DOCSLIB.ORG

<Title of Work, Centered

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
<Title of Work, Centered A Schaefferian Sociology: The Social theory of Francis Schaeffer. by James Henson, B.S.W. A Thesis In SOCIOLOGY Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Texas Tech University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS Approved Dr. Charlotte Dunham Chair Dr. Jerome Koch Fred Hartmeister Dean of the Graduate School December, 2008 Copyright 2007, James Henson Texas Tech University, James Henson, December, 2008 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS First and foremost I would like to thank my committee for their help and understanding in the process of completing this thesis. Dr. Dunham has been exceptionally patient and open to new ideas as my thesis gradually morphed into an entirely different paper than was originally planned. Her help and insight was invaluable throughout the process and I would not have completed it without her. Dr. Koch offered guidance and insight that greatly changed the nature of what I was looking at with this thesis, making it much more interesting and worthwhile to pursue. I greatly appreciate both of them. I would like to thank Dr. Yung-Mei Tsai for consistently pushing me in his classes and opening new avenues of interest for me in my time at Texas Tech. I also appreciate his conversing with me on various topics, often outside the realm of what was pertinent to the issue at hand, I have learned a lot from him. The content analysis for this thesis would not have been completed without the help of Dr. Jason Wasserman. His depth and insight allowed me to see past what were surface level ideas and find something more in the work I was reading. I appreciate the friends I made in the program. I have never been part of a group as accepting and supportive of one another as they were. Coming in with little understanding of academia made their help invaluable to me and I liked them enough to marry one of them. That being said, I also thank Barbara for being a source of constant support in my life. ii Texas Tech University, James Henson, December, 2008 My parents have tolerated more than any parent should have to from a child and I am appreciative of their patience. There is little doubt I would be in prison or the ground without them. Lastly, I would like to thank Dr. Julie Harms-Cannon for her years of friendship and support. She stopped me from dropping out of college years ago and was the reason I came to graduate school in the first place; without her the idea of a graduate degree would not have even crossed my radar. As the first teacher to truly take an interest in me as a student Julie changed the course of my life and I will always be in her debt for this. iii Texas Tech University, James Henson, December, 2008 TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ..................................................................................................... i ABSTRACT..................................................................................................................... vi I. INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................... 1 Why Francis Schaeffer?............................................................................................. 1 II. LITERATURE REVIEW / THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK........................... 5 The Christian Right.................................................................................................... 5 The Battle for Secular Influence ................................................................................ 5 The Battle for Internal Control ................................................................................ 11 Variety in the Movement .......................................................................................... 12 Stability Through Change ........................................................................................ 14 The Christian Left .................................................................................................... 15 The Christian Right and the Culture Wars .............................................................. 17 The Historical War................................................................................................... 17 Orthodox versus Progressive ................................................................................... 19 The Importance of Moral Authority......................................................................... 25 The Discourse .......................................................................................................... 27 War Zones ................................................................................................................ 33 The Christian Right in the Culture War................................................................... 38 Francis Schaeffer ..................................................................................................... 41 The Life and Influence of Francis Schaeffer............................................................ 42 Francis Schaeffer’s Belief and Philosophy.............................................................. 50 Problems and Inconsistencies.................................................................................. 53 Impact on Christianity ............................................................................................. 57 A Christian Manifesto .............................................................................................. 58 III. METHODS............................................................................................................ 