasa, A. Kato, F.D. Juma, [137] J.A.S. Zuanazzi, V. Tremea, R.P. Limberger, S.G. Mathenge, P.B.C. Mutiso, J. Nat. Med. 61, M. Sobral, A.T. Henriques, Biochem. Sys. Ecol. 56 (2007) 29, 819 (2001) [117] G. Bringmann, C. Günther, J. Mühlbacher, [138] R.K. Suleiman, M.A. Zarga, S.S. Sabri, Fitoterapia M.D. Lalith, P. Gunathilake, A. Wickramasinghe, 81, 864 (2010) Phytochemistry 53, 409 (2000) [139] C. Bucher, C. Sparr, W.B. Schweizer, R. Gilmour, [118] T. Mroczek, K. Głowniak, J. Kowalska, Chem. Eur. J. 15, 7637 (2009) J. Chromatogr. A, 1107, 9 (2006) [140] P. Duret , M.A. Fakhfakh, C. Herrenknecht, [119] A. Singh, N.K. Nirala, S. Das, A. Narula, A. Fournet, X. Franck, B. Figadere, M.V. Rajam, P.S. Srivastava, Acta Physiol. Plant. R. Hocquemiller, J. Chromatogr. A 1011, 55 33(6), 2453 (2011) (2003) [120] H.R. El-Seedi, P.A.G.M. De Smet, O. Beck, [141] S.-E. Lee, M.-R. Kim, J.-H. Kim, G. R. Takeoka, G. Possnert, J.G. Bruhn, J. Ethnopharmacol. 101, T.-W. Kim, B.-S. Park, Phytomedicine 15, 533 238 (2005) (2008) [121] E. Bodoki, R. Oprean, L. Vlase, M. Tamas, [142] C. Ferreira, D.C. Soares, C.B. Barreto-Junior, R Sandulescu, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 37, 971 M.T. Nascimento, L. Freire-de-Lima, J.C. Delorenzi, (2005) M.E.F. Lima, G.C. Atella, E. Folly, T.M.U. Carvalho, [122] V. Mirakor, V. Vaidya, S. Menon, P. Champanerker, E.M. Saraiva, L.H. Pinto-da-Silva, Phytochemistry A. Laud, J. Planar Chromatogr. 21, 187 (2008) 72, 2155 (2011) [123] S. Khatoon, M. Srivastava, A.K.S. Rawat, [143] D. Suresh, H. Manjunatha, K. Srinivasan, J. Food S. Mehrotra, J. Planar Chromatogr. 18, 364 Compos. Anal. 20 (2007) 346 (2005) [144] K.C. Patra, K.J. Kumar, J. Planar Chromatogr. 23, [124] R.S. Allen, J.A.C. Miller, J.A. Chitty, A.J. Fist, W.L. 293 (2010) Gerlach, P.J. Larkin, Plant Biotechnol. J. 6, 22 [145] C. Cimpoiu, A. Hosu, L. Seserman, M. Sandru, (2007) V. Miclaus, J. Sep. Sci. 33, 3794 (2010) [125] C. L. Gopu, S. Aher, H. Mehta, A. R. Paradkar, [146] Y. Koshiro, X.-Q. Zheng, M.-L. Wang, C. Nagai, K. R. Mahadzik, Phytochem. Anal. 19, 116 (2008) H. Ashihara, Plant Sci. 171, 242 (2006) [126] F. Alali, K. Tawaha, R. M. Qasaymeh, Phytochem. [147] M. Aranda, G. Morlock, J. Chromatogr. A 1131,
829 830 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
253 (2006) [170] M. Ruhland, J. Tischler, Mycotoxin Research 24, [148] G. Guella, I. N’Diaye, M. Fofana, I. Mancini, 73 (2008) Tetrahedron 62, 1165 (2006) [171] C.M.Y. Ong, C.M. Heard, Int. J. Pharm. 366, 58 [149] W.Ternes, E.L. Krause, Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 374, (2009) 155 (2002) [172] I. Kim, M.A. Huestis, J. Mass Spectrom. 41, 815 [150] T. Haarmann, I. Ortel, P. Tudzynski, U. Keller, (2006) Chem. Biochem. 7, 645 (2006) [173] Y.J. Yuan, Z.X. Lu, L.J. Huang, X.M. Bie, F.X. Lu, [151] A.T. Henriques, S.O. Lopes, J.T. Paranhos, Y. Li, J.App. Microbiol. 