DOCSLIB.ORG

The Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure The Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure October 15-17, 2019 Catamaran - San Diego, CA https://trustedci.org/2019-nsf-cybersecurity-summit/ Acknowledgements The Summit would not have been possible without the commitment and dedicated work of many individuals. The organizers wish to thank all those who attended the Summit. Special gratitude goes to all who responded to the CFP, spoke, provided training, and actively participated, including the 2019 Program Committee (highlighted in Section 3), without whom the event would not have been as successful. Our sincere thanks goes to the National Science Foundation and Indiana University’s Center for Applied Cybersecurity Research for making this community event possible. This event was supported in part by the National Science Foundation under Grant Number 1547272. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed at the event or in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. About this Report This document is the product of Trusted CI: The NSF Cybersecurity Center of Excellence and was supported by the National Science Foundation under the grant - ACI-1547272. Citing this Report Please cite as: Andrew Adams, Kay Avila, Kathy Benninger, Jeannette Dopheide, Mark Krenz, James Marsteller, and John Zage. Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Cyberinfrastructure and Large Facilities: http://hdl.handle.net/2142/105533. License This work is made available under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/). For the latest information on the Summit, please see: https://trustedci.org/summit/ Title: Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure 1 Distribution: Public Table of Contents Executive Summary 4 1 Summit Session Summaries 6 1.1 Presentations 6 1.2 Panels 13 1.3 Lightning Talks 14 1.4 Table Talks 17 1.5 Project Showcase 18 2 Common Themes and Challenges 18 3 The Organizing and Program Committees 20 4 The Call for Participation 20 5 Summit Attendees 22 5.1 Summary of Attendees 22 5.2 NSF Project Representation 22 5.3 Inclusiveness 26 5.4 Attendee Evaluations 27 6 Conclusion 28 Appendix A: Findings from Past Summits 30 2018 Observations 31 2017 Recommendations 31 2016 Recommendations 32 2015 Recommendations 32 2014 Recommendations 33 2013 Recommendations 34 Title: Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure 2 Distribution: Public Appendix B: Summit Agenda 36 Appendix C: Descriptions of Workshops and Training Sessions 41 Concurrent Morning Sessions 42 Concurrent Afternoon Sessions 46 Appendix D: Bios for Speakers, Program Committee, and Organizers 49 Appendix E: Student Participation 66 Student Bios 68 Students’ Final Thoughts on Attending the Summit 70 Appendix F: Attendee Survey Summary Report 72 Appendix G: Training Evaluation Summary Report 79 Title: Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure 3 Distribution: Public Executive Summary The 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure, now in its seventh consecutive year, once again provided a valuable forum for NSF scientists, researchers, and security experts to collaborate on addressing core cybersecurity challenges. Trusted CI organizes the annual Summit with the goals of advancing cybersecurity awareness and practice and increasing trust in the integrity of research results produced using cyberinfrastructure. Responding to the constantly changing state of cybersecurity challenges can be difficult for any organization, whether commercial, academic, or governmental. The Summit serves as a valuable tool toward securing NSF scientific cyberinfrastructure (CI) through the opportunities it provides for attendees to meet with colleagues, share experiences, benchmark and debate cybersecurity best practices, identify common challenges, and receive practical, relevant training. Moreover, the Summit presents an excellent opportunity for the science, research, and security communities to highlight cybersecurity challenges to NSF program officers, leadership, and stakeholders, as well as provide basic cybersecurity awareness and education. Finally, the Summit presents an opportunity for the Trusted CI team to gain insight into the needs, concerns, and challenges facing the community. The 2019 Summit was held at the Catamaran Resort Hotel, San Diego, CA, October 