A Shango Heligious Group and the Problem Op Prestige In
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A SHANGO HELIGIOUS GROUP AND THE PROBLEM OP PRESTIGE IN TRINIDADIAN SOCIETY DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Prances Osterman Mischel, B. A., M. A. •it **•*•*• The Ohio State University 1958 Approved "by: UAdviser Department of Sociology and Anthropology ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I wish to thank the members of my reading committee, Drs. J. W. Bennett, E. Bourguignon, and R, Hinkle for f their help. 1 I am deeply indebted to my husbsnd, Walter Mischel, for his aid and moral support. ii TABLE OP CONTENTS Chapter I The Problem ..1 Chapter II Prestige and Mobility in Trinidadian Society . .15 1. Ethnicity and Color ,.,.lo 2. Economic Attainment 22 3. Educational Advancement. 26 Chapter III Prestige Attainment in the Negro Lower Class . .36 1. Carnival . 37 2. Steel Bands .39 3. Gangs . .4-1 Religion ^2 Chapter IV The Shango Group: Organization and Ceremonies. .51 Organization 52 1. Comparisons 56 2. Comparisons .61 Ceremonies 6^ 1. Comparisons 72 Chapter V The Shango Group: Possession, Cosmology, and Deities 75 Possession . ?o 1. Illustration .76 2. Range of Possession 78 3. Range of Occurrence 79 Induction of Possession 80 5. Recovery 86 Shango Cosmology 87 1. Comparison .90 Shango Deities 92 Chapter VI Prestige Attainment in the Shango Group. 99 1. Hildy: High Prestige ..... 100 2. Anna:; Low Prestige 104 3. The Prerequisites for Initial Prestige . 113 4-. Achieved Prestige. 116 Chapter VII Relationships between Prestige and Shango Group Structure 129 111 iv Chapter VIII The Consequences of Shango-Derived Prestige. .150 Bewards of the High Prestige Group 150 Rewards of the Lower Prestige Groups 159 The Generalization of Shango-Derived Prestige. .162 Chapter IX Summary and Conclusions 168 Selected Bibliography and References Cited 178 Preface The group with which this thesis will be concerned, is called the 3hango cult}-, or as the members call themselves, the Orisha workers. It is an Afro-American Negro religious cult in Trinidad, Eritish West Indies, and derives from the complex of religious beliefs found among the Yoruba of Nigeria.2 its most striking characteristic is the syn cretism between African beliefs and Roman Catholic dogma and ritual so that old African gods have become identified with Catholic saints. Catholic prayers are interspersed with African chants, songs, and other items of African i ritual which have been remembered and retained. We went to Trinidad during the summer of 195^ with the intention of collecting data on its Shango group. We were soon impressed by the vast variety of data that seemed available not only with respect to the group but also on many other aspects of Trinidadian culture. Everywhere we 1. Although it is popularly known as a "cult", we restricted our study to one group and we shall, therefore, use the word "group" rather than "cult". 2. "The Yoruba tribe includes over 3,000,000 individuals living in the southwestern portion of Nigeria, British West Africa and in the eastern section of Dahomey. Within the tribe there are a number of autonomous but related 'kingdoms' which center about the larger cities ruled by 'kings'. (W. Bascom, "The Sociological Eole of the Yoruba Cult Group", American Anthrp-pologlcal Association Memoir no. 63, Jan., 19^4, p. (T) Of Yoruba religionBascom indicates that the social structure of the Yoruba is intimately connected with the cult groups and secret societies. In describing Yoruba religion, Bascom states: "While the worship of one's immediate ancestors'are modest and private, the annual festivals of the Orlshas involve elaborate ceremonies extending over seven or eight days, when friends and affinal relatives visit the worshippers and join them in feasting, drinking, and dancing." v vi were confronted with potentially interesting data on a vari ety of problems we had not anticipated. Trinidad was obvi ously an exciting field situation, with tempting problems in the area of acculturation, prejudice, communication, politi cal and economic transitions and the like. We were intent upon Shango as the phenomenon to be studied but found the study of Shango leading us to other aspects of Trinidadian society. The Shango group itself, as will be seen in Chapter k was hardly a tightly organized, well structured group with clear boundaries; on the contrary, it appeared geographically diffuse, scattered throughout various parts of the island and; was characterized by much geographical mobility. Ceremonies were held in different pe.rts of the island and group members travelled to the various parts in order to attend ceremonies. Our idea of locating a "Shango village" was thus quickly dis pelled. Once our inital contacts were made, our physical route became quickly established for us; we were going to try to see the group activities in some of the major locations within one "circuit" (see chapter 4). To make this possible, we located ourselves in Port of Spain, the capital, and in Lengua, a small southern Trinidad village and the home of the major Shango leader of the island. Our time was approximate ly equally divided in residence at each of these locations, and we travelled back and forth depending on where ceremonies were being held at a particular time. Rapport with group vii leaders and members as well as with necessary government officials was established without much difficulty and the task of getting to know more members of the group, learning where it flourished, and being permitted to observe it was not too formidable. The general aim of this thesis will be to present and interpret selected portions of the data collected within this field study. CHAPTER I THE PROBLEM We went to Trinidad to investigate Shango religion. We came to the field with minimal knowledge of this group; it had received very little previous study. Our first task, thus, was to describe the group ethnographically. That is, we gathered data on its ritual, cosmology, the deities worshiped, and the like. In general, our approach was to •observe behavior in a variety of situations, to interview as many informants as possible, to live in the localities Indi cated in the Preface and to participate as observers in a large variety of situations. As we have already indicated, we found that Shango was diffusely practiced throughout the Island. In spite of much searching we were unable to find a "Shango village," i.e., a place In which most of the inhabitants participated in Shango activities. Our search for a Shango village took us throughout the island, and while living In Port-of-Spain to observe the activities of two major Shango leaders and their followers who lived in the area, we became acquainted with many non-Shango Trinldadlans from various levels of society. Throughout, In these contacts, we continued to use the observation and Interview methods indicated above and, essentially, treated all our acquaintances as Informants or at least as potential informants. 1 2 We came without pre-conceived notions or concepts about how to interpret our data concerning either the Shango group or Trinidadian society. Rather, from our observations, and particularly from the detailed data gathered about Shango mem bers and their activities, the concepts and problems with which this thesis deals emerged. From our heterogenous data one very major theme appeared. This was the intense concern with in the vernacular "not being a nobody" and "becoming somebody big"..."being respected"..."able to stand up proud"..."having people look up when you pass by." This was generally expressed pessimistically rather than hopefully, and was frequently talked about by numerous informants. Tales of Insult and injury, particularly of blows to one's "pride" were most common, and persisted consistently even after it become clear that we were not in a position to be of direct personal help to informants and were not, as some tried to hope, going to "carry me away...give me a chance." Similar themes were expressed, but to a lesser degree, by many of the middle and upper class persons whom we met and observed. Recognition wishes were frequently referred to and signs of ^recognition were constantly sought at all levels of society, e.g., the middle class woman endlessly fussing with her numerous servants; the clerk loudly abusing his "helpers" who, in turn, lament their plight or try desperately to somehow assert their own worth. These kinds of concerns about being big and Important, i.e., being esteemed and gaining / 3 recognition, having power, etc., with which our informants seemed so intensely involved, corresponded, In large part, with our own impressions about aspects of personal inter actions and group behavior and structure in the Shango group itself. Our data suggested that recognition striving char acterized large segments of the Shango group. Further, the social structure of the group seemed, to a large degree, to be divided into sub-groups; each sub-group consisting of members who were accorded relatively equal recognition and esteem. There also appeared to be definite and distinct ways available within the total group for furthering the degree to which one is recognized, held in esteem, or positively valued in the group. It will be shown later that certain persons never attain recognition in the eyes of other members of the group, and that some people receive more than others. Through further observation, we became increasingly con vinced that our Informants* concerns with recognition, esteem and so forth, and our own perceptions that attribution of these structured much of the behavior within the group, reflected one very major aspect of Trlnidadian society and of the Shango group. The conceptual problem which emerged from this was what concepts, what labels, might be used to deal with these observations.