61 IV. CONTENT ANALYSIS........................................................................................ 64 Overarching Structure ............................................................................................. 64 Authority – God’s versus Human............................................................................. 71 Belief ........................................................................................................................ 73 Foundational Decay................................................................................................. 78 Impending Foundational Destruction...................................................................... 81 Diametric Enemies................................................................................................... 83 Comprehensive Spirituality...................................................................................... 85 V. ANALYSIS ............................................................................................................. 88 Francis Schaeffer’s Life and the Culture War ......................................................... 88 Francis Schaeffer’s Philosophy and the Culture War ............................................. 91 A Manifesto for a Culture War ................................................................................ 93 Fundamental Conflict .............................................................................................. 94 Rhetorical War......................................................................................................... 95 A Manifesto for the Real World ............................................................................... 99 Comprehensive Understanding.............................................................................. 102 iv Texas Tech University, James Henson, December, 2008 The Social Theory of Francis Schaeffer................................................................. 103 VI. CONCLUSION ................................................................................................... 108 SOURCES CITED ................................................................................................... 110 v Texas Tech University, James Henson, December, 2008 ABSTRACT This thesis seeks to explore the role of Christian philosopher Francis Schaeffer in the culture war as delineated by author James Davison Hunter through his influence on the Christian Right. After a brief examination of the history of the Christian Right and an exploration of Francis Schaeffer’s life and philosophy, the culture war as conceived by Hunter will be introduced and examined. Following this will be an in- depth analysis of Schaeffer’s work A Christian Manifesto. The paper will conclude with an analysis of Schaeffer’s overall role in the culture war and an examination of the social theory implicit in his work. The findings of this paper suggest that, through his status in the Christian Right, Francis Schaeffer has a significant impact on the culture war and, therefore, the landscape of American culture as well. vi Texas Tech University, James Henson, December, 2008 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION Why Francis Schaeffer? Francis Schaeffer is hardly a household name. In fact, few outside of a specifically defined circle seem to have even heard of him. In contrast, names such as Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, James Dobson, Tim LaHaye and Ronald Reagan all carry a high degree of recognition and may even be some of the most high-profile in the last century, certainly so if one is to limit his or her focus to the United States and even more so if the focus is further limited to what has come to be known as the Religious Right. However, these high-profile names have more in common than a connection to conservative values in American culture; all were heavily influenced by the writings and philosophy of Francis Schaeffer. Schaeffer’s influence in pulling Christians
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Francis Schaeffer's Burdens
    “The Church Before the Watching World:” Francis Schaeffer’s Burdens Andrew Fellows Andrew Fellows is a teacher and conference speaker, and the director of apologetics for Christian Heritage, Cambridge. After serving a term in the pastorate he spent twenty one years with his family in the English branch of L’Abri Fellowship and from 2011 to 2016 served as the Chairman of L’Abri International. Andrew has recently writtenSmuggling Jesus Back Into the Church; How the Church Became Worldly and What to do About It due for publication by IVP in early 2022. He has several other books in the pipeline written for skeptics. Andrew has a special interest in cultural apologetics. In this article I am arguing for a retrieval and serious re-engagement with Francis Schaeffer’s message to the church. There is no doubting that Schaeffer left a considerable and enduring legacy—one I would argue is worthy of our attention today. For many he is best known for L’Abri, the community he founded in Switzerland with his wife Edith in 1955. Among its various purposes, this “shelter” served as a place of asylum for doubters who had questions the church failed to take seriously. Schaeffer also achieved notoriety for his work as an apologist to sceptics. Through his lectures, writings and documentary styled films he argued for the credibility of the faith, encour- aging a generation of evangelicals to be confident in the truth. Others may remember him for bravely tackling the ethical issues of the day. His book entitled, Whatever Happened to the Human Race (later turned into a film) brought issues like abortion infanticide and euthanasia to the attention of Christians who otherwise would have remained oblivious to such matters.