15th through October 17th. The Summit’s call for participation (CFP1) yielded a total of 44 responses, more than could be accommodated in the program schedule. The full program schedule comprised 13 plenary talks, ten training sessions, four panel discussions, three “table talks”, and seven “lightning talks” (new in 2019). As with previous summits, the first day’s sessions consisted of training and focused workshops, including a full day WISE (Wise Information Security for collaborating E-infrastructures) Community2 training event. Of note among this year’s training sessions was the first ever security-focused training workshop on Project Jupyter, which exists to develop open-source software, open-standards, and services for interactive computing across dozens of programming languages. Feedback from the first group of attendees will inform the shape this training will take in future presentations. The second and third days’ sessions were composed of plenary presentations, panels, and lightning talks that focused on the security of cyberinfrastructure projects and Large Facilities. 1 https://trustedci.org/cfp2019 2 https://wise-community.org/ Title: Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure 4 Distribution: Public Summit plenary attendance was 143, up from 117 attendees last year. These attendees represented 84 NSF projects, including 12 of the 20 NSF Large Facilities. 46% of the attendees actively participated in either planning, presenting, co-authoring a CFP submission, or leading a lunch table talk. The attendees expressed overwhelmingly positive and constructive feedback. A list of observations and challenges along with notations of the presentations highlighting each of these issues is presented in Section 2 of this report, with the following summary key findings derived from this year’s Summit: ● Community member interaction and knowledge share remain a key to success. The value in developing and strengthening researcher / cybersecurity professional relationships was emphasized. ● Workforce development continues to be important, with demonstrable success resulting from hands-on training opportunities. ● The community values the availability of centralized cybersecurity resources. ● Measuring the effectiveness or impact of cybersecurity implementation, i.e., determining appropriate metrics to use, is a challenging, but important, area of investigation. ● Access control and credential management are extremely important to the community. The recommendation to use federated and/or external providers and industry standard protocols as much as possible was presented in several sessions. ● Social engineering remains a significant threat to cybersecurity. ● AI and ML can provide valuable cyberinfrastructure services, but have an inherent vulnerability in the potential for incorporating misinformation into models. ● Ensuring and maintaining data integrity is becoming an increasingly important issue. ● As the number of organizations handling PII and medical data increases, implementation of HIPAA compliance is becoming more widespread. Title: Report of the 2019 NSF Cybersecurity Summit for Large Facilities and Cyberinfrastructure 5 Distribution: Public 1 Summit Session Summaries Biographies of speakers are included in Appendix D. Slides from the talks can be found at https://trustedci.org/2019-presentations. 1.1 Presentations Keynote: Advancing Cybersecurity as an Evidence-based Discipline - Stefan Savage There is a disconnect between security researchers and operators. Cybersecurity attacks are much easier to measure than the effectiveness of defenses against these attacks. Consequently, the return on investments in cybersecurity countermeasures is difficult to calculate. One possibility to solve issues of measurability and metrics in relation to implementing effective cybersecurity practices is to make cybersecurity more like health care, with evidence-based actions. Examples of evidence-based actions include looking at the security outcomes (e.g., was a machine compromised or not? Were credentials stolen or not?) and viewing the human factors of security such as the impact of economics on implementing attacks. Collaborating with industrial partners and government can also provide broader insights. Key points: ● SPAM filtering is not working for things people want ● No empirical evidence for best practices, but having good empirical data implies good security ● Measuring security isn’t impossible, it’s just hard Cyberinfrastructure Center of Excellence PILOT - Establishing Effective Practices for Large Facilities - Ewa Deelman The Cyberinfrastructure Center of Excellence (CI CoE) Pilot is a recently launched NSF-funded project that aims to: 1) create and establish effective practices and innovative solutions for cyberinfrastructure (CI) challenges prevalent among existing facilities; and 2) assist in CI construction and design for developing facilities. The
