Robert C. Jubelirer Senate of Pennsylvania 1975-2006

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Robert C. Jubelirer Senate of Pennsylvania 1975-2006 Lessons from a Legislative Life First Edition Robert C. Jubelirer Senate of Pennsylvania 1975-2006 As told to Vincent P. Carocci With David A. Atkinson Bassim Hamadeh, CEO and Publisher Kassie Graves, Director of Acquisitions and Sales Jamie Giganti, Senior Managing Editor Miguel Macias, Senior Graphic Designer John Remington, Senior Field Acquisitions Editor Monika Dziamka, Project Editor Brian Fahey, Licensing Specialist Christian Berk, Interior Designer Copyright © 2018 by Cognella, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information retrieval system without the written permission of Cognella, Inc. For inquiries regarding permissions, translations, foreign rights, audio rights, and any other forms of reproduction, please contact the Cognella Licensing Department at [email protected]. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Copyright © 2013 by iStockphoto LP/gnagel. Printed in the United States of America ISBN: 978-1-5165-1136-5 (pbk) / 978-1-5165-1137-2 (br) Contents Dedication v About the Principal vii About the Collaborators ix Acknowledgments xi INTRODUCTION xv CHAPTER I A Pay Raise, a Primary, and Poof, a New Career Path 1 CHAPTER II The Beginning: Influences, Inspirations, and Elections 11 CHAPTER III Welcome to the Capitol 15 CHAPTER IV The Principal Players 21 CHAPTER V Grading the Governors 41 CHAPTER VI The General Assembly 67 iv | Lessons from a Legislative Life CHAPTER VII Hits, Misses, and (If Only We Could) Do-Overs 75 CHAPTER VIII The Media 101 CHAPTER IX The Lobbyists 113 CHAPTER X Legal vs. Legislative 123 CHAPTER XI The Projects 135 CHAPTER XII Friends and Allies 155 EPILOGUE: LESSONS FROM, AND FOR, LEGISLATIVE LIFE 159 DEDICATION o my mother and father, who were endlessly faithful in their encour- T agement and never stopped believing in me. My mother was as loving and supportive as any mother could be. My father taught me the value of honesty and hard work. He frequently reminded me that all he had to leave me was his good name, and admonished that I better not screw things up. To Laurie and Jeff, two amazing kids who did not always have it easy during my campaigns, during my time away from home, and during the many times when I was publicly criticized and scorned. They could not have been more supportive or more patient with me. I am so very proud of who they have become as adults, with wonderful spouses and children and careers they fashioned in their own right. To Andy, who I dearly miss and think about daily. To Renee, who has been at my side for more than a decade, who keeps me focused and looking at the bright side of life, and who encouraged me to chronicle my experiences and insight in this book. She is a truly wonderful partner and daily demonstrates the attributes of a brilliant and exceedingly hard-working judge, characteristics and traits she possessed long before meeting me. To my staff, in Harrisburg and in the district, who gave me loyalty, dedication, intelligence, skill, and so much more for thirty-two years. There was a saying that “the staff reflects the member,” but this member was able to succeed more often than not because of the outstanding people and profes- sionals I was privileged to work with. vi | Lessons from a Legislative Life To the residents of the Thirtieth Senatorial District, who put their trust in me for more than three decades, who gave me the chance to serve and to lead through good times and tough times, and who always offered plain-spoken and unvarnished opinions, advice, suggestions, and criticism as the circumstances warranted. To the public-spirited men and women with whom I served, foremost for their service and contributions, but also for their confidence in me. To the many individuals whose instruction, encouragement, guidance, and support made my career possible, and by extension, this book. They are owed more credit and gratitude than I can possibly express. —Robert C. Jubelirer August 2017 ABOUT THE PRINCIPAL obert C. Jubelirer, with thirty-two years of electoral service cover- R ing eight consecutive four-year terms between 1975 and 2006, is the longest-serving president pro tempore—the third-highest elective office in the commonwealth—in the chamber’s history, nearly twenty-one years. He also is the first elected Pennsylvania official to serve simultaneously as lieutenant governor and president pro tempore, following the resignation in October 2001 of former Governor Tom Ridge to become the nation’s first national security advisor of the president. When first elected in November 1974, he was the only Republican candidate for the state Senate to win in the