101, 691 (2006) T.S. Gregianini, G. Lino Von Poser, A.G. Fett-Neto, [174] H.R. Inoue, K. Yagi, K. Saito, J. Pharm. Biomed. J. Schripsema, Phytochemistry 65, 449 (2004) Anal. 49, 108 (2009) [152] J. Wang, Y. Zheng, T. Efferth, R. Wang, Y. Shen, [175] Y. Zhang, Q. Shi, P. Shi, W. Zhang, Y. Cheng, X. Hao, Phytochemistry 66, 697 (2005) Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 20, 2328 [153] F. Wang, F.-C. Ren, J-K. Liu, Phytochemistry 70, (2006) 650 (2009) [176] F. Liua, S.Y. Wana, Z. Jianga, S.F.Y. Li, E.S. Ong, [154] F. Baumann, R. Regenthal, I.L. Burgos-Guerrero, J.C.C. Osorio, Talanta 80, 916 (2009) U. Hegerl, R. Preiss, J. Chromatogr. B 878, 107 [177] H. Zheng, G. Chen, L. Shi, Z. Lou, F. Chen, J. Hu, (2010) J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 49, 427 (2009) [155] P.D. Tzanavaras, D.G. Themelis, Anal. Chim. Acta [178] D.R. Gardner, D. Cook, Phytochem. Anal. 22, 124 581, 89 (2007) (2011) [156] Z. Lou, C. Er, J. Li, H. Wang, S. Zhu, J. Sun, Anal. [179] J. Pietsch, J. Günther, T. Henle, J. Dreßler, J. Sep. Chim. Acta 716, 49 (2012) Sci. 31, 2410 (2008) [157] C. Hua Jin, J.W. Lee, K.H. Row, J. Sep. Sci. 31, [180] T.S. Gregianini, V.C. da Silveira, D.D. Porto, 23 (2008) V.A. Kerber, A.T. Henriques, A.G. Fett-Neto, [158] Z. Tao, R.K. Ho, Chin. J. Chem. 28, 1463 (2010) Photochem. Photobiol. 78, 470 (2003) [159] M. del Rosario Brunetto, L. Gutiérrez, Y. Delgado, [181] J.T. Paranhos, V. Fragoso, V.C. da Silveira, M. Gallignani, A. Zambrano, A. Gómez, G. Ramos, A.T. Henriques, A.G. Fett-Neto, Biochem. Syst. C. Romero, Food Chemistry 100, 459 (2007) Ecol. 37, 707 (2009) [160] H. Wang, L. Chen, Y. Xu, Q. Zeng, X. Zhang, [182] S. Goklany, R.H. Loring, J. Glick, Q. Zhao, L. Ding, Food Sci. Technol. 44, 1490 C.W.T. Lee-Parsons, Biotechnol. Prog. 25, 1289 (2011) (2009) [161] J. Fiot, B. Baghdikian, L. Boyer, V. Mahiou, [183] A.A. Philipp, D.K. Wissenbach, S.W. Zoerntlein, N. Azas, M. Gasquet, P. Timon-David, O.N. Klein, J. Kanogsunthornratc, H.H. Maurer, G. Balansard, E. Ollivier, Phytochem. Anal. 16, 30 J. Mass. Spectrom. 44, 1249 (2009) (2005) [184] R.B. Volk, Microbiol. Res. 163, 307 (2008) [162] K.X. Tang, D.H. Liu, Y.L. Wang, L.J. Cui, [185] W. Schliemann, B. Schneider, V. Wray, J. Schmidt, W.W. Ren, X.F. Sun, Rus. J. Plant Physiology 58, M. Nimtz, A. Porzel, H. Böhm, Phytochemistry 67, 415 (2011) 191 (2006) [163] J. Pietsch, J. Günther, T. Henle, J. Dreßler, J. Sep. [186] V. Fragoso, N. Cannes do Nascimento, Sci. 31, 2410 (2008) D.J. Moura, A.C. Romano e Silva, M.F. Richter, [164] S.N. Wang, Z. Liu, P. Xu, J. App. Microbiol. 107, J. Saffi, A.G. Fett-Neto, Toxicology in Vitro 22, 559 838 (2009) (2008) [165] T. Haarmann, C. Machado, Y. Lübbe, T. Correia, [187] J.A. González-Vera, M.T. García-López, C.L. Schardl, D.G. Panaccione, P. Tudzynski, R. Herranz, Tetrahedron 63, 9229 (2007) Phytochemistry 66, 1312 (2005) [188] H. Arai, Y. Hirasawa, A. Rahman, [166] D. Mulaca, H.