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Hubbard Brook Research Foundation
    Hubbard Brook Research Foundation A Report for 2007 Promoting the understanding and stewardship of ecosystems through scientific research, policy outreach, and education Page Trustees Advisory Council Stuart V. Smith, Jr., Chair Edward A. Ames Susan Arnold John Aber, Vice Chair Posy Bass University of New Hampshire Ellen Baum Peter R. Stein, Secretary Alison Chase Lyme Timber Company Dave Chase Starling Childs Sarah E. Muyskens, Treasurer Fred Ernst Larry K. Forcier Christopher C. Barton Anne T. Forcier Wright State University Isabel Freeman Tom Gross Charles T. Driscoll Dick Henry Syracuse University Joseph Hill Timothy J. Fahey Harold W. Janeway Cornell University Thomas Kehler Lia Lloyd-Clare Kehler Richard T. Holmes Sherman T. Kent Dartmouth College Jenepher Lingelbach Marcy Lyman Thomas C. Jorling Peter Martin Mark Latham Constance L. Royster Vermont Law School Jean Smith Gene E. Likens Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies Mission Jane E. S. Sokolow The Hubbard Brook Research Foundation’s mission is to promote the understanding Kathleen C. Weathers and stewardship of ecosystems through Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies scientific research, long-term monitoring, and Stanton Williams education. Founded in 1993, HBRF works to sustain and enhance the Hubbard Brook F. Herbert Bormann, Advisor Ecosystem Study, in partnership with the USDA Forest Yale University Service, the National Science Foundation’s LTER program, Founding Trustee Emeritus and many colleges, universities, and other institutions. Christopher Eagar, Ex Officio Hubbard Brook Consortium, Charter Members: USDA Forest Service Dartmouth College, Plymouth State University, Syracuse University, USDA Forest Service/Northern Research Station, and Wellesley College. Cover photo by Buck Sleeper. Inside photos by Buck Sleeper, Nick Rodenhouse, Scott Schwenk, Judy Brown, Chris Eagar, Hubbard Brook archives.
    [Show full text]
  • Highlights 2010 NORTHERN RESEARCH STATION
    Highlights 2010 NORTHERN RESEARCH STATION Research that improves people’s lives and helps sustain natural resources in the Northeast and Midwest . OUR VISION: HEALTHY FORESTS, HEALTHY PEOPLE, HEALTHY COMMUNITIES Th e Northern Research Station serves the most densely populated and most heavily forested portion of the United States. We envision a region where trees and natural resources support a high quality of life; where resilient habitat supports thriving wildlife, fi sh, and plant communities; where clean water abounds and where people work together to sustain, and where necessary, restore the health of forests, from urban centers to deep wilderness. We further envision forests that provide a wide array of benefi ts and renewable products from hardwood for furniture to bark for native basketry, to bioenergy to heat homes and schools, to a sunset viewed from a mountain top. Th e Northern Research Station is dedicated, organized, and staff ed to provide the high-quality scientifi c information that people need in a form they can use. 1 FROM THE STATION DIRECTOR Th e Northern Research Station (NRS) is making a diff erence. From tools that help city planners expand urban tree cover and its associated environmental benefi ts to workshops that train foresters on the latest techniques for growing healthier forests, the work of NRS scientists is improving people’s lives and the health of our nation’s natural resources. Th ese pages highlight some of the scientifi c advancements made in 2010. More detail is available on our website, www.nrs.fs.fed.us. Th is year, the NRS, and the Forest Service as a whole, also made a diff erence in local communities through the 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act.