wake of the national Watergate political scandal. When his Senate service ended in 2006, he became the head of the Government Relations Division of the Obermayer Rebmann Maxwell & Hippel law firm, with offices in Harrisburg and Altoona, Pennsylvania. He is married to Commonwealth Court Judge Renee Cohn Jubelirer and is the father of three—Laurie Jubelirer Langman, married to Dr. Charles Langman; Andrew (deceased); and Jeffrey, married to Dr. Tracey Friedman Jubelirer. He also is the stepfather of three sons—Gideon, Michael, and Jonathan Cohn—and the grandfather of two boys and three girls: Samuel, Rebecca and Andrew Langman, and Sofie and Alison Jubelirer. Former Senator Jubelirer and Judge Cohn Jubelirer reside in Boalsburg, Pennsylvania. He is a graduate of the Pennsylvania State University and the Penn State Dickinson School of Law. He was elected in May 2014 as an alumni member of the Penn State Board of Trustees. ABOUT THE COLLABORATORS ince Carocci is a graduate of the Pennsylvania State University with V a BA in journalism. After an active duty tour as a lieutenant with a US military intelligence unit in Washington, DC, he entered a career as a capitol correspondent in Harrisburg for United Press International (1961); the Associated Press (1962–68) and the Philadelphia Inquirer (1970–71). He entered public service in 1971 as a senior aide with the Democratic caucus of the Pennsylvania Senate. He served on the senior staff of the late Governor Robert P. Casey (1987–95), the last five years of which he was press secretary to the governor. He is the author of four books (A Father’s Life, self-published; A Capitol Journey, Penn State Press; Harry’s Way, Tuxedo Press; and Part of the Parade, Mawby Project Group) and a collaborator on two others (this one and Ward Leader in circulation to potential publishers). He and his wife, Antoinette, live in Camp Hill. They are the parents of four grown children. David Atkinson is a graduate of Shippensburg University with a BA in Government and an MS in Mass Communications. He was a senior staff aide and advisor to Senator Robert C. Jubelirer for nearly thirty years, then spent two years on the staff of Senator Gib Armstrong of Lancaster County before retiring in March 2012 after thirty-five years of staff service with the Pennsylvania Senate. Prior to joining the Senate, he worked for the Pennsylvania Republican State Committee, including an assignment as me- dia relations director for the Pennsylvania delegation to the 1976 Republican National Convention in Kansas City. He now works as a consultant in the Harrisburg area and is an associate with the Susquehanna Valley Center for Public Policy. He and his wife, Anne, live in Susquehanna Township. They are the parents of a daughter and a son, and the grandparents of two girls. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS FROM BOB JUBELIRER hen we began thinking about a collaborator for this “as told to” W book, our initial fishing expedition among academic types—even at my alma mater—turned up no interest whatsoever. Then David Atkinson suggested Vince Carocci. Vince had written and had published several books, one in particular about his experiences in Pennsylvania state government, politics, and the press corps. He started out professionally as a reporter, so clearly he had the requisite journalistic training and know-how. He was a Democrat, so he brought political balance to the effort. His career spanned mine, so he was familiar with most of the events we would be discussing and could serve as an additional fact-checker. I had interacted with Vince when he worked for the Senate Democrats, when he was representing the State System of Higher Education, when he was in the inner circle during the Casey administration, and when he was doing public affairs work at Capital BlueCross. I knew him to be intelligent, fair, and capable. We met for lunch, with Steve MacNett and John Giannelli joining David and me for the presentation—and, as it turned out, persuasion. Vince was hesitant at first, no doubt haunted still by the memory of the exceptionally partisan and disputatious Casey years. But as we talked about our enthusiasm xii | Lessons from a Legislative Life for the project, showed him the outline we had assembled, and assured him our intention was not to do a version of Harrisburg Babylon, he began to warm to the idea. Having spent more than two years putting a manuscript together, which was deeper and broader than I ever imagined, I have no hesitation in saying our choice was inspired. Vince exhibited remarkable patience in coaxing out the stories in coherent fashion, in waiting for my recovered memories to kick in, and in having to constantly add material and reedit what had sup- posedly been put to bed.