-U. Humpf, Toxicology 282, 112 I. Kusumawati, N.C. Zaini, S. Sato, C. Aoyama, (2011) J. Takeo, H. Morita, Bioorg. Med. Chem.18, 2152 [167] S. Uhlig, D. Petersen, E. Rolèn, W. Egge-Jacobsen, (2010) T. Vrålstad, Phytochem. Lett. 4, 79 (2011) [189] L.S. Fernandez, M.L. Sykes, K.T. Andrews, [168] U. Lauber, R. Schnaufer, M. Gredziak, V.M. Avery, Int. J. Antimicrob. Agents 36, 275 Y. Kiesswetter, Mycotoxin Research 21, 258 (2010) (2005) [190] G. Van Baelen, S. Hostyn, L. Dhooghe, [169] J. Wang, C. Machado, D.G. Panaccione, H.-F. Tsai, P. Tapolcsányi, P. Mátyus, G. Lemičre, C.L. Schardl, Fung. Gen. Biol. 41, 189 (2004) R. Dommisse, M. Kaiser, R. Brun, P. Cos,
831 832 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
L. Maes, G. Hajós, Z. Riedl, I. Nagy, B.U.W. Maes, [210] J. Zhanga, B. Michniak-Kohn, Int. J. Phar maceut. L. Pieters, Bioorg. Med. Chem. 17, 7209 (2009) 421, 34 (2011) [191] C. Jousse, T.D. Vu, T.L.M. Tran, M.H.A. Balkhi, [211] I. Bucsi, M. Sutyinszki, K. Felföldi, M. Bartók, R. Molinié, M. Boitel-Conti, S. Pilard, D. Mathiron, Catal. Commun. 7, 104 (2006) A. Hehn, F. Bourgaud, E. Gontier, Phytochem. [212] E. Kayitarea, C. Vervaet, E. Mehuys, Anal. 21, 118 (2010) P.C. Kayumba, J.D. Ntawukulilyayo, C. Karema, [192] R.S. Sangwan, N.D. Chaurasiya, P. Lal, L. Misra, Van Bortel, J.P. Remon, Int. J.Pharmaceut. 392, R. Tuli, N.S. Sangwan, Physiol. Plant. 133, 278 29 (2010) (2008) [213] A.A. Koffi, F. Agnely, M. Besnard, J. Kablan [193] N. el Jaber-Vazdekiz, F. Gutierrez-Nicolas, Brou, J.L. Grossiord, G. Ponchel, Eur. J. Pharm. Á.G. Ravelo, R. Zárate, Phytochem. Anal. 17, 107 Biopharm. 69, 167 (2008) (2006) [214] P.C. Kayumba, N. Huyghebaert, C. Cordella, [194] S.-M. Kang, H.-Y. Jung, Y.-M. Kang, D.-J. Yun, J.D. Ntawukuliryayo , C. Vervaet, J.P. Remon, Eur. J.-D. Bahk, J.-k. Yang, M.-S. Choi, Plant Sci. 166, J. Pharm. Biopharm. 66, 460 (2007) 745 (2004) [215] G.O. Petersen, C.E. Leite, J.M. Chatkin, [195] S. Bieri, E. Varesio, J.-L. Veuthey, O. Muñoz, F.V. Thiesen, J. Sep. Sci. 33, 516 (2010) L.-H. Tseng, U. Bramann, M. Spraul, P. Christen, [216] H. Wang, Q. Zhao, W. Song, Y. Xu, X. Zhang, Phytochem. Anal. 17, 78 (2006) Q. Zeng, H. Chen, L. Ding, N. Ren, Talanta 85, [196] H. John, T. Binder, H. Höchstetter, H. Thiermann, 743 (2011) Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 396,751 (2010) [217] D.M. Shakleya, M.A. Huestis, J.Chromatogr. B, [197] S. Bieri, E. Varesio, O. Muñoz, J.-L. Veuthey, 877, 3537 (2009) P. Christen, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 40, 545 [218] S. Bajad, R.K. Khajuria, O.P. Suri, K.L. Bedi, (2006) J. Sep. Sci. 26, 943 (2003) [198] H. John, F. Eyer, T. Zilker, H. Thiermann, Anal. [219] J. Liu, Y. Bi, R. Luo, X. Wu, J.Chromatogr. B, 879, Chim. Acta 680, 32 (2010) 2885 (2011) [199] P. K. Harrison, J. E. H. Tattersall, E. Gosden, Arch. [220] S.N.S. Anumolu, Y. Singh, D. Gao, S. Stein, Pharmacol. 373, 230 (2006) P.J. Sinko, J. Control. Release 137, 152 (2009) [200] D. Satpati, A. Korde, U. Pandey, P. Dhami, [221] S.G. Musharraf, M. Goher, A. Ali, A. Adhikari, S. Banerjee, M. Venkatesh, J. Label Compd. M.I. Choudhary, A. Rahman, Steroids 77, 138 Radiopharm 49, 951 (2006) (2012) [201] S.Y. Cho, E. Fox, C. McCully, J. Bauch, K. Marsh, [222] V. Perera, A.S. Grossa, A.J. McLachlan, Biomed. F.M. Balis, Cancer Chemother. Pharmacol. 