    [Show full text]
  • NADP 2009 Technical Committee Meeting
    NADP Proceedings 2009-01 NADP 2009 Technical Committee Meeting October 6 – 8, 2009 Saratoga Springs, New York Scientific Symposium Chair Mark Nilles U.S. Geological Survey PROCEEDINGS Prepared by Kathryn E. Douglas NADP Program Office Illinois State Water Survey University of Illinois Institute of Natural Resource and Sustainability 2204 Griffith Drive Champaign, IL 61820 October 2009 Acknowledgements The NADP would like to express their appreciation to the NY20, Huntington Wildlife MDN and NTN site for hosting our field trip, especially Myron Mitchell, Doug Burns and Karen Roy. A special thank you to NADP and Illinois State Water Survey staff members Pam Bedient, Roger Claybrooke, Bob Larson, Sara Olson and Lisa Volk for their support in assisting with the proceedings book, service awards, graphic support and meeting registration. Cover photo credit: Adirondack Regional Tourism Council CONTENTS Page Agenda - NADP Annual Meeting and Scientific Symposium ................................................. 1 2009 NADP Site Operator Awards .......................................................................................... 11 Keynote Speakers: Coupled Biogeochemical Cycles: How They Arise and What They Mean Bill Schlesinger, Director, Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies…………………………….19 The Response of Lake-Watersheds in the Adirondack Region of New York To Decreases in Acidic Deposition and Linkages to Climate Change and Mercury Deposition Charles Driscoll, Syracuse University ..............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Ecological Society of America Announces 2021 Award Recipients
    Ecological Society of America announces 2021 award recipients Posted by Heidi Swanson on April 6, 2021 April 6, 2021 For Immediate Release Contact: Heidi Swanson, (202) 833-8773 ext. 211, gro.ase@idieh The Ecological Society of America is pleased to announce the winners of its 2021 awards, which recognize outstanding contributions to ecology in new discoveries, teaching, sustainability, diversity, and lifelong commitment to the profession. “This year’s award recipients have shown remarkable leadership and creativity,” said Kathleen Weathers, ESA President. “On behalf of the Ecological Society of America, I congratulate the award winners and thank them for their significant contributions to building both ecological knowledge and the community of ecologists.” ESA will present the 2021 awards during a ceremony at the Society’s upcoming Virtual Annual Meeting, which will take place from Monday, August 2, to Sunday, August 6, 2021. Learn more about ESA awards. Eminent Ecologist Award: Steward T. A. Pickett The Eminent Ecologist Award honors a senior ecologist for an outstanding body of ecological work or sustained ecological contributions of extraordinary merit. Dr. Steward T. A. Pickett, Distinguished Senior Scientist at the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, is a pioneer in understanding the non-equilibrium dynamics of landscapes and the ecology of urban environments. During his nearly 45-year research career, he has advanced knowledge in areas including physiological plant ecology, disturbance, succession and the nature of ecological theory, and his work has spanned environments from forests and old fields to urban centers. His scholarship on the philosophy and practice of ecological science has provided clarity for a complex science.
    [Show full text]
  • Scits Conference Program
    SciTS 2019 Conference May 20-23, 2019 |Lansing, Michigan Host: Center for Interdisciplinarity at Michigan State University Building the knowledge base for effective team science INSciTS International Network for the Science of Team Science Become a Founding Member of INSciTS INSciTS launched in 2018 as the membership organization for team science and the SciTS field. INSciTS provides a forum to share the latest evidence for what works in team science and collaborate with colleagues to advance the SciTS field. Individuals leading, engaging in, managing, facilitating, supporting, evaluating, and producing scholarship on team science will find a professional home in INSciTS. All individuals who join INSciTS in 2019 and 2020 will be recognized as founding members. Benefits of Membership: • Receive a reduced annual conference registration rate • Join up to two special interest groups that focus on your core interests • Participate in a year-round forum for dialogue, coordination, and collaboration • Be included in, and access, the INSciTS member directory • Access leadership opportunities in the INSciTS organization To learn more about membership, including levels and dues, go to: https://www.inscits.org/ While you’re there, read testimonials from current INSciTS members about why they joined. Please join the conversation -- attend an INSciTS Special Interest Group Meeting at SciTS 2019! INSciTS Special Interest Groups (SIGs) will meet during the SciTS 2019 conference on Tuesday, May 21 at 12:15 pm. Meeting rooms are listed in the conference program. Please join the conversation! You do not have to be an INSciTS member to participate in a SIG meeting at the SciTS 2019 meeting – all are welcome to participate and share their input! SIGs are chaired by national leaders on key topics in the SciTS field.