    [Show full text]
  • The Legacy of Francis Schaeffer — an Apologetic for Post-Moderns
    201 Fifty Years on: The Legacy of Francis Schaeffer — An Apologetic for Post-moderns Christopher Tinker and Melvin Tinker IT was in 1955 ThaT one of The mosT significanT evangelical apologeTic movemenTs was born: The L’Abri fellowship, founded by Dr. Francis Schaeffer and his wife EdiTh. WhaT began almosT ‘accidenTally’ wiTh a few young enquirers having Their searching quesTions handled honesTly and compassionaTely, was To become a force for The gospel which has influenced many Thousands around The world up To, and including, The presenT day. Given ThaT Schaeffer was an acTive apologisT from The 1950s To The early 1980s, his work was conducTed in a largely modernisT conTexT. As such, his apologeTic may seem To come down To us wiTh a long elapsed ‘sell by daTe’ readily aTTached. Schaeffer has been criTicised for having a far Too raTionalisTic approach To apologeTics and his hisTories of WesTern ThoughT have been rendered as Too simplisTic. 1 WhaT is more, Schaeffer was working wiTh a concepT of absoluTe TruTh in a climaTe dominaTed by raTionalism, boTh of which are, aT The very leasT, TreaTed wiTh suspicion if noT downrighT disdain by posT- moderns. WhilsT recognising The limiTaTions of Schaeffer’s work (and of course The same is True of all apologisTs—C. S. Lewis, G. K. ChesTerTon To name buT Two), we mainTain ThaT Schaeffer’s approach To apologeTics sTill provides a valuable resource for The way in which ChrisTians mighT engage wiTh The posT- modern mind. NoT only do Schaeffer’s ideas provide a framework for undersTanding The posT-modern world, buT various aspecTs of his approach prove eminenTly suiTed To The presenT posT-modern scene.
    [Show full text]
  • 20 Changing American Evangelical Attitudes Towards
    Changing American Evangelical Attitudes towards Roman Catholics: 1960-2000 Don Sweeting Don Sweeting is Senior Pastor of Introduction summing up forty years of evangelicalism Cherry Creek Presbyterian Church, in In 1960, Presidential campaign historian since 1945, Bayly said, “We inherited a Englewood, Colorado. He has also Theodore H. White observed that “the Berlin Wall between evangelical Chris- served as the founding pastor of the largest and most important division in tians and Roman Catholics; we bequeath Chain of Lakes Community Bible Church American society was that between Prot- a spirit of love and rapprochement on in Antioch, Illinois. Dr. Sweeting was estants and Catholics.”1 As a vital part of the basis of the Bible rather than fear and educated at Moody Bible Institute, American Protestant life, evangelicalism hatred.”7 Lawrence University, Oxford University reflected the strains of this conflict.2 Anti- By the mid 1990s, it was clear that atti- (M.A.), and Trinity Evangelical Divinity Catholicism, according to church historian tudes were changing. On a local level, School (Ph.D.) where he wrote his dis- George Marsden, “was simply an unques- evangelicals and Catholics were meeting sertation on the relationship between tioned part of the fundamentalist- to discuss issues from poverty and wel- evangelicals and Roman Catholics. evangelicalism of the day.”3 fare reform to abortion. On the national This posture of outright public hostil- level changes were also apparent. Evan- ity was evidenced in many ways. It could gelical publishing houses were printing be seen in the opposition of many evan- books by Catholic authors. Some evangeli- gelical leaders to the presidential candi- cal parachurch ministries began placing dacy of John F.
    [Show full text]
  • Thurman Stresses Spiritual Race,- Illustrates with Training Practices
    ClClassesasses ElectElect Heads Heads Another roster roster of class of officersclass officers Thurman StressesStresses Spiritual Spiritual Race,- Race for CovenantCovenant College College students students was was ; named for for the the new newschool school year. year. Having only only a few a membersfew members in in Illustrates WithWith TrainingTraining Practices Practices their classes, classes, neither neither the seniors the seniors B ECAUSE nor thethe juniors juniors felt it feltnecessary it necessary BECAUSE a aChristian ChrisUan cannot cannot be be running a arace race spiritually spiritually and must and must to holdhold elections elections this year.this