Recommended publications
  • Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Friday
    COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA FRIDAY, OCTOBER 5,2001 SESSION OF 2001 185TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 47 SENATE MEMBER OF THE ERIE COUNTY CONVENTION CENTER AUTHORITY FRIDAY, October 5, 2001 The Senate met at 1 p.m., Eastern Daylight Saving Time. October 2, 200I The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mary Jo White) in the Chair. To the Honorable, the Senate ofthe Commonwealth ofPennsylvania: PRAYER In confonnity with law, I have the honor hereby to nominate for the advice and consent ofthe Senate, Roger W. Richards, 969 Dutch Road, The Chaplain, The Most Reverend JOSEPH V. ADAMEC, Fairview 16415, Erie County, Forty-ninth Senatorial District, for ap­ Bishop of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Altoona and pointment as a member ofthe Erie County Convention Center Author­ Johnstown, offered the following prayer: ity, to serve for a tenn offour years and until his successor is appointed and qualified, newly created pursuant to section 2399.4 ofthe Third Blessed are You, Lord, God ofall creation, whose goodness Class County Convention Center Authority Act. fills our hearts with joy. In You all things have their beginning, THOMAS 1. RIDGE continuation, and end. Grace us with Your saving presence. You Governor have brought us together this day to witness the inauguration of new leadership for this Commonwealth ofPennsylvania. We pray MEMBER OF THE ERIE COUNTY that what is begun this day with Your inspiration, may continue CONVENTION CENTER AUTHORITY with Your help. Strengthen Your servant Robert with Your grace and wisdom, October 2, 200I that he might always work toward harmony, justice, and peace for Your people.
    [Show full text]
  • Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Legislative
    COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL TUESDAY, JANUARY 15, 1991 SESSION OF 1991 175TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 3 SENATE mercy. May You grant to each a full measure of wisdom and TUESDAY, January 15, 1991. an even fuller measure of courage to stand against the wiles of The Senate met at 10:15 a.m., Eastern Standard Time. temptation and evil. For the Governor and the Lieutenant Governor we pray, be with them as they assume these special The PRESIDENT pro tempore (Robert C. Jubelirer) in the tasks a second time. Grant them Your blessings, that in the Chair. exercise of their continued duties, they may be a light to the The PRESIDENT pro tempore. Let me first clarify the path of others. Be with us all as each faithfully discharges the program. I am the President pro tempore of the Senate, responsibilities of government, and insured with this sacred Senator Robert Jubelirer of Blair County who will be presid­ trust, help each to pass on to the next generation a vital Com­ ing over this ceremony, and the Lieutenant Governor will not monwealth prepared to embrace them and their dreams. have to preside over his own swearing in, so I call that correc­ For the people of Pennsylvania and the confidence they tion to your attention. have placed in those chosen to lead, we also on this day lift Let me welcome each and every one of you to this cere­ our thanks, and it is not as an afterthought, but effective gov­ mony, and I am sure that it will be a most enjoyable day for ernment reflects a strong relationship between leaders and all of us.
    [Show full text]
  • Birds of a Feather….You Have Chosen Your Associates And, Although You
    Birds of a Feather….You have chosen your associates and, although you are, clearly, intelligent, well-informed and very experienced, you have chosen to associate with obstinate, self-serving, incompetent blockheads who do not hear the anger and anguish of the grassroots, the Forgotten Taxpayers, and the middle class working people who are being exploited by ever escalating size and cost of government and are selling out the loyal and credulous Republican voter. Pennsylvania Republican Party Leadership (sometimes called The Establishment, or, as a rude child of nature might say “the bad guys”) To learn more about the leadership of the state party, click the links below. Chairman Rob Gleason Vice Chairman Joyce Haas National Committeewoman Christine J. Toretti National Committeeman Robert Asher Finance Chairman Chris Gleason Deputy Chairman Renee Amoore Treasurer Carolyn “Bunny” Welsh Assistant Treasurer Dick Stewart Secretary John McNally Assistant Secretary Peg Ferraro General Counsel Lawrence Tabas Caucus Chairmen Caucus Chairmen Don Yost Northeast Caucus Chairman Bill Darr Southwest Caucus Chairman Blake Marles Northeast Central Caucus Chairman Michael Meehan Southeast Caucus Chairman Donna Reinaker Central Caucus Co-Chairman Dick Stewart Central Caucus Co-Chairman Robyn Sye Northwest Caucus Chairman You may think it “guilt by association” but when you associate with the guilty, what is any common sense person to think: “birds of a feather flock together”. And here are some of the people you are ‘guilty’ of associating with: BETRAYED and Financially ABUSED 1) LeRoy Zimmerman profited from his position at Hershey Trust ( a charity for disadvantaged children or Republican slush fund) "When Leroy S. Zimmerman was named in late 2002 to the board of the small state- chartered Pennsylvania bank that managed the assets of the Hershey charity for disadvantaged youth, the post paid about $35,000 a year and came with restrictions.