    [Show full text]
  • An Interdisciplinary Research Agenda for Coastal Fog Systems White Paper
    Fog Research Frontiers: An Interdisciplinary Research Agenda for Coastal Fog Systems White Paper 30 June 2014 White Paper Citation: Weathers, K.C., J. Collett, Jr., R. Garreaud, C. Jordan, P. Matrai, M. O’Rourke, A. Torregrosa, and L. Borre. 2014. Fog Research Frontiers: An Interdisciplinary Research Agenda for Coastal Fog Systems. Kathleen C. Weathers, Ph.D. Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies Box AB, 2801 Sharon Turnpike Millbrook, NY 12545 Tel: (845) 677-7600 ext. 137 www.caryinstitute.org with Coastal Fog as a System Steering Committee: Jeffrey Collett, Jr., Ph.D. Rene Garreaud, Ph.D. Carolyn Jordan, Ph.D. Patricia Matrai, Ph.D. Michael O’Rourke, Ph.D. Alicia Torregrosa, MS Lisa Borre (scribe), MES Table of Contents Acknowledgments……………………………………………………………………………………………………i Executive Summary…………………………………………………………………………………………………ii I. Introduction………………………………………………………………………………………………..1 II. Process Overview………………………………………………………………………………………..6 III. Current State of Fog Research……………………………………………………………………13 IV. Coastal Fog System Research Frontiers………………………………………………….....19 V. Lessons for Interdisciplinary Science………………………………………………………….32 VI. Immediate Priorities for Coastal Fog Research…………………………………………..34 References…………………………………………………………………………………………………………….36 Appendices……………………………………………………………………………………………………………43 Coastal Fog-as-a-System K.C. Weathers et al. Acknowledgments The Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies gratefully acknowledges the participation of and encouragement from the international fog science community in developing this fog research agenda. This report was funded by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation through Grant GBMF3414 to Kathleen C. Weathers, Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies. We offer special thanks to Gary Knoblock, former Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation Program Director, Dr. Ajit Subramaniam, Program Director, and Fransheska Rivera Vega of the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation. Dr. Jonathan Kramer and Emily Shepard were especially helpful in providing verbal and artistic facilitation for the Frontiers Workshop.
    [Show full text]
  • Organized Oral Session 43. Novel Applications of High-Frequency
    Reports Organized Oral Session 43. Novel Applications of High-Frequency Sensor Data in Aquatic Ecosystems: Discoveries from GLEON, the Global Lake Ecological Observatory Network Session 43 was organized by C. C. Carey and P. C. Hanson and was held on Thursday, 11 August 2011 at the ESA Annual Meeting in Austin, Texas. Report authors Cayelan C. Carey, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York Paul C. Hanson, Center for Limnology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin Denise A. Bruesewitz, University of Texas Austin Marine Science Institute, Port Aransas, Texas Gordon W. Holtgrieve, School of Aquatic and Fishery Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington Emily L. Kara, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin Kevin C. Rose, Smithsonian Environmental Research Center, Edgewater, Maryland Robyn L. Smyth, Smithsonian Environmental Research Center, Edgewater, Maryland Kathleen C. Weathers, Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, New York Presenters Paul Hanson. “Dissolved oxygen from 20 lake observatories: changing drivers from minutes to months” Robyn Smyth. “Diurnal mixed-layer dynamics: insights from high-frequency sensor data” Kevin Rose. “Understanding allochthony: new techniques and tools” Denise Bruesewitz. “Drivers of pelagic metabolism: evidence from high-frequency free-water measurements in lakes around the globe” Gordon Holtgrieve. “Intra-diel patterns in ecosystem respiration revealed using continuous
    [Show full text]
  • Curriculum Vitae Nancy Beth Grimm