year. an effectiveeffective soldier soldier of Christ of Christ if if abide by by training training rules, rules, Thurman’s Thurman's Sophomores chose chose as theiras theirlead­ lead­ he doesdoes not not have have a close a close walk walkwith with messages were were straight straight to the to the ers: Bill Bill McColley, McColley, president; president; Ju­ Ju­ the Lord,Lord, Covenant Covenant College College held aheld a point. dy Kesselring,Kesselring, vice-president; vice-president; Bill Bill series of of meetings meetings last lastmonth, month, with with In anan interview, interview, Rev. Rev. Kyle Kyle Thur­ Thur­ Ketterer, secretary-treasurer; secretary-treasurer; and and Rev. KyleKyle Thurman, Thurman, pastor pastor of the of the man said: said: “The "The most wonderfulmost wonderful Jeanne Morris Morris and andDave DaveFiol, so­ Fiol, so­ Gainesville, Texas, Tex,as,
    [Show full text]
  • Son of a Mother's
    by Timothy Tow an autobiography 2 Son of a Mother’s Vow Son of a Mother’s Vow © 2001 Rev. (Dr.) Timothy Tow 9A Gilstead Road, Singapore 309063. ISBN 981-04-2907-X Published by FEBC Bookroom 9A Gilstead Road, Singapore 309063. http://www.lifefebc.com Printed in the Republic of Singapore. Cover design by Charles Seet. Contents 3 Contents Acknowledgement ......................................................................... 6 Prologue ......................................................................................... 7 1. Discovering Our Roots 1815-1868 ................................................................................. 9 2. Childhood Memories of China 1920-1926 ............................................................................... 29 3. Exodus To Nanyang (The South Seas) 1926-1935 ............................................................................... 45 4. The Singapore Pentecost 1935 ........................................................................................ 63 5. No Failure, No Success 1936-1948 ............................................................................... 85 6. Faith Of Our Fathers 1948-1950 ............................................................................. 125 7. Mother’s Vow Fulfilled 1950 ...................................................................................... 131 8. Beginnings Of A Young Pastor 1950-1951 ............................................................................. 138 9. By Sword and Trowel 1951-1956 ............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Critiques of Francis Schaeffer's Work
    The Critiques of Francis Schaeffer’s Work The Critiques of Francis Schaeffer’s Work Niko Sudibjo Faculty of Education, Universitas Pelita Harapan, Tangerang, Banten [email protected] Abstract This paper will attempt to discuss Francis Schaeffer’s life and thought, with special emphasis on his apologetics. The primary resource is one of his books, ‘How Should We Then Live?’ and also several books about Schaeffer from various other authors: (1) Francis Schaeffer’s Apologetics: A Critique by Thomas Morris, (2) Reflection on Francis Schaeffer, edited by Ronald W. Ruegsegger, and (3) Francis Schaeffer: The Man and His Message, written by Louis Gifford Parkhurst, Jr. In his method of apologetical verification, he used of elements of common ground as a point of contact with unbelievers. Unlike the inductive approach, he majors on inner, existential values as well as outer empirical data. In contrast with the pre-suppositional approach, Schaeffer’s method discovers and appeals to factual and personal data in confirmation of his hypothesis Keywords: apologetics, presupposition, verificationalist Abstrak Tulisan ini mencoba untuk mendiskusikan kehidupan dan pemikiran Francis Schaeffer, terutama pada bidang apologetik. Bahan utama diskusi adalah berasal dari bukunya yang berjudul How Should we Then Live, dan juga pengarang-pengarang lainnya yang membahas pemikiran Shaeffer dalam buku-bukunya antara lain: (1) Francis Schaeffer’s Apologetics: A Critique by Thomas Morris, (2) Reflection on Francis Schaeffer, edited by Ronald W. Ruegsegger, dan (3) Francis Schaeffer: The Man and His Message, written by Louis Gifford Parkhurst, Jr. Dalam metodenya verifikasi apologetik, Shaeffer menggunakan unsur-unsur kesamaan sebagai titik kontak dengan orang-orang yang belum mengenal Tuhan.