    [Show full text]
  • Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Legislative
    COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL TUESDAY, JANUARY 7, 2003 SESSION OF 2003 187TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 1 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Indeed, as we leave this historic event this afternoon, may we The House convened at 12 m., e.s.t. always have faith in You, O Lord. Be proud of our great country, be more loyal to this Commonwealth, be more friendly toward one another, and be more indebted to our common God, THE CHIEF CLERK (TED MAZIA) who is number one in heaven as all Pennsylvanians are always PRESIDING number one on earth. Amen. Shalom. God bless. That is it. CALL TO ORDER PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The CHIEF CLERK. This being the day and the hour appointed by Article II, section 4, of the Constitution of (The Pledge of Allegiance was recited by members-elect and Pennsylvania for the meeting of the General Assembly, the visitors.) House of Representatives will now come to order. The Sergeants at Arms will close the doors of the House. The CHIEF CLERK. The Sergeants at Arms will open the doors of the House. Members and guests, please be seated. MOMENT OF SILENCE ELECTION RETURNS PRESENTED The CHIEF CLERK. As many of you know, one of our members, Leroy Zimmerman, died December 6 of 2002. Prior The CHIEF CLERK. The Chair recognizes the Sergeant at to the prayer being offered by Rev. Dr. George F. Riley, Arms of the House. assistant to the president of Villanova University, members and The SERGEANT AT ARMS. Mr. Chief Clerk, the guests will please rise for a moment of silence in remembrance Deputy Secretary of the Commonwealth, Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • C:\My Documents\Dailey
    The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School College of Communications THE NEW CATHEDRALS: THE SPORTS STADIUM AND MASS MEDIA’S ROLE IN FACILITATING NEW CONSTRUCTION A Thesis in Mass Communication by Robert C. Trumpbour © 2001 Robert C. Trumpbour Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 2001 We approve the thesis of Robert C. Trumpbour. Date of Signature _____________________________ _____________________ Richard L. Barton Professor of Communications Associate Dean of Graduate Studies and Research Thesis Adviser Chair of Committee _____________________________ ______________________ Suzanna DeBoef Associate Professor of Political Science _____________________________ ______________________ Patrick Parsons Associate Professor of Communications _____________________________ ______________________ Ronald A. Smith Professor Emeritus of Exercise and Sport Science iii Abstract Stadium construction has occurred at record-breaking level in major metropolitan areas of the United States in the last decade. This dissertation traces media coverage of stadium construction policy throughout the twentieth century and the beginning of the twenty-first century, focusing specifically on newspaper coverage of this issue. The hypothesis that media practitioners in smaller metropolitan areas will be more likely to privilege voices supporting new stadium construction is examined. The case study method is utilized and content analysis is employed to determine media coverage trends in major American metropolitan areas. Cincinnati and Pittsburgh are examined as small market cities, while Boston and New York are explored as larger market cities. Evidence is provided that larger markets adopt a more critical position than small market cities regarding new stadium construction in newspaper opinion content. Large market publications are similar to smaller market counterparts in providing greater opportunity for expression to pro-stadium voices.