    Curriculum Vitae Nancy Beth Grimm School of Life Sciences (480) 965-4735 (Office) Faculty of Ecology, Evolution & Environmental Science (480) 965-1517 (Lab) Arizona State University ( (480) 965-6899 (FAX) Tempe, AZ 85287-4501 email: [email protected] Married to Scott L. Collins Two children: Ian B. Fisher, Orion B. Fisher EDUCATION AND EMPLOYMENT HISTORY Education B.A. in Natural Science (ecology), Hampshire College, Amherst, MA, 1978. Thesis title: Factors controlling abundance of Nostoc parmeloides in Oregon mountain streams. Advisors: C. D’Avanzo, J. Sedell M.S. in Zoology, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, 1980. Thesis title: Nitrogen and phosphorus dynamics in southwestern desert stream ecosystems. Advisor: W. L. Minckley Ph.D. in Zoology, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, 1985. Dissertation title: Roles of primary producers and consumers in the nitrogen cycle of a Sonoran Desert stream. Advisor: W. L. Minckley Post-doctoral Fellowship (National Science Foundation), Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, 1987–1989. Factors controlling periphyton abundance and production during stream succession. Mentor: S. G. Fisher. Principal Professional Employment 2018– Virginia M. Ullman Professor of Ecology, School of Life Sciences, Arizona State University 2003–2018 Professor, School of Life Sciences, Arizona State University 2010– Senior Sustainability Scientist, Global Institute of Sustainability, Arizona State University 2011–2012 Senior Scientist for the National Climate Assessment, US Global Change Research Program (on detail from the
    [Show full text]
  • Kathleen Cushing Weathers
    Curriculum Vitae Kathleen Cushing Weathers G. Evelyn Hutchinson Chair in Ecology Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies Box AB, Millbrook, New York 12545 (845) 677-7600 x 137 E-mail: [email protected] Education Rutgers University, Piscataway, New Jersey Ph.D., Ecology, 1993 Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut M.F.S., Forest Science, 1983 Albion College, Albion, Michigan B.A., English (cum laude), 1978 Professional Experience Primary Positions 2016-2021 G. Evelyn Hutchinson Chair in Ecology, Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, NY 2007-present Senior Scientist, Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, NY 2009-2010 Program Director, DEB, Ecosystem Cluster, National Science Foundation, VA 2004-2006 Senior Scientist, Head of Laboratory Services, Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, NY 2004 Scientist, Head of Laboratory Services, Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, NY (50:50 Administration/Research) 1999-2004 Associate Scientist, Head of Laboratory Services, Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, NY (50:50 Administration/Research) 1994-1999 Forest Ecologist, Head of Laboratory Services, Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, NY (50:50 Administration/Research) 1988-1994 Forest Ecologist, Manager of Laboratory Facilities, Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, NY (75:25 Administration/Research) 1984-1986 Coordinator, Cloud Water Project, Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, NY 1982, 1983 Research Assistant, Yale University/AMC, New Haven, CT Additional Positions 2019-2020 Expert, National
    [Show full text]
  • Ambient Air Quality Standards
    Policy Assessment for the Review of the Lead National Ambient Air Quality Standards This page is intentionally blank. EPA-452/R-14-001 May 2014 Policy Assessment for the Review of the Lead National Ambient Air Quality Standards U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards Health and Environmental Impacts Division Research Triangle Park, North Carolina DISCLAIMER This document has been reviewed by the Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards (OAQPS), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and approved for publication. This OAQPS Policy Assessment contains conclusions of the staff of the OAQPS and does not necessarily reflect the views of the Agency. Mention of trade names or commercial products is not intended to constitute endorsement or recommendation for use. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This Policy Assessment is the product of the Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards. It has been developed as part of the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) ongoing review of the national ambient air quality standards (NAAQS) for lead (Pb). The Pb NAAQS review team has been led by Dr. Deirdre Murphy. For the chapter on the health effects evidence and exposure/risk information, the principal authors include Dr. Deirdre Murphy and Dr. Zach Pekar, and Dr. Murphy served as the principal author for the chapter on the primary Pb standard. For the chapters on welfare effects evidence and exposure/risk information and the secondary Pb standard, the principal author is Ms. Ginger Tennant. The principal author on the section discussing ambient air monitoring is Mr. Kevin Cavender. Contributors of emissions information and air quality analyses are Mr.
    [Show full text]