    [Show full text]
  • Carl Mcintire and the Politicization of Fundamentalism
    No Uncertain Trumpet: Carl McIntire and the Politicization of Fundamentalism A Thesis Submitted to the Temple University Graduate Board In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree MASTER OF ARTS By Paul Matzko May, 2010 Thesis Approvals: David Watt, Thesis Advisor, Department of History Jonathan Wells, Temple University Department of History ABSTRACT Fundamentalist preacher Carl McIntire played an important role in the politicization of fundamentalism. His political beliefs and activism complicate the standard accountings for the rise of modern conservatism and the New Christian Right. Hispolitics were inherited from Gresham Machen and were rooted in the nineteenth century tension between evangelical Whigs and confessional Democrats. McIntire’s libertarian political philosophy coalesced during the denominational politics of the fundamentalist – modernist controversy of the 1920s and ‘30s.He criticized theological modernists for supporting an expansion of federal government authority and being “soft” on communism. He gained national attention for his campaigns to purchases airtime on radio stations. McIntire influenced a number of prominent fundamentalist leaders, like Billy Hargis, Fred Schwarz, and Francis Schaeffer. McIntire’s political consciousness can be used to describe the concepts of “ideological creep” and “mainstreaming.” i TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………………………….i CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………………...1 2. BIOGRAPHY AND DENOMINATIONAL POLITICS……………………………….7 3. GRESHAM MACHEN
    [Show full text]
  • SBJT Forum SBJT: in Your Life, You Briefly Interacted with Francis Schaef- Fer and Were Influenced by Him
    SBJT Forum SBJT: In your life, you briefly interacted with Francis Schaef- fer and were influenced by him. Reflect on Schaeffer’s legacy and importance for the evangelical church. Mark T. Coppenger: As I was begin- Mark T. Coppenger was Professor of Christian ning my doctoral work in philosophy at Philosophy and Ethics at The Southern Baptist Vanderbilt in 1970, I became aware of a Theological Seminary, Louisville, Kentucky, Christian mentor of some sort in Switzer- prior to his retirement. In addition to pastoring land, one sporting knee pants and a billy churches in Arkansas and Illinois, he has done goat beard. I somehow laid my hands on denominational service with the Indiana Baptist his little book,Escape from Reason, and convention, the SBC Executive Committee, and was intrigued and pleasantly surprised Midwestern Baptist Seminary, as well short term that he was conversant and engaged with missionary stints on five continents. Dr. Cop- some secular philosophers. Most of the penger has also taught at Vanderbilt, Wheaton, Christian literature with which I was Elmhurst, Trinity, and Midwestern. His columns familiar came in the form of commen- have appeared online for The Gospel Coalition, tary, devotion, and biography. But here Cornwall Alliance, and The American Spectator. was a fellow mixing it up with the likes His most recent book is Moral Apologetics for of Kant and Rousseau. Contemporary Christians (B&H 2011); For Little did I know that, in the years Such a Time as This (Westbow, 2018); Cases ahead, I would lead the discussion of and Maps: A Christian Introduction to Philosophy his film seriesHow Should We Then (Wipf & Stock, 2019); God and Humanity at Live? in Wheaton, at College Church Marshall: Toward November 14, 1970 and Beyond and Bethany Chapel (Plymouth Breth- (Wipf & Stock, 2020).
    [Show full text]
  • 4 Francis A. Schaeffer
    Francis A. Schaef fer (1912-1984): Lessons from His Thought and Life Stephen J. Wellum Stephen J. Wellum is an associate Why Study the Life and Thought be constantly written to apply the professor of Christian Theology at The of Francis Schaeffer?1 unchanging Word to a changing world, so Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. There are two ways that this question we need to study contemporary individu- Dr. Wellum received his Ph.D. degree could be asked. First, why study any his- als who can better help us to respond in theology from Trinity Evangelical torical figure? And second, why specifi- faithfully, without compromise, to Divinity School, and has also taught cally reflect on the life and thought of present-day challenges that confront the theology at the Associated Canadian Francis Schaeffer? After all, what makes church. Theological Schools and Northwest him so important to reflect on in contrast But why study Francis Schaeffer? The Baptist Theological College and Semi- to other people? answer to this second question is that nary in Canada. He has contributed The simple answer to the first question there is probably no single figure that has to several publications and a collection is that we want to learn and be challenged affected and impacted evangelicalism in of essays on theology and worldview by Christian men and women who have the latter half of the twentieth century issues. gone before us. In Scripture the theme of more than Francis Schaeffer. For this people serving as role models for us, both reason alone, we need to take him seri- positively and even negatively, is abun- ously.