    [Show full text]
  • Commonwealto of Pennsylvania Legislative
    COMMONWEALTO OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 22,1994 SESSION OF 1994 178TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 51 SENATE The PRESIDENT. The Chair thanks Colonel Woods, who lUESDAY, November 22, 1994 is the guest today of Senator Robbins. The Senate met at 10 a.m., Eastern Standard Time. JOURNAL APPROVED The PRESIDENT (Lieutenant Governor Mark S. Singel) in The PRESIDENT. A quorum of the Senate being present, the Chair. the Clerk will read the Journal from the preceding Session of November 21, 1994. PRAYER The Clerk proceeded to read the Journal of the preceding Session, when on motion ofSenator LOEPER, further reading The Chaplain, Colonel JOHN O. WOODS, of Holy Trinity was dispensed with and the Journal was approved. Lutheran Church, Greenville, offered the following prayer: Before I give this prayer, I want you to know that I am HOUSE MESSAGES going to be thinking about all of you all through this building this morning, and especially those who are leaving office and HOUSE CONCURS IN SENATE BILLS those who have gone to their heavenly home. The Clerk of the House of Representatives returned to the Let us pray. Senate SB 653, SB 849, SB 850 and SB 1046, with the Our gracious Heavenly Father, in this great building, in this information the House has passed the same without great institution ofleaders who lead our country and especially amendments. our great State of Pennsylvania, we thank You for the services of those who are leaving office: Lieutenant Governor Singel, HOUSE CONCURS IN SENATE AMENDMENTS Senator Reibman, Senator Lewis, Senator Lincoln, Senator TO HOUSE BILL Pecora, Senator Fattah, Senator Bortner, and Senator Marks, The Clerk of the House of Representatives informed the who have given faithfully of their lives and their time for the Senate that the House has concurred in amendments made by good of this great nation and this State.
    [Show full text]
  • 1Fiegislatifte Mournal
    COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA 1fiegislatifte mournal TUESDAY, JANUARY 3,1995 SESSION OF 1995 179TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No.1 SENATE The PRESIDENT. The Chairthanks Reverend Pattillo, who is the guest today of Senator Jubelirer. TUESDAY, January 3, 1995 PRESENTATION OF ELECTION RETURNS The PRESIDENT. This is the constitutional day and hour for the convening ofthe 179th Regular Session ofthe General The PRESIDENT. At this time, the Chair recognizes the Assembly. Sergeant-at-Arms. The SERGEANT-AT-ARMS. Mr. President, I have the The PRESIDENT (Lieutenant Governor Mark S. Singel) honor to present the Deputy Secretai)' of the Commonwealth, called the Senate to order at 12:00 m., Eastern Standard Time. Iris Foggs-Wilcox. Deputy Secretai)' FOGGS-WILCOX. Mr. President, on PRAYER behalf of the Secretary of the Commonwealth, Robert N. The Chaplain, Reverend GWENDOLYN PATTILLO, of Grant, I have the honor of presenting to you today the Altoona, offered the following prayer: November 8, 1994 election returns for the offices ofGovernor, Lieutenant Governor, and Senator in the General Assembly, Let us bow our heads. along with the corresponding campaign expense reporting o universal spirit of love, truth, and peace, called many compliance certifications for those offices. different names by many different people, search the hearts The PRESIDENT. The Chair thanks Secretary Foggs­ and minds of those whose actions during this 179th Session Wilcox. shall impact the quality of life of so many who are unknown to them, and empower this august body with compassion, ELECTION RETURNS FOR GOVERNOR AND integrity, and high moral values. When they reach crossroads LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR LAID ON TABLE or corne to impasses in their decisionrnaking process, may they The PRESIDENT.