60, Chromatogr. 24, 1136 (2010) 563 (2007) [223] K.-H. Chou, L.N. Bell, J. Food Sci. 72, 337 (2007) [202] O. Ogunbodede, D. McCombs, K. Trout, P. Daley, [224] Y. Dessalegn, M.T. Labuschagne, G. Osthoff, M. Terry, J. Ethnopharmacol. 131, 356 (2010) L. Herselman, J. Sci. Food Agric. 88, 1726 (2008) [203] R. Mohamed, E. Gremaud, J. Richoz-Payot, [225] T.W. Vickroy, S.-K. Chang, C.-C. Chou, J. vet. J.-C. Tabet, P.A. Guy, J.Chromatogr. A, 1114, 62 Pharmacol. Therap. 31, 156 (2008) (2006) [226] R. Davicino, R. Alonso, C. Anesini, J. Food [204] A. Koulman, G.A. Lane, M.J. Christensen, Biochem. 35, 877 (2011) K. Fraser, B.A. Tapper, Phytochemistry 68, 355 [227] M. Pedrouzo, S. Reverté, F. Borrull, E. Pocurull, (2007) R.M. Marcé, J. Sep. Sci. 30, 297 (2007) [205] X. Dong, W. Wang, S. Ma, H. Sun, Y. Li, J. Guo, [228] Q. Chen, Z. Guo, J. Zhao, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. J. Chromatogr. A 1070, 125 (2005) 48, 1321 (2008) [206] B. Tisserat, M. Berhow, Eng. Life Sci. 9, 190 [229] I. Hečimović, A. Belščak-Cvitanović, D. Horžic´, (2009) D. Komes, Food Chem. 129, 991 (2011) [207] J. Ziegler, S. Voigtländer, J. Schmidt, R. Kramell, [230] M. Ito, T. Suzuki, S. Yada, A. Kusai, H. Nakagami, O. Miersch, C. Ammer, A. Gesell, T.M. Kutchan, E. Yonemochi, K. Terada, J. Pharm. Biomed.Anal. The Plant Journal 48, 177 (2006) 47, 819 (2008) [208] W. Zhong, C. Zhu, M. Shu, K. Sun, L. Zhao, [231] Y. Zhang, N. Mehrotra, N.R. Budha, C. Wang, Z. Ye, J. Chen, Bioresour. Technol. 101, M.L. Christensen, B. Meibohm, Clin. Chim. Acta 6935 (2010) 398, 105 (2008) [209] J. Beyer, F.T. Peters, T. Kraemer, H.H. Maurer, [232] A.S. Ptolemy, E. Tzioumis, A. Thomke, S. Rifai, J. Mass Spectrom. 42, 621 (2007) M. Kellogg, J. Chromatogr. B, 878, 409 (2010)
831 832 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
[233] J. Castro, T. Pregibon, K. Chumanov, P.T. Pollak, D.R. Brocks, Biomed. Chromatogr. 25, R.K. Marcus, Talanta 82, 1687 (2010) 1124 (2011) [234] K. Wei, L.-Y. Wang, J. Zhou, W. He, J.-M. Zeng, [255] X. Wang, Z. Pi, W. Liu, Y. Zhao, S. Liu, Chin. J. Y.-W. Jiang, H. Cheng, Food Chem. 130, 720 Chem. 28, 2494 (2010) (2012) [256] Z.-H. Jiang, Y. Xie, H. Zhou, J.-R. Wang, Z.-Q. Liu, [235] C. Frölich, T. Hartmann, D. Ober, Phytochemistry Y.-F. Wong, X. Cai, H.-X. Xu, L. Liu, Phytochem. 67, 1493 (2006) Anal. 16, 415 (2005) [236] J.C. Marín-Loaiza, L. Ernst, T. Beuerle, [257] D. Csupor, E.M. Wenzig, I. Zupko, K. Wolkart, C. Theuring, C.L. Céspedes, T. Hartmann, J. Hohmann, R. Bauer, J. Chromatogr. A, 1216, Phytochemistry 69, 154 (2008) 2079 (2009) [237] F.Q. Alali, Y.R. Tahboub, E.S. Ibrahim, A.M. Qandil, [258] P. Qiu, X. Chena, X. Chen, L. Lin, C. Ai, K. Tawaha, J.P. Burgess, A. Sy, Y. Nakanishi, J. Chromatogr. B, 875, 471 (2008) D.J. Kroll, N.H. Oberlies, Phytochemistry 69, 2341 [259] J. Crommen, G. Shill, L. Hackzell, D. Westerlund, (2008) Chromatographia 24, 252 (1987) [238] Z. Jiang, F. Liu, J.J.L. Goh, L. Yu, S.F.Y. Li, [260] J. Stahlberg, Chromatographia 24, 820 (1987) E.S. Ong, C.N. Ong, Talanta 79, 539 (2009) [261] P. Jandera, J. Churaček, B. Taraba, J. Chromatogr. [239] I. Narberhaus, U. Papke, C. Theuring, T. Beuerle, 262, 121 (1983) T. Hartmann, S. Dobler, J.Chem. Ecol. 30, 2003 [262] J. Inczedy, F. Szokoli, J. Chromatogr. 