    [Show full text]
  • Building a Theological Library
    Building a Theological Library The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary Published by Daniel L. Akin, Academic Vice President Dean, School of Theology Why Build a Biblical{fheologlcal Library? Books are to the minister of the gospel of Jesus Christ what tools are to the carpenter: the essentials of the trade. A call to ministry is a call to preparation, and the building of a ministerial library is a must, not an option. As the apostle Paul faced his impending death he still remained a student, requesting of Timothy that he bring the books when he came to visit him in prison (2 Tim. 4:13). This booklet has been prepared for those who desire to follow in Paul's steps. Over 600 titles are listed as those books which should be acquired first as you begin your library. Each is an important title which you will find helpful in ministry for our Lord. Most titles are written from an evangelical perspective, hav­ ing been authored by individuals who affirm the full authority and inspiration of Scripture (Matt. 5:17-18; 2 Tim. 3:16-17,2 Pet. 1:20-21). However, though a good library is necessary as a solid foundation for ministry, training under godly men and women is also important (2 Tim. 2:2). You may be someone who senses God's calling for further study and preparation. The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary exists for this very purpose, with a faculty and program of study designed to enable the student to be a careful and equipped teacher of Holy Scripture.
    [Show full text]
  • La•E•A•I 1• 111!11! Luar1er11
    la•e•a•I 1• 111!11! luar1er11 PUBLISHED BY COVENANT COLLEGE, LOOKOUT MOUNTAIN, TENNESSEE · EARLY SUMMER, 1969 Covenant College's main building became "Carter Hall" in a simple outdoor ceremony on April 8. Many of Chatta­ nooga's foremost citizens gathered to honor Paul Burton Carter, a local industrialist and real estate developer who originally constructed the building in which Covenant is now located. That was in the late twenties. The economic depression which followed closely after the building's gala opening wiped out Mr. Carter's early investment. But a determined spirit and a keen financial sense brought Mr. Carter again to a place of leadership in Chattanooga's business and civic circles. Even though the hotel which Mr. Carter built was oper­ ated independently of him for many years, still it stood as a symbol of his style and vision. "It was always my dream," he said recently, "that through the hotel we would attract people from all over the country to come and visit the Chattanooga area." Now- in a sense - that dream is fulfilled. Not only from all parts of the country, but literally from all over the world, students come to Covenant College. They live and eat and study and worship in the castle-like structure which Paul Carter dreamed of and built. That building, more than any other single human factor, was the reason for the move of Covenant College to Lookout Mountain in 1964. Now just a little more than comfortably full, the '\ President Barnes (left) and Chairman of the Board U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Francis Schaeffer— an Appreciation Barry Seagren
    Francis Schaeffer— An Appreciation Barry Seagren Barry Seagren received his BA in Physics from Haverford College and then worked as an engineer in the US space program. During that time he was converted and his life redirected. He received his MDiv from Covenant Seminary, graduating first in his class and winning the homiletics prize. During his Covenant years he spent a summer at L’Abri in Switzerland where he met his English wife, Veronica. After Covenant Sem- inary they joined the staff of L’Abri, serving for 23 years first in Switzerland, then in Southborough, MA, and finally in Greatham, England. Barry then became pastor of the church that had grown out of the English L’Abri, serving there for twelve years before retiring. He and his wife continue to live in England where they have three children and eight grandchildren. They try to contribute where they can in their church and community and family. The person who touched me more deeply and shaped me more profoundly than anyone else was Francis Schaeffer. He had his faults and his critics. It’s not my purpose to discuss those. I want to briefly recount his life in an attempt to show why he had such an impact on me and on so many others, and why his legacy is still crucial for us today. Francis Schaeffer was born in Philadelphia in 1912. He was the only child of working class, unbelieving parents. He was converted at the age of 18. He had become interested in philosophy and was reading some of the Greek and Latin classics.
    [Show full text]