    [Show full text]
  • Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Legislative
    COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 18, 1985 SESSION OF 1985 169TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 54 SENATE May the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and of Jesus WEDNESDAY, September 18, 1985. Christ, grant you His peace on this day and always. Amen. The Senate met at 2:00 p.m., Eastern Daylight Saving The PRESIDENT. The Chair thanks the Reverend Hill Time. who is the guest this week of Senator Jubelirer. The PRESIDENT (Lieutenant Governor William W. Scranton III) in the Chair. JOURNAL APPROVED The PRESIDENT. A quorum of the Senate being present, PRAYER the Clerk will read the Journal of the preceding Session of The Chaplain, the Reverend Mr. CARL HILL, Pastor of June 28, 1985. Bedford United Methodist Church, Bedford, offered the fol­ The Clerk proceeded to read the Journal of the preceding lowing prayer: Session, when, on motion of Senator STAUFFER, further reading was dispensed with, and the Journal was approved. Let us pray. Eternal and creative Spirit, we pause at the beginning of LEGISLATIVE LEAVE this legislative term grateful for the resources of our Com­ monwealth. From the shores of Lake Erie to the banks of the Senator STAUFFER. Mr. President, I would ask for a leg­ Delaware, from the Mason-Dixon Line to the Northern Tier, islative leave for the balance of today's Session for Senator we are blessed with the beauty of Your creative power. Enable Armstrong. us to respond with utmost appreciation for the most valuable The PRESIDENT. Are there objections to a legislative resource of all: the men, women, children and youth who live leave for today for Senator Armstrong? The Chair hears and work in the hamlets, towns and cities of our beloved none.
    [Show full text]
  • Political Contributions and Related Activity Report 2006 Aetna PAC and Aetna Inc
    Political contributions and related activity report 2006 Aetna PAC and Aetna Inc. 31.05.904.1-06 AETNA PAC BOARD OF OFFICERS FEDERAL CONTRIBUTIONS DIRECTORS — 2006 COMMITTEE Mark Bertolini Thomas Strohmenger Charlie Iovino Executive Vice President, Regional Businesses Chairman Vice President & Counsel Vice President & Head of Federal Government Affairs Mary Claire Bonner Government Affairs Segment Head, Regional Business Thomas Strohmenger Jonathan Topodas Vice President & Head of William Casazza Treasurer and Counsel Government Affairs Senior Vice President and General Counsel Vice President & Counsel Federal Government Affairs Jonathan Topodas James Foreman Vice President & Counsel Executive Vice President, National Businesses Tammy Preisner Federal Government Affairs Assistant Treasurer William Hauser and Administrator Regional Medical Director STATE CONTRIBUTIONS COMMITTEE Manager, Law & Regulatory Affairs Paul Hebert Brooke Flaherty Head, Provider Data Services, Credentialing Senior State Government Affairs Specialist Felicia Norwood, President President and COO, Active Health Kris Frank Senior State Government Paul Silva Affairs Specialist Product Head, Student Health Thomas Strohmenger Vice President & Head of Government Affairs Aetna PAC is a bipartisan political action committee that enables company employees to have a voice with state and federal legislators and offi cials who make laws and policy that have a direct impact on the way the company does business. Its purpose is to collect voluntary contributions from eligible Aetna employees and then use these funds to support candidates for federal and state political offi ce pursuant to our internal contribution guidelines and in accordance with applicable election laws. Aetna PAC began 2006 with a balance of $360,049 and, during the year, eligible Aetna employees contributed an additional $344,547.
    [Show full text]
  • In the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania Richard Vieth, Norma Jean : Civil No.1:Cv-01-2439 Vi
    IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA RICHARD VIETH, NORMA JEAN : CIVIL NO.1:CV-01-2439 VIETH, and SUSAN FUREY, : : Plaintiffs : : v. : : COMMONWEALTH OF : PENNSYLVANIA, et al. : : Defendants : OPINION OF THE COURT1 Before the court are: (1) a motion to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1) filed by Defendants Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania Governor Mark Schweiker, Secretary of State Kim Pizzingrilli, and Commissioner of the Bureau of Commissions, Elections, and Legislation Richard Filling (“Executive Officers”); (2) Defendant Executive Officers’ motion to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6); (3) a Rule 12(b)(1) motion to dismiss filed by Defendants Matthew Ryan and Robert Jubelirer (“Presiding Officers”)2; and (4) Defendant Presiding Officers’ motion to dismiss pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6). The parties have briefed the issues, and the matter is ripe for disposition. 1RAMBO, SENIOR DISTRICT JUDGE authored the Opinion of the Court in which NYGAARD, CIRCUIT JUDGE and YOHN, DISTRICT JUDGE join. 2Defendant Ryan is the Speaker of the Pennsylvania House of Representatives, and Defendant Jubelirer is the Lieutenant Governor of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Thus, Speaker Ryan presides over the Pennsylvania House of Representatives, and Lieutenant Governor Jubelirer presides over the Pennsylvania State Senate. I. Background A. Factual Allegations Plaintiffs Richard Vieth, Norma Jean Vieth, and Susan Furey brought this action, pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983, against Defendant Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Defendant Executive Officers, and Defendant Presiding Officers. Plaintiffs’ claims arise out of the enactment of Pennsylvania Senate Bill 1200 (“Act 1”), Pennsylvania’s Congressional redistricting plan, which Governor Schweiker signed into law on January 7, 2002.