508, 309 (2004) (1990) [240] Y. Li, Z. Hu, L. He, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 43, [263] C. J. Jones, N. Membreno, C.K. Larive, 1667 (2007) J Chromatogr. A, 1217, 479 (2010) [241] L. Zhang, W. Liu, R. Zhang, Z. Wang, Z. Shen, [264] H. Zou, Y. Zhang, P. Lu, J. Chromatogr. 545, 59 X. Chen, K. Bi, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 47, 892 (1991) (2008) [265] C.T. Huang, R.B. Tylor, J. Chromatogr. 202, 333 [242] G. Tan, Z. Zhu, J. Jing, L. Lv, Z. Lou, G. Zhang, (1980) Y. Chai, Biomed. Chromatogr. 25, 913 (2011) [266] S. Afrashtehfar, F.C. Cantwell, Anal. Chem. 54, [243] J. Beyer, F.T. Peters, T. Kraemer, H.H. Maurer, 2422 (1982) J. Mass Spectrom. 42,621 (2007) [267] C.M. Riley, E. TomLinson, T.M. Jefferies, [244] J.-H. Chen, C.-Y. Lee, B.-C. Liau, M.-R. Lee, J. Chromatogr. 185, 197 (1979) T.-T. Jong, S.-T. Chiang, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. [268] H. Knox, R.A. Hartwick, J. Chromatogr. 204, 3 48, 1105 (2008) (1981) [245] F. Zhang, M.-h. Tang, L.-j. Chena, R. Li, X.-h.Wang, [269] A.P. Goldberg, E. Nowakowska, P.E. Antle, J.-g. Duan, X. Zhao, Y.-q. Wei, J. Chromatogr. B, L.R. Snyder, J. Chromatogr. 316, 241 (1984) 873, 173 (2008) [270] J. Stahlberg, J. Chromatogr. 356, 231 (1986) [246] C. Lopez, B. Claude, Ph. Morin, J.-P. Max, R. Pena, [271] B.A. Bidlingmeyer, S.N. Deming, W.P. Price Jr., J.-P. Ribet, Anal. Chim. Acta 683, 198 (2011) B. Sachok, M. Petrusek, J. Chromatogr. 186, 419 [247] G. Schröder, E. Unterbusch, M. Kaltenbach, (1979) J. Schmidt, D. Strack, V. De Luca, J. Schröder, [272] I. Gerasimenko, Y. Sheludko, M. Unger, FEBS Lett. 458, 97 (1999) J. Stöckigt, Phytochem. Anal. 12, 96 (2001) [248] C.A.M. Peebles, S.-B. Hong, S.I. Gibson, [273] A.B. Cardillo, A.A.M. Otalvaro, V.D. Busto, J. V. Shanks, K.-Y. San, Biotechnol. Bioeng. 93(3), J.R. Talou, L.M.E. Velasquez, A.M. Giulietti, 401 (2006) Process Biochem. 45, 1577 (2010) [249] A. Verma, K. Hartonen, M.-L. Riekkola, [274] A.B. Cardillo, J.R. Talou, A.M. Giulietti, Microbial Phytochem. Anal. 19, 52 (2008) Cell Factories 7, 17 (2008) [250] R.K. Satdive, D.P. Fulzele, S. Eapen, Biotechnol. [275] E.Ch. Kotzagiorgis, S. Michaleas, Prog. 19, 1071 (2003) E. Antoniadou-Vyza, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 43, [251] S. Uhlig, D. Petersen, Toxicon 52, 175 (2008) 1370 (2007) [252] N.W. Shappeld, D.J. Smith, In Vitro Cell. Dev. Biol. [276] M. Ganzera, C. Lanser, H. Stuppner, Talanta 66, Animal 41, 245 (2005) 889 (2005) [253] R. Hu, J. Zhao, L.-W. Qi, P. Li, S.-L. Jing, [277] A.T.W. Eng, M.Y. Heng, E.S. Ong, Anal. Chim. H.-J. Li, Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 23, Acta 583, 289 (2007) 1619 (2009) [278] B. Remberg, A.F. Sterrantino, R. Artner, [254] R.Q. Gabr, M.E. Elsherbiny, V. Somayaji, C. Janitsch, L. Krenn, Chem. Biodiver. 5, 1770