    [Show full text]
  • 14Tgialntiut 3Jnurunl MONDAY, OCTOBER 19, 1981
    COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA 14tgialntiut 3Jnurunl MONDAY, OCTOBER 19, 1981 SESSION OF 1981 165TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 58 SENATE SENATOR SCANLON TO VOTE FOR MONDAY, October 19, 1981. SENATOR ROMANELLI The Senate met at 1:00 p.m., Eastern Daylight Saving Senator SCANLON. Mr. President, I request a legislative Time. leave for today's Session only, for Senator Romanelli. THE PRESIDENT (Lieutenant Governor William W. Mr. President, I also renew the medical leave indefinitely Scranton III) in the Chair. for Senator Ross. The PRESIDENT. Senator Scanlon requests a legislative PRAYER leave for Senator Romanelli and, of course, the leave of absence for Senator Ross is still in effect. The Chaplain, the Reverend JAMES H. GOLD, Pastor of The Chair hears no objection to that leave and the leave is the Lutheran Church and the United Church of Christ, granted. Ickesburg, offered the following prayer: Let us pray. COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE GOVERNOR 0 Thou who art the provider of every good and perfect gift, as we call on Thee in prayer today, we give Thee thanks. APPROVAL OF SENATE BILLS We give Thee thanks for our Nation and for our Common­ The PRESIDENT laid before the Senate the following wealth. We give Thee thanks for Thy guidance in years past. communications in writing from His Excellency, the Gover­ Today, mindful of seventy-five years of this Capitol Build­ nor of the Commonwealth, advising that the following Senate ing with its beauty and historical significance, we pray that, as Bills had been approved ana signed by the Governor: Thou hast guided us in the years past, Thou will continue to SB 653 and 775.
    [Show full text]
  • Open Laurenboyerthesis.Pdf
    THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY SCHREYER HONORS COLLEGE DEPARTMENT OF JOURNALISM BUDGETING THE BUDGET: AN ANALYSIS OF FOUR DAILY NEWSPAPERS’ COVERAGE OF THE 2009/2010 PENNSYLVANIA BUDGET IMPASSE LAUREN MARIE BOYER Fall 2009 A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a baccalaureate degree in Journalism with honors in Journalism Reviewed and approved* by the following: John J. Curley Distinguished Professional in Residence Thesis Supervisor Robert D. Richards John and Ann Curley Professor of First Amendment Studies Honors Adviser * Signatures are on file in the Schreyer Honors College. ABSTRACT The purpose of this thesis is to examine how different Pennsylvania newspapers and their statehouse reporters boiled down the complex issues surrounding the 2009/2010 state budget impasse and how that process has changed with the advent of new technology. Through a coverage analysis, it is apparent that reporters from the The Patriot-News, Philadelphia Inquirer, Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, and Pittsburgh Post-Gazette faced significant and different challenges in covering a the 101-day budget stalemate, the longest in state history. Through an analysis of articles from May 2009 to August 2009 and interviews with reporters, this research analyzes and evaluates how these publications carved their own paths in covering the budget- related issues of state worker payless paydays, a personal income tax increase proposal, the effects on state-supported programs and services, and Gov. Ed Rendell’s role in the debate. In an effort to provide comprehensive reporting of the contentious political deliberations surrounding the impasse, many reporters employed Internet blogs and social media sites like Facebook.com and Twitter.com to keep citizenry informed.
    [Show full text]