833 834 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
(2008) 806 (2005) [279] J.O. Soyinka, C.O. Onyeji, S.I. Omoruyi, [301] H. Yue, Z.-F. Pi, H.-L. Li, F.-R. Song, Z.-Q. Liu, J. Chromatogr. B, 877, 441 (2009) S.-Y. Liu, Phytochem. Anal. 19, 141 (2008) [280] J. Yang, Y. Hu, J.-B. Cai, X.-L. Zhu, Q.-D. Su, Anal. [302] H. Yuea, Z. Pi, F. Song, Z. Liu, Z. Cai, S. Liu, Bioanal. Chem. 384, 761 (2006) Talanta 77, 1800 (2009) [281] G.C. Uniyal, S. Bala, A.K. Mathur, R.N. Kulkarni, [303] Y. Yanga, J. Chena, Y.-P. Shi, J. Chromatogr. B, Phytochem. Anal. 12, 206 (2001) 878, 2811 (2010) [282] S. Grün, M. Frey, A. Gierl, Phytochemistry 66, [304] M. Zhu, F. Han, H. Chen, Z. Peng, Y. Chen, Rapid 1264 (2005) Commun. Mass Spectrom. 21, 2019 (2007) [283] J. Zhao, W.-H. Zhu, Q. Hu, Enzyme Microb. [305] Y. Sawabe, K. Yamasaki, T. Tagami, Technol. 28, 666 (2001) M. Kawaguchi, S. Taguchi, J. Nat. Med. 65, 395 [284] N. Misra, A.K. Gupta, J. Plant Physiol. 163, 11 (2011) (2006) [306] F. Pellati, S. Benvenuti, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. [285] L. Yang, H. Wang, Y.-g. Zu, C. Zhao, L. Zhang, 48, 254 (2008) X. Chen, Z. Zhang, Chem. Eng. J. 172, 705 [307] J. Santana, K.E. Sharpless, B.C. Nelson, Food (2011) Chem. 109, 675 (2008) [286] M. Magnotta, J. Murata, J. Chen, V. De Luca, [308] K.M. El-Azony, A.A. El-Mohty, H. M. Killa, Phytochemistry 68, 1922 (2007) U. Seddik, S.I. Khater, J. Label Compd. [287] B. Zanolari, J.-L. Wolfender, D. Guilet, Radiopharm 52, 1 (2008) A. Marston, E.F. Queiroz, M.Q. Paulo, [309] D. Usmanov, U. Khasanov, A. Pantsirev, K. Hostettmann, J. Chromatogr. A, 1020, 75 J. Van Bocxlaer, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 53, (2003) 1058 (2010) [288] L. Li, J. Wang, W. Wang, Y. Lu, Y. Wang, G. Zhou, [310] J. Kempf, U. Stedtler, C. Neusüß, W. Weinmann, G. Kai, Biotechnol. Bioprocess Eng. 13, 606 V. Auwärter, Forensic Sci. Int. 179, e57 (2008) (2008) [311] L. Peng, X. Song, X. Shi, J. Li, C. Ye, J. Food [289] H. Hong, H.-B. Chen, D.-H. Yang, M.-Y. Shang, Composition Anal. 21, 559 (2008) X. Wang, S.-Q. Cai, M. Mikage, J. Nat. Med. 65, [312] C.V. Hoffmann, M. Lämmerhofer, W. Lindner, Anal. 623 (2011) Bioanal. Chem. 393, 1257 (2009) [290] X. Hu, J. Peng, Y. Huang, D. Yin, J. Liu. J. Sep. [313] D.L. Heavner, J.D. Richardson, W.T. Morgan, Sci. 32, 4126 (2009) M.W. Ogden, Biomed. Chromatogr. 19, 312 [291] S.Li, C. He, H. Liu, K. Li, F. Liu, J.Chromatogr. B (2005) 826, 58 (2005) [314] T. Zhu, W. Bi, K.H. Row, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 118, [292] M. Bian, Z. Zhang, H. Yin, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 3425 (2010) 58, 163 (2012) [315] L. Zhang, D.M. Kujawinski, M.A. Jochmann, [293] M.A. Atemnkeng, B. Chimanuka, T.C. Schmidt, Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. J. Plaizier-Vercammen, J. Clin. Pharm. Therapeut. 25, 2971 (2011) 32, 123 (2007) [316] S. Caccamese, G. Principato, R. Jokela, [294] S.E. Haas, C.C. Bettoni, L.K. de Oliveira, A. Tolvanen, D.D. Belle, Chirality 13, 691 (2001) S.S. Guterres, T.D. Costa, Int. J. Antimicrob. [317] P. Selig, E. Herdtweck, T. Bach, Chem. Eur. J. 15, Agents 34, 156 (2009) 3509 (2009) [295] A. Cheomung, K. Na-Bangchang, J. Pharm. [318] R. Lock, H. Waldmann, Clrem. Eur J. 3, 143 Biomed. Anal. 55, 1031 (2011) (1997) [296] X. Fu, L. Ye, L. Kang, F. Ge, Plant Cell and [319] J. Sun, A. Baker, P. Chen, Rapid Commun. Mass Environment 33, 2056 (2010) Spectrom. 25, 2591 (2011) [297] X.-L. Yang, M.-B. Luo, J.-H. Ding, Chin. J. Anal. [320] P. Kintz, M. Villain, J. Evans, M.-L. Pujol, Chem. 35, 171 (2007) G. Salquebre, V. Cirimele, Forensic Toxicol. 25, 49 [298] C. Chen, X. Li, J. Yang, X. Gong, B. Li, (2007) K.-Q. Zhang, Int. Biodeter. Biodegr. 62, 226 [321] J.Olšovska, M. Šulc, P. Novak, S. Pažoutova, (2008) M. Flieger, J.Chromatogr. B, 873, 165 (2008) [299] S. El Deeb, L. Preu, H. Wätzig, J. Pharm. Biomed. [322] Y. Zhou, N. Li, F. F.-K. Choi, C.-F. Qiao, Anal. 44, 85 (2007) J.-Z. Song, S.-L. Li , X. Liu, Z.-W. Cai, P.P. Fu, G. Lin, [300] I.N. De Abreu, A.C.H.F. Sawaya, M.N. Eberlin, H.-X. Xu, Anal. Chim. Acta 681, 33 (2010) P. Mazzafera, In Vitro Cell. Dev. Biol. Plant 41, [323] Y. Gu, D. Qian, J.-a. Duan, Z. Wang, J. Guo,
833 834 A. Petruczynik Analysis of alkaloids from different chemical groups by different liquid chromatography methods
Y. Tang, S. Guo, J. Sep. Sci. 33, 1004 (2010) [344] A.T.A. Pimenta, R. Braz-Filho, P.G. Delprete, [324] J.-Z. Chen, Y. Xu, G.-X. Chou, C.-H. Wang, E.B. de Souza, E.R. Silveira, M.A.S. Lima, Magn. L. Yanga, Z.-T. Wang, Biomed. Chromatogr. Reson. Chem. 48, 734 (2010) 25,367 (2011) [345] S.D. Sarker, A. Laird, L. Nahar, Y. Kumarasamy, [325] L. Tang, Y. Gong, C. Lv, L. Ye, L. Liu, Z. Liu, M. Jaspars, Phytochemistry 57, 1273 (2001) J. Ethnopharmacol. (2011) (doi:10.1016/j. [346] X.-H.Cai, H.Jiang, LI Yan, G.-G. Cheng, jep.2011.08.070) (in press) Y.-P. Liu, T.Feng, X.-D. Luo, Chin. J. Nat. Med. 9, [326] Y. F. Fan, Y.Xie, L. Liu, H. M. Ho, Y. F. Wong, 259 (2011) Z. Q. Liu, H. Zhou, J. Ethnopharmacol. (2011) [347] A. Moldes-Anaya, T. Rundberget, S. Uhlig, F. Rise, (doi:10.1016/j.jep.2011.09.005) (in press) A.L. Wilkins, Toxicon 57, 259 (2011) [327] H. Ibrahim, J. Bouajila, N. Siri, G. Rozing, [348] A. Itoh, T. Tanahashi, N. Nagakura, T. Nishi, F. Nepveu, F. Couderc, J. Chromatogr. B, 850, Phytochemistry 62, 359 (2003) 481 (2007) [349] H. Matsuo, R. Okamoto, K. Zaima, Y. Hirasawa, [328] E. Deconinck, P.Y. Sacre, S. Baudewyns, I.S. Ismail, N.H. Lajis, H. Morita, Bioorg. Med. P. Courselle, J. De Beer, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. Chem. 19, 4075 (2011) 56, 200 (2011) [350] H. Kuang, S. Sun, B. Yang, Y. Xia, W. Feng, [329] F. Marclay, E. Grata, L. Perrenoud, M. Saugy, Fitoterapia 80, 35 (2009) Forensic Sci. Int. 213, 73 (2011) [351] F. Wang, Y. Fang, T. Zhu, M. Zhang, A. Lin, Q. Gu, [330] P. Jandera, J. Fischer, J. Jebavá, H. Effenberger, W. Zhu, Tetrahedron 64, 7986 (2008) J. Chromatogr. A, 914, 233 (2001) [352] Y. Wu, Z.-X. Zhang, H.Hu, D. Li, G. Qiu, X. Hu, [331] M.-L. Chin-Chen, S. Carda-Broch, D. Bose, X. He, Fitoterapia 82, 288 (2011) J. Esteve-Romero, Food Chem. 120, 915 (2010) [353] H.-S. Lee, K.-M. Yoon, Y.-R. Han, K.J. Lee, [332] T. Rezanka, P. Rezanka, K. Sigler, Phytochemistry S.-C. Chung, T.-I. Kim, S.-H. Lee, J. Shin, 71, 301 (2010) K.-B. Oh, Bioorg.Med. Chem. Lett.19, 1051 [333] P.K. Vuppala, S.P. Boddu, E.B. Furr, C.R. McCurdy, (2009) B.A. Avery, Chromatographia (2011) (In press) [354] K. Koyama, Y. Hirasawa, K. Zaima, T.C. Hoe, doi:10.1007/s10337-011-2128-x K.-L. Chan, H. Morita, Bioorg. Med. Chem. 16, [334] C. Giroud, K. Michaud, F. Sporkert, C. Eap, 6483 (2008) M. Augsburger, P. Cardinal, P. Mangin, J Anal. [355] I. Mancini, G. Guella, H. Zibrowius, F. Pietrac, Toxicol. 28, 464 (2004) Tetrahedron 59, 8757 (2003) [335] M. Nakamura, M. Ono, T. Nakajima, Y. Ito, [356] S. Ouyang, L. Wang, Q.-W. Zhang, Gu.-C. Wang, T. Aketo, J. Haginaka, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 37, Y. Wang, X.-J. Huang, X.-Q. Zhang, R.-W. Jiang, 231 (2005) X.-S. Yao, C.-T. Che, W.-C. Ye, Tetrahedron 67, [336] J. Ouyang, X. Gao, W. R. G. Baeyens, 4807 (2011) J. R. Delanghe, Biomed. Chromatogr. 19, 266 [357] K. Koyama, Y. Hirasawa, T. Hosoya, T. C. Hoe, (2005) K.-L. Chan, H. Morita, Bioorg. Med. Chem. 18, [337] P. E. Morgan, V. Manwaring, R. J. Flanagan, 4415 (2010) Biomed. Chromatogr. 24, 318 (2010) [358] K. Jenett-Siems, R. Weigl, A. Böhm, P. Mann, [338] J.M.C. Ribeiro, N.S. Zeidner, K. Ledin, M.C. Dolan, B. Tofern-Rebli, S. C. Ott, A. Ghomian, M. Kaloga, T.N. Mather, Med. Vet. Entomol. 18, 20 (2004) K. Siems, L. Witte, M. Hilker, F. Müller, E. Eich, [339] S. Yin, X.-F. He, Y. Wu, J.-M. Yue, Chem. Asian J. Phytochemistry 66, 1448 (2005) 3, 1824 (2008) [359] B.-Y. Yang, Y.-G. Xia, Q.-H. Wang, D.-Q. Dou, [340] B. Ma, C.-F. Wu, J.-Y. Yang, R. Wang, Y. Kano, H.-X. Kuang, Fitoterapia 81, 1003 (2010) D. Yuan, Helv. Chim. Acta 92, 1575 (2009) [360] I.-S. Kim, Y.-J. Park, S.-J. Yoon, H.-B. Lee, Int. [341] A. Teichert, J. Schmidt, A. Porzel, N. Arnold, Immunopharmacol. 10, 1616 (2010) L. Wessjohann, Chem. Biodiv. 5, 664 (2008) [361] S.G. Toske, S.D. Cooper, D.R. Morello, P.A. Hays, [342] H.-J. Krämer, M. Podobinska, A. Bartsch, J.F. Casale, E. Casale, J. Forensic Sci. 51, 308 A. Battmann, W. Thoma, A. Bernd, W. Kummer, (2006) B. Irlinger, W. Steglich, P. Mayser, Chem. Bio. [362] J.F. Casale, S.G. Toske, P.A. Hays, J. Forensic Chem. 6, 860 (2005) Sci. 54, 359 (2009) [343] H.-J. Krämer, D. Kessler, U.-C. Hipler, B. Irlinger, [363] Y. Nishiyama, M. Moriyasu, M. Ichimaru, W. Hort, R.-H. Bçdeker, W. Steglich, P. Mayser, K. Iwasa, A. Kato, S.G. Mathenge, P.B.C. Mutiso, Chem. Bio. Chem. 6, 2290 (2005) F.D. Juma, Phytochemistry 67, 2671 